Format

P04. Agency Policymaking: Dynamics and Contributions to National Public Policies

POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Ebinezer Florano
University of the Philippines Diliman
Main chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Much of the discussions, literature, and studies on public policymaking focus on the role of legislative bodies and policy implementation in the executive branch of the government. More often than not, the role of public agencies or the bureaucracy in public policymaking is glossed over. Yet, the scant literature about them points out their importance in the formulation of public policies. As policy implementors, and the ones involved in the monitoring and evaluation of the relevant programs or projects, the bureaucracy is in the position to speak clearly about the need to correct the implementation of the existing public policies, amend/modify or altogether, terminate them. A handful of studies have already raised issues about agencification (Bach, Niklasson and Painter, 2012), policy autonomy or independence from politicians (Berry and Gersen, 2017; Selin, 2015; Rose-Ackerman and Perroud, 2013; Bach, Niklasson and Painter, 2012), judicial/statutory interpretation or adjudication (Phillips, 2021; Stack, 2009; De Mesquita and Stephenson, 2007; Koch, 2005; Magillt, 2004), delegation to the bureaucracy of the regulatory policymaking function of the legislature (Wiseman, 2009; De Mesquita and Stephenson, 2007), public participation or mass public engagement (Judge-Lord, 2021; Mendelson, 2007), legislative oversight (Clinton et al., 2014; Feinstein, 2017), executive turnover’s influence on policy implementation (Bertelli and Lewis, 2013), multiple agency policymaking (Bils, 2020), etc. In spite of these, there is still a need to conduct more studies on the dynamics of internal policymaking in government bureaucracies and their contributions to (national) public policymaking. For this purpose, the following questions have to be satisfactorily answered: What is the role of agencies in public policymaking? What factors affect their participation in public policymaking? Are there areas for autonomous public policymaking reserved for agencies? Do they produce better policies that lead to effective public service? What factors could this be attributed to? What is the state of internal policymaking in agencies? Or, how well-developed is the internal policymaking in agencies? What are the dynamics involved?

 

References

 

Bach, T., Niklasson, B. and Painter, M. (2012) The role of agencies in policy-making. Policy and Society. [online]. 31 (3), Policy and Society Associates Ltd Partnership, pp.183–193. Available from: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.polsoc.2012.07.001.

 

Berry, C.R. and Gersen, J.E. (2017) Agency design and political control. The Yale Law Journal. [online]. 126 (4), pp.1002–1049. Available from: https://www.jstor.org/stable/44863339.

 

Bertelli, A.M. and Lewis, D.E. (2013) Policy influence, agency-specific expertise, and exit in the federal service. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory. [online]. 23 (2), pp.223–245. Available from: https://www.jstor.org/stable/24484815.

 

Bils, P. (2020) Policymaking with multiple agencies. American Journal of Political Science. [online]. 64 (3), pp.634–648. Available from: https://www.jstor.org/stable/45295338.

 

Clinton, J.D., Lewis, D.E. and Selin, J.L. (2014) Influencing the bureaucracy: The irony of congressional oversight. American Journal of Political Science. [online].  58 (2), pp.387–401. Available from: https://www.jstor.org/stable/24363492.

 

Feinstein, B.D. (2017) Designing executive agencies for congressional influence. Administrative Law Review. [online].  Spring (2), pp.259–289. Available from: https://www.jstor.org/stable/44648616.

 

Judge-Lord, D. (2021) Public pressure campaigns and bureaucratic policymaking The University of Wisconsin-Madison. Koch, C.H. (2005) Policymaking by the administrative judiciary. Faculty Publications. [online]. 1278. Available from: https://scholarship.law.wm.edu/facpubs/1278.

 

Magillt, M.E. (2004) Agency choice of policymaking form. The University of Chicago Law Review. [online]. 71 (4), pp.1383–1447. Available from: https://www.jstor.org/stable/1600528.

 

Mendelson, N.A. (2007) Regulatory beneficiaries and informal agency policymaking. Cornell Law Review. [online]. 397, pp.397–452. Available from: http://scholarship.law.cornell.edu/clr/vol92/iss3/1. 

 

(Note: Not all references could not be included due to space limitations.)

 

Format of the panel: Hybrid (onsite & online)

CALL FOR PAPERS

Agency Policymaking: Dynamics and Contributions to National Public Policies

 

The panel is calling for theoretical and empirical papers that tackle the nature of agency policymaking, the dynamics of agency internal policy development, and their contributions to the formulation of (national) public policies. The papers should be able to answer one or more of the following questions:

 

1. What is the role of agencies in public policymaking?

 

2. What factors affect their participation in public policymaking?

 

3. Are there areas for autonomous public policymaking reserved for agencies?

 

4. Do agencies produce better policies that lead to effective public service? What factors could this be attributed to?

 

5. What is the state of internal policymaking in agencies? Or, how well-developed is the internal policymaking in agencies? What are the dynamics involved?

 

“Agency” as utilized in this call, generally refers to executive government agencies at the national level, e.g., ministry/department, bureau, etc.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - The Agenda Setting Power of the COMESA Competition Commission in COMESA Member State Competition Policy Legislative Process
Vellah Kedogo Kigwiru (Technical University of Munich)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

While the role of international organizations (IOs) in the rulemaking process at the international level has received considerable scholarly attention, how and when IOs seek to shape national legislative processes has received little attention. This paper explores the strategies IOs can use to shape legislative outcomes in specific policy areas at the Member State level. And because IOs cannot directly shape national legislative outcomes, I argue that they can do so through agenda-setting power, defined as the IO's ability to influence policymakers to consider and pay attention to an issue. Empirically,  I adopt process tracing, qualitative document analysis, and elite interviews, tracing the role of IO in the pre-legislative processes at the national level. I use the COMESA Competition Commission (CCC) as a case study. CCC is a regional competition institution established by COMESA. COMESA is made up of 21 Member States. Article 17(2, c) of the Competition Regulations (CCR) requires CCC to promote national competition laws that increase the uniformity in the interpretation and application of CCR in COMESA. So far, Kenya, Eswatini, and Uganda have adopted legislation recognizing the application of CCR in their domestic markets. Zambia and Malawi have initiated legislative processes to include competition provisions in their competition laws recognizing CCR. However, despite being a fascinating and informative object of study, no scholarly work has paid any theoretical or empirical attention to how CCC has sought to influence national-level legislative outcomes through national bureaucrats. I interviewed a number of national competition agencies to explore their role in adopting competition policy legislation that grants CCR applicability in domestic legal systems. Secondly, the role of CCC in the pre-legislative process.   Preliminary findings show that CCC has adopted agenda-setting strategies to build its credibility and gain attention among actors with formal, gatekeeping, and leadership agenda-setting power at the national level. In tandem with the agenda-setting literature, CCC has established institutional venues such as courtesy calls, training, and technical assistance to incentivize Member States and institutions to adopt legislations that recognize the application of CCR. Consequently, some COMESA countries have initiated legislative processes to grant CCR applicability in their domestic legal system. This study, therefore, shows how IOs can, through agenda-setting power, gain the attention of bureaucrats at the Member State level to consider legislative outcomes that grant enhance the application and interpretation of international rules.  

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - “A seminal study of the President’s Executive Orders against that of Congress’ Republic Acts”
Eufracio Primer Pagunuran (University of the Philippines - Center for Integrative and Development Studies)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

“A seminal study of the President’s Executive Orders against that of Congress’ Republic Acts”

 

Abstract: In so far as public policies are concerned, there are two competing branches of government in a tug of war. Despite the establishment of a Legislative-Executive Development Advisory Council as “a venue to facilitate high level policy discussions on vital issues and concerns affecting national development”, the council hardly convenes to deliberate shared or common development agenda. Instead, both branches play the “autonomy game” as if to mimic a kind of “power struggle” or “clash” between them.  Legislated enactments or the proposed bills in Congress that go through the legislative mill until they get to be approved by the President and become Republic Acts are relatively slow compared to Executive Orders signed by the President. Offhand, EOs are quantitatively more but qualitatively inferior than RAs. Put another way, RAs are qualitatively superior but quantitatively less than EOs. Against this theoretical backdrop, this seminal study aims to explore the public policy landscape and to foreground few assumptions that compare and contrast the dynamics at work in the field of policy-making when bureaucrats holding cabinet positions tend to dominate if not outsmart politicians or legislators in Congress. To this end, the paper aims to do a discourse analysis of the Executive Orders already signed by President Ferdinand Marcos, Jr. and the Republic Acts or legislated enactments spawned by the Bicameral Legislature. Notwithstanding a foreseen problem in the data-gathering since it would include, for purposes of study, even Republic Acts that merely lapsed into law, the study forthwith intends to advance an argument against public policies that merely passed this “groove” and became laws for their possible adverse effects upon the present dispensation in terms of policy trajectory consistent or inconsistent with good governance. While Samuel Huntington peddles the view that the “interest of the president is consistent with nothing else” in one of his published works, this paper begs to disagree that in the case of Congress, public policy making fully satisfies the principle of appropriateness, collaboration, and an entirely nationalized approach to public policy or rule-making praxis.

Keywords: tug of war, “autonomy game”, discourse analysis, legislated enactments, nationalized approach to public policy.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Research and Statecraft: An Encounter with the Global South
Frederick Rey (University of Santo Tomas)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Policymaking rest not purely on its design nor its content, but also on the appropriation of power between and among actors involved in the interaction. As the separation between scholarship and statecraft becomes more apparent, the concentration of power likewise becomes more defined. The location of the scholar in relation to policymaking maybe characterized by an ill condition of actors with scarce capital (scholars) competing against actors with surplus capital (politicians).

 

But with the scholar’s recognition on the need to influence policymaking, it is indispensable first, for the scholar to accept the present situation with humility and hope. Modesty is the understanding that politics is a life that is independent of the theories and speculations of the academe. It is a being that can only be understood by assuming and presupposing nothing since nothing is permanent in any political construct. Instead, politics can only be or can be best understood by temporarily abandoning the security of scholastic prejudgment and momentarily living a life of a politician (verstehen – emphatic understanding).

