Format

P03. Designing Effective Policies to Trigger Technological Innovation

SCIENCE, INTERNET AND TECHNOLOGY POLICY
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Sebastian Sewerin
Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Zurich
Main chair
Tobias Schmidt
ETH Zurich
Second chair
Michael Howlett
Simon Fraser University
Third chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
SCIENCE, INTERNET AND TECHNOLOGY POLICY
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Technological innovation is considered a key lever for tackling persistent and complex societal problems, such as the transition to low-carbon energy technology in order to mitigate climate change or fostering medical innovation to tackle persistent health challenges. Also, technological innovation is a key driver behind the competition between states and world regions for industry leadership in future lead technologies, such as the EU’s policy strategy to catch up with East Asia in energy storage technologies (Beuse et al. 2018). While it is well established in the literature that public policy has a strong influence on technological change (e.g., Mowery 1983, Mazzucato 2015), how to design effective policies for steering technological innovation remains a central challenge for policy design and policy designers at all levels of policy-making. While the older literature on policy effectiveness related to technological innovation revolved around questions of instrument choice (i.e., what is the best instrument to foster innovation) (e.g., Carley 2011), more recent empirical investigations have turned attention instead to investigating the effect of policy design choices on lower levels of abstraction (i.e., the calibration and settings of policy instruments) (Howlett & Lejano 2012). At the same time, the ‘new’ policy design literature (Howlett 2014; Peters et al. 2018) has called for greater attention to questions of designing, i.e. the processes that lead to the adoption, implementation and subsequent evaluation and (potential) reform.

Studying technology-related policies offers the opportunity to engage with important questions regarding design and designing:

 

I. Technologies can be differentiated along the types of capabilities needed to master innovation: they can be simple or complex in terms of their inherent design and they can be simple or complex in terms of their manufacturing (Schmidt & Huenteler 2016; Huenteler et al. 2016). This conceptualisation of technology-complexity, however, is just beginning to gain traction in empirical policy analysis (e.g., Schmidt & Sewerin 2018). Yet, effective policy design, i.e. the identification of policy design elements that foster technological innovation, requires a solid understanding of technology-complexity. Also, policy design has to address the problem of lock-in of technology choices (Hoppmann et al. 2013; Sandén & Azar 2005; Schmidt et al. 2016) while balancing general uncertainty about technologies’ future development (Hoppmann et al. 2014). Thus, questions of effective policy design, i.e. finding the best policy instrumentation and design, remain pertinent.

 

II. Designing technology-related policies also involves potentially very conflictual policy-making processes: emerging or sufficiently developed technologies can pose a direct threat to powerful incumbents, impeding the political feasibility of policy action. Crucially, these threats to incumbents often are policy-induced, i.e. are feedback effects of previous policy decisions (Schmidt & Sewerin 2017; Meckling et al. 2015) Yet, the role of actors and agency in such long-term policy feedback loops is not well established, particularly since the role of actors and agency in the initial designing of technology-specific policies and the feedback effects of policy-induced technological change on politics are seldom studied systematically. Since public policy plays a huge role for technological change, the field of technology-related policy is particularly suited to study the relationship between agency in the designing of policies and policy-induced real-world changes.

 

Overall, policy design and designing in the field of technology policy is far from routine, making it a fascinating area of investigation for researchers interested in effective policy design. (See the Call for Papers for more specific research questions we’re interested in.)

 

Literature

· Beuse, M., Schmidt, T. S., & Wood, V. (2018). A “technology-smart” battery policy strategy for Europe. Science, 361(6407), 1075-1077.

· Carley, S. (2011). The era of state energy policy innovation: A review of policy instruments. Review of Policy Research, 28(3), 265-294.

· Hoppmann, J., Peters, M., Schneider, M., & Hoffmann, V. H. (2013). The two faces of market support—How deployment policies affect technological exploration and exploitation in the solar photovoltaic industry. Research Policy, 42(4), 989-1003.

· Hoppmann, J., Huenteler, J., & Girod, B. (2014). Compulsive policy-making—The evolution of the German feed-in tariff system for solar photovoltaic power. Research policy, 43(8), 1422-1441.

· Howlett, M., & Lejano, R. P. (2013). Tales from the crypt: The rise and fall (and rebirth?) of policy design. Administration & Society, 45(3), 357-381.

· Howlett, M. (2014). From the ‘old’ to the ‘new’ policy design: design thinking beyond markets and collaborative governance. Policy Sciences, 47(3), 187-207.

· Huenteler, J., Schmidt, T. S., Ossenbrink, J., & Hoffmann, V. H. (2016). Technology life-cycles in the energy sector—Technological characteristics and the role of deployment for innovation. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 104, 102-121.

· Mazzucato, M. (2015). The entrepreneurial state: Debunking public vs. private sector myths (Vol. 1). Anthem Press.

· Meckling, J., Kelsey, N., Biber, E., & Zysman, J. (2015). Winning coalitions for climate policy. Science, 349(6253), 1170-1171.

· Mowery, D. C. (1983). Economic theory and government technology policy. Policy sciences, 16(1), 27-43.

· Peters, B. G., Capano, G., Howlett, M., Mukherjee, I., Chou, M. H., & Ravinet, P. (2018). Designing for Policy Effectiveness: Defining and Understanding a Concept. Cambridge University Press.

· Sandén, B. A., & Azar, C. (2005). Near-term technology policies for long-term climate targets—economy wide versus technology specific approaches. Energy policy, 33(12), 1557-1576.

· Schmidt, T. S., & Huenteler, J. (2016). Anticipating industry localization effects of clean technology deployment policies in developing countries. Global Environmental Change, 38, 8-20.

· Schmidt, T. S., & Sewerin, S. (2017). Technology as a driver of climate and energy politics. Nature Energy, 2(6), 17084.

· Schmidt, T. S., & Sewerin, S. (2018). Measuring the temporal dynamics of policy mixes–An empirical analysis of renewable energy policy mixes’ balance and design features in nine countries. Research Policy.

· Schmidt, T. S., Battke, B., Grosspietsch, D., & Hoffmann, V. H. (2016). Do deployment policies pick technologies by (not) picking applications?—A simulation of investment decisions in technologies with multiple applications. Research Policy, 45(10), 1965-1983.

CALL FOR PAPERS

There are a number of gaps in the literature on technology-related policy design, two of which we seek to address in this panel: the design of effective policies for fostering technological innovation remains challenging given the varying complexity of technologies and the role of actors and agency in designing policies remains elusive (see the description of the panel). Against this background, we invite empirical as well as conceptual contributions, comparative or single-case studies relating (but not limited) to these topics:

I. How does policy design accommodate technology differences? What are possible policy designs to foster (innovation in) technologies of varying degrees of complexity? Are there country or sector specific patterns of technology policy design?

II. How effective are policy designs for technological innovation? What kind of interventions are most effective? Are policy design choices at lower levels of abstraction (policy calibrations) more important than design choices at higher levels (policy instruments and policy instrument logics)?

III. What is the role of actors and agency in the designing of technology-related policies? What are motivations and/or strategies of actors during the policy design phase? Do actors have long-term strategies aiming at picking their preferred technologies over others or are they technology-agnostic? What is the role of policy entrepreneurs, advocacy coalitions or design coalitions?

IV. What are the feedback effects of policy-induced technological change on subsequent politics and policy dynamics? What are the precise mechanisms behind these feedback effects? Can feedback effects (or path-dependency) be designed?

V. What is the role of ideas and learning for the design and designing of technology-related policies? Do actors have established ideas or beliefs about technologies that are fixed or are these ideas or beliefs open to learning? Over time, do actors gain a better understanding of the feedback effects their previous design choices have induced and do they apply these insights to subsequent policy design loops?

VI. How does policy design accommodate the spillover of technologies from other sectors or countries? Do policy-makers build on policy designs from these sectors or countries or do they build on established practices in their sector or policy field?

VII. Does improving the efficiency of existing technologies constitute a specific challenge for policy design(ers)? How can policy design address the challenge of updating existing (public or private) technological infrastructure? What is the role of regulation vs. voluntary measures or incentives for effective policy design for increasing efficiency?

