CATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
Policymaking in India and much of the Global South occurs under persistent fiscal constraint, uneven administrative capacity, and substantial social heterogeneity. At the same time, governments are expected to pursue sustainable development in a carbon-constrained environment shaped by geopolitical uncertainty and rapid technological change. These conditions place sustained on governments to deliver on promises while maintaining political legitimacy.
One response to these challenges is frugal policy innovation. Rather than treating constraint as a temporary limitation, frugal policy innovation takes it as a starting point for policy practice. It refers to a deliberate approach of policymaking and implementation that is scalable under limited capacity and high contextual variation. In practice, this is reflected in different forms of innovation, such as change in institutional structures, policy processes, governance arrangements, or administrative practices.
Frugal policy innovation involves the following characteristics: (i) persistent resource constraint; (ii) reconfiguration of capacity rather than simple cost reduction; (iii) prioritization of sufficiency over optimality; (iv) adaptation to local institutional and social context; and (v) scaling through simplicity and modularity. Such innovation may occur at any stage of the policy cycle, including agenda setting, formulation, decision-making, implementation, and evaluation.
By bringing together empirical and practice-oriented work, the panel aims to clarify how frugal policy innovation shapes policy practice in India and what this implies for governing under constraint in the Global South.
CALL FOR PAPERS
The panel welcomes contributions examining frugal policy innovation in India across policy domains, levels of government, and geographic settings. Submissions may focus on specific characteristics of frugality, analyse different forms of policy innovation, or examine why and how such innovations emerge and operate at particular stages of the policy cycle.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The paper explores how the cost of regulation can be reduced when the state attempts to induce environmental behaviours among ordinary people. It draws empirical evidence from a set of regulations that sought to induce behaviour change among urban households in India, specifically regarding the segregation of household waste into two streams—organic and inorganic—at the point of consumption or disposal. In this context, the law and various behavioural public policy interventions attempted to regulate behaviour by altering choice architecture and by repeatedly influencing individuals cognitive mind through social media and awareness campaigns, to do the right thing.
The analytical premise of the paper draws from behavioural law and economics(Ostrom, 1998; Ellickson, 1991; Sunstein, 1996; Thaler & Sunstein, 2003)
, which conceptualises regulation as operating across multiple domains—formal legal rules, social norms, and moral norms—each providing different forms of rewards and sanctions to socially control human behaviour. Regulations in this domain have primarily emphasised formal legal rules, notably the Municipal Solid Waste Management Rules, 2016, along with extensive use of behavioural intervention policies (Swachh Bharat Abhiyan and Garbage Free Cities). Both approaches attempted either to normatively incentivise compliance or to punish violations, effectively leaving responsibility within the domain of formal law and individual moral action.
However, when such low payoff and high effort, everyday behaviours are subject to regulation, people often free ride or partially comply with the law. As a result, compliance remains short-lived, or the regulation fails to achieve its broader normative goals. Fieldwork conducted in Aurangabad and Delhi (2021) suggests a different outcome. Where normative incentives and disincentives were enforced through the waste collector (Dalit)—who interacted with households on a daily basis—lasting/durable behaviour change was observed within neighbourhoods/wards.
Rather than relying solely on formal legal rules or behavioural public policy instruments, the findings show that when these mechanisms are embedded within social norm based regulation, mediated through the waste collector as a norm manager, the cost of regulation declines significantly. In such contexts, regulation becomes frugal, as sustained compliance is achieved with minimal enforcement expenditure and without heavy reliance on coercive legal mechanisms.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The Wealth of Trust: Analyzing Self-Attestation as a Frugal Process Innovation in Indian Public Policy
Abstract:
For decades, Indian public administration relied heavily on procedural verification mechanisms, most notably the mandatory submission of affidavits—legally sworn documents authenticated by notaries or magistrates—to access routine public services. While intended to ensure accuracy and accountability, this requirement generated a substantial compliance burden for citizens, particularly those in rural and low-income contexts. These burdens included direct financial costs, opportunity costs associated with travel and lost wages, and systemic inefficiencies that increased bureaucratic friction.
This paper examines the 2014 policy shift toward self-attestation, under which the state accepts a citizen’s signed declaration as prima facie verification, with penalties applied ex post in cases of fraud. Conceptually situated within the literature on frugal policy innovation, self-attestation represents a rare case of “zero-cost” process innovation: rather than introducing new technologies or infrastructure, it improves administrative efficiency by eliminating a non-essential procedural layer. The reform thus exemplifies frugal governance through institutional simplification and a recalibration of trust between the state and citizens.
