CATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
Panel Proposal for ‘Public Policy Praxis in the Global South: Building Coherence and Capacity for Future Challenges’, 6th India Public Policy Network Conference | June 1 to 4, 2026, National Law School of India University, Bengaluru An Indian Perspective on Public Policy Satyajit Singh, Shailaja Fennell & Namrata Chindarkar Should policy issues in India be analyzed using the same perspectives and standards as those in the developed world? Should policymaking in India be guided by the “best practices” established by the Global North? This panel calls for papers that argue for a different institutional framework to address the trajectory and milestones defining Indian public policy. It notes that the weaknesses seen in Indian public policy originate from adherence to international templates. This approach has led to ignoring the specificities inherent in the country—such as economic resilience, security, gender, and identity—that cannot be addressed through concepts like market failure, which are typical of international public policy approaches. Ideas and measures for Indian development must be grounded in detailed descriptions and robust evidence to improve the provision of legal rights, including property rights, to marginalized communities. It is also crucial to analyze policy failures arising from the adoption of international templates and to shift toward institutional regulations better aligned with access to and adoption of new opportunities, such as digital technology, AI, and international and strategic regional alliances. It can be argued that no other country in the world can match India's diversity and complexity. With its complex history, development path, evolving democracy, deeply plural social fabric, and now high ambitions for growth and global influence, policymaking in India remains a uniquely challenging endeavor. In recent years, India's policymaking landscape has undergone several significant paradigm shifts. First, the narrative has shifted from viewing the government as the primary provider to embracing "more governance, less government," fundamentally changing perceptions of the government’s role in policymaking. There is now increased involvement from non-state actors—such as the private sector, civil society, and citizens—in shaping policies, which has improved state capacity and spurred policy innovation. Second, central planning has been replaced by policy coordination and cooperative federalism, with important implications for policy formulation, implementation, and capacity across sectors. Third, efforts to promote evidence-based policymaking and digital governance aim to enhance transparency, accountability, and agility, although their impact on policy effectiveness still needs full assessment. Lastly, a proactive and risk-taking approach is emerging in policymaking, addressing complex issues like inequality, climate change, and artificial intelligence instead of avoiding them. These paradigm shifts and issues merit closer examination, and this panel aims to provide that.
CALL FOR PAPERS
This panel calls for papers that argue for a different institutional framework to address the trajectory and milestones defining Indian public policy. It notes that the weaknesses seen in Indian public policy originate from adherence to international templates. This approach has led to ignoring the specificities inherent in the country—such as economic resilience, security, gender, and identity—that cannot be addressed through concepts like market failure, which are typical of international public policy approaches. Ideas and measures for Indian development must be grounded in detailed descriptions and robust evidence to improve the provision of legal rights, including property rights, to marginalized communities.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Policymaking in India is characterized by formal inclusion and substantive hierarchy. State, industry, and civil society actors interact frequently, yet the basis of coordination in such settings remains unclear. This chapter examines how belief structures and network configurations shape coordination in India’s energy sector and what this reveals about the organization of policymaking more broadly.
The analysis asks how actors’ beliefs about coal, their perceptions of others’ views, and their positions within the policy network influence interaction and influence. It draws on a social network analysis of actors involved in national debates on the coal phase-out. The network includes central and state government agencies, public and private firms, industry associations, research organizations, and non-governmental groups. Measures of centrality, density, and modularity capture network structure, while survey data identify actors’ own beliefs and their perceptions of others’ beliefs regarding coal.
The results show a single, highly connected network dominated by central government agencies and large industrial actors. Civil society organizations occupy peripheral positions. The network is dense but weakly modular, suggesting limited clustering by belief or actor type. Most actors express neutral positions on coal, and many misperceive others’ views—particularly overestimating pro-coal sentiment. The pattern points to limited belief differentiation and incomplete information among participants.
Interpreted through the lens of the Advocacy Coalition Framework, which expects stable and observable belief systems as the basis of coalition formation, these findings present three deviations. Belief ambiguity refers to weakly structured or unstable beliefs that prevent ideological alignment. Belief opacity denotes limited visibility and systematic misperception of others’ beliefs, which obstructs recognition of allies and opponents. Belief inconsequentiality captures the weak link between belief and coordination, implying that relational dependence and hierarchical access—not ideology—shape network interaction.
These findings are broadly consistent with policy network theory’s emphasis on interdependence and asymmetric centrality, but they qualify a key assumption: network density does not guarantee information exchange or learning. The Indian energy policy network is structurally integrated yet cognitively fragmented. Coordination arises from positional dependence rather than shared understanding.
The chapter concludes that India’s energy policy network exemplifies a form of dense but opaque governance, in which policy stability results from hierarchy, access, and resource dependence rather than belief-based coalitioning. The analysis also identifies a direction for further research: examining how resource dependence, information exchange, and trust evolve over time within such networks. Future work applying policy network theory longitudinally could clarify how interdependence and epistemic constraints jointly sustain coordination and stability in state-dominated policy systems.”
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Several bottom-up scholars have emphasised and prescribed the importance of factoring in the local context when assessing policy design and implementation. As articulated by Jann and Wegrich (2006), “a central feature of the policy process in modern societies is the interaction between policy-related activities at different levels and arenas of governance. The local context or level is often spoken of in relation to local bureaucrats (Lipsky, 1971, 1980), agencies (Elmore, 1980), politicians, and actors. However, just as Ferguson (1994) highlights, the Thaba-Tseka Project in Lesotho was intended to increase agricultural productivity, but the institutions that were implementing the project tended to generalise development metrics to fit various local contexts and districts into the “standard development package” for Africa.[1] In this case, there was a homogenisation of the ‘local’ that failed to factor in history, socio-political conditions and contexts. The Indian agricultural context further adds to this heterogeneity as there are nuances of caste, class, gender, organic vs. chemical farming, education level, and cropping patterns as well. Using the case study of two farmers (one large/upper caste/male/educated/organic and one small, non-upper caste/female/uneducated/traditional), the chapter narrows in on how they navigate the process of accessing one policy - PMKSY’s micro-irrigation scheme - and their differing adoption methods and responses to the scheme. This chapter underscores the importance of considering the diversity and heterogeneity of farmers within the ‘local context’ when designing agrarian policies, especially in the Indian context.
[1] Ferguson, J. (1990). The anti-politics machine: "development," depoliticization, and bureaucratic power in Lesotho. Cambridge University Press.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This chapter will critically examine how public policy education contributes to building policy capacity – the “skills, resources, and capabilities necessary to perform policy functions” (Wu et al., 2015) – in India, and how this capacity shapes policy design in the country’s distinct institutional context. While public policy education is broadly recognized as vital for fostering effective governance, scholarly inquiry into its role in strengthening policy capacity remains strikingly limited, particularly in the Global South (Denny & Zittoun, 2024). Although a handful of studies (e.g., El-Taliawi et al., 2021; Nair et al., 2024) have begun exploring public policy education in non-Western settings, systematic analyses of how curricula, pedagogies, and institutional adaptations respond to Asia’s, and especially India’s unique governance challenges remain sparse. This chapter addresses this gap by interrogating the interplay between policy education, capacity development, and context-sensitive policy design in India.
India’s significance as a focal point for public policy education stems from its rapid economic growth, diverse governance regimes, and escalating demand for skilled policy practitioners. Yet the region’s educational institutions operate within complex political landscapes, hybrid administrative traditions, and labor markets shaped by competing pressures for global standardization and local relevance. This raises two interconnected questions:
First, how do public policy programs in India cultivate the specific competencies required for effective policy work? While the link between education and capacity-building is widely acknowledged, the mechanisms through which curricula and pedagogies target distinct dimensions of policy capacity – analytical, operational, or political skills (Wu et al., 2015) – remain undertheorized. For instance, do programs prioritize technical expertise over political negotiation skills, or vice versa? By mapping these connections, this chapter aims to inform strategies for aligning education with the region’s most pressing capacity deficits.
Second, how do India’s public policy programs adapt to their local institutional, political, and socioeconomic contexts? Existing research suggests a nuanced reality: while a residual “pro-Western bias” persists in pedagogy and curriculum design (Mukherjee & Maurya, 2023), Asian institutions rarely replicate Western models wholesale (Pal & Clark, 2016a, 2016b). For example, El-Taliawi et al. (2021) find that emerging policy schools in the Global South often blend global best practices with localized innovations, such as case studies reflecting regional governance challenges or partnerships with domestic bureaucracies.
By interrogating these questions, this chapter presents empirical findings on public policy student experiences to bridges critical gaps in understanding how pedagogical approaches in public policy education in India both inform – and are shaped by – the demands of policy design in India’s distinct governance contexts.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The exercise of matching policy goals and means is the central essence of the activities linked with policy design in the policy process. While by no means a neutral or ‘objective’ or technical process, policy design embodies the conscious effort to articulate policy aims and devise combinations of policy solutions to address them. Policy design is thus, ia deeply political activity thoroughly immersed and grounded in questions about “who gets what, when and how” in society (Lasswell, 1936).
A key feature in designing policies under future policy uncertainty, a key characteristic of the Indian agricultural sector, is that of being adaptive- i.e. policies that are designed to adapt to a host of anticipated conditions in future, trigger policy adjustments to maintain policy performance or potentially terminate policy when it ceases to be relevant. Adaptive policies are also designed to accommodate unforeseen changes in the policy context for which the policy was not originally designed but in ways that support the intended policy goals, recognize emerging issues that will need to be addressed and trigger further analysis and deliberation for policy adjustments (Swanson and Bhadwal, 2009). A key tenet of adaptive policies is that of policy experimentation or designing policy initiatives as experiments for addressing policy uncertainty and complexity (Rondinelli, 1993).
In such scenarios, experiments have long served as a source of evidence for policy-making in several sectors such as including education, healthcare, environment and social welfare (Bennion, 2011) and as tools for generating new knowledge for research and practice (Cloutier et al., 2015), (Seyfang and Smith, 2007), (Hoffmann, 2011). Experiments could be leveraged by central and state governments as a low-risk policy tool to provide information on the expected performance of a proposed policy change ahead of its full implementation (Tassey, 2013). Experimentation can also be a mode of exploring a range of alternatives as policy solutions to increase the chances of achieving effective outcomes under uncertain policy circumstances (Swanson and Bhadwal, 2009). This chapter will focus on anticipatory policy design and risk management focusing on examples from Indian agriculture. The discussion will focus on leveraging policy experimentation and piloting to address risks and uncertainties in the long-term.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Public policy has conventionally been understood as a technical instrument of governance aimed at solving social problems through rational decision-making and institutional design. Most of the policy science models, however, tend to treat policies as neutral tools and primarily evaluate them in terms of efficiency, implementation, and outcomes. This paper argues that such a framework is not sufficient for understanding public policy in postcolonial contexts like India. It advances the claim that public policy in India has been operating not merely as a mode of governance, but as a cultural–political project through which the state seeks to produce legitimacy, authority, and social order.
Taking from Indian political thought, particularly the works of Ashis Nandy, Partha Chatterjee, and Rajni Kothari, the paper reconceptualizes public policy as a form of political rule that engages populations not only administratively but symbolically and morally. It shows how policy functions as a site where competing narratives of development, democracy, justice, and national purpose are negotiated, imposed, and contested. Through an analysis of the evolution of Indian policymaking from centralized planning and technocratic governance to participatory reforms and contemporary institutional transformations, the paper establishes that policies derive their effectiveness not only from institutional capacity but from their ability to generate cultural legitimacy.
By foregrounding the cultural and moral dimensions of policymaking, this paper challenges the universalist assumptions of policy science and seeks to propose an alternative conceptualization of public policy as a legitimacy-producing practice embedded in specific historical, social, and political contexts. It concludes by suggesting that understanding policy as cultural–political legitimacy provides a more adequate framework for analyzing both the possibilities and limits of democratic governance in India.
Keywords
Public Policy; Political Legitimacy; Indian Political Thought; Governance; Cultural Politics; Democracy; State and Society; Postcolonial Theory
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Background: Indian agrarian policy has largely been shaped by linear, top-down approaches that abstract farmers into a homogenous category, reinforcing structural constraints that exacerbate agrarian distress, crop failures, weak income discovery, intensive fertiliser use, and rising household indebtedness. Understanding how these constraints shape farmer agency is essential for designing public policy responsive to India’s complex agrarian realities. A bottom-up approach, which enables farmer-led decision-making, is crucial for reframing public policy and facilitating transitions toward sustainable and context-responsive farming practices.
Research Methodology: This paper examines how structural constraints shape farmer agency in fertiliser use, and what does this imply for policy design in India? The study draws on qualitative fieldwork across nine districts in seven states, covering diverse agro-ecological contexts. Data were gathered through 16 mini-group discussions (1 with women) and 40 in-depth interviews (13 with women). The sample captures variation in landholding size, tenancy status, gender, caste, and farming practices, including natural farming. A thematic analysis is being conducted to examine fertiliser decision-making as an entry point into broader questions of agency, risk and institutional design. Policy documents were also reviewed to examine how farmers are represented, providing context to observed decision-making patterns.
Key Findings: Field observations indicate that fertiliser use is shaped by structural and institutional conditions rather than individual preference alone. Dependence on synthetic fertilisers arises from yield pressures, market-driven quality standards, and agro-ecological constraints. These factors define crop choices, which in turn shape fertiliser practises. Farmers reflect an awareness of potential soil and health impacts, yet decision-making is limited, especially among households near subsistence margins. Synthetic fertilisers are often perceived as a form of risk mitigation: while they may not guarantee a quantum of profits, not using them can increase the likelihood of crop loss, with unequal consequences across farmer profiles. Awareness and use of “organic” fertilisers are constrained by labour-intensive preparation, declining livestock ownership, insecure tenancy, limited state support, and uncertain market access. Many farmers equate organic inputs primarily with cow dung, reflecting uneven knowledge of organic practices. Natural farmers face additional challenges, including access to inputs, extension services, certification, and assured pricing.
Contribution: Early observations suggest that focusing solely on organic farming or natural fertiliser adoption, without complementary input access, extension support, and market assurances, may limit farmers’ ability to change practices in contexts of structural constraint. Effective policy support requires both back-end measures, such as input availability and extension services, and front-end measures, including assured markets and price incentives. Fertiliser decisions reflect institutional arrangements, market structures, and livelihood imperatives, highlighting the systemic nature of farmer agency. Narrative analysis of policy documents reveals that policy assumptions frequently portray farmers as passive beneficiaries, highlighting opportunities to align interventions and representations more closely with field realities. These findings suggest that policy interventions that account for structural conditions and institutional contexts, and that are grounded in detailed evidence of farmers’ lived experience, are more likely to support sustainable and context-specific transitions in Indian agriculture.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Over the last three decades, policy making for health and healthcare in India has systematically moved away from health being a fundamental human right as articulated in the Alma Ata Declaration (1978) to a multi-billion dollar market commodity, with citizens being reduced to consumers paying for private profits.
While the former centre- staged health promotion /disease prevention as the bedrock of public health, largely focused on the social determinants of health such as nutrition, sanitation, potable drinking water among others, we have now been reduced to a situation where substantial democratic space has been ceded and tax payers’ resources routed overtly and covertly to private entities, with simultaneous breakdown of the public health system. This Chapter will cover this trajectory of policy- making in health care with a focus on nutrition, a key social determinant of health.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Public Policy cannot be evaluated without assessing its normative goals and asking what are the values it seeks to promote. Divorcing the study of policy from this intrinsic characteristic not only reduces the relevance of policy research but also contributes to the ruptures we are currently witnessing between government actions around the world taken for granted democratic values. Acknowledging the infancy of the discipline of Public Policy in India and the need to build its foundations, the Chapter will discuss the possibilities of using ideas from action research to study policy implementation from the bottom-up in India from both a pragmatic and normative perspective. In doing so, it will also engage with an alternate formulation of “evidence-based” policy making that could contribute to democratic deepening.
From a pragmatic perspective, the limited capacity and resources available for public policy make it essential that researchers studying policy “get their hands dirty” in understanding policy implementation especially those targeted at socially disadvantaged groups. As Schneider and Ingram argue, the design of policies targeted at these groups are likely to be characterized by high on rhetoric while being low on actual reallocation and distribution of resources. A characteristic that often leads policy to begin with very visible announcements and ambitious targets only to fade away with other competing announcements. Those at the bottom of the administrative hierarchy are blamed for “implementation failures”, without a serious investigation of what led to them. In such a context, adopting a bottom-up perspective also enables the voicing of critical but often ignored experiences in the implementation process.
Normatively, even as the ideas of action research promote a democratic ethos they serve to draw attention to the technical –”nuts and bolts” – aspects of policy implementation. The emphasis on participation and working closely with communities ensures that researchers remain grounded in the social realities of the populations they seek to speak on behalf of. Further as the discipline of public policy seeks to develop its legitimacy, conducting research with communities around them also helps research and academic institutions become more meaningful to the larger population rather than being seen as engaged in exclusive conversations with the elite.
While acknowledging the challenges and limitations of studying policy implementation bottom-up using ideas inspired by action research, the chapter will discuss arenas and spaces for intellectual creativity seeking to address them.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper investigates how Indian public policy produces and legitimises environmental inequalities through a graded model of entitlements in water, housing space, and energy supply. While scholarship on environmental justice in India has documented disparities in access and ownership, less attention has been paid to how the state codifies differentiated standards of provision, thereby embedding inequality as a matter of agenda setting, policymaking and institutional design.
The first arena examined is water and sanitation policy. Official planning norms established by the Central Public Health and Environmental Engineering Organisation (CPHEEO), Government of India allocate 150 litres per capita per day (lpcd) in metropolitan areas and 135 lpcd in cities with sewerage networks, but only 70 lpcd where sewerage is absent. Where public standposts serve as the delivery mechanism - common in slums and resettlement colonies - the allocation drops to 40 lpcd. These reduced entitlements are not the outcome of scarcity alone but reflect explicit policy choices. Empirical evidence from Delhi demonstrates that actual supply in informal settlements often falls below even these thresholds, with households surviving on as little as 4–10 lpcd, in stark contrast to middle-class colonies with near-continuous access. Such differentiation makes inequality in water access not accidental but designed into state policy frameworks.
