P17. Hy-Policies: Policy Transfer, Policy Learning and Hybridization of Policies in different Institutional Contexts.
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICYCATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
The objective of this panel is to analyze in comparative perspective the processes of policy transfer in different institutional contexts. Our main questions are 1) What are the influence of micro and meso political factors at the decisional stage of the policy transfer process? 2) What domestic factors are involved on the adaptation of policies at the implementation stage? And 3) How and in which cases, the characteristics of the policy transfer process affects its results, generating policy learning, hybridization or innovation. This panel will contribute to the comparative research on public policies in an area of growing interest and complexity, paying special attention to the constraints offered by different political and institutional contexts to its characteristics and outcomes.
CALL FOR PAPERS
This panel focuses on policy transfer studies, defining policy transfer as "the process by which a political system integrates policies that have previously been used in another political system" Dolowitz (2017). Our interest is to analyze how knowledge is used in the policy making process, how new ideas and policies are "translated" on their way from one system to another during the implementation stage, and what evidence can be provided about the reasons for success or failure of this translations. We are particularly interested in analyzing the influence of governance, micro politics and institutional factors that influence hybridization, adaptation and mutation of policies, generating different processes of policy learning, innovation or "indigenization of policies" (Stone, 2012). We welcome papers based on theoretical or empirical qualitative and / or quantitative methodologies for the analysis of policy transfer in different institutional contexts.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Corruption, because of the deleterious effects on countries' economy and development, is always in the sights of international agencies and donors from developing countries. There are different anti-corruption models in the Global South: anti-corruption laws without the strengthening of any agency (Japan); anti-corruption laws with the reinforcement of multiple agencies (India, Philippines, Taiwan); anti-corruption laws with the reinforcement of a single agency (Hong Kong, Singapore, Thailand, South Korea, Mongolia) (QUAH, 2011). An institutional novelty little investigated as a mechanism to combat corruption are specialized courts (Baum, 2009, 2014). Specialized courts are created for the same reasons as anti-corruption agencies: instilling cases of corruption in existing corrupt systems, and building expertise to deal with complex cases in countries like Senegal (1981), the Philippines (1984), Pakistan (1999), Uganda, India and Malaysia, and the most well-known case in Asia, which is Indonesia (Butt, Schutte, 2014). In Latin America, Brazil stands out as having created specialized anti-corruption policies with effects not only in the criminal justice system but mainly in the political and electoral system. The objective of this work is to investigate the similarities and differences between the formulation and the transfer of public anti-corruption policies of the two main institutional models in operation: agencies and specialized courts. Based on the Qualitative Comparative Analysis method, we investigate the different trajectories and recent national contexts (level of corruption, political regime); the influences of international actors (adherence to international bodies, recommendations and rules by countries); the type of criminal justice system (accusatory or inquisitorial); role of actors and judicial institutions in the formulation of this public policy (if of protagonism, participation or resistance); and the characteristics and functioning of these institutions from the point of view of bureaucratic structure and autonomy. After comparing cases of judicial specialization (Indonesia, Philippines, Pakistan, Uganda, India, Malaysia, Senegal and Brazil), it will be possible to analyze in a comparative perspective the processes of transfer of anti-corruption policies in different institutional contexts.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since the return to electoral democracy in 1990, the Chilean Foreign Ministry has emphasized the importance of strengthening international institutions. Consequently, Chile participates in multiple supranational organizations and has sought to strengthen its voice in the United Nations. As a result, Chile has assumed important commitments while also maintaining a certain degree of freedom based on its technical expertise and policy success with respect to the Millennium Development Goals.
