Format

P03. Administrative Processes in the Digital Era

POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Sarah Giest
Leiden University
Main chair
Justin Longo
University of Regina
Second chair
Ian Roberge
York University
Third chair
Francesco Leoni
Politecnico di Milano
Fourth chair
Erin McAuliffe
Politecnico di Milano
Fifth chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

This panel will take stock and look to the future of administrative processes in the digital era. The digital revolution, with the shift from mechanical and analog technology to digital electronics, has been underway for more than half a century. Governments in all regions of the world are undergoing digital transformations: organizations are increasingly conducting operations digitally or even automatically while connecting digitally among each other and with citizens. In this panel, we build on prior work on the intersection of agency, structure, and technology (Orlikowski 1992; Giddens 1994) as well as more recent work on the shifting role of bureaucrats in an increasingly digitized and automated environment (Buffat 2015; Giest and Klievink 2022; Longo 2022).

In this context, the panel will address larger themes in current e-governance and digital policy and public administration literature, which include:

 

*How digitization is affecting governments, and public administration, in different regions of the world especially in light of how the COVID pandemic has influenced developments;

*The role of digitization in specific government processes including government procurement, financial and human resources management, administration of justice and the courts, etc.;

*Digitization in select public policy fields such as healthcare, communications, transportation, the environment, and consumer and financial regulation;

*Digitization in the policy process especially considering issues such as AI, ethics, privacy, big data, and regulator technology; and finally

*The impact of digitization on individuals and groups within – and outside – government, paying special attention to the fact that digitization not only creates information asymmetry among government and citizens, but also disadvantages certain groups of citizens. This also includes an examination of the impact of digitization on citizens including positive and exclusionary effects accounting for gender, age discrimination, marginalized and racialized communities, as well as rural communities.

 

By combining these themes, we aim to fill a gap in the current research landscape by integrating research on bureaucratic structures and digital or automated decision-making processes from the perspective of both public servants and citizens. More broadly, this panel will provide a comprehensive and rich overview of the effects and prospects of public administration in the digital era.

 

 

References:

Buffat, A. 2015. Street-Level Bureaucracy and E-Government. Public Management Review 17(1), 149-161.

Giddens, A. 1994. The Constitutions of Society. Oxford: Polity Press.

Giest, Sarah and Bram Klievink. 2022. More than a digital system: How AI is changing the role of bureaucrats in different organizational contexts. Public Management Review, DOI: 10.1080/14719037.2022.2095001.

Longo, J. 2022. When Artificial Intelligence Meets Real Public Administration. Canadian Public Administration, 65(2), 389-393. DOI: 10.1111/capa.12465

Orlikowski, W. 1992. The duality of technology: Rethinking the concept of technology in organizations. Organization Science 3(3), 398–427.

CALL FOR PAPERS

The panel addresses the digital transformation of administrative processes by building on a longer history of digitization research as well as more recent developments on automation or the use of artificial intelligence tools. In order to grasp the myriads of ways in which public administration is being transformed, this panel specifically looks for contributions on:

 

*The intersection of digital applications and existing administrative structures and processes including, but not limited to, government procurement, financial and human resources management, administration of justice and the courts;

*The changing administrative tasks, roles, and discretion of bureaucrats;

*Digitalization in the policy process linked to, among other possibilities, AI, ethics, privacy rights, big data, regulator technology, and digitalization in select policy fields such as healthcare, communications, the environment, and finance; and,

*The differentiated impact of digitization on citizens accounting for gender, age discrimination, marginalized and racialized communities, as well as rural communities

 

We invite theoretical and methodological papers as well as empirical work from different parts of the world. The cases can include reports on both successful and unsuccessful public sector digital initiatives. We further hope to engage in a lively discussion on shifts in public administration over time and the larger effects of this on the government-citizen relationship, including potential ‘blind spots’ of policymaking that these processes create.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Fintech, RegTech, SupTech: Digital Administration in (and the limits of) Financial Governance
Malcolm Campbell-Verduyn (University of Groningen)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper analyses the growing application of emergent technologies to regulatory activities, focusing on financial governance. We trace how RegTechs were developed primary as supervisory technologies (SupTech) for regulators coping with the flurry of new financial technology (FinTech) products based on novel technologies like blockchains. The ‘turn’ towards RegTech and SupTech that Fintech engendered reflects incremental efforts to keep pace with such market developments. It has had two paradoxical implications for global financial governance. First, and despite arising in the wake of the 2008 global financial crisis, RegTech and SupTech shy away from offering tools for addressing macroprudential issues such as systemic instability. We trace back this evolution to the underlying model supporting data-based solutions, often taking the form of binary yet complex processes focused on individual users, rather than more systemic perspectives. Second, and in contrast to the democratizing promises heralded by FinTech, SupTech and RegTech advance even more technocratic forms of financial governance that performs a rigidified type of normativity closing, rather than opening up, possibilities. Together, the turn towards more digital administration in financial governance counter rather than support much-needed efforts to inject stability and democracy in financial regulation.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Development of AI assisted processes in public sector organisations: Lessons from the AI initiatives of Estonian Tax and Customs Board
Kerli Onno (Tallinn University of Technology)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Recent years have brought scholars’ attention to the potential of artificial intelligence supported transformation in public administration. This interest is accompanied by wide range of research on the topic, including value propositions of AI (see, for example Borges et al 2020, Wirtz et al 2019, Kouziokas 2017), success factors and enablers to make AI projects happen (see, for example Noordt & Misuraca 2022, Hamm & Klesel 2021, Keding 2021) or risks that it entails (see, for example Young et al. 2019). However, the knowledge about whether and how artificial intelligence supports transformation of existing routines of public sector remains scarce.   

 

Theoretical approaches and empirical studies often explore the AI landscape top-down, including  studies of strategy documents (see Noordt et al. 2020; Fatima et al 2022) or attempts to outline factors or patterns based on existing literature on the topic (Hamm & Klesel 2021). However, researchers have already pointed to a necessity to assess the impact of AI on organisational processes within public sector (van Noordt & Misuraca 2020). Such studies could lead to deeper knowledge about the influence of AI solutions on existing processes and routines of public administration, but also illustrate the reasons for its absence.

 

This paper is a case study of implementing AI in Estonian Tax and Customs Board (ETCB). The case was selected due to the diversity of different AI-related initiatives undertaken in recent years: including organisation-wide hackathon, development of risk assessment models, and development of AI strategy. Thus, it has potential to offer insights about the effects of different types of AI initiatives in the same setting. However, as these initiatives have not (yet) brought about profound changes in current work practices, they provide valuable insights into potential barriers to transforming public sector processes with the assistance of AI. Therefore, this study proposes a research question: What would it take to create AI-assisted change in existing public sector routines?

 

To explore the factors that support or hinder AI-assisted change in organisational processes, interviews with public servants at ETCB are conducted. Additionally, partners outside public sector (who provided competence and guidance with studied AI initiatives) are consulted. Combined with existing theoretical approaches on factors influencing AI implementation in public administration, this study helps to understand the aspects that influence the development of AI-enabled processes in public sector organisations. From theoretical perspective, this is a step towards conceptualising the role of AI in improving organisational capabilities.

 

This is an abstract submitted to panel T05P03 and is exploring the transformation of administrative processes with the assistance of AI tools.

 

References

 

Borges, A.F., Laurindo, F.J., Spínola, M.M., Gonçalves, R.F. and Mattos, C.A., 2021. The strategic use of artificial intelligence in the digital era: Systematic literature review and future research directions. International Journal of Information Management, 57, p.102225.

Hamm, P. and Klesel, M., 2021. Success Factors for the Adoption of Artificial Intelligence in Organizations: A Literature Review. In AMCIS.

Keding, C., 2021. Understanding the interplay of artificial intelligence and strategic management: four decades of research in review. Management Review Quarterly, 71(1), pp.91-134.

Kouziokas, G.N., 2017. The application of artificial intelligence in public administration for forecasting high crime risk transportation areas in urban environment. Transportation research procedia, 24, pp.467-473.

Noordt, C. V., Medaglia, R., & Misuraca, G. (2020). Stimulating the Uptake of AI in Public Administrations: Overview and Comparison of AI Strategies of European Member States . In S. Virkar, M. Janssen, I. Lindgren, U. Melin, F. Mureddu, P. Parycek, E. Tambouris, G. Schwabe, & H. J. Scholl (Eds.), Proceedings of Ongoing Research, Practitioners, Workshops, Posters, and Projects of the International Conference EGOV-CeDEM-ePart 2020 (pp. 269-277). Digital Government Society. CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol. 2797 http://dgsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/CEUR-WS-Proceedings-2020_Full-Manuscript.pdf

Noordt, C. V. and Misuraca, G., 2022. Exploratory insights on artificial intelligence for government in Europe. Social Science Computer Review, 40(2), pp.426-444.

Wirtz, B.W., Weyerer, J.C. and Geyer, C., 2019. Artificial intelligence and the public sector—applications and challenges. International Journal of Public Administration, 42(7), pp.596-615.

Young, M.M., Himmelreich, J., Bullock, J.B. and Kim, K.C., 2019. Artificial intelligence and administrative evil. Perspectives on Public Management and Governance, 4(3), pp.244-258.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Teaching public servants in the digital era
Maria Gintova (McMaster University)
CO-AUTHORS
Vasiliki Bednar (McMaster University)
ABSTRACT

As new technologies are rapidly being adopted in all areas of modern society, they also present an additional layer of complexity governments across the world have to navigate. Additionally, the COVID-19 pandemic played a significant role in accelerating digitization of public services and tested traditional government structures and policy-making processes in the face of uncertainty. This signals that public servants now need to identify new policy challenges early on as well as possess digital era knowledge and skills (e.g. agile project management and data analytics), while being able to challenge status quo and navigate existing government norms and processes. Thus, training of future public servants or professional development of those already in the public service need to be focused on developing the ability to recognize problems that have not yet been acknowledged, innovate within existing government constraints, effectively collaborate and communicate in multi-disciplinary teams, and look for solutions to address existing complex social, political and economic issues. This chapter explores how public servants should be trained to effectively face digital era challenges. Building on our experience in the Master of Public Policy in Digital Society program at McMaster University in Canada, we will discuss how its new curriculum that blends traditional university courses with skill development labs prepares students for the digital era public service careers.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Digital employment services: A case study on Workforce Australia
Sarah Ball (University of Queensland)
CO-AUTHORS
Jenny Lewis (University of Melbourne)
ABSTRACT
Governments are increasingly turning towards online platforms as a replacement for, or supplement to, bricks and mortar provision of government services. Welfare services, as one of the largest areas of government expenditure, are frequently the target of ever greater cost-savings by governments through these online platforms. The Australian Government has invested heavily in becoming a ‘leader of digital government’ (Digital Transformation Agency, 2021) in this space, partly through automating payments administration but also through seeking to ‘digitalise’ its public employment services. In 2022, it launched one of the world’s first digital-first employment services systems, Workforce Australia (WfA). The hope is that many jobseekers will self-service online, while face-to-face services provided by contracted providers will function as services of last resort for those with the most complex needs. In this presentation we will review the challenges and opportunities presented by this digital turn, drawing on research conducted with service providers to understand how they were preparing for the transition to WfA. These discussions revealed that engagement with digital solutions was limited at the front-line. There also remained significant concerns about how the transition to WfA would impact jobseekers, including issues with employer engagement in the digital environment and the effectiveness of tools for service targeting. Overall, while providers were optimistic about the potential for WfA they worried that ongoing challenges from past reforms, such as entrenched long-term unemployment and the largely administrative orientation of casework, were being glossed over in the pursuit of new digital tools.
ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Government Digital Capabilities: Connecting the Government Digital Transformation Paradigm
Larissa de Magalhães Santos ( University of the United Nations - Policy-Driven Electronic Governance Operational Unit (UNU-EGOV))
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In response to political, economic, and social pressures, the digital government transformation is evolving in its capabilities to interact with citizens and others, engage in cross-agency service delivery and offer service platforms.