 

We welcome contributions from any scientific background – but are particularly interested in attempts to bridge literature and/or insights from different fields, e.g. innovation studies and public policy/policy design studies.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Technological Innovation and Emission Permits Trading Instruments
Aviel Verbruggen (University of Antwerp)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Research question: What was, is, and may be the contribution of emissions trading to low-carbon innovations in the energy and industrial sectors.

 

Methodology: Long-time (20 years) observation of the designing and constructing of EU’s climate policy flagship: the ETS (Emission Trading Scheme/System). Added were comparative studies of the EU ETS with SO2 emissions reduction policies in the U.S. on the one hand, and on the other hand with tradable green certificate systems tried in a few EU countries. The research is multidisciplinary, implying neoclassical economics, political economy, corporate business economics and strategy, and political science.

 

The paper is based on investigating EU’s Emissions Trading System (ETS) and the abundant literature about the topic. A concurrent line of research is dealing with support of renewable power technology development and deployment. The paper focuses on how ETS handles technological innovation.

Several studies revealed the absent or very poor innovation pull impact of the EU ETS. Successful innovations and deployment of wind and PV power generation in Europe were realized by policies in Germany and Denmark outside and mostly in loggerhead with the EU ETS. While cooperatives, households, local communities, maverick companies, scientists, etc. created the renewable power disruption, incumbent electricity companies were ordering coal-fired power stations, not impeded by the EU ETS. Similarly, the industrial sectors continued business-as-usual, harvesting some low-hanging fruit in carbon emission reductions.

 

Neoclassical economics theory and recipes molded the EU ETS. A few salient attributes are directly related to the research questions of T13/P03.

Ad question I: The ETS claims superior cost-effectiveness (least costs) by amalgamating all carbon-emitting activities under a uniform price ruling. This assumes a particular accommodation of technology differences, however not functioning in practice.

Ad question II: Technological innovation is a dynamic phenomenon. The ETS assumes innovations to be mainly (exclusively) price-induced. This assumption is widely spread in the current climate policy debate, by its adoption in the Integrated Assessment Models (IAM) feeding the IPCC Working Group III policy scenarios. The paper clarifies the basic mechanism of price-induced innovation, and offers evidence why it did not deliver the announced results.

Ad question III: Several scholars (e.g., Meckling, 2011) studied the role of actors and agency in the designing of the ETS. The paper will refer to the studies.

Ad question IV: The feedback effects may be described by the repetitive revisions of the EU ETS designs. The last design (Directive 2018) has metamorphosed the instrument from a quantity (cap) driven approach to a price collar setting mechanism. Description and discussion fall beyond the scope of the paper.

Ad question V: Learning is an aspect of the previous question. Interesting is the impact of learning during the design period (1999-2005) of the ETS, from U.S. SO2 emissions policies and from EU Commission promoted Tradable Green Certificates. The paper will refer to available studies.

Ad question VI: The ambition of carbon emissions trading systems is to grow to a global, uniform instrument, amalgamating all (major) emission sources and their related technologies under a single umbrella. The conflict between theoretical mirage and practical considerations is significant.

Ad question VII: The paper will not address this question.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - A quantitative, cross-country evaluation of responsive policy designs to accelerate technology deployment
Alejandro Nuñez-Jimenez (ETH Zurich)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Despite the diversity in the growing number of strategies to decarbonize energy generation and consumption, they all share the need for rapid technology innovation and deployment. Many of the technologies that are essential to such strategies are not experiencing the rate of innovation and speed of diffusion consistent with limiting global warming to below 2°C. Accelerating the decarbonization, thus, requires speeding up the adoption of these technologies.
Deployment policies that aim to foster the uptake of immature technologies through economic incentives, such as feed-in tariffs, have been among the most effective policy tools to boost the growth of clean technologies, such as solar photovoltaics (PV). Similar policies could as well accelerate the diffusion of other technologies, such as energy storage or electric vehicles. However, as several countries abandoned their policies for solar PV after policy costs skyrocketed, concerns about the cost-efficiency of deployment policies have grown larger. The erosion of public support for these policy interventions has eventually slowed down the deployment of these technologies in many European countries.
In order to regain confidence in deployment policies and avoid repeating the mistakes of the past, the design of the policies needs to be revisited. Countries that experienced booming deployment and spiralling policy costs failed to adjust policy incentives quickly and adequately enough to the evolution of deployment and technology prices.
Over the years, policy-makers tried out several policy designs for steering adoption towards the deployment targets while reining policy costs: However, few of these attempts succeeded and even if they worked in one country, they often failed when applied in others. Thus, to exploit the potential of deployment policies for accelerating technology innovation and diffusion across multiple countries, there is a need to identify what policy designs for adjusting incentives over time produce more effective and cost-efficient policies that work in multiple countries.
In this paper, we address this gap with a quantitative, cross-country evaluation of policy designs to adjust a feed-in tariff policy for solar photovoltaics in three European countries: Germany, Spain and Switzerland. These three countries experienced challenging but markedly different evolutions of their solar PV socio-technical systems. Despite using similar policy designs, Germany reached a high level of deployment at moderate policy costs, Spain a low deployment at very high costs, and Switzerland ran into moderate adoption at low policy costs. We use an agent-based model of solar PV adoption to simulate six policy designs in each country, three historical and three novel ones, each with a different degree of responsiveness in the timing and the size of the incentive corrections.
Our study identifies under which factors the use of one policy design or another may be more advisable, providing a wealth of information for future deployment policies targeting technologies such as energy storage, electric mobility, or renewable heating. Furthermore, we reveal the important role of policy responsiveness by comparing policy designs that are able to adapt to a larger or smaller degree to the evolution of the socio-technical system in which they operate.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Designing ‘technology-smart’, self-reinforcing policies: Lithium-ion battery policy and industry localisation
Sebastian Sewerin (Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Zurich)
CO-AUTHORS
Martin Beuse
Tobias Schmidt (ETH Zurich)
ABSTRACT

The transition of the electricity systems is crucial for climate change mitigation. While technological change, in the form of falling costs of renewable electricity technologies as well as better electricity system control and integration technologies, has begun to fundamentally alter the economics of the electricity system (Mitchell 2016), accelerating this transition remains a challenge for policy design. With the recent advent of cheap(er) and more efficient energy storage technologies (Schmuch et al. 2018; Stephan et al. 2016), particularly in the form of lithium-ion (Li-ion) battery cells, the economics of the electricity system will shift further (Malhotra et al. 2016). Li-ion cells will also profoundly impact other energy sectors, i.e. technology will spill over to the transport sector: here, the world market for battery and hybrid electric vehicles is growing rapidly, testing the resilience of the automotive industry, a cornerstone of the economy in Europe and the US with a high share of GDP generated and, even more importantly, high numbers of jobs (Beuse et al. 2018). In other words, while Li-ion battery cells have a high transformative potential, policy intervention in their favour also risks increased resistance from powerful incumbents and overall negative or self-undermining feedback. At the same time, almost all existing Li-ion battery production is situated in East Asia (China, Korea, and Japan), with the US and particularly Europe lagging behind in manufacturing capacity. To seize the opportunities of a future mega-industry, the US and Europe want to catch-up with East Asian manufacturers that have been successful in improving performance and cost of batteries (Beuse et al. 2018). Crucially, for designing policy for the energy transition, these industry policy goals could serve as a lever to create positive feedback that help making transformative policies ‘stick’ (Schmidt and Sewerin 2017). Against this background, we are interested in uncovering whether industry localization goals contribute to a stronger policy mix targeting energy storage.

