Format

PR00. Public policy praxis in India

Practice
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Shreya Shree
National Law School of India University
Main chair
Devyani Pande
National Law School of India University
Second chair
Srikrishna Ayyangar
Third chair
Manpreet Dhillon
National Law School of India University
Fourth chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
Practice
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Public policy praxis—the knowledge derived from practice and reflection—is transforming governance across developing economies. In India, this transformation is visible through the exponential growth of policy education programs, research institutions, and a vast industry of policy practice that spans government, consulting, and civil society. Yet, this expansion unfolds amidst technological, administrative, ecological, and political shifts that challenge existing legal and policy frameworks.

Developing economies are now key laboratories for governance innovation. From AI-enabled service delivery to local-level participatory experiments, these contexts highlight how governance capacity, institutional coherence, and policy equity must evolve together. The conference invites reflection on how public policy praxis can help bridge theory and action, regulation and innovation, and local and global approaches to policymaking.

We aim to foster dialogue between academia, practitioners, and policymakers to explore how developing economies can build coherence and capacity to meet future challenges in governance, technology, and sustainability.

 

CALL FOR PAPERS

This panel will focus on scholarship addressing the governance challenges of developing economies. Papers and panels will explore methodological innovations in studying law–policy intersections, comparative governance in the Global South, and the role of interdisciplinary frameworks. Key themes include technological governance, digital inequality, climate change, urban transformation, and human rights in digital spaces. The research track will highlight how developing economies are not only case studies but also producers of theoretical insights that can shape global debates.

Some illustrative questions could include the following:

  • What are the challenges to policymaking for sustainability in India and how can they be addressed?
  • How do law and policy interact in the face of uncertainty?
  • What are the emerging policy issues within sectors that require further research? What lessons can be drawn from comparative studies of governance in the Global South?
  • What has been the impact of networks and actors on governance?
  • How can developing economies balance innovation and regulation in policymaking?
  • What are some new concepts and methodologies that are relevant to public policy research in India?
  •  
ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Law, Policy, and Discretion: Rethinking Welfare Governance in India
Anurag Shukla (Tata Institute of Social Sciences)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The current approach of Indian policymakers is to launch large-scale programs with a far-reaching welfare architecture. However, these often lack justiciability due to weak or partial rights-based legal enforceability. In practice, schemes such as Direct Benefit Transfers (DBT), MGNREGA (now renamed as G RAM-G), PM-KISAN, and the reformed Public Distribution System (PDS) rely on executive discretion, shifting the primary focus towards digital infrastructures and administrative routines rather than legal entitlements. From this backdrop, the paper deliberately focuses on a counterintuitive question: why do welfare delivery programs in India function as instruments of rules rather than being justiciable rights? Moreover, how does this arrangement impact state capacity and governance in India, including its evaluation criteria? By investigating this question, the research aims to gain insights into the effectiveness of policy in India, focusing on a layered system where law, policy, technology, and administrative prerogative interact in complex ways, leading to subsidy delivery at scale through schemes and programs that operate via executive notifications, scheme guidelines, and digital authentication protocols instead of statute-based entitlements. This question becomes even more pertinent when the aforementioned restructuring is readily apparent across schemes and programs. The PDS's disassociation with the National Food Security Act and its everyday functioning governed by state-level rules, dealer discretion, and administrative enforcement rather than litigation, is one such example. Similarly, PM-KISAN is an executive scheme without a rights-based statutory framework, yet it enjoys political legitimacy and continuity across governments, shaping electoral outcomes. Additionally, MGNREGA, often cited as a rights-based program, reveals the limits of judicial enforcement in practice. The research contends that in these instances, courts intervene sporadically rather than systematically, functioning merely as boundary actors instead of primary enforcers. To study this paradox of legal entitlement versus informal rules, the paper employs a conceptual comparative analysis that situates this paradox in both Western democratic contexts and contexts like India. The study relies on secondary sources, drawing exclusively from existing government reports, policy documents, and independently published datasets. The research study contributes to the existing understanding of the policy implementation paradox in four ways: analyzing entitlement versus discretion, examining judicial precedents in welfare adjudication, governing administrative law within executive schemes, and, lastly, mapping the gray zones between legality and legitimacy.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - The process of drafting a policy document on tourism in Ladakh
PADMA RIGZIN (Shiv Nadar University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In this presentation, I dwell on the process of making a tourism policy by local NGOs in Ladakh and how this process intersects with policy praxis and what the broader implications this has on the relationship between academic research and on-ground practice. The tourism policy in question is tentatively titled the People's Charter for Tourism in Ladakh and is still in the process of being made. I am the lead author of the document, and I have been associated with the Ladakh chapter of Local Futures, an NGO, since 2019. Local Futures, along with two other local NGOs, namely Snow Leopard Conservancy-India Trust and Ladakh Arts and Media Organisation, have been working on the People’s Charter for the last five years to produce a tourism vision that is different from the state’s tourism policy, like the Tourism Vision Document for Ladakh. The presentation will focus on two dimensions of tourism policy-making and the ethical questions they raise. The first is related to the anxiety of producing a 'genuinely’ community-based policy document. In the meetings among the three NGOs, the members stress the need for more stakeholder engagement. They suggested that the drafting team needs to have more consultative meetings with different villagers, tourism stakeholders, monastic communities, students/youth, women's organisations, religious groups and varied regional representatives, so that the People’s Charter for Tourism in Ladakh genuinely becomes a people’s charter. The question that emerges here, then, is how much engagement is enough to make a particular policy document people’s. The second aspect that this presentation addresses is related to the question of appropriation by the state apparatus. The People’s Charter deals with multiple pluriversal knowledges that are completely missing in state tourism policies, such as the new expanded version of commons by including milam (tradition trails), ralam (livestock trails), uru (gravity-driven water channels), and chumik (water springs). Once pluriversal knowledges are out in the policy document or in the public domain, it becomes available for the state to appropriate and incorporate into its bureaucratic mechanisms. This throws an ethical question around the issue of visiblising pluriversal knowledges. Is the work ofthe practitioner-researcher about showing pluriversal knowledges to the state so that it could be appropriated? By engaging with the two dimensions, I dwell on the details of policy praxis in the Himalayan context. 

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - The Journey to Agentic Governance: Synthesizing Practice and Reflection in the Design of Behavioral AI for the Global South
Siddharth Singh (Indian School of Business)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Public policy praxis—the knowledge synthesized from the iterative cycle of practice and reflection—is fundamentally transforming governance within developing economies. As India emerges as a primary laboratory for technological innovation, there is a critical need to bridge the gap between algorithmic design and the behavioral realities of administrative systems. This paper, submitted under the Practice track, chronicles a practitioner’s journey in building and deploying Behavioral Human-Centered AI (BHCAI) Agents within the Aadhaar-enabled Public Distribution System (AePDS). It reflects on the transition from building a startup focused on Agentic solutions to developing a reflective methodology for public sector efficiency.

 

Traditional Information Systems (IS) in the public sector have historically prioritized digitization and fraud mitigation through biometric identification. However, this "tech-first" approach often ignores the "sludge"—the administrative friction and cognitive load—that impedes last-mile delivery. This research explores a shift toward Agentic workflows capable of capturing and reasoning with human behavioral traits embedded in transactional program data. By viewing AI agents as "choice architects" rather than mere automation tools, the study demonstrates how the "Return on AI" in governance is optimized when systems align with the mental models of both administrators and beneficiaries.

