Format

P11. Are Public Policies still Public? Questioning the Relationship between the Public and Private Sector in the Global South

COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Clément Soriat
Center for European Research on Administration, Politics and Society (CERAPS) - University of Lille
Main chair
Olivier Provini
Université de La Réunion
Second chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Research in public policy analysis has shown a reconfiguration of the boundaries between the public and the private sector since the 1980s, which is due to the expansion of liberalization policies, the privatization of public companies or even the advent of management standards within public administrations. The “public” character of public policies has been questioned to the effect that the term “governance” has become a recurrent concept for describing the coproduction of policies by a heterogeneous set of public and private stakeholders (Hyden, 1992 ; Kooiman, 2003).
Yet, numerous scholars disprove the idea of the private sector “cannibalizing” the public (Hibou, 2013). The ongoing dynamics would reflect a redefinition of the role of the state rather than provoking its retreat. The decreasing scope of state intervention can instead be considered as a deliberate strategy of adaption to a number of constraints. As a result, new styles of government “by delegation” emerge, whereby the market and the private sector are used as an instrument of a state, whose functions are focused on regulation and incentives (Ansaloni and Smith, 2017). From this point of view, an opposition of the public and private dynamics would be scientifically misleading. Instead, it is crucial to study the intertwining relationships between both sectors.
The intention of this panel is to move the debate about transforming borders between the public and private sectors from empirical fields in the “Global North” to “Southern” contexts, where public stakeholders dispose a priori of fewer human, economic and knowledge-based resources. This empirical shift is even more important, as the limited capacities of states – compared to the North – have been interpreted by several scholars as a decline or even an absence of public policies (Chabal & Daloz, 1999 ; Carment et al., 2010). This intertwining between public management and private interests in Southern contexts has been analyzed by scholars dealing with state-building in Africa (Médard, 1990 ; Bayart, 1989). They tend to argue that these boundaries are even more blurred in African contexts (Ferguson, 2006 ; Hibou, 2012; Harrison, 2005 ; Kelsall, 2013).
Thus, shifting the focus on the Global South seems relevant to reconsider the frontiers between the private and the public sector, to discuss the results stemming from Northern contexts and to move the historical and sociological trajectory of the state at the center of public policy analysis. Whereas the literature on public policy analysis is tending towards an ever-greater hyperspecialization and to untie its approaches from state sociology (Smyrl, 2002 ; Bezes & Pierru, 2012), we argue that studying the public character of public policies in the Global South is crucial for understanding the long-term transformations of the state (Evans et al., 1985).
This panel proposal is part of the research program “Making policies in Africa”, backed by the research laboratory Les Afriques dans le Monde at Sciences Po Bordeaux. However, the panel aims to exceed the initial frame of the project in order to establish new scientific collaborations and to internationalize the exchange on this relevant research question.

CALL FOR PAPERS

Research in public policy analysis has shown a reconfiguration of the boundaries between the public and the private sector since the 1980s. The intention of this panel is to move the debate about these transforming borders from empirical fields in the “Global North” to “Southern” contexts, where public stakeholders dispose a priori of fewer human, economic and knowledge-based resources. This analytical and empirical shift seems relevant to reconsider the frontiers between the private and the public sector, to discuss the results stemming from Northern contexts and to put the emphasis of public policy analysis on the historical and sociological trajectory of the state.
Paper proposals may address at least one of the following topics:
1) Circulation of norms and instruments stemming from the “private” sector and their appropriation (transfer, translation, hybridization) in specific policy sectors in the Global South: to what extent do these forms of circulation inform about transforming frontiers between the public and private sector? Looking beyond the technical character of policy reform, how do they contribute to transforming power plays between stakeholders, their visions and representations? Concretely, how is this circulation and hybridization carried out?
2) Circulation of stakeholders between the public and the private sphere: is it possible to identify stakeholder networks at the intersections of these spheres, thereby questioning their separation? In a context of neo-liberal governance new stakeholder configurations are shaping the formulation and the implementation of public policies, whereby the collusion of the private and the public sector are more and more assumed and even promoted. To what extent do these dynamics invite us to reconsider the classical literature about the neo-patrimonial character of states in the Global South?
3) The role of the state in these new configurations. Questioning the traditional boundaries between the public and the private sphere brings us to the question of the changing nature of state intervention, without jumping to the conclusion about the breakdown or the retreat of the state. Given this competitive environment, what do state agents do to retain a predominant role in political and social regulation? How do these relations interact with private stakeholders? Do they derive from competition, partnership or other forms of interaction? Which objectives and common goals possibly bring them together?
4) The history of the relationships between the public and the private sector in the Global South. The aim is to trace back the intertwining of public-private relationships within public policy configurations in a long-term perspective. How have these relationships developed over time? Have they been shaped specifically under the colonial and the postcolonial period? And to what extent have the Structural Adjustment Programs transformed the Global South into a laboratory of neo-liberal reforms for the Global North?
The expected contributions should rely on qualitative and/or quantitative empirical data from a Global South context. Priority will be given to comparative research in order to diversify case studies and to encourage crossed discussions. This panel aims to create new research networks and to lay the ground for common publications.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Blurring boundaries between public and private modes of governance in the water sector Lessons learned from a project on water access in informal settlements of Ouagadougou (Burkina Faso)
catherine baron (LEREPS/Political Science Institute)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

During the 1990's, in the context of the Dublin conference (1992), the water sector was characterized by the implementation of rules related to neoliberal principles (Bakker 2010). The Public Private Partnership (PPP) model was the concrete expression of this “new” logic and public policy analysis focused on the blurring of the line between public and private logics regulating this sector. PPP can be considered as a “travelling model” (Behrends, Park, Rottenburg 2014) and scholars have discussed its dissemination in Africa focusing on water utilities (Balance, Trémolet 2005).

