P02. Making Sense of Complex Policy Worlds Using Interpretive Methods
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCHCATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
There is increasing recognition that policy institutions are complex and studying structure and culture on their own is not enough – scholars need to understand the totality of the ‘policy world’ within which agents operate. The concept of a policy world draws on Shore and Wright (2011) who saw policies as having complex ‘social lives’ and ‘agency’, both shaped by interactions with actors and agents as well as shaping them (3). It also draws on Glynos and Howarth (2007) who see policies enacted within a policy regime as well as within an established system of social and political practices. As such, policy worlds are at heart radically contingent and open up ambiguous spaces in which actors and agents compete for influence.
Mainstream scientific methods are often reductionist, subordinating real-world complexity. If we are to be able to make sense of complex policy worlds, policy analysis needs to embrace the larger context, including the political. Interpretive methods provide the means required to delve into the complex, mediated and ambiguous realities within which policies are developed and implemented.
Interpretivist scholars are interested in the practical ways that policy practitioners recognise and manage the complexity that confronts them. As such, much interpretive analysis concentrates on close, micro-level interactions and contextualised self-interpretations. The challenge is to scale up established interpretive methodologies to make sense of ‘policy worlds’ in ways that consider the complexities at a larger scope of policy analysis, but which still express the variety of conflicting interpretations of actors.
References:
Glynos, Jason, and David R. Howarth. 2007. Logics of critical explanation in social and political theory. Vol. 26. New York, NY: Routledge.
Shore, Cris, and Susan Wright. 2011. "Conceptualising Policy: Technologies of Governance and the Politics of Visibility." In Policy worlds: anthropology and the analysis of contemporary power, edited by Cris Shore, Susan Wright and Davide Però, 1-25. New York: Berghahn Books.
CALL FOR PAPERS
Interpretivist scholars are interested in the practical ways that policy practitioners recognise and manage the complexity that confronts them, how they interpret actions and discourses, and contribute to their formulation in turn. Interpretive policy analysis has been dominated by close, micro-level interactions and contextualised self-interpretations. The challenge for interpretivists is to scale up interpretive methodologies to make sense of ‘policy worlds’ of a much greater scope, but which nonetheless express the variety of conflicting interpretations of actors.
This panel seeks papers using interpretive methods to apprehend policy worlds. Papers are sought which make theoretical, methodological or empirical contributions to the extension of interpretive methods to a more holistic analysis of the complex, mediated and ambiguous realities of policy worlds. This might include comparative analyses of discourse across policy fields or countries, large-scale interpretations of policy worlds beyond micro-level ethnographies, or interpretive accounts of the state and other political institutions. We welcome contributions from interpretive scholars who draw on intersectional approaches to policy, or approaches that foreground intersections of race, gender, class, and ability.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Governments are increasingly recognising that they need new approaches to address complex problems (Brunner, 2010: 303). I am interested in why, despite repeated attempts to do so, policy actors continue to struggle to make the shift away from old rational-technical approaches (Phillips-Brown et al., 2012). I focus on the administrative level and examine the tensions between the existing rational-technical approaches and the new norms required that arise in the practice of policy actors as a result of the introduction of reforms (Getha-Taylor et al., 2011: i86). This is in no way to minimize the importance of Indigenous perspectives, but to shine a light on the much neglected administrative failures which contribute to poor outcomes. We often hear that reforms failed because they were “too hard”, but why is it too hard? Why is it so difficult for policy actors to add new approaches to their practice toolkit?
My starting point is that reforms are not introduced onto a blank canvas. They are introduced into an existing policy world, which is both shaped by interactions with policy actors as well as shaping these actors (Shore et al., 2011: 3). If I am to understand why governments struggle with new approaches, I need to understand the existing policy world. I also need to pay careful attention to the ways that policy actors either adapt their practices or resist reforms, and to the role of the existing policy world in these processes.
In this paper I use Logics of Critical Explanation to better understand how policy actors engaged with inherent tensions in Australian remote Indigenous policy where new ways of working are being tested at a national level. I suggest this approach provides important insights into the ongoing resistance to attempts to introduce new norms and into the capacities needed in policy actors asked to implement them.