 

Reflections on the Praxis Journey: Drawing from the friction of field implementation, the paper identifies several critical reflective pillars, including;

 

1. Decoding Temporal Behavioral Surges: Analysis of millions of transactions revealed that 85% of biometric authentications are concentrated within the first fifteen days of the month, with significant surges during peak morning hours (10:00 AM to 1:00 PM). These behavioral patterns often lead to server-side latency and system-induced exclusion. The BHCAI agents were architected to autonomously manage these surges, providing predictive nudges to local administrators to redistribute traffic and mitigate "sludge" during high-stress windows.

 

2.Bridging the Trust-Technological Gap: Reflection on field data showed that high-tech modalities, such as Iris-based authentication, often yielded higher practical failure rates (>2%) compared to theoretical benchmarks, while OTP errors accounted for nearly half of transaction failures in certain regions. This led to an architectural pivot toward "Trust-Centered AI," where agents prioritize explainable contingency paths, ensuring that technical friction does not translate into the denial of food security rights.

 

3.Empowering Decision-Makers through Agentic Reasoning: By transforming fragmented data into high-fidelity behavioral insights, the agents empower policy-makers to move beyond retrospective monitoring toward proactive intervention. This allows for the classification of vulnerable households requiring targeted support, thereby enhancing institutional coherence.


By synthesizing behavioral science with Agentic governance, this work offers a novel methodology for public policy research in India. It argues that the future of the digital state lies in "Behavioral Human-Centered AI"—a system that accounts for human behavior to ensure inclusive, equitable, and efficient state delivery in the Global South.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Public Policy Praxis in India: Case Studies in Law, Technology, and Institutional Learning
D.V.V Raj (Intellect Juris Law Offices)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Policy making in the public domain of developing countries is generally measured with ready-made models and with greater emphasis placed on policy design and formal legal frameworks. But they also tend to obscure how policy is made, through implementation, contestation and institutional change. In such settings like those of India, public policy does not simply exist in the texts of policies; it is a product of continued interaction with social constraints, technological limits and administrative capabilities. This paper addresses these dynamics in terms of public policy praxis as the knowledge developed through practice and reflection.

The paper contends that in India, iterative processes of implementation, contestation, and institutional learning have a greater influence on public policy outcomes than formal legislative design. Using a socio-legal and institutional lens, the paper examines three contemporary policy sites in India: The Aadhaar digital identity program; expansion of digital service delivery platforms; and regulatory experimentation in the FinTech sector. These instances are chosen because they are policy domains located at the intersection of law, technology and governance and where policy results have been heavily influenced by implementation experience, rather than original design vis-à-vis technology.

The Aadhaar project demonstrates how the policy logic of efficiency and welfare targeting ran into a set of complicated problems driven by exclusion, privacy, and accountability as it exponentially scaled up across heterogeneous populations. Both the legal and policy structure of the system were later re-cast by judicial intervention and administrative recalibration, revealing how rights-driven considerations actually emerged through “doing” rather than high-level visioning. The introduction of digital service delivery under the rubric of Digital India also suggests how technological solutions to transparency and improved access may simply re-entrench extant inequalities whether digital-literacy, infrastructure or regional administrative capacities based. The institutional responses such as the assisted service devices and partial design changes- are indicative of its learning process in governance.

The paper also explores India’s policy towards regulation of FinTech where regulators have resorted to responsive instruments like regulatory sandboxes. Instead of predetermining rigid ex ante rules, this approach permits regulatory structures to be altered over time in response to market dynamics, technological innovation, and consumer effects, in line with a practice-oriented model of policy making that draws on learning by doing and institutional coordination.

By viewing policy-making in the Global South as a place of governance learning and adaptation rather than departure from idealized policy models, the paper advances socio-legal scholarship. Between them, these cases demonstrate that public policy in India is a dynamic, evolving process which involves law interacting with administration, technology and society.

