Format

P10. Policy Transaction, a pragmatic and constructivist Approach

POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Christopher Ansell
University of California, Berkeley
Main chair
Patrick Hassenteufel
Université Paris-Saclay
Second chair
Philippe Zittoun
ENTPE - LAET - University of Lyon
Third chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

This panel proposes to build on the Pragmatist concept of “transaction” to analyze public policy and policy processes.  The concept of a “transaction” was originally introduced by philosopher John Dewey and political scientist Arthur Bentley to describe a dynamic approach to knowledge that did not start with fixed elements.  Applied to policy processes, a transactional perspective stresses the co-constitution of policy actors and the policy field iteratively through time through via the mediation of action and meaning. Rather than starting with the fixed preferences, interests, and belief of independent policy actors, a transactional view assumes that they are fluid and will emerge relationally within a given policy situation.

There is little in the existing policy studies literature that explicitly applies the concept of transaction to policy processes, with the exception of Kuruvilla and Dorstewitz’s (2010) model of “transactive rationality,” which emphasizes that policy inquiry begins with an “indeterminate situation” (or “enigma” in Boltanski’s terms) and depends on a “community of inquiry.” While their approach focuses on policy analysis, this panel applies the idea to the policy process. As such, it does not assume that policy actors will converge on a singular understanding of policy problems.  However, the policy transaction perspective does expect rival interpretations to be progressively articulated with respect to one another—that is, they are co-constituted in the policy situation.

A policy transaction perspective emphasizes how policy problems become structured through processes of communication, valuation and reflexivity. Although policy research on “policy definition,” “framing” and “policy discourse” have already take us a long way toward understanding how policy problems are shaped by communication, the policy transaction approach takes us a step further.  Adopting what communication theorists have called a “triple contingency” view of communication, the policy transaction approach views communication between ego and alter as taking shape through a perspective that transcends either of their initial perspectives and implicitly takes account of third parties. Thus, policy transactions both depend on and create “publics” that shape problem definition.  

The co-constitution of policy actors and policy fields also takes shape through processes of valuation where policy actors develop justifications for the worth of certain actions. A policy transaction perspective stresses that values are constructed through and emerge from engagement with specific policy situations.  In other words, this approach does not start with competing values and subsequently examine policy conflict; rather it emphasizes how values become articulated and structured in the course of policy conflict.

CALL FOR PAPERS

This panel builds on the Pragmatist concept of “transaction” to analyze public policy and policy processes.  The concept of a “transaction” was originally introduced by philosopher John Dewey and political scientist Arthur Bentley to describe a dynamic approach to knowledge that did not start with fixed elements.  Applied to policy processes, a transactional perspective stresses the co-constitution of policy actors and the policy field iteratively through time through via the mediation of action and meaning. Policy transactions are structured through processes of communication, valuation and reflexivity and both depend on and create publics that shape problem definition. 

Papers for this panel should advance the policy transaction perspective through either theoretical or empirical research.  Theoretical papers might deepen our understanding of the Pragmatist concept of transaction and how it applies to policy studies.  Papers might also investigate how a policy transaction perspective intersects with various constructivist approaches to policy studies. We would especially welcome papers that contrast a policy transaction approach with other well-established policy process approaches, such as policy streams, punctuated equilibrium, and advocacy and discourse coalitions. Papers that make connections between a policy transaction approach and core concepts in the public policy literature—such as policy discourse, policy change, coalitions, or policy subsystems—would also be relevant.

Empirically, the policy transaction perspective investigates how actor preferences, interests and beliefs emerge within the policy process and how these emergent outcomes subsequently structure the policy field. The panel would welcome papers that examine this emergent process in detail and that investigate how this structuring occurs through processes of communication, valuation and reflexivity.   A focus on how policy problems are defined transactionally would be particularly useful. The panel is open to papers about any policy sector, subsystem or level but would especially welcome papers that examine cross-sectoral or multi-level dynamics or interactions between subsystems.  

