P10. Governing Complex Problems: Issues of Uncertainty, Time, Scale and Transformation
POLICY DESIGN, POLICY ANALYSIS, EXPERTISE AND EVALUATIONCATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
Although one of the oldest activities of the human race, governance has never been more complex or difficult (Dahlstrom et al. 2011). Governance arrangements effectively determine how decisions are made in society, how resources are distributed, which problems are solved and how, and, to some extent, how various voices are heard. Definitions of governance vary, but many refer to formal and informal rules, the interactions among formal and informal institutions, the political, legal, social, economic and administrative institutions that develop, manage, and distribute societal goods (water, health services, employment benefits, recognize some human rights, and not others) involving public, private, and civil society organizations that practice and implement norms, programmes, regulations, and laws.
21st Century problems are increasingly complex, wicked problems that defy complete definitions, for which there is not always one definite, accepted, immediate or ultimate solution. Often one problem is a symptom of another problem (Rittel and Weber, 1973). Uncertainty, unknown unknowns, and residual risk (the threat remaining after all efforts to identify and eliminate risk have been made) can be a barrier to evidence based policy and decision making. Normative judgments can be involved in these determinations. Risks may vary along spatial scales in relation to both human and natural systems with differing vulnerability and exposure in different areas and communities; Risks may vary in relation to current and future risks (with some events being slow onset, or chronic (drought and migration), some conflicts being covert, and other acute shocks or conflicts (extreme events of fire, flood, or security). Risks may cascade through sectors, regions, countries (such as the financial collapse of 2008, or potential for multi-bread basket failures as a result of ENSO events of drought, civil war) and there will be winners and losers both within and between countries.
The working hypothesis of governance research is that some governance arrangements are better than others at solving the problems facing a society. Traditional governance distinctions have focussed on formal and largely binary institutional structures—e.g., bicameralism versus unicameralism; presidential verses parliamentarism; proportional representation versus plurality. For governance theorists, these macro distinctions are important but no longer sufficient.A new set of distinctions have been including adaptive governance, collaborative cross-scale governance (Bodin 2017), inclusive governance, polycentric governance, multi-level, or global governance. They have been developed in close proximity to the complex problems of risk and uncertainty that they are intended to address. How best to respond to complex problems, what are the best governance arrangements, how these governance arrangements can be assessed and measured, becomes pressing social, academic and political questions. Do specific governance frameworks apply depending on the nature, sector, magnitude or some other feature of the complex problems, or depending on the demands of the citizenry?
Do measures of good governance align with the framework of governance? Are measures of good governance, including procedural, capacity, output measures, or dimensions of corruption, economic, political, democratic, or representative best in relation to the nature of the complex problem? How best can the frameworks and the measures be studied and analyzed?
This panel will explore theoretically and empirically what are the best frameworks of governance, and how governance might be studied, and evaluated.
CALL FOR PAPERS
We welcome submissions of papers that explore theoretically and empirically the best frameworks of governance, in the context of social and policy problems from a variety of sectors, countries, and contexts. Implicit in the determination of the best frameworks is a consideration of the ontological and epistemological underpinnings of the framework, and how this informs the methodology of how one or several frameworks of governance might be studied and assessed. What methods can be used in studying and assessing governance and what methods specifically for studying governance in the context of complex social and political problems in the context of issues of risk (varying over time, scale and level of government) and uncertainty. How might governance be measured and evaluated and what indicators might best inform decision makers about whether good governance has been achieved, or improvements are required? Ultimately how can a solutions space be creating to address complex problems and achieve transformation required to address them?
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Situate within new institutionalism literature, this paper builds a complex system model of institutional analysis for adaptive governance and decision making in the context of deep uncertainty. This model combines Young’s institutional environmental analysis method (2005), elements of subsequent environmental governance models, and ideas of multiple institutional levels and drivers, together with uncertainty science. The model identifies types of decision making for different degrees of uncertainty including complex, chaotic, and knowable causes and effects.
By applying the model, and based on qualitative semi-structured research interviews, policy instruments are identified that build agricultural producer livelihoods improving their adaptive capacity to respond to climate change and drought. In relation to three case studies in Canada, Chile, and Argentina, policy instruments that deliver co benefits to improve agricultural producer technological, social, human, economic, and natural capital include crop insurance, income stabilization instruments, farm water infrastructure grants, environmental farm planning (improving soil management), drought predictions and alerts, and watershed management plans. this paper identifies the logic and decision making surrounding each policy instrument in the context of uncertainty. This exploration of uncertainty shed lights on missing instruments including international instruments of mitigation and adaptation through disaster risk reduction, climate change mitigation instruments, and involvement of people in review and assessment of instruments in the context of climate change (iterative anticipatory governance). By combining decision making and uncertainty into the institutional model, proposals for missing instruments are made. The model allows for instrument redesign through interdisciplinary interaction with the agricultural and policy community, reviewing climate change scenarios, identifying strategies to reduce uncertainty, employ missing and buttress weak instruments in the context of adaptive governance.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The low levels of approval from both governments and authorities around the world reflect a problem of political legitimacy. The success of an organization relies partially on its reputation, on how the organization is perceived by its stakeholders, however, while reputation is an intangible that has been measured in the private sector for a long time, in the public sector and particularly the government reputation is a trend.
