Format

W07. Bringing policy actors back in. Relevance and prospects of actor-centered approaches in policy studies

Policy Process , Policy & Politics, Policymaking, Policy implentation
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Jose Luis Mendez
El Colegio de México
Main chair
Patrick Hassenteufel
Université Paris-Saclay
Second chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
Policy Process , Policy & Politics, Policymaking, Policy implentation
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Overall objective

This workshop will aim to tackle three main topics. The first one is the perception of the role of actors in the main theories or approaches for the study of public policy. The second one is related to the several dimensions involved in the role of actors in policy processes as compared to other factors, for instance institutions or junctures. The third issue is the methodology for the analysis of policy actors. The overall objective is to set off a more systematic and coherent research agenda which could lead to the further theoretical clarification and empirical support of the role of actors in the policy process and politics in general.

Context, state of the art and scientific relevance

Although by no means the only perspective, in the last decades the neo-institutionalist approach (in its three versions, sociologic, historic and rational choice) has exerted a great influence in the study of social and political processes. In turn, the comparison of dominant theories of the policy process (Sabatier and Weible 2017) shows that they mainly focus on the systemic level of analysis. Even if these theories take into account individual actors (for instance policy entrepreneurs in the multiple stream framework or policy brokers in the advocacy coalition approach) or collective agents (for instance interest groups and administrations in the punctuated equilibrium theory), they don’t directly address the role of actors in the policy processes as compared to other factors, such as institutions or junctures.

After more than two decades in which structural-centered approaches brought a great deal of the attention in social sciences, more recently the importance of actors has started to emerge, for instance in revised neo-institutionalist perspectives (Scharpf 1997; Mahoney and Thelen 2010) as well as studies on political leadership (Edwards 2009; Helms 2012), neopopulist leaders (Moffit 2016) or public policy (Knoepfel, Larrue, Varone and Hill 2011)

In fact, it can be said that there is in the social sciences a long theoretical tradition stressing the importance of agents´ strategic action. Although it goes back to Machiavelli and Weber, this perspective started to slowly reemerge in various fields after Arrow showed the instability of social choice, for instance in political science (Schattschneider 1961; Riker 1986) or the sociology of organizations (Crozier and Friedberg 1980).

As it can be seen, since some time ago several authors have made important contributions for the development of an actor-centered approach. However, we believe that such contributions still do not offer a precise enough set of traits of agents´ action as to allow for a systematic comparison of cases in order to develop a clearer actor-centered framework for the understanding of policy processes. This workshop aims at discussing the ways in which such framework can be better developed; thus, we expect it will make a key contribution to the study of public policy processes and political processes more generally.

Main hypotheses

The hypotheses this workshop wants to explore are related to the idea that actors are key factors for the adequate explanation of policy processes. The main tenant we start from is that although institutions are no doubt key factors for the understanding of political or policy equilibrium, such equilibrium is not self-sustaining; in other words, it is also kept by the strategic moves of its upholders against its opponents. Likewise, institutional decline may encourage but cannot directly produce policy change, which requires the intervention of actors. In turn, ideas may be floating around but it is actors who choose them (or not) to define the direction and intensity of change. Therefore, it is expected that the workshop shows how within institutional or ideological settings agents enjoy important “degrees of freedom” (Archer 1995), based on the accumulation of specific resources, and in which ways their decisions are crucial for policy outcomes. In short, instead of conflating structure and agency and falling into one or other determinism, the actor-centered perspective argues that institutions, ideologies, junctures, etc. are important because they frame agent´s perceptions and strategies, but such contextual factors do not determine specific courses of action: agents still have to choose among different options and the specific way (strategic or not) they do so is a key factor precipitating or precluding certain policy outcomes.

Organization of the workshop

The workshop will be organized around three topics, corresponding to three workshop´s sessions:

1.     Actors in approaches of the policy process.

In this session the aim is to discuss the role assigned to actors in dominant theories of the policy process, such as neo-institutionalism, advocacy coalition framework, policy narratives, multiple stream framework, etc. The session would address the following questions: What kind of actors (individual/collective, informal/organized, local/national/international) are taken into account in the theories of the policy process? How are they defined and analyzed? Are actors considered as an explaining factor of policy change (or continuity)?

2. Characteristics and role of actors in the policy process.

This session is focused on the empirical study of the role of specific kinds of actors in the policy process: individual actors (policy brokers, policy entrepreneurs, political leaders) and/or collective actors (parties, interest groups, networks), in relation to the following questions: How far can policy actors be considered as an explaining factor of the policy process (or part of it)? What are we referring to when focusing on agents, i.e. ideas, interests, strategies, resources or capacities? To what extent does their role depend on context? What should be considered as an actor: individuals, networks, groups? What is their relationship with stability and change? How is it possible to explain the role of these actors in the policy process (holding of specific resources, strategic capacities, institutional positions, policy learning, policy discourses, etc.)?

3.     Methods for the analysis of policy actors.

The core questions of this session are: What methodologies better help to identify, characterize and understand the role of actors in the policy process? Is it possible to combine them? An analysis of policy actors supposes to rely on methods able to analyze topics such as the trajectories and resources of individual actors in order to understand their involvement in the policy process; the relations between actors, especially personal links and shared policy conceptions and discourses; organized actors, especially their functioning and internal relations; and the involvement of policy actors at different stages of the policy process.

Type of papers, dynamics of sessions and expected result

Given the above mentioned three sessions of the workshop, the kind of papers that we expect to receive are theoretical, empirical and methodological. The dynamics of the sessions would be organized around several sets of papers within each session, followed by short reactions by one discussant and the rest of the participants within each set; each session will be concluded by a general discussion. In the months following the workshop, the chairs will follow-up on the development of the drafts presented, so that a collective book “bringing back” actors in the study of the policy process can be presented to a publishing house in 2019.

Possible participants (to be confirmed)

First session

1.     Actors and neo-institutional approaches (Raul Pacheco-Vega, Center for Economic Research, Aguascalientes, Mexico)

2.     Actors and ideational/cognitive perspectives on the policy process (Melina Rocha, Getulio Vargas Foundation, Rio de Janeiro)

3.     Actors and interpretative approaches on the policy process (Jennifer Dodge, State University of New York-Albany)

4.     Actors and the multiple stream approach (Ana Diaz, Center for Economic Research, Mexico City)

5.     Actors and the policy instruments perspective (Michael Howlett, John Fraser University, Vancouver)

Second session

1.     Actors as veto-players (Larry Brown, Columbia University)

2.     Transnational networks of actors (Osmany Porto de Oliveira, Federal University of Sao-Paulo)

3.     Intermediary role of actors and political work (Andy Smith, Sciences Po Bordeaux, France)

4.     Actors and strategic interaction (Jose-Luis Mendez, El Colegio de Mexico)

Third session

1.     Sociology of elites methods and the analysis of programmatic actors (William Genieys, University of Montpellier and Patrick Hassenteufel, University of Versailles, France)

2.     Integrating psychological dimensions in the empirical analysis of policy actors (Nils Bandelow and Johanna Hornung, University of Braunschweig, Germany)

3.     Methodologies for the analysis of actor’s policy learning (Stéphane Moyson, Catholic University of Leuwen, Belgium)

 

References

Archer, M., 1995, Realist Social Theory. The Morphogenetic Approach. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Crozier, M. and E. Friedberg, 1980, Actors and Systems. Chicago, The University of Chicago Press.

Edwards, G., The Strategic President. Princeton, Princeton University Press.

Helms, L., 2012, Comparative Political Leadership. London, Palgrave.

Knoepfel, P.  C. Larrue, F. Varone and M. Hill, 2011, Public Policy Analysis. Bristol, Policy Press.

Mahoney, J. and K. Thelen (eds.) 2010, Explaining Institutional Change: Ambiguity, Agency, and Power. Cambridge, UK, Cambridge University Press.

Moffit, B., 2016, The Global Rise of Populism: Performance, Political Style, and Representation. Stanford, Cal., Stanford University Press.

Riker, W., 1986, The Art of Political Manipulation. New Heaven, Yale University Press.

Sabatier, P. and C. Weible, 2017, Theories of the Policy Process. Boulder, Westview.

Scharpf, F., 1997, Games Real Actors Play: Actor-Centered Institutionalism in Policy Research. Boulder, Westview.

Schattschneider, E.E., 1961, The semi-sovereign people. New York, Rinehart and Winston.

CALL FOR PAPERS

The comparison of dominant theories of the policy process (Sabatier/Weible 2017) shows that they mainly focus on the systemic level of analysis. Even if they take into account individual actors (for instance policy entrepreneurs in the multiple stream framework or policy brokers in the advocacy coalition approach) or collective agents (for instance interest groups and administrations in the punctuated equilibrium theory), they don’t directly address two main issues this workshop would aim to tackle. The first one is the role of policy actors in the policy processes as compared to other factors, for instance institutions or junctures. In this regard, the workshop would address some questions rather neglected in the policy field, such as: What is the role of actors in the various theories of the policy process? What is the specific relevance of policy actors in policy-making? What are we referring to when focusing on actors, i.e. ideas, interests, strategies, resources or capacities? To what extent does their role depend on specific contexts? What should be considered as an actor: individuals, networks, groups? What is their relationship with stability and change? The second issue is the methodology for the analysis of policy actors, as the methodologies proposed by the main theories of the policy process do not aim directly at the analysis of agents: for instance the coding of hearings (advocacy coalition framework), of discourses (policy narrative approach) or of the content of policy agendas (punctuated equilibrium framework). A key question in this regard is therefore: What methodologies help to identify, characterize and understand the role of actors in the policy process?

The workshop will be organized around three topics:

  1. Actors in approaches of the policy process. In this session we are interested in papers discussing the role assigned to actors in dominant theories of the policy process: neo-institutionalism, advocacy coalition framework, policy narratives, multiple stream framework, constructivism, punctuated equilibrium framework, etc., and/or proposing new frameworks based on policy actors.
  2. Characteristics and role of actors in the policy process. For this more empirical session we are looking for contributions comparing different policy fields and taking into account the multi-level dimensions of the policy process and focused on the empirical study of the role of specific kind of actors in the policy actors: individual actors (policy brokers, policy entrepreneurs, political leaders, etc.) and/or collective actors (organized and institutionalized or more loosely structured around shared ideas, discourses and/or informal interpersonal links) in relation to the following questions: Are these actors involved in the whole policy process or only part of it? How is it possible to explain the role of these actors in the policy process? Are these actors favoring or limiting policy change? How far can policy actors be considered as an explaining factor of the policy process (or part of it)?
  3. Methods for the analysis of policy actors. For this session we are interested in papers presenting and discussing the methods allowing to characterize and assess of the role of specific actors in the policy process.
ABSTRACT

The comparison of dominant theories of the policy process (Sabatier/Weible 2015) shows that they mainly focus on the systemic level of analysis. Even if they take into account individual actors (for instance policy entrepreneurs in the multiple stream framework or policy brokers in the advocacy coalition approach) or collective agents (for instance interest groups and administrations in the punctuated equilibrium theory), they don’t directly address two main issues this workshop will aim to tackle. The first one is the role of policy actors in the policy processes as compared to other factors, for instance institutions or junctures. In this regard, the workshop would address some questions rather neglected in the policy field, such as: What is the relevance of actors in the policy process? What are we referring to when focusing on agents, i.e. ideas, interests, strategies, resources or capacities? To what extent does their role depend on specific contexts? What should be considered as an actor: individuals, networks, groups? What is their relationship with stability and change? The second issue is the methodology for the analysis of policy actors, as the methodologies proposed by the main theories of the policy process do not aim directly at the analysis of agents: for instance the coding of hearings (advocacy coalition framework), of discourses (policy narrative approach) or of the content of policy agendas (punctuated equilibrium framework). A key question in this regard is therefore: What methodologies help to identify, characterize and understand the role of actors in the policy process? According to the previous discussion, the workshop will be organized around three topics, corresponding to the three workshop´s sessions: 1) The role of actors in approaches of the policy process. 2) Characteristics and role of agents in the policy process. And 3) Methods for the analysis of policy actors.