The covid-19 pandemic has been a capacity test for countries to lead toward digital transformation with emerging technologies proactively. As the complexity of issues and political pressures that affect government digital transformation strategies increases, public sector organizations seek to design processes and manage resources, competencies, and competencies to perform public functions as additional efforts in the search for results.

It is known that digital transformation leads to the emergence of new governance paradigms (Janowski, 2015). It is only possible to talk about the Digital Transformation of the government by referring to changes in public governance models. Research (see Nielsen, Jordanoski, 2020) indicates that the relative success of digital transformation strategies depends on governance (process model), coordination (leader), and intergovernmental cooperation (alliances).


The literature assumes that the public sector must acquire and reconfigure organizational and dynamic capabilities to carry out the digital transformation of government (Vignieri, Zeinali, 2022).

That is, to develop dynamic capabilities to detect ideas and products, capture critical knowledge, obtain external resources and craft a new business model; reconfigure and transform the organization with new assets and patterns (Teece, 2009, 2014, 2022)


However, there needs to be more research on governance paradigms in digital transformation, such as agile government, government as a platform, and the mobilization of dynamic capabilities.


The issue ahead is debating how public sector organizations operationalize dynamic capabilities and the governance framework to lead digital transformation with emerging technologies. Connect governments' digital transformation governance models and dynamic capabilities.


This article analyzes dynamic capabilities applied to governance paradigms in digital government transformation. The guide aims to facilitate the implementation of digital transformation leveraged by emerging technologies by operationalizing dynamic capabilities. Literature review, document analysis, case studies, and research methods are used.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Live-Streaming Entrepreneurship in Rural China’s Platform Urbanism
Wayne Wang (University of Hong Kong & Fundação Getulio Vargas)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Chinese policy, beginning with the Maoist era's strategy to "encircle the cities from the countryside," (农村包围城市) has long regarded the rural areas as an essential source of legitimacy for the state. Up to the present, China's rural policy has prioritized the digital transformation of rural China through a succession of digital village-building initiatives. Additionally, the use of government accounts on social media has been an ongoing trend in China for years to increase public information transparency and administer grassroots bureaucracy.

 

Coincidentally, content moderation models employed by private platforms dominated the digitally literate Generation Z after the proliferation of algorithm-intensive applications such as Douyin. These models transformed digitally literate citizens into bureaucratic self-agents who perform traditional grassroots governance duties in rural China. Meanwhile, some rural grassroots cadres became increasingly (self-)recognized as online influencers with the aim of achieving social and economic policy objectives.

 

This chapter explores China's use of social media as a tool for governance and explains by means of case studies how and why platforms' metadata behavioural ad-targeting designs of e-commerce and/or social media have been modified/framed historically and more recently as a result of the state's stringent content moderation legislation. It aims to study how live-streaming culture has altered contemporary social entrepreneurship in and beyond the Chinese administrative hierarchy by examining both the positive and adverse implications of digitalization on rural Gen-Z communities as algorithm-unaware marginal populations.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Digital Government and Service Delivery: The Challenges and Prospects of M-Government in Service Delivery in Ghana
Frank Ohemeng (Yorkville University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The emergence of electronic government continues to impact the way governments deliver public services. This was more pronounced at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, where services had to deliver at minimum personal contacts. Governments in advanced societies therefore stepped up the use of mobile phones in service delivery and other important government services. Electronic service delivery, commonly referred to as Mobile-government (M-Gov), has, therefore, come to stay. It is estimated that of the 7 billion people on Earth, 6.5 billion have access to a mobile phone. As of 2018, mobile phone penetration is around 100 per cent in low and middle income, and 55 per cent in low-income countries. In South Africa half the population owns a smartphone as do a third of the people in Ghana, Senegal, and Nigeria. This mobile penetration, it is argued makes it easy for the government to reach citizens, if not instantly, then with less time.
Quite recently, the Ghanaian government launched various digital platforms not only to enhance service delivery, but also to help reduce corruption by reducing the interface between people in the service delivery process, enhancing financial inclusion, ensuring effective social accountability, and enhancing governance. Consequently, the government has developed a strategic framework called MGOV for development (MGOV4D), which integrates the implementation of Mobile ICT for Development (MICT4D) initiatives with the implementation of the relevant governance mechanisms. The MGOV4D strategies include the promotion of low-cost mobile phones accessible to the poor; developing government capabilities for delivering information and services; involving civil society organizations in MICT4D and MGOV4D initiatives by the government; integrating support for vulnerable groups into existing public reform and decentralization programs; accessing government information and submitting information to the government using mobile phones; supporting the delivery of legal evidence and information through mobile phones, and enabling the participation of the vulnerable groups in elections and decision-making processes.
This paper aims to examine the effectiveness of the government’s MGOV4D approach, especially in ensuring effective service delivery, enhancing social accountability and reducing public sector corruption. It also examines the challenges in implementing the program and the involvement of citizens and civil society in service delivery. This is necessary since a citizen-centric design is one of the main tenets of GovTech to ensure that it is accessible and user-friendly. After all, the whole purpose of mGov is to make service delivery more accessible, efficient, and effective to citizens.
 

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Emerging Trends in Philippine Government Agencies’ Use of Social Media: A Closer Look in Facebook for Digital Governance
Charmaine Distor (United Nations University)
CO-AUTHORS
Soumaya Ben Dhaou (United Nations University)
ABSTRACT

Worldwide, governments have utilised social media platforms to disseminate information about their public services. One of the most used social media platforms is Facebook for its wide range of features and broad reach across all age groups. With the evolution of Facebook as a platform, governments have also taken advantage of this by innovating their approach to public service delivery. In this paper, case studies from several Philippine government agencies are introduced outlining emerging trends in the age of Facebook. First, the use of Facebook groups and the role of local governments as moderators for a government-initiated sharing economy to promote co-production and participatory governance will be presented. Second, the implementation of artificial intelligence-enabled chatbots by national government agencies for increased responsiveness will also be explained. Lastly, the increasing trend of using informal messaging or strategic humour for information dissemination by public officials and government agencies will also be highlighted. The case studies shall be analysed on their opportunities and implications for governments' future programmatic or policy implementations. Further discussions will also be made in terms of strategies to maximise the potentials of social media, especially towards digital transformation that would benefit both the governments and their constituents.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Leveraging public sector decision-making and accountability in public policy processes using blockchain based digital technologies.
Ondiek Japheth (University of Nairobi)
CO-AUTHORS
Gedion Onyango (Dept. Political Science and Public Administration, University of Nairobi)
ABSTRACT

Leveraging public sector decision-making and accountability in public policy processes using blockchain based digital technologies.

By

Japheth Ondiek and Gedion Onyango

 

Abstract

 

Public sector institutions can be seen to increasingly focus their attention on potential digital application of blockchain technology in public sector administration. Blockchain technology is deemed to provide a new paradigm in the new user-centric, agile and innovative public service delivery models and government policy making. Its potentiality to replace human agency in public administration, decentralize data governance in public sector and create autonomous, transparent systems that gives public administrators and citizens the confidence in public policy design as well as enhancing the efficiency of public services is deemed as the next frontier in public service delivery.  As an emerging technology, blockchain is adopted by public sector organizations to improve on their decision-making and accountability in public policy making processes.

 

Parallel to legacy systems, digital transformation of public sector is gaining traction with a focus on efficient delivery of government businesses. Even though public sector blockchain transformation is impeccably faced with various challenges including governance models, accountability, scalability, lack of privacy concerns and interoperability, its deployment in public policy processes offers a new paradigm in transactional accountability and decision-making in public management. Therefore, this study aims to address the following questions; 1) how does blockchain-based system in the public sector enables accountability in public policy making? And 2) how does blockchain-based digital technologies impact decision-making in public policy processes? Through this research questions, we aim to elucidate how blockchain based digital technologies can be used to provide innovative public service.

 

By exploring the state of the art, current practices, conceptual approaches of blockchain to public policy processes and specific governance requirements in public sector, this study systematically reviews literatures and analyses different approaches of blockchain accountability and decision-making in public policy process. An institutional framework of blockchain based system for public policy accountability and decision making is conceptualized for public sector organizations. In conclusion, the study recommends evidence-informed policy dimensions that enables blockchain intergration public sector institutions.

 

Keywords: Blockchain, public sector, digital technologies, accountability, decision-making, public policy.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - Designing Data collaboratives’ governance for their long-term stability: a key success factor analysis
Federico Bartolomucci (Politecnico di Milano)
CO-AUTHORS
Simone Bartalucci (Politecnico di Milano)
ABSTRACT

The momentum surrounding the use of big data for the public good has developed over the past few years, resulting in a proliferation of initiatives (see www.datacollaboratives.org) and a rise in the interest of public bodies, intergovernmental, and private organizations. The potential benefits derived from the cross-sectoral and collaborative use of both public and private datasets to stimulate socially oriented innovation have been proved in several contexts (e.g. health, migration, pandemics, and public transport) (Lapucci & Cattuto, 2021; Susha et al., 2022). These cross-sectoral initiatives have however not frequently progressed beyond the pilot level, a condition hindering their ability to generate long-term benefits and scale their impact (Flanagan Anne & Sheila, 2022; GSMA, 2018)

The lack of well-defined incentives schemas for both public and private actors (Klievink et al., 2018a; Susha et al., 2019), the lack of effective intermediation reference schemas (Klievink et al., 2018b; Perkmann & Schildt, 2015; Susha et al., 2022), and the lack of business models able to make these collaborations economically sustainable (GSMA, 2018; Susha et al., 2020), are among the governance-related variables (Bharosa, 2022; Bryson et al., 2015; Vangen et al., 2015) that undermine the long-term stability of these sort of collaboration.

To fulfill this gap, the paper investigates cross-sectoral governance dimensions’ settings in search of critical success factors enhancing Data Collaborative's long-term stability. It does so by combining pieces of evidence derived from two literature streams. The one on data collaboratives’ governance (Ruijer, 2021; Stalla-Bourdillon et al., 2019; Susha & Gil-Garcia, 2019), calling for an adaptation of cross-sectoral partnerships’ governance models to the peculiarities and challenges presented by data collaboratives, with the most developed and robust literature on cross-sectoral partnership governance (Ansell & Gash, 2008; Bryson et al., 2006; Emerson et al., 2012).