The second arena is energy supply. India has achieved near-universal household electrification, yet major disparities persist in capacity, reliability, and usage. National surveys report an average of 22 hours of supply in urban areas and 20 hours in rural areas, but the poorest neighbourhoods within cities endure more frequent and longer outages. Per-capita electricity consumption, at about 1,395 kWh in 2023–24, hides deep class, caste and urban–rural divides in appliance ownership and usage. Policy discourse further reinforces stratification by often promoting mini-grids, micro-grids, and biomass as ‘appropriate technologies’ for rural and low-income areas, while 24×7 grid electricity is reserved for urban middle-class users.
The third arena is land and housing. Resettlement policies in Delhi grant evictees plots as small as 12.5–25 square metres, compared to 60–200 square metres or more in middle-income housing societies and government colonies. Official master plans explicitly sanction such differentiated allocations: the minimum plot for resettlement can be reduced to 18 square metres, while middle-income plotted housing frequently begins at 100–300 square metres. This sharp contrast institutionalises spatial inequality in environmental entitlements, with smaller plots exacerbating overcrowding, limiting infrastructure, reducing green space, and often relocating poor households to peripheral areas with weaker connectivity and higher costs of access to livelihood.
Taken together, these cases demonstrate that environmental inequalities in India are not only outcomes of socio-economic hierarchy or governance failure but are embedded in the architecture of public policy. By differentiating minimum standards of access across class, caste and settlement categories, the state actively produces a graded system of environmental citizenship. This paper argues for reframing policy debates around equitable- not just “equal” - and rights-based entitlements in water, energy, and housing space, rather than perpetuating graded service models.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Policy theorization has traditionally been dominated by macro and centralized perspectives, largely imported from Western and colonial institutions. Up until the 1980s, public policy was primarily influenced by a statist viewpoint. Diana Stone aptly observed, “Public policy has been a prisoner of the word “state’” (2008). Policy processes were seen as arising from an elite group of government experts within specialized institutions such as planning agencies, other executive bodies, as well as legislative and judicial systems. Social learning in policymaking was also confined to a closed circle of economists and bureaucrats, given that these tasks are highly technical and demand elite skills (Hall, 1993). In contrast to this statist approach, a growing democratic perspective in India challenges the autonomy of the state and the elite’s conceptualization of national interest. It recognizes demands that emerge from democratic contestation by political parties, interest groups, and evolving social needs. A large, democratic country like India faces policy challenges and processes unmatched anywhere else. These are typical challenges for developing countries: eradicating poverty, creating opportunities for growth, and restoring environmental health. India also has a rich history, a strong democratic system, and maintained robust institutions for nearly all of its eight decades of independence. These qualities provide ample material for analyzing public policies (Mathur and Mathur, 2007; Ganapathy et al, 1985). The chapter examines developments since the 1980s to argue that democratic processes at the federal, state, and local levels intersect with policies and policy-making. The decentralization of the state began alongside an increased role for the market since the 1990s, which has shifted the state's role in relation to the market. While this does not eliminate the centralized, elite-driven policy discourse of economists and bureaucrats, it expands policy analysis across disciplines such as political science, law, international relations, sociology, anthropology, public health, media studies, and more. This introduces new perspectives into public policy and, importantly, amplifies the voices of those who have not benefited from mainstream economic policy discourse—a people-centered approach to policymaking and development (Dreze, 2017).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
India’s current environmental and conservation policies have been shaped both by historical legacies and contemporary responses to multiple drivers. The relatively recent emphasis on climate change mitigation has now intersected with sectors such as water, biodiversity and forest conservation. This has reshaped the narrative, regulations and policy responses in the environmental sector in a changing political economy. This is in the face of complex challenges, synergies and trade-offs are emerging between food, water, energy, environmental hazards, ecological and climate security. Certain legacy and new infrastructure priorities have been repackaged within the climate change concerns, with severe trade-offs in certain fragile social-ecological systems, such as pitting local ecological costs against global benefits from “green energy”.
We critically analyse the dynamics and shifts in the environment policy and regulatory environment at multiple levels of governance from local to national across the three pillars: executive, legislature and judiciary. In addition, the changing role of academia, civil society and non-governmental organizations, think tanks and media in shaping the public discourse on environment, ecology, renewable energy and climate change will be examined. Finally, India’s engagement with international conventions, UN Sustainable Development Goals, and science-policy platforms such as IPCC and IPBES will be examined.
This critical review will encompass case-studies involving green energy, forest rights and biodiversity conservation, regional and transboundary river water sharing and environmental and climate hazards in the Himalaya, as well as ecotourism and rewilding and reintroductions, management of invasive species and urban and rural ecological restoration. We will examine the role of National Green Tribunals and Judiciary and the role of centre and state in conservation policies and practice. The fault lines in conservation policies especially escalating human wildlife conflict and the response to mitigation measures for linear barriers and infrastructural development will be examined.
We will draw upon peer-reviewed literature, technical reports, news articles, debates in legislatures and judicial records and pronouncements as well as a rapid assessment of the biophysical state of the environment, environmental and climate hazards to explore the actual outcomes on the ground even as policy and regulations have changed.
Biodiversity conservation, climate resilience and human well-being are closely linked. Yet, mismatches in the scale at which these three priority issues are governed have exacerbated biodiversity loss and degradation of ecosystem services and declining human well-being.
We conclude with some future directions in achieving synergies between the biodiversity conservation and climate resilient development. Insights from this review and syntheses can help meet the twin goals of biodiversity conservation and sustainable development in India and other countries across the Global South.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The changing relationship between the state and communities has been much debated among policy-makers, academics, and civil society activists in the contemporary period. Such debates focus on different dynamics and forms associated with social, economic, political and cultural backwardness and the unequal power relationship between various social groups. Within the broader framework of the debate, tribes are seen as one of the most dispossessed, deprived and marginalised communities in India.
After centuries of exclusion from social, economic, cultural and political realms, a ray of hope emerged for the tribes in the post-colonial period. The different experiences of discrimination, marginalisation and exploitation by the tribal communities provided the ground for the democratic state to adopt policy measures for tribal communities in India. Subsequently, the state has taken several targeted public policy initiatives to safeguard the rights of tribal communities. Moreover, the state has adopted several general policy measures that can benefit tribal communities. Meanwhile, it has been observed that the post-colonial state continues to follow the footsteps of the colonial state in different forms while developing a policy approach towards tribal communities. The policy-making of the post-colonial state appears more paternalistic than collaborative with tribal communities, which is one of the most prominent reasons for policy failure. The policy instruments followed neglect the contextual socio-cultural institutions. Such policy processes reduce the tribes to merely socio-economic, political and culturally marginalised communities without referring to their history, context and location.
Within this backdrop, the paper problematises the tribal public policy domain and explores the interplay between the tribes, state and public policy in India. While doing so, it provides a policy overview and explores the historical past, contemporary realities, and future concerns of policy measures affecting tribal communities. The paper would address pertinent questions, such as how the dynamics of tribes could be incorporated into public policy discourse in India, especially by highlighting their role at the stages of agenda setting, policy formulation, decision-making, implementation, and policy evaluation. Why, how and to what extent does public policy become the critical arena of continuous engagement between tribes and the state, and to what extent does such engagement shape the policy formulation? The paper would argue that at every level of policy engagement, from evolution to formulation to implementation, there were multiple signs of policy paradoxes concerning tribal communities in India.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In late 20th Century New Public Management scholarship, the growing use of technology was seen as one that made systems more efficient. Technology was understood as transformative, in improving citizens’ access to services, enabling real-time data for faster decision making, and providing tools to improve the process and make it more streamlined (Traunmüller and Lenk, 1996). As US literatures proliferated in India through a variety of reform measures, contemporarily so did technology’s materially commodified forms - datafication and digitalisation. Digitalization began to be viewed as a sign of ‘modernity’ in governance (Dunleavy, 2005). In India, digitalisation was offered as the answer to the problem of inefficient bureaucratic processes and administrative performance.
This technology discourse was accompanied by the narrative of improving ‘transparency’ in the services, making the bureaucracy more accountable and open to citizens. The shift from ‘paper’ to ‘digital’ was the key trope justifying the criticality of digitalisation. Its formal adoption could also be seen in headling of nomenclatures in Indian policymaking institutions. In 2015, the central government launched the Digital India program, to ‘transform India into a knowledge-based economy’, by harnessing digital technologies (Ministry of Electronics and IT, 2024). Under this mission, several schemes were implemented, which relied on technological infrastructure and digital systems (Ministry of Communications, 2024)
However, the prevalence of digitalization also led to research on ‘digital divide’, connoting exclusions based on lack of access, costs of adoption and material scarcities. In India, the digital divide was seen to be particularly prevalent in rural areas, where digital penetration was lower. Given these concerns, the focus of the government was to ensure widespread development of digital infrastructure, particularly in these rural areas. One part of this entailed the adoption of technology for welfare services such as Public Distribution Service, Anganwadi Service, National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme and so forth. Similar to the narrative of NPM, the government portrayed its commitment to improving efficiency in services by transforming these schemes, and improving access for the beneficiaries (Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food & Public Distribution, 2024; Ministry of Rural Development, 2025; Ministry of Women and Child Development, 2025).
This “no-alternatives” emphasis towards digitalization seemed to be unfettered in face of the concerns of the digital divide. Especially given these schemes catered to the rural population, the discussion around how those most affected by the digital divide would experience digitalization was absent. This paper takes a critical approach to the study of the transformation in policy-making in India as it flows through the logics of digitalisation and the platform economy. Departing from an analytical focus on improving technology adoption and integration, we are concerned with the way in which those processes produce decontextualised data, invisiblisation of labour processes in producing digital imageries of the policy process, and transformations that shift power and resources away from street-level bureaucrats, citizens, their representatives and collective institutions upwards to global technology corporations and quasi-governmental bodies that continue to steer policy towards the enablement of privatisation of public services.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper proposes to critically examine how models of urban water supply and sanitation services, drawing on templates and ‘best practices’ from the global north, play out in India.
Underpinned by a neoliberal governance paradigm, current institutional arrangements, governance models, and sector interventions typically focus on how financial flows are allocated and utilised and introduce market-based mechanisms to involve the private sector to improve accountability, efficiency, and service delivery. Using the context of public water supply and sanitation services in three urban areas of Karnataka, this paper argues that this limited notion of accountability does not adequately engage with or address systemic factors that shape the lived realities of governance and particularly public service delivery.
We draw from instances in Bengaluru, Hubballi-Dharwad and Gubbi, which illustrate three different institutional configurations across different hierarchies of urban governance. Bengaluru, the capital city, has the Bengaluru Water Supply and Sewerage Board (BWSSB), with the newly formed Greater Bengaluru Authority (GBA), which includes five different corporations (urban local bodies). In Hubballi-Dharwad, urban water supply, which was handled by the Karnataka Urban Water Supply and Drainage Board (KUWSDB) since 2003, has been contracted out by the Hubballi-Dharwad Municipal Corporation to a private operator under a series of World Bank projects being implemented through the Karnataka Urban Infrastructure Development and Finance Corporation (KUID&FC). In Gubbi, a town panchayat, it is the Karnataka Urban Water Supply and Drainage Board (KUWSDB) addressing wastewater, while the water supply component still rests with the town panchayat.
The cases illustrate that the planning, development and operation of water supply and sewerage services in urban areas remains weak and fragmented. The assumptions of improving accountability and efficiency in sector reforms and governance approaches modelled on such paradigms from the global north do not bear out owing to complex and fragmented conditions in which such services are developed, along with inadequate regulatory frameworks and limited capacities of key actors. Rather, they can deepen a systemic accountability deficit by rescaling decision-making powers by externalising issues of access, equity and sustainability, weakening state capacity of local bodies and foreclosing meaningful participation and alternate models and imaginations of such public services.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Governing Surrogacy in India: A case for an inclusive regulatory framework
Author: Sonshikha Sahoo
Affiliation: Student, MBA-PPM, XIM University, Bhubaneswar, Odisha
e-mail: sahoo.sonshikha@gmai.com
Abstract:
India's legal approach to surrogacy has undergone a dramatic transformation, moving from one of the world's most liberal frameworks, a global hub for "fertility tourism" to one of the most restrictive, culminating in the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021. This paper critically examines the political debates, institutional challenges and ethical tensions surrounding this legislative shift, which abolished commercial surrogacy and limited altruistic arrangements to married heterosexual Indian couples. Drawing on concepts of state capacity, gender roles and inclusive versus extractive institutions, the analysis argues that the blanket ban, while intended to prevent the exploitation of poor women, fundamentally undermines reproductive autonomy, ignores diverse family structures (single individuals, LGBTQ+ families) and risks driving the practice into an unregulated black market due to weak enforcement capacity. Through a comparative review of international experiences, the paper concludes that the current prohibition reflects an extractive institutional approach that denies women dignity and economic agency by refusing to recognize surrogacy as legitimate labour. It proposes a comprehensive, rights-based alternative: a transparent, regulated commercial model that prioritizes strengthening state oversight, mandates robust health and financial protections for surrogates and broadens eligibility to ensure the law is inclusive, ethical, and enforceable.
Key words: reproductive autonomy | women dignity | legitimate labour | inclusive governance institutions
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
For over three decades, public policy in India has been increasingly influenced by the global paradigm of New Public Management (NPM). Promoted by multilateral stakeholders as a “best practice” for the Global South, these principles advocate for market-like efficiency, disaggregation, and “client-centric” administration. This paper examines the implementation trajectory of these international templates within the urban governance landscape of Karnataka, India, arguing that the blind adoption of these frameworks has led to a significant translation loss that undermines the democratic and ethical fabric of Indian public policy.
A combination of field visits, review of archival information, newspaper reports, available literature, annual reports by respective institutions, along with online and institutional ethnography of 19 state-owned for-profit companies, was undertaken to carry out this study. Specifically, the evolution of urban service delivery from the early 1990s to the present was traced. The research focuses on the emergence of “Special Purpose Vehicles” (SPVs) and parastatal agencies in sectors such as transport, power, and infrastructure. While these entities were theoretically designed to enhance efficiency through “bureaucratic entrepreneurship,” our findings reveal a different reality.
The analysis indicates that the adoption of these international templates has encouraged the creation of monopolistic, state-controlled for-profit entities that operate with minimal public accountability. By shifting the governance of essential services to corporatised boards, often led exclusively by senior civil servants (IAS cadre), the state has effectively bypassed the constitutional mandate of the 74th Amendment Act. This has resulted in the disenfranchisement of elected urban local body representatives and the transformation of the “citizen-voter” into a mere “consumer.” Furthermore, quantitative data show that despite the “for-profit” mandate, many of these entities remain inefficient, accumulating significant losses while reducing the scope for a democratic feedback loop.
This study directly addresses the core question of Panel NR49: should Indian policy be analysed through the same standards as the developed world? We argue that the weaknesses in India’s urban policy do not stem from a lack of management expertise, but rather from an adherence to international templates that ignore the specificities of India’s plural social fabric and its unique federal-local power dynamics. The market failure lens typical of Global North approaches fails to capture the administrative evil that arises when technical rationality is used to obscure the erosion of social equity and local representation.
As a corrective, the paper proposes an integrated process model that explicitly incorporates ethical dimensions, Accountability, Social Equity, Market Control, and Citizen Ethics, tailored to the Indian context. By operationalising these measures, the study provides a roadmap for policymakers to move away from the efficiency-only metrics of the Global North toward a governance framework that balances professional management with democratic participation. Ultimately, the paper calls for a shift toward institutional regulations that are better aligned with India’s specific socio-political milestones, ensuring that urban governance remains a tool for public value rather than a site for unaccountable bureaucratic expansion.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Envisioning Users’ Role in Transforming Urban Public Service Delivery in India
By 2047, India’s 100th year of independence, 50 per cent of India will be urbanised. 70 per cent of the urban infrastructure required by 2047 has not yet been built. Therefore, India needs to develop climate-resilient, livable cities with the necessary infrastructure and efficient public services, including water, public transport, sanitation, waste management, and health care, to support its urban residents. The World Bank has stated that, while India stands out as a major engine of growth, only sustained and comprehensive reforms will enable it to realise its ambitious development goals in a complex global context. Effective and equitable urban public services are clearly a vital component (Auguste Tano Kouame, 2024).
At present, in India, public participation for shaping public services is through democratic institutions. At the grassroots level, urban local bodies provide direct platforms for citizen participation. However, the decentralisation initiative is half-hearted (Hamid, 2004). In recent years, technology-based platforms and frameworks have expanded citizen engagement. A notable example is the Right to Information Act (RTI), which empowers citizens to seek information from public authorities and promotes transparency and accountability in service delivery. Political leaders are expected to deliver public services on behalf of citizens, who are the principals (Besley and Burgess, 2002).
Creating effective and efficient public services is foundational to a city's livability (Latupeirissa et al., 2024). The “theory of unbalanced growth” postulates that investments in key strategic sectors can spur economic development in the region (Hirschman, 2015). India has also committed to the Sustainable Development Goals in the realm of urban public services and sustainable urbanisation.
This study is an early-stage analysis and focuses on understanding the user perspective, including the marginalised voices of different age groups, genders, and social classes. The study draws on an earlier public opinion survey conducted by the authors in four metropolitan cities across three public services: water supply, public transport, and waste management (Banerji and Maitra, 2024). For this study, mixed-methods research was employed, incorporating quantitative and qualitative data. Study results clearly indicate that user involvement will enhance transparency, introduce diverse perspectives, strengthen regulations, and improve governance. When users and governments collaborate, public services can better meet societal needs more effectively and equitably. Sustainability and climate-resilient public service policies are necessary, and users' contributions to their implementation are well understood.
