Format

NPD07. INTROSPECTING UNIVERSITIES AS A SPACE FOR PUBLIC POLICY STUDIES: REFLECTIONS ON PEDAGOGY AND PRACTICES IN INDIA

Pedagogy
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Kasturi Datta
University of Delhi
Main chair
Smita Agarwal
University of Delhi
Second chair
Rashmi Gopi
University of Delhi
Third chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
Pedagogy
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

The academic discipline of public policy, historically rooted in the United States, has witnessed rapid global expansion over the last three decades. Existing literature suggests that while the demand for policy education is universal, the "standardisation" of the curriculum, which is heavily reliant on microeconomics and quantitative analysis, has created significant pedagogical friction when applied in non-Western contexts (Pal & Clark, 2016). A dominant theme in recent scholarship is the incongruity between Western pedagogical models and the political realities of the "Global South". Western curricula typically presuppose a "thick state"—a governance environment characterised by the rule of law, strong institutions, and formalised bureaucracy. However, scholars like Sony Pellissery argue that in countries like India and China, policy often operates within a "thin state" where formal institutions are weak, and "thick social" networks or informal power structures dictate outcomes (Pellissery, 2013). This disconnect creates a pedagogical crisis. When students in the Global South are taught policy analysis using exclusively Western frameworks, they often graduate ill-equipped to navigate the informal, relational, and often chaotic policy environments of their home countries. Research highlights a critical need for "indigenisation" of the curriculum, replacing generic American case studies with local examples that address specific regional challenges such as the informal economy, colonial legacies, and distinctive state-society relations (El-Taliawi et al., 2021). To bridge this gap, educators are increasingly moving away from purely theoretical instruction toward experiential learning. In Latin America and Asia, there is a push for "decolonising" the syllabus by integrating indigenous knowledge systems and emphasising social justice and equity over pure efficiency. Furthermore, the rise of digital governance has introduced new convergences. Programmes worldwide are now integrating data analytics and e-governance into their syllabi, creating a shared global language of "digital policy" that transcends some, though not all, regional differences. While the structure of public policy degrees is converging globally, the content must diverge to remain relevant. The future of the discipline lies in hybrid models that retain the rigorous analytical tools of the Western tradition but apply them through the lens of local political sociology. Effective teaching in the 21st century requires a shift from merely exporting "best practices" to cultivating "context-specific" problem-solving capabilities. 

 

A central question emerges from this: Can there be more effective and indigenous methods through which public policy as a discipline carves its identity and evolves in public universities? How has pedagogy delivery changed over a period of time and how?  Is the interest in this discipline a homogeneous choice, or does it cater to particular groups?

CALL FOR PAPERS

The panel invites a range of theoretical, analytical and empirical research papers as well as reflective commentaries and evolving critiques from public policy educators based in Indian universities and institutes. The core context of this panel is to understand how university spaces are created and designed to deliver public policy courses. The papers we seek to engage with should be able to engage with some of the following (not exhaustive) indicative questions, substantiated with their particular case studies and experiences in teaching public policy:

 

How have the instructors adapted to the changing needs of this discipline? In the Indian context, there is a surge in public policy schools in the private sector. How to navigate shifting paradigms of market requirements without making it exclusionary? How have new methodologies and technologies impacted public policy as a subdiscipline? Is the structure, curriculum and pedagogy able to map the context of the space it is situated in? How are the curriculum and pedagogy perceived elsewhere, especially in American universities? Is it only perceived as a developing market meant for opening up new opportunities, or does it aid in disseminating knowledge for an equitable world order?  What are the pedagogical approaches being used to incorporate heterodox approaches that can overcome disciplinary boundaries? Are there learning outcomes expected beyond disciplinary foundations? What types of innovations have been tried in assessment, concept building, and application to meet learning requirements? These are some of the indicative queries that this panel seeks to explore.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Understanding the Undergraduate Public Policy Syllabus at the University of Delhi since 2000: Paradigm Shifts in Policy Analysis
Rashmi Gopi (University of Delhi)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The syllabus of Public Policy, like any subject-syllabus, is contextual. It reflects the priorities and perspectives of the academicians, politicians, bureaucrats and the common citizens of that particular context. In the past twenty-five years, Public Policy as a discipline has been trying to establish itself as an independent academic stream, with the scaffolding of parent departments like Public Administration and Political Science dissolving. In these years, at the undergraduate level in the University of Delhi (DU), Public Policy began its journey as a sub-topic in Public Administration or as an optional paper in the third year. It is interesting to note that some policies, like the forest policy and Jawaharlal Nehru Urban Renewal Mission, disappeared from the syllabus, whereas policies like the Right to Education survive various syllabus revisions and restructuring. The public policies on health often found its place in the syllabus. However, the tweaking is unmissable when the National Rural Health Mission silently becomes the National Health Mission, covering both rural and urban health missions. Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MNREGA), Right to Information and Lokpal got included in the syllabus in 2011 to reflect the changing contours of government policies. Similarly, E-governance and the Right to Food Security policies became an integral part of the syllabus in the years between 2013 and 2015. In the latest syllabus restructuring under the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020, policies like Corporate Social Responsibility, NEP 2020, Pradhan Mantri Jan-Dhan Yogana (PMJDY), and Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) got integrated into the public policy syllabus.    

