P05. Governance of Intersectoral Policies with the Population: Illusions and Reality
POLICY IMPLEMENTATIONCATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
Crowdsourcing, citizen panel, world cafe are all methodologies to foster a direct involvement of citizens into public decisions. Some countries encourage digital participation at the stage of agenda settings, as some western government did through the e-government move. Latin American countries encouraged wide on-site population design of public policies and citizen accountability in the monitoring of policy implementation with participatory institutions such as councils and conferences (Isunza Vera & Gurza Lavalle,2010; Cruz & Daroit, 2017). Initiatives multiplies, with their load of disappointments and complexities regarding how to keep mechanisms time efficient for the population and for managers and policy makers (Cunill-Grau, 2014). Arnstein long mentioned weaknesses and lack of authenticity in participatory process (Arnstein, 1969).
Challenges to keep both voices in balance, the voice of policy makers and the voice of the population, are numerous. Methodology-wise, one needs to capture precise information from the population that can bring up generic comments. Also, the question of best instruments to enable authentic participation of the population is relevant (Halpern, Lascoumes, Le Galès, 2014). Value-wise, one has to combine potentially divergent set of opinions from the population and from decision-makers. Ethically-wise, great care has to be taken for prevention of the cooptation of the population by interest groups defending one agenda, etc.
We propose to host researchers interested in intersectoral public policy governance, especially those converging interest in both participatory and multi-sectoral experiences. Hence, this panel aims at recognizing complex state tactics (Smits et al 2016; Smits 2018, Cruz & Daroit, 2017a) responding to population demands.
We intend to generate debate around empirical and/or theoretical advances with respect to structural/cognitive/ethical aspects of governing intersectoral policies with the population, sharing arguments on new axis for research. Scholars with supportive and critical experience are welcome. We will prioritize papers on review, multiple cases and comparatives cases, intriguing or disturbing single case study are also welcome.
Therefore, the indicative panel questions are:
- Which are the conditions (i.e. structures, practices and values) to enable governance of intersectorial policies with the population (i.e. arenas, morphologies and instruments that are entailing transversally the public action among societal groups and government agencies, autonomous actors in binding institutional environment)?
- At the policy design stage, who is able to participate? Why? How?
- Where, in which settings, are complex policies proposals being designed with or for the population? How are these hybrid arenas among population, public servants and politicians being organized?
- Which kind of instruments are being mobilized to link actors and projects from multiple sectors, institutions and branches?
- Which kind of relations are produced among the actors involved in intersectoral management policies? How?
- Which results have risen up from the mobilization of the population in intersectoral initiatives?
- What theories are informative to understand the governance of intersectoral policies with the population?
References:
Arnstein, S.R. (1969) A Ladder of Citizen Participation. Journal of the American Institute of Planners. 35(4), 216-224
Cruz, F. N. B., & Daroit, D. (2017). Das vias para o desenvolvimento democrático: regimentos internos de conselhos de políticas públicas como instrumentos de ação pública transversal e participativa." GIGAPP ESTUDIOS. V. 66-72, p. 231-254.
Cruz, F. N. B., & Daroit, D. (2017a). Dos nexos efêmeros ao fazer estado: ensaio sobre transversalidade em conferências nacionais de políticas públicas. NAU Social, 8(15).
Cunill-Grau, N. (2014). La intersectorialidad en las nuevas políticas sociales: Un acercamiento analítico-conceptual. Gestión y política pública, 23(1), 5-46.
Isunza Vera, E., & Gurza Lavalle, A. (2010). La innovación democrática en América Latina: tramas y nudos de la representación, la participación y el control social. Centro de Investigaciones y Estudios Superiores en Antropología Social (CIESAS).
Halpern, C., Lascoumes, P., & Le Galès, P. (2014). L'instrumentation de l'action publique: controverses, résistances, effets. Presses de Sciences Po.
Smits, P., Préval, J., & Denis, J. L. (2016). Prendre en compte la santé dans les politiques publiques. Étude d’un régime de gouvernementalité au Québec. Sciences sociales et santé, 34(2), 45-70.
Smits, Therrien MC, Touati N., Denis JL. (2018) A Complexity Case Study: The Implementation of an Interministerial Policy — A View from Within Government. Journal on Policy and Complex Systems, V. 4(1).
CALL FOR PAPERS
This Panel recognizes contemporary changes in our societies that are reframing the State. The classic fragmented and hierarchic State structures are unable to tackle goals such as promoting gender and race equality, social development, healthy environments or the social participation deepening. Public policy intersectoral management have been approached by researchers and managers as a relevant path to solve multidimensional problems. There are many inquiries regarding strategies to overcome complex (or wicked) public issues, observing coordination, instrumentation, mainstreaming, governance, common goals, articulation, decision-making or bureaucratic organization. Considering both the relevance of intersectoral management to produce effective social policies, the quest for more authentic public participation in framing public policies, and the importance of academic reflexion to understand and improve these initiatives, we encourage academic-practitioners to engage in writing their experiences, and also authors of applied researches to share their discoveries into the authentic involvement of the population in the design of complex intersectoral public policies. In order to host a forum that recognizes initiatives from around the globe, we welcome papers on specific or compared local, regional, national and also transnational population-centered intersectoral management.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Authors: Pernelle Smits, Canada & Fernanda Natasha Bravo Cruz,
Brazil
Research questions:
-what are the specifics of both sectoral and intersectoral policies in favor of the mobilization of the population?
- what are the specifics of both sectoral and intersectoral policies against mobilizing the population?
-what are opinions of public servants regarding the mobilization of the population for both sectoral and intersectoral policies?
Methodology:
The research is eminently qualitative, based on the analysis of policy documents, as well as practices and discourses from interviews with public servants.
