Format

NR48. ESG and the Evolution of Environmental Governance in India

Research
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Priyanshu Gupta
Indian Institute of Management Lucknow
Main chair
Sanchayan Nath
XLRI, Delhi NCR Campus, India
Second chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
Research
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

General Objectives

The primary objective of this panel is to advance an integrated understanding of how Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) frameworks are transforming the architecture of environmental governance and corporate accountability in India. At a time when statutory environmental regulations are perceived to be weakening—through procedural relaxations, expedited clearances, and diminished consultative processes—the simultaneous rise of corporate ESG practices creates a complex and evolving governance landscape. Businesses are increasingly confronted with mandatory disclosure norms, heightened sustainability reporting requirements, proliferating ESG ratings, net-zero commitments, and sustainable finance instruments. Yet the actual efficacy, distributional consequences, and political economy of these tools remain under-examined in the Indian context.

 

The panel therefore seeks to (i) bring together scholarship that examines the institutional, regulatory, and market forces influencing corporate ESG practices; (ii) foreground the interactions between public regulation, private standards, investor expectations and civil society scrutiny; and (iii) interrogate how these hybrid mechanisms affect environmental justice, transparency, and accountability. By inviting conceptual, empirical, and theoretical analyses, the panel aims to build a collective space for scholars to critically engage with the ongoing reconfiguration of environmental governance in India—highlighting not only trends, but also their underlying tensions, contradictions, and implications.

More specifically, the panel intends to foster dialogue between public policy scholars concerned with regulatory design and enforcement, and management scholars studying corporate responses to ESG requirements. It seeks to illuminate how firm-level ESG strategies intersect with broader political-economic processes, including investor activism, regulatory shifts, technological transitions, and community mobilisation. Ultimately, the panel’s objective is to deepen understanding of whether emerging ESG mechanisms meaningfully enhance corporate accountability or primarily serve symbolic, reputational, and market-driven purposes.


Research Questions

The panel is structured around a set of core research questions that open up multiple lines of inquiry across disciplines and methodological approaches:

1. How are evolving ESG frameworks reshaping the nature of environmental governance in India?

This includes examining how ESG norms—whether through mandatory BRSR reporting, sectoral ecolabels, or global disclosure standards—intersect with, complement, or potentially substitute statutory environmental regulations. Papers may explore whether ESG tools fill governance gaps or create new forms of fragmented, market-driven oversight.

2. To what extent do corporate ESG practices lead to substantive improvements in environmental performance and accountability?

A central focus is assessing the efficacy of ESG disclosures, ratings, and voluntary commitments. Are firms engaging in meaningful behavioural change, or are they primarily responding through symbolic compliance, selective reporting, or narrative management? How do investors, regulators, and rating agencies shape the credibility and enforcement of ESG claims?

3. What new power dynamics and institutional arrangements are emerging as ESG mechanisms gain prominence?

The rise of ESG has introduced new actors—rating agencies, sustainability consultants, investors, proxy advisors—into the governance arena. This raises questions about expertise, authority, conflicts of interest, and the shifting balance between state-led regulation and private governance regimes. How do these dynamics influence corporate behaviour and policy outcomes?

4. How do ESG-driven governance processes align with or challenge environmental justice concerns?

India’s environmental conflicts are deeply social, involving issues of land rights, health impacts, displacement, and access to natural resources. The panel invites inquiry into whether ESG mechanisms recognise community perspectives or remain largely insulated within corporate and investor networks. Does ESG language create new opportunities for justice-based advocacy, or does it obscure grassroots concerns through technocratic framing?

5. How do sector-specific, regional, or comparative contexts shape the functioning and implications of ESG frameworks?

ESG adoption varies widely across industries—energy, manufacturing, agriculture, mining, finance—and across regions with different regulatory capacities and socio-political conditions. Comparative work, both within India and internationally, can help reveal structural patterns, institutional divergences, and context-specific challenges.

 

Scientific Relevance

This panel holds significant scientific relevance for several reasons.

1. ESG is transforming governance, yet scholarly analysis lags behind practice.

While ESG has become a dominant discourse in corporate and investment circles, academic research—especially in the Indian context—remains fragmented. Public policy scholarship has traditionally focused on state regulation, while management research often concentrates on firm-level strategy or investor behaviour. This panel creates a needed interdisciplinary bridge, offering a platform to examine ESG not merely as a corporate trend but as a governance transformation with regulatory, political, and societal implications.

2. The Indian context presents unique institutional and political-economic dynamics.

India is simultaneously witnessing regulatory dilution and the rapid expansion of ESG requirements—a paradox that challenges existing theories of governance. Unlike many Western contexts where ESG tends to supplement already robust environmental regulation, in India it may be filling regulatory vacuums, reshaping state–market relations, or generating hybrid governance models. Understanding these dynamics contributes to global debates on environmental regulation, private governance, and sustainability transitions.

3. The panel foregrounds environmental justice within ESG debates.

Much global ESG discourse remains dominated by investor materiality and corporate risk perspectives. However, questions of distributional equity, community rights, and environmental justice are fundamental to India’s environmental challenges. By explicitly inviting work that interrogates the justice dimensions of ESG, the panel advances a more socially grounded, critical scholarship that resists the technocratic narrowing of governance debates.

4. It contributes to theoretical development around hybrid governance and accountability.

The proliferation of ESG instruments—ratings, disclosures, voluntary targets—raises fundamental theoretical questions: What counts as accountability in hybrid governance systems? How does authority shift when private actors play regulatory roles? What forms of legitimacy underpin ESG tools? This panel encourages papers that deepen conceptual frameworks around regulation-by-disclosure, private authority, institutional isomorphism, greenwashing, and the political economy of sustainability.

5. It encourages methodological pluralism in studying emerging governance mechanisms.

The panel welcomes case studies, ethnographies, comparative analyses, quantitative assessments, policy analyses, and conceptual explorations. ESG governance evolves in dispersed and opaque ways; therefore, capturing its complexity requires varied methods. Bringing together diverse approaches allows for cross-pollination and richer understanding of empirical realities.