 

Hope, however, springs from the eternal nobility of a dialogue allowing the politician and the scholar to achieve a unity of purpose and a symphony of action for public administration. 

 

It is proposed that sound policymaking requires the collaboration of primary institutions. The dominance of one institution in understanding the varieties of human conditions is destined to fail since its intellectual resources are too narrow, and the universe is too complex (Comte 1896). 

 

Thus, the starting place as well as the arrival of this paper resides on the fact that policymaking is all about the accumulation of capital (Bourdieu 1986). This model allows the agencies to become conscious of their roles and locations in the interplay of power-capital in relation to statecraft.  

 

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Civil Servants as Policy Entrepreneurs: Evidence from South Korea
Don Lee
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Recent research in public administration and policy emphasizes the role of public servants beyond as policy executers, by paying attention to their active roles in policy making and evaluation processes (Arnold 2015; De Vries, Bekkers, and Tummers 2016; Lavee and Cohen 2019). However, who are motivated to become policy entrepreneurs and how they do so are relatively overlooked in the literature, particularly in the local government context. This article contributes experimental evidence to this growing literature with a large survey sample of more than 2,000 local civil servants from South Korea. Specifically, three factors are examined to address these questions concerning policy entrepreneurship in local government: 1) How intergovernmental relations shape public servants’ willingness to play more active roles in policy making and evaluation processes; 2) whether intrinsic versus extrinsic motivation have a stronger impact on policy entrepreneurship; and 3) whom local civil servants are willing to discuss in policy making and evaluation processes. Using indirect questioning methods, such as list and endorsement experiments, an analysis of original survey data will add value to the literature with important policy implications.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Making Civil Society Integral to Local Public Finance
Joan Ruiz (Isabela State University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Section 23 of Article II of the 1987 Philippine Constitution states that the participation of non-governmental, community-based, and other sectoral organizations shall be encouraged by the State. Likewise, Section 67 of Republic Act No. 10964 (General Appropriations Act of 2018) allows national government agencies to partner with civil society organizations (CSOs) in implementing specific programs and projects.

This paper examines the role of CSOs in local public finance in the Philippines. It specifically covers the local government unit of Echague, Isabela, a first-class municipality located in southern Isabela Province. Eighteen accredited CSOs for 2019-2022 were noted in Echague, Isabela, which is a manifestation of the CSOs’ commitment to formalize their engagement with the LGU.

This is a project that was funded by the Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) through its Technical Assistance Program for Local Resource Institutes to empower the CSOs. Specifically, it aims to identify the accredited CSOs, determine their level of engagement in public procurement, and capacitate CSOs to sustain their participation in local public finance.

Civil society organizations were found to be effective in enabling services, According to the accredited CSOs, their participation in government processes is vital for providing check and balance and exacting accountability. They believed that active CSO participation is an indicator of healthy participatory governance. However, they face key challenges in their recognition and procurement expertise.

 

Keywords: Civil Society Organizations; Local Government Units; Local Public Finance; Philippines

 

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Science of Delivery: Knowledge Management in Guidance Policy Formulation and Curricular Contest Winners' Declaration Dynamics
Xeniah Caryl Dando (University of the Philippines Open University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

From an independent communication practitioner perspective, a guidance coordinator's duty and responsibility to formulate guidance policies for the district can provide due care in a real-time response for the educational community. Why does a guidance coordinator craft a guidance policy? How can due care be attained in guidance policy formulation? How can a DepED School District, at its governance level, produce a better policy that could lead to effective public service? Based on these questions, this paper aims to illustrate the significance of critical communication in a guidance coordinator's duty and responsibility to formulate the district's guidance policy in a DepEd School District in Elementary Schools. With effect from the Key Responsibility Areas (KRAs) of a Principal's position title, functional due care could harmoniously support an innovative guidance policy to provide preventive care to both learners and employees. In this paper, the tenets of (a) guidance policy formulation rationale, (b) composite Science of Delivery (SOD) in Knowledge Management (KM), and (c) proposed innovative district policy for a range-based ranking of ranks in the declaration of school district curricular contest winners and school curricular contest winners are posited. It is autonomous to explain the critical communication that connects to a better policy leading to effective public service. An innovative policy's greater access, timely response, quality care, and child-friendly trauma-preventive intervention at zero cost could be attributed to the issuance of DepEd Orders and DepEd Memorandums, Science of Delivery, and Knowledge Management. These elements are critical in developing a nondiscriminatory guidance policy. Guidance counselors' openness to working as a team with principals is a practical zero-cost advantage in public service outflow and increased participation rate inflow. Functional due care converges on the importance of teachers and guidance counselors as partners in inclusive transparency. It complements learning from DepEd issuances as it safeguards participation and mental health.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - An Overview of the Formation Process of International Cooperation in Personnel Administration: From the Case of Ministry of Personnel Management (MPM)
Sung Min Park (Sunkyunkwan University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

1.  Background

The Ministry of Personnel Management (MPM), newly established in November 2014 to strengthen the openness and expertise of public officials, is the Central Personnel Management Agency in charge of the personnel system of the Korean government. The MPM, which has been striving for personnel innovation, such as civil servant pension reform, open career system, and the introduction of the professional civil service system, established the Department for International Cooperation on July 23, 2019 to proactively and systematically respond to the growing interest and demand for personnel administration consulting. Three years after the establishment of a dedicated department, it is necessary to look back on the footsteps and briefly look into the future direction of international cooperation in personnel administration.

 

2. Expanding the Scope of International Cooperation in Personnel Administration

Since the launch of MPM, the number of foreign public officials visiting the MPM to learn the Korean personnel system has gradually increased, and that of foreign governments, international organizations and institutions signing a memorandum of understanding (for cooperation) with our Ministry to share experiences in personnel management has also increased rapidly. Until the first half of 2017, the only agencies that signed new agreements in personnel administration were the Human Resources Management Service of the Government of the Republic of Serbia and the Turkish Personnel Office, however, the scope of international cooperation has expanded as new agreements were signed with a total of 8 institutions by the end of 2019, including Uzbekistan’s Ministry of Employment and Labor, the Cabinet Secretariat of Government of Mongolia, the Astana Civil Service Hub (ACSH) and the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB). In May of last year, when face-to-face exchanges were difficult due to the spread of the COVID-19, the MPM signed a memorandum of cooperation in personnel administration with the Ministry of Human Resource and Social Development of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.

In 2020, international exchange and cooperation projects were carried out in a non-face-to-face manner due to COVID-19, which made it difficult to efficiently promote those projects. However, we had video conferences several times and continued to communicate with our counterparts to agree on the draft of memorandum of understanding (for cooperation) with Uzbekistan’s Civil Service Development Agency and Kyrgyzstan’s State Personnel Agency. In addition, on October 28 in 2021, we held a signing ceremony of a memorandum of understanding via a video conference with the Ministry of Civil Service of Cambodia, one of the new southern countries. Additionally, the MPM has agreed with the Personnel Committee of the Ministry of Administrative and Bureaucratic Reform of Indonesia and the IDB to continue cooperation and has been preparing to renew a memorandum of understanding.

 

3. Research Inquiries

Against this backdrop of MPM’s ODA policies for promoting International Cooperation in Personnel Administration, on the basis of a qualitative research approach, this study tries to explore and test a set of research inquiries. First, what are the institutional, organizational, and political roles of MPM in designing and implementing ODA policies? Second, How and to what extent such factors as leadership, organizational structures, cultures, and strategies, HRM, communication, network, etc. would affect the ODA policy success or failure? Third, what is the state of internal ODA policymaking processes, dynamics, and mechanisms within MPM? Fourth, what are the main internal and external environmental conditions (e.g., strengths, opportunities, weaknesses, and threats) in implementing MPM’s ODA policies? What is the best way to overcome these limitations and to enhance policy outcome performance?

  In order to explore and confirm these research questions, this study will adopt in-depth qualitative research methods (i.e., focus group interviews, case and content analyses, and on-line surveys). Drawing upon these findings, this study will propose policy implications and caveats for more successful agency policymaking processes and outcomes.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Agency Policy Development Processes in the Philippines: Roles, Processes, and Patterns
Ebinezer Florano (University of the Philippines Diliman)
CO-AUTHORS
Eunice Teodoro (University of the Philippines Diliman)
ABSTRACT

Theoretically speaking, government agencies are considered direct and official participants in policymaking at the national level. In the policy development process, they are expected to be actively involved in the development of public policies and their implementation. In the Philippines, while many studies had been conducted on public policies enacted by the national legislature, still, not much is known about the internal processes of policymaking of government and their roles in national public policy development. Therefore, this exploratory study seeks to discern the roles of and patterns in the policymaking of national government agencies. Specifically, it aims to answer the following panel questions: What is the role of agencies in public policymaking? What is the state of internal policymaking in them? How well-developed is the internal policymaking in these agencies? What are the dynamics involved? For this purpose, the policy development processes of seven government agencies were investigated by the researchers using the institutionalist approach. The seven agencies consist of a science high school system, a bureau, a law enforcement agency, a public enterprise, a presidential commission, and two departments representing the education, finance, peace and order, water resources, urban poor, social welfare, and migrant labor sectors, respectively,  Interviews or focus group discussion were conducted among key informants and relevant documents were studied. In a nutshell, the major findings from these seven case studies are: that while many of these agencies have developed manuals or flow process charts for policymaking, the processes are incomplete because most of them end at either the approval of the policy or their dissemination; most of the policies are limited to internal policies, and their processes in contributing to public policies at the national level are not clear; and, the stakeholders or their “publics,” in some of these agencies, are not involved in the policymaking processes. The implication of these findings is that if these trends among the seven agencies are the norms in the national bureaucracy of the country, the practice of Public Policy could only be halfway ingrained in the Philippine administrative system.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Resident-government relations and residents' trust in local government in the Philippines
KENICHI NISHIMURA (Osaka University)
CO-AUTHORS
Masao Kikuchi (Meiji University)
ABSTRACT

This paper explores what improves residents' trust in local government, focusing on the Philippines as a case. Trust in government affects government performance. Fujii (2006), who examined the relationship between public works projects by Japan's central government and government trust, points out that "ensuring transparency" and the attitude of "carrying out public works for a good cause" increase residents' trust in government and make it easier to implement public works projects. Murayama et al. (2021) also found that prefectures in Japan with stronger ties among residents and higher government trust had lower mortality rates from new coronavirus infection, based on a survey conducted between August and September 2020.