The paper also questions linear models of policy-making and emphasizes the need for adaptive, context-specific governance in the Global South, which would allow developing economies to emerge as actors from which we can learn about what kinds of policies work where and under what circumstances.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Practising Groundwater Governance: Learning from the Implementation of the Atal Bhujal Yojana in India
Zahra Afreen (WELL Labs, India)
CO-AUTHORS
Aditya Jain (WELL LABS)
ABSTRACT

Groundwater governance in India requires sustained behavioural change across communities, administrative systems, and sectoral institutions. As the world’s largest user of groundwater, India depends heavily on this invisible and privately extracted resource for irrigation, drinking water, and urban supply, yet governance remains fragmented across sectors and levels of the state. The Atal Bhujal Yojana (ABY), launched in 2020-21, is India’s largest national programme focused explicitly on groundwater governance. Covering 229 of the most groundwater-stressed blocks across seven states, ABY represents a major experiment in institutional design, using incentive-linked financing to influence planning, coordination, and water-use behaviour through a Programme-for-Results framework.

This paper draws on a learning-focused qualitative study of ABY’s implementation to examine how institutional design translates into governance practice. Rather than assessing hydrological outcomes, the study foregrounds public policy praxis by analysing how behavioural assumptions embedded in policy instruments play out on the ground. The analysis focuses on three interlinked Disbursement-Linked Indicators. DLI-2 incentivises community-led Water Security Plans. DLI-3 seeks to reshape administrative behaviour through the convergence of public finance across line departments. DLI-4 promotes the adoption of water-efficient practices among water users.

The study is based on fieldwork across selected gram panchayats in Karnataka, Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, and Haryana. Data were collected through key informant interviews (KIIs), focus group discussions (FGDs), and journey-mapping exercises tracing planning and implementation processes, and triangulated with programme dashboards, Water Security Plans, and administrative records.

Findings show that DLI-2 helped institutionalise participatory planning as a governance practice. Water Security Plans were effective in mobilising communities and reframing groundwater as a shared resource, though the depth of participation depended heavily on facilitation quality and institutional support. DLI-3 created a formal architecture for convergence, but behavioural change within the administrative system was uneven. Effective coordination required alignment of planning cycles, clear leadership signals, and mechanisms to overcome entrenched departmental silos. DLI-4 contributed to shifts in on-farm practices where incentives, awareness, and local facilitation aligned, but adoption remained difficult to sustain without continued engagement.

Taken together, the experience of ABY shows that behavioural change in groundwater governance cannot be achieved through isolated instruments. Outcomes depend on the coherence of institutional design and the quality of mediation between communities, administrators, and water users. By drawing lessons from implementation rather than outcomes alone, the paper contributes to debates on public policy praxis in developing economies, highlighting how large-scale sustainability programmes generate critical knowledge through practice, iteration, and learning.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Beyond One Size Fits All: Rethinking Urban Governance through a Differentiated Approach
Priyanka Tibrewal (Janaagraha Centre for Citizenship and Democracy)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The 2011 Census classified India to be 31% urban based on statutory definitions, with this population distributed across million-plus cities, >100k cities and <100k cities, each hosting approximately one-third of India’s urban population. Despite this numerical parity, they have diverse characteristics in terms of demographics, jobs and employment sectors and therefore, potential for economic growth, their infrastructure requirements and capacities, and resources of their local governments. Yet, these cities are frequently constrained by a “one-size-fits-all” governance paradigm, subjected to similar legislations and standardised funding schemes.  


Janaagraha’s ASICS 2023 finds that India has a unique spatial pattern of urbanisation with 50% of India’s urban population living within 60km of 45 million-plus cities and 92% within 60km of 470 100k-plus cities. There is a need to leverage this clustering for agglomeration economies, shared infrastructure and services, and state capacities without viewing cities as 4,000+ distinct units for building capacities and infrastructure. 


The 74th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1992 establishes municipal corporations, municipalities and town panchayats. While some state governments have attempted institutional differentiation by classifying or grading urban local governments within the 74th CAA framework, it struggles to effectively respond to the complexity and scale of urbanisation. Outside this framework, exists the million-plus and >100k cities.  


