CATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
With many post-industrial democracies undergoing dramatic shifts to the right, a few states, such as Canada, New Zealand, and Iceland, for example, stand out on the world stage for their explicit commitment to progressive, specifically feminist, politics. Indeed, the Prime Ministers in these countries have expressly committed to improving the lives of women and marginalized groups through their established feminist policy agendas. While these developments appear promising, the literatures on state feminism, state engagement, and feminist public administration remind us of the potential contradictory effects that result when states take up and deploy feminist knowledge. Towards this end, the objectives of this panel (which is one of two proposed panels on feminist governance and policy) are as follows:
- to explore the factors that have contributed to the re-emergence of feminism as a political force;
- to investigate and unpack what feminism means in these contexts and how it is practiced;
- to explore how feminist knowledges are taken up and deployed by governments and its effects;
- to understand how feminist mobilization is resisting populist forces
CALL FOR PAPERS
With many post-industrial democracies undergoing dramatic shifts to the right, a few states, such as Canada, New Zealand, and Iceland, for example, stand out on the world stage for their explicit commitment to progressive, specifically feminist, politics. Indeed, the Prime Ministers in these countries have expressly committed to improving the lives of women and marginalized groups through their established feminist policy agendas. With this panel, we seek to understand the emergence of these feminist policy agendas, particularly against the current backdrop of right-wing radicalism, as well as their associated processes and content. How might we explain the (re)emergence of feminism as a political force in contemporary politics? What does feminism mean in these contexts? How has it shaped policy discourses, architectures, processes, and outcomes? Towards this end, we invite papers that address, but are not limited to, the following topics:
· Feminism in policy practice: policy analysis, consultation/deliberation, implementation and evaluation
· Feminist policy in practice: feminist expertise, policy outcomes, etc.
· Feminist political discourse: what does it mean, who is included, etc.
· Backlash against feminism
· Protest politics and social movements
· Governance feminism/feminist governance
· Intersectionality in feminist policy and institutions
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the course of recent decades, scientists from psychology, economics, sociology and other different disciplines have attempted to comprehend why women are under-represented in STEM (science, technology, engineering and mathematics) field. One of the main causes of the gender wage gap is male-female sorting into different degrees and corresponding occupations, this is why encouraging women into STEM fields has become an important policy. Our STEM workforce is crucial to Kazakhstan’s innovative capacity and global competitiveness. Yet women are vastly underrepresented in STEM jobs and among STEM degree holders despite making up nearly half of the Kazakhstan workforce and half of the educated workforce. That leaves an untapped opportunity to expand STEM employment in the Republic of Kazakhstan, even as there is wide agreement that the nation must do more to improve its competitiveness. Although women fill close to half of all jobs in the Kazakhstan economy, they hold less than 10 percent of STEM jobs. This has been the case throughout the past decade, even as educated women have increased their share of the overall workforce.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The first police services, taking the place of what is now the Cameroonian police, have always been the sanctuary of masculinity since its creation in 1928. Inspired by France, this police institution was created, and welcomed as head of the Captain Beauquinot, under the name of Commissariat de Douala by an Order of the High Commissioner of the French Republic in Cameroon. Following plural dynamics, we have witnessed major social, economic and political transformations in the majority of sectors of social life; which transformations have had important consequences for social relations of sex and gender. Since the years 1966, some women (04) were enlisted within this microcosm following the presidential decree n ° 66 / DF / 024 of June 05 bearing general regime of the contests. Since then, the number of girls and women has been steadily increasing. Because they counted until then at the end of the fingers and today they count to more than 2512 police officers against 13415 police (Direction of the Human Resources of Cameroonian police, 2017). Despite of this legal provision in favor of gender diversity, girls and women are still the subject of many gender-based violence to the point of disrupting the principle of gender equality and generating new problems such as identity discomfort. Therefore, how can we understand the resurgence of representations and practices that challenge and transgress the egalitarian values enshrined in a legal arsenal of promotion and protection of gender equality ? From this questioning, we formulate the hypothesis that the Cameroonian police constitute an excellent microcosm to understand the actions of perpetuation of gender inequalities. The purpose of this paper is to analyze the logic of action of the persistence of gender asymmetries, the unspoken survivals of gender-based violence and the strength of the hyper-masculinization of the cameroonian police. The analysis proposed here is based on a perspective that combines historical sociology (Norbert Elias), symbolic interactionism (Herbert Blumer) and ethnomethodology (Harold Garfinkel). Enriched with field data collected in Cameroon in 2014 and 2016, this contribution by focusing on the qualitative approach (interviews) allows us to identify and especially to analyze the explanatory logics of the resistance of patriarchal structures of domination and maintenance, sometimes the reinforcement of disparities and gender inequalities in the Cameroonian police in the era of gender promotion in Cameroon's public space.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The development debates during the last three decades have been conducted from the vantage points of different protagonists. It is noteworthy that among them a new protagonist has arrived and has forcefully established her presence—the women. The commonality among theses different strata of women is that they face oppression and subordination in and from the society due to their gender. Thus, gender discrimination in society has been accepted as a variable in the development paradigm. The perspectives and viewpoints of women provide a unique and powerful vantage point from which we can examine the developmental programmes and strategies (Sen and Grown). The issue of participation also needs to be viewed from a gendered aspect. The disproportionate participation of women in political institutions and process is an established fact. In fact, it is perhaps, not an exaggeration to say that one of the major achievements of Women’s Studies is that it has equipped various aspects and issue to be studied through a gender-lens. Participation in the political system or, politics as such is one such issue.
Although it is difficult to establish a linear relationship between feminism and increased political participation, feminist ideals do stress egalitarian participation, democratization of all leadership roles, careful listening, respect for the experiences of all women, self-transformation and autonomy through intimate sharing and small group support. The issue of participation is generally viewed from a liberal, individualistic framework. However,the capability approach as developed by Sen (2000) and Martha Nussbaum (2000) has a powerful influence in the development paradigm today. Sen’s work has been particularly influential in the formulation of the United Nations’ “Human Development Index”. Thus we may reference to a new vision of participatory democracy which focuses on gender. Alexander and Mohanty have developed this concept of feminist democracy that links commitments to participatory democracy, the development of capacities and the eradication of gender and other forms of structural inequality. For them, feminist democracy is both the ultimate goal and the collective process through which it will be achieved. Further, feminist democracy suggests a different order of relationships among people. Keeping in view the above theoretical backdrop, the paper seeks to examine the experiences of womens’ participation in the local self government in India.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This study addresses the question of why Japan, a country with a long-established democracy, has failed to introduce a gender quota law to address the gender imbalance in the national and subnational legislatures. Many prior analyses have attributed this failure to Japan’s women’s movement, despite its efforts to exert strong pressure for reform, for being too weak and fragmented to achieve its objective. Contrary to this prevailing perspective, this study argues that it is not the weakness of women’s movement but, under the conservative rule of the Liberal Democratic Party’s protracted political dominance, the absence of male elites’ strategic or electoral incentives that has decreased the likelihood of Japan’s quota adoption. It is then argued that the passage of the Candidate Gender Equality Law in 2018 is a political compromise and byproduct of the power imbalance between the ruling Liberal Democratic Party and the opposition parties. Given the weakness of the fragmented opposition parties, the conservative Liberal Democratic Party approved the bill drafted by a supra-partisan parliamentary group ostensibly to promote the principle of equality in the proportion of male and female candidates, but made it contingent upon the condition that it is only a symbolic law and not legally binding with a punitive clause.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The Canadian government has committed to implementing gender-based analysis plus (GBA+) in its federal departments. GBA+ assesses how women, men and gender diverse individuals experience policy and programs differently and the ways that intersecting identities influence these experiences. In this paper, I will assess whether the implementation of GBA+ by the LGBTQ2 Secretariat is evident, particularly in their efforts directed towards Two-Spirit communities. The LGBTQ2 Secretariat was created in 2017 to support the Canadian Prime Minister’s special advisor on LGBTQ2 issues and to inform the government about important issues regarding LGBTQ2 communities. Considering LGBTQ2 communities are not homogeneous, questioning the level of intersectionality employed by the LGBTQ2 Secretariat in its efforts is necessary. For example, Two-Spirit communities are not only considered gender and/or sexually diverse, but they are also members of Indigenous communities; consequently, they are at risk of experiencing multiple forms of oppression related to sexism, homophobia/transphobia, settler colonialism, racism and classism.
Therefore, in this paper, I will question whether the LGBTQ2 Secretariat uses GBA+ to assess how proposed LGBTQ2-related policies and programs may impact Two-Spirit communities differently than other LGBTQ communities. For instance, does the LGBTQ2 Secretariat simply ‘add on’ Two-Spirit communities to the LGBTQ acronym in its initiatives, or does it consider that Two-Spirit communities not only experience homophobia/transphobia within their Indigenous communities, but also racism within LGBTQ communities? Does the LGBTQ2 Secretariat's policies/programs acknowledge that Two-Communities are not universal, but that each Indigenous tribe may have different beliefs and values regarding gender and sexual diversity? Finally, are there policies/programs proposed to address the loss of Two-Spirit culture through colonization, through the imposition of gender and sexual binaries, as well as address ongoing settler colonialism?
In order to answer these questions, I will assess the various efforts by the LGBTQ2 Secretariat. For example, I will analyse their ‘Free to be me’ website, particularly under their ‘news and update’ section; I will search through the Hansard for references to the LGBTQ community and/or Two-Spirit communities; and I will question if there are any intergovernmental efforts between the LGBTQ Secretariat and Indigenous Services Canada. If the LGBTQ2 Secretariat is implementing GBA+, then an intersectional consideration for Two-Spirit communities should be evident.
This paper fits with the theme of the “Feminist Governance in the 21st Century” panel because GBA+ developed from gender-based analysis; a policy tool used to assess how policy may impact men and women differently. GBA was originally adopted by the Canadian federal government to advance gender equality and is based on feminist knowledges; consequently, GBA+ is a feminist policy tool that has been implemented by the federal government to improve the lives of not only women, but all marginalized communities. Therefore, questioning whether the LGBTQ2 Secretariat uses GBA+ will not only exemplify how a feminist policy tool can contribute to understanding how policies and programs are experienced differently, but will also hold the Canadian government accountable to its commitment in implementing GBA+.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In 2019, the Nevada State Legislature became the first congress to assemble a government where female lawmakers comprised the majority. From the bordellos of the Comstock to the Las Vegas Strip, Nevada’s history has been characterized by a unique culture of vice and virtue. This legacy endures, exhibited predominately today by an international tourist economy which capitalizes on colorful histories and competing motifs disseminated within a culture of nonstop action and entertainment. Whether its live shows, gentlemen’s clubs, or state-sanctioned prostitution, Nevada’s feminine mystique is often portrayed by popular culture through a dialogue of female stereotypes. Yet, despite this Nevadans’ have elected a majority of women to state government, and female politicos have now come to be the majority within the Nevada State Legislature. Considering the competing narratives, it begs the question of how did this happen and what are the public policy implications of a female-majority legislature? Certainly, many post-industrial democracies have seen the rise of female-majority governments, as a new political discourse inclusive to feminist policies has arrived and shifted the legislative debate towards increased social intervention for our most marginalized populations. Nevada’s new female majority state legislature represents a new chapter in this movement, and as a result, presents a social context ripe for empirical study. Through an assemblage of qualitative data – personal interviews, legislative artifacts, and reports of legislative activity – we seek to understand how a female majority legislature impacts public policy. Specifically, how has a female majority in the Nevada State Legislature shaped policy priorities and altered the dynamics of discourse within the policymaking process? Has a new dialogue emerged, and if so how has this impacted policymaking in Nevada?
For this paper, we utilize a critical discourse analysis framework because language utilized by policymakers can serve as a mechanism to delimit the legislative arena, and unavoidably impact legislative actions (Fischer, 2003; Fischer & Gottweis, 2012). Language use is always strategic and all expressions have an epistemological agenda or a way of seeing the world (Hajer, 2006; Johnstone, 2002). Agendas are present within policymaking discourse, as actors utilize dialogue to make representations concerning actions and events, and depictions of knowledge status are revealed through the nomenclature or word choice of actors through the incorporation of stakeholders and other voices into the legislative process (Fischer & Gottweis, 2012; Hajer, 2006). In this way, beliefs, whether conscious or unconscious, are mediated through discourse, and the utility of language corresponds with the perception of reality. Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA) focuses on unveiling the hidden agenda of discourse in the social world and is drawn from critical theory (Fairclough, 2001; Cameron, 2001). Critical theory and CDA discern the connections between language and other elements in social life that are often opaque. By utilizing this methodology, we will uncover how discourse connects to social expressions of power and domination, including how language and ideology intersect with a policymaker’s personal and social identities.
References
Cameron, D. (2001). Working with spoken discourse. London; Thousand Oaks, Calif.: Sage.
Fairclough, N. (2001). The discourse of new labour: Critical discourse analysis. In M. Wetherell, S. Taylor, & S. Yates (Eds.), Discourse as data: a guide for analysis. (pp. 229-265). London; Thousand Oaks, Calif.: SAGE in association with The Open University.
Fischer, F. (2003). Reframing public policy: Discursive politics and deliberative practices. Oxford, NY: Oxford University Press.
Fischer, F. & Gottweis, H. (Eds.). (2012). The argumentative turn revisited: Public policy as communicative practice. Duke University Press.
Hajer, M. A. (2006). Doing discourse analysis: Coalitions, practices, meaning. In M. van den Brink & T. Metze (Eds.), Words matter in policy and planning (pp. 65-74). The Netherlands: Netherlands Geographical Studies (ISSN 0169-4839).
Johnstone, B. (2002). Discourse analysis: Introducing linguistics. Malden, MA: Black-
well Publishers.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The university should ideally represent an environment where each student and staff member enjoys equal safety, freedoms and opportunities. Sadly, however, this is not always the case. Sometimes, universities are also a place of sexual violence, harassment, oppression and domination. As a consequence of discussions triggered by #MeToo and #timesup, the universities started to pro-actively address sexual violence, and harassment by adopting new institutional policies, reporting mechanisms, and campaigns.
The research has three goals. First, it aims to explore the implications of intersectionality in the context of sexual violence and harassment within the context of the higher education sector in Scotland. Second, it examines to what extent the intersectional approach is embraced in newly adopted institutional policies. Third, the study provides recommendations for improving these policies to account for the complexity of inequalities.
The study explores how gender intersects with race, ethnicity, sexual orientation, and disability in terms of the impact of sexual violence and harassment on university staff and students. Contemporary feminist research has emphasised intersectionality as a holistic paradigm in investigating the complexity of inequalities. This study builds on the work of Crenshaw and hooks to explore how cumulative inequalities impact on experiences of sexual violence and harassment and whether it differentially impacts university staff and students depending on their particular location within the intersectionality paradigm.
Quantitative (campus-wide survey) and qualitative research methods (interviews and focus groups with self-selected students and staff at the selected Scottish universities) were employed. The research framework utilised an ecological model and is unique in involving a countrywide sector, higher education, in the research methodology.
While data collection is ongoing, the pilot data and data from previous research indicate that cumulative disadvantages amplify the overall experience of inequality and translate into an increase in sexual violence and harassment experienced during the life course. In addition to gender being a key determinant in sexual violence and harassment, i.e. women are more likely to experience sexual violence, and harassment than men, women of colour, lesbian or with a disability are more at risk of sexual violence and harassment victimisation. The higher education environment, therefore, seems to offer no mitigation against the multiplicities of women's disadvantage and risk of experiencing sexual violence and harassment.
These results have important policy implications. While new university sexual violence and harassment reporting policies and prevention programmes are laudable; they will only ever be partially successful if they do not engage with the multiple inequalities that women experience and that impact sexual violence and harassment. At the moment, a very few of these newly adopted university policies account for these cumulative disadvantages.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In 2017, the Government of Canada announced a Feminist International Assistance Policy (FIAP), where 95 percent of Canada’s total aid budget will be used to “help advance gender equality and the empowerment of women and girls” by 2022. This ambitious policy was viewed as setting a new standard internationally; while countries like Australia, Sweden and Norway have explicit feminist foreign policies that put women at the center of humanitarian work and crisis negotiations - Canada is the first donor country to explicitly “gender” its international assistance budget in this way. However, since its announcement – the efficacy of the FIAP’s implementation has been called into question. Some suggest that the FIAP’s approach to gender equality needs to look beyond technocratic solutions to address the deeply held systemic norms that exist at the heart of gender-related issues in countries that receive development assistance. Additionally, while focusing on “women and girls” refines Canada’s development mandate, it also runs the risk of homogenizing the experiences of women in developing countries by approaching all gender related constraints the same way or from a Canadian point of view. This presentation will examine the efficacy and implementation of feminism in international assistance projects through an analysis of data and experiential evidence from implementing a Global Affairs Canada funded project (APEC-Canada Growing Business Partnership). It will look at the practical challenges faced by programming to support women entrepreneurs in Southeast Asia, with a focus on implementing FIAP in the context of Indonesia. It will outline the larger programmatic challenges associated with implementing a feminist policy, and the opportunities that exist for improving Canada’s feminist development mandate.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Violence against women has been recognized globally as a public problem. However, some spaces remain invisible as locus of violation of rights. This is the case of universities, where the systematic presence of violence and discrimination based on gender and race only now gains prominence in the public arena. Nonetheless, there is a well-established agenda in feminist science studies that seeks to understand the existence of the glass gender of gender equality, ie the existence of invisible and insurmountable barriers that impede equal rights and opportunities. Such phenomena, disseminated in the most prestigious universities in the world, must be viewed not only by the individual damage it has caused but also by the political and epistemological reflexes it produces and reproduces (from the perspective of Donna Haraway, Sandra Harding and Raewyn Connell). The increase in the visibility of violence in the academic world could be explained, at least in part, to some factors: i) the constitution of violence against women as a public problem and no longer restricted to private life and interpersonal relations, thanks to the transnational feminist movements; ii) the expansion of dialogue and interaction with the differences between the social segments, which is mainly due to the implementation of affirmative policies in the university, which caused a greater diversity of students, but also an increase in violence, especially racial violence; iii) advances in the autonomy and empowerment of university students as a form of resistance to the growing conservative and fundamentalist wave that criticizes the gender perspective in education.
At the University of Brasilia (UnB), one of the most important universities in Brazil, this phenomenon has intensified, even though it has a long history. It began with the abusive hazing practiced to the freshmen and today raises with cases of rape and a recent feminicide case inside the campus. In view of this situation, the Center for Studies and Research on Women at the UnB, which has been working for more than 30 years, has decided to conduct interdisciplinary research, with a quantitative and qualitative approach and the use of diversified data collection techniques. We sought to produce evidence on the phenomenon of violence against women at university and on gender equity policies developed.
Data collection took place through the application of semi-structured questionnaires to 827 female students, equivalent to 5% of the total number of students enrolled in each course. The questionnaire sought to understand the complexity and variability of the phenomenon of violence against students, as well as how the victims interpreted the actions of the University to combat the phenomenon. Among the results obtained so far, it is noteworthy that 34.46% of the interviewees have already suffered violence. Of the total number of violence suffered, 28.23% were of the sexual type and 34.69% were of a psychological nature. The second stage of the research was carried out through 16 interviews with young people who suffered violence. The third stage, in progress, analyzes the university policies of coping with violence on campus.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The relationship between feminist organizations and the Peruvian government has been modifying itself since the arrival of democracy and the institutionalization of such organizations. The 2011-2016 parliamentary term was especially relevant for the feminist agenda as certain topics, such as violence against women and their political and sexual rights, were discussed. In this investigation, we will analyze the relationship between the gender agenda, the feminist organizations and the members of the parliament. For said purpose, we propose both a prior and a subsequent analysis of the draft laws which supported women rights.
A qualitative analysis of four feminist draft laws has been made, under the following criteria: the legislator’s gender: two men and two women; their political parties: conservative or progressive; the different stages that each of the drafts reached: their
success or failure; and their relationship with the national feminist agenda. In this exploratory investigation, we used three indicators to analyze how a draft law is born: the legislator’s own experience, the context and the organized society’s influence.
The experience is understood as the commitment with the topic, through work, academic or personal experiences. Second, the environment is understood as experiences which create awareness, either by people close or unrelated to the congressman. And lastly, the organized society’s influence is understood as the issues which are identified by feminist organizations. We find that at least one out of the three indicators must be present for a congressman to present a draft law in favor of women rights.
Then, we do an analysis subsequent to the draft law’s presentation, where we identify three other factors: the commitment understood as both the formal and informal practices of the congressman for the draft to manage to pass the political filters. The
second indicator is the congressman’s power, regarding to having key positions, such as the presidency of commissions or of the Board of Officers, we also consider the spokesmanship of the party and its cohesion. And third, we consider the juncture and
political and social environment, which is related to how the political agenda is working.
We find that the institutional dynamic becomes fundamental, especially having key charges; most draft laws stay in the referral in commission stage. And so, the part can either mean an advantage or a disadvantage for the congressman or congresswoman,
since the formation of the commissions presidency is proportional to the number of congressmen, as is the political leverage at the moment of negotiation the Congress’agenda.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
On May 19, 2016 the Government of British Columbia approved the Sexual Violence and Misconduct Policy Act requiring post-secondary institutions to develop procedures and guidelines to address sexual misconduct and harassment on campus. For many, the Act was seen as long overdue, and the culmination of years of activism and social pressure to deal with toxic organizational culture and entrenched hierarchies within post-secondary institutions. To some extent, post-secondary institutions were behind the times; feminist scholars and activists have long argued that sexual violence cannot be understand as a ‘personal trouble’ and must be recognized as a ‘public issue’ embedded within deeper structures of power and inequality. Addressing sexual violence in any setting requires reshaping the nature and culture of said institution, but equally engaging in broader work around shifting the structural conditions that support and legitimate continued violence and domination. Developing policy can be seen as taking an important step in the right direction. Drawing on the insight of policy scholars, it is worthwhile to recognize that policies themselves can be understood as important sites for the cultural production of discourses about sexual violence, even without considering their intent or implementation.
This paper presents preliminary results from an analysis of sexual violence and misconduct policies, from a sample of post-secondary institutions in the Metro Vancouver region. This nascent analysis will be placed within the wider context of changes and shifts taking place within British Columbia, but also Canada, in relation to sexual violence and gender-based violence. Drawing on Bacchi’s work on post-structural policy analysis, we may consider the following questions: In what way do these policies construct the problem of sexual violence? In what way do these policies conceive of power and inequality in relation to sexual violence? How are the needs of survivors conceptualized and addressed? Who is left out of these policies and what are the consequences? We will speak to the homogenizing effects of policy seeking to address social problems. Initial reviews suggest that there is an ongoing absence of those most vulnerable and marginalized groups within policy documents, most notably Indigenous women and girls, racialized women, differently abled, trans, queer and gender fluid folks. While there is a movement toward addressing sexual violence as a form of structural violence, we argue that the scope of the social problem as defined within policy, is still too limited. Through this analysis, we hope to highlight the need for continued and ongoing discussion, dialogue and action. We encourage institutions to continue working with and alongside those who have been engaging in grassroots activism, within the community and not-for-profit sector with a view to moving towards a meaningful commitment to social change in policy, but also to extend far beyond.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the course of recent decades, scientists from psychology, economics, sociology and other different disciplines have attempted to comprehend why women are under-represented in STEM (science, technology, engineering and mathematics) field. One of the main causes of the gender wage gap is male-female sorting into different degrees and corresponding occupations, this is why encouraging women into STEM fields has become an important policy. Our STEM workforce is crucial to Kazakhstan’s innovative capacity and global competitiveness. Yet women are vastly underrepresented in STEM jobs and among STEM degree holders despite making up nearly half of the Kazakhstan workforce and half of the educated workforce. That leaves an untapped opportunity to expand STEM employment in the Republic of Kazakhstan, even as there is wide agreement that the nation must do more to improve its competitiveness. Although women fill close to half of all jobs in the Kazakhstan economy, they hold less than 10 percent of STEM jobs. This has been the case throughout the past decade, even as educated women have increased their share of the overall workforce.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The first police services, taking the place of what is now the Cameroonian police, have always been the sanctuary of masculinity since its creation in 1928. Inspired by France, this police institution was created, and welcomed as head of the Captain Beauquinot, under the name of Commissariat de Douala by an Order of the High Commissioner of the French Republic in Cameroon. Following plural dynamics, we have witnessed major social, economic and political transformations in the majority of sectors of social life; which transformations have had important consequences for social relations of sex and gender. Since the years 1966, some women (04) were enlisted within this microcosm following the presidential decree n ° 66 / DF / 024 of June 05 bearing general regime of the contests. Since then, the number of girls and women has been steadily increasing. Because they counted until then at the end of the fingers and today they count to more than 2512 police officers against 13415 police (Direction of the Human Resources of Cameroonian police, 2017). Despite of this legal provision in favor of gender diversity, girls and women are still the subject of many gender-based violence to the point of disrupting the principle of gender equality and generating new problems such as identity discomfort. Therefore, how can we understand the resurgence of representations and practices that challenge and transgress the egalitarian values enshrined in a legal arsenal of promotion and protection of gender equality ? From this questioning, we formulate the hypothesis that the Cameroonian police constitute an excellent microcosm to understand the actions of perpetuation of gender inequalities. The purpose of this paper is to analyze the logic of action of the persistence of gender asymmetries, the unspoken survivals of gender-based violence and the strength of the hyper-masculinization of the cameroonian police. The analysis proposed here is based on a perspective that combines historical sociology (Norbert Elias), symbolic interactionism (Herbert Blumer) and ethnomethodology (Harold Garfinkel). Enriched with field data collected in Cameroon in 2014 and 2016, this contribution by focusing on the qualitative approach (interviews) allows us to identify and especially to analyze the explanatory logics of the resistance of patriarchal structures of domination and maintenance, sometimes the reinforcement of disparities and gender inequalities in the Cameroonian police in the era of gender promotion in Cameroon's public space.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The development debates during the last three decades have been conducted from the vantage points of different protagonists. It is noteworthy that among them a new protagonist has arrived and has forcefully established her presence—the women. The commonality among theses different strata of women is that they face oppression and subordination in and from the society due to their gender. Thus, gender discrimination in society has been accepted as a variable in the development paradigm. The perspectives and viewpoints of women provide a unique and powerful vantage point from which we can examine the developmental programmes and strategies (Sen and Grown). The issue of participation also needs to be viewed from a gendered aspect. The disproportionate participation of women in political institutions and process is an established fact. In fact, it is perhaps, not an exaggeration to say that one of the major achievements of Women’s Studies is that it has equipped various aspects and issue to be studied through a gender-lens. Participation in the political system or, politics as such is one such issue.
Although it is difficult to establish a linear relationship between feminism and increased political participation, feminist ideals do stress egalitarian participation, democratization of all leadership roles, careful listening, respect for the experiences of all women, self-transformation and autonomy through intimate sharing and small group support. The issue of participation is generally viewed from a liberal, individualistic framework. However,the capability approach as developed by Sen (2000) and Martha Nussbaum (2000) has a powerful influence in the development paradigm today. Sen’s work has been particularly influential in the formulation of the United Nations’ “Human Development Index”. Thus we may reference to a new vision of participatory democracy which focuses on gender. Alexander and Mohanty have developed this concept of feminist democracy that links commitments to participatory democracy, the development of capacities and the eradication of gender and other forms of structural inequality. For them, feminist democracy is both the ultimate goal and the collective process through which it will be achieved. Further, feminist democracy suggests a different order of relationships among people. Keeping in view the above theoretical backdrop, the paper seeks to examine the experiences of womens’ participation in the local self government in India.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This study addresses the question of why Japan, a country with a long-established democracy, has failed to introduce a gender quota law to address the gender imbalance in the national and subnational legislatures. Many prior analyses have attributed this failure to Japan’s women’s movement, despite its efforts to exert strong pressure for reform, for being too weak and fragmented to achieve its objective. Contrary to this prevailing perspective, this study argues that it is not the weakness of women’s movement but, under the conservative rule of the Liberal Democratic Party’s protracted political dominance, the absence of male elites’ strategic or electoral incentives that has decreased the likelihood of Japan’s quota adoption. It is then argued that the passage of the Candidate Gender Equality Law in 2018 is a political compromise and byproduct of the power imbalance between the ruling Liberal Democratic Party and the opposition parties. Given the weakness of the fragmented opposition parties, the conservative Liberal Democratic Party approved the bill drafted by a supra-partisan parliamentary group ostensibly to promote the principle of equality in the proportion of male and female candidates, but made it contingent upon the condition that it is only a symbolic law and not legally binding with a punitive clause.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The Canadian government has committed to implementing gender-based analysis plus (GBA+) in its federal departments. GBA+ assesses how women, men and gender diverse individuals experience policy and programs differently and the ways that intersecting identities influence these experiences. In this paper, I will assess whether the implementation of GBA+ by the LGBTQ2 Secretariat is evident, particularly in their efforts directed towards Two-Spirit communities. The LGBTQ2 Secretariat was created in 2017 to support the Canadian Prime Minister’s special advisor on LGBTQ2 issues and to inform the government about important issues regarding LGBTQ2 communities. Considering LGBTQ2 communities are not homogeneous, questioning the level of intersectionality employed by the LGBTQ2 Secretariat in its efforts is necessary. For example, Two-Spirit communities are not only considered gender and/or sexually diverse, but they are also members of Indigenous communities; consequently, they are at risk of experiencing multiple forms of oppression related to sexism, homophobia/transphobia, settler colonialism, racism and classism.
Therefore, in this paper, I will question whether the LGBTQ2 Secretariat uses GBA+ to assess how proposed LGBTQ2-related policies and programs may impact Two-Spirit communities differently than other LGBTQ communities. For instance, does the LGBTQ2 Secretariat simply ‘add on’ Two-Spirit communities to the LGBTQ acronym in its initiatives, or does it consider that Two-Spirit communities not only experience homophobia/transphobia within their Indigenous communities, but also racism within LGBTQ communities? Does the LGBTQ2 Secretariat's policies/programs acknowledge that Two-Communities are not universal, but that each Indigenous tribe may have different beliefs and values regarding gender and sexual diversity? Finally, are there policies/programs proposed to address the loss of Two-Spirit culture through colonization, through the imposition of gender and sexual binaries, as well as address ongoing settler colonialism?
In order to answer these questions, I will assess the various efforts by the LGBTQ2 Secretariat. For example, I will analyse their ‘Free to be me’ website, particularly under their ‘news and update’ section; I will search through the Hansard for references to the LGBTQ community and/or Two-Spirit communities; and I will question if there are any intergovernmental efforts between the LGBTQ Secretariat and Indigenous Services Canada. If the LGBTQ2 Secretariat is implementing GBA+, then an intersectional consideration for Two-Spirit communities should be evident.
This paper fits with the theme of the “Feminist Governance in the 21st Century” panel because GBA+ developed from gender-based analysis; a policy tool used to assess how policy may impact men and women differently. GBA was originally adopted by the Canadian federal government to advance gender equality and is based on feminist knowledges; consequently, GBA+ is a feminist policy tool that has been implemented by the federal government to improve the lives of not only women, but all marginalized communities. Therefore, questioning whether the LGBTQ2 Secretariat uses GBA+ will not only exemplify how a feminist policy tool can contribute to understanding how policies and programs are experienced differently, but will also hold the Canadian government accountable to its commitment in implementing GBA+.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In 2019, the Nevada State Legislature became the first congress to assemble a government where female lawmakers comprised the majority. From the bordellos of the Comstock to the Las Vegas Strip, Nevada’s history has been characterized by a unique culture of vice and virtue. This legacy endures, exhibited predominately today by an international tourist economy which capitalizes on colorful histories and competing motifs disseminated within a culture of nonstop action and entertainment. Whether its live shows, gentlemen’s clubs, or state-sanctioned prostitution, Nevada’s feminine mystique is often portrayed by popular culture through a dialogue of female stereotypes. Yet, despite this Nevadans’ have elected a majority of women to state government, and female politicos have now come to be the majority within the Nevada State Legislature. Considering the competing narratives, it begs the question of how did this happen and what are the public policy implications of a female-majority legislature? Certainly, many post-industrial democracies have seen the rise of female-majority governments, as a new political discourse inclusive to feminist policies has arrived and shifted the legislative debate towards increased social intervention for our most marginalized populations. Nevada’s new female majority state legislature represents a new chapter in this movement, and as a result, presents a social context ripe for empirical study. Through an assemblage of qualitative data – personal interviews, legislative artifacts, and reports of legislative activity – we seek to understand how a female majority legislature impacts public policy. Specifically, how has a female majority in the Nevada State Legislature shaped policy priorities and altered the dynamics of discourse within the policymaking process? Has a new dialogue emerged, and if so how has this impacted policymaking in Nevada?
For this paper, we utilize a critical discourse analysis framework because language utilized by policymakers can serve as a mechanism to delimit the legislative arena, and unavoidably impact legislative actions (Fischer, 2003; Fischer & Gottweis, 2012). Language use is always strategic and all expressions have an epistemological agenda or a way of seeing the world (Hajer, 2006; Johnstone, 2002). Agendas are present within policymaking discourse, as actors utilize dialogue to make representations concerning actions and events, and depictions of knowledge status are revealed through the nomenclature or word choice of actors through the incorporation of stakeholders and other voices into the legislative process (Fischer & Gottweis, 2012; Hajer, 2006). In this way, beliefs, whether conscious or unconscious, are mediated through discourse, and the utility of language corresponds with the perception of reality. Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA) focuses on unveiling the hidden agenda of discourse in the social world and is drawn from critical theory (Fairclough, 2001; Cameron, 2001). Critical theory and CDA discern the connections between language and other elements in social life that are often opaque. By utilizing this methodology, we will uncover how discourse connects to social expressions of power and domination, including how language and ideology intersect with a policymaker’s personal and social identities.
References
Cameron, D. (2001). Working with spoken discourse. London; Thousand Oaks, Calif.: Sage.
Fairclough, N. (2001). The discourse of new labour: Critical discourse analysis. In M. Wetherell, S. Taylor, & S. Yates (Eds.), Discourse as data: a guide for analysis. (pp. 229-265). London; Thousand Oaks, Calif.: SAGE in association with The Open University.
Fischer, F. (2003). Reframing public policy: Discursive politics and deliberative practices. Oxford, NY: Oxford University Press.
Fischer, F. & Gottweis, H. (Eds.). (2012). The argumentative turn revisited: Public policy as communicative practice. Duke University Press.
Hajer, M. A. (2006). Doing discourse analysis: Coalitions, practices, meaning. In M. van den Brink & T. Metze (Eds.), Words matter in policy and planning (pp. 65-74). The Netherlands: Netherlands Geographical Studies (ISSN 0169-4839).
Johnstone, B. (2002). Discourse analysis: Introducing linguistics. Malden, MA: Black-
well Publishers.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The university should ideally represent an environment where each student and staff member enjoys equal safety, freedoms and opportunities. Sadly, however, this is not always the case. Sometimes, universities are also a place of sexual violence, harassment, oppression and domination. As a consequence of discussions triggered by #MeToo and #timesup, the universities started to pro-actively address sexual violence, and harassment by adopting new institutional policies, reporting mechanisms, and campaigns.
The research has three goals. First, it aims to explore the implications of intersectionality in the context of sexual violence and harassment within the context of the higher education sector in Scotland. Second, it examines to what extent the intersectional approach is embraced in newly adopted institutional policies. Third, the study provides recommendations for improving these policies to account for the complexity of inequalities.
The study explores how gender intersects with race, ethnicity, sexual orientation, and disability in terms of the impact of sexual violence and harassment on university staff and students. Contemporary feminist research has emphasised intersectionality as a holistic paradigm in investigating the complexity of inequalities. This study builds on the work of Crenshaw and hooks to explore how cumulative inequalities impact on experiences of sexual violence and harassment and whether it differentially impacts university staff and students depending on their particular location within the intersectionality paradigm.
Quantitative (campus-wide survey) and qualitative research methods (interviews and focus groups with self-selected students and staff at the selected Scottish universities) were employed. The research framework utilised an ecological model and is unique in involving a countrywide sector, higher education, in the research methodology.
While data collection is ongoing, the pilot data and data from previous research indicate that cumulative disadvantages amplify the overall experience of inequality and translate into an increase in sexual violence and harassment experienced during the life course. In addition to gender being a key determinant in sexual violence and harassment, i.e. women are more likely to experience sexual violence, and harassment than men, women of colour, lesbian or with a disability are more at risk of sexual violence and harassment victimisation. The higher education environment, therefore, seems to offer no mitigation against the multiplicities of women's disadvantage and risk of experiencing sexual violence and harassment.
These results have important policy implications. While new university sexual violence and harassment reporting policies and prevention programmes are laudable; they will only ever be partially successful if they do not engage with the multiple inequalities that women experience and that impact sexual violence and harassment. At the moment, a very few of these newly adopted university policies account for these cumulative disadvantages.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In 2017, the Government of Canada announced a Feminist International Assistance Policy (FIAP), where 95 percent of Canada’s total aid budget will be used to “help advance gender equality and the empowerment of women and girls” by 2022. This ambitious policy was viewed as setting a new standard internationally; while countries like Australia, Sweden and Norway have explicit feminist foreign policies that put women at the center of humanitarian work and crisis negotiations - Canada is the first donor country to explicitly “gender” its international assistance budget in this way. However, since its announcement – the efficacy of the FIAP’s implementation has been called into question. Some suggest that the FIAP’s approach to gender equality needs to look beyond technocratic solutions to address the deeply held systemic norms that exist at the heart of gender-related issues in countries that receive development assistance. Additionally, while focusing on “women and girls” refines Canada’s development mandate, it also runs the risk of homogenizing the experiences of women in developing countries by approaching all gender related constraints the same way or from a Canadian point of view. This presentation will examine the efficacy and implementation of feminism in international assistance projects through an analysis of data and experiential evidence from implementing a Global Affairs Canada funded project (APEC-Canada Growing Business Partnership). It will look at the practical challenges faced by programming to support women entrepreneurs in Southeast Asia, with a focus on implementing FIAP in the context of Indonesia. It will outline the larger programmatic challenges associated with implementing a feminist policy, and the opportunities that exist for improving Canada’s feminist development mandate.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Violence against women has been recognized globally as a public problem. However, some spaces remain invisible as locus of violation of rights. This is the case of universities, where the systematic presence of violence and discrimination based on gender and race only now gains prominence in the public arena. Nonetheless, there is a well-established agenda in feminist science studies that seeks to understand the existence of the glass gender of gender equality, ie the existence of invisible and insurmountable barriers that impede equal rights and opportunities. Such phenomena, disseminated in the most prestigious universities in the world, must be viewed not only by the individual damage it has caused but also by the political and epistemological reflexes it produces and reproduces (from the perspective of Donna Haraway, Sandra Harding and Raewyn Connell). The increase in the visibility of violence in the academic world could be explained, at least in part, to some factors: i) the constitution of violence against women as a public problem and no longer restricted to private life and interpersonal relations, thanks to the transnational feminist movements; ii) the expansion of dialogue and interaction with the differences between the social segments, which is mainly due to the implementation of affirmative policies in the university, which caused a greater diversity of students, but also an increase in violence, especially racial violence; iii) advances in the autonomy and empowerment of university students as a form of resistance to the growing conservative and fundamentalist wave that criticizes the gender perspective in education.
At the University of Brasilia (UnB), one of the most important universities in Brazil, this phenomenon has intensified, even though it has a long history. It began with the abusive hazing practiced to the freshmen and today raises with cases of rape and a recent feminicide case inside the campus. In view of this situation, the Center for Studies and Research on Women at the UnB, which has been working for more than 30 years, has decided to conduct interdisciplinary research, with a quantitative and qualitative approach and the use of diversified data collection techniques. We sought to produce evidence on the phenomenon of violence against women at university and on gender equity policies developed.
Data collection took place through the application of semi-structured questionnaires to 827 female students, equivalent to 5% of the total number of students enrolled in each course. The questionnaire sought to understand the complexity and variability of the phenomenon of violence against students, as well as how the victims interpreted the actions of the University to combat the phenomenon. Among the results obtained so far, it is noteworthy that 34.46% of the interviewees have already suffered violence. Of the total number of violence suffered, 28.23% were of the sexual type and 34.69% were of a psychological nature. The second stage of the research was carried out through 16 interviews with young people who suffered violence. The third stage, in progress, analyzes the university policies of coping with violence on campus.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The relationship between feminist organizations and the Peruvian government has been modifying itself since the arrival of democracy and the institutionalization of such organizations. The 2011-2016 parliamentary term was especially relevant for the feminist agenda as certain topics, such as violence against women and their political and sexual rights, were discussed. In this investigation, we will analyze the relationship between the gender agenda, the feminist organizations and the members of the parliament. For said purpose, we propose both a prior and a subsequent analysis of the draft laws which supported women rights.
A qualitative analysis of four feminist draft laws has been made, under the following criteria: the legislator’s gender: two men and two women; their political parties: conservative or progressive; the different stages that each of the drafts reached: their
success or failure; and their relationship with the national feminist agenda. In this exploratory investigation, we used three indicators to analyze how a draft law is born: the legislator’s own experience, the context and the organized society’s influence.
The experience is understood as the commitment with the topic, through work, academic or personal experiences. Second, the environment is understood as experiences which create awareness, either by people close or unrelated to the congressman. And lastly, the organized society’s influence is understood as the issues which are identified by feminist organizations. We find that at least one out of the three indicators must be present for a congressman to present a draft law in favor of women rights.
Then, we do an analysis subsequent to the draft law’s presentation, where we identify three other factors: the commitment understood as both the formal and informal practices of the congressman for the draft to manage to pass the political filters. The
second indicator is the congressman’s power, regarding to having key positions, such as the presidency of commissions or of the Board of Officers, we also consider the spokesmanship of the party and its cohesion. And third, we consider the juncture and
political and social environment, which is related to how the political agenda is working.
We find that the institutional dynamic becomes fundamental, especially having key charges; most draft laws stay in the referral in commission stage. And so, the part can either mean an advantage or a disadvantage for the congressman or congresswoman,
since the formation of the commissions presidency is proportional to the number of congressmen, as is the political leverage at the moment of negotiation the Congress’agenda.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
On May 19, 2016 the Government of British Columbia approved the Sexual Violence and Misconduct Policy Act requiring post-secondary institutions to develop procedures and guidelines to address sexual misconduct and harassment on campus. For many, the Act was seen as long overdue, and the culmination of years of activism and social pressure to deal with toxic organizational culture and entrenched hierarchies within post-secondary institutions. To some extent, post-secondary institutions were behind the times; feminist scholars and activists have long argued that sexual violence cannot be understand as a ‘personal trouble’ and must be recognized as a ‘public issue’ embedded within deeper structures of power and inequality. Addressing sexual violence in any setting requires reshaping the nature and culture of said institution, but equally engaging in broader work around shifting the structural conditions that support and legitimate continued violence and domination. Developing policy can be seen as taking an important step in the right direction. Drawing on the insight of policy scholars, it is worthwhile to recognize that policies themselves can be understood as important sites for the cultural production of discourses about sexual violence, even without considering their intent or implementation.
This paper presents preliminary results from an analysis of sexual violence and misconduct policies, from a sample of post-secondary institutions in the Metro Vancouver region. This nascent analysis will be placed within the wider context of changes and shifts taking place within British Columbia, but also Canada, in relation to sexual violence and gender-based violence. Drawing on Bacchi’s work on post-structural policy analysis, we may consider the following questions: In what way do these policies construct the problem of sexual violence? In what way do these policies conceive of power and inequality in relation to sexual violence? How are the needs of survivors conceptualized and addressed? Who is left out of these policies and what are the consequences? We will speak to the homogenizing effects of policy seeking to address social problems. Initial reviews suggest that there is an ongoing absence of those most vulnerable and marginalized groups within policy documents, most notably Indigenous women and girls, racialized women, differently abled, trans, queer and gender fluid folks. While there is a movement toward addressing sexual violence as a form of structural violence, we argue that the scope of the social problem as defined within policy, is still too limited. Through this analysis, we hope to highlight the need for continued and ongoing discussion, dialogue and action. We encourage institutions to continue working with and alongside those who have been engaging in grassroots activism, within the community and not-for-profit sector with a view to moving towards a meaningful commitment to social change in policy, but also to extend far beyond.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)