Format

P02. Public policies for hybrid governance

POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Jan-Erik Johanson
Tampere University
Main chair
Jarmo Vakkuri
University of Tampere
Second chair
Tero Erkkilä
University of Helsinki
Third chair
Romulo Pinheiro
University of Agder
Fourth chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Governing societal activities, institutions and work has always been ubiquitous but never self-explanatory. With respect to addressing global problems and pursuing important societal aims, such as combating climate change, easing up urban congestion, advancing welfare or providing education, it is difficult to disentangle public policies and agencies from private efforts, economic institutions and civic activities (Johanson and Vakkuri 2017; Pekkola, Pinheiro et al. 2022). Recent developments in commissioning public services, welfare mixes, corporate social responsibility and global rise in social enterprises signify the fluidity of institutional boundaries. Societies have learnt that both evolutionary adaptation and institutional design occur at multiple levels of society, which produces impacts undetected by our current policy instruments.

This panel “Public policies for hybrid governance”, investigates the dynamic and complex relationship, rationalities (implicit and/or explicit) and tensions and dilemmas among public, private and civic domains contributing to policy outcomes. A chief aim of this panel is to extend our understanding on governance by relating it with hybridity both as a form of governance (“hybrid governance”) and as an object of governance (“governance of hybridity”) and by connecting such an inquiry with policymaking of different contexts.  Governments have fundamental problems with understanding why, how and with what impacts this occurs. The problem is even more pronounced with the interplay between domains that we conceptualize as hybridity. By hybridity we refer to the interaction among public, private and civil society via distinct modes of ownership, parallel but often competing institutional logics, diverse funding bases and various forms of social and institutional control (Skelcher and Smith 2015; Grossi et al. 2017).

 

We propose three main questions for the panel:

1)     How are public policies influenced by hybridity and hybrid forms of governance?

2)     To what extent and via what mechanisms do governments influence (foster or hamper) hybridity?

3)     How does hybridity shape the agenda-setting, implementation and evaluation of public policies?

 

An interesting aspect is the extent to which hybridity shapes the design of governmental structures and arrangements. The policies of the nation states are often labeled as “public” primarily due to the dominant role of governments in instigating political agendas and social change in their territories. Therefore, it is also commonplace to understand the multiplicity of policy rationalities only via “public sector” outcomes. However, policies often include several aspects of public-private linkages and collaboration between governments and business corporations, as well as public-private-civil societal relationships (Erkkilä 2012). Our panel aims to bridge the gap between public policy and public administration scholars in discussing hybridity.

 

It has been assumed that mixing “public” and “private” creates contaminated institutions, and dysfunctional modes of organizations (Jacobs 1992; Ménard 2004). The side effects of specialization of scientific disciplines have contributed to the assumption of monstrous hybridity, which is assumed to compromise the neutrality of government (Vakkuri and Johanson, 2020). Accordingly, the governance solutions of societies have been based on a narrow understanding of institutional mixtures. Hybridity over time may have evolved both “by design” and “by default” (Johanson and Vakkuri 2017).

 

 

 

CALL FOR PAPERS

This panel invites both conceptual and empirical contributions that explore various facets of the policies on hybridity and hybridization of societies, in view of their implications on public policy analysis.

Many ideas of governance acknowledge the variety of public, private and community actors in policy networks, but the significance and implications of this diversity to either public policy or to participating actors has not attracted enough attention. This gives rise to a number of questions. 

Papers may address (among other possibilities) the following issues and questions:

What is the impact of public policies on hybridity? Do public policies increase hybrid forms of governance?
Empirical approaches to assessing the way in which policies approach hybridity: How is it different from governing public agencies or private enterprises? Are there differences in governing or regulating hybrids across policy fields?
A comparison of the perspectives on ‘hybrid governance’ vs. ‘governance of hybridity’ adopted by policy-relevant research and practical policy action: What new aspects does hybridity impose on the shaping of the agenda-setting and policy formation?
How do different types of hybrids (e.g. state-owned enterprises, social enterprises, universities) adapt to public policies? How do community self- and co-regulating practices in tandem with corporate social responsibility and entrepreneurial self-regulation influence public policies?
To what extent and through what mechanisms is hybridity linked to transnational governance and policy diffusion?

 

One of the objective of the panel is to present and continue our ongoing work on special issues e.g. in Australian Journal of Public Administration and in edited volume on the topic of Public policies for hybrid governance, (E.Elgar).

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Political Economy of Corporate Social Responsibility in the Mining Industry of Kazakhstan and Mongolia: A Game-Theoretic Analysis
Peter Howie (Nazarbayev University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This research develops and tests a model of decision-making for actors involved in corporate social responsibility (CSR) projects within the mining industry in Kazakhstan and Mongolia. The research takes into account interactions between actors rather than just concentrating on decisions and motivations of a corporation to perform CSR. In order to perform the analysis, we use a game-theoretic approach. Game theory can be useful for two major reasons. First, it allows us to analyze the dynamic interaction between multiple actors and the interdependence of their strategies. Second, a cooperative game model allows comparing real-life decisions of the players (actors) to a potential Pareto-optimal equilibrium, under which all actors benefit from CSR.

 

Several key actors are involved in the decision-making on CSR projects: (1) the government (subregional, regional and national levels), (2) companies working in extractive sector, and (3) local communities. Each of these actors have their own set of interests, beliefs, and goals. These interests are determined by economic, political, and ethical considerations, as well as by the perception of risks. The process of actors transforming their interests into actual decisions on specific projects is shaped by the regulatory requirements, institutional framework, level of knowledge and capacity of the actors, their perception filters and biases, their previous experience and relationships, and general context of a national and regional development. As a result, it is possible that economic and political objectives of the actors may be in conflict.