References
Brunner RD. (2010) Adaptive governance as a reform strategy. Policy Sciences 43: 301-341.
Getha-Taylor H, Holmes MH, Jacobson WS, et al. (2011) Focusing the Public Leadership Lens: Research Propositions and Questions in the Minnowbrook Tradition. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 21: i83-i97.
Phillips-Brown P, Reddel T and Gleeson B. (2012) Learning from experience? Getting governments to listen to what evaluations are telling them. In: Commission P (ed) Better Indigenous Policies: The Role of Evaluation: Roundtable Proceedings, Canberra, 22-23 October 2012. Canberra: Productivity Commission.
Shore C, Wright S and Però D. (2011) Policy worlds: anthropology and the analysis of contemporary power, New York: Berghahn Books.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Ethical critique is a promising analytical approach for those using interpretive methods to understand complex policy worlds. It involves examining social practices and critiquing the values underlying them in order to open up a discursive space to develop something new. In this paper, I outline an ethical critique of a supported housing program for people living with serious mental illness in Queensland, Australia. I draw on interview data collected as part of a 14-year follow up of clients on the program. The policy was framed using a fantasmatic logic where clients would become autonomous, self-actualising people whose need for ongoing care would diminish over time. This was not found to be the case, as many people felt lonely with few social contacts outside the paid support hours. An alternative normative framework that promotes justice for people living with serious mental illness in terms of relationality as well as autonomy opens up new avenues for policy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Global policy assemblages, global policy discourse, global knowledges policy transfers and policy borrowing have all been used to describe the increasing globalisation in education policy. Ball calls this activity ‘global policyspeak’ (2017, 2). Captured by this global policyspeak are ideas such as school choice, the importance of literacy and numeracy and a concentration on lifelong learning and even the importance of equity. Materially the work of international agencies such as the OECD, World Bank and UNESCO have further contributed to global education policy convergence. In many countries this trend is understood as a threat to the national education systems, which have been a key activity of the nation-state. However, in Australia it has had the perverse effect of creating a national school education system, where none has previously existed. School education in Australia has been the responsibility of the state governments within its federated system. This paper uses an interpretive lens to consider how the national scale is legitimised in policy documents while invoking the global and considers what this means for the category of the state using the experience in Australia as a case study.
Ball, Stephen J. 2017. Education policy : major themes in education: Abingdon, Oxon
New York, NY : Routledge.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The central research question addressed in this paper is how grassroots organizing introduce and institutionalize the narrative of fundamental rights in state agencies such as courts, as an effective strategy for their politics of rights claiming through legal validation. The theory that courts can affect pure politics or mega politics is often treated as a backdrop of post-industrial and consolidated democracies of global north, and most cases of civil rights litigation are limited in scope to American-style constitutional experience.
This paper seeks to fill this gap by analyzing the strategies and outcomes of a rights movement in the semi authoritarian context of Pakistan. I argue that, in case of Pakistan, an “issue networks” of professionals, rights-oriented lawyers, and grassroots groups from the impoverished region of Fata, federally administered tribal areas of Pakistan, strategically used protests and litigation at a lower-level court to push for the advancement and recognition of their fundamental rights at the level of Parliament and Supreme Court of Pakistan that did not previously exist in the Constitution. My central explanation for the outcome of the movement is the combined effect of the judicial ideology, institutional changes and organizational support structure in rights litigation which was enabled through the critical national political timing of the movement that resonated well with actors’ demands.