Methodologically, the study adopts a qualitative, secondary-data-based approach, synthesizing evidence from state-level reform documentation, including materials from the Punjab Governance Reforms Commission, national policy guidance issued by the Department of Administrative Reforms and Public Grievances, and recommendations of the Second Administrative Reforms Commission. Focusing on the implementation stage of the policy cycle, the paper traces the evolution of self-attestation from a subnational administrative experiment to a nationally endorsed standard.
The analysis indicates that self-attestation significantly reduced compliance costs for service users while simplifying administrative workflows and enabling rapid diffusion across jurisdictions without additional fiscal investment. Official estimates suggest substantial aggregate savings in notarial expenses and citizen time, underscoring the policy’s scalability and distributive impact. More broadly, the findings demonstrate that frugality in public policy need not be limited to technological solutions; it can also emerge through strategic process simplification and trust-based institutional design.
The paper concludes that self-attestation offers an instructive example of frugal policy innovation with relevance beyond India, highlighting the potential of low-cost administrative reforms to enhance state capacity and citizen accessibility simultaneously.
Keywords: Public Administration, Innovation, Infrastructure, Accountability, Accessibility
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Governments are often faced by policy problems marked by uncertainty, ambiguity, and the prospect of multiple possible futures. This paper examines how governments respond to such conditions by adopting different routes and tools for policy design, rather than relying on a single optimal approach. While some forms of uncertainty can be addressed through information gathering and model‑based analysis, others involve unpredictable system dynamics or contested interpretations that cannot be resolved through additional knowledge alone. In response, governments deploy a diverse repertoire of policy approaches, ranging from “high cost” anticipatory planning and robustness‑oriented designs to more frugal adaptive, experimental, and incremental strategies that evolve over time. The choice among these routes reflects not only the nature of the policy problem, but also institutional capacities, resource constraints, and prevailing governance traditions. In some settings, adaptiveness is pursued through formal mechanisms such as monitoring, review, and pre‑specified adjustments, while in others it emerges through frugal, learning‑by‑doing approaches that prioritise flexibility and responsiveness. The paper highlights the trade‑offs inherent in these strategies, particularly between commitment and flexibility in the face of long‑term transitions.
We study the case of green hydrogen mission in India to analyse how the union government in India addresses technological, economic, and geopolitical uncertainties involved in the creation of the hydrogen ecosystem and the realization of the objectives of this mission. Initial findings suggest that while the government is continuously adapting to the changing environment, its approach diverges from the approach of adaptive policymaking. Instead, it is better characterized as “muddling through”: a rational, low-cost strategy of governing uncertainty through successive limited comparisons than comprehensive design.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Authors and Affiliation: Madhuri Dhariwal, Director (East Zone, Operations), Indus Action; Sanjana Saxena, Sr Manager (East Zone, Operations), Indus Action
Abstract: The construction sector is India’s second-largest source of employment, engaging about 12% of the workforce, amounting to around 7.3 crore workers (PLFS 2023-24). Chhattisgarh reflects a similar situation, with nearly 9.7% of its workforce, i.e. about 22 lakh workers are employed in construction sector (NITI Ayog Report, 2025). Meagre daily wages (Rs. 400 - Rs. 600 per day), along with high levels of migration within and across states, weaken workers’ access to social security and basic support.
To mitigate these vulnerabilities, the Building and Other Construction Workers (BOCW) Acts of 1996, now subsumed under the Social Security Code, 2020, mandate State BOCW Boards to collect a 1% cess on construction costs. This cess is meant to provide social security benefits such as health care, education support, pensions, and other welfare measures for construction workers and their families. However, actual cess collection is far below its potential, leading to limited resources and restricting welfare benefits to only a small portion of the workforce. An analysis of secondary data (fetched from Rajya Sabha Unstarred Question No. 259, 2022) from 2017 to 2022 shows that although Chhattisgarh has registered more than 20 lakh construction workers, its cess collection per worker is only ₹8,728, which is much lower than the national average of ₹17,194. In comparison, states such as Madhya Pradesh and Kerala perform much better in cess collection.
