P06. Gender, Diversity, and Representation of Target Groups in Public Policy-Making/Implementing Venues
GENDER, DIVERSITY AND PUBLIC POLICYCATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
Objectives and scientific relevance:
Embedded within the question of which problems or issues are gaining attention, are the related questions: who are the target groups, and how are they represented in policy-making venues and affected by policy implementation? Public policy-making and their implementation is not always fair or equitable- some policies exclude target group that are more likely to benefit from them and give benefits to certain groups more so than others. Representation and meaningful engagement of diverse and marginalized groups such as, women, LGBTQ people, racialized groups, Indigenous people, and persons with disabilities can shape policy issues and solutions.
The Diversity Institute is organizing a panel discussion to explore ways of entrenching gender and diversity within institutions, governing structures, and organizations within the context of existing power and gender imbalances that traditionally exclude marginalized groups and their interests from public policy venues. The broad aim of this panel is to understand the ways in which institutions and organizational structures exclude some target groups and their interests in policy-making and policy implementation in these settings.
This panel will be organized into two sessions, one focusing on the representation and differential treatment of diverse and marginalized groups such as, women, LGBTQ people, and racialized groups in various settings across the world, and one aimed at understanding how change can be brought about in institutional frameworks and organizational structures for more equitable representation of such groups.
We will examine diverse policy-making and implementing venues such as political institutions, local governance structures, schools, and academia as well as several target groups including women and LGBTQ groups in developed and developing countries.
The question of target group representation can be explored from an institutional approach or critical perspective. While some argue that powerful actors or strong advocacy /interest groups can increase representation of target groups in policy venues, others believe that institutions constrain actors' choices and actions. From an institutionalist perspective, representation could be made better and more effective by changing institutional laws and norms. This view could be challenged from a critical policy perspective; arguing that all decision-making is subject to biases, issue framing, and social constructions of target groups which are unlikely to be influenced by legislation.
Theoretical and empirical works that have looked at existing laws, frameworks, and practices, discussed their strengths and limitations, and proposed solutions that apply to diverse settings are included.
CALL FOR PAPERS
Call for papers: Gender, Diversity, and Representation of Target Groups in Public Policy Making Venues
The Diversity Institute is organizing a panel discussion to explore whether legislative measures can have an impact on entrenching gender and diversity within institutional frameworks, governing structures, and organizational norms within the context of existing power and gender imbalances that traditionally exclude marginalized groups and their interests from policy-making venues.
Some public policies tend to exclude a target group that is most likely to benefit from it and deem some people less deserving than others. Representation and meaningful engagement of diverse and marginalized groups in governing and policy-making venues remains a challenge for ethno-racially diverse Western countries. Canada has adopted Bill C-25 mandating the representation of women and diverse groups on the governing boards as a possible solution to it. Whether legislative measures can increase representation of groups such as, women, LGBTQ people, racialized groups, Indigenous people, and persons with disabilities in pubic policy making venues and processes remains unclear. This panel aims to discuss this issue.
The organizers are interested in both theoretical and empirical works which could take an institutional or critical policy analytic approach to address broad research question: whether legislative measures can change institutional frameworks, governing structures, and organizational norms within the context of existing power and gender imbalances that traditionally exclude marginalized groups and their interests from policy-making venues? focusing on Canadian and other immigrant receiving Western Societies.
Papers exploring a range of related research questions could be included. Examples of some research questions are:
- How can we increase gender, diversity, and representation in decision making venues, including public and private corporations and agencies?
- Can legislature improve representation of target groups in institutional contexts in ways that drive positive policy change?
- Could such legislature be institutionalized so as to become normative and exclusionary to the groups that they deem to represent?
- What other some of the non-legislative approaches to improving representation of target groups in Western societies (lessons learnt)?
- What is the role of independent groups, think tanks, interest groups in gender and diversity representation?
Instructions: Please submit an abstract with no more than 350 words including the background and aim, theoretical framework(s), methods of data collection (if applicable), results/findings, and conclusions. Empirical research, theoretical discussions as well as other evidence-based policy papers that fit with the panel theme could be submitted.
About the organizer: The Diversity Institute at Ryerson University conducts and coordinates multi-disciplinary, multi-stakeholder research to address the needs of diverse Canadians. Our action-oriented, evidence-based approach is advancing knowledge of the complex barriers faced by underrepresented groups, leading practices to effect change, and producing concrete results.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Reversing Public Policies for a Sustainable Education for Women in Nigeria.
By
Abdullahi Bala Ado
Department of Local Govt. Studies, School of Rural Technology and Entrepreneurship Development Rano, Kano State Polytechnic, Kano Nigeria.
Email: lajaa10@gmail.com Phone: +2348036917566.
Abstract: The major part of the global struggle is geared towards realizing a sustainable education for women. It is a non fact that women were unjustly left in education due to discrimination arising from gender inequality. The consequence for this discrimination resulted to the present global lost and backwardness. The major question that is still hanging is how the world can bridge the gap education existing between men and their women counter parts. Of course this could be through reversing public policies of education in favor of women. The objective of the study is to analyse the impact of a revised government policies on women education. The paper will also study how these new policies narrows down the existing gap between men and women in terms of educational development. The methodology is drawn from both primary and secondary methods. Questionnaires were distributed to the respondents and oral interviews were conducted. Data was analyzed using structural equation modeling (SEM). It was finally found out that the gap between men and women education has reduced by ten percent (10%) due to the introduction of policies supporting scholarships and free education for women in Jigawa state, Nigeria. The paper recommends that government should maintain the policy of free education. Government should also make partnership with foreign countries and private organisations both local and international for the development of women education.
Keywords: Public Policies, Reversing, Sustainable Education, Women.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This research expands upon the field of gender policy and male domestic violence acceptance in different groups of countries. This work includes an index of women’s empowerment policies understood as defamilisation (Gornick, Bambra, Leitner, Mandel and Shalev, Kröger, Lohmann & Zagel) in the acceptance of the phenomenon.
Theoretically, parental leaves, child care expenditure in pre-primary education, and women’s access to work force lead for woman to have more independence (Farmer & Tiefenthaler, 1996). We envision that women’s empowerment policies reduce acceptability of these practices. This is particularly important to the field, because attitudes towards male domestic violence have shown to increase violent acts (Wang, 2016) and the effects of defamilisation policies should be carefully considered when designing policy.
Male domestic violence attitudes have been analysed from different perspectives on both an individual (England, Gornick, & Fitzgibbons,2012) and country level (Lenze & Klasen, 2017, Heise & Kotsadam,2015). Additionally, welfare state (Yin-Nei Cho, 2014; Bambra, 2004; Gornick & Jacobs, 1998; Sainsbury, 1999; Korpi,2000; O'Connor, 1993) intervention regarding women’s independence from family relationships and with that lead to having more opportunities to leave or avoid being in a relationship with male domestic violence acceptability.
This research utilises individual data from male and female target populations obtained from the most recent wave of the World Values Survey. We focus on sociodemographic data from 47 countries. Secondly, we combine country level data by constructing a defamilisation index, economic related indicators of education and macro economy per country. Finally, we categorize countries using the Esping-Andersen (1990) classic welfare state classification. In general, we anticipate a negative effect of defamilisation policies and varied effects of sociodemographic on opinion towards male domestic violence.
In this regard, its suggested that the more economic independence a woman has—as a consequence of paid work outside the household or outside the marriage—it is more likely for a woman to leave a violent relationship, while it is also less likely for women with economic independence to be in a violent relationship (Farmer & Tiefenthaler, 1996).
We argue, that economic prosperity of women, meaning higher levels of defamilisation reduce positive acceptance of domestic violence. Additionally, countries with certain welfare state traits tend to have lower levels of acceptance of the phenomenon. This systematic investigation contributes in the inclusion of defamilisation policies and its effects towards acceptance of male domestic violence ranging beyond developed countries.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The transformation of the role of women in society has been systematically studied and numerous researches indicate that one of the factors of extreme relevance for this fact is the generalized increase of their presence in the labor market. However, some researchers argue that this increase did not reflect equally in all sectors and positions. , Leadership positions in public administration and management, for instance, still lack gender equity.. This study aims to identify how the presence of women in the Brazilian Federal Agency for the Support and Evaluation of Graduate Education (CAPES) has evolved over the last 20 years. For the quantitative analysis, a survey was conducted in the personnel management systems of the Federal Public Administration. The qualitative analysis will be carried out by interviews with male and female servants who occupy or have held chief and advisory positions in the Agency. The initial hypothesis was that the female presence had increased both in the total number of female servants and in the occupation of chief and advisory positions and that the qualitative analysis reflected this change. However, the preliminary results show that, women have reduced their presence in the Agency, especially in the number of analysts occupying chief and advisory positions. In the next steps will be made the interviews, in parallel, will be lifted the history of the career of Science and Technology and the attributions of the Agency to check if there were any changes that could have contributed to the formation of the current scenario.
Contribution to the panel: The panel proposes to discuss increase gender, diversity, and representation in decision-making venues, which is certainly related to the evaluation of the presence of women in CAPES. In addition, it is a very opportune moment to deepen the discussion since the Agency is producing a guidance document on the subject, which should be followed not only internally but also throughout the Brazilian system of postgraduate and science. With my experience as a Phd student, practioner and member of the CAPES equity committee, I will be able to contribute to the panel discussions and learn a lot from the experiences and theories that will be shared.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
As the last country in the Americas to abolish slavery, Brazil and its society carry a burdening heritage from this period until today. Black citizens still face the worst social conditions expressed by social indicators in health, education and living conditions, and they are also the major part of the population suffering from homicides. In contrast to this scenario, racism was just a recent topic on the governmental agenda. For a very long period, Brazilian society denied the existence of racism and norished the myth of a racial democracy. According to this common belief, in Brazil we live in a racial paradise, where all ethnic groups, blacks, indigenous and whites, live together in perfect harmony. With the implementation of the most recent constitution in the year 1988, the first federal constitution after the end of the military dictatorship in 1985, the situation started to change. By it racism was defined as high-level crime and Afro-Brazilian culture and especially its African heritage were finally considered as national legacy. After the release of the UN Convention against Racism in Durban in the year 2001, the topic received more attention in the governmental agenda.
The last decades witnessed the development of important legal and administrative sanctions: a quota system for black students at Brazil’s public universities and at civil servants selection processes, changes in the national education law in order to include African history and black heritage in the various school curricula etc.. All this was combined with various affirmative actions in culture, health and labour policies as well. Besides these activities, a Ministry of Racial Equality was established in 2003, with the task to promote racial equality mainstreaming within federal government policies and to stimulate these activities on the sub-national government levels as well.
Despite all these activities and actions, having real racial equality still seems far away with a long way to go to reach that objective. Although parts of these policies has been well implemented, some of them have failed to reach their initial goals for various reasons. But this is not only just a problem of implementation, part of the legal support for racial policies is fairly neglected by political stakeholders for various reasons. This situation will be analysed using the theorical approach of institutional change, especially from a gradual and transformative process' point of view. The persistence of the racial democracy discourse within Brazilian society will also be considered.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
ABSTRACT
Universities have historically within the global context been the purview and domain of men who have occupied the senior academic and managerial ranks. This status quo has been and remains evident in the South African context on account of its socio-political history. Recruitment to universities has been defined by historic segregation and a system steeped in patriarchy where men in academic leadership positions have been instrumental in defining the organisational structure and culture of universities (Morley 2012:117, Thaver 2010:44). The primary question that under pins this discussion is as follows: Does the dominant ideology of the separatism of the apartheid regime hold a continued footprint in the university landscape in the democratic dispensation relative to gender equity and equality within the senior academic ranks and university management?
Concerted efforts have been made to minimise the gender gap. However, the representation of women at the top echelons of academia continues to be limited and gender disparity remains evident consequently a challenge to co-creation of decision-making befitting to transformation and diversity within academia (Guarino & Borden 2017:674, Mbokela & Mlambo 2017, Zulu 2016). The primary focus of this conceptual paper is an exploration of policy initiatives and strategies that seeks gender equity in academia as well as equality of opportunity to progress within the ranks. The discussion will in respect of the democratic era explore the policy goals and priorities adopted toward achieving gender equity within the academic staffing compliment of South African universities from 2005 to 2017. Policy narrative analysis is in respect of the tenets of critical discourse analysis.
Equity in the context of this paper is the representation of women at all strata within the university, while equality is the opportunity to progress within the ranks as well as to share in the power distribution and decision-making within academia to influence institutional decision-making and the definition of the organisational culture. The quest for equality infers that women should hold the same civil liberties and access within the academic landscape as their male counterparts, particularly in an era that deems decolonisation of the academic landscape as critical for engendering social cohesion. The discussion is premised in the Rawlsian construct of social justice with the lens on The Principle of Fair Equality of Opportunity (Buchanan 1980:27).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Ontario’s urban Indigenous Peoples are understudied despite the facts that half of Canada’s Indigenous population live in urban centres, one in five of Canada’s Indigenous population live in Ontario, and the Six Nations of the Grand River, adjacent to the town of Brantford, has the largest reserve population in Canada. This research project selected Brantford, Hamilton and Niagara to build on previous research that mapped Municipal-Indigenous relations in seven municipalities across Canada. Brantford, Hamilton and Niagara are pivotal in demonstrating how Indigenous inclusive governance is emerging in Canada.
Answering the question, What does inclusive governance look like? involves an investigation that builds on addressing the following: How are Indigenous Peoples represented in municipal government in Ontario? What is the relationship between municipal government and urban Indigenous peoples? The paper commences with context that positions urban Indigenous peoples in Canada, followed by a discussion of Municipal-Indigenous relations in selected cities in Canada. Next, is an introduction to, and a discussion of Municipal-Indigenous relationships in Brantford, Hamilton and Niagara.
This empirical study addresses inclusive governance by mapping the representation of Indigenous peoples in Canada generally, and three municipalities in Ontario (Canada’s largest province in population), specifically. The three Ontario municipalities are pivotal in disclosing the finding that larger urban centres with proportionately smaller Indigenous populations are moving toward substantive Indigenous inclusion in municipal governance when compared to smaller municipalities with proportionately higher Indigenous populations.
A place-based policy approach is specifically designed to analyze Municipal-Indigenous relationships (Bradford and Chouinard 2010; Bradford 2005). This approach bridges the physical and power infrastructures at a specific geographical scale with social infrastructures and community networks characterized by the following four elements. First, it acknowledges that local knowledge is key to effective problem-solving. Second, it locates the desired policy mix by balancing targeted measures for spatial locations and “aspatial” polices for housing and education, for example. Third, it emphasizes collaboration among government and civil society and across and between varying levels of government. And finally, it acknowledges local governments as crucial actors in the governance of the place-based policy framework supported with recognition and capacity (Bradford 2005: v). The anticipated significance of this approach is to bring awareness to a broader policy community and enable dialogues that can best address Indigenous inclusion in policy processes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
There is a long history of “gender mainstreaming” in Europe and North America and, more recently, increased attention to intersectionality. Alongside this we have witnessed the growth of “gender budgeting” tools, promulgated by a range of governments and international organisations. However, while there has been considerable discussion about the importance of intersectionality and attention to diversity in both these policy projects, it is not yet evident that 1) the term intersectionality resonates with policy makers and 2) that sufficient attention has been given to indigenous perspectives in analysing how best to design inclusive gender responsive budgeting. In this paper we engage with both feminist and indigenous scholarship on the operationalisation and integration of intersectionality into public policy, recognising that these approaches might provide diverse understandings on what “best practice” looks like. We then seek to apply these learnings to the case of a (potential) gender budgeting strategy for New Zealand. Specifically we are interested in identifying what is required to ensure the design and implementation of gender budgeting as a new policy instrument, is inclusive of Māori (NZ’s indigenous peoples).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
One of the ways by which women enter the political arena is through political dynasties—families or clans with members holding the same elected position in succession or occupying different elected positions at the same time. While studies suggest that dynasties particularly in Western democracies are declining, they remain resilient in certain countries. In the Philippines, dynasties ensure that elective positions remain within the family. Recent literature suggests that political dynasties help to increase the number of women in government elective positions and that dynastic politics favour women political aspirants more than men.
This paper takes a particular interest in the study of political dynasties in relation to the substantive representation of women (SRW). It examines how dynastic politics pervades institutional practices that support or constrain SRW. It takes a comprehensive approach to determining the various factors that influenced the ratification of the Philippines’ Magna Carta of Women (MCW) Act of 2009. The MCW is considered as the country’s women’s human rights law and its version of the Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW).
The paper asks the following questions: What factors contributed to the passage of the Philippines’ Women’s Rights Law (Magna Carta of Women Act of 2009)? How did institutional arrangements shape policy outcomes? Who are the critical actors in the passage of this legislation? Considering the dynastic feature of the Philippine legislature and that majority of women legislators are from dynastic backgrounds, how do political dynasties impact the work of women legislators as regards gender equality laws? How does the work of dynastic women legislators differ from non-dynastic women legislators?
The paper contributes to the aims and objectives of the panel by presenting an unexplored aspect of women’s representation and how it influences women’s rights policy making. Political dynasties blur the lines between the personal and the official hence the proclivity for familial relationships to encroach on official boundaries, especially about contentious issues such as women’s rights.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Based on interviews with police officers who define themselves as homosexual, bi-, trans- and heterosexual as well as with the French LGBT Police Association, our communication analyses the emergence of an "LGBT cause" within the French police. What are the dynamics of this mobilization and how does it "troubles" the gender of an occupational culture based on male heteronormativity? How are the individual trajectories of police officers affected by this context?
Our communication documents the history of this atypical mobilization, examines its resources and its repertoire of action. By working for both cultural and legal change with regard to LGBT police officers, this professional association is a major player in the transition from a repressive paradigm of homosexuality in the police environment to a dynamic of recognition. On the one hand, it aims to ensure that discrimination experienced by gay, lesbian and transgender police officers is recognized within the institution. On the other hand, it is working to improve the reception and treatment by police services of gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender applicants. We assume that this politicization of the homosexual question within the institution has the effect of challenging the gender order within the police professional culture as well as some professional standards: the duty of reserve, the strict control of corporatist interests by unions and the right to demonstrate police officers (particularly during the "Pride March").
The interviews (N=30) we conducted with LGBT police officers, whether or not they are members of this association, reveal the dynamics of individual trajectories. We show that non-heterosexual sexualities are minorized and struggling for their legitimization within the police occupational culture: our investigation reveals tensions between forms of recognition of homosexuality and the persistence of assignatory, discriminatory and/or violent speech and practices inherited from a professional culture marked by heteronormativity and homophobia. This dimension is often a major issue in a profession where the relationship between physical strength and the body is central and where private and professional life are mixed.
Based on this material, our communication questions the articulation between gender norms and sexualities. Our survey shows that perceptions of sexuality are based on gender norms in the police environment. In a heterogeneous universe where the dominant gender of the institution remains heterosexual masculinity, the deviant nature of homosexuality tends to be measured against the male/female divide: non-heterosexual sexualities will tend to be better accepted if the police associated with them conform to the attributes of virile masculinity; conversely, non-heterosexual sexualities associated with brands of femininity will tend to be regarded as deviant.
Finally, this research allows us to observe the intersection of causes in practice. Indeed, the "French LGBT Police Association" refuses for the moment to intervene in the field of ethno-racial discrimination despite the increasing number of requests addressed to it. The research thus makes it possible to understand the differentiated conditions for legitimizing issues related to sexuality and those related to ethno-racial belonging.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Reversing Public Policies for a Sustainable Education for Women in Nigeria.
By
Abdullahi Bala Ado
Department of Local Govt. Studies, School of Rural Technology and Entrepreneurship Development Rano, Kano State Polytechnic, Kano Nigeria.
Email: lajaa10@gmail.com Phone: +2348036917566.
Abstract: The major part of the global struggle is geared towards realizing a sustainable education for women. It is a non fact that women were unjustly left in education due to discrimination arising from gender inequality. The consequence for this discrimination resulted to the present global lost and backwardness. The major question that is still hanging is how the world can bridge the gap education existing between men and their women counter parts. Of course this could be through reversing public policies of education in favor of women. The objective of the study is to analyse the impact of a revised government policies on women education. The paper will also study how these new policies narrows down the existing gap between men and women in terms of educational development. The methodology is drawn from both primary and secondary methods. Questionnaires were distributed to the respondents and oral interviews were conducted. Data was analyzed using structural equation modeling (SEM). It was finally found out that the gap between men and women education has reduced by ten percent (10%) due to the introduction of policies supporting scholarships and free education for women in Jigawa state, Nigeria. The paper recommends that government should maintain the policy of free education. Government should also make partnership with foreign countries and private organisations both local and international for the development of women education.
Keywords: Public Policies, Reversing, Sustainable Education, Women.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This research expands upon the field of gender policy and male domestic violence acceptance in different groups of countries. This work includes an index of women’s empowerment policies understood as defamilisation (Gornick, Bambra, Leitner, Mandel and Shalev, Kröger, Lohmann & Zagel) in the acceptance of the phenomenon.
Theoretically, parental leaves, child care expenditure in pre-primary education, and women’s access to work force lead for woman to have more independence (Farmer & Tiefenthaler, 1996). We envision that women’s empowerment policies reduce acceptability of these practices. This is particularly important to the field, because attitudes towards male domestic violence have shown to increase violent acts (Wang, 2016) and the effects of defamilisation policies should be carefully considered when designing policy.
Male domestic violence attitudes have been analysed from different perspectives on both an individual (England, Gornick, & Fitzgibbons,2012) and country level (Lenze & Klasen, 2017, Heise & Kotsadam,2015). Additionally, welfare state (Yin-Nei Cho, 2014; Bambra, 2004; Gornick & Jacobs, 1998; Sainsbury, 1999; Korpi,2000; O'Connor, 1993) intervention regarding women’s independence from family relationships and with that lead to having more opportunities to leave or avoid being in a relationship with male domestic violence acceptability.
This research utilises individual data from male and female target populations obtained from the most recent wave of the World Values Survey. We focus on sociodemographic data from 47 countries. Secondly, we combine country level data by constructing a defamilisation index, economic related indicators of education and macro economy per country. Finally, we categorize countries using the Esping-Andersen (1990) classic welfare state classification. In general, we anticipate a negative effect of defamilisation policies and varied effects of sociodemographic on opinion towards male domestic violence.
In this regard, its suggested that the more economic independence a woman has—as a consequence of paid work outside the household or outside the marriage—it is more likely for a woman to leave a violent relationship, while it is also less likely for women with economic independence to be in a violent relationship (Farmer & Tiefenthaler, 1996).
We argue, that economic prosperity of women, meaning higher levels of defamilisation reduce positive acceptance of domestic violence. Additionally, countries with certain welfare state traits tend to have lower levels of acceptance of the phenomenon. This systematic investigation contributes in the inclusion of defamilisation policies and its effects towards acceptance of male domestic violence ranging beyond developed countries.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The transformation of the role of women in society has been systematically studied and numerous researches indicate that one of the factors of extreme relevance for this fact is the generalized increase of their presence in the labor market. However, some researchers argue that this increase did not reflect equally in all sectors and positions. , Leadership positions in public administration and management, for instance, still lack gender equity.. This study aims to identify how the presence of women in the Brazilian Federal Agency for the Support and Evaluation of Graduate Education (CAPES) has evolved over the last 20 years. For the quantitative analysis, a survey was conducted in the personnel management systems of the Federal Public Administration. The qualitative analysis will be carried out by interviews with male and female servants who occupy or have held chief and advisory positions in the Agency. The initial hypothesis was that the female presence had increased both in the total number of female servants and in the occupation of chief and advisory positions and that the qualitative analysis reflected this change. However, the preliminary results show that, women have reduced their presence in the Agency, especially in the number of analysts occupying chief and advisory positions. In the next steps will be made the interviews, in parallel, will be lifted the history of the career of Science and Technology and the attributions of the Agency to check if there were any changes that could have contributed to the formation of the current scenario.
Contribution to the panel: The panel proposes to discuss increase gender, diversity, and representation in decision-making venues, which is certainly related to the evaluation of the presence of women in CAPES. In addition, it is a very opportune moment to deepen the discussion since the Agency is producing a guidance document on the subject, which should be followed not only internally but also throughout the Brazilian system of postgraduate and science. With my experience as a Phd student, practioner and member of the CAPES equity committee, I will be able to contribute to the panel discussions and learn a lot from the experiences and theories that will be shared.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
As the last country in the Americas to abolish slavery, Brazil and its society carry a burdening heritage from this period until today. Black citizens still face the worst social conditions expressed by social indicators in health, education and living conditions, and they are also the major part of the population suffering from homicides. In contrast to this scenario, racism was just a recent topic on the governmental agenda. For a very long period, Brazilian society denied the existence of racism and norished the myth of a racial democracy. According to this common belief, in Brazil we live in a racial paradise, where all ethnic groups, blacks, indigenous and whites, live together in perfect harmony. With the implementation of the most recent constitution in the year 1988, the first federal constitution after the end of the military dictatorship in 1985, the situation started to change. By it racism was defined as high-level crime and Afro-Brazilian culture and especially its African heritage were finally considered as national legacy. After the release of the UN Convention against Racism in Durban in the year 2001, the topic received more attention in the governmental agenda.
The last decades witnessed the development of important legal and administrative sanctions: a quota system for black students at Brazil’s public universities and at civil servants selection processes, changes in the national education law in order to include African history and black heritage in the various school curricula etc.. All this was combined with various affirmative actions in culture, health and labour policies as well. Besides these activities, a Ministry of Racial Equality was established in 2003, with the task to promote racial equality mainstreaming within federal government policies and to stimulate these activities on the sub-national government levels as well.
Despite all these activities and actions, having real racial equality still seems far away with a long way to go to reach that objective. Although parts of these policies has been well implemented, some of them have failed to reach their initial goals for various reasons. But this is not only just a problem of implementation, part of the legal support for racial policies is fairly neglected by political stakeholders for various reasons. This situation will be analysed using the theorical approach of institutional change, especially from a gradual and transformative process' point of view. The persistence of the racial democracy discourse within Brazilian society will also be considered.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
ABSTRACT
Universities have historically within the global context been the purview and domain of men who have occupied the senior academic and managerial ranks. This status quo has been and remains evident in the South African context on account of its socio-political history. Recruitment to universities has been defined by historic segregation and a system steeped in patriarchy where men in academic leadership positions have been instrumental in defining the organisational structure and culture of universities (Morley 2012:117, Thaver 2010:44). The primary question that under pins this discussion is as follows: Does the dominant ideology of the separatism of the apartheid regime hold a continued footprint in the university landscape in the democratic dispensation relative to gender equity and equality within the senior academic ranks and university management?
Concerted efforts have been made to minimise the gender gap. However, the representation of women at the top echelons of academia continues to be limited and gender disparity remains evident consequently a challenge to co-creation of decision-making befitting to transformation and diversity within academia (Guarino & Borden 2017:674, Mbokela & Mlambo 2017, Zulu 2016). The primary focus of this conceptual paper is an exploration of policy initiatives and strategies that seeks gender equity in academia as well as equality of opportunity to progress within the ranks. The discussion will in respect of the democratic era explore the policy goals and priorities adopted toward achieving gender equity within the academic staffing compliment of South African universities from 2005 to 2017. Policy narrative analysis is in respect of the tenets of critical discourse analysis.
Equity in the context of this paper is the representation of women at all strata within the university, while equality is the opportunity to progress within the ranks as well as to share in the power distribution and decision-making within academia to influence institutional decision-making and the definition of the organisational culture. The quest for equality infers that women should hold the same civil liberties and access within the academic landscape as their male counterparts, particularly in an era that deems decolonisation of the academic landscape as critical for engendering social cohesion. The discussion is premised in the Rawlsian construct of social justice with the lens on The Principle of Fair Equality of Opportunity (Buchanan 1980:27).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Ontario’s urban Indigenous Peoples are understudied despite the facts that half of Canada’s Indigenous population live in urban centres, one in five of Canada’s Indigenous population live in Ontario, and the Six Nations of the Grand River, adjacent to the town of Brantford, has the largest reserve population in Canada. This research project selected Brantford, Hamilton and Niagara to build on previous research that mapped Municipal-Indigenous relations in seven municipalities across Canada. Brantford, Hamilton and Niagara are pivotal in demonstrating how Indigenous inclusive governance is emerging in Canada.
Answering the question, What does inclusive governance look like? involves an investigation that builds on addressing the following: How are Indigenous Peoples represented in municipal government in Ontario? What is the relationship between municipal government and urban Indigenous peoples? The paper commences with context that positions urban Indigenous peoples in Canada, followed by a discussion of Municipal-Indigenous relations in selected cities in Canada. Next, is an introduction to, and a discussion of Municipal-Indigenous relationships in Brantford, Hamilton and Niagara.
This empirical study addresses inclusive governance by mapping the representation of Indigenous peoples in Canada generally, and three municipalities in Ontario (Canada’s largest province in population), specifically. The three Ontario municipalities are pivotal in disclosing the finding that larger urban centres with proportionately smaller Indigenous populations are moving toward substantive Indigenous inclusion in municipal governance when compared to smaller municipalities with proportionately higher Indigenous populations.
A place-based policy approach is specifically designed to analyze Municipal-Indigenous relationships (Bradford and Chouinard 2010; Bradford 2005). This approach bridges the physical and power infrastructures at a specific geographical scale with social infrastructures and community networks characterized by the following four elements. First, it acknowledges that local knowledge is key to effective problem-solving. Second, it locates the desired policy mix by balancing targeted measures for spatial locations and “aspatial” polices for housing and education, for example. Third, it emphasizes collaboration among government and civil society and across and between varying levels of government. And finally, it acknowledges local governments as crucial actors in the governance of the place-based policy framework supported with recognition and capacity (Bradford 2005: v). The anticipated significance of this approach is to bring awareness to a broader policy community and enable dialogues that can best address Indigenous inclusion in policy processes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
There is a long history of “gender mainstreaming” in Europe and North America and, more recently, increased attention to intersectionality. Alongside this we have witnessed the growth of “gender budgeting” tools, promulgated by a range of governments and international organisations. However, while there has been considerable discussion about the importance of intersectionality and attention to diversity in both these policy projects, it is not yet evident that 1) the term intersectionality resonates with policy makers and 2) that sufficient attention has been given to indigenous perspectives in analysing how best to design inclusive gender responsive budgeting. In this paper we engage with both feminist and indigenous scholarship on the operationalisation and integration of intersectionality into public policy, recognising that these approaches might provide diverse understandings on what “best practice” looks like. We then seek to apply these learnings to the case of a (potential) gender budgeting strategy for New Zealand. Specifically we are interested in identifying what is required to ensure the design and implementation of gender budgeting as a new policy instrument, is inclusive of Māori (NZ’s indigenous peoples).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
One of the ways by which women enter the political arena is through political dynasties—families or clans with members holding the same elected position in succession or occupying different elected positions at the same time. While studies suggest that dynasties particularly in Western democracies are declining, they remain resilient in certain countries. In the Philippines, dynasties ensure that elective positions remain within the family. Recent literature suggests that political dynasties help to increase the number of women in government elective positions and that dynastic politics favour women political aspirants more than men.
This paper takes a particular interest in the study of political dynasties in relation to the substantive representation of women (SRW). It examines how dynastic politics pervades institutional practices that support or constrain SRW. It takes a comprehensive approach to determining the various factors that influenced the ratification of the Philippines’ Magna Carta of Women (MCW) Act of 2009. The MCW is considered as the country’s women’s human rights law and its version of the Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW).
The paper asks the following questions: What factors contributed to the passage of the Philippines’ Women’s Rights Law (Magna Carta of Women Act of 2009)? How did institutional arrangements shape policy outcomes? Who are the critical actors in the passage of this legislation? Considering the dynastic feature of the Philippine legislature and that majority of women legislators are from dynastic backgrounds, how do political dynasties impact the work of women legislators as regards gender equality laws? How does the work of dynastic women legislators differ from non-dynastic women legislators?
The paper contributes to the aims and objectives of the panel by presenting an unexplored aspect of women’s representation and how it influences women’s rights policy making. Political dynasties blur the lines between the personal and the official hence the proclivity for familial relationships to encroach on official boundaries, especially about contentious issues such as women’s rights.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Based on interviews with police officers who define themselves as homosexual, bi-, trans- and heterosexual as well as with the French LGBT Police Association, our communication analyses the emergence of an "LGBT cause" within the French police. What are the dynamics of this mobilization and how does it "troubles" the gender of an occupational culture based on male heteronormativity? How are the individual trajectories of police officers affected by this context?
Our communication documents the history of this atypical mobilization, examines its resources and its repertoire of action. By working for both cultural and legal change with regard to LGBT police officers, this professional association is a major player in the transition from a repressive paradigm of homosexuality in the police environment to a dynamic of recognition. On the one hand, it aims to ensure that discrimination experienced by gay, lesbian and transgender police officers is recognized within the institution. On the other hand, it is working to improve the reception and treatment by police services of gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender applicants. We assume that this politicization of the homosexual question within the institution has the effect of challenging the gender order within the police professional culture as well as some professional standards: the duty of reserve, the strict control of corporatist interests by unions and the right to demonstrate police officers (particularly during the "Pride March").
The interviews (N=30) we conducted with LGBT police officers, whether or not they are members of this association, reveal the dynamics of individual trajectories. We show that non-heterosexual sexualities are minorized and struggling for their legitimization within the police occupational culture: our investigation reveals tensions between forms of recognition of homosexuality and the persistence of assignatory, discriminatory and/or violent speech and practices inherited from a professional culture marked by heteronormativity and homophobia. This dimension is often a major issue in a profession where the relationship between physical strength and the body is central and where private and professional life are mixed.
Based on this material, our communication questions the articulation between gender norms and sexualities. Our survey shows that perceptions of sexuality are based on gender norms in the police environment. In a heterogeneous universe where the dominant gender of the institution remains heterosexual masculinity, the deviant nature of homosexuality tends to be measured against the male/female divide: non-heterosexual sexualities will tend to be better accepted if the police associated with them conform to the attributes of virile masculinity; conversely, non-heterosexual sexualities associated with brands of femininity will tend to be regarded as deviant.
Finally, this research allows us to observe the intersection of causes in practice. Indeed, the "French LGBT Police Association" refuses for the moment to intervene in the field of ethno-racial discrimination despite the increasing number of requests addressed to it. The research thus makes it possible to understand the differentiated conditions for legitimizing issues related to sexuality and those related to ethno-racial belonging.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)