Format

P09. Policy Decision-making in low- and middle-income countries – the role and interplay of state, business and civil society

POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
PANEL CHAIR(S)
NOOR Alabbas
University of Nottingham
Main chair
Ruby Chau
University of Nottingham
Second chair
Kevin Zapata Celestino
London School of Economics and Political Science, University of London
Third chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

The study of public policy has been dominated by theories and experiences of countries in richer Western countries. There are few international platforms for public policy researchers from low and middle-income countries, mostly from the Global South, to disseminate their original work. This has not only confined the understanding of public policies in these countries but also limited the scope of existing academic debate to conceptualise experiences of countries that are less economically developed. There may also be a missed opportunity of knowledge and policy transfer between countries in different regions and with different historical and political backgrounds.

This proposed panel aims to provide an intellectual space for public policy researchers from low- and middle-income countries and their counterparts from other parts of the world to explore the policy decision making process in different national contexts. The dialogue would have high scientific relevance and stimulate a discussion that goes beyond the state of the art. It would enrich the knowledge production of public policy mainly in four ways. The first is to contribute to filling the knowledge gap of the public policy process in low- and middle-income countries. The second is to supplement the existing debate of public policy in these countries that is mainly from political science or developmental perspectives. The third is to identify the gaps in existing public policy conceptions and review to what extent they are applicable to the analysis of public policy in these countries. Finally, by focusing on the role and interplay of the state, business and civil society in the decision-making process, the discussion would facilitate comparison between countries from different entry points.     

The main research questions:

1.       To what extent and in what ways is the public policy decision-making process different in low- and middle-income countries?

2.       Do low- and middle-income countries share a similar process or have diverse patterns in public policy decision-making?

3.       How and to what extent do socio-political and cultural contexts affect the public policy decision-making process in these countries? 

4.       To what extent are existing public policy concepts and theories appropriate in the analysis of such processes in these countries? Are there any gaps and what are they?

5.       What theoretical and practical lessons can be learnt from the study of public policy in low- and middle-income countries?   

6.       How to make the existing public policy debate (especially comparative studies) more inclusive to research on low- and middle-income countries?        

CALL FOR PAPERS

Call for Papers

The panel organisers would welcome papers with a focus on the public policy decision-making process in low- and middle-income countries as broadly defined by the Word Bank and the UN. An analysis of the role and interplay of the state, business and civil society will be particularly welcome. The paper can be based on the analysis of a single country or a group of countries, as case studies or in comparison with others. Both theoretical papers and research-based papers will be welcome.

The panel will be in an onsite format which allows for both in-personal and virtual presentations. Presenters who have time and/or financial constraints that make travelling difficult should not hesitate to submit a paper proposal. Presentations could be online with a follow-up discussion with other online and onsite participants via the conference online platform. 

There is a possibility that a selection of suitable papers would be invited to develop into an edited collection in the format of a book or a themed section in an international journal.

In the paper proposal, please clearly state the following:

1.       The country or countries to be analysed

2.       The area(s) of public policy to be analysed

3.       A highlight of the main conceptual tools

4.       A brief description of the methodology (for research-based papers)

5.       The key findings or arguments.

6.       The potential contributions of the paper to the understanding of the policy process in low- and middle-income countries

7.       The potential contributions to the wider international public policy debate

8.       The preference for in-person or virtual presentation

 

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Public policy, social forces, and post-conflict state building in post-colonial Africa: Evidence from South Sudan
Bantayehu Chanie (Bahir Dar University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

State building has been an intricate task African states that experienced conflict must grapple with since the era of decolonization. This continues to be the case in South Sudan that was born in July 2011 following a prolonged civil war. Although the world’s newest nation problem emanates from the policy of SPLM-led regime towards social forces, South Sudan’s success or failure in state building has largely been explained in relations to inexperienced personnel and weak institutions. Post-conflict state building mainly includes the state’s policy and action involving social forces that work side-by-side or contradicting state actors. This article explores South Sudan’s state building from the perspective of the state’s policy towards social forces. It uncovers the legal and institutional obstacles that have impacted on the state and role of civil society, political parties, and ethnic relations in South Sudan’s state building. The finding shows that CSOs working on service delivery appear to have contributed a lot in filling the gap in state institutions. However, generally, CSOs in South Sudan are weak to impact significantly on the multi-faceted state building challenges. This is mainly because of the dominance of interest driven INGOs, dependency syndrome, financial and capacity limitations among national and local CSOs, their growing partisanship, and restrictive government measures. Dominated by increasingly fragmented and militarized political groups under the SPLM party state, competitive party politics is non-existent in South Sudan. Ethnic division and violence due to an inherited social structure and SPLM’s exclusionary practices have also negatively affected South Sudan’s state building process.