Fit with panel:
The panel is interested in deepening our understanding of authentic participation by population. We choose different country settings, and propose to explore two sides: public administrations’ point of view, the content of policies themselves.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Producing public policies is a matter not only of technical knowledge and public interest, but also of possibilities of governance agreements among political, societal, bureaucratic, scientific and economic actors – specially in complex themes. In contemporary Brazil, the uncertainty of political and economic crisis add even more value to concertation for policy implementation. This paper recognizes the challenges of multidimensional policies to achieve effectiveness in solving wicked problems. To present cross-cutting public action processes in a country in the global south, we reviewed Brazilian graduate researches regarding cross-cutting and intersectoral policies. Afterwards, we collated their results and main theoretical arguments to approaches in the political sociology of public action and sociology of science. The derived conceptual framework allowed us to investigate some emblematic initiatives such as the instrumentation that sets the already known Bolsa Família conditional cash-transfer, observing its organizational strategies and devices; and also the complex structure and dynamics of a classic participatory hybrid forum in Brazil, the National Health Council. The field research was based on interpreting present observations, interviews and documents. The approach among literature and field research leaded to the necessity of pointing out the following systematization of dimensions:
- multidimensional/interseccional problems, considering experience, sense, and material, science, political and cultural aspects;
- paths/interaction dynamics, observing aspects on operation/management, interaction, coordination, decentralization, control;
- & results, taking into account change and innovation, stabilization, normative instruments and effects.
The potent detailed aspects of the arena and the policy introduced by the dimensions motivated us to propose the supradescripted systematization as an analytical framework for cross-cutting public action.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper discusses the implementation of the public policy of special education for students with high skills and intellectual giftedness. The main purpose was to verify the role played by the Center for the Development of Potential and Talent - CEDET in its institutional arrangement (PIRES, GOMIDE, 2014) to understand how the policy is implemented and to analyze the means and instruments that are used for its effectiveness.
CEDET was created in 1993 and operates regularly in Lavras-MG, a city in the south of Minas Gerais with 102,124 thousand inhabitants (IBGE 2017). CEDET is a space of support and educational complementation to gifted and talented students, attending the different schools of the community at all levels of Basic Education (GUENTHER, 2006). It currently serves about 500 students, from eleven municipal schools, eight state schools and two private schools. It promotes Integration and Co-responsibility with the schools and with its partners, assuming co-responsibility both in relation to the process and the expected results (SILVA, 2018).
The research focuses on the municipality of Lavras, in the State of Minas Gerais, although similar initiatives inspired by CEDET have already been developed in other municipalities. The focus of the work is to understand the participation of social actors in the public policy examined here, highlighting the articulation role played by CEDET.
The main concepts about the subject of intellectual giftedness and talent are taken from the studies of Guenther (2000, 2006, 2007), Alencar, Feldhusen and French (2004), Fleith (2007) and Antipoff (2010), as well as government regulations made by the brazilian Ministry of Education (MEC, 2008; BRASIL 2008).
The paper highlights social participation in public policies and the involvement of social actors and associations as a way of executing and cooperating with policy implementation and, thus, verify the institutional arrangements that allow CEDET to carry out its activities. The paper also exposes the historical context and explains the activities carried out by CEDET throughout its twenty-five years of existence.
Data collection was done through interviews and bibliographical and documentary researches, in order to get a better understanding of the way this public policy is implemented, thereby obtaining relevant information on the subject.
One of the findings of the research was that despite the city hall maintain the CEDET, the Association of Parents and Friends for Talent - ASPAT plays a fundamental role in the execution and maintenance of the Center, as well as guiding the activities. This association is responsible for articulating a wide network of volunteers and managing the agreements that CEDET has with the public power, with the university, with clubs and a number of other organizations for the public policy of special education to materialize.
In addition, this research highlights the importance that volunteer work and institutional cooperation have and their importance for policy implementation. This is an emblematic case of successful implementation of the public policy for special education that inspires other cooperative and associative initiatives in the implementation of educational policies across the country.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In this paper we analyze the performance of civil society represented by peasants, fishermen, extractivists, community leaders, activists, consumers and specialists from different regions of the globe in the Civil Society Mechanism (MCS) in the Food Security Committee of the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization Agriculture (FAO / UN).
This participation forum involves the diplomatic representation of the member countries of this UN agency, corporate representatives and civil society.
Thus, we seek to know aspects about the representativeness of each participant by virtue of their segments and regions.
In addition, we seek to understand the forms of political influence at national and international level, as well as the repercussion of the international agenda in the area of food and agriculture in the daily lives of local communities.
Among the main themes of the Committee on Food Security are agroecology, gender and youth, prolonged crises and migrations, agro-food systems and healthy diets, rural transformations and rubanization. And, in particular, the realization of the Human Right to Adequate and Healthy Food.
More specifically, we demonstrate the Mechanism's (MCS) internal processes to ensure plurality of participants, regional demands, consensus-building, and position-building mechanisms to be taken to the Committee to effect international negotiations.
Food and nutritional sovereignty and security are intersectoral fields that have their own status, integrating knowledge and practices that articulate different dimensions associated with production, access, and food education based on health promoting practices, referenced in the local culture and socially and economically just.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The present study aims to support the development and application of the concept of Healthy and Sustainable Territories (TSS) in the Bay of All Saints (BTDS) region, in particular, Ilha de Maré, Salvador - BA - Brazil, from the articulation , identification and evaluation of social demands, as well as the diagnosis of the epidemiological profile of the local population, in order to promote the development of social technologies, the systematization of health and socio-environmental indicators, considering the context of the National Policy of Integral Health of the Populations of the Field, the Forest and the Water (PNSIPCFA), the National Policy of Integral Health of the Black Population (PNSIPN) and the National Policy on Worker Health (PNSTT).
The Movement of Fishermen and Fisherwomen of Brazil (MPP) emerged in 2009, based on the need of the fishing communities to have a representation before the public power in the establishment of public policies that would meet their demands. Currently 50 (fifty) thousand fishermen or fisherwomen participate in the debate and fight for their rights of cultural identity, fishing, to remain in the territory, among others are respected and guaranteed.
This Movement (MPP) presented to FIOCRUZ a social demand, aiming at cooperation of the institution in order to develop actions in the community, aiming at guaranteeing citizenship and social rights as recommended by the Organic Law of Health (lei 8080) - "health is a fundamental human right, and the State must provide the necessary conditions for its full exercise, "and, in consequence of the 2030 strategic agenda and the Sustainable Development Objectives (ODS), which affirm in their principles that no individual or community should be "left behind".
It should be noted that among the demands presented, MPP calls for a sanitary, epidemiological and environmental diagnosis of the resident population of the Maré Island, focusing in particular on the families of fishermen/fisherwomen and shellfish; the construction of a health plan taking into account the specificities of the region and the vulnerabilities arising from geographical location and large industrial enterprises, among other demands.