 

Our model is tested empirically through qualitative case-study analyses of three major mining operations in Kazakhstan and Mongolia. For our research, 32 individuals were interviewed. These comprised 10 corporate managers of different levels, 11 community members/activists, and 12 experts. Twenty-two interviews were conducted in Kazakhstan; 10 in Mongolia.

 

We have three key findings from our research.  First, if the costs for conducting negotiations with the community are high and the estimated probability of the social unrest is low, the coalition of the company and national government joint venture (CGJV) and the regional government will prefer not to cooperate with the community. Second, if the coalition of CGJV and the regional government values the social license to operate and, therefore, the value of including the community in decision-making is high, the coalition will prefer to cooperate with the community. Third, if the probability of social unrest in case of non-cooperation is considered to be high, the coalition of CGJV and the regional government will prefer to cooperate. Overall, our research suggests that a political economic angle of analysis provides important insights into understanding of the mechanics of CSR cooperation, thus giving actors an opportunity to improve existing practices and gain the full potential benefits of the CSR projects performed by an extractive sector in a developing country.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Does Governance Plays A Key Role In Influencing Public-Private Partnership In Uganda Healthcare System: A Case Study Of Uganda Local Health Care System
Vivian Babirye (Victoria University)
CO-AUTHORS
Isaac Ddumba (African Research Centre 4 Ageing & Dementia )
ABSTRACT

Background:

Over the past two decades, low Middle Income countries (LMICs) have witnessed the rapid increase in private health sector. In countries with mixed mode of health care financing, private health sectors plays a critical role. In order to achieve Universal Health care coverage (UHC), LMICs should focus on harnessing Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs). As one of the strategies to leverage the available limited resources (especially human, infrastructural and financial), the Ugandan government has embarked on promoting and encouraging the Public-Private Partnership model as a way to improve efficiency and achieve economic growth, national health development, and poverty eradication. However, the implementation process of the PPPH policy in local health care systems is slow.

General objective: To assess the governance factors that affect partnerships between the public and private health sectors in local health care system.  

Methods: This study employed a case study approach that allowed in-depth data collection through literature review of relevant studies and documents related to PPPs in health in Uganda. A conceptual framework that identifies and defines the interactions between governance and Public Private Partnerships in health was used to systematize data synthesis and analysis. Findings were triangulated with literature from LMICs especially in the Sub-Saharan region. Additional literature at national level was also consulted together with secondary data from reports (including project, performance and evaluation reports) and policy documents.

Result: District level, health sector governance is provided through three oversight structures: the management, governance and partnership structures. District Health office (DHO) assumes stewardship of the health sector through the management structure with coordination of all actors (public and private). The government interacts with private actors through PPP coordination structures, guided by the PPPH policy. There is noted evidence of weaknesses in the functionality of the coordination structures including the private sector governance bodies. The documented reasons includes: inconsistencies in convenings, under-resourced operations, and weak participation of both public and private actors. The study reveals factors that facilitated the PPPH policy development process that included: the historical government-faith based collaboration; the presence of influential private sector (PNFP and PFP) and champions; donor support and influence; a supportive health Minister (after 2010); political will for PPPs; and the proliferation of PFPs that under-pinned government to propagate engagement of private actors among others.

Conclusion: Sustainable PPPH in Uganda thus calls for stronger coordination and creation of legitimate collaborative frameworks that stipulate mutually agreed goals and provide for balanced participation, informed monitoring, complementarity, transparency, accountability and effective governance structures. Integration of strategies to mitigate and solve system-wide challenges is critical to facilitate health system strengthening, including alignment of HDPs/donor actions with national priorities. Increased focus should be delved into resourcing the operationalization of the PPPH policy up to district level, while ensuring engagement of all essential actors with development and implementation of a communication strategy plus effective monitoring and evaluation frameworks.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Hybrid decision making in higher education – the case of strategic alliances
Romulo Pinheiro (University of Agder)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper seeks to address a lacuna in the organisational literature by investigating how decision-making processes take place in the context of meta-organisations, as is the case of transnational strategic alliances involving several European universities. Empirically, the paper builds on two distinct case studies related to the European University Initiative– Circle U. and FORTHEM. The study is qualitative in character, focusing on semi-structured interviews with key actors from the alliances and review of relevant literature and policy documents. Conceptually, in addition to the concept of meta-organisations, and the notion of universities as hybrid organisations, the paper builds on decision theory, whereby four decision-making models are operationalised; the rational actor model, the collegial model, the political model and the garbage can model. More specifically, the study investigates two main stages in the alliances – the initiation stage and the consolidation stage. The findings demonstrate the prevalence of key features associated with each of the four decision models, resulting in hybrid decision dynamics. That said, the data clearly show that most decisions are made by consensus, and that resource dependency, soft power, trust, and tensions underpin these decision-making processes. The paper reflects on the implications of these findings in terms of the growing literature on hybrid- organisations, organising and policy making, and concludes by proposing a way forward. 

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Hybridity and non-human agency in digital governance
Tero Erkkilä (University of Helsinki)
CO-AUTHORS
Konstantinos Kostas (University of Helsinki)
ABSTRACT

Hybridity in public governance is often identified in ownership arrangements that are blurring public and private boundaries or as public-private partnerships in service delivery. Hybridity is also discussed in the context of institutional complexity owing to various, potentially conflicting, institutional logics associated with a single institution, posing challenges to accountability. This paper discusses hybridity in the context of digital and algorithmic governance, highlighting emerging forms of hybridity in human - non-human agency that are present in the automation of decision-making and use of AI applications. We also acknowledge new stakeholders and forms of collaboration that are tied with digitization, as well as the emerging questions of accountability. Our paper explores the transformations of state due to the emergence of non-human agency in automated decision-making conceptually, focusing on the shifting conceptualizations of accountability and transparency as well as the novel concept of human-centricity of algorithmic governance. To understand the digital transformations of state, one needs to engage in contextual analysis of the actual changes that might show even paradoxical effects, such as the calls for “human-centricity” amid the increasing non-human agency in automated decision-making.