We also invite papers that explore how value is articulated in policy fields and papers that closely investigate how policymakers engage in activities like persuading, convincing, struggling, negotiating, defining, and analyzing would be welcomed.  In addition, papers that point to how individual and collective reflexivity emerges in the course of policy dynamics, particularly in the form of “publics,” would contribute significantly to this project.  Methodologically, the panel is interested in how we can observe and understand emergent policy processes.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Shifting goal posts, broken promises: The Problematization of maternal death in Uganda (2000-2015)
Moses Mukuru (Nottingham Trent University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Maternal health is one of the policy areas for which global and national targets have consistently been missed since the safe motherhood initiative to date. In Uganda, maternal mortality remains one of the priorities on national policy agenda with a long history of recycling unattained targets. A better understanding of why stated policy goals do not achieve their intended targets could be reached through the deconstruction of narratives on maternal mortality and questioning how powerful but misplaced ‘framing’ can and did (re)produce policy failure. We pose two provocations related to the MDG years 2000-15: first, What is the relationship between the facts of Ugandan maternal mortality and the language used by policymakers to describe it in the policy process? Second, How is this language of understanding reflected in the narratives of decision-makers, its subsequent entrenchment in policies and the repeated failure to achieve policy targets? This paper posits that the way policymakers understand and describe maternal mortality in policies engenders an inadequate definition of the problem producing policies that partially tackle the problem. We consequently introduce a bifurcated typology based on the analytical distinction between ‘shifting goalposts’ and ‘broken promises’ to distinguish key but different types of failure both conceptual and operational. We contend there is value in focusing on how maternal mortality has been socially constructed over the years to understand how the ‘problematisation’ of issues in the policy process can embed and sustain failure or even worsen situations the policy was intended to alleviate. We reviewed four policy documents that introduced the major maternal health policies in Uganda during the period 2000-2015. The policies were: basic package, comprehensive package, universal rollout of basic package and high impact package. We further reviewed manifestos of the political party that was in government during the period 2000- 2015 and interviewed seven national policymakers who were involved in the policies under consideration. Using a social constructivist lens, data were analysed and presented under two themes; shifting goalposts (changing problematisations of maternal mortality) and broken promises (missed targets). Whilst obstetric causes were consistently the main causes of maternal mortality throughout the reference period, policy actors (re)constructed it in multiple and contested ways. Gynaecologists defined it in medical terms (obstetric complications requiring functioning emergency obstetric care and health systems). Politicians defined maternal death in two ways: lack of women’s empowerment to exercise control over their reproductive health, and subversion of government policy and criminal neglect by medical workers. To advocacy groups, it was lack of government commitment towards fulfilling its policy promises – a symptom of government failure. Each of these actors cherrypicked statistical data and interpreted it in ways that supported their stance. This produced shifting policies with shifting foci without holistically targeting the problem thus, repeatedly missing all the targets as high maternal mortality persisted. We conclude, whilst maternal mortality like many public problems is multifaceted and complex, multiple and competing social constructions of maternal death by policy actors (‘shifting goalposts’) made it difficult to define a holistic and coherent policy framework over the years. This in part could explain why for more than two decades, among all the policy changes introduced, none achieved half of its stated targets (broken promises). This paper calls for a reflective and holistic (re)definition of maternal mortality to guide systematic policy responses. We contend that by using a social constructivist lens, a thorough (re)conceptualization of maternal health issues is achievable by both practitioners and scholars of health policy

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Focusing on focusing events: the role of contingency in the translation of anti-corruption policy
sofia wickberg (University of Amsterdam)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper applies the concept of transaction to the process of policy transfer, by studying the role of contingency and timing in the translation of conflict of interest regulation into the British, French and Swedish parliaments. Using parliamentary archives, documentary sources and semi-structured interviews with key stakeholders conducted between 2015 and 2019, the paper shows that timing, and more specifically focusing events, matters in (at least) two ways: because it affects the policy actors involved and influences policy promoters’ legitimisation strategies, modifying opportunities and constraints, but also because it ultimately affects how the problem of conflicts of interest is conceived of and regulated in practice. The article puts the transactional perspective – stressing the co-constitution of policy actors and the policy field via the mediation of action and meaning – in dialogue with constructivist institutionalism – with stresses the constructed nature of policy actors’ interests. It shows that the context of politicisation, and focusing events in particular, can modify actors perception of a situation, of the problem at hand and of their interests and role. The paper argues that students of policy transaction need to pay attention not only to the transactions between policy actors but also the transactions between policy actors and their different contexts.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Policy out of place: Applying Mary Parker Follett’s pragmatic theory of situations to understand policy processes in remote and hybrid office workplaces
George Martin (York University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