In our paper, we aim at bringing together technology innovation studies and policy design literature to assess current policy mixes targeting Li-ion batteries. We argue that Li-ion batteries can be regarded as “dually complex” (Huenteler et al. 2016), i.e. a technology that is complex both in design and manufacturing. Such technologies pose a particular challenge for designing effective policy mixes that aim at localizing a manufacturing industry. Based on previous research on technology characteristics (Beuse et al. 2018; Huenteler et al. 2016), we introduce six technology-specific (or “technology-smart”) policy design features that affect the localization of battery manufacturing industries outside of East Asia. We also know from existing research that the general design features of a policy mix (Schaffrin et al. 2015) determine its overall effectiveness (Schmidt and Sewerin 2018). Thus, we aim at assessing both technology-specific and general design features of policy mixes targeting Li-ion batteries. Empirically, we compare, over time (1998 to present), the policy mixes of two large, (quasi-)federal political entities, the US and EU. To also include policy dynamics at the sub-federal level, we include California and the UK as well. Doing so, we contribute to fostering our understanding of how policy mixes aiming at transformative change actually develop over time. Our approach and empirical findings have wide implications for the governance of transitions by highlighting the importance of cross-sectoral policy intervention to nurture and mobilize actor coalitions supporting the transition to a low-carbon energy production system.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Undesired effects of innovation policy on Mexico in non-traditional innovation sectors
Michele Gonzalez Galindo (Secretary of Science, Humanities, Technology and Innovation (SECIHTI))
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The literature on the study of innovation identifies different models which try to explain how the innovation process takes place. Some has identified what can be called the linear, non-linear, mixed, and the network models. It is plausible to argue that linear models of innovation are found more frequently in traditional technology sectors, while non-linear models might be more powerful to explain how sectors of new and disruptive technologies develop. This is due to critical differences of the process of invention, development and risk that are structural to new and disruptive technologies such as biotechnology, nanotechnology and artificial intelligence. This presents a challenge for the public policy of a nation that wants to participate intensely and strategically in order to increase the capabilities of the different agents involved in the generation of innovation. Specially when there is an international movement where the power of the State is retaken as an empowered agent capable of driving innovation. The State is not a passive entity, but a key actor for the development of innovation, as Mazzucato (2013) mentions when referring to the State not only as a corrector of "market failures", but also as a wealth creator and engine of innovation.
 
The principal question of this study is what are the positive and negative effects of implementing a government program based on a homogeneous and linear paradigm of innovation in sectors of non-linear innovation, that is, with critical factors of innovation cycles and processes distinct from the linear knowledge sectors? So, the basic hypothesis is that a public policy that assumes a general paradigm of linear innovation will likely produce a negative final effects in non-traditional technological sectors. This might be the case of Mexico and this paper aims to demonstrate how the public policy model of innovation, historically assuming a linear model of innovation, has had some critical negative and undesired effects on non-traditional technological sectors that are characterized by following non-linear models of innovation.
 
The methodology of this paper is a quantitative and qualitative analyzes of one of the most important instrument of the innovation policy in Mexico, the Innovation Incentive Program (PEI), which promotes investment in innovation in the private sector in Mexico. For this, I select a non-traditional sector of innovation, biotechnology. To identify the impact of the Program on the biotechnology sector, I use the Survey on Technological Research and Development (Module on Biotechnology and Nanotechnology Activities) from INEGI-CONACYT. Through an econometric model it is expected to find the state in which the biotechnology sector is located in Mexico and to evaluate the impact of the PEI on the sector, to compare the effect of the PEI on a traditional and non-traditional sector.
 
Finally, this empirical study fits in the panel of “Designing Effective Policies to Trigger Technological Innovation” because it shows how a bad design of an innovation policy could have undesired effects in innovation sectors that are different from the traditional technology sectors.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Fostering sustainability technological innovation transitions: Five lenses to explain transversal policy mixes’ dynamics in South Africa, 2002-2018
Mapula Tshangela (University of Stellenbosch)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

RESEARCH QUESTION

This paper contributes empirical quantitative analysis of how transversal policy instruments co-evolved to foster sustainability technological innovation transitions. We examine how policy actors, institutions and ideas position the country to take advantage of sustainability technological innovation transitions and policy change- And why? This relates to the conference panel questions on the role of actors and ideas in the design and designing of technology related policies. Understanding the role of actors and ideas in transversal sustainability policy mixes is important as government policy may also be a barrier, particularly existing regulatory framework (Kemp et al., 1998).

 

THEORY

The evolution of sustainability technological innovation policies is investigated using the adapted frameworks multi-level perspective (MLP)-policy regime framework (PRF) overlaps in the context of five lenses on (1) perspectives, (2) stages, (3) dimensions, (4) pathways and (5) types (outcomes) of sustainability transitions (Tshangela and Swilling, 2017). With the lens on type of policy mixes outcomes we provide a complementary quantitative context. The analysis contributes research gaps in measuring the temporal dynamics of policy mixes to include more countries, beyond renewable energy and application to other policy fields (Schmidt and Sewerin, 2018).

 

METHOD

The study is commissioned through a systematic review of academic literature to identify the transversal policies regarded as relevant for sustainability technological innovation efforts between 2002 and 2018 in South Africa. The analysis is conducted of policy mix dynamics (balance and design) of such identified national transversal policy instruments. The intergovernmental panel on climate change and International Energy Agency policies and measures categorization are used as a starting point towards calculating the policy mix balance (IPCC, 2007, Schmidt and Sewerin, 2018). New contribution also includes to adapt the coding scheme for calculating the Index of Policy Activity, in particular scope and objectives such that the coding values are not energy specific but transversal sustainability technology innovations transitions. 

   

PRELIMINARY FINDINGS

Type of policy mix outcomes lens. About thirty-seven transversal sustainability technology innovation transitions related policies in South Africa are identified from a systematic review of academic literature. The policies include the 2002 national research and development strategy, 2008 ten-year innovation plan, 2012 global change research plan and 2018 white paper on science, technology and innovation. In terms of policy mix balance, these four policies represent R&D support policy instrument type. The others include about 26 frameworks, 4 regulations, 3 financial and 2 incentives instrument types with the rest from nine policy instrument types not represented. The policy mix instrument type balance is estimated at 0.46, representing a lower balance (high concentration) of policies across instrument types.

 

A further analysis of these policy instruments mixes design offers an opportunity to better understand South Africa’s economy-tier transversal policies and how they indirectly foster sector, field and technology tiers of specificity within them. This enable a quantitative analysis of transversal policy mixes dynamics. The paper contribute knowledge on the roles of policy actors, institutions and ideas in fostering sustainability technological innovation transitions through transversal policy instruments and mix levels (Schmidt and Sewerin, 2018).

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Entrepreneurship at the Frontier of the Public and Private Technology Sector: The Case of the Institut National d’Optique as Policy Instrument
Mahdi Khelfaoui (University of Ottawa)
CO-AUTHORS
Luc Bernier (University of Ottawa)
Shirley Anne Scharf
ABSTRACT

How to take advantage or generate more entrepreneurship in the public and private sectors has been an issue in the design of technology and innovation policies for sometimes now. Several studies have focused on the various organizations involved in fostering innovation, insisting on their different operating modes, management culture and entrepreneurship. In the public sector,  technological innovation is driven by organizations as diverse as national research laboratories, government agencies, universities, university spin-off incubators, and State-owned enterprises. In the private sector, technological innovation can be fostered by corporate R&D laboratories, start-up firms, R&D intensive SMEs or multinationals. However, boundaries between public and private technology-based entrepreneurship can be fuzzy, especially since innovations are increasingly resulting from academic, industrial and government partnerships and collaboration projects.

 

In this paper, we are interested in a technological organization that operates at the frontier of the private and public sectors. We study the Institut National d’Optique (INO), Canada’s largest center of expertise in optical and photonic technologies, and compare it to the use made of other similar organizations in Europe and North America. Although half-subsidized by public funds and driven by economic development goals, INO operates as a private non-profit organization and demonstrates an entrepreneurial culture that is traditionally associated with private sector behavior. INO’s pivotal position is also reflected in its intimate ties with academic institutions and government bodies, as well as its deep rootedness in Quebec’s industrial base. INO currently employs around 200 scientists and engineers. Since its inception in 1988, it has spun off 33 companies, carried out 77 technology transfers, sold 6000 customized solutions to Canadian and international firms, and produced several hundred scientific papers and nearly 300 patents.