6. The outcomes of this panel have policy and practice significance.

Beyond advancing academic debates, the panel can inform regulatory design, investor decision-making, corporate strategy, and civil society advocacy. Insights generated here have the potential to shape the broader discourse on sustainability and governance in India at a time of rapid economic transitions.

 

We are proposing two papers for preliminary consideration, and shall invite more papers through an open call for papers. We are open to hosting multi-session panel if needed:

1.     Paper Title: Ethics of Science-based Targets

Authors: Dr. Sanchayan Nath (XLRI Xavier School of Management, Delhi-NCR)

               Dr Ayatakshee Sarkar (XLRI Xavier School of Management, Jamshedpur)

 

2.     Paper Title: Whither environmental justice?  ESG and shifting regimes of environmental governance

Authors: Dr. Priyanshu Gupta (Indian Institute of Management Lucknow)

               Dr. Vandana (Jindal Global Business School, Sonepat)

 

 

CALL FOR PAPERS

India’s environmental governance landscape is undergoing a profound transformation. While public policy scholars and civil society actors raise concerns about the dilution of environmental regulations—through expedited clearances, reduced oversight, and shrinking deliberative spaces—corporate actors simultaneously face an expanding suite of Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) expectations. These include evolving disclosure norms, enhanced Business Responsibility and Sustainability Reporting (BRSR) requirements, rapidly proliferating ESG ratings, sector-specific ecolabels, voluntary net-zero and science-based targets, as well as the rise of sustainable and transition finance.

 

This juxtaposition raises pressing questions about how corporate ESG instruments are reshaping accountability structures: Do new ESG policies and market-based tools meaningfully drive changes in firm behaviour, or do they risk becoming symbolic compliance mechanisms? How do rating agencies, investors, regulators, and civil society influence the design and enforcement of ESG norms? And how do these trends intersect with longstanding concerns around environmental justice, community rights, and the role of the state?

 

This panel invites theoretical, empirical, and conceptual papers that analyse the changing nature of environmental governance in India. We welcome work examining the performance, institutional dynamics, impacts, politics and ethics of ESG disclosures, reporting frameworks (including BRSR and global standards), rating methodologies, sustainable finance criteria, supply-chain accountability, voluntary commitments, and corporate climate strategies.

 

Interdisciplinary contributions from public policy, management studies, law, sustainability, environmental studies, ecology, economics, political science, and allied fields are encouraged. We particularly welcome research that illuminates how ESG-driven governance interacts with statutory regulation, shapes corporate conduct, and affects communities and ecosystems on the ground.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Ethics of Science-based targets
Sanchayan Nath (XLRI, Delhi NCR Campus, India)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The planetary boundaries framework was proposed in 2009 to define the safe operating space required to maintain Earth's stability. Recent reports suggest that 7 out of 9 planetary boundaries have now been breached, indicating that planetary health is declining rapidly and humanity's life-support systems are being disrupted at an unprecedented pace. This decline has existential consequences for businesses, not only because their impact on the Earth's ecosystem is disproportionately high compared to other types of organisations, but also because the survival and profitability of their operations depend on the sustainable development of planetary resources. In 2019, Science-based targets (SBT) were developed by operationalising the planetary boundaries framework to help businesses measure and contain their environmental impact.  SBTs are focused on measuring carbon emissions, nitrogen pollution, phosphorus pollution, water quality and impact on terrestrial ecosystems. Although businesses have increasingly adopted impact-reduction targets aligned with the Science Based Targets Network (SBTN) framework, limited research exists on how business leaders and managers perceive the significance and viability of these targets. To address this research gap, Q methodology was used to collect data on perceptions of SBTN from 43 chief managers (male and female) of India's leading public sector banks. These managers have been identified by their organisation as high performers and are expected to assume increasingly responsible positions within the bank. This research focuses on the financial sector because a well-performing banking sector indicates overall economic well-being, while weaknesses within the sector can signal potential economic crises. Although the environmental impact of banks can be high and often not directly visible, strategic investment decisions made by the banking sector can tip the scales in favour of environmental well-being. Each Q interview lasted about 2 hours. 36 Q statements were used. Preliminary factor analysis suggests that respondents can be categorised into three categories. The first category believes that there is little need for banks to align their emission targets to help reduce global temperatures, but remains silent on the importance of reducing nitrogen and phosphorus pollution, improving water quality, and mitigating impacts on terrestrial ecosystems. The second category believes that banks should set emission-reduction targets, but is divided on the necessity of adopting water-use targets and is silent on the importance of measuring other impacts. The third category is split on the importance of emission-reduction targets, but feels that habitat-restoration targets are irrelevant for banking operations. These findings have implications for the ethics of science-based targets. If targets embody normative, value-laden choices, this research suggests that banking sector leaders are either unaware or unconcerned about inter- and intra-generational sustainability, thereby questioning the rationale for businesses' increasing adoption of impact-reduction targets. In other words, questions arise about how businesses perceive SBTs – if the adoption of SBTs is an extension of greenwashing, image building, and corporate relations exercises, then our research suggests that businesses prioritise the maximisation of short-term gains at the expense of long-term survival.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Tracing Planted Forests after CAMPA: A Spatial Proxy Analysis from Korba District in India
Ahana Talukdar (International Institute of Information Technology, Hyderabad)
CO-AUTHORS
Radhika Krishnan (IIIT Hyderabad)
ABSTRACT

Compensatory Afforestation (CA) in India has become a central instrument of forest governance, particularly in extractive regions where large scale natural forest diversion is justified through the promise of ecological restoration elsewhere. Under the Compensatory Afforestation Fund Act (CAMPA), plantations are formally mobilised to offset forest cleared for mining and infrastructure development. In coal mining districts such as Korba, Chhattisgarh, where most active mines are operated by South Eastern Coal Limited (SECL), a public sector enterprise, CA functions at the intersection of state regulation, corporate responsibility, and environmental accountability. Despite the growing scale and fiscal importance of CA, there is limited empirical understanding of how these plantations behave spatially and temporally after establishment and whether they meaningfully compensate for forest loss in practice.