I conducted archival research of the relevant PHC’s judgments on Fata since 2008, relevant policy reports and research studies by several Civil Society Organizations that were key actors in the movement. I also used snowballing method of interviewing to identify key actors and organizations of the movement. The fieldwork allowed me to get archival access to policy reports, briefs, manuals, relevant judgments and a detailed legal and political perspective of the litigants who filed those cases and how they interacted with the court. Finally, I used Critical Discourse Analysis as a tool and insight to detect if the court’s judgments responded to the actors’ demands and if the judgments varied in content over time.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This study focused on the evaluation of the implementation of the Youth Protection Act (LPJ) 2007 amendments in three Youth Centres (CJ) in Quebec. We were interested in the implementation as a process during which the meaning of a policy is constructed by the actors engaged in this process. We examined how this process does or does not lead to a change in their practices and eventually in their understanding and behavior (Spillane, Reiser & Reimer, 2002; Yanow, 2000). We opted for “sensemaking” (Denis et al., 2009; Weick, 1995) and “sensegiving” (Jeong & Brower, 2008) theories to focus not only on the behavior (action) of the actors involved in implementation, but also on the constructive process which led to this action - meanings and how these meanings are communicated. Sensegiving and sensemaking are two interrelated, continuous and perpetual processes (Maitlis, 2005; Stensaker et al., 2008). Specifically, we attempted to respond to this research question: Beyond the observation of the gap between design and implementation of public policies, how to understand this gap in an interpretive perspective? The study is a qualitative secondary analysis of primary data (Heaton, 2004). The evaluator adopted a hermeneutical phenomenology perspective. The phenomenological element is descriptive and account for the organizing experiences and principles that give shape and meaning to the lived world (Kvale 1996, Osborne 1994, Polkinghorne 1983). The second element is hermeneutic, and activates interpretive historical meanings and individual and social developments (Laverty, 2003).
Methodologically, we opted for a research strategy based on multiple, instrumental studies (Stake, 2003; Yin, 2003). The data consisted on individual interviews, focus groups, online questionnaire. Several levels of actors, representatives of all the structures of the three youth centers (CJ), participated in the research: stakeholders, department heads and directors. In all, 159 people participated in an individual or a focus group and 384 responded to the questionnaire. In addition, as each document is a representation of the negotiated self-perception of the organization, we analyzed more than 200 documents (departmental and administrative documents; organizational documentation; the DPJ's provincial results as well as the annual management reports of the three CJs; briefs tabled to the parliamentary committee; and press article). The implementation operates in a context of exchanges and interactions. The use of the sensemaking and sensegiving theories allowed us to consider the flow of information from the political towards the administrative during the implementation process. The analysis insisted on how the policy practitioners recognize, interpret and manage the flow of clues they receive in a complex and an interrelated world of challenges and constraints. We were interested in the mutual influence of different hierarchical level actors and how they succeed -or not- the trajectory of objectified creation towards the intersubjective creation of a collective policy meaning.
References
Denis, J.-L., Lamothe, L., Langley, A., Breton, M., Gervais, J., Trottier, L.-H., . . . Dubois, C.-A. (2009). The reciprocal dynamics of organizing and sense-making in the implementation of major public-sector reforms. Canadian Public Administration, 52(2), 225-248.
Heaton, J. (2004). Reworking qualitative data. UK: Sage Publications Ltd.
Jeong, H.-S. et Brower, R. S. (2008). Extending the present understanding of organizational sensemaking. Administration & Society, 40(3), 223-252.
Kvale, S. (1996). InterViews—An introduction to qualitative research interviewing. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Laverty, S. M. (2003). Hermeneutic phenomenology and phenomenology: A comparison of historical and methodological considerations. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 2(3), 21-35.
Maitlis, S. (2005). The Social processes of organizational sensemaking. The Academy of Management Journal, 48(1), 21-49.
Osborne, J. W. (1994). Some similarities and differences among phenomenological and other methods of psychological qualitative research. Canadian Psychology, 35(2), 167-189.
Polkinghorne, D. (1983). Methodology for the human sciences: Systems of inquiry. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Spillane, J. P., Reiser, B. J. et Reimer, T. (2002). Policy implementation and cognition: Reframing and refocusing implementation research. Review of Educational Research, 72(3), 387-431.
Stake, R. (2003). Standard-based and responsive evaluation. Thousand Oaks, Ca: Sage Publications.
Stensaker, I., Falkenberg, J. et Grønhaug, K. (2008). Implementation activities and organizational sensemaking. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 44(2), 162-185.
Weick, K. E. (1995). Sensemaking in organizations. Thousand Oaks, Ca: Sage Publications.
Yanow, D. (2000). Conducting interpretive policy analysis. Newbury Park: Sage.