Thus, in tracing Public Policy’s imprints in the DU syllabus, the growth is noticeable but not immensely impressive. The core concerns of pedagogy in the higher educational institutions in India are to enable students connect theory and practice, enhance innovative and critical thinking. Public Policy, as a discipline, is an excellent avenue to foster these qualities in students. It helps students to be aware of various policies of the government. They get the opportunity to unravel the history of policies and analyse the present policy implementation incentives and impediments. However, as teachers and researchers, we observe that Western theories and paradigms dominate the public policy teaching-learning process. Indian scholars most often undertake empirical studies of policies, either as standalone state-level experiences or as comparative studies of a few states. This paper argues that this has created a chasm between the ‘universal’ Western theories in books and scholarly articles on one hand and the ‘contextual, Indian experience on the other hand. There is a need to bridge this gap.

This paper is based on a textual analysis of the DU syllabus in the past twenty-five years. This qualitative endeavour involves reading a text and connecting it with different contexts. This work attempts to bring classroom experiences of reading public policy at the DU. Thus, connecting the syllabus with collective reading and interpretations by the teachers and students. This can act as an insight for academicians and bureaucrats to revisit Public Policy in India.  

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - PEDAGOGY, PRACTICE, AND THE POST-COLONIAL PREDICAMENT: MAPPING THE LANDSCAPE OF PUBLIC POLICY EDUCATION IN INDIA
Kasturi Datta (University of Delhi)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Public policy education in India has been undergoing a paradigmatic shift, transitioning from the traditional, state-centric discipline of public administration to a modern, outcome-oriented framework of public policy. This paper maps the emerging landscape of the discipline, identifying a critical bifurcation between two institutional archetypes: the ‘Technocratic’ approach of new-age private universities and the ‘Political Economy’ approach of traditional public universities. The analysis reveals that while private institutions have successfully adopted global best practices in data analysis using quantitative tools and design thinking, they often suffer from a context deficit, applying Western theoretical models to the complex, informal realities of Indian governance. Conversely, public universities, while grounded in social justice, equity, and constitutional theory, face a skills deficit due to rigid curricula, alignment with the demands of the UPSC competitive examination, and a lack of practice-oriented faculty. There is also a lacuna in developing an interdisciplinary lens to teach public policy, since the standpoint for curriculum design and methodology remains grounded in traditional disciplines in social sciences like Political Science, Economics as well as Management. This study concludes that the future of public policy education in India lies in decolonising its pedagogy and curriculum. This move toward epistemic sovereignty should integrate indigenous ethical frameworks and local case studies with rigorous modern methodologies. A synthesis of the technocratic and the sociological is proposed as the only viable path to creating policy professionals capable of navigating the unique trajectory of Indian democracy.

 

Keywords: Public Policy Education, Decolonisation, Technocracy, Political Economy, Indian Governance, Pedagogy.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Teaching Public Policy as Process: Employing Screenwriting as pedagogy
Harsh Mittal (Birla Institute of Technology and Science)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Through this commentary, I reflect on the pedagogy employed at BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus, over the last three years, to engage undergraduate engineering students with the politics of policymaking and policy implementation in the Indian context. Sharing a broader discontent with mainstream approaches to policy analysis—and with the ways in which dominant policy frameworks are often taught—I discuss the gradual development of a public policy course structured around project work that builds directly on classroom discussion.