Prior socio legal research, notably Oskarsson and Shukla (2024), has criticised how CAMPA plantations are “missing” both physically and normatively. The authors document how plantations are difficult to locate through official records, poorly linked to specific diversion projects, and largely detached from participatory governance processes, raising concerns about recentralisation of forest control and weakened accountability under the Forest Rights Act (2006). Building on this literature, this study examines whether such “missingness” is observable in spatial land-use dynamics over time, particularly in mining dominated landscapes where corporate and state responsibilities intersect.

Using the Global 30m Forest Age Map (Natural vs. Planted Forest; 1985–2024), multi-year Sentinel derived land use-land cover (LULC) datasets, and mining lease boundary vectors, this analysis tracks planted forest pixels over multiple decades, with particular emphasis on plantations established after the enactment of the CAMPA Act in 2016. The study focuses on the Korba coal belt, where mining leases operated by SECL account for substantial forest diversion, yet publicly accessible, spatially explicit data linking CAMPA plantations to individual user agencies or projects remain limited. In this context, the study adopts a proxy-indicator approach, treating planted forests as observable governance outcomes rather than definitively attributed policy artefacts.

Three proxy indicators are analysed. First, plantation stability is assessed by tracking land-use transitions for post-2016 planted forest pixels across successive years to examine whether they persist as forest cover. Second, proximity to mining is evaluated using spatial buffers around mining leases to identify plantation clustering near extractive frontiers. Third, pre-plantation land use is examined using historical LULC data to characterise the landscape contexts, such as cropland, scrub, or existing forest into which plantations are introduced.

Initial results confirm the presence of post-2016 afforestation across the district, while revealing substantial variation in how these plantations persist over time. A considerable share of planted forest pixels undergo repeated land-use transitions, indicating uneven maintenance as forest cover. A significant proportion of plantations are spatially concentrated near mining leases, and pre-plantation land-use patterns show that afforestation has been conducted across diverse landscape contexts rather than exclusively on areas previously classified as forest. These findings highlight limitations in assessing compensatory afforestation solely through administrative reporting and point to broader challenges of transparency, traceability, and accountability within contemporary environmental governance frameworks. By demonstrating how proxy-based spatial analysis can complement official records, the study contributes to ongoing debates on the effectiveness of state led and corporate linked environmental interventions in mining affected regions.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Whither environmental justice? ESG and shifting regimes of environmental governance in India
Vandana . (Jindal Global Business School, O P Jindal Global University )
CO-AUTHORS
Priyanshu Gupta (Indian Institute of Management Lucknow)
ABSTRACT

The environmental, social, and governance (ESG) reporting framework has emerged as an essential policy instrument of environmental governance in India. While there has been a strong regulatory push by the state, aimed at encouraging businesses to embrace the narrative of doing well by doing good, it stands in stark contrast to parallel trends involving the discrediting, delegitimizing, and actual crackdown on environmental NGOs and civil society groups in the country as well as reduction of the traditional state regulatory framework-including the Environmental Impact Assessment and other forest conservation laws. While the implications of ESG, including its limitations and challenges, are being discussed and debated in both scholarly work and popular media, it’s implication for the larger environmental governance questions remain unscrutinized.
Our research aims to address this gap by developing an environmental justice analysis and reflections on these shifts, and developing suggestions for civil society engagements in this emergent governance regime. We first present the emergent regime as a shift from a state-led model to a market-led governance model. This means that from an earlier system where the state was the custodian and adjudicator of public interest, including natural resources and forest commons, market mechanisms are entrusted with the role of protecting the environment. Next, we examine the market mechanism of environmental governance that includes an analysis of the following reporting tools: The Business responsibility and sustainability reporting (BRSR) format – compulsory for top 1000 companies since 2022 and the ESG/sustainability reports of companies and ESG ratings of selected corporations. The main assumption of this market-based governance regime is that all key environmental, social, and governance-related indicators as per the compulsory format will be reported, and that will translate into the company's ESG rating, which in turn will determine the investment behavior by market participants. Investment behavior has been observed to be sensitive to ESG ratings, and therefore, it can be considered a necessary financial nudge for the company to do environmentally and socially better. Our analysis uncovers that reporting formats create a hierarchy of values, marginalizing key human rights and environmental values. We also highlight that these reports help in creating a positive narrative about the corporation and, therefore, are not a credible instrument for investors to rely on. Furthermore, we also show that the MSCI ratings and its methodology fail to capture what it claims and therefore, don’t do much to address the existing power inequalities among the stakeholder groups. We argue that these changes lead to further privatization of the public interest space as the power of the public or civil society declines, helping the neoliberal governance systems form deeper roots. We refer to this as the financialization of the public sphere, as the language of the markets and finance gains prominence. We conclude by reflecting on the possible strategies of resistance for civil society actors as the power of the market institutions grows.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - ESG Governance, Regulatory Displacement, and International Positioning: India's Approach to Plastic Pollution
Suchithra Suchithra (Technische Universität München)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

India faces a governance puzzle in plastic pollution control. Despite being among the countries most severely affected by plastic pollution – with contaminated rivers, overstretched urban waste systems, and rising microplastic exposure disproportionately burdening marginalised communities – India has resisted binding production controls in Global Plastics Treaty negotiations while expanding Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) disclosure requirements domestically.

 

The fundamental question is: why does India adopt market-based ESG governance at home while resisting binding international commitments? Do these parallel trajectories reflect a coherent political-economic logic privileging voluntary compliance over regulatory intervention? Are these governance mechanisms oriented toward environmental outcomes, justice, and equity, or do they primarily serve investor materiality, corporate reputation, and industrial expansion objectives?