BIOGRAPHICAL PRESENTATION

Jose-Luis Mendez. He is Research-Professor at El Colegio de Mexico, in Mexico City, and Level III National Researcher of the National Council of Science and Technology. He is a member of the College of the International Public Policy Association. His main research interests are the evolution of the policy field, policy change and actor-centered approaches for the study of policy. Some of his recent publications are “Presidents’ Strategic Action and Policy Change in Mexico: A Comparison of the Hydrocarbon Policy Reforms of Enrique Peña and Felipe Calderon”, Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice, 2017; “Policy Analysis and Bureaucratic Capacity” (co-author with M. Dussauge), in M. Brans, I. Geva-May and M. Howlett (eds.), Routledge Handbook of Comparative Policy Analysis. Routledge, 2017; Policy Analysis in Mexico (coeditor with Mauricio Dussauge). Bristol, The Policy Press, 2017; "Implementing Developed Countries Administrative Reforms in Developing Countries: The Case of Mexico", in J. Pierre and P. Ingraham (eds.), Public Sector Administrative Reform and the Challenges of Effective Change. Ottawa. McGill University Press, 2010; "Toward More Balanced Approaches in the Reform of the State", in J. Dominguez and A. Jones (eds.), The Construction of Democracy. Lessons from Practice & Research. Baltimore, The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2007.

 

Patrick Hassenteufel. He is Professor of political science at the University of Versailles-Paris Saclay and researcher at Printemps (CNRS research center). His main research interests are actor-centered approaches for the comparative study of policy changes, mainly in the fields of health, social security and economic policies. Some of his recent publications are “From Policy Analytical Styles to Policy Making Styles” (co-authored with P. Zittoun), in M. Brans, I. Geva-May and M. Howlett (eds.), Routledge Handbook of Comparative Policy Analysis, Routledge, 2017; Policy Analysis in France (coedited with C. Halpern and P. Zittoun), Bristol, The Policy Press, 2017; “The shaping of New State Elites. Healthcare policy making since 1981” (co-authored with W. Genieys), Comparative Politics, 2015; “Still the sound of Silence? Towards a new phase in the Europeanisation of Welfare State policies in France” (co-authored with B. Palier), Comparative European Politics, 2015. He is the co-editor in chief of Gouvernement et action publique and member of the board of the French Political Science Association (AFSP).

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Whom can you trust? Comparing policy positions from surveys or content analysis
Marlene Kammerer (Institute for Political Science )
CO-AUTHORS
Karin Ingold (University of Bern)
Frédéric Varone (University of Geneva)
ABSTRACT

Theories of the policy process in general and of interest group lobbying in particular are concerned in how corporate actors translate their ideologies, values, and preferences into concrete policy decisions. To identify these policy preferences, empirical studies apply two main techniques: content analysis of official documents and surveys of policy stakeholders. This information about actors’ positions is then used to explain the policy process or outputs, coordination or collaboration, and policy success or failure. Policy preferences gathered through content analysis or survey data are given considerable explanatory power in many empirical studies. In consequence, identifying and explaining a potential mismatch between officially and survey-stated preferences is highly relevant for policy studies. However, not much is understood about the differences between positions stated in official documents as contrasted to elite surveys on the same policy issue. This article analyses whether we observe such alterations between data on policy preferences produced by content analysis or surveys and asks how these divergences can be explained. Specifically, it investigates why some political actors diverge in their policy preferences and what kind of policy instruments or subsystem types are more prone for divergent preference statements. This article relies empirically on three different policy subsystems in Switzerland: climate, energy, and water protection. In all three policy fields, public and private actors, such as non-governmental organizations (NGO), trade unions, business and citizen groups, scientific experts, political parties, and public agencies, were invited by the Swiss federal government to public consultation procedures to officially pronounce their policy preferences on specific aspects in the respective policy processes. These rich official documents constitute the basis for coding policy positions by content analysis. Once the policy-making process was over, the same policy actors were surveyed and asked about the policy positions they had supported during the decision-making process. By comparing both sources of information on policy preferences, we are able to identify which actors deviate in their policy positions between official statements and survey answers. This (potential) reporting gap constitutes the main dependent variable in this analysis. A multi-level regression analysis is applied to assess the impact of both individual actor- and subsystem-based variables on this reporting gap. The preliminary results show that actors more strongly deviate in their policy positions between surveys and official statements in relation to contested policy instruments, and when the level of conflict in the subsystem is high.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Policy Elites and Programmatic Actors : The Role of Custodians of State Policies in Health Care Policy change in the United States since the 1970s
William Genieys (Sciencespo Paris- CEE - CNRS )
CO-AUTHORS
Lawrence Brown (Columbia University in the city of New York)
ABSTRACT

Policy elites-- what William Genieys has termed "custodians of state policy"-- have played crucial roles in shaping health care policy in the United States. The backgrounds and agendas of these elites have shifted, however, as the nation's struggles over national health insurance came to accommodate the preoccupation with cost containment and as policymakers sought to forge innovative combinations of public authority and market forces. Drawing on three important episodes-- legislation to promote health maintainance organizations in the early 1970s, the reform proposed by President Bill Clinton in 1993-94, and the creation of the Affordable Care Act in 2010-- this paper explores patterns of continuity and change in the composition and contributions of policy elites in the shaping of US health care policy.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - The Political Rigging Framework: A Research Agenda for Analyzing Who Influences Policy Decisions in the 21st Century, and How
Janine Wedel (George Mason University)
CO-AUTHORS
Dana Dolan (George Mason University, Schar School of Policy and Government)
Hussain Nazia (Center for Policy Research, United Nations University)
ABSTRACT

The Political Rigging Framework: A Research Agenda for Analyzing Who Influences Policy Decisions in the 21st Century, and How

 

Democracy is under siege around the world. Many analysts point to the 2016 election of Donald Trump – a businessman, television celebrity, and political outsider who continues to display open contempt for constitutional rights and the norms of political behavior – as marking a new era of democratic fragility. We contend it has not. Instead, the rise of Trump, and indeed a growing number of elected “populists” in nations around the world, are symptoms of a democratic governance reconfiguration underpinned by the interactions of several long-term processes over the past several decades: financialization; privatization and deregulation; the end of the Cold War, dispersing global authority and opening up sparsely governed arenas; and digitization and new information technologies. These four transformational developments have created opportunities for novel forms of influencing, with dramatic implications for democratic accountability. The developments call into question traditional assumptions about policymaking. If we are to understand the impact of these shifts on contemporary policymaking, our seminal public policy theories require a frank reappraisal. Ironically, this call comes at a time when scholars are extending several theoretical frameworks, many developed in U.S. contexts, and some dating back to the early 1980s, to explain policymaking in international contexts.

 

Our project focuses beyond Lasswell's definition of politics as “who gets what, when, and how,” to ask not only who decides, but more tellingly: who influences those who decide, and how? These questions direct attention to a new set of policy actors - influence elites - who bypass democratic accountability to engage in what we call “political rigging,” a set of novel influencing practices.  The outcome is a self-reinforcing cycle that enables actors to avoid accountability. Influence elites draw their power from occupying multiple official and private roles and blurring the boundaries among political, economic, media, cultural, and social arenas. Importantly, scholars trying to make sense of contemporary policymaking by using traditional theories of the policy process can easily overlook these new actors, who fail to fit neatly into existing conceptual categories of policy actors such as congresspersons, lobbyists, or interest groups.

 

To address this critical blind spot, we introduce several concepts as a first stage in developing our Political Rigging Framework (PRF). Specifically, we draw on theoretical insights and empirical examples to show how influence elites manipulate the system through an evolving set of practices that incorporate the principles of informality, flexibility, and digital-powered simulacra. Informality refers to practices that actors employ as they navigate shifting (and normatively constructed) formal arenas.  Flexibility empowers individual actors, groups, organizations, and social networks to maneuver among official and private spheres and among political, economic, and legal arenas in unaccountable ways. Finally, digital-powered simulacra leverage the “civic” space of the Internet, as well changing traditional media, to invisibly mold public opinion toward undetectable ends.

 

Scholars may employ these three concepts to extend and update traditional policy process frameworks; however, we suggest that a fundamentally new framework is required to uncover the structures and practices of political rigging that influence elites help create, of which they are a part, and from which they benefit. This new framework must look beyond formal institutions and organizations to recognize the less visible—but ever-present—role of informality in shaping living governing systems. It must move beyond static frameworks that limit understanding of dynamic processes and the roles of flexible, mobile players in shaping the system. It must recognize that systems can be rigged in different ways and combinations, rather than existing as either “captured” or otherwise. Finally, the new framework must begin with individual influencers as the point of entry to examining complex, dynamic systems. We propose a new research agenda aimed at developing the Political Rigging Framework, guided by these three concepts.

 

Further, we invite fellow workshop participants to explore how these concepts might challenge the underlying assumptions of dominant theories of the policy process. For example, do the practices of informality and flexibility enable new ways of influencing the problem, policy, and political streams in the Multiple Streams Framework? Do digital-powered simulacra undermine the validity of using national newspaper reports to study attention swings in the Punctuated Equilibrium Theory? Can digital-powered simulacra enabled by Twitter and other forms of social media be taken at face value to inform Narrative Policy Analysis studies?

 

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - The Relevance of Actor-Centred Approaches to Effective Policy Formulation and Implementation
Chikowore Andrew Itai (ActionAid )
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The study seeks to highlight the importance and efficiency of actor-centred approaches in policy formulation. Attention will focus on actors and their roles in policy formulation processes such as the public, media, legislators, political parties, judiciary, government executive and civil society. Actors will be categorised into formal and informal entities where the executive, legislators, judiciary and civil servants are the formal players and the civil society (interest groups, political parties and pressure groups), individual citizens, media, think tanks and research institutions make up the informal actors. While the formal actors are tasked with the overall policy formulation process, the informal actors are important in expressing policy demnads, proposing policy alternatives, providing research, mobilizing citizens through political activisms to advance rational policy formulation. This justifies the intention of this paper which is meant to advance and respond to questions about the importance of the actor-centrerd approachs in policy studies, the effectiveness, role and rational of different actors and how solutions can be sought by engaging different actors in policy studies.

 Based on the above, it is premised that effective policies, including implementation is possible through effective engagement of all actors. The policy cycle approach through its six stages in collaboration with other policy models will be used to understand the role and rational of having various actors involved in policy formulation in each of the stages. This will make it possible to analyse whether these actors advance or limit policy processes either by genuinely advocating for development or selfishly advancing their own interests. The other frameworks and models that will be used together with the policy cycle approach include: the multiple stream, advocacy coalition, policy narrative frameworks, and the punctuated equilibrum, rational, incremental and institutional models.  

Kingdon’s “Multiple Streams Framework” focuses on stages of problem identification (alteration specification) and agenda setting. The Advocacy Coalition framework will reveal the significance of actors in developing effective policies by translating group beliefs of engagement in policy making. The Policy Narrative Framework will be employed for its importance in determining public opinion and influencing governmental action. The Punctuated Equilibrium model will be essential in monitoring and evaluating the magnitude of policy change emanating from the policies implemented and depicting and measuring policy making stability and impact. The incremental model will validate the importance of improving ineffective policies, while the rational and group theories will ascertain the process of selecting the best policy options for adoption and the influence of groups in policy formation. The impact of including or abandoning some actors in the different stages and or models and frameworks will be critically assessed in an effort to come up with solutions for successful policy development without governement monopoly.