What influences trust in government? Oyama (2010) distinguished between factors that define trust in government that relate to characteristics on the government side and those that relate to characteristics on the citizen side, and examined which factor defines trust in government. He found that although the most significant factor defining government trust is government performance, the most important factor on the citizen side is political participation. Chida and Arai (2011) point out that if individuals frequently use local government services and facilities and frequently attend government-sponsored events, they are likely to strongly trust the local government. Furthermore, they believe that trust would be further increased if citizens could participate in some way in local government planning. They also point out that, in the case of local governments, the dissemination of information by the government itself affects residents' trust in the government. OECD, which conducted a project to measure the drivers of trust in democratic government, notes that South Korea, one of East Asia's democracies, needs to better listen to and engage its citizens in order to increase government trust (OECD/KDI 2018).

Given the above points, we use statistical analysis to identify what drives government trust in the Philippines. For this purpose, we use the results of our 2019 public opinion survey on the local governance. The analysis will test how residents' relationship with local government, information dissemination by local government, and residents' political opinions affect their trust in local government.

 

 

References

1. Chida, Ryoukichi and Arai, Kazuhiro (2011), “Determinants of Trust in Local Government: Comparison with Central Government (Chihouseifu ni taisuru Shinrai no Ketteiyouin)”, Hitotsubashi economics; Vol. 4, No. 1, pp. 950129.

 

2. Fujii, Satoshi (2006), “Public Trust in Government: Building Trust through Public Works for a Good Cause (Seifu ni taisuru Kokumin no Shinrai)”, Proceedings of JSCE; 807/IV-70, pp.29-41.

 

3. Murayama H, Nakamoto I, Tabuchi T. (2021). “Social Capital and COVID-19 Deaths: An Ecological Analysis in Japan”. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health; 18(20): 10982.

 

4. OECD/KDI (2018), Understanding the Drivers of Trust in Government Institutions in Korea, Building Trust in Public Institutions, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264308992-en.

 

5. Oyana, Kousuke (2010), “Factors on the Government and Citizen Sides of Administrative Trust: Focusing on Data from the World Values Survey 2005 (Gyoseishinrai no Seifugawa to Shimingawa no Youin)”, The Annuals of Japanese Political Science Association; Vol. 61, No.1, pp. 31-48.

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - THE PUSH-AND-PULL DYNAMICS BETWEEN COURTS AND ADMINISTRATIVE AGENCIES
Roentgen Bronce (University of the Philippines Diliman)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

A number of government actors control the actions of administrative agencies in the Philippines. One such actor is the judiciary, with the Supreme Court at the apex of its hierarchy. Through its power of judicial review, and by exercising its role as the ultimate arbiter of legal issues, the SC influences how administrative agencies perform its mandate, and specially, how they develop policy through their rule-making and adjudication functions.

 

The Philippine Supreme Court has, time and again, emphasized the significance of administrative agencies; for instance, it has described them collectively as the “fourth branch of government.” It has also reiterated in a long line of cases that delegation of power to these bodies is the rule, rather than the exception. However, the Court has also, in a great number of decisions, invalidated agency actions which have diminished the import of the norm. By wielding judicial review, and through inconsistent jurisprudence, it has weakened the power of administrative agencies. In other words, the Court has maintained a “push and pull” attitude on agency policy development.

 

Using multiple case studies and reviews of Court decisions, this paper explores the dynamics between the judiciary and administrative agencies in the Philippines. In particular, this paper shows how the Philippine Supreme Court shapes the adjudication and rule-making power of administrative agencies. It explains the impact of these judicial pronouncements on administrative policy. It also suggests a framework- a set of parameters- on how the Court can strike a balance between an eager approach to review of agency interpretations, on one hand, and restraint through deference to agency actions, on the other.

ACCEPTED
Format
11 - Internal Policymaking: Interpreting and Reinterpreting Hiring Protocols
Loreta Vivian Galima (Nueva Vizcaya State University)
CO-AUTHORS
Gydabelle Olaya
MILD HOMBREBUENO
ABSTRACT

The Civil Service Comission (CSC) 2017 Omnibus Rules on Appointments and Other Human Resource Actions (ORAOHRA) governs all actions pertaining to appointments and other human resource movements in government owned institutions and agencies in the Philippines. Said ORAOHRA was revised in July 2018 to include amendments as a result of the Levelling of Interpretation on the original ORAOHRA done by the CSC to ensure that the provisions contained therein are in accordance with other administrative issuances and other pertinent laws. From this experience, it is assumed that there may be future amendments, as agencies implement the provisions of ORAOHRA.

This paper studies the dynamics of internal policymaking as policy makers and officials involved in the recruitment of personnel needed by the organization interpret and reinterpret policies as they implement hiring protocols, procedures and rules pertaining to recruitment. for this paper, the focus is on the implementation of policies pertaining to the recruitment of applicants to the organization, as well as practices and procedures that have evolved over the years in the process of implementing the rules prescribed in the ORAOHRA, using the case study approach to generate an in-depth, multifaceted understanding of internal policymaking in its real life context. The approach uses both retrospective and introspective techniques to include both in-depth and historical information on the phenomenon being studied.

This study fits Panel 04 under TO5, since it is about policy formulation, administration and policymakers, and takes a closer look into the dynamics of internal policymaking. The research may elicit deeper insights not only into the dynamics of internal policymaking but it may also identify best or worst practices in the implementation of national policies and how these may eventually contribute to the improvement of public service and policy formulation on the national level.

ACCEPTED
Format
12 - Does the Background of the Regulator Matter? Representative Bureaucracy, Critical Mass and Cultural Capture in Regulatory Bodies
Juan Carlos Triviño Salazar (Universitat Pompeu Fabra)
CO-AUTHORS
Ixchel Pérez-Durán (Universitat Autónoma de Barcelona)
Yannis Papadopoulos (University of Lausanne)
ABSTRACT

Regulatory bodies (RAs) have been conceived as expert bodies able to enhance the credible commitment problem of policies due to their technical capacities and knowledge (Majone, 1994). In contrast to other political organizations, it might be argued that RAs do not need to fulfill social representation. However, previous studies (Jasanoff, 2011; Krick, 2018; Pérez-Durán and Bravo-Laguna, 2019) have emphasized that expert bodies and their members also need to meet some requirements related to: (i) the reliability of their knowledge and competence; and (ii) the credibility of their independence -as opposing to bias- in their background and professional trajectories. For this reason, our purpose is to examine representation in RAs and its potential effects on the risks of cultural capture and the lack of critical mass and plurality of voices in their regulatory process. To this end, we propose answering the following questions: To what extent do regulatory bodies have representative bureaucracy in regulatory domains? To what extent does such representative bureaucracy affect the risk of cultural capture in regulatory domains? We respond to the questions by examining an original biographical dataset developed in the H2020 TiGRE (Trust in Governance and Regulation in Europe) with 1070 profiles covering members of national (Belgium, Denmark, Germany, Israel, Spain, Switzerland) and EU agencies in three policy sectors, finance, data protection and food safety.  In particular, we focused on examining: agency heads, members of management boards (or similar bodies); members of stakeholder bodies/advisory boards (or similar bodies), and top high-ranking officials (i.e. directors and sub-directors). Through our study, we seek to provide insights about  the extent to which diversity is present in regulatory bodies; the extent to which critical mass is needed in expert bodies and regulatory domains; and finally,  to contribute to the debate of democratization in expert bodies. All in all, our results contribute to critiques that signal the potential (lack of) representation within these bodies and the dangers of a cultural capture in regulatory policies.

 

Our paper is strongly connected to the theme of IPPA’s panel on “Agency Policymaking: Dynamics and Contributions to National Public Policies” as it precisely looks for answers to the questions: What is the state of internal policymaking in agencies? how well-developed is the internal policymaking in agencies? What are the dynamics involved? These questions are strongly connected to organizational dynamics linked to the governance of these public bodies.

ACCEPTED
Format
13 - Barangay Policymaking Processes: Public Policies at the Frontline
Ebinezer Florano (University of the Philippines Diliman)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Barangay (literally “village” in English) is the basic politico-administrative unit in the Philippines that is at the frontline of public service for its residents ranging between a hundred to tens of thousands. According to the 1991 Local Government Code, barangays serve as the primary planning and implementing units of government policies, plans, programs, projects, and activities in the community. It is in the barangays that residents are able to articulate their issues, problems, and concerns. Most of the relevant literature about it delves on legislating barangay ordinances or resolutions, which is only halfway through the entire policymaking process. Furthermore, there is a question on the “policymaking space” of barangays because their policymaking authority is already limited given that there are too many of them handed down by national government agencies and local government units (provincial, city/municipal) for implementation. In addition, some of the studies do not dwell on the dynamics of policymaking involving the residents. Therefore, there is a need to conduct a deeper institutional study on the practices of barangay policy development processes. This paper aims to investigate how policymaking is officially conducted in barangays with a special focus on the participation of the residents. For this purpose, four barangays located in four cities (Pasig, Quezon City, Makati, and Tagum) were investigated. They were chosen based on the reported “best practices” in their policymaking. The researchers interviewed key informants mostly barangay officials, conducted focus group discussions with them together with the residents, examined the contents of their ordinances and resolutions, and poured over their manuals and relevant documents. The major finding of the study is that “policymaking” and “policy analysis” are still foreign concepts among the barangay officials. Being at the frontline of public service, their policymaking processes are strong in the participation of their residents but they are unequipped with the technicalities of policy analysis, implementation, and assessment (i.e., monitoring and evaluation). Still, there are nuggets of wisdom that could be learned from their experiences in local policy development in their own ways.