Government reputation is defined as the collective assessment of multiple stakeholders towards a government, based on personal experiences, perceptions or mediated experiences, therefore, it is communicable, government reputation is also based on the stakeholders´ expectations about the government; it is a continuous intangible because it depends on past, present and future experiences or perceptions, it implies a comparison with other governments and generates attitudes and behaviors of the stakeholders towards the organization.
Considering government reputations as a tool that measures local governments and provides information for those involved in the decision-making process, the problem posed by this paper is the absence of model to measure government reputation applicable to municipal governments in Mexico, in addition, factors of government reputation are not determined for Mexican reality and therefore there are no indicators or any index to measure those factors and their incidence in reputation.
The objective of the paper is to discover the main elements of government reputation and to present the Local Government Reputation Index. The methodology to establish the values of the index is based on the analytical hierarchy process (Saaty´s Algorithm). This methodology was implemented based on the literature review, including more than 30 papers and verified through a process of interviews and focus groups in Mexico.
It has been found government performance, ethical behavior, the leadership of the authorities and government communication as the most influential variables of government reputation.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Grand challenges such as circularity, climate change, renewable energy, new technologies require water management organizations to invest in their water infrastructure in a forward-looking manner (Ferraro et al., 2015; Pot et al., 2018). In response to these challenges, organizations will for example need to adhere to long-term goals that are formulated at other governmental levels such as the EU; will need to formulate their own long-term goals; will need to find robust or flexible solutions that can cope with changing future circumstances; and will need to find governance arrangements that can facilitate their transformational goals and ideas (Dewulf and Termeer, 2015; Ferguson et al., 2013). Often such arrangements need to be innovate in itself, because of the many uncertainties involved in dealing with grand challenges. An example of such an innovative arrangement is the competitive dialogue (CD) procurement procedure that was introduced by the EU in 2004. The competitive dialogue facilitates the governance strategies of coordination, cooperation, and competition, and deciding upon the most suitable technical solution. The procedure is especially suitable when the project is complex and the government itself is unable to define the technical means that will satisfy their long-term objectives (Lenferink et al., 2013).
This paper aims to elucidate the contribution of the CD procedure for addressing grand challenges; and to focus on the specific barriers at play when governments aim to arrive at forward-looking decisions. With this aim, this paper makes three contributions: 1. To reveal tensions between water governance ideas and water management practice; 2. To discuss contributions of CD procedures and possible other public-private arrangements to facilitate governments to anticipate the future; 3. And to discuss the barriers, or ingrained patterns that impede water management organizations to anticipate the future. To do so, this paper investigates a specific case of a CD procedure that a Dutch regional water authority started to realize the ‘most sustainable water pumping station of the world’. The paper adopts a process-tracing research approach with visual mapping that results in a chronological narrative of events and a causal map (Bennett and Checkel, 2015; Langley, 1999). Results rely on observations of the entire CD procedure (i.e., market consultation, dialogue, submitting offers, and selection) between 2017 and 2019, as well as on documents (including decision documents), and conversational and in-depth interviews. The study finds that risk reduction, ambition specification, and fairness maximization interfere with governmental ambitions to address grand challenges.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the twenty first century, corruption emerges as one of the biggest wicked problem both in developed and developing countries resulting to decline the level of trust in the government. United Nations Convention Against Corruption (UNCAC) in its Article 5 mentioning “effective and coordinated anti-corruption polices” as a necessity to the fight against corruption. The Sustainable Development Goals (SGDs) were signed by head of the governments of 168 countries after replacing the Millennium Development Goals, in which goal number 16 has clearly highlighted to substantially reduce corruption and develop effective, accountable and transparent institutions at all levels. In India, a series of acts, laws, anti-corruption strategies have been promulgated and multiple anti-corruption agencies created at national and sub-national levels to tackle corruption. Transparency International Annual Corruption Perception Index (CPI) for 2017 ranks India 81 out of 180 countries with a CPI score of 4 out of 10 reflecting high degree of corruption among politicians and public officials. The major challenges before the state is corrupt behaviour of the individuals working in government institutions. The purpose of this research paper is to measure the level of satisfaction and trust among different groups of general public towards anti-corruption institutions in the state of Himachal Pradesh, where the police officials are responsible for dealing with the matter of corruption cases and implementation of anti-corruption policies. The research questions arises are: (1) How far Anti-corruption Institutions are performing their role and functions effectively and efficiently at regional and grass root level in accordance with the expectation of the citizens? (2) What key challenges facing by the general public and police officials of Anti-Corruption Insitutions in the State (3) Is there is an effective way to facilitate public trust in the governance of anti-corruption institutions to achieve both administrative efficiency and policy innovation for combating corruption? The study finds that satisfaction and trust among general public was low towards Anti-Corruption Institutions in the state. On analysis of data, it is revealed that unethical behaviour of police officials, unawareness about rules, regulations and anti-corruption policies among general public, lack of political will for creation of separate independent anti-corruption institutions free from political interference and low level of people participations have proven the most serious risks for eradication corruption and implementation of an effective anti-corruption polices. Further, the weak civil societies and independent media are the major challenges for combating corruption. The study also recommended remedial measures to re-design anti-corruption policies for combating corruption and restoring trust among citizen’s towards anti-corruption institutions.
The study also recommended remedial measures to re-design anti-corruption policies for combating corruption and restoring trust among citizens towards anti-corruption institutions. The present study is based on primary data. Secondary data has also been used. The sample size for the study comprised of 360 public respondents which includes students, government employees, businessmen, agriculturists, advocates and journalists were selected on the basis of stratified random sampling. Apart from public, 85 police officials from different ranks and positions who are directly investigating the corruption cases in the state, have been included in the sample.
