Format

P09. 'Doing' Feminist Policy Analysis: Canadian and Comparative Case Studies

GENDER, DIVERSITY AND PUBLIC POLICY
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Francesca Scala
Concordia University
Main chair
Stephanie Paterson
Concordia University
Second chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
GENDER, DIVERSITY AND PUBLIC POLICY
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Feminist policy studies is a broad field ranging from analysis of substantive issue areas to those addressing the micro-dimensions of policy processes and outcomes. Borrowing heavily from but also challenging critical policy studies, feminist policy studies has resulted in an impressive range of theoretical and methodological frameworks designed to expose the ubiquity of gender in policy processes and outcomes. As part of a broader feminist project, feminist policy analysis is concerned with the mechanisms through which power is developed and maintained in all aspects of the policy process, including problem definition, policy formulation and policy implementation (Bacchi, 1999: Marshall, 1999). As Marshall explains (1999:59), feminist critical policy analysis “directly questions the entire policy analysis process, from the formation of research questions to the development and use of methodology to the analysis and write-up of results. It assumes that policymakers (i.e., the state) will act in ways to sustain and build dominance in society”. Recognizing differences among women, feminist critical policy analysis also makes social location, including in intersecting factors, such as gender, race, class, ability, sexuality and gender identity and expression relevant and central to policy theory, inquiry and practice.

 

The panel, the second of two panel proposals on feminist governance and policy (see Feminist Governance in the 21st Century), builds on this work by directly engaging with feminist critical policy analysis through case studies on policy issues in different country settings. Individually and together, the case studies will advance theory-building in feminist policy studies as well as provide insights on the benefits and challenges of ‘doing’ feminist policy analysis as both research and practice.

CALL FOR PAPERS

We invite contributions that use a case study approach and that draws on both theoretical perspectives and empirical examination to explore a policy issue through a feminist lens.  While the panel is open to a range of topics, country settings, and methodologies, papers are asked to use feminist critical policy analysis to examine the gendered nature and consequences of how policies are developed and implemented. Structuring their analysis around questions of difference and power, papers should also highlight how gender intersects with other categories of marginalization such as race, class and age to produce and maintain inequalities. Questions addressed by the case studies include but are not limited to:

 

  • How does the policy reflect notions of gender and gender relations?
  • How do problems representations exclude and disadvantage others?
  • How do gender ideologies and norms shape policy processes and outcomes?
  • How does the policy shape, reinforce, or modify particular notions of identities and to what effect?
  • How is gender and the public/private distinction inscribed in the policy?
  • How does the policy shape gender relations in households and the public domain?
  • Are women included or excluded as actors in the policy process?
ACCEPTED
Format
01 - What lies beyond statistical parity? Lessons from Africa’s gender balanced cabinets
Betel Bekele Birhanu (University of Zurich )
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Both scholars and practitioners have recently started to emphasize the potential of gender parity cabinets in advancing women’s empowerment. Based on evidence drawn from East Africa with case studies on Ethiopia and Rwanda, two of the three gender parity cabinets in Africa, out of 10 in the world, the likelihood of this phenomenon is explored. The research questions that the study addresses include, but not limited to: does the 50:50 statistical parity between the genders translate into actual empowerment of women? What are the challenges of retaining the positions? These questions are particularly pertinent in the context of the case studies, as both are composed of patriarchal societies with an authoritarian oriented state machinery and weak public institutions. The appointments are policy measures that are being executed by the “political will” of the “strong men” in the highest political offices. This situation makes one question the sustainability of such an arrangement in a non-liberal context. Both Rwanda and Ethiopia subscribe to the developmental state model. A minimalist definition of this model is a development trajectory that tries to champion economic development by downplaying the relevance of political rights and civil liberties. With regards to the methodology, group administered questioners and interviews with various experts, including the women ministers themselves, are the major data collection tools. 