From the combination of the two literature streams, we deductively derived seven governance dimensions that are considered relevant for the long-term stability of a partnership. We then developed multiple case studies to investigate how more stable types of data collaboratives have managed these dimensions. The construction of several case studies allowed us to inductively identify critical success factors and the best design choices for each of the investigated dimensions. To validate our findings, we compared the identified critical success factors with two examples of data collaboration that failed to continue their activity over time.

Results demonstrate that the peculiarities of data collaboratives, in particular the implications derived from the extensive use of data they make, and their social purposes, require managing this type of partnership with different logics than those applied in traditional cross-sectoral partnerships, thereby necessitating the adaptation of existing governance models. The paper also enriches existing literature moving from previous descriptive literature (Ruijer, 2021) identifying relevant governance dimensions, to an explanatory approach, clarifying how to best design and manage these dimensions. In doing so it contributes to theory-building on the topic and might stimulate further studies. It also has substantial implications for practitioners from diverse sectors (private, public, and third sector), providing them with valuable insights on how to promote the establishment of stable data collaboratives, and challenging them to take an active role in exploiting the use of data to generate public good.

ACCEPTED
Format
11 - Data-driven technologies in fraud detection: The case of the Belgian Federal Government
Evrim Tan (Katholieke Universiteit Leuven)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper shares the empirical findings and analysis from the DIGI4FED project that researched the factors affecting the implementation of fraud detection technologies at the federal level in the social security and taxation domains in Belgium. Three factors define the contextual framework in the Belgian federal government. The first factor is the growing attention to the potential impact of Big Data (BD) and Artificial Intelligence (AI) on traditional government information processes. The second factor is the growing expectation of society from public administrations, to adopt new technological means to advance efficient and effective governance and public service delivery whilst ensuring the core democratic and moral values are not lost out of sight. The third factor concerns the Belgian federal administration itself. Although several steps were taken toward the digital transformation of the Belgian federal state in the past, challenges remain. DIGI4FED project has researched the conditions to introduce new digital technologies such as big data, AI, and blockchain to improve fraud detection processes in the taxation and social security domain. The project has gathered data through various means (e.g. experiments, interviews, living lab) to identify challenges to overcome in compliance with this aim. The research has revealed several challenges in seven categorical areas; namely, trust challenges, operational challenges, administrative challenges, technical challenges, user acceptance challenges, legal challenges, and policy challenges. The paper summarizes the main findings from the project and highlights the key takeaways about how to address challenges. 

ACCEPTED
Format
12 - Digital transformations and data rights of citizens in non-democratic contexts
Ixchel Perez-Duran (Autonomous University of Barcelona)
CO-AUTHORS
Júlia García-Puig (Leiden University)
ABSTRACT

Unprecedented large amounts of data are being generated as a result of the digital transformation. Consequently, data governance has become a priority for policy-makers, practitioners and scholars across the world. Governments and public administrations are implementing new laws and policies to regulate not only how data is used, gathered, managed and stored, but also how to safeguard citizens’ digital rights, privacy and security. At the supra-national level, the EU’s GDPR is a game-changer in data governance, with wide implications not only for member states but also for third countries. Simultaneously, non-state actors at the regional and international level are advocating and demanding greater data regulations worldwide.

In such a context, this chapter discusses where data rights of citizens stand in different contexts, including non-democracies in Asia, where the available literature is limited. Hence, the chapter will first provide a brief but concise overview of the conceptualization of digital data and its different types, and a review of the literature on governments’ use of data and anticipated impacts, with particular attention to open government data. Second, the chapter will present key specific challenges of data governance in the digital era in non-democratic countries. These might include - but are not limited to - data privacy and security, the data divide, data sovereignty and cross-border data-sharing, and vulnerable groups. In doing so, we will include examples of data regulation in Cambodia, which appears as an interesting case of a non-democratic government that is currently in the process of developing its digital and data policy framework.

ACCEPTED
Format
13 - Application of Artificial Intelligence in Governance: The Indian Experience
Mohammad Sohail (Department of Public Administration, Government Mohindra College, Patiala, Punjab, India-147001)
CO-AUTHORS
B.S. Ghuman (Former Vice-Chancellor, Punjabi University, Patiala, Punjab, India)
ABSTRACT

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has touched human lives considerably and has opened new avenues for changing the functioning of the governments for better. The private sector has so far taken a lead in the use of AI; making it part of its functioning and investing in research and development activities for promoting its further applications. Its potential in the government sector is yet to be fully tapped. The increasing body of literature has revealed the tremendous ability of AI to make improvements in decision making processes, quality and efficient delivery of public services thus fostering citizens’ trust in governments. Empirical evidence also suggests that the role of AI in governance is dynamic and evolving continuously.

 

The Government of India (GoI) has made considerable efforts to provide facilitative regime for exploring the application of AI in its governance process. The National Institute for Transforming India (NITI) Aayog, a think tank of GoI, brought out a Discussion Paper in the year 2018 titled National Strategy for Artificial Intelligence for articulating the vision for AI, identifying key sectors for introducing AI-driven interventions; formulating a policy framework and to locate policy barriers to AI. The NITI Aayog identified five focus areas for AI-driven interventions; namely, healthcare, agriculture, education, smart cities and infrastructure and smart mobility and transportation. Lack of expertise in research and application of AI; absence of enabling data ecosystems; high resource cost and low awareness for adoption of AI; privacy and security; and absence of collaborative approach to adoption and application of AI have been cited as major challenges to the application of AI in India. The NITI Aayog has proposed two-tier structure to meet research agenda for AI in the form of Centre of Research Excellence and International Centers of Transformational AI.

 

Simultaneously, Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MEITY), for providing a policy framework for adoption of AI in governance, constituted four committees in the year 2018 on platforms and data for AI; identifying key sectors; mapping technological capabilities; and cyber security, safety, legal and ethical Issues. The committees submitted detailed reports in the year 2019.

 

For building capacity in the form of institutions, infrastructure, trained human resources and dissemination of information for adoption of AI, the GoI has introduced various measures. For example, it has launched ‘National AI Portal’- a repository of AI-based initiatives in the country at a single place;  ‘Visvesvaraya PhD Scheme’ to enhance the number of PhDs in electronics system design & manufacturing and IT/IT-enabled services sectors in the country; National Programme on Responsible Use of AI for Youth to empower the youth to become AI ready and reduce the skill gap; and MeitY’s programme ‘Future Skills PRIME’ for re-skilling/ up-skilling of IT professionals in 10 emerging including Artificial Intelligence. The public academic and research institutions have set up research centres dealing with the various facets of AI.

 

The existing literature suggests that adoption of AI-driven initiatives in government in India is at nascent stage. GoI and provincial governments are in the process of establishing policy regime for AI and have also introduced AI-driven initiatives in select sectors such as finance, agriculture, defence, public service delivery, healthcare and cyber security and its applications in other sectors are being explored. At this juncture it is important to examine the status of AI in governance and discuss the roadmap for future. It is in this backdrop that the present paper has been conceived.

 

The objectives of the paper are to: (i) discuss the policy regime for AI in governance in India; (ii) examine the AI-initiatives in governance in different sectors and at national and sub-national levels; (iii) identify challenges to the use of AI in governance; (iv) draw lessons from the international experience; and (iv) suggest a roadmap for facilitating the use of AI in governance and prospective sectors.  The paper makes use of extensive sources available in the form of reports of governments, non-government agencies, think tanks and international bodies; research papers; case studies; and blogs.  

ACCEPTED
Format
14 - Digital Transformation of Indonesian Administration and Bureaucratic System
Oscar Danar (Faculty of Administrative Sciences)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Digital Transformation of Indonesian Administration and Bureaucratic System

 

     COVID-19 pandemic has profoundly impacted the way many public servants work. In addition, it also accelerated the use of technological developments. The pace of digitalization and reliance on ubiquitous technologies has exponentially increased both in citizens and all sectors. Due to the pressure from this external imposition, the digital transformation became the condition of existence of a new reality. Rapid digital transformation is often heralded as providing opportunities for the availability of electronic public services and innovations in the digital. Thus, they pose a new unprecedented challenge to public policies.

    Lately, Indonesian mechanisms to control the performance of administration and bureaucracy have transformed using digital technology, which is called the electronic performance accountability system of government institutions (e-SAKIP). This electronic platform is used in response to citizen demand for digital technology to provide more transparency and accountability in public services institutions. Furthermore, it covers various aspects related to financial management, human resources, public service, and others. A lesson learned from the Dutch cases, the role of digitized bureaucratic systems contributed to an incremental innovation change that affected the organizational structure, whereas in Michigan cases this administrative innovation provides a new way of dealing with fraud problems in their public servants.

     This digitalization of government processes in most developing countries including Indonesia plays an important role to make a system more dynamic, flexible, and efficient regarding regional financial data management and leave the manual process that has been done. Moreover, both local or central governments are preparing adequate resources, training, and public servant commitment in order to ensure that the system is fully utilized and integrated into their daily operations, as well as the implementation of e-SAKIP.  Under this circumstance, regional leaders can easily monitor and collect regional financial data through online connected systems.

     This paper provides a quantitative methodology by elaborating on several local government journeys applying the e-SAKIP in order to foster flexibility and effective bureaucratic control. Hence, this paper also applied the theoretical perspective of smart governance and digital era governance theory. By combining those methods and theoretical approaches, this paper should be able to determine the extent to which e-SAKIP impacted the quality of public service and strengthened government accountability through data driven decisions.

   Eventually, the implementation of e-SAKIP has a significant administrative impact by providing a more accurate standardized and transparent framework for managing and reporting performance. In a more detailed look, e-SAKIP can also assist organizations monitor and evaluate their performance by identifying the areas for improvement through data driven decisions. Apart from that, the availability of technology-savvy human resources, adequate technology infrastructure, and organizational resistance to change are several factors that are referred to as the public sector organizations digital maturity and influence the successful implementation of e-SAKIP in Indonesia.

ACCEPTED
Format
15 - Exploring the Relationship between Digital Era Governance and Public Administration
John Halligan (University of Canberra)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The paper will engage with a sub-theme of the panel, the relationship between public administration and governance in the digital era. The focus will be macro and systemic rather than on specific administrative and digitisation processes. It will also have a comparative basis (the broader research project covers four Anglophone countries and builds on previous comparative research: Craft and Halligan 2020), although the focus here will be on Australia
 
The paper will approach the relationship from three perspectives:
1.  Debate about the standing and relevance of models of public administration and governance have included digital era governance, and the argument that it has displaced new public management (Dunleavy and Evans 2019). The evidence for this and the means by which this might occur remains contested. The international literature on the significance of reform models now is inclined to favour hybrid conceptions that encompass two or more models (Halligan 2022a), but what of digital governance?
 