Over successive iterations of the course, various basic concepts have been identified that orient students to participate in project work which culminates in the writing of a screenplay on a policy process. Rather than beginning with established policy frameworks, the course introduces public policy as a process: one that unfolds through ideas, institutionalized objects, actors, interest group activity, agency of street-level bureaucrats, institutional rules, and power relations over time. Students are trained to empirically trace a policy process using these concepts through various exercises in class. Working in groups, students first map a policy process through blackboard presentations that seek to apply these concepts to a single case of interest to them. They then translate this analysis into a screenplay by engaging with a specific policy process theory, such as the Multiple Streams approach, Policy Feedback theory, and the Discourse Coalition Framework.

The decision to engage particular theories for specific groups is arrived at through consultation with groups following the blackboard presentations. The aim is not to illustrate theory directly; rather, the exercise—encompassing deliberation over theoretical choice and the staging of policy action—seeks to make the analytical focus, assumptions, and explanatory value of different frameworks explicit. The screenplay typically involves scripting policy action across three to four settings, highlighting interaction, conflict, value differences, and negotiation. While it draws primarily on empirical analysis, it also employs limited elements of fiction where necessary to craft a coherent narrative. The purpose is not creative storytelling per se, but the analytical task of making visible the concepts discussed in class and the assumptions embedded within the chosen theoretical framework.

Reflecting on the above process, the paper engages critically with the premise of an alternative “indigenous” policy theory, to instead explore the potential of recrafting "theories" in the classroom through creative pedagogies. It illustrates how such a collaborative exercise of policy analysis can engage diverse audiences  some of whom are without prior training in the social sciences. In engaging with the panel’s questions, the paper suggests that the evolution of public policy as a discipline in Indian public universities may lie less in the production of new theories and more in pedagogical experimentation responsive to diverse student backgrounds. It argues that interest in public policy emerges when teaching methods allow students to encounter policy as a lived, contested, and evolving process that shapes everyday life, rather than as a settled body of knowledge or even as a settled critique of that knowledge.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Reimagining Undergraduate Public Policy Education in India: A Case-study from University of Delhi
Rituraj Sharma (University of Delhi)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Reimagining Undergraduate Public Policy Education in India: A Case-study from University of Delhi

 

Public universities in India must be understood as crucial institutional sites for imagining, building and furthering public policy capacity, democratic and critical orientation and governance literacy informing about policy discussions and debates. In the last decade, public policy has expanded as a domain in higher education and research, but the pedagogic foundations of policy education, especially at undergraduate level remain insufficiently deliberated and theorised. This paper argues that undergraduate classrooms are not merely preparatory spaces but are decisive-sites where policy imaginaries, normative commitments and analytical competencies of learners are shaped actively. Strengthening undergraduate public policy pedagogy therefore is a strategic imperative for India’s governance ecosystem. Taking the case of an undergraduate course- Sociology and Social Policy offered at University of Delhi, this paper demonstrates how sociological pedagogy enables learners to move towards a deeper engagement with values, inequality, law and implementation, a movement well beyond technocratic, managerial and instrument-driven understanding. This perspective positions the discipline of sociology as a foundational discipline for public policy education in India, particularly important in studying the context/s marked by persistent stratification and uneven welfare outcomes. The course is anchored in interdisciplinary readings that help conceptualise social policy and public policy as a normative and political field. Paul Spicker’s work provides the much needed conceptual base, enabling learners to analyse social policy through principles, values, institutional arrangements and ideological frameworks. Spicker’s emphasis on policy-in-practice is used pedagogically to foreground implementation processes. Similarly Jean Drèze’s analysis of welfare schemes like MGNREGA act as central policy case enabling learners to critically examine rights-based legislation, accountability of state towards its people and also the limits to the delivery of such welfare in India. The course also comprehensively integrates feminist and intersectional perspectives drawing on the works of Amanda Coffey and Tiffany Manuel enabling learners to analyse how public policy differentially impact social groups and how at times exclusions are reproduced even as a result of well thought out, deliberated and crafted policies. Further policy and economy debates informed by Jayati Ghosh’s work help learners to interrogate the relationship between development and inequality, while historical and legal perspectives from the works of Sony Pellissery and Sarbani Sen situates the contemporary policy within India’s historical, legal and especially post-colonial context. Pedagogically, the course design follows an applied approach. Problem-based learning, policy briefs, classroom simulations and field based assessments are used to translate sociological insights within policy-analysis. Students engaged critically with the influence of New Public Management reforms, debates on policy making as the process of statecraft, the role of big data (concerns of surveillance and privacy), evidence-based policy-making and deliberative policy analysis, understanding the complex yet evolving landscape of policy-studies. This paper highlights that universities- particularly large public institutions such as the University of Delhi- are core sites which are indispensable to building an inclusive, reflexive and democratic public policy ecosystem in India. In this process, undergraduate pedagogy acts as an intellectually informed policy-infrastructure rather than just a content delivery mechanism. This informed pedagogy with its ever evolving vocabulary, concepts, method and methodologies addresses the changing requirements of policy landscape thus, plays a decisive role in shaping future policy practitioners, researchers and informed citizens.

