P01. How Much Does State Architecture Matter for Feminist Policy Outputs?
GENDER, DIVERSITY AND PUBLIC POLICYCATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
Feminist social scientists have been grappling with the question of whether particular forms of state architecture (federal vs. unitary; centralized women’s policy agencies [WPA] or not) produce better policy results for women in different policy areas. This question has been taken up by various feminist political scientists and policy analysts, including McEwen and Moreno (2005); Chappell (2002); McBride and Mazur (2010); Krook and Mackay (2011); Haussman, Sawer and Vickers (2010); Lombardo, Meier and Verloo (2009); Roth (2008); Outshoorn and Kantola (2007); Van der Vleuten (2007), Freidenvall (2019) and MacRae and Weiner (2017). For example, many studies theorize that a strong WPA network, closely tied to the central government, achieved gender equality objectives. Some, such as Collier (2010) and Grace (2018) have shown that in federal states, regional governments enact and implement good policies in policy areas such as child care and employment equity.. Most studies also theorize that a leftist government is necessary but not sufficient for good outcomes for diverse groups of women. But more recent research suggests that there are different kinds of leftist governments and that which kind is in power matters.
The papers in this panel will explore what we know about relations between state architecture including age and type of federation, level and type of goverment in relation to policy outcomes that to benefit women of majority populations or of diverse minorities.
CALL FOR PAPERS
Research questions for "How Much does State Architecture Matter for Feminist Policy Outputs?"
The papers in this panel will explore what we know about relations between state architecture including age and type of federation, level and type of goverment in relation to policy outcomes that to benefit women of majority populations or of diverse minorities.
In addition to the research questions, papers submitted to this panel are expected to engage with one of the following hypotheses:
1. What are the benefits of unitary states or federations for majority and diverse, minority women?
2. Does government party matter in such states? If so, how?
3. What are drawbacks are posed by federal states which often have governments from different parties elected at different levels. E.g. are “institutional vetoes”a problem?
4. What impact does “legal pluralism” have on organized women’s efforts to achieve positive policy outcomes and does the impact vary across policy areas?
5. Do WPAs help organized women persuade unfriendly governments in states with different architectures?
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper explores the "causal stories" (from Deborah Stone's work) used to justify workfare arrangements for Medicaid, never implemented before the Trump administration in 2017. Trump's Secretaries of Health and Human Services have claimed that the Medicaid expansions allowed under the Affordable Care Act, passed under President Obama in 2010, were "unconstitutional." When President Trump came to office in 2017, he allowed the Centers for Medicaid and Medicare Services (housed in HHS) to promulgate far-ranging rules by which the states can make Medicaid harder to access. The workfare strategy, already approved in three states, is one such avenue by which he and his administration seek to undo the Affordable Care Act. From Stone's work, we find that the Trump administration's rhetorical strategy is to counter the "intended consquences" of Medicaid expansion. However, from the work of Frank Thompson and Laura Katz Olson, we know that the primary beneficiaries of Medicaid dollars are health-care provider institutions, mainly for the elderly and disabled, and insurance companies working with these institutions. Thus, a clash of causal stories emerges, in which the poor are unfairly labelled for accessing their legally-framed benefits, while the subterranean text is that institutions have grown rich from Medicaid. The workfare requirements are misguided and punitive devices, justified rhetorically by Republican governors who claim, incorrectly, to wish to save their states money.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Corruption is the main obstacle to development which reduces the efficiency of the resource use, slows down economic growth and sets the stage for human rights violations. Although corruption has a negative impact on the entire populatione, empirical evidence suggests that men and women perceive it differently. They also face different forms of abuse of powers and different outcomes of corruption in their everyday lives. The impacts of corruption may also be gender-specified, making women more vulnerable to negative effects and consequences of corruptive practices. Corruption is an important barrier on the way to mainstream gender equality in the public policy. Therefore, it is important to combine the efforts on promoting gender equality, empowering women, and implementing anti-corruption programs as mutually reinforcing development strategies.