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Maternity leave, gender equality, and rights: how the problems behind the paid parental leave policies in New Zealand and Norway were represented.
Suzy Morrissey (Victoria University of Wellington)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper presents a comparative case study of the paid parental leave policies in New Zealand and Norway.  It applies two critical analysis frameworks, Bacchi’s ‘What’s the Problem Represented to be?’ or WPR approach (2009), and Bacchi and Bonham’s ‘Poststructural Interview Analysis’ or PIA (2016).  It is drawn from my PhD which answers the research question ‘What assumptions about women and family contributed to the design of the paid parental leave (PPL) policies in New Zealand and Norway?’ 

 

As the methodologies are both poststructural, the paper considers how we ‘know’ things, and examines the language we use to assign words to people and things.  This includes the concept of subjectivity, and the way people are discussed in terms of subjects or subject positions, roles within society such as working mother, good citizen, or natural carer.  The paper also considers how some people are excluded from certain subject positions (such as positions of power and influence) and other people will be subject to a discourse that positions them in a particular existence or performing a particular role (such as a welfare beneficiary). 

 

The two critical analysis frameworks are used to examine two different data sets.  The WPR approach is applied to historical documents, including records of parliamentary debate, public submissions on the PPL bill, reports by various Ministries, documentation from women’s groups, and media articles.  The PIA is applied to a new set of primary data, interviews with people who were actively involved in the introduction of the PPL policy and the father’s quota (politicians, public servants, women’s rights advocates, and family policy academics). 

 

The paper presents the problem behind PPL in New Zealand as ‘the public responsibility for the lack of payment for maternity leave’ and the problem behind PPL in Norway as ‘a shared responsibility for the unequal use of parental leave’.  The research exposes a number of assumptions about the role of women within the family, including the relationship between women and the state, the value placed on the care role, and the rights of children and fathers.  It reveals commonality within seemingly diverse discourse and the impact it has had on policy design in the two countries.  These are reflected in the research findings, which explain the different rates of payment of PPL in each country, the way in which the fathers’ eligibility for PPL is linked to the mother’s employment status in both countries, and the expanded concept of rights in Norway compared to New Zealand.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Caring political processes to create supportive housing for lone-mothers in Canadian cities
Marie-Eve Desroches (Insitut national de la recherche scientifique)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Home should be a place of care. However, an increasing number of Canadian woman and families find themselves in emergency shelters following a marital breakdown or domestic violence (Gaetz et al., 2016). For women heads of single-parent families, homelessness means a vulnerability that affects their possibility to care for themselves and their children, profoundly influences their mental and physical health and on a larger scale, contributes to health inequalities (Tischler et al., 2007). Social housing, and in particular supportive housing, is recognized as an important solution to assist homeless families: by accessing a safe, affordable and suitable unit, they can regain residential stability. While the needs are particularly acute, a limited number of new supportive housing projets are built due to a lack of adequate funding. Despite various cutbacks, health remains a priority area since these interventions are seen as part of responsible management of public funds (Berkeley and Springett, 2006). However, housing is often omitted over health care and healthy lifestyles policies. Its association with the private sphere can explain this relegation. The public/private dichotomy has a crucial role in the reproduction of gender and sex-based inequalities (Staeheli and Mitchell, 2004). This division excludes from public debate or devalues a set of activities and dynamics associated with the private sphere, such as care and housing issues (Duncan, 1996). Although this dichotomy is perceived as natural by some, it is socially and politically constructed. Consequently, this division is not fixed and homogeneous: logics of privatization, contestation or politicization contribute to re-territorialize and redefine these spheres (Duncan, 1996). Care and housing concerns can, therefore, be recognized as a tool to reduce health inequalities.