Even though the Constitution mandates the formation of Metropolitan Planning Committees (MPCs) to coordinate planning in million-plus cities, only 3 of the 13 states audited by the CAG had constituted MPCs of which none were functional. Moreover, its primary role as a planning body is insufficient to address governance and coordination challenges that arise in such large urban areas. Smaller towns, especially those transitioning from rural to urban, face resource constraints, limited skilled personnel and inadequate institutional frameworks to support such transitions. Thus, it becomes imperative to explore differentiated urban governance models that are tailored for the city.  

 

This study argues that the uniform application of laws and policies across varied urban context critically undermines effective urban development and governance, particularly for urban areas that fall outside existing the constitutional framework. In this light, it will look at India’s metropolitan cities which require distinct governance mechanisms to plan, coordinate and deliver services across the region. Second, it will identify how transitioning towns and settlements require financial and human resources, and targeted institutional support.  

 

The methodology for the study would combine comparative case studies and secondary research. Comparative case studies from India, South Africa, Southeast Asia and other regions of the Global South will inform innovative and best practices for India. Secondary research will include policies, government reports and academic literature on differentiated urban governance.  

 

This study will explore governance structures and pathways for differentiated approaches to urban governance and highlighting the limitations of current standardised practices. By analysing financial & human resources, and institutional factors, this study intends to determine how nuanced, city-specific frameworks would help address the challenges of urbanisation in a systemic and sustainable manner. 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The current approach of Indian policymakers is to launch large-scale programs with a far-reaching welfare architecture. However, these often lack justiciability due to weak or partial rights-based legal enforceability. In practice, schemes such as Direct Benefit Transfers (DBT), MGNREGA (now renamed as G RAM-G), PM-KISAN, and the reformed Public Distribution System (PDS) rely on executive discretion, shifting the primary focus towards digital infrastructures and administrative routines rather than legal entitlements. From this backdrop, the paper deliberately focuses on a counterintuitive question: why do welfare delivery programs in India function as instruments of rules rather than being justiciable rights? Moreover, how does this arrangement impact state capacity and governance in India, including its evaluation criteria? By investigating this question, the research aims to gain insights into the effectiveness of policy in India, focusing on a layered system where law, policy, technology, and administrative prerogative interact in complex ways, leading to subsidy delivery at scale through schemes and programs that operate via executive notifications, scheme guidelines, and digital authentication protocols instead of statute-based entitlements. This question becomes even more pertinent when the aforementioned restructuring is readily apparent across schemes and programs. The PDS's disassociation with the National Food Security Act and its everyday functioning governed by state-level rules, dealer discretion, and administrative enforcement rather than litigation, is one such example. Similarly, PM-KISAN is an executive scheme without a rights-based statutory framework, yet it enjoys political legitimacy and continuity across governments, shaping electoral outcomes. Additionally, MGNREGA, often cited as a rights-based program, reveals the limits of judicial enforcement in practice. The research contends that in these instances, courts intervene sporadically rather than systematically, functioning merely as boundary actors instead of primary enforcers. To study this paradox of legal entitlement versus informal rules, the paper employs a conceptual comparative analysis that situates this paradox in both Western democratic contexts and contexts like India. The study relies on secondary sources, drawing exclusively from existing government reports, policy documents, and independently published datasets. The research study contributes to the existing understanding of the policy implementation paradox in four ways: analyzing entitlement versus discretion, examining judicial precedents in welfare adjudication, governing administrative law within executive schemes, and, lastly, mapping the gray zones between legality and legitimacy.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In this presentation, I dwell on the process of making a tourism policy by local NGOs in Ladakh and how this process intersects with policy praxis and what the broader implications this has on the relationship between academic research and on-ground practice. The tourism policy in question is tentatively titled the People's Charter for Tourism in Ladakh and is still in the process of being made. I am the lead author of the document, and I have been associated with the Ladakh chapter of Local Futures, an NGO, since 2019. Local Futures, along with two other local NGOs, namely Snow Leopard Conservancy-India Trust and Ladakh Arts and Media Organisation, have been working on the People’s Charter for the last five years to produce a tourism vision that is different from the state’s tourism policy, like the Tourism Vision Document for Ladakh. The presentation will focus on two dimensions of tourism policy-making and the ethical questions they raise. The first is related to the anxiety of producing a 'genuinely’ community-based policy document. In the meetings among the three NGOs, the members stress the need for more stakeholder engagement. They suggested that the drafting team needs to have more consultative meetings with different villagers, tourism stakeholders, monastic communities, students/youth, women's organisations, religious groups and varied regional representatives, so that the People’s Charter for Tourism in Ladakh genuinely becomes a people’s charter. The question that emerges here, then, is how much engagement is enough to make a particular policy document people’s. The second aspect that this presentation addresses is related to the question of appropriation by the state apparatus. The People’s Charter deals with multiple pluriversal knowledges that are completely missing in state tourism policies, such as the new expanded version of commons by including milam (tradition trails), ralam (livestock trails), uru (gravity-driven water channels), and chumik (water springs). Once pluriversal knowledges are out in the policy document or in the public domain, it becomes available for the state to appropriate and incorporate into its bureaucratic mechanisms. This throws an ethical question around the issue of visiblising pluriversal knowledges. Is the work ofthe practitioner-researcher about showing pluriversal knowledges to the state so that it could be appropriated? By engaging with the two dimensions, I dwell on the details of policy praxis in the Himalayan context. 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Public policy praxis—the knowledge synthesized from the iterative cycle of practice and reflection—is fundamentally transforming governance within developing economies. As India emerges as a primary laboratory for technological innovation, there is a critical need to bridge the gap between algorithmic design and the behavioral realities of administrative systems. This paper, submitted under the Practice track, chronicles a practitioner’s journey in building and deploying Behavioral Human-Centered AI (BHCAI) Agents within the Aadhaar-enabled Public Distribution System (AePDS). It reflects on the transition from building a startup focused on Agentic solutions to developing a reflective methodology for public sector efficiency.