 

Currently, there is a lot of ambiguity regarding the concepts of digital governance, including human-centricity. Typically, in the context of governance, human-centric mode of thought is portrayed as the antithesis for ‘non-human’ types of governance, such as algorithmic governance. Moreover, the concept of human-centricity is employed as a political metaphor in debates around the social impacts of automation. Human-centricity has also been defined as the main design principle for the implementation and management of public policies concerning digitalization. The concept is applied as a design approach in order to settle the institutional dynamics in digital transformation. For instance, the notion of ‘human-centric AI’ is prevalent in major AI governance strategies. Indeed, human-centric AI is an exemplar of a hybrid governance concept. Through analysing the concept of human-centricity through the lens of hybridity, the paper aims to examine the institutional dynamics and conceptual incoherencies in digital governance.  

 

Empirically our paper analyses the changes in Finnish context, where legislation on automated decision-making and access to government information are being revised to suite the demands of algorithmic governance. In addition, we analyse the changes in national governance of knowledge, including the Finnish National AI program AuroraAI. In the program, the state aims to produce a network that utilizes human and non-human agency together in state governance, while declaring human-centricity as its main design principle. The program reveals the hybrid characteristics and issues in state transformation through digitization. For example, the utilization of human and algorithmic decision-making together in state governance generates new difficulties for assessing accountability. Additionally, it shows how the state is taking a central role in the field of digitalization, generally dominated by modes of private governance.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Coping with institutional complexity – blending institutional logics in public management
Tim Busscher (University of Groningen)
CO-AUTHORS
Elina Vikstedt (University of Tampere)
ABSTRACT

During the past decades, the public sector has undergone notable institutional transformations involving managerial reforms and the rise of economic rationalism in public sector management and decision-making (Dunleavy & Hood, 1994; Hood, 1991) and as a result, public management practices are confronted with increasing institutionally complexity: elements of multiple, often conflicting institutional logics are enacted by various individuals and organisations (Greenwood et al., 2011; Mair et al., 2015). Institutional logics are generally understood as “the socially constructed, historical patterns of cultural symbols and material practices, including assumptions, values, and beliefs, by which individuals and organisations provide meaning to their daily activity, organise time and space, and reproduce their lives and experiences” (Thornton et al., 2012). The institutional logics approach draws attention to the construction of society through institutional orders composed of institutional logics as macro-level meaning structures, and the organizations and individuals located within those orders, and whose practices are constituted and constrained by institutional logics, but also capable of instigating changes and influencing their surroundings (Friedland & Alford, 1991).

 

In the spirit of past public sector reforms, a growing number of studies observe and discuss mixing managerial and market logics with state and public welfare logics. Literature on the hybridisation of institutional logics has put forth the idea of blends and blending of institutional logics, where the normative, regulative, and cognitive elements of two or more institutional logics merge together in field, organisation, and individual-level practices. Definitions of blending range from blurring distinctions between different and potentially conflicting logics (Haveman & Rao, 2006; Thornton et al., 2012) to an ‘amalgamate’ of two or more logics in which the original components are no longer discernible (Polzer et al., 2016). In line with the growing attention for the role of institutions in practices, more attention for the role of actors in enacting and potentially shaping and blending seemingly conflicting logics also provides more insight into how responses at the micro-level can radiate into broad institutional change.

 

The present study seeks to respond to the recent calls for closer scrutiny of the co-constitute relationship between actors and institutions (Zilber, 2016; Lounsbury et al., 2021), institutional logic constellations (Jancsary et al., 2017), and their multi-level interactions and dynamics in hybridisation processes through a whole chain of situational, transformational, and action-formation mechanisms of institutional change (Hedström and Ylikoski, 2010). We have analyzed over 90 articles that discuss blending of institutional logics in the field of public management. On this basis, we will provide insight into the mechanisms, antecedents, and consequences of blending in public management, and increase the coherence of the literature on hybridisation in the public sector. This review of the extant literature on blending helps to better understand blending in public management, and what its consequences are to public management discipline.

 

Literature

- Dunleavy, P., & Hood, C. (1994). From old public administration to new public management. Public money & management, 14(3), 9-16.

- Friedland, R. & Alford, R. (1991). Bringing society back in: Symbols, practices, and institutional contradictions. The new institutionalism in organizational analysis, 232-263.

- Greenwood, R., Raynard, M., Kodeih, F., Micelotta, E. R., & Lounsbury, M. (2011). Institutional complexity and organizational responses. Academy of Management annals, 5(1), 317-371.

- Haveman, H. A., & Rao, H. (2006). Hybrid forms and the evolution of thrifts. American Behavioral Scientist, 49(7), 974-986.

- Hedström, P., & Ylikoski, P. (2010). Causal mechanisms in the social sciences. Annual review of sociology, 36, 49-67.

- Hood, C. (1991). A public management for all seasons?. Public administration, 69(1), 3-19.

- Jancsary, D., Meyer, R. E., Höllerer, M. A., & Barberio, V. (2017). Toward a structural model of organizational-level institutional pluralism and logic interconnectedness. Organization Science, 28(6), 1150-1167.

- Lounsbury, M., Anderson, D. A., & Spee, P. (2021). On practice and institution. In On Practice and Institution: New Empirical Directions. Emerald Publishing Limited.

- Mair, J., Mayer, J., & Lutz, E. (2015). Navigating institutional plurality: Organizational governance in hybrid organizations. Organization studies, 36(6), 713-739.