How does supportive housing may blur the public/private dichotomy, reduce vulnerability and address health inequalities? Our paper compares the policy processes that have led to the creation of new supportive housing for lone mothers in Montreal, Toronto and Vancouver. We explored the point of view of the stakeholders involved through qualitative analysis of mind maps, semi-directed interviews, and archival documents. Canadian policies are generally analyzed through liberal theories that see individuals as autonomous and self-sufficient. In contrast, care ethics recognize the interdependence necessary to ensure the well-being of communities. These feminist ethics offer conceptual tools to question how actors understand and address social problems critically. In this paper, we explore these political processes from the phases of care: care about, care for, caregiving, care receiving and caring with (Fisher and Tronto 1990; Tronto, 2013). Our analyses reveal that these processes aim to open up specific spaces, relationships and temporalities that expand the landscapes of care. Therefore, the tenant can take care of themselves, their families and ultimately their communities. Within these projects, the housing unit is seen as a starting point to reduce vulnerability but is not sufficient to have sustainable and structuring impacts on health. The units must be part of a set of scales that provide public and private spaces to receive, but also provide care beyond the family unit.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - InFeminism: A Study of Women-Women Marginalisation in Nigeria
Adewale Kupoluyi, (Babcock University, Ilishan-Remo, Nigeria)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

InFeminism: A Study of Women-Women Marginalisation in Nigeria

Adewale K. Kupoluyi

Department of Political Science and Public Administration, Veronica Adeleke School of Social Sciences, Babcock University, Ilishan-Remo, Ogun State, Nigeria. E-mail: adewalekupoluyi@yahoo.co.uk

 

Abstract

The role of women in the political and socio-economic development of any nation cannot be over-emphasised. Unfortunately, a number of factors continue to negate this reality, causing inequality and making women to be excluded and disadvantaged in governance in countries like Nigeria. A major challenge identified in this regard is women-women marginalisation, which is a new area of study, known as InFeminism. The main objective of the study was to examine InFeminism and policy analysis process in Nigeria. Research questions addressed by the study are: What is the nature of InFeminism? What are the causes of women-women marginalisation in Nigeria? What are the consequences of women-women marginalisation in Nigeria? How can women-women marginalisation be curbed in Nigeria? The study adopted both qualitative and quantitative research methods. Primary data was obtained using the questionnaire to elicit information from the study population while secondary data sources include books, conferences papers, reports, official publications, Internet and journal articles. The study population was one hundred and eighty (180) women that were randomly selected in Lagos State, Nigeria. The women were selected through the multi-stage sampling procedure. The first stage of the sampling procedure was the purposive selection of Lagos State among the thirty-six (36) states and the Federal Capital Territory of Nigeria. Lagos State was selected due to its multi-cultural and cosmopolitan nature, comprising a cross-section of Nigerian women. The second stage involved the random selection of senatorial districts while the third stage entailed the random selection of one local government each in Lagos State. Ninety (90) women were randomly selected from each of the local government selected to make up the sample size of one hundred and eighty (180) respondents. Analysis of the data was done using descriptive statistics such as frequencies, percentages, mean, tables and charts. Findings revealed that the involvement of Nigerian women in governance is limited due to marginalisation by women themselves. The study recommends that necessary public policy should be engineered to tackle women-women marginalisation, non-governmental actors at local and international levels should encourage diversity, encourage adequate women participation in governance as well as promote collaborative studies and research in various aspects of women-women marginalisation such as InFeminism.

 

Keywords: Gender, Governance, InFeminism, Policy Process, Women Marginalisation.

 

 

 

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Institutional Ethnography as Feminist Policy Analysis: A Canadian Case Study
Elizabeth McGibbon (St. Francis Xavier University)
CO-AUTHORS
Katherine Fierlbeck (Dalhousie University)
Ifeoluwatari Ajadi (Dalhousie University)
ABSTRACT