The present paper analyzes the mainstreaming process of two policy goals through collaboration con the FAO and PNUD: 1) “Strengthening the Adaptive Capacity to Climate Change in the Fisheries and Aquaculture Sector” and 2) National capacity-building for intercultural conflict prevention and management in Chile. Based in analysis of official documents and semi-structure interviews with the civil servants, we compare and contrast the policy integration narrative promoted by the Indigenous Affairs Unit of the Ministry of Social Development with the interpretation/adaptation of this narrative within each Ministry, visibilizing the learning process as well as the obstacles and advances.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the last three decades, environments and ways of implementing public policies have been changed, as a consequence of the idea of the New Public Management (NPM), which introduced market principles and efficiency in the provision of public services. Government actors and private actors, both for profit and non-profit, started to collaborate in the implementation of policies, which gave rise to hybrid public policies. The concept of these is not clearly demarcated in the literature, but for the purpose of this work, it was considered hybrid public policies that are formulated by public actors and implemented by private for profit and non-profit actors, which have different institutional logics, but shared goals. Denis, Ferlie and Gestel (2015) emphasized that hybridization in public services is a trend and therefore should be further explored. Thomann, Hupe, and Sager (2017) emphasized that little known about private actors in the implementation of public policy because the hybrid policy literature neglects individuals and studies of street level bureaucrats do not consider hybridization. In view of the lack of studies of this nature, the present work intends to analyze and compare the implementation of a hybrid educational policy, called the Student Financing Fund (FIES), through which the Brazilian Federal Government finances higher education for students with income limitations and are enrolled in private for profit and non-profit institutions. It should be noted that, in principle, this program was established in 1976 as an educational credit program and in 1999 it was remodeled and renamed FIES. This was elaborated by the Ministry of Education (MEC), created through Provisional Measure No. 1827/99 and made official by Law 10.260 / 2001. Based on the foregoing, we will answer the following research question: How does the implementation of FIES occur in private profit and non-profit institutions of higher education (IES)? If there are differences, what can they entail? This empirical qualitative study will be implemented in two stages: (i) analysis of FIES legislation and (ii) analysis of the FIES implementation process in two private IES, one for profit and another for non-profit. To do so, it will use documentary research and primary data collection from semi-structured interviews with the managers responsible for FIES in the analyzed institutions. The data collected will be considered through the technique of content analysis. This proposal of work is related to questions 2 and 3 of this panel, because it will seek to identify the influence of factors that are present in the different institutional contexts in which a hybrid public policy is being implemented. It is hoped that the findings found may contribute to the learning process regarding hybrid policies and that evidence can be provided in reasons of the success or failure of the policy analyzed in relation to the different contexts.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Local democracy in Spain turns 40 years old. During these four decades of validity of the municipal model that was born in 1979, local governments have been pioneers in the implementation of various policies on good governance, transparency and the fight against corruption. In addition, municipal democracy has made local governments the main source of supply for the central government and emerging governments in the regions of its political elites.
The paper assumes that in Spain there is a transfer of policies from the local level to the regional and national levels. For this, the paper focuses on analyzing the case of participation policy in Barcelona and the local governments of its metropolitan area, proposing how the generalization of municipal departments of citizen participation later reaches the regional government that copies the model when the political elites Municipalities occupy positions of responsibility in the Catalan Government.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
I. Background
Taiwan has experienced a series of dramatic educational reforms since the 1990s. One of the appeals is "to promote the modernization of education", and the main approach is to lean from the west. In respect of curriculum, an important reform is the constructivist mathematics learning from the United States. That is, to abandon the traditional "solving mathematical problem through mechanically memorizing formula," to teach instruments and to emphasize the significance of constructing the meaning and understanding of mathematics by students themselves. Constructivist mathematics has been implemented at the primary education level since 1996; however, the policy has been regarded as failed in 2003 for the first policy generation students were found to have significant degenerated achievement in math when entering to junior high schools.
I. The puzzle and research purpose
Educational administrators, academia and practitioners have discussed the causes of policy failures. Some believe it is a policy implementation issue, and some believe it results from being inconsistent with the context (Yu & Han, 2009, Chiu & Whitebread, 2011). With regard to policy transfer, there are other questions that are worth to be addressed: 1. According to the result of the international competitions (i.e., PISA, TIMSS), the U.S. students’ mathematics learning achievements are actually not as good as Taiwan, then why do Taiwanese government still need to draw lessons from the U.S.? 2. The effectiveness of constructivist mathematics in the U.S. has not yet been confirmed, is it still suitable for transfer? 3. Whether the invalidation of the U.S. policy in the context of Taiwan is probably due to mislearning or mistranslation (Stone, 2012)? This paper aims to explore relative issues: Why and how the Taiwanese government transferred constructivist mathematics from the U.S., and the focus of research will be on policy planning rather than policy implementation.
II. Research method
This research will conduct the document analysis and interviews to collect research data. Firstly, I will widely collect and analyze policy documents related to constructivist mathematics in the U.S. and Taiwan to understand the policy planning and interpretation of the two countries. Then I will investigate the reasons, methods and contents of policy transfer through interviewing the Taiwanese officials of the Ministry of Education and reformers who were responsible for the policy planning of constructivist mathematics.
