Format

NPD03. Encasing Public Policy: Using Case Based Method for teaching and research

Pedagogy
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Srikrishna Ayyangar
National Law School of India University
Main chair
Namrata Chindarkar
Indian Institute of Management Ahmedabad
Second chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
Pedagogy
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

This panel will explore the meaning and significance of public policy cases for teaching, research and for showcasing practice. It will highlight the meanings of case study based method, its importance in the context of the overwhelming attention to multi methods research, its relevance in the context of quantitative methods and its significance to concept building, comparative approaches and as a qualitative pedagogy and method. 

CALL FOR PAPERS

We invite papers to explain and highlight how they use the case based method to undertake teaching, research, and showcase their practice. What does a case mean in your area of interest? How do you create, use and apply the insights from the cases in your area of interest?  What kinds of insights does it provide that are distinct from multi methods research? How do you teach a case and what learning outcomes do you expect from such a method? This panel will seek to explore these questions, among many others not mentioned in this call, with a focus to highlight the relevance, importance and possibilities of case based methodology and research.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Layering gender into the ‘doing’ of public policy: Deconstructing case-studies through an interdisciplinary social sciences framework
Vidya Subramanian (Jindal School of Government and Public Policy)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The teaching of conventional Gender and Development courses often emphasize the need to foreground a critical gender lens amongst students of development studies and public policy. However, the changing desires and demands of graduate students entering professional public policy programs where applied economics courses and quantitative approaches dominate and are seen as more ‘useful’ and relevant in the ‘job market’, there is more hesitation amongst students to engage with qualitative sociological approaches that are viewed as being ‘too critical’ or ‘theoretical’. As a qualitative sociologist teaching Gender and Development at a prominent School of Public Policy in India, I employ an autoethnographic approach to discuss my pedagogical engagements and reflections in bringing the case-study approach into the classroom and situating it within a broader interdisciplinary lens drawing from sociology, development studies and gender studies. These processes allow for what I call a ‘layering’ of gender into the ‘thinking’ of public policy design. I begin by reflecting on reorienting the curricular design of the Gender and Development course where I juxtapose key academic research articles alongside supplementary resources such as news-reports, data reports and documentary films to expand thinking both conceptually and empirically. I then move towards discussing vignettes of my pedagogical efforts and challenges in interspersing a wider interdisciplinary critical lens in deconstructing select gender-centred policy case-studies beyond the prescriptive gaze of ‘outcomes’. In order to have students ‘see the skills’ they acquired through these discussions in more tangible terms, I designed one of the assessments as a group-based project where students develop a qualitative research tool for a gender-centred policy research question. The aim of this exercise was to have students think outside of conventional close-ended forms of designing questions and initiate thinking and dialogue around open-ended interviewing methods and researcher positionalities. Through these diverse efforts, I attempted to bridge some gaps between abstract ‘theory’ and naïve ‘practices’, with the aim that students developed a more grounded interest in qualitative sociological approaches towards understanding themes in gender and development outside conventional quantitative frameworks that dominate public policy studies.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Encasing a policy event : reflections on developing a social-relational approach to policy research
Meera S (Center for study of science technology and Policy)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

I use this paper as an opportunity to identify and discuss a few advantages that the case study method offers in the context of public policy research but have not been utilised enough. Existing approaches to studying public policy starts with some key metaphors:  as a multi-actor process of innovation or learning that focuses primarily on actors in the state – mainly, political or bureaucratic. While these are illuminating metaphors and important actors to understand and explain policy events, I identify some gaps that seem relevant in Indian contexts for a fuller picture. I draw on illustrations from my doctoral research work in India and experience of teaching a cohort of public policy at the post-graduate-level in Indian colleges to identify why these gaps might be relevant in Indian policymaking contexts.

 

I start with reflecting on some questions that are part of many research contexts and the ones that case studies are particularly well-suited to answer before identifying why they might be relevant for public policy research in India.

 

1) Encountering an event from multiple locations before abstraction: I start the illustration from a place that is familiar to many early career researchers  – wanting to understand a phenomenon of interest and asking whether it is similar to or different from what the disciplinary domain has seen before.  In other words : answering the question – ‘what is this a case of’ too soon. This includes the ability to make decisions such as:

a.      Should one develop new metaphors and concepts to understand the phenomenon?

b.      What does one lose in terms of what is unique to the event when using established concepts and frameworks?  

c.      Is the particularity salient to the event or a minor feature of the context?

d.      Should one use this particularity to interrogate existing frameworks or develop new concepts?

 

2)     Contextualizing the event longitudinally:  This has to do with a better or a allowing for a new understanding of the dependent variable in a policy event.

a.       What changed after a policy event? What remained the same?

b.      What are the main assumptions that were wrong and controls that malfunctioned?

c.      Do these questions suggest a primarily qualitative or a mixed-methods study?

 

 

 

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Making a case for Encasing Public Policy
Srikrishna Ayyangar (National Law School of India University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The proliferation of multi methods research (MMR), which essentially seems to be a label that can provide legitimate cover for the excessive valorization of quantitative based and experimental methods accompanied by a qualitative approach as an appendage, to research questions in the Social Sciences (of which development is a part), is arguably, critics point out, a myopic and in fact a fraught approach because it can lead to false complementarities and the loss of crucial ontologies of the things we want to observe and explain.