Yin, R. K. (2003). Case study research: Design and methods. New-York: Newbury Park, Sage Publications.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This research, developed between 2015 and 2018, was destined to produce data on politics of justice access in the region of Porto Seguro in Southern Bahia, Brazil, both in relation to the operation of the local justice system, as well on the perception of the actors involved in different positions. Porto Seguro is characterized as one of the oldest cities of Brazil, since it was in its territory that the Portuguese caravels docked in 24 of April of 1500. According to the 2010 Census, 5,329 indigenous people were registered in the region, which means that the city is the second in presence of indigenous people in the State of Bahia. It is questioned if the available structure and the solutions to broaden access to justice are adequate to the real needs of its users. Moreover, it is examined whether the agents of the justice system are aware of the local problems and if they are able to recognize differences between their practices and the needs of users to whom they are intended, as proposed by Boaventura de Sousa Santos. Finally, it is asked whether the concept of access to justice of the system agents is compatible with the ethnic and cultural diversity of the region, which would eventually lead to the inadequacy of official mechanisms and the recognition of alternative and community forms of conflicts resolution. It will be examined the conditions and representations about politics of access to justice in Southern Bahia, identifying whether and how the local social and economic changes in recent years have had an impact on the perception of the actors and thw members of the judicial system. The research worked with quantitative and qualitative methodologies focused on the empirical-rhetorical analysis of the discourse. This type of strategy, also called "mixed methods study" (Creswell, Clark), is usefull in researches that requires multiple perspectives of the same problem, as in the case of public or judicial policy evaluation. In accordance with what the "mixed methods" propose, the present research intended to know the speeches and the practices of access to justice in the South of Bahia from two dimensions: I. politics of access to justice and; II. perception of actors about the Justice System and of actual and potential users of the judicial services regarding access to justice. The main research findings, still under analysis, indicate a recent increase in the demand for policies of access to justice, caused by the growth of the touristic sector, as well as the vulnerability of the indigenous population to interpersonal violence and to agrarian conflicts with ruralists. The increase in the rate of urbanization has also been indicated as a catalyst for conflicts, especially in the context of a historic city whose patrimony is protected by law. There was a significant discrepancy between the speeches of state agents and the various civil society actors regarding the concept of justice and the provision of public policies aimed at the attainment of rights.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
New Zealand’s centrally administered housing programme for low income and vulnerable citizens (‘State Housing’) has been a core part of the welfare state since the 1930s. Recent reforms have transformed the programme into a new ‘quasi-market’ system where the government provider now competes with community housing providers for tenants and funding. Scholars have questioned the economics of the reforms (Dykes 2016) and their efficacy in a time of increasing housing scarcity (Howden-Chapman & Baker, 2014). However, little attention has focused on the provenance of the reforms. My paper addresses why and how the reform agenda was pursued by the New Zealand government with special attention paid to the interactions of actors inside and outside of the state. The ‘policy worlds’ approach outlined by Shore and Wright (1997, 2011) provides an interpretivist perspective for analysing the myriad strands and connections of people, ideas, and spaces that interact in a policy field with the ‘aim to deconstruct policy in order to reveal patterns and processes in the organisation of power in society’ (Shore and Wright, 2011: 4). This necessitates tracing key ideas and arguments across multiple sites of activity through the analysis of materials with ethnographic value (including documents, interviews, newspaper articles, parliamentary proceedings). In my paper I apply this approach to examine the use of narratives and modes of political organisation used by key actors inside and outside of government in the development of the reform agenda. I argue that the political claims of a fledgling NGO housing sector seeking a greater role in the housing system elided comfortably with a Treasury and Cabinet agenda to consider new models while seeking overall to minimise the fiscal impact of the existing programme. The paper sheds new light on a major area of social policy reform in New Zealand through the use of interpretive methods.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Often understood to be discarded, ‘waste’ is sought to be made ‘invisible’ or 'hidden' from the gaze of citizens. However, the same standards are not upheld for all residents, or for all forms of waste. The desire for invisibility of waste, often spills over to the experiences of ‘invisibility’ of workers dealing with waste. Waste-work usually entails occupational rigidities, poor conditions of work and low social security (Gill, 2010). Government policies promise ‘improvements’ (Li, 2007), albeit not uncontestedly. Even so, illegal forms of waste-work (e.g. manual scavenging) continue, workers die, and their deaths remain under-reported. Largely unrecognized, waste workers struggle to protect their livelihoods while pathways out of it remain marred by disadvantages of caste and gender, among others.