Reports by the community about some of the symptoms and serious health problems that had not previously existed on the island, which the MPP leadership says are now "common people on the island have died of cancer due to pollution, rhinitis, vision problems are constant . With the environment is no different, they observe the decrease of clams and fish, the loss of banana production, the odors, especially in the late afternoon, catch the attention of the residents. They emphasized the concern with the accidents that happen and the lack of communication between the authorities of Porto of Aratu and the community in case of emergencies.
They cited the last accident that leaked large amount of fuel oil and contamination of the region. The dialogue that established between the island community and Fiocruz researchers on the right to health, an environment and healthy work indicates as a process of claims for public policies services for the improvement and quality of life of the local population and, finally, for a healthy and sustainable territory for all.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The paper analyzes the urgency of the reform of the management of basic sanitation proposed by the Provisional Measure (MPV) Nº 844/2018, in view of the hidden subjects of this reform and the context of scientific and political regression. It is a documentary research that adopts the analytical key of critical social theory, especially Antonio Gramsci, inserted in the debates about basic sanitation. We indicate elements to verify that this reform expresses the scientific and political contradiction of the thought and ethics of reckless management begun in 2016 after impeachment. In its process the population was invited to participate in a Public Consultation. The reason for the Public Consultation is in the great mobilization carried out around the Provisional Measure on screen. The Public Consultation is governed by Resolution No. 26, dated July 10, 2013, of the Federal Senate. Of course, this process came from the scenario of the June 2013 Days, which explained how complex policies are being demanded by the population. It is important to remember that in terms of civil society all the main associations involved in the Provisional Measure, namely the Brazilian Association of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (ABES), the Brazilian Association of Regulatory Agencies (ABAR), the Brazilian Association of State Sanitation Companies (AESBE), the National Association of Municipal Sanitation Services (ASSEMAE) and the National Confederation of Municipalities (CNM) opposed the Provisional Measure and mobilized for its rejection. The result of the mobilization of the population in the Popular Consultation was the rejection by a large majority: 85% of the participants said no to the Provisional Measure. Finally, we seek to show the close relationship between the Provisional Measure Nº 844/2018 as a set of setbacks in basic sanitation. We find that such "urgency" has as a background the reckless administration of the "public budget".
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The present article intends to analyze the most recent data of regional scope on the International Human Trafficking relating them to the dynamics of the flows for the inclusion of the gender perspective in the face of its combat at the Mercosur level on the Intersectoral Policy since the creation of the regional integration block in Latin America. The methodology used is qualitative in order to understand the practices of social relations, working both with the experience and subjectivity of the strategic actors and their relations with the institutions as a result of public action encompassing the complexity of social problems. In this way, we use critical discourse analysis, with an antitraditional epistemological position and orientation of the discourse function as a social practice of approaching to the population, which allows the subtlety of interpretation as a skillful art of handmade research, intercalating between the text and the context, demanding rigor to the details in order to obtain the balance for a discursive organization with the responsibility of authorship for the understanding and evaluation of the readers. To this end, we verified the systematization of recent data (UN Global Reports and each country information) and the official records of the Mercosur on its strategic tools (Mercosur Guide on Attention to Women in Trafficking for Sexual Exploitation, Regional Diagnoses, Gender Equality Policy of Mercosur, etc.), highlighting that the gender perspective is inserted in its combat mainly from the feminist movements for a Latin American transnational advocacy project, which systematizes knowledge for the development of new negotiation skills as a practice on a complex and continuous process that seeks to surpass the limits of a linear sequential logic as would be the traditional cycle of Public Policy. Thus, there is an orientation of a strong discourse within the Mercosur on the gender perspective, but alluded to the real limitations of the advances obtained and their possibilities in relation to the inherent complexities of Human Trafficking theme. After all, in the Americas there has historically been a predominance of Women Trafficking for sexual exploitation and perhaps the main message of the most recent data on the subject is to remember how to continue to generate cooperation and collaboration at national, regional and international level to prevent, detect, attend and effectively combat cases in their new forms of the phenomenon.
Keywords: Human Trafficking; Mercosur; Gender.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The construction of contemporary public policies highlights the need to think about social participation, coordination and articulation between sectors and actors. As a mean to ensure these principles, the Brazilian democratic Constitution of 1988 provided mechanisms to strengthen the links between government decision making and civil society. With constitutional provision and created by a legislation published few years later, the Brazilian Unified Health System (SUS) shares this vision, being a complex structure that has as pillars decentralization, participation, universality and integrality of the services provided, valuing the instruments of social participation and active listening. For that reason, SUS has conferences and councils established in the three spheres of autonomous government (federal, state and municipal) as hybrid arenas of participation and commissions formed by managers, acting throw negotiation and agreement.
In the case of health policies, each federate entity has only one organism responsible for coordination, working in a single direction. It can be said that health policy in Brazil functions in a paradoxical way, established in cooperation and network, at the same time as it is ascending and hierarchical. The SUS’s structure form is transversal and intersectoral, involving the multiple actors involved in the construction of the health public action.
In recent years, there has been an effort by general and regional governments to strengthen SUS health regions. Regionalization focuses on the territoriality of politics and the socioeconomic and cultural characteristics of each locality, understanding in a better way the specific need of each region. This form of organization works in reducing regional inequalities, a great challenge for a country with huge territorial extension. The health regions are established not only with the same level of government spheres, demanding actors to work in cooperation, integration and articulation.
Therefore, this paper proposes to draw a critical analysis of SUS’s participation mechanisms, focusing on the regionalization of health, as a mean to establish a system of governance that act in concordance with the principles and directives established in the creation of SUS.
The methodology of the paper is based primarily on a bibliographical review, basing the precepts on participation, intersectionality and regionalization of health. It involves also a legislative survey of the construction of Brazilian health policy on these subjects, besides a vast documentary analysis.
