Format

P07. Policy analysis to address the climate crisis: the politics of knowledge production for public policy

POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Charlotte Halpern
Sciences Po Paris - Centre d'Etudes Européennes (CEE)
Main chair
Philippe Zittoun
ENTPE - LAET - University of Lyon
Second chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

One of the major characteristics of “super wicked problems” (Levin et al., 2012; Auld et al. 2021) lies in the disconnect between, on the one hand, the framing of the problem through expert and academic knowledge, on-streets mobilizations and litigation, and on the other hand, the range of public policy solutions aimed at making the climate issue governable. In this regard, a substantial amount of academic work accounts for the way in which risk dramaturgies deployed by whistleblowers have managed to put the Anthropocene paradigm on the agenda. Policy research across the social sciences has also been able to account for why public policies have, so far, failed to overcome sectoral clashes, paths dependency and competing issues and are never up to the challenges deployed by cause entrepreneurs.

 

Yet the dynamics pertaining to the knowledge production for public policies, the way in which it mutates and transforms according to circulations, tensions and criticisms, the enlistments to which they contribute, the arenas they navigate and the changes in public policies they produce, are yet to be examined. 

 

Drawing on the notion of policy analysis as an overarching concept (Geva-May, Howlett 2012; Cairney 2022), this panel focuses on the production of knowledge for public action (policy analysis) to re-examining transformative change in public policy processes (policy studies). It proposes to build a research agenda aimed at documenting and understanding how, by whom and in which arenas policy analysis to address the climate crisis is being produced and selected. More specifically, it examines how Policy analysis, as a specific type of knowledge, historically concentrated within the state apparatus and produced by large specialized bureaucracies or professions, takes up the ecological and climate problems, and generates acceptable policy solutions.

 

This panel will take place onsite.

CALL FOR PAPERS

Proposals addressing one or the other of the following questions are welcome : 

1) The production of policy analysis, which consists in putting insoluble problems back onto the agenda, redefining them to make them governable, domesticating them to ensure their compatibility with the repertoire of instruments and actions available, transforming them into vehicles for recruiting problem owners and shaping coalitions, supporting the redefinition of possible futures and legitimizing governments in their capacity to act. 
2) A theoretical discussion addressing how discussions and disputes about policy analysis and the study of policy processes contribute to shaping both knowledge production dynamics. This will also allow us to identify possible analytical and conceptual blind spots, as well as to explore existing attempts at revisiting them thanks to the development of new methods and datasets, as well as through interdisciplinary cross-fertilization including natural sciences.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Working with climate refugees for world adaptation: Social work knowledge and practices addressing global human mobility in the context of climate change
Carmen Monico (North Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University, USA)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The global and accelerated dynamics of disasters and pandemics have included ecological degradation and human-made actions producing increased climate displacement and impactful health emergencies. This paper discusses the environmental degradation and ecological disasters associated with climate change, and the resulting planetary, socio-economic and health emergencies. Using case studies and specific examples, the authors review notions about climate refugees, their status around the world, the vulnerabilities of this growing population, and the consequences for not addressing these problems. We examine the nexus of climate change with global migration, and its relevance to those providing assistance to climate refugees. We discuss emerging policy options considered by international agencies and governments at the national and local levels. We examine innovative interventions in working with climate refugees in selected countries, regions, and communities affected by these drastic ecological changes; as well as, practice techniques for radical self-care. We propose to integrate the human face of climate change, and highlight national, regional and global responses for prevention, mitigation and recovery promoting resilience at the individual, family, community and system levels. We analyze the implications for public policy, professional practice, higher education and research of these global changes and adaptation solutions within and across borders.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Balancing Power: Managing the Grid and Political Expectations of Decarbonisation
Jose Maria Valenzuela (University of Oxford)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Political societies expect electricity systems to go through the monumental transformation of full decarbonisation that places pressure on most dimensions of electricity governance. Policymakers, regulators and industrial actors are revisiting objectives and structures, fostering or responding to technological change. This research emphasises two key findings. Firstly, there has been a redefinition of system reliability both technically and discursively, for instance, moving away from an emphasis on “baseload power” to “flexibility” as the basis of reliability. Secondly, system operators have acquired new responsibilities, such as exploring new technologies deployment and developing long-term planning. The research argues that system operators and their mandate to keep the system reliable are thermostatic institutions that are flexible enough to anchor the transformation not only of the electricity system but the whole energy system. They anchor political expectations of future technological transformation. We provide evidence through a social-networks and qualitative research of the organisation of technical knowledge for the transformation of electricity systems across different jurisdictions that have consolidated system operators as stand-alone agencies in Chile, Mexico, and the UK. Interviews with system operators and industrial stakeholders confirm system operators and their focus on reliability as keeping the transition on track through the deployment of both tools for technical regulation, as well as for regulatory and political deliberation.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - The Politics of Diffusion of River Chief System in China
Tingting Wan
CO-AUTHORS
yaguang hao
ABSTRACT