ACCEPTED
Format
14 - The road better taken – A comparison of the policy formulation route taken by select ASEAN countries on their domestic adoption and regulation of modern agricultural biotechnology
Abraham Manalo (University of the Philippines Diliman)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The global adoption of modern biotechnology in agriculture, particularly in plants and plant products, has been quite impressive. From the 1.7 million hectares reported when biotech crops were first commercially grown in 1996, latest figures from the International Service for the Acquisition of Agri-biotech Applications (ISAAA 2020) reveal that 23 years later, about 190.4 million hectares of farmland have been devoted to biotech crops in 2019, spread across 29 countries and planted by approximately 17 million farmers from both developing and developed countries. In spite of its widespread commercial planting and direct use for human food or animal feed, different countries have set in place different policies and regulations that can either facilitate or stifle their adoption of this technology to agriculture and the domestic economy at large. One of the essential elements that differentiates these issuances is the source of the basic policy formulation – as a law enacted by the national legislature or as a policy directive emanating from a regulatory agency of the executive branch. There are historical, legal, institutional, and political reasons behind the policy-formulation route taken by a particular country, and this will be the main focus of this study, as it surveys and compares the basic policies on biotech regulation in the Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, and Vietnam. The lead policymaking bodies will be identified and the role they played will be substantially discussed. This paper will also examine the policy implication of taking such route, how it may have affected the adoption and use of the technology in agriculture and commerce. It will strive to answer an important and timely question: on highly technical matters such as in modern agricultural biotechnology, which policymaking and regulatory-formulating route leads to more effective public service? Which route better serves the people that are the intended beneficiaries of these new interventions? Aside from documentary analysis of pertinent laws, policies, regulations, and similar issuances on modern biotechnology from the five case countries mentioned above, the author intends to conduct in-depth interviews with key informants from these countries to be able to answer the research problems that have been put forward.

ACCEPTED
Format
15 - EXPLORING THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS ON PUBLIC POLICYMAKING IN DEVELOPING ECONOMIES
Joel Mangahas (Asian Development Bank)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper will discuss the role of international financial institutions (IFIs) in supporting the policy reforms and development expenditure programs of their borrowing member countries. Based on a review of policies, programs, reports, and publications, including interviews of selected staff of IFIs and governments, this paper will explain the pathways through which IFIs such as the Asian Development Bank (ADB) and the World Bank (WB) create opportunities for government agencies to formulate better policies and to implement them more efficiently and effectively. These pathways, which remain largely unknown or unclear to many scholars and practitioners include loans, grants, technical assistance, and knowledge work.
 
As one of ADB’s lending modalities, policy-based lending (PBL) – which is the equivalent of WB’s development policy financing – is linked to the implementation of priority policy reforms in developing countries that can generate sector-wide and economy wide impacts. It is an important instrument for initiating long-term public sector reforms and can be used in many sectors. PBLs support economic management, institutional development, structural transformation, and sector policy reforms. PBLs can focus on macroeconomic management and fiscal policy, competition policy, capital market development, climate resilience, disaster preparedness, human capital development, social protection, decentralization, governance, access to finance among others. Reform programs supported by PBLs may include formulation or amendment of policies, laws, and regulations to address structural bottlenecks and measures to enhance capacities of public institutions.  
 
This paper will also discuss how PBLs are complemented and reenforced by grants, technical assistance, and knowledge pieces, which are mobilized to provide evidence-based and well-considered advice on formulating and implementing reform programs as well as enhancing the know-how of policymakers and implementors.
 
Alongside the benefits from the pathways mentioned above that can be derived by developing countries, this paper will likewise discuss the pitfalls, caveats, and areas for improvement.

ACCEPTED
Format
16 - Changing landscapes in educational reality; ChatGPT and the shift to non-formal learning
Grigoriy Grigoryev
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

While education is often facing bureaucratic delays and digital transformations, not enough time or other valuable resources are being spent on its counter intuitive chum. Non-formal and in various ways the informal education are left to battle their own conflicts. This paper provides the outline and analysis of Erasmus+ Key Action initiatives in the non-formal sector within Germany and the EU. It analysis the investment and importance of joint educational framework that incorporates a number of pathways to address learning in pupils and the populace.

 

In network society as described by Manuel Castells, nodes are the collectors and distributors of information and can be thought of as educational hubs. Although the formal education structures like the schools and libraries are becoming obsolete, particularly as was evident during the Covid-19 pandemic around the world, digital learning and educational hubs are not only premiering but possibly replacing the old ways of teaching and learning. Artificial initiatives like personalized learning algorithms, along with the help of open source ChatGPT are providing more individualized approach to and possibly for the student. Answering, exchanging and providing space for deep and thought provoking realizations.

 

As the world transformation continues and human reliance on machines becomes ever more necessary, the formal education will continue to focus by uniting students in providing them space and time for formation and possible motivation. Allowing pupils to acquire certain norms and become social citizens. On the other hand, the curriculum and certain assessments will be left for the machine algorithms. To sum-up, this paper examines how do societies face the current and upcoming challenges as it relates to formal education in the schools and how does the informal & non-formal education propagate learning that will become ever more necessary.

 

 

ACCEPTED
Format
17 - Role of Public Agencies in Policy making: A review of the K+12 policy of the Philippines and the Role of the Department of Education
Maricel Carag (De La Salle College of Saint Benilde)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The Philippine Department of Education (DepEd) has issued a landmark policy in 2013 called the “Enhanced Basic Education Act of 2012” or RA10553 which added two more years in basic education that will equip learners with skills that prepare them for the future. Through the years, the Philippine government continues to invest significant resources to improve quality and access to basic education Mirasol et al 2021. The Philippines expected improvements in national, regional and international assessment. For example, for the NAT taken by Grades 6 to 12, the performance of students have been declining, placing them at “low mastery” or low proficiency (DepEd Region, 2019).  In 2018, the Philippines ranked 79th out of 79 participating countries in the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA). In particular, fifteen-year-old students in the Philippines scored lower in reading, mathematics and science than those in most of the countries and economies that participated in PISA 2018. The South East Asia -Primary Learning Metrics (SEA-PLM) 2019 study showed that only 10% of Filipino Grade 5 students were able to meet the reading proficiency level at the end of primary education. With these alarming state of education in the Philippines, the  current President of the Republic of the Philippines has ordered the Philippine Department of Education to introduce drastic reforms in the DepEd’s K to 12 policy. It is within this context that this paper would like to look into the role of the Philippine Department of Education in education policy-making. In particular, the paper will attempt to answer the following questions: (1) What is the role of DepEd in influencing policy makers to amend RA10553? (2) Are there areas for autonomous public policymaking reserved for the DepEd? (3) What factors affect their participation in policy making? And finally (4) what are some proposed mechanisms to enhance the participation in policy making.
 
References:
Joy Molina Mirasol, Joanne Vivien Belderol Necosia, Beverly Badajos Bicar, Helen Pelandas Garcia (2021). Statutory policy analysis on access to Philippine quality basic education, International Journal of Educational Research Open,Volume 2, 100093 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijedro.2021.100093 accessed on Jan 30, 2023 at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2666374021000637)
OECD (2019), PISA 2018 Results (Volume I): What Students Know and Can Do, PISA, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/5f07c754-en.
UNICEF (2022). What does SEA-PLM 2019 tell us about child well-being and learning in six Southeast Asian countries? United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) East Asia and Pacific Regional Office (EAPRO) and UNICEF Office of Research – Innocenti. Accessed at https://www.unicef.org/eap/reports/child-well-being-and-learning
 

ACCEPTED
Format
18 - Entrepreneurial Orientation as a Personnel Development Policy in Public Universities
Alessandro Silva Junior (Federal University of Viçosa)
CO-AUTHORS
Magnus Emmendoerfer (Universidade Federal de Viçosa - UFV / UNESCO CHAIR CEPPBRASIL )
Josiel Valadares (Universidade Federal de Viçosa)
Tamiris Resende (Prefeitura Municipal de Belo Horizonte)
ABSTRACT

Contextualization: In the complex scenario coming from globalization, public universities have been undergoing transformation caused by new social demands and the inclusion of new technologies, demanding the ability to debate and implement entrepreneurial actions (Cai & Etzkowitz, 2020). Thus, entrepreneurial orientation (EO) emerges as an important strategic construct to stimulate entrepreneurship in public organizations through new processes, practices, and activities aimed at organizational development (Diefenbach, 2011; Emmendoerfer, 2019). Within public universities, it is believed that these practices can be important personnel development policies, stimulating an academic culture that leads them to act in an innovative, proactive, competitive way and to take risks since they seek external financial resources and application of scientific knowledge, aiming at a promising posture for the future (Ruiz, 2018).

Research problem: What is the evidence in the international literature of personnel development policies based on Entrepreneurial Orientation (EO) in public universities? This article aimed to analyze in the international literature evidence of theoretical and empirical studies that demonstrate the application and results of the EO as a policy of personnel development in public universities.

Methodology: Considering the proposed objective, this is a bibliographic research of exploratory-descriptive level. A systematic literature review will be conducted in Scopus and Web of Science international databases. As search strings will be used "entrepreneurial orientation" AND "universities"; "public universities" AND "entrepreneurship"; "entrepreneurial orientation" AND "public universities." A priori exclusion criteria will not be adopted to allow a complete view of the phenomenon. The PRISMA method (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses) will be used as a strategy of systematization and discussion of the results alongside the content analysis technique. One proposition to be verified from data analysis is the appropriation of The EO centered on graduate students.

Panel Applicability: The UNESCO Chair on Creative Economy and Public Policies: governing through alternative economic models and creative policy solutions aims to discuss possibilities and actions to stimulate creativity and governance. In this sense, it is believed that the article can contribute to the discussion of stimulating creativity and innovation of public servants, as well as in the change in educational and governance policies of public universities, stimulating local and regional cooperation by inserting universities as a protagonist for sustainable development.