III. The significance of this research
This study explores a valuable topic of policy transfer: When are the outcomes of the target policy evident to be less or uncertain effective than existing policies, then why and how to conduct policy learning? In other words, is learning from the west a sort of “superstitious learning” (March & Olsen, 1976)? Although there have been many discussions on constructivist mathematics, most focus on the issue of policy implementation. This paper concentrates to address the policy planning perspective, which helps to supplement existing viewpoints and literature.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Nordic countries are among the main destinations for immigrants in the world because of their traditionally generous policies. They are also some of the most integrated and similar countries. Yet, in the 1970s when they became confronted with the “multicultural question”, they made different choices. This paper argues that the presence or absence of sizeable immigration size was the main factor of explanation. It explains why Sweden adopted multiculturalism while Finland and Iceland did not. However, this factor was sufficient and not necessary. The formulation of multicultural policy provisions (MCPs) in Norway despite a small and late labour immigration was the result of diffusion from Sweden. In Denmark, the absence of sizeable immigration combined with the presence of a nationally-oriented policy legacy to further deny such outcome. There was an upward albeit slow convergence towards multiculturalism over time that materialized when Finland joined Sweden and Norway in the 1990s. Yet the degree of convergence (policy content) did not narrow. Groupings of multiculturalist and assimilationist countries persisted until the purported civic turn and multiculturalism retreat in the mid-2000s.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Corruption, because of the deleterious effects on countries' economy and development, is always in the sights of international agencies and donors from developing countries. There are different anti-corruption models in the Global South: anti-corruption laws without the strengthening of any agency (Japan); anti-corruption laws with the reinforcement of multiple agencies (India, Philippines, Taiwan); anti-corruption laws with the reinforcement of a single agency (Hong Kong, Singapore, Thailand, South Korea, Mongolia) (QUAH, 2011). An institutional novelty little investigated as a mechanism to combat corruption are specialized courts (Baum, 2009, 2014). Specialized courts are created for the same reasons as anti-corruption agencies: instilling cases of corruption in existing corrupt systems, and building expertise to deal with complex cases in countries like Senegal (1981), the Philippines (1984), Pakistan (1999), Uganda, India and Malaysia, and the most well-known case in Asia, which is Indonesia (Butt, Schutte, 2014). In Latin America, Brazil stands out as having created specialized anti-corruption policies with effects not only in the criminal justice system but mainly in the political and electoral system. The objective of this work is to investigate the similarities and differences between the formulation and the transfer of public anti-corruption policies of the two main institutional models in operation: agencies and specialized courts. Based on the Qualitative Comparative Analysis method, we investigate the different trajectories and recent national contexts (level of corruption, political regime); the influences of international actors (adherence to international bodies, recommendations and rules by countries); the type of criminal justice system (accusatory or inquisitorial); role of actors and judicial institutions in the formulation of this public policy (if of protagonism, participation or resistance); and the characteristics and functioning of these institutions from the point of view of bureaucratic structure and autonomy. After comparing cases of judicial specialization (Indonesia, Philippines, Pakistan, Uganda, India, Malaysia, Senegal and Brazil), it will be possible to analyze in a comparative perspective the processes of transfer of anti-corruption policies in different institutional contexts.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since the return to electoral democracy in 1990, the Chilean Foreign Ministry has emphasized the importance of strengthening international institutions. Consequently, Chile participates in multiple supranational organizations and has sought to strengthen its voice in the United Nations. As a result, Chile has assumed important commitments while also maintaining a certain degree of freedom based on its technical expertise and policy success with respect to the Millennium Development Goals.
The present paper analyzes the mainstreaming process of two policy goals through collaboration con the FAO and PNUD: 1) “Strengthening the Adaptive Capacity to Climate Change in the Fisheries and Aquaculture Sector” and 2) National capacity-building for intercultural conflict prevention and management in Chile. Based in analysis of official documents and semi-structure interviews with the civil servants, we compare and contrast the policy integration narrative promoted by the Indigenous Affairs Unit of the Ministry of Social Development with the interpretation/adaptation of this narrative within each Ministry, visibilizing the learning process as well as the obstacles and advances.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the last three decades, environments and ways of implementing public policies have been changed, as a consequence of the idea of the New Public Management (NPM), which introduced market principles and efficiency in the provision of public services. Government actors and private actors, both for profit and non-profit, started to collaborate in the implementation of policies, which gave rise to hybrid public policies. The concept of these is not clearly demarcated in the literature, but for the purpose of this work, it was considered hybrid public policies that are formulated by public actors and implemented by private for profit and non-profit actors, which have different institutional logics, but shared goals. Denis, Ferlie and Gestel (2015) emphasized that hybridization in public services is a trend and therefore should be further explored. Thomann, Hupe, and Sager (2017) emphasized that little known about private actors in the implementation of public policy because the hybrid policy literature neglects individuals and studies of street level bureaucrats do not consider hybridization. In view of the lack of studies of this nature, the present work intends to analyze and compare the implementation of a hybrid educational policy, called the Student Financing Fund (FIES), through which the Brazilian Federal Government finances higher education for students with income limitations and are enrolled in private for profit and non-profit institutions. It should be noted that, in principle, this program was established in 1976 as an educational credit program and in 1999 it was remodeled and renamed FIES. This was elaborated by the Ministry of Education (MEC), created through Provisional Measure No. 1827/99 and made official by Law 10.260 / 2001. Based on the foregoing, we will answer the following research question: How does the implementation of FIES occur in private profit and non-profit institutions of higher education (IES)? If there are differences, what can they entail? This empirical qualitative study will be implemented in two stages: (i) analysis of FIES legislation and (ii) analysis of the FIES implementation process in two private IES, one for profit and another for non-profit. To do so, it will use documentary research and primary data collection from semi-structured interviews with the managers responsible for FIES in the analyzed institutions. The data collected will be considered through the technique of content analysis. This proposal of work is related to questions 2 and 3 of this panel, because it will seek to identify the influence of factors that are present in the different institutional contexts in which a hybrid public policy is being implemented. It is hoped that the findings found may contribute to the learning process regarding hybrid policies and that evidence can be provided in reasons of the success or failure of the policy analyzed in relation to the different contexts.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Local democracy in Spain turns 40 years old. During these four decades of validity of the municipal model that was born in 1979, local governments have been pioneers in the implementation of various policies on good governance, transparency and the fight against corruption. In addition, municipal democracy has made local governments the main source of supply for the central government and emerging governments in the regions of its political elites.