 

This puzzle reveals broader tensions where statutory regulation is perceived as weakening while ESG frameworks - including Business Responsibility and Sustainability Reporting (BRSR), ESG ratings, Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) regimes, and voluntary commitments - assume growing prominence. The paper examines whether ESG-driven governance meaningfully constrains corporate conduct or primarily enables regulatory displacement, and how this domestic transformation aligns with India's international positioning.

 

The study addresses four core questions: How do ESG frameworks interact with statutory plastics regulation – do they complement, substitute, or fragment regulatory authority? Do ESG disclosures and corporate commitments translate into substantive reductions in plastic production and pollution, or do they serve primarily as narrative tools? How do private governance actors – rating agencies, sustainability consultants, and investors – reshape power dynamics and accountability, and whose interests do these mechanisms serve? Do ESG governance processes incorporate environmental justice and equity concerns, including impacts on informal waste workers, vulnerable communities, and public health – or do they remain insulated within corporate-investor networks that privilege market logics over environmental and social outcomes?

 

The analysis draws on qualitative examination of corporate ESG disclosures and BRSR reports, regulatory documents including Plastic Waste Management Rules, EPR compliance data, ESG rating methodologies, and India's treaty submissions. This enables examination of how accountability narratives are constructed, what gets disclosed versus omitted, and whether community perspectives and environmental justice considerations feature in ESG metrics.

 

Initial findings suggest coherence between domestic regulatory displacement and international resistance to binding controls. Domestically, ESG mechanisms enable downstream interventions – waste management, recycling, circular economy – while deprioritising upstream issues like production volumes and petrochemical expansion. Internationally, India's treaty position emphasises flexibility while resisting production controls. This alignment appears reinforced by shared drivers: petrochemical industry expansion, employment concerns, limited enforcement capacity, and ESG metrics designed around investor materiality rather than environmental justice. Rating agencies operate with minimal oversight. Critically, ESG frameworks largely exclude informal waste workers' livelihoods, community health impacts, and distributive equity concerns – revealing governance orientated toward corporate risk management rather than environmental protection or social justice.

 

The paper contributes to debates on hybrid governance and private authority by examining how domestic ESG arrangements and international positions mutually reinforce one another, revealing how market-based mechanisms may reconfigure governance gaps while marginalising justice and equity considerations.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Sustainable or Strategic? Analysing How Firms Allocate Corporate Social Responsibility Funds Across Competing Sectors
Yogita Parmar (Indian Institute of Technology, Tirupati (India))
CO-AUTHORS
Abhigyan . (Indian Institute of Management Indore )
Varun Varghese (Indian Institute of Technology Tirupati)
ABSTRACT

The Companies Act of 2013 introduced mandatory Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) in India, requiring organisations to allocate a proportion of their profits to CSR and make repeated decisions about where and how to allocate their CSR. While CSR is being touted as a pathway to achieve sustainable development, there is little evidence on how companies make these allocation decisions and how such decisions shape trade-offs between aspects of development, equity, and sustainability. Additionally, there exists little evidence on how firm level characteristics such as the industry in which the firm operates and their classification according to regulatory authorities such as the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB), and the gender composition of their top management affect CSR allocation across different sectors. These raise critical questions about how companies contribute to sustainable development through CSR.

 

This study uses a longitudinal dataset of 17,390 distinct CSR investment records from the top 50 companies listed on India's national stock exchange, starting in 2014. CSR investments are categorised under six sectors, including 1) education and skill development, 2) health and nutrition, 3) environmental sustainability and natural resource conservation, 4) social inclusion and gender equity, 5) rural and community development, and 6) national relief and public funds. An Extended Multiple Discrete–Continuous Extreme Value (e-MDCEV) modelling framework is used in the empirical analysis to explicitly account for the panel structure of firm-level investment decisions over time, while simultaneously modelling the selection of multiple CSR sectors and the distribution of finite CSR budgets across them.

 

Preliminary findings indicate that trade-offs exist between long-term investments in human capital and environmental sustainability and short-term relief-oriented spending, often substituting one with the other. Meanwhile, companies with a higher amount of total profits are more likely to diversify their CSR allocation across sectors. In addition, the presence of women in leadership positions was observed to have a positive effect on the allocation in education, health, and social inclusion sectors. Overall, the study fills an important gap in existing CSR and sustainability research by advancing understanding of organisational decision-making in CSR allocation.  

 

Keywords: Corporate Social Responsibility; Resource Allocation; Sustainable Development; Organisational Behaviour

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - RIVERBED MINING IN PAONTA SAHIB, HIMACHAL PRADESH
Himanshu garg (Indian Institute of Management , Sirmaur)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Riverbed mining of minor minerals has emerged as a pressing governance and environmental issue in India, particularly in ecologically sensitive areas where the economy is inextricably linked to mining. This paper, focusing on the Paonta Sahib area of District Sirmaur in Himachal Pradesh, explores riverbed mining as a public policy issue that is informed by the complex interplay of regulatory intentions, livelihoods, inter-state politics, and enforcement capacities. Though mining helps meet the demand for construction, jobs, and state finances, the issues of illegal mining, environmental damage, and low compliance rates have led to doubts about the efficiency of the current governance framework.

On the basis of interactions at the field level with government officials, analysis of the legal and institutional framework, analysis of District Survey Reports, and secondary literature such as policy documents and satellite images, the study assesses the regulation, monitoring, and ground situation of riverbed sand mining. Particular attention is given to the regulation of mining leases, performance of stone crusher-based units, depth constraints based on replenishment concepts, and monitoring of mining and mineral transportation. The findings indicate that there is a huge gap between the two. Although a regulatory framework is in place as per the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act and state rules, its implementation is affected by imprecise definition of mining leases, absence of control over spatial boundaries, and monitoring capacity.