To gather evidence to substantiate the actor-centred approach in policy formulation, a purposive sample of approximately 50 respondents from the public, civil society (political parties, pressure groups, NGOs, lobby and interest groups), government, media and think tanks in Tanzania will be interviewed. The systems analysis approach will be used as a methodology to analyse information by breaking policy making process into component pieces to enable the varied actors to work and interrelate harmoniously to develop effective policies. The systems analysis will be intergrated with the mixed research approach where both qualitative and quantitative reseach methods will be used making it possible to achieve complimentarity through triangulation of each others strengths and weaknesses. Through the mixed research methods ability for inductive and deductive analysis, it will be possible to critically scrutinise the impact of policies which are quantitative and qualitative in nature, making it possible to analyse the policy models and analysing the bottlenecks faced in different political, economic and social policy settings across the globe.

A set of different data collection tools such as interview guides, questionnaires and desk and documentary reviews including observations will be used. Using these methods will enable the management of the negative effects or the weaknesses of each technique selected as some tools maybe elusive, while others may reveal and provide a niche towards understanding policy studies on the part of the researcher.

In conclusion, debates on the importance of the actor-centered approach to policy studies will be advanced through the use of the different policy models, approached and frameworks and the involvement of different different actors. The systems analysis approached and the mixed reseach methis will be used to gather and analyse data to come up with a comperehensive basis in support of the actor centered approach in policy studies.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - The Gates Foundation and transnational social policy transfer – assessing actors and avenues
Roosa Jolkkonen (University of Oxford)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Contemporary ‘big philanthropies’, emerging namely from world-leading American businesses, are deeply vested in political engagement to further their approaches to development and other global social policy issues (see Callahan, 2017). This has not come without effect; as Moran (2014) has highlighted, the ‘philanthrocapitalist’ approaches “have begun to diffuse widely throughout the international development architecture and across organs of global governance” (2014, p. 27). Indeed, private philanthropies are increasingly present in the systems and structures of global governance, as demonstrated by their participation in the UN’s Sustainable Development Goal plenaries. Such global policy-making structures function as key conduits for spreading policies and paradigms for two primary reasons; they are constructed around a motivation for policy change – development and its multiple challenges – and they are home to a variety of motors, diverse development actors competing for policy influence (see Daigneault, 2014, p. 457). The unstructured global governance systems are thus naturally “fluid” and full of policy windows for new policy entrepreneurs to engage in (Ney, 2012; Stone and Ladi, 2015).

 

When discussing the rising role of big philanthropies as global development and policy actors, the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation deserves particular attention – particularly in the area of health. The Foundation is known for having “taken private, philanthropic funding for international development, especially for health, to new and unprecedented heights” (McCoy et al., 2009, p. 410), and represents today the third most important source of development financing for health (behind the US and the UK) (IHME, 2017). Yet, lacking political mandate, private philanthropies have been claimed to rely particularly on scientific justifications to build up expert authority, as well as networking with other established actors to gain legitimacy as policy suppliers (ed. Edwards, 2011; Stone, 2004, 2010). Thus, the width and depth of their policy influence is defined, at least partially, by their ability to engage with different actors from the public, private and third sectors operating at the global, national and local avenues.

 

Based on a qualitative case study on the Gates Foundation as a health donor in Tanzania, this paper takes a closer look at the ways in which big philanthropies – largely neglected in the current social policy and policy transfer studies – are dependent upon and strategically utilising different actors for transnational social policy transfer. More precisely, these diverse actors refer to key global health organisations, private pharmaceutical companies, high-level government representatives and other gate-keepers within aid-receiving countries as well as project implementing NGOs. As such, drawing from the existing literature on policy transfer, diffusion and circulation, this paper seeks to provide new insights on transnational policy transfer processes initiated by private philanthropies, particularly concerning the interdependencies between exporting philanthropic policy suppliers and the importing (and further exporting) actors and their avenues of influence.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Policy Entrepreneurs and Instrument Constituencies in EU Innovation Policy
Ceren Ark Yildirim (Istanbul University)
CO-AUTHORS
Marc Smyrl (Université de Montpellier)
ABSTRACT

The opacity of policy-making in the institutions of the European Union is well known, but efforts to elucidate it have long been dominated by debates among rival ‘grand theories’ of Europeanization.  Whether based on the formal institutions of the EU, interests attributed to member states, or the presumed dynamic of sectoral spillover, they share a common blind spot when it comes to conceptualizing the roles and motivations of the individual and collective actors who actually make policy choices.

We take as starting point Smith’s (2010) challenge to think in terms of a “government of the European Union” made up of all actors contributing to the definition and resolution of European problems, whose perimeter and participants vary across issue areas and whose functioning can best be understood by the systematic application of an actor centered approach to political sociology. We apply this approach to an area that has risen to prominence since the 1990s: open or “user-centered” innovation.  Based on a systematic documentary analysis supplemented by interviews with key informants, we highlight the importance of two collective actors inside the “government of the EU” but distinct from more commonly studied types such as ‘Eurocrats” and representatives of member states or interest groups.

The first is the Open Innovation Strategy and Policy Group (OISPG). Building on Kingdon’s (1984) original concept of the necessity of intermediaries linking problems and solutions, we highlight the central role of this unit, housed within the European Commission’ DG CONNECT but consisting of a partnership among technology firms, academic specialists, and territorial authorities, as a policy entrepreneur linking the solution of open innovation with the previously identified problem of Europe’s perceived innovation shortfall. Seizing on one of the possible incarnations of the open innovation model championed by the OISPG, the European Network of Living Labs has become an instrument constituency (Béland and Howlett, 2015) whose institutional identity is now bound up with the Living Lab model, and whose role has gone beyond the facilitation of a European priority to embrace the active promotion of this particular instrument well beyond the EU perimeter, offering its condulting services to a growing list of global clients.

Together, these two collective actors, straddling the frontier of the European Commission but clearly part of a broader “government of the EU,” illustrate how the dynamic of competition among elite actors can be a driver for policy change and, more specifically, a key factor explaining why some instruments rather than others emerge as the preferred solution to perceived problems.

 

References:

Béland, Daniel and Michael Howlett. 2015. “How Solutions Chase Problems: Instrument Constituencies in the Policy Process.” Governance, 29(3): 393‑40.

Kingdon, John. 1984. Agendas, Alternative, and Public Policies. Boston: Little, Brown and Co.

Smith, Andrew. 2010. Le Gouvernement de l’Union Européenne: Une Sociologie Politique. Paris: LGDJ.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - The Role of Actors in the Neo-institutionalist Approach
Fernanda Somuano (El Colegio de México)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The objective of this paper is twofold. One the one side, it aims to discuss and compare the role assigned to actors in three versions of the neo-institutionalist approach: historical institutionalism, sociological institutionalism and rational choice. On the other, it points to find out what kind of actors are taken into account in these theoretical frames and to what extent are they considered as explaining factors of policy change.

The paper sets off by recognizing that neo-institutionalism does not constitute a unified body of thought. Instead, I consider three different analytical approaches that are usually called” new institutionalism”, that have developed in reaction to the behavioral perspectives, and that search to explain the role that institutions play in the determination of social and political outcomes.

Each of these approaches has, not only a different definition of institutions and actors, but also a different view of the relationship between both. For rational choice scholars, individual behavior is quite relevant in the policy process, but institutions are also important because they provide the context in which actors define their strategies and pursue their interests. Although historical institutionalists do not have a problem with the idea of institutions as features of strategic context, imposing constraints on self-interested behavior, they clearly focus on institutions’ and organizations’ behavior (rather than individual) and emphasize path dependence and unintended consequences of agents’ actions. Sociological institutionalists go further and conceive individual behavior only as a result of institutions influence and socialization. In this approach institutions almost determine individuals’ actions, not only by specifying what one should do, but also by specifying what one can imagine oneself doing in a given context.

Clearly the relationship assumed between institutions and individual actors define, to a large extent, their respective role in policy change. Although diverse scholars seem to agree that none of the three approaches are convincing when they try to explain policy change, rational choice analysis is much more voluntarist than the other two and directly addresses the role of actors in the policy process.  The other two approaches focus on the systemic level of analysis and see policy change more as a result of unintended consequences of political battles.

I am convinced that each of these schools may be useful to understand part of the role of individual actors in how policy process develops. In this paper I propose a more open and extensive interchange among them, in order to achieve that goal.

 

 

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Unchartered Territories. The Analysis of Euro-Parties as Political Actors in the EU Foreign Policy
Mignone Andrea (University of genova)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

 

This research paper is about the foreign policy positions of Euro-Parties. It focuses on EU Foreign Policy, an often ignored dimension of parties manifestos, and on the role of the parties in influencing EU Foreign Policies decision making.

Most contemporary theoretical work in IR gives the impression that its ground lies only in States. We adopt an actor-centered perspective crossing the borders of IR studies and pubic policy analysis: the role of Euro-Parties. It is IR’s subfield of Foreign Policy Analysis (FPA) that develops the actor-specific theory required to engage the ground of IR. With its assumption that  political parties are an actor of all that happens in international relations and that such decision makers are not best approximated as unitary rational actors equivalent to the state, FPA is positioned to provide the concrete theory that can reinvigorate the connection between IR actor-general theory and European studies.

Aim of the paper is to promote a new typology of EU foreign policy following the role of Euro-Parties: security/diplomacy vs. economics; normative-symbolic vs. strategic; structural vs. instrumental; transnational vs.domestic.

EU Foreign Policy is in a system of governance with the involvement of non state actors, in relation with the growing role of European Parliament and the involvement of party families and EU parliamentary groups (for example, the rotating Council Presidency still chairs some of the working parties and Council formations with external action portfolios).

European Institutions, indeed, are trying to improve their role and influence on decision making process in Foreign Policy, despite their enduring character as an interstates policy area.

Things being so, it is however interesting to examine ideological and societal roots of the foreign and security policy preferences of the major party families in Europe. That is: 1) Transnational societal cleavages that gave rise to European party families also serve as roots of different preferences on European foreign and security policies? 2) The dominant axes of party competition in EP (between EP party groups) also structure rival policy preferences in FP? The results point to a consistency: the major core party families contend issues of EU FP along Left/Right and Integration axes (peripheral political families are more fledging organizations); 3) The role of parties is increased with the growing of levels of decision making processes: multilevel and multi actor policy makers, not only states.

The analysis outlines different cleavages, not only L/R or nationalism/supranationalism, pro-integration/anti-integration.

But also Atlanticism/Europeanism; pro-NATO/anti_NATO; material-institutional/identital-ideological; economic/normative or value issue.

Finally, we can evaluate the role of political parties as providers of mechanisms of information and coordination in order to promote specific ideological positions within the frame of EU Foreign Policy

 

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - The Role of the President in the Development of U.S. Science and Technology Policy
Renee Johnson (Rhodes College)
CO-AUTHORS
Erin Dolgoy (Rhodes College)
ABSTRACT

In this project, we investigate the role of the President in the development of science and technology policy in the U.S. since WWII.  We focus on the president because dominant theories of the policy process (i.e. advocacy coalition framework, social construction, punctuated equilibrium) do not have strong conceptualizations of the role of the president in policymaking.  Nevertheless, many contemporary presidency scholars contend that presidents can have a significant effect on policymaking because of the powers of the office (Gitterman 2017; Howell 2003; Cooper 2002).  In this project, our goal is to weave together the insights from contemporary policy theory with the insights of the presidency literature to conceptualize the role of the president in policymaking.

 

We focus on science and technology policy for several reasons.  Because it is an under-examined area of public policymaking, an examination of this policy domain might result in different understandings of the role of the president in policymaking in comparison to other policy areas. Additionally, science and technology policy generally lacks public salience at the same time it is highly technically complex.  This combination of characterisitics suggests that the president may have little to gain from pursuing science and technology policy goals; yet an examination of presidential actions suggests that presidents are quite active in this policy domain. 

