CATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
Governments and policy makers around the world are initiating and implementing open government initiatives. Governments which are signatories to the Open Government Partnership (OGP) commit to making government more inclusive, responsive and accountable (OGP 2018). As a term, open government is now used to describe a wide range of goals and functions, including making government data publicly available, improving the delivery of public services and encouraging public participation in government decision-making (Clarke and Francoli 2014).
As a member of the OGP, Canada has developed an open government policy framework and commitment to impact change. However, to this day, the major focus remains on making government data publicly available, while implementation of other open government initiatives, including public participation commitments lag behind (Clarke and Francoli 2014, 2017; Roy 2016). Other countries, such as the USA, Australia and New Zealand experience similar challenges (Evans and Campos 2013; Price 2017; Stewart 2018).
It is important to understand challenges that governments face in order to engage the public in a meaningful way. However, the analysis of these challenges should be complemented by practical solutions on how governments can foster public participation and inclusion. This panel will explore the future of public participation and inclusion initiatives within an open government agenda, and help to drive government action. Specifically, the panel will discuss trends and developments (or lack of) in advancing opportunities for public participation, and implications for policy-making.
References:
Clarke, Amanda and Mary Francoli. 2017. “Digital Government and Permanent Campaigning” in Permanent Campaigning in Canada edited by Alex Marland, Anna Esselment, and Thierry Giasson. 241–258. Vancouver: UBC Press.
Clarke, Amanda and Mary Francoli. 2014. “What’s in a name? Questioning the homogeneity of ‘open government’ programs across seven countries”, Journal of e-Democracy and Open Government. 6(1): 248-266.
Evans, Angela M. and Adriana Campos. 2013. Open government initiatives: Challenges of citizen participation. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management. 32(1): 172-185.
Open Government Partnership. 2018. “What Is the Open Government Partnership.” Accessed October 13, 2018. http://www.opengovpartnership.org/about
Price, Steven. 2017. “New Zealand End-Of-Term Report 2014–2016”. Accessed October 13, 2018. https://www.opengovpartnership.org/documents/new-zealand-end-of-term-report-2014-2016
Roy, Jeffrey. 2017. “Digital government and service delivery: An examination of performance and prospects”. Canadian Public Administration. 60(4): 538–561.
Stewart, Daniel. 2018. “Australia Mid-Term Report 2016-2018.” Accessed October 13, 2018. https://www.opengovpartnership.org/report/australia-mid-term-report-2016-2018-year-1
CALL FOR PAPERS
As a part of their open government agenda, governments have been emphasizing the need for increased public participation in government decision-making. However, in Canada, the major focus remains on making government data publicly available, while implementation of other open government initiatives, including public participation commitments lag behind (Clarke and Francoli 2014, 2017; Roy 2016).
For 2019, the Government of Canada has declared its priorities for the Open Government Partnership (OGP) Global Summit as participation, inclusion and impact, thus signaling the importance of enhancing public participation in government decision-making. It is important to understand challenges that governments face in order to engage the public in a meaningful way.
This panel calls for papers that address aspects of public participation and inclusion initiatives within an open government agenda. There are no geographical restrictions: we welcome papers that focus on public participation and inclusion initiatives in any country and/or level of government. Research questions can explore (but not limited to):
- How and why governments encourage public participation and inclusion in government decision-making?
- How under-represented citizens can be engaged in government decision-making?
- What role does technology play in fostering public participation and inclusion?
- How and why to measure the impact of public participation initiatives?
- What are the existing challenges that hinder meaningful public participation and inclusion?
- What are the ways of overcoming existing challenges and ensuring meaningful engagement?
- What are the ways to promote public participation on the federal, regional and municipal levels, and globally?
Papers can be theoretical or empirical in nature, and employ quantitative, qualitative or mixed methods. We aim to stimulate the discussion about benefits and challenges of public participation in government decision-making, and ways to advance opportunities for public participation as well as identify implications for policy-making.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In recent years, Chile has implemented legislation on transparency, access to information and citizen participation in public administration. But studies of the real-world effects of these mechanisms on municipal-level democratic governance have been rare or absent. This article sets out a theoretical and methodological toolkit that is then applied to analyze the effects of institutional mechanisms to promote transparency, access to information and citizen participation in intermediate cities in Chiles. The results reveal that, even in cases where levels of compliance are high, the institutional design for local open government can impede and sometimes even prevent the emergence of local democratic governance. Nonetheless, the evidence also suggests that local collaborative initiatives have emerged, improving the interaction between municipal administrations and civil society at local level.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
-
As part of Canada’s Open Government plans, the federal Science-based Departments and Agencies (SBDAs) have committed to promote open science, both internally and through external partnerships. Open science has many dimensions, including making data, methods and publications freely accessible. However, another important aspect of open science is the activities done by government departments and agencies to foster open science practices, further public involvement in government science, and provide access to government science products and scientists.
In order to implement Canada’s current Open Government Action Plan—Canada’s 2018-2020 National Action Plan on Open Government, released on December 17, 2018—the Government of Canada committed to hold public engagement sessions led by Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC). The goal of these sessions is to promote open science and actively solicit feedback from partners, stakeholders, and federal scientists on their needs with respect to federal open data and open science. These sessions will take place across Canada, starting with four public engagements in February and March 2019.