 

The success of INO over the years raises interesting technology policy questions about its management style, organizational structure and entrepreneurial culture. It also raises issues about the use of organizations at the frontier of the public and private technology sectors as technology policy instruments. In order to understand their use, we examine the characteristics of INO, as well as its technological and commercial strategies. More specifically, we want to answer two main questions. First, what kind of entrepreneurship dominates in organizations, such as INO, that operate at the intersection of public and private technology sectors? Second, how is the nature of this entrepreneurship determined or influenced by the different bonds maintained by INO with the academic community, government bodies, and private businesses?

 

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - The dynamics of institutional and technological co-evolution in renewable industries: an agent-based model for the analysis of promotion policies for solar photovoltaic, biomass and wind sources
Andreão Gustavo (PPGE-UFF )
CO-AUTHORS
Miguel Vazquez (PPGE-UFF)
Hallack Michelle (PPGE-UFF)
José Maria F. J. Da Silveira (Institute of Economics, State University of Campinas (IE-UNICAMP))
ABSTRACT

The co-evolution of rules and technology affects policy makers, who make decisions and revise such decisions in an uncertain environment. There exists a relation between policy and technology change regarding renewables (Schmidt and Sewerin 2017). We analyse renewables: specifically solar photovoltaic (solar PV), biomass and wind (Huenteler et al. 2016; Bueno et al. 2014).

 

Energy projects may be regarded as infrastructure projects, being divided in two phases: construction and operation phases. Different phases require different sets of support instruments: in the operation phase, revenue-enhancing mechanisms can be used, e.g. Feed-in tariffs; nevertheless, in the construction phase, financing mechanisms must be used as there is no cash flow. Regarding this, public financing is a key factor, especially in developing countries (Egli, Steffen, and Schmidt 2018; Hochstetler and Kostka 2015; Vazquez et al. 2018).

 

We use an agent-based model (ABM), highlighting the co-evolution of rules and technologies. We analyse the interactions between banks (public and private), energy producers, technology providers, energy users and policy makers. The proposed ABM emphasises feedbacks between agents decisions and outcomes (Ostrom 2005; Vazquez and Hallack 2018).

 

We model five cash-flow support policies: Feed-in tariffs, feed-in premium, quotas, long-term PPAs and carbon tax. We also model three financing scenarios: with focus on public financing, on private financing, and with public banks acting as catalyst for the entry of private financing. Policy makers define the rules of support policies, whereas public and private banks define the rules for agents to access their funds, i.e., the two agents define the rules for accessing cash-flow and financing incentives respectively. Energy providers make investment decisions. Banks decide their propensity to financing fossil, wind, solar PV or biomass technology individually, with Development banks having more than the base probability alongside lower interest rates and more amortisation time (D’Orazio and Valente 2018). Technology providers may innovate based on the more their individual technology is used (Fagiolo and Dosi 2003). We are analysing coherence between beliefs (simplified interpretations of reality) and results; more specifically coherence between policies and technology diffusion. A focus of the proposed ABM is network creation, especially between banks, energy providers and technology providers: banks finance the acquisition of generation technology and the use of a specific technology prompts innovation, as such, banks are ultimately financing innovation. Brazil, Chile, Italy and Germany are our case studies (Gawel et al. 2017; Vazquez et al. 2018).

 

Coherent policies need to be coherent with the context that they are facing, with the other policies and with agents’ beliefs, as such, we are ultimately analysing a problem of coherent decision-making in a complex environment. As such, the paper combines policy analysis with simulation. After analysing our case studies and elucidating the model, we intertwine both analysis by: 1) replicating stylised facts, and 2) clashing the produced results with some alternative scenarios. Understanding how Brazil successfully expanded its biomass and wind sources but not its solar PV source at the same time that Chile expanded its solar PV source would be an example of proposed experiments.

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Approaches to climate neutral electric mobility in India
Annika Bose Styczynski (O.P. Jindal Global University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

For long, the breakthrough of electric vehicles seemed an intractable challenge. All kinds of concerns and reservations were uttered: these vehicles were too expensive, had range issues, would require a separate charging infrastructure, and were not more environmentally friendly than conventional vehicles when running on a power mix dominated by fossil fuels. These perceptions are gradually changing. National and sub-national policy efforts are taking shape, prices for electric vehicles are coming down, and established and new auto manufacturers, energy utilities and other service providers are reconfiguring their activities.

 

With this paper, I intend to disentangle the complexity of the socio-technical transition process to electric vehicles in India (1994-2018) through an event history analysis of structures (actors, institutions, technologies) and corresponding system innovation functions (entrepreneurial activities, knowledge development and knowledge diffusion, guidance of the search, market formation, resource mobilization, and support from advocacy coalitions). The main interest of this research is to better understand major converging drivers toward the market formation of electric vehicles including national and sub-national policy intervention (whether at lower or higher levels of abstraction) and their degree of effectiveness.

 

Preliminary results of the event history analysis show three different phases in the transition to electric vehicles in India. The early-mover entrepreneurial phase (1994-2002) followed by years of apparent inaction (2003-2009) leading to an extended period of predominantly Government driven multi-stakeholder interactions (2010-2018). Especially since 2017, India is at an accelerated stage in the socio-technical transition process toward electric mobility. Nonetheless, niche features such as pilot and demonstration projects continue to dominate the technological innovation system, and e-vehicle registration figures lag far behind what would be needed to reach the NEMMP target of 6-7 million vehicles by 2020. Yet, the past years have been filled with particularly promising signs of cumulative causation which manifest themselves in continued growth in vehicle sales, installed charging stations, and rising levels of renewable energy in the Indian energy mix.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Between Regulatory Parsimony and the Precautionary Principle: Regulatory Governance of Pharmaceutical Nanotechnologies and CRISPR/cas9 Genome Editing
Inna Krachkovskaya (SOAS University of London)
CO-AUTHORS
Alberto Asquer (School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London)
ABSTRACT

The rise of nanotechnologies and modern biotechnology poses formidable regulatory issues. The fast pace of technological development results in streams of innovations whose effects and side-effects may not be completely predictable. Knowledge about these technologies accumulates among researchers and firms while policy-makers, regulatory authorities and the general public may lack fully understand the implications of their applications. While concerns about health and safety call for prudency to embrace new technologies, potential benefits and profitability lure scientists and businessmen to invest into ventures that could result in dramatic technological breakthroughs and commercial blockbusters.
 
Within such scenario, regulatory governance of emerging technologies seems stuck between two opposite tendencies. On the one hand, the concept of regulatory parsimony (US PCSBI 2010) provides a broad guidance for the regulation of emerging technologies, which should be subjected only to as much oversight as it is strictly necessary to ensure safety, security, fairness and justice while carrying out research and developing applications. On the other one, the precautionary principle (EPRS 2015) calls for controlling risky activities even before any scientific evidence proves a causal relationship between the activities and harmful or unwelcome effects. These tendencies provide contrasting ways to frame the issues that arise from emerging technologies, to organise the policy discourse and agenda, and to assess alternative courses of actions to provide a regulatory response to related health and safety concerns.
 
This study aims to explore the relationship between regulatory parsimony and the precautionary principles in the regulatory governance of emerging technologies. Empirically, this study consists of a comparative case study of regulatory arrangements of two particular kinds of emergent technologies, namely pharmaceutical nanotechnologies and CRISPR/cas9 genome editing.The analysis will focus on the efforts that have been exerted to make sense of the implications of the new technologies and to form a shared consensus on how better they should be regulated. Findings from the comparative analysis will provide some evidence to enrich the theorizing of regulatory parsimony and of the precautionary principles in regulatory governance.
 
References
 
EPRS (European Parliamentary Research Services) (2015). The Precautionary Principle: Definitions, Applications and Governance. Retrieved from  http://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/IDAN/2015/573876/EPRS_IDA(2015)573876_EN.pdfon 30/1/2019.
 
US Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues (US PCSBI) (2010). New Directions: The Ethics of Synthetic Biology and Emerging Technologies. Washington, DC. (www.bioethics.gov)

 

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - Governing Data-Driven Innovation in Cyber-Physical Systems: Open Data for Integrated Smart Cities through Regulatory Sandboxes
Masaru Yarime (The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The development of smart cities, increasingly integrating various urban aspects ranging from energy and buildings to transportation and health, depends critically on the availability of and accessibility to data in the relevant sectors. It is hence of particular importance to facilitate efficient and effective collection, diffusion, and utilization of data in creating innovation in cyber-physical systems. Unlike the traditional mode of innovation, which tends to rely on closed, well-established relationships between enterprises in a specific sector, the new mode of data-driven innovation requires open, dynamic interactions with stakeholders possessing different sets of data. There have been few empirical studies, however, that investigates what policy approaches would be effective in stimulating data-driven innovation by facilitating coordination and integration of emerging technologies through open exchange and sharing of data.


This research conducts a case study of Japan to examine in details the process of coordination among novel technologies in the context of increasing integration and interdependence in innovation for smart cities, with implications for policy design. In Japan, proprietary standards among competing providers initially slowed down the development of smart technologies. Eventually the standard of Open Automated Demand Response 2.0 was adopted, following feasibility, interoperability and connectivity testing through close collaboration between major players in the energy industry and the government. The adoption of the common scheme had a significant impact on driving innovation on home and building energy management systems, with smart thermostats, rooftop solar, battery energy storage, and other appliances smoothly integrated through data exchange and sharing.


Novel technologies are rapidly advancing, however, in other sectors related to the Internet of Things, in which virtually everything is getting connected so that many technologies that were formerly operated separately can coordinate with each other efficiently. Various standards, such as ZigBee and Bluetooth Low Energy, are under rapid advancement, leading to a serious need to promote cooperation among relevant actors working in different sectors. The traditional system of government-industry collaboration does not function effectively, as new players including start-ups and entrepreneurs are entering the field of smart cities with innovative technologies that are often developed independently. That poses a serious challenge to policy making, as different sectors have their specific issues and concerns and the policies and regulations to deal with them are not necessarily coordinated with each other, which effectively creates an obstacle to facilitating data exchange and sharing for innovation in integrated smart cities.


The approach of regulatory sandboxes, initially introduced to fintech, has been recently applied to stimulate innovation in other fields by allowing experimental trials of novel technologies in designated geographical or technological domains. Regulatory sandboxes enable greater data availability, accessibility, and usability for innovators by reducing regulatory constraints and uncertainty. This study examines how regulatory sandboxes are implemented to facilitate open data and what impacts are made on innovation in cyber-physical systems such as smart cities. Opportunities and challenges in policy design are explored for stimulating data-driven innovation through compatibility, interoperability, and integration of data while addressing societal concerns about privacy, cyber security, and public safety.

ACCEPTED
Format
11 - Solution Design for the SDG attainment
Rene Kemp (Maastricht University)
CO-AUTHORS
Shyama Ramani (United Nations University - UNU-MERIT)
ABSTRACT

In this paper, we present a model for solution design in the form of actionable guidelines for government-assisted innovation-based development paths to a more sustainable future and SDGs attainment.

Our solution design approach is based on system analysis, capability building, engagement and replication. It starts from the assumption that any stakeholder in the system can provide elements of a solution to a societal problem but since societal systems are complex, no one actor can control the systemic outcomes completely or perfectly – not even the state. Governments have to fine-tune their policies periodically in accordance with the impact of solution designs introduced by public agencies or other actors in the system.

The framework which is termed ‘SISTER’ for easy recall, involves the following  elements. 

First, in order to map the possibilities for change, the system boundaries have to be drawn and the systemic actors of interest have to be identified. This means that the leading actors who will be concerned by any stage or outcome of the process of self-managed transition have to be identified. Their present action possibilities, objectives and constraints have to be mapped and compared against possible action profiles necessary and sufficient for a solution-based transition. An analysis of the sources of lock-in to prevailing practices is part of the analysis Let this step be given by ‘S’ (S for System analysis as a joint task for stakeholders and researchers).

Second, in order to ‘nudge’ the learning process as a precursor for action,  capacity development at the level of government (agencies), knowledge institutes and business actors,  might have to be created and mobilized. Thus, we consider the first three elements of solution design as I, S, T standing for the variables given below:

I – could refer to infrastructure, new institutions or innovation.

S – for social learning that will address the needs for knowledge creation and knowledge transfer or circulation for capacity building, awareness and motivation creation in order to structure the educational needs.

 T- for Technology or technology redesign or better/new utilisation of existing technology.

                Solution designs have to identify the investments necessary to introduce a vector of I,S, T elements to incentivize the transition.

Third, in order to implement the solution design, a variety of engagement strategies, say E, might need to be implemented. These might issue from the state, in the form of regulation or public investment. At the same time, they might come from other actors within the system, in the form of entrepreneurship, intrapreneurship, NGO activity and civil society movements, resulting in contextual-sensitive Replication (R).  

The SISTER approach for solution design draws on Reflexive Monitoring in Action (van Mierlo et al., 2010), Reflexive Iterative Design (Bos et al., 2009) and recommendations about green industrial policy (Rodrik, 2014, Kemp and Never, 2016). The value of the approach is demonstrated by two examples (Genetically modified plant varieties and Eliminating open defecation in India).

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Research question: What was, is, and may be the contribution of emissions trading to low-carbon innovations in the energy and industrial sectors.

 

Methodology: Long-time (20 years) observation of the designing and constructing of EU’s climate policy flagship: the ETS (Emission Trading Scheme/System). Added were comparative studies of the EU ETS with SO2 emissions reduction policies in the U.S. on the one hand, and on the other hand with tradable green certificate systems tried in a few EU countries. The research is multidisciplinary, implying neoclassical economics, political economy, corporate business economics and strategy, and political science.

 

The paper is based on investigating EU’s Emissions Trading System (ETS) and the abundant literature about the topic. A concurrent line of research is dealing with support of renewable power technology development and deployment. The paper focuses on how ETS handles technological innovation.

Several studies revealed the absent or very poor innovation pull impact of the EU ETS. Successful innovations and deployment of wind and PV power generation in Europe were realized by policies in Germany and Denmark outside and mostly in loggerhead with the EU ETS. While cooperatives, households, local communities, maverick companies, scientists, etc. created the renewable power disruption, incumbent electricity companies were ordering coal-fired power stations, not impeded by the EU ETS. Similarly, the industrial sectors continued business-as-usual, harvesting some low-hanging fruit in carbon emission reductions.

 

Neoclassical economics theory and recipes molded the EU ETS. A few salient attributes are directly related to the research questions of T13/P03.

Ad question I: The ETS claims superior cost-effectiveness (least costs) by amalgamating all carbon-emitting activities under a uniform price ruling. This assumes a particular accommodation of technology differences, however not functioning in practice.

Ad question II: Technological innovation is a dynamic phenomenon. The ETS assumes innovations to be mainly (exclusively) price-induced. This assumption is widely spread in the current climate policy debate, by its adoption in the Integrated Assessment Models (IAM) feeding the IPCC Working Group III policy scenarios. The paper clarifies the basic mechanism of price-induced innovation, and offers evidence why it did not deliver the announced results.

Ad question III: Several scholars (e.g., Meckling, 2011) studied the role of actors and agency in the designing of the ETS. The paper will refer to the studies.

Ad question IV: The feedback effects may be described by the repetitive revisions of the EU ETS designs. The last design (Directive 2018) has metamorphosed the instrument from a quantity (cap) driven approach to a price collar setting mechanism. Description and discussion fall beyond the scope of the paper.

Ad question V: Learning is an aspect of the previous question. Interesting is the impact of learning during the design period (1999-2005) of the ETS, from U.S. SO2 emissions policies and from EU Commission promoted Tradable Green Certificates. The paper will refer to available studies.

Ad question VI: The ambition of carbon emissions trading systems is to grow to a global, uniform instrument, amalgamating all (major) emission sources and their related technologies under a single umbrella. The conflict between theoretical mirage and practical considerations is significant.