2. A second relevant question is how to explain variable progress towards digital government. Digital agendas feature in government plans, but priorities may include inter alia efficiency (cost savings), supporting the economy and the private sector, the interest of a segment of the population and improved citizen engagement and service delivery. These have different implications for the development of digital government and transformation. Contextual, cultural and institutional factors shape the pattern of change and digital transformation.
 
3. Digital transformation involves using new technology to rethink and develop core processes and service delivery. It entails new relationships and engagement with stakeholders through addressing holism horizontally and vertically in ways that go beyond the integrated service delivery of the e-government phase, and to advance to new technological thresholds as envisaged by models of digital era governance (Dunleavy and Evans 2019).
 
The Australian case provides a potential exemplar of digital transformation because of specialist agencies and strategic aspirations, but performance has been mixed and not systematically assessed. The credibility of one key dimension, citizen engagement, was blotted by the misuse of artificial intelligence for developing a debt recovery program. The case underscores the problems when a government ignores advice that is discordant with its objectives (Halligan 2022b).
 
The paper will evaluate the character and condition of digital transformation in Australia’s central government drawing on the evolution of the relationship over time, analysis of digital transformation and reform programs, and interviews with experts and stakeholders about
the extent to which digital government is being incorporated and mainstreamed.
 
References
Craft, J. and Halligan, J. (2020) Policy Advice and the Westminster Tradition: Policy Advisory Systems in Australia, Britain, Canada and New Zealand, Cambridge University Press.
Dunleavy, P. & Evans, M. (2019) Digital Transformation, in M. Evans, M. Grattan and P. Dunleavy (eds.) From Turnbull to Morrison: The Trust Divide, Melbourne University Press.
Halligan, J. (2022a) ‘Public Management Reform’ in Schedler, K. (ed.) Elgar Encyclopedia of Public Management, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2022, pp.283-287.
Halligan, J. (2022b) Implementing Digital Transformation in Australia: Performance and Paradoxes, International Research Society for Public Management Conference, 20 April.

ACCEPTED
Format
16 - Socialized leadership through Digital Service Teams
Srinivas Yerramsetti (KIMEP University, Kazakhstan)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Digital Service Teams (DSTs) have emerged as a new organizational form to facilitate Governments in meeting the technological, administrative, and societal challenges of public sector digitalization in many countries. The role of digital service teams is critical, given their role involves a shift from a hierarchical to a network form of governance, and facilitating effective responses to the complex challenges of digital transformation, often in a multilevel polity context. While much of the research has thus far focused on the role of digital service teams in realizing digital transformations in the context of Anglo-Saxon countries, this research will focus on India, a pioneer in advancing digitalization across a wide swath of public services leading to a fundamental restructuring of citizen-state interactions.

 

DSTs are a form of outsourced bureaucracy that facilitates shadow state capacity in emerging democracies eager to transform the functioning of the government through wide-ranging plans for digitalization. India has created a National e-Governance Plan as part of which it has initiated many Mission Mode Projects (MMPs) aimed at the sectoral transformation of policy areas such as land records, public distribution, welfare, health, and so on. It is the first country to create internal capacity for digital transformation through a direct hiring model for private sector experts to realize the successful implementation of its MMPs, which span various levels of its multi-level polity. India’s State e-Mission Teams (SeMTs) face the challenge of what is referred to in project management scholarship as socialized leadership – a form of shared project leadership in which various actors contribute towards accomplishing project goals by performing situational roles as learners as well as leaders.

 

This study will present an interpretive case study of SeMTs, established as part of India’s National e-Governance Program (NeGP) by the Department of Information Technology of India’s central government. It seeks to answer the research question ‘How do India’s State e-Mission Teams facilitate socialized leadership in Mission Mode Project implementation?’ It will examine the unique institutional context in which SeMTs have emerged in India and their role in facilitating digitalization-driven administrative reform through MMPs that sometimes fall within the overlapping jurisdictions of central and state governments. It will discuss the advantages and limitations of India’s SeMT model in facilitating digital transformation through socialized leadership and how they play a role in advancing the realization of digitalization.

 

The findings of this qualitative research will draw evidence from books, parliamentary committee reports, annual reports, interviews with serving and retired administrators, governance actors from both the public and private sectors, members of the SeMTs, including those who work with such digital service teams at various level of India’s federal polity. The study will engage with the advantages and disadvantages of India’s direct sourcing model of DSTs, and the blind spots they create in reconciling the instrumental goals of digitalization with a broader democratic vision of social progress. It will identify pathways to institutionalize the practices of sourcing private sector expertise and bridging the technocracy-democracy divide in digitalization-driven development.

ACCEPTED
Format
17 - A Multistakeholder Perspective on Digital Health Innovations: Evidence from a Nationwide Teleconsultation Platform in India
AREIBA ARIF (Jindal Global Business School, OPJGU)
CO-AUTHORS
Vanita Singh (Management Development Institute Gurgaon, India)
ABSTRACT

In 2018, the Indian government initiated a national health reform that ensures the provision of comprehensive primary health care to the population. Under this reform, 1.5 lakh existing primary health facilities were planned to be upgraded to Ayushman Bharat- Health and Wellness Centers (AB-HWCs). Besides the provision of selective (reproductive and child health / few major infectious diseases) primary care, AB-HWCs aim to provide comprehensive primary care services, including screening and management of NCDs, screening and basic management of mental health ailments, care for common ophthalmic and ENT problems, basic dental health care, geriatric and palliative health care, and basic trauma and emergency care. However, the newly introduced cadre of Community Health Officers (CHOs) at AB-HWCs are mainly paramedics, with no specialization in providing comprehensive health services, and digital policy interventions are crucial. To address the shortage of specialists, the Indian government leveraged technology to ensure quality care to rural and remote areas and introduced a nationwide teleconsultation platform, e-sanjeevani.


e-Sanjeevani is a primary healthcare innovation that bridges the digital health divide by extending the reach of quality health services to the population in the rural and remotest parts of the country. The teleconsultation services under eSanjeevani are delivered through two modes: "eSanjeevani AB-HWC" and "eSanjeevani OPD." Using a hub and spoke telemedicine model, the 'eSanjeevani AB-HWC' enables virtual connection between the beneficiary (along with paramedic) at the spoke, i.e., HWC, and doctor/specialist at the hub (tertiary healthcare facility/hospital/medical college). With around 100,000 primary health centers upgraded as AB-HWCs by April 2022 and more than 25,000 hubs providing teleconsultations, the e-Sanjeevani portal has facilitated access to healthcare services across the country. 


Certainly, e-Sanjeevani plays a crucial role in ensuring the provision of good quality specialized healthcare services to the masses. However, recent studies have pointed out implementation challenges for this digital innovation. In this study, we aim to explore the challenges faced by multiple stakeholders in this digital innovation, including healthcare providers, patients, and scheme implementers.  The insights from this study could guide the implementation of future digital innovations in healthcare settings.

ACCEPTED
Format
18 - From Physical to Digital Markets: The Role of Policy Tools in The Digital Age
Charlie Thompson (Norwegian University of Science and Technology)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

 

This article sketches out the use of policy tools in digital markets, which have proven difficult to regulate because of technological developments, territorial uncertainty, and slow implementation of policies. We discuss, through institutional theory and regulatory governance, the consequences in shift from physical to digital markets for regulation of market arrangements. Empirically, we draw on a comparative case study of the public agencies in the Nordic countries of Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden which regulates and control gambling markets. Despite formulating similar political objectives, all four entities organize regulatory practices and market arrangements differently. Through a document analysis and semi-structured interviews, the paper fleshes out the role of policy tools in the digital age of government, where our findings showcase two-fold implications. While state agencies are limited in effectiveness due to policy formulation and steering arrangements, they find through agile practices innovative tools to improve policy performance. While digital transformation has proven to be both sluggish and slow, public agencies are increasingly robust in regulating digital markets.


 

ACCEPTED
Format
19 - Digital Transformation: Effective tool in strengthening governance and its challenges
Manish Adwani (Pandit Deendayal Energy University)
CO-AUTHORS
Abhishikt Chauhan (National Law School of India University)
ABSTRACT

The aim of this paper is to provide insights regarding digital technology and tools used to make more effective and gradual progress in strengthening governance as well as highlighting challenges in adopting digital technology and tools in India. Digitalization aids in promoting transparency, time-money saving process, and quicker and faster communication between citizens-state.

 

In the past few years programs like Digital India have made remarkable progress in grabbing the attention towards digital tools & internet usage in the public sector as well as government machinery working.

 

However, as per a federal policy think tank of  India, NITI Aayog reported in 2022, more than 60% of India's population lives in rural areas and only 50 % of citizens have access to the internet and smartphone.

 

Here we will examine the effective manner to improve digital literacy and ecosystem to adapt the digitalization, especially in rural areas. The public-private cooperation in Unified Payment Interface (UPI) developed by NPCI has gradually increased digital payments. UPI transactions have increased from nearly 50 crores to 771444 crore worth of transactions in the last 4 years, and more than 100% growth from 2.42 billion to 3.46 billion compared to last year.

 

This observation suggests that creating the standard gateway and easy-to-use payment method for users by partnering with all available private players like Bhim UPI, G Pay, Phonepe, and Paytm leads to promoting a positive environment regarding digital payment as it is easy to use, faster, rewarding and at the same time providing many alternatives to the user by reducing the burden to state without compromising user requirement and needs.

ACCEPTED
Format
20 - Theorising and Conceptualising Digital Economy Policies in Kenya: An Analysis of Current Trends and Future Prospects.
Patrick Kambi (University of Nairobi)
CO-AUTHORS
Caroline Ikiriinya (University of Nairobi)
ABSTRACT

Theorising and Conceptualising Digital Economy Policies in Kenya: An Analysis of Current Trends and Future Prospects.

 

Abstract

Building on the gap in the theorising and conceptualising African digital economy policies; this paper explores frames for understanding the development of digital economy policies. The findings will also offer recommendations for improving digital economy policies in Kenya and developing a more robust and inclusive digital economy. The digital economy is rapidly growing globally and has become a key driver of economic growth and development. Kenya is no exception; with a thriving digital sector that has the potential to transform the country's economy, the government has developed several policy instruments in response. This paper examines the theorising and conceptualisation of digital economy policies in Kenya. It delves into the theories and concepts through which these policies are formulated and implemented, exploring their impact on the growth and development of Kenya's digital economy. The paper also considers the policy issues, challenges, and opportunities faced by Kenya in the digital economy and how existing policies address these.

Modelled on mixed methods, the paper critically analyses the existing literature and case studies. It triangulates four theories that play a crucial role in shaping the digital economy policy-making process; Network society theory, innovation system theory, resource-based view theory, and institutional theory to identify and model critical structural design of ordering a digital economy. This will allow us to develop, for example, four policy practices; Network society policy practice, innovation system policy practice, resource-based view policy practice, and institutional policy practice. In the end, the proposed study provides valuable insights into the current state and narratives of the digital economy in Kenya, taking into considering the role of the state in its development.

 

 

 Keywords: Conceptualization, theorising, digital economy, public policy, policy formulation.