- Polzer, T., Meyer, R. E., Höllerer, M. A., & Seiwald, J. (2016). Institutional Hybridity in Public Sector Reform: Replacement, Blending, or Layering of Administrative Paradigms. In How Institutions Matter!. Emerald Group Publishing Limited.

- Thornton, P. H., Ocasio, W., & Lounsbury, M. (2012). The institutional logics perspective: A new approach to culture, structure and process. OUP Oxford.

- Zilber, T. B. (2016). How institutional logics matter: A bottom-up exploration. In How institutions matter!. Emerald Group Publishing Limited

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - The Impact of 'Governance in Hybridity' on Public Policy: A Case Study of Konza Technopolis
Caroline Ikiriinya (University of Nairobi)
CO-AUTHORS
Lydiah Kiriinya (University of Nairobi)
Emmanuel Chepkwony
Fredrick Otieno (Tianjin Normal University)
ABSTRACT

Abstract

 

Building a smart city from scratch requires a multi-faceted approach that takes into account the intricacy of governance structures and public policy challenges. The governance of hybridity, which recognizes the complexity and diversity of urban systems, and seeks to manage the coexistence of different actors, technologies, and systems within the city is a relatively new approach to managing the development of smart cities. Konza Technopolis is a smart city under construction in Kenya that aims to provide a model for sustainable urban development in Africa. This study will examine concepts and the impact of ‘governance in hybridity’ in shaping public policy development in the context of building a sustainable smart city.

 

Modeled along a mixed-methods approach which includes a literature review, case study analysis, and expert interviews to unravel the concept of ‘governance in hybridity’ and its role in the contextualization of the governance and public policy process in building a smart city from scratch.  This paper provides insights into the impact of ‘governance in hybridity’ on public policy development in the context of building a smart city from scratch, contributing to the discourse of new aspects shaping agenda setting and policy development. Moreover, the findings provide valuable insights for policymakers, practitioners, and researchers in the field of smart city development.

 

Keywords: 'Governance in Hybridity', Public Policy, Smart City, Financing,  Konza Technopolis

 

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Policies of hybridity and hybridity of policies – exploring policy processes and mechanisms from the hybridity perspective
Jan-Erik Johanson (Tampere University)
CO-AUTHORS
Jarmo Vakkuri (University of Tampere)
ABSTRACT

Policies of hybridity and hybridity of policies – exploring policy processes and mechanisms from the hybridity perspective
Governing hybridity provides a new way of populating the mechanistic perspective of the policy process (Capano et al. 2019). From a mechanistic perspective policy process consists of situational activators, direct first order mechanisms influencing individual action and second order mechanisms aggregating the multiple first order mechanisms. According to the traditional model, together these lead into outputs and impacts. Observing and measuring policy impacts has been one of the cornerstones of the model.
The mechanistic view embraces the idea that policy processes are not always directly observable, but it also gives analytic tools to see why this is the case. From a theoretical point of view academic disciplines separate the subject matter of hybridity into their own realms by segregating business and public policies. Moreover, they separate mission-oriented civil activity from the operation of governments and markets, Second, the administrative and economic classification instruments promote the distinction between public and private which hides obvious interaction between parts of the society. Third, the practice of governing echoes the well-established distinctions between governments, markets and civil society. ‘Business of business is business’, ‘business of government is government’ and ‘business of civil society is mission’.
The objective of this paper is to scrutinize theoretico-conceptual possibilities for connecting the hybridity perspective with mechanistically oriented policy models. In the paper, we discuss first and second order policy mechanisms by linking distinct dimensions of hybridity and modes of policy value creation in the policy system. Moreover, we explore distinct triggering processes of policy making which makes policy impacts both often unexpected and unintended, and difficult to detect and measure.
Keywords: policy making, mechanistic perspective, hybridity, value creation
 
 

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Difference in the performance of hybrid governance and bureaucracy against COVID-19 pandemic in Japan
Atsuo SATO (Hiroshima City University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper aims to examine the performance of hybrid governance and bureaucracy as a measure against COVID-19 in Japan. The bureaucracy from central to local governments is believed to be strong in Japan. The Infectious Disease Control Law was also enacted based on the traditional bureaucratic approach. However, under central and local administrative reform policies over the past two decades, local governments had already reduced the number of civil servants. In particular, public health centers, which were responsible for communicable diseases such as tuberculosis, were targeted for public reform because those diseases were considered to have already been conquered in Japan. After the COVID-19 pandemic, although the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare knew the situation of local governments, they decided to conduct aggressive epidemiological surveys under the Infectious Disease Control Law and asked public health centers to play a major role in this process. In addition, public health centers were assigned various tasks ranging from having patients undergo PCR testing to coordinating hospitalization. Many local governments asked for support from other departments in order to devote human resources to the health centers. Under these circumstances, some local governments began to outsource or use networks of medical associations, private companies, universities, and NPOs to solve the problems at hand. The research questions for this study were (1) What hybrid forms of governance existed and how did they affect public policy against COVID-19? (2) How did local governments influence hybridity? What is the mechanism? (3) How did hybridity shape the agenda-setting, implementation, and evaluation of public policy on coronavirus countermeasures? Responding to these research questions, the effect of traditional bureaucracy system in the local governments were also examined. In comparison with the bureaucracy system, hybrid governance was verified as the key factor for the success of the COVID-19 measures. Thus, the new infectious disease control measures in Japan offered many cases and lessons for the effectiveness of hybrid governance.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Gouvernance hybride des politiques publiques et budget programme au cameroun.
Brice Youbi (CERDAP)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

 