Studying policy diffusion of River Chief System in China, the paper raises the question how a local river chiefs initiative diffuses successfully in China. Little attention has been devoted to the political dimensions of policy diffusion, and this study addresses the gap using a case study approach to examine the politics of policy diffusion model, underpinning the phases and associated mechanisms of diffusion of River Chief System. In this study, we argue that at the issue-definition stage policy entrepreneurs’ political learning and issue definition plays a critical role in River Chief System diffusion, matching between local needs and central preferences in the Chinese ‘politics of diffusion’ mode within specific local policy environment.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Interpretive capacities of indigenous people to adapt to climate change: Can it be incorporated in official climate change agendas?
Ksenia Gerasimova (Higher School of Economics S)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In 2019 the World Bank changed its climate change resilience strategy from addressing adaptation as an incremental cost and isolated investment to syste3matically managing and incorporating climate risks and opportunities ar evwery  phase of policy planning, investment design, implementation and evaluation (WB, 2019). Does it mean a complete transfer from mitigation measures into climate crisis adaptation strategy? The importnat question is who should and adopt such strategies? One of the most affected gropus are indigenous communities in most vulnerable eco-systems. As they are facing existential threatas at higher speed than others, they also have a capacity 'to interpret and react to the impacts of climate change in creative ways, drawing on traditional knowledge and other technologies to find solutions which may help society at large to cope with impending changes' (UN, 2008). 

This paper will compare applied strategies to adapt to climate change by Tibetans in the Chinese Tibetan Autonomous Region and the Nenets people (Samoyeds) in the Yamalo-Nenetz region, Russia, drawing on the fieldwork conducted in 2018-2023 to assess policy capacities of this stakeholder group from three perspectives: analytical, operational and political (Wu et al, 2018). The discussion will conclude with the review of existing policy tools to enhance resilience among indigenous communities and discuss how their internal strategies match with official regional agendas and climate change policies.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - When inventories are the policy : Paris and the (still) fragmentary accounting of GHG emissions
Charlotte Halpern (Sciences Po Paris - Centre d'Etudes Européennes (CEE))
CO-AUTHORS
Alvaro Artigas (Institut d'Etudes Politiques de Paris (Sciences Po))
ABSTRACT

Often introduced as part of local climate action plans, GHG inventories contribute to assigning policy priorities, targeting sectors considered instrumental to much needed environmental change, and to the sidelining of those deemed less prominent in this endeavor. Eisenack and Roggero (2022) describe the main research on urban climate action as addressing mitigation planning, adaptation planning, emissions reductions, and network membership. However, recent research (Neij and Heiskanen 2021) has found a relevant gap into how the measurement of urban climate policy success is assessed, as well as how the specific arrangements pertaining to the governance of urban climate transitions and policy learning dynamics work when seeking to improve the instrumentation and ultimately the greater impact of these programs.


Departing of the increasing disconnect between ambitious environmental policy objectives and their material expression in local climate plans, this paper will explore the case of Paris, seeking to address the full extent of the complexity of GHG inventories in a context of rapid city innovation, shifting climate action plans and still fragmentary metropolitan coordination. It will in particular address how GHG inventorisation have evolved from an environmental policy instrument into a fully fledged policy of its own, as a consequence of the increasing complexity of emissions assessment, but also the politicization of the methods and sectors concerned in the form of new services (e.g., distributed energy), technologies (e.g., H2, electric mobilities) and stakeholders of these new services (e.g., global platforms among others), and ultimately the extent to which GHG inventories account for it. Examining the processes through which these inventories were developed and transformed, it will seek to account in particular how evolving environmental policy capacities (whereas national or local) connected to them have become critical components of local climate action plans credibility.

 

 

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Developing a dynamic adaptive policy pathway exploring the roles of technology-based carbon dioxide removal in Canada to make the grand challenges of decarbonisation and socioeconomic equity more governable
Vanessa Schweizer (University of Waterloo)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The insolubility of climate change has evolved over time from an inconvenient truth with high up-front costs for reconfiguring global energy and land-use systems to a behemoth, multi-faceted quandary of multiple interconnected forms (e.g., man vs. nature, man vs. society, man vs. man) under unforgiving time pressure. Technological innovations such as carbon dioxide removal (CDR) put more options on the table for policymakers; however, expanding the menu of policy options complicates further the decision context and creates demand for policy analysis. This paper reports the progress of such policy analysis in Canada delivered through an ongoing interdisciplinary project led by a team of engineers, legal scholars, and an economist. The project employs the analytical approach of developing a dynamic adaptive policy pathway (DAPP) from the field of decision making under deep uncertainty. A feature of DAPP is that it distils various complexities of a long-term policy problem into an information-dense yet readily understandable visual similar to a metro map. Key project goals are to employ DAPP to give shape to the potential of technology-based CDR (specifically direct air capture technology) to provide Canadians opportunities in low-carbon and potentially more just futures that expand energy access. The project serves as an example of policy analysis that aims to make the grand challenges of decarbonisation and socioeconomic equity more governable and aims to shape policy processes affecting the future of Canadian climate policy.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Translating Global Policy Instruments: The Case of the Adoption of São Paulo Climate Action Plan
Osmany Porto de Oliveira (Universidade Federal de São Paulo)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT
 