Institutional ethnography (IE), developed by Canadian feminist sociologist Dorothy Smith, focuses on identifying and challenging conceptual practices of power. Smith is specifically interested in the articulation of everyday work practices with extralocal relations of ruling. Relations of ruling are a complex of organized and dominant practices, including government, law, business and financial management, professional organizations, and educational institutions as well as the discourses and texts that interpenetrate these multiple sites of power. These ideas open debate about power relations in the texts of underlying policy language and knowledge production, and in who can be knowers, or what can be known. This paper contributes to the nascent application of IE to critical public policy analyses in Canada. Specifically, we use health equity discourses in Canadian public policy as a case study to provide a detailed description of IE as a method to analyse public policy from a critical feminist perspective. IE offers analytic tools that make it particularly salient for feminist policy analyses in several distinct ways. First, IE directs an explicit focus on the gendered and exclusionary nature of ruling relations, and the complex synergies of intersectionality that locate oppressed people(s) in particular ways in public policy texts and discourses—texts that occur largely outside the experiences of the oppressed. Second, IE provides a method to identify and confront the complex invisibility of oppressed people(s) in public policy. Not only is it very difficult to map this invisibility, the process that creates and maintains invisibility is itself hidden. We conclude with a synopsis of IE as a central tool in feminist policy analyses, particularly in its potential to create and maintain justice-oriented policy change.  

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Pregnancy without permanency: A critical feminist look at reproductive justice for migrant women in Canada
Lindsay Larios (Concordia University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Over the last ten years, Canada’s immigration system has shifted such that more people enter Canada with temporary status than permanent residency, and often live for prolonged periods of time in states of relative precarity. Immigration programs and policies produce various temporary immigration statuses which become categories of marginalization that often determine what rights temporary residents can access in Canada and under what conditions. A critical feminist analysis of precarious status migration highlights, in particular, the ways in which this marginalization intersects with gender to exacerbate inequalities felt by precarious status women in Canada. For example, while citizens and permanent residents of the state may navigate issues relating to the creation and care for families under the purview of their civil rights and the state protections guaranteed them, precarious status residents engage in these same experiences but in a state of precarity and exclusion, and struggle with losing their jobs and residency status, accessing health care for themselves and their children, and family separation.
 
Using reproductive justice (Ross & Solinger, 2017) as a critical feminist conceptual framework, the objective of this research is to understand how immigration status shapes people’s experience of creating and caring for their families in Canada, focusing specifically on the experience of pregnancy. This research examines how the Canadian state through its immigration policy produces and maintains a system in which certain groups of people are supported as they create and care for their families and others are denied their full reproductive rights.
 
The research uses semi-structured narrative interviews with women who have experienced pregnancy while living in Montreal with precarious immigration status. It brings together experiences of international students, temporary workers, refugee claimants, and others, to highlight the ways in which their immigration status and lack of permanency shapes their experience of creating and caring for their families.
 
In particular, preliminary findings explore the ways in which family policies, health care policies, and immigration policies intersect and impact their ability to access services, benefits, and rights, and ultimately undermine the principles of reproductive justice. People experience these barriers not only as a matter of eligibility for service or not, but as a representation of their “otherness” within Canada, stress related to the instability and precarity of their home life, and an overall neglect of the relational element of human day-to-day lives (e.g. their access, care for, and right to family).
 
This research demonstrates, how the categorization of certain residents as temporary through their immigration status, allows states to bypass responsibility for their needs and protection of their rights – this has gendered and racialized effects. Critical feminist policymaking must allow all women to access their full reproductive rights, including the right to create and care for families, as conceptualized through reproductive justice. A state’s use of immigration policy and status categorizations as justification for failing to do so is an exercise of state power that is fundamentally discriminatory.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Framing of maternal versus paternal employment as a policy problem in Australian social policy for separated couples with children
Michelle Brady (University of Victoria)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Australia has a comparatively low and stagnant maternal employment rate which increases women’s risks of poverty and social exclusion and impedes the advancement of gender equality. Over a decade of policy reform, including parental leave, childcare and family tax benefits, has failed to remedy this situation. Conceptualising the use of evidence as ‘boundary work ’ and drawing on a problem framing approach this paper examines how the issue of maternal employment was framed in social policies developed to support couples with children after separation. Specifically it will examine childcare policies, family tax benefits, child support and parenting payments. It will argue that policy makers have overwhelmingly prioritized maximining paid work incentives for fathers following separation and has given less consideration to  maximining paid work incentives for mothers.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Both scholars and practitioners have recently started to emphasize the potential of gender parity cabinets in advancing women’s empowerment. Based on evidence drawn from East Africa with case studies on Ethiopia and Rwanda, two of the three gender parity cabinets in Africa, out of 10 in the world, the likelihood of this phenomenon is explored. The research questions that the study addresses include, but not limited to: does the 50:50 statistical parity between the genders translate into actual empowerment of women? What are the challenges of retaining the positions? These questions are particularly pertinent in the context of the case studies, as both are composed of patriarchal societies with an authoritarian oriented state machinery and weak public institutions. The appointments are policy measures that are being executed by the “political will” of the “strong men” in the highest political offices. This situation makes one question the sustainability of such an arrangement in a non-liberal context. Both Rwanda and Ethiopia subscribe to the developmental state model. A minimalist definition of this model is a development trajectory that tries to champion economic development by downplaying the relevance of political rights and civil liberties. With regards to the methodology, group administered questioners and interviews with various experts, including the women ministers themselves, are the major data collection tools. 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper presents a comparative case study of the paid parental leave policies in New Zealand and Norway.  It applies two critical analysis frameworks, Bacchi’s ‘What’s the Problem Represented to be?’ or WPR approach (2009), and Bacchi and Bonham’s ‘Poststructural Interview Analysis’ or PIA (2016).  It is drawn from my PhD which answers the research question ‘What assumptions about women and family contributed to the design of the paid parental leave (PPL) policies in New Zealand and Norway?’ 