The paper assumes that in Spain there is a transfer of policies from the local level to the regional and national levels. For this, the paper focuses on analyzing the case of participation policy in Barcelona and the local governments of its metropolitan area, proposing how the generalization of municipal departments of citizen participation later reaches the regional government that copies the model when the political elites Municipalities occupy positions of responsibility in the Catalan Government.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
I. Background
Taiwan has experienced a series of dramatic educational reforms since the 1990s. One of the appeals is "to promote the modernization of education", and the main approach is to lean from the west. In respect of curriculum, an important reform is the constructivist mathematics learning from the United States. That is, to abandon the traditional "solving mathematical problem through mechanically memorizing formula," to teach instruments and to emphasize the significance of constructing the meaning and understanding of mathematics by students themselves. Constructivist mathematics has been implemented at the primary education level since 1996; however, the policy has been regarded as failed in 2003 for the first policy generation students were found to have significant degenerated achievement in math when entering to junior high schools.
I. The puzzle and research purpose
Educational administrators, academia and practitioners have discussed the causes of policy failures. Some believe it is a policy implementation issue, and some believe it results from being inconsistent with the context (Yu & Han, 2009, Chiu & Whitebread, 2011). With regard to policy transfer, there are other questions that are worth to be addressed: 1. According to the result of the international competitions (i.e., PISA, TIMSS), the U.S. students’ mathematics learning achievements are actually not as good as Taiwan, then why do Taiwanese government still need to draw lessons from the U.S.? 2. The effectiveness of constructivist mathematics in the U.S. has not yet been confirmed, is it still suitable for transfer? 3. Whether the invalidation of the U.S. policy in the context of Taiwan is probably due to mislearning or mistranslation (Stone, 2012)? This paper aims to explore relative issues: Why and how the Taiwanese government transferred constructivist mathematics from the U.S., and the focus of research will be on policy planning rather than policy implementation.
II. Research method
This research will conduct the document analysis and interviews to collect research data. Firstly, I will widely collect and analyze policy documents related to constructivist mathematics in the U.S. and Taiwan to understand the policy planning and interpretation of the two countries. Then I will investigate the reasons, methods and contents of policy transfer through interviewing the Taiwanese officials of the Ministry of Education and reformers who were responsible for the policy planning of constructivist mathematics.
III. The significance of this research
This study explores a valuable topic of policy transfer: When are the outcomes of the target policy evident to be less or uncertain effective than existing policies, then why and how to conduct policy learning? In other words, is learning from the west a sort of “superstitious learning” (March & Olsen, 1976)? Although there have been many discussions on constructivist mathematics, most focus on the issue of policy implementation. This paper concentrates to address the policy planning perspective, which helps to supplement existing viewpoints and literature.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Nordic countries are among the main destinations for immigrants in the world because of their traditionally generous policies. They are also some of the most integrated and similar countries. Yet, in the 1970s when they became confronted with the “multicultural question”, they made different choices. This paper argues that the presence or absence of sizeable immigration size was the main factor of explanation. It explains why Sweden adopted multiculturalism while Finland and Iceland did not. However, this factor was sufficient and not necessary. The formulation of multicultural policy provisions (MCPs) in Norway despite a small and late labour immigration was the result of diffusion from Sweden. In Denmark, the absence of sizeable immigration combined with the presence of a nationally-oriented policy legacy to further deny such outcome. There was an upward albeit slow convergence towards multiculturalism over time that materialized when Finland joined Sweden and Norway in the 1990s. Yet the degree of convergence (policy content) did not narrow. Groupings of multiculturalist and assimilationist countries persisted until the purported civic turn and multiculturalism retreat in the mid-2000s.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)