Urban Public Service Design in India follows a multi-layered, participatory and policy-driven process shaped by constitutional mandates, national missions and frameworks. This study recognises that user inputs can complement, but cannot replace, expert input, and that while the government must design inclusive and representative participation mechanisms, the public perspective must be balanced against evidence-based policy. In conclusion, “voice of end-user” may be one of the missing links in the cycle of public policy formulation, adoption, implementation, maintenance and monitoring. The critical question is how to incorporate diverse user perspectives throughout the chain, from public policy formulation to implementation.
Key words: public services delivery, user perspective, urban public policy, public transport, waste management, water supply
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Competitive markets often operate on the principle that government regulations should apply uniformly to all firms, yet such uniformity can impose disproportionate burdens on smaller enterprises that lack the scale to absorb high fixed compliance costs. This study examines the unequal regulatory burden faced by Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) in India, focusing on the case of electricity sector regulations. Beyond high tariffs, MSMEs also contend with poor reliability of supply—characterized by frequent outages and voltage fluctuations—which compels many to seek better alternatives through open access procurement. We analyse the threshold requirements and regulatory costs associated with availing open access across Indian states, as determined by their respective State Electricity Regulatory Commission (SERC) guidelines. Our findings reveal that the costs of metering upgrades, contract demand thresholds, cross-subsidy surcharges, and administrative procedures are substantial and vary widely across states, and ultimately fall more heavily on MSMEs than on larger firms. These burdens limit MSMEs’ ability to escape unreliable local supply and undermine national policy goals aimed at strengthening small and medium industries. The study highlights the need for more nuanced, scale-sensitive regulatory design to ensure that MSMEs can participate equitably in competitive markets.
Keywords: MSME, open access, electricity markets, regulatory burden, competitive markets, India
JEL Codes: L51, L94, O13, O25
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Public policy has emphasised the need for national economies to develop an ability to manage economic shocks, in response to the challenges imposed by endogenous and exogenous occurrences has become increasingly evident over recent decades. These shocks and the responses have been framing using an engineering approach where a system is presumed to be in a steady state. This conceptualisation has restricted our understanding of economic resilience to the study of shocks to that of a simple mechanical action, akin to the bounce back of an elastic band.
Moving away from an engineering approach and towards the adoption of an ecological approach to understanding economic resilience deepens thinking to consider the processes within a system, similar to examining cogs and wheels in a complex machine. Processual thinking is conducive to a dynamic and fuller investigation of absorptive capacity, particularly on how specific processes in the system can be improved by changing existing policy directives.
This chapter will map the processes evident in recent policy agendas in India that adopt the proposition that public goods and the commons complement each other and are backed by government commitment. It will investigate the forms of institutional engagement that had been put into place to facilitate a richer understanding of this more inclusive approach to economic security- e.g., for increasing supply chain resilience and energy security. It will show how new mechanisms for advancing expertise and capacity have increased information flow between institutions and this has also reduced the costs of institutional engagement. It will also make the case that the inclusive approach that had moved away from setting up public goods against the commons also has important implications for new forms of policymaking where an emphasis on economic resilience will also have the ability to prevent the growth of vulnerabilities – e.g., in making communities/districts less likely than previously to remain in a disrupted state in the wake of shocks.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The international legal system, which resolves infrastructure disputes, currently faces a complete structural transformation because private dispute resolution methods create operational problems while countries need to maintain their public responsibilities. The research paper would examine the significant policy change that India implemented through its January 2026 circular for the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI). The circular establishes a ban on arbitration as a method to resolve disputes which exceed 10 crore rupees in value for major projects because it requires parties to use mediation before they can proceed to court in domestic civil litigation. The analysis investigates the reasons for this decision because its main objective focuses on reducing emerging financial obligations while solving problems of unfairness which exist in temporary arbitration systems. The study will compare the Indian experiences with the "public policy" exception through a comparative study of American and British legal systems. The US maintains strict control over its ADR process which requires agreement from involved parties according to Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) rules, while the UK system allows private parties to select their preferred forum under Model Services Contracts, yet India shows a complete change toward judicial control. The research investigates how project bankability, foreign direct investment (FDI), and rule-of-law development interact with emerging markets. The research shows that the Indian governmental action responds to real financial fears, but it incorrectly defines the problem because it mixes up contract management problems with contract administration operations.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
India’s Foreign Policy: National Interests and Citizen Aspirations
Sanjay Bhattacharyya
(An abstract for a chapter in OUP Handbook on Public Policy)
As en emerging economy and a growing power, India’s foreign policy has evolved to integrate new approaches, while retaining elements of continuity. It remains both familiar and flexible. India’s traditional value based and principled approach towards foreign relations has expanded to include interest based approaches that respond to geopolitical and geoeconomic changes and seek to integrate citizen aspirations in contemporary circumstances.
The chapter will discuss India's foreign policy and how it aligns with national interest and citizen aspirations. It will briefly outline the historical tradition of Indian diplomacy; detail the features of India’s foreign policy, the institutional structures and mechanisms of decision making and its implementation; explore the evolution of India’s foreign policy since independence and evaluate key milestones; and discuss the transitions in policy from the perspective of leadership, political ideology, economic situation, geopolitical developments, etc.
India gained leverage as an articulate champion for the independence of colonised States after WW2. Later, she obtained special and differential treatment for developing countries within an overall framework of increasing representation in multilateral forum. Second, India’s economic reforms changed the dynamics of growth and development and lead to an expansion of national priorities in scope and scale. This growth provided opportunity for expansion in capacity, capability and willingness for deeper engagement on regional and global issues. Third, the role of multilateralism ebbed after initial successes, leading to new initiatives at neighbourhood, regional, plurilateral and minilateral levels. While India continued to repose faith in the multilateral system and sought reforms that would facilitate her wider participation, she also exercised leverage through other mechanisms. Fourth, technology transformation and globalisation led India to build new forms of exchanges, with both developed countries and emerging economies. Fifth, the imbalance between geopolitics and geoeconomics needed adjustments in postures towards global governance as India positioned herself for a multipolar world with greater recognition of the Global South.
For India, most transitions have be positive and have enlarged the concept of national interests to include the dividends of democracy, development and demography. Foreign policy was integrated to the primary task of enlarging national strength and economic growth with inclusive and sustainable development. In addition to the traditional function of promoting state to state relations, foreign policy also considered domestic priorities of governance and citizen aspiration in the context of national interest. Foreign policy adopted developments in evidence based policy making, updating of legislation, new instruments and agreement for Interstate exchanges. India views the world of diplomacy and foreign policy from the perspective of new opportunities and challenges in an increasingly complex world.
Tentative sections in the chapter
1. Introduction
2. The making of foreign policy
3. Trends in India’s foreign policy
4. Governance and foreign policy
5. New issues in diplomacy
6. Critique of India's foreign policy
7. Conclusion
***
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Across the growing landscape of sustainability and climate-transition policies, governments worldwide, and in India, have relied heavily on financial incentives, technological substitution, and infrastructural expansion to achieve environmental goals. India’s current sustainability transition initiatives - from clean cooking under Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana (PMUY) and rooftop solar adoption through PM Surya Ghar, to energy-efficient housing under PM Awas Yojana-Urban (PMAY-U) and sustainable agricultural support via PM-Kisan - seek to accelerate low-carbon transitions. Yet, what these policies ultimately require is sustained behavioural change across social and economic systems. The sustainability-transitions literature (Markard et al., 2012; Kuzemko et al., 2016; Scoones et al., 2020; Avelino & Wittmayer, 2016) has illuminated institutional and technological dimensions, as well as the multi-level governance and innovation systems, but paid limited attention to citizens as capacity-bearing actors who interpret, internalise, and adapt these transitions in practice.
This chapter argues that citizen capacity constitutes the social foundation of the sustainable state and that policy effectiveness depends on how well design, implementation, and feedback processes recognise and engage this capacity.
We conceptualise citizen capacity along three dimensions as constitutive of policy capacity, rather being peripheral: cognitive capacity (citizens’ ability to comprehend policy intent, process information, and act upon design instruments); moral-affective capacity(emotions, values, and identifications conditioned by social and cultural position that mediate policy uptake); and adaptive capacity(the situated practices and informal mechanisms through which citizens sustain policy delivery under constraint). These dimensions interact as mechanisms linking policy design to behavioural outcomes: instrument assumptions set expectations, moral-affective engagement enables or limits adoption, and adaptive practices stabilise implementation on the ground.
We examine these dimensions and mechanisms across two interlinked aspects. First, drawing on policy-design and instrument-choice literature (Howlett & Cashore, 2014), we intend to study policy instruments and their embedded assumptions about citizens’ cognitive, moral-emotional, and adaptive abilities, expressed in subsidies, eligibility norms, digital interfaces, and communication tools. Second, utilising Schneider and Ingram’s (1993, 2005) theory of the social construction of target populations, to study how constructions of citizens activate or diffuse citizens’ moral and emotional capacities shaped by socio-demographic and cultural contexts, influencing trust, legitimacy, and identification with sustainability goals.
Methodologically, the chapter employs a conceptual-illustrative analysis of India’s major sustainability policies. Using programme guidelines, policy documents, government communication artefacts, and evaluation studies, we analyse each scheme across the three stages - design, implementation, and feedback - to identify points of capacity alignment and friction between the capacities imagined in policy and those lived by citizens. The approach is diagnostic rather than evaluative: it traces how cognitive, moral-affective, and adaptive capacities shape the functioning and recalibration of sustainability policies.
The chapter thus intends to portray the sustainable state not as a technocratic project but as a dynamic system continually shaped and sustained through the capacities of its citizens, and makes two important contributions in this regard. Firstly, it connects policy-design and instrument-choice scholarship (Howlett & Cashore, 2014) with social-construction theory, showing how moral narratives and design instruments jointly define expectations of citizen competence and motivation. Secondly, it offers a capacity alignment framework for examining whether sustainability policies, through their instruments, constructions, and feedback systems, acknowledge and utilise citizens’ cognitive, moral-affective, and adaptive capacities as essential conditions for durable environmental change.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
We contend that some innovating firms are motivated by an altruistic desire to ‘do good’ by contributing to societal benefit. Historically such motivational differences may have straddled the divide between socially minded public vs profit-oriented private sectors. In one characterization, socially-minded scientist would carry out the basic research in publicly funded universities or government labs while private sector firms would profit from the development of that research for specific applications. This implied vertical division of labor in R&D is, of course, simplistic. Increasingly universities enter downstream markets themselves through spinoffs or through contractual collaborations with downstream firms to capture the financial rewards from their research. Even though such start-ups aspire to profitability they may nonetheless also be driven by a strong desire to contribute to societal wellbeing.
Thus, in many sectors we might expect profit-focused firms competing with socially-motivated rivals. The latter may not eschew financial profits altogether but append to that the hope of some wider economic benefits, displaying a willingness to sacrifice some profits for the larger economic good. They would be keen to set prices below the levels that maximise commercial profits. Importantly, in competitive markets where products are substitutes to some extent, such altruistic behaviour might lower the profits of all firms, not just the altruistic ones.
The nature of player interactions impacts innovation outcomes of the market in three ways. First, market structure is endogenously determined, with the likelihood of successful innovation and new entry dependent on how much each player invests in R&D. A duopoly emerges if both succeed and a monopoly if only one is successful. Second, while socially motivated pricing raises total economic welfare for any given market structure, it reduces both players’ incentives to invest in R&D. Third, this shift in incentives tilts outcomes towards market structures that are less conducive to aggregate economic welfare. Very high levels of social motivation can increase the likelihood of monopolization or even foregone innovations, resulting in welfare loss.
Recognizing that market structure and research intensities are jointly determined provides valuable insights into the effect of social motivation on aggregate welfare. From the perspective of maximizing total welfare a competitive duopoly is the most desirable outcome, outperforming a monopoly. However, if a monopoly does emerge, a monopoly with a socially motivated player generates greater welfare than one that is profit-focused. We also find that very high levels of social motivation can distort the market structure, tipping it towards a profit-focused monopoly or foregone innovations.
Specific policy interventions, such as innovation prizes or tax credits, can be calibrated to improve welfare. In practice, the implementation of these intervention is limited by information asymmetries and uncertainty, as detailed in Burstein and Murray (2016) and Mandel (2020). While a full-fledged mechanism design is beyond the scope of this paper, our model offers a first step in thinking about innovation support for socially motivated firms.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the face of unprecedented urbanisation in the Global South, a critical knowledge gap exists regarding the effectiveness of urban environmental policies on its dwindling biodiversity, climate resilience, and overall well-being. Bengaluru, India's “Garden City,” exemplifies this crisis. Its once-abundant green canopy is threatened by fragmented, top-down governance and a lack of meaningful data, exacerbating living conditions, especially for vulnerable sections.
In this context, the Karnataka Preservation of Trees Act (KPTA) of 1976 was enacted during a period of global environmental awakening following the 1972 Stockholm Conference. In spite of this, its contemporary relevance is questioned due to indiscriminate and large-scale felling of trees to make way for urbanisation. This research provides a critical evaluation of the KPTA’s efficacy, specifically within the metropolitan context of Bengaluru, where the green cover has plummeted from 68% in 1973 to less than 15% today. The study identifies a profound mismatch between the Act’s statutory intent to maintain ecological balance and the material outcomes of its implementation, which are characterised by a 20:1 asymmetry in ecological destruction versus replacement.
Through a Social-Ecological Systems (SES) framework and a PRISMA-guided systematic review, this study analyses the mechanisms of statutory dilution, most notably the 2014 and 2015 tree amendments, which offered substantial tree-felling exemptions and bypassed public consultation and Tree Officer oversight for developmental projects. The analysis further highlights the critical lacunae in the KPTA, such as the absence of neighbourhood-level canopy standards, the lack of local radius requirements for compensatory planting, and the failure to protect the disproportionate biomass and cultural value of heritage trees. More importantly, a bottom-up approach to governance would be explored, modelling for a policy that seeks civil society engagement and data collection through citizen science and views trees as vital urban commons.
To address these challenges, the study advocates for a locally grounded framework with decentralised oversight. Neighbourhood-level canopy standards overseen by local citizens would be prioritised for this. Furthermore, the study explores the transformative potential of granting legal personhood to trees, drawing on Indian judicial precedents in Haryana and Tamil Nadu that have recognised animals and “Mother Nature” as juristic entities, respectively. By transitioning from an anthropocentric, “utility-based” conservation model to a “rights-based” ecological jurisprudence, Karnataka can safeguard its urban forests as vital, interconnected systems rather than inconsequential spatial burdens. The study concludes that without these radical, locally informed reforms, the city faces a thermal trap and hydrological collapse as it approaches critical ecological tipping points. The lessons drawn from here could potentially inform other similar cities in the Global South.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Caste interacting with Labour – Public policy making in India
Abstract: One of the most defining characteristics of India’s society continues to be the institution of caste. This primordial institution influences almost all walks of life, way beyond the perceived confines of its seemingly societal concerns. The social system that flows from the hegemonic influence of caste system with its inbuilt structures of graded inequality negatively effects the very organisation of the life process in India. Thus also making its impact felt in the making of the public policy – from its conception to the execution. The reach and the hold of neoliberal capitalism notwithstanding, public policy in India is caught in the web of primordial and customary values which privileges a tiny section of social elites over its vast and marginalised populace. This paper proposes to analyse the caste situation vis-a-vis its impact over public policy making, chiefly in two parts. Firstly, we aim to underline the importance and the centrality of the functioning of caste as a system that shapes the very value and ethics of a society wherein the possibility of a rational policy making for the public good faces a structural impediment. Secondly, and more importantly, we aim to highlight the relationship of caste with the understanding of working of labour in India – which has a direct impact again on the working of the public sphere wherein the policy making is conceived.
This proposed paper maintains that India has a unique situation where the labour theory of value cannot be seen and understood in isolation from the social structure its embedded in. Therefore, the relations of production play a decisive role in affirming the ability of doing labour for each individual in India – which primarily get determined by one’s location in the caste society. Question of Labour and social status then are deeply intertwined due to the mechanisms of the caste society – a direct consequence of existing social norms which perpetuates disparities in employment along with the corresponding disparities in social attitude (Robb 1993).
Lastly, the work aims to take into account the values gained through the gradual unfolding of the European enlightenment, which actually went a long way in the making of a rational individual citizen as visualized by the transformative constitution of India. The undervalued and degraded perception of labour is partly the story of the unfinished project of Indian modernity/enlightenment whereby we don’t get to see a pan India anti-caste movement. We aim to bring together these background theoretical interpretation arguing for the possibility of an inclusive public sphere – an essential material binding for making inclusive policies designed for the public good.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Policy capacity has been established as a central concept in public policy and administration over the past decade. Not least, the integrated and nested framework developed by Wu et al. (2015) addressed the poor conceptualisation of capacity from the earlier literature and offered a more promising and feasible approach to examine policymaking functions and governance effectiveness. Although the focus of this literature is still largely on the Global North (Cameron and Evans 2024), recent research has paid increasing attention to various issues pertaining to policy capacity in the under-investigated contexts of developing countries, including India (Yan et al. forthcoming).
The aim of this paper is to first take a comprehensive stock of this emerging literature on policy capacity in India. This review will be guided by the following questions: How has the original policy capacity framework been used when examining the specific context of India? How has that advanced our understanding of the stock, deficits and development of the competences and capabilities in performing key policy functions in India across different public sectors and governance levels? How has the empirical scrutiny of the Indian context contributed to the development of the policy capacity scholarship?
This review builds a foundation for us to further assess the overall contributions as well as limitations of the literature to date. The objective is to propose an agenda for future research to help close the remaining gaps identified and, ultimately, improve policy capacity in India in both research and practice.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Launched in 2015, Delhi’s Mohalla Clinics represent a prominent attempt to reimagine urban primary healthcare delivery in India through decentralised, neighbourhood-based service provision. Designed to offer free consultations, essential medicines, and basic diagnostic services, the programme sought to reduce financial and spatial barriers to care for underserved urban populations. Often cited as an innovative policy intervention, Mohalla Clinics have also been implicitly assessed against international “best practice” frameworks for primary healthcare delivery. This paper argues that such assessments risk overlooking the institutional, social, and governance contexts that fundamentally shape how policies unfold in India.