 

Our project focuses on an analysis of presidential speeches and executive orders since WWII to develop an understanding of the role of the president in science and technology policymaking.  This enables us to determine whether science and technology policy largely mirrors the policy dynamics in which it is embedded or whether there is a policy dynamic specific to science and technology policy.  Each of the authors of this project lends specific expertise in theories of science and technology (Dolgoy) and the empirical study of public policy (Johnson). Because of the interdisciplinary background of the co-authors, this project will speak to audiences interested in the policy process, science and technology policy, political theory, and the presidency.

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - Strategic Action and Policy Outcomes. The cases of Felipe Calderon and Enrique Peña in Mexico and Fernando Collor and Fernando Cardoso in Brazil
Jose Luis Mendez (El Colegio de México)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper aims at empirically supporting the hypothesis that the degree of presidential strategic action affects the level of policy achievement and thus the type of government. Strategic action is studied in two areas of presidential activity: agenda-setting and policy development. In turn, policy achievement/government type is considered based on the degree to which at the end of a given administration a pertinent policy agenda is reached without causing collateral damage. Four cases are compared to empirically support this hypothesis, namely the presidencies of Enrique Peña (2012-2018) and Felipe Calderon (2006-2012) in Mexico and of Fernando Cardoso (1995-1998) and Fernando Collor (1990-1992) in Brazil. The comparison of each of these pair of administrations involves a most similar cases research design (George and Bennett 2005) where, despite involving the same institutional framework and the same party and electoral system, in each pair of cases different levels of strategic action can be associated with different levels of policy/governmental achievement. The study of each administration is based on the use of primary and secondary sources of evidence as well as field interviews. The paper thus aims at stressing strategic action as a key independent variable for the understanding of policy outcomes and governmental types, rather than structural factors such as institutional frameworks or historical junctures (without meaning that they are not important).

ACCEPTED
Format
11 - The Programmatic Action Framework (PAF)
Nils Bandelow (Technische Universität Carolo-Wilhelmina Braunschweig)
CO-AUTHORS
Marc Smyrl (Université de Montpellier)
ABSTRACT

Leading theories of the policy process mostly stem from peculiarities of American politics and neglect career trajectories as a central explanation for collective action in policy processes. Originating from French public policy research (Genieys and Smyrl, 2008; Hassenteufel et al., 2010), the Programmatic Action Framework (PAF) brings in a new perspective that proves its potential to reveal valuable insights into policy processes also beyond the French borders. In introducing this framework, this paper aims to do two things. Firstly, it clarifies the original contribution of the latest leading policy process frameworks (Weible and Sabatier, 2017) with regard to their explanatory power. As a response, the main contribution then presents the theoretical outline of the PAF as a new framework for public policy research. Thereby, the paper discusses the PAF as a demarcated framework as well as a potential complementation of existing frameworks by integrating PAF.

 

The PAF proposes that elites compete for authority within policy sectors through the promotion of rival policy programs, as well as competing with elites from outside their sector for authoritative and regulatory resources. Furthermore, elite formation essentially depends on shared biographies and career interests, instead of stable beliefs or purely rational motives. Success of programmatic elites is contingent upon homogeneity of biographies, a continuing history of linkages, as well as the coherence and strength of the policy program.

 

Besides outlining these theoretical foundations, the contribution formulates explicit hypotheses on the conditions under which programmatic elites form and dissolve. In addition, the hypotheses address the formation and possible development of programs and the success of programmatic elites in realizing their policy program depending on composition and resources of programmatic elites, program contents, opponents, and institutional constraints of the political system as well as peculiarities of the policy issue.

 

References

 

Genieys W and Smyrl M. (2008) Elites, Ideas, and the Evolution of Public Policy, New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.

Hassenteufel P, Smyrl M, Genieys W, et al. (2010) Programmatic Actors and the Transformation of European Health Care Sates. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 35: 517–538.

Weible CM and Sabatier PA. (2017) Theories of the Policy Process. Fourth edition ed. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
12 - Psychological Perspectives on Individual Actors in the Policy Process
Johanna Hornung (University of Lausanne)
CO-AUTHORS
Nils Bandelow (Technische Universität Carolo-Wilhelmina Braunschweig)
ABSTRACT

In analyzing the policy process, theories and frameworks base on different models of individual actors. These models implicitly or explicitly refer to psychological research as the essential tradition in understanding individual actors’ preferences and behavior. In detail, policy process frameworks make use of different concepts, such as belief systems (Zafonte and Sabatier, 1998) and ambiguity (Zohlnhöfer and Rüb, 2016). Whereas most of the frameworks apply some concept of bounded rationality, the concrete embodiment varies (Heikkila and Cairney, 2017). Psychological foundations are equally relevant to the explanatory factors in the theories of the process as to the currently increasing debate around an optimization of communication between policy studies and policy actors (Cairney and Kwiatkowski, 2017; Cairney and Weible, 2017).

 

Yet the psychological state of the art developed, and the advances of policy process research lack systematic recognition of this development. The proposed workshop paper aims to fill this gap by, firstly, assessing the most relevant and most applied psychological approaches in policy process research and showing how they are integrated into policy analysis. Secondly, it reviews the state of the art in social psychology, reflecting which psychological approaches may be transferred to which theories of the policy process in what way. In doing so, the contribution equally outlines which policy process frameworks base on the same foundations as this is a central question for cross-fertilization of theories (Bandelow et al., 2017). Concerning the selection of psychological theories for review, this will be an empirical process and might include theories such as the Theory of Reasoned Action/Theory of Planned Behavior, Social Identity Theory, and Belief Systems explaining actor behavior in policy-making processes.

References

 

Bandelow NC, Vogeler CS, Hornung J, et al. (2017) Learning as a Necessary but Not Sufficient Condition for Major Health Policy Change: A Qualitative Comparative Analysis Combining ACF and MSF. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice: 1-16.

Cairney P and Kwiatkowski R. (2017) How to Communicate Effectively with Policymakers: Combine Insights from Psychology and Policy Studies. Palgrave Communications 3: 37.

Cairney P and Weible CM. (2017) The New Policy Sciences: Combining the Cognitive Science of Choice, Multiple Theories of Context, and Basic and Applied Analysis. Policy Sciences 50: 619-627.

Heikkila T and Cairney P. (2017) Comparison of Theories of the Policy Process. In: Weible CM and Sabatier PA (eds) Theories of the Policy Process. Fourth edition ed. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 301–326.

Zafonte M and Sabatier PA. (1998) Shared Beliefs and Imposed Interdependencies as Determinants of Ally Networks in Overlapping Subsystems. Journal of Theoretical Politics 10: 473-505.

Zohlnhöfer R and Rüb FW. (2016) Decision-Making Under Ambiguity and Time Constraints: Assessing the Multiple-Streams Framework. Studies in European Political Science. Colchester: ECPR Press, 280.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
13 - Analyzing Programmatic actors: methodological challenges for the understanding of policy change
Patrick Hassenteufel (Université Paris-Saclay)
CO-AUTHORS
William Genieys (Sciencespo Paris- CEE - CNRS )
ABSTRACT

The aim of this paper is to present and discuss the methodological and theoretical challenges of the analysis of policy elites promoting change in a policy field. Based on different empirical researches focused on policy change in healthcare (in Europe and in the USA), it presents the contributions of a method combining the study of the sociological background, the careers, the ideas, the involvement in the decision process and the relations between actors holding key position in the policy process. It sheds the light on the specific of role programmatic actors, corresponding to narrow groups defining, promoting and producing policy change over a middle or long term period. The contribution of this kind of actors to policy change is strongly related to the power interactions with other policy elites and interest groups, depending of the distribution of relevant resources for public policy and their evolution over time in different contexts.

ACCEPTED
Format
14 - Technology-related actors and policy design choices: the case of the Swiss renewable energy feed-in tariff
Leonore Haelg (ETH Zurich)
CO-AUTHORS
Tobias Schmidt (ETH Zurich)
Sebastian Sewerin (Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Zurich)
ABSTRACT

Policies to induce deployment of low-carbon technologies and hence mitigate climate change have seen large global diffusion. While the specific transfer mechanisms have been extensively covered in the literature, how and why policy instruments and their specific design are accommodated in the receiving country remains underexplored. Against this background and in line with the argument that policy design rather than the instrument type is more decisive for technology deployment, we seek to shed light on the role of technology-related actors, i.e. technology suppliers and technology users, in the implementation and design phase of deployment policy instruments. Based on the concept of instrument constituencies which we expand to the more general design constituencies, we analyse around which arguments such constituencies form and disaggregate at the different abstraction levels of Cashore and Howlett’s (2007) and Howlett and Cashore’s (2009) taxonomy of policy elements. The aim is to establish these actors’ role specific policy design choices. Empirically, we focus on the implementation of the renewable energy feed-in tariff in Switzerland. This case is particularly interesting for two reasons: First, while a blueprint of the policy was directly transferred to Switzerland from Germany, the Swiss policy shows significant adaptations for specific design elements where the actor bases differ between the two countries. Second, the design of the feed-in tariff is different for different technologies hence providing the opportunity for a comparative analysis. The empirical material includes policy documents and parliamentary debates as well as interviews with policymakers and technology-related actors who were involved in the policymaking process. The preliminary results suggest the existence and exertion of influence of dynamic design constituencies on all levels of the policy process.

Our study contributes to the question of the characteristics and role of actors in the policy process not only by introducing the often overlooked technology-related actor groups but also by analysing their role in policy design choices at the different levels of the policymaking process.

ACCEPTED
Format
15 - Explaining the role of civil servants in the policy process: Policy advice and learning dynamics
David Aubin (Université Catholique de Louvain)
CO-AUTHORS
Lev Lhommeau (Université catholique de Louvain)
Pierre Squevin (University of Oslo)
ABSTRACT

Civil servants are essential and often neglected actors in the policy process. Their involvement in policymaking is essential to democracy and good public policy. They play a mediating role between interest groups and politicians which both push their agenda without necessarily weighting the different problem frames and policy options. The detachment of their position makes their advice to politicians more informed and based on an accumulation of in-house knowledge and a plurality of external advice than any other stakeholder. Theories like the advocacy coalition framework for example tend to refer to decision makers without specifying the position and role of these public actors (top civil servants, politicians, political advisers or heads of agencies). The involvement of civil servants in the policy process has been studied for long (e.g. Lindblom 1959, Dahl 1961), but it needs a fresh look. In the recent years, civil servants have gained more attention by policy scholars. Their importance in the policy process was reassessed in sector-specific case studies (Montpetit 2011, Paquet 2015). Their policy work was specifically investigated (Colebatch, Howlett), as well as their involvement into political advice (Shaw & Eichbaum 2017, Maley 2015). This communication intends to go beyond description and proposes to further theorize the role of civil servants in the policy process. Relying on a synthesis of the most recent literature, the theoretical framework explains the role of civil servants according to both their position and behavior. Their role is related to the kind of advice they formulate (fact-driven vs. normative, and issue- vs. process-specific) (Nekola and Kohoutec 2016) and its utilization of their policy advice, that is its impact on policy formulation (Landry et al. 2001). The role in the policy process is explained by a combination of institutional position and individual behavior. The position depends on the institutional context (Scharpf 1997), in this case the national political-administrative relation or tradition, the type of network within the policy subsystem (for example pluralist vs. neocorporatist), as well as the position in the government (or public administration). Relying on the policy learning literature, individual behavior refers to the way civil servants commit themselves in the production of advice: What kind of information do they mobilize? Do they stick to prior beliefs or do they update their beliefs, attitudes and opinions (Strickland et al. 2011)? Do politicians trust them and collaborate to develop a shared understanding of the policy problem? In sum, the role of civil servants in the policy process increases when their policy advisory role is recognized in the political-administrative system and they have a mediating function between interest groups and politicians, but this is not enough. Individual civil servants must also be trusted by the politicians, rely on information based on evidence and maintain a learning dynamics. The communication will rely on illustrations from a survey conducted in Belgium and will propose a comparative agenda for empirical testing.

 

References

Colebatch, Hal K., Hoppe, Robert, Noordegraaf, Mirko (Eds.) 2010. Working for Policy. Amsterdam University Press, Amsterdam.