The governance of public policies and the program budget are important instruments for the management of public affairs in Cameroon. Public policy governance involves the development, implementation and evaluation of effective and efficient public policies to meet the needs of the population. The program budget is a key tool for managing public policies. It is a results-based management tool, as it helps to plan expenditures and allocate the financial resources needed to achieve policy objectives. The preparation of the program budget begins with an analysis of public policy needs. Public policies are then formulated to meet these needs, and budgetary programs and projects are set up to implement them. Financial resources are allocated accordingly to support these efforts as part of a hybridization of the country's economic governance. However, in Cameroon, with the advent of so-called emergence policies intended to stimulate development, with a view to supporting the State in carrying out its structuring projects, there is a strong involvement of new non-State actors ( private companies, universities, etc. .) in the design and implementation of the Program Budget Policy in Cameroon. In view of the ever-increasing weight of these new actors in the formulation of public policies in various sectors of social life, to what extent do their interventions shape the design and implementation of Program Budget policy in Cameroon? The analysis of this question will inform us about the influence of these new actors in the shaping and implementation of public policies relating to the program budget in Cameroon. Within the framework of this research, we will appeal not only to the theories of governance and public action. Applied to our work, the theory of governance will allow us to identify the actions upstream and downstream of the authorities invested with public powers; while the theory of public action will allow us to better shed light on the different interrelationships between state actors andnon-state actors in the design and implementation of program budget public policies in Cameroon. 

 

Keywords: Hybrid governance; Program Budget; Public policies ; Cameroon

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - Hybrid Organisations: Different Development Patterns of Welfare Associations on Markets and Society
Thomas Lange
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Welfare associations (Wohlfahrtsverbände) are organisations with specific characteristics and with several functions. On the one hand, they are service providers through their member institutions and, on the other hand, they are interest associations for social groups that are considered socially disadvantaged. They can thus be described as multifunctional organisations operating simultaneously in different environments.

The socio-political upheavals in Germany in the mid-1990s are intended to show that the multifunctionality of welfare associations leads to contrasting patterns of development, which in turn have different effects on the environment.

A hybridity approach shows that welfare associations are a polycentric acting network and are thus able to react to different environments. While individual organisations of the network react in some environments according to isomorphic patterns and copy organisational models, they develop at the same time individually and innovative in other environments, which is understood as polymorphic development. The extent to which welfare associations act isomorphically or polymorphically depends on the (un-)certainty of the environment in which they operate.

Two different directions of effect between welfare associations and their environment can be derived from this: While their development is determined within the framework of isomorphic patterns in uncertain environments (markets), they develop innovatively and are able to shape socio-political structures in certain environments. They have an effect on the structures surrounding them.

The shaping potential of welfare associations is reflected along their impact on society (e.g. poverty policy). In the sociopolitical system, welfare associations have created a new form of corporatism, that I define as "confrontational corporatism", which, unlike its predecessors, is no longer characterized by cooperative coexistence, but by opposition between politics and welfare associations. Central to this is that this confrontational attitude can avoid destabilizing the socio-political system through social forces. Welfare associations become (again) a quasi- non-governmental organization (QUANGO).

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This research develops and tests a model of decision-making for actors involved in corporate social responsibility (CSR) projects within the mining industry in Kazakhstan and Mongolia. The research takes into account interactions between actors rather than just concentrating on decisions and motivations of a corporation to perform CSR. In order to perform the analysis, we use a game-theoretic approach. Game theory can be useful for two major reasons. First, it allows us to analyze the dynamic interaction between multiple actors and the interdependence of their strategies. Second, a cooperative game model allows comparing real-life decisions of the players (actors) to a potential Pareto-optimal equilibrium, under which all actors benefit from CSR.

 

Several key actors are involved in the decision-making on CSR projects: (1) the government (subregional, regional and national levels), (2) companies working in extractive sector, and (3) local communities. Each of these actors have their own set of interests, beliefs, and goals. These interests are determined by economic, political, and ethical considerations, as well as by the perception of risks. The process of actors transforming their interests into actual decisions on specific projects is shaped by the regulatory requirements, institutional framework, level of knowledge and capacity of the actors, their perception filters and biases, their previous experience and relationships, and general context of a national and regional development. As a result, it is possible that economic and political objectives of the actors may be in conflict.

 

Our model is tested empirically through qualitative case-study analyses of three major mining operations in Kazakhstan and Mongolia. For our research, 32 individuals were interviewed. These comprised 10 corporate managers of different levels, 11 community members/activists, and 12 experts. Twenty-two interviews were conducted in Kazakhstan; 10 in Mongolia.

 

We have three key findings from our research.  First, if the costs for conducting negotiations with the community are high and the estimated probability of the social unrest is low, the coalition of the company and national government joint venture (CGJV) and the regional government will prefer not to cooperate with the community. Second, if the coalition of CGJV and the regional government values the social license to operate and, therefore, the value of including the community in decision-making is high, the coalition will prefer to cooperate with the community. Third, if the probability of social unrest in case of non-cooperation is considered to be high, the coalition of CGJV and the regional government will prefer to cooperate. Overall, our research suggests that a political economic angle of analysis provides important insights into understanding of the mechanics of CSR cooperation, thus giving actors an opportunity to improve existing practices and gain the full potential benefits of the CSR projects performed by an extractive sector in a developing country.

CO-AUTHORS
Isaac Ddumba (African Research Centre 4 Ageing & Dementia )
ABSTRACT

Background:

Over the past two decades, low Middle Income countries (LMICs) have witnessed the rapid increase in private health sector. In countries with mixed mode of health care financing, private health sectors plays a critical role. In order to achieve Universal Health care coverage (UHC), LMICs should focus on harnessing Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs). As one of the strategies to leverage the available limited resources (especially human, infrastructural and financial), the Ugandan government has embarked on promoting and encouraging the Public-Private Partnership model as a way to improve efficiency and achieve economic growth, national health development, and poverty eradication. However, the implementation process of the PPPH policy in local health care systems is slow.