 

Keywords: Public policy pedagogy, Undergraduate education, Sociology and social policy, Public university, Policy-in-practice, Intersectionality, Welfare State.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - 'Doing' Public Policy: Insights from Teaching and Curriculum Development for Public Policy Studies in India
Ekta Singh (Dr. B. R. Ambedkar University Delhi)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

‘Doing’ Public Policy: Insights from Teaching and Curriculum Development for Public Policy Studies in India

Dr. Ekta Singh

School of Public Policy and Governance

Dr. B. R. Ambedkar University Delhi (AUD)

Abstract

 

Public Policy has emerged as an increasingly popular and sought after choice among students in Indian universities and also worldwide. Not surprisingly, in recent years several universities and institutes in India have started programmes in public policy. Seen as an ‘umbrella’ field, rather an all-encompassing field of inquiry, a degree in public policy seems to be more prestigious than other interdisciplinary fields of study. As a faculty who has been teaching public policy at post graduate level for over five years in Indian universities space (in two different universities first at Tata Institute of Social Sciences (TISS), Hyderabad Campus and presently at Ambedkar University Delhi) and also involved in curriculum development and course updation for Masters in Public Policy, the paper is a reflective exercise bringing insights from first-hand experience of engaging in teaching and curriculum development for public policy studies in India.

 

Developing content and pedagogy for a field that is widely recognized as market-driven in a social science university setting has had its own challenges in carving an orientation that brings context specific issues of exclusion, marginalization, uncertainty and complexity at the centre stage. First and foremost, it meant confronting the question of positioning public policy studies with respect to other disciplines as a multidisciplinary or an interdisciplinary domain that aspires and claims to break disciplinary silos. In addition concerns for context-sensitivity were ever present especially when emphasizing evidence-based policy analysis. What began as a process of seeking insights from experts both from the field of practice and academia to referring to course structures both within and outside India led us to engage with deeper theoretical questions. The need to allow students to not just study public policy theories which have largely developed and evolved from the West and apply in different contexts, but to appreciate theorization itself as a “process” emerging from varied contexts (Chaudhuri and Thakur, 2017) seemed more relevant for public policy than any other discipline. As a practice-oriented domain, appreciating historical specificity of concepts and theories was seen as foundational. It meant incorporating and emphasizing the need for an ‘ethnographic sensibility’ (Lisa & Zacka, 2017) that allows one to theorize ‘with’ rather than ‘about’ marginalized groups. Some of these issues were critical in course of curriculum development and deciding the bent of the programme.

 

In this backdrop, the paper seeks to highlight insights gained about content and pedagogy in designing public policy curriculum in the Indian setting in an attempt to make it truly interdisciplinary and relevant. More particularly, the paper will shed light on some of the ways in which attempts were made to navigate the complexities through innovative teaching-learning practices to meet learning requirements. Bringing in the voices and perspectives from the field of practice to the classroom, giving students exposure in hands-on learning in different organizations through mandatory internship, and field immersion are some of the ways in which public policy pedagogy has tried to become relevant to the field with the stated goal of imparting both academic rigor and practical knowledge and skills to the students. The paper will also delve into how far the actual delivery is able to align with the design expectations. In addition, voices of the learners based on periodic feedback received from students regarding both curriculum and pedagogy will also be incorporated.