Ad question VII: The paper will not address this question.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Despite the diversity in the growing number of strategies to decarbonize energy generation and consumption, they all share the need for rapid technology innovation and deployment. Many of the technologies that are essential to such strategies are not experiencing the rate of innovation and speed of diffusion consistent with limiting global warming to below 2°C. Accelerating the decarbonization, thus, requires speeding up the adoption of these technologies.
Deployment policies that aim to foster the uptake of immature technologies through economic incentives, such as feed-in tariffs, have been among the most effective policy tools to boost the growth of clean technologies, such as solar photovoltaics (PV). Similar policies could as well accelerate the diffusion of other technologies, such as energy storage or electric vehicles. However, as several countries abandoned their policies for solar PV after policy costs skyrocketed, concerns about the cost-efficiency of deployment policies have grown larger. The erosion of public support for these policy interventions has eventually slowed down the deployment of these technologies in many European countries.
In order to regain confidence in deployment policies and avoid repeating the mistakes of the past, the design of the policies needs to be revisited. Countries that experienced booming deployment and spiralling policy costs failed to adjust policy incentives quickly and adequately enough to the evolution of deployment and technology prices.
Over the years, policy-makers tried out several policy designs for steering adoption towards the deployment targets while reining policy costs: However, few of these attempts succeeded and even if they worked in one country, they often failed when applied in others. Thus, to exploit the potential of deployment policies for accelerating technology innovation and diffusion across multiple countries, there is a need to identify what policy designs for adjusting incentives over time produce more effective and cost-efficient policies that work in multiple countries.
In this paper, we address this gap with a quantitative, cross-country evaluation of policy designs to adjust a feed-in tariff policy for solar photovoltaics in three European countries: Germany, Spain and Switzerland. These three countries experienced challenging but markedly different evolutions of their solar PV socio-technical systems. Despite using similar policy designs, Germany reached a high level of deployment at moderate policy costs, Spain a low deployment at very high costs, and Switzerland ran into moderate adoption at low policy costs. We use an agent-based model of solar PV adoption to simulate six policy designs in each country, three historical and three novel ones, each with a different degree of responsiveness in the timing and the size of the incentive corrections.
Our study identifies under which factors the use of one policy design or another may be more advisable, providing a wealth of information for future deployment policies targeting technologies such as energy storage, electric mobility, or renewable heating. Furthermore, we reveal the important role of policy responsiveness by comparing policy designs that are able to adapt to a larger or smaller degree to the evolution of the socio-technical system in which they operate.

CO-AUTHORS
Martin Beuse
Tobias Schmidt (ETH Zurich)
ABSTRACT

The transition of the electricity systems is crucial for climate change mitigation. While technological change, in the form of falling costs of renewable electricity technologies as well as better electricity system control and integration technologies, has begun to fundamentally alter the economics of the electricity system (Mitchell 2016), accelerating this transition remains a challenge for policy design. With the recent advent of cheap(er) and more efficient energy storage technologies (Schmuch et al. 2018; Stephan et al. 2016), particularly in the form of lithium-ion (Li-ion) battery cells, the economics of the electricity system will shift further (Malhotra et al. 2016). Li-ion cells will also profoundly impact other energy sectors, i.e. technology will spill over to the transport sector: here, the world market for battery and hybrid electric vehicles is growing rapidly, testing the resilience of the automotive industry, a cornerstone of the economy in Europe and the US with a high share of GDP generated and, even more importantly, high numbers of jobs (Beuse et al. 2018). In other words, while Li-ion battery cells have a high transformative potential, policy intervention in their favour also risks increased resistance from powerful incumbents and overall negative or self-undermining feedback. At the same time, almost all existing Li-ion battery production is situated in East Asia (China, Korea, and Japan), with the US and particularly Europe lagging behind in manufacturing capacity. To seize the opportunities of a future mega-industry, the US and Europe want to catch-up with East Asian manufacturers that have been successful in improving performance and cost of batteries (Beuse et al. 2018). Crucially, for designing policy for the energy transition, these industry policy goals could serve as a lever to create positive feedback that help making transformative policies ‘stick’ (Schmidt and Sewerin 2017). Against this background, we are interested in uncovering whether industry localization goals contribute to a stronger policy mix targeting energy storage.

In our paper, we aim at bringing together technology innovation studies and policy design literature to assess current policy mixes targeting Li-ion batteries. We argue that Li-ion batteries can be regarded as “dually complex” (Huenteler et al. 2016), i.e. a technology that is complex both in design and manufacturing. Such technologies pose a particular challenge for designing effective policy mixes that aim at localizing a manufacturing industry. Based on previous research on technology characteristics (Beuse et al. 2018; Huenteler et al. 2016), we introduce six technology-specific (or “technology-smart”) policy design features that affect the localization of battery manufacturing industries outside of East Asia. We also know from existing research that the general design features of a policy mix (Schaffrin et al. 2015) determine its overall effectiveness (Schmidt and Sewerin 2018). Thus, we aim at assessing both technology-specific and general design features of policy mixes targeting Li-ion batteries. Empirically, we compare, over time (1998 to present), the policy mixes of two large, (quasi-)federal political entities, the US and EU. To also include policy dynamics at the sub-federal level, we include California and the UK as well. Doing so, we contribute to fostering our understanding of how policy mixes aiming at transformative change actually develop over time. Our approach and empirical findings have wide implications for the governance of transitions by highlighting the importance of cross-sectoral policy intervention to nurture and mobilize actor coalitions supporting the transition to a low-carbon energy production system.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The literature on the study of innovation identifies different models which try to explain how the innovation process takes place. Some has identified what can be called the linear, non-linear, mixed, and the network models. It is plausible to argue that linear models of innovation are found more frequently in traditional technology sectors, while non-linear models might be more powerful to explain how sectors of new and disruptive technologies develop. This is due to critical differences of the process of invention, development and risk that are structural to new and disruptive technologies such as biotechnology, nanotechnology and artificial intelligence. This presents a challenge for the public policy of a nation that wants to participate intensely and strategically in order to increase the capabilities of the different agents involved in the generation of innovation. Specially when there is an international movement where the power of the State is retaken as an empowered agent capable of driving innovation. The State is not a passive entity, but a key actor for the development of innovation, as Mazzucato (2013) mentions when referring to the State not only as a corrector of "market failures", but also as a wealth creator and engine of innovation.
 
The principal question of this study is what are the positive and negative effects of implementing a government program based on a homogeneous and linear paradigm of innovation in sectors of non-linear innovation, that is, with critical factors of innovation cycles and processes distinct from the linear knowledge sectors? So, the basic hypothesis is that a public policy that assumes a general paradigm of linear innovation will likely produce a negative final effects in non-traditional technological sectors. This might be the case of Mexico and this paper aims to demonstrate how the public policy model of innovation, historically assuming a linear model of innovation, has had some critical negative and undesired effects on non-traditional technological sectors that are characterized by following non-linear models of innovation.
 
The methodology of this paper is a quantitative and qualitative analyzes of one of the most important instrument of the innovation policy in Mexico, the Innovation Incentive Program (PEI), which promotes investment in innovation in the private sector in Mexico. For this, I select a non-traditional sector of innovation, biotechnology. To identify the impact of the Program on the biotechnology sector, I use the Survey on Technological Research and Development (Module on Biotechnology and Nanotechnology Activities) from INEGI-CONACYT. Through an econometric model it is expected to find the state in which the biotechnology sector is located in Mexico and to evaluate the impact of the PEI on the sector, to compare the effect of the PEI on a traditional and non-traditional sector.
 
Finally, this empirical study fits in the panel of “Designing Effective Policies to Trigger Technological Innovation” because it shows how a bad design of an innovation policy could have undesired effects in innovation sectors that are different from the traditional technology sectors.

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

RESEARCH QUESTION

This paper contributes empirical quantitative analysis of how transversal policy instruments co-evolved to foster sustainability technological innovation transitions. We examine how policy actors, institutions and ideas position the country to take advantage of sustainability technological innovation transitions and policy change- And why? This relates to the conference panel questions on the role of actors and ideas in the design and designing of technology related policies. Understanding the role of actors and ideas in transversal sustainability policy mixes is important as government policy may also be a barrier, particularly existing regulatory framework (Kemp et al., 1998).