Since the beginning of the 21st century, this model has been criticized not only by those who challenged it from the start but also by those who contributed to spread it (Marin 2009). All around the world, in the Global South but also in Northern countries, governments are taking back control of water services previously contracted out to the private sector. Corporatization is one of the forms this renewed interest in government ownership has taken. According to McDonald (2014), corporatization “refers to the creation of public entities that are fully owned and operated by the state but have a degree of autonomy from the government. […] They often have a corporate structure similar to publicly traded private sector companies”. Water utility is a good example of this new logic. It illustrates the flexible boundaries between public and private logics concerning water governance, and the new role of the State in a different way than in the 1990’s as we’ll demonstrate in the paper.

This evolution of the role of the State can be analysed through the conceptual framework elaborated by scholars in Northern and Southern contexts (Brenner, Theodore 2002 ; Hibou 2013). Two periods can be distinguished: the "roll-back" of the State during the 1980's is synonymous of the withdrawal of the State from the economy and a reduction of public spending; the “roll-out” during the 1990s, responding to the social-spatial tensions and inconsistencies of the neoliberal project, relates to the "regulation" mechanisms established by the State to strengthen the market in the case of market failures. We will discuss if we can consider the emergence of a new era of water utilities governance in the context of the international agenda of Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs, 2015-2030).

 

The Burkina Faso water sector case study is a specific one. It enables us to discuss the public dimension of a public policy in the context of neoliberalism in the Global South using the conceptual framework of public policy analysis (Provini, Darbon 2018). Even if the country depends on international aid and conditionality, the government has apparently always resisted to the privatization of the water sector questioning the idea of the absence of public policy in the Global South. The public water operator, ONEA, is considered as a success story in West Africa if we refer to efficiency criteria (Baron 2014). We will discuss in the first part of our paper the ambiguity of the choices the government has made through the history of the public water operator, ONEA, which can be considered as an example of corporatization. The criteria selected to measure and assess efficiency of the water service will be analysed through a political science analysis focusing on public policy implementation tools. We will then analyse in the second part of our paper a specific project financed by the World Bank and the French Development Agency (AFD) to provide water in informal neighbourhoods of the capital city, Ouagadougou (Hydroconseil 2013 ; Baron et al. 2016). The public operator sells water to small private operators (SPO) who manage decentralized water networks in urban areas where the public operator cannot provide this basic service. This original experience reflects the blurring boundaries between private (SPO) and public (ONEA) logics.

Through this case study we are able to accurately document the long term transformations of the Burkina Faso state through its water policy and the tensions between international recommendations and its own agenda.

 

Key words: Public policies, Water sector, Public private partnerships, Informal settlements, Burkina Faso

 

References

Bakker, K. 2010. Privatizing Water. Governance Failure and the World's Urban Water Crisis, Cornell University Press.

Balance, T., Trémolet, S. 2005. Private sector participation in urban water supply in Sub-Saharan Africa, London: GIZ and KFW.

Baron, C. 2014. « Hybrid Water Governance in Burkina Faso : the ONEA experience”, in McDonald D. (dir.), Rethinking Corporatization and Public Services in the Global South, London&New York, Zed Press, 62-87.

Baron, C. Bonnassieux, A. Bontianti, A. 2016. «Eau des villes, assainissement et précarités : Des réalités contrastées à Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso et Niamey, Niger», Paris, Editions AFD, Notes techniques-Coll Recherches, n°19, Septembre.  http://librairie.afd.fr/nt-19-eau-burkina-niger/

Behrends, A., Park, S.J., Rottenburg, R. 2014. « Travelling Models: Introducing an Analytical Concept to Globalisation Studies », in Travelling Models in African Conflict Management: Translating Technologies of Social Ordering. Africa-Europe Group for Interdisciplinary Studies. Leiden ; Boston: Brill, 1-40.

Brenner, N., Theodore, N. 2002. «Cities and the Geographies of “Actually Existing Neoliberalism”», Antipode, 34 (3), 349-379.

Hibou, B. 2013. La bureaucratisation néolibérale, Paris, La Découverte, Collection Recherches.

Hydroconseil. 2013. “Evaluation du projet pilote de la délégation de gestion dans cinq quartiers périphériques non lotis de Ouagadougou dans la perspective d’amélioration du service pour les plus défavorisés”. Rapport final. 31 janvier. 100 pages.

Marin, P. 2009. “Public-Private Partnerships for Urban Water Utilities – A Review of Experiences in Developing Countries”, World Bank Publications/PPIAF, Washington, Trends and Policy opinions, n°8.

McDonald, D. (dir.) 2014. Rethinking Corporatization and Public Services in the Global South, London&New York, Zed Press.