At the onset of the COVID pandemic, organizations embraced virtual meetings, hybrid arrangements and remote work as emergency measures. Now that these arrangements have become normalized, the question of how policy processes are affected by these situations has become a central concern in organizational planning and strategy. While discussions of off-site work often highlight technology or psychological aspects of face-to-face interaction, at the basis of the debate is the matter of how members of an organization come to define a situation collectively as a meaningful and effective basis of decision-making. Responding to this context, this presentation discusses the ideas of Mary Parker Follett, a notable early 20th-century theorist of pragmatism to explore emerging research on decision-making situations (Bartels, 2013; Norton, 2014; Stout, 2019) While Follett’s contribution to organization studies and business management is well recognized, the applicability of her ground-breaking thought on policy-making processes has yet to be fully explored (Stout, 2019). Specifically, Follett’s insights about the context of decision-making may help develop a ‘post-workplace’ perspective on policy processes attuned to the dynamics of socially-constructed notions of place, identity, and ethos that continue to reshape norms of policy-making and administrative processes.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Deliberative Ecologies: A Relational Critique of Deliberative Systems
Bruno Magalhães (Fundação João Pinheiro)
CO-AUTHORS
Ricardo Mendonça (Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais)
Lucas Veloso
Filipe Motta (Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais)
ABSTRACT

The concept of deliberative systems has had an enormous influence in the field of deliberative democracy. Due to its relevance and undeniable contributions, the concept thrived with scarce friction. This article aims at challenging the idea of deliberative systems and at advocating an alternative to it. We argue that the notion of deliberative ecology can deliver the necessary conceptual elements that deliberative democrats seek in deliberative systems without some problems they either overlook or embrace in the concept. One may acknowledge that public discussions can (and should) happen in a variety of arenas spread over space and time without adopting a systemic perspective. An ecological approach can grasp this idea while also avoiding conceptual and practical limitations inherent to the premises of structural functionalism that pervade, in a way or another, the idea of deliberative systems. Drawing from theories of complexity and from pragmatism, an ecological approach considers social entities according to the webs of interdependence that simultaneously support and constrain them at a given moment in time. Since it understands those relational webs as fluid and complex, it does not qualify actors and political arenas with fixed, universal and aprioristic categories, roles and functions. Such perspective values the dynamic and unpredictable features of reality, refusing the quest to organize it in ways that would enable a causal understanding of the world. It also pays attention to the contradictions and tensions pervading a given ecology. In doing so, this ecological approach recognizes the multiple, recursive, and shifty nature of relationships grounding the vivid and non-teleological unfolding of beings, spaces, and temporalities. To advocate the difference and advantages of this perspective in comparison to the notion of deliberative systems, we organize this article in two parts. In the first part, we briefly reconstruct the notion of deliberative systems and deal with the main criticisms raised against it, arguing that they are insufficient to grasp the problems inherent to the idea of systems. In the second part, we advance six comparative points, aimed at showing limitations of the systemic approach and the different angles enabled by an ecological perspective: (1) functions of arenas and players vs. performances of actants; (2) transmission across arenas vs. articulations and translations; (3) pathologies and disfunctions vs. vulnerabilities; (4) design vs. practice; (5) linear temporality vs. diverse temporalities; (6) organic analysis vs. hologram-based approach. In a nutshell, we claim that the way deliberative systems conceive of the relationships between different discursive arenas simplifies and linearizes complex and recursive interconnections. Deliberative democrats frequently look for transmission processes and for the functions or roles of different arenas, without acknowledging the open-ended dynamic of discursive flows. This has thwarted a proper conceptualization, for instance, of forms or relationship between discursive arenas that actually obstruct deliberation. An ecological approach to deliberation has the advantage of conceptualizing an ever-changing web of relations of interdependency, which connects diverse entities that are relevant to a public discussion or that hinder its enactment.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Transformative Ideas: School Choice and Swedish Educational Policy in the 1990s
Paula Blomqvist (Dept of Government)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Constructivist analyses of policy-making demonstrate that ideas can play an important role in such processes by influencing the goals and preferences of stakeholders. Despite general agreement that ideas “matter” in this regard, more work needs to be done to identify the specific mechanisms which lead policy actors to endorse new ideas and which enable ideas to become institutionalized and exert a long-lasting political influence. One way to approach this task is to look at international patterns of policy diffusion and investigate why a certain idea becomes adopted in some countries but not others in a given time period. A policy idea which gained international influence in the 1990s in the area of education, leading to reforms in several countries, is school choice. School choice can be loosely understood as a market-inspired organization model where public and private schools compete for public funding on basis of how many students they attract. The fact that this idea, originally developed by neoliberal economist Milton Friedman, spread from the US to the UK, New Zeeland and Australia is perhaps less surprising. More counterintuitive is that it also became the basis for a comprehensive education reform in 1992 in Sweden, where it was endorsed not only by right-wing but also left-wing parties. The Swedish school choice reform turned out to be more radical than in virtually any other country, creating a nationwide system of competitive markets for primary schools open to both for-profit firms and religious organizations.