In this paper, we embed the ‘invisibility’ of waste and waste-workers in practices and processes of the state and society. ‘Visibilizing/seeing,’ and consequent ‘invisibilizing/unseeing’ are not monopolised by the state but are “a labyrinth of forces at work” (Mbembe, 2001). We examine how academic disciplines, government, market and social institutions (un)see waste and waste-workers. Through an understanding of the ‘policy worlds’ (Shore & Wright, 2011) in which waste and waste-workers function, we try and explore how unseeing comes to be used as mechanism/instrument for governance.
We draw on an ethnographic account of a small urban area in central India. We map waste locations, interview waste-workers and government officials, and analyse media reports and policy documents. We use and develop ‘unseeing’ as an analytical tool to traverse and examine the urban landscape. Methodologically, this entails that we focus on the (un)spoken, the (in)action, the (un)written, the (un)heard in the structures, functions, processes and practices of the state and society. We on analyse the data using an iterative analytic strategy using the principles of abductive reasoning (Huffman & Tracy, 2017).
As waste-workers strive to “defend” their position even at the margins (Guru, 2000), we hope to contribute to the understanding of the processes that mediate their continued invisibilization.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Governments are increasingly recognising that they need new approaches to address complex problems (Brunner, 2010: 303). I am interested in why, despite repeated attempts to do so, policy actors continue to struggle to make the shift away from old rational-technical approaches (Phillips-Brown et al., 2012). I focus on the administrative level and examine the tensions between the existing rational-technical approaches and the new norms required that arise in the practice of policy actors as a result of the introduction of reforms (Getha-Taylor et al., 2011: i86). This is in no way to minimize the importance of Indigenous perspectives, but to shine a light on the much neglected administrative failures which contribute to poor outcomes. We often hear that reforms failed because they were “too hard”, but why is it too hard? Why is it so difficult for policy actors to add new approaches to their practice toolkit?
My starting point is that reforms are not introduced onto a blank canvas. They are introduced into an existing policy world, which is both shaped by interactions with policy actors as well as shaping these actors (Shore et al., 2011: 3). If I am to understand why governments struggle with new approaches, I need to understand the existing policy world. I also need to pay careful attention to the ways that policy actors either adapt their practices or resist reforms, and to the role of the existing policy world in these processes.
In this paper I use Logics of Critical Explanation to better understand how policy actors engaged with inherent tensions in Australian remote Indigenous policy where new ways of working are being tested at a national level. I suggest this approach provides important insights into the ongoing resistance to attempts to introduce new norms and into the capacities needed in policy actors asked to implement them.
References
Brunner RD. (2010) Adaptive governance as a reform strategy. Policy Sciences 43: 301-341.
Getha-Taylor H, Holmes MH, Jacobson WS, et al. (2011) Focusing the Public Leadership Lens: Research Propositions and Questions in the Minnowbrook Tradition. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 21: i83-i97.
Phillips-Brown P, Reddel T and Gleeson B. (2012) Learning from experience? Getting governments to listen to what evaluations are telling them. In: Commission P (ed) Better Indigenous Policies: The Role of Evaluation: Roundtable Proceedings, Canberra, 22-23 October 2012. Canberra: Productivity Commission.