The proposed paper presents the key findings of gender analysis of data of population-based surveys conducted in Ukraine. It is also focused at multiple gendered impacts of corruption in terms of vulberabilities, lost opportunities, unequal access to public goods and services.
The paper address some general recommendations on gender-responsive approach of anticorruption policies and awareness raising campaigns.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Changes in the state architecture and the introduction of novel institutional arrangements are seen as important for promoting the opportunity for gender policy change in feminist scholarship (Haussman, Sawyer and Vickers, 2010; Krook and Mackay, 2010). Feminist institutionalist scholars highlight the disruption of the existing gender order, the introduction of new actors and operating procedures and priorities where political arrangements are reformed. This feminist institutional scholarship enhances analysis of the relationship between institutional change and policy outcomes adding a gendered lens (Annesley and Gains, 2010; Waylen, 2017).
However there are areas where the analysis is under-developed in the current scholarship. We need to investigate the interaction between new actors and new rules, and the particular mix of formal and informal rules in play especially in the area of sub national governance (Gains and Lowndes 2018). Policies addressing gender equality are not heterogeneous and reform trajectories differ across policy domains (Annesley, Engeli and Gains, 2014). Additionally the determinants of gender policy reform are dynamic and iterative (Gains and Lowndes, 2014). A focus on ‘rules in use’ is needed – the mix of formal and informal standard operating procedures that guide the way ‘things are done around here’ (Lowndes and Roberts, 2013). And rules in of themselves do not achieve change. Rather it is how rules in use are interpreted and enacted by actors which is important and the actors involved are unlikely to be only women or feminist women (Childs and Krook, 2009; Lowndes, 2014).
This paper builds on earlier research examining the prioritisation of policies addressing violence against women following the introduction of directly elected Police and Crime Commissioners (PCCs) and devolved policing governance in the UK (Gains and Lowndes, 2018). This research highlighted the importance of the gender of executive actors, and also institutional rules around equalities duties. However, quantitative analysis was unable to fully uncover why these determinants made a difference, and how new actors worked with the changed policing governance arrangements.
To interrogate the dynamic and iterative relationship between gendered actors and gendered institutions this paper presents comparative case study research in six localities*. We draw on over twenty interviews with the newly elected commissioners and other elite actors to probe how formal and also informal ‘rules-in-use’ are interpreted and enacted by gendered actors. We find PCCs used informal networks both nationally and in localities to lobby for resources, drew on their directly elected status to call for evidence to challenge policing practices and exploited their ability to direct resources to partnerships offering new forms of intervention. Our analysis uncovers the micro foundations of policy processes to address violence against women in these cases and in so doing makes a broader conceptual contribution to understanding the determinants of gender policy change. The paper also contributes to methodological debates about how best to research actors’ interpretation of institutional rules-in-use, including informal elements.
*We acknowledge support of funding from the European Research Council (PI Georgina Waylen) see https://www.socialsciences.manchester.ac.uk/politics/research/projects-and-networks/uic/
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper will explore how key aspects of state architecture can affect policy-making by promoting or hindering gender equality rights. A rapidly growing literature is studying how federal arrangements that divide power vertically and horizontally affect policy-making, focusing especially on the effects of legal pluralism, i.e. when two or more legal codes govern within a state’s territory. Most gender-and-politics theories assume ‘the state’ they theorize about is unitary despite the fact that over 40 percent of the world's population live in federations (Watts 2008). Furthermore, globalization and neoliberal ideology increased regionalization and the devolution of power which federalized some governance institutions even in unitary states. Moreover, policy-making increasingly is influenced by international agencies making the transnational tier important in both unitary and federal contexts. Therefore, the impact of state architectures on policy-making is important to gender-and-politics theorizing generally. So, while socio-economic and ideological forces shape gender/power relations, governments and movements must respond to those forces from within state architectures with specific histories. Consequently, the paper will show how legal pluralism – a constant feature of MLG -challenges the rule of law in gender/power contexts.