These factors make way for regular violations of the approved conditions of extraction, such as mining beyond the approved depth, thus challenging the scientific basis of natural replenishment. In addition to the design and implementation of the regulations, the article also points out the socio-economic context of riverbed mining in Paonta Sahib. Mining-related livelihoods, especially those related to transport and crushers, have become crucial to household economies, thus making mining activity socially acceptable and reducing community pressure for regulation and enforcement. On the other hand, reliance on minor mineral royalties creates a dilemma for the state, making trade-offs between revenue, livelihood, and sustainability even more difficult. On the environmental front, over and uneven extraction has resulted in changes to river morphology, drainage patterns, aquatic biodiversity, wildlife corridors, and safety and pollution hazards for downstream communities. The article concludes that riverbed mining in Paonta Sahib is a systemic governance problem rather than a series of isolated illegalities.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - ESG as a Global Justice Project: Substantive Reminders and Urgent Reflections to Drive Policy
Arunika Mishra (Indian Institute of Management, Kolkata)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) is a regulatory policy tool that has emerged as a risk management strategy, market signalling, and investor assurance for global businesses. However, the value-neutral framing of ESG policy obscures its inherent potential for harmonizing global justice.

 

Using climate resilience and living wages as a construct of global justice, this paper evaluates the substantive blind-spots of ESG based regulations such as BRSR core, Dodd-Frank Act, the Dutch Child Labour Abolition act, and the French Vigilance Act. We conceptualize ESG as a global justice project that runs on substantive underpinnings dependent on centering voices of vulnerable stakeholders who suffer adverse human rights impacts in global production networks. Climate resilience and living wages are not peripheral ESG indicators but preconditions of global justice, determining who absorbs environmental shocks and who is rendered disposable within global value chains. An ESG framework that measures resilience while ignoring wage security redistributes climate risk downward from capital to labor, and, from Global North to the Global South.

 

Substantively, ESG policy aims to regulate contemporary forms of global capitalism characterized by fragmented global value chains, outsourced production, and fictionalized corporate control, where profit is extracted by shifting social and environmental costs onto extraterritorial sites. ESG reporting seeks to regulate harms that are structurally embedded in global production networks, such as, rampant use of conflict minerals, child labor, forced and bonded labor, wage suppression, and precarious work, and climate vulnerability. These harms disproportionately affect communities in the Global South, specifically informal workers in climate vulnerable regions. ESG must therefore be understood as a justice-oriented intervention, not a voluntary market tool, reinforcing the state’s substantive efforts toward social welfare, justice, and protection of labor, communities, and ecological commons.

 

The paper seeks to offer urgent reflections on the sociopolitical and legal organization of ESG policy which increasingly suggests neoliberal market imperatives which prioritize corporate autonomy through self-regulation beyond the latches of state governance. Such a decentralized ESG-disclosures policy risks reproducing injustices by shifting adaptation onto already precarious actors. Reflecting on integration of climate resilience in ESG laws helps understand why ESG policy shuns functional outcomes, alienating the larger project of global justice through a decontextualized technocratic compliance system based on fulfilling indices and metrics system.

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - BioE3 and ESG-Based Environmental Governance in India: Examining the Policy–Disclosure Interface
Manish Adwani (Pandit Deendayal Energy University)
CO-AUTHORS
Anurag Srivastava (Pandit Deendayal Energy University)
ABSTRACT

India’s environmental governance is increasingly shaped by the interaction between state-led sustainability policies and corporate Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) disclosure regimes. The BioE3 (Biotechnology for Economy, Environment, and Employment) Policy represents a key intervention in this landscape, promoting biotechnology-led industrial growth through sustainability narratives such as net-zero transitions, circular bioeconomy models, and reduced environmental impact. However, the policy provides limited clarity on how these sustainability objectives are translated into measurable environmental accountability at the firm level.

 

This paper examines the interface between the BioE3 policy framework and ESG-based corporate disclosure mechanisms in India to assess how environmental accountability is operationalised in practice. Empirically, the study draws on qualitative document analysis of the BioE3 policy, the Business Responsibility and Sustainability Reporting (BRSR) framework, and environmental disclosures from selected biotechnology and agri-biotechnology firms. The analysis focuses on identifying points of alignment and divergence between policy-level sustainability expectations and disclosure-based accountability requirements.

 

The findings suggest that while BioE3 strongly shapes sustainability narratives adopted by firms, its environmental governance effects are largely mediated through ESG disclosure practices rather than outcome-based performance measurement or enforcement. This creates an accountability structure centred on reporting alignment and reputational signalling, with limited mechanisms to assess substantive environmental outcomes. The paper argues that BioE3 exemplifies an ESG-mediated, hybrid model of environmental governance in which industrial policy influences how sustainability is articulated, but not necessarily how it is verified. By highlighting this policy–disclosure gap, the study contributes to debates on regulation-by-disclosure and the effectiveness of ESG frameworks in India’s evolving environmental governance landscape.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The planetary boundaries framework was proposed in 2009 to define the safe operating space required to maintain Earth's stability. Recent reports suggest that 7 out of 9 planetary boundaries have now been breached, indicating that planetary health is declining rapidly and humanity's life-support systems are being disrupted at an unprecedented pace. This decline has existential consequences for businesses, not only because their impact on the Earth's ecosystem is disproportionately high compared to other types of organisations, but also because the survival and profitability of their operations depend on the sustainable development of planetary resources. In 2019, Science-based targets (SBT) were developed by operationalising the planetary boundaries framework to help businesses measure and contain their environmental impact.  SBTs are focused on measuring carbon emissions, nitrogen pollution, phosphorus pollution, water quality and impact on terrestrial ecosystems. Although businesses have increasingly adopted impact-reduction targets aligned with the Science Based Targets Network (SBTN) framework, limited research exists on how business leaders and managers perceive the significance and viability of these targets. To address this research gap, Q methodology was used to collect data on perceptions of SBTN from 43 chief managers (male and female) of India's leading public sector banks. These managers have been identified by their organisation as high performers and are expected to assume increasingly responsible positions within the bank. This research focuses on the financial sector because a well-performing banking sector indicates overall economic well-being, while weaknesses within the sector can signal potential economic crises. Although the environmental impact of banks can be high and often not directly visible, strategic investment decisions made by the banking sector can tip the scales in favour of environmental well-being. Each Q interview lasted about 2 hours. 36 Q statements were used. Preliminary factor analysis suggests that respondents can be categorised into three categories. The first category believes that there is little need for banks to align their emission targets to help reduce global temperatures, but remains silent on the importance of reducing nitrogen and phosphorus pollution, improving water quality, and mitigating impacts on terrestrial ecosystems. The second category believes that banks should set emission-reduction targets, but is divided on the necessity of adopting water-use targets and is silent on the importance of measuring other impacts. The third category is split on the importance of emission-reduction targets, but feels that habitat-restoration targets are irrelevant for banking operations. These findings have implications for the ethics of science-based targets. If targets embody normative, value-laden choices, this research suggests that banking sector leaders are either unaware or unconcerned about inter- and intra-generational sustainability, thereby questioning the rationale for businesses' increasing adoption of impact-reduction targets. In other words, questions arise about how businesses perceive SBTs – if the adoption of SBTs is an extension of greenwashing, image building, and corporate relations exercises, then our research suggests that businesses prioritise the maximisation of short-term gains at the expense of long-term survival.