Provini, O., Darbon, D. (dir) 2018. “Penser l’action publique en contextes africains. Les enjeux d’une décentration”, Gouvernement et action publique, 2018/2, n°2.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - The Indispensable Role of International Human Rights Organizations in Strengthening CSOs
Muhammad Faraz (University of Massachusetts)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper aims to contribute to the empirical and theoretical debate over the role of international
organizations in shaping domestic policies and institutions including civil society organizations. The research
question addressed here is this: why is it that several semi authoritarian and hybrid regimes in African great lakes,
primarily Kenya, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, and Rwanda, have agreed (Lawrence 2013; Orchard
2016; Kälin and Schrepfer 2012)i to fulfill civil society and NGOs’ demands related to the legal rights of Internally
Displaced Persons while have continually suppressed other sections of civil society organizations (e.g. those
working against female genital mutilation, and freedom of press etc.). It is argued that strong regional (Orchard
2016) and inter-governmental institutional framework of the African Union (Kälin and Schrepfer 2012), and
limited statehood, has enabled a forceful entry and presence of international human rights organizations and
institutions (especially those headquartered in Geneva and New York) that successfully (Fariss 2016)ii lobbied on
behalf of local groups and eventually strengthened local CSOs and rights groups in the long term. The case study
confirms the validity of the wider literatureiii on political opportunity structures and the structural, normative, &
institutional power of International/intergovernmental Organizations in effecting domestic policy change. I will
do extensive literature review for my theoretical understanding of: civic participation, international human rights
regimes, and political-institutional dynamics of African Union countries vis-à-vis
international/intergovernmental organizations. I will also read documents such as: Kampala Pact, Great Lakes
Convention, Fourth Regional Programme of Action on Humanitarian and Social Issues, African Human Rights
Charter, domestic constitutional protections; and policy documents such as the ones by Geneva based Internal
Displacement Monitoring Unit etc. to draw inferences and insights for my conclusion. This paper attends to the
dynamics of institutional, rhetorical and legal-political choices for addressing contemporary human rights
discourse in the global south. The paper also, through present comparative analysis of this issue, contributes to
the study of the third sector both from a public policy and an international relations perspective.

 

 

Juma, Lawrence, “Protection of development-induced internally displaced persons under the African Charter: the case of the Endorois
community of Northern Kenya,” The Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa
Vol. 46, No. 2 (JULY 2013), pp. 211-233
Orchard Phil, “Regionalizing Protection: AU and ASEAN Responses to Mass Atrocity Crimes against Internally Displaced Persons,
Global Responsibility to Protect, Volume 8, Issue 2-3, P. 295 – 326, 2016
Kälin Walter and Schrepfer Nina, “ Internal displacement and the Kampala Convention: an opportunity for development actors,” IDMC under
an initiative by the Global Program on Forced Displacement of the World Bank, (2012): 15
ii CHRISTOPHER J. FARISS, “The Changing Standard of Accountability and the 1 Positive Relationship between Human Rights Treaty 2
Ratification and Compliance,” Cambridge University Press, 2016, pp. 1-33
iii Classical works include Haas 1992; Florini 1996; Finnemore and Sikkink 1998; and Goodman and Jinks 2004. For “Norm Diffusion”
literature in recent empirical studies, see, for example, Greenhill 2010; and Bearce and Bondanella 2007; and Graham, Shipan, and
Volden 2013, Dupuy, Ron et.al 2016, Ron 2004
Also see: Evans Peter, “Collective Capabilities, Culture and Amartya Sen’s Development as Freedom,” Symposium on Development
as Freedom by Amartya Sen, Studies in Comparative International Development, Summer 2002, Vol. 37, No. 2, pp. 59

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Public Transit Governance in the Metropolitan Area of São Paulo: an analysis based on the 2010 Census data and the municipal budgets.
Mauricio Fronzaglia ( Mackenzie Presbyterian University)
CO-AUTHORS
Vladimir Maciel (Universidade Presbiteriana Mackenzie)
ABSTRACT

 

This paper aims to analyze the governance’s challenges in the public transit policies in the Metropolitan Area of São Paulo , based on the 2010 Census data regarding home-to-work commuting, as well as the municipal finances obtained from the Secretariat of National Treasury (SNT). There are any standardization of the transportation services’ quality and its infrastructures in order to allow fluidity and decrease the inter- and intra-municipal commuting time. The economic space and the activities’ distribution do not respect the existing administrative boundaries. It is very common for people to commute between two municipalities. There is not a unified standardized billing system, nor is there an intermodal infrastructure integration, so that the public expenses (both municipal and state) are inefficient. In addition, the governance is affected by the Brazilian federalism that considers cities as federated entities with autonomy and responsibility to implement their own public policies, transportation included.

 

This research consists of the following steps: initially, there are presented the mobility indicators and their spatial distribution patterns, as well as the municipal budget data on transportation. Once the diagnosis is established, there are raised the institutional characteristics of the metropolitan transportation arrangement in São Paulo, as well as the governance practice problems as inter-municipal public policy.

 

The main theoretical approach of this work uses the Political Sociology of Public Action and its three main components: the global sectorial relation (how the public action in the transportation area can be combined with other policies adopted in the municipalities and how they can be integrated in the context of metropolitan interaction), the referential (the legal, institutional and cultural parameters, such as Metropolitan area specific legislation, federative tensions and public budget) and both the actors description and their interaction dynamics in the design and implementation of public transportation policies. Metropolitan governance could, therefore, be described as a continuous articulation exercise in the pursue of balance between needs, interests and relations of cooperation and conflict between the actors involved.

 

The importance of this study can be expressed in the characteristics of RMSP itself: 39 municipalities with their own political and socioeconomic particularities, about 22 million inhabitants, the concentration of the Brazilian industry base and almost 20% of the country's GDP. The cities that make up the Metropolitan area  have very distinct characteristics and include from global cities like São Paulo to tiny towns like Salesópolis. According to official IBGE data, the first, São Paulo’s state capital, concentrates more than 12 million inhabitants, has a GDP of almost US$186,5 billion  and is the financial capital of the country, while the second has less than 20 thousand inhabitants and a GDP of US$ 53  million .