The paper explores the concept of legal pluralism and its impact on gendered policy-making. The importance of legal pluralism was stressed by UN Women in its 2011-12 Report which found that discriminatory family law which poses the greatest barrier to equality women face is highly correlated with legal pluralism. There are two types of legal pluralism : territorial legal pluralism in which the alternate code governs a regional state’s territory, a basic design feature which is constitutionally sanctioned in all federations and non-territorial legal pluralism in which personal law codes apply to members of a religious or ethnic community regardless of territorial location. Federalists believe legal pluralism promotes equity by giving minority nations some self-rule and enhancing democracy by letting ‘local’ communities govern ‘morality issues.’ This could deny gender equality rights to women- rights which international law treats as universal ‘human rights’. One outcome of legal pluralism is the fragmentation of women’s citizenship as but it poses other dangers for women. When family law is part of self-rule, women may be denied protection by central governments if leaders of minority nations or ‘cultural’ communities with autonomy over family law insist on control. Therefore, the ability of central governments to regulate the effects of legal pluralism depends on the extent of diversity and conflict federations must manage and the willingness and capacity of central government actors to defend gender equality rights.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Focusing on the case of Mexico, this paper examines how federalism affects the work of women’s policy agencies. In Mexico, the national government established the Instituto Nacional de las Mujeres (National Institute of Women, INMUJERES) in 2001, and encouraged each state to establish a state level women’s institute. All 32 states now have their own women’s institute, providing a perfect laboratory for testing the effectiveness of women’s policy agencies under the control of different parties and in different social and economic contexts, but in a broadly similar cultural context. What are the consequences of this institutional diversity for gender policy outcomes across the country? Using a subnational comparative analysis, this paper will examine the diversity of women’s policy agencies across the states of Mexico and assess the impact of these institutions on gender policy outcomes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The recent Zika outbreak has brought renewed attention to Latin America’s restrictive sexual and reproductive health laws. While Sustainable Development Goal 5 includes the goal of ensuring universal access to sexual and reproductive health and reproductive rights for all women and girls, the status of abortion remains a contested area. On the one hand, abortion is accepted by many international actors as both an evidence-based and rights-based means for women to have control over and decide freely on matters related to the timing and space of births. On the other hand, many governments continue to restrict access to abortion. A tacit assumption is that governments are working against the interests and preferences of their citizens in restricting access to abortion. But what happens when the normative assumptions advanced by transnational actors are in conflict with the values and opinions of the citizenry of countries where they work? This conflict came into sharp focus during the Zika outbreak when Latin American countries resisted appeals to liberalize their restrictive abortion laws even in the face of a public health emergency. This presentation will explore attitudes towards abortion in Latin American countries, factors associated with support/opposition to abortion and, through a difference-in-difference approach, test whether the crisis of the Zika outbreak of 2014 changed attitudes towards abortion in affected countries, and in what direction. The paper draws on data from three recent rounds of the AmericasBarometer public opinion surveys (2012, 2014 and 2017) that contain questions on attitudes towards abortion when the mother’s health is at risk and information on abortion restrictions in the region. We analyze the prevalence of support for restricting abortion when a mother’s health is at risk for men and women and predictors of support for this attitude including religiosity, political affiliation and gender. We find that pluralities of the public continue to oppose abortion among the countries studied even after the Zika outbreak and in some countries, including those affected directly by Zika, the public decreased their support for abortion. Women and men were equally likely to oppose abortion in the case where a woman’s health is compromised. Religion and religiosity explains some but not all of this attitude. We discuss the implications of the results for collective efforts to reform sexual and reproductive health policy in the region, particularly in light of the Zika threat, as well as implications for theories of policy feedback and policy change.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The goal of this presentation is to draw on research from feminist, non-feminist policy studies and from the doctoral research of the first author to propose a roadmap for measuring what happens to explicitly women empowerment policies after they are bureaucratically made in the highly complex political environment of State of Pakistan in the South Asia. The presentation makes a case for political analysis of feminist policy post adoption and proposes ways to influence the policy processes that result in to women empowerment.