 

References
Cai, Y., & Etzkowitz, H. (2020). Theorizing the Triple Helix model: Past, present, and future. Triple Helix, 7(2/3), 189-226.

Diefenbach, F. E. (2011). Entrepreneurial orientation in the public sector. (Doctoral dissertation). University of St. Gallen, St. Gallen, Switzerland.
Emmendoerfer, M. L. (2019). Inovação e empreendedorismo no setor público. Brasília: Enap.
Ruiz, S. M. A. (2018). Universidade empreendedora: proposição de um modelo para as instituições de ensino superior públicas brasileiras. Tese (Doutorado em Administração), Universidade Nove de Julho – UNINOVE, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.

ACCEPTED
Format
19 - Recruitment and Promotion Protocols and Practices in State Universities: A Comparative Analysis
Loreta Vivian Galima (Nueva Vizcaya State University)
CO-AUTHORS
MILD HOMBREBUENO
Catherine Dela Cruz (Nueva Vizcaya State University)
ABSTRACT

Recruitment protocols and practices in chartered colleges and universities in the Philippines, just like in other government agencies, are governed by the provisions of the Civil Service Commission(CSC) 2017 Omnibus Rules on Appointments and Other Human Resource Actions (ORAOHRA), while promotions are based on the common criteria for evaluation guidelines as prescribed in the National Budget Circular 461 (NBC 461). In the process of implementing policies and procedures stipulated in the ORAOHRA and the NBC 461, internal policies and procedures as well as practices have evolved over the years.

This paper studies how two universities from one region, sharing many things in common, including governing policies, differ in the implementation of identical hiring and promotion protocols. The comparative study focuses on recruitment and promotion policies and procedures as interpreted and implemented by the two universities. The first part of the study consists of document scanning and analysis of the same governing policies that pertain to recruitment and promotion, as well as the internal policies formulated by both universities in implementing the national policies. The second part of the study uses face to face interviews with internal policymakers and decision-makers in the organization. The third part of the study draws comparisons between how the two universities have been implementing promotion policies inntwo cycles and recruitment practices of both over the past five years.

This paper is being submitted for consideration to this panel, Panel 04, T05, because it focuses on internal policymaking while it considers the dynamics behind recruitment and promotion in two state universities. Eventually, internal policies that evolve from the implementers of national policies, may serve as bases for the formulation of new policies or the amendment of existing policies.

ACCEPTED
Format
20 - The Legislation and Policymaking in the Local Government Units (LGUs) in the Philippines: The Science and Participatory Challenge
Geraldo Petilla (University of the City of Manila)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The legislation and policymaking process in the Philippines, particularly in local government units (LGUs), is a conundrum. The prevailing practice raises questions about its crafting and the level of difficulty in creating accurate, fair, objective, and impactful policies. These are considered essential characteristics of all policies, as they are expected to secure and promote the welfare of constituents. The basis and substance of local legislations and policies adopted and implemented have long eluded public scrutiny.

 

As representatives of the people, local legislators and policymakers are accountable for satisfactorily addressing questions about the construction of statutes and policies. This includes evidence provided to support and validate the legislation, the sources used to inform the legislation (e.g. sectors, specialists, scientists, and ordinary people), and whether the legislation was informed by testing, study, application, and review. Effective governance requires considering both the scientific and participatory aspects of the legislative and policymaking process, leading to evidence-based decision making.

 

This paper argues for the significance of science (both substance and process) and participatory aspects in local legislation and policymaking, which are integral to the principles of Good Governance, particularly accountability and participation. The role of science in providing a deeper understanding of accountability in public service and building trust and confidence among the public is emphasized. The participatory process highlights the importance of incorporating a human element in science. This study aims to assess the level of utilization of evidence, public consultations, and involvement of specialists, researchers, and scientists in local legislation and policymaking in the Philippines. It also examines the resources available for developing data and knowledge capacity, evaluating the impact of legislation and policies, and investigating the correlation between evidence in legislation and policies and the public's level of trust and confidence.

 

Given the realities and limitations of local government units (LGUs), the paper argues that the growth of science and participatory policymaking are crucial to addressing challenges and advancing governance.

Keywords: science, evidence- based, participatory

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

While the role of international organizations (IOs) in the rulemaking process at the international level has received considerable scholarly attention, how and when IOs seek to shape national legislative processes has received little attention. This paper explores the strategies IOs can use to shape legislative outcomes in specific policy areas at the Member State level. And because IOs cannot directly shape national legislative outcomes, I argue that they can do so through agenda-setting power, defined as the IO's ability to influence policymakers to consider and pay attention to an issue. Empirically,  I adopt process tracing, qualitative document analysis, and elite interviews, tracing the role of IO in the pre-legislative processes at the national level. I use the COMESA Competition Commission (CCC) as a case study. CCC is a regional competition institution established by COMESA. COMESA is made up of 21 Member States. Article 17(2, c) of the Competition Regulations (CCR) requires CCC to promote national competition laws that increase the uniformity in the interpretation and application of CCR in COMESA. So far, Kenya, Eswatini, and Uganda have adopted legislation recognizing the application of CCR in their domestic markets. Zambia and Malawi have initiated legislative processes to include competition provisions in their competition laws recognizing CCR. However, despite being a fascinating and informative object of study, no scholarly work has paid any theoretical or empirical attention to how CCC has sought to influence national-level legislative outcomes through national bureaucrats. I interviewed a number of national competition agencies to explore their role in adopting competition policy legislation that grants CCR applicability in domestic legal systems. Secondly, the role of CCC in the pre-legislative process.   Preliminary findings show that CCC has adopted agenda-setting strategies to build its credibility and gain attention among actors with formal, gatekeeping, and leadership agenda-setting power at the national level. In tandem with the agenda-setting literature, CCC has established institutional venues such as courtesy calls, training, and technical assistance to incentivize Member States and institutions to adopt legislations that recognize the application of CCR. Consequently, some COMESA countries have initiated legislative processes to grant CCR applicability in their domestic legal system. This study, therefore, shows how IOs can, through agenda-setting power, gain the attention of bureaucrats at the Member State level to consider legislative outcomes that grant enhance the application and interpretation of international rules.  

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

“A seminal study of the President’s Executive Orders against that of Congress’ Republic Acts”

 

Abstract: In so far as public policies are concerned, there are two competing branches of government in a tug of war. Despite the establishment of a Legislative-Executive Development Advisory Council as “a venue to facilitate high level policy discussions on vital issues and concerns affecting national development”, the council hardly convenes to deliberate shared or common development agenda. Instead, both branches play the “autonomy game” as if to mimic a kind of “power struggle” or “clash” between them.  Legislated enactments or the proposed bills in Congress that go through the legislative mill until they get to be approved by the President and become Republic Acts are relatively slow compared to Executive Orders signed by the President. Offhand, EOs are quantitatively more but qualitatively inferior than RAs. Put another way, RAs are qualitatively superior but quantitatively less than EOs. Against this theoretical backdrop, this seminal study aims to explore the public policy landscape and to foreground few assumptions that compare and contrast the dynamics at work in the field of policy-making when bureaucrats holding cabinet positions tend to dominate if not outsmart politicians or legislators in Congress. To this end, the paper aims to do a discourse analysis of the Executive Orders already signed by President Ferdinand Marcos, Jr. and the Republic Acts or legislated enactments spawned by the Bicameral Legislature. Notwithstanding a foreseen problem in the data-gathering since it would include, for purposes of study, even Republic Acts that merely lapsed into law, the study forthwith intends to advance an argument against public policies that merely passed this “groove” and became laws for their possible adverse effects upon the present dispensation in terms of policy trajectory consistent or inconsistent with good governance. While Samuel Huntington peddles the view that the “interest of the president is consistent with nothing else” in one of his published works, this paper begs to disagree that in the case of Congress, public policy making fully satisfies the principle of appropriateness, collaboration, and an entirely nationalized approach to public policy or rule-making praxis.

Keywords: tug of war, “autonomy game”, discourse analysis, legislated enactments, nationalized approach to public policy.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Policymaking rest not purely on its design nor its content, but also on the appropriation of power between and among actors involved in the interaction. As the separation between scholarship and statecraft becomes more apparent, the concentration of power likewise becomes more defined. The location of the scholar in relation to policymaking maybe characterized by an ill condition of actors with scarce capital (scholars) competing against actors with surplus capital (politicians).

 

But with the scholar’s recognition on the need to influence policymaking, it is indispensable first, for the scholar to accept the present situation with humility and hope. Modesty is the understanding that politics is a life that is independent of the theories and speculations of the academe. It is a being that can only be understood by assuming and presupposing nothing since nothing is permanent in any political construct. Instead, politics can only be or can be best understood by temporarily abandoning the security of scholastic prejudgment and momentarily living a life of a politician (verstehen – emphatic understanding).

 

Hope, however, springs from the eternal nobility of a dialogue allowing the politician and the scholar to achieve a unity of purpose and a symphony of action for public administration. 

 

It is proposed that sound policymaking requires the collaboration of primary institutions. The dominance of one institution in understanding the varieties of human conditions is destined to fail since its intellectual resources are too narrow, and the universe is too complex (Comte 1896). 

 

Thus, the starting place as well as the arrival of this paper resides on the fact that policymaking is all about the accumulation of capital (Bourdieu 1986). This model allows the agencies to become conscious of their roles and locations in the interplay of power-capital in relation to statecraft.  

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Recent research in public administration and policy emphasizes the role of public servants beyond as policy executers, by paying attention to their active roles in policy making and evaluation processes (Arnold 2015; De Vries, Bekkers, and Tummers 2016; Lavee and Cohen 2019). However, who are motivated to become policy entrepreneurs and how they do so are relatively overlooked in the literature, particularly in the local government context. This article contributes experimental evidence to this growing literature with a large survey sample of more than 2,000 local civil servants from South Korea. Specifically, three factors are examined to address these questions concerning policy entrepreneurship in local government: 1) How intergovernmental relations shape public servants’ willingness to play more active roles in policy making and evaluation processes; 2) whether intrinsic versus extrinsic motivation have a stronger impact on policy entrepreneurship; and 3) whom local civil servants are willing to discuss in policy making and evaluation processes. Using indirect questioning methods, such as list and endorsement experiments, an analysis of original survey data will add value to the literature with important policy implications.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Section 23 of Article II of the 1987 Philippine Constitution states that the participation of non-governmental, community-based, and other sectoral organizations shall be encouraged by the State. Likewise, Section 67 of Republic Act No. 10964 (General Appropriations Act of 2018) allows national government agencies to partner with civil society organizations (CSOs) in implementing specific programs and projects.