 

In this paper, I employ a constructivist approach to understand why ideas about school choice gained such wide traction and eventually become institutionalized in Sweden in the late 1980s and early 1990s. The research method used in the paper combines process -tracing with discourse analysis, as I trace the process through which different political actors formulated and reformulated their policy positions over time in relation to the school choice idea, gradually moving closer to each other. The materials used are policy documents and party platforms. To inform the analysis, I draw on recent theorizing about policy ideas as a form of bricolage, which can be taken apart and rebuilt to fit better with core values of policy actors. This can also be conceived of as a form of transaction, where ideas, or parts of them, become a sort of currency which opens new discursive spaces between policy actors. The empirical contribution of the paper is that it casts new light on the question of why a leftist political actor like the Swedish social democratic party (SAP) came to endorse a blatantly neoliberal idea like school choice. The theoretical contribution is that the paper uncovers mechanisms through which novel policy ideas can be adopted by actors with different core values if the ideas in question are re-interpreted and reformulated in ways that at least appear to make them consistent with these values.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - From values to valuations: towards a new policy analytical methodology
Katharina Paul (University of Vienna)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The challenges of the current era – including global health and the climate crisis – have brought to the fore a series of wicked problems: problems that are socially complex and resistant to solutions due to differing stakeholder perspectives of what the problem is (Rittel & Weber 1973). Vaccination governance is a paradigmatic example and in the face of declining vaccine uptake, public health advocates and decisionmakers have emphasized the value of vaccination, expressing it in medical terms and metrics, such as in the number of lives saved or percentage of the population vaccinated. This narrow and monolithic understanding of ‘value’, however, has exacerbated already polarized debates by failing to accommodate how different actors value and assess the importance of vaccination – for example, its scientific, economic, ethical, social, or personal value.
To address this scientific and political deadlock, we propose a new methodology for the study of wicked problems, labelled policy valuography. Borrowing from science and technology studies (Dussauge et al 2015; Lamont 2012) and informed by critical public health scholarship (cf. Reubi 2018a, 2018b; Adams 2016) as well as critical policy studies (Freeman 2019; Dodge & Metze 2017), such a methodology entails studying valuation practices – rather than seemingly static values - across different sites of governance. In the present case of vaccination policy, this will include an analysis of value repertoires in policy programs, primary care, industry, scientific research, and social media. We ask: how do different actors assign value to vaccination and its governance, and how, in turn, do these valuations both reflect and produce particular forms of governance? This paper maps out the methodology used to address this question in the framework of a larger study. It speaks to a transactional perspective in that it emphasizes the contingency of value concepts and the intricate relationship between action and meaning. This new methodology, we propose, can not only contribute to politically sustainable immunization strategies both for existing and emerging vaccines but may be relevant for the study of other wicked problems, too, including those associated with the global climate crisis.
 