This study examines the reasons behind the gap between the estimated cess potential and the actual cess collected in Chhattisgarh, and suggests practical, low-cost solutions to reduce this gap. Using a mixed-methods approach that includes data analysis, review of existing processes/SOPs and structured interviews with key stakeholders and field officers in Raipur, Durg, Bilaspur and Korba, the study identifies key bottlenecks in the current cess assessment and collection system. It argues that small, low-cost changes in processes can lead to significant improvements in revenue. The study also presents a clear roadmap for administrative reforms that can help bridge the collection gap and strengthen social security coverage for construction workers, both in Chhattisgarh and in other states.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The present paper forefronts frugality as a core strategy that drives policy decisions, implementation, and evaluation in the context of India. The authors – public health practitioners – have drawn insights from programmatic learnings in the course of operationalizing Project Utthan. Utthan is a system-strengthening adolescent health project working in Uttar Pradesh, the state home to India’s largest adolescent population (aged 10-19), with a deep focus in three districts of Barabanki, Bareilly and Sonbhadra. The cornerstone of the project is streamlining convergence of the Rashtriya Kishore Swasthya Karyakram(RKSK), School Health and Wellness Program (SHWP), the Weekly Iron and Folic Acid Supplementation (WIFS) Program, and the District Mental Health Program (DMHP). At the level of policy design, the authors trace the recent history of the adolescent health framework in India, which has inherent components of co-ownership, integrating itself into existing public health structures and leveraging long-trusted service delivery touchpoints. While the model of convergence – here between Health and Education departments – is not novel, the authors propose that it continues to be a deep-rooted challenge since an iterative, design-as-you-go approach is a diminishing space within the development sector. At the level of implementation, the authors assert that praxis is being driven by top-down, pre-determined designs that preclude reflection and context-specificity. Through grounded practice, the authors find that learning levers guide micro inputs, and simple system fixes unlock large gains. Input levers at the district, block, and school levels, though not impacting at scale, serve as learning models to create embedded, sustainable change. Evidence based and field insights are readily accepted by policy makers and implementing officers, as they are cognizant of the need for continuous improvement and are willing to partner with like-minded experts. By applying the learnings of this model of frugal policy innovations, the authors have delivered significant improvement in system capacities of health and education departments to deliver quality information and services to adolescents. By bridging gaps between different stakeholders, concrete improvement in adolescent knowledge, health seeking behavior, and anemia levels among school going adolescents is evident.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The concept of "frugal policy innovation" is known as a response to the governance challenges present in the Global South. These innovations are adaptations to fiscal constraints and inadequate administrative capacity, and are often praised for turning scarcity into efficient, context-specific solutions. However, this paper presents the "other side of the coin" regarding adaptive practices at the last mile of policy delivery in India. We argue that while such innovations are praised for their utility, they frequently mask the deep-seated institutional weaknesses that necessitate them in the first place.
Drawing on Street-Level Bureaucracy theory (Lipsky, 2010) and empirical data across water supply, solid waste and sanitation, education, and electricity sectors. This paper examines "frugal innovation" through the lens of "coping mechanisms" of frontline workers in service delivery sectors. We argue that frontline service delivery actors—workers, supervisors, and managers—often do not innovate out of strategic design, but out of survival necessity. They bear the burden of systemic deficiencies, bridging the gap between ambitious policy targets and the ground realities of resource scarcity through ad-hocism and personal stewardship.
Our findings suggest that while these coping mechanisms ensure the immediate policy implementation, they simultaneously mask the need for systemic reform. By "making do," frontline workers, these innovations alleviate the pressure on the state to address the institutional weakness that create the constraints. Consequently, what is labeled as "innovation" may effectively normalize the permanent austerity and administrative fragility.
While the discourse of frugal innovation has roots in Gandhian philosophy and rural development—where local knowledge meets material constraints—transposing this concept to policy delivery requires caution. We argue that the celebration of frugality must not provide intellectual cover for a deliberate policy design of under-resourcing. This paper concludes by differentiating between genuine innovation that enhances state capacity and the glamorization of ad-hocism that merely hides the lack of it.