This paper examines the role of CSOs in local public finance in the Philippines. It specifically covers the local government unit of Echague, Isabela, a first-class municipality located in southern Isabela Province. Eighteen accredited CSOs for 2019-2022 were noted in Echague, Isabela, which is a manifestation of the CSOs’ commitment to formalize their engagement with the LGU.

This is a project that was funded by the Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) through its Technical Assistance Program for Local Resource Institutes to empower the CSOs. Specifically, it aims to identify the accredited CSOs, determine their level of engagement in public procurement, and capacitate CSOs to sustain their participation in local public finance.

Civil society organizations were found to be effective in enabling services, According to the accredited CSOs, their participation in government processes is vital for providing check and balance and exacting accountability. They believed that active CSO participation is an indicator of healthy participatory governance. However, they face key challenges in their recognition and procurement expertise.

 

Keywords: Civil Society Organizations; Local Government Units; Local Public Finance; Philippines

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

From an independent communication practitioner perspective, a guidance coordinator's duty and responsibility to formulate guidance policies for the district can provide due care in a real-time response for the educational community. Why does a guidance coordinator craft a guidance policy? How can due care be attained in guidance policy formulation? How can a DepED School District, at its governance level, produce a better policy that could lead to effective public service? Based on these questions, this paper aims to illustrate the significance of critical communication in a guidance coordinator's duty and responsibility to formulate the district's guidance policy in a DepEd School District in Elementary Schools. With effect from the Key Responsibility Areas (KRAs) of a Principal's position title, functional due care could harmoniously support an innovative guidance policy to provide preventive care to both learners and employees. In this paper, the tenets of (a) guidance policy formulation rationale, (b) composite Science of Delivery (SOD) in Knowledge Management (KM), and (c) proposed innovative district policy for a range-based ranking of ranks in the declaration of school district curricular contest winners and school curricular contest winners are posited. It is autonomous to explain the critical communication that connects to a better policy leading to effective public service. An innovative policy's greater access, timely response, quality care, and child-friendly trauma-preventive intervention at zero cost could be attributed to the issuance of DepEd Orders and DepEd Memorandums, Science of Delivery, and Knowledge Management. These elements are critical in developing a nondiscriminatory guidance policy. Guidance counselors' openness to working as a team with principals is a practical zero-cost advantage in public service outflow and increased participation rate inflow. Functional due care converges on the importance of teachers and guidance counselors as partners in inclusive transparency. It complements learning from DepEd issuances as it safeguards participation and mental health.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

1.  Background

The Ministry of Personnel Management (MPM), newly established in November 2014 to strengthen the openness and expertise of public officials, is the Central Personnel Management Agency in charge of the personnel system of the Korean government. The MPM, which has been striving for personnel innovation, such as civil servant pension reform, open career system, and the introduction of the professional civil service system, established the Department for International Cooperation on July 23, 2019 to proactively and systematically respond to the growing interest and demand for personnel administration consulting. Three years after the establishment of a dedicated department, it is necessary to look back on the footsteps and briefly look into the future direction of international cooperation in personnel administration.

 

2. Expanding the Scope of International Cooperation in Personnel Administration

Since the launch of MPM, the number of foreign public officials visiting the MPM to learn the Korean personnel system has gradually increased, and that of foreign governments, international organizations and institutions signing a memorandum of understanding (for cooperation) with our Ministry to share experiences in personnel management has also increased rapidly. Until the first half of 2017, the only agencies that signed new agreements in personnel administration were the Human Resources Management Service of the Government of the Republic of Serbia and the Turkish Personnel Office, however, the scope of international cooperation has expanded as new agreements were signed with a total of 8 institutions by the end of 2019, including Uzbekistan’s Ministry of Employment and Labor, the Cabinet Secretariat of Government of Mongolia, the Astana Civil Service Hub (ACSH) and the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB). In May of last year, when face-to-face exchanges were difficult due to the spread of the COVID-19, the MPM signed a memorandum of cooperation in personnel administration with the Ministry of Human Resource and Social Development of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.

In 2020, international exchange and cooperation projects were carried out in a non-face-to-face manner due to COVID-19, which made it difficult to efficiently promote those projects. However, we had video conferences several times and continued to communicate with our counterparts to agree on the draft of memorandum of understanding (for cooperation) with Uzbekistan’s Civil Service Development Agency and Kyrgyzstan’s State Personnel Agency. In addition, on October 28 in 2021, we held a signing ceremony of a memorandum of understanding via a video conference with the Ministry of Civil Service of Cambodia, one of the new southern countries. Additionally, the MPM has agreed with the Personnel Committee of the Ministry of Administrative and Bureaucratic Reform of Indonesia and the IDB to continue cooperation and has been preparing to renew a memorandum of understanding.

 

3. Research Inquiries

Against this backdrop of MPM’s ODA policies for promoting International Cooperation in Personnel Administration, on the basis of a qualitative research approach, this study tries to explore and test a set of research inquiries. First, what are the institutional, organizational, and political roles of MPM in designing and implementing ODA policies? Second, How and to what extent such factors as leadership, organizational structures, cultures, and strategies, HRM, communication, network, etc. would affect the ODA policy success or failure? Third, what is the state of internal ODA policymaking processes, dynamics, and mechanisms within MPM? Fourth, what are the main internal and external environmental conditions (e.g., strengths, opportunities, weaknesses, and threats) in implementing MPM’s ODA policies? What is the best way to overcome these limitations and to enhance policy outcome performance?

  In order to explore and confirm these research questions, this study will adopt in-depth qualitative research methods (i.e., focus group interviews, case and content analyses, and on-line surveys). Drawing upon these findings, this study will propose policy implications and caveats for more successful agency policymaking processes and outcomes.

 

CO-AUTHORS
Eunice Teodoro (University of the Philippines Diliman)
ABSTRACT

Theoretically speaking, government agencies are considered direct and official participants in policymaking at the national level. In the policy development process, they are expected to be actively involved in the development of public policies and their implementation. In the Philippines, while many studies had been conducted on public policies enacted by the national legislature, still, not much is known about the internal processes of policymaking of government and their roles in national public policy development. Therefore, this exploratory study seeks to discern the roles of and patterns in the policymaking of national government agencies. Specifically, it aims to answer the following panel questions: What is the role of agencies in public policymaking? What is the state of internal policymaking in them? How well-developed is the internal policymaking in these agencies? What are the dynamics involved? For this purpose, the policy development processes of seven government agencies were investigated by the researchers using the institutionalist approach. The seven agencies consist of a science high school system, a bureau, a law enforcement agency, a public enterprise, a presidential commission, and two departments representing the education, finance, peace and order, water resources, urban poor, social welfare, and migrant labor sectors, respectively,  Interviews or focus group discussion were conducted among key informants and relevant documents were studied. In a nutshell, the major findings from these seven case studies are: that while many of these agencies have developed manuals or flow process charts for policymaking, the processes are incomplete because most of them end at either the approval of the policy or their dissemination; most of the policies are limited to internal policies, and their processes in contributing to public policies at the national level are not clear; and, the stakeholders or their “publics,” in some of these agencies, are not involved in the policymaking processes. The implication of these findings is that if these trends among the seven agencies are the norms in the national bureaucracy of the country, the practice of Public Policy could only be halfway ingrained in the Philippine administrative system.

CO-AUTHORS
Masao Kikuchi (Meiji University)
ABSTRACT

This paper explores what improves residents' trust in local government, focusing on the Philippines as a case. Trust in government affects government performance. Fujii (2006), who examined the relationship between public works projects by Japan's central government and government trust, points out that "ensuring transparency" and the attitude of "carrying out public works for a good cause" increase residents' trust in government and make it easier to implement public works projects. Murayama et al. (2021) also found that prefectures in Japan with stronger ties among residents and higher government trust had lower mortality rates from new coronavirus infection, based on a survey conducted between August and September 2020.

What influences trust in government? Oyama (2010) distinguished between factors that define trust in government that relate to characteristics on the government side and those that relate to characteristics on the citizen side, and examined which factor defines trust in government. He found that although the most significant factor defining government trust is government performance, the most important factor on the citizen side is political participation. Chida and Arai (2011) point out that if individuals frequently use local government services and facilities and frequently attend government-sponsored events, they are likely to strongly trust the local government. Furthermore, they believe that trust would be further increased if citizens could participate in some way in local government planning. They also point out that, in the case of local governments, the dissemination of information by the government itself affects residents' trust in the government. OECD, which conducted a project to measure the drivers of trust in democratic government, notes that South Korea, one of East Asia's democracies, needs to better listen to and engage its citizens in order to increase government trust (OECD/KDI 2018).

Given the above points, we use statistical analysis to identify what drives government trust in the Philippines. For this purpose, we use the results of our 2019 public opinion survey on the local governance. The analysis will test how residents' relationship with local government, information dissemination by local government, and residents' political opinions affect their trust in local government.

 

 

References

1. Chida, Ryoukichi and Arai, Kazuhiro (2011), “Determinants of Trust in Local Government: Comparison with Central Government (Chihouseifu ni taisuru Shinrai no Ketteiyouin)”, Hitotsubashi economics; Vol. 4, No. 1, pp. 950129.

 

2. Fujii, Satoshi (2006), “Public Trust in Government: Building Trust through Public Works for a Good Cause (Seifu ni taisuru Kokumin no Shinrai)”, Proceedings of JSCE; 807/IV-70, pp.29-41.