This paper provides a preliminary summary of the findings from these first four public engagement sessions and the insights gained by engaging a diverse range of stakeholders and partners, including representatives from academia, industry, and citizens on variety of topics such as data needs, citizens science, community monitoring, and accessibility of information. The paper then discusses how open science user needs can inform federal open science activities and practices as a contribution to the ongoing development of federal open science policy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Based on the principles of transparency, participation and collaboration, the open government has positioned itself as an emerging paradigm that tries to respond to the exhaustion of the traditional models in the public administration, in a world in which Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) have been increasingly used by public management (Lathrop e Ruma, 2010; Evans e Campos 2013; Clarke e Francoli, 2014, 2017; Roy 2016). Based on such assumptions, as a result of an international debate, in September 2011, the Open Government Partnership (OGP) was created, initially signed by a group of eight founding countries, including Brazil, with the commitment of promoting more inclusive and responsible governments (OGP 2018; Lee e Kwak, 2012). The literature remarks, however, that although governments use technological tools, they have been unable to make use of them to manage and engage citizen participation (Bertot et al., 2010; Dawes, 2009; Dawes e Helbig, 2010; Tapscott, Williams, e Herman, 2008). Therefore, it should be discussed whether the implementation of policies that aim at making a more opened management possible has been incorporated into the Brazilian public agenda in addition to the technological trends. Thus, considering the context of the municipal Brazilian public administration, which by being closer to the citizens represents the primary space for the exercise of participation, the subject of research that will guide the construction of this work shall be: What is the role of Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) in promoting public participation? As a general objective, therefore, it is intended to analyze what local governments have done with regard to the access to public information provided by ICTs and what their possible implications on public participation. The research will have as object of study the context of two Brazilian municipalities, encompassing the executive and legislative branches, as well as entities of organized civil society that operate in the exercise of social control. For its operation, a qualitative approach will be utilized based on the bibliographical and documentary research, interviews and field research notes, contributing to data triangulation. Documentary research will include the analysis of laws, decrees, ordinances, resolutions, institutional websites and folders. Based on a script, thirteen interviews will be carried out with civil servants belonging to the upper and middle step bureaucracy, and also with ten members of three different social movements. The data will be analyzed through content analysis, based on definitions of analytical categories that will serve as a basis for the research findings discussion. Regarding the expected results, it is believed that information and communication technologies favor the monitoring of public management by organized civil society groups. However, municipal governments still lack measures that promote overall public participation, since although there are investments in technological tools, these measures have so far failed to broaden citizen engagement. The proposed study, therefore, fits in the discussions promoted by this panel, since it aims to discuss, in the context of the Brazilian municipalities, whether the opening of public management is going beyond technological modernization, contributing to greater citizen participation.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
As open government is under the spotlight many scholars are trying to assess its achievements and identify what remains to be done in order to allow greater citizen participation and more transparency in government activities. If the latter has been addressed to certain degrees of success, the quest for greater citizen participation in the policy making and implementation processes remains rather left aside (Clarke and Francoli, 2014).
In order to understand the state’s reluctance, or the struggles it faces in trying to better involve the population in policy processes we propose to take a peek at the past in search for answers. The case we want to stretch is that of the United States, and more specifically the relation between the federal state and the people in public policy-making and implementing.
Even though we do not seek to tell the story of more than 200 years of public and private cooperation, we argue that studying the collaboration between citizen associations and the federal state in the 1920s and 1930s is relevant to understand the issue of distribution of power at stake with present day open government. Indeed, studying citizen organizations in the 20s and 30s allows for a redefinition of what we generally assume to be state interventionism.
In fact, the federal government, supported by various citizen groups, developed new ambitions during the Progressive Era that reached their apex with the introduction of Franklin Delano Rooesevelt’s New Deal in 1933. However, most scholars tend to overlook the founding influence of Prohibition as a field experiment for new ways of implementing interventionist federal public policies. Therefore, this paper proposes to examine how the American federal state expanded its capacity by working hand in hand with the people at the local level, and with strong citizen interest groups at the national level in a model of grassroots administration (Selznick, 1949).
Based on a research dissertation and the beginning of the author’s PhD dissertation, this paper offers a different perspective to the contemporary debate on open government. By shedding light on how citizen participation used to operate in an intricate relation with the federal government, we seek to contribute to a better understanding of the precedents that influence decision making regarding the issue of open government. At the heart of this research is a reflection on “who governs” (Dahl, 1961) and who claims the “ownership of public problems” and of their solutions (Gusfield, 1981). This way, this contribution wishes to reinvigorate the debate between Robert Dahl and C. Wright Mills (Mills, 1971) about the distribution of power in the United States by testing its relevance in today’s time.
This paper is the product of a research on the activities of several local citizen groups supporting the implementation of Prohibition between 1920 and 1933 in the state of Rhode Island. This research is now being expanded to other states such as Massachusetts and Illinois in trying to follow the evolution of these groups’ activities following the repeal of the 18thamendment and the launch of the New Deal programs.
We shall begin by discussing the role the citizen did play in the development of big government (Part 1). How this partnership did develop and how it evolved throughout the 20s and 30s is the next point that we will explore. Did the citizen groups remain relevant in the public arena following the repeal of Prohibition? (Part 2) Finally, shall we consider citizen participation only as an instrument for the state to enhance democracy and policy implementation, or an expression of the powerful interest group culture that the state ought to take into account? (Part 3).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since its initiation in 2010-2012, the open government policy in Canada has been focused on three major streams of initiatives: open data, open information and open dialogue. To date, Canada made quite significant progress on open data commitments while the open dialogue stream of initiatives remains a work in progress (Clarke and Francoli 2014, 2017; Roy 2016). This issue is not new for government agencies. Scholars note that government leaders and officials lack an understanding of the need for public engagement in government decision-making, regardless if it is virtual or in person (Clarke 2012; McNutt 2014).
It is, however, interesting to see how the Government of Canada’s approach to the use of social media in “opening up” government has changed over time. In 2010-2012, social media was viewed as a primary vehicle for public engagement and conducting public consultations on public policy. Moreover, the emphasis was on ensuring that government agencies and the public were engaged in two-way interactions on government social media platforms. Now the approach to public engagement has changed significantly. In Canada’s 2018-2020 National Action Plan on Open Government, it is acknowledged that social media is one of the many ways to engage with the public and the Government of Canada is committed to use a variety of in person and online platforms (Treasury Board Secretariat 2018).
This paper explores the connection between open government policies of the Government of Canada and the Ontario Government, and existing government social media practices. It specifically looks into if and how the use of social media by two largest immigration agencies in Canada – Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) and the Ontario Ministry of Citizenship and Immigration (MCI) [1]– has been impacted by the open dialogue stream of open government initiatives. The results discussed in the paper are derived from several qualitative research methods: six semi-structured interviews with public servants, content analysis of IRCC tweets and Facebook posts, and the analysis of IRCC and MCI social media documents. The social media data were collected between September 2015 and August 2016, and the interviews were conducted between March and June 2016.
The findings of this research confirm those from literature. The existing open government policy is not the primary reason for the government use of social media. Both IRCC and MCI noted their interest in social media use stemmed from the desire to reach out audiences and cut down costs of promotional campaigns. Furthermore, government agencies did not see social media being used as a potential engagement tool but rather a customer service tool. This was supported by findings of social media content analysis – with the exception of one consultation on the future of immigration in Canada that was held in July 2016, IRCC did not seek to engage public in policy-making.