 

Taking some international examples into consideration, one can see that Brazilian institutions are similar to other cases in some ways, but the result is a hybrid pattern that reflects the disarticulation of the transportation policies at intermediate levels of the federal arrangement: both municipal and state.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - The promotion of public-private parnership in a neo-patrimonial context, comparison of two mixt policies in Madagascar
Zoé Tinturier (Science po Bordeaux)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Since the 1990s, financial institutions have increasingly trust in private sector, believing in its ability to solve global problem (WB, 1990; PNUD, 1990, FMI, 1999) The exponential implication of private sector in the construction of public policy have been interpreted by some authors as a retreat of the state, whereas others speak more about a delegation system controlled by public authorities (Hibou, 2013). Institutional institutions have finally follow that trend considering private sector cannot be developed correctly without an adequate institutional public frame. After being criticized with force, multiplication of reports valorises the come back of the state whereas the promotion of public-private partnership promises reconciliation between private and public sectors.

 

Strongly connected to international actors (Roubaud and al, 2017), the Malagasy elites have adopted very early strategic official frames and plans approving those international assets (DCPE, 1999, Banque mondiale, 2005). However, analyses in different areas show that Malagasy state is characterised by neo-patrimonial links, public institutions surviving only because they permit an access to resources for elites' competition (Galibert, 2009, Chartier, 2016). In a context where the category of public and private sectors are permanently scrambled by actors' practices and strategies, it seems meaningless to speak about a reconciliation or coordination of public and private sectors.

 

In this presentation, we want question the impact of the importation of public-private partnership model in a context where the frontier between private and public sphere are not clearly acted and fixed. Based on a comparison of two concrete cases of public-private partnership set up in two cities of Madagascar (one in the sector of nutrition in Antananarivo, another in the waste sector in Tamatave), we want to observe the forms of institutionalisation implied by that the promotion of that type of politics in the international scene and the development of new kind of links between public and private actors.

 

We will show that public policies promoted by international actors, locally traduced by national "brokers" (De Sardan, 1993; Nakanabo Diallo, 2013), have favoured the supplying of an "administrative frontage" (Fremiggacci, 2014) which have been kept in live by Malagasy elites over time (Raison Jourde, 1991; Randrianja, 2009; Fremiggaci, 2014). Its renewal thanks to the promotion of private sector has favoured the development of a type of elite who knew how adapts themselves to the entrepreneurship figure promoted in the international areas. The come back of the state in official programs can trigger new types of rivalries with public authorities who are in fact kept at the margins of the policies. The presentation aims at showing the effects of interplays of actors on the shaping of mixt policies gathering international and local actors, entrepreneurs and public authorities.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Who rules the transport of Recife? Institutional configuration of the Urban Mobility Policy of Recife-PE, Brazil.
S. F. SALES RAFAEL (Federal University of Paraíba, Brasil)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In Brazil, the Urban Mobility policies were historically articulated at the national level. But it is at the local level that they are operationalized, and it is up to the Municipalities to organize and provide, either directly or under a concession or permit regime, collective transportation services through concession contracts or permits with private companies. This fact gives the model of supply of urban mobility policy in Brazil a strong characteristic of commodification. Among the existing modalities, the bus stands out as the one with the greater performance of the private market compared to other modes.

 

The model of interaction between the State and companies gave them access to strategic arenas, mainly for the defense of certain sectoral interests, related to tariff protection, incentive and subsidy policies, fomenting industrialization, among others. In other words, the performance of the Brazilian state is strongly influenced by the political influence of the business elites, which relates both to the political, historical and economic development of, and in the specific configuration of the relationship between private and public sectors in Brazilian capitalism. In the specific case of the Urban Mobility policy, this is a process of commodification in the supply of services (especially in the modal bus), accompanied by the reproduction of manifest inequalities in the supply, quality and comfort of the service, as well as in the disparity of influence of business actors in relation to users.

 

In this context, the present work sought to identify the actors that participate in some way of negotiating politics, the negotiation spaces, as well as the main strategies (formal and informal) of exercising power related to the Urban Mobility Policy in the Metropolitan Region of Recife, in the northeastern region of Brazil. It was found that in these negotiation spaces, some individuals may have greater access to government power than others, and may have a greater capacity to implement strategies due to the resources (allocative and/or authority) that are available to them. The research has eminently qualitative character, having as a theoretical-methodological tool the Sociological Neoinstitutionalism and Structuring Theory.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - The Antinomies of Social Policy Making in South Africa and Brazil: Comparative Perspectives from the Global South.
Madalitso Phiri (University of Johannesburg)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

South Africa and Brazil social policy architectures attempt to address the residues of institutional poverty, inequality and unemployment. South Africa’s social assistance programmes has received less attention as inequality is still persistent across strata.  At a heightened period of ‘progressive’ politics (2003—2016), under the PT led government Brazil’s social assistance programmes like the Bolsa Familia was viewed as a model to be emulated across most countries in the Global South. This paper answers two questions: What are the key values and principles underpinning the welfare regimes in the two countries? and which domestic interests and alliances shape social policies? The paper departs from the theoretical prison of studying welfare regimes through Eurocentric lenses, exemplified in the typologies of the welfare regime approach (WRA), liberal, corporatist, and social democratic regimes; and advocates a transformative social policy (TSP) as a paradigm to be considered. The experimentation of social assistance should be examined in the wider social policy architecture which presents new opportunities to comprehend social and political change in the Global South. South Africa and Brazil’s social policies contain ideational and practical antinomies which are discursively discussed by analyzing the role of local and international actors in social policy making; private actors and taxation architecture; and labour contestations. Drawing on original key informant interviews of seven policy makers in both South Africa and Brazil and quantitative public datasets; the paper argues that the shrinking of public sphere in an aggressive capitalist epoch has reconfigured power and social relations which threaten the imagination of a new social compact.  Both countries are not becoming 21st Century developmental states of the Global South; where the social is not displaced from the economy to address institutional inequalities predicated on anti-black racism.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Reflections about subnational public debt for financing metropolitan policies: In the context of the sharing economy
Alain Dimitrius Izquierdo Reyes (Universidad de Guadalajara)
CO-AUTHORS
Juan Diego Omar Martínez Delgado (Universidad de Guadalajara)
ABSTRACT

Main.