CO-AUTHORS
Radhika Krishnan (IIIT Hyderabad)
ABSTRACT

Compensatory Afforestation (CA) in India has become a central instrument of forest governance, particularly in extractive regions where large scale natural forest diversion is justified through the promise of ecological restoration elsewhere. Under the Compensatory Afforestation Fund Act (CAMPA), plantations are formally mobilised to offset forest cleared for mining and infrastructure development. In coal mining districts such as Korba, Chhattisgarh, where most active mines are operated by South Eastern Coal Limited (SECL), a public sector enterprise, CA functions at the intersection of state regulation, corporate responsibility, and environmental accountability. Despite the growing scale and fiscal importance of CA, there is limited empirical understanding of how these plantations behave spatially and temporally after establishment and whether they meaningfully compensate for forest loss in practice.

Prior socio legal research, notably Oskarsson and Shukla (2024), has criticised how CAMPA plantations are “missing” both physically and normatively. The authors document how plantations are difficult to locate through official records, poorly linked to specific diversion projects, and largely detached from participatory governance processes, raising concerns about recentralisation of forest control and weakened accountability under the Forest Rights Act (2006). Building on this literature, this study examines whether such “missingness” is observable in spatial land-use dynamics over time, particularly in mining dominated landscapes where corporate and state responsibilities intersect.

Using the Global 30m Forest Age Map (Natural vs. Planted Forest; 1985–2024), multi-year Sentinel derived land use-land cover (LULC) datasets, and mining lease boundary vectors, this analysis tracks planted forest pixels over multiple decades, with particular emphasis on plantations established after the enactment of the CAMPA Act in 2016. The study focuses on the Korba coal belt, where mining leases operated by SECL account for substantial forest diversion, yet publicly accessible, spatially explicit data linking CAMPA plantations to individual user agencies or projects remain limited. In this context, the study adopts a proxy-indicator approach, treating planted forests as observable governance outcomes rather than definitively attributed policy artefacts.

Three proxy indicators are analysed. First, plantation stability is assessed by tracking land-use transitions for post-2016 planted forest pixels across successive years to examine whether they persist as forest cover. Second, proximity to mining is evaluated using spatial buffers around mining leases to identify plantation clustering near extractive frontiers. Third, pre-plantation land use is examined using historical LULC data to characterise the landscape contexts, such as cropland, scrub, or existing forest into which plantations are introduced.

Initial results confirm the presence of post-2016 afforestation across the district, while revealing substantial variation in how these plantations persist over time. A considerable share of planted forest pixels undergo repeated land-use transitions, indicating uneven maintenance as forest cover. A significant proportion of plantations are spatially concentrated near mining leases, and pre-plantation land-use patterns show that afforestation has been conducted across diverse landscape contexts rather than exclusively on areas previously classified as forest. These findings highlight limitations in assessing compensatory afforestation solely through administrative reporting and point to broader challenges of transparency, traceability, and accountability within contemporary environmental governance frameworks. By demonstrating how proxy-based spatial analysis can complement official records, the study contributes to ongoing debates on the effectiveness of state led and corporate linked environmental interventions in mining affected regions.

CO-AUTHORS
Priyanshu Gupta (Indian Institute of Management Lucknow)
ABSTRACT

The environmental, social, and governance (ESG) reporting framework has emerged as an essential policy instrument of environmental governance in India. While there has been a strong regulatory push by the state, aimed at encouraging businesses to embrace the narrative of doing well by doing good, it stands in stark contrast to parallel trends involving the discrediting, delegitimizing, and actual crackdown on environmental NGOs and civil society groups in the country as well as reduction of the traditional state regulatory framework-including the Environmental Impact Assessment and other forest conservation laws. While the implications of ESG, including its limitations and challenges, are being discussed and debated in both scholarly work and popular media, it’s implication for the larger environmental governance questions remain unscrutinized.
Our research aims to address this gap by developing an environmental justice analysis and reflections on these shifts, and developing suggestions for civil society engagements in this emergent governance regime. We first present the emergent regime as a shift from a state-led model to a market-led governance model. This means that from an earlier system where the state was the custodian and adjudicator of public interest, including natural resources and forest commons, market mechanisms are entrusted with the role of protecting the environment. Next, we examine the market mechanism of environmental governance that includes an analysis of the following reporting tools: The Business responsibility and sustainability reporting (BRSR) format – compulsory for top 1000 companies since 2022 and the ESG/sustainability reports of companies and ESG ratings of selected corporations. The main assumption of this market-based governance regime is that all key environmental, social, and governance-related indicators as per the compulsory format will be reported, and that will translate into the company's ESG rating, which in turn will determine the investment behavior by market participants. Investment behavior has been observed to be sensitive to ESG ratings, and therefore, it can be considered a necessary financial nudge for the company to do environmentally and socially better. Our analysis uncovers that reporting formats create a hierarchy of values, marginalizing key human rights and environmental values. We also highlight that these reports help in creating a positive narrative about the corporation and, therefore, are not a credible instrument for investors to rely on. Furthermore, we also show that the MSCI ratings and its methodology fail to capture what it claims and therefore, don’t do much to address the existing power inequalities among the stakeholder groups. We argue that these changes lead to further privatization of the public interest space as the power of the public or civil society declines, helping the neoliberal governance systems form deeper roots. We refer to this as the financialization of the public sphere, as the language of the markets and finance gains prominence. We conclude by reflecting on the possible strategies of resistance for civil society actors as the power of the market institutions grows.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