It is hoped that the work will contribute to the strengthening of the studies invoked on the panel, besides giving visibility to a health policy based of participatory principles developed in Latin America.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The political turmoil in Brazil got deeper with two presidential shifts in less than three years. Firstly, in 2016, the re-elected president Dilma Roussef suffered a controversial process of impeachment and was replaced by her vice-president Michel Temer. Secondly, in 2018, the former president Lula da Silva was convicted and incarcerated over disputable charges, when leading the presidential polls, which opened ways to the victory of right-wing extremist Jair Bolsonaro, the current president. Besides the questionable means which led them to the presidency and a common reluctance to promote public participation, Temer and Bolsonaro also share a specific coincidence: in the very first day after confirmed on charge, both presidents issued provisional measures extinguishing a major intersectoral national council – the Curatorial Council of the Brazil Communications Company (CC-EBC) in 2016 and the Food and Nutritional Security Council (CONSEA) in 2019. Taking note of but surpassing the officially declared motivations, this paper tries to identify common grounds, if any, that would have caused two different presidents in two different periods to adopt such extreme measures against two successful and recognized mechanisms of public participation – and so urgently. Methodology is based on documental research over official documents and civil society manifests about the termination of the councils, as well as a retrospective overview of the last issues addresses and last communications launched by each collegiate body. The main hypothesis is that both councils were composed by a wide and dynamic collection of social actors that would directly oppose the interest groups that promoted each of the presidential shifts. More than that, due to either its expertise or to its influence, each council would be able to win some battles against the government (as they already did) and affect public opinion regarding its political agenda. However, this possible explanation – that places those public bodies as internal enemies – does not make enough sense unless a scenario of a turn towards post-democracy is considered. Thus, assuming the latter, a disturbing pattern would be recognizable in both cases. More than internal enemies, the collegiate bodies would be regarded as potential democratic enclaves that should be controlled immediately, before they managed to damage governmental public image. Hence, the two councils would have been victims of its own successes, through a reaction that would match the label of simulative politics (which addresses the dichotomy between “illusions and reality” proposed by this panel). Under this model, the two cases can be seen as symptoms of the same condition of transition to post-democracy, whose theoretical approach could help not only to identify, but to respond to.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The object of this paper is to bring a brief historical about the political participation of transgender people in Brazil from 2016 to 2018, with focus on the difficulties on the access to the politics and public policies in consequence of the discrimination and gender prejudice. To ensure a public policy aligned with the population’s needs, it is absolutely crucial that the excluded groups can be listened and represented in the political scenario. However, the lack of representativeness have been one of the biggest barriers to the public policies design, although, in the last years, the number of transsexual people in the political scenario, mostly in the municipal and state level, have been increasing. Other important question is to identify the regions with a high level of transgender people elected and the political parties represented by them. We analysed data from several transgender’ institutions and associations to map the performance of these people on the definition of public policies as well as the information from the Election Supreme Court, and other sources. We intent to bring up some significant results regarding the increasing of the number of transgender people in the Brazilian political scenario and how this fact can affect the public policies to guarantee the rights to transgender people in Brazil.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
It is notable that the recognition of the importance of evaluation as a fundamental part of the analysis of public policies is growing. This is essential, both for the policy makers themselves and their beneficiaries, so that it is possible to measure the most diverse effects of the policies and their respective programs. In order for this task to be successful, apart from dedicating itself to finding appropriate and refined methods and analysis tools, it is necessary to reflect on the meaning of evaluations as something that, beyond a technical sense, has a political meaning, much more complex and demanding: a democratic sense in terms of the construction of citizenship.
The construction of citizenship, in modern times and in increasingly fragmented and complex societies, has demanded more refined tools in order to face their demands and needs (Brugué, 2008). So, as Fraser (2006) affirms, demands for "recognition of difference" that were raised with more force since the end of the century for the struggles by organized groups.
With the perspective of contributing to this debate, this research, developed in the NEPPs – “Núcleo de Estudos em Políticas Públicas” (Center of Studies in Public Policies) of the São Paulo State University (UNESP/Brazil), proposes to present an evaluation tool capable of exploiting transversal dimensions that corresponds to questions of race, gender and sexual diversity, in the Brazilian case.
In general, the policies on which evaluations are made are sectoral, embedded in a restricted context of analysis, closed to the respective managers, while in practice, the issues surrounding the struggle for citizenship are much broader and cross-cutting. So, in this communication, we seek to propose an evaluation format that considers the various dimensions proposed, as well as the ideas and interests of the respective actors involved.
From this point of view, the broader perspective that marks this research is presented by the understanding that each of these dimensions are established by a process of social construction: social and historical construction of identities that is always collective result, not without conflicts, but nothing natural. Taking this perspective into account, the work will be presented in two main parts. A first, where race, gender and sexual diversity will be defined, at least in terms of essential indicators, so that it will be possible to specify questions related to each of the dimensions postulated in an evaluation, as well as their connections, in the presented context. In the second part, having this conceptualization as reference, a set of social indicators will be propose as a basis for the development of a concrete evaluation tool that includes race, gender and sexual diversity transversally in the social policies of the state and federal levels from the Brazilian government.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Glasby and Beresford (2005) question the assumption underlying the concept of ‘evidence-based practice’ in a context where policymakers, practitioners, evaluators, and researchers recognize the importance of experiential data; the authors proposed a new concept ‘knowledge-based practice’. In fact, there is an increasing call for users services to participate in the policy-making process (Leung and Larn; 2019) as well as in evaluation and research processes (Breth & al., 2014; Bush & al. 2017). Many authors tried to explore the different venues of research about users’ participation (ethical issues, participation impacts on users). Particularly, young users’ participation presents more challenges, even if there are a large number of writings from different contexts exploring young people's participation, especially on research projects (Flemming, 2010; McLaughlin, 2005). The young people role in research made huge progress and they become active participants (McLaughlin, 2005). However, many issues remain important to explore, discuss and resolve to optimize young people's participation.
In this paper, we adopted the definition of Canada's Strategy for Patient-Oriented Research (SPOR). The user becomes a partner who collaborates actively to a continuum of research (governance, priority setting, conducting research and knowledge translation). We will present descriptive case studies (EDJeP and AO), and process evaluation of the engagement of youths. The two cases are successful experiences of the participation of youth. The first EDJeP is a provincial longitudinal study interested in the transition to the adulthood of youth placed in the youth center. The study focused on their trajectories, the services to which they have access, and how they were prepared for their autonomous life. A youth committee accompanied the project since the project was funded. The youth committee is an important component of the governance strategy since the project design. The second project “Air ouverte (AO)” is an integrated network of youth mental health services 12-25 years. Only three demonstrative projects in Quebec were financed in 2018 to implement and to evaluate those projects. In this paper, we will cover Laval’s project. The youth user’s participation was a condition of the fund organizations. The participation of youth covered the entire project continuum. Youth users are mobilized in different governance instances and a youth committee is involved in the implementation of “Aire Ouverte”.