 

As the methodologies are both poststructural, the paper considers how we ‘know’ things, and examines the language we use to assign words to people and things.  This includes the concept of subjectivity, and the way people are discussed in terms of subjects or subject positions, roles within society such as working mother, good citizen, or natural carer.  The paper also considers how some people are excluded from certain subject positions (such as positions of power and influence) and other people will be subject to a discourse that positions them in a particular existence or performing a particular role (such as a welfare beneficiary). 

 

The two critical analysis frameworks are used to examine two different data sets.  The WPR approach is applied to historical documents, including records of parliamentary debate, public submissions on the PPL bill, reports by various Ministries, documentation from women’s groups, and media articles.  The PIA is applied to a new set of primary data, interviews with people who were actively involved in the introduction of the PPL policy and the father’s quota (politicians, public servants, women’s rights advocates, and family policy academics). 

 

The paper presents the problem behind PPL in New Zealand as ‘the public responsibility for the lack of payment for maternity leave’ and the problem behind PPL in Norway as ‘a shared responsibility for the unequal use of parental leave’.  The research exposes a number of assumptions about the role of women within the family, including the relationship between women and the state, the value placed on the care role, and the rights of children and fathers.  It reveals commonality within seemingly diverse discourse and the impact it has had on policy design in the two countries.  These are reflected in the research findings, which explain the different rates of payment of PPL in each country, the way in which the fathers’ eligibility for PPL is linked to the mother’s employment status in both countries, and the expanded concept of rights in Norway compared to New Zealand.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Home should be a place of care. However, an increasing number of Canadian woman and families find themselves in emergency shelters following a marital breakdown or domestic violence (Gaetz et al., 2016). For women heads of single-parent families, homelessness means a vulnerability that affects their possibility to care for themselves and their children, profoundly influences their mental and physical health and on a larger scale, contributes to health inequalities (Tischler et al., 2007). Social housing, and in particular supportive housing, is recognized as an important solution to assist homeless families: by accessing a safe, affordable and suitable unit, they can regain residential stability. While the needs are particularly acute, a limited number of new supportive housing projets are built due to a lack of adequate funding. Despite various cutbacks, health remains a priority area since these interventions are seen as part of responsible management of public funds (Berkeley and Springett, 2006). However, housing is often omitted over health care and healthy lifestyles policies. Its association with the private sphere can explain this relegation. The public/private dichotomy has a crucial role in the reproduction of gender and sex-based inequalities (Staeheli and Mitchell, 2004). This division excludes from public debate or devalues a set of activities and dynamics associated with the private sphere, such as care and housing issues (Duncan, 1996). Although this dichotomy is perceived as natural by some, it is socially and politically constructed. Consequently, this division is not fixed and homogeneous: logics of privatization, contestation or politicization contribute to re-territorialize and redefine these spheres (Duncan, 1996). Care and housing concerns can, therefore, be recognized as a tool to reduce health inequalities.