[1] Until 2018, MCI was a standalone ministry. It is now merged into the Ministry of Children, Community and Social Services that currently has responsibility for immigration policy in Ontario.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Recent incidences of citizen participation in the South Korean politics and policy making – especially the citizen protest against the former President Park’s regime and deliberative decision making by the panel of 500 citizens concerning the construction of two additional nuclear power plants - have shown that citizens can participate in very deliberative and considerate, self-restraint, and orderly manners as a key actor to decide upon critical political and policy matters. It seems, however, that citizens are still quite divergent in terms of their attitudes toward the feasibility of citizen governance, as it is contrasted with the governance by the bureaucratic technocracy. So to speak, some citizens are more confident, as well as positive upon the feasibility of wider application of citizen governance in policy making, while others are much skeptical of its feasibility and leaning more toward the governance by bureaucratic technocracy. Such divergence on the view of the feasibility of citizen governance seems to have not only theoretical significance but also practical significance in South Korea, as it has created another cleavage in the Korean politics and policy making.
This study investigates what factors affect citizens’ attitude toward the feasibility of citizen governance in policy making, and how these perceptions are shaped among clustered groups of citizens. It will also try to delineate the profiles of the citizens in the clustered groups of citizens in terms of the dimensions affecting the attitude toward citizen governance.
This study uses a national citizen survey that was conducted in July of 2018. A stratified random sampling technique was adopted to cover 16 provinces of South Korea. The sample size of the data is 5,000.
Using a factor analysis, this study will posit two dependent variables – the citizen governance at the instrumental level such as participatory budgeting, and the citizen governance at the goal-setting or agenda-setting level. A possible list of independent variables that affect citizens’ attitude toward citizen governance could include their perceptions on the capability of public officials, the levels of trust upon the government, the perceptions on the capability of citizens governance, the senses of political efficacy, political knowledge, etc.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The growing deployment of tools that allow popular participation through the Internet, in legislative houses, can be conceived as a phenomenon resulting from the political system and, in this sense, as a public policy. Worldwide, several democratic countries, despite the form of state adopted in them, have been promoting and encouraging innovations in direct popular participation, dismissing the traditional parliamentary representation. In the Federative Republic of Brazil, in parallel to the open government initiatives, e-democracy initiatives are under way at the subnational level, and more and more the Legislative Assemblies and the City Councils seek ways to enable the direct participation of citizens in drafting and reformulating laws.
The e-democracy instruments make explicit the systemic, non-governmental agenda within the Legislative Branch. In other words, they address issues of public interest in the formulation of new legislation, the reformulation of old legislation, and the popular control of parliamentary mandates. Also, in a narrower approach, these instruments also allow the identification of the government agenda and, more precisely, the decision agenda. That is, the list of subjects, within the government's agenda, that were sent to the deliberation of the political system in the short and medium term.
E-democracy tools in legislative houses are central if one wishes to increase popular participation, directly impacting the decision-making processes of governments. In this sense, this work seeks to identify, in a comparative way, what are the e-democracy tools that have been adopted by the parliaments of democratic countries and if there is any pattern of diffusion and replication of these initiatives worldwide. In terms of identification, it also aims to propose a taxonomy for these tools, considering their transparency, access to public information and means of social participation in the legislative process.
Whereas Brazil is a founding member of the Open Government Partnership and the 4th National Action Plan in Open Government is in progress, deontologically this research is guided by the Commitment nº 7: "To increase the participation of diverse social segments in the legislative process using integrated efforts that enhance transparency, align language and communication, and promote innovation. " The research methodology involves the tabulation and the interpretation of qualitative and descriptive information available in a fragmented way in each site of the parliaments around the world, with the intentions to map the adoption of e-democracy tools and to identify determinants or clues of their diffusion or transfer between countries.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In Canada, official language obligations are often seen as a barrier to open government. Open government involves improving the quantity and quality of information and data released to the public in a timely manner. However, under the Official Languages Act, any “publications” produced by government need to be translated into both official languages. This slows down the implementation of open government and can make it a costly endeavour. Similarly, the requirement to hold civic engagement exercises -another vital component of open government -in both official languages can be both costly and logistically complicated.
This paper examines this contentious relationship between official languages and open government. It questions whether the two are fundamentally at odds with one another, and explores ways in which they might be seen as complementary. In doing this, the paper draws on two case studies: Canada and Paraguay. The two cases are the only two officially bilingual countries with membership in the Open Government Partnership in the region of the Americas. This study is timely as language has not yet been the subject of much scholarship in the open government space in spite of its clear relationship to the potential for inclusion, impact, and participation.
Two bodies of literature are used to frame the paper: literature looking at language policy, and literature looking at open government. Identifying the motivations and goals of each help to determine an intersection between the two. Documentary research, including a study of legal frameworks outlining language obligations, and documents submitted by Canada and Paraguay to the Open Government Partnership, is conducted to get a sense of the current relationship between language and open government. A series of interviews are conducted in each country to determine how official language obligations are realized in practice, where these obligations might pose challenges to the implementation of open government, where the two might be complementary, and finally, options for facilitating future implementation of both. This includes exploring the risks and benefits of solutions such as machine translation.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since its launch in 2011, the Open Government Partnership (OGP) has transformed into a global movement “working to make government more effective and responsive to its citizens” (OGP Commitments, 2013) even as membership has grown from the original eight to the current 79 governments.
Jetzek, et al. (2012) argued that the social value of a transparency policy, and consequently Open Government Data, is proportional to a government’s ability to contribute to participation, i.e. the more useful the information to the public, the higher the value. As two of the eight founding members of the Open Government Partnership (OGP), the Philippines and Indonesia are committed to developing a National Action Plan towards making government data publicly available, which in turn should transform into concrete actions demonstrating their openness towards greater public participation.