 

The expansion of large cities around the world promotes greater growth of the metropolis, in which various municipalities converge. Therefore, urban boundaries between local entities are reduced, which unify in practice in the provision of public and private services to residents. At the same time, the economy is evolving in an accelerated way in its new forms of association and presence, both in the physical and digital world, which increases and scales new possibilities for interaction in the provision of services that test the regulation of these. Therefore, the present study proposal aims to reflect on whether these changes can affect the evolution of public finances in cities. In particular, subnational public debt instruments and sustainability in a context of metropolis and governance. The document purposes to explore aspects of the new economy and trends of the instruments of the collaborative economy in favor of a better efficiency in the provision of services between supply and demand.

 

  

Methodology.

 

This review of instruments and reflections allows us to discuss the opportunity of these to achieve the financing of metropolitan policies, whether with traditional finance tools, or if there is scope for new instruments in the collaborative economy. A great challenge is it studies the essential component of metropolitan public policies: financing. Therefore, it is important to explore sustainable public debt instruments in the subnational scope or other financing tools that free resources to build urban governance in a collaborative environment.

 

Finally, in most cases public budgets are restrictive to integrate the demands of society, these are offered in a public agenda, when these are policies; But when finances are weak and limited, there is a lesser capacity to respond to public problems. Therefore, it is very important to innovate in this sector to maximize resources.

 

The present proposal paper connects with two lines of this panel: 1) The new economy and finance strategy in the context of the metropolis, and 2) Trends and financing instruments for a build a governance in the new economy

 

 

Key words: public debt, subnational, public finance, governance, sharing economy

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - The interdependence of public policies and private interests. The case study of the social policy in the Ivory Coast
Clément Soriat (Center for European Research on Administration, Politics and Society (CERAPS) - University of Lille )
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This communication is based upon a field survey carried out in Ivory Coast. It aims to analyze the socio-historical trajectory of the Ivorian state through the study of a specific policy sector (Universal Health Coverage -UHC -). Thus, beyond its sectoral stakes, the UHC contributes to question the reconfiguration of the boundaries between the public and the private sector. More specifically, I focus on an Ivorian company involved in the implementation of the UHC (SNEDAI). I assume this kind of Public-Private Partnership reflects a redefinition of the role of the state rather than the idea of the private sector “cannibalizing” the public. “Governing by the market”, the state experiments neoliberal instruments and new styles of political regulation. As a result, the historical collusions between political and economic elites are more and more assumed. From this point of view, “governing by the market” does not refer to outsourcing of tasks and responsibilities outside the public sector.  I consider the dynamic more as a flow of resources within a politico-economic space structured by clientelist networks, the process contributing to reinforce the positions of the elites.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

During the 1990's, in the context of the Dublin conference (1992), the water sector was characterized by the implementation of rules related to neoliberal principles (Bakker 2010). The Public Private Partnership (PPP) model was the concrete expression of this “new” logic and public policy analysis focused on the blurring of the line between public and private logics regulating this sector. PPP can be considered as a “travelling model” (Behrends, Park, Rottenburg 2014) and scholars have discussed its dissemination in Africa focusing on water utilities (Balance, Trémolet 2005).

Since the beginning of the 21st century, this model has been criticized not only by those who challenged it from the start but also by those who contributed to spread it (Marin 2009). All around the world, in the Global South but also in Northern countries, governments are taking back control of water services previously contracted out to the private sector. Corporatization is one of the forms this renewed interest in government ownership has taken. According to McDonald (2014), corporatization “refers to the creation of public entities that are fully owned and operated by the state but have a degree of autonomy from the government. […] They often have a corporate structure similar to publicly traded private sector companies”. Water utility is a good example of this new logic. It illustrates the flexible boundaries between public and private logics concerning water governance, and the new role of the State in a different way than in the 1990’s as we’ll demonstrate in the paper.

This evolution of the role of the State can be analysed through the conceptual framework elaborated by scholars in Northern and Southern contexts (Brenner, Theodore 2002 ; Hibou 2013). Two periods can be distinguished: the "roll-back" of the State during the 1980's is synonymous of the withdrawal of the State from the economy and a reduction of public spending; the “roll-out” during the 1990s, responding to the social-spatial tensions and inconsistencies of the neoliberal project, relates to the "regulation" mechanisms established by the State to strengthen the market in the case of market failures. We will discuss if we can consider the emergence of a new era of water utilities governance in the context of the international agenda of Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs, 2015-2030).