Employing a qualitative research design, this study utilizes data gathered from in-depth interviews with frontline actors in the above-mentioned service delivery sectors. The collected qualitative data were then analysed through thematic analysis to identify various themes and insights.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
PM Gati Shakti Initiative: An exemplar case of Frugal Policy Innovation in Infrastructure governance
Globally, infrastructure is a critical multiplier of growth. Studies estimate that India could realise a potential gain of 2.5-3.5 rupees in GDP per rupee spent on infrastructure. However, historically, infrastructure governance in India has often been associated with fragmented planning, asynchronous execution and lack of standardisation. Siloed working across multiple levels of government often resulted in delayed approvals and gridlocks. But in an era of surging aspirations and shrinking resources, Governments are exploring innovative ways to reform infrastructure governance and deliver public services economically and efficiently.
This paper examines India’s PM Gati Shakti initiative (PMGS) as a case of frugal policy innovation, in which institutional reform and technology have been leveraged to bring speed, scale and synergy. Launched in 2021, it adopts a “Whole of Government” approach to enhance multimodal connectivity and ease of living. At the core of PMGS is a shared digital platform on which 58 ministries and departments and 36 states and Union Territories are onboarded. 200 data layers have been integrated, and a comprehensive database of ongoing and planned infrastructure projects across sectors such as railways, highways, waterways, and logistics.
Drawing on qualitative interviews with key informants and documentary analysis, the study finds that PMGS has accelerated more than 340 projects valued at over ₹15 lakh crore. It has contributed to evidence-based decision-making, faster project execution, and improved utilisation of existing infrastructure capacity.
According to the National Council of Applied Economic Research (NCAER), India’s logistics costs have declined to 7.8–8.9 per cent of GDP, down from earlier estimates of 13–14 per cent. Aligned with the National Logistics Policy, PM Gati Shakti is contributing to reduced logistics costs and closing critical infrastructure gaps, reflected in India’s improved 38th rank in the World Bank’s Logistics Performance Index (2023).
Beyond connecting ports, railways, and highways, the platform is increasingly used to identify and bridge gaps in social infrastructure (including healthcare and education) and to support the planning of disaster-resilient infrastructure. Tangible efficiency gains aside, the initiative has fostered greater interagency trust, stronger stakeholder ownership, and improved collaborative federalism.
By directly engaging Union ministries, state governments, and district administrations, it ensures that delays are flagged and accountability is fixed. Many stalled projects in rail, road and irrigation initiatives have been expedited through delivery-driven governance, real-time data and leadership oversight. In combination with the PRAGATI monitoring system, the PMGS platform has created a powerful ecosystem that imparts mission-mode momentum to infrastructure projects.
The study demonstrates that PMGS prioritises institutional alignment and collaboration over expenditure expansion, hallmarks of frugal policy innovation. It addresses systemic inefficiencies rooted in disjointed governance. Instead of creating additional layers of bureaucracy, it focuses on aligning the dataset, skill set, and mindset around clearly defined priorities and targets. PRAGATI and PMGS represent a paradigm shift towards outcome-driven governance.
The initiative offers a replicable governance model for emerging economies grappling with systemic complexities and legacy constraints. Expanding the scope and sustaining the project momentum, however, will require collective effort and continued leadership oversight.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The paper explores how the cost of regulation can be reduced when the state attempts to induce environmental behaviours among ordinary people. It draws empirical evidence from a set of regulations that sought to induce behaviour change among urban households in India, specifically regarding the segregation of household waste into two streams—organic and inorganic—at the point of consumption or disposal. In this context, the law and various behavioural public policy interventions attempted to regulate behaviour by altering choice architecture and by repeatedly influencing individuals cognitive mind through social media and awareness campaigns, to do the right thing.
The analytical premise of the paper draws from behavioural law and economics(Ostrom, 1998; Ellickson, 1991; Sunstein, 1996; Thaler & Sunstein, 2003)
, which conceptualises regulation as operating across multiple domains—formal legal rules, social norms, and moral norms—each providing different forms of rewards and sanctions to socially control human behaviour. Regulations in this domain have primarily emphasised formal legal rules, notably the Municipal Solid Waste Management Rules, 2016, along with extensive use of behavioural intervention policies (Swachh Bharat Abhiyan and Garbage Free Cities). Both approaches attempted either to normatively incentivise compliance or to punish violations, effectively leaving responsibility within the domain of formal law and individual moral action.
However, when such low payoff and high effort, everyday behaviours are subject to regulation, people often free ride or partially comply with the law. As a result, compliance remains short-lived, or the regulation fails to achieve its broader normative goals. Fieldwork conducted in Aurangabad and Delhi (2021) suggests a different outcome. Where normative incentives and disincentives were enforced through the waste collector (Dalit)—who interacted with households on a daily basis—lasting/durable behaviour change was observed within neighbourhoods/wards.