 

Keywords: Teaching, Curriculum development, Pedagogy, Public Policy

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The syllabus of Public Policy, like any subject-syllabus, is contextual. It reflects the priorities and perspectives of the academicians, politicians, bureaucrats and the common citizens of that particular context. In the past twenty-five years, Public Policy as a discipline has been trying to establish itself as an independent academic stream, with the scaffolding of parent departments like Public Administration and Political Science dissolving. In these years, at the undergraduate level in the University of Delhi (DU), Public Policy began its journey as a sub-topic in Public Administration or as an optional paper in the third year. It is interesting to note that some policies, like the forest policy and Jawaharlal Nehru Urban Renewal Mission, disappeared from the syllabus, whereas policies like the Right to Education survive various syllabus revisions and restructuring. The public policies on health often found its place in the syllabus. However, the tweaking is unmissable when the National Rural Health Mission silently becomes the National Health Mission, covering both rural and urban health missions. Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MNREGA), Right to Information and Lokpal got included in the syllabus in 2011 to reflect the changing contours of government policies. Similarly, E-governance and the Right to Food Security policies became an integral part of the syllabus in the years between 2013 and 2015. In the latest syllabus restructuring under the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020, policies like Corporate Social Responsibility, NEP 2020, Pradhan Mantri Jan-Dhan Yogana (PMJDY), and Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) got integrated into the public policy syllabus.    

Thus, in tracing Public Policy’s imprints in the DU syllabus, the growth is noticeable but not immensely impressive. The core concerns of pedagogy in the higher educational institutions in India are to enable students connect theory and practice, enhance innovative and critical thinking. Public Policy, as a discipline, is an excellent avenue to foster these qualities in students. It helps students to be aware of various policies of the government. They get the opportunity to unravel the history of policies and analyse the present policy implementation incentives and impediments. However, as teachers and researchers, we observe that Western theories and paradigms dominate the public policy teaching-learning process. Indian scholars most often undertake empirical studies of policies, either as standalone state-level experiences or as comparative studies of a few states. This paper argues that this has created a chasm between the ‘universal’ Western theories in books and scholarly articles on one hand and the ‘contextual, Indian experience on the other hand. There is a need to bridge this gap.

This paper is based on a textual analysis of the DU syllabus in the past twenty-five years. This qualitative endeavour involves reading a text and connecting it with different contexts. This work attempts to bring classroom experiences of reading public policy at the DU. Thus, connecting the syllabus with collective reading and interpretations by the teachers and students. This can act as an insight for academicians and bureaucrats to revisit Public Policy in India.  

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Public policy education in India has been undergoing a paradigmatic shift, transitioning from the traditional, state-centric discipline of public administration to a modern, outcome-oriented framework of public policy. This paper maps the emerging landscape of the discipline, identifying a critical bifurcation between two institutional archetypes: the ‘Technocratic’ approach of new-age private universities and the ‘Political Economy’ approach of traditional public universities. The analysis reveals that while private institutions have successfully adopted global best practices in data analysis using quantitative tools and design thinking, they often suffer from a context deficit, applying Western theoretical models to the complex, informal realities of Indian governance. Conversely, public universities, while grounded in social justice, equity, and constitutional theory, face a skills deficit due to rigid curricula, alignment with the demands of the UPSC competitive examination, and a lack of practice-oriented faculty. There is also a lacuna in developing an interdisciplinary lens to teach public policy, since the standpoint for curriculum design and methodology remains grounded in traditional disciplines in social sciences like Political Science, Economics as well as Management. This study concludes that the future of public policy education in India lies in decolonising its pedagogy and curriculum. This move toward epistemic sovereignty should integrate indigenous ethical frameworks and local case studies with rigorous modern methodologies. A synthesis of the technocratic and the sociological is proposed as the only viable path to creating policy professionals capable of navigating the unique trajectory of Indian democracy.