India faces a governance puzzle in plastic pollution control. Despite being among the countries most severely affected by plastic pollution – with contaminated rivers, overstretched urban waste systems, and rising microplastic exposure disproportionately burdening marginalised communities – India has resisted binding production controls in Global Plastics Treaty negotiations while expanding Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) disclosure requirements domestically.

 

The fundamental question is: why does India adopt market-based ESG governance at home while resisting binding international commitments? Do these parallel trajectories reflect a coherent political-economic logic privileging voluntary compliance over regulatory intervention? Are these governance mechanisms oriented toward environmental outcomes, justice, and equity, or do they primarily serve investor materiality, corporate reputation, and industrial expansion objectives?

 

This puzzle reveals broader tensions where statutory regulation is perceived as weakening while ESG frameworks - including Business Responsibility and Sustainability Reporting (BRSR), ESG ratings, Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) regimes, and voluntary commitments - assume growing prominence. The paper examines whether ESG-driven governance meaningfully constrains corporate conduct or primarily enables regulatory displacement, and how this domestic transformation aligns with India's international positioning.

 

The study addresses four core questions: How do ESG frameworks interact with statutory plastics regulation – do they complement, substitute, or fragment regulatory authority? Do ESG disclosures and corporate commitments translate into substantive reductions in plastic production and pollution, or do they serve primarily as narrative tools? How do private governance actors – rating agencies, sustainability consultants, and investors – reshape power dynamics and accountability, and whose interests do these mechanisms serve? Do ESG governance processes incorporate environmental justice and equity concerns, including impacts on informal waste workers, vulnerable communities, and public health – or do they remain insulated within corporate-investor networks that privilege market logics over environmental and social outcomes?

 

The analysis draws on qualitative examination of corporate ESG disclosures and BRSR reports, regulatory documents including Plastic Waste Management Rules, EPR compliance data, ESG rating methodologies, and India's treaty submissions. This enables examination of how accountability narratives are constructed, what gets disclosed versus omitted, and whether community perspectives and environmental justice considerations feature in ESG metrics.

 

Initial findings suggest coherence between domestic regulatory displacement and international resistance to binding controls. Domestically, ESG mechanisms enable downstream interventions – waste management, recycling, circular economy – while deprioritising upstream issues like production volumes and petrochemical expansion. Internationally, India's treaty position emphasises flexibility while resisting production controls. This alignment appears reinforced by shared drivers: petrochemical industry expansion, employment concerns, limited enforcement capacity, and ESG metrics designed around investor materiality rather than environmental justice. Rating agencies operate with minimal oversight. Critically, ESG frameworks largely exclude informal waste workers' livelihoods, community health impacts, and distributive equity concerns – revealing governance orientated toward corporate risk management rather than environmental protection or social justice.

 

The paper contributes to debates on hybrid governance and private authority by examining how domestic ESG arrangements and international positions mutually reinforce one another, revealing how market-based mechanisms may reconfigure governance gaps while marginalising justice and equity considerations.

CO-AUTHORS
Abhigyan . (Indian Institute of Management Indore )
Varun Varghese (Indian Institute of Technology Tirupati)
ABSTRACT

The Companies Act of 2013 introduced mandatory Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) in India, requiring organisations to allocate a proportion of their profits to CSR and make repeated decisions about where and how to allocate their CSR. While CSR is being touted as a pathway to achieve sustainable development, there is little evidence on how companies make these allocation decisions and how such decisions shape trade-offs between aspects of development, equity, and sustainability. Additionally, there exists little evidence on how firm level characteristics such as the industry in which the firm operates and their classification according to regulatory authorities such as the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB), and the gender composition of their top management affect CSR allocation across different sectors. These raise critical questions about how companies contribute to sustainable development through CSR.

 

This study uses a longitudinal dataset of 17,390 distinct CSR investment records from the top 50 companies listed on India's national stock exchange, starting in 2014. CSR investments are categorised under six sectors, including 1) education and skill development, 2) health and nutrition, 3) environmental sustainability and natural resource conservation, 4) social inclusion and gender equity, 5) rural and community development, and 6) national relief and public funds. An Extended Multiple Discrete–Continuous Extreme Value (e-MDCEV) modelling framework is used in the empirical analysis to explicitly account for the panel structure of firm-level investment decisions over time, while simultaneously modelling the selection of multiple CSR sectors and the distribution of finite CSR budgets across them.

 

Preliminary findings indicate that trade-offs exist between long-term investments in human capital and environmental sustainability and short-term relief-oriented spending, often substituting one with the other. Meanwhile, companies with a higher amount of total profits are more likely to diversify their CSR allocation across sectors. In addition, the presence of women in leadership positions was observed to have a positive effect on the allocation in education, health, and social inclusion sectors. Overall, the study fills an important gap in existing CSR and sustainability research by advancing understanding of organisational decision-making in CSR allocation.  