A structured questionnaire was prepared based on five-point likert scale. Data was collected through interview with the respondents, personnel observations and occasional informal discussions. Out of twelve districts, three districts were selected for this study on the basis of highest number of registered corruption and trap cases in the State Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau (SV&ACB) in the State. Descriptive statistics and non-parametric test (Chi-square) have been applied to test the hypotheses. Though the findings of this study may not have universal applicability in different cultural contexts, however, the challenges facing by the general public at regional and local level in the governance of anti-corruption institutions are relevant among all the developing nations.
Key words: Anti-Corruption, Building Trust, Citizen Satisfaction, People Participation, Political Will
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Developing subnational climate policies under uncertainty: A case study on development of State Action Planning for climate Change
[1]Ashok Kumar Singha, PhD
Abstract
Climate science is a science of uncertainty. The planning process at the national level as well as at the sub-national level attaches utmost importance to certainty and predictability of intended plans and policies. There is inherent tensions in planning climate change policies and action plans. There are several, political, economic, social and technological processes and choices that influence planning, policy and prioritization of resources for adaptation. This case-study chronicles the challenging journey of formulation of sub-national climate policies that intends to address national level climate goals (i.e. Intended Nationally Determined Contribution, Sustainable Development Goals) as well state vision and state priorities. The process involves both top-down and bottom-up approaches. The inter-play between scientifically assessed spatial vulnerability and adaptation polices and action plans to address such vulnerabilities is challenging. A score card based system has been used to seek alignment between national goals and sub-national adaption action plans. Odisha is one of the states in India, which has developed the first sub-national action plan on climate change. It has also produced the monitoring report of the first state action plan and climate change. It has prepared its second action plan which is aligned to INDC and SDG. In the process, the case study analyses the influence of various stakeholders, roles of city governments and political leadership in the formulation of these plans. It also examines the dialogues, conflicts and consensus within sectors, across sectors, institutions at the state level and national level to prioritise an adaptation policy (through a multi-criteria analysis). Impact of climate change varies from state to state as well as within the state, therefore developing the institutional processes and measures to reduce climate change-related risks enhances resilience of the state. The case study elaborates not only the innovative approaches adopted for institutionalisation of such process but also to build capacity of various institutions to respond to such vulnerabilities and risks under uncertainty. The case study brings out some specific adaptation interventions on storm water drainage, cyclone shelters, and interventions in paddy cultivation as examples.
Keywords: Intended nationally Determined Contribution (INDC), Sustainable Development Goal (SDG), vulnerability, science-policy, resilience, climate policy, adaptation, multi-criteria analysis
[1] Ashok Kumar Singha, is the founder and CEO of CTRAN consulting (www.ctranconsulting.com). He has been involved in the sub-national climate change action planning, climate finance, climate policy issues in as many as 15 Indian states for close to a decade. Email: ashoksingha@gmail.com
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Multi-level and democratic governance, to co-produce 21st century public policies
Pierre Bauby
How to meet the increasingly complex and uncertain challenges of the 21st century?
It can no longer be done with mechanisms based on exclusivity and extreme centralization of public authorities and essentially top-down governance.
The communication will aim, both theoretically and from empirical situations in France and in the European Union, to explore another governance based on the one hand on the combination of different levels of public authorities - from territorial to Europe - (multi-level), on the other hand, on the democratic participation of all the actors concerned:
- The systematic organization of the expression of the needs of each citizen and user and their evolutions, including their complaints - which makes it possible to fill somewhat the information asymmetries which exist between them and the public authorities - by using in particular the extraordinary interactive means of digital;
- Organize public debates on the different public policies and organizational solutions to address the issues raised;
- Determine the relevant area and the most suitable mode of definition and organisation of each public policy (organizing authorities, who are responsible for clearly define the objectives and missions of each public policy, the specific rules and standards to which they are subject, developing interactions with other levels of public action and ultimately deciding) ;
- Organize the democratic evaluation of effects of public policies in order to have a feedback and to make the necessary adaptations.
These initiatives and responsibilities, to be carried out successfully, require commitment to the complementarity of "top-down" and "bottom-up" approaches, to democratic participation, co-definition, co-production.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The city of São Paulo, as well as other large Brazilian cities, has a trajectory of urban growth characterized by intense socioeconomic and territorial inequality. Highly valued areas, where high-rise constructions are increasingly, and have privileged access to services and transit infrastructure coexist in the same place with peripheral regions, poorly connected to workplaces and education, with a horizontal and extensive occupation pattern - which menaces environmentally fragile areas. The challenges posed to public policies that intervene in urban space are extremely complex and fall almost exclusively on state coordination.
In the last decades it has been possible to verify important changes in the governments responsible for urban policies. As a consequence of the strengthening and participation of new agents and non-state organizations, the perspective of governance has become fundamental to understand the dynamics of public policy production in cities (Le Galès, 2015, Marques, 2018). It starts from the argument that the state and political institutions are dimensions and processes relevant to be investigated, as well as the dynamics of disputes over urban space. As pointed out in the literature, power is no longer only identified as intrinsic to government (Pierre, 1999). The role of local authority in the urban governance model is no longer guided by technocracy and results maximization, but rather operates in a more fragmented way in the networks of social and private actors (Stoker, 1998).