 

Traditional Information Systems (IS) in the public sector have historically prioritized digitization and fraud mitigation through biometric identification. However, this "tech-first" approach often ignores the "sludge"—the administrative friction and cognitive load—that impedes last-mile delivery. This research explores a shift toward Agentic workflows capable of capturing and reasoning with human behavioral traits embedded in transactional program data. By viewing AI agents as "choice architects" rather than mere automation tools, the study demonstrates how the "Return on AI" in governance is optimized when systems align with the mental models of both administrators and beneficiaries.

 

Reflections on the Praxis Journey: Drawing from the friction of field implementation, the paper identifies several critical reflective pillars, including;

 

1. Decoding Temporal Behavioral Surges: Analysis of millions of transactions revealed that 85% of biometric authentications are concentrated within the first fifteen days of the month, with significant surges during peak morning hours (10:00 AM to 1:00 PM). These behavioral patterns often lead to server-side latency and system-induced exclusion. The BHCAI agents were architected to autonomously manage these surges, providing predictive nudges to local administrators to redistribute traffic and mitigate "sludge" during high-stress windows.

 

2.Bridging the Trust-Technological Gap: Reflection on field data showed that high-tech modalities, such as Iris-based authentication, often yielded higher practical failure rates (>2%) compared to theoretical benchmarks, while OTP errors accounted for nearly half of transaction failures in certain regions. This led to an architectural pivot toward "Trust-Centered AI," where agents prioritize explainable contingency paths, ensuring that technical friction does not translate into the denial of food security rights.

 

3.Empowering Decision-Makers through Agentic Reasoning: By transforming fragmented data into high-fidelity behavioral insights, the agents empower policy-makers to move beyond retrospective monitoring toward proactive intervention. This allows for the classification of vulnerable households requiring targeted support, thereby enhancing institutional coherence.