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Lowering the age of pension in France between 1981 and 1983 : a negociation and its policy transactions
Ilias Naji (Universität Linz)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Reforming pension systems has been on the agenda of social policies in European countries for more than three decades. The literature on welfare and institutional change explains how pension systems have been reformed by considering the demographic, economic and institutional context, including the governance of welfare institution by constituted interest groups (Bonoli and Palier 2007, Da Conceicao-Heldt 2007, Naczyk and Palier 2011). This article uses the notion of policy transaction to understand the making of a pension reform (between 1981 and 1983) decided by the French socialist newly elected government. We examine how a series of actors (government, administration, trade unions and employers’ representatives) connected through relations occurring during and between sessions of the negotiation. This method allows us to understand the gap between the initial confrontation of actors’ preferences (that blocked discussions) and the result of the negotiation (that lowered the age of pension). Considering the fluidity of strategies, demands and objectives of actors involved in the negotiation helps us to better analyze the making of an agreement that consisted in changing institutions of welfare states and financial flows between them. This institutional and financial creativity respected the constraints put by the powerful employers’ representatives, opposed to rise in the contribution rate, but also by the government who expected the pension at 60 to be realized. Trade unions limited damages by avoiding any planed decrease in pensions but still had to give up an advantageous form of early pensions. If trade unions were initially able to block the negotiation, their abandonment can be understood by focusing on the dynamics of the discussion. Actors are thus regularly redefining their objectives and strategies in order to face the unexpected consequences resulting from the negotiation. An attention to the actors’ reflexivity and discourses production (Durnova, Fischer and Zittoun 2016) can be led thanks to our archival material collected during a phd thesis (Naji 2020). In particular, the archive of minutes summarizing the discussion of each negotiation session, and produced by the different actors, allows us to observe and interpret these changes. The transactional approach is thus particularly heuristic for analyzing a public policy built on a negotiation phase.

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Researching Policy Practices in Action: A Policy Transaction Approach to the European Union’s International Cultural Relations Framework
Szilvia Nagy (Central European University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The introduction of the European Union’s International Cultural Relations (ICR) framework in the Global Strategy for the European Union’s Foreign and Security Policy signalled a new, strategic turn to culture in its foreign policy. The Global Strategy (GS) sought to harness culture’s capacity to engage with global challenges and to provide a seemingly depoliticised platform for the strategy through the ICR framework.

This paper will address this framework by following a policy transaction approach. First, it will introduce the this approach as it is discussed by Ansell, Hassenteufel and Zittoun (2022). Next, it will contextualise the introduction of the International Cultural Relation framework in the European Union’s cultural diplomacy as a case study for this inquiry. Finally, it will analyse the strategic changes related to the introduction of the ICR by focusing on two aspects highlighted by the policy transaction approach: the framing of the ‘problem’ through a new discourse and the situatedness of actors.

Policy transaction is an ideal framework for this analysis, as it helps to overcome the dualisms (discourse/actors; essentialism/strategy, etc) embedded in the pragmatist-constructivist tradition. With the help of this approach, the research suggests that ICR is highly politicised: it does not only aim to build a framework to rebuild the European Union’s soft power toolkit, but also introduces new actors – cultural intermediaries – through orchestration in order to translate EU GS priorities into cultural activities and actions.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Policy transaction: An Introduction
Philippe Zittoun (ENTPE - LAET - University of Lyon)
CO-AUTHORS
Christopher Ansell (University of California, Berkeley)
Patrick Hassenteufel (Université Paris-Saclay)
ABSTRACT

Introduction

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Maternal health is one of the policy areas for which global and national targets have consistently been missed since the safe motherhood initiative to date. In Uganda, maternal mortality remains one of the priorities on national policy agenda with a long history of recycling unattained targets. A better understanding of why stated policy goals do not achieve their intended targets could be reached through the deconstruction of narratives on maternal mortality and questioning how powerful but misplaced ‘framing’ can and did (re)produce policy failure. We pose two provocations related to the MDG years 2000-15: first, What is the relationship between the facts of Ugandan maternal mortality and the language used by policymakers to describe it in the policy process? Second, How is this language of understanding reflected in the narratives of decision-makers, its subsequent entrenchment in policies and the repeated failure to achieve policy targets? This paper posits that the way policymakers understand and describe maternal mortality in policies engenders an inadequate definition of the problem producing policies that partially tackle the problem. We consequently introduce a bifurcated typology based on the analytical distinction between ‘shifting goalposts’ and ‘broken promises’ to distinguish key but different types of failure both conceptual and operational. We contend there is value in focusing on how maternal mortality has been socially constructed over the years to understand how the ‘problematisation’ of issues in the policy process can embed and sustain failure or even worsen situations the policy was intended to alleviate. We reviewed four policy documents that introduced the major maternal health policies in Uganda during the period 2000-2015. The policies were: basic package, comprehensive package, universal rollout of basic package and high impact package. We further reviewed manifestos of the political party that was in government during the period 2000- 2015 and interviewed seven national policymakers who were involved in the policies under consideration. Using a social constructivist lens, data were analysed and presented under two themes; shifting goalposts (changing problematisations of maternal mortality) and broken promises (missed targets). Whilst obstetric causes were consistently the main causes of maternal mortality throughout the reference period, policy actors (re)constructed it in multiple and contested ways. Gynaecologists defined it in medical terms (obstetric complications requiring functioning emergency obstetric care and health systems). Politicians defined maternal death in two ways: lack of women’s empowerment to exercise control over their reproductive health, and subversion of government policy and criminal neglect by medical workers. To advocacy groups, it was lack of government commitment towards fulfilling its policy promises – a symptom of government failure. Each of these actors cherrypicked statistical data and interpreted it in ways that supported their stance. This produced shifting policies with shifting foci without holistically targeting the problem thus, repeatedly missing all the targets as high maternal mortality persisted. We conclude, whilst maternal mortality like many public problems is multifaceted and complex, multiple and competing social constructions of maternal death by policy actors (‘shifting goalposts’) made it difficult to define a holistic and coherent policy framework over the years. This in part could explain why for more than two decades, among all the policy changes introduced, none achieved half of its stated targets (broken promises). This paper calls for a reflective and holistic (re)definition of maternal mortality to guide systematic policy responses. We contend that by using a social constructivist lens, a thorough (re)conceptualization of maternal health issues is achievable by both practitioners and scholars of health policy