The governance approach that reveals institutional aspects is promising because it considers: how political actors operate within and outside institutional frameworks, formal and informal rules, expressed values and ideas, and thus verify behaviors in the production of public policies urban The present paper aims to emphasize that even in the context of governance, such transformations in the role and structure of local power remain a relevant object of analysis.
Based on recent changes to urban planning policy in the city of São Paulo, as well as on others that preceded it, the present article seeks to analyze the changes in institutional patterns (Mahoney and Thelen, 2010) of this policy over the last few municipal governments. Using the idea that institutions are processes and not things (Lowndes, 2012), the objective is to identify the main types of institutional changes carried out during different governments that produced varied results of urban planning policy, while considering the characteristics of the political context, the main agents involved in these transformations and associated strategies.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
While first identified over 50 years ago, wicked problems, which are characterized in part by their endless and changing nature, expansive scope and numberous stakeholders, may be becoming increasingly challenging as across the globe minimalist democracy continues to win out over maximalist, thereby reducing the participation of citizens and civil society in problem solving to electing representatives and attempting to influence their policy decision-making respectively (Cheema and Maguire, 2002).
After briefly surveying the sociocultural, economic, and technological landscapes of western democracies, this paper will summarize case studies of intractable health policy problems in two countries with distinct systems of government--Canada, which employs the Westminster system, and the United States, which employs the presidential model. Next, building on the work of Rittel (1972), Roberts (2000), Knapp (2008), and others, it will theorize that wicked problems can be contained or better managed via the constant collaborative participation of the public and policy communities throughout the implementation, evaluation and monitoring, and problem reidentification steps of the policy cycle. Afterwards, using the example of Canadian pharmacare, which is once again on the national decision-making agenda, it will describe enhanced communication and public engagement strategies that government institutions and their partners can deploy to foster ongoing participation in problem-solving. These proposed strategies could be added to Health Canada and the Public Health Agency of Canada Guidelines on Public Engagement (2016). Finally, the paper will propose measures of process and scope to be used in determining whether the strategies have been effective in addressing wicked problems.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the realm of employment, segregation of migrants in the labour market has emerged as a critical issue and its consequences cut across many areas of concern. This paper addresses the deficiency in the literature by focusing on how the system of subcontracting and institution of maistry in informal construction sector interacts with the process of social capital building and finally modifying the working conditions of migrant labour while controlling the other theoretical concerns such as human capital. To the rural population, maistry working under subcontractors serves as an entry point to urban labour pool and a facilitator at the destination. Social capital being capital in the sense, that it yields positive returns. This paper has two objectives: firstly, compare the working condition of migrants and natives. Secondly, explain those results with the help of destination based social capital formation given the circumstances of subcontracting and employee referral system through the institution of maistry. This inter-disciplinary research which integrates social capital theories with quantitative methodological framework using primary survey data illustrates that social capital continues to exist as a crucial determinant of the labour market outcomes of migrant labour. The ‘fragmentation of economic relations within the firm’ fostered a hierarchical arrangement in which contractors remained at the top and migrant labour at the bottom. Working condition of migrant labour is showing a divergence from native labour especially regarding the daily wage rate, the task assigned, annual bonus and hours of work.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Fight against clandestine transport in Cameroon: from the complexity of a public problem to ineffective institutionalized bricolage
The historical trajectory of public policies in Cameroon is marked by three highlights: A central state presence as planner and producer of public policies after independence (1960 to 1980), then a democratization of public space with the arrival civil society actors and foreign partners in the production of policies in the 1990s. And finally a growing complexity of public issues marked by a strong interdependence between different sectors of public life. It is in this context of complexity of public policies that we intend to analyze the policy of the fight against clandestine transport in Cameroon.
In fact, after the repeated complaints of trade unions and transport companies and the increasing number of accidents on highways, the Cameroonian authorities in charge of transport undertook to clean up the sector by limiting the activity of "clandestine transport". It is in this sense that the "National Committee for the fight against clandestine road transport" was set up. But when is it exactly "clandestine transport" in the cities of Douala and Yaoundé, ground of our research. From the outset we can say that the "clandestine transport" in these big cities emerges in an environment of strong urbanization, populations cannot reach the areas of urban dwellings borrowed from "clandos", "opeps" qualifying vehicles used for clandestine transport. Beside this unmontrolled urbanization, there is the defective state of the roads which does not encourage the regular carriers to frequent certain hard-to-reach areas. From this non-exhaustive overview, it emerges that the clandestine transport has reached rather large proportions to the point of often marginalizing the regular road carriers. It is in this context that the Ministry of Transport intends to intervene to restore the norm and put all actors under the guise of legislation. Only after our observations and research on the ground it appears that this problem is quite complex because affecting other sectors of public life. The authorities' clumsy coercion and awakening appear just as an "institutionalized bricolage" that cannot solve the problem of clandestine transport in the cities of Douala and Yaounde in a sustainable way. This communication is therefore an opportunity to understand the state in action in Africa in a complex environment or at the same time it is much expected of public authorities.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Policy implementation and evaluation in complex environmental governance systems continues to pose challenges for scholars and practitioners. New developments in complexity theory and adaptive governance theory increasingly highlight the difficulties associated with governance in complex, multi-level, multi-jurisdictional systems. Many systems must address new governance challenges with existing institutional and policy regimes which policy actors are attempting to push in innovative directions. Policy evaluation in these contexts is particularly challenging. While public policy and governance theory increasingly embrace complexity there has been a simultaneous move to use indicators to assess governance in hopes of improving progress and outcomes, and capturing these innovations. This paper uses two cases of transboundary and multi-level water governance – the Great Lakes region as a system of abundance and the Rio Grande-Bravo as a system of scarcity -- to outline how governance can be assessed and evaluated using indicators and how this approach may serve as a foundation for better integrating scholarship and practice.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Empowering community and implementing a number of emergency training programs are the main bottom-up community based approaches which emphasize the participation of community residents and grassroots organizations. Governments deploy multiple approaches to accomplish their objectives of emergency management. In addition, governments have spawned a number of empowerment and emergency education programs in order to prepare community pre-disaster to avoid risk and respond post-disaster. Community development association, which is a main neighborhood organization in Taiwan, engages in some form of collaboration with local government. Much has asserted that community development association could coproduce public services with local government or produce in-house services to community residents. Community development association plays a critical role in collaborative emergency management progress.