Dahl, Robert A. (Ed.) 1961. Who Governs? Yale University Press, New Haven, London.

Landry, Réjean, Amara, Nabil, Lamari, Moktar, 2001. 'Utilization of Social Science Research Knowledge in Canada'. Research Policy 30, 333–349.

Lindblom, Charles E., 1959. ‘The science of muddling through’. Public Administration Review 19, 79-88.

Maley, Maria, 2015. ‘The Policy Work of Australian Political Staff’. International Journal of Public Administration 38, 46-55.

Montpetit, Eric, 2011. ‘Between detachment and responsiveness: Civil servants in Europe and North America’. West European Politics 34, 1250-1271.

Nekola, Martin, Kohoutek, Jan, 2016. ‘Policy work at the sub-national level: Analytical styles of Canadian and Czech directors and managers’. Canadian Public Administration 59, 289-309.

Paquet, Mireille, 2015. ‘Bureaucrats as immigration policy-makers: The case of subnational immigration activism in Canada, 1990-2010’. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 41, 1815-1835.

Scharpf, Fritz W. (Ed.) 1997. Games real actors play: Actor-centered institutionalism in policy research. Westview Press, Boulder.

Shaw, Richard, Eichbaum, Chris, 2017. ‘Politicians, political advisers and the vocabulary of public service bargains: Speaking in tongues?’. Public Administration 95, 312-326

Strickland, April A., Taber, Charles S., Lodge, Milton, 2011. ‘Motivated Reasoning and Public Opinion’. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 36, 935-944.

ACCEPTED
Format
16 - THE POWER OF NON-STATE ACTORS AND INCLUSIVE PUBLIC POLICY PROCESS: A CASE OF KENYA
Tiberius Barasa (East African Institute for Futures Studies)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

THE POWER OF NON-STATE ACTORS AND INCLUSIVE PUBLIC POLICY PROCESS: A CASE OF KENYA

 

Tiberius Barasa, (Email: tibsrasa@yahoo.com)

 

ABSTRACT

Public policy process has for a long time been dominated by state actors and has not been participatory. Despite the constraint on the participation of non-state actors in the policy process, these organizations have succeeded in influencing public policy to satisfy their interests in the midst of a reluctant state. Thus, whereas non-state actors seem to have made a contribution towards removing obstacles to citizens’ engagement in public policy process, the actual role of the non-state actors in public policy process remains unclear. More significantly, the manner in which non-state actors have tried to open public policy space is unclear. This raises questions not only about the non-state actors’ contribution in opening the policy process and increasing space for participation in the policy process but also how they negotiate to be included in the process and contribute to inclusive public policy process. Using the case of Kenya, this study investigates the contribution of non-state actors to opening the public policy process. The objective of this study is to examine how non-state actors use their power to be included in public policy decision and delivery processes. Based on the assumption that public policy is framed within a context of relationships and dependencies.This study employs power relations analytical model to investigate the contribution of non-state actors to opening the public policy process in Kenya. The study will employ mixed methods research design combining qualitative and quantitative survey. Its population will include four categories of organisations: the local and international non-governmental organisations, private sector organisations and donor organizations operating in Kenya. For qualitative survey, stratified sampling will be used to select 16 organisations while purposive sampling will be used to select 2 senior managers from each organisation who are knowledgeable about public policy process. For quantitative survey, all the 20 Government ministries will be chosen. Data for qualitative survey will be collected through an in-depth interview using schedule and guidelines. Supplementary information will be obtained through document reviews. Data for quantitative survey will be collected through administering a questionnaire. Data analysis will include triangulation, power analysis using power cube and simple descriptive statistics. This study is likely to strengthen the contribution of non-state actors in public policy process as it will employ power relations analytical model to understand the contribution of non-state actors in public policy process.

ACCEPTED
Format
17 - Intermediary actors in increasingly interdependent and complex policy processes
Ulrike Zeigermann (Universtity of Würzburg, Department for Political Science and Sociology)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Increasing interdependence of political decisions raises new questions on how to ensure coherence across different national, international and sectoral policies as manifested in SDG 17 of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. It also raises new theoretic and methodologic questions on how to understand those complex policy processes. Recent literature has addressed the issue of policy trade-offs and coherence in policy analyses and in studies on multi-level governance (cf. Hoebink 2004, Sianes 2013, Siitonen 2015, Carbone and Keijzer 2016). Yet, we know very little about the role of actors in policy processes at the intersection of both different policy levels and fields.

Taking this disjunction as a starting point, the analysis in this paper explores the role and characteristics of actors in the emerging field of sustainability policy which is particularly interesting due to its unique international and interdepartmental orientation. Specifically, the paper focuses on actors dealing with questions of Policy Coherence for Sustainable Development. It argues that those intermediary actors are crucial for understanding policy processes and the change in modern societies. In order to understand their capabilities, orientations and interactions in relation to the institutional setting and policy environment (cf. Scharpf 1997) this paper offers new findings from case studies in France and Germany. My research design combines a qualitative analysis of 49 semi-structured expert interviews, with results from a participant observation conducted in international meetings on Policy Coherence for Development between October 2013 and March 2015, and thorough analysis of official documents linked to the work of these actors in France and Germany.

The first part of the paper offers a mapping of relevant actors in France and Germany and illustrates that their orientations and capabilities have changed over the years. Both case studies demonstrate that actors from within national bureaucracies that have interacted in an international epistemic community were crucial for the circulation of knowledge and proliferation of policies for Policy Coherence for Development between 2005 and 2015. Contrary to traditional theories focusing on the role of either individual or collective actors in policy processes, my analysis shows that this distinction may not always be helpful for characterizing actors at the intersection of different policy sectors and levels in the field of sustainability.

The second part of the paper analyses those intermediary actors in greater detail and focuses on their interactions. Operationalizing theories of policy transfer, translation and resistance (cf. Dolowitz and Marsh 2000; James and Lodge 2003; Stone 2004, Delpeuch 2009; Saurugger and Terpan 2013; Hassenteufel 2013) it raises the question on how far these interactions can explain policy change. The comparison of interactions of similar actors dealing with questions of Policy Coherence for Sustainable Development in France and Germany indicates, that the institutional setting and policy environment both limits and enables their role in policy processes. 

Based on empirical analysis of actors in the emerging field of sustainability policy, my paper seeks to contribute to the debate academic debate on characterizing actors in increasingly complex and interdependent policy processes. It offers new thoughts for studying actors at the intersection of both different policy levels and fields combining the framework of actor-centred institutionalism with transfer theories.

ACCEPTED
Format
18 - Understanding the Role of Advocacy Coalitions in Canada’s Immigration Detention Policy
Vanessa C. Wachuku (Ryerson University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Public policy design surrounding migrants with irregular status legitimizes the adoption of immigration detention practices in Canada. This practice imposes undue hardship and is considered harsh and arbitrary by domestic and international actors such as the United Nations. Meanwhile, policy changes that reinforce the immigration detention of foreign nationals are implemented without an investigation that traces the role and influence of advocacy coalition groups, primarily comprised of closed border supporters and open border advocates, on these policy changes. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap and contribute to scholarship on immigration detention policy in Canada by exploring the role of advocacy coalition groups in the policy change process in Canada. Accordingly, this workshop paper traces the role of closed border supporters and open border advocates in policy changes relating to the immigration detention of asylum seekers and irregular migrants in Canada.

 

 

ACCEPTED
Format
19 - Media Representations of American Health Reforms: The Role of Policy Actors in Transmitting Policy Narratives in the Massachusetts and Utah Cases (2002-2011)
Brent Epperson (University of Alberta)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

A generation after the failure of the Clinton Administration’s 1994 Health Security Act, between 2002 and 2012, a number of state-level health reform efforts preceded and paralleled the federal Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) debates. Collectively, the state and federal reforms of the period revealed greater political openness to health care policy change. Building from literature in narrative policy analysis and media framing and effects theory, this paper examines newspaper media coverage of two state-level health reform efforts—the Massachusetts Health Reform Law (Romneycare) (2002-2006) and the Utah Health System Reform (2004-2011). My research critically examines the role of policy actors in the movement of neoliberal language framing metaphors and narratives of health within the state-based and national newspaper media. This paper demonstrates coalescence of policy actors’ discourses in media representations between Republican-leaning and Democratic-leaning newspapers. Specifically, this paper focuses on the role of key policy and media actors—state legislators, governors, political columnists, and leaders of health reform advocacy organizations and coalitions—in (re)diffusing reform narratives.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
20 - General discussion and next-steps planning
Jose Luis Mendez (El Colegio de México)
CO-AUTHORS
Patrick Hassenteufel (Université Paris-Saclay)
ABSTRACT

General discussion and next-steps planning

CO-AUTHORS
Karin Ingold (University of Bern)
Frédéric Varone (University of Geneva)
ABSTRACT

Theories of the policy process in general and of interest group lobbying in particular are concerned in how corporate actors translate their ideologies, values, and preferences into concrete policy decisions. To identify these policy preferences, empirical studies apply two main techniques: content analysis of official documents and surveys of policy stakeholders. This information about actors’ positions is then used to explain the policy process or outputs, coordination or collaboration, and policy success or failure. Policy preferences gathered through content analysis or survey data are given considerable explanatory power in many empirical studies. In consequence, identifying and explaining a potential mismatch between officially and survey-stated preferences is highly relevant for policy studies. However, not much is understood about the differences between positions stated in official documents as contrasted to elite surveys on the same policy issue. This article analyses whether we observe such alterations between data on policy preferences produced by content analysis or surveys and asks how these divergences can be explained. Specifically, it investigates why some political actors diverge in their policy preferences and what kind of policy instruments or subsystem types are more prone for divergent preference statements. This article relies empirically on three different policy subsystems in Switzerland: climate, energy, and water protection. In all three policy fields, public and private actors, such as non-governmental organizations (NGO), trade unions, business and citizen groups, scientific experts, political parties, and public agencies, were invited by the Swiss federal government to public consultation procedures to officially pronounce their policy preferences on specific aspects in the respective policy processes. These rich official documents constitute the basis for coding policy positions by content analysis. Once the policy-making process was over, the same policy actors were surveyed and asked about the policy positions they had supported during the decision-making process. By comparing both sources of information on policy preferences, we are able to identify which actors deviate in their policy positions between official statements and survey answers. This (potential) reporting gap constitutes the main dependent variable in this analysis. A multi-level regression analysis is applied to assess the impact of both individual actor- and subsystem-based variables on this reporting gap. The preliminary results show that actors more strongly deviate in their policy positions between surveys and official statements in relation to contested policy instruments, and when the level of conflict in the subsystem is high.

CO-AUTHORS
Lawrence Brown (Columbia University in the city of New York)
ABSTRACT

Policy elites-- what William Genieys has termed "custodians of state policy"-- have played crucial roles in shaping health care policy in the United States. The backgrounds and agendas of these elites have shifted, however, as the nation's struggles over national health insurance came to accommodate the preoccupation with cost containment and as policymakers sought to forge innovative combinations of public authority and market forces. Drawing on three important episodes-- legislation to promote health maintainance organizations in the early 1970s, the reform proposed by President Bill Clinton in 1993-94, and the creation of the Affordable Care Act in 2010-- this paper explores patterns of continuity and change in the composition and contributions of policy elites in the shaping of US health care policy.