Using the lens of the tyranny of participation (Cooke and Kothari, 2001) and the framework developed by Fung, Graham and Weil, the aim of this study is two-fold. First, it seeks to compare the level of commitment and progress in their respective National Action Plans toward increasing publicly available government data. Secondly, it seeks to explore whether the data has led to greater public participation. Rooted in new public management thought, Fung, Graham, and Weil (2007) laid out what they deemed were important dynamics for a successful transparency policy in what they dubbed as the Transparency Action Cycle. The study will conduct a content analysis of these countries’ open government data and develop indicators measuring the usability of these data.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Corruption is impoverishing the citizens and distorting socio- economic development in Nigeria. As a consequence, there is lack of credibility, weak institutional and policy instruments and under-representation of the citizens in the public policy process. To strengthen these gaps, Federal Government of Nigeria joined the Open Government Partnership (OGP) in July 2016 as the 70th country in the world. The Government aims to tackle Corruption, improve Fiscal and Revenue Transparency, enhance Citizens Access to Information, utilise Technology and Innovation in resolving citizen’s issues; and ensure informed citizens participation in governance process. Although the Open Government Partnership is increasingly accepted among citizens, only seven out of thirty–six (36) sub-national governments in Nigeria have signed on to the partnership. This is attributed to the challenges in the propagation and implementation of open governance initiatives in the country. One of the critical challenges is lack of meaningful engagement of underrepresented citizens in decision making. The paper leans on the theory of Ownership to argue for participation and inclusion of the following critical, but underrepresented citizens and groups in policy governance; People With Disability (PWD), Women, Local Governance Stakeholders, ethnic nationalities, Community Based Organisations /Groups and Faith based Group /individuals for a meaningful engagement that will make Open Government Partnership work in Nigeria. The papers argues that ownership drives coalition building and networking among these citizens’ groups and enhances their confidence and contribution to transparent and accountable policy governance. The engagement must be grassroots and stakeholder oriented to actualise meaningful engagement.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Coyllurqui is a district located in the province of Cotabambas, Apurímac Region in Peru. This district has important social gaps, but insufficient resources to deal with its major problems, as the levels of monetary poverty, reached 71% of its population. In the past, when the municipality of Coyllurqui developed the process of participatory budgeting, recruited generally external consultants who developed workshops to prioritize projects without the participation of key officials of the municipality, and without performing training and capacity building workshops for local leaders of the peasant communities of the district. As a result, as in many municipalities in the Peru, the agreements adopted in the participatory budget were not formalised and included in the institutional budget of the municipality.
In a survey conducted in June of 2015, only 2% of the population of the district considered that their municipality was solving the major problems of the community. In that same survey, citizens indicated that more needed investments in their district were those related to water and sanitation, education, health and transport. However, in that same year, only 30% of the executed budget of the municipality was invested in these sectors.
The main cause of the difference between the interests of the citizens, and the priorities of the local Government was the lack of spaces for dialogue and participation of the population, such as the participatory budget.
The municipality of Coyllurqui with the technical assistance of the Apurimac good Municipal Government project improve the participatory budget process; to promote the collaboration of various sectors of the population, including women and youth, in such a way that identified the most relevant investment projects for the community. Thus, the municipality implemented a multi-year approach to align the vision of development of the community to the necessary investments, and at the same time ensure its continuity before a change of management.
This paper presents the participatory budget process developed by the district municipality of Coyllurqui and the lessons learned from this process.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Brazil is a federalist country, where sovereignty regarding decisions and responsibilities are shared between three spheres of autonomous governments: union, states and municipalities. This allows that, in spite of the constitutional attributions, these entities establish their own agendas and priorities and they can administer themselves.
These federative spheres have different Public Policy Councils, that are joint bodies between state and society, set up at the heart of the public administration in Brazil, in order to produce a more democratic environment for public management. These Councils are the main experiences of participatory democracy in Brazil, and local government is considered the administrative political unit that offers the best conditions for such a practice (Martins et al, 2008).
With regard to the environmental area, in 2017, Environmental Councils were present in 4,130 municipalities of Brazil (74% of the in the total), and they have the responsibility of supervise, deliberate and propose norms to municipal environmental management.
In this paper the concept of environmental management expenditures carried out by the municipal government is a criterion of effectiveness of the popular participation in municipal environmental management. Although imperfect, this indicator establishes a way of measuring whether the existence of Municipal Environmental Councils has concrete effects, supposing that the greater participation of the environmental expenses in the budget of the municipality represents greater importance of environmental subjects in the list of policies supported by the municipality.
The objective of this research is to identify how citizen participation in Brazil, through Municipal Environmental Councils, is related with environmental management expenses and contribute to the greater transfer of financial resources from the states that have legislation on Ecological ICMS (ICMS-E) for the municipalities. The ICMS-E establishes that part of state tax revenues must be transferred to its municipalities according to environmental criteria. Seventeen Brazilian states introduce different environmental criteria in the definition of the distribution to the municipalities of the resources collected as ICMS-E. Municipalities presenting better environmental performance receive more resources, considering parameters such as protected areas for conservation, Indigenous lands, sanitation and solid waste disposal.
Crossing data for municipal public finances (2012-2016) with administration information (2017), it is shown that the existence of Municipal Environmental Councils is positively related to expenses with environmental management and fiscal transfer received through ICMS-E. These effects are higher when the Municipal Environmental Councils have power over financial decisions. These results confirm the hypothesis that citizen participation, via Municipal Environmental Councils, positively affect local environmental policymaking in Brazil.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Studies and decades of experience suggest that the U.S. Citizen Utility Board (CUB) method is a very low-cost, effective means of facilitating hundreds of thousands of citizens banding together their financial resources, energy and social capital to establish broad-based, well-resourced, self-sustaining organizations that serve their needs and interests. One of the needs and interests CUBs have served is increasing the capacity of the CUB members to engagement meaningfully in government decision-making processes.
The CUB method, developed by Ralph Nader in the early 1980s, is generic and can be applied to a wide variety of sectors of society. Governments can enact laws that apply to business sectors (banking, insurance, telecommunications, airlines, energy/electricity, food etc.) and establish a “CUB” (or whatever it is called depending on the sector) as a non-profit corporation. The law requires big businesses in various sectors to hand out, mail out or email out notices to their customers. The notices invite customers to join the CUB for a nominal annual membership fee. Governments can also enact laws that apply to public sectors and institutions, such as taxation, government ethics, health care, and require institutions in those sectors to send a notice to citizens/taxpayers/voters inviting them to join "CUBs" to watch over those public sectors.
A variation on the CUB method, applied to natural resource industry sectors, is to require big businesses in those sectors to pay an extra royalty for resource extraction, with the royalty being transferred to a fund that citizen groups that watch over the sector can apply to for funding.
The CUB is democratically structured, with a board elected by, and from amongst, its members. Because the fundraising method for the CUB is essentially free (because businesses in the sector are distributing the funding/membership appeal for the CUB), even with a relatively low response rate a CUB can be financially viable.
The paper examines the studies and experiences in the U.S. of the CUB method, and then examines the potential of implementing the CUB method in Canada in various business and government sectors as a case study. Some of the existing barriers to participation in Canada will be examined, including of lack of funding, lack of active members, and lack of overall resources for citizen advocacy organizations, and past attempts by Canadian governments to sustain citizen organizations. The potential for the CUB method to remove these systemic barriers in Canada will then be explored.