Water Resources Agency of Taiwan has implemented flood-prone community polices which includes main community organizations, such as districts, villages, regional nonprofit organizations, local business, and community development associations. However, community development associations have lacked of resources, emergency expertise, and network to support the implementation of disaster-resistant programs. Hence, the development of disaster-resistant community in Taiwan is limited and have some challenges which have not clearly explored.
This study would explore the development of Taiwan flood disaster-resistant community, and comb the challenges based upon the perspectives of community development association heads. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with community development association heads, which are the main stakeholder in implementing flood-prone community program of Water Resources Agency. This study would expect to fill the literature gap of collaborative emergency management research and have policy suggestions to Taiwan community-based emergency management.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Situate within new institutionalism literature, this paper builds a complex system model of institutional analysis for adaptive governance and decision making in the context of deep uncertainty. This model combines Young’s institutional environmental analysis method (2005), elements of subsequent environmental governance models, and ideas of multiple institutional levels and drivers, together with uncertainty science. The model identifies types of decision making for different degrees of uncertainty including complex, chaotic, and knowable causes and effects.
By applying the model, and based on qualitative semi-structured research interviews, policy instruments are identified that build agricultural producer livelihoods improving their adaptive capacity to respond to climate change and drought. In relation to three case studies in Canada, Chile, and Argentina, policy instruments that deliver co benefits to improve agricultural producer technological, social, human, economic, and natural capital include crop insurance, income stabilization instruments, farm water infrastructure grants, environmental farm planning (improving soil management), drought predictions and alerts, and watershed management plans. this paper identifies the logic and decision making surrounding each policy instrument in the context of uncertainty. This exploration of uncertainty shed lights on missing instruments including international instruments of mitigation and adaptation through disaster risk reduction, climate change mitigation instruments, and involvement of people in review and assessment of instruments in the context of climate change (iterative anticipatory governance). By combining decision making and uncertainty into the institutional model, proposals for missing instruments are made. The model allows for instrument redesign through interdisciplinary interaction with the agricultural and policy community, reviewing climate change scenarios, identifying strategies to reduce uncertainty, employ missing and buttress weak instruments in the context of adaptive governance.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The low levels of approval from both governments and authorities around the world reflect a problem of political legitimacy. The success of an organization relies partially on its reputation, on how the organization is perceived by its stakeholders, however, while reputation is an intangible that has been measured in the private sector for a long time, in the public sector and particularly the government reputation is a trend.
Government reputation is defined as the collective assessment of multiple stakeholders towards a government, based on personal experiences, perceptions or mediated experiences, therefore, it is communicable, government reputation is also based on the stakeholders´ expectations about the government; it is a continuous intangible because it depends on past, present and future experiences or perceptions, it implies a comparison with other governments and generates attitudes and behaviors of the stakeholders towards the organization.
Considering government reputations as a tool that measures local governments and provides information for those involved in the decision-making process, the problem posed by this paper is the absence of model to measure government reputation applicable to municipal governments in Mexico, in addition, factors of government reputation are not determined for Mexican reality and therefore there are no indicators or any index to measure those factors and their incidence in reputation.
The objective of the paper is to discover the main elements of government reputation and to present the Local Government Reputation Index. The methodology to establish the values of the index is based on the analytical hierarchy process (Saaty´s Algorithm). This methodology was implemented based on the literature review, including more than 30 papers and verified through a process of interviews and focus groups in Mexico.
It has been found government performance, ethical behavior, the leadership of the authorities and government communication as the most influential variables of government reputation.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Grand challenges such as circularity, climate change, renewable energy, new technologies require water management organizations to invest in their water infrastructure in a forward-looking manner (Ferraro et al., 2015; Pot et al., 2018). In response to these challenges, organizations will for example need to adhere to long-term goals that are formulated at other governmental levels such as the EU; will need to formulate their own long-term goals; will need to find robust or flexible solutions that can cope with changing future circumstances; and will need to find governance arrangements that can facilitate their transformational goals and ideas (Dewulf and Termeer, 2015; Ferguson et al., 2013). Often such arrangements need to be innovate in itself, because of the many uncertainties involved in dealing with grand challenges. An example of such an innovative arrangement is the competitive dialogue (CD) procurement procedure that was introduced by the EU in 2004. The competitive dialogue facilitates the governance strategies of coordination, cooperation, and competition, and deciding upon the most suitable technical solution. The procedure is especially suitable when the project is complex and the government itself is unable to define the technical means that will satisfy their long-term objectives (Lenferink et al., 2013).