CO-AUTHORS
Dana Dolan (George Mason University, Schar School of Policy and Government)
Hussain Nazia (Center for Policy Research, United Nations University)
ABSTRACT

The Political Rigging Framework: A Research Agenda for Analyzing Who Influences Policy Decisions in the 21st Century, and How

 

Democracy is under siege around the world. Many analysts point to the 2016 election of Donald Trump – a businessman, television celebrity, and political outsider who continues to display open contempt for constitutional rights and the norms of political behavior – as marking a new era of democratic fragility. We contend it has not. Instead, the rise of Trump, and indeed a growing number of elected “populists” in nations around the world, are symptoms of a democratic governance reconfiguration underpinned by the interactions of several long-term processes over the past several decades: financialization; privatization and deregulation; the end of the Cold War, dispersing global authority and opening up sparsely governed arenas; and digitization and new information technologies. These four transformational developments have created opportunities for novel forms of influencing, with dramatic implications for democratic accountability. The developments call into question traditional assumptions about policymaking. If we are to understand the impact of these shifts on contemporary policymaking, our seminal public policy theories require a frank reappraisal. Ironically, this call comes at a time when scholars are extending several theoretical frameworks, many developed in U.S. contexts, and some dating back to the early 1980s, to explain policymaking in international contexts.

 

Our project focuses beyond Lasswell's definition of politics as “who gets what, when, and how,” to ask not only who decides, but more tellingly: who influences those who decide, and how? These questions direct attention to a new set of policy actors - influence elites - who bypass democratic accountability to engage in what we call “political rigging,” a set of novel influencing practices.  The outcome is a self-reinforcing cycle that enables actors to avoid accountability. Influence elites draw their power from occupying multiple official and private roles and blurring the boundaries among political, economic, media, cultural, and social arenas. Importantly, scholars trying to make sense of contemporary policymaking by using traditional theories of the policy process can easily overlook these new actors, who fail to fit neatly into existing conceptual categories of policy actors such as congresspersons, lobbyists, or interest groups.

 

To address this critical blind spot, we introduce several concepts as a first stage in developing our Political Rigging Framework (PRF). Specifically, we draw on theoretical insights and empirical examples to show how influence elites manipulate the system through an evolving set of practices that incorporate the principles of informality, flexibility, and digital-powered simulacra. Informality refers to practices that actors employ as they navigate shifting (and normatively constructed) formal arenas.  Flexibility empowers individual actors, groups, organizations, and social networks to maneuver among official and private spheres and among political, economic, and legal arenas in unaccountable ways. Finally, digital-powered simulacra leverage the “civic” space of the Internet, as well changing traditional media, to invisibly mold public opinion toward undetectable ends.

 

Scholars may employ these three concepts to extend and update traditional policy process frameworks; however, we suggest that a fundamentally new framework is required to uncover the structures and practices of political rigging that influence elites help create, of which they are a part, and from which they benefit. This new framework must look beyond formal institutions and organizations to recognize the less visible—but ever-present—role of informality in shaping living governing systems. It must move beyond static frameworks that limit understanding of dynamic processes and the roles of flexible, mobile players in shaping the system. It must recognize that systems can be rigged in different ways and combinations, rather than existing as either “captured” or otherwise. Finally, the new framework must begin with individual influencers as the point of entry to examining complex, dynamic systems. We propose a new research agenda aimed at developing the Political Rigging Framework, guided by these three concepts.

 

Further, we invite fellow workshop participants to explore how these concepts might challenge the underlying assumptions of dominant theories of the policy process. For example, do the practices of informality and flexibility enable new ways of influencing the problem, policy, and political streams in the Multiple Streams Framework? Do digital-powered simulacra undermine the validity of using national newspaper reports to study attention swings in the Punctuated Equilibrium Theory? Can digital-powered simulacra enabled by Twitter and other forms of social media be taken at face value to inform Narrative Policy Analysis studies?

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The study seeks to highlight the importance and efficiency of actor-centred approaches in policy formulation. Attention will focus on actors and their roles in policy formulation processes such as the public, media, legislators, political parties, judiciary, government executive and civil society. Actors will be categorised into formal and informal entities where the executive, legislators, judiciary and civil servants are the formal players and the civil society (interest groups, political parties and pressure groups), individual citizens, media, think tanks and research institutions make up the informal actors. While the formal actors are tasked with the overall policy formulation process, the informal actors are important in expressing policy demnads, proposing policy alternatives, providing research, mobilizing citizens through political activisms to advance rational policy formulation. This justifies the intention of this paper which is meant to advance and respond to questions about the importance of the actor-centrerd approachs in policy studies, the effectiveness, role and rational of different actors and how solutions can be sought by engaging different actors in policy studies.

 Based on the above, it is premised that effective policies, including implementation is possible through effective engagement of all actors. The policy cycle approach through its six stages in collaboration with other policy models will be used to understand the role and rational of having various actors involved in policy formulation in each of the stages. This will make it possible to analyse whether these actors advance or limit policy processes either by genuinely advocating for development or selfishly advancing their own interests. The other frameworks and models that will be used together with the policy cycle approach include: the multiple stream, advocacy coalition, policy narrative frameworks, and the punctuated equilibrum, rational, incremental and institutional models.  

Kingdon’s “Multiple Streams Framework” focuses on stages of problem identification (alteration specification) and agenda setting. The Advocacy Coalition framework will reveal the significance of actors in developing effective policies by translating group beliefs of engagement in policy making. The Policy Narrative Framework will be employed for its importance in determining public opinion and influencing governmental action. The Punctuated Equilibrium model will be essential in monitoring and evaluating the magnitude of policy change emanating from the policies implemented and depicting and measuring policy making stability and impact. The incremental model will validate the importance of improving ineffective policies, while the rational and group theories will ascertain the process of selecting the best policy options for adoption and the influence of groups in policy formation. The impact of including or abandoning some actors in the different stages and or models and frameworks will be critically assessed in an effort to come up with solutions for successful policy development without governement monopoly.

To gather evidence to substantiate the actor-centred approach in policy formulation, a purposive sample of approximately 50 respondents from the public, civil society (political parties, pressure groups, NGOs, lobby and interest groups), government, media and think tanks in Tanzania will be interviewed. The systems analysis approach will be used as a methodology to analyse information by breaking policy making process into component pieces to enable the varied actors to work and interrelate harmoniously to develop effective policies. The systems analysis will be intergrated with the mixed research approach where both qualitative and quantitative reseach methods will be used making it possible to achieve complimentarity through triangulation of each others strengths and weaknesses. Through the mixed research methods ability for inductive and deductive analysis, it will be possible to critically scrutinise the impact of policies which are quantitative and qualitative in nature, making it possible to analyse the policy models and analysing the bottlenecks faced in different political, economic and social policy settings across the globe.

A set of different data collection tools such as interview guides, questionnaires and desk and documentary reviews including observations will be used. Using these methods will enable the management of the negative effects or the weaknesses of each technique selected as some tools maybe elusive, while others may reveal and provide a niche towards understanding policy studies on the part of the researcher.

In conclusion, debates on the importance of the actor-centered approach to policy studies will be advanced through the use of the different policy models, approached and frameworks and the involvement of different different actors. The systems analysis approached and the mixed reseach methis will be used to gather and analyse data to come up with a comperehensive basis in support of the actor centered approach in policy studies.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Contemporary ‘big philanthropies’, emerging namely from world-leading American businesses, are deeply vested in political engagement to further their approaches to development and other global social policy issues (see Callahan, 2017). This has not come without effect; as Moran (2014) has highlighted, the ‘philanthrocapitalist’ approaches “have begun to diffuse widely throughout the international development architecture and across organs of global governance” (2014, p. 27). Indeed, private philanthropies are increasingly present in the systems and structures of global governance, as demonstrated by their participation in the UN’s Sustainable Development Goal plenaries. Such global policy-making structures function as key conduits for spreading policies and paradigms for two primary reasons; they are constructed around a motivation for policy change – development and its multiple challenges – and they are home to a variety of motors, diverse development actors competing for policy influence (see Daigneault, 2014, p. 457). The unstructured global governance systems are thus naturally “fluid” and full of policy windows for new policy entrepreneurs to engage in (Ney, 2012; Stone and Ladi, 2015).

 

When discussing the rising role of big philanthropies as global development and policy actors, the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation deserves particular attention – particularly in the area of health. The Foundation is known for having “taken private, philanthropic funding for international development, especially for health, to new and unprecedented heights” (McCoy et al., 2009, p. 410), and represents today the third most important source of development financing for health (behind the US and the UK) (IHME, 2017). Yet, lacking political mandate, private philanthropies have been claimed to rely particularly on scientific justifications to build up expert authority, as well as networking with other established actors to gain legitimacy as policy suppliers (ed. Edwards, 2011; Stone, 2004, 2010). Thus, the width and depth of their policy influence is defined, at least partially, by their ability to engage with different actors from the public, private and third sectors operating at the global, national and local avenues.

 

Based on a qualitative case study on the Gates Foundation as a health donor in Tanzania, this paper takes a closer look at the ways in which big philanthropies – largely neglected in the current social policy and policy transfer studies – are dependent upon and strategically utilising different actors for transnational social policy transfer. More precisely, these diverse actors refer to key global health organisations, private pharmaceutical companies, high-level government representatives and other gate-keepers within aid-receiving countries as well as project implementing NGOs. As such, drawing from the existing literature on policy transfer, diffusion and circulation, this paper seeks to provide new insights on transnational policy transfer processes initiated by private philanthropies, particularly concerning the interdependencies between exporting philanthropic policy suppliers and the importing (and further exporting) actors and their avenues of influence.

CO-AUTHORS
Marc Smyrl (Université de Montpellier)
ABSTRACT

The opacity of policy-making in the institutions of the European Union is well known, but efforts to elucidate it have long been dominated by debates among rival ‘grand theories’ of Europeanization.  Whether based on the formal institutions of the EU, interests attributed to member states, or the presumed dynamic of sectoral spillover, they share a common blind spot when it comes to conceptualizing the roles and motivations of the individual and collective actors who actually make policy choices.

We take as starting point Smith’s (2010) challenge to think in terms of a “government of the European Union” made up of all actors contributing to the definition and resolution of European problems, whose perimeter and participants vary across issue areas and whose functioning can best be understood by the systematic application of an actor centered approach to political sociology. We apply this approach to an area that has risen to prominence since the 1990s: open or “user-centered” innovation.  Based on a systematic documentary analysis supplemented by interviews with key informants, we highlight the importance of two collective actors inside the “government of the EU” but distinct from more commonly studied types such as ‘Eurocrats” and representatives of member states or interest groups.

The first is the Open Innovation Strategy and Policy Group (OISPG). Building on Kingdon’s (1984) original concept of the necessity of intermediaries linking problems and solutions, we highlight the central role of this unit, housed within the European Commission’ DG CONNECT but consisting of a partnership among technology firms, academic specialists, and territorial authorities, as a policy entrepreneur linking the solution of open innovation with the previously identified problem of Europe’s perceived innovation shortfall. Seizing on one of the possible incarnations of the open innovation model championed by the OISPG, the European Network of Living Labs has become an instrument constituency (Béland and Howlett, 2015) whose institutional identity is now bound up with the Living Lab model, and whose role has gone beyond the facilitation of a European priority to embrace the active promotion of this particular instrument well beyond the EU perimeter, offering its condulting services to a growing list of global clients.

Together, these two collective actors, straddling the frontier of the European Commission but clearly part of a broader “government of the EU,” illustrate how the dynamic of competition among elite actors can be a driver for policy change and, more specifically, a key factor explaining why some instruments rather than others emerge as the preferred solution to perceived problems.

 

References:

Béland, Daniel and Michael Howlett. 2015. “How Solutions Chase Problems: Instrument Constituencies in the Policy Process.” Governance, 29(3): 393‑40.

Kingdon, John. 1984. Agendas, Alternative, and Public Policies. Boston: Little, Brown and Co.

Smith, Andrew. 2010. Le Gouvernement de l’Union Européenne: Une Sociologie Politique. Paris: LGDJ.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The objective of this paper is twofold. One the one side, it aims to discuss and compare the role assigned to actors in three versions of the neo-institutionalist approach: historical institutionalism, sociological institutionalism and rational choice. On the other, it points to find out what kind of actors are taken into account in these theoretical frames and to what extent are they considered as explaining factors of policy change.