The lessons and conclusions of this examination of the potential for the CUB method to remove these barriers to participation in government decision-making processes will hopefully provide useful information concerning the potential of implementing the CUB method in other countries and jurisdictions.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Open government has long been regarded as a pareto-efficient policy – after all, who could be against such compelling policy objectives as transparency, accountability, citizen engagement and integrity? Using Kingdon’s Multiple Streams Approach we draw on original empirical research and process tracking, to produce evidence to the contrary, demonstrating that open government policies can be (unintentionally) skewed by bureaucrats, and thereby promote policy interventions that bring about more closed, authoritarian government, rather than open, accountable government originally intended. Contrary to existing research this paper, which uses Kazakhstan as a case study of Central Asia, urges caution in the transfer of the open government agenda to authoritarian regimes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since last local election in 2014, France has seen the number of PB raising from 4 to 110 in 2018. Looking at how these policy transfers in France have been adopted, this paper analyses past and active cases of local PB.
While PB used to be in Brazil a first step towards a much bigger discussion about local assets and source of incomes, comparing french cases of PB shows they are following distinct patterns, showing participation has limited effects to democratic decision-making when budget is at stake.
This paper presents three waves of PB in France for the last 20 years and interviews of former implementers are used in order to explain the challenges the two first waves faced before collapsing (such as lack of procedural clarity and lack of impact).
New cases are unrelated to former cases, because they rely on formal rules that are published. The paper presents a socio-semantic analysis of the cases, comparing the regulations across local authorities, which shows policy learning across cities. Thanks to this method and interviews, it distinguishes 4 procedural families. The use of digital platforms in the third wave could also be explained by the marketization happening in digital and participatory democracy.
The last section of the paper show the limited scope of projects getting eventually funded through participatory budgeting. Most of the winning proposals in PB are related to very traditional policies and capital investments such as sport facilities, community gardens and basic infrastructures whereas submitted proposals are covering broader issues. Only 13% of local authorities provide online explanation why rejected proposals are unfit for the vote. This could mean than informal cherrypicking is still happening, before the vote through a selection of projects that fit the agenda of the executive power.
They are not about raising awareness about finance constraints or making budgets more transparent. The current wave of PB in France fails to foster accountability and appears unlikely to increase citizenry trust or democratize bureaucracy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In recent years, Chile has implemented legislation on transparency, access to information and citizen participation in public administration. But studies of the real-world effects of these mechanisms on municipal-level democratic governance have been rare or absent. This article sets out a theoretical and methodological toolkit that is then applied to analyze the effects of institutional mechanisms to promote transparency, access to information and citizen participation in intermediate cities in Chiles. The results reveal that, even in cases where levels of compliance are high, the institutional design for local open government can impede and sometimes even prevent the emergence of local democratic governance. Nonetheless, the evidence also suggests that local collaborative initiatives have emerged, improving the interaction between municipal administrations and civil society at local level.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
-
As part of Canada’s Open Government plans, the federal Science-based Departments and Agencies (SBDAs) have committed to promote open science, both internally and through external partnerships. Open science has many dimensions, including making data, methods and publications freely accessible. However, another important aspect of open science is the activities done by government departments and agencies to foster open science practices, further public involvement in government science, and provide access to government science products and scientists.
In order to implement Canada’s current Open Government Action Plan—Canada’s 2018-2020 National Action Plan on Open Government, released on December 17, 2018—the Government of Canada committed to hold public engagement sessions led by Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC). The goal of these sessions is to promote open science and actively solicit feedback from partners, stakeholders, and federal scientists on their needs with respect to federal open data and open science. These sessions will take place across Canada, starting with four public engagements in February and March 2019.
This paper provides a preliminary summary of the findings from these first four public engagement sessions and the insights gained by engaging a diverse range of stakeholders and partners, including representatives from academia, industry, and citizens on variety of topics such as data needs, citizens science, community monitoring, and accessibility of information. The paper then discusses how open science user needs can inform federal open science activities and practices as a contribution to the ongoing development of federal open science policy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Based on the principles of transparency, participation and collaboration, the open government has positioned itself as an emerging paradigm that tries to respond to the exhaustion of the traditional models in the public administration, in a world in which Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) have been increasingly used by public management (Lathrop e Ruma, 2010; Evans e Campos 2013; Clarke e Francoli, 2014, 2017; Roy 2016). Based on such assumptions, as a result of an international debate, in September 2011, the Open Government Partnership (OGP) was created, initially signed by a group of eight founding countries, including Brazil, with the commitment of promoting more inclusive and responsible governments (OGP 2018; Lee e Kwak, 2012). The literature remarks, however, that although governments use technological tools, they have been unable to make use of them to manage and engage citizen participation (Bertot et al., 2010; Dawes, 2009; Dawes e Helbig, 2010; Tapscott, Williams, e Herman, 2008). Therefore, it should be discussed whether the implementation of policies that aim at making a more opened management possible has been incorporated into the Brazilian public agenda in addition to the technological trends. Thus, considering the context of the municipal Brazilian public administration, which by being closer to the citizens represents the primary space for the exercise of participation, the subject of research that will guide the construction of this work shall be: What is the role of Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) in promoting public participation? As a general objective, therefore, it is intended to analyze what local governments have done with regard to the access to public information provided by ICTs and what their possible implications on public participation. The research will have as object of study the context of two Brazilian municipalities, encompassing the executive and legislative branches, as well as entities of organized civil society that operate in the exercise of social control. For its operation, a qualitative approach will be utilized based on the bibliographical and documentary research, interviews and field research notes, contributing to data triangulation. Documentary research will include the analysis of laws, decrees, ordinances, resolutions, institutional websites and folders. Based on a script, thirteen interviews will be carried out with civil servants belonging to the upper and middle step bureaucracy, and also with ten members of three different social movements. The data will be analyzed through content analysis, based on definitions of analytical categories that will serve as a basis for the research findings discussion. Regarding the expected results, it is believed that information and communication technologies favor the monitoring of public management by organized civil society groups. However, municipal governments still lack measures that promote overall public participation, since although there are investments in technological tools, these measures have so far failed to broaden citizen engagement. The proposed study, therefore, fits in the discussions promoted by this panel, since it aims to discuss, in the context of the Brazilian municipalities, whether the opening of public management is going beyond technological modernization, contributing to greater citizen participation.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
As open government is under the spotlight many scholars are trying to assess its achievements and identify what remains to be done in order to allow greater citizen participation and more transparency in government activities. If the latter has been addressed to certain degrees of success, the quest for greater citizen participation in the policy making and implementation processes remains rather left aside (Clarke and Francoli, 2014).
In order to understand the state’s reluctance, or the struggles it faces in trying to better involve the population in policy processes we propose to take a peek at the past in search for answers. The case we want to stretch is that of the United States, and more specifically the relation between the federal state and the people in public policy-making and implementing.