This paper aims to elucidate the contribution of the CD procedure for addressing grand challenges; and to focus on the specific barriers at play when governments aim to arrive at forward-looking decisions. With this aim, this paper makes three contributions: 1. To reveal tensions between water governance ideas and water management practice; 2. To discuss contributions of CD procedures and possible other public-private arrangements to facilitate governments to anticipate the future; 3. And to discuss the barriers, or ingrained patterns that impede water management organizations to anticipate the future. To do so, this paper investigates a specific case of a CD procedure that a Dutch regional water authority started to realize the ‘most sustainable water pumping station of the world’. The paper adopts a process-tracing research approach with visual mapping that results in a chronological narrative of events and a causal map (Bennett and Checkel, 2015; Langley, 1999). Results rely on observations of the entire CD procedure (i.e., market consultation, dialogue, submitting offers, and selection) between 2017 and 2019, as well as on documents (including decision documents), and conversational and in-depth interviews. The study finds that risk reduction, ambition specification, and fairness maximization interfere with governmental ambitions to address grand challenges.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the twenty first century, corruption emerges as one of the biggest wicked problem both in developed and developing countries resulting to decline the level of trust in the government. United Nations Convention Against Corruption (UNCAC) in its Article 5 mentioning “effective and coordinated anti-corruption polices” as a necessity to the fight against corruption. The Sustainable Development Goals (SGDs) were signed by head of the governments of 168 countries after replacing the Millennium Development Goals, in which goal number 16 has clearly highlighted to substantially reduce corruption and develop effective, accountable and transparent institutions at all levels. In India, a series of acts, laws, anti-corruption strategies have been promulgated and multiple anti-corruption agencies created at national and sub-national levels to tackle corruption. Transparency International Annual Corruption Perception Index (CPI) for 2017 ranks India 81 out of 180 countries with a CPI score of 4 out of 10 reflecting high degree of corruption among politicians and public officials. The major challenges before the state is corrupt behaviour of the individuals working in government institutions. The purpose of this research paper is to measure the level of satisfaction and trust among different groups of general public towards anti-corruption institutions in the state of Himachal Pradesh, where the police officials are responsible for dealing with the matter of corruption cases and implementation of anti-corruption policies. The research questions arises are: (1) How far Anti-corruption Institutions are performing their role and functions effectively and efficiently at regional and grass root level in accordance with the expectation of the citizens? (2) What key challenges facing by the general public and police officials of Anti-Corruption Insitutions in the State (3) Is there is an effective way to facilitate public trust in the governance of anti-corruption institutions to achieve both administrative efficiency and policy innovation for combating corruption? The study finds that satisfaction and trust among general public was low towards Anti-Corruption Institutions in the state. On analysis of data, it is revealed that unethical behaviour of police officials, unawareness about rules, regulations and anti-corruption policies among general public, lack of political will for creation of separate independent anti-corruption institutions free from political interference and low level of people participations have proven the most serious risks for eradication corruption and implementation of an effective anti-corruption polices. Further, the weak civil societies and independent media are the major challenges for combating corruption. The study also recommended remedial measures to re-design anti-corruption policies for combating corruption and restoring trust among citizen’s towards anti-corruption institutions.
The study also recommended remedial measures to re-design anti-corruption policies for combating corruption and restoring trust among citizens towards anti-corruption institutions. The present study is based on primary data. Secondary data has also been used. The sample size for the study comprised of 360 public respondents which includes students, government employees, businessmen, agriculturists, advocates and journalists were selected on the basis of stratified random sampling. Apart from public, 85 police officials from different ranks and positions who are directly investigating the corruption cases in the state, have been included in the sample.
A structured questionnaire was prepared based on five-point likert scale. Data was collected through interview with the respondents, personnel observations and occasional informal discussions. Out of twelve districts, three districts were selected for this study on the basis of highest number of registered corruption and trap cases in the State Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau (SV&ACB) in the State. Descriptive statistics and non-parametric test (Chi-square) have been applied to test the hypotheses. Though the findings of this study may not have universal applicability in different cultural contexts, however, the challenges facing by the general public at regional and local level in the governance of anti-corruption institutions are relevant among all the developing nations.
Key words: Anti-Corruption, Building Trust, Citizen Satisfaction, People Participation, Political Will
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Developing subnational climate policies under uncertainty: A case study on development of State Action Planning for climate Change
[1]Ashok Kumar Singha, PhD
Abstract
Climate science is a science of uncertainty. The planning process at the national level as well as at the sub-national level attaches utmost importance to certainty and predictability of intended plans and policies. There is inherent tensions in planning climate change policies and action plans. There are several, political, economic, social and technological processes and choices that influence planning, policy and prioritization of resources for adaptation. This case-study chronicles the challenging journey of formulation of sub-national climate policies that intends to address national level climate goals (i.e. Intended Nationally Determined Contribution, Sustainable Development Goals) as well state vision and state priorities. The process involves both top-down and bottom-up approaches. The inter-play between scientifically assessed spatial vulnerability and adaptation polices and action plans to address such vulnerabilities is challenging. A score card based system has been used to seek alignment between national goals and sub-national adaption action plans. Odisha is one of the states in India, which has developed the first sub-national action plan on climate change. It has also produced the monitoring report of the first state action plan and climate change. It has prepared its second action plan which is aligned to INDC and SDG. In the process, the case study analyses the influence of various stakeholders, roles of city governments and political leadership in the formulation of these plans. It also examines the dialogues, conflicts and consensus within sectors, across sectors, institutions at the state level and national level to prioritise an adaptation policy (through a multi-criteria analysis). Impact of climate change varies from state to state as well as within the state, therefore developing the institutional processes and measures to reduce climate change-related risks enhances resilience of the state. The case study elaborates not only the innovative approaches adopted for institutionalisation of such process but also to build capacity of various institutions to respond to such vulnerabilities and risks under uncertainty. The case study brings out some specific adaptation interventions on storm water drainage, cyclone shelters, and interventions in paddy cultivation as examples.