 

THEORY

The evolution of sustainability technological innovation policies is investigated using the adapted frameworks multi-level perspective (MLP)-policy regime framework (PRF) overlaps in the context of five lenses on (1) perspectives, (2) stages, (3) dimensions, (4) pathways and (5) types (outcomes) of sustainability transitions (Tshangela and Swilling, 2017). With the lens on type of policy mixes outcomes we provide a complementary quantitative context. The analysis contributes research gaps in measuring the temporal dynamics of policy mixes to include more countries, beyond renewable energy and application to other policy fields (Schmidt and Sewerin, 2018).

 

METHOD

The study is commissioned through a systematic review of academic literature to identify the transversal policies regarded as relevant for sustainability technological innovation efforts between 2002 and 2018 in South Africa. The analysis is conducted of policy mix dynamics (balance and design) of such identified national transversal policy instruments. The intergovernmental panel on climate change and International Energy Agency policies and measures categorization are used as a starting point towards calculating the policy mix balance (IPCC, 2007, Schmidt and Sewerin, 2018). New contribution also includes to adapt the coding scheme for calculating the Index of Policy Activity, in particular scope and objectives such that the coding values are not energy specific but transversal sustainability technology innovations transitions. 

   

PRELIMINARY FINDINGS

Type of policy mix outcomes lens. About thirty-seven transversal sustainability technology innovation transitions related policies in South Africa are identified from a systematic review of academic literature. The policies include the 2002 national research and development strategy, 2008 ten-year innovation plan, 2012 global change research plan and 2018 white paper on science, technology and innovation. In terms of policy mix balance, these four policies represent R&D support policy instrument type. The others include about 26 frameworks, 4 regulations, 3 financial and 2 incentives instrument types with the rest from nine policy instrument types not represented. The policy mix instrument type balance is estimated at 0.46, representing a lower balance (high concentration) of policies across instrument types.

 

A further analysis of these policy instruments mixes design offers an opportunity to better understand South Africa’s economy-tier transversal policies and how they indirectly foster sector, field and technology tiers of specificity within them. This enable a quantitative analysis of transversal policy mixes dynamics. The paper contribute knowledge on the roles of policy actors, institutions and ideas in fostering sustainability technological innovation transitions through transversal policy instruments and mix levels (Schmidt and Sewerin, 2018).

CO-AUTHORS
Luc Bernier (University of Ottawa)
Shirley Anne Scharf
ABSTRACT

How to take advantage or generate more entrepreneurship in the public and private sectors has been an issue in the design of technology and innovation policies for sometimes now. Several studies have focused on the various organizations involved in fostering innovation, insisting on their different operating modes, management culture and entrepreneurship. In the public sector,  technological innovation is driven by organizations as diverse as national research laboratories, government agencies, universities, university spin-off incubators, and State-owned enterprises. In the private sector, technological innovation can be fostered by corporate R&D laboratories, start-up firms, R&D intensive SMEs or multinationals. However, boundaries between public and private technology-based entrepreneurship can be fuzzy, especially since innovations are increasingly resulting from academic, industrial and government partnerships and collaboration projects.

 

In this paper, we are interested in a technological organization that operates at the frontier of the private and public sectors. We study the Institut National d’Optique (INO), Canada’s largest center of expertise in optical and photonic technologies, and compare it to the use made of other similar organizations in Europe and North America. Although half-subsidized by public funds and driven by economic development goals, INO operates as a private non-profit organization and demonstrates an entrepreneurial culture that is traditionally associated with private sector behavior. INO’s pivotal position is also reflected in its intimate ties with academic institutions and government bodies, as well as its deep rootedness in Quebec’s industrial base. INO currently employs around 200 scientists and engineers. Since its inception in 1988, it has spun off 33 companies, carried out 77 technology transfers, sold 6000 customized solutions to Canadian and international firms, and produced several hundred scientific papers and nearly 300 patents.

 

The success of INO over the years raises interesting technology policy questions about its management style, organizational structure and entrepreneurial culture. It also raises issues about the use of organizations at the frontier of the public and private technology sectors as technology policy instruments. In order to understand their use, we examine the characteristics of INO, as well as its technological and commercial strategies. More specifically, we want to answer two main questions. First, what kind of entrepreneurship dominates in organizations, such as INO, that operate at the intersection of public and private technology sectors? Second, how is the nature of this entrepreneurship determined or influenced by the different bonds maintained by INO with the academic community, government bodies, and private businesses?

 

CO-AUTHORS
Miguel Vazquez (PPGE-UFF)
Hallack Michelle (PPGE-UFF)
José Maria F. J. Da Silveira (Institute of Economics, State University of Campinas (IE-UNICAMP))
ABSTRACT

The co-evolution of rules and technology affects policy makers, who make decisions and revise such decisions in an uncertain environment. There exists a relation between policy and technology change regarding renewables (Schmidt and Sewerin 2017). We analyse renewables: specifically solar photovoltaic (solar PV), biomass and wind (Huenteler et al. 2016; Bueno et al. 2014).

 

Energy projects may be regarded as infrastructure projects, being divided in two phases: construction and operation phases. Different phases require different sets of support instruments: in the operation phase, revenue-enhancing mechanisms can be used, e.g. Feed-in tariffs; nevertheless, in the construction phase, financing mechanisms must be used as there is no cash flow. Regarding this, public financing is a key factor, especially in developing countries (Egli, Steffen, and Schmidt 2018; Hochstetler and Kostka 2015; Vazquez et al. 2018).

 

We use an agent-based model (ABM), highlighting the co-evolution of rules and technologies. We analyse the interactions between banks (public and private), energy producers, technology providers, energy users and policy makers. The proposed ABM emphasises feedbacks between agents decisions and outcomes (Ostrom 2005; Vazquez and Hallack 2018).

 

We model five cash-flow support policies: Feed-in tariffs, feed-in premium, quotas, long-term PPAs and carbon tax. We also model three financing scenarios: with focus on public financing, on private financing, and with public banks acting as catalyst for the entry of private financing. Policy makers define the rules of support policies, whereas public and private banks define the rules for agents to access their funds, i.e., the two agents define the rules for accessing cash-flow and financing incentives respectively. Energy providers make investment decisions. Banks decide their propensity to financing fossil, wind, solar PV or biomass technology individually, with Development banks having more than the base probability alongside lower interest rates and more amortisation time (D’Orazio and Valente 2018). Technology providers may innovate based on the more their individual technology is used (Fagiolo and Dosi 2003). We are analysing coherence between beliefs (simplified interpretations of reality) and results; more specifically coherence between policies and technology diffusion. A focus of the proposed ABM is network creation, especially between banks, energy providers and technology providers: banks finance the acquisition of generation technology and the use of a specific technology prompts innovation, as such, banks are ultimately financing innovation. Brazil, Chile, Italy and Germany are our case studies (Gawel et al. 2017; Vazquez et al. 2018).

 

Coherent policies need to be coherent with the context that they are facing, with the other policies and with agents’ beliefs, as such, we are ultimately analysing a problem of coherent decision-making in a complex environment. As such, the paper combines policy analysis with simulation. After analysing our case studies and elucidating the model, we intertwine both analysis by: 1) replicating stylised facts, and 2) clashing the produced results with some alternative scenarios. Understanding how Brazil successfully expanded its biomass and wind sources but not its solar PV source at the same time that Chile expanded its solar PV source would be an example of proposed experiments.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

For long, the breakthrough of electric vehicles seemed an intractable challenge. All kinds of concerns and reservations were uttered: these vehicles were too expensive, had range issues, would require a separate charging infrastructure, and were not more environmentally friendly than conventional vehicles when running on a power mix dominated by fossil fuels. These perceptions are gradually changing. National and sub-national policy efforts are taking shape, prices for electric vehicles are coming down, and established and new auto manufacturers, energy utilities and other service providers are reconfiguring their activities.

 

With this paper, I intend to disentangle the complexity of the socio-technical transition process to electric vehicles in India (1994-2018) through an event history analysis of structures (actors, institutions, technologies) and corresponding system innovation functions (entrepreneurial activities, knowledge development and knowledge diffusion, guidance of the search, market formation, resource mobilization, and support from advocacy coalitions). The main interest of this research is to better understand major converging drivers toward the market formation of electric vehicles including national and sub-national policy intervention (whether at lower or higher levels of abstraction) and their degree of effectiveness.