 

Keywords: State building, public policy, social forces, civil society, political parties, ethnicity, South Sudan

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Civil Society and Pro-Poor Policy: The Case of Sub-Saharan Africa
Nicholas Odongo (Korea University, South Korea)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The gulf between theory, concept, policy, and outcome about poverty eradication in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) remains wide, congested, and contentious, witnessing many prescriptions, diverse successes, and an even wider scholarship. This study aims at creating an understanding of civil society’s integral role in poverty eradication in Sub-Saharan Africa through its participation in public policy. The study begins by discussing the poverty situation in the continent and continues to describe how markets and government have dominated this domain, critically analyzing both market-based structural and government-based institutional reform interventions in the quest for poverty eradication. In this aspect, political systems, institutions, and economic policies are analyzed considering their successes in addressing poverty. The study introduces and demonstrates civil society and its participation in public policy as a critical factor that enhances pro-poor policies and poverty reduction.

While civil society participation in public policy processes and its effect on poverty eradication remains an amorphous phenomenon in many existing debates and literature, I argue that it is indeed the missing link in the fight against poverty in the continent. In an attempt at a formal explanatory analysis of the role of civil society in pro-poor policies, the study discusses mechanisms that sustain the causal relationship between civil society and pro-poor policies. Through a multiple comparative panel regression analysis of 43 African countries between 2000 and 2020, results show that by interacting civil society participation in public policy with institutional factors namely public administration, local government, and democracy, countries experienced reduced out-of-pocket health expenditure per capita, one of the leading causes of household poverty in SSA. This demonstrates how civil society participation in public policy is instrumental and strategic for pro-poor policies; the increase in attaining increased pro-poor policy outcomes may only be accounted for in terms of enhanced civil society participation in public policy. The study discusses the empirical evidence needed to establish the indispensability of and desire to support civil society and institutionalize civil society participatory processes in public policy for the effective and efficient eradication of poverty in Sub-Saharan Africa. The future of poverty eradication and participatory democracy in Sub-Saharan Africa is tied to the ability to expand civil society participation in public policy.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Women and the Policy Process - Minimum Marriageable Age Policy in Nigeria
Ene Ikpebe (Florida State University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Nigeria has the eleventh highest incidence of early marriage – marriage before the age of 18 – in the world. This is problematic because early marriage has been shown to have significant health and socioeconomic disadvantages for girls. In 2003, the Child Rights Act (CRA) was adopted by the federal government of Nigeria. One of its provisions was a prohibition of early marriage. As of 2022, 25 of Nigeria’s 36 states had adopted the CRA. However, only 23 adopted its minimum marriageable age provision without exception. This paper discusses the factors affecting the adoption of the CRA’s minimum marriageable age policy, arguing that although religion provides a legitimate perspective on adoption decisions, women policy actors have also played a significant role. This paper therefore both presents a more comprehensive approach to understanding this policy process and provides support for the presence and participation of women in policymaking as an effective approach to the problem of early marriage.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - The Rise of Populism: Decision Making of the State Government in Poverty Reduction Policy – The State Welfare Scheme of Thailand
Aphiradee Wongsiri (Khon Kaen University)
CO-AUTHORS
Panu Suppatkul (Khon Kaen University)
Thanapauge Chamaratana (Khon Kaen University)
ABSTRACT

   This study is based on the shortcomings we observed in Thailand’s state welfare scheme in four rural and urban areas of Thai villages in Khon Kaen province through a mixed methods approach. This study asks two simple questions: how does the state government influence the state welfare scheme? and what are the pitfalls of the state welfare scheme? The Thai government has attempted to reduce poverty in the country by providing social welfare scheme known as “the poor card (state welfare card)” to those unable to meet their basic needs across the nation. Problems arose, however, when the government was unable to precisely identify those who were desperately poor and in need of assistance within the recruitment system, placing the greatest strain on the government's limited budget to allocate resources to non-target groups. Practically, the extremely poor are powerless because their voices are never heard in the public sphere and they are not involved in policy decision-making; consequently, they are subject to neglect and abuse, which is an indication of poor state governance.                             