 

Keywords: Public Policy Education, Decolonisation, Technocracy, Political Economy, Indian Governance, Pedagogy.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Through this commentary, I reflect on the pedagogy employed at BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus, over the last three years, to engage undergraduate engineering students with the politics of policymaking and policy implementation in the Indian context. Sharing a broader discontent with mainstream approaches to policy analysis—and with the ways in which dominant policy frameworks are often taught—I discuss the gradual development of a public policy course structured around project work that builds directly on classroom discussion.

Over successive iterations of the course, various basic concepts have been identified that orient students to participate in project work which culminates in the writing of a screenplay on a policy process. Rather than beginning with established policy frameworks, the course introduces public policy as a process: one that unfolds through ideas, institutionalized objects, actors, interest group activity, agency of street-level bureaucrats, institutional rules, and power relations over time. Students are trained to empirically trace a policy process using these concepts through various exercises in class. Working in groups, students first map a policy process through blackboard presentations that seek to apply these concepts to a single case of interest to them. They then translate this analysis into a screenplay by engaging with a specific policy process theory, such as the Multiple Streams approach, Policy Feedback theory, and the Discourse Coalition Framework.

The decision to engage particular theories for specific groups is arrived at through consultation with groups following the blackboard presentations. The aim is not to illustrate theory directly; rather, the exercise—encompassing deliberation over theoretical choice and the staging of policy action—seeks to make the analytical focus, assumptions, and explanatory value of different frameworks explicit. The screenplay typically involves scripting policy action across three to four settings, highlighting interaction, conflict, value differences, and negotiation. While it draws primarily on empirical analysis, it also employs limited elements of fiction where necessary to craft a coherent narrative. The purpose is not creative storytelling per se, but the analytical task of making visible the concepts discussed in class and the assumptions embedded within the chosen theoretical framework.

Reflecting on the above process, the paper engages critically with the premise of an alternative “indigenous” policy theory, to instead explore the potential of recrafting "theories" in the classroom through creative pedagogies. It illustrates how such a collaborative exercise of policy analysis can engage diverse audiences  some of whom are without prior training in the social sciences. In engaging with the panel’s questions, the paper suggests that the evolution of public policy as a discipline in Indian public universities may lie less in the production of new theories and more in pedagogical experimentation responsive to diverse student backgrounds. It argues that interest in public policy emerges when teaching methods allow students to encounter policy as a lived, contested, and evolving process that shapes everyday life, rather than as a settled body of knowledge or even as a settled critique of that knowledge.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Reimagining Undergraduate Public Policy Education in India: A Case-study from University of Delhi

 

Public universities in India must be understood as crucial institutional sites for imagining, building and furthering public policy capacity, democratic and critical orientation and governance literacy informing about policy discussions and debates. In the last decade, public policy has expanded as a domain in higher education and research, but the pedagogic foundations of policy education, especially at undergraduate level remain insufficiently deliberated and theorised. This paper argues that undergraduate classrooms are not merely preparatory spaces but are decisive-sites where policy imaginaries, normative commitments and analytical competencies of learners are shaped actively. Strengthening undergraduate public policy pedagogy therefore is a strategic imperative for India’s governance ecosystem. Taking the case of an undergraduate course- Sociology and Social Policy offered at University of Delhi, this paper demonstrates how sociological pedagogy enables learners to move towards a deeper engagement with values, inequality, law and implementation, a movement well beyond technocratic, managerial and instrument-driven understanding. This perspective positions the discipline of sociology as a foundational discipline for public policy education in India, particularly important in studying the context/s marked by persistent stratification and uneven welfare outcomes. The course is anchored in interdisciplinary readings that help conceptualise social policy and public policy as a normative and political field. Paul Spicker’s work provides the much needed conceptual base, enabling learners to analyse social policy through principles, values, institutional arrangements and ideological frameworks. Spicker’s emphasis on policy-in-practice is used pedagogically to foreground implementation processes. Similarly Jean Drèze’s analysis of welfare schemes like MGNREGA act as central policy case enabling learners to critically examine rights-based legislation, accountability of state towards its people and also the limits to the delivery of such welfare in India. The course also comprehensively integrates feminist and intersectional perspectives drawing on the works of Amanda Coffey and Tiffany Manuel enabling learners to analyse how public policy differentially impact social groups and how at times exclusions are reproduced even as a result of well thought out, deliberated and crafted policies. Further policy and economy debates informed by Jayati Ghosh’s work help learners to interrogate the relationship between development and inequality, while historical and legal perspectives from the works of Sony Pellissery and Sarbani Sen situates the contemporary policy within India’s historical, legal and especially post-colonial context. Pedagogically, the course design follows an applied approach. Problem-based learning, policy briefs, classroom simulations and field based assessments are used to translate sociological insights within policy-analysis. Students engaged critically with the influence of New Public Management reforms, debates on policy making as the process of statecraft, the role of big data (concerns of surveillance and privacy), evidence-based policy-making and deliberative policy analysis, understanding the complex yet evolving landscape of policy-studies. This paper highlights that universities- particularly large public institutions such as the University of Delhi- are core sites which are indispensable to building an inclusive, reflexive and democratic public policy ecosystem in India. In this process, undergraduate pedagogy acts as an intellectually informed policy-infrastructure rather than just a content delivery mechanism. This informed pedagogy with its ever evolving vocabulary, concepts, method and methodologies addresses the changing requirements of policy landscape thus, plays a decisive role in shaping future policy practitioners, researchers and informed citizens.