Using the Theory of Change framework as an analytical lens rather than an evaluative benchmark, the paper examines the design, evolution, and implementation of the Mohalla Clinic programme from its inception through early 2025. Drawing on administrative records, secondary datasets, policy documents, and published studies, the analysis traces temporal trends in programme expansion, utilisation, and service delivery, and examines how core policy assumptions interacted with on-the-ground institutional realities. By early 2025, the programme had expanded rapidly to approximately 546 clinics across all 70 assembly constituencies of Delhi, reflecting strong political commitment and administrative scale-up. Utilisation was initially high, with clinics attracting large numbers of patients, particularly women and economically disadvantaged groups, suggesting progress toward improved equity in access.
At the same time, the paper highlights important gaps between policy design and implementation. The service model remained narrowly focused on episodic and acute care, with limited integration of preventive services, chronic disease management, or broader public health outreach. Several assumptions embedded within the programme’s theory of change, such as sustained public awareness, uninterrupted medicine supply, and stable administrative capacity, proved fragile over time. Declining utilisation following widespread drug stockouts illustrates how implementation bottlenecks, rather than policy intent, shaped outcomes. Moreover, while the clinics altered care-seeking behaviour for minor ailments, there is limited evidence that the programme, in its current form, can deliver longer-term health outcomes without deeper institutional integration.
The paper argues that while Theory of Change frameworks are useful for structuring policy narratives, they are insufficient on their own to capture the complexities of policymaking in India, including uneven state capacity, informal health-seeking practices, and evolving governance arrangements. Evaluating policies like Mohalla Clinics through standard international templates risks misdiagnosing both success and failure. Instead, the paper calls for policy analysis grounded in India’s specific institutional conditions, where adaptive implementation, governance capability, and political economy considerations are central. The Mohalla Clinic experience offers broader lessons for rethinking urban social policy in India, not as a replication of global models, but as an evolving institutional experiment shaped by local realities.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The expansion of oil and gas-based industries in the Tinsukia district of Assam has led to land dispossession and the shrinking of landholdings of the local farming and fishing communities. The gas blowout in Baghjan in May 2020 resulted in an ecological disaster. Studies by the Wildlife Institute of India and the Justice BP Katakey Committee interim report to the National Green Tribunal found the discharge of a large amount of oil and carcinogenic pollutants into the environment. The release of toxins, Carcinogenic Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon (PAH) pollutants into the ecosystem has implied health risk to the local population, flora, and fauna (NGT 2020). Using the Sustainable Livelihoods Framework and Human-Centred Environmental Security, this study used an ethnographic approach to understand the implications of the gas blowout. It examined the negotiations of the affected community, non-state actors with Oil India Limited (OIL) officials, street-level bureaucrats, and the judiciary following the gas blowout. The paper focuses on the bargaining process of non-state actors contesting institutional responses, demanding adequate compensation, and the restoration of the environment. It also examines the pivotal role played by street-level bureaucrats during and after the blowout.
In-depth interviews were conducted with the Civil Society Organizations, OIL officials, and government representatives. The findings highlight the layered vulnerabilities of the local population and argue that the blowout has heightened environmental and livelihood insecurities in Baghjan. The study finds that non-state actors played a pivotal role in shaping and reshaping claims after the disaster through protests, demonstrations, memorandums, and petitions. They have organized the local communities, constantly negotiated with the street-level bureaucrats and OIL during the blowout, and collectively bargained for adequate compensation and environmental restoration.
Street-level bureaucrats have played a proactive role in understanding the damage after the blowout, given their proximity to the local community. Their everyday administrative discretion and constant interaction with pressure groups, OIL, and the judiciary have influenced the whole compensation process. After the gas leak, not only did the consequences of the oil spill become prominent, with massive environmental destruction, but it also put pressure on civil society groups to engage and negotiate with the state and OIL to improve the implementation of policies related to environmental security and ecological restoration, focusing on land justice. As contestations concerning compensation continue, ecological restoration is fragmented, and environmental security remains uncertain. The paper concludes that top-down approaches to public policy centered on procedural compliance have not adequately addressed the specificities of the Indian public policy process, including land justice, ecological dependence, climate vulnerability, and differentiated marginalization.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
For last two decades voices of post-colonial theorist have come together to challenge the dominant western theories. With public policy as a discipline emerging in the context of changing governance structure it all the more becomes important to have an Indian public policy lens to understanding today’s Indian public policy paradigm. For this the colonial rule interaction with Indian society and its indigenous response can lay down the foundation of Indian public policy. This paper shall try to understand state- economic interaction in thoughts of select political thinkers who paved the way for nature of policy making in post-Independent India. It shall study the history of ideas of these thinkers and reflect upon convergences and divergences of their though that paved the way for public policy in India. The thinkers at that time were constantly engaging with English dominated universal ideas and its India specific needs. The present nature of public policy is therefore seen to oscillate between ‘driven’-‘limited’ role of state which is expected by all stake holders.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since the 1950s, India has undertaken one of the most extensive state-led policy transformations in the Global South. Through the Green Revolution and sustained public investment, the country achieved a structural transformation of its agricultural sector and attained national-level cereals self-sufficiency. However, these gains have not been accompanied by significant improvements in food and nutrition outcomes at the household level. Progress in nutritional indicators has been considerably slower, and undernutrition and inadequate dietary quality continue to persist across regions and social groups. In this context, this paper argues that such divergence cannot be adequately explained by policy implementation or by gaps in evidence. Instead, it reflects a deeper public policy challenge shaped by limited institutional learning processes, priority-setting, and the path-dependent consolidation of policy choices over a period of time.
Drawing on a historical analysis of India’s Five-Year Plans and major agriculture, food, and nutrition policy interventions, the paper addresses two interrelated questions. First, how and why did agricultural and nutrition policies evolve along sharply divergent institutional trajectories after the 1950s? The analysis demonstrates that agricultural policy was developed through cumulative and incremental learning, driven by concerns over food scarcity, political legitimacy, and clearly centred around productivity-oriented performance metrics. In contrast, nutrition policy followed a distinct trajectory. This remains institutionally fragmented, predominantly considered as a health or welfare concern, and weakly converged within agricultural policies. This divergence was neither accidental nor the result of policy neglect; instead, it emerged from the consolidation of separate policy subsystems characterised by differing core beliefs, policy instruments, and criteria of success.
The second question examines what a policy-oriented learning perspective reveals about the limits of this policy change in the context of agricultural-nutrition divergence. Viewed through this lens, learning within agricultural policy largely reinforced dominant core beliefs and most notably cereal-centric production, procurement mechanisms, and price stabilisation. This results in incremental yet deeply entrenched change. In contrast, despite repeated recognition of malnutrition and the various forms of evidence, nutrition policy shows predominantly instrument-level adjustments. And, with limited realignment of core policy beliefs or institutional incentives. External factors such as global markets, technological change, and changing development discourse shaped these trajectories selectively, primarily reinforcing existing domestic priorities rather than inducing substantive structural transformation.
Using the institutional and policy-learning framework, this paper contributes to debates on Indian public policy that move beyond imported policy templates and the limitations of transferred evidence-based approaches. It demonstrates that persistent policy incoherence is best understood as the outcome of asymmetric learning and institutional path dependence. Without addressing these underlying dynamics and core policy beliefs, efforts to promote coordination, evidence-based reform, or policy coherence are unlikely to generate transformative change.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
By: Dr. Mohit Kumar Gupta
Assistant Professor, Public Policy and Governance
TISS Hyderabad
Abstract: Dominant policy frameworks for understanding the governance of the corporate sector—heavily influenced by neoclassical economic theories and Anglo-American models from the Global North—treat the discrete, standalone “firm” as the primary unit of analysis and regulation. However, this dominant firm-centric approach, situated in concepts such as market failure, separation of ownership and control, and shareholder primacy, does not serve as a useful yardstick for understanding the governance and operations of the private corporate sector in countries of the Global South such as India. This is because India’s private corporate sector has historically been dominated by family-owned and family-controlled business groups and continues to be so. These multi-entity conglomerates extend beyond the conventional notion of the firm and are coordinated under familial authority through complex inter-corporate investments.
Moreover, policies derived from the standalone firm model fail to account for institutional forms prevalent in the Indian context, such as promoter group holdings, Hindu Undivided Families (HUFs), trusts, Limited Liability Partnerships (LLPs), and other hybrid organizational forms. The distinguishing policy implication of the coordination of these institutional forms within the private corporate sector is that it allows business groups to exhibit high degrees of effective control despite dispersed ownership, enables capital accumulation, facilitates diversification into state-regulated sectors with natural monopoly characteristics (e.g., ports, telecom, and energy), supports debt-financed expansion via finance capital, and provides mechanisms for tax planning—features that transcend the atomistic firm model.
This paper argues that adherence to imported “best practices” has produced policy weaknesses by ignoring India’s historical trajectory, plural social fabric, and institutional specificities. Post-liberalization regulatory shifts—such as the repeal of the MRTP Act (1969), which uniquely treated interconnected business groups as analytical units, and the move toward self-regulation under the Companies Act, 2013, and SEBI norms—have compartmentalized oversight to discrete entities and transactions. This has created regulatory lacunae and avenues for governance failures (e.g., lack of clarity on corporate governance issues such as pledging, related-party transactions, and offshore linkages), as evidenced by case studies of selected business groups examined in this study.
The trajectories of these groups reveal continuities in family control alongside spatial and temporal mobility in institutional configurations, countering Global North theories that frame business groups merely as “gap-fillers” for institutional voids in emerging markets. Even the existing scholarship on corporate governance policy in India falls short of providing a succinct analysis due to its ahistorical approach and a priori generalizations. Grounded in detailed publicly available evidence—including financial statements, shareholding patterns, and regulatory filings—the analysis calls for an India-centric institutional framework for corporate governance policy. This entails recognizing “business groups” as the appropriate unit of analysis for corporate governance codes and taxation. Shifting from firm-centric templates toward evidence-based, contextually aligned regulation would enhance coherence, equity, and state capacity in India’s public policy praxis, while offering broader lessons for the Global South
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
During the British Raj, forests and forest resources were crucial to economic growth and the expansion of the colonial state. However, access to forests was made illegal for forest-dwelling communities through the legal framework. The legal framework for forest access has been shaped by forest policies and instruments enacted over the past hundred years during colonial and postcolonial India. The forest governance's legal framework framed a forest dweller as a criminal during the colonial period. Eventually, it did not allow access to the forest rights. The evolution of forest governance in India is shaped by the complex system of forest policies, instruments, and sectoral policies that have evolved in response to the social and ecological dynamics of forests. Sectoral policies are considered in the context of biodiversity, environmental law, wildlife, deforestation, participatory governance, land rehabilitation and resettlement, and climate change. This paper examines the evolution of forest governance discourse, which has affected the access to forest rights and played a crucial role in the formalisation and institutionalisation of forest management. The formalisation of forest governance resulted in a web of forest and sectoral policies during the colonial and postcolonial periods. The study uses a policy document analysis method to examine the colonial and postcolonial forest policies. In addition, thematic analysis of secondary literature was used to categorise the literature. This paper identifies the evolution of forest governance legal framework as an interaction of policy mixes – a combination of policy instruments, resulting in fragmented and incoherent governance design. Using this design framework, this paper introduces a five-layer analytical model that identifies how policy persists despite changes in the governance paradigm. The paper develops a policy design-mix framework that categorised forest governance instruments into five categories: (1) Authority instruments (e.g., forest department, scientific forestry, punitive action, classification of forests); (2) Conservation instruments (e.g., protected areas, clearance and diversion procedures); (3) Participatory instruments (e.g., gram sabhas, Joint-forest management committee); (4) Rights-based instruments (e.g., Forest Rights Committee, Community Forest Rights Management Committee, Sub-Divisional Lelvel Committee, and District level Committee– FRA tool mix); (5) Market-based instruments (transit rules for minor forest produce). In India’s forest governance, the layering of post-independence instruments over colonial authoritarian tools has shaped the current policy mix, leading to overlapping instruments and incoherence in the design of forest governance. This kind of policy packaging of design elements has created path dependency, which was instrumental in establishing a monopoly over forest products, all wastelands and timberlands in colonial India. It was due to design incoherence in India’s forest governance and policy instruments overlapping, causing fragmentation, bureaucratic dominance, and implementation bottlenecks for rights-based instruments such as the Forest Rights Act, 2006.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In this paper, I attempt to understand the Civil Society Coalitions (CSCs) coalitions to influence the FRA implementation processes at the village and block levels. Since recognising Community Forest Rights (CFRs) in the Vidarbha region of Maharashtra, the socioeconomic benefits to forest-dwelling communities have increased profoundly. So, it is worth examining the policy processes and factors that contributed to the post-Community Forest Rights (post-CFR) implementation processes and their impact on the socioeconomic conditions of the forest community in the Vidarbha region. This paper attempts to understand the formation of civil society-led coalitions in the context of post-CFR policy processes in the Vidarbha region of Maharashtra, India. CFR recognised under India’s 2006 Forest Rights Act transfers community rights and responsibilities to forest-dwelling communities for sustainable use of their customary forests. It examines the emergence of a de-facto collective institution, such as the gram sabha federation of forest dwellers, which came into existence after the recognition of CFRs in the Vidarbha region. In addition, it intends to examine how post-CFR policy processes have led to the formation of Gram Sabha MahaSangh (GSMS) Federation Kurkheda-Wadsa – enabling the democratic management of forest resource such as tendu leaves – in Gadchiroli district of Maharashtra. It argues that advocacy coalition politics in the context of tendu has encouraged community forest management, biodiversity conservation, livelihoods, and local self-determination at the village level. It presents a story of the counter-narrative of underlying colonial continuities, entrenched power asymmetries, and persisting inequalities in forest governance discourse in India. Furthermore, I will explain how Gram Sabhas took the lead in grounding collective action at the block level after the recognition of CFR. The collective action resulted from embedded deep core beliefs in forest communities about the conservation of biodiversity, sustainable practices, and forest management, inspired by self-reliance and self-determination. Community forest rights coalitions and economic development coalitions supported this collective action process. The collective action is anchored in the community forest rights coalition and is congruent with the economic coalition. Both coalitions play a profound role in framing and making collective action.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Air pollution remains one of the most pressing environmental and public health challenges in the developing world. India and China are home to some of the world’s most polluted cities, driven by rapid industrialization, urbanization, energy consumption patterns, and demographic pressures. This paper conducts a comparative analysis of the severity of air pollution in India and China, the policy responses adopted by their governments, the outcomes of these interventions, and key lessons India can extract from China’s multi-decadal efforts to curb air pollution. The study aims to contribute to policy discourse in environmental governance by identifying pathways that enhance air quality while balancing economic development.
India’s air pollution crisis is characterized by persistently high concentrations of fine particulate matter (PM₂.₅) in major urban centres such as Delhi, Kolkata, Varanasi, Kanpur and more. These concentrations often exceed World Health Organization (WHO) guidelines by over tenfold, contributing to elevated respiratory and cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. Sources of pollution in India are diverse, including coal-fired power plants, vehicular emissions, construction dust, agricultural residue burning, and unregulated industrial emissions. Seasonal phenomena, particularly wintertime temperature inversions and crop burning in the Indo-Gangetic Plains, exacerbate air quality deterioration.
China, while historically facing similar challenges during its rapid industrialization phase, documented peak pollution levels in the early 2010s that surpassed those in India by some indicators. In response, the Chinese government launched the “Air Pollution Prevention and Control Action Plan” (2013–2017) and subsequent “Three-Year Action Plan for Winning the Blue Sky Defense Battle” (2018–2020). These comprehensive policy frameworks included stringent emissions standards for industry, systematic closure of coal plants in urban regions, expansion of renewable energy, traffic control measures, and extensive monitoring networks. The emphasis on enforcement, coupled with measurable targets and cross-sectoral coordination, led to significant declines in average PM₂.₅ levels in major cities such as Beijing and Shanghai.
This paper will systematically compare the policy frameworks in both countries through a mixed-methods approach, using literature survey, data collection from government sources and policy documents, alongside interviews with key stakeholders. Preliminary analysis suggests that China’s experience underscores the importance of legally binding standards, sustained financing for clean technology adoption, real-time data transparency, and stringent enforcement mechanisms. The study concludes by outlining actionable lessons for India to strengthen its air quality governance while accelerating improvements in public health and environmental sustainability.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper examines the cumulative impact of state-led hydropower development and climate
change on community managed irrigation systems, with a focus on the kuhls of Kangra in
Himachal Pradesh. The study investigates how large-scale hydroelectric projects and
shifting climatic patterns reconfigure water access, land use, and agrarian livelihoods in
fragile mountain ecosystems It argues that while kuhls have historically functioned as
resilient socio-ecological institutions embedded in customary land and water relations, their
viability is increasingly undermined by upstream river diversions, altered hydrological
regimes, and climate induced variability. These pressures are not merely environmental, they
are also political, as state-led infrastructural expansion reorders control over water in ways
that marginalize community governance systems.
Kuhls are gravity fed irrigation channels that draw water from snow and rainfed streams,
distributing it across terraced fields through rotational norms enforced by locally recognized
functionaries. Their sustainability depends on predictable seasonal flows, stable catchments,
and collective maintenance. However, the rapid expansion of hydropower projects in Kangra
has introduced structural changes to river systems in multiple ways .Reduced downstream
flows, erratic release schedules, and sediment disruption have directly affected the intake
points of many kuhls. In several cases, traditional diversion structures have either dried up or
require costly modifications. State compensation and rehabilitation measures, where
provided, tend to treat irrigation as a technical asset rather than as a community institution,
thereby weakening customary authority and collective labour arrangements.