 

Preliminary results of the event history analysis show three different phases in the transition to electric vehicles in India. The early-mover entrepreneurial phase (1994-2002) followed by years of apparent inaction (2003-2009) leading to an extended period of predominantly Government driven multi-stakeholder interactions (2010-2018). Especially since 2017, India is at an accelerated stage in the socio-technical transition process toward electric mobility. Nonetheless, niche features such as pilot and demonstration projects continue to dominate the technological innovation system, and e-vehicle registration figures lag far behind what would be needed to reach the NEMMP target of 6-7 million vehicles by 2020. Yet, the past years have been filled with particularly promising signs of cumulative causation which manifest themselves in continued growth in vehicle sales, installed charging stations, and rising levels of renewable energy in the Indian energy mix.

CO-AUTHORS
Alberto Asquer (School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London)
ABSTRACT

The rise of nanotechnologies and modern biotechnology poses formidable regulatory issues. The fast pace of technological development results in streams of innovations whose effects and side-effects may not be completely predictable. Knowledge about these technologies accumulates among researchers and firms while policy-makers, regulatory authorities and the general public may lack fully understand the implications of their applications. While concerns about health and safety call for prudency to embrace new technologies, potential benefits and profitability lure scientists and businessmen to invest into ventures that could result in dramatic technological breakthroughs and commercial blockbusters.
 
Within such scenario, regulatory governance of emerging technologies seems stuck between two opposite tendencies. On the one hand, the concept of regulatory parsimony (US PCSBI 2010) provides a broad guidance for the regulation of emerging technologies, which should be subjected only to as much oversight as it is strictly necessary to ensure safety, security, fairness and justice while carrying out research and developing applications. On the other one, the precautionary principle (EPRS 2015) calls for controlling risky activities even before any scientific evidence proves a causal relationship between the activities and harmful or unwelcome effects. These tendencies provide contrasting ways to frame the issues that arise from emerging technologies, to organise the policy discourse and agenda, and to assess alternative courses of actions to provide a regulatory response to related health and safety concerns.
 
This study aims to explore the relationship between regulatory parsimony and the precautionary principles in the regulatory governance of emerging technologies. Empirically, this study consists of a comparative case study of regulatory arrangements of two particular kinds of emergent technologies, namely pharmaceutical nanotechnologies and CRISPR/cas9 genome editing.The analysis will focus on the efforts that have been exerted to make sense of the implications of the new technologies and to form a shared consensus on how better they should be regulated. Findings from the comparative analysis will provide some evidence to enrich the theorizing of regulatory parsimony and of the precautionary principles in regulatory governance.
 
References
 
EPRS (European Parliamentary Research Services) (2015). The Precautionary Principle: Definitions, Applications and Governance. Retrieved from  http://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/IDAN/2015/573876/EPRS_IDA(2015)573876_EN.pdfon 30/1/2019.
 
US Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues (US PCSBI) (2010). New Directions: The Ethics of Synthetic Biology and Emerging Technologies. Washington, DC. (www.bioethics.gov)

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The development of smart cities, increasingly integrating various urban aspects ranging from energy and buildings to transportation and health, depends critically on the availability of and accessibility to data in the relevant sectors. It is hence of particular importance to facilitate efficient and effective collection, diffusion, and utilization of data in creating innovation in cyber-physical systems. Unlike the traditional mode of innovation, which tends to rely on closed, well-established relationships between enterprises in a specific sector, the new mode of data-driven innovation requires open, dynamic interactions with stakeholders possessing different sets of data. There have been few empirical studies, however, that investigates what policy approaches would be effective in stimulating data-driven innovation by facilitating coordination and integration of emerging technologies through open exchange and sharing of data.


This research conducts a case study of Japan to examine in details the process of coordination among novel technologies in the context of increasing integration and interdependence in innovation for smart cities, with implications for policy design. In Japan, proprietary standards among competing providers initially slowed down the development of smart technologies. Eventually the standard of Open Automated Demand Response 2.0 was adopted, following feasibility, interoperability and connectivity testing through close collaboration between major players in the energy industry and the government. The adoption of the common scheme had a significant impact on driving innovation on home and building energy management systems, with smart thermostats, rooftop solar, battery energy storage, and other appliances smoothly integrated through data exchange and sharing.


Novel technologies are rapidly advancing, however, in other sectors related to the Internet of Things, in which virtually everything is getting connected so that many technologies that were formerly operated separately can coordinate with each other efficiently. Various standards, such as ZigBee and Bluetooth Low Energy, are under rapid advancement, leading to a serious need to promote cooperation among relevant actors working in different sectors. The traditional system of government-industry collaboration does not function effectively, as new players including start-ups and entrepreneurs are entering the field of smart cities with innovative technologies that are often developed independently. That poses a serious challenge to policy making, as different sectors have their specific issues and concerns and the policies and regulations to deal with them are not necessarily coordinated with each other, which effectively creates an obstacle to facilitating data exchange and sharing for innovation in integrated smart cities.


The approach of regulatory sandboxes, initially introduced to fintech, has been recently applied to stimulate innovation in other fields by allowing experimental trials of novel technologies in designated geographical or technological domains. Regulatory sandboxes enable greater data availability, accessibility, and usability for innovators by reducing regulatory constraints and uncertainty. This study examines how regulatory sandboxes are implemented to facilitate open data and what impacts are made on innovation in cyber-physical systems such as smart cities. Opportunities and challenges in policy design are explored for stimulating data-driven innovation through compatibility, interoperability, and integration of data while addressing societal concerns about privacy, cyber security, and public safety.

CO-AUTHORS
Shyama Ramani (United Nations University - UNU-MERIT)
ABSTRACT

In this paper, we present a model for solution design in the form of actionable guidelines for government-assisted innovation-based development paths to a more sustainable future and SDGs attainment.

Our solution design approach is based on system analysis, capability building, engagement and replication. It starts from the assumption that any stakeholder in the system can provide elements of a solution to a societal problem but since societal systems are complex, no one actor can control the systemic outcomes completely or perfectly – not even the state. Governments have to fine-tune their policies periodically in accordance with the impact of solution designs introduced by public agencies or other actors in the system.

The framework which is termed ‘SISTER’ for easy recall, involves the following  elements. 

First, in order to map the possibilities for change, the system boundaries have to be drawn and the systemic actors of interest have to be identified. This means that the leading actors who will be concerned by any stage or outcome of the process of self-managed transition have to be identified. Their present action possibilities, objectives and constraints have to be mapped and compared against possible action profiles necessary and sufficient for a solution-based transition. An analysis of the sources of lock-in to prevailing practices is part of the analysis Let this step be given by ‘S’ (S for System analysis as a joint task for stakeholders and researchers).

Second, in order to ‘nudge’ the learning process as a precursor for action,  capacity development at the level of government (agencies), knowledge institutes and business actors,  might have to be created and mobilized. Thus, we consider the first three elements of solution design as I, S, T standing for the variables given below:

I – could refer to infrastructure, new institutions or innovation.

S – for social learning that will address the needs for knowledge creation and knowledge transfer or circulation for capacity building, awareness and motivation creation in order to structure the educational needs.

 T- for Technology or technology redesign or better/new utilisation of existing technology.

                Solution designs have to identify the investments necessary to introduce a vector of I,S, T elements to incentivize the transition.

Third, in order to implement the solution design, a variety of engagement strategies, say E, might need to be implemented. These might issue from the state, in the form of regulation or public investment. At the same time, they might come from other actors within the system, in the form of entrepreneurship, intrapreneurship, NGO activity and civil society movements, resulting in contextual-sensitive Replication (R).  

The SISTER approach for solution design draws on Reflexive Monitoring in Action (van Mierlo et al., 2010), Reflexive Iterative Design (Bos et al., 2009) and recommendations about green industrial policy (Rodrik, 2014, Kemp and Never, 2016). The value of the approach is demonstrated by two examples (Genetically modified plant varieties and Eliminating open defecation in India).