Even though we do not seek to tell the story of more than 200 years of public and private cooperation, we argue that studying the collaboration between citizen associations and the federal state in the 1920s and 1930s is relevant to understand the issue of distribution of power at stake with present day open government. Indeed, studying citizen organizations in the 20s and 30s allows for a redefinition of what we generally assume to be state interventionism.
In fact, the federal government, supported by various citizen groups, developed new ambitions during the Progressive Era that reached their apex with the introduction of Franklin Delano Rooesevelt’s New Deal in 1933. However, most scholars tend to overlook the founding influence of Prohibition as a field experiment for new ways of implementing interventionist federal public policies. Therefore, this paper proposes to examine how the American federal state expanded its capacity by working hand in hand with the people at the local level, and with strong citizen interest groups at the national level in a model of grassroots administration (Selznick, 1949).
Based on a research dissertation and the beginning of the author’s PhD dissertation, this paper offers a different perspective to the contemporary debate on open government. By shedding light on how citizen participation used to operate in an intricate relation with the federal government, we seek to contribute to a better understanding of the precedents that influence decision making regarding the issue of open government. At the heart of this research is a reflection on “who governs” (Dahl, 1961) and who claims the “ownership of public problems” and of their solutions (Gusfield, 1981). This way, this contribution wishes to reinvigorate the debate between Robert Dahl and C. Wright Mills (Mills, 1971) about the distribution of power in the United States by testing its relevance in today’s time.
This paper is the product of a research on the activities of several local citizen groups supporting the implementation of Prohibition between 1920 and 1933 in the state of Rhode Island. This research is now being expanded to other states such as Massachusetts and Illinois in trying to follow the evolution of these groups’ activities following the repeal of the 18thamendment and the launch of the New Deal programs.
We shall begin by discussing the role the citizen did play in the development of big government (Part 1). How this partnership did develop and how it evolved throughout the 20s and 30s is the next point that we will explore. Did the citizen groups remain relevant in the public arena following the repeal of Prohibition? (Part 2) Finally, shall we consider citizen participation only as an instrument for the state to enhance democracy and policy implementation, or an expression of the powerful interest group culture that the state ought to take into account? (Part 3).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since its initiation in 2010-2012, the open government policy in Canada has been focused on three major streams of initiatives: open data, open information and open dialogue. To date, Canada made quite significant progress on open data commitments while the open dialogue stream of initiatives remains a work in progress (Clarke and Francoli 2014, 2017; Roy 2016). This issue is not new for government agencies. Scholars note that government leaders and officials lack an understanding of the need for public engagement in government decision-making, regardless if it is virtual or in person (Clarke 2012; McNutt 2014).
It is, however, interesting to see how the Government of Canada’s approach to the use of social media in “opening up” government has changed over time. In 2010-2012, social media was viewed as a primary vehicle for public engagement and conducting public consultations on public policy. Moreover, the emphasis was on ensuring that government agencies and the public were engaged in two-way interactions on government social media platforms. Now the approach to public engagement has changed significantly. In Canada’s 2018-2020 National Action Plan on Open Government, it is acknowledged that social media is one of the many ways to engage with the public and the Government of Canada is committed to use a variety of in person and online platforms (Treasury Board Secretariat 2018).
This paper explores the connection between open government policies of the Government of Canada and the Ontario Government, and existing government social media practices. It specifically looks into if and how the use of social media by two largest immigration agencies in Canada – Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) and the Ontario Ministry of Citizenship and Immigration (MCI) [1]– has been impacted by the open dialogue stream of open government initiatives. The results discussed in the paper are derived from several qualitative research methods: six semi-structured interviews with public servants, content analysis of IRCC tweets and Facebook posts, and the analysis of IRCC and MCI social media documents. The social media data were collected between September 2015 and August 2016, and the interviews were conducted between March and June 2016.
The findings of this research confirm those from literature. The existing open government policy is not the primary reason for the government use of social media. Both IRCC and MCI noted their interest in social media use stemmed from the desire to reach out audiences and cut down costs of promotional campaigns. Furthermore, government agencies did not see social media being used as a potential engagement tool but rather a customer service tool. This was supported by findings of social media content analysis – with the exception of one consultation on the future of immigration in Canada that was held in July 2016, IRCC did not seek to engage public in policy-making.
[1] Until 2018, MCI was a standalone ministry. It is now merged into the Ministry of Children, Community and Social Services that currently has responsibility for immigration policy in Ontario.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Recent incidences of citizen participation in the South Korean politics and policy making – especially the citizen protest against the former President Park’s regime and deliberative decision making by the panel of 500 citizens concerning the construction of two additional nuclear power plants - have shown that citizens can participate in very deliberative and considerate, self-restraint, and orderly manners as a key actor to decide upon critical political and policy matters. It seems, however, that citizens are still quite divergent in terms of their attitudes toward the feasibility of citizen governance, as it is contrasted with the governance by the bureaucratic technocracy. So to speak, some citizens are more confident, as well as positive upon the feasibility of wider application of citizen governance in policy making, while others are much skeptical of its feasibility and leaning more toward the governance by bureaucratic technocracy. Such divergence on the view of the feasibility of citizen governance seems to have not only theoretical significance but also practical significance in South Korea, as it has created another cleavage in the Korean politics and policy making.
This study investigates what factors affect citizens’ attitude toward the feasibility of citizen governance in policy making, and how these perceptions are shaped among clustered groups of citizens. It will also try to delineate the profiles of the citizens in the clustered groups of citizens in terms of the dimensions affecting the attitude toward citizen governance.
This study uses a national citizen survey that was conducted in July of 2018. A stratified random sampling technique was adopted to cover 16 provinces of South Korea. The sample size of the data is 5,000.
Using a factor analysis, this study will posit two dependent variables – the citizen governance at the instrumental level such as participatory budgeting, and the citizen governance at the goal-setting or agenda-setting level. A possible list of independent variables that affect citizens’ attitude toward citizen governance could include their perceptions on the capability of public officials, the levels of trust upon the government, the perceptions on the capability of citizens governance, the senses of political efficacy, political knowledge, etc.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The growing deployment of tools that allow popular participation through the Internet, in legislative houses, can be conceived as a phenomenon resulting from the political system and, in this sense, as a public policy. Worldwide, several democratic countries, despite the form of state adopted in them, have been promoting and encouraging innovations in direct popular participation, dismissing the traditional parliamentary representation. In the Federative Republic of Brazil, in parallel to the open government initiatives, e-democracy initiatives are under way at the subnational level, and more and more the Legislative Assemblies and the City Councils seek ways to enable the direct participation of citizens in drafting and reformulating laws.