The above mentioned challenges are further compounded due to climate change. Field
evidence indicates shifts in precipitation patterns, with shorter, more intense rainfall events
and declining winter snowfall in higher catchments. Increased frequency of extreme rainfall
events has led to flash floods that tend to damage channel embankments and intake
structures, raising maintenance burdens. This combined effect of hydropower induced
alteration and climate variability have created a regime of uncertainty that traditional
rotational systems are now struggling to absorb.
Methodologically, the study has adopts a political ecology approach that links infrastructural
expansion and climatic processes to local institutional change. It is based on indepth
fieldwork in select villages across upper and lower Kangra , which included interviews with
irrigators, kuhl committee members, and irrigation department officials, as well as focus
group discussions organized by landholding size and gender.
The paper argues that community-managed irrigation systems in Kangra are not relics of a
pre-modern past but adaptive institutions whose resilience is contingent upon ecological
stability and secure access to flowing water. State-led hydropower development, combined
with climate change, has progressively reconfigured this access, shifting control upstream
and exposing kuhls to hydrological precarity. Finally the paper argues that rethinking
sustainability in the Himalaya requires strengthening community tenure over water and land,
recognizing customary irrigation institutions as legitimate governance actors, and designing
policy frameworks that integrate ecological limits with social equity.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Policymaking in India is characterized by formal inclusion and substantive hierarchy. State, industry, and civil society actors interact frequently, yet the basis of coordination in such settings remains unclear. This chapter examines how belief structures and network configurations shape coordination in India’s energy sector and what this reveals about the organization of policymaking more broadly.
The analysis asks how actors’ beliefs about coal, their perceptions of others’ views, and their positions within the policy network influence interaction and influence. It draws on a social network analysis of actors involved in national debates on the coal phase-out. The network includes central and state government agencies, public and private firms, industry associations, research organizations, and non-governmental groups. Measures of centrality, density, and modularity capture network structure, while survey data identify actors’ own beliefs and their perceptions of others’ beliefs regarding coal.
The results show a single, highly connected network dominated by central government agencies and large industrial actors. Civil society organizations occupy peripheral positions. The network is dense but weakly modular, suggesting limited clustering by belief or actor type. Most actors express neutral positions on coal, and many misperceive others’ views—particularly overestimating pro-coal sentiment. The pattern points to limited belief differentiation and incomplete information among participants.
Interpreted through the lens of the Advocacy Coalition Framework, which expects stable and observable belief systems as the basis of coalition formation, these findings present three deviations. Belief ambiguity refers to weakly structured or unstable beliefs that prevent ideological alignment. Belief opacity denotes limited visibility and systematic misperception of others’ beliefs, which obstructs recognition of allies and opponents. Belief inconsequentiality captures the weak link between belief and coordination, implying that relational dependence and hierarchical access—not ideology—shape network interaction.
These findings are broadly consistent with policy network theory’s emphasis on interdependence and asymmetric centrality, but they qualify a key assumption: network density does not guarantee information exchange or learning. The Indian energy policy network is structurally integrated yet cognitively fragmented. Coordination arises from positional dependence rather than shared understanding.
The chapter concludes that India’s energy policy network exemplifies a form of dense but opaque governance, in which policy stability results from hierarchy, access, and resource dependence rather than belief-based coalitioning. The analysis also identifies a direction for further research: examining how resource dependence, information exchange, and trust evolve over time within such networks. Future work applying policy network theory longitudinally could clarify how interdependence and epistemic constraints jointly sustain coordination and stability in state-dominated policy systems.”
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Several bottom-up scholars have emphasised and prescribed the importance of factoring in the local context when assessing policy design and implementation. As articulated by Jann and Wegrich (2006), “a central feature of the policy process in modern societies is the interaction between policy-related activities at different levels and arenas of governance. The local context or level is often spoken of in relation to local bureaucrats (Lipsky, 1971, 1980), agencies (Elmore, 1980), politicians, and actors. However, just as Ferguson (1994) highlights, the Thaba-Tseka Project in Lesotho was intended to increase agricultural productivity, but the institutions that were implementing the project tended to generalise development metrics to fit various local contexts and districts into the “standard development package” for Africa.[1] In this case, there was a homogenisation of the ‘local’ that failed to factor in history, socio-political conditions and contexts. The Indian agricultural context further adds to this heterogeneity as there are nuances of caste, class, gender, organic vs. chemical farming, education level, and cropping patterns as well. Using the case study of two farmers (one large/upper caste/male/educated/organic and one small, non-upper caste/female/uneducated/traditional), the chapter narrows in on how they navigate the process of accessing one policy - PMKSY’s micro-irrigation scheme - and their differing adoption methods and responses to the scheme. This chapter underscores the importance of considering the diversity and heterogeneity of farmers within the ‘local context’ when designing agrarian policies, especially in the Indian context.
[1] Ferguson, J. (1990). The anti-politics machine: "development," depoliticization, and bureaucratic power in Lesotho. Cambridge University Press.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This chapter will critically examine how public policy education contributes to building policy capacity – the “skills, resources, and capabilities necessary to perform policy functions” (Wu et al., 2015) – in India, and how this capacity shapes policy design in the country’s distinct institutional context. While public policy education is broadly recognized as vital for fostering effective governance, scholarly inquiry into its role in strengthening policy capacity remains strikingly limited, particularly in the Global South (Denny & Zittoun, 2024). Although a handful of studies (e.g., El-Taliawi et al., 2021; Nair et al., 2024) have begun exploring public policy education in non-Western settings, systematic analyses of how curricula, pedagogies, and institutional adaptations respond to Asia’s, and especially India’s unique governance challenges remain sparse. This chapter addresses this gap by interrogating the interplay between policy education, capacity development, and context-sensitive policy design in India.
India’s significance as a focal point for public policy education stems from its rapid economic growth, diverse governance regimes, and escalating demand for skilled policy practitioners. Yet the region’s educational institutions operate within complex political landscapes, hybrid administrative traditions, and labor markets shaped by competing pressures for global standardization and local relevance. This raises two interconnected questions:
First, how do public policy programs in India cultivate the specific competencies required for effective policy work? While the link between education and capacity-building is widely acknowledged, the mechanisms through which curricula and pedagogies target distinct dimensions of policy capacity – analytical, operational, or political skills (Wu et al., 2015) – remain undertheorized. For instance, do programs prioritize technical expertise over political negotiation skills, or vice versa? By mapping these connections, this chapter aims to inform strategies for aligning education with the region’s most pressing capacity deficits.
Second, how do India’s public policy programs adapt to their local institutional, political, and socioeconomic contexts? Existing research suggests a nuanced reality: while a residual “pro-Western bias” persists in pedagogy and curriculum design (Mukherjee & Maurya, 2023), Asian institutions rarely replicate Western models wholesale (Pal & Clark, 2016a, 2016b). For example, El-Taliawi et al. (2021) find that emerging policy schools in the Global South often blend global best practices with localized innovations, such as case studies reflecting regional governance challenges or partnerships with domestic bureaucracies.
By interrogating these questions, this chapter presents empirical findings on public policy student experiences to bridges critical gaps in understanding how pedagogical approaches in public policy education in India both inform – and are shaped by – the demands of policy design in India’s distinct governance contexts.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The exercise of matching policy goals and means is the central essence of the activities linked with policy design in the policy process. While by no means a neutral or ‘objective’ or technical process, policy design embodies the conscious effort to articulate policy aims and devise combinations of policy solutions to address them. Policy design is thus, ia deeply political activity thoroughly immersed and grounded in questions about “who gets what, when and how” in society (Lasswell, 1936).
A key feature in designing policies under future policy uncertainty, a key characteristic of the Indian agricultural sector, is that of being adaptive- i.e. policies that are designed to adapt to a host of anticipated conditions in future, trigger policy adjustments to maintain policy performance or potentially terminate policy when it ceases to be relevant. Adaptive policies are also designed to accommodate unforeseen changes in the policy context for which the policy was not originally designed but in ways that support the intended policy goals, recognize emerging issues that will need to be addressed and trigger further analysis and deliberation for policy adjustments (Swanson and Bhadwal, 2009). A key tenet of adaptive policies is that of policy experimentation or designing policy initiatives as experiments for addressing policy uncertainty and complexity (Rondinelli, 1993).
In such scenarios, experiments have long served as a source of evidence for policy-making in several sectors such as including education, healthcare, environment and social welfare (Bennion, 2011) and as tools for generating new knowledge for research and practice (Cloutier et al., 2015), (Seyfang and Smith, 2007), (Hoffmann, 2011). Experiments could be leveraged by central and state governments as a low-risk policy tool to provide information on the expected performance of a proposed policy change ahead of its full implementation (Tassey, 2013). Experimentation can also be a mode of exploring a range of alternatives as policy solutions to increase the chances of achieving effective outcomes under uncertain policy circumstances (Swanson and Bhadwal, 2009). This chapter will focus on anticipatory policy design and risk management focusing on examples from Indian agriculture. The discussion will focus on leveraging policy experimentation and piloting to address risks and uncertainties in the long-term.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Public policy has conventionally been understood as a technical instrument of governance aimed at solving social problems through rational decision-making and institutional design. Most of the policy science models, however, tend to treat policies as neutral tools and primarily evaluate them in terms of efficiency, implementation, and outcomes. This paper argues that such a framework is not sufficient for understanding public policy in postcolonial contexts like India. It advances the claim that public policy in India has been operating not merely as a mode of governance, but as a cultural–political project through which the state seeks to produce legitimacy, authority, and social order.
Taking from Indian political thought, particularly the works of Ashis Nandy, Partha Chatterjee, and Rajni Kothari, the paper reconceptualizes public policy as a form of political rule that engages populations not only administratively but symbolically and morally. It shows how policy functions as a site where competing narratives of development, democracy, justice, and national purpose are negotiated, imposed, and contested. Through an analysis of the evolution of Indian policymaking from centralized planning and technocratic governance to participatory reforms and contemporary institutional transformations, the paper establishes that policies derive their effectiveness not only from institutional capacity but from their ability to generate cultural legitimacy.
By foregrounding the cultural and moral dimensions of policymaking, this paper challenges the universalist assumptions of policy science and seeks to propose an alternative conceptualization of public policy as a legitimacy-producing practice embedded in specific historical, social, and political contexts. It concludes by suggesting that understanding policy as cultural–political legitimacy provides a more adequate framework for analyzing both the possibilities and limits of democratic governance in India.
Keywords
Public Policy; Political Legitimacy; Indian Political Thought; Governance; Cultural Politics; Democracy; State and Society; Postcolonial Theory
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Background: Indian agrarian policy has largely been shaped by linear, top-down approaches that abstract farmers into a homogenous category, reinforcing structural constraints that exacerbate agrarian distress, crop failures, weak income discovery, intensive fertiliser use, and rising household indebtedness. Understanding how these constraints shape farmer agency is essential for designing public policy responsive to India’s complex agrarian realities. A bottom-up approach, which enables farmer-led decision-making, is crucial for reframing public policy and facilitating transitions toward sustainable and context-responsive farming practices.
Research Methodology: This paper examines how structural constraints shape farmer agency in fertiliser use, and what does this imply for policy design in India? The study draws on qualitative fieldwork across nine districts in seven states, covering diverse agro-ecological contexts. Data were gathered through 16 mini-group discussions (1 with women) and 40 in-depth interviews (13 with women). The sample captures variation in landholding size, tenancy status, gender, caste, and farming practices, including natural farming. A thematic analysis is being conducted to examine fertiliser decision-making as an entry point into broader questions of agency, risk and institutional design. Policy documents were also reviewed to examine how farmers are represented, providing context to observed decision-making patterns.
Key Findings: Field observations indicate that fertiliser use is shaped by structural and institutional conditions rather than individual preference alone. Dependence on synthetic fertilisers arises from yield pressures, market-driven quality standards, and agro-ecological constraints. These factors define crop choices, which in turn shape fertiliser practises. Farmers reflect an awareness of potential soil and health impacts, yet decision-making is limited, especially among households near subsistence margins. Synthetic fertilisers are often perceived as a form of risk mitigation: while they may not guarantee a quantum of profits, not using them can increase the likelihood of crop loss, with unequal consequences across farmer profiles. Awareness and use of “organic” fertilisers are constrained by labour-intensive preparation, declining livestock ownership, insecure tenancy, limited state support, and uncertain market access. Many farmers equate organic inputs primarily with cow dung, reflecting uneven knowledge of organic practices. Natural farmers face additional challenges, including access to inputs, extension services, certification, and assured pricing.
Contribution: Early observations suggest that focusing solely on organic farming or natural fertiliser adoption, without complementary input access, extension support, and market assurances, may limit farmers’ ability to change practices in contexts of structural constraint. Effective policy support requires both back-end measures, such as input availability and extension services, and front-end measures, including assured markets and price incentives. Fertiliser decisions reflect institutional arrangements, market structures, and livelihood imperatives, highlighting the systemic nature of farmer agency. Narrative analysis of policy documents reveals that policy assumptions frequently portray farmers as passive beneficiaries, highlighting opportunities to align interventions and representations more closely with field realities. These findings suggest that policy interventions that account for structural conditions and institutional contexts, and that are grounded in detailed evidence of farmers’ lived experience, are more likely to support sustainable and context-specific transitions in Indian agriculture.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Over the last three decades, policy making for health and healthcare in India has systematically moved away from health being a fundamental human right as articulated in the Alma Ata Declaration (1978) to a multi-billion dollar market commodity, with citizens being reduced to consumers paying for private profits.
While the former centre- staged health promotion /disease prevention as the bedrock of public health, largely focused on the social determinants of health such as nutrition, sanitation, potable drinking water among others, we have now been reduced to a situation where substantial democratic space has been ceded and tax payers’ resources routed overtly and covertly to private entities, with simultaneous breakdown of the public health system. This Chapter will cover this trajectory of policy- making in health care with a focus on nutrition, a key social determinant of health.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Public Policy cannot be evaluated without assessing its normative goals and asking what are the values it seeks to promote. Divorcing the study of policy from this intrinsic characteristic not only reduces the relevance of policy research but also contributes to the ruptures we are currently witnessing between government actions around the world taken for granted democratic values. Acknowledging the infancy of the discipline of Public Policy in India and the need to build its foundations, the Chapter will discuss the possibilities of using ideas from action research to study policy implementation from the bottom-up in India from both a pragmatic and normative perspective. In doing so, it will also engage with an alternate formulation of “evidence-based” policy making that could contribute to democratic deepening.
From a pragmatic perspective, the limited capacity and resources available for public policy make it essential that researchers studying policy “get their hands dirty” in understanding policy implementation especially those targeted at socially disadvantaged groups. As Schneider and Ingram argue, the design of policies targeted at these groups are likely to be characterized by high on rhetoric while being low on actual reallocation and distribution of resources. A characteristic that often leads policy to begin with very visible announcements and ambitious targets only to fade away with other competing announcements. Those at the bottom of the administrative hierarchy are blamed for “implementation failures”, without a serious investigation of what led to them. In such a context, adopting a bottom-up perspective also enables the voicing of critical but often ignored experiences in the implementation process.
Normatively, even as the ideas of action research promote a democratic ethos they serve to draw attention to the technical –”nuts and bolts” – aspects of policy implementation. The emphasis on participation and working closely with communities ensures that researchers remain grounded in the social realities of the populations they seek to speak on behalf of. Further as the discipline of public policy seeks to develop its legitimacy, conducting research with communities around them also helps research and academic institutions become more meaningful to the larger population rather than being seen as engaged in exclusive conversations with the elite.
While acknowledging the challenges and limitations of studying policy implementation bottom-up using ideas inspired by action research, the chapter will discuss arenas and spaces for intellectual creativity seeking to address them.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper investigates how Indian public policy produces and legitimises environmental inequalities through a graded model of entitlements in water, housing space, and energy supply. While scholarship on environmental justice in India has documented disparities in access and ownership, less attention has been paid to how the state codifies differentiated standards of provision, thereby embedding inequality as a matter of agenda setting, policymaking and institutional design.
The first arena examined is water and sanitation policy. Official planning norms established by the Central Public Health and Environmental Engineering Organisation (CPHEEO), Government of India allocate 150 litres per capita per day (lpcd) in metropolitan areas and 135 lpcd in cities with sewerage networks, but only 70 lpcd where sewerage is absent. Where public standposts serve as the delivery mechanism - common in slums and resettlement colonies - the allocation drops to 40 lpcd. These reduced entitlements are not the outcome of scarcity alone but reflect explicit policy choices. Empirical evidence from Delhi demonstrates that actual supply in informal settlements often falls below even these thresholds, with households surviving on as little as 4–10 lpcd, in stark contrast to middle-class colonies with near-continuous access. Such differentiation makes inequality in water access not accidental but designed into state policy frameworks.
The second arena is energy supply. India has achieved near-universal household electrification, yet major disparities persist in capacity, reliability, and usage. National surveys report an average of 22 hours of supply in urban areas and 20 hours in rural areas, but the poorest neighbourhoods within cities endure more frequent and longer outages. Per-capita electricity consumption, at about 1,395 kWh in 2023–24, hides deep class, caste and urban–rural divides in appliance ownership and usage. Policy discourse further reinforces stratification by often promoting mini-grids, micro-grids, and biomass as ‘appropriate technologies’ for rural and low-income areas, while 24×7 grid electricity is reserved for urban middle-class users.
The third arena is land and housing. Resettlement policies in Delhi grant evictees plots as small as 12.5–25 square metres, compared to 60–200 square metres or more in middle-income housing societies and government colonies. Official master plans explicitly sanction such differentiated allocations: the minimum plot for resettlement can be reduced to 18 square metres, while middle-income plotted housing frequently begins at 100–300 square metres. This sharp contrast institutionalises spatial inequality in environmental entitlements, with smaller plots exacerbating overcrowding, limiting infrastructure, reducing green space, and often relocating poor households to peripheral areas with weaker connectivity and higher costs of access to livelihood.