 

3. Murayama H, Nakamoto I, Tabuchi T. (2021). “Social Capital and COVID-19 Deaths: An Ecological Analysis in Japan”. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health; 18(20): 10982.

 

4. OECD/KDI (2018), Understanding the Drivers of Trust in Government Institutions in Korea, Building Trust in Public Institutions, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264308992-en.

 

5. Oyana, Kousuke (2010), “Factors on the Government and Citizen Sides of Administrative Trust: Focusing on Data from the World Values Survey 2005 (Gyoseishinrai no Seifugawa to Shimingawa no Youin)”, The Annuals of Japanese Political Science Association; Vol. 61, No.1, pp. 31-48.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

A number of government actors control the actions of administrative agencies in the Philippines. One such actor is the judiciary, with the Supreme Court at the apex of its hierarchy. Through its power of judicial review, and by exercising its role as the ultimate arbiter of legal issues, the SC influences how administrative agencies perform its mandate, and specially, how they develop policy through their rule-making and adjudication functions.

 

The Philippine Supreme Court has, time and again, emphasized the significance of administrative agencies; for instance, it has described them collectively as the “fourth branch of government.” It has also reiterated in a long line of cases that delegation of power to these bodies is the rule, rather than the exception. However, the Court has also, in a great number of decisions, invalidated agency actions which have diminished the import of the norm. By wielding judicial review, and through inconsistent jurisprudence, it has weakened the power of administrative agencies. In other words, the Court has maintained a “push and pull” attitude on agency policy development.

 

Using multiple case studies and reviews of Court decisions, this paper explores the dynamics between the judiciary and administrative agencies in the Philippines. In particular, this paper shows how the Philippine Supreme Court shapes the adjudication and rule-making power of administrative agencies. It explains the impact of these judicial pronouncements on administrative policy. It also suggests a framework- a set of parameters- on how the Court can strike a balance between an eager approach to review of agency interpretations, on one hand, and restraint through deference to agency actions, on the other.

CO-AUTHORS
Gydabelle Olaya
MILD HOMBREBUENO
ABSTRACT

The Civil Service Comission (CSC) 2017 Omnibus Rules on Appointments and Other Human Resource Actions (ORAOHRA) governs all actions pertaining to appointments and other human resource movements in government owned institutions and agencies in the Philippines. Said ORAOHRA was revised in July 2018 to include amendments as a result of the Levelling of Interpretation on the original ORAOHRA done by the CSC to ensure that the provisions contained therein are in accordance with other administrative issuances and other pertinent laws. From this experience, it is assumed that there may be future amendments, as agencies implement the provisions of ORAOHRA.

This paper studies the dynamics of internal policymaking as policy makers and officials involved in the recruitment of personnel needed by the organization interpret and reinterpret policies as they implement hiring protocols, procedures and rules pertaining to recruitment. for this paper, the focus is on the implementation of policies pertaining to the recruitment of applicants to the organization, as well as practices and procedures that have evolved over the years in the process of implementing the rules prescribed in the ORAOHRA, using the case study approach to generate an in-depth, multifaceted understanding of internal policymaking in its real life context. The approach uses both retrospective and introspective techniques to include both in-depth and historical information on the phenomenon being studied.

This study fits Panel 04 under TO5, since it is about policy formulation, administration and policymakers, and takes a closer look into the dynamics of internal policymaking. The research may elicit deeper insights not only into the dynamics of internal policymaking but it may also identify best or worst practices in the implementation of national policies and how these may eventually contribute to the improvement of public service and policy formulation on the national level.

CO-AUTHORS
Ixchel Pérez-Durán (Universitat Autónoma de Barcelona)
Yannis Papadopoulos (University of Lausanne)
ABSTRACT

Regulatory bodies (RAs) have been conceived as expert bodies able to enhance the credible commitment problem of policies due to their technical capacities and knowledge (Majone, 1994). In contrast to other political organizations, it might be argued that RAs do not need to fulfill social representation. However, previous studies (Jasanoff, 2011; Krick, 2018; Pérez-Durán and Bravo-Laguna, 2019) have emphasized that expert bodies and their members also need to meet some requirements related to: (i) the reliability of their knowledge and competence; and (ii) the credibility of their independence -as opposing to bias- in their background and professional trajectories. For this reason, our purpose is to examine representation in RAs and its potential effects on the risks of cultural capture and the lack of critical mass and plurality of voices in their regulatory process. To this end, we propose answering the following questions: To what extent do regulatory bodies have representative bureaucracy in regulatory domains? To what extent does such representative bureaucracy affect the risk of cultural capture in regulatory domains? We respond to the questions by examining an original biographical dataset developed in the H2020 TiGRE (Trust in Governance and Regulation in Europe) with 1070 profiles covering members of national (Belgium, Denmark, Germany, Israel, Spain, Switzerland) and EU agencies in three policy sectors, finance, data protection and food safety.  In particular, we focused on examining: agency heads, members of management boards (or similar bodies); members of stakeholder bodies/advisory boards (or similar bodies), and top high-ranking officials (i.e. directors and sub-directors). Through our study, we seek to provide insights about  the extent to which diversity is present in regulatory bodies; the extent to which critical mass is needed in expert bodies and regulatory domains; and finally,  to contribute to the debate of democratization in expert bodies. All in all, our results contribute to critiques that signal the potential (lack of) representation within these bodies and the dangers of a cultural capture in regulatory policies.

 

Our paper is strongly connected to the theme of IPPA’s panel on “Agency Policymaking: Dynamics and Contributions to National Public Policies” as it precisely looks for answers to the questions: What is the state of internal policymaking in agencies? how well-developed is the internal policymaking in agencies? What are the dynamics involved? These questions are strongly connected to organizational dynamics linked to the governance of these public bodies.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Barangay (literally “village” in English) is the basic politico-administrative unit in the Philippines that is at the frontline of public service for its residents ranging between a hundred to tens of thousands. According to the 1991 Local Government Code, barangays serve as the primary planning and implementing units of government policies, plans, programs, projects, and activities in the community. It is in the barangays that residents are able to articulate their issues, problems, and concerns. Most of the relevant literature about it delves on legislating barangay ordinances or resolutions, which is only halfway through the entire policymaking process. Furthermore, there is a question on the “policymaking space” of barangays because their policymaking authority is already limited given that there are too many of them handed down by national government agencies and local government units (provincial, city/municipal) for implementation. In addition, some of the studies do not dwell on the dynamics of policymaking involving the residents. Therefore, there is a need to conduct a deeper institutional study on the practices of barangay policy development processes. This paper aims to investigate how policymaking is officially conducted in barangays with a special focus on the participation of the residents. For this purpose, four barangays located in four cities (Pasig, Quezon City, Makati, and Tagum) were investigated. They were chosen based on the reported “best practices” in their policymaking. The researchers interviewed key informants mostly barangay officials, conducted focus group discussions with them together with the residents, examined the contents of their ordinances and resolutions, and poured over their manuals and relevant documents. The major finding of the study is that “policymaking” and “policy analysis” are still foreign concepts among the barangay officials. Being at the frontline of public service, their policymaking processes are strong in the participation of their residents but they are unequipped with the technicalities of policy analysis, implementation, and assessment (i.e., monitoring and evaluation). Still, there are nuggets of wisdom that could be learned from their experiences in local policy development in their own ways.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The global adoption of modern biotechnology in agriculture, particularly in plants and plant products, has been quite impressive. From the 1.7 million hectares reported when biotech crops were first commercially grown in 1996, latest figures from the International Service for the Acquisition of Agri-biotech Applications (ISAAA 2020) reveal that 23 years later, about 190.4 million hectares of farmland have been devoted to biotech crops in 2019, spread across 29 countries and planted by approximately 17 million farmers from both developing and developed countries. In spite of its widespread commercial planting and direct use for human food or animal feed, different countries have set in place different policies and regulations that can either facilitate or stifle their adoption of this technology to agriculture and the domestic economy at large. One of the essential elements that differentiates these issuances is the source of the basic policy formulation – as a law enacted by the national legislature or as a policy directive emanating from a regulatory agency of the executive branch. There are historical, legal, institutional, and political reasons behind the policy-formulation route taken by a particular country, and this will be the main focus of this study, as it surveys and compares the basic policies on biotech regulation in the Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, and Vietnam. The lead policymaking bodies will be identified and the role they played will be substantially discussed. This paper will also examine the policy implication of taking such route, how it may have affected the adoption and use of the technology in agriculture and commerce. It will strive to answer an important and timely question: on highly technical matters such as in modern agricultural biotechnology, which policymaking and regulatory-formulating route leads to more effective public service? Which route better serves the people that are the intended beneficiaries of these new interventions? Aside from documentary analysis of pertinent laws, policies, regulations, and similar issuances on modern biotechnology from the five case countries mentioned above, the author intends to conduct in-depth interviews with key informants from these countries to be able to answer the research problems that have been put forward.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper will discuss the role of international financial institutions (IFIs) in supporting the policy reforms and development expenditure programs of their borrowing member countries. Based on a review of policies, programs, reports, and publications, including interviews of selected staff of IFIs and governments, this paper will explain the pathways through which IFIs such as the Asian Development Bank (ADB) and the World Bank (WB) create opportunities for government agencies to formulate better policies and to implement them more efficiently and effectively. These pathways, which remain largely unknown or unclear to many scholars and practitioners include loans, grants, technical assistance, and knowledge work.
 
As one of ADB’s lending modalities, policy-based lending (PBL) – which is the equivalent of WB’s development policy financing – is linked to the implementation of priority policy reforms in developing countries that can generate sector-wide and economy wide impacts. It is an important instrument for initiating long-term public sector reforms and can be used in many sectors. PBLs support economic management, institutional development, structural transformation, and sector policy reforms. PBLs can focus on macroeconomic management and fiscal policy, competition policy, capital market development, climate resilience, disaster preparedness, human capital development, social protection, decentralization, governance, access to finance among others. Reform programs supported by PBLs may include formulation or amendment of policies, laws, and regulations to address structural bottlenecks and measures to enhance capacities of public institutions.  
 