Keywords: Intended nationally Determined Contribution (INDC), Sustainable Development Goal (SDG), vulnerability, science-policy, resilience, climate policy, adaptation, multi-criteria analysis
[1] Ashok Kumar Singha, is the founder and CEO of CTRAN consulting (www.ctranconsulting.com). He has been involved in the sub-national climate change action planning, climate finance, climate policy issues in as many as 15 Indian states for close to a decade. Email: ashoksingha@gmail.com
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Multi-level and democratic governance, to co-produce 21st century public policies
Pierre Bauby
How to meet the increasingly complex and uncertain challenges of the 21st century?
It can no longer be done with mechanisms based on exclusivity and extreme centralization of public authorities and essentially top-down governance.
The communication will aim, both theoretically and from empirical situations in France and in the European Union, to explore another governance based on the one hand on the combination of different levels of public authorities - from territorial to Europe - (multi-level), on the other hand, on the democratic participation of all the actors concerned:
- The systematic organization of the expression of the needs of each citizen and user and their evolutions, including their complaints - which makes it possible to fill somewhat the information asymmetries which exist between them and the public authorities - by using in particular the extraordinary interactive means of digital;
- Organize public debates on the different public policies and organizational solutions to address the issues raised;
- Determine the relevant area and the most suitable mode of definition and organisation of each public policy (organizing authorities, who are responsible for clearly define the objectives and missions of each public policy, the specific rules and standards to which they are subject, developing interactions with other levels of public action and ultimately deciding) ;
- Organize the democratic evaluation of effects of public policies in order to have a feedback and to make the necessary adaptations.
These initiatives and responsibilities, to be carried out successfully, require commitment to the complementarity of "top-down" and "bottom-up" approaches, to democratic participation, co-definition, co-production.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The city of São Paulo, as well as other large Brazilian cities, has a trajectory of urban growth characterized by intense socioeconomic and territorial inequality. Highly valued areas, where high-rise constructions are increasingly, and have privileged access to services and transit infrastructure coexist in the same place with peripheral regions, poorly connected to workplaces and education, with a horizontal and extensive occupation pattern - which menaces environmentally fragile areas. The challenges posed to public policies that intervene in urban space are extremely complex and fall almost exclusively on state coordination.
In the last decades it has been possible to verify important changes in the governments responsible for urban policies. As a consequence of the strengthening and participation of new agents and non-state organizations, the perspective of governance has become fundamental to understand the dynamics of public policy production in cities (Le Galès, 2015, Marques, 2018). It starts from the argument that the state and political institutions are dimensions and processes relevant to be investigated, as well as the dynamics of disputes over urban space. As pointed out in the literature, power is no longer only identified as intrinsic to government (Pierre, 1999). The role of local authority in the urban governance model is no longer guided by technocracy and results maximization, but rather operates in a more fragmented way in the networks of social and private actors (Stoker, 1998).
The governance approach that reveals institutional aspects is promising because it considers: how political actors operate within and outside institutional frameworks, formal and informal rules, expressed values and ideas, and thus verify behaviors in the production of public policies urban The present paper aims to emphasize that even in the context of governance, such transformations in the role and structure of local power remain a relevant object of analysis.
Based on recent changes to urban planning policy in the city of São Paulo, as well as on others that preceded it, the present article seeks to analyze the changes in institutional patterns (Mahoney and Thelen, 2010) of this policy over the last few municipal governments. Using the idea that institutions are processes and not things (Lowndes, 2012), the objective is to identify the main types of institutional changes carried out during different governments that produced varied results of urban planning policy, while considering the characteristics of the political context, the main agents involved in these transformations and associated strategies.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
While first identified over 50 years ago, wicked problems, which are characterized in part by their endless and changing nature, expansive scope and numberous stakeholders, may be becoming increasingly challenging as across the globe minimalist democracy continues to win out over maximalist, thereby reducing the participation of citizens and civil society in problem solving to electing representatives and attempting to influence their policy decision-making respectively (Cheema and Maguire, 2002).