ACCEPTED
Format
21 - Responsible Urban Digital Twins
Bram Klievink (Leiden University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Paper proposal for ICPP T05P03: Administrative Processes in the Digital Era.

Author listed in the system is the corresponding author.

 

Responsible Urban Digital Twins
Over the past few years, there has been a strong push for responsible use of data and digital systems in public services and public policy. Responsible here translate to initiatives that seek to take into account public values and ethical considerations in the design, deployment and use of digital systems in government. Often, this push results in some form of framework or the creation of an actor or institution. As a result, government organisations that consider or deploy digital systems – and AI systems in particular – find a variety of checklists, frameworks and transparency forums that all mean to ensure public value impacts of the technology are considered. We witness a similar development in the case of urban digital twins, where data-driven models and systems represent a city to aid policy making, public services, or decision making. Professionals working on the development of such digital twins find the host of frameworks to represent important concerns yet at the same time find them unwieldly, too far away from their actual practice, and find that there are too many, none of them really implementable and actionable within the local government organization.
This paper presents a nested case study of a large municipality developing an actionable public values framework for its digital twin initiative. Based on desk research of current codes and frameworks that seek to support these considerations, we study three subcases (environmental permit, geo-information, and crowd safety management) through interviews to identify why such approaches fail to become actionable. Based on a co-design process with the municipality, we propose a values framework and implementation guideline for digital twin initiatives and evaluate its actionability for the case organisation.
 
This proposed paper fits with the following two CfP topics for this panel:
*Digitization in the policy process especially considering issues such as AI, ethics, privacy, big data, and regulator technology;   addresses how ethics and public values are made actionable in digital innovation processes that employ big data, models and (sometimes) AI for public services, decision making and control/inspections.
*Digitization in select public policy fields such as healthcare, communications, transportation, the environment, and consumer and financial regulation;  mostly the built environment and the policy fields that cover it or are informed by it (e.g. permit procedures)

ACCEPTED
Format
22 - Technology futures and stagnant economies: the power of imagination
Lena Kalaycian
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper focuses on the power of storytelling and narratives to drive decision making for a fully digital future. The stories we tell have the power to transform our worldview and are most interesting when they correctly predict aspects of the future, however, they are most powerful when they motivate the hard work needed to build a radically better future. Imagination is critical to these narratives, acting as a fundamental tool for seeking and making change in the world today, igniting resilience and empowering us to confront systemic challenges. 

 

To illustrate the possible impacts of storytelling, this paper will study the role of optimism to provide a sense of coherence and belonging for citizens and bureaucrats amidst deep uncertainty and administrative complexity. We will do this by probing into the stories we tell about digital futures and asking how inclusive and inspiring these technically grounded visions of the future really are. 

 

We will look at the extent to which governments can increase their role in developing environments for progress related to advancements in technology, like AI, with an emphasis on fairness for future generations and socially beneficial applications. We will do this by asking what role should governments play in imagining futures?  And what (if any) role should governments play in ‘protecting’ citizens from these imagined futures? Our analysis will confirm that technology futures and storytelling, as driving forces, provide compelling views into system level dynamics to understand key interactions which could fuel policy making agendas for: AI ethics, good digital governance and the roadmap to a mature (and adaptive) digital state, including guidelines on artificial and inclusive design. We will also examine the impacts of delayed technological or societal advancements should the potential of these driving forces not be realized. 


Ultimately, this paper aims to formalize a set of practices and guiding principles by contributing new conceptual frameworks for public administrators and will argue for widespread and sustained interest in developing technology narratives that inspire, adapt and reignite ambitions for innovation and discovery.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper analyses the growing application of emergent technologies to regulatory activities, focusing on financial governance. We trace how RegTechs were developed primary as supervisory technologies (SupTech) for regulators coping with the flurry of new financial technology (FinTech) products based on novel technologies like blockchains. The ‘turn’ towards RegTech and SupTech that Fintech engendered reflects incremental efforts to keep pace with such market developments. It has had two paradoxical implications for global financial governance. First, and despite arising in the wake of the 2008 global financial crisis, RegTech and SupTech shy away from offering tools for addressing macroprudential issues such as systemic instability. We trace back this evolution to the underlying model supporting data-based solutions, often taking the form of binary yet complex processes focused on individual users, rather than more systemic perspectives. Second, and in contrast to the democratizing promises heralded by FinTech, SupTech and RegTech advance even more technocratic forms of financial governance that performs a rigidified type of normativity closing, rather than opening up, possibilities. Together, the turn towards more digital administration in financial governance counter rather than support much-needed efforts to inject stability and democracy in financial regulation.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Recent years have brought scholars’ attention to the potential of artificial intelligence supported transformation in public administration. This interest is accompanied by wide range of research on the topic, including value propositions of AI (see, for example Borges et al 2020, Wirtz et al 2019, Kouziokas 2017), success factors and enablers to make AI projects happen (see, for example Noordt & Misuraca 2022, Hamm & Klesel 2021, Keding 2021) or risks that it entails (see, for example Young et al. 2019). However, the knowledge about whether and how artificial intelligence supports transformation of existing routines of public sector remains scarce.   

 

Theoretical approaches and empirical studies often explore the AI landscape top-down, including  studies of strategy documents (see Noordt et al. 2020; Fatima et al 2022) or attempts to outline factors or patterns based on existing literature on the topic (Hamm & Klesel 2021). However, researchers have already pointed to a necessity to assess the impact of AI on organisational processes within public sector (van Noordt & Misuraca 2020). Such studies could lead to deeper knowledge about the influence of AI solutions on existing processes and routines of public administration, but also illustrate the reasons for its absence.

 

This paper is a case study of implementing AI in Estonian Tax and Customs Board (ETCB). The case was selected due to the diversity of different AI-related initiatives undertaken in recent years: including organisation-wide hackathon, development of risk assessment models, and development of AI strategy. Thus, it has potential to offer insights about the effects of different types of AI initiatives in the same setting. However, as these initiatives have not (yet) brought about profound changes in current work practices, they provide valuable insights into potential barriers to transforming public sector processes with the assistance of AI. Therefore, this study proposes a research question: What would it take to create AI-assisted change in existing public sector routines?

 

To explore the factors that support or hinder AI-assisted change in organisational processes, interviews with public servants at ETCB are conducted. Additionally, partners outside public sector (who provided competence and guidance with studied AI initiatives) are consulted. Combined with existing theoretical approaches on factors influencing AI implementation in public administration, this study helps to understand the aspects that influence the development of AI-enabled processes in public sector organisations. From theoretical perspective, this is a step towards conceptualising the role of AI in improving organisational capabilities.

 

This is an abstract submitted to panel T05P03 and is exploring the transformation of administrative processes with the assistance of AI tools.

 

References

 

Borges, A.F., Laurindo, F.J., Spínola, M.M., Gonçalves, R.F. and Mattos, C.A., 2021. The strategic use of artificial intelligence in the digital era: Systematic literature review and future research directions. International Journal of Information Management, 57, p.102225.

Hamm, P. and Klesel, M., 2021. Success Factors for the Adoption of Artificial Intelligence in Organizations: A Literature Review. In AMCIS.

Keding, C., 2021. Understanding the interplay of artificial intelligence and strategic management: four decades of research in review. Management Review Quarterly, 71(1), pp.91-134.

Kouziokas, G.N., 2017. The application of artificial intelligence in public administration for forecasting high crime risk transportation areas in urban environment. Transportation research procedia, 24, pp.467-473.

Noordt, C. V., Medaglia, R., & Misuraca, G. (2020). Stimulating the Uptake of AI in Public Administrations: Overview and Comparison of AI Strategies of European Member States . In S. Virkar, M. Janssen, I. Lindgren, U. Melin, F. Mureddu, P. Parycek, E. Tambouris, G. Schwabe, & H. J. Scholl (Eds.), Proceedings of Ongoing Research, Practitioners, Workshops, Posters, and Projects of the International Conference EGOV-CeDEM-ePart 2020 (pp. 269-277). Digital Government Society. CEUR Workshop Proceedings Vol. 2797 http://dgsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/CEUR-WS-Proceedings-2020_Full-Manuscript.pdf

Noordt, C. V. and Misuraca, G., 2022. Exploratory insights on artificial intelligence for government in Europe. Social Science Computer Review, 40(2), pp.426-444.

Wirtz, B.W., Weyerer, J.C. and Geyer, C., 2019. Artificial intelligence and the public sector—applications and challenges. International Journal of Public Administration, 42(7), pp.596-615.

Young, M.M., Himmelreich, J., Bullock, J.B. and Kim, K.C., 2019. Artificial intelligence and administrative evil. Perspectives on Public Management and Governance, 4(3), pp.244-258.

CO-AUTHORS
Vasiliki Bednar (McMaster University)
ABSTRACT

As new technologies are rapidly being adopted in all areas of modern society, they also present an additional layer of complexity governments across the world have to navigate. Additionally, the COVID-19 pandemic played a significant role in accelerating digitization of public services and tested traditional government structures and policy-making processes in the face of uncertainty. This signals that public servants now need to identify new policy challenges early on as well as possess digital era knowledge and skills (e.g. agile project management and data analytics), while being able to challenge status quo and navigate existing government norms and processes. Thus, training of future public servants or professional development of those already in the public service need to be focused on developing the ability to recognize problems that have not yet been acknowledged, innovate within existing government constraints, effectively collaborate and communicate in multi-disciplinary teams, and look for solutions to address existing complex social, political and economic issues. This chapter explores how public servants should be trained to effectively face digital era challenges. Building on our experience in the Master of Public Policy in Digital Society program at McMaster University in Canada, we will discuss how its new curriculum that blends traditional university courses with skill development labs prepares students for the digital era public service careers.

CO-AUTHORS
Jenny Lewis (University of Melbourne)
ABSTRACT
Governments are increasingly turning towards online platforms as a replacement for, or supplement to, bricks and mortar provision of government services. Welfare services, as one of the largest areas of government expenditure, are frequently the target of ever greater cost-savings by governments through these online platforms. The Australian Government has invested heavily in becoming a ‘leader of digital government’ (Digital Transformation Agency, 2021) in this space, partly through automating payments administration but also through seeking to ‘digitalise’ its public employment services. In 2022, it launched one of the world’s first digital-first employment services systems, Workforce Australia (WfA). The hope is that many jobseekers will self-service online, while face-to-face services provided by contracted providers will function as services of last resort for those with the most complex needs. In this presentation we will review the challenges and opportunities presented by this digital turn, drawing on research conducted with service providers to understand how they were preparing for the transition to WfA. These discussions revealed that engagement with digital solutions was limited at the front-line. There also remained significant concerns about how the transition to WfA would impact jobseekers, including issues with employer engagement in the digital environment and the effectiveness of tools for service targeting. Overall, while providers were optimistic about the potential for WfA they worried that ongoing challenges from past reforms, such as entrenched long-term unemployment and the largely administrative orientation of casework, were being glossed over in the pursuit of new digital tools.
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In response to political, economic, and social pressures, the digital government transformation is evolving in its capabilities to interact with citizens and others, engage in cross-agency service delivery and offer service platforms.