Women empowerment has been one of the core policy objectives of Asian governments and Pakistan is not an isolated case.Whereas, Pakistan has seen various forms of government (military led, democratic) over the decades and they have significantly affected the women empowerment policy formulation and implementation in the country. During those government regimes women empowerment policy subject has been ruled out at various places from federal to province and vice versa. Various institutional solutions brought forwarded and back including women development department, section, ministry at federal level, national and provincial commissions on status of women, women parliamentarian caucus, district committees and so on. Despite of these efforts, the socio-economic and political status of women on the ground has not improved considerably as envisioned by the ‘stated policies’.This presentation based on the first author’s doctoral research explored the link between women empowerment policies and the state architecture in Pakistan.The field research was carried out in Sindh province of Pakistan. Employing a qualitative methodology, the study has used both primary and secondary data sources. Primary data was based on key informants’ interviews with government and non-government policy actors. For secondary data provincial women empowerment policy along with CEDAW reports were reviewed. The findings of this study revealed that despite all efforts women empowerment have not been achieved fully as anticipated by the policies.This study argues that a stable State structure guided by democratic and human rights is utmost crucial for achieving women empowerment.
Key Words: Women empowerment- Policy-Constitutional amendment- Government
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this paper is to analyze the characteristics and evolution of the Federal Brazilian “Gender and Race Pro-Equality Program” (PPEGR) between 2005 and 2019. PPEGR is a public policy elaborated by Secretariat for Policies for Women (SPM), supported by the UN Women and the International Labor Organization (ILO), that complies the Brazilian legislation and the international agreements on human rights signed by Brazil. It aims to eliminate gender and race inequalities in public and private enterprises, and enhance women’s economic and social empowerment, based on conceptions from social demands, people management and organizational culture. Participation in the Program is voluntary and companies that reach at least 70% of compliance with the program’s principles and standards are awarded the Gender and Race Seal. Our analysis was based on the Program’s information made available by the three different Federal governments since 2005, including the left Workers’ Party (PT), followed by centrist Brazilian Democratic Movement (MDB) and the current right-wing conservative Social Liberal Party (PSL). The results suggest that PPEGR (as a social policy for gender and race equity and equality) has been conditioned in distinct ways by the political party and institutional environment in which it operates. During the PT government, there was a democratic formulation and implementation Program’s process that involved thousands of women and feminist organizations. A different scenario was observed during the MDB government when several changes to public expenses reduced labor rights and closed government ministries, such as the Ministry of Women, Racial Equality and Human Rights, which has contributed to gains in women’s rights. During this administration, PPEGR was modified on its management and behavior. In addition, the present government, which has a massive presence of religious and conservative groups, has included a new rule to organizations that have been implementing actions based on PPEGR, making the development process slower. Although the Program has not been extinguished by the government, it doesn’t integrate the civil society in the process of discussion of its strategic lines anymore, with substantial effects on representativeness and expression of the diversity of the population as well as on the organized women’s effort.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper explores the "causal stories" (from Deborah Stone's work) used to justify workfare arrangements for Medicaid, never implemented before the Trump administration in 2017. Trump's Secretaries of Health and Human Services have claimed that the Medicaid expansions allowed under the Affordable Care Act, passed under President Obama in 2010, were "unconstitutional." When President Trump came to office in 2017, he allowed the Centers for Medicaid and Medicare Services (housed in HHS) to promulgate far-ranging rules by which the states can make Medicaid harder to access. The workfare strategy, already approved in three states, is one such avenue by which he and his administration seek to undo the Affordable Care Act. From Stone's work, we find that the Trump administration's rhetorical strategy is to counter the "intended consquences" of Medicaid expansion. However, from the work of Frank Thompson and Laura Katz Olson, we know that the primary beneficiaries of Medicaid dollars are health-care provider institutions, mainly for the elderly and disabled, and insurance companies working with these institutions. Thus, a clash of causal stories emerges, in which the poor are unfairly labelled for accessing their legally-framed benefits, while the subterranean text is that institutions have grown rich from Medicaid. The workfare requirements are misguided and punitive devices, justified rhetorically by Republican governors who claim, incorrectly, to wish to save their states money.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Corruption is the main obstacle to development which reduces the efficiency of the resource use, slows down economic growth and sets the stage for human rights violations. Although corruption has a negative impact on the entire populatione, empirical evidence suggests that men and women perceive it differently. They also face different forms of abuse of powers and different outcomes of corruption in their everyday lives. The impacts of corruption may also be gender-specified, making women more vulnerable to negative effects and consequences of corruptive practices. Corruption is an important barrier on the way to mainstream gender equality in the public policy. Therefore, it is important to combine the efforts on promoting gender equality, empowering women, and implementing anti-corruption programs as mutually reinforcing development strategies.