This paper will also discuss how PBLs are complemented and reenforced by grants, technical assistance, and knowledge pieces, which are mobilized to provide evidence-based and well-considered advice on formulating and implementing reform programs as well as enhancing the know-how of policymakers and implementors.
 
Alongside the benefits from the pathways mentioned above that can be derived by developing countries, this paper will likewise discuss the pitfalls, caveats, and areas for improvement.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

While education is often facing bureaucratic delays and digital transformations, not enough time or other valuable resources are being spent on its counter intuitive chum. Non-formal and in various ways the informal education are left to battle their own conflicts. This paper provides the outline and analysis of Erasmus+ Key Action initiatives in the non-formal sector within Germany and the EU. It analysis the investment and importance of joint educational framework that incorporates a number of pathways to address learning in pupils and the populace.

 

In network society as described by Manuel Castells, nodes are the collectors and distributors of information and can be thought of as educational hubs. Although the formal education structures like the schools and libraries are becoming obsolete, particularly as was evident during the Covid-19 pandemic around the world, digital learning and educational hubs are not only premiering but possibly replacing the old ways of teaching and learning. Artificial initiatives like personalized learning algorithms, along with the help of open source ChatGPT are providing more individualized approach to and possibly for the student. Answering, exchanging and providing space for deep and thought provoking realizations.

 

As the world transformation continues and human reliance on machines becomes ever more necessary, the formal education will continue to focus by uniting students in providing them space and time for formation and possible motivation. Allowing pupils to acquire certain norms and become social citizens. On the other hand, the curriculum and certain assessments will be left for the machine algorithms. To sum-up, this paper examines how do societies face the current and upcoming challenges as it relates to formal education in the schools and how does the informal & non-formal education propagate learning that will become ever more necessary.

 

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The Philippine Department of Education (DepEd) has issued a landmark policy in 2013 called the “Enhanced Basic Education Act of 2012” or RA10553 which added two more years in basic education that will equip learners with skills that prepare them for the future. Through the years, the Philippine government continues to invest significant resources to improve quality and access to basic education Mirasol et al 2021. The Philippines expected improvements in national, regional and international assessment. For example, for the NAT taken by Grades 6 to 12, the performance of students have been declining, placing them at “low mastery” or low proficiency (DepEd Region, 2019).  In 2018, the Philippines ranked 79th out of 79 participating countries in the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA). In particular, fifteen-year-old students in the Philippines scored lower in reading, mathematics and science than those in most of the countries and economies that participated in PISA 2018. The South East Asia -Primary Learning Metrics (SEA-PLM) 2019 study showed that only 10% of Filipino Grade 5 students were able to meet the reading proficiency level at the end of primary education. With these alarming state of education in the Philippines, the  current President of the Republic of the Philippines has ordered the Philippine Department of Education to introduce drastic reforms in the DepEd’s K to 12 policy. It is within this context that this paper would like to look into the role of the Philippine Department of Education in education policy-making. In particular, the paper will attempt to answer the following questions: (1) What is the role of DepEd in influencing policy makers to amend RA10553? (2) Are there areas for autonomous public policymaking reserved for the DepEd? (3) What factors affect their participation in policy making? And finally (4) what are some proposed mechanisms to enhance the participation in policy making.
 
References:
Joy Molina Mirasol, Joanne Vivien Belderol Necosia, Beverly Badajos Bicar, Helen Pelandas Garcia (2021). Statutory policy analysis on access to Philippine quality basic education, International Journal of Educational Research Open,Volume 2, 100093 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijedro.2021.100093 accessed on Jan 30, 2023 at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2666374021000637)
OECD (2019), PISA 2018 Results (Volume I): What Students Know and Can Do, PISA, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/5f07c754-en.
UNICEF (2022). What does SEA-PLM 2019 tell us about child well-being and learning in six Southeast Asian countries? United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) East Asia and Pacific Regional Office (EAPRO) and UNICEF Office of Research – Innocenti. Accessed at https://www.unicef.org/eap/reports/child-well-being-and-learning
 

CO-AUTHORS
Magnus Emmendoerfer (Universidade Federal de Viçosa - UFV / UNESCO CHAIR CEPPBRASIL )
Josiel Valadares (Universidade Federal de Viçosa)
Tamiris Resende (Prefeitura Municipal de Belo Horizonte)
ABSTRACT

Contextualization: In the complex scenario coming from globalization, public universities have been undergoing transformation caused by new social demands and the inclusion of new technologies, demanding the ability to debate and implement entrepreneurial actions (Cai & Etzkowitz, 2020). Thus, entrepreneurial orientation (EO) emerges as an important strategic construct to stimulate entrepreneurship in public organizations through new processes, practices, and activities aimed at organizational development (Diefenbach, 2011; Emmendoerfer, 2019). Within public universities, it is believed that these practices can be important personnel development policies, stimulating an academic culture that leads them to act in an innovative, proactive, competitive way and to take risks since they seek external financial resources and application of scientific knowledge, aiming at a promising posture for the future (Ruiz, 2018).

Research problem: What is the evidence in the international literature of personnel development policies based on Entrepreneurial Orientation (EO) in public universities? This article aimed to analyze in the international literature evidence of theoretical and empirical studies that demonstrate the application and results of the EO as a policy of personnel development in public universities.

Methodology: Considering the proposed objective, this is a bibliographic research of exploratory-descriptive level. A systematic literature review will be conducted in Scopus and Web of Science international databases. As search strings will be used "entrepreneurial orientation" AND "universities"; "public universities" AND "entrepreneurship"; "entrepreneurial orientation" AND "public universities." A priori exclusion criteria will not be adopted to allow a complete view of the phenomenon. The PRISMA method (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses) will be used as a strategy of systematization and discussion of the results alongside the content analysis technique. One proposition to be verified from data analysis is the appropriation of The EO centered on graduate students.

Panel Applicability: The UNESCO Chair on Creative Economy and Public Policies: governing through alternative economic models and creative policy solutions aims to discuss possibilities and actions to stimulate creativity and governance. In this sense, it is believed that the article can contribute to the discussion of stimulating creativity and innovation of public servants, as well as in the change in educational and governance policies of public universities, stimulating local and regional cooperation by inserting universities as a protagonist for sustainable development.

 

References
Cai, Y., & Etzkowitz, H. (2020). Theorizing the Triple Helix model: Past, present, and future. Triple Helix, 7(2/3), 189-226.

Diefenbach, F. E. (2011). Entrepreneurial orientation in the public sector. (Doctoral dissertation). University of St. Gallen, St. Gallen, Switzerland.
Emmendoerfer, M. L. (2019). Inovação e empreendedorismo no setor público. Brasília: Enap.
Ruiz, S. M. A. (2018). Universidade empreendedora: proposição de um modelo para as instituições de ensino superior públicas brasileiras. Tese (Doutorado em Administração), Universidade Nove de Julho – UNINOVE, São Paulo, SP, Brasil.

CO-AUTHORS
MILD HOMBREBUENO
Catherine Dela Cruz (Nueva Vizcaya State University)
ABSTRACT

Recruitment protocols and practices in chartered colleges and universities in the Philippines, just like in other government agencies, are governed by the provisions of the Civil Service Commission(CSC) 2017 Omnibus Rules on Appointments and Other Human Resource Actions (ORAOHRA), while promotions are based on the common criteria for evaluation guidelines as prescribed in the National Budget Circular 461 (NBC 461). In the process of implementing policies and procedures stipulated in the ORAOHRA and the NBC 461, internal policies and procedures as well as practices have evolved over the years.

This paper studies how two universities from one region, sharing many things in common, including governing policies, differ in the implementation of identical hiring and promotion protocols. The comparative study focuses on recruitment and promotion policies and procedures as interpreted and implemented by the two universities. The first part of the study consists of document scanning and analysis of the same governing policies that pertain to recruitment and promotion, as well as the internal policies formulated by both universities in implementing the national policies. The second part of the study uses face to face interviews with internal policymakers and decision-makers in the organization. The third part of the study draws comparisons between how the two universities have been implementing promotion policies inntwo cycles and recruitment practices of both over the past five years.

This paper is being submitted for consideration to this panel, Panel 04, T05, because it focuses on internal policymaking while it considers the dynamics behind recruitment and promotion in two state universities. Eventually, internal policies that evolve from the implementers of national policies, may serve as bases for the formulation of new policies or the amendment of existing policies.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The legislation and policymaking process in the Philippines, particularly in local government units (LGUs), is a conundrum. The prevailing practice raises questions about its crafting and the level of difficulty in creating accurate, fair, objective, and impactful policies. These are considered essential characteristics of all policies, as they are expected to secure and promote the welfare of constituents. The basis and substance of local legislations and policies adopted and implemented have long eluded public scrutiny.

 

As representatives of the people, local legislators and policymakers are accountable for satisfactorily addressing questions about the construction of statutes and policies. This includes evidence provided to support and validate the legislation, the sources used to inform the legislation (e.g. sectors, specialists, scientists, and ordinary people), and whether the legislation was informed by testing, study, application, and review. Effective governance requires considering both the scientific and participatory aspects of the legislative and policymaking process, leading to evidence-based decision making.

 

This paper argues for the significance of science (both substance and process) and participatory aspects in local legislation and policymaking, which are integral to the principles of Good Governance, particularly accountability and participation. The role of science in providing a deeper understanding of accountability in public service and building trust and confidence among the public is emphasized. The participatory process highlights the importance of incorporating a human element in science. This study aims to assess the level of utilization of evidence, public consultations, and involvement of specialists, researchers, and scientists in local legislation and policymaking in the Philippines. It also examines the resources available for developing data and knowledge capacity, evaluating the impact of legislation and policies, and investigating the correlation between evidence in legislation and policies and the public's level of trust and confidence.

 

Given the realities and limitations of local government units (LGUs), the paper argues that the growth of science and participatory policymaking are crucial to addressing challenges and advancing governance.

Keywords: science, evidence- based, participatory