 

This paper will argue for revisiting the idea of a ‘case’ as a way to imagine the field beyond just as a site of exposure to study. In imagining that idea, the paper will further point out what that approach would capture (encase) in a way that helps us better understand and explore questions of development that cannot be covered by MMR or quantitative research, perhaps even qualitative research.

 

In doing so, the paper will highlight two things. It will first try to understand the meaning and ontology of a case study as seen through its genealogy in the social sciences, the medical and legal studies. What is a case and why is it used as a site for study? The second part of the paper will focus on the question of comparisons and the advantages and disadvantages of a comparative case study.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The teaching of conventional Gender and Development courses often emphasize the need to foreground a critical gender lens amongst students of development studies and public policy. However, the changing desires and demands of graduate students entering professional public policy programs where applied economics courses and quantitative approaches dominate and are seen as more ‘useful’ and relevant in the ‘job market’, there is more hesitation amongst students to engage with qualitative sociological approaches that are viewed as being ‘too critical’ or ‘theoretical’. As a qualitative sociologist teaching Gender and Development at a prominent School of Public Policy in India, I employ an autoethnographic approach to discuss my pedagogical engagements and reflections in bringing the case-study approach into the classroom and situating it within a broader interdisciplinary lens drawing from sociology, development studies and gender studies. These processes allow for what I call a ‘layering’ of gender into the ‘thinking’ of public policy design. I begin by reflecting on reorienting the curricular design of the Gender and Development course where I juxtapose key academic research articles alongside supplementary resources such as news-reports, data reports and documentary films to expand thinking both conceptually and empirically. I then move towards discussing vignettes of my pedagogical efforts and challenges in interspersing a wider interdisciplinary critical lens in deconstructing select gender-centred policy case-studies beyond the prescriptive gaze of ‘outcomes’. In order to have students ‘see the skills’ they acquired through these discussions in more tangible terms, I designed one of the assessments as a group-based project where students develop a qualitative research tool for a gender-centred policy research question. The aim of this exercise was to have students think outside of conventional close-ended forms of designing questions and initiate thinking and dialogue around open-ended interviewing methods and researcher positionalities. Through these diverse efforts, I attempted to bridge some gaps between abstract ‘theory’ and naïve ‘practices’, with the aim that students developed a more grounded interest in qualitative sociological approaches towards understanding themes in gender and development outside conventional quantitative frameworks that dominate public policy studies.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

I use this paper as an opportunity to identify and discuss a few advantages that the case study method offers in the context of public policy research but have not been utilised enough. Existing approaches to studying public policy starts with some key metaphors:  as a multi-actor process of innovation or learning that focuses primarily on actors in the state – mainly, political or bureaucratic. While these are illuminating metaphors and important actors to understand and explain policy events, I identify some gaps that seem relevant in Indian contexts for a fuller picture. I draw on illustrations from my doctoral research work in India and experience of teaching a cohort of public policy at the post-graduate-level in Indian colleges to identify why these gaps might be relevant in Indian policymaking contexts.

 

I start with reflecting on some questions that are part of many research contexts and the ones that case studies are particularly well-suited to answer before identifying why they might be relevant for public policy research in India.

 

1) Encountering an event from multiple locations before abstraction: I start the illustration from a place that is familiar to many early career researchers  – wanting to understand a phenomenon of interest and asking whether it is similar to or different from what the disciplinary domain has seen before.  In other words : answering the question – ‘what is this a case of’ too soon. This includes the ability to make decisions such as:

a.      Should one develop new metaphors and concepts to understand the phenomenon?

b.      What does one lose in terms of what is unique to the event when using established concepts and frameworks?  

c.      Is the particularity salient to the event or a minor feature of the context?

d.      Should one use this particularity to interrogate existing frameworks or develop new concepts?

 

2)     Contextualizing the event longitudinally:  This has to do with a better or a allowing for a new understanding of the dependent variable in a policy event.

a.       What changed after a policy event? What remained the same?

b.      What are the main assumptions that were wrong and controls that malfunctioned?

c.      Do these questions suggest a primarily qualitative or a mixed-methods study?

 

 

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The proliferation of multi methods research (MMR), which essentially seems to be a label that can provide legitimate cover for the excessive valorization of quantitative based and experimental methods accompanied by a qualitative approach as an appendage, to research questions in the Social Sciences (of which development is a part), is arguably, critics point out, a myopic and in fact a fraught approach because it can lead to false complementarities and the loss of crucial ontologies of the things we want to observe and explain.

 

This paper will argue for revisiting the idea of a ‘case’ as a way to imagine the field beyond just as a site of exposure to study. In imagining that idea, the paper will further point out what that approach would capture (encase) in a way that helps us better understand and explore questions of development that cannot be covered by MMR or quantitative research, perhaps even qualitative research.

 

In doing so, the paper will highlight two things. It will first try to understand the meaning and ontology of a case study as seen through its genealogy in the social sciences, the medical and legal studies. What is a case and why is it used as a site for study? The second part of the paper will focus on the question of comparisons and the advantages and disadvantages of a comparative case study.