Taken together, these cases demonstrate that environmental inequalities in India are not only outcomes of socio-economic hierarchy or governance failure but are embedded in the architecture of public policy. By differentiating minimum standards of access across class, caste and settlement categories, the state actively produces a graded system of environmental citizenship. This paper argues for reframing policy debates around equitable- not just “equal” - and rights-based entitlements in water, energy, and housing space, rather than perpetuating graded service models.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Policy theorization has traditionally been dominated by macro and centralized perspectives, largely imported from Western and colonial institutions. Up until the 1980s, public policy was primarily influenced by a statist viewpoint. Diana Stone aptly observed, “Public policy has been a prisoner of the word “state’” (2008). Policy processes were seen as arising from an elite group of government experts within specialized institutions such as planning agencies, other executive bodies, as well as legislative and judicial systems. Social learning in policymaking was also confined to a closed circle of economists and bureaucrats, given that these tasks are highly technical and demand elite skills (Hall, 1993). In contrast to this statist approach, a growing democratic perspective in India challenges the autonomy of the state and the elite’s conceptualization of national interest. It recognizes demands that emerge from democratic contestation by political parties, interest groups, and evolving social needs. A large, democratic country like India faces policy challenges and processes unmatched anywhere else. These are typical challenges for developing countries: eradicating poverty, creating opportunities for growth, and restoring environmental health. India also has a rich history, a strong democratic system, and maintained robust institutions for nearly all of its eight decades of independence. These qualities provide ample material for analyzing public policies (Mathur and Mathur, 2007; Ganapathy et al, 1985). The chapter examines developments since the 1980s to argue that democratic processes at the federal, state, and local levels intersect with policies and policy-making. The decentralization of the state began alongside an increased role for the market since the 1990s, which has shifted the state's role in relation to the market. While this does not eliminate the centralized, elite-driven policy discourse of economists and bureaucrats, it expands policy analysis across disciplines such as political science, law, international relations, sociology, anthropology, public health, media studies, and more. This introduces new perspectives into public policy and, importantly, amplifies the voices of those who have not benefited from mainstream economic policy discourse—a people-centered approach to policymaking and development (Dreze, 2017).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
India’s current environmental and conservation policies have been shaped both by historical legacies and contemporary responses to multiple drivers. The relatively recent emphasis on climate change mitigation has now intersected with sectors such as water, biodiversity and forest conservation. This has reshaped the narrative, regulations and policy responses in the environmental sector in a changing political economy. This is in the face of complex challenges, synergies and trade-offs are emerging between food, water, energy, environmental hazards, ecological and climate security. Certain legacy and new infrastructure priorities have been repackaged within the climate change concerns, with severe trade-offs in certain fragile social-ecological systems, such as pitting local ecological costs against global benefits from “green energy”.
We critically analyse the dynamics and shifts in the environment policy and regulatory environment at multiple levels of governance from local to national across the three pillars: executive, legislature and judiciary. In addition, the changing role of academia, civil society and non-governmental organizations, think tanks and media in shaping the public discourse on environment, ecology, renewable energy and climate change will be examined. Finally, India’s engagement with international conventions, UN Sustainable Development Goals, and science-policy platforms such as IPCC and IPBES will be examined.
This critical review will encompass case-studies involving green energy, forest rights and biodiversity conservation, regional and transboundary river water sharing and environmental and climate hazards in the Himalaya, as well as ecotourism and rewilding and reintroductions, management of invasive species and urban and rural ecological restoration. We will examine the role of National Green Tribunals and Judiciary and the role of centre and state in conservation policies and practice. The fault lines in conservation policies especially escalating human wildlife conflict and the response to mitigation measures for linear barriers and infrastructural development will be examined.
We will draw upon peer-reviewed literature, technical reports, news articles, debates in legislatures and judicial records and pronouncements as well as a rapid assessment of the biophysical state of the environment, environmental and climate hazards to explore the actual outcomes on the ground even as policy and regulations have changed.
Biodiversity conservation, climate resilience and human well-being are closely linked. Yet, mismatches in the scale at which these three priority issues are governed have exacerbated biodiversity loss and degradation of ecosystem services and declining human well-being.
We conclude with some future directions in achieving synergies between the biodiversity conservation and climate resilient development. Insights from this review and syntheses can help meet the twin goals of biodiversity conservation and sustainable development in India and other countries across the Global South.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The changing relationship between the state and communities has been much debated among policy-makers, academics, and civil society activists in the contemporary period. Such debates focus on different dynamics and forms associated with social, economic, political and cultural backwardness and the unequal power relationship between various social groups. Within the broader framework of the debate, tribes are seen as one of the most dispossessed, deprived and marginalised communities in India.
After centuries of exclusion from social, economic, cultural and political realms, a ray of hope emerged for the tribes in the post-colonial period. The different experiences of discrimination, marginalisation and exploitation by the tribal communities provided the ground for the democratic state to adopt policy measures for tribal communities in India. Subsequently, the state has taken several targeted public policy initiatives to safeguard the rights of tribal communities. Moreover, the state has adopted several general policy measures that can benefit tribal communities. Meanwhile, it has been observed that the post-colonial state continues to follow the footsteps of the colonial state in different forms while developing a policy approach towards tribal communities. The policy-making of the post-colonial state appears more paternalistic than collaborative with tribal communities, which is one of the most prominent reasons for policy failure. The policy instruments followed neglect the contextual socio-cultural institutions. Such policy processes reduce the tribes to merely socio-economic, political and culturally marginalised communities without referring to their history, context and location.
Within this backdrop, the paper problematises the tribal public policy domain and explores the interplay between the tribes, state and public policy in India. While doing so, it provides a policy overview and explores the historical past, contemporary realities, and future concerns of policy measures affecting tribal communities. The paper would address pertinent questions, such as how the dynamics of tribes could be incorporated into public policy discourse in India, especially by highlighting their role at the stages of agenda setting, policy formulation, decision-making, implementation, and policy evaluation. Why, how and to what extent does public policy become the critical arena of continuous engagement between tribes and the state, and to what extent does such engagement shape the policy formulation? The paper would argue that at every level of policy engagement, from evolution to formulation to implementation, there were multiple signs of policy paradoxes concerning tribal communities in India.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In late 20th Century New Public Management scholarship, the growing use of technology was seen as one that made systems more efficient. Technology was understood as transformative, in improving citizens’ access to services, enabling real-time data for faster decision making, and providing tools to improve the process and make it more streamlined (Traunmüller and Lenk, 1996). As US literatures proliferated in India through a variety of reform measures, contemporarily so did technology’s materially commodified forms - datafication and digitalisation. Digitalization began to be viewed as a sign of ‘modernity’ in governance (Dunleavy, 2005). In India, digitalisation was offered as the answer to the problem of inefficient bureaucratic processes and administrative performance.
This technology discourse was accompanied by the narrative of improving ‘transparency’ in the services, making the bureaucracy more accountable and open to citizens. The shift from ‘paper’ to ‘digital’ was the key trope justifying the criticality of digitalisation. Its formal adoption could also be seen in headling of nomenclatures in Indian policymaking institutions. In 2015, the central government launched the Digital India program, to ‘transform India into a knowledge-based economy’, by harnessing digital technologies (Ministry of Electronics and IT, 2024). Under this mission, several schemes were implemented, which relied on technological infrastructure and digital systems (Ministry of Communications, 2024)
However, the prevalence of digitalization also led to research on ‘digital divide’, connoting exclusions based on lack of access, costs of adoption and material scarcities. In India, the digital divide was seen to be particularly prevalent in rural areas, where digital penetration was lower. Given these concerns, the focus of the government was to ensure widespread development of digital infrastructure, particularly in these rural areas. One part of this entailed the adoption of technology for welfare services such as Public Distribution Service, Anganwadi Service, National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme and so forth. Similar to the narrative of NPM, the government portrayed its commitment to improving efficiency in services by transforming these schemes, and improving access for the beneficiaries (Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food & Public Distribution, 2024; Ministry of Rural Development, 2025; Ministry of Women and Child Development, 2025).
This “no-alternatives” emphasis towards digitalization seemed to be unfettered in face of the concerns of the digital divide. Especially given these schemes catered to the rural population, the discussion around how those most affected by the digital divide would experience digitalization was absent. This paper takes a critical approach to the study of the transformation in policy-making in India as it flows through the logics of digitalisation and the platform economy. Departing from an analytical focus on improving technology adoption and integration, we are concerned with the way in which those processes produce decontextualised data, invisiblisation of labour processes in producing digital imageries of the policy process, and transformations that shift power and resources away from street-level bureaucrats, citizens, their representatives and collective institutions upwards to global technology corporations and quasi-governmental bodies that continue to steer policy towards the enablement of privatisation of public services.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper proposes to critically examine how models of urban water supply and sanitation services, drawing on templates and ‘best practices’ from the global north, play out in India.
Underpinned by a neoliberal governance paradigm, current institutional arrangements, governance models, and sector interventions typically focus on how financial flows are allocated and utilised and introduce market-based mechanisms to involve the private sector to improve accountability, efficiency, and service delivery. Using the context of public water supply and sanitation services in three urban areas of Karnataka, this paper argues that this limited notion of accountability does not adequately engage with or address systemic factors that shape the lived realities of governance and particularly public service delivery.
We draw from instances in Bengaluru, Hubballi-Dharwad and Gubbi, which illustrate three different institutional configurations across different hierarchies of urban governance. Bengaluru, the capital city, has the Bengaluru Water Supply and Sewerage Board (BWSSB), with the newly formed Greater Bengaluru Authority (GBA), which includes five different corporations (urban local bodies). In Hubballi-Dharwad, urban water supply, which was handled by the Karnataka Urban Water Supply and Drainage Board (KUWSDB) since 2003, has been contracted out by the Hubballi-Dharwad Municipal Corporation to a private operator under a series of World Bank projects being implemented through the Karnataka Urban Infrastructure Development and Finance Corporation (KUID&FC). In Gubbi, a town panchayat, it is the Karnataka Urban Water Supply and Drainage Board (KUWSDB) addressing wastewater, while the water supply component still rests with the town panchayat.
The cases illustrate that the planning, development and operation of water supply and sewerage services in urban areas remains weak and fragmented. The assumptions of improving accountability and efficiency in sector reforms and governance approaches modelled on such paradigms from the global north do not bear out owing to complex and fragmented conditions in which such services are developed, along with inadequate regulatory frameworks and limited capacities of key actors. Rather, they can deepen a systemic accountability deficit by rescaling decision-making powers by externalising issues of access, equity and sustainability, weakening state capacity of local bodies and foreclosing meaningful participation and alternate models and imaginations of such public services.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Governing Surrogacy in India: A case for an inclusive regulatory framework
Author: Sonshikha Sahoo
Affiliation: Student, MBA-PPM, XIM University, Bhubaneswar, Odisha
e-mail: sahoo.sonshikha@gmai.com
Abstract:
India's legal approach to surrogacy has undergone a dramatic transformation, moving from one of the world's most liberal frameworks, a global hub for "fertility tourism" to one of the most restrictive, culminating in the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021. This paper critically examines the political debates, institutional challenges and ethical tensions surrounding this legislative shift, which abolished commercial surrogacy and limited altruistic arrangements to married heterosexual Indian couples. Drawing on concepts of state capacity, gender roles and inclusive versus extractive institutions, the analysis argues that the blanket ban, while intended to prevent the exploitation of poor women, fundamentally undermines reproductive autonomy, ignores diverse family structures (single individuals, LGBTQ+ families) and risks driving the practice into an unregulated black market due to weak enforcement capacity. Through a comparative review of international experiences, the paper concludes that the current prohibition reflects an extractive institutional approach that denies women dignity and economic agency by refusing to recognize surrogacy as legitimate labour. It proposes a comprehensive, rights-based alternative: a transparent, regulated commercial model that prioritizes strengthening state oversight, mandates robust health and financial protections for surrogates and broadens eligibility to ensure the law is inclusive, ethical, and enforceable.
Key words: reproductive autonomy | women dignity | legitimate labour | inclusive governance institutions
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
For over three decades, public policy in India has been increasingly influenced by the global paradigm of New Public Management (NPM). Promoted by multilateral stakeholders as a “best practice” for the Global South, these principles advocate for market-like efficiency, disaggregation, and “client-centric” administration. This paper examines the implementation trajectory of these international templates within the urban governance landscape of Karnataka, India, arguing that the blind adoption of these frameworks has led to a significant translation loss that undermines the democratic and ethical fabric of Indian public policy.
A combination of field visits, review of archival information, newspaper reports, available literature, annual reports by respective institutions, along with online and institutional ethnography of 19 state-owned for-profit companies, was undertaken to carry out this study. Specifically, the evolution of urban service delivery from the early 1990s to the present was traced. The research focuses on the emergence of “Special Purpose Vehicles” (SPVs) and parastatal agencies in sectors such as transport, power, and infrastructure. While these entities were theoretically designed to enhance efficiency through “bureaucratic entrepreneurship,” our findings reveal a different reality.
The analysis indicates that the adoption of these international templates has encouraged the creation of monopolistic, state-controlled for-profit entities that operate with minimal public accountability. By shifting the governance of essential services to corporatised boards, often led exclusively by senior civil servants (IAS cadre), the state has effectively bypassed the constitutional mandate of the 74th Amendment Act. This has resulted in the disenfranchisement of elected urban local body representatives and the transformation of the “citizen-voter” into a mere “consumer.” Furthermore, quantitative data show that despite the “for-profit” mandate, many of these entities remain inefficient, accumulating significant losses while reducing the scope for a democratic feedback loop.
This study directly addresses the core question of Panel NR49: should Indian policy be analysed through the same standards as the developed world? We argue that the weaknesses in India’s urban policy do not stem from a lack of management expertise, but rather from an adherence to international templates that ignore the specificities of India’s plural social fabric and its unique federal-local power dynamics. The market failure lens typical of Global North approaches fails to capture the administrative evil that arises when technical rationality is used to obscure the erosion of social equity and local representation.
As a corrective, the paper proposes an integrated process model that explicitly incorporates ethical dimensions, Accountability, Social Equity, Market Control, and Citizen Ethics, tailored to the Indian context. By operationalising these measures, the study provides a roadmap for policymakers to move away from the efficiency-only metrics of the Global North toward a governance framework that balances professional management with democratic participation. Ultimately, the paper calls for a shift toward institutional regulations that are better aligned with India’s specific socio-political milestones, ensuring that urban governance remains a tool for public value rather than a site for unaccountable bureaucratic expansion.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Envisioning Users’ Role in Transforming Urban Public Service Delivery in India
By 2047, India’s 100th year of independence, 50 per cent of India will be urbanised. 70 per cent of the urban infrastructure required by 2047 has not yet been built. Therefore, India needs to develop climate-resilient, livable cities with the necessary infrastructure and efficient public services, including water, public transport, sanitation, waste management, and health care, to support its urban residents. The World Bank has stated that, while India stands out as a major engine of growth, only sustained and comprehensive reforms will enable it to realise its ambitious development goals in a complex global context. Effective and equitable urban public services are clearly a vital component (Auguste Tano Kouame, 2024).
At present, in India, public participation for shaping public services is through democratic institutions. At the grassroots level, urban local bodies provide direct platforms for citizen participation. However, the decentralisation initiative is half-hearted (Hamid, 2004). In recent years, technology-based platforms and frameworks have expanded citizen engagement. A notable example is the Right to Information Act (RTI), which empowers citizens to seek information from public authorities and promotes transparency and accountability in service delivery. Political leaders are expected to deliver public services on behalf of citizens, who are the principals (Besley and Burgess, 2002).
Creating effective and efficient public services is foundational to a city's livability (Latupeirissa et al., 2024). The “theory of unbalanced growth” postulates that investments in key strategic sectors can spur economic development in the region (Hirschman, 2015). India has also committed to the Sustainable Development Goals in the realm of urban public services and sustainable urbanisation.
This study is an early-stage analysis and focuses on understanding the user perspective, including the marginalised voices of different age groups, genders, and social classes. The study draws on an earlier public opinion survey conducted by the authors in four metropolitan cities across three public services: water supply, public transport, and waste management (Banerji and Maitra, 2024). For this study, mixed-methods research was employed, incorporating quantitative and qualitative data. Study results clearly indicate that user involvement will enhance transparency, introduce diverse perspectives, strengthen regulations, and improve governance. When users and governments collaborate, public services can better meet societal needs more effectively and equitably. Sustainability and climate-resilient public service policies are necessary, and users' contributions to their implementation are well understood.
Urban Public Service Design in India follows a multi-layered, participatory and policy-driven process shaped by constitutional mandates, national missions and frameworks. This study recognises that user inputs can complement, but cannot replace, expert input, and that while the government must design inclusive and representative participation mechanisms, the public perspective must be balanced against evidence-based policy. In conclusion, “voice of end-user” may be one of the missing links in the cycle of public policy formulation, adoption, implementation, maintenance and monitoring. The critical question is how to incorporate diverse user perspectives throughout the chain, from public policy formulation to implementation.
Key words: public services delivery, user perspective, urban public policy, public transport, waste management, water supply
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Competitive markets often operate on the principle that government regulations should apply uniformly to all firms, yet such uniformity can impose disproportionate burdens on smaller enterprises that lack the scale to absorb high fixed compliance costs. This study examines the unequal regulatory burden faced by Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) in India, focusing on the case of electricity sector regulations. Beyond high tariffs, MSMEs also contend with poor reliability of supply—characterized by frequent outages and voltage fluctuations—which compels many to seek better alternatives through open access procurement. We analyse the threshold requirements and regulatory costs associated with availing open access across Indian states, as determined by their respective State Electricity Regulatory Commission (SERC) guidelines. Our findings reveal that the costs of metering upgrades, contract demand thresholds, cross-subsidy surcharges, and administrative procedures are substantial and vary widely across states, and ultimately fall more heavily on MSMEs than on larger firms. These burdens limit MSMEs’ ability to escape unreliable local supply and undermine national policy goals aimed at strengthening small and medium industries. The study highlights the need for more nuanced, scale-sensitive regulatory design to ensure that MSMEs can participate equitably in competitive markets.