The paper sets off by recognizing that neo-institutionalism does not constitute a unified body of thought. Instead, I consider three different analytical approaches that are usually called” new institutionalism”, that have developed in reaction to the behavioral perspectives, and that search to explain the role that institutions play in the determination of social and political outcomes.

Each of these approaches has, not only a different definition of institutions and actors, but also a different view of the relationship between both. For rational choice scholars, individual behavior is quite relevant in the policy process, but institutions are also important because they provide the context in which actors define their strategies and pursue their interests. Although historical institutionalists do not have a problem with the idea of institutions as features of strategic context, imposing constraints on self-interested behavior, they clearly focus on institutions’ and organizations’ behavior (rather than individual) and emphasize path dependence and unintended consequences of agents’ actions. Sociological institutionalists go further and conceive individual behavior only as a result of institutions influence and socialization. In this approach institutions almost determine individuals’ actions, not only by specifying what one should do, but also by specifying what one can imagine oneself doing in a given context.

Clearly the relationship assumed between institutions and individual actors define, to a large extent, their respective role in policy change. Although diverse scholars seem to agree that none of the three approaches are convincing when they try to explain policy change, rational choice analysis is much more voluntarist than the other two and directly addresses the role of actors in the policy process.  The other two approaches focus on the systemic level of analysis and see policy change more as a result of unintended consequences of political battles.

I am convinced that each of these schools may be useful to understand part of the role of individual actors in how policy process develops. In this paper I propose a more open and extensive interchange among them, in order to achieve that goal.

 

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

 

This research paper is about the foreign policy positions of Euro-Parties. It focuses on EU Foreign Policy, an often ignored dimension of parties manifestos, and on the role of the parties in influencing EU Foreign Policies decision making.

Most contemporary theoretical work in IR gives the impression that its ground lies only in States. We adopt an actor-centered perspective crossing the borders of IR studies and pubic policy analysis: the role of Euro-Parties. It is IR’s subfield of Foreign Policy Analysis (FPA) that develops the actor-specific theory required to engage the ground of IR. With its assumption that  political parties are an actor of all that happens in international relations and that such decision makers are not best approximated as unitary rational actors equivalent to the state, FPA is positioned to provide the concrete theory that can reinvigorate the connection between IR actor-general theory and European studies.

Aim of the paper is to promote a new typology of EU foreign policy following the role of Euro-Parties: security/diplomacy vs. economics; normative-symbolic vs. strategic; structural vs. instrumental; transnational vs.domestic.

EU Foreign Policy is in a system of governance with the involvement of non state actors, in relation with the growing role of European Parliament and the involvement of party families and EU parliamentary groups (for example, the rotating Council Presidency still chairs some of the working parties and Council formations with external action portfolios).

European Institutions, indeed, are trying to improve their role and influence on decision making process in Foreign Policy, despite their enduring character as an interstates policy area.

Things being so, it is however interesting to examine ideological and societal roots of the foreign and security policy preferences of the major party families in Europe. That is: 1) Transnational societal cleavages that gave rise to European party families also serve as roots of different preferences on European foreign and security policies? 2) The dominant axes of party competition in EP (between EP party groups) also structure rival policy preferences in FP? The results point to a consistency: the major core party families contend issues of EU FP along Left/Right and Integration axes (peripheral political families are more fledging organizations); 3) The role of parties is increased with the growing of levels of decision making processes: multilevel and multi actor policy makers, not only states.

The analysis outlines different cleavages, not only L/R or nationalism/supranationalism, pro-integration/anti-integration.

But also Atlanticism/Europeanism; pro-NATO/anti_NATO; material-institutional/identital-ideological; economic/normative or value issue.

Finally, we can evaluate the role of political parties as providers of mechanisms of information and coordination in order to promote specific ideological positions within the frame of EU Foreign Policy

 

CO-AUTHORS
Erin Dolgoy (Rhodes College)
ABSTRACT

In this project, we investigate the role of the President in the development of science and technology policy in the U.S. since WWII.  We focus on the president because dominant theories of the policy process (i.e. advocacy coalition framework, social construction, punctuated equilibrium) do not have strong conceptualizations of the role of the president in policymaking.  Nevertheless, many contemporary presidency scholars contend that presidents can have a significant effect on policymaking because of the powers of the office (Gitterman 2017; Howell 2003; Cooper 2002).  In this project, our goal is to weave together the insights from contemporary policy theory with the insights of the presidency literature to conceptualize the role of the president in policymaking.

 

We focus on science and technology policy for several reasons.  Because it is an under-examined area of public policymaking, an examination of this policy domain might result in different understandings of the role of the president in policymaking in comparison to other policy areas. Additionally, science and technology policy generally lacks public salience at the same time it is highly technically complex.  This combination of characterisitics suggests that the president may have little to gain from pursuing science and technology policy goals; yet an examination of presidential actions suggests that presidents are quite active in this policy domain. 

 

Our project focuses on an analysis of presidential speeches and executive orders since WWII to develop an understanding of the role of the president in science and technology policymaking.  This enables us to determine whether science and technology policy largely mirrors the policy dynamics in which it is embedded or whether there is a policy dynamic specific to science and technology policy.  Each of the authors of this project lends specific expertise in theories of science and technology (Dolgoy) and the empirical study of public policy (Johnson). Because of the interdisciplinary background of the co-authors, this project will speak to audiences interested in the policy process, science and technology policy, political theory, and the presidency.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper aims at empirically supporting the hypothesis that the degree of presidential strategic action affects the level of policy achievement and thus the type of government. Strategic action is studied in two areas of presidential activity: agenda-setting and policy development. In turn, policy achievement/government type is considered based on the degree to which at the end of a given administration a pertinent policy agenda is reached without causing collateral damage. Four cases are compared to empirically support this hypothesis, namely the presidencies of Enrique Peña (2012-2018) and Felipe Calderon (2006-2012) in Mexico and of Fernando Cardoso (1995-1998) and Fernando Collor (1990-1992) in Brazil. The comparison of each of these pair of administrations involves a most similar cases research design (George and Bennett 2005) where, despite involving the same institutional framework and the same party and electoral system, in each pair of cases different levels of strategic action can be associated with different levels of policy/governmental achievement. The study of each administration is based on the use of primary and secondary sources of evidence as well as field interviews. The paper thus aims at stressing strategic action as a key independent variable for the understanding of policy outcomes and governmental types, rather than structural factors such as institutional frameworks or historical junctures (without meaning that they are not important).

CO-AUTHORS
Marc Smyrl (Université de Montpellier)
ABSTRACT

Leading theories of the policy process mostly stem from peculiarities of American politics and neglect career trajectories as a central explanation for collective action in policy processes. Originating from French public policy research (Genieys and Smyrl, 2008; Hassenteufel et al., 2010), the Programmatic Action Framework (PAF) brings in a new perspective that proves its potential to reveal valuable insights into policy processes also beyond the French borders. In introducing this framework, this paper aims to do two things. Firstly, it clarifies the original contribution of the latest leading policy process frameworks (Weible and Sabatier, 2017) with regard to their explanatory power. As a response, the main contribution then presents the theoretical outline of the PAF as a new framework for public policy research. Thereby, the paper discusses the PAF as a demarcated framework as well as a potential complementation of existing frameworks by integrating PAF.

 

The PAF proposes that elites compete for authority within policy sectors through the promotion of rival policy programs, as well as competing with elites from outside their sector for authoritative and regulatory resources. Furthermore, elite formation essentially depends on shared biographies and career interests, instead of stable beliefs or purely rational motives. Success of programmatic elites is contingent upon homogeneity of biographies, a continuing history of linkages, as well as the coherence and strength of the policy program.

 

Besides outlining these theoretical foundations, the contribution formulates explicit hypotheses on the conditions under which programmatic elites form and dissolve. In addition, the hypotheses address the formation and possible development of programs and the success of programmatic elites in realizing their policy program depending on composition and resources of programmatic elites, program contents, opponents, and institutional constraints of the political system as well as peculiarities of the policy issue.

 

References

 

Genieys W and Smyrl M. (2008) Elites, Ideas, and the Evolution of Public Policy, New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.

Hassenteufel P, Smyrl M, Genieys W, et al. (2010) Programmatic Actors and the Transformation of European Health Care Sates. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 35: 517–538.

Weible CM and Sabatier PA. (2017) Theories of the Policy Process. Fourth edition ed. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

 

CO-AUTHORS
Nils Bandelow (Technische Universität Carolo-Wilhelmina Braunschweig)
ABSTRACT

In analyzing the policy process, theories and frameworks base on different models of individual actors. These models implicitly or explicitly refer to psychological research as the essential tradition in understanding individual actors’ preferences and behavior. In detail, policy process frameworks make use of different concepts, such as belief systems (Zafonte and Sabatier, 1998) and ambiguity (Zohlnhöfer and Rüb, 2016). Whereas most of the frameworks apply some concept of bounded rationality, the concrete embodiment varies (Heikkila and Cairney, 2017). Psychological foundations are equally relevant to the explanatory factors in the theories of the process as to the currently increasing debate around an optimization of communication between policy studies and policy actors (Cairney and Kwiatkowski, 2017; Cairney and Weible, 2017).

 

Yet the psychological state of the art developed, and the advances of policy process research lack systematic recognition of this development. The proposed workshop paper aims to fill this gap by, firstly, assessing the most relevant and most applied psychological approaches in policy process research and showing how they are integrated into policy analysis. Secondly, it reviews the state of the art in social psychology, reflecting which psychological approaches may be transferred to which theories of the policy process in what way. In doing so, the contribution equally outlines which policy process frameworks base on the same foundations as this is a central question for cross-fertilization of theories (Bandelow et al., 2017). Concerning the selection of psychological theories for review, this will be an empirical process and might include theories such as the Theory of Reasoned Action/Theory of Planned Behavior, Social Identity Theory, and Belief Systems explaining actor behavior in policy-making processes.

References

 

Bandelow NC, Vogeler CS, Hornung J, et al. (2017) Learning as a Necessary but Not Sufficient Condition for Major Health Policy Change: A Qualitative Comparative Analysis Combining ACF and MSF. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice: 1-16.

Cairney P and Kwiatkowski R. (2017) How to Communicate Effectively with Policymakers: Combine Insights from Psychology and Policy Studies. Palgrave Communications 3: 37.

Cairney P and Weible CM. (2017) The New Policy Sciences: Combining the Cognitive Science of Choice, Multiple Theories of Context, and Basic and Applied Analysis. Policy Sciences 50: 619-627.

Heikkila T and Cairney P. (2017) Comparison of Theories of the Policy Process. In: Weible CM and Sabatier PA (eds) Theories of the Policy Process. Fourth edition ed. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 301–326.

Zafonte M and Sabatier PA. (1998) Shared Beliefs and Imposed Interdependencies as Determinants of Ally Networks in Overlapping Subsystems. Journal of Theoretical Politics 10: 473-505.

Zohlnhöfer R and Rüb FW. (2016) Decision-Making Under Ambiguity and Time Constraints: Assessing the Multiple-Streams Framework. Studies in European Political Science. Colchester: ECPR Press, 280.

 

CO-AUTHORS
William Genieys (Sciencespo Paris- CEE - CNRS )
ABSTRACT

The aim of this paper is to present and discuss the methodological and theoretical challenges of the analysis of policy elites promoting change in a policy field. Based on different empirical researches focused on policy change in healthcare (in Europe and in the USA), it presents the contributions of a method combining the study of the sociological background, the careers, the ideas, the involvement in the decision process and the relations between actors holding key position in the policy process. It sheds the light on the specific of role programmatic actors, corresponding to narrow groups defining, promoting and producing policy change over a middle or long term period. The contribution of this kind of actors to policy change is strongly related to the power interactions with other policy elites and interest groups, depending of the distribution of relevant resources for public policy and their evolution over time in different contexts.