The literature on global public policies has gained space in discussions on public policy studies. The concept is used to analyze responses to problems that affect people on a global scale, such as hunger, poverty, health crises, among others. Examples of global public policies are the United Nations agendas, such as the New Urban Agenda or the 2030 Agenda. Climate instability is one of the most complex and imminent problems of contemporary times. Global public policies, aimed at mitigating the evolution of climate instability and helping society adapt to this situation, are embedded in a complex transnational architecture. Among the main pillars of this architecture are the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change and the Paris Agreement. One of the paradoxes of global public policies for the climate concerns the fact that it is a global risk, which is experienced at the local level. This research aims to understand the transfer of global public policies to the climate in the city of São Paulo. More specifically, it seeks to answer the following questions: Why the city of São Paulo decided to transfer global climate change policies? Which policy instruments were transferred and how these were translated to the local context? This research proposes to make an innovative analysis based on the association between the literature on global public policies, policy transfers and policy instruments. The methodological strategy is carried out through a case study, which will use the process-tracing technique, as an analytical tool, and interviews, research in official documents and the media, as instruments for the collection of empirical evidence.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The global and accelerated dynamics of disasters and pandemics have included ecological degradation and human-made actions producing increased climate displacement and impactful health emergencies. This paper discusses the environmental degradation and ecological disasters associated with climate change, and the resulting planetary, socio-economic and health emergencies. Using case studies and specific examples, the authors review notions about climate refugees, their status around the world, the vulnerabilities of this growing population, and the consequences for not addressing these problems. We examine the nexus of climate change with global migration, and its relevance to those providing assistance to climate refugees. We discuss emerging policy options considered by international agencies and governments at the national and local levels. We examine innovative interventions in working with climate refugees in selected countries, regions, and communities affected by these drastic ecological changes; as well as, practice techniques for radical self-care. We propose to integrate the human face of climate change, and highlight national, regional and global responses for prevention, mitigation and recovery promoting resilience at the individual, family, community and system levels. We analyze the implications for public policy, professional practice, higher education and research of these global changes and adaptation solutions within and across borders.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Political societies expect electricity systems to go through the monumental transformation of full decarbonisation that places pressure on most dimensions of electricity governance. Policymakers, regulators and industrial actors are revisiting objectives and structures, fostering or responding to technological change. This research emphasises two key findings. Firstly, there has been a redefinition of system reliability both technically and discursively, for instance, moving away from an emphasis on “baseload power” to “flexibility” as the basis of reliability. Secondly, system operators have acquired new responsibilities, such as exploring new technologies deployment and developing long-term planning. The research argues that system operators and their mandate to keep the system reliable are thermostatic institutions that are flexible enough to anchor the transformation not only of the electricity system but the whole energy system. They anchor political expectations of future technological transformation. We provide evidence through a social-networks and qualitative research of the organisation of technical knowledge for the transformation of electricity systems across different jurisdictions that have consolidated system operators as stand-alone agencies in Chile, Mexico, and the UK. Interviews with system operators and industrial stakeholders confirm system operators and their focus on reliability as keeping the transition on track through the deployment of both tools for technical regulation, as well as for regulatory and political deliberation.

CO-AUTHORS
yaguang hao
ABSTRACT

Studying policy diffusion of River Chief System in China, the paper raises the question how a local river chiefs initiative diffuses successfully in China. Little attention has been devoted to the political dimensions of policy diffusion, and this study addresses the gap using a case study approach to examine the politics of policy diffusion model, underpinning the phases and associated mechanisms of diffusion of River Chief System. In this study, we argue that at the issue-definition stage policy entrepreneurs’ political learning and issue definition plays a critical role in River Chief System diffusion, matching between local needs and central preferences in the Chinese ‘politics of diffusion’ mode within specific local policy environment.