How does supportive housing may blur the public/private dichotomy, reduce vulnerability and address health inequalities? Our paper compares the policy processes that have led to the creation of new supportive housing for lone mothers in Montreal, Toronto and Vancouver. We explored the point of view of the stakeholders involved through qualitative analysis of mind maps, semi-directed interviews, and archival documents. Canadian policies are generally analyzed through liberal theories that see individuals as autonomous and self-sufficient. In contrast, care ethics recognize the interdependence necessary to ensure the well-being of communities. These feminist ethics offer conceptual tools to question how actors understand and address social problems critically. In this paper, we explore these political processes from the phases of care: care about, care for, caregiving, care receiving and caring with (Fisher and Tronto 1990; Tronto, 2013). Our analyses reveal that these processes aim to open up specific spaces, relationships and temporalities that expand the landscapes of care. Therefore, the tenant can take care of themselves, their families and ultimately their communities. Within these projects, the housing unit is seen as a starting point to reduce vulnerability but is not sufficient to have sustainable and structuring impacts on health. The units must be part of a set of scales that provide public and private spaces to receive, but also provide care beyond the family unit.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

InFeminism: A Study of Women-Women Marginalisation in Nigeria

Adewale K. Kupoluyi

Department of Political Science and Public Administration, Veronica Adeleke School of Social Sciences, Babcock University, Ilishan-Remo, Ogun State, Nigeria. E-mail: adewalekupoluyi@yahoo.co.uk

 

Abstract

The role of women in the political and socio-economic development of any nation cannot be over-emphasised. Unfortunately, a number of factors continue to negate this reality, causing inequality and making women to be excluded and disadvantaged in governance in countries like Nigeria. A major challenge identified in this regard is women-women marginalisation, which is a new area of study, known as InFeminism. The main objective of the study was to examine InFeminism and policy analysis process in Nigeria. Research questions addressed by the study are: What is the nature of InFeminism? What are the causes of women-women marginalisation in Nigeria? What are the consequences of women-women marginalisation in Nigeria? How can women-women marginalisation be curbed in Nigeria? The study adopted both qualitative and quantitative research methods. Primary data was obtained using the questionnaire to elicit information from the study population while secondary data sources include books, conferences papers, reports, official publications, Internet and journal articles. The study population was one hundred and eighty (180) women that were randomly selected in Lagos State, Nigeria. The women were selected through the multi-stage sampling procedure. The first stage of the sampling procedure was the purposive selection of Lagos State among the thirty-six (36) states and the Federal Capital Territory of Nigeria. Lagos State was selected due to its multi-cultural and cosmopolitan nature, comprising a cross-section of Nigerian women. The second stage involved the random selection of senatorial districts while the third stage entailed the random selection of one local government each in Lagos State. Ninety (90) women were randomly selected from each of the local government selected to make up the sample size of one hundred and eighty (180) respondents. Analysis of the data was done using descriptive statistics such as frequencies, percentages, mean, tables and charts. Findings revealed that the involvement of Nigerian women in governance is limited due to marginalisation by women themselves. The study recommends that necessary public policy should be engineered to tackle women-women marginalisation, non-governmental actors at local and international levels should encourage diversity, encourage adequate women participation in governance as well as promote collaborative studies and research in various aspects of women-women marginalisation such as InFeminism.

 

Keywords: Gender, Governance, InFeminism, Policy Process, Women Marginalisation.