By synthesizing behavioral science with Agentic governance, this work offers a novel methodology for public policy research in India. It argues that the future of the digital state lies in "Behavioral Human-Centered AI"—a system that accounts for human behavior to ensure inclusive, equitable, and efficient state delivery in the Global South.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Policy making in the public domain of developing countries is generally measured with ready-made models and with greater emphasis placed on policy design and formal legal frameworks. But they also tend to obscure how policy is made, through implementation, contestation and institutional change. In such settings like those of India, public policy does not simply exist in the texts of policies; it is a product of continued interaction with social constraints, technological limits and administrative capabilities. This paper addresses these dynamics in terms of public policy praxis as the knowledge developed through practice and reflection.

The paper contends that in India, iterative processes of implementation, contestation, and institutional learning have a greater influence on public policy outcomes than formal legislative design. Using a socio-legal and institutional lens, the paper examines three contemporary policy sites in India: The Aadhaar digital identity program; expansion of digital service delivery platforms; and regulatory experimentation in the FinTech sector. These instances are chosen because they are policy domains located at the intersection of law, technology and governance and where policy results have been heavily influenced by implementation experience, rather than original design vis-à-vis technology.

The Aadhaar project demonstrates how the policy logic of efficiency and welfare targeting ran into a set of complicated problems driven by exclusion, privacy, and accountability as it exponentially scaled up across heterogeneous populations. Both the legal and policy structure of the system were later re-cast by judicial intervention and administrative recalibration, revealing how rights-driven considerations actually emerged through “doing” rather than high-level visioning. The introduction of digital service delivery under the rubric of Digital India also suggests how technological solutions to transparency and improved access may simply re-entrench extant inequalities whether digital-literacy, infrastructure or regional administrative capacities based. The institutional responses such as the assisted service devices and partial design changes- are indicative of its learning process in governance.

The paper also explores India’s policy towards regulation of FinTech where regulators have resorted to responsive instruments like regulatory sandboxes. Instead of predetermining rigid ex ante rules, this approach permits regulatory structures to be altered over time in response to market dynamics, technological innovation, and consumer effects, in line with a practice-oriented model of policy making that draws on learning by doing and institutional coordination.

By viewing policy-making in the Global South as a place of governance learning and adaptation rather than departure from idealized policy models, the paper advances socio-legal scholarship. Between them, these cases demonstrate that public policy in India is a dynamic, evolving process which involves law interacting with administration, technology and society.

The paper also questions linear models of policy-making and emphasizes the need for adaptive, context-specific governance in the Global South, which would allow developing economies to emerge as actors from which we can learn about what kinds of policies work where and under what circumstances.

CO-AUTHORS
Aditya Jain (WELL LABS)
ABSTRACT

Groundwater governance in India requires sustained behavioural change across communities, administrative systems, and sectoral institutions. As the world’s largest user of groundwater, India depends heavily on this invisible and privately extracted resource for irrigation, drinking water, and urban supply, yet governance remains fragmented across sectors and levels of the state. The Atal Bhujal Yojana (ABY), launched in 2020-21, is India’s largest national programme focused explicitly on groundwater governance. Covering 229 of the most groundwater-stressed blocks across seven states, ABY represents a major experiment in institutional design, using incentive-linked financing to influence planning, coordination, and water-use behaviour through a Programme-for-Results framework.

This paper draws on a learning-focused qualitative study of ABY’s implementation to examine how institutional design translates into governance practice. Rather than assessing hydrological outcomes, the study foregrounds public policy praxis by analysing how behavioural assumptions embedded in policy instruments play out on the ground. The analysis focuses on three interlinked Disbursement-Linked Indicators. DLI-2 incentivises community-led Water Security Plans. DLI-3 seeks to reshape administrative behaviour through the convergence of public finance across line departments. DLI-4 promotes the adoption of water-efficient practices among water users.