Rather than relying solely on formal legal rules or behavioural public policy instruments, the findings show that when these mechanisms are embedded within social norm based regulation, mediated through the waste collector as a norm manager, the cost of regulation declines significantly. In such contexts, regulation becomes frugal, as sustained compliance is achieved with minimal enforcement expenditure and without heavy reliance on coercive legal mechanisms.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The Wealth of Trust: Analyzing Self-Attestation as a Frugal Process Innovation in Indian Public Policy
Abstract:
For decades, Indian public administration relied heavily on procedural verification mechanisms, most notably the mandatory submission of affidavits—legally sworn documents authenticated by notaries or magistrates—to access routine public services. While intended to ensure accuracy and accountability, this requirement generated a substantial compliance burden for citizens, particularly those in rural and low-income contexts. These burdens included direct financial costs, opportunity costs associated with travel and lost wages, and systemic inefficiencies that increased bureaucratic friction.
This paper examines the 2014 policy shift toward self-attestation, under which the state accepts a citizen’s signed declaration as prima facie verification, with penalties applied ex post in cases of fraud. Conceptually situated within the literature on frugal policy innovation, self-attestation represents a rare case of “zero-cost” process innovation: rather than introducing new technologies or infrastructure, it improves administrative efficiency by eliminating a non-essential procedural layer. The reform thus exemplifies frugal governance through institutional simplification and a recalibration of trust between the state and citizens.
Methodologically, the study adopts a qualitative, secondary-data-based approach, synthesizing evidence from state-level reform documentation, including materials from the Punjab Governance Reforms Commission, national policy guidance issued by the Department of Administrative Reforms and Public Grievances, and recommendations of the Second Administrative Reforms Commission. Focusing on the implementation stage of the policy cycle, the paper traces the evolution of self-attestation from a subnational administrative experiment to a nationally endorsed standard.
The analysis indicates that self-attestation significantly reduced compliance costs for service users while simplifying administrative workflows and enabling rapid diffusion across jurisdictions without additional fiscal investment. Official estimates suggest substantial aggregate savings in notarial expenses and citizen time, underscoring the policy’s scalability and distributive impact. More broadly, the findings demonstrate that frugality in public policy need not be limited to technological solutions; it can also emerge through strategic process simplification and trust-based institutional design.
The paper concludes that self-attestation offers an instructive example of frugal policy innovation with relevance beyond India, highlighting the potential of low-cost administrative reforms to enhance state capacity and citizen accessibility simultaneously.
Keywords: Public Administration, Innovation, Infrastructure, Accountability, Accessibility
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Governments are often faced by policy problems marked by uncertainty, ambiguity, and the prospect of multiple possible futures. This paper examines how governments respond to such conditions by adopting different routes and tools for policy design, rather than relying on a single optimal approach. While some forms of uncertainty can be addressed through information gathering and model‑based analysis, others involve unpredictable system dynamics or contested interpretations that cannot be resolved through additional knowledge alone. In response, governments deploy a diverse repertoire of policy approaches, ranging from “high cost” anticipatory planning and robustness‑oriented designs to more frugal adaptive, experimental, and incremental strategies that evolve over time. The choice among these routes reflects not only the nature of the policy problem, but also institutional capacities, resource constraints, and prevailing governance traditions. In some settings, adaptiveness is pursued through formal mechanisms such as monitoring, review, and pre‑specified adjustments, while in others it emerges through frugal, learning‑by‑doing approaches that prioritise flexibility and responsiveness. The paper highlights the trade‑offs inherent in these strategies, particularly between commitment and flexibility in the face of long‑term transitions.
We study the case of green hydrogen mission in India to analyse how the union government in India addresses technological, economic, and geopolitical uncertainties involved in the creation of the hydrogen ecosystem and the realization of the objectives of this mission. Initial findings suggest that while the government is continuously adapting to the changing environment, its approach diverges from the approach of adaptive policymaking. Instead, it is better characterized as “muddling through”: a rational, low-cost strategy of governing uncertainty through successive limited comparisons than comprehensive design.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Authors and Affiliation: Madhuri Dhariwal, Director (East Zone, Operations), Indus Action; Sanjana Saxena, Sr Manager (East Zone, Operations), Indus Action
Abstract: The construction sector is India’s second-largest source of employment, engaging about 12% of the workforce, amounting to around 7.3 crore workers (PLFS 2023-24). Chhattisgarh reflects a similar situation, with nearly 9.7% of its workforce, i.e. about 22 lakh workers are employed in construction sector (NITI Ayog Report, 2025). Meagre daily wages (Rs. 400 - Rs. 600 per day), along with high levels of migration within and across states, weaken workers’ access to social security and basic support.