The covid-19 pandemic has been a capacity test for countries to lead toward digital transformation with emerging technologies proactively. As the complexity of issues and political pressures that affect government digital transformation strategies increases, public sector organizations seek to design processes and manage resources, competencies, and competencies to perform public functions as additional efforts in the search for results.

It is known that digital transformation leads to the emergence of new governance paradigms (Janowski, 2015). It is only possible to talk about the Digital Transformation of the government by referring to changes in public governance models. Research (see Nielsen, Jordanoski, 2020) indicates that the relative success of digital transformation strategies depends on governance (process model), coordination (leader), and intergovernmental cooperation (alliances).


The literature assumes that the public sector must acquire and reconfigure organizational and dynamic capabilities to carry out the digital transformation of government (Vignieri, Zeinali, 2022).

That is, to develop dynamic capabilities to detect ideas and products, capture critical knowledge, obtain external resources and craft a new business model; reconfigure and transform the organization with new assets and patterns (Teece, 2009, 2014, 2022)


However, there needs to be more research on governance paradigms in digital transformation, such as agile government, government as a platform, and the mobilization of dynamic capabilities.


The issue ahead is debating how public sector organizations operationalize dynamic capabilities and the governance framework to lead digital transformation with emerging technologies. Connect governments' digital transformation governance models and dynamic capabilities.


This article analyzes dynamic capabilities applied to governance paradigms in digital government transformation. The guide aims to facilitate the implementation of digital transformation leveraged by emerging technologies by operationalizing dynamic capabilities. Literature review, document analysis, case studies, and research methods are used.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Chinese policy, beginning with the Maoist era's strategy to "encircle the cities from the countryside," (农村包围城市) has long regarded the rural areas as an essential source of legitimacy for the state. Up to the present, China's rural policy has prioritized the digital transformation of rural China through a succession of digital village-building initiatives. Additionally, the use of government accounts on social media has been an ongoing trend in China for years to increase public information transparency and administer grassroots bureaucracy.

 

Coincidentally, content moderation models employed by private platforms dominated the digitally literate Generation Z after the proliferation of algorithm-intensive applications such as Douyin. These models transformed digitally literate citizens into bureaucratic self-agents who perform traditional grassroots governance duties in rural China. Meanwhile, some rural grassroots cadres became increasingly (self-)recognized as online influencers with the aim of achieving social and economic policy objectives.

 

This chapter explores China's use of social media as a tool for governance and explains by means of case studies how and why platforms' metadata behavioural ad-targeting designs of e-commerce and/or social media have been modified/framed historically and more recently as a result of the state's stringent content moderation legislation. It aims to study how live-streaming culture has altered contemporary social entrepreneurship in and beyond the Chinese administrative hierarchy by examining both the positive and adverse implications of digitalization on rural Gen-Z communities as algorithm-unaware marginal populations.

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The emergence of electronic government continues to impact the way governments deliver public services. This was more pronounced at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, where services had to deliver at minimum personal contacts. Governments in advanced societies therefore stepped up the use of mobile phones in service delivery and other important government services. Electronic service delivery, commonly referred to as Mobile-government (M-Gov), has, therefore, come to stay. It is estimated that of the 7 billion people on Earth, 6.5 billion have access to a mobile phone. As of 2018, mobile phone penetration is around 100 per cent in low and middle income, and 55 per cent in low-income countries. In South Africa half the population owns a smartphone as do a third of the people in Ghana, Senegal, and Nigeria. This mobile penetration, it is argued makes it easy for the government to reach citizens, if not instantly, then with less time.
Quite recently, the Ghanaian government launched various digital platforms not only to enhance service delivery, but also to help reduce corruption by reducing the interface between people in the service delivery process, enhancing financial inclusion, ensuring effective social accountability, and enhancing governance. Consequently, the government has developed a strategic framework called MGOV for development (MGOV4D), which integrates the implementation of Mobile ICT for Development (MICT4D) initiatives with the implementation of the relevant governance mechanisms. The MGOV4D strategies include the promotion of low-cost mobile phones accessible to the poor; developing government capabilities for delivering information and services; involving civil society organizations in MICT4D and MGOV4D initiatives by the government; integrating support for vulnerable groups into existing public reform and decentralization programs; accessing government information and submitting information to the government using mobile phones; supporting the delivery of legal evidence and information through mobile phones, and enabling the participation of the vulnerable groups in elections and decision-making processes.
This paper aims to examine the effectiveness of the government’s MGOV4D approach, especially in ensuring effective service delivery, enhancing social accountability and reducing public sector corruption. It also examines the challenges in implementing the program and the involvement of citizens and civil society in service delivery. This is necessary since a citizen-centric design is one of the main tenets of GovTech to ensure that it is accessible and user-friendly. After all, the whole purpose of mGov is to make service delivery more accessible, efficient, and effective to citizens.
 

CO-AUTHORS
Soumaya Ben Dhaou (United Nations University)
ABSTRACT

Worldwide, governments have utilised social media platforms to disseminate information about their public services. One of the most used social media platforms is Facebook for its wide range of features and broad reach across all age groups. With the evolution of Facebook as a platform, governments have also taken advantage of this by innovating their approach to public service delivery. In this paper, case studies from several Philippine government agencies are introduced outlining emerging trends in the age of Facebook. First, the use of Facebook groups and the role of local governments as moderators for a government-initiated sharing economy to promote co-production and participatory governance will be presented. Second, the implementation of artificial intelligence-enabled chatbots by national government agencies for increased responsiveness will also be explained. Lastly, the increasing trend of using informal messaging or strategic humour for information dissemination by public officials and government agencies will also be highlighted. The case studies shall be analysed on their opportunities and implications for governments' future programmatic or policy implementations. Further discussions will also be made in terms of strategies to maximise the potentials of social media, especially towards digital transformation that would benefit both the governments and their constituents.

CO-AUTHORS
Gedion Onyango (Dept. Political Science and Public Administration, University of Nairobi)
ABSTRACT

Leveraging public sector decision-making and accountability in public policy processes using blockchain based digital technologies.

By

Japheth Ondiek and Gedion Onyango

 

Abstract

 

Public sector institutions can be seen to increasingly focus their attention on potential digital application of blockchain technology in public sector administration. Blockchain technology is deemed to provide a new paradigm in the new user-centric, agile and innovative public service delivery models and government policy making. Its potentiality to replace human agency in public administration, decentralize data governance in public sector and create autonomous, transparent systems that gives public administrators and citizens the confidence in public policy design as well as enhancing the efficiency of public services is deemed as the next frontier in public service delivery.  As an emerging technology, blockchain is adopted by public sector organizations to improve on their decision-making and accountability in public policy making processes.

 

Parallel to legacy systems, digital transformation of public sector is gaining traction with a focus on efficient delivery of government businesses. Even though public sector blockchain transformation is impeccably faced with various challenges including governance models, accountability, scalability, lack of privacy concerns and interoperability, its deployment in public policy processes offers a new paradigm in transactional accountability and decision-making in public management. Therefore, this study aims to address the following questions; 1) how does blockchain-based system in the public sector enables accountability in public policy making? And 2) how does blockchain-based digital technologies impact decision-making in public policy processes? Through this research questions, we aim to elucidate how blockchain based digital technologies can be used to provide innovative public service.

 

By exploring the state of the art, current practices, conceptual approaches of blockchain to public policy processes and specific governance requirements in public sector, this study systematically reviews literatures and analyses different approaches of blockchain accountability and decision-making in public policy process. An institutional framework of blockchain based system for public policy accountability and decision making is conceptualized for public sector organizations. In conclusion, the study recommends evidence-informed policy dimensions that enables blockchain intergration public sector institutions.

 

Keywords: Blockchain, public sector, digital technologies, accountability, decision-making, public policy.

 

CO-AUTHORS
Simone Bartalucci (Politecnico di Milano)
ABSTRACT

The momentum surrounding the use of big data for the public good has developed over the past few years, resulting in a proliferation of initiatives (see www.datacollaboratives.org) and a rise in the interest of public bodies, intergovernmental, and private organizations. The potential benefits derived from the cross-sectoral and collaborative use of both public and private datasets to stimulate socially oriented innovation have been proved in several contexts (e.g. health, migration, pandemics, and public transport) (Lapucci & Cattuto, 2021; Susha et al., 2022). These cross-sectoral initiatives have however not frequently progressed beyond the pilot level, a condition hindering their ability to generate long-term benefits and scale their impact (Flanagan Anne & Sheila, 2022; GSMA, 2018)

The lack of well-defined incentives schemas for both public and private actors (Klievink et al., 2018a; Susha et al., 2019), the lack of effective intermediation reference schemas (Klievink et al., 2018b; Perkmann & Schildt, 2015; Susha et al., 2022), and the lack of business models able to make these collaborations economically sustainable (GSMA, 2018; Susha et al., 2020), are among the governance-related variables (Bharosa, 2022; Bryson et al., 2015; Vangen et al., 2015) that undermine the long-term stability of these sort of collaboration.

To fulfill this gap, the paper investigates cross-sectoral governance dimensions’ settings in search of critical success factors enhancing Data Collaborative's long-term stability. It does so by combining pieces of evidence derived from two literature streams. The one on data collaboratives’ governance (Ruijer, 2021; Stalla-Bourdillon et al., 2019; Susha & Gil-Garcia, 2019), calling for an adaptation of cross-sectoral partnerships’ governance models to the peculiarities and challenges presented by data collaboratives, with the most developed and robust literature on cross-sectoral partnership governance (Ansell & Gash, 2008; Bryson et al., 2006; Emerson et al., 2012).

From the combination of the two literature streams, we deductively derived seven governance dimensions that are considered relevant for the long-term stability of a partnership. We then developed multiple case studies to investigate how more stable types of data collaboratives have managed these dimensions. The construction of several case studies allowed us to inductively identify critical success factors and the best design choices for each of the investigated dimensions. To validate our findings, we compared the identified critical success factors with two examples of data collaboration that failed to continue their activity over time.

Results demonstrate that the peculiarities of data collaboratives, in particular the implications derived from the extensive use of data they make, and their social purposes, require managing this type of partnership with different logics than those applied in traditional cross-sectoral partnerships, thereby necessitating the adaptation of existing governance models. The paper also enriches existing literature moving from previous descriptive literature (Ruijer, 2021) identifying relevant governance dimensions, to an explanatory approach, clarifying how to best design and manage these dimensions. In doing so it contributes to theory-building on the topic and might stimulate further studies. It also has substantial implications for practitioners from diverse sectors (private, public, and third sector), providing them with valuable insights on how to promote the establishment of stable data collaboratives, and challenging them to take an active role in exploiting the use of data to generate public good.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper shares the empirical findings and analysis from the DIGI4FED project that researched the factors affecting the implementation of fraud detection technologies at the federal level in the social security and taxation domains in Belgium. Three factors define the contextual framework in the Belgian federal government. The first factor is the growing attention to the potential impact of Big Data (BD) and Artificial Intelligence (AI) on traditional government information processes. The second factor is the growing expectation of society from public administrations, to adopt new technological means to advance efficient and effective governance and public service delivery whilst ensuring the core democratic and moral values are not lost out of sight. The third factor concerns the Belgian federal administration itself. Although several steps were taken toward the digital transformation of the Belgian federal state in the past, challenges remain. DIGI4FED project has researched the conditions to introduce new digital technologies such as big data, AI, and blockchain to improve fraud detection processes in the taxation and social security domain. The project has gathered data through various means (e.g. experiments, interviews, living lab) to identify challenges to overcome in compliance with this aim. The research has revealed several challenges in seven categorical areas; namely, trust challenges, operational challenges, administrative challenges, technical challenges, user acceptance challenges, legal challenges, and policy challenges. The paper summarizes the main findings from the project and highlights the key takeaways about how to address challenges. 