The e-democracy instruments make explicit the systemic, non-governmental agenda within the Legislative Branch. In other words, they address issues of public interest in the formulation of new legislation, the reformulation of old legislation, and the popular control of parliamentary mandates. Also, in a narrower approach, these instruments also allow the identification of the government agenda and, more precisely, the decision agenda. That is, the list of subjects, within the government's agenda, that were sent to the deliberation of the political system in the short and medium term.
E-democracy tools in legislative houses are central if one wishes to increase popular participation, directly impacting the decision-making processes of governments. In this sense, this work seeks to identify, in a comparative way, what are the e-democracy tools that have been adopted by the parliaments of democratic countries and if there is any pattern of diffusion and replication of these initiatives worldwide. In terms of identification, it also aims to propose a taxonomy for these tools, considering their transparency, access to public information and means of social participation in the legislative process.
Whereas Brazil is a founding member of the Open Government Partnership and the 4th National Action Plan in Open Government is in progress, deontologically this research is guided by the Commitment nº 7: "To increase the participation of diverse social segments in the legislative process using integrated efforts that enhance transparency, align language and communication, and promote innovation. " The research methodology involves the tabulation and the interpretation of qualitative and descriptive information available in a fragmented way in each site of the parliaments around the world, with the intentions to map the adoption of e-democracy tools and to identify determinants or clues of their diffusion or transfer between countries.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In Canada, official language obligations are often seen as a barrier to open government. Open government involves improving the quantity and quality of information and data released to the public in a timely manner. However, under the Official Languages Act, any “publications” produced by government need to be translated into both official languages. This slows down the implementation of open government and can make it a costly endeavour. Similarly, the requirement to hold civic engagement exercises -another vital component of open government -in both official languages can be both costly and logistically complicated.
This paper examines this contentious relationship between official languages and open government. It questions whether the two are fundamentally at odds with one another, and explores ways in which they might be seen as complementary. In doing this, the paper draws on two case studies: Canada and Paraguay. The two cases are the only two officially bilingual countries with membership in the Open Government Partnership in the region of the Americas. This study is timely as language has not yet been the subject of much scholarship in the open government space in spite of its clear relationship to the potential for inclusion, impact, and participation.
Two bodies of literature are used to frame the paper: literature looking at language policy, and literature looking at open government. Identifying the motivations and goals of each help to determine an intersection between the two. Documentary research, including a study of legal frameworks outlining language obligations, and documents submitted by Canada and Paraguay to the Open Government Partnership, is conducted to get a sense of the current relationship between language and open government. A series of interviews are conducted in each country to determine how official language obligations are realized in practice, where these obligations might pose challenges to the implementation of open government, where the two might be complementary, and finally, options for facilitating future implementation of both. This includes exploring the risks and benefits of solutions such as machine translation.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since its launch in 2011, the Open Government Partnership (OGP) has transformed into a global movement “working to make government more effective and responsive to its citizens” (OGP Commitments, 2013) even as membership has grown from the original eight to the current 79 governments.
Jetzek, et al. (2012) argued that the social value of a transparency policy, and consequently Open Government Data, is proportional to a government’s ability to contribute to participation, i.e. the more useful the information to the public, the higher the value. As two of the eight founding members of the Open Government Partnership (OGP), the Philippines and Indonesia are committed to developing a National Action Plan towards making government data publicly available, which in turn should transform into concrete actions demonstrating their openness towards greater public participation.
Using the lens of the tyranny of participation (Cooke and Kothari, 2001) and the framework developed by Fung, Graham and Weil, the aim of this study is two-fold. First, it seeks to compare the level of commitment and progress in their respective National Action Plans toward increasing publicly available government data. Secondly, it seeks to explore whether the data has led to greater public participation. Rooted in new public management thought, Fung, Graham, and Weil (2007) laid out what they deemed were important dynamics for a successful transparency policy in what they dubbed as the Transparency Action Cycle. The study will conduct a content analysis of these countries’ open government data and develop indicators measuring the usability of these data.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Corruption is impoverishing the citizens and distorting socio- economic development in Nigeria. As a consequence, there is lack of credibility, weak institutional and policy instruments and under-representation of the citizens in the public policy process. To strengthen these gaps, Federal Government of Nigeria joined the Open Government Partnership (OGP) in July 2016 as the 70th country in the world. The Government aims to tackle Corruption, improve Fiscal and Revenue Transparency, enhance Citizens Access to Information, utilise Technology and Innovation in resolving citizen’s issues; and ensure informed citizens participation in governance process. Although the Open Government Partnership is increasingly accepted among citizens, only seven out of thirty–six (36) sub-national governments in Nigeria have signed on to the partnership. This is attributed to the challenges in the propagation and implementation of open governance initiatives in the country. One of the critical challenges is lack of meaningful engagement of underrepresented citizens in decision making. The paper leans on the theory of Ownership to argue for participation and inclusion of the following critical, but underrepresented citizens and groups in policy governance; People With Disability (PWD), Women, Local Governance Stakeholders, ethnic nationalities, Community Based Organisations /Groups and Faith based Group /individuals for a meaningful engagement that will make Open Government Partnership work in Nigeria. The papers argues that ownership drives coalition building and networking among these citizens’ groups and enhances their confidence and contribution to transparent and accountable policy governance. The engagement must be grassroots and stakeholder oriented to actualise meaningful engagement.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Coyllurqui is a district located in the province of Cotabambas, Apurímac Region in Peru. This district has important social gaps, but insufficient resources to deal with its major problems, as the levels of monetary poverty, reached 71% of its population. In the past, when the municipality of Coyllurqui developed the process of participatory budgeting, recruited generally external consultants who developed workshops to prioritize projects without the participation of key officials of the municipality, and without performing training and capacity building workshops for local leaders of the peasant communities of the district. As a result, as in many municipalities in the Peru, the agreements adopted in the participatory budget were not formalised and included in the institutional budget of the municipality.
In a survey conducted in June of 2015, only 2% of the population of the district considered that their municipality was solving the major problems of the community. In that same survey, citizens indicated that more needed investments in their district were those related to water and sanitation, education, health and transport. However, in that same year, only 30% of the executed budget of the municipality was invested in these sectors.
The main cause of the difference between the interests of the citizens, and the priorities of the local Government was the lack of spaces for dialogue and participation of the population, such as the participatory budget.
The municipality of Coyllurqui with the technical assistance of the Apurimac good Municipal Government project improve the participatory budget process; to promote the collaboration of various sectors of the population, including women and youth, in such a way that identified the most relevant investment projects for the community. Thus, the municipality implemented a multi-year approach to align the vision of development of the community to the necessary investments, and at the same time ensure its continuity before a change of management.