 

The Burkina Faso water sector case study is a specific one. It enables us to discuss the public dimension of a public policy in the context of neoliberalism in the Global South using the conceptual framework of public policy analysis (Provini, Darbon 2018). Even if the country depends on international aid and conditionality, the government has apparently always resisted to the privatization of the water sector questioning the idea of the absence of public policy in the Global South. The public water operator, ONEA, is considered as a success story in West Africa if we refer to efficiency criteria (Baron 2014). We will discuss in the first part of our paper the ambiguity of the choices the government has made through the history of the public water operator, ONEA, which can be considered as an example of corporatization. The criteria selected to measure and assess efficiency of the water service will be analysed through a political science analysis focusing on public policy implementation tools. We will then analyse in the second part of our paper a specific project financed by the World Bank and the French Development Agency (AFD) to provide water in informal neighbourhoods of the capital city, Ouagadougou (Hydroconseil 2013 ; Baron et al. 2016). The public operator sells water to small private operators (SPO) who manage decentralized water networks in urban areas where the public operator cannot provide this basic service. This original experience reflects the blurring boundaries between private (SPO) and public (ONEA) logics.

Through this case study we are able to accurately document the long term transformations of the Burkina Faso state through its water policy and the tensions between international recommendations and its own agenda.

 

Key words: Public policies, Water sector, Public private partnerships, Informal settlements, Burkina Faso

 

References

Bakker, K. 2010. Privatizing Water. Governance Failure and the World's Urban Water Crisis, Cornell University Press.

Balance, T., Trémolet, S. 2005. Private sector participation in urban water supply in Sub-Saharan Africa, London: GIZ and KFW.

Baron, C. 2014. « Hybrid Water Governance in Burkina Faso : the ONEA experience”, in McDonald D. (dir.), Rethinking Corporatization and Public Services in the Global South, London&New York, Zed Press, 62-87.

Baron, C. Bonnassieux, A. Bontianti, A. 2016. «Eau des villes, assainissement et précarités : Des réalités contrastées à Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso et Niamey, Niger», Paris, Editions AFD, Notes techniques-Coll Recherches, n°19, Septembre.  http://librairie.afd.fr/nt-19-eau-burkina-niger/

Behrends, A., Park, S.J., Rottenburg, R. 2014. « Travelling Models: Introducing an Analytical Concept to Globalisation Studies », in Travelling Models in African Conflict Management: Translating Technologies of Social Ordering. Africa-Europe Group for Interdisciplinary Studies. Leiden ; Boston: Brill, 1-40.

Brenner, N., Theodore, N. 2002. «Cities and the Geographies of “Actually Existing Neoliberalism”», Antipode, 34 (3), 349-379.

Hibou, B. 2013. La bureaucratisation néolibérale, Paris, La Découverte, Collection Recherches.

Hydroconseil. 2013. “Evaluation du projet pilote de la délégation de gestion dans cinq quartiers périphériques non lotis de Ouagadougou dans la perspective d’amélioration du service pour les plus défavorisés”. Rapport final. 31 janvier. 100 pages.

Marin, P. 2009. “Public-Private Partnerships for Urban Water Utilities – A Review of Experiences in Developing Countries”, World Bank Publications/PPIAF, Washington, Trends and Policy opinions, n°8.

McDonald, D. (dir.) 2014. Rethinking Corporatization and Public Services in the Global South, London&New York, Zed Press.

Provini, O., Darbon, D. (dir) 2018. “Penser l’action publique en contextes africains. Les enjeux d’une décentration”, Gouvernement et action publique, 2018/2, n°2.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper aims to contribute to the empirical and theoretical debate over the role of international
organizations in shaping domestic policies and institutions including civil society organizations. The research
question addressed here is this: why is it that several semi authoritarian and hybrid regimes in African great lakes,
primarily Kenya, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, and Rwanda, have agreed (Lawrence 2013; Orchard
2016; Kälin and Schrepfer 2012)i to fulfill civil society and NGOs’ demands related to the legal rights of Internally
Displaced Persons while have continually suppressed other sections of civil society organizations (e.g. those
working against female genital mutilation, and freedom of press etc.). It is argued that strong regional (Orchard
2016) and inter-governmental institutional framework of the African Union (Kälin and Schrepfer 2012), and
limited statehood, has enabled a forceful entry and presence of international human rights organizations and
institutions (especially those headquartered in Geneva and New York) that successfully (Fariss 2016)ii lobbied on
behalf of local groups and eventually strengthened local CSOs and rights groups in the long term. The case study
confirms the validity of the wider literatureiii on political opportunity structures and the structural, normative, &
institutional power of International/intergovernmental Organizations in effecting domestic policy change. I will
do extensive literature review for my theoretical understanding of: civic participation, international human rights
regimes, and political-institutional dynamics of African Union countries vis-à-vis
international/intergovernmental organizations. I will also read documents such as: Kampala Pact, Great Lakes
Convention, Fourth Regional Programme of Action on Humanitarian and Social Issues, African Human Rights
Charter, domestic constitutional protections; and policy documents such as the ones by Geneva based Internal
Displacement Monitoring Unit etc. to draw inferences and insights for my conclusion. This paper attends to the
dynamics of institutional, rhetorical and legal-political choices for addressing contemporary human rights
discourse in the global south. The paper also, through present comparative analysis of this issue, contributes to
the study of the third sector both from a public policy and an international relations perspective.