CO-AUTHORS
Júlia García-Puig (Leiden University)
ABSTRACT

Unprecedented large amounts of data are being generated as a result of the digital transformation. Consequently, data governance has become a priority for policy-makers, practitioners and scholars across the world. Governments and public administrations are implementing new laws and policies to regulate not only how data is used, gathered, managed and stored, but also how to safeguard citizens’ digital rights, privacy and security. At the supra-national level, the EU’s GDPR is a game-changer in data governance, with wide implications not only for member states but also for third countries. Simultaneously, non-state actors at the regional and international level are advocating and demanding greater data regulations worldwide.

In such a context, this chapter discusses where data rights of citizens stand in different contexts, including non-democracies in Asia, where the available literature is limited. Hence, the chapter will first provide a brief but concise overview of the conceptualization of digital data and its different types, and a review of the literature on governments’ use of data and anticipated impacts, with particular attention to open government data. Second, the chapter will present key specific challenges of data governance in the digital era in non-democratic countries. These might include - but are not limited to - data privacy and security, the data divide, data sovereignty and cross-border data-sharing, and vulnerable groups. In doing so, we will include examples of data regulation in Cambodia, which appears as an interesting case of a non-democratic government that is currently in the process of developing its digital and data policy framework.

CO-AUTHORS
B.S. Ghuman (Former Vice-Chancellor, Punjabi University, Patiala, Punjab, India)
ABSTRACT

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has touched human lives considerably and has opened new avenues for changing the functioning of the governments for better. The private sector has so far taken a lead in the use of AI; making it part of its functioning and investing in research and development activities for promoting its further applications. Its potential in the government sector is yet to be fully tapped. The increasing body of literature has revealed the tremendous ability of AI to make improvements in decision making processes, quality and efficient delivery of public services thus fostering citizens’ trust in governments. Empirical evidence also suggests that the role of AI in governance is dynamic and evolving continuously.

 

The Government of India (GoI) has made considerable efforts to provide facilitative regime for exploring the application of AI in its governance process. The National Institute for Transforming India (NITI) Aayog, a think tank of GoI, brought out a Discussion Paper in the year 2018 titled National Strategy for Artificial Intelligence for articulating the vision for AI, identifying key sectors for introducing AI-driven interventions; formulating a policy framework and to locate policy barriers to AI. The NITI Aayog identified five focus areas for AI-driven interventions; namely, healthcare, agriculture, education, smart cities and infrastructure and smart mobility and transportation. Lack of expertise in research and application of AI; absence of enabling data ecosystems; high resource cost and low awareness for adoption of AI; privacy and security; and absence of collaborative approach to adoption and application of AI have been cited as major challenges to the application of AI in India. The NITI Aayog has proposed two-tier structure to meet research agenda for AI in the form of Centre of Research Excellence and International Centers of Transformational AI.

 

Simultaneously, Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MEITY), for providing a policy framework for adoption of AI in governance, constituted four committees in the year 2018 on platforms and data for AI; identifying key sectors; mapping technological capabilities; and cyber security, safety, legal and ethical Issues. The committees submitted detailed reports in the year 2019.

 

For building capacity in the form of institutions, infrastructure, trained human resources and dissemination of information for adoption of AI, the GoI has introduced various measures. For example, it has launched ‘National AI Portal’- a repository of AI-based initiatives in the country at a single place;  ‘Visvesvaraya PhD Scheme’ to enhance the number of PhDs in electronics system design & manufacturing and IT/IT-enabled services sectors in the country; National Programme on Responsible Use of AI for Youth to empower the youth to become AI ready and reduce the skill gap; and MeitY’s programme ‘Future Skills PRIME’ for re-skilling/ up-skilling of IT professionals in 10 emerging including Artificial Intelligence. The public academic and research institutions have set up research centres dealing with the various facets of AI.

 

The existing literature suggests that adoption of AI-driven initiatives in government in India is at nascent stage. GoI and provincial governments are in the process of establishing policy regime for AI and have also introduced AI-driven initiatives in select sectors such as finance, agriculture, defence, public service delivery, healthcare and cyber security and its applications in other sectors are being explored. At this juncture it is important to examine the status of AI in governance and discuss the roadmap for future. It is in this backdrop that the present paper has been conceived.

 

The objectives of the paper are to: (i) discuss the policy regime for AI in governance in India; (ii) examine the AI-initiatives in governance in different sectors and at national and sub-national levels; (iii) identify challenges to the use of AI in governance; (iv) draw lessons from the international experience; and (iv) suggest a roadmap for facilitating the use of AI in governance and prospective sectors.  The paper makes use of extensive sources available in the form of reports of governments, non-government agencies, think tanks and international bodies; research papers; case studies; and blogs.  

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Digital Transformation of Indonesian Administration and Bureaucratic System

 

     COVID-19 pandemic has profoundly impacted the way many public servants work. In addition, it also accelerated the use of technological developments. The pace of digitalization and reliance on ubiquitous technologies has exponentially increased both in citizens and all sectors. Due to the pressure from this external imposition, the digital transformation became the condition of existence of a new reality. Rapid digital transformation is often heralded as providing opportunities for the availability of electronic public services and innovations in the digital. Thus, they pose a new unprecedented challenge to public policies.

    Lately, Indonesian mechanisms to control the performance of administration and bureaucracy have transformed using digital technology, which is called the electronic performance accountability system of government institutions (e-SAKIP). This electronic platform is used in response to citizen demand for digital technology to provide more transparency and accountability in public services institutions. Furthermore, it covers various aspects related to financial management, human resources, public service, and others. A lesson learned from the Dutch cases, the role of digitized bureaucratic systems contributed to an incremental innovation change that affected the organizational structure, whereas in Michigan cases this administrative innovation provides a new way of dealing with fraud problems in their public servants.

     This digitalization of government processes in most developing countries including Indonesia plays an important role to make a system more dynamic, flexible, and efficient regarding regional financial data management and leave the manual process that has been done. Moreover, both local or central governments are preparing adequate resources, training, and public servant commitment in order to ensure that the system is fully utilized and integrated into their daily operations, as well as the implementation of e-SAKIP.  Under this circumstance, regional leaders can easily monitor and collect regional financial data through online connected systems.

     This paper provides a quantitative methodology by elaborating on several local government journeys applying the e-SAKIP in order to foster flexibility and effective bureaucratic control. Hence, this paper also applied the theoretical perspective of smart governance and digital era governance theory. By combining those methods and theoretical approaches, this paper should be able to determine the extent to which e-SAKIP impacted the quality of public service and strengthened government accountability through data driven decisions.

   Eventually, the implementation of e-SAKIP has a significant administrative impact by providing a more accurate standardized and transparent framework for managing and reporting performance. In a more detailed look, e-SAKIP can also assist organizations monitor and evaluate their performance by identifying the areas for improvement through data driven decisions. Apart from that, the availability of technology-savvy human resources, adequate technology infrastructure, and organizational resistance to change are several factors that are referred to as the public sector organizations digital maturity and influence the successful implementation of e-SAKIP in Indonesia.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The paper will engage with a sub-theme of the panel, the relationship between public administration and governance in the digital era. The focus will be macro and systemic rather than on specific administrative and digitisation processes. It will also have a comparative basis (the broader research project covers four Anglophone countries and builds on previous comparative research: Craft and Halligan 2020), although the focus here will be on Australia
 
The paper will approach the relationship from three perspectives:
1.  Debate about the standing and relevance of models of public administration and governance have included digital era governance, and the argument that it has displaced new public management (Dunleavy and Evans 2019). The evidence for this and the means by which this might occur remains contested. The international literature on the significance of reform models now is inclined to favour hybrid conceptions that encompass two or more models (Halligan 2022a), but what of digital governance?
 
2. A second relevant question is how to explain variable progress towards digital government. Digital agendas feature in government plans, but priorities may include inter alia efficiency (cost savings), supporting the economy and the private sector, the interest of a segment of the population and improved citizen engagement and service delivery. These have different implications for the development of digital government and transformation. Contextual, cultural and institutional factors shape the pattern of change and digital transformation.
 
3. Digital transformation involves using new technology to rethink and develop core processes and service delivery. It entails new relationships and engagement with stakeholders through addressing holism horizontally and vertically in ways that go beyond the integrated service delivery of the e-government phase, and to advance to new technological thresholds as envisaged by models of digital era governance (Dunleavy and Evans 2019).
 
The Australian case provides a potential exemplar of digital transformation because of specialist agencies and strategic aspirations, but performance has been mixed and not systematically assessed. The credibility of one key dimension, citizen engagement, was blotted by the misuse of artificial intelligence for developing a debt recovery program. The case underscores the problems when a government ignores advice that is discordant with its objectives (Halligan 2022b).
 
The paper will evaluate the character and condition of digital transformation in Australia’s central government drawing on the evolution of the relationship over time, analysis of digital transformation and reform programs, and interviews with experts and stakeholders about
the extent to which digital government is being incorporated and mainstreamed.
 
References
Craft, J. and Halligan, J. (2020) Policy Advice and the Westminster Tradition: Policy Advisory Systems in Australia, Britain, Canada and New Zealand, Cambridge University Press.
Dunleavy, P. & Evans, M. (2019) Digital Transformation, in M. Evans, M. Grattan and P. Dunleavy (eds.) From Turnbull to Morrison: The Trust Divide, Melbourne University Press.
Halligan, J. (2022a) ‘Public Management Reform’ in Schedler, K. (ed.) Elgar Encyclopedia of Public Management, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2022, pp.283-287.
Halligan, J. (2022b) Implementing Digital Transformation in Australia: Performance and Paradoxes, International Research Society for Public Management Conference, 20 April.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Digital Service Teams (DSTs) have emerged as a new organizational form to facilitate Governments in meeting the technological, administrative, and societal challenges of public sector digitalization in many countries. The role of digital service teams is critical, given their role involves a shift from a hierarchical to a network form of governance, and facilitating effective responses to the complex challenges of digital transformation, often in a multilevel polity context. While much of the research has thus far focused on the role of digital service teams in realizing digital transformations in the context of Anglo-Saxon countries, this research will focus on India, a pioneer in advancing digitalization across a wide swath of public services leading to a fundamental restructuring of citizen-state interactions.