This paper presents the participatory budget process developed by the district municipality of Coyllurqui and the lessons learned from this process.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Brazil is a federalist country, where sovereignty regarding decisions and responsibilities are shared between three spheres of autonomous governments: union, states and municipalities. This allows that, in spite of the constitutional attributions, these entities establish their own agendas and priorities and they can administer themselves.
These federative spheres have different Public Policy Councils, that are joint bodies between state and society, set up at the heart of the public administration in Brazil, in order to produce a more democratic environment for public management. These Councils are the main experiences of participatory democracy in Brazil, and local government is considered the administrative political unit that offers the best conditions for such a practice (Martins et al, 2008).
With regard to the environmental area, in 2017, Environmental Councils were present in 4,130 municipalities of Brazil (74% of the in the total), and they have the responsibility of supervise, deliberate and propose norms to municipal environmental management.
In this paper the concept of environmental management expenditures carried out by the municipal government is a criterion of effectiveness of the popular participation in municipal environmental management. Although imperfect, this indicator establishes a way of measuring whether the existence of Municipal Environmental Councils has concrete effects, supposing that the greater participation of the environmental expenses in the budget of the municipality represents greater importance of environmental subjects in the list of policies supported by the municipality.
The objective of this research is to identify how citizen participation in Brazil, through Municipal Environmental Councils, is related with environmental management expenses and contribute to the greater transfer of financial resources from the states that have legislation on Ecological ICMS (ICMS-E) for the municipalities. The ICMS-E establishes that part of state tax revenues must be transferred to its municipalities according to environmental criteria. Seventeen Brazilian states introduce different environmental criteria in the definition of the distribution to the municipalities of the resources collected as ICMS-E. Municipalities presenting better environmental performance receive more resources, considering parameters such as protected areas for conservation, Indigenous lands, sanitation and solid waste disposal.
Crossing data for municipal public finances (2012-2016) with administration information (2017), it is shown that the existence of Municipal Environmental Councils is positively related to expenses with environmental management and fiscal transfer received through ICMS-E. These effects are higher when the Municipal Environmental Councils have power over financial decisions. These results confirm the hypothesis that citizen participation, via Municipal Environmental Councils, positively affect local environmental policymaking in Brazil.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Studies and decades of experience suggest that the U.S. Citizen Utility Board (CUB) method is a very low-cost, effective means of facilitating hundreds of thousands of citizens banding together their financial resources, energy and social capital to establish broad-based, well-resourced, self-sustaining organizations that serve their needs and interests. One of the needs and interests CUBs have served is increasing the capacity of the CUB members to engagement meaningfully in government decision-making processes.
The CUB method, developed by Ralph Nader in the early 1980s, is generic and can be applied to a wide variety of sectors of society. Governments can enact laws that apply to business sectors (banking, insurance, telecommunications, airlines, energy/electricity, food etc.) and establish a “CUB” (or whatever it is called depending on the sector) as a non-profit corporation. The law requires big businesses in various sectors to hand out, mail out or email out notices to their customers. The notices invite customers to join the CUB for a nominal annual membership fee. Governments can also enact laws that apply to public sectors and institutions, such as taxation, government ethics, health care, and require institutions in those sectors to send a notice to citizens/taxpayers/voters inviting them to join "CUBs" to watch over those public sectors.
A variation on the CUB method, applied to natural resource industry sectors, is to require big businesses in those sectors to pay an extra royalty for resource extraction, with the royalty being transferred to a fund that citizen groups that watch over the sector can apply to for funding.
The CUB is democratically structured, with a board elected by, and from amongst, its members. Because the fundraising method for the CUB is essentially free (because businesses in the sector are distributing the funding/membership appeal for the CUB), even with a relatively low response rate a CUB can be financially viable.
The paper examines the studies and experiences in the U.S. of the CUB method, and then examines the potential of implementing the CUB method in Canada in various business and government sectors as a case study. Some of the existing barriers to participation in Canada will be examined, including of lack of funding, lack of active members, and lack of overall resources for citizen advocacy organizations, and past attempts by Canadian governments to sustain citizen organizations. The potential for the CUB method to remove these systemic barriers in Canada will then be explored.
The lessons and conclusions of this examination of the potential for the CUB method to remove these barriers to participation in government decision-making processes will hopefully provide useful information concerning the potential of implementing the CUB method in other countries and jurisdictions.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Open government has long been regarded as a pareto-efficient policy – after all, who could be against such compelling policy objectives as transparency, accountability, citizen engagement and integrity? Using Kingdon’s Multiple Streams Approach we draw on original empirical research and process tracking, to produce evidence to the contrary, demonstrating that open government policies can be (unintentionally) skewed by bureaucrats, and thereby promote policy interventions that bring about more closed, authoritarian government, rather than open, accountable government originally intended. Contrary to existing research this paper, which uses Kazakhstan as a case study of Central Asia, urges caution in the transfer of the open government agenda to authoritarian regimes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since last local election in 2014, France has seen the number of PB raising from 4 to 110 in 2018. Looking at how these policy transfers in France have been adopted, this paper analyses past and active cases of local PB.
While PB used to be in Brazil a first step towards a much bigger discussion about local assets and source of incomes, comparing french cases of PB shows they are following distinct patterns, showing participation has limited effects to democratic decision-making when budget is at stake.
This paper presents three waves of PB in France for the last 20 years and interviews of former implementers are used in order to explain the challenges the two first waves faced before collapsing (such as lack of procedural clarity and lack of impact).
New cases are unrelated to former cases, because they rely on formal rules that are published. The paper presents a socio-semantic analysis of the cases, comparing the regulations across local authorities, which shows policy learning across cities. Thanks to this method and interviews, it distinguishes 4 procedural families. The use of digital platforms in the third wave could also be explained by the marketization happening in digital and participatory democracy.
The last section of the paper show the limited scope of projects getting eventually funded through participatory budgeting. Most of the winning proposals in PB are related to very traditional policies and capital investments such as sport facilities, community gardens and basic infrastructures whereas submitted proposals are covering broader issues. Only 13% of local authorities provide online explanation why rejected proposals are unfit for the vote. This could mean than informal cherrypicking is still happening, before the vote through a selection of projects that fit the agenda of the executive power.
They are not about raising awareness about finance constraints or making budgets more transparent. The current wave of PB in France fails to foster accountability and appears unlikely to increase citizenry trust or democratize bureaucracy.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)