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper applies the concept of transaction to the process of policy transfer, by studying the role of contingency and timing in the translation of conflict of interest regulation into the British, French and Swedish parliaments. Using parliamentary archives, documentary sources and semi-structured interviews with key stakeholders conducted between 2015 and 2019, the paper shows that timing, and more specifically focusing events, matters in (at least) two ways: because it affects the policy actors involved and influences policy promoters’ legitimisation strategies, modifying opportunities and constraints, but also because it ultimately affects how the problem of conflicts of interest is conceived of and regulated in practice. The article puts the transactional perspective – stressing the co-constitution of policy actors and the policy field via the mediation of action and meaning – in dialogue with constructivist institutionalism – with stresses the constructed nature of policy actors’ interests. It shows that the context of politicisation, and focusing events in particular, can modify actors perception of a situation, of the problem at hand and of their interests and role. The paper argues that students of policy transaction need to pay attention not only to the transactions between policy actors but also the transactions between policy actors and their different contexts.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

At the onset of the COVID pandemic, organizations embraced virtual meetings, hybrid arrangements and remote work as emergency measures. Now that these arrangements have become normalized, the question of how policy processes are affected by these situations has become a central concern in organizational planning and strategy. While discussions of off-site work often highlight technology or psychological aspects of face-to-face interaction, at the basis of the debate is the matter of how members of an organization come to define a situation collectively as a meaningful and effective basis of decision-making. Responding to this context, this presentation discusses the ideas of Mary Parker Follett, a notable early 20th-century theorist of pragmatism to explore emerging research on decision-making situations (Bartels, 2013; Norton, 2014; Stout, 2019) While Follett’s contribution to organization studies and business management is well recognized, the applicability of her ground-breaking thought on policy-making processes has yet to be fully explored (Stout, 2019). Specifically, Follett’s insights about the context of decision-making may help develop a ‘post-workplace’ perspective on policy processes attuned to the dynamics of socially-constructed notions of place, identity, and ethos that continue to reshape norms of policy-making and administrative processes.

CO-AUTHORS
Ricardo Mendonça (Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais)
Lucas Veloso
Filipe Motta (Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais)
ABSTRACT