 

 

 

CO-AUTHORS
Katherine Fierlbeck (Dalhousie University)
Ifeoluwatari Ajadi (Dalhousie University)
ABSTRACT

Institutional ethnography (IE), developed by Canadian feminist sociologist Dorothy Smith, focuses on identifying and challenging conceptual practices of power. Smith is specifically interested in the articulation of everyday work practices with extralocal relations of ruling. Relations of ruling are a complex of organized and dominant practices, including government, law, business and financial management, professional organizations, and educational institutions as well as the discourses and texts that interpenetrate these multiple sites of power. These ideas open debate about power relations in the texts of underlying policy language and knowledge production, and in who can be knowers, or what can be known. This paper contributes to the nascent application of IE to critical public policy analyses in Canada. Specifically, we use health equity discourses in Canadian public policy as a case study to provide a detailed description of IE as a method to analyse public policy from a critical feminist perspective. IE offers analytic tools that make it particularly salient for feminist policy analyses in several distinct ways. First, IE directs an explicit focus on the gendered and exclusionary nature of ruling relations, and the complex synergies of intersectionality that locate oppressed people(s) in particular ways in public policy texts and discourses—texts that occur largely outside the experiences of the oppressed. Second, IE provides a method to identify and confront the complex invisibility of oppressed people(s) in public policy. Not only is it very difficult to map this invisibility, the process that creates and maintains invisibility is itself hidden. We conclude with a synopsis of IE as a central tool in feminist policy analyses, particularly in its potential to create and maintain justice-oriented policy change.  

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Over the last ten years, Canada’s immigration system has shifted such that more people enter Canada with temporary status than permanent residency, and often live for prolonged periods of time in states of relative precarity. Immigration programs and policies produce various temporary immigration statuses which become categories of marginalization that often determine what rights temporary residents can access in Canada and under what conditions. A critical feminist analysis of precarious status migration highlights, in particular, the ways in which this marginalization intersects with gender to exacerbate inequalities felt by precarious status women in Canada. For example, while citizens and permanent residents of the state may navigate issues relating to the creation and care for families under the purview of their civil rights and the state protections guaranteed them, precarious status residents engage in these same experiences but in a state of precarity and exclusion, and struggle with losing their jobs and residency status, accessing health care for themselves and their children, and family separation.
 
Using reproductive justice (Ross & Solinger, 2017) as a critical feminist conceptual framework, the objective of this research is to understand how immigration status shapes people’s experience of creating and caring for their families in Canada, focusing specifically on the experience of pregnancy. This research examines how the Canadian state through its immigration policy produces and maintains a system in which certain groups of people are supported as they create and care for their families and others are denied their full reproductive rights.
 
The research uses semi-structured narrative interviews with women who have experienced pregnancy while living in Montreal with precarious immigration status. It brings together experiences of international students, temporary workers, refugee claimants, and others, to highlight the ways in which their immigration status and lack of permanency shapes their experience of creating and caring for their families.
 
In particular, preliminary findings explore the ways in which family policies, health care policies, and immigration policies intersect and impact their ability to access services, benefits, and rights, and ultimately undermine the principles of reproductive justice. People experience these barriers not only as a matter of eligibility for service or not, but as a representation of their “otherness” within Canada, stress related to the instability and precarity of their home life, and an overall neglect of the relational element of human day-to-day lives (e.g. their access, care for, and right to family).
 
This research demonstrates, how the categorization of certain residents as temporary through their immigration status, allows states to bypass responsibility for their needs and protection of their rights – this has gendered and racialized effects. Critical feminist policymaking must allow all women to access their full reproductive rights, including the right to create and care for families, as conceptualized through reproductive justice. A state’s use of immigration policy and status categorizations as justification for failing to do so is an exercise of state power that is fundamentally discriminatory.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Australia has a comparatively low and stagnant maternal employment rate which increases women’s risks of poverty and social exclusion and impedes the advancement of gender equality. Over a decade of policy reform, including parental leave, childcare and family tax benefits, has failed to remedy this situation. Conceptualising the use of evidence as ‘boundary work ’ and drawing on a problem framing approach this paper examines how the issue of maternal employment was framed in social policies developed to support couples with children after separation. Specifically it will examine childcare policies, family tax benefits, child support and parenting payments. It will argue that policy makers have overwhelmingly prioritized maximining paid work incentives for fathers following separation and has given less consideration to  maximining paid work incentives for mothers.