After briefly surveying the sociocultural, economic, and technological landscapes of western democracies, this paper will summarize case studies of intractable health policy problems in two countries with distinct systems of government--Canada, which employs the Westminster system, and the United States, which employs the presidential model. Next, building on the work of Rittel (1972), Roberts (2000), Knapp (2008), and others, it will theorize that wicked problems can be contained or better managed via the constant collaborative participation of the public and policy communities throughout the implementation, evaluation and monitoring, and problem reidentification steps of the policy cycle. Afterwards, using the example of Canadian pharmacare, which is once again on the national decision-making agenda, it will describe enhanced communication and public engagement strategies that government institutions and their partners can deploy to foster ongoing participation in problem-solving. These proposed strategies could be added to Health Canada and the Public Health Agency of Canada Guidelines on Public Engagement (2016). Finally, the paper will propose measures of process and scope to be used in determining whether the strategies have been effective in addressing wicked problems.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the realm of employment, segregation of migrants in the labour market has emerged as a critical issue and its consequences cut across many areas of concern. This paper addresses the deficiency in the literature by focusing on how the system of subcontracting and institution of maistry in informal construction sector interacts with the process of social capital building and finally modifying the working conditions of migrant labour while controlling the other theoretical concerns such as human capital. To the rural population, maistry working under subcontractors serves as an entry point to urban labour pool and a facilitator at the destination. Social capital being capital in the sense, that it yields positive returns. This paper has two objectives: firstly, compare the working condition of migrants and natives. Secondly, explain those results with the help of destination based social capital formation given the circumstances of subcontracting and employee referral system through the institution of maistry. This inter-disciplinary research which integrates social capital theories with quantitative methodological framework using primary survey data illustrates that social capital continues to exist as a crucial determinant of the labour market outcomes of migrant labour. The ‘fragmentation of economic relations within the firm’ fostered a hierarchical arrangement in which contractors remained at the top and migrant labour at the bottom. Working condition of migrant labour is showing a divergence from native labour especially regarding the daily wage rate, the task assigned, annual bonus and hours of work.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Fight against clandestine transport in Cameroon: from the complexity of a public problem to ineffective institutionalized bricolage
The historical trajectory of public policies in Cameroon is marked by three highlights: A central state presence as planner and producer of public policies after independence (1960 to 1980), then a democratization of public space with the arrival civil society actors and foreign partners in the production of policies in the 1990s. And finally a growing complexity of public issues marked by a strong interdependence between different sectors of public life. It is in this context of complexity of public policies that we intend to analyze the policy of the fight against clandestine transport in Cameroon.
In fact, after the repeated complaints of trade unions and transport companies and the increasing number of accidents on highways, the Cameroonian authorities in charge of transport undertook to clean up the sector by limiting the activity of "clandestine transport". It is in this sense that the "National Committee for the fight against clandestine road transport" was set up. But when is it exactly "clandestine transport" in the cities of Douala and Yaoundé, ground of our research. From the outset we can say that the "clandestine transport" in these big cities emerges in an environment of strong urbanization, populations cannot reach the areas of urban dwellings borrowed from "clandos", "opeps" qualifying vehicles used for clandestine transport. Beside this unmontrolled urbanization, there is the defective state of the roads which does not encourage the regular carriers to frequent certain hard-to-reach areas. From this non-exhaustive overview, it emerges that the clandestine transport has reached rather large proportions to the point of often marginalizing the regular road carriers. It is in this context that the Ministry of Transport intends to intervene to restore the norm and put all actors under the guise of legislation. Only after our observations and research on the ground it appears that this problem is quite complex because affecting other sectors of public life. The authorities' clumsy coercion and awakening appear just as an "institutionalized bricolage" that cannot solve the problem of clandestine transport in the cities of Douala and Yaounde in a sustainable way. This communication is therefore an opportunity to understand the state in action in Africa in a complex environment or at the same time it is much expected of public authorities.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Policy implementation and evaluation in complex environmental governance systems continues to pose challenges for scholars and practitioners. New developments in complexity theory and adaptive governance theory increasingly highlight the difficulties associated with governance in complex, multi-level, multi-jurisdictional systems. Many systems must address new governance challenges with existing institutional and policy regimes which policy actors are attempting to push in innovative directions. Policy evaluation in these contexts is particularly challenging. While public policy and governance theory increasingly embrace complexity there has been a simultaneous move to use indicators to assess governance in hopes of improving progress and outcomes, and capturing these innovations. This paper uses two cases of transboundary and multi-level water governance – the Great Lakes region as a system of abundance and the Rio Grande-Bravo as a system of scarcity -- to outline how governance can be assessed and evaluated using indicators and how this approach may serve as a foundation for better integrating scholarship and practice.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Empowering community and implementing a number of emergency training programs are the main bottom-up community based approaches which emphasize the participation of community residents and grassroots organizations. Governments deploy multiple approaches to accomplish their objectives of emergency management. In addition, governments have spawned a number of empowerment and emergency education programs in order to prepare community pre-disaster to avoid risk and respond post-disaster. Community development association, which is a main neighborhood organization in Taiwan, engages in some form of collaboration with local government. Much has asserted that community development association could coproduce public services with local government or produce in-house services to community residents. Community development association plays a critical role in collaborative emergency management progress.
Water Resources Agency of Taiwan has implemented flood-prone community polices which includes main community organizations, such as districts, villages, regional nonprofit organizations, local business, and community development associations. However, community development associations have lacked of resources, emergency expertise, and network to support the implementation of disaster-resistant programs. Hence, the development of disaster-resistant community in Taiwan is limited and have some challenges which have not clearly explored.
This study would explore the development of Taiwan flood disaster-resistant community, and comb the challenges based upon the perspectives of community development association heads. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with community development association heads, which are the main stakeholder in implementing flood-prone community program of Water Resources Agency. This study would expect to fill the literature gap of collaborative emergency management research and have policy suggestions to Taiwan community-based emergency management.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)