To mitigate these vulnerabilities, the Building and Other Construction Workers (BOCW) Acts of 1996, now subsumed under the Social Security Code, 2020, mandate State BOCW Boards to collect a 1% cess on construction costs. This cess is meant to provide social security benefits such as health care, education support, pensions, and other welfare measures for construction workers and their families. However, actual cess collection is far below its potential, leading to limited resources and restricting welfare benefits to only a small portion of the workforce. An analysis of secondary data (fetched from Rajya Sabha Unstarred Question No. 259, 2022) from 2017 to 2022 shows that although Chhattisgarh has registered more than 20 lakh construction workers, its cess collection per worker is only ₹8,728, which is much lower than the national average of ₹17,194. In comparison, states such as Madhya Pradesh and Kerala perform much better in cess collection.
This study examines the reasons behind the gap between the estimated cess potential and the actual cess collected in Chhattisgarh, and suggests practical, low-cost solutions to reduce this gap. Using a mixed-methods approach that includes data analysis, review of existing processes/SOPs and structured interviews with key stakeholders and field officers in Raipur, Durg, Bilaspur and Korba, the study identifies key bottlenecks in the current cess assessment and collection system. It argues that small, low-cost changes in processes can lead to significant improvements in revenue. The study also presents a clear roadmap for administrative reforms that can help bridge the collection gap and strengthen social security coverage for construction workers, both in Chhattisgarh and in other states.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The present paper forefronts frugality as a core strategy that drives policy decisions, implementation, and evaluation in the context of India. The authors – public health practitioners – have drawn insights from programmatic learnings in the course of operationalizing Project Utthan. Utthan is a system-strengthening adolescent health project working in Uttar Pradesh, the state home to India’s largest adolescent population (aged 10-19), with a deep focus in three districts of Barabanki, Bareilly and Sonbhadra. The cornerstone of the project is streamlining convergence of the Rashtriya Kishore Swasthya Karyakram(RKSK), School Health and Wellness Program (SHWP), the Weekly Iron and Folic Acid Supplementation (WIFS) Program, and the District Mental Health Program (DMHP). At the level of policy design, the authors trace the recent history of the adolescent health framework in India, which has inherent components of co-ownership, integrating itself into existing public health structures and leveraging long-trusted service delivery touchpoints. While the model of convergence – here between Health and Education departments – is not novel, the authors propose that it continues to be a deep-rooted challenge since an iterative, design-as-you-go approach is a diminishing space within the development sector. At the level of implementation, the authors assert that praxis is being driven by top-down, pre-determined designs that preclude reflection and context-specificity. Through grounded practice, the authors find that learning levers guide micro inputs, and simple system fixes unlock large gains. Input levers at the district, block, and school levels, though not impacting at scale, serve as learning models to create embedded, sustainable change. Evidence based and field insights are readily accepted by policy makers and implementing officers, as they are cognizant of the need for continuous improvement and are willing to partner with like-minded experts. By applying the learnings of this model of frugal policy innovations, the authors have delivered significant improvement in system capacities of health and education departments to deliver quality information and services to adolescents. By bridging gaps between different stakeholders, concrete improvement in adolescent knowledge, health seeking behavior, and anemia levels among school going adolescents is evident.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The concept of "frugal policy innovation" is known as a response to the governance challenges present in the Global South. These innovations are adaptations to fiscal constraints and inadequate administrative capacity, and are often praised for turning scarcity into efficient, context-specific solutions. However, this paper presents the "other side of the coin" regarding adaptive practices at the last mile of policy delivery in India. We argue that while such innovations are praised for their utility, they frequently mask the deep-seated institutional weaknesses that necessitate them in the first place.