Keywords: MSME, open access, electricity markets, regulatory burden, competitive markets, India
JEL Codes: L51, L94, O13, O25
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Public policy has emphasised the need for national economies to develop an ability to manage economic shocks, in response to the challenges imposed by endogenous and exogenous occurrences has become increasingly evident over recent decades. These shocks and the responses have been framing using an engineering approach where a system is presumed to be in a steady state. This conceptualisation has restricted our understanding of economic resilience to the study of shocks to that of a simple mechanical action, akin to the bounce back of an elastic band.
Moving away from an engineering approach and towards the adoption of an ecological approach to understanding economic resilience deepens thinking to consider the processes within a system, similar to examining cogs and wheels in a complex machine. Processual thinking is conducive to a dynamic and fuller investigation of absorptive capacity, particularly on how specific processes in the system can be improved by changing existing policy directives.
This chapter will map the processes evident in recent policy agendas in India that adopt the proposition that public goods and the commons complement each other and are backed by government commitment. It will investigate the forms of institutional engagement that had been put into place to facilitate a richer understanding of this more inclusive approach to economic security- e.g., for increasing supply chain resilience and energy security. It will show how new mechanisms for advancing expertise and capacity have increased information flow between institutions and this has also reduced the costs of institutional engagement. It will also make the case that the inclusive approach that had moved away from setting up public goods against the commons also has important implications for new forms of policymaking where an emphasis on economic resilience will also have the ability to prevent the growth of vulnerabilities – e.g., in making communities/districts less likely than previously to remain in a disrupted state in the wake of shocks.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The international legal system, which resolves infrastructure disputes, currently faces a complete structural transformation because private dispute resolution methods create operational problems while countries need to maintain their public responsibilities. The research paper would examine the significant policy change that India implemented through its January 2026 circular for the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI). The circular establishes a ban on arbitration as a method to resolve disputes which exceed 10 crore rupees in value for major projects because it requires parties to use mediation before they can proceed to court in domestic civil litigation. The analysis investigates the reasons for this decision because its main objective focuses on reducing emerging financial obligations while solving problems of unfairness which exist in temporary arbitration systems. The study will compare the Indian experiences with the "public policy" exception through a comparative study of American and British legal systems. The US maintains strict control over its ADR process which requires agreement from involved parties according to Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) rules, while the UK system allows private parties to select their preferred forum under Model Services Contracts, yet India shows a complete change toward judicial control. The research investigates how project bankability, foreign direct investment (FDI), and rule-of-law development interact with emerging markets. The research shows that the Indian governmental action responds to real financial fears, but it incorrectly defines the problem because it mixes up contract management problems with contract administration operations.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
India’s Foreign Policy: National Interests and Citizen Aspirations
Sanjay Bhattacharyya
(An abstract for a chapter in OUP Handbook on Public Policy)
As en emerging economy and a growing power, India’s foreign policy has evolved to integrate new approaches, while retaining elements of continuity. It remains both familiar and flexible. India’s traditional value based and principled approach towards foreign relations has expanded to include interest based approaches that respond to geopolitical and geoeconomic changes and seek to integrate citizen aspirations in contemporary circumstances.
The chapter will discuss India's foreign policy and how it aligns with national interest and citizen aspirations. It will briefly outline the historical tradition of Indian diplomacy; detail the features of India’s foreign policy, the institutional structures and mechanisms of decision making and its implementation; explore the evolution of India’s foreign policy since independence and evaluate key milestones; and discuss the transitions in policy from the perspective of leadership, political ideology, economic situation, geopolitical developments, etc.
India gained leverage as an articulate champion for the independence of colonised States after WW2. Later, she obtained special and differential treatment for developing countries within an overall framework of increasing representation in multilateral forum. Second, India’s economic reforms changed the dynamics of growth and development and lead to an expansion of national priorities in scope and scale. This growth provided opportunity for expansion in capacity, capability and willingness for deeper engagement on regional and global issues. Third, the role of multilateralism ebbed after initial successes, leading to new initiatives at neighbourhood, regional, plurilateral and minilateral levels. While India continued to repose faith in the multilateral system and sought reforms that would facilitate her wider participation, she also exercised leverage through other mechanisms. Fourth, technology transformation and globalisation led India to build new forms of exchanges, with both developed countries and emerging economies. Fifth, the imbalance between geopolitics and geoeconomics needed adjustments in postures towards global governance as India positioned herself for a multipolar world with greater recognition of the Global South.
For India, most transitions have be positive and have enlarged the concept of national interests to include the dividends of democracy, development and demography. Foreign policy was integrated to the primary task of enlarging national strength and economic growth with inclusive and sustainable development. In addition to the traditional function of promoting state to state relations, foreign policy also considered domestic priorities of governance and citizen aspiration in the context of national interest. Foreign policy adopted developments in evidence based policy making, updating of legislation, new instruments and agreement for Interstate exchanges. India views the world of diplomacy and foreign policy from the perspective of new opportunities and challenges in an increasingly complex world.
Tentative sections in the chapter
1. Introduction
2. The making of foreign policy
3. Trends in India’s foreign policy
4. Governance and foreign policy
5. New issues in diplomacy
6. Critique of India's foreign policy
7. Conclusion
***
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Across the growing landscape of sustainability and climate-transition policies, governments worldwide, and in India, have relied heavily on financial incentives, technological substitution, and infrastructural expansion to achieve environmental goals. India’s current sustainability transition initiatives - from clean cooking under Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana (PMUY) and rooftop solar adoption through PM Surya Ghar, to energy-efficient housing under PM Awas Yojana-Urban (PMAY-U) and sustainable agricultural support via PM-Kisan - seek to accelerate low-carbon transitions. Yet, what these policies ultimately require is sustained behavioural change across social and economic systems. The sustainability-transitions literature (Markard et al., 2012; Kuzemko et al., 2016; Scoones et al., 2020; Avelino & Wittmayer, 2016) has illuminated institutional and technological dimensions, as well as the multi-level governance and innovation systems, but paid limited attention to citizens as capacity-bearing actors who interpret, internalise, and adapt these transitions in practice.
This chapter argues that citizen capacity constitutes the social foundation of the sustainable state and that policy effectiveness depends on how well design, implementation, and feedback processes recognise and engage this capacity.
We conceptualise citizen capacity along three dimensions as constitutive of policy capacity, rather being peripheral: cognitive capacity (citizens’ ability to comprehend policy intent, process information, and act upon design instruments); moral-affective capacity(emotions, values, and identifications conditioned by social and cultural position that mediate policy uptake); and adaptive capacity(the situated practices and informal mechanisms through which citizens sustain policy delivery under constraint). These dimensions interact as mechanisms linking policy design to behavioural outcomes: instrument assumptions set expectations, moral-affective engagement enables or limits adoption, and adaptive practices stabilise implementation on the ground.
We examine these dimensions and mechanisms across two interlinked aspects. First, drawing on policy-design and instrument-choice literature (Howlett & Cashore, 2014), we intend to study policy instruments and their embedded assumptions about citizens’ cognitive, moral-emotional, and adaptive abilities, expressed in subsidies, eligibility norms, digital interfaces, and communication tools. Second, utilising Schneider and Ingram’s (1993, 2005) theory of the social construction of target populations, to study how constructions of citizens activate or diffuse citizens’ moral and emotional capacities shaped by socio-demographic and cultural contexts, influencing trust, legitimacy, and identification with sustainability goals.
Methodologically, the chapter employs a conceptual-illustrative analysis of India’s major sustainability policies. Using programme guidelines, policy documents, government communication artefacts, and evaluation studies, we analyse each scheme across the three stages - design, implementation, and feedback - to identify points of capacity alignment and friction between the capacities imagined in policy and those lived by citizens. The approach is diagnostic rather than evaluative: it traces how cognitive, moral-affective, and adaptive capacities shape the functioning and recalibration of sustainability policies.
The chapter thus intends to portray the sustainable state not as a technocratic project but as a dynamic system continually shaped and sustained through the capacities of its citizens, and makes two important contributions in this regard. Firstly, it connects policy-design and instrument-choice scholarship (Howlett & Cashore, 2014) with social-construction theory, showing how moral narratives and design instruments jointly define expectations of citizen competence and motivation. Secondly, it offers a capacity alignment framework for examining whether sustainability policies, through their instruments, constructions, and feedback systems, acknowledge and utilise citizens’ cognitive, moral-affective, and adaptive capacities as essential conditions for durable environmental change.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
We contend that some innovating firms are motivated by an altruistic desire to ‘do good’ by contributing to societal benefit. Historically such motivational differences may have straddled the divide between socially minded public vs profit-oriented private sectors. In one characterization, socially-minded scientist would carry out the basic research in publicly funded universities or government labs while private sector firms would profit from the development of that research for specific applications. This implied vertical division of labor in R&D is, of course, simplistic. Increasingly universities enter downstream markets themselves through spinoffs or through contractual collaborations with downstream firms to capture the financial rewards from their research. Even though such start-ups aspire to profitability they may nonetheless also be driven by a strong desire to contribute to societal wellbeing.
Thus, in many sectors we might expect profit-focused firms competing with socially-motivated rivals. The latter may not eschew financial profits altogether but append to that the hope of some wider economic benefits, displaying a willingness to sacrifice some profits for the larger economic good. They would be keen to set prices below the levels that maximise commercial profits. Importantly, in competitive markets where products are substitutes to some extent, such altruistic behaviour might lower the profits of all firms, not just the altruistic ones.
The nature of player interactions impacts innovation outcomes of the market in three ways. First, market structure is endogenously determined, with the likelihood of successful innovation and new entry dependent on how much each player invests in R&D. A duopoly emerges if both succeed and a monopoly if only one is successful. Second, while socially motivated pricing raises total economic welfare for any given market structure, it reduces both players’ incentives to invest in R&D. Third, this shift in incentives tilts outcomes towards market structures that are less conducive to aggregate economic welfare. Very high levels of social motivation can increase the likelihood of monopolization or even foregone innovations, resulting in welfare loss.
Recognizing that market structure and research intensities are jointly determined provides valuable insights into the effect of social motivation on aggregate welfare. From the perspective of maximizing total welfare a competitive duopoly is the most desirable outcome, outperforming a monopoly. However, if a monopoly does emerge, a monopoly with a socially motivated player generates greater welfare than one that is profit-focused. We also find that very high levels of social motivation can distort the market structure, tipping it towards a profit-focused monopoly or foregone innovations.
Specific policy interventions, such as innovation prizes or tax credits, can be calibrated to improve welfare. In practice, the implementation of these intervention is limited by information asymmetries and uncertainty, as detailed in Burstein and Murray (2016) and Mandel (2020). While a full-fledged mechanism design is beyond the scope of this paper, our model offers a first step in thinking about innovation support for socially motivated firms.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the face of unprecedented urbanisation in the Global South, a critical knowledge gap exists regarding the effectiveness of urban environmental policies on its dwindling biodiversity, climate resilience, and overall well-being. Bengaluru, India's “Garden City,” exemplifies this crisis. Its once-abundant green canopy is threatened by fragmented, top-down governance and a lack of meaningful data, exacerbating living conditions, especially for vulnerable sections.
In this context, the Karnataka Preservation of Trees Act (KPTA) of 1976 was enacted during a period of global environmental awakening following the 1972 Stockholm Conference. In spite of this, its contemporary relevance is questioned due to indiscriminate and large-scale felling of trees to make way for urbanisation. This research provides a critical evaluation of the KPTA’s efficacy, specifically within the metropolitan context of Bengaluru, where the green cover has plummeted from 68% in 1973 to less than 15% today. The study identifies a profound mismatch between the Act’s statutory intent to maintain ecological balance and the material outcomes of its implementation, which are characterised by a 20:1 asymmetry in ecological destruction versus replacement.
Through a Social-Ecological Systems (SES) framework and a PRISMA-guided systematic review, this study analyses the mechanisms of statutory dilution, most notably the 2014 and 2015 tree amendments, which offered substantial tree-felling exemptions and bypassed public consultation and Tree Officer oversight for developmental projects. The analysis further highlights the critical lacunae in the KPTA, such as the absence of neighbourhood-level canopy standards, the lack of local radius requirements for compensatory planting, and the failure to protect the disproportionate biomass and cultural value of heritage trees. More importantly, a bottom-up approach to governance would be explored, modelling for a policy that seeks civil society engagement and data collection through citizen science and views trees as vital urban commons.
To address these challenges, the study advocates for a locally grounded framework with decentralised oversight. Neighbourhood-level canopy standards overseen by local citizens would be prioritised for this. Furthermore, the study explores the transformative potential of granting legal personhood to trees, drawing on Indian judicial precedents in Haryana and Tamil Nadu that have recognised animals and “Mother Nature” as juristic entities, respectively. By transitioning from an anthropocentric, “utility-based” conservation model to a “rights-based” ecological jurisprudence, Karnataka can safeguard its urban forests as vital, interconnected systems rather than inconsequential spatial burdens. The study concludes that without these radical, locally informed reforms, the city faces a thermal trap and hydrological collapse as it approaches critical ecological tipping points. The lessons drawn from here could potentially inform other similar cities in the Global South.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Caste interacting with Labour – Public policy making in India
Abstract: One of the most defining characteristics of India’s society continues to be the institution of caste. This primordial institution influences almost all walks of life, way beyond the perceived confines of its seemingly societal concerns. The social system that flows from the hegemonic influence of caste system with its inbuilt structures of graded inequality negatively effects the very organisation of the life process in India. Thus also making its impact felt in the making of the public policy – from its conception to the execution. The reach and the hold of neoliberal capitalism notwithstanding, public policy in India is caught in the web of primordial and customary values which privileges a tiny section of social elites over its vast and marginalised populace. This paper proposes to analyse the caste situation vis-a-vis its impact over public policy making, chiefly in two parts. Firstly, we aim to underline the importance and the centrality of the functioning of caste as a system that shapes the very value and ethics of a society wherein the possibility of a rational policy making for the public good faces a structural impediment. Secondly, and more importantly, we aim to highlight the relationship of caste with the understanding of working of labour in India – which has a direct impact again on the working of the public sphere wherein the policy making is conceived.
This proposed paper maintains that India has a unique situation where the labour theory of value cannot be seen and understood in isolation from the social structure its embedded in. Therefore, the relations of production play a decisive role in affirming the ability of doing labour for each individual in India – which primarily get determined by one’s location in the caste society. Question of Labour and social status then are deeply intertwined due to the mechanisms of the caste society – a direct consequence of existing social norms which perpetuates disparities in employment along with the corresponding disparities in social attitude (Robb 1993).
Lastly, the work aims to take into account the values gained through the gradual unfolding of the European enlightenment, which actually went a long way in the making of a rational individual citizen as visualized by the transformative constitution of India. The undervalued and degraded perception of labour is partly the story of the unfinished project of Indian modernity/enlightenment whereby we don’t get to see a pan India anti-caste movement. We aim to bring together these background theoretical interpretation arguing for the possibility of an inclusive public sphere – an essential material binding for making inclusive policies designed for the public good.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Policy capacity has been established as a central concept in public policy and administration over the past decade. Not least, the integrated and nested framework developed by Wu et al. (2015) addressed the poor conceptualisation of capacity from the earlier literature and offered a more promising and feasible approach to examine policymaking functions and governance effectiveness. Although the focus of this literature is still largely on the Global North (Cameron and Evans 2024), recent research has paid increasing attention to various issues pertaining to policy capacity in the under-investigated contexts of developing countries, including India (Yan et al. forthcoming).
The aim of this paper is to first take a comprehensive stock of this emerging literature on policy capacity in India. This review will be guided by the following questions: How has the original policy capacity framework been used when examining the specific context of India? How has that advanced our understanding of the stock, deficits and development of the competences and capabilities in performing key policy functions in India across different public sectors and governance levels? How has the empirical scrutiny of the Indian context contributed to the development of the policy capacity scholarship?
This review builds a foundation for us to further assess the overall contributions as well as limitations of the literature to date. The objective is to propose an agenda for future research to help close the remaining gaps identified and, ultimately, improve policy capacity in India in both research and practice.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Launched in 2015, Delhi’s Mohalla Clinics represent a prominent attempt to reimagine urban primary healthcare delivery in India through decentralised, neighbourhood-based service provision. Designed to offer free consultations, essential medicines, and basic diagnostic services, the programme sought to reduce financial and spatial barriers to care for underserved urban populations. Often cited as an innovative policy intervention, Mohalla Clinics have also been implicitly assessed against international “best practice” frameworks for primary healthcare delivery. This paper argues that such assessments risk overlooking the institutional, social, and governance contexts that fundamentally shape how policies unfold in India.
Using the Theory of Change framework as an analytical lens rather than an evaluative benchmark, the paper examines the design, evolution, and implementation of the Mohalla Clinic programme from its inception through early 2025. Drawing on administrative records, secondary datasets, policy documents, and published studies, the analysis traces temporal trends in programme expansion, utilisation, and service delivery, and examines how core policy assumptions interacted with on-the-ground institutional realities. By early 2025, the programme had expanded rapidly to approximately 546 clinics across all 70 assembly constituencies of Delhi, reflecting strong political commitment and administrative scale-up. Utilisation was initially high, with clinics attracting large numbers of patients, particularly women and economically disadvantaged groups, suggesting progress toward improved equity in access.
At the same time, the paper highlights important gaps between policy design and implementation. The service model remained narrowly focused on episodic and acute care, with limited integration of preventive services, chronic disease management, or broader public health outreach. Several assumptions embedded within the programme’s theory of change, such as sustained public awareness, uninterrupted medicine supply, and stable administrative capacity, proved fragile over time. Declining utilisation following widespread drug stockouts illustrates how implementation bottlenecks, rather than policy intent, shaped outcomes. Moreover, while the clinics altered care-seeking behaviour for minor ailments, there is limited evidence that the programme, in its current form, can deliver longer-term health outcomes without deeper institutional integration.