     The findings of this study indicate that central government agencies have formulated and made decisions regarding the state welfare scheme. In addition, the state welfare scheme is administered and managed by the central government via provincial administration assigned to provincial offices or districts. This state welfare scheme has evolved into a political campaign to mobilize government supporters for voting, rather than a nationwide effort to eradicate poverty, resulting in an increase in the number of poor people. Consequently, one lesson to be learned from the pitfalls of the state welfare scheme is that an effective policy to reduce poverty requires good governance practices, such as accountability, transparency, and public participation. In particular, the state government must delegate authority to local administrative organizations to alleviate poverty within their jurisdictions, as well as engage other sectors, such as civil society, in the policy formulation, decision-making, and monitoring processes.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - ‘It is Identity, Stupid’: How Captive Minds Work in Contexts of Decision Making
Anubhav Bishen (National Law School of India University)
CO-AUTHORS
Sony Pellissery (National Law School of India University)
ABSTRACT

‘It is economy, stupid’, a phrase that found popularity in the US elections in 1992 holds true for public policy theories too. The literature on public policy has kept economics and economic rationality at the centre of all decision-making. The paper aims to show how the explanation has numerous flaws in the Indian context, and a better understanding can be gained if the phrase is changed to ‘It is identity. stupid’. The scholarly work on policy decision-making in the Global North has failed to comprehend the decision-making in the Global South. The paper will depict through a case study in India why theories that are used to explain or predict the process from agenda setting to decision making such as the advocacy coalitions, punctuated equilibrium, the policy window, etc. will find it difficult to explain the decision-making in the Global South.


The paper will argue that to analyse the policies in the Global South, there is a need to look beyond the captive mindset. Captive mind is a concept that says that an uncritical acceptance of all constituents of scientific activity of the West will not help the scholarly work in the Global South. It denotes a hierarchical ordering of knowledge and the impossibility of creating a knowledge system relevant to one. The paper will show why there is a need for an independent theoretical, analytical, and empirical perspective to better analyse policy decision-making in the Global South.


The paper will take up the case of reservation policy in India. It is a strong form of affirmative action that provides reservation in government services, educational institutes, and legislatures to groups that are socially and economically backward, where the identity of caste has played a critical role. Special socio-historical circumstances have taken India on a social policy path where the decision-making process has been pivotal. By discussing the evolution and decision-making process on reservation policy in India, the paper aims to depict how social policy is designed to target communities based on identity. Decisions on such targeting are politically inherent. Once targeted, there are the repercussions- advantages and disadvantages- of the decision on the larger policy framework.


The paper will emphasise that there is a need to take a clear break from Western thinking. The first part is moving beyond economic rationality and recognising the importance of identity from the perspective of benefactors of the policy. There is also a need to look at the culture of institutionalisation in the Global South. The practice of decision-making in the Global South has not imitated how decisions are made in the Global North. Despite borrowing similar kinds of democratic institutions, the decision-making culture differs. The paper will argue that there are lesser checks and balances to decision-making in the Global South, making it difficult to make sense of the decisions made. What our captive minds see as absurd decisions are rationally taken risks with instrumental goals in mind.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - The Development of the Third Sector and the Welfare State in Iraq: Anti-poverty and Social Service Provision Policies
Ali Hamoudi (American University of Iraq, Baghdad)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

 

Since 2003, Iraq’s policies towards the third sector transformed dramatically from implicitly banning the formation of civil society organisations (CSOs) to arguably encouraging their formation. Simultaneously, major developments in the field of Iraq’s social policies raised fundamental consideration on the state’s role in the provision of social welfare. Both policy shifts are illustrated in the second article of the new permanent constitution titled, “rights and freedoms”.  On the one hand, the state places the responsibility for providing a wide array of welfare services, from housing, to health, to education, to the guarantee of basic livelihood firmly upon itself. On the other hand, the state allows for associations and groups to form and to participate in welfare provision. Though these general ideals have been codified into law, we have little empirical knowledge about the actual development of the third sector in Iraq and its relationship to government social policy. Specifically examining Iraq’s anti-poverty and social service policies, this paper asks how do civil society organizations (CSOs) currently engage in Iraq's anti-poverty and social service provision policies? 