CO-AUTHORS
Tobias Schmidt (ETH Zurich)
Sebastian Sewerin (Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Zurich)
ABSTRACT

Policies to induce deployment of low-carbon technologies and hence mitigate climate change have seen large global diffusion. While the specific transfer mechanisms have been extensively covered in the literature, how and why policy instruments and their specific design are accommodated in the receiving country remains underexplored. Against this background and in line with the argument that policy design rather than the instrument type is more decisive for technology deployment, we seek to shed light on the role of technology-related actors, i.e. technology suppliers and technology users, in the implementation and design phase of deployment policy instruments. Based on the concept of instrument constituencies which we expand to the more general design constituencies, we analyse around which arguments such constituencies form and disaggregate at the different abstraction levels of Cashore and Howlett’s (2007) and Howlett and Cashore’s (2009) taxonomy of policy elements. The aim is to establish these actors’ role specific policy design choices. Empirically, we focus on the implementation of the renewable energy feed-in tariff in Switzerland. This case is particularly interesting for two reasons: First, while a blueprint of the policy was directly transferred to Switzerland from Germany, the Swiss policy shows significant adaptations for specific design elements where the actor bases differ between the two countries. Second, the design of the feed-in tariff is different for different technologies hence providing the opportunity for a comparative analysis. The empirical material includes policy documents and parliamentary debates as well as interviews with policymakers and technology-related actors who were involved in the policymaking process. The preliminary results suggest the existence and exertion of influence of dynamic design constituencies on all levels of the policy process.

Our study contributes to the question of the characteristics and role of actors in the policy process not only by introducing the often overlooked technology-related actor groups but also by analysing their role in policy design choices at the different levels of the policymaking process.

CO-AUTHORS
Lev Lhommeau (Université catholique de Louvain)
Pierre Squevin (University of Oslo)
ABSTRACT

Civil servants are essential and often neglected actors in the policy process. Their involvement in policymaking is essential to democracy and good public policy. They play a mediating role between interest groups and politicians which both push their agenda without necessarily weighting the different problem frames and policy options. The detachment of their position makes their advice to politicians more informed and based on an accumulation of in-house knowledge and a plurality of external advice than any other stakeholder. Theories like the advocacy coalition framework for example tend to refer to decision makers without specifying the position and role of these public actors (top civil servants, politicians, political advisers or heads of agencies). The involvement of civil servants in the policy process has been studied for long (e.g. Lindblom 1959, Dahl 1961), but it needs a fresh look. In the recent years, civil servants have gained more attention by policy scholars. Their importance in the policy process was reassessed in sector-specific case studies (Montpetit 2011, Paquet 2015). Their policy work was specifically investigated (Colebatch, Howlett), as well as their involvement into political advice (Shaw & Eichbaum 2017, Maley 2015). This communication intends to go beyond description and proposes to further theorize the role of civil servants in the policy process. Relying on a synthesis of the most recent literature, the theoretical framework explains the role of civil servants according to both their position and behavior. Their role is related to the kind of advice they formulate (fact-driven vs. normative, and issue- vs. process-specific) (Nekola and Kohoutec 2016) and its utilization of their policy advice, that is its impact on policy formulation (Landry et al. 2001). The role in the policy process is explained by a combination of institutional position and individual behavior. The position depends on the institutional context (Scharpf 1997), in this case the national political-administrative relation or tradition, the type of network within the policy subsystem (for example pluralist vs. neocorporatist), as well as the position in the government (or public administration). Relying on the policy learning literature, individual behavior refers to the way civil servants commit themselves in the production of advice: What kind of information do they mobilize? Do they stick to prior beliefs or do they update their beliefs, attitudes and opinions (Strickland et al. 2011)? Do politicians trust them and collaborate to develop a shared understanding of the policy problem? In sum, the role of civil servants in the policy process increases when their policy advisory role is recognized in the political-administrative system and they have a mediating function between interest groups and politicians, but this is not enough. Individual civil servants must also be trusted by the politicians, rely on information based on evidence and maintain a learning dynamics. The communication will rely on illustrations from a survey conducted in Belgium and will propose a comparative agenda for empirical testing.

 

References

Colebatch, Hal K., Hoppe, Robert, Noordegraaf, Mirko (Eds.) 2010. Working for Policy. Amsterdam University Press, Amsterdam.

Dahl, Robert A. (Ed.) 1961. Who Governs? Yale University Press, New Haven, London.

Landry, Réjean, Amara, Nabil, Lamari, Moktar, 2001. 'Utilization of Social Science Research Knowledge in Canada'. Research Policy 30, 333–349.

Lindblom, Charles E., 1959. ‘The science of muddling through’. Public Administration Review 19, 79-88.

Maley, Maria, 2015. ‘The Policy Work of Australian Political Staff’. International Journal of Public Administration 38, 46-55.

Montpetit, Eric, 2011. ‘Between detachment and responsiveness: Civil servants in Europe and North America’. West European Politics 34, 1250-1271.

Nekola, Martin, Kohoutek, Jan, 2016. ‘Policy work at the sub-national level: Analytical styles of Canadian and Czech directors and managers’. Canadian Public Administration 59, 289-309.

Paquet, Mireille, 2015. ‘Bureaucrats as immigration policy-makers: The case of subnational immigration activism in Canada, 1990-2010’. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 41, 1815-1835.

Scharpf, Fritz W. (Ed.) 1997. Games real actors play: Actor-centered institutionalism in policy research. Westview Press, Boulder.

Shaw, Richard, Eichbaum, Chris, 2017. ‘Politicians, political advisers and the vocabulary of public service bargains: Speaking in tongues?’. Public Administration 95, 312-326

Strickland, April A., Taber, Charles S., Lodge, Milton, 2011. ‘Motivated Reasoning and Public Opinion’. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 36, 935-944.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

THE POWER OF NON-STATE ACTORS AND INCLUSIVE PUBLIC POLICY PROCESS: A CASE OF KENYA

 

Tiberius Barasa, (Email: tibsrasa@yahoo.com)

 

ABSTRACT

Public policy process has for a long time been dominated by state actors and has not been participatory. Despite the constraint on the participation of non-state actors in the policy process, these organizations have succeeded in influencing public policy to satisfy their interests in the midst of a reluctant state. Thus, whereas non-state actors seem to have made a contribution towards removing obstacles to citizens’ engagement in public policy process, the actual role of the non-state actors in public policy process remains unclear. More significantly, the manner in which non-state actors have tried to open public policy space is unclear. This raises questions not only about the non-state actors’ contribution in opening the policy process and increasing space for participation in the policy process but also how they negotiate to be included in the process and contribute to inclusive public policy process. Using the case of Kenya, this study investigates the contribution of non-state actors to opening the public policy process. The objective of this study is to examine how non-state actors use their power to be included in public policy decision and delivery processes. Based on the assumption that public policy is framed within a context of relationships and dependencies.This study employs power relations analytical model to investigate the contribution of non-state actors to opening the public policy process in Kenya. The study will employ mixed methods research design combining qualitative and quantitative survey. Its population will include four categories of organisations: the local and international non-governmental organisations, private sector organisations and donor organizations operating in Kenya. For qualitative survey, stratified sampling will be used to select 16 organisations while purposive sampling will be used to select 2 senior managers from each organisation who are knowledgeable about public policy process. For quantitative survey, all the 20 Government ministries will be chosen. Data for qualitative survey will be collected through an in-depth interview using schedule and guidelines. Supplementary information will be obtained through document reviews. Data for quantitative survey will be collected through administering a questionnaire. Data analysis will include triangulation, power analysis using power cube and simple descriptive statistics. This study is likely to strengthen the contribution of non-state actors in public policy process as it will employ power relations analytical model to understand the contribution of non-state actors in public policy process.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Increasing interdependence of political decisions raises new questions on how to ensure coherence across different national, international and sectoral policies as manifested in SDG 17 of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. It also raises new theoretic and methodologic questions on how to understand those complex policy processes. Recent literature has addressed the issue of policy trade-offs and coherence in policy analyses and in studies on multi-level governance (cf. Hoebink 2004, Sianes 2013, Siitonen 2015, Carbone and Keijzer 2016). Yet, we know very little about the role of actors in policy processes at the intersection of both different policy levels and fields.

Taking this disjunction as a starting point, the analysis in this paper explores the role and characteristics of actors in the emerging field of sustainability policy which is particularly interesting due to its unique international and interdepartmental orientation. Specifically, the paper focuses on actors dealing with questions of Policy Coherence for Sustainable Development. It argues that those intermediary actors are crucial for understanding policy processes and the change in modern societies. In order to understand their capabilities, orientations and interactions in relation to the institutional setting and policy environment (cf. Scharpf 1997) this paper offers new findings from case studies in France and Germany. My research design combines a qualitative analysis of 49 semi-structured expert interviews, with results from a participant observation conducted in international meetings on Policy Coherence for Development between October 2013 and March 2015, and thorough analysis of official documents linked to the work of these actors in France and Germany.

The first part of the paper offers a mapping of relevant actors in France and Germany and illustrates that their orientations and capabilities have changed over the years. Both case studies demonstrate that actors from within national bureaucracies that have interacted in an international epistemic community were crucial for the circulation of knowledge and proliferation of policies for Policy Coherence for Development between 2005 and 2015. Contrary to traditional theories focusing on the role of either individual or collective actors in policy processes, my analysis shows that this distinction may not always be helpful for characterizing actors at the intersection of different policy sectors and levels in the field of sustainability.

The second part of the paper analyses those intermediary actors in greater detail and focuses on their interactions. Operationalizing theories of policy transfer, translation and resistance (cf. Dolowitz and Marsh 2000; James and Lodge 2003; Stone 2004, Delpeuch 2009; Saurugger and Terpan 2013; Hassenteufel 2013) it raises the question on how far these interactions can explain policy change. The comparison of interactions of similar actors dealing with questions of Policy Coherence for Sustainable Development in France and Germany indicates, that the institutional setting and policy environment both limits and enables their role in policy processes. 

Based on empirical analysis of actors in the emerging field of sustainability policy, my paper seeks to contribute to the debate academic debate on characterizing actors in increasingly complex and interdependent policy processes. It offers new thoughts for studying actors at the intersection of both different policy levels and fields combining the framework of actor-centred institutionalism with transfer theories.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Public policy design surrounding migrants with irregular status legitimizes the adoption of immigration detention practices in Canada. This practice imposes undue hardship and is considered harsh and arbitrary by domestic and international actors such as the United Nations. Meanwhile, policy changes that reinforce the immigration detention of foreign nationals are implemented without an investigation that traces the role and influence of advocacy coalition groups, primarily comprised of closed border supporters and open border advocates, on these policy changes. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap and contribute to scholarship on immigration detention policy in Canada by exploring the role of advocacy coalition groups in the policy change process in Canada. Accordingly, this workshop paper traces the role of closed border supporters and open border advocates in policy changes relating to the immigration detention of asylum seekers and irregular migrants in Canada.

 

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

A generation after the failure of the Clinton Administration’s 1994 Health Security Act, between 2002 and 2012, a number of state-level health reform efforts preceded and paralleled the federal Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) debates. Collectively, the state and federal reforms of the period revealed greater political openness to health care policy change. Building from literature in narrative policy analysis and media framing and effects theory, this paper examines newspaper media coverage of two state-level health reform efforts—the Massachusetts Health Reform Law (Romneycare) (2002-2006) and the Utah Health System Reform (2004-2011). My research critically examines the role of policy actors in the movement of neoliberal language framing metaphors and narratives of health within the state-based and national newspaper media. This paper demonstrates coalescence of policy actors’ discourses in media representations between Republican-leaning and Democratic-leaning newspapers. Specifically, this paper focuses on the role of key policy and media actors—state legislators, governors, political columnists, and leaders of health reform advocacy organizations and coalitions—in (re)diffusing reform narratives.

 

CO-AUTHORS
Patrick Hassenteufel (Université Paris-Saclay)
ABSTRACT

General discussion and next-steps planning