General objective: To assess the governance factors that affect partnerships between the public and private health sectors in local health care system.  

Methods: This study employed a case study approach that allowed in-depth data collection through literature review of relevant studies and documents related to PPPs in health in Uganda. A conceptual framework that identifies and defines the interactions between governance and Public Private Partnerships in health was used to systematize data synthesis and analysis. Findings were triangulated with literature from LMICs especially in the Sub-Saharan region. Additional literature at national level was also consulted together with secondary data from reports (including project, performance and evaluation reports) and policy documents.

Result: District level, health sector governance is provided through three oversight structures: the management, governance and partnership structures. District Health office (DHO) assumes stewardship of the health sector through the management structure with coordination of all actors (public and private). The government interacts with private actors through PPP coordination structures, guided by the PPPH policy. There is noted evidence of weaknesses in the functionality of the coordination structures including the private sector governance bodies. The documented reasons includes: inconsistencies in convenings, under-resourced operations, and weak participation of both public and private actors. The study reveals factors that facilitated the PPPH policy development process that included: the historical government-faith based collaboration; the presence of influential private sector (PNFP and PFP) and champions; donor support and influence; a supportive health Minister (after 2010); political will for PPPs; and the proliferation of PFPs that under-pinned government to propagate engagement of private actors among others.

Conclusion: Sustainable PPPH in Uganda thus calls for stronger coordination and creation of legitimate collaborative frameworks that stipulate mutually agreed goals and provide for balanced participation, informed monitoring, complementarity, transparency, accountability and effective governance structures. Integration of strategies to mitigate and solve system-wide challenges is critical to facilitate health system strengthening, including alignment of HDPs/donor actions with national priorities. Increased focus should be delved into resourcing the operationalization of the PPPH policy up to district level, while ensuring engagement of all essential actors with development and implementation of a communication strategy plus effective monitoring and evaluation frameworks.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper seeks to address a lacuna in the organisational literature by investigating how decision-making processes take place in the context of meta-organisations, as is the case of transnational strategic alliances involving several European universities. Empirically, the paper builds on two distinct case studies related to the European University Initiative– Circle U. and FORTHEM. The study is qualitative in character, focusing on semi-structured interviews with key actors from the alliances and review of relevant literature and policy documents. Conceptually, in addition to the concept of meta-organisations, and the notion of universities as hybrid organisations, the paper builds on decision theory, whereby four decision-making models are operationalised; the rational actor model, the collegial model, the political model and the garbage can model. More specifically, the study investigates two main stages in the alliances – the initiation stage and the consolidation stage. The findings demonstrate the prevalence of key features associated with each of the four decision models, resulting in hybrid decision dynamics. That said, the data clearly show that most decisions are made by consensus, and that resource dependency, soft power, trust, and tensions underpin these decision-making processes. The paper reflects on the implications of these findings in terms of the growing literature on hybrid- organisations, organising and policy making, and concludes by proposing a way forward. 

CO-AUTHORS
Konstantinos Kostas (University of Helsinki)
ABSTRACT

Hybridity in public governance is often identified in ownership arrangements that are blurring public and private boundaries or as public-private partnerships in service delivery. Hybridity is also discussed in the context of institutional complexity owing to various, potentially conflicting, institutional logics associated with a single institution, posing challenges to accountability. This paper discusses hybridity in the context of digital and algorithmic governance, highlighting emerging forms of hybridity in human - non-human agency that are present in the automation of decision-making and use of AI applications. We also acknowledge new stakeholders and forms of collaboration that are tied with digitization, as well as the emerging questions of accountability. Our paper explores the transformations of state due to the emergence of non-human agency in automated decision-making conceptually, focusing on the shifting conceptualizations of accountability and transparency as well as the novel concept of human-centricity of algorithmic governance. To understand the digital transformations of state, one needs to engage in contextual analysis of the actual changes that might show even paradoxical effects, such as the calls for “human-centricity” amid the increasing non-human agency in automated decision-making.

 

Currently, there is a lot of ambiguity regarding the concepts of digital governance, including human-centricity. Typically, in the context of governance, human-centric mode of thought is portrayed as the antithesis for ‘non-human’ types of governance, such as algorithmic governance. Moreover, the concept of human-centricity is employed as a political metaphor in debates around the social impacts of automation. Human-centricity has also been defined as the main design principle for the implementation and management of public policies concerning digitalization. The concept is applied as a design approach in order to settle the institutional dynamics in digital transformation. For instance, the notion of ‘human-centric AI’ is prevalent in major AI governance strategies. Indeed, human-centric AI is an exemplar of a hybrid governance concept. Through analysing the concept of human-centricity through the lens of hybridity, the paper aims to examine the institutional dynamics and conceptual incoherencies in digital governance.  

 

Empirically our paper analyses the changes in Finnish context, where legislation on automated decision-making and access to government information are being revised to suite the demands of algorithmic governance. In addition, we analyse the changes in national governance of knowledge, including the Finnish National AI program AuroraAI. In the program, the state aims to produce a network that utilizes human and non-human agency together in state governance, while declaring human-centricity as its main design principle. The program reveals the hybrid characteristics and issues in state transformation through digitization. For example, the utilization of human and algorithmic decision-making together in state governance generates new difficulties for assessing accountability. Additionally, it shows how the state is taking a central role in the field of digitalization, generally dominated by modes of private governance.