 

Using a detailed literature review of the academic discussion within Iraq and the broader discussion generally, this paper traces the historical development of the third sector in modern Iraq within the greater context of the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region. It examines the factors and conditions following the political transition in 2003 which brought about the mixed economies of welfare.  It discusses the status of the third sector in Iraq and its relationship to Iraq's social policies. Finally, it discusses a future research agenda to better understand how Iraq’s social policies help or hinder the development of a vibrant third sector as a potentially important partner in its current anti-poverty strategies.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Using Comparative Data to Explore Health Policy Decisions made by the Government in Three Low- and Middle-Income Countries In East Asia (Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand)
Iris Po Yee Lo (The Hong Kong Polytechnic University)
CO-AUTHORS
Grace Ho (Hong Kong Polytechnic Univeristy )
Clement Yu (Sheffield Hallam University)
K. C. Franco Ho (University of Sheffield)
ABSTRACT

Authors (adding here only because the online registration system does not allow the entry of the name of the fifth author): Iris Po Yee Lo, Grace Ho, Clement Yu, K. C. Franco Ho, Sam Wai Kam Yu

 

This paper aims to explore important health policy decisions made by low- and middle-income countries concerning health care from a comparative perspective. Our focus is on Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand. We carry out three analytical tasks. The first is to develop a health index covering these three countries. This health index is composed of both input elements (the proportion of private health expenditure to GDP, proportion of private hospital beds to total bed stock, and public health care system coverage) and output elements (the infant mortality rate, life expectancy at birth, and maternal mortality rate). The input elements are intended to show the government’s commitment to the development of health care. Such commitment is manifested in the government’s decisions concerning not only the allocation of financial resources and hospital bed resources to the development of health care but also the proportion of the population served by public health resources. The output elements are intended to show the impacts of these government decisions on people’s health. 

 

The second task is to compare the similarities and differences in the government’s commitment to health care between the three low- and middle-income countries and richer countries/territories in East Asia. To carry out this task, we compare the data drawn from the above-mentioned health index with data drawn from the health index covering four other countries/territories (Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea, and Taiwan). This comparison will be conducted by developing a health care typology using the statistical techniques of cluster analysis.  

 

Using the same research method (cluster analysis for building a health care typology), the third task is to compare the similarities and differences in the government’s commitment to health care between the three low- and middle-income countries and 18 OECD countries (Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland, the UK, and USA). These OECD countries have been studied in Esping-Andersen’s research on the ‘three worlds of welfare capitalism’. 

 

This paper will contribute to the debates on the uniqueness of the ‘three worlds of welfare capitalism’ and the ‘East Asian world of welfare capitalism’. Through the inclusion of Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand into analysis, this paper will not only enhance our understanding of the development of health care in the three low- and middle-income countries from a comparative perspective, but it will also build a dialogue between the studies of low- and middle-income countries and those of the existing worlds of welfare capitalism.

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Process analysis and an indication of policy design elements for implementing and adopting digital health technology, in specific telemedicine in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs)
Christopher Adlung (TPM-Health)
CO-AUTHORS
Saba Hinrichs-Krapels (Delft University of Technology)
ABSTRACT

Aiming to make medical care more accessible to individuals in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), frugal innovation (FI), and digital health technology in the form of telemedicine, can provide a resource-efficient solution. However, its application and maintenance can be challenging for decision- and policymakers. Too little is understood about the implementation and adoption barriers of telemedicine, impacting effective decision-making in policy-design, and the allocation of resources in complex health systems. This can be addressed by analysing the socio-technical and complex multi-actor environment in which telemedicine operates. Considering the uncertain, dynamic, conflicting, and cohesive environment in which digital health technology operates in many LMICs, there is value in examining FI and telemedicine within policy processes. In this paper, we aim to present a conceptual framework for addressing these challenges for LMICs. Our analysis is based on a scoping review of implementation barriers and facilitators of telemedicine in LMICs, complemented by exploring potential policy analysis and implementation frameworks. An interdisciplinary approach will evaluate best practices from various knowledge domains, aiming to overcome these challenges. The conceptual framework will inform a future research plan where we address implementation challenges using telemedicine in Togo as a case study. The aimed results will first identify potential gaps in the decision-making process of the policy design, and second indicate policy design elements, to improve the implementation and adoption of telemedicine in LMICs.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Slaying the Dragon of Corruption: Application of Multiple-Streams Framework in Anticorruption Policy Processes in Devolved Systems of Government in Kenya
Justa Mwangi (University of Sussex)
CO-AUTHORS
Wilson Muna (Kenyatta University)
ABSTRACT

Although John Kingdon’s multiple streams framework has been utilized by scholars to explain public policy processes in the U.S, and western countries, there is little empirical evidence of its applicability in Africa. This paper addresses this knowledge