 

Keywords: Corporate Social Responsibility; Resource Allocation; Sustainable Development; Organisational Behaviour

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Riverbed mining of minor minerals has emerged as a pressing governance and environmental issue in India, particularly in ecologically sensitive areas where the economy is inextricably linked to mining. This paper, focusing on the Paonta Sahib area of District Sirmaur in Himachal Pradesh, explores riverbed mining as a public policy issue that is informed by the complex interplay of regulatory intentions, livelihoods, inter-state politics, and enforcement capacities. Though mining helps meet the demand for construction, jobs, and state finances, the issues of illegal mining, environmental damage, and low compliance rates have led to doubts about the efficiency of the current governance framework.

On the basis of interactions at the field level with government officials, analysis of the legal and institutional framework, analysis of District Survey Reports, and secondary literature such as policy documents and satellite images, the study assesses the regulation, monitoring, and ground situation of riverbed sand mining. Particular attention is given to the regulation of mining leases, performance of stone crusher-based units, depth constraints based on replenishment concepts, and monitoring of mining and mineral transportation. The findings indicate that there is a huge gap between the two. Although a regulatory framework is in place as per the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act and state rules, its implementation is affected by imprecise definition of mining leases, absence of control over spatial boundaries, and monitoring capacity.

These factors make way for regular violations of the approved conditions of extraction, such as mining beyond the approved depth, thus challenging the scientific basis of natural replenishment. In addition to the design and implementation of the regulations, the article also points out the socio-economic context of riverbed mining in Paonta Sahib. Mining-related livelihoods, especially those related to transport and crushers, have become crucial to household economies, thus making mining activity socially acceptable and reducing community pressure for regulation and enforcement. On the other hand, reliance on minor mineral royalties creates a dilemma for the state, making trade-offs between revenue, livelihood, and sustainability even more difficult. On the environmental front, over and uneven extraction has resulted in changes to river morphology, drainage patterns, aquatic biodiversity, wildlife corridors, and safety and pollution hazards for downstream communities. The article concludes that riverbed mining in Paonta Sahib is a systemic governance problem rather than a series of isolated illegalities.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) is a regulatory policy tool that has emerged as a risk management strategy, market signalling, and investor assurance for global businesses. However, the value-neutral framing of ESG policy obscures its inherent potential for harmonizing global justice.

 

Using climate resilience and living wages as a construct of global justice, this paper evaluates the substantive blind-spots of ESG based regulations such as BRSR core, Dodd-Frank Act, the Dutch Child Labour Abolition act, and the French Vigilance Act. We conceptualize ESG as a global justice project that runs on substantive underpinnings dependent on centering voices of vulnerable stakeholders who suffer adverse human rights impacts in global production networks. Climate resilience and living wages are not peripheral ESG indicators but preconditions of global justice, determining who absorbs environmental shocks and who is rendered disposable within global value chains. An ESG framework that measures resilience while ignoring wage security redistributes climate risk downward from capital to labor, and, from Global North to the Global South.

 

Substantively, ESG policy aims to regulate contemporary forms of global capitalism characterized by fragmented global value chains, outsourced production, and fictionalized corporate control, where profit is extracted by shifting social and environmental costs onto extraterritorial sites. ESG reporting seeks to regulate harms that are structurally embedded in global production networks, such as, rampant use of conflict minerals, child labor, forced and bonded labor, wage suppression, and precarious work, and climate vulnerability. These harms disproportionately affect communities in the Global South, specifically informal workers in climate vulnerable regions. ESG must therefore be understood as a justice-oriented intervention, not a voluntary market tool, reinforcing the state’s substantive efforts toward social welfare, justice, and protection of labor, communities, and ecological commons.

 

The paper seeks to offer urgent reflections on the sociopolitical and legal organization of ESG policy which increasingly suggests neoliberal market imperatives which prioritize corporate autonomy through self-regulation beyond the latches of state governance. Such a decentralized ESG-disclosures policy risks reproducing injustices by shifting adaptation onto already precarious actors. Reflecting on integration of climate resilience in ESG laws helps understand why ESG policy shuns functional outcomes, alienating the larger project of global justice through a decontextualized technocratic compliance system based on fulfilling indices and metrics system.

CO-AUTHORS
Anurag Srivastava (Pandit Deendayal Energy University)
ABSTRACT

India’s environmental governance is increasingly shaped by the interaction between state-led sustainability policies and corporate Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) disclosure regimes. The BioE3 (Biotechnology for Economy, Environment, and Employment) Policy represents a key intervention in this landscape, promoting biotechnology-led industrial growth through sustainability narratives such as net-zero transitions, circular bioeconomy models, and reduced environmental impact. However, the policy provides limited clarity on how these sustainability objectives are translated into measurable environmental accountability at the firm level.

 

This paper examines the interface between the BioE3 policy framework and ESG-based corporate disclosure mechanisms in India to assess how environmental accountability is operationalised in practice. Empirically, the study draws on qualitative document analysis of the BioE3 policy, the Business Responsibility and Sustainability Reporting (BRSR) framework, and environmental disclosures from selected biotechnology and agri-biotechnology firms. The analysis focuses on identifying points of alignment and divergence between policy-level sustainability expectations and disclosure-based accountability requirements.

 

The findings suggest that while BioE3 strongly shapes sustainability narratives adopted by firms, its environmental governance effects are largely mediated through ESG disclosure practices rather than outcome-based performance measurement or enforcement. This creates an accountability structure centred on reporting alignment and reputational signalling, with limited mechanisms to assess substantive environmental outcomes. The paper argues that BioE3 exemplifies an ESG-mediated, hybrid model of environmental governance in which industrial policy influences how sustainability is articulated, but not necessarily how it is verified. By highlighting this policy–disclosure gap, the study contributes to debates on regulation-by-disclosure and the effectiveness of ESG frameworks in India’s evolving environmental governance landscape.