Our question research is interested on: what are the successful conditions to engage youth users in a participative process? Analysis of methodological, organizational and practical issues encountered during this process and the solutions implemented to achieve a meaningful, active and continuous participation of youth users will be presented.
Financial issues, ethical issues, and youth coaching seem to be the preconditions of any process of youth user’s involvement. However, real life exposes researchers and evaluators to other issues they have to resolve in an innovative way. In fact, the perception of youth participation of all stakeholders, the manipulation of the concept of participation as well as their coaching and training to enhance their self-confidence and self-esteem continuously are key elements to maintain their motivation, interest, and engagement.
References
Brett, J. Staniszewska, S., Mockford, C., Herron-Marx, S., Hughes, J., Tysall, C. & Suleman, R. (2014). A Systematic Review of the Impact of Patient and Public Involvement on Service Users, Researchers and Communities Patient, The Patient - Patient-Centered Outcomes Research, 7(4):387–395.
Bush, P. L., Pluye, P., Loignon, C., Granikov, V., Wright, M. T., Pelletier, J.-F., Bartlett-Esquilant, G., Macaulay, A. C., Haggerty, J., Parry, S., & Repchinsky, C. (2017). Organizational participatory research: a systematic mixed studies review exposing its extra benefits and the key factors associated with them. Implementation Science, 12(1):119-253.
Fleming, J. (2010). Young People’s Involvement in Research. Still a Long Way to Go? Qualitative Social Work, 10(2): 207–223.
Glasby, J. et Beresford, P. (2006) ‘Who knows best? Evidence-based practice and the service user contribution’, Critical Social Policy, 26(1):268-284.
Leung, T. T., & Lam, B. C. (2019). Building consensus on user participation in social work: A conversation analysis. Journal of Social Work, 19(10):20–40.
McLaughlin , H (2005). Young Service Users as Co-researchers Methodological Problems and Possibilities. Qualitative Social Work, 4(2):211-228.
Canada. Canadian Institutes of Health Research. Strategy for patient-oriented research (SPOR): Putting patients first; the patient engagement framework, [Online], http://www.cihr-irsc.gc.ca/e/documents/spor_framework-en.pdf.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Authors: Pernelle Smits, Canada & Fernanda Natasha Bravo Cruz,
Brazil
Research questions:
-what are the specifics of both sectoral and intersectoral policies in favor of the mobilization of the population?
- what are the specifics of both sectoral and intersectoral policies against mobilizing the population?
-what are opinions of public servants regarding the mobilization of the population for both sectoral and intersectoral policies?
Methodology:
The research is eminently qualitative, based on the analysis of policy documents, as well as practices and discourses from interviews with public servants.
Fit with panel:
The panel is interested in deepening our understanding of authentic participation by population. We choose different country settings, and propose to explore two sides: public administrations’ point of view, the content of policies themselves.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Producing public policies is a matter not only of technical knowledge and public interest, but also of possibilities of governance agreements among political, societal, bureaucratic, scientific and economic actors – specially in complex themes. In contemporary Brazil, the uncertainty of political and economic crisis add even more value to concertation for policy implementation. This paper recognizes the challenges of multidimensional policies to achieve effectiveness in solving wicked problems. To present cross-cutting public action processes in a country in the global south, we reviewed Brazilian graduate researches regarding cross-cutting and intersectoral policies. Afterwards, we collated their results and main theoretical arguments to approaches in the political sociology of public action and sociology of science. The derived conceptual framework allowed us to investigate some emblematic initiatives such as the instrumentation that sets the already known Bolsa Família conditional cash-transfer, observing its organizational strategies and devices; and also the complex structure and dynamics of a classic participatory hybrid forum in Brazil, the National Health Council. The field research was based on interpreting present observations, interviews and documents. The approach among literature and field research leaded to the necessity of pointing out the following systematization of dimensions:
- multidimensional/interseccional problems, considering experience, sense, and material, science, political and cultural aspects;
- paths/interaction dynamics, observing aspects on operation/management, interaction, coordination, decentralization, control;
- & results, taking into account change and innovation, stabilization, normative instruments and effects.
The potent detailed aspects of the arena and the policy introduced by the dimensions motivated us to propose the supradescripted systematization as an analytical framework for cross-cutting public action.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper discusses the implementation of the public policy of special education for students with high skills and intellectual giftedness. The main purpose was to verify the role played by the Center for the Development of Potential and Talent - CEDET in its institutional arrangement (PIRES, GOMIDE, 2014) to understand how the policy is implemented and to analyze the means and instruments that are used for its effectiveness.
CEDET was created in 1993 and operates regularly in Lavras-MG, a city in the south of Minas Gerais with 102,124 thousand inhabitants (IBGE 2017). CEDET is a space of support and educational complementation to gifted and talented students, attending the different schools of the community at all levels of Basic Education (GUENTHER, 2006). It currently serves about 500 students, from eleven municipal schools, eight state schools and two private schools. It promotes Integration and Co-responsibility with the schools and with its partners, assuming co-responsibility both in relation to the process and the expected results (SILVA, 2018).
The research focuses on the municipality of Lavras, in the State of Minas Gerais, although similar initiatives inspired by CEDET have already been developed in other municipalities. The focus of the work is to understand the participation of social actors in the public policy examined here, highlighting the articulation role played by CEDET.
The main concepts about the subject of intellectual giftedness and talent are taken from the studies of Guenther (2000, 2006, 2007), Alencar, Feldhusen and French (2004), Fleith (2007) and Antipoff (2010), as well as government regulations made by the brazilian Ministry of Education (MEC, 2008; BRASIL 2008).
The paper highlights social participation in public policies and the involvement of social actors and associations as a way of executing and cooperating with policy implementation and, thus, verify the institutional arrangements that allow CEDET to carry out its activities. The paper also exposes the historical context and explains the activities carried out by CEDET throughout its twenty-five years of existence.