The paper argues that while Theory of Change frameworks are useful for structuring policy narratives, they are insufficient on their own to capture the complexities of policymaking in India, including uneven state capacity, informal health-seeking practices, and evolving governance arrangements. Evaluating policies like Mohalla Clinics through standard international templates risks misdiagnosing both success and failure. Instead, the paper calls for policy analysis grounded in India’s specific institutional conditions, where adaptive implementation, governance capability, and political economy considerations are central. The Mohalla Clinic experience offers broader lessons for rethinking urban social policy in India, not as a replication of global models, but as an evolving institutional experiment shaped by local realities.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The expansion of oil and gas-based industries in the Tinsukia district of Assam has led to land dispossession and the shrinking of landholdings of the local farming and fishing communities. The gas blowout in Baghjan in May 2020 resulted in an ecological disaster. Studies by the Wildlife Institute of India and the Justice BP Katakey Committee interim report to the National Green Tribunal found the discharge of a large amount of oil and carcinogenic pollutants into the environment. The release of toxins, Carcinogenic Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon (PAH) pollutants into the ecosystem has implied health risk to the local population, flora, and fauna (NGT 2020). Using the Sustainable Livelihoods Framework and Human-Centred Environmental Security, this study used an ethnographic approach to understand the implications of the gas blowout. It examined the negotiations of the affected community, non-state actors with Oil India Limited (OIL) officials, street-level bureaucrats, and the judiciary following the gas blowout. The paper focuses on the bargaining process of non-state actors contesting institutional responses, demanding adequate compensation, and the restoration of the environment. It also examines the pivotal role played by street-level bureaucrats during and after the blowout.
In-depth interviews were conducted with the Civil Society Organizations, OIL officials, and government representatives. The findings highlight the layered vulnerabilities of the local population and argue that the blowout has heightened environmental and livelihood insecurities in Baghjan. The study finds that non-state actors played a pivotal role in shaping and reshaping claims after the disaster through protests, demonstrations, memorandums, and petitions. They have organized the local communities, constantly negotiated with the street-level bureaucrats and OIL during the blowout, and collectively bargained for adequate compensation and environmental restoration.
Street-level bureaucrats have played a proactive role in understanding the damage after the blowout, given their proximity to the local community. Their everyday administrative discretion and constant interaction with pressure groups, OIL, and the judiciary have influenced the whole compensation process. After the gas leak, not only did the consequences of the oil spill become prominent, with massive environmental destruction, but it also put pressure on civil society groups to engage and negotiate with the state and OIL to improve the implementation of policies related to environmental security and ecological restoration, focusing on land justice. As contestations concerning compensation continue, ecological restoration is fragmented, and environmental security remains uncertain. The paper concludes that top-down approaches to public policy centered on procedural compliance have not adequately addressed the specificities of the Indian public policy process, including land justice, ecological dependence, climate vulnerability, and differentiated marginalization.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
For last two decades voices of post-colonial theorist have come together to challenge the dominant western theories. With public policy as a discipline emerging in the context of changing governance structure it all the more becomes important to have an Indian public policy lens to understanding today’s Indian public policy paradigm. For this the colonial rule interaction with Indian society and its indigenous response can lay down the foundation of Indian public policy. This paper shall try to understand state- economic interaction in thoughts of select political thinkers who paved the way for nature of policy making in post-Independent India. It shall study the history of ideas of these thinkers and reflect upon convergences and divergences of their though that paved the way for public policy in India. The thinkers at that time were constantly engaging with English dominated universal ideas and its India specific needs. The present nature of public policy is therefore seen to oscillate between ‘driven’-‘limited’ role of state which is expected by all stake holders.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since the 1950s, India has undertaken one of the most extensive state-led policy transformations in the Global South. Through the Green Revolution and sustained public investment, the country achieved a structural transformation of its agricultural sector and attained national-level cereals self-sufficiency. However, these gains have not been accompanied by significant improvements in food and nutrition outcomes at the household level. Progress in nutritional indicators has been considerably slower, and undernutrition and inadequate dietary quality continue to persist across regions and social groups. In this context, this paper argues that such divergence cannot be adequately explained by policy implementation or by gaps in evidence. Instead, it reflects a deeper public policy challenge shaped by limited institutional learning processes, priority-setting, and the path-dependent consolidation of policy choices over a period of time.
Drawing on a historical analysis of India’s Five-Year Plans and major agriculture, food, and nutrition policy interventions, the paper addresses two interrelated questions. First, how and why did agricultural and nutrition policies evolve along sharply divergent institutional trajectories after the 1950s? The analysis demonstrates that agricultural policy was developed through cumulative and incremental learning, driven by concerns over food scarcity, political legitimacy, and clearly centred around productivity-oriented performance metrics. In contrast, nutrition policy followed a distinct trajectory. This remains institutionally fragmented, predominantly considered as a health or welfare concern, and weakly converged within agricultural policies. This divergence was neither accidental nor the result of policy neglect; instead, it emerged from the consolidation of separate policy subsystems characterised by differing core beliefs, policy instruments, and criteria of success.
The second question examines what a policy-oriented learning perspective reveals about the limits of this policy change in the context of agricultural-nutrition divergence. Viewed through this lens, learning within agricultural policy largely reinforced dominant core beliefs and most notably cereal-centric production, procurement mechanisms, and price stabilisation. This results in incremental yet deeply entrenched change. In contrast, despite repeated recognition of malnutrition and the various forms of evidence, nutrition policy shows predominantly instrument-level adjustments. And, with limited realignment of core policy beliefs or institutional incentives. External factors such as global markets, technological change, and changing development discourse shaped these trajectories selectively, primarily reinforcing existing domestic priorities rather than inducing substantive structural transformation.
Using the institutional and policy-learning framework, this paper contributes to debates on Indian public policy that move beyond imported policy templates and the limitations of transferred evidence-based approaches. It demonstrates that persistent policy incoherence is best understood as the outcome of asymmetric learning and institutional path dependence. Without addressing these underlying dynamics and core policy beliefs, efforts to promote coordination, evidence-based reform, or policy coherence are unlikely to generate transformative change.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
By: Dr. Mohit Kumar Gupta
Assistant Professor, Public Policy and Governance
TISS Hyderabad
Abstract: Dominant policy frameworks for understanding the governance of the corporate sector—heavily influenced by neoclassical economic theories and Anglo-American models from the Global North—treat the discrete, standalone “firm” as the primary unit of analysis and regulation. However, this dominant firm-centric approach, situated in concepts such as market failure, separation of ownership and control, and shareholder primacy, does not serve as a useful yardstick for understanding the governance and operations of the private corporate sector in countries of the Global South such as India. This is because India’s private corporate sector has historically been dominated by family-owned and family-controlled business groups and continues to be so. These multi-entity conglomerates extend beyond the conventional notion of the firm and are coordinated under familial authority through complex inter-corporate investments.
Moreover, policies derived from the standalone firm model fail to account for institutional forms prevalent in the Indian context, such as promoter group holdings, Hindu Undivided Families (HUFs), trusts, Limited Liability Partnerships (LLPs), and other hybrid organizational forms. The distinguishing policy implication of the coordination of these institutional forms within the private corporate sector is that it allows business groups to exhibit high degrees of effective control despite dispersed ownership, enables capital accumulation, facilitates diversification into state-regulated sectors with natural monopoly characteristics (e.g., ports, telecom, and energy), supports debt-financed expansion via finance capital, and provides mechanisms for tax planning—features that transcend the atomistic firm model.
This paper argues that adherence to imported “best practices” has produced policy weaknesses by ignoring India’s historical trajectory, plural social fabric, and institutional specificities. Post-liberalization regulatory shifts—such as the repeal of the MRTP Act (1969), which uniquely treated interconnected business groups as analytical units, and the move toward self-regulation under the Companies Act, 2013, and SEBI norms—have compartmentalized oversight to discrete entities and transactions. This has created regulatory lacunae and avenues for governance failures (e.g., lack of clarity on corporate governance issues such as pledging, related-party transactions, and offshore linkages), as evidenced by case studies of selected business groups examined in this study.
The trajectories of these groups reveal continuities in family control alongside spatial and temporal mobility in institutional configurations, countering Global North theories that frame business groups merely as “gap-fillers” for institutional voids in emerging markets. Even the existing scholarship on corporate governance policy in India falls short of providing a succinct analysis due to its ahistorical approach and a priori generalizations. Grounded in detailed publicly available evidence—including financial statements, shareholding patterns, and regulatory filings—the analysis calls for an India-centric institutional framework for corporate governance policy. This entails recognizing “business groups” as the appropriate unit of analysis for corporate governance codes and taxation. Shifting from firm-centric templates toward evidence-based, contextually aligned regulation would enhance coherence, equity, and state capacity in India’s public policy praxis, while offering broader lessons for the Global South
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
During the British Raj, forests and forest resources were crucial to economic growth and the expansion of the colonial state. However, access to forests was made illegal for forest-dwelling communities through the legal framework. The legal framework for forest access has been shaped by forest policies and instruments enacted over the past hundred years during colonial and postcolonial India. The forest governance's legal framework framed a forest dweller as a criminal during the colonial period. Eventually, it did not allow access to the forest rights. The evolution of forest governance in India is shaped by the complex system of forest policies, instruments, and sectoral policies that have evolved in response to the social and ecological dynamics of forests. Sectoral policies are considered in the context of biodiversity, environmental law, wildlife, deforestation, participatory governance, land rehabilitation and resettlement, and climate change. This paper examines the evolution of forest governance discourse, which has affected the access to forest rights and played a crucial role in the formalisation and institutionalisation of forest management. The formalisation of forest governance resulted in a web of forest and sectoral policies during the colonial and postcolonial periods. The study uses a policy document analysis method to examine the colonial and postcolonial forest policies. In addition, thematic analysis of secondary literature was used to categorise the literature. This paper identifies the evolution of forest governance legal framework as an interaction of policy mixes – a combination of policy instruments, resulting in fragmented and incoherent governance design. Using this design framework, this paper introduces a five-layer analytical model that identifies how policy persists despite changes in the governance paradigm. The paper develops a policy design-mix framework that categorised forest governance instruments into five categories: (1) Authority instruments (e.g., forest department, scientific forestry, punitive action, classification of forests); (2) Conservation instruments (e.g., protected areas, clearance and diversion procedures); (3) Participatory instruments (e.g., gram sabhas, Joint-forest management committee); (4) Rights-based instruments (e.g., Forest Rights Committee, Community Forest Rights Management Committee, Sub-Divisional Lelvel Committee, and District level Committee– FRA tool mix); (5) Market-based instruments (transit rules for minor forest produce). In India’s forest governance, the layering of post-independence instruments over colonial authoritarian tools has shaped the current policy mix, leading to overlapping instruments and incoherence in the design of forest governance. This kind of policy packaging of design elements has created path dependency, which was instrumental in establishing a monopoly over forest products, all wastelands and timberlands in colonial India. It was due to design incoherence in India’s forest governance and policy instruments overlapping, causing fragmentation, bureaucratic dominance, and implementation bottlenecks for rights-based instruments such as the Forest Rights Act, 2006.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In this paper, I attempt to understand the Civil Society Coalitions (CSCs) coalitions to influence the FRA implementation processes at the village and block levels. Since recognising Community Forest Rights (CFRs) in the Vidarbha region of Maharashtra, the socioeconomic benefits to forest-dwelling communities have increased profoundly. So, it is worth examining the policy processes and factors that contributed to the post-Community Forest Rights (post-CFR) implementation processes and their impact on the socioeconomic conditions of the forest community in the Vidarbha region. This paper attempts to understand the formation of civil society-led coalitions in the context of post-CFR policy processes in the Vidarbha region of Maharashtra, India. CFR recognised under India’s 2006 Forest Rights Act transfers community rights and responsibilities to forest-dwelling communities for sustainable use of their customary forests. It examines the emergence of a de-facto collective institution, such as the gram sabha federation of forest dwellers, which came into existence after the recognition of CFRs in the Vidarbha region. In addition, it intends to examine how post-CFR policy processes have led to the formation of Gram Sabha MahaSangh (GSMS) Federation Kurkheda-Wadsa – enabling the democratic management of forest resource such as tendu leaves – in Gadchiroli district of Maharashtra. It argues that advocacy coalition politics in the context of tendu has encouraged community forest management, biodiversity conservation, livelihoods, and local self-determination at the village level. It presents a story of the counter-narrative of underlying colonial continuities, entrenched power asymmetries, and persisting inequalities in forest governance discourse in India. Furthermore, I will explain how Gram Sabhas took the lead in grounding collective action at the block level after the recognition of CFR. The collective action resulted from embedded deep core beliefs in forest communities about the conservation of biodiversity, sustainable practices, and forest management, inspired by self-reliance and self-determination. Community forest rights coalitions and economic development coalitions supported this collective action process. The collective action is anchored in the community forest rights coalition and is congruent with the economic coalition. Both coalitions play a profound role in framing and making collective action.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Air pollution remains one of the most pressing environmental and public health challenges in the developing world. India and China are home to some of the world’s most polluted cities, driven by rapid industrialization, urbanization, energy consumption patterns, and demographic pressures. This paper conducts a comparative analysis of the severity of air pollution in India and China, the policy responses adopted by their governments, the outcomes of these interventions, and key lessons India can extract from China’s multi-decadal efforts to curb air pollution. The study aims to contribute to policy discourse in environmental governance by identifying pathways that enhance air quality while balancing economic development.
India’s air pollution crisis is characterized by persistently high concentrations of fine particulate matter (PM₂.₅) in major urban centres such as Delhi, Kolkata, Varanasi, Kanpur and more. These concentrations often exceed World Health Organization (WHO) guidelines by over tenfold, contributing to elevated respiratory and cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. Sources of pollution in India are diverse, including coal-fired power plants, vehicular emissions, construction dust, agricultural residue burning, and unregulated industrial emissions. Seasonal phenomena, particularly wintertime temperature inversions and crop burning in the Indo-Gangetic Plains, exacerbate air quality deterioration.
China, while historically facing similar challenges during its rapid industrialization phase, documented peak pollution levels in the early 2010s that surpassed those in India by some indicators. In response, the Chinese government launched the “Air Pollution Prevention and Control Action Plan” (2013–2017) and subsequent “Three-Year Action Plan for Winning the Blue Sky Defense Battle” (2018–2020). These comprehensive policy frameworks included stringent emissions standards for industry, systematic closure of coal plants in urban regions, expansion of renewable energy, traffic control measures, and extensive monitoring networks. The emphasis on enforcement, coupled with measurable targets and cross-sectoral coordination, led to significant declines in average PM₂.₅ levels in major cities such as Beijing and Shanghai.
This paper will systematically compare the policy frameworks in both countries through a mixed-methods approach, using literature survey, data collection from government sources and policy documents, alongside interviews with key stakeholders. Preliminary analysis suggests that China’s experience underscores the importance of legally binding standards, sustained financing for clean technology adoption, real-time data transparency, and stringent enforcement mechanisms. The study concludes by outlining actionable lessons for India to strengthen its air quality governance while accelerating improvements in public health and environmental sustainability.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper examines the cumulative impact of state-led hydropower development and climate
change on community managed irrigation systems, with a focus on the kuhls of Kangra in
Himachal Pradesh. The study investigates how large-scale hydroelectric projects and
shifting climatic patterns reconfigure water access, land use, and agrarian livelihoods in
fragile mountain ecosystems It argues that while kuhls have historically functioned as
resilient socio-ecological institutions embedded in customary land and water relations, their
viability is increasingly undermined by upstream river diversions, altered hydrological
regimes, and climate induced variability. These pressures are not merely environmental, they
are also political, as state-led infrastructural expansion reorders control over water in ways
that marginalize community governance systems.
Kuhls are gravity fed irrigation channels that draw water from snow and rainfed streams,
distributing it across terraced fields through rotational norms enforced by locally recognized
functionaries. Their sustainability depends on predictable seasonal flows, stable catchments,
and collective maintenance. However, the rapid expansion of hydropower projects in Kangra
has introduced structural changes to river systems in multiple ways .Reduced downstream
flows, erratic release schedules, and sediment disruption have directly affected the intake
points of many kuhls. In several cases, traditional diversion structures have either dried up or
require costly modifications. State compensation and rehabilitation measures, where
provided, tend to treat irrigation as a technical asset rather than as a community institution,
thereby weakening customary authority and collective labour arrangements.
The above mentioned challenges are further compounded due to climate change. Field
evidence indicates shifts in precipitation patterns, with shorter, more intense rainfall events
and declining winter snowfall in higher catchments. Increased frequency of extreme rainfall
events has led to flash floods that tend to damage channel embankments and intake
structures, raising maintenance burdens. This combined effect of hydropower induced
alteration and climate variability have created a regime of uncertainty that traditional
rotational systems are now struggling to absorb.
Methodologically, the study has adopts a political ecology approach that links infrastructural
expansion and climatic processes to local institutional change. It is based on indepth
fieldwork in select villages across upper and lower Kangra , which included interviews with
irrigators, kuhl committee members, and irrigation department officials, as well as focus
group discussions organized by landholding size and gender.
The paper argues that community-managed irrigation systems in Kangra are not relics of a
pre-modern past but adaptive institutions whose resilience is contingent upon ecological
stability and secure access to flowing water. State-led hydropower development, combined
with climate change, has progressively reconfigured this access, shifting control upstream
and exposing kuhls to hydrological precarity. Finally the paper argues that rethinking
sustainability in the Himalaya requires strengthening community tenure over water and land,
recognizing customary irrigation institutions as legitimate governance actors, and designing
policy frameworks that integrate ecological limits with social equity.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)