 

DSTs are a form of outsourced bureaucracy that facilitates shadow state capacity in emerging democracies eager to transform the functioning of the government through wide-ranging plans for digitalization. India has created a National e-Governance Plan as part of which it has initiated many Mission Mode Projects (MMPs) aimed at the sectoral transformation of policy areas such as land records, public distribution, welfare, health, and so on. It is the first country to create internal capacity for digital transformation through a direct hiring model for private sector experts to realize the successful implementation of its MMPs, which span various levels of its multi-level polity. India’s State e-Mission Teams (SeMTs) face the challenge of what is referred to in project management scholarship as socialized leadership – a form of shared project leadership in which various actors contribute towards accomplishing project goals by performing situational roles as learners as well as leaders.

 

This study will present an interpretive case study of SeMTs, established as part of India’s National e-Governance Program (NeGP) by the Department of Information Technology of India’s central government. It seeks to answer the research question ‘How do India’s State e-Mission Teams facilitate socialized leadership in Mission Mode Project implementation?’ It will examine the unique institutional context in which SeMTs have emerged in India and their role in facilitating digitalization-driven administrative reform through MMPs that sometimes fall within the overlapping jurisdictions of central and state governments. It will discuss the advantages and limitations of India’s SeMT model in facilitating digital transformation through socialized leadership and how they play a role in advancing the realization of digitalization.

 

The findings of this qualitative research will draw evidence from books, parliamentary committee reports, annual reports, interviews with serving and retired administrators, governance actors from both the public and private sectors, members of the SeMTs, including those who work with such digital service teams at various level of India’s federal polity. The study will engage with the advantages and disadvantages of India’s direct sourcing model of DSTs, and the blind spots they create in reconciling the instrumental goals of digitalization with a broader democratic vision of social progress. It will identify pathways to institutionalize the practices of sourcing private sector expertise and bridging the technocracy-democracy divide in digitalization-driven development.

CO-AUTHORS
Vanita Singh (Management Development Institute Gurgaon, India)
ABSTRACT

In 2018, the Indian government initiated a national health reform that ensures the provision of comprehensive primary health care to the population. Under this reform, 1.5 lakh existing primary health facilities were planned to be upgraded to Ayushman Bharat- Health and Wellness Centers (AB-HWCs). Besides the provision of selective (reproductive and child health / few major infectious diseases) primary care, AB-HWCs aim to provide comprehensive primary care services, including screening and management of NCDs, screening and basic management of mental health ailments, care for common ophthalmic and ENT problems, basic dental health care, geriatric and palliative health care, and basic trauma and emergency care. However, the newly introduced cadre of Community Health Officers (CHOs) at AB-HWCs are mainly paramedics, with no specialization in providing comprehensive health services, and digital policy interventions are crucial. To address the shortage of specialists, the Indian government leveraged technology to ensure quality care to rural and remote areas and introduced a nationwide teleconsultation platform, e-sanjeevani.


e-Sanjeevani is a primary healthcare innovation that bridges the digital health divide by extending the reach of quality health services to the population in the rural and remotest parts of the country. The teleconsultation services under eSanjeevani are delivered through two modes: "eSanjeevani AB-HWC" and "eSanjeevani OPD." Using a hub and spoke telemedicine model, the 'eSanjeevani AB-HWC' enables virtual connection between the beneficiary (along with paramedic) at the spoke, i.e., HWC, and doctor/specialist at the hub (tertiary healthcare facility/hospital/medical college). With around 100,000 primary health centers upgraded as AB-HWCs by April 2022 and more than 25,000 hubs providing teleconsultations, the e-Sanjeevani portal has facilitated access to healthcare services across the country. 


Certainly, e-Sanjeevani plays a crucial role in ensuring the provision of good quality specialized healthcare services to the masses. However, recent studies have pointed out implementation challenges for this digital innovation. In this study, we aim to explore the challenges faced by multiple stakeholders in this digital innovation, including healthcare providers, patients, and scheme implementers.  The insights from this study could guide the implementation of future digital innovations in healthcare settings.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

 

This article sketches out the use of policy tools in digital markets, which have proven difficult to regulate because of technological developments, territorial uncertainty, and slow implementation of policies. We discuss, through institutional theory and regulatory governance, the consequences in shift from physical to digital markets for regulation of market arrangements. Empirically, we draw on a comparative case study of the public agencies in the Nordic countries of Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden which regulates and control gambling markets. Despite formulating similar political objectives, all four entities organize regulatory practices and market arrangements differently. Through a document analysis and semi-structured interviews, the paper fleshes out the role of policy tools in the digital age of government, where our findings showcase two-fold implications. While state agencies are limited in effectiveness due to policy formulation and steering arrangements, they find through agile practices innovative tools to improve policy performance. While digital transformation has proven to be both sluggish and slow, public agencies are increasingly robust in regulating digital markets.


 

CO-AUTHORS
Abhishikt Chauhan (National Law School of India University)
ABSTRACT

The aim of this paper is to provide insights regarding digital technology and tools used to make more effective and gradual progress in strengthening governance as well as highlighting challenges in adopting digital technology and tools in India. Digitalization aids in promoting transparency, time-money saving process, and quicker and faster communication between citizens-state.

 

In the past few years programs like Digital India have made remarkable progress in grabbing the attention towards digital tools & internet usage in the public sector as well as government machinery working.

 

However, as per a federal policy think tank of  India, NITI Aayog reported in 2022, more than 60% of India's population lives in rural areas and only 50 % of citizens have access to the internet and smartphone.

 

Here we will examine the effective manner to improve digital literacy and ecosystem to adapt the digitalization, especially in rural areas. The public-private cooperation in Unified Payment Interface (UPI) developed by NPCI has gradually increased digital payments. UPI transactions have increased from nearly 50 crores to 771444 crore worth of transactions in the last 4 years, and more than 100% growth from 2.42 billion to 3.46 billion compared to last year.

 

This observation suggests that creating the standard gateway and easy-to-use payment method for users by partnering with all available private players like Bhim UPI, G Pay, Phonepe, and Paytm leads to promoting a positive environment regarding digital payment as it is easy to use, faster, rewarding and at the same time providing many alternatives to the user by reducing the burden to state without compromising user requirement and needs.

CO-AUTHORS
Caroline Ikiriinya (University of Nairobi)
ABSTRACT

Theorising and Conceptualising Digital Economy Policies in Kenya: An Analysis of Current Trends and Future Prospects.

 

Abstract

Building on the gap in the theorising and conceptualising African digital economy policies; this paper explores frames for understanding the development of digital economy policies. The findings will also offer recommendations for improving digital economy policies in Kenya and developing a more robust and inclusive digital economy. The digital economy is rapidly growing globally and has become a key driver of economic growth and development. Kenya is no exception; with a thriving digital sector that has the potential to transform the country's economy, the government has developed several policy instruments in response. This paper examines the theorising and conceptualisation of digital economy policies in Kenya. It delves into the theories and concepts through which these policies are formulated and implemented, exploring their impact on the growth and development of Kenya's digital economy. The paper also considers the policy issues, challenges, and opportunities faced by Kenya in the digital economy and how existing policies address these.

Modelled on mixed methods, the paper critically analyses the existing literature and case studies. It triangulates four theories that play a crucial role in shaping the digital economy policy-making process; Network society theory, innovation system theory, resource-based view theory, and institutional theory to identify and model critical structural design of ordering a digital economy. This will allow us to develop, for example, four policy practices; Network society policy practice, innovation system policy practice, resource-based view policy practice, and institutional policy practice. In the end, the proposed study provides valuable insights into the current state and narratives of the digital economy in Kenya, taking into considering the role of the state in its development.

 

 

 Keywords: Conceptualization, theorising, digital economy, public policy, policy formulation.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Paper proposal for ICPP T05P03: Administrative Processes in the Digital Era.

Author listed in the system is the corresponding author.

 

Responsible Urban Digital Twins
Over the past few years, there has been a strong push for responsible use of data and digital systems in public services and public policy. Responsible here translate to initiatives that seek to take into account public values and ethical considerations in the design, deployment and use of digital systems in government. Often, this push results in some form of framework or the creation of an actor or institution. As a result, government organisations that consider or deploy digital systems – and AI systems in particular – find a variety of checklists, frameworks and transparency forums that all mean to ensure public value impacts of the technology are considered. We witness a similar development in the case of urban digital twins, where data-driven models and systems represent a city to aid policy making, public services, or decision making. Professionals working on the development of such digital twins find the host of frameworks to represent important concerns yet at the same time find them unwieldly, too far away from their actual practice, and find that there are too many, none of them really implementable and actionable within the local government organization.
This paper presents a nested case study of a large municipality developing an actionable public values framework for its digital twin initiative. Based on desk research of current codes and frameworks that seek to support these considerations, we study three subcases (environmental permit, geo-information, and crowd safety management) through interviews to identify why such approaches fail to become actionable. Based on a co-design process with the municipality, we propose a values framework and implementation guideline for digital twin initiatives and evaluate its actionability for the case organisation.
 
This proposed paper fits with the following two CfP topics for this panel:
*Digitization in the policy process especially considering issues such as AI, ethics, privacy, big data, and regulator technology;   addresses how ethics and public values are made actionable in digital innovation processes that employ big data, models and (sometimes) AI for public services, decision making and control/inspections.
*Digitization in select public policy fields such as healthcare, communications, transportation, the environment, and consumer and financial regulation;  mostly the built environment and the policy fields that cover it or are informed by it (e.g. permit procedures)

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper focuses on the power of storytelling and narratives to drive decision making for a fully digital future. The stories we tell have the power to transform our worldview and are most interesting when they correctly predict aspects of the future, however, they are most powerful when they motivate the hard work needed to build a radically better future. Imagination is critical to these narratives, acting as a fundamental tool for seeking and making change in the world today, igniting resilience and empowering us to confront systemic challenges. 

 

To illustrate the possible impacts of storytelling, this paper will study the role of optimism to provide a sense of coherence and belonging for citizens and bureaucrats amidst deep uncertainty and administrative complexity. We will do this by probing into the stories we tell about digital futures and asking how inclusive and inspiring these technically grounded visions of the future really are. 

 

We will look at the extent to which governments can increase their role in developing environments for progress related to advancements in technology, like AI, with an emphasis on fairness for future generations and socially beneficial applications. We will do this by asking what role should governments play in imagining futures?  And what (if any) role should governments play in ‘protecting’ citizens from these imagined futures? Our analysis will confirm that technology futures and storytelling, as driving forces, provide compelling views into system level dynamics to understand key interactions which could fuel policy making agendas for: AI ethics, good digital governance and the roadmap to a mature (and adaptive) digital state, including guidelines on artificial and inclusive design. We will also examine the impacts of delayed technological or societal advancements should the potential of these driving forces not be realized. 


Ultimately, this paper aims to formalize a set of practices and guiding principles by contributing new conceptual frameworks for public administrators and will argue for widespread and sustained interest in developing technology narratives that inspire, adapt and reignite ambitions for innovation and discovery.