Data collection was done through interviews and bibliographical and documentary researches, in order to get a better understanding of the way this public policy is implemented, thereby obtaining relevant information on the subject.
One of the findings of the research was that despite the city hall maintain the CEDET, the Association of Parents and Friends for Talent - ASPAT plays a fundamental role in the execution and maintenance of the Center, as well as guiding the activities. This association is responsible for articulating a wide network of volunteers and managing the agreements that CEDET has with the public power, with the university, with clubs and a number of other organizations for the public policy of special education to materialize.
In addition, this research highlights the importance that volunteer work and institutional cooperation have and their importance for policy implementation. This is an emblematic case of successful implementation of the public policy for special education that inspires other cooperative and associative initiatives in the implementation of educational policies across the country.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In this paper we analyze the performance of civil society represented by peasants, fishermen, extractivists, community leaders, activists, consumers and specialists from different regions of the globe in the Civil Society Mechanism (MCS) in the Food Security Committee of the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization Agriculture (FAO / UN).
This participation forum involves the diplomatic representation of the member countries of this UN agency, corporate representatives and civil society.
Thus, we seek to know aspects about the representativeness of each participant by virtue of their segments and regions.
In addition, we seek to understand the forms of political influence at national and international level, as well as the repercussion of the international agenda in the area of food and agriculture in the daily lives of local communities.
Among the main themes of the Committee on Food Security are agroecology, gender and youth, prolonged crises and migrations, agro-food systems and healthy diets, rural transformations and rubanization. And, in particular, the realization of the Human Right to Adequate and Healthy Food.
More specifically, we demonstrate the Mechanism's (MCS) internal processes to ensure plurality of participants, regional demands, consensus-building, and position-building mechanisms to be taken to the Committee to effect international negotiations.
Food and nutritional sovereignty and security are intersectoral fields that have their own status, integrating knowledge and practices that articulate different dimensions associated with production, access, and food education based on health promoting practices, referenced in the local culture and socially and economically just.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The present study aims to support the development and application of the concept of Healthy and Sustainable Territories (TSS) in the Bay of All Saints (BTDS) region, in particular, Ilha de Maré, Salvador - BA - Brazil, from the articulation , identification and evaluation of social demands, as well as the diagnosis of the epidemiological profile of the local population, in order to promote the development of social technologies, the systematization of health and socio-environmental indicators, considering the context of the National Policy of Integral Health of the Populations of the Field, the Forest and the Water (PNSIPCFA), the National Policy of Integral Health of the Black Population (PNSIPN) and the National Policy on Worker Health (PNSTT).
The Movement of Fishermen and Fisherwomen of Brazil (MPP) emerged in 2009, based on the need of the fishing communities to have a representation before the public power in the establishment of public policies that would meet their demands. Currently 50 (fifty) thousand fishermen or fisherwomen participate in the debate and fight for their rights of cultural identity, fishing, to remain in the territory, among others are respected and guaranteed.
This Movement (MPP) presented to FIOCRUZ a social demand, aiming at cooperation of the institution in order to develop actions in the community, aiming at guaranteeing citizenship and social rights as recommended by the Organic Law of Health (lei 8080) - "health is a fundamental human right, and the State must provide the necessary conditions for its full exercise, "and, in consequence of the 2030 strategic agenda and the Sustainable Development Objectives (ODS), which affirm in their principles that no individual or community should be "left behind".
It should be noted that among the demands presented, MPP calls for a sanitary, epidemiological and environmental diagnosis of the resident population of the Maré Island, focusing in particular on the families of fishermen/fisherwomen and shellfish; the construction of a health plan taking into account the specificities of the region and the vulnerabilities arising from geographical location and large industrial enterprises, among other demands.
Reports by the community about some of the symptoms and serious health problems that had not previously existed on the island, which the MPP leadership says are now "common people on the island have died of cancer due to pollution, rhinitis, vision problems are constant . With the environment is no different, they observe the decrease of clams and fish, the loss of banana production, the odors, especially in the late afternoon, catch the attention of the residents. They emphasized the concern with the accidents that happen and the lack of communication between the authorities of Porto of Aratu and the community in case of emergencies.
They cited the last accident that leaked large amount of fuel oil and contamination of the region. The dialogue that established between the island community and Fiocruz researchers on the right to health, an environment and healthy work indicates as a process of claims for public policies services for the improvement and quality of life of the local population and, finally, for a healthy and sustainable territory for all.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The paper analyzes the urgency of the reform of the management of basic sanitation proposed by the Provisional Measure (MPV) Nº 844/2018, in view of the hidden subjects of this reform and the context of scientific and political regression. It is a documentary research that adopts the analytical key of critical social theory, especially Antonio Gramsci, inserted in the debates about basic sanitation. We indicate elements to verify that this reform expresses the scientific and political contradiction of the thought and ethics of reckless management begun in 2016 after impeachment. In its process the population was invited to participate in a Public Consultation. The reason for the Public Consultation is in the great mobilization carried out around the Provisional Measure on screen. The Public Consultation is governed by Resolution No. 26, dated July 10, 2013, of the Federal Senate. Of course, this process came from the scenario of the June 2013 Days, which explained how complex policies are being demanded by the population. It is important to remember that in terms of civil society all the main associations involved in the Provisional Measure, namely the Brazilian Association of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (ABES), the Brazilian Association of Regulatory Agencies (ABAR), the Brazilian Association of State Sanitation Companies (AESBE), the National Association of Municipal Sanitation Services (ASSEMAE) and the National Confederation of Municipalities (CNM) opposed the Provisional Measure and mobilized for its rejection. The result of the mobilization of the population in the Popular Consultation was the rejection by a large majority: 85% of the participants said no to the Provisional Measure. Finally, we seek to show the close relationship between the Provisional Measure Nº 844/2018 as a set of setbacks in basic sanitation. We find that such "urgency" has as a background the reckless administration of the "public budget".