 

 

Juma, Lawrence, “Protection of development-induced internally displaced persons under the African Charter: the case of the Endorois
community of Northern Kenya,” The Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa
Vol. 46, No. 2 (JULY 2013), pp. 211-233
Orchard Phil, “Regionalizing Protection: AU and ASEAN Responses to Mass Atrocity Crimes against Internally Displaced Persons,
Global Responsibility to Protect, Volume 8, Issue 2-3, P. 295 – 326, 2016
Kälin Walter and Schrepfer Nina, “ Internal displacement and the Kampala Convention: an opportunity for development actors,” IDMC under
an initiative by the Global Program on Forced Displacement of the World Bank, (2012): 15
ii CHRISTOPHER J. FARISS, “The Changing Standard of Accountability and the 1 Positive Relationship between Human Rights Treaty 2
Ratification and Compliance,” Cambridge University Press, 2016, pp. 1-33
iii Classical works include Haas 1992; Florini 1996; Finnemore and Sikkink 1998; and Goodman and Jinks 2004. For “Norm Diffusion”
literature in recent empirical studies, see, for example, Greenhill 2010; and Bearce and Bondanella 2007; and Graham, Shipan, and
Volden 2013, Dupuy, Ron et.al 2016, Ron 2004
Also see: Evans Peter, “Collective Capabilities, Culture and Amartya Sen’s Development as Freedom,” Symposium on Development
as Freedom by Amartya Sen, Studies in Comparative International Development, Summer 2002, Vol. 37, No. 2, pp. 59

CO-AUTHORS
Vladimir Maciel (Universidade Presbiteriana Mackenzie)
ABSTRACT

 

This paper aims to analyze the governance’s challenges in the public transit policies in the Metropolitan Area of São Paulo , based on the 2010 Census data regarding home-to-work commuting, as well as the municipal finances obtained from the Secretariat of National Treasury (SNT). There are any standardization of the transportation services’ quality and its infrastructures in order to allow fluidity and decrease the inter- and intra-municipal commuting time. The economic space and the activities’ distribution do not respect the existing administrative boundaries. It is very common for people to commute between two municipalities. There is not a unified standardized billing system, nor is there an intermodal infrastructure integration, so that the public expenses (both municipal and state) are inefficient. In addition, the governance is affected by the Brazilian federalism that considers cities as federated entities with autonomy and responsibility to implement their own public policies, transportation included.

 

This research consists of the following steps: initially, there are presented the mobility indicators and their spatial distribution patterns, as well as the municipal budget data on transportation. Once the diagnosis is established, there are raised the institutional characteristics of the metropolitan transportation arrangement in São Paulo, as well as the governance practice problems as inter-municipal public policy.

 

The main theoretical approach of this work uses the Political Sociology of Public Action and its three main components: the global sectorial relation (how the public action in the transportation area can be combined with other policies adopted in the municipalities and how they can be integrated in the context of metropolitan interaction), the referential (the legal, institutional and cultural parameters, such as Metropolitan area specific legislation, federative tensions and public budget) and both the actors description and their interaction dynamics in the design and implementation of public transportation policies. Metropolitan governance could, therefore, be described as a continuous articulation exercise in the pursue of balance between needs, interests and relations of cooperation and conflict between the actors involved.

 

The importance of this study can be expressed in the characteristics of RMSP itself: 39 municipalities with their own political and socioeconomic particularities, about 22 million inhabitants, the concentration of the Brazilian industry base and almost 20% of the country's GDP. The cities that make up the Metropolitan area  have very distinct characteristics and include from global cities like São Paulo to tiny towns like Salesópolis. According to official IBGE data, the first, São Paulo’s state capital, concentrates more than 12 million inhabitants, has a GDP of almost US$186,5 billion  and is the financial capital of the country, while the second has less than 20 thousand inhabitants and a GDP of US$ 53  million .

 

Taking some international examples into consideration, one can see that Brazilian institutions are similar to other cases in some ways, but the result is a hybrid pattern that reflects the disarticulation of the transportation policies at intermediate levels of the federal arrangement: both municipal and state.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Since the 1990s, financial institutions have increasingly trust in private sector, believing in its ability to solve global problem (WB, 1990; PNUD, 1990, FMI, 1999) The exponential implication of private sector in the construction of public policy have been interpreted by some authors as a retreat of the state, whereas others speak more about a delegation system controlled by public authorities (Hibou, 2013). Institutional institutions have finally follow that trend considering private sector cannot be developed correctly without an adequate institutional public frame. After being criticized with force, multiplication of reports valorises the come back of the state whereas the promotion of public-private partnership promises reconciliation between private and public sectors.

 

Strongly connected to international actors (Roubaud and al, 2017), the Malagasy elites have adopted very early strategic official frames and plans approving those international assets (DCPE, 1999, Banque mondiale, 2005). However, analyses in different areas show that Malagasy state is characterised by neo-patrimonial links, public institutions surviving only because they permit an access to resources for elites' competition (Galibert, 2009, Chartier, 2016). In a context where the category of public and private sectors are permanently scrambled by actors' practices and strategies, it seems meaningless to speak about a reconciliation or coordination of public and private sectors.

 

In this presentation, we want question the impact of the importation of public-private partnership model in a context where the frontier between private and public sphere are not clearly acted and fixed. Based on a comparison of two concrete cases of public-private partnership set up in two cities of Madagascar (one in the sector of nutrition in Antananarivo, another in the waste sector in Tamatave), we want to observe the forms of institutionalisation implied by that the promotion of that type of politics in the international scene and the development of new kind of links between public and private actors.

 

We will show that public policies promoted by international actors, locally traduced by national "brokers" (De Sardan, 1993; Nakanabo Diallo, 2013), have favoured the supplying of an "administrative frontage" (Fremiggacci, 2014) which have been kept in live by Malagasy elites over time (Raison Jourde, 1991; Randrianja, 2009; Fremiggaci, 2014). Its renewal thanks to the promotion of private sector has favoured the development of a type of elite who knew how adapts themselves to the entrepreneurship figure promoted in the international areas. The come back of the state in official programs can trigger new types of rivalries with public authorities who are in fact kept at the margins of the policies. The presentation aims at showing the effects of interplays of actors on the shaping of mixt policies gathering international and local actors, entrepreneurs and public authorities.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In Brazil, the Urban Mobility policies were historically articulated at the national level. But it is at the local level that they are operationalized, and it is up to the Municipalities to organize and provide, either directly or under a concession or permit regime, collective transportation services through concession contracts or permits with private companies. This fact gives the model of supply of urban mobility policy in Brazil a strong characteristic of commodification. Among the existing modalities, the bus stands out as the one with the greater performance of the private market compared to other modes.