 

Keywords: Public policy pedagogy, Undergraduate education, Sociology and social policy, Public university, Policy-in-practice, Intersectionality, Welfare State.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

‘Doing’ Public Policy: Insights from Teaching and Curriculum Development for Public Policy Studies in India

Dr. Ekta Singh

School of Public Policy and Governance

Dr. B. R. Ambedkar University Delhi (AUD)

Abstract

 

Public Policy has emerged as an increasingly popular and sought after choice among students in Indian universities and also worldwide. Not surprisingly, in recent years several universities and institutes in India have started programmes in public policy. Seen as an ‘umbrella’ field, rather an all-encompassing field of inquiry, a degree in public policy seems to be more prestigious than other interdisciplinary fields of study. As a faculty who has been teaching public policy at post graduate level for over five years in Indian universities space (in two different universities first at Tata Institute of Social Sciences (TISS), Hyderabad Campus and presently at Ambedkar University Delhi) and also involved in curriculum development and course updation for Masters in Public Policy, the paper is a reflective exercise bringing insights from first-hand experience of engaging in teaching and curriculum development for public policy studies in India.

 

Developing content and pedagogy for a field that is widely recognized as market-driven in a social science university setting has had its own challenges in carving an orientation that brings context specific issues of exclusion, marginalization, uncertainty and complexity at the centre stage. First and foremost, it meant confronting the question of positioning public policy studies with respect to other disciplines as a multidisciplinary or an interdisciplinary domain that aspires and claims to break disciplinary silos. In addition concerns for context-sensitivity were ever present especially when emphasizing evidence-based policy analysis. What began as a process of seeking insights from experts both from the field of practice and academia to referring to course structures both within and outside India led us to engage with deeper theoretical questions. The need to allow students to not just study public policy theories which have largely developed and evolved from the West and apply in different contexts, but to appreciate theorization itself as a “process” emerging from varied contexts (Chaudhuri and Thakur, 2017) seemed more relevant for public policy than any other discipline. As a practice-oriented domain, appreciating historical specificity of concepts and theories was seen as foundational. It meant incorporating and emphasizing the need for an ‘ethnographic sensibility’ (Lisa & Zacka, 2017) that allows one to theorize ‘with’ rather than ‘about’ marginalized groups. Some of these issues were critical in course of curriculum development and deciding the bent of the programme.

 

In this backdrop, the paper seeks to highlight insights gained about content and pedagogy in designing public policy curriculum in the Indian setting in an attempt to make it truly interdisciplinary and relevant. More particularly, the paper will shed light on some of the ways in which attempts were made to navigate the complexities through innovative teaching-learning practices to meet learning requirements. Bringing in the voices and perspectives from the field of practice to the classroom, giving students exposure in hands-on learning in different organizations through mandatory internship, and field immersion are some of the ways in which public policy pedagogy has tried to become relevant to the field with the stated goal of imparting both academic rigor and practical knowledge and skills to the students. The paper will also delve into how far the actual delivery is able to align with the design expectations. In addition, voices of the learners based on periodic feedback received from students regarding both curriculum and pedagogy will also be incorporated.

 

Keywords: Teaching, Curriculum development, Pedagogy, Public Policy