Shore C, Wright S and Però D. (2011) Policy worlds: anthropology and the analysis of contemporary power, New York: Berghahn Books.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Ethical critique is a promising analytical approach for those using interpretive methods to understand complex policy worlds. It involves examining social practices and critiquing the values underlying them in order to open up a discursive space to develop something new. In this paper, I outline an ethical critique of a supported housing program for people living with serious mental illness in Queensland, Australia. I draw on interview data collected as part of a 14-year follow up of clients on the program. The policy was framed using a fantasmatic logic where clients would become autonomous, self-actualising people whose need for ongoing care would diminish over time. This was not found to be the case, as many people felt lonely with few social contacts outside the paid support hours. An alternative normative framework that promotes justice for people living with serious mental illness in terms of relationality as well as autonomy opens up new avenues for policy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Global policy assemblages, global policy discourse, global knowledges policy transfers and policy borrowing have all been used to describe the increasing globalisation in education policy. Ball calls this activity ‘global policyspeak’ (2017, 2). Captured by this global policyspeak are ideas such as school choice, the importance of literacy and numeracy and a concentration on lifelong learning and even the importance of equity. Materially the work of international agencies such as the OECD, World Bank and UNESCO have further contributed to global education policy convergence. In many countries this trend is understood as a threat to the national education systems, which have been a key activity of the nation-state. However, in Australia it has had the perverse effect of creating a national school education system, where none has previously existed. School education in Australia has been the responsibility of the state governments within its federated system. This paper uses an interpretive lens to consider how the national scale is legitimised in policy documents while invoking the global and considers what this means for the category of the state using the experience in Australia as a case study.
Ball, Stephen J. 2017. Education policy : major themes in education: Abingdon, Oxon
New York, NY : Routledge.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The central research question addressed in this paper is how grassroots organizing introduce and institutionalize the narrative of fundamental rights in state agencies such as courts, as an effective strategy for their politics of rights claiming through legal validation. The theory that courts can affect pure politics or mega politics is often treated as a backdrop of post-industrial and consolidated democracies of global north, and most cases of civil rights litigation are limited in scope to American-style constitutional experience.
This paper seeks to fill this gap by analyzing the strategies and outcomes of a rights movement in the semi authoritarian context of Pakistan. I argue that, in case of Pakistan, an “issue networks” of professionals, rights-oriented lawyers, and grassroots groups from the impoverished region of Fata, federally administered tribal areas of Pakistan, strategically used protests and litigation at a lower-level court to push for the advancement and recognition of their fundamental rights at the level of Parliament and Supreme Court of Pakistan that did not previously exist in the Constitution. My central explanation for the outcome of the movement is the combined effect of the judicial ideology, institutional changes and organizational support structure in rights litigation which was enabled through the critical national political timing of the movement that resonated well with actors’ demands.
I conducted archival research of the relevant PHC’s judgments on Fata since 2008, relevant policy reports and research studies by several Civil Society Organizations that were key actors in the movement. I also used snowballing method of interviewing to identify key actors and organizations of the movement. The fieldwork allowed me to get archival access to policy reports, briefs, manuals, relevant judgments and a detailed legal and political perspective of the litigants who filed those cases and how they interacted with the court. Finally, I used Critical Discourse Analysis as a tool and insight to detect if the court’s judgments responded to the actors’ demands and if the judgments varied in content over time.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This study focused on the evaluation of the implementation of the Youth Protection Act (LPJ) 2007 amendments in three Youth Centres (CJ) in Quebec. We were interested in the implementation as a process during which the meaning of a policy is constructed by the actors engaged in this process. We examined how this process does or does not lead to a change in their practices and eventually in their understanding and behavior (Spillane, Reiser & Reimer, 2002; Yanow, 2000). We opted for “sensemaking” (Denis et al., 2009; Weick, 1995) and “sensegiving” (Jeong & Brower, 2008) theories to focus not only on the behavior (action) of the actors involved in implementation, but also on the constructive process which led to this action - meanings and how these meanings are communicated. Sensegiving and sensemaking are two interrelated, continuous and perpetual processes (Maitlis, 2005; Stensaker et al., 2008). Specifically, we attempted to respond to this research question: Beyond the observation of the gap between design and implementation of public policies, how to understand this gap in an interpretive perspective? The study is a qualitative secondary analysis of primary data (Heaton, 2004). The evaluator adopted a hermeneutical phenomenology perspective. The phenomenological element is descriptive and account for the organizing experiences and principles that give shape and meaning to the lived world (Kvale 1996, Osborne 1994, Polkinghorne 1983). The second element is hermeneutic, and activates interpretive historical meanings and individual and social developments (Laverty, 2003).