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The present article intends to analyze the most recent data of regional scope on the International Human Trafficking relating them to the dynamics of the flows for the inclusion of the gender perspective in the face of its combat at the Mercosur level on the Intersectoral Policy since the creation of the regional integration block in Latin America. The methodology used is qualitative in order to understand the practices of social relations, working both with the experience and subjectivity of the strategic actors and their relations with the institutions as a result of public action encompassing the complexity of social problems. In this way, we use critical discourse analysis, with an antitraditional epistemological position and orientation of the discourse function as a social practice of approaching to the population, which allows the subtlety of interpretation as a skillful art of handmade research, intercalating between the text and the context, demanding rigor to the details in order to obtain the balance for a discursive organization with the responsibility of authorship for the understanding and evaluation of the readers. To this end, we verified the systematization of recent data (UN Global Reports and each country information) and the official records of the Mercosur on its strategic tools (Mercosur Guide on Attention to Women in Trafficking for Sexual Exploitation, Regional Diagnoses, Gender Equality Policy of Mercosur, etc.), highlighting that the gender perspective is inserted in its combat mainly from the feminist movements for a Latin American transnational advocacy project, which systematizes knowledge for the development of new negotiation skills as a practice on a complex and continuous process that seeks to surpass the limits of a linear sequential logic as would be the traditional cycle of Public Policy. Thus, there is an orientation of a strong discourse within the Mercosur on the gender perspective, but alluded to the real limitations of the advances obtained and their possibilities in relation to the inherent complexities of Human Trafficking theme. After all, in the Americas there has historically been a predominance of Women Trafficking for sexual exploitation and perhaps the main message of the most recent data on the subject is to remember how to continue to generate cooperation and collaboration at national, regional and international level to prevent, detect, attend and effectively combat cases in their new forms of the phenomenon.
Keywords: Human Trafficking; Mercosur; Gender.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The construction of contemporary public policies highlights the need to think about social participation, coordination and articulation between sectors and actors. As a mean to ensure these principles, the Brazilian democratic Constitution of 1988 provided mechanisms to strengthen the links between government decision making and civil society. With constitutional provision and created by a legislation published few years later, the Brazilian Unified Health System (SUS) shares this vision, being a complex structure that has as pillars decentralization, participation, universality and integrality of the services provided, valuing the instruments of social participation and active listening. For that reason, SUS has conferences and councils established in the three spheres of autonomous government (federal, state and municipal) as hybrid arenas of participation and commissions formed by managers, acting throw negotiation and agreement.
In the case of health policies, each federate entity has only one organism responsible for coordination, working in a single direction. It can be said that health policy in Brazil functions in a paradoxical way, established in cooperation and network, at the same time as it is ascending and hierarchical. The SUS’s structure form is transversal and intersectoral, involving the multiple actors involved in the construction of the health public action.
In recent years, there has been an effort by general and regional governments to strengthen SUS health regions. Regionalization focuses on the territoriality of politics and the socioeconomic and cultural characteristics of each locality, understanding in a better way the specific need of each region. This form of organization works in reducing regional inequalities, a great challenge for a country with huge territorial extension. The health regions are established not only with the same level of government spheres, demanding actors to work in cooperation, integration and articulation.
Therefore, this paper proposes to draw a critical analysis of SUS’s participation mechanisms, focusing on the regionalization of health, as a mean to establish a system of governance that act in concordance with the principles and directives established in the creation of SUS.
The methodology of the paper is based primarily on a bibliographical review, basing the precepts on participation, intersectionality and regionalization of health. It involves also a legislative survey of the construction of Brazilian health policy on these subjects, besides a vast documentary analysis.
It is hoped that the work will contribute to the strengthening of the studies invoked on the panel, besides giving visibility to a health policy based of participatory principles developed in Latin America.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The political turmoil in Brazil got deeper with two presidential shifts in less than three years. Firstly, in 2016, the re-elected president Dilma Roussef suffered a controversial process of impeachment and was replaced by her vice-president Michel Temer. Secondly, in 2018, the former president Lula da Silva was convicted and incarcerated over disputable charges, when leading the presidential polls, which opened ways to the victory of right-wing extremist Jair Bolsonaro, the current president. Besides the questionable means which led them to the presidency and a common reluctance to promote public participation, Temer and Bolsonaro also share a specific coincidence: in the very first day after confirmed on charge, both presidents issued provisional measures extinguishing a major intersectoral national council – the Curatorial Council of the Brazil Communications Company (CC-EBC) in 2016 and the Food and Nutritional Security Council (CONSEA) in 2019. Taking note of but surpassing the officially declared motivations, this paper tries to identify common grounds, if any, that would have caused two different presidents in two different periods to adopt such extreme measures against two successful and recognized mechanisms of public participation – and so urgently. Methodology is based on documental research over official documents and civil society manifests about the termination of the councils, as well as a retrospective overview of the last issues addresses and last communications launched by each collegiate body. The main hypothesis is that both councils were composed by a wide and dynamic collection of social actors that would directly oppose the interest groups that promoted each of the presidential shifts. More than that, due to either its expertise or to its influence, each council would be able to win some battles against the government (as they already did) and affect public opinion regarding its political agenda. However, this possible explanation – that places those public bodies as internal enemies – does not make enough sense unless a scenario of a turn towards post-democracy is considered. Thus, assuming the latter, a disturbing pattern would be recognizable in both cases. More than internal enemies, the collegiate bodies would be regarded as potential democratic enclaves that should be controlled immediately, before they managed to damage governmental public image. Hence, the two councils would have been victims of its own successes, through a reaction that would match the label of simulative politics (which addresses the dichotomy between “illusions and reality” proposed by this panel). Under this model, the two cases can be seen as symptoms of the same condition of transition to post-democracy, whose theoretical approach could help not only to identify, but to respond to.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The object of this paper is to bring a brief historical about the political participation of transgender people in Brazil from 2016 to 2018, with focus on the difficulties on the access to the politics and public policies in consequence of the discrimination and gender prejudice. To ensure a public policy aligned with the population’s needs, it is absolutely crucial that the excluded groups can be listened and represented in the political scenario. However, the lack of representativeness have been one of the biggest barriers to the public policies design, although, in the last years, the number of transsexual people in the political scenario, mostly in the municipal and state level, have been increasing. Other important question is to identify the regions with a high level of transgender people elected and the political parties represented by them. We analysed data from several transgender’ institutions and associations to map the performance of these people on the definition of public policies as well as the information from the Election Supreme Court, and other sources. We intent to bring up some significant results regarding the increasing of the number of transgender people in the Brazilian political scenario and how this fact can affect the public policies to guarantee the rights to transgender people in Brazil.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
It is notable that the recognition of the importance of evaluation as a fundamental part of the analysis of public policies is growing. This is essential, both for the policy makers themselves and their beneficiaries, so that it is possible to measure the most diverse effects of the policies and their respective programs. In order for this task to be successful, apart from dedicating itself to finding appropriate and refined methods and analysis tools, it is necessary to reflect on the meaning of evaluations as something that, beyond a technical sense, has a political meaning, much more complex and demanding: a democratic sense in terms of the construction of citizenship.