The proposed paper presents the key findings of gender analysis of data of population-based surveys conducted in Ukraine. It is also focused at multiple gendered impacts of corruption in terms of vulberabilities, lost opportunities, unequal access to public goods and services.
The paper address some general recommendations on gender-responsive approach of anticorruption policies and awareness raising campaigns.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Changes in the state architecture and the introduction of novel institutional arrangements are seen as important for promoting the opportunity for gender policy change in feminist scholarship (Haussman, Sawyer and Vickers, 2010; Krook and Mackay, 2010). Feminist institutionalist scholars highlight the disruption of the existing gender order, the introduction of new actors and operating procedures and priorities where political arrangements are reformed. This feminist institutional scholarship enhances analysis of the relationship between institutional change and policy outcomes adding a gendered lens (Annesley and Gains, 2010; Waylen, 2017).
However there are areas where the analysis is under-developed in the current scholarship. We need to investigate the interaction between new actors and new rules, and the particular mix of formal and informal rules in play especially in the area of sub national governance (Gains and Lowndes 2018). Policies addressing gender equality are not heterogeneous and reform trajectories differ across policy domains (Annesley, Engeli and Gains, 2014). Additionally the determinants of gender policy reform are dynamic and iterative (Gains and Lowndes, 2014). A focus on ‘rules in use’ is needed – the mix of formal and informal standard operating procedures that guide the way ‘things are done around here’ (Lowndes and Roberts, 2013). And rules in of themselves do not achieve change. Rather it is how rules in use are interpreted and enacted by actors which is important and the actors involved are unlikely to be only women or feminist women (Childs and Krook, 2009; Lowndes, 2014).
This paper builds on earlier research examining the prioritisation of policies addressing violence against women following the introduction of directly elected Police and Crime Commissioners (PCCs) and devolved policing governance in the UK (Gains and Lowndes, 2018). This research highlighted the importance of the gender of executive actors, and also institutional rules around equalities duties. However, quantitative analysis was unable to fully uncover why these determinants made a difference, and how new actors worked with the changed policing governance arrangements.
To interrogate the dynamic and iterative relationship between gendered actors and gendered institutions this paper presents comparative case study research in six localities*. We draw on over twenty interviews with the newly elected commissioners and other elite actors to probe how formal and also informal ‘rules-in-use’ are interpreted and enacted by gendered actors. We find PCCs used informal networks both nationally and in localities to lobby for resources, drew on their directly elected status to call for evidence to challenge policing practices and exploited their ability to direct resources to partnerships offering new forms of intervention. Our analysis uncovers the micro foundations of policy processes to address violence against women in these cases and in so doing makes a broader conceptual contribution to understanding the determinants of gender policy change. The paper also contributes to methodological debates about how best to research actors’ interpretation of institutional rules-in-use, including informal elements.