The concept of deliberative systems has had an enormous influence in the field of deliberative democracy. Due to its relevance and undeniable contributions, the concept thrived with scarce friction. This article aims at challenging the idea of deliberative systems and at advocating an alternative to it. We argue that the notion of deliberative ecology can deliver the necessary conceptual elements that deliberative democrats seek in deliberative systems without some problems they either overlook or embrace in the concept. One may acknowledge that public discussions can (and should) happen in a variety of arenas spread over space and time without adopting a systemic perspective. An ecological approach can grasp this idea while also avoiding conceptual and practical limitations inherent to the premises of structural functionalism that pervade, in a way or another, the idea of deliberative systems. Drawing from theories of complexity and from pragmatism, an ecological approach considers social entities according to the webs of interdependence that simultaneously support and constrain them at a given moment in time. Since it understands those relational webs as fluid and complex, it does not qualify actors and political arenas with fixed, universal and aprioristic categories, roles and functions. Such perspective values the dynamic and unpredictable features of reality, refusing the quest to organize it in ways that would enable a causal understanding of the world. It also pays attention to the contradictions and tensions pervading a given ecology. In doing so, this ecological approach recognizes the multiple, recursive, and shifty nature of relationships grounding the vivid and non-teleological unfolding of beings, spaces, and temporalities. To advocate the difference and advantages of this perspective in comparison to the notion of deliberative systems, we organize this article in two parts. In the first part, we briefly reconstruct the notion of deliberative systems and deal with the main criticisms raised against it, arguing that they are insufficient to grasp the problems inherent to the idea of systems. In the second part, we advance six comparative points, aimed at showing limitations of the systemic approach and the different angles enabled by an ecological perspective: (1) functions of arenas and players vs. performances of actants; (2) transmission across arenas vs. articulations and translations; (3) pathologies and disfunctions vs. vulnerabilities; (4) design vs. practice; (5) linear temporality vs. diverse temporalities; (6) organic analysis vs. hologram-based approach. In a nutshell, we claim that the way deliberative systems conceive of the relationships between different discursive arenas simplifies and linearizes complex and recursive interconnections. Deliberative democrats frequently look for transmission processes and for the functions or roles of different arenas, without acknowledging the open-ended dynamic of discursive flows. This has thwarted a proper conceptualization, for instance, of forms or relationship between discursive arenas that actually obstruct deliberation. An ecological approach to deliberation has the advantage of conceptualizing an ever-changing web of relations of interdependency, which connects diverse entities that are relevant to a public discussion or that hinder its enactment.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Constructivist analyses of policy-making demonstrate that ideas can play an important role in such processes by influencing the goals and preferences of stakeholders. Despite general agreement that ideas “matter” in this regard, more work needs to be done to identify the specific mechanisms which lead policy actors to endorse new ideas and which enable ideas to become institutionalized and exert a long-lasting political influence. One way to approach this task is to look at international patterns of policy diffusion and investigate why a certain idea becomes adopted in some countries but not others in a given time period. A policy idea which gained international influence in the 1990s in the area of education, leading to reforms in several countries, is school choice. School choice can be loosely understood as a market-inspired organization model where public and private schools compete for public funding on basis of how many students they attract. The fact that this idea, originally developed by neoliberal economist Milton Friedman, spread from the US to the UK, New Zeeland and Australia is perhaps less surprising. More counterintuitive is that it also became the basis for a comprehensive education reform in 1992 in Sweden, where it was endorsed not only by right-wing but also left-wing parties. The Swedish school choice reform turned out to be more radical than in virtually any other country, creating a nationwide system of competitive markets for primary schools open to both for-profit firms and religious organizations.

 