Drawing on Street-Level Bureaucracy theory (Lipsky, 2010) and empirical data across water supply, solid waste and sanitation, education, and electricity sectors. This paper examines "frugal innovation" through the lens of "coping mechanisms" of frontline workers in service delivery sectors. We argue that frontline service delivery actors—workers, supervisors, and managers—often do not innovate out of strategic design, but out of survival necessity. They bear the burden of systemic deficiencies, bridging the gap between ambitious policy targets and the ground realities of resource scarcity through ad-hocism and personal stewardship.
Our findings suggest that while these coping mechanisms ensure the immediate policy implementation, they simultaneously mask the need for systemic reform. By "making do," frontline workers, these innovations alleviate the pressure on the state to address the institutional weakness that create the constraints. Consequently, what is labeled as "innovation" may effectively normalize the permanent austerity and administrative fragility.
While the discourse of frugal innovation has roots in Gandhian philosophy and rural development—where local knowledge meets material constraints—transposing this concept to policy delivery requires caution. We argue that the celebration of frugality must not provide intellectual cover for a deliberate policy design of under-resourcing. This paper concludes by differentiating between genuine innovation that enhances state capacity and the glamorization of ad-hocism that merely hides the lack of it.
Employing a qualitative research design, this study utilizes data gathered from in-depth interviews with frontline actors in the above-mentioned service delivery sectors. The collected qualitative data were then analysed through thematic analysis to identify various themes and insights.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
PM Gati Shakti Initiative: An exemplar case of Frugal Policy Innovation in Infrastructure governance
Globally, infrastructure is a critical multiplier of growth. Studies estimate that India could realise a potential gain of 2.5-3.5 rupees in GDP per rupee spent on infrastructure. However, historically, infrastructure governance in India has often been associated with fragmented planning, asynchronous execution and lack of standardisation. Siloed working across multiple levels of government often resulted in delayed approvals and gridlocks. But in an era of surging aspirations and shrinking resources, Governments are exploring innovative ways to reform infrastructure governance and deliver public services economically and efficiently.
This paper examines India’s PM Gati Shakti initiative (PMGS) as a case of frugal policy innovation, in which institutional reform and technology have been leveraged to bring speed, scale and synergy. Launched in 2021, it adopts a “Whole of Government” approach to enhance multimodal connectivity and ease of living. At the core of PMGS is a shared digital platform on which 58 ministries and departments and 36 states and Union Territories are onboarded. 200 data layers have been integrated, and a comprehensive database of ongoing and planned infrastructure projects across sectors such as railways, highways, waterways, and logistics.
Drawing on qualitative interviews with key informants and documentary analysis, the study finds that PMGS has accelerated more than 340 projects valued at over ₹15 lakh crore. It has contributed to evidence-based decision-making, faster project execution, and improved utilisation of existing infrastructure capacity.
According to the National Council of Applied Economic Research (NCAER), India’s logistics costs have declined to 7.8–8.9 per cent of GDP, down from earlier estimates of 13–14 per cent. Aligned with the National Logistics Policy, PM Gati Shakti is contributing to reduced logistics costs and closing critical infrastructure gaps, reflected in India’s improved 38th rank in the World Bank’s Logistics Performance Index (2023).
Beyond connecting ports, railways, and highways, the platform is increasingly used to identify and bridge gaps in social infrastructure (including healthcare and education) and to support the planning of disaster-resilient infrastructure. Tangible efficiency gains aside, the initiative has fostered greater interagency trust, stronger stakeholder ownership, and improved collaborative federalism.
By directly engaging Union ministries, state governments, and district administrations, it ensures that delays are flagged and accountability is fixed. Many stalled projects in rail, road and irrigation initiatives have been expedited through delivery-driven governance, real-time data and leadership oversight. In combination with the PRAGATI monitoring system, the PMGS platform has created a powerful ecosystem that imparts mission-mode momentum to infrastructure projects.
The study demonstrates that PMGS prioritises institutional alignment and collaboration over expenditure expansion, hallmarks of frugal policy innovation. It addresses systemic inefficiencies rooted in disjointed governance. Instead of creating additional layers of bureaucracy, it focuses on aligning the dataset, skill set, and mindset around clearly defined priorities and targets. PRAGATI and PMGS represent a paradigm shift towards outcome-driven governance.
The initiative offers a replicable governance model for emerging economies grappling with systemic complexities and legacy constraints. Expanding the scope and sustaining the project momentum, however, will require collective effort and continued leadership oversight.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)