CO-AUTHORS
Elina Vikstedt (University of Tampere)
ABSTRACT

During the past decades, the public sector has undergone notable institutional transformations involving managerial reforms and the rise of economic rationalism in public sector management and decision-making (Dunleavy & Hood, 1994; Hood, 1991) and as a result, public management practices are confronted with increasing institutionally complexity: elements of multiple, often conflicting institutional logics are enacted by various individuals and organisations (Greenwood et al., 2011; Mair et al., 2015). Institutional logics are generally understood as “the socially constructed, historical patterns of cultural symbols and material practices, including assumptions, values, and beliefs, by which individuals and organisations provide meaning to their daily activity, organise time and space, and reproduce their lives and experiences” (Thornton et al., 2012). The institutional logics approach draws attention to the construction of society through institutional orders composed of institutional logics as macro-level meaning structures, and the organizations and individuals located within those orders, and whose practices are constituted and constrained by institutional logics, but also capable of instigating changes and influencing their surroundings (Friedland & Alford, 1991).

 

In the spirit of past public sector reforms, a growing number of studies observe and discuss mixing managerial and market logics with state and public welfare logics. Literature on the hybridisation of institutional logics has put forth the idea of blends and blending of institutional logics, where the normative, regulative, and cognitive elements of two or more institutional logics merge together in field, organisation, and individual-level practices. Definitions of blending range from blurring distinctions between different and potentially conflicting logics (Haveman & Rao, 2006; Thornton et al., 2012) to an ‘amalgamate’ of two or more logics in which the original components are no longer discernible (Polzer et al., 2016). In line with the growing attention for the role of institutions in practices, more attention for the role of actors in enacting and potentially shaping and blending seemingly conflicting logics also provides more insight into how responses at the micro-level can radiate into broad institutional change.

 

The present study seeks to respond to the recent calls for closer scrutiny of the co-constitute relationship between actors and institutions (Zilber, 2016; Lounsbury et al., 2021), institutional logic constellations (Jancsary et al., 2017), and their multi-level interactions and dynamics in hybridisation processes through a whole chain of situational, transformational, and action-formation mechanisms of institutional change (Hedström and Ylikoski, 2010). We have analyzed over 90 articles that discuss blending of institutional logics in the field of public management. On this basis, we will provide insight into the mechanisms, antecedents, and consequences of blending in public management, and increase the coherence of the literature on hybridisation in the public sector. This review of the extant literature on blending helps to better understand blending in public management, and what its consequences are to public management discipline.

 

Literature

- Dunleavy, P., & Hood, C. (1994). From old public administration to new public management. Public money & management, 14(3), 9-16.

- Friedland, R. & Alford, R. (1991). Bringing society back in: Symbols, practices, and institutional contradictions. The new institutionalism in organizational analysis, 232-263.

- Greenwood, R., Raynard, M., Kodeih, F., Micelotta, E. R., & Lounsbury, M. (2011). Institutional complexity and organizational responses. Academy of Management annals, 5(1), 317-371.

- Haveman, H. A., & Rao, H. (2006). Hybrid forms and the evolution of thrifts. American Behavioral Scientist, 49(7), 974-986.

- Hedström, P., & Ylikoski, P. (2010). Causal mechanisms in the social sciences. Annual review of sociology, 36, 49-67.

- Hood, C. (1991). A public management for all seasons?. Public administration, 69(1), 3-19.

- Jancsary, D., Meyer, R. E., Höllerer, M. A., & Barberio, V. (2017). Toward a structural model of organizational-level institutional pluralism and logic interconnectedness. Organization Science, 28(6), 1150-1167.

- Lounsbury, M., Anderson, D. A., & Spee, P. (2021). On practice and institution. In On Practice and Institution: New Empirical Directions. Emerald Publishing Limited.

- Mair, J., Mayer, J., & Lutz, E. (2015). Navigating institutional plurality: Organizational governance in hybrid organizations. Organization studies, 36(6), 713-739.

- Polzer, T., Meyer, R. E., Höllerer, M. A., & Seiwald, J. (2016). Institutional Hybridity in Public Sector Reform: Replacement, Blending, or Layering of Administrative Paradigms. In How Institutions Matter!. Emerald Group Publishing Limited.

- Thornton, P. H., Ocasio, W., & Lounsbury, M. (2012). The institutional logics perspective: A new approach to culture, structure and process. OUP Oxford.

- Zilber, T. B. (2016). How institutional logics matter: A bottom-up exploration. In How institutions matter!. Emerald Group Publishing Limited

CO-AUTHORS
Lydiah Kiriinya (University of Nairobi)
Emmanuel Chepkwony
Fredrick Otieno (Tianjin Normal University)
ABSTRACT

Abstract

 

Building a smart city from scratch requires a multi-faceted approach that takes into account the intricacy of governance structures and public policy challenges. The governance of hybridity, which recognizes the complexity and diversity of urban systems, and seeks to manage the coexistence of different actors, technologies, and systems within the city is a relatively new approach to managing the development of smart cities. Konza Technopolis is a smart city under construction in Kenya that aims to provide a model for sustainable urban development in Africa. This study will examine concepts and the impact of ‘governance in hybridity’ in shaping public policy development in the context of building a sustainable smart city.

 

Modeled along a mixed-methods approach which includes a literature review, case study analysis, and expert interviews to unravel the concept of ‘governance in hybridity’ and its role in the contextualization of the governance and public policy process in building a smart city from scratch.  This paper provides insights into the impact of ‘governance in hybridity’ on public policy development in the context of building a smart city from scratch, contributing to the discourse of new aspects shaping agenda setting and policy development. Moreover, the findings provide valuable insights for policymakers, practitioners, and researchers in the field of smart city development.

 

Keywords: 'Governance in Hybridity', Public Policy, Smart City, Financing,  Konza Technopolis

 

CO-AUTHORS
Jarmo Vakkuri (University of Tampere)
ABSTRACT

Policies of hybridity and hybridity of policies – exploring policy processes and mechanisms from the hybridity perspective
Governing hybridity provides a new way of populating the mechanistic perspective of the policy process (Capano et al. 2019). From a mechanistic perspective policy process consists of situational activators, direct first order mechanisms influencing individual action and second order mechanisms aggregating the multiple first order mechanisms. According to the traditional model, together these lead into outputs and impacts. Observing and measuring policy impacts has been one of the cornerstones of the model.
The mechanistic view embraces the idea that policy processes are not always directly observable, but it also gives analytic tools to see why this is the case. From a theoretical point of view academic disciplines separate the subject matter of hybridity into their own realms by segregating business and public policies. Moreover, they separate mission-oriented civil activity from the operation of governments and markets, Second, the administrative and economic classification instruments promote the distinction between public and private which hides obvious interaction between parts of the society. Third, the practice of governing echoes the well-established distinctions between governments, markets and civil society. ‘Business of business is business’, ‘business of government is government’ and ‘business of civil society is mission’.
The objective of this paper is to scrutinize theoretico-conceptual possibilities for connecting the hybridity perspective with mechanistically oriented policy models. In the paper, we discuss first and second order policy mechanisms by linking distinct dimensions of hybridity and modes of policy value creation in the policy system. Moreover, we explore distinct triggering processes of policy making which makes policy impacts both often unexpected and unintended, and difficult to detect and measure.
Keywords: policy making, mechanistic perspective, hybridity, value creation
 
 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper aims to examine the performance of hybrid governance and bureaucracy as a measure against COVID-19 in Japan. The bureaucracy from central to local governments is believed to be strong in Japan. The Infectious Disease Control Law was also enacted based on the traditional bureaucratic approach. However, under central and local administrative reform policies over the past two decades, local governments had already reduced the number of civil servants. In particular, public health centers, which were responsible for communicable diseases such as tuberculosis, were targeted for public reform because those diseases were considered to have already been conquered in Japan. After the COVID-19 pandemic, although the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare knew the situation of local governments, they decided to conduct aggressive epidemiological surveys under the Infectious Disease Control Law and asked public health centers to play a major role in this process. In addition, public health centers were assigned various tasks ranging from having patients undergo PCR testing to coordinating hospitalization. Many local governments asked for support from other departments in order to devote human resources to the health centers. Under these circumstances, some local governments began to outsource or use networks of medical associations, private companies, universities, and NPOs to solve the problems at hand. The research questions for this study were (1) What hybrid forms of governance existed and how did they affect public policy against COVID-19? (2) How did local governments influence hybridity? What is the mechanism? (3) How did hybridity shape the agenda-setting, implementation, and evaluation of public policy on coronavirus countermeasures? Responding to these research questions, the effect of traditional bureaucracy system in the local governments were also examined. In comparison with the bureaucracy system, hybrid governance was verified as the key factor for the success of the COVID-19 measures. Thus, the new infectious disease control measures in Japan offered many cases and lessons for the effectiveness of hybrid governance.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

 

The governance of public policies and the program budget are important instruments for the management of public affairs in Cameroon. Public policy governance involves the development, implementation and evaluation of effective and efficient public policies to meet the needs of the population. The program budget is a key tool for managing public policies. It is a results-based management tool, as it helps to plan expenditures and allocate the financial resources needed to achieve policy objectives. The preparation of the program budget begins with an analysis of public policy needs. Public policies are then formulated to meet these needs, and budgetary programs and projects are set up to implement them. Financial resources are allocated accordingly to support these efforts as part of a hybridization of the country's economic governance. However, in Cameroon, with the advent of so-called emergence policies intended to stimulate development, with a view to supporting the State in carrying out its structuring projects, there is a strong involvement of new non-State actors ( private companies, universities, etc. .) in the design and implementation of the Program Budget Policy in Cameroon. In view of the ever-increasing weight of these new actors in the formulation of public policies in various sectors of social life, to what extent do their interventions shape the design and implementation of Program Budget policy in Cameroon? The analysis of this question will inform us about the influence of these new actors in the shaping and implementation of public policies relating to the program budget in Cameroon. Within the framework of this research, we will appeal not only to the theories of governance and public action. Applied to our work, the theory of governance will allow us to identify the actions upstream and downstream of the authorities invested with public powers; while the theory of public action will allow us to better shed light on the different interrelationships between state actors andnon-state actors in the design and implementation of program budget public policies in Cameroon. 

 

Keywords: Hybrid governance; Program Budget; Public policies ; Cameroon

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Welfare associations (Wohlfahrtsverbände) are organisations with specific characteristics and with several functions. On the one hand, they are service providers through their member institutions and, on the other hand, they are interest associations for social groups that are considered socially disadvantaged. They can thus be described as multifunctional organisations operating simultaneously in different environments.

The socio-political upheavals in Germany in the mid-1990s are intended to show that the multifunctionality of welfare associations leads to contrasting patterns of development, which in turn have different effects on the environment.

A hybridity approach shows that welfare associations are a polycentric acting network and are thus able to react to different environments. While individual organisations of the network react in some environments according to isomorphic patterns and copy organisational models, they develop at the same time individually and innovative in other environments, which is understood as polymorphic development. The extent to which welfare associations act isomorphically or polymorphically depends on the (un-)certainty of the environment in which they operate.

Two different directions of effect between welfare associations and their environment can be derived from this: While their development is determined within the framework of isomorphic patterns in uncertain environments (markets), they develop innovatively and are able to shape socio-political structures in certain environments. They have an effect on the structures surrounding them.

The shaping potential of welfare associations is reflected along their impact on society (e.g. poverty policy). In the sociopolitical system, welfare associations have created a new form of corporatism, that I define as "confrontational corporatism", which, unlike its predecessors, is no longer characterized by cooperative coexistence, but by opposition between politics and welfare associations. Central to this is that this confrontational attitude can avoid destabilizing the socio-political system through social forces. Welfare associations become (again) a quasi- non-governmental organization (QUANGO).