Methodologically, we opted for a research strategy based on multiple, instrumental studies (Stake, 2003; Yin, 2003). The data consisted on individual interviews, focus groups, online questionnaire. Several levels of actors, representatives of all the structures of the three youth centers (CJ), participated in the research: stakeholders, department heads and directors. In all, 159 people participated in an individual or a focus group and 384 responded to the questionnaire. In addition, as each document is a representation of the negotiated self-perception of the organization, we analyzed more than 200 documents (departmental and administrative documents; organizational documentation; the DPJ's provincial results as well as the annual management reports of the three CJs; briefs tabled to the parliamentary committee; and press article). The implementation operates in a context of exchanges and interactions. The use of the sensemaking and sensegiving theories allowed us to consider the flow of information from the political towards the administrative during the implementation process. The analysis insisted on how the policy practitioners recognize, interpret and manage the flow of clues they receive in a complex and an interrelated world of challenges and constraints. We were interested in the mutual influence of different hierarchical level actors and how they succeed -or not- the trajectory of objectified creation towards the intersubjective creation of a collective policy meaning.
References
Denis, J.-L., Lamothe, L., Langley, A., Breton, M., Gervais, J., Trottier, L.-H., . . . Dubois, C.-A. (2009). The reciprocal dynamics of organizing and sense-making in the implementation of major public-sector reforms. Canadian Public Administration, 52(2), 225-248.
Heaton, J. (2004). Reworking qualitative data. UK: Sage Publications Ltd.
Jeong, H.-S. et Brower, R. S. (2008). Extending the present understanding of organizational sensemaking. Administration & Society, 40(3), 223-252.
Kvale, S. (1996). InterViews—An introduction to qualitative research interviewing. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Laverty, S. M. (2003). Hermeneutic phenomenology and phenomenology: A comparison of historical and methodological considerations. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 2(3), 21-35.
Maitlis, S. (2005). The Social processes of organizational sensemaking. The Academy of Management Journal, 48(1), 21-49.
Osborne, J. W. (1994). Some similarities and differences among phenomenological and other methods of psychological qualitative research. Canadian Psychology, 35(2), 167-189.
Polkinghorne, D. (1983). Methodology for the human sciences: Systems of inquiry. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Spillane, J. P., Reiser, B. J. et Reimer, T. (2002). Policy implementation and cognition: Reframing and refocusing implementation research. Review of Educational Research, 72(3), 387-431.
Stake, R. (2003). Standard-based and responsive evaluation. Thousand Oaks, Ca: Sage Publications.
Stensaker, I., Falkenberg, J. et Grønhaug, K. (2008). Implementation activities and organizational sensemaking. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 44(2), 162-185.
Weick, K. E. (1995). Sensemaking in organizations. Thousand Oaks, Ca: Sage Publications.
Yanow, D. (2000). Conducting interpretive policy analysis. Newbury Park: Sage.
Yin, R. K. (2003). Case study research: Design and methods. New-York: Newbury Park, Sage Publications.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This research, developed between 2015 and 2018, was destined to produce data on politics of justice access in the region of Porto Seguro in Southern Bahia, Brazil, both in relation to the operation of the local justice system, as well on the perception of the actors involved in different positions. Porto Seguro is characterized as one of the oldest cities of Brazil, since it was in its territory that the Portuguese caravels docked in 24 of April of 1500. According to the 2010 Census, 5,329 indigenous people were registered in the region, which means that the city is the second in presence of indigenous people in the State of Bahia. It is questioned if the available structure and the solutions to broaden access to justice are adequate to the real needs of its users. Moreover, it is examined whether the agents of the justice system are aware of the local problems and if they are able to recognize differences between their practices and the needs of users to whom they are intended, as proposed by Boaventura de Sousa Santos. Finally, it is asked whether the concept of access to justice of the system agents is compatible with the ethnic and cultural diversity of the region, which would eventually lead to the inadequacy of official mechanisms and the recognition of alternative and community forms of conflicts resolution. It will be examined the conditions and representations about politics of access to justice in Southern Bahia, identifying whether and how the local social and economic changes in recent years have had an impact on the perception of the actors and thw members of the judicial system. The research worked with quantitative and qualitative methodologies focused on the empirical-rhetorical analysis of the discourse. This type of strategy, also called "mixed methods study" (Creswell, Clark), is usefull in researches that requires multiple perspectives