The study is based on fieldwork across selected gram panchayats in Karnataka, Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, and Haryana. Data were collected through key informant interviews (KIIs), focus group discussions (FGDs), and journey-mapping exercises tracing planning and implementation processes, and triangulated with programme dashboards, Water Security Plans, and administrative records.

Findings show that DLI-2 helped institutionalise participatory planning as a governance practice. Water Security Plans were effective in mobilising communities and reframing groundwater as a shared resource, though the depth of participation depended heavily on facilitation quality and institutional support. DLI-3 created a formal architecture for convergence, but behavioural change within the administrative system was uneven. Effective coordination required alignment of planning cycles, clear leadership signals, and mechanisms to overcome entrenched departmental silos. DLI-4 contributed to shifts in on-farm practices where incentives, awareness, and local facilitation aligned, but adoption remained difficult to sustain without continued engagement.

Taken together, the experience of ABY shows that behavioural change in groundwater governance cannot be achieved through isolated instruments. Outcomes depend on the coherence of institutional design and the quality of mediation between communities, administrators, and water users. By drawing lessons from implementation rather than outcomes alone, the paper contributes to debates on public policy praxis in developing economies, highlighting how large-scale sustainability programmes generate critical knowledge through practice, iteration, and learning.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The 2011 Census classified India to be 31% urban based on statutory definitions, with this population distributed across million-plus cities, >100k cities and <100k cities, each hosting approximately one-third of India’s urban population. Despite this numerical parity, they have diverse characteristics in terms of demographics, jobs and employment sectors and therefore, potential for economic growth, their infrastructure requirements and capacities, and resources of their local governments. Yet, these cities are frequently constrained by a “one-size-fits-all” governance paradigm, subjected to similar legislations and standardised funding schemes.  


Janaagraha’s ASICS 2023 finds that India has a unique spatial pattern of urbanisation with 50% of India’s urban population living within 60km of 45 million-plus cities and 92% within 60km of 470 100k-plus cities. There is a need to leverage this clustering for agglomeration economies, shared infrastructure and services, and state capacities without viewing cities as 4,000+ distinct units for building capacities and infrastructure. 


The 74th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1992 establishes municipal corporations, municipalities and town panchayats. While some state governments have attempted institutional differentiation by classifying or grading urban local governments within the 74th CAA framework, it struggles to effectively respond to the complexity and scale of urbanisation. Outside this framework, exists the million-plus and >100k cities.  


Even though the Constitution mandates the formation of Metropolitan Planning Committees (MPCs) to coordinate planning in million-plus cities, only 3 of the 13 states audited by the CAG had constituted MPCs of which none were functional. Moreover, its primary role as a planning body is insufficient to address governance and coordination challenges that arise in such large urban areas. Smaller towns, especially those transitioning from rural to urban, face resource constraints, limited skilled personnel and inadequate institutional frameworks to support such transitions. Thus, it becomes imperative to explore differentiated urban governance models that are tailored for the city.  

 

This study argues that the uniform application of laws and policies across varied urban context critically undermines effective urban development and governance, particularly for urban areas that fall outside existing the constitutional framework. In this light, it will look at India’s metropolitan cities which require distinct governance mechanisms to plan, coordinate and deliver services across the region. Second, it will identify how transitioning towns and settlements require financial and human resources, and targeted institutional support.  

 

The methodology for the study would combine comparative case studies and secondary research. Comparative case studies from India, South Africa, Southeast Asia and other regions of the Global South will inform innovative and best practices for India. Secondary research will include policies, government reports and academic literature on differentiated urban governance.  

 

This study will explore governance structures and pathways for differentiated approaches to urban governance and highlighting the limitations of current standardised practices. By analysing financial & human resources, and institutional factors, this study intends to determine how nuanced, city-specific frameworks would help address the challenges of urbanisation in a systemic and sustainable manner.