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In 2019 the World Bank changed its climate change resilience strategy from addressing adaptation as an incremental cost and isolated investment to syste3matically managing and incorporating climate risks and opportunities ar evwery  phase of policy planning, investment design, implementation and evaluation (WB, 2019). Does it mean a complete transfer from mitigation measures into climate crisis adaptation strategy? The importnat question is who should and adopt such strategies? One of the most affected gropus are indigenous communities in most vulnerable eco-systems. As they are facing existential threatas at higher speed than others, they also have a capacity 'to interpret and react to the impacts of climate change in creative ways, drawing on traditional knowledge and other technologies to find solutions which may help society at large to cope with impending changes' (UN, 2008). 

This paper will compare applied strategies to adapt to climate change by Tibetans in the Chinese Tibetan Autonomous Region and the Nenets people (Samoyeds) in the Yamalo-Nenetz region, Russia, drawing on the fieldwork conducted in 2018-2023 to assess policy capacities of this stakeholder group from three perspectives: analytical, operational and political (Wu et al, 2018). The discussion will conclude with the review of existing policy tools to enhance resilience among indigenous communities and discuss how their internal strategies match with official regional agendas and climate change policies.

CO-AUTHORS
Alvaro Artigas (Institut d'Etudes Politiques de Paris (Sciences Po))
ABSTRACT

Often introduced as part of local climate action plans, GHG inventories contribute to assigning policy priorities, targeting sectors considered instrumental to much needed environmental change, and to the sidelining of those deemed less prominent in this endeavor. Eisenack and Roggero (2022) describe the main research on urban climate action as addressing mitigation planning, adaptation planning, emissions reductions, and network membership. However, recent research (Neij and Heiskanen 2021) has found a relevant gap into how the measurement of urban climate policy success is assessed, as well as how the specific arrangements pertaining to the governance of urban climate transitions and policy learning dynamics work when seeking to improve the instrumentation and ultimately the greater impact of these programs.


Departing of the increasing disconnect between ambitious environmental policy objectives and their material expression in local climate plans, this paper will explore the case of Paris, seeking to address the full extent of the complexity of GHG inventories in a context of rapid city innovation, shifting climate action plans and still fragmentary metropolitan coordination. It will in particular address how GHG inventorisation have evolved from an environmental policy instrument into a fully fledged policy of its own, as a consequence of the increasing complexity of emissions assessment, but also the politicization of the methods and sectors concerned in the form of new services (e.g., distributed energy), technologies (e.g., H2, electric mobilities) and stakeholders of these new services (e.g., global platforms among others), and ultimately the extent to which GHG inventories account for it. Examining the processes through which these inventories were developed and transformed, it will seek to account in particular how evolving environmental policy capacities (whereas national or local) connected to them have become critical components of local climate action plans credibility.

 

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The insolubility of climate change has evolved over time from an inconvenient truth with high up-front costs for reconfiguring global energy and land-use systems to a behemoth, multi-faceted quandary of multiple interconnected forms (e.g., man vs. nature, man vs. society, man vs. man) under unforgiving time pressure. Technological innovations such as carbon dioxide removal (CDR) put more options on the table for policymakers; however, expanding the menu of policy options complicates further the decision context and creates demand for policy analysis. This paper reports the progress of such policy analysis in Canada delivered through an ongoing interdisciplinary project led by a team of engineers, legal scholars, and an economist. The project employs the analytical approach of developing a dynamic adaptive policy pathway (DAPP) from the field of decision making under deep uncertainty. A feature of DAPP is that it distils various complexities of a long-term policy problem into an information-dense yet readily understandable visual similar to a metro map. Key project goals are to employ DAPP to give shape to the potential of technology-based CDR (specifically direct air capture technology) to provide Canadians opportunities in low-carbon and potentially more just futures that expand energy access. The project serves as an example of policy analysis that aims to make the grand challenges of decarbonisation and socioeconomic equity more governable and aims to shape policy processes affecting the future of Canadian climate policy.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT
 

The literature on global public policies has gained space in discussions on public policy studies. The concept is used to analyze responses to problems that affect people on a global scale, such as hunger, poverty, health crises, among others. Examples of global public policies are the United Nations agendas, such as the New Urban Agenda or the 2030 Agenda. Climate instability is one of the most complex and imminent problems of contemporary times. Global public policies, aimed at mitigating the evolution of climate instability and helping society adapt to this situation, are embedded in a complex transnational architecture. Among the main pillars of this architecture are the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change and the Paris Agreement. One of the paradoxes of global public policies for the climate concerns the fact that it is a global risk, which is experienced at the local level. This research aims to understand the transfer of global public policies to the climate in the city of São Paulo. More specifically, it seeks to answer the following questions: Why the city of São Paulo decided to transfer global climate change policies? Which policy instruments were transferred and how these were translated to the local context? This research proposes to make an innovative analysis based on the association between the literature on global public policies, policy transfers and policy instruments. The methodological strategy is carried out through a case study, which will use the process-tracing technique, as an analytical tool, and interviews, research in official documents and the media, as instruments for the collection of empirical evidence.