The construction of citizenship, in modern times and in increasingly fragmented and complex societies, has demanded more refined tools in order to face their demands and needs (Brugué, 2008). So, as Fraser (2006) affirms, demands for "recognition of difference" that were raised with more force since the end of the century for the struggles by organized groups.
With the perspective of contributing to this debate, this research, developed in the NEPPs – “Núcleo de Estudos em Políticas Públicas” (Center of Studies in Public Policies) of the São Paulo State University (UNESP/Brazil), proposes to present an evaluation tool capable of exploiting transversal dimensions that corresponds to questions of race, gender and sexual diversity, in the Brazilian case.
In general, the policies on which evaluations are made are sectoral, embedded in a restricted context of analysis, closed to the respective managers, while in practice, the issues surrounding the struggle for citizenship are much broader and cross-cutting. So, in this communication, we seek to propose an evaluation format that considers the various dimensions proposed, as well as the ideas and interests of the respective actors involved.
From this point of view, the broader perspective that marks this research is presented by the understanding that each of these dimensions are established by a process of social construction: social and historical construction of identities that is always collective result, not without conflicts, but nothing natural. Taking this perspective into account, the work will be presented in two main parts. A first, where race, gender and sexual diversity will be defined, at least in terms of essential indicators, so that it will be possible to specify questions related to each of the dimensions postulated in an evaluation, as well as their connections, in the presented context. In the second part, having this conceptualization as reference, a set of social indicators will be propose as a basis for the development of a concrete evaluation tool that includes race, gender and sexual diversity transversally in the social policies of the state and federal levels from the Brazilian government.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Glasby and Beresford (2005) question the assumption underlying the concept of ‘evidence-based practice’ in a context where policymakers, practitioners, evaluators, and researchers recognize the importance of experiential data; the authors proposed a new concept ‘knowledge-based practice’. In fact, there is an increasing call for users services to participate in the policy-making process (Leung and Larn; 2019) as well as in evaluation and research processes (Breth & al., 2014; Bush & al. 2017). Many authors tried to explore the different venues of research about users’ participation (ethical issues, participation impacts on users). Particularly, young users’ participation presents more challenges, even if there are a large number of writings from different contexts exploring young people's participation, especially on research projects (Flemming, 2010; McLaughlin, 2005). The young people role in research made huge progress and they become active participants (McLaughlin, 2005). However, many issues remain important to explore, discuss and resolve to optimize young people's participation.
In this paper, we adopted the definition of Canada's Strategy for Patient-Oriented Research (SPOR). The user becomes a partner who collaborates actively to a continuum of research (governance, priority setting, conducting research and knowledge translation). We will present descriptive case studies (EDJeP and AO), and process evaluation of the engagement of youths. The two cases are successful experiences of the participation of youth. The first EDJeP is a provincial longitudinal study interested in the transition to the adulthood of youth placed in the youth center. The study focused on their trajectories, the services to which they have access, and how they were prepared for their autonomous life. A youth committee accompanied the project since the project was funded. The youth committee is an important component of the governance strategy since the project design. The second project “Air ouverte (AO)” is an integrated network of youth mental health services 12-25 years. Only three demonstrative projects in Quebec were financed in 2018 to implement and to evaluate those projects. In this paper, we will cover Laval’s project. The youth user’s participation was a condition of the fund organizations. The participation of youth covered the entire project continuum. Youth users are mobilized in different governance instances and a youth committee is involved in the implementation of “Aire Ouverte”.
Our question research is interested on: what are the successful conditions to engage youth users in a participative process? Analysis of methodological, organizational and practical issues encountered during this process and the solutions implemented to achieve a meaningful, active and continuous participation of youth users will be presented.
Financial issues, ethical issues, and youth coaching seem to be the preconditions of any process of youth user’s involvement. However, real life exposes researchers and evaluators to other issues they have to resolve in an innovative way. In fact, the perception of youth participation of all stakeholders, the manipulation of the concept of participation as well as their coaching and training to enhance their self-confidence and self-esteem continuously are key elements to maintain their motivation, interest, and engagement.
References
Brett, J. Staniszewska, S., Mockford, C., Herron-Marx, S., Hughes, J., Tysall, C. & Suleman, R. (2014). A Systematic Review of the Impact of Patient and Public Involvement on Service Users, Researchers and Communities Patient, The Patient - Patient-Centered Outcomes Research, 7(4):387–395.
Bush, P. L., Pluye, P., Loignon, C., Granikov, V., Wright, M. T., Pelletier, J.-F., Bartlett-Esquilant, G., Macaulay, A. C., Haggerty, J., Parry, S., & Repchinsky, C. (2017). Organizational participatory research: a systematic mixed studies review exposing its extra benefits and the key factors associated with them. Implementation Science, 12(1):119-253.
Fleming, J. (2010). Young People’s Involvement in Research. Still a Long Way to Go? Qualitative Social Work, 10(2): 207–223.
Glasby, J. et Beresford, P. (2006) ‘Who knows best? Evidence-based practice and the service user contribution’, Critical Social Policy, 26(1):268-284.
Leung, T. T., & Lam, B. C. (2019). Building consensus on user participation in social work: A conversation analysis. Journal of Social Work, 19(10):20–40.
McLaughlin , H (2005). Young Service Users as Co-researchers Methodological Problems and Possibilities. Qualitative Social Work, 4(2):211-228.
Canada. Canadian Institutes of Health Research. Strategy for patient-oriented research (SPOR): Putting patients first; the patient engagement framework, [Online], http://www.cihr-irsc.gc.ca/e/documents/spor_framework-en.pdf.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)