 

The model of interaction between the State and companies gave them access to strategic arenas, mainly for the defense of certain sectoral interests, related to tariff protection, incentive and subsidy policies, fomenting industrialization, among others. In other words, the performance of the Brazilian state is strongly influenced by the political influence of the business elites, which relates both to the political, historical and economic development of, and in the specific configuration of the relationship between private and public sectors in Brazilian capitalism. In the specific case of the Urban Mobility policy, this is a process of commodification in the supply of services (especially in the modal bus), accompanied by the reproduction of manifest inequalities in the supply, quality and comfort of the service, as well as in the disparity of influence of business actors in relation to users.

 

In this context, the present work sought to identify the actors that participate in some way of negotiating politics, the negotiation spaces, as well as the main strategies (formal and informal) of exercising power related to the Urban Mobility Policy in the Metropolitan Region of Recife, in the northeastern region of Brazil. It was found that in these negotiation spaces, some individuals may have greater access to government power than others, and may have a greater capacity to implement strategies due to the resources (allocative and/or authority) that are available to them. The research has eminently qualitative character, having as a theoretical-methodological tool the Sociological Neoinstitutionalism and Structuring Theory.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

South Africa and Brazil social policy architectures attempt to address the residues of institutional poverty, inequality and unemployment. South Africa’s social assistance programmes has received less attention as inequality is still persistent across strata.  At a heightened period of ‘progressive’ politics (2003—2016), under the PT led government Brazil’s social assistance programmes like the Bolsa Familia was viewed as a model to be emulated across most countries in the Global South. This paper answers two questions: What are the key values and principles underpinning the welfare regimes in the two countries? and which domestic interests and alliances shape social policies? The paper departs from the theoretical prison of studying welfare regimes through Eurocentric lenses, exemplified in the typologies of the welfare regime approach (WRA), liberal, corporatist, and social democratic regimes; and advocates a transformative social policy (TSP) as a paradigm to be considered. The experimentation of social assistance should be examined in the wider social policy architecture which presents new opportunities to comprehend social and political change in the Global South. South Africa and Brazil’s social policies contain ideational and practical antinomies which are discursively discussed by analyzing the role of local and international actors in social policy making; private actors and taxation architecture; and labour contestations. Drawing on original key informant interviews of seven policy makers in both South Africa and Brazil and quantitative public datasets; the paper argues that the shrinking of public sphere in an aggressive capitalist epoch has reconfigured power and social relations which threaten the imagination of a new social compact.  Both countries are not becoming 21st Century developmental states of the Global South; where the social is not displaced from the economy to address institutional inequalities predicated on anti-black racism.

CO-AUTHORS
Juan Diego Omar Martínez Delgado (Universidad de Guadalajara)
ABSTRACT

Main.

 

The expansion of large cities around the world promotes greater growth of the metropolis, in which various municipalities converge. Therefore, urban boundaries between local entities are reduced, which unify in practice in the provision of public and private services to residents. At the same time, the economy is evolving in an accelerated way in its new forms of association and presence, both in the physical and digital world, which increases and scales new possibilities for interaction in the provision of services that test the regulation of these. Therefore, the present study proposal aims to reflect on whether these changes can affect the evolution of public finances in cities. In particular, subnational public debt instruments and sustainability in a context of metropolis and governance. The document purposes to explore aspects of the new economy and trends of the instruments of the collaborative economy in favor of a better efficiency in the provision of services between supply and demand.

 

  

Methodology.

 

This review of instruments and reflections allows us to discuss the opportunity of these to achieve the financing of metropolitan policies, whether with traditional finance tools, or if there is scope for new instruments in the collaborative economy. A great challenge is it studies the essential component of metropolitan public policies: financing. Therefore, it is important to explore sustainable public debt instruments in the subnational scope or other financing tools that free resources to build urban governance in a collaborative environment.

 

Finally, in most cases public budgets are restrictive to integrate the demands of society, these are offered in a public agenda, when these are policies; But when finances are weak and limited, there is a lesser capacity to respond to public problems. Therefore, it is very important to innovate in this sector to maximize resources.

 

The present proposal paper connects with two lines of this panel: 1) The new economy and finance strategy in the context of the metropolis, and 2) Trends and financing instruments for a build a governance in the new economy

 

 

Key words: public debt, subnational, public finance, governance, sharing economy

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This communication is based upon a field survey carried out in Ivory Coast. It aims to analyze the socio-historical trajectory of the Ivorian state through the study of a specific policy sector (Universal Health Coverage -UHC -). Thus, beyond its sectoral stakes, the UHC contributes to question the reconfiguration of the boundaries between the public and the private sector. More specifically, I focus on an Ivorian company involved in the implementation of the UHC (SNEDAI). I assume this kind of Public-Private Partnership reflects a redefinition of the role of the state rather than the idea of the private sector “cannibalizing” the public. “Governing by the market”, the state experiments neoliberal instruments and new styles of political regulation. As a result, the historical collusions between political and economic elites are more and more assumed. From this point of view, “governing by the market” does not refer to outsourcing of tasks and responsibilities outside the public sector.  I consider the dynamic more as a flow of resources within a politico-economic space structured by clientelist networks, the process contributing to reinforce the positions of the elites.