CATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
This panel is to discuss new developments, discoveries, and challenges in research applying the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) to policy processes. Developed in the USA within the last 15 years, the NPF has started to gain traction in research from other world regions, investigating a plethora of policy fields with a diverse set of methodologies (e.g. Huda, 2019; McBeth & Lybecker, 2018; Weible, Olofsson, Costie, Katz, & Heikkila, 2016; Merry 2016; Jones 2014; Shanahan et al. 2013).
Neuroscience has long acknowledged the central role of narratives for human cognition. The NPF takes up this finding by explicitly conceptualizing the human being as a homo narrans, i.e. as individual that uses narratives to make sense and of the world around and communicate this sense-making.
The NPF enables researchers to understand the dynamics of policy making by investigating narrative structure and narrative content (Jones and McBeth 2010). The framework defines narrative structure consisting of setting, characters, plot, and moral of the story that can be studied and compared systematically and empirically (Shanahan et al., 2017; Shanahan, Jones, & McBeth, 2011). Recurring character types are the victim suffering from a policy problem, the villain causing the problem, and the hero solving it (Shanahan et al., 2017).
According to the NPF, policy actors use narrative content in a strategic way to reach their policy goals. Based on various hypotheses, such as the devil-angel-shift or the scope of conflict, the framework claims that these content-related narrative elements can also be studied using systematic empirical approaches (Jones and McBeth 2010; for studies of the NPF hypotheses cf. for instance Brewer, 2019; Shanahan et al., 2017; Shanahan, Jones, McBeth, & Lane, 2013).
The goal of this panel is to enable discussions on new developments, discoveries, and challenges around the NPF. With the NPF still being a relatively young theory of the policy process, many research gaps remain to be filled (cf. also Shanahan et al. in C. M. Weible & P. A. Sabatier (Eds.), Theories of the Policy Process, pp. 173–213). Research topics may include (but are not restricted to):
· Comparative analyses applying the NPF
· Innovative methods
· The NPF applied to new policy contexts and geographies
· Investigating macro-level narratives
· Exploring the role of institutions in the NPF
· Non-results using the NPF
· NPF applications to post decision-making processes, e.g. policy implementation or evaluation
CALL FOR PAPERS
The panel welcomes papers that contribute to ongoing research around and engage critically with the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF). Research topics may include (but are not restricted to):
· Comparative analyses applying the NPF
· Innovative methods
· The NPF applied to new policy contexts and geographies
· Investigating macro-level narratives
· Exploring the role of institutions in the NPF
· Non-results using the NPF
· NPF applications to post decision-making processes, e.g. policy implementation or evaluation
Applicants should clearly anchor their research in the NPF framework or engage critically with it to enable fruitful discussions during the panel.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
On June 24, 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, the landmark legislation that made access to abortion a federal right. It was a success for the anti-abortion campaign, which many members of the Republican party supported. As a popular online social network among policy actors (Stier, 2016), Democrat and Republican politicians use Twitter to share their opinion and stance on various issues and advocate for their preferred policies. In their tweets, some House and Senate representatives also convey stories and narratives about abortions. This study examines whether overturning Roe vs. Wade had an effect on how House and Senate representatives frame narratives about abortion policies.
As a relatively new and emerging approach in policy-based scholarship (Stauffer and Kuenzler (2021) in Special Issue of European Policy Analysis), the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) is an ideal tool to analyze the research question. While there are numerous story types, the NPF highlights four specific types outlined by Stone (2012): a story of decline, a story of stymied progress, a story of helplessness, and a story of control (Jones, Shanahan, and McBeth 2014). Depending on the narrators’ policy agenda, they use different story types.
Several policy actors construct and circulate policy narratives (Jones, Shanahan, and McBeth 2014). This study examines data from 405 House and Senate representatives involved in the Twitter debate about abortion. As a timeframe, narratives from the year 2022 –
including the overturning of Roe vs. Wade in June, the previous leaked initial draft majority opinion in May (Politico, 2022), and the 2022 U.S. elections in November – are examined. Narrative data can be sourced from any communication, such as text, video, or symbols. For this case, study data are generated through computational content analysis of the communication involved in the policy debate, including 5293 tweets that contain the word “abortion.”
Methodologically, the paper uses an advanced text-as-data approach including structured topic modeling (Blei, Ng, and Jordan, 2003) and sentiment analysis (Silge & Robinson, 2017) to find out which kinds of narratives are told and which notion they convey. Specifically, the analysis focuses on what narratives were told before and after overturning Roe vs. Wade and what differences can be identified regarding their story type. While there have been first steps in using computational methods in the NPF analysis (Wolton, Crow & Heikkila, 2022; Guenduez & Mettler, 2022), the field still needs to be developed more.
The study’s hypothesis claims that there is a change in the narratives by Republicans as the Pew Research Center has found that most of the U.S. public disapproves of the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe (Pew Research Center 2022). Thus, Republican representatives might have adjusted their narratives on abortion, particularly the story type, to gain voters in the midterm election.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Authors: Giovanni Esposito, Gaia Taffoni, Andrea Terlizzi, and Nathalie Crutzen
Among the public management and policy scholars’ community the unifying theme of strategic behavior as part of collective action has gained momentum. Specifically, explanations for collective action focus on both institutional arrangements and narratives, conceived as means that shape the practices of policy actors. Therefore, when reasoning about what drives collective action, scholars may refer to at least two separate but interrelated analytical frameworks. On the one hand, approaches focusing on institutional designs emphasize the role of rules-in-use to guide human behavior. On the other hand, accounting for the different discursive practices through which policy actors narrate and make sense of their institutional actions helps understanding actors’ strategic behavior. However, examining institutional and narrative approaches together is daunting, in part because there has not been a common way to incorporate the two approaches in a comparative way.
In this article, we investigate how policy-makers strategically use narratives and institutional arrangements to establish relational connections between governmental and non-governmental actors in the empirical settings of an innovation policy process. In fact, entrepreneurial actions aimed at promoting innovation require coordination among multiple actors who share the same purpose. We draw from assemblage thinking and Actor-Network Theory (ANT) in order to elaborate a novel analytical approach that combines ANT with the Institutional Grammar Tool (IGT) and the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF). According to ANT, any innovation is the result of a translation process through which a network of actors is created, and different interests, goals, desires, visions, and beliefs are gathered together. We use IGT and NPF as analytical categories in a processual perspective to examine how actors narrate institutional statements within the process through which multiple heterogeneous components (humans and non-humans) are assembled to create governable forms. In bringing together ANT, the IGT and the NPF, we shed new light on the study of agency and strategic behavior in complex policy environments.
We illustrate our approach through an in-depth analysis of the development of a smart city, namely, an ICT-enabled policy innovation made in urban settings. Developing a smart city is a complex policy-making endeavor requiring profound socio-technical changes about “hard” (e.g. buildings, energy grids, water networks, mobility) and “soft” (e.g. human and social capital, urban culture) elements of cities. We focus on the smart city development of a Belgian city that we call Alphaville. By relying on qualitative coding of twenty-one semi-structured interviews, the article emphasizes the crucial role of leadership in the smart transformation of the city—with the mayor having the ability to transform an initial (fuzzy and ambiguous) smart city idea into a political program supported by multiple stakeholders.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The COVID-19 pandemic sparked substantial emergency welfare reforms in Germany. Significantly, contentious changes to basic social assistance, colloquially known as Hartz IV, were effected through a temporary sanctions moratorium and increasingly unconditional access to benefits. The free welfare associations (Freie Wohlfahrtspflege), long overlooked in policy research, were particularly active in reform processes and public discourse as institutionalized – and thus powerful – civil society representatives of disempowered groups such as the long-termed unemployed and the poor. This contribution therefore seeks to uncover how federal welfare associations advocated for the marginalized by identifying ‘process’ narrative elements in the policy cycle of emergency measures during the pandemic (Kuenzler and Stauffer 2022). Building on previous narrative research (Smith Ochoa 2020; Smith Ochoa et al. 2021) and following Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) scholarship (Blum and Kuhlmann 2019; Schlaufer et al. 2022), I argue that narrativized representations of vulnerable groups as deserving victims of a neglectful system were integral to legitimizing enduring and potentially transformative social policies. Theoretical insights from Steven Lukes’ (2005) approach on power are furthermore adopted, conceptualizing welfare associations as powerful collective actors with both the ability to shape policy processes in corporatist policymaking as well as the capacity to influence public perceptions through regular interventions in media and political debates. In line with the NPF, narrative policy strategies are identified and reconstructed using a narrative analysis of welfare associations’ storytelling in print media (Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung and Süddeutsche Zeitung), press releases, as well as nine semi-structured qualitative interviews with leading welfare association practitioners. Ultimately, welfare associations engage in power conflicts in policy processes by effectively utilizing narrative elements that combine emotional, moral characterizations of victimhood with legalistic advocacy of social citizenship through guaranteed rights.
References
Blum, S. and Kuhlmann, J. (2019) Stories of how to give or take – towards a typology of social policy reform narratives, in: Policy and Society, 38(3), 339–355.
Kuenzler, J. and Stauffer, B. (2022) Policy Dimension: A New Concept to Distinguish Substance from Process in the Narrative Policy Framework, in: Policy Studies Journal, Early view.
Lukes, S. (2005) Power: A Radical View, 2nd edn, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Schlaufer, C., Kuenzler, J., Jones, M. D. and Shanahan, E. A. (2022) The Narrative Policy Framework: A Traveler’s Guide to Policy Stories, in: Politische Vierteljahresschrift, 63(2), 249–273.
Smith Ochoa, C. (2020) Trivializing inequality by narrating facts: a discourse analysis of contending storylines in Germany, in: Critical Policy Studies, 14(3), 319–338.
Smith Ochoa, C., Gadinger, F. and Yildiz, T. (2021) Surveillance under dispute: Conceptualising narrative legitimation politics, in: European Journal of International Security, 6(2), 210–232.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Informed by the recent turn to the implementation of gender equality policies in feminist policy studies, this paper examines policy narratives in relation to power, empowerment, and inclusion in policy implementation. In particular, I draw on the concept of inclusive policy empowerment as employed by Engeli and Mazur (2018) to refer to the participation and integration of the diversity of voices on gender equality in the policy implementation process. Not only can inclusive policy empowerment be considered a normative ideal for representative democracies, but it is also assumed to increase the likelihood of policy success. Hence, Mazur and Engeli (2020) emphasize the need to examine who comes forward to speak for women’s interests, what they say, and for which groups of women they are speaking.
With this theoretical underpinning, I use the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) to study part of the implementation of the Swedish national violence prevention program as an example of a gender equality policy. More specifically, I employ the NPF to examine (1) what narratives are being told, (2) who the narrators are, and (3) what character types narrators cast themselves as in the narratives.
The empirical data for this study consists of funding applications for government grants allocated by the Swedish Gender Equality Agency to projects that contribute to the prevention of men’s violence against women. The grants are part of the implementation of the Swedish national violence prevention program and can be allocated to regions, municipalities, and civil organizations to fund projects aimed to improve violence prevention. Each funding application entails a project plan with a problem definition, descriptions of target groups and policy tools, and the expected outcome – meeting the minimum criteria of what constitutes a policy narrative. Once the funding decisions have been made, I will have the opportunity to study power differential at a meta-level, focusing on the applications that were chosen as proxy implementation for the governmental policy.
References
Engeli, Isabelle, & Mazur, Amy. 2018. “Taking implementation seriously in assessing success: the politics of gender equality policy.” European Journal of Politics and Gender 1(1-2): 111-129
Mazur, Amy, & Engeli, Isabelle. 2020. “The search for the elusive recipe for gender equality: when policy implementation matters.” French Politics 18: 3-27.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The grand question in risk communication studies is centered on what mechanisms in risk messages result in support for preparation-focused policy action and/or behaviors. Studies have demonstrated the positive effects of narrative risk communication on support for and engagement with hazard preparation policies and behaviors. Specifically, casting the target audience as the hero to solve the problem through preparation is found to be effective. We advance this work by testing the effects of two different mechanisms. First, we test different problem definitions that cast different sources of harm resulting from the risk issue (villains). Different problem definitions are theorized to lead to different policy or behavioral actions. Do different problem definitions of risk translate to varying support for different preparation versus prevention policy solutions? Second, we ask whether different narrators assigned to a risk message result in different levels of support for policy support.
We investigate these questions in the context of emerging zoonotic viruses and disease by testing the popular One Health approach, which grounds the problem as a critical need to support health across human, wildlife, and ecosystems. In eastern Australia, there is a complex interaction of (i) loss of endemic forests critical to flying fox (mega bats) food sources, (ii) increased human-bat interaction as bats are now roosting closer to residential areas for optimal foraging, and (iii) increase in zoonotic viral spread. Australian communities are struggling with policies to address this issue, from long term strategic planting of critical food sources away from residential areas to short term culling of bat roosts in close proximity to urban centers. Narrators represent proximal to distal entities.
We conducted a two wave experimental survey of residents in Australia (n = 3750; n=2500), focusing on three eastern states with flying fox populations. In the first wave, we randomly assigned participants to one of four experimental conditions: three treatment conditions that present different problem definitions (human based; human-wildlife, and One Health) and one control. The experimental conditions included text and a visual image. The text in each condition followed the same general three part structure. The first part identifies the problem and the cause of the problem (the victim). The second part identifies the cause of the problem (the villain). The final sentence suggests a solution. The Control condition excludes narrative features (e.g., victim, villain). In the second wave, four different narrators and a control (no narrator) were assigned to the One Health message.
Outcome variables were measured by support of eight policies: two were preparation and 6 were prevention. We hypothesize narrative treatments to have higher levels of support for prevention policies in comparison to the control condition. We also assessment the relative priority of policies through a willingness to pay assessment. We control for demographics, feelings toward bats, and horse ownership.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Urban green spaces provide diverse advantages ranging from environmental benefits to positive health impacts and socio-economic benefits. However, urban green spaces have been increasingly under contention from potential land development activities due to rapid urbanization and increasing migration from rural to urban areas. Research on urban commons (under which these urban green spaces fall) has focused on collective action and how social movements or community-based organizations form primarily through the lens of the Institutional Analysis and Development Framework broadly. Urban commons are important sites for contestation and transformation, and many have lost their identity due to land use changes following urbanization. This transformation and contestation remains poorly studied. For citizens and civil society organizations, urban commons are important sites for civic expression and collective identity, wherein they use political mechanisms to contest and transform urban commons through local governance processes. While much research has focused on how social movements and community-based organizations form, our project aims to understand how these movements and organizations use policy narratives to interact with political and governance structures to shape socio-environmental outcomes, while at the same time examine the variable forms of advocacy within urban commons. We do so by examining the policy narratives of key actors who play a crucial role in the collective governance of the commons.
We ground our analysis in an urban common called the Vetal Hill located in Pune, India’s seventh most populous city with a population of 7.4 million people and growing. In recent years, there have been multiple proposals from the local municipal corporation to construct a road and/or tunnel that will cut across the hill to help ease traffic congestion in the city, but these proposals have often been shelved in the face of opposition from civil society and environmental organizations. Using the Narrative Policy Framework, we analyze policy narratives in social media of groups (1) fighting to protect this urban common and (2) groups advocating for the necessity of infrastructural development to understand intercoalitional differences in the use of narrative elements and strategies across opposing coalitions. Findings reveal critical differences in the communication strategies used by coalitions to interact with political and governance structures to shape socio-environmental outcomes and provide insight into the role of stakeholder communication in the infrastructural development vs. environmental conservation debate.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In recent years, the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) has emerged as one of the theoretical lenses seeking to analyse public policy processes. It is based on the assumption that policy problems are the result of a conjunct construction of meanings – developing in policy narratives – by different actors involved in the policy process. From a theoretical and analytical perspective, the framework relies on specific, generalisable structures embedded in narratives at different levels. Since its first applications, the NPF has evolved theoretically, has expanded beyond its borders empirically, and constantly seeks for methodological coherence. The aim of this paper is to expand NPF’s reach, by theoretically and analytically integrating it with other two public policy analysis frameworks, namely the Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF) and the Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD) framework’s Institutional Grammar Tool (IGT). Said combination allows for the analysis of public policies from different perspectives, bringing the focus on multiple elements constructing policy processes and their outcomes. In order to do so, the methodological tools of discourse network analysis are employed. Through the Discourse Network Analyzer (DNA) software, the analytical categories of each framework are related at multiple levels. The main elements of the narratives – narrator, characters, moral, plot – are detected, as far as the NPF is concerned. For the ACF, policy core beliefs – operationalised as policy solutions proposed by policy actors – are identified. Finally, for the IGT, the grammatical – ADICO – and the semantical – seven rule typologies – categorisations are applied. Such an effort allows for the construction of multi-layer networks, linking policy actors to policy solutions, narrators to their story elements, and connecting them to the outcome of the policy process (such as an act, a regulation, a legislative framework) through the categories of the IGT. In order to empirically apply such overarching analytical approach, the analysis focuses on UK education policy subsystem and, more specifically, on the reform of the higher education policy. Accordingly, the Higher Education and Research Act (2017) amended the Further and Higher Education Pact (1992), and provides a new regulatory framework for higher education, including the establishment of the Office for Students and the United Kingdom Research and Innovation (UKRI). Therefore, the data comprise all the parliamentary debates discussing the Bill, as well as the legislative provisions of the Act. Thus, this paper brings a threefold contribution. Firstly, it opens a dialogue among the three frameworks at the theoretical level. Secondly, it establishes an analytical approach by interrelating analytical categories from the three frameworks, and therefore, opening the opportunity for multi-layered analyses with the NPF, the ACF and the IGT. Lastly, it brings the methodological tools to coherently perform and visualise such analytical efforts.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The power of expert narratives during the Covid-19 pandemic
Abstract for the Panel Narrative Policy Framework: Developments, Discoveries, and Challenges, ICPP Toronto 2023 (online participation)
Jule Ksinsik & Caroline Schlaufer, KPM Center of Public Management, University of Bern
The COVID-19 pandemic has generated much scholarly attention to the power of scientific experts in policy making (Armingeon und Sager 2022; Cairney 2021; Hodges et al. 2022; Kuhlmann et al. 2022; Hadorn et al. 2022). However, research on how scientists have used their power to influence policy debates and policy outcomes during the pandemic is still lacking. This article draws on an operationalization of Lukes’ three dimensions of power (Lukes 2004) using the Narrative Policy Framework (Sievers und Jones 2020) to identify the power of scientific experts in the Swiss COVID-19 policy debate. First, the article addresses the question of which expert perspectives are expressed in governmental narratives about COVID-19 to assess experts’ decision-making power (Lukes’ first dimension) and agenda-setting power (Lukes’ second dimension). Second, the article examines whether dominant value paradigms are expressed in experts’ narratives and identifies potential discrepancies with preferences expressed by different groups in Swiss society (Lukes’ third dimension). To empirically address these questions, we use a quantitative content analysis of Swiss print media as well as survey data on the acceptance of Swiss COVID-19 policy measures. To examine the first and second power dimensions, we compare the narrative of experts with the narrative of government officials over time. Such a comparison allows to examine whether the predominant governmental narrative has shifted to give more or less voice to experts over the course of the pandemic. To examine the third power dimension, i.e., the preference-shaping power of experts, we compare the beliefs of experts as expressed by their narratives with beliefs of Swiss societal groups as expressed in national surveys. Results are expected to show incongruence of governmental and expert narratives in the beginning of the pandemic when experts still lacked agenda-setting power and incongruence of beliefs between science-skeptic groups in Swiss society and expert narratives.
References
Armingeon, Klaus; Sager, Fritz (2022): Muting Science: Input Overload Versus Scientific Advice in Swiss Policy Making During the Covid‐19 Pandemic. In: The Political Quarterly.
Cairney, Paul (2021): The UK government’s COVID-19 policy: What does “guided by the science” mean in practice? In: Frontiers in Political Science 3, S. 624068.
Hadorn, Susanne; Sager, Fritz; Mavrot, Céline; Malandrino, Anna; Ege, Jörn (2022): Evidence-Based Policymaking in Times of Acute Crisis: Comparing the Use of Scientific Knowledge in Germany, Switzerland, and Italy. In: Politische Vierteljahresschrift, S. 1–24.
Hodges, Ron; Caperchione, Eugenio; van Helden, Jan; Reichard, Christoph; Sorrentino, Daniela (2022): The Role of Scientific Expertise in COVID-19 Policy-making: Evidence from Four European Countries. In: Public Organization Review, S. 1–19.
Kuhlmann, Sabine; Franzke, Jochen; Dumas, Benoît Paul (2022): Technocratic Decision-Making in Times of Crisis? The Use of Data for Scientific Policy Advice in Germany’s COVID-19 Management. In: Public Organization Review, S. 1–21.
Lukes, Steven (2004): Power: A Radical View, 2nd ed. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Sievers, Tjorven; Jones, Michael D. (2020): Can power be made an empirically viable concept in policy process theory? Exploring the power potential of the Narrative Policy Framework. In: irpp 2 (1), S. 90–114. DOI: 10.4000/irpp.942.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The presence and use of narratives are widely acknowledged as an important feature of policy-making, worthy of research attention and part of skill-building for policy analysis and advising (Roe, 1994; Lowndes, 2016; Jones et al, 2019). The purpose of this paper is to explore how far we have come with theorizing and analyzing narratives for better understanding problem definition, policy-making dynamics, and outcomes (Weible & Sabatier, 2018). Some theoretical frameworks have explicitly modeled narratives (e.g. Jones et al, 2018, along with a host of related studies), but to what extent does this reflect the full range of productive approaches to understanding and analyzing narratives? Moreover, given that various understandings of narratives overlap with concepts of policy argumentation, persuasion, learning, and framing (Majone, 1989; Roe, 1994; Fischer, 2007; Baumgartner & Jones, 2007; Moyson et al, 2017), how do they fit in with leading frameworks (e.g. ACF, MSA, PET, HI) for understanding policy-making (see Weible & Sabatier, 2018)? By folding narratives into these frameworks, what would be seeking to explain from the past or in the moment, or, looking to the future, design? Should the ubiquity and functions of narratives be built into these frameworks in a different way?
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This study analyzes empirically dynamics of policy narrative and policy feedback in the deliberative policy design process through the case of deliberative polling for Shin-gori No.5&6. Nuclear plant in Korea. Participatory Governance paradigm has come across many countries with the demand of direct democracy and civic participation to resolve wicked problems like the matter of nuclear power plant keeping policy conflict continuously. The government has tried to design policy process to involve civic participation and active interaction among policy actors including stakeholders and public has been positioned as the mechanism of policy output in the policy process. Especially, language or text and actual words people use have performed important role in the mechanism. Many policy process studies has had limit of explain mechanism but Narrative Policy Framework(NPF) emphasize narratives formed from communication or debate in policy conflict situation as a core element the mechanism indicating the policy process and policy change. The understanding of mechanism produces contextual knowledge and deeper interpretation which have been overlooked in the policy study. This study tested meso-level NPF hypotheses using News media and transcript which was recorded when citizen discussed during deliberation program were refined by text mining and analyzed by semantic network analysis and sensitive analysis. The implications of this study are rendered by academic and policy aspects. Firstly, this study is contributive to academic aspects in that it make more empirical that narrative is a significant factors of policy change by elaborating theoretical review of NPF and applying mixed research method including big data analysis. Second, this study propose how the participatory policy and policy design for democracy would be more effective and produce successful outcomes. In the case of deliberating polling, this study suggest the frame of policy problem and alternatives need to be more diversified and the process of understanding interaction like unrefined narratives formed by public also need to be considered when policy decision making.
Keyword. Narrative Policy Framework, Policy Design, Deliberative Polling, Sementic Network Big Data Analysis, Shin-gori No.5&6 Nuclear Plant, Conflict Management
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Applying Narrative Policy Framework under Conditions of Democratic Backsliding: Case of Protest Regulation in Mumbai, India
Narrative policy framework (NPF) has been applied in the global north to systematically collect and analyze narratives that influence policy processes in populist and authoritarian settings (Jones & McBeth, 2020; Uldanov et al., 2021). In the context of democratic erosion and overarching curtailment of civil liberties worldwide (Haggard & Kaufman, 2021), it has become essential to investigate the multifaceted relationship between narratives and policy processes in non-democratic political regimes in non-Western geographies (Schlaufer, 2022). More diverse and context-specific examinations of narratives in policy geographies that exhibit illiberal political characteristics are required – this is where the literature on democratic backsliding becomes useful. Democratic backsliding is the incremental erosion of democratic values and ideals in a society (Haggard & Kaufman, 2021). The Indian state under the rule of the Bharatiya Janata Party is an example of a democracy undergoing backsliding (Jaffrelot, 2019; Heller, 2020; Varshney, 2022) – a claim backed by various global democratic indices (EIU, 2021; Freedom House, 2022).
In this paper, I apply NPF to understand the narratives and discourses influencing protest regulation in Mumbai, India, where state responses to protests have become repressive in the recent past (Shantha, 2020). I draw from the idea that regimes use narratives of actions being ‘in-place’ or ‘out-of-place’ to justify and propagate repressive institutional responses that limit access to public space (Cresswell, 1994, p. 95). In my NPF model, I consider narratives in the national political sphere to be at the macro level because these play an important role in defining cultural and institutional perceptions of protests in the country. Mumbai’s city-level institutions, specifically the Bombay Municipal Corporation and the Mumbai Police, constitute the meso level in the model. I will examine both macro level narratives that shape broader discourses about protests and meso level narratives that influence sub-national policy actions and responses to protests – along with interactions between these levels. Specifically, the NPF research question that the paper seeks to answer is: how do macro level narratives that take form at the national level inform and influence policy responses to protests at the meso level (city-level) under conditions of democratic backsliding?
To study the macro level narratives, I will draw from references to protests and protestors in publicly available speeches by Prime Minister Narendra Modi and other prominent political actors from 2014 to 2022. To discern meso level narratives, I will employ primary interviews with organizers and state officials in Mumbai, and secondary documents, including police circulars and press releases. Once the narrative components (including characters, plot, morals, and beliefs) at both levels are identified, it will be possible to study how narratives under conditions of democratic backsliding influence protest regulation at the city-level.
This paper will add to the NPF literature in two ways: first, it will tell us more about the applicability of NPF under conditions of democratic backsliding (a concern also raised by Schlaufer, 2022) and the challenges of such applications; and second, it will foreground the role of macro level narratives in influencing meso level policy processes and institutions in these settings.
References
Cresswell, T. J. (1996). In place/out of place: Geography, ideology and transgression. The University of Wisconsin-Madison.
EIU (2021). Economic Intelligence Unit Democracy Index Report. Available at https://www.eiu.com/n/campaigns/democracy-index-2021.
Freedom House (2022). Freedom House Freedom in the World Report. Country report for India available at https://freedomhouse.org/country/india/freedom-world/2022.
Haggard, S., & Kaufman, R. (2021). Backsliding: Democratic regress in the contemporary world. Cambridge University Press.
Heller, P. (2020). The age of reaction: Retrenchment populism in India and Brazil. International Sociology, 35(6), 590-609.
Jaffrelot, C. (2019). A de facto ethnic democracy? Obliterating and targeting the other, Hindu vigilantes, and the ethno-state.
Jones, M. D., & McBeth, M. K. (2010). A narrative policy framework: Clear enough to be wrong?. Policy studies journal, 38(2), 329-353.
Jones, M. D., & McBeth, M. K. (2020). Narrative in the Time of Trump: Is the Narrative Policy Framework good enough to be relevant?. Administrative Theory & Praxis, 42(2), 91-110.
Jones, M. D., McBeth, M. K., & Shanahan, E. A. (2014). Introducing the narrative policy framework. In The science of stories (pp. 1-25). Palgrave Macmillan, New York.
Schlaufer, C., Kuenzler, J., Jones, M. D., & Shanahan, E. A. (2022). The narrative policy framework: a traveler’s guide to policy stories. Politische Vierteljahresschrift, 63(2), 249-273.
Shanahan, E. A., Jones, M. D., & McBeth, M. K. (2018). How to conduct a Narrative Policy Framework study. The Social Science Journal, 55(3), 332-345.
Shantha, S. (2020, August 29). ‘Attempt to Curtail Dissent’: Mumbai Police seeks Rs 50 lakh as Surety from Activist for Protesting. The Wire. Retrieved January 30, 2023, from https://thewire.in/rights/mumbai-police-rs-50-lakh-surety-protesting.
Uldanov, A., Gabriichuk, T., Karateev, D., & Makhmutova, M. (2021). Narratives in an authoritarian environment: Narrative strategies, plots, and characters in Moscow’s public transport reforms debate. European Policy Analysis, 7(2), 433- 450.
Varshney, A. (2022). How India's Ruling Party Erodes Democracy. Journal of Democracy, 33(4), 104-118.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Narratives play a pivotal role in policymaking and are highly relied upon by policy actors, as they structure the way those actors argue in favour of their own preferred policy solutions in order to convince colleagues and citizens of the ‘goodness’ of those solutions. This value of narratives has been exalted especially within the context of crisis management. Yet, little is known about the explanatory power of policy narratives in relation to the achievement of desired policy outputs. In other words, we have little empirical evidence about the extent to which a certain kind of policy narrative really helps policymakers to achieve their goals, including in times of crisis. In light of the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF), this paper aims to explore this aspect. It does so through a case study of narratives employed during the pandemic in Italy, which represented an emblematic case of a problematic context becoming the protagonist of narratives. Moreover, it exploits the relatively simple policy context offered by the education sector during the crisis, where the main policy solutions proposed and adopted were clearly identifiable, divided as they were between school closures and reopenings. In addition, focusing on a specific policy sector offers the possibility to construct a more context-sensitive 'narrative of narratives' than with general containment measures. Not least, the paper applies the NPF to a country in a geographical area (Southern Europe) in which the framework has so far found very little application. Based on this case study, which compares the narratives of the different policy actors and governments that managed school policies during the pandemic, the article argues that policy narratives are only a part of the story and that they need to be put in context to explain the success of policymakers in attaining (or not attaining) their preferred policy solutions. It then identifies these additional factors that need to be considered when using the NPF for explanatory purposes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper discusses the Narrative Policy Framework and qualitative approaches to studying the LGBTQ+ community. Sabatier and Weible invited researchers in Theories of the Policy Process to advance the Narrative Policy Framework through various innovative applications. One of these areas more recently has been an interest in qualitative research on the LGBTQ+ community in substantive public policy areas. This paper will examine recently published articles that apply the Narrative Policy Framework to LGBTQ+ qualitative research specifically, and then it will examine similar approaches for other public policy frameworks.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The paper apply the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) for empirical exploration of macrolevel narratives in debates around the landscape fire policy in Russia in 2010 - 2020. Macrolevel NPF research are generally underrepresented in literature and all existing studies are related to the context of democratic regimes. This paper expands our knowledge about using this level of framework beyond liberal democracies. The problem of landscape fires has firmly entered the public discourse in Russia since 2010, when the catastrophic forest and peatland fires occurred in the European part of the country. After this focusing event several NGOs started systematic work to promote the necessary changes in landscape fire policy. This pro-reform coalition advocated a change in the policy paradigm (from just reaction to prevention). One of the most notable and discussed proposals was a ban on burning grass (including ban for agricultural burning), which was finally adopted in 2015. Based on the macrolevel narratives conceptualization and empirical approach, proposed by previous scholars, this study answers the questions - did the macronarratives about the landscape fire policy change after the ban was adopted, and if so, how did this change affect the meso-level - the use of narratives by policy actors in this policy subsystem, namely the state and NGOs.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In Sweden, health care is formally politically governed on several governance levels. The regional authorities, governed by elected politicians, are responsible for the main part of the financing as well as the provision of health care. The regional politicians’ main responsibilities are to decide on taxation, allocate the public resources and to formulate political goals and strategies. Their democratic assignment means that citizens can influence health care policy through the politicians and hold them accountable.
Governing authorities in Sweden have however during the last two decades increasingly relied on a form of management which is called “knowledge-driven management” when regulating health care. The primary method for implementing knowledge-driven management in health care organizations is different kinds of expert guidelines specifying “best practices”. In Sweden, both the guidelines and the national organizations for the production of guidelines have become increasingly comprehensive and complex.
Previous research indicates that national knowledge-driven management is part of a process of centralisation, standardization and technocratization of health care governance in Sweden. Very little is however known about the arguments for (and against) national knowledge-driven management. The notion of expert knowledge is very dominating in health care, but it can differ between contexts and times what knowledge that is considered as expertise and who is considered an expert. National knowledge-driven management might have promoted new actors and new ideas about how health care should be governed, and obstructed other.
The overall aim of the study is to analyze policy narratives about an organization for national knowledge-driven management in Sweden and how the narratives have developed historically, by studying policy documents. The policy documents include official documents about different initiatives of organized national/centralized knowledge-driven management of health care, including comment letters from different policy actors, in the time period 1999-2022.
Tools from the Narrative Policy Framework will be employed to analyze the narrative structures and contents, and to compare the policy actors’ different narratives. How the settings, plots, characters, and morals are described in policy documents and how they have changed over time is an illuminating way of exploring national knowledge-driven management’s emergence and how it relates to ideas about for example political regional self-governance.
In addition to the Narrative Policy Framework, frameworks from previous research about rationales in the construction of public policies for health care will be employed. In research about the construction of target groups of health care policy and the underlying rationales, different types of reasoning for the justification and legitimation of the different policies have been identified. Rationales can for example be technocratic/scientific, cultural, social, or political. This taxonomy of categories of rationales can potentially be useful in analyzing how the narrative elements are labelled and what values that are attached to them by different actors.
To our knowledge, the NPF has not previously been used to analyze health care policy in Sweden. The study could also contribute to the field of macro narratives and the role of institutions.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
On June 24, 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, the landmark legislation that made access to abortion a federal right. It was a success for the anti-abortion campaign, which many members of the Republican party supported. As a popular online social network among policy actors (Stier, 2016), Democrat and Republican politicians use Twitter to share their opinion and stance on various issues and advocate for their preferred policies. In their tweets, some House and Senate representatives also convey stories and narratives about abortions. This study examines whether overturning Roe vs. Wade had an effect on how House and Senate representatives frame narratives about abortion policies.
As a relatively new and emerging approach in policy-based scholarship (Stauffer and Kuenzler (2021) in Special Issue of European Policy Analysis), the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) is an ideal tool to analyze the research question. While there are numerous story types, the NPF highlights four specific types outlined by Stone (2012): a story of decline, a story of stymied progress, a story of helplessness, and a story of control (Jones, Shanahan, and McBeth 2014). Depending on the narrators’ policy agenda, they use different story types.
Several policy actors construct and circulate policy narratives (Jones, Shanahan, and McBeth 2014). This study examines data from 405 House and Senate representatives involved in the Twitter debate about abortion. As a timeframe, narratives from the year 2022 –
including the overturning of Roe vs. Wade in June, the previous leaked initial draft majority opinion in May (Politico, 2022), and the 2022 U.S. elections in November – are examined. Narrative data can be sourced from any communication, such as text, video, or symbols. For this case, study data are generated through computational content analysis of the communication involved in the policy debate, including 5293 tweets that contain the word “abortion.”
Methodologically, the paper uses an advanced text-as-data approach including structured topic modeling (Blei, Ng, and Jordan, 2003) and sentiment analysis (Silge & Robinson, 2017) to find out which kinds of narratives are told and which notion they convey. Specifically, the analysis focuses on what narratives were told before and after overturning Roe vs. Wade and what differences can be identified regarding their story type. While there have been first steps in using computational methods in the NPF analysis (Wolton, Crow & Heikkila, 2022; Guenduez & Mettler, 2022), the field still needs to be developed more.
The study’s hypothesis claims that there is a change in the narratives by Republicans as the Pew Research Center has found that most of the U.S. public disapproves of the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe (Pew Research Center 2022). Thus, Republican representatives might have adjusted their narratives on abortion, particularly the story type, to gain voters in the midterm election.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Authors: Giovanni Esposito, Gaia Taffoni, Andrea Terlizzi, and Nathalie Crutzen
Among the public management and policy scholars’ community the unifying theme of strategic behavior as part of collective action has gained momentum. Specifically, explanations for collective action focus on both institutional arrangements and narratives, conceived as means that shape the practices of policy actors. Therefore, when reasoning about what drives collective action, scholars may refer to at least two separate but interrelated analytical frameworks. On the one hand, approaches focusing on institutional designs emphasize the role of rules-in-use to guide human behavior. On the other hand, accounting for the different discursive practices through which policy actors narrate and make sense of their institutional actions helps understanding actors’ strategic behavior. However, examining institutional and narrative approaches together is daunting, in part because there has not been a common way to incorporate the two approaches in a comparative way.
In this article, we investigate how policy-makers strategically use narratives and institutional arrangements to establish relational connections between governmental and non-governmental actors in the empirical settings of an innovation policy process. In fact, entrepreneurial actions aimed at promoting innovation require coordination among multiple actors who share the same purpose. We draw from assemblage thinking and Actor-Network Theory (ANT) in order to elaborate a novel analytical approach that combines ANT with the Institutional Grammar Tool (IGT) and the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF). According to ANT, any innovation is the result of a translation process through which a network of actors is created, and different interests, goals, desires, visions, and beliefs are gathered together. We use IGT and NPF as analytical categories in a processual perspective to examine how actors narrate institutional statements within the process through which multiple heterogeneous components (humans and non-humans) are assembled to create governable forms. In bringing together ANT, the IGT and the NPF, we shed new light on the study of agency and strategic behavior in complex policy environments.
We illustrate our approach through an in-depth analysis of the development of a smart city, namely, an ICT-enabled policy innovation made in urban settings. Developing a smart city is a complex policy-making endeavor requiring profound socio-technical changes about “hard” (e.g. buildings, energy grids, water networks, mobility) and “soft” (e.g. human and social capital, urban culture) elements of cities. We focus on the smart city development of a Belgian city that we call Alphaville. By relying on qualitative coding of twenty-one semi-structured interviews, the article emphasizes the crucial role of leadership in the smart transformation of the city—with the mayor having the ability to transform an initial (fuzzy and ambiguous) smart city idea into a political program supported by multiple stakeholders.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The COVID-19 pandemic sparked substantial emergency welfare reforms in Germany. Significantly, contentious changes to basic social assistance, colloquially known as Hartz IV, were effected through a temporary sanctions moratorium and increasingly unconditional access to benefits. The free welfare associations (Freie Wohlfahrtspflege), long overlooked in policy research, were particularly active in reform processes and public discourse as institutionalized – and thus powerful – civil society representatives of disempowered groups such as the long-termed unemployed and the poor. This contribution therefore seeks to uncover how federal welfare associations advocated for the marginalized by identifying ‘process’ narrative elements in the policy cycle of emergency measures during the pandemic (Kuenzler and Stauffer 2022). Building on previous narrative research (Smith Ochoa 2020; Smith Ochoa et al. 2021) and following Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) scholarship (Blum and Kuhlmann 2019; Schlaufer et al. 2022), I argue that narrativized representations of vulnerable groups as deserving victims of a neglectful system were integral to legitimizing enduring and potentially transformative social policies. Theoretical insights from Steven Lukes’ (2005) approach on power are furthermore adopted, conceptualizing welfare associations as powerful collective actors with both the ability to shape policy processes in corporatist policymaking as well as the capacity to influence public perceptions through regular interventions in media and political debates. In line with the NPF, narrative policy strategies are identified and reconstructed using a narrative analysis of welfare associations’ storytelling in print media (Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung and Süddeutsche Zeitung), press releases, as well as nine semi-structured qualitative interviews with leading welfare association practitioners. Ultimately, welfare associations engage in power conflicts in policy processes by effectively utilizing narrative elements that combine emotional, moral characterizations of victimhood with legalistic advocacy of social citizenship through guaranteed rights.
References
Blum, S. and Kuhlmann, J. (2019) Stories of how to give or take – towards a typology of social policy reform narratives, in: Policy and Society, 38(3), 339–355.
Kuenzler, J. and Stauffer, B. (2022) Policy Dimension: A New Concept to Distinguish Substance from Process in the Narrative Policy Framework, in: Policy Studies Journal, Early view.
Lukes, S. (2005) Power: A Radical View, 2nd edn, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Schlaufer, C., Kuenzler, J., Jones, M. D. and Shanahan, E. A. (2022) The Narrative Policy Framework: A Traveler’s Guide to Policy Stories, in: Politische Vierteljahresschrift, 63(2), 249–273.
Smith Ochoa, C. (2020) Trivializing inequality by narrating facts: a discourse analysis of contending storylines in Germany, in: Critical Policy Studies, 14(3), 319–338.
Smith Ochoa, C., Gadinger, F. and Yildiz, T. (2021) Surveillance under dispute: Conceptualising narrative legitimation politics, in: European Journal of International Security, 6(2), 210–232.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Informed by the recent turn to the implementation of gender equality policies in feminist policy studies, this paper examines policy narratives in relation to power, empowerment, and inclusion in policy implementation. In particular, I draw on the concept of inclusive policy empowerment as employed by Engeli and Mazur (2018) to refer to the participation and integration of the diversity of voices on gender equality in the policy implementation process. Not only can inclusive policy empowerment be considered a normative ideal for representative democracies, but it is also assumed to increase the likelihood of policy success. Hence, Mazur and Engeli (2020) emphasize the need to examine who comes forward to speak for women’s interests, what they say, and for which groups of women they are speaking.
With this theoretical underpinning, I use the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) to study part of the implementation of the Swedish national violence prevention program as an example of a gender equality policy. More specifically, I employ the NPF to examine (1) what narratives are being told, (2) who the narrators are, and (3) what character types narrators cast themselves as in the narratives.
The empirical data for this study consists of funding applications for government grants allocated by the Swedish Gender Equality Agency to projects that contribute to the prevention of men’s violence against women. The grants are part of the implementation of the Swedish national violence prevention program and can be allocated to regions, municipalities, and civil organizations to fund projects aimed to improve violence prevention. Each funding application entails a project plan with a problem definition, descriptions of target groups and policy tools, and the expected outcome – meeting the minimum criteria of what constitutes a policy narrative. Once the funding decisions have been made, I will have the opportunity to study power differential at a meta-level, focusing on the applications that were chosen as proxy implementation for the governmental policy.
References
Engeli, Isabelle, & Mazur, Amy. 2018. “Taking implementation seriously in assessing success: the politics of gender equality policy.” European Journal of Politics and Gender 1(1-2): 111-129
Mazur, Amy, & Engeli, Isabelle. 2020. “The search for the elusive recipe for gender equality: when policy implementation matters.” French Politics 18: 3-27.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The grand question in risk communication studies is centered on what mechanisms in risk messages result in support for preparation-focused policy action and/or behaviors. Studies have demonstrated the positive effects of narrative risk communication on support for and engagement with hazard preparation policies and behaviors. Specifically, casting the target audience as the hero to solve the problem through preparation is found to be effective. We advance this work by testing the effects of two different mechanisms. First, we test different problem definitions that cast different sources of harm resulting from the risk issue (villains). Different problem definitions are theorized to lead to different policy or behavioral actions. Do different problem definitions of risk translate to varying support for different preparation versus prevention policy solutions? Second, we ask whether different narrators assigned to a risk message result in different levels of support for policy support.
We investigate these questions in the context of emerging zoonotic viruses and disease by testing the popular One Health approach, which grounds the problem as a critical need to support health across human, wildlife, and ecosystems. In eastern Australia, there is a complex interaction of (i) loss of endemic forests critical to flying fox (mega bats) food sources, (ii) increased human-bat interaction as bats are now roosting closer to residential areas for optimal foraging, and (iii) increase in zoonotic viral spread. Australian communities are struggling with policies to address this issue, from long term strategic planting of critical food sources away from residential areas to short term culling of bat roosts in close proximity to urban centers. Narrators represent proximal to distal entities.
We conducted a two wave experimental survey of residents in Australia (n = 3750; n=2500), focusing on three eastern states with flying fox populations. In the first wave, we randomly assigned participants to one of four experimental conditions: three treatment conditions that present different problem definitions (human based; human-wildlife, and One Health) and one control. The experimental conditions included text and a visual image. The text in each condition followed the same general three part structure. The first part identifies the problem and the cause of the problem (the victim). The second part identifies the cause of the problem (the villain). The final sentence suggests a solution. The Control condition excludes narrative features (e.g., victim, villain). In the second wave, four different narrators and a control (no narrator) were assigned to the One Health message.
Outcome variables were measured by support of eight policies: two were preparation and 6 were prevention. We hypothesize narrative treatments to have higher levels of support for prevention policies in comparison to the control condition. We also assessment the relative priority of policies through a willingness to pay assessment. We control for demographics, feelings toward bats, and horse ownership.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Urban green spaces provide diverse advantages ranging from environmental benefits to positive health impacts and socio-economic benefits. However, urban green spaces have been increasingly under contention from potential land development activities due to rapid urbanization and increasing migration from rural to urban areas. Research on urban commons (under which these urban green spaces fall) has focused on collective action and how social movements or community-based organizations form primarily through the lens of the Institutional Analysis and Development Framework broadly. Urban commons are important sites for contestation and transformation, and many have lost their identity due to land use changes following urbanization. This transformation and contestation remains poorly studied. For citizens and civil society organizations, urban commons are important sites for civic expression and collective identity, wherein they use political mechanisms to contest and transform urban commons through local governance processes. While much research has focused on how social movements and community-based organizations form, our project aims to understand how these movements and organizations use policy narratives to interact with political and governance structures to shape socio-environmental outcomes, while at the same time examine the variable forms of advocacy within urban commons. We do so by examining the policy narratives of key actors who play a crucial role in the collective governance of the commons.
We ground our analysis in an urban common called the Vetal Hill located in Pune, India’s seventh most populous city with a population of 7.4 million people and growing. In recent years, there have been multiple proposals from the local municipal corporation to construct a road and/or tunnel that will cut across the hill to help ease traffic congestion in the city, but these proposals have often been shelved in the face of opposition from civil society and environmental organizations. Using the Narrative Policy Framework, we analyze policy narratives in social media of groups (1) fighting to protect this urban common and (2) groups advocating for the necessity of infrastructural development to understand intercoalitional differences in the use of narrative elements and strategies across opposing coalitions. Findings reveal critical differences in the communication strategies used by coalitions to interact with political and governance structures to shape socio-environmental outcomes and provide insight into the role of stakeholder communication in the infrastructural development vs. environmental conservation debate.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In recent years, the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) has emerged as one of the theoretical lenses seeking to analyse public policy processes. It is based on the assumption that policy problems are the result of a conjunct construction of meanings – developing in policy narratives – by different actors involved in the policy process. From a theoretical and analytical perspective, the framework relies on specific, generalisable structures embedded in narratives at different levels. Since its first applications, the NPF has evolved theoretically, has expanded beyond its borders empirically, and constantly seeks for methodological coherence. The aim of this paper is to expand NPF’s reach, by theoretically and analytically integrating it with other two public policy analysis frameworks, namely the Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF) and the Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD) framework’s Institutional Grammar Tool (IGT). Said combination allows for the analysis of public policies from different perspectives, bringing the focus on multiple elements constructing policy processes and their outcomes. In order to do so, the methodological tools of discourse network analysis are employed. Through the Discourse Network Analyzer (DNA) software, the analytical categories of each framework are related at multiple levels. The main elements of the narratives – narrator, characters, moral, plot – are detected, as far as the NPF is concerned. For the ACF, policy core beliefs – operationalised as policy solutions proposed by policy actors – are identified. Finally, for the IGT, the grammatical – ADICO – and the semantical – seven rule typologies – categorisations are applied. Such an effort allows for the construction of multi-layer networks, linking policy actors to policy solutions, narrators to their story elements, and connecting them to the outcome of the policy process (such as an act, a regulation, a legislative framework) through the categories of the IGT. In order to empirically apply such overarching analytical approach, the analysis focuses on UK education policy subsystem and, more specifically, on the reform of the higher education policy. Accordingly, the Higher Education and Research Act (2017) amended the Further and Higher Education Pact (1992), and provides a new regulatory framework for higher education, including the establishment of the Office for Students and the United Kingdom Research and Innovation (UKRI). Therefore, the data comprise all the parliamentary debates discussing the Bill, as well as the legislative provisions of the Act. Thus, this paper brings a threefold contribution. Firstly, it opens a dialogue among the three frameworks at the theoretical level. Secondly, it establishes an analytical approach by interrelating analytical categories from the three frameworks, and therefore, opening the opportunity for multi-layered analyses with the NPF, the ACF and the IGT. Lastly, it brings the methodological tools to coherently perform and visualise such analytical efforts.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The power of expert narratives during the Covid-19 pandemic
Abstract for the Panel Narrative Policy Framework: Developments, Discoveries, and Challenges, ICPP Toronto 2023 (online participation)
Jule Ksinsik & Caroline Schlaufer, KPM Center of Public Management, University of Bern
The COVID-19 pandemic has generated much scholarly attention to the power of scientific experts in policy making (Armingeon und Sager 2022; Cairney 2021; Hodges et al. 2022; Kuhlmann et al. 2022; Hadorn et al. 2022). However, research on how scientists have used their power to influence policy debates and policy outcomes during the pandemic is still lacking. This article draws on an operationalization of Lukes’ three dimensions of power (Lukes 2004) using the Narrative Policy Framework (Sievers und Jones 2020) to identify the power of scientific experts in the Swiss COVID-19 policy debate. First, the article addresses the question of which expert perspectives are expressed in governmental narratives about COVID-19 to assess experts’ decision-making power (Lukes’ first dimension) and agenda-setting power (Lukes’ second dimension). Second, the article examines whether dominant value paradigms are expressed in experts’ narratives and identifies potential discrepancies with preferences expressed by different groups in Swiss society (Lukes’ third dimension). To empirically address these questions, we use a quantitative content analysis of Swiss print media as well as survey data on the acceptance of Swiss COVID-19 policy measures. To examine the first and second power dimensions, we compare the narrative of experts with the narrative of government officials over time. Such a comparison allows to examine whether the predominant governmental narrative has shifted to give more or less voice to experts over the course of the pandemic. To examine the third power dimension, i.e., the preference-shaping power of experts, we compare the beliefs of experts as expressed by their narratives with beliefs of Swiss societal groups as expressed in national surveys. Results are expected to show incongruence of governmental and expert narratives in the beginning of the pandemic when experts still lacked agenda-setting power and incongruence of beliefs between science-skeptic groups in Swiss society and expert narratives.
References
Armingeon, Klaus; Sager, Fritz (2022): Muting Science: Input Overload Versus Scientific Advice in Swiss Policy Making During the Covid‐19 Pandemic. In: The Political Quarterly.
Cairney, Paul (2021): The UK government’s COVID-19 policy: What does “guided by the science” mean in practice? In: Frontiers in Political Science 3, S. 624068.
Hadorn, Susanne; Sager, Fritz; Mavrot, Céline; Malandrino, Anna; Ege, Jörn (2022): Evidence-Based Policymaking in Times of Acute Crisis: Comparing the Use of Scientific Knowledge in Germany, Switzerland, and Italy. In: Politische Vierteljahresschrift, S. 1–24.
Hodges, Ron; Caperchione, Eugenio; van Helden, Jan; Reichard, Christoph; Sorrentino, Daniela (2022): The Role of Scientific Expertise in COVID-19 Policy-making: Evidence from Four European Countries. In: Public Organization Review, S. 1–19.
Kuhlmann, Sabine; Franzke, Jochen; Dumas, Benoît Paul (2022): Technocratic Decision-Making in Times of Crisis? The Use of Data for Scientific Policy Advice in Germany’s COVID-19 Management. In: Public Organization Review, S. 1–21.
Lukes, Steven (2004): Power: A Radical View, 2nd ed. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Sievers, Tjorven; Jones, Michael D. (2020): Can power be made an empirically viable concept in policy process theory? Exploring the power potential of the Narrative Policy Framework. In: irpp 2 (1), S. 90–114. DOI: 10.4000/irpp.942.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The presence and use of narratives are widely acknowledged as an important feature of policy-making, worthy of research attention and part of skill-building for policy analysis and advising (Roe, 1994; Lowndes, 2016; Jones et al, 2019). The purpose of this paper is to explore how far we have come with theorizing and analyzing narratives for better understanding problem definition, policy-making dynamics, and outcomes (Weible & Sabatier, 2018). Some theoretical frameworks have explicitly modeled narratives (e.g. Jones et al, 2018, along with a host of related studies), but to what extent does this reflect the full range of productive approaches to understanding and analyzing narratives? Moreover, given that various understandings of narratives overlap with concepts of policy argumentation, persuasion, learning, and framing (Majone, 1989; Roe, 1994; Fischer, 2007; Baumgartner & Jones, 2007; Moyson et al, 2017), how do they fit in with leading frameworks (e.g. ACF, MSA, PET, HI) for understanding policy-making (see Weible & Sabatier, 2018)? By folding narratives into these frameworks, what would be seeking to explain from the past or in the moment, or, looking to the future, design? Should the ubiquity and functions of narratives be built into these frameworks in a different way?
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This study analyzes empirically dynamics of policy narrative and policy feedback in the deliberative policy design process through the case of deliberative polling for Shin-gori No.5&6. Nuclear plant in Korea. Participatory Governance paradigm has come across many countries with the demand of direct democracy and civic participation to resolve wicked problems like the matter of nuclear power plant keeping policy conflict continuously. The government has tried to design policy process to involve civic participation and active interaction among policy actors including stakeholders and public has been positioned as the mechanism of policy output in the policy process. Especially, language or text and actual words people use have performed important role in the mechanism. Many policy process studies has had limit of explain mechanism but Narrative Policy Framework(NPF) emphasize narratives formed from communication or debate in policy conflict situation as a core element the mechanism indicating the policy process and policy change. The understanding of mechanism produces contextual knowledge and deeper interpretation which have been overlooked in the policy study. This study tested meso-level NPF hypotheses using News media and transcript which was recorded when citizen discussed during deliberation program were refined by text mining and analyzed by semantic network analysis and sensitive analysis. The implications of this study are rendered by academic and policy aspects. Firstly, this study is contributive to academic aspects in that it make more empirical that narrative is a significant factors of policy change by elaborating theoretical review of NPF and applying mixed research method including big data analysis. Second, this study propose how the participatory policy and policy design for democracy would be more effective and produce successful outcomes. In the case of deliberating polling, this study suggest the frame of policy problem and alternatives need to be more diversified and the process of understanding interaction like unrefined narratives formed by public also need to be considered when policy decision making.
Keyword. Narrative Policy Framework, Policy Design, Deliberative Polling, Sementic Network Big Data Analysis, Shin-gori No.5&6 Nuclear Plant, Conflict Management
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Applying Narrative Policy Framework under Conditions of Democratic Backsliding: Case of Protest Regulation in Mumbai, India
Narrative policy framework (NPF) has been applied in the global north to systematically collect and analyze narratives that influence policy processes in populist and authoritarian settings (Jones & McBeth, 2020; Uldanov et al., 2021). In the context of democratic erosion and overarching curtailment of civil liberties worldwide (Haggard & Kaufman, 2021), it has become essential to investigate the multifaceted relationship between narratives and policy processes in non-democratic political regimes in non-Western geographies (Schlaufer, 2022). More diverse and context-specific examinations of narratives in policy geographies that exhibit illiberal political characteristics are required – this is where the literature on democratic backsliding becomes useful. Democratic backsliding is the incremental erosion of democratic values and ideals in a society (Haggard & Kaufman, 2021). The Indian state under the rule of the Bharatiya Janata Party is an example of a democracy undergoing backsliding (Jaffrelot, 2019; Heller, 2020; Varshney, 2022) – a claim backed by various global democratic indices (EIU, 2021; Freedom House, 2022).
In this paper, I apply NPF to understand the narratives and discourses influencing protest regulation in Mumbai, India, where state responses to protests have become repressive in the recent past (Shantha, 2020). I draw from the idea that regimes use narratives of actions being ‘in-place’ or ‘out-of-place’ to justify and propagate repressive institutional responses that limit access to public space (Cresswell, 1994, p. 95). In my NPF model, I consider narratives in the national political sphere to be at the macro level because these play an important role in defining cultural and institutional perceptions of protests in the country. Mumbai’s city-level institutions, specifically the Bombay Municipal Corporation and the Mumbai Police, constitute the meso level in the model. I will examine both macro level narratives that shape broader discourses about protests and meso level narratives that influence sub-national policy actions and responses to protests – along with interactions between these levels. Specifically, the NPF research question that the paper seeks to answer is: how do macro level narratives that take form at the national level inform and influence policy responses to protests at the meso level (city-level) under conditions of democratic backsliding?
To study the macro level narratives, I will draw from references to protests and protestors in publicly available speeches by Prime Minister Narendra Modi and other prominent political actors from 2014 to 2022. To discern meso level narratives, I will employ primary interviews with organizers and state officials in Mumbai, and secondary documents, including police circulars and press releases. Once the narrative components (including characters, plot, morals, and beliefs) at both levels are identified, it will be possible to study how narratives under conditions of democratic backsliding influence protest regulation at the city-level.
This paper will add to the NPF literature in two ways: first, it will tell us more about the applicability of NPF under conditions of democratic backsliding (a concern also raised by Schlaufer, 2022) and the challenges of such applications; and second, it will foreground the role of macro level narratives in influencing meso level policy processes and institutions in these settings.
References
Cresswell, T. J. (1996). In place/out of place: Geography, ideology and transgression. The University of Wisconsin-Madison.
EIU (2021). Economic Intelligence Unit Democracy Index Report. Available at https://www.eiu.com/n/campaigns/democracy-index-2021.
Freedom House (2022). Freedom House Freedom in the World Report. Country report for India available at https://freedomhouse.org/country/india/freedom-world/2022.
Haggard, S., & Kaufman, R. (2021). Backsliding: Democratic regress in the contemporary world. Cambridge University Press.
Heller, P. (2020). The age of reaction: Retrenchment populism in India and Brazil. International Sociology, 35(6), 590-609.
Jaffrelot, C. (2019). A de facto ethnic democracy? Obliterating and targeting the other, Hindu vigilantes, and the ethno-state.
Jones, M. D., & McBeth, M. K. (2010). A narrative policy framework: Clear enough to be wrong?. Policy studies journal, 38(2), 329-353.
Jones, M. D., & McBeth, M. K. (2020). Narrative in the Time of Trump: Is the Narrative Policy Framework good enough to be relevant?. Administrative Theory & Praxis, 42(2), 91-110.
Jones, M. D., McBeth, M. K., & Shanahan, E. A. (2014). Introducing the narrative policy framework. In The science of stories (pp. 1-25). Palgrave Macmillan, New York.
Schlaufer, C., Kuenzler, J., Jones, M. D., & Shanahan, E. A. (2022). The narrative policy framework: a traveler’s guide to policy stories. Politische Vierteljahresschrift, 63(2), 249-273.
Shanahan, E. A., Jones, M. D., & McBeth, M. K. (2018). How to conduct a Narrative Policy Framework study. The Social Science Journal, 55(3), 332-345.
Shantha, S. (2020, August 29). ‘Attempt to Curtail Dissent’: Mumbai Police seeks Rs 50 lakh as Surety from Activist for Protesting. The Wire. Retrieved January 30, 2023, from https://thewire.in/rights/mumbai-police-rs-50-lakh-surety-protesting.
Uldanov, A., Gabriichuk, T., Karateev, D., & Makhmutova, M. (2021). Narratives in an authoritarian environment: Narrative strategies, plots, and characters in Moscow’s public transport reforms debate. European Policy Analysis, 7(2), 433- 450.
Varshney, A. (2022). How India's Ruling Party Erodes Democracy. Journal of Democracy, 33(4), 104-118.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Narratives play a pivotal role in policymaking and are highly relied upon by policy actors, as they structure the way those actors argue in favour of their own preferred policy solutions in order to convince colleagues and citizens of the ‘goodness’ of those solutions. This value of narratives has been exalted especially within the context of crisis management. Yet, little is known about the explanatory power of policy narratives in relation to the achievement of desired policy outputs. In other words, we have little empirical evidence about the extent to which a certain kind of policy narrative really helps policymakers to achieve their goals, including in times of crisis. In light of the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF), this paper aims to explore this aspect. It does so through a case study of narratives employed during the pandemic in Italy, which represented an emblematic case of a problematic context becoming the protagonist of narratives. Moreover, it exploits the relatively simple policy context offered by the education sector during the crisis, where the main policy solutions proposed and adopted were clearly identifiable, divided as they were between school closures and reopenings. In addition, focusing on a specific policy sector offers the possibility to construct a more context-sensitive 'narrative of narratives' than with general containment measures. Not least, the paper applies the NPF to a country in a geographical area (Southern Europe) in which the framework has so far found very little application. Based on this case study, which compares the narratives of the different policy actors and governments that managed school policies during the pandemic, the article argues that policy narratives are only a part of the story and that they need to be put in context to explain the success of policymakers in attaining (or not attaining) their preferred policy solutions. It then identifies these additional factors that need to be considered when using the NPF for explanatory purposes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper discusses the Narrative Policy Framework and qualitative approaches to studying the LGBTQ+ community. Sabatier and Weible invited researchers in Theories of the Policy Process to advance the Narrative Policy Framework through various innovative applications. One of these areas more recently has been an interest in qualitative research on the LGBTQ+ community in substantive public policy areas. This paper will examine recently published articles that apply the Narrative Policy Framework to LGBTQ+ qualitative research specifically, and then it will examine similar approaches for other public policy frameworks.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The paper apply the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) for empirical exploration of macrolevel narratives in debates around the landscape fire policy in Russia in 2010 - 2020. Macrolevel NPF research are generally underrepresented in literature and all existing studies are related to the context of democratic regimes. This paper expands our knowledge about using this level of framework beyond liberal democracies. The problem of landscape fires has firmly entered the public discourse in Russia since 2010, when the catastrophic forest and peatland fires occurred in the European part of the country. After this focusing event several NGOs started systematic work to promote the necessary changes in landscape fire policy. This pro-reform coalition advocated a change in the policy paradigm (from just reaction to prevention). One of the most notable and discussed proposals was a ban on burning grass (including ban for agricultural burning), which was finally adopted in 2015. Based on the macrolevel narratives conceptualization and empirical approach, proposed by previous scholars, this study answers the questions - did the macronarratives about the landscape fire policy change after the ban was adopted, and if so, how did this change affect the meso-level - the use of narratives by policy actors in this policy subsystem, namely the state and NGOs.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In Sweden, health care is formally politically governed on several governance levels. The regional authorities, governed by elected politicians, are responsible for the main part of the financing as well as the provision of health care. The regional politicians’ main responsibilities are to decide on taxation, allocate the public resources and to formulate political goals and strategies. Their democratic assignment means that citizens can influence health care policy through the politicians and hold them accountable.
Governing authorities in Sweden have however during the last two decades increasingly relied on a form of management which is called “knowledge-driven management” when regulating health care. The primary method for implementing knowledge-driven management in health care organizations is different kinds of expert guidelines specifying “best practices”. In Sweden, both the guidelines and the national organizations for the production of guidelines have become increasingly comprehensive and complex.
Previous research indicates that national knowledge-driven management is part of a process of centralisation, standardization and technocratization of health care governance in Sweden. Very little is however known about the arguments for (and against) national knowledge-driven management. The notion of expert knowledge is very dominating in health care, but it can differ between contexts and times what knowledge that is considered as expertise and who is considered an expert. National knowledge-driven management might have promoted new actors and new ideas about how health care should be governed, and obstructed other.
The overall aim of the study is to analyze policy narratives about an organization for national knowledge-driven management in Sweden and how the narratives have developed historically, by studying policy documents. The policy documents include official documents about different initiatives of organized national/centralized knowledge-driven management of health care, including comment letters from different policy actors, in the time period 1999-2022.
Tools from the Narrative Policy Framework will be employed to analyze the narrative structures and contents, and to compare the policy actors’ different narratives. How the settings, plots, characters, and morals are described in policy documents and how they have changed over time is an illuminating way of exploring national knowledge-driven management’s emergence and how it relates to ideas about for example political regional self-governance.
In addition to the Narrative Policy Framework, frameworks from previous research about rationales in the construction of public policies for health care will be employed. In research about the construction of target groups of health care policy and the underlying rationales, different types of reasoning for the justification and legitimation of the different policies have been identified. Rationales can for example be technocratic/scientific, cultural, social, or political. This taxonomy of categories of rationales can potentially be useful in analyzing how the narrative elements are labelled and what values that are attached to them by different actors.
To our knowledge, the NPF has not previously been used to analyze health care policy in Sweden. The study could also contribute to the field of macro narratives and the role of institutions.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)