of the same problem, as in the case of public or judicial policy evaluation. In accordance with what the "mixed methods" propose, the present research intended to know the speeches and the practices of access to justice in the South of Bahia from two dimensions: I. politics of access to justice and; II. perception of actors about the Justice System and of actual and potential users of the judicial services regarding access to justice. The main research findings, still under analysis, indicate a recent increase in the demand for policies of access to justice, caused by the growth of the touristic sector, as well as the vulnerability of the indigenous population to interpersonal violence and to agrarian conflicts with ruralists. The increase in the rate of urbanization has also been indicated as a catalyst for conflicts, especially in the context of a historic city whose patrimony is protected by law. There was a significant discrepancy between the speeches of state agents and the various civil society actors regarding the concept of justice and the provision of public policies aimed at the attainment of rights.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
New Zealand’s centrally administered housing programme for low income and vulnerable citizens (‘State Housing’) has been a core part of the welfare state since the 1930s. Recent reforms have transformed the programme into a new ‘quasi-market’ system where the government provider now competes with community housing providers for tenants and funding. Scholars have questioned the economics of the reforms (Dykes 2016) and their efficacy in a time of increasing housing scarcity (Howden-Chapman & Baker, 2014). However, little attention has focused on the provenance of the reforms. My paper addresses why and how the reform agenda was pursued by the New Zealand government with special attention paid to the interactions of actors inside and outside of the state. The ‘policy worlds’ approach outlined by Shore and Wright (1997, 2011) provides an interpretivist perspective for analysing the myriad strands and connections of people, ideas, and spaces that interact in a policy field with the ‘aim to deconstruct policy in order to reveal patterns and processes in the organisation of power in society’ (Shore and Wright, 2011: 4). This necessitates tracing key ideas and arguments across multiple sites of activity through the analysis of materials with ethnographic value (including documents, interviews, newspaper articles, parliamentary proceedings). In my paper I apply this approach to examine the use of narratives and modes of political organisation used by key actors inside and outside of government in the development of the reform agenda. I argue that the political claims of a fledgling NGO housing sector seeking a greater role in the housing system elided comfortably with a Treasury and Cabinet agenda to consider new models while seeking overall to minimise the fiscal impact of the existing programme. The paper sheds new light on a major area of social policy reform in New Zealand through the use of interpretive methods.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Often understood to be discarded, ‘waste’ is sought to be made ‘invisible’ or 'hidden' from the gaze of citizens. However, the same standards are not upheld for all residents, or for all forms of waste. The desire for invisibility of waste, often spills over to the experiences of ‘invisibility’ of workers dealing with waste. Waste-work usually entails occupational rigidities, poor conditions of work and low social security (Gill, 2010). Government policies promise ‘improvements’ (Li, 2007), albeit not uncontestedly. Even so, illegal forms of waste-work (e.g. manual scavenging) continue, workers die, and their deaths remain under-reported. Largely unrecognized, waste workers struggle to protect their livelihoods while pathways out of it remain marred by disadvantages of caste and gender, among others.
In this paper, we embed the ‘invisibility’ of waste and waste-workers in practices and processes of the state and society. ‘Visibilizing/seeing,’ and consequent ‘invisibilizing/unseeing’ are not monopolised by the state but are “a labyrinth of forces at work” (Mbembe, 2001). We examine how academic disciplines, government, market and social institutions (un)see waste and waste-workers. Through an understanding of the ‘policy worlds’ (Shore & Wright, 2011) in which waste and waste-workers function, we try and explore how unseeing comes to be used as mechanism/instrument for governance.
We draw on an ethnographic account of a small urban area in central India. We map waste locations, interview waste-workers and government officials, and analyse media reports and policy documents. We use and develop ‘unseeing’ as an analytical tool to traverse and examine the urban landscape. Methodologically, this entails that we focus on the (un)spoken, the (in)action, the (un)written, the (un)heard in the structures, functions, processes and practices of the state and society. We on analyse the data using an iterative analytic strategy using the principles of abductive reasoning (Huffman & Tracy, 2017).
As waste-workers strive to “defend” their position even at the margins (Guru, 2000), we hope to contribute to the understanding of the processes that mediate their continued invisibilization.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)