*We acknowledge support of funding from the European Research Council (PI Georgina Waylen) see https://www.socialsciences.manchester.ac.uk/politics/research/projects-and-networks/uic/
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper will explore how key aspects of state architecture can affect policy-making by promoting or hindering gender equality rights. A rapidly growing literature is studying how federal arrangements that divide power vertically and horizontally affect policy-making, focusing especially on the effects of legal pluralism, i.e. when two or more legal codes govern within a state’s territory. Most gender-and-politics theories assume ‘the state’ they theorize about is unitary despite the fact that over 40 percent of the world's population live in federations (Watts 2008). Furthermore, globalization and neoliberal ideology increased regionalization and the devolution of power which federalized some governance institutions even in unitary states. Moreover, policy-making increasingly is influenced by international agencies making the transnational tier important in both unitary and federal contexts. Therefore, the impact of state architectures on policy-making is important to gender-and-politics theorizing generally. So, while socio-economic and ideological forces shape gender/power relations, governments and movements must respond to those forces from within state architectures with specific histories. Consequently, the paper will show how legal pluralism – a constant feature of MLG -challenges the rule of law in gender/power contexts.
The paper explores the concept of legal pluralism and its impact on gendered policy-making. The importance of legal pluralism was stressed by UN Women in its 2011-12 Report which found that discriminatory family law which poses the greatest barrier to equality women face is highly correlated with legal pluralism. There are two types of legal pluralism : territorial legal pluralism in which the alternate code governs a regional state’s territory, a basic design feature which is constitutionally sanctioned in all federations and non-territorial legal pluralism in which personal law codes apply to members of a religious or ethnic community regardless of territorial location. Federalists believe legal pluralism promotes equity by giving minority nations some self-rule and enhancing democracy by letting ‘local’ communities govern ‘morality issues.’ This could deny gender equality rights to women- rights which international law treats as universal ‘human rights’. One outcome of legal pluralism is the fragmentation of women’s citizenship as but it poses other dangers for women. When family law is part of self-rule, women may be denied protection by central governments if leaders of minority nations or ‘cultural’ communities with autonomy over family law insist on control. Therefore, the ability of central governments to regulate the effects of legal pluralism depends on the extent of diversity and conflict federations must manage and the willingness and capacity of central government actors to defend gender equality rights.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Focusing on the case of Mexico, this paper examines how federalism affects the work of women’s policy agencies. In Mexico, the national government established the Instituto Nacional de las Mujeres (National Institute of Women, INMUJERES) in 2001, and encouraged each state to establish a state level women’s institute. All 32 states now have their own women’s institute, providing a perfect laboratory for testing the effectiveness of women’s policy agencies under the control of different parties and in different social and economic contexts, but in a broadly similar cultural context. What are the consequences of this institutional diversity for gender policy outcomes across the country? Using a subnational comparative analysis, this paper will examine the diversity of women’s policy agencies across the states of Mexico and assess the impact of these institutions on gender policy outcomes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The recent Zika outbreak has brought renewed attention to Latin America’s restrictive sexual and reproductive health laws. While Sustainable Development Goal 5 includes the goal of ensuring universal access to sexual and reproductive health and reproductive rights for all women and girls, the status of abortion remains a contested area. On the one hand, abortion is accepted by many international actors as both an evidence-based and rights-based means for women to have control over and decide freely on matters related to the timing and space of births. On the other hand, many governments continue to restrict access to abortion. A tacit assumption is that governments are working against the interests and preferences of their citizens in restricting access to abortion. But what happens when the normative assumptions advanced by transnational actors are in conflict with the values and opinions of the citizenry of countries where they work? This conflict came into sharp focus during the Zika outbreak when Latin American countries resisted appeals to liberalize their restrictive abortion laws even in the face of a public health emergency. This presentation will explore attitudes towards abortion in Latin American countries, factors associated with support/opposition to abortion and, through a difference-in-difference approach, test whether the crisis of the Zika outbreak of 2014 changed attitudes towards abortion in affected countries, and in what direction. The paper draws on data from three recent rounds of the AmericasBarometer public opinion surveys (2012, 2014 and 2017) that contain questions on attitudes towards abortion when the mother’s health is at risk and information on abortion restrictions in the region. We analyze the prevalence of support for restricting abortion when a mother’s health is at risk for men and women and predictors of support for this attitude including religiosity, political affiliation and gender. We find that pluralities of the public continue to oppose abortion among the countries studied even after the Zika outbreak and in some countries, including those affected directly by Zika, the public decreased their support for abortion. Women and men were equally likely to oppose abortion in the case where a woman’s health is compromised. Religion and religiosity explains some but not all of this attitude. We discuss the implications of the results for collective efforts to reform sexual and reproductive health policy in the region, particularly in light of the Zika threat, as well as implications for theories of policy feedback and policy change.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The goal of this presentation is to draw on research from feminist, non-feminist policy studies and from the doctoral research of the first author to propose a roadmap for measuring what happens to explicitly women empowerment policies after they are bureaucratically made in the highly complex political environment of State of Pakistan in the South Asia. The presentation makes a case for political analysis of feminist policy post adoption and proposes ways to influence the policy processes that result in to women empowerment.