In this paper, I employ a constructivist approach to understand why ideas about school choice gained such wide traction and eventually become institutionalized in Sweden in the late 1980s and early 1990s. The research method used in the paper combines process -tracing with discourse analysis, as I trace the process through which different political actors formulated and reformulated their policy positions over time in relation to the school choice idea, gradually moving closer to each other. The materials used are policy documents and party platforms. To inform the analysis, I draw on recent theorizing about policy ideas as a form of bricolage, which can be taken apart and rebuilt to fit better with core values of policy actors. This can also be conceived of as a form of transaction, where ideas, or parts of them, become a sort of currency which opens new discursive spaces between policy actors. The empirical contribution of the paper is that it casts new light on the question of why a leftist political actor like the Swedish social democratic party (SAP) came to endorse a blatantly neoliberal idea like school choice. The theoretical contribution is that the paper uncovers mechanisms through which novel policy ideas can be adopted by actors with different core values if the ideas in question are re-interpreted and reformulated in ways that at least appear to make them consistent with these values.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The challenges of the current era – including global health and the climate crisis – have brought to the fore a series of wicked problems: problems that are socially complex and resistant to solutions due to differing stakeholder perspectives of what the problem is (Rittel & Weber 1973). Vaccination governance is a paradigmatic example and in the face of declining vaccine uptake, public health advocates and decisionmakers have emphasized the value of vaccination, expressing it in medical terms and metrics, such as in the number of lives saved or percentage of the population vaccinated. This narrow and monolithic understanding of ‘value’, however, has exacerbated already polarized debates by failing to accommodate how different actors value and assess the importance of vaccination – for example, its scientific, economic, ethical, social, or personal value.
To address this scientific and political deadlock, we propose a new methodology for the study of wicked problems, labelled policy valuography. Borrowing from science and technology studies (Dussauge et al 2015; Lamont 2012) and informed by critical public health scholarship (cf. Reubi 2018a, 2018b; Adams 2016) as well as critical policy studies (Freeman 2019; Dodge & Metze 2017), such a methodology entails studying valuation practices – rather than seemingly static values - across different sites of governance. In the present case of vaccination policy, this will include an analysis of value repertoires in policy programs, primary care, industry, scientific research, and social media. We ask: how do different actors assign value to vaccination and its governance, and how, in turn, do these valuations both reflect and produce particular forms of governance? This paper maps out the methodology used to address this question in the framework of a larger study. It speaks to a transactional perspective in that it emphasizes the contingency of value concepts and the intricate relationship between action and meaning. This new methodology, we propose, can not only contribute to politically sustainable immunization strategies both for existing and emerging vaccines but may be relevant for the study of other wicked problems, too, including those associated with the global climate crisis.
 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Reforming pension systems has been on the agenda of social policies in European countries for more than three decades. The literature on welfare and institutional change explains how pension systems have been reformed by considering the demographic, economic and institutional context, including the governance of welfare institution by constituted interest groups (Bonoli and Palier 2007, Da Conceicao-Heldt 2007, Naczyk and Palier 2011). This article uses the notion of policy transaction to understand the making of a pension reform (between 1981 and 1983) decided by the French socialist newly elected government. We examine how a series of actors (government, administration, trade unions and employers’ representatives) connected through relations occurring during and between sessions of the negotiation. This method allows us to understand the gap between the initial confrontation of actors’ preferences (that blocked discussions) and the result of the negotiation (that lowered the age of pension). Considering the fluidity of strategies, demands and objectives of actors involved in the negotiation helps us to better analyze the making of an agreement that consisted in changing institutions of welfare states and financial flows between them. This institutional and financial creativity respected the constraints put by the powerful employers’ representatives, opposed to rise in the contribution rate, but also by the government who expected the pension at 60 to be realized. Trade unions limited damages by avoiding any planed decrease in pensions but still had to give up an advantageous form of early pensions. If trade unions were initially able to block the negotiation, their abandonment can be understood by focusing on the dynamics of the discussion. Actors are thus regularly redefining their objectives and strategies in order to face the unexpected consequences resulting from the negotiation. An attention to the actors’ reflexivity and discourses production (Durnova, Fischer and Zittoun 2016) can be led thanks to our archival material collected during a phd thesis (Naji 2020). In particular, the archive of minutes summarizing the discussion of each negotiation session, and produced by the different actors, allows us to observe and interpret these changes. The transactional approach is thus particularly heuristic for analyzing a public policy built on a negotiation phase.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The introduction of the European Union’s International Cultural Relations (ICR) framework in the Global Strategy for the European Union’s Foreign and Security Policy signalled a new, strategic turn to culture in its foreign policy. The Global Strategy (GS) sought to harness culture’s capacity to engage with global challenges and to provide a seemingly depoliticised platform for the strategy through the ICR framework.

This paper will address this framework by following a policy transaction approach. First, it will introduce the this approach as it is discussed by Ansell, Hassenteufel and Zittoun (2022). Next, it will contextualise the introduction of the International Cultural Relation framework in the European Union’s cultural diplomacy as a case study for this inquiry. Finally, it will analyse the strategic changes related to the introduction of the ICR by focusing on two aspects highlighted by the policy transaction approach: the framing of the ‘problem’ through a new discourse and the situatedness of actors.

Policy transaction is an ideal framework for this analysis, as it helps to overcome the dualisms (discourse/actors; essentialism/strategy, etc) embedded in the pragmatist-constructivist tradition. With the help of this approach, the research suggests that ICR is highly politicised: it does not only aim to build a framework to rebuild the European Union’s soft power toolkit, but also introduces new actors – cultural intermediaries – through orchestration in order to translate EU GS priorities into cultural activities and actions.

CO-AUTHORS
Christopher Ansell (University of California, Berkeley)
Patrick Hassenteufel (Université Paris-Saclay)
ABSTRACT

Introduction