Women empowerment has been one of the core policy objectives of Asian governments and Pakistan is not an isolated case.Whereas, Pakistan has seen various forms of government (military led, democratic) over the decades and they have significantly affected the women empowerment policy formulation and implementation in the country. During those government regimes women empowerment policy subject has been ruled out at various places from federal to province and vice versa. Various institutional solutions brought forwarded and back including women development department, section, ministry at federal level, national and provincial commissions on status of women, women parliamentarian caucus, district committees and so on. Despite of these efforts, the socio-economic and political status of women on the ground has not improved considerably as envisioned by the ‘stated policies’.This presentation based on the first author’s doctoral research explored the link between women empowerment policies and the state architecture in Pakistan.The field research was carried out in Sindh province of Pakistan. Employing a qualitative methodology, the study has used both primary and secondary data sources. Primary data was based on key informants’ interviews with government and non-government policy actors. For secondary data provincial women empowerment policy along with CEDAW reports were reviewed. The findings of this study revealed that despite all efforts women empowerment have not been achieved fully as anticipated by the policies.This study argues that a stable State structure guided by democratic and human rights is utmost crucial for achieving women empowerment.
Key Words: Women empowerment- Policy-Constitutional amendment- Government
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this paper is to analyze the characteristics and evolution of the Federal Brazilian “Gender and Race Pro-Equality Program” (PPEGR) between 2005 and 2019. PPEGR is a public policy elaborated by Secretariat for Policies for Women (SPM), supported by the UN Women and the International Labor Organization (ILO), that complies the Brazilian legislation and the international agreements on human rights signed by Brazil. It aims to eliminate gender and race inequalities in public and private enterprises, and enhance women’s economic and social empowerment, based on conceptions from social demands, people management and organizational culture. Participation in the Program is voluntary and companies that reach at least 70% of compliance with the program’s principles and standards are awarded the Gender and Race Seal. Our analysis was based on the Program’s information made available by the three different Federal governments since 2005, including the left Workers’ Party (PT), followed by centrist Brazilian Democratic Movement (MDB) and the current right-wing conservative Social Liberal Party (PSL). The results suggest that PPEGR (as a social policy for gender and race equity and equality) has been conditioned in distinct ways by the political party and institutional environment in which it operates. During the PT government, there was a democratic formulation and implementation Program’s process that involved thousands of women and feminist organizations. A different scenario was observed during the MDB government when several changes to public expenses reduced labor rights and closed government ministries, such as the Ministry of Women, Racial Equality and Human Rights, which has contributed to gains in women’s rights. During this administration, PPEGR was modified on its management and behavior. In addition, the present government, which has a massive presence of religious and conservative groups, has included a new rule to organizations that have been implementing actions based on PPEGR, making the development process slower. Although the Program has not been extinguished by the government, it doesn’t integrate the civil society in the process of discussion of its strategic lines anymore, with substantial effects on representativeness and expression of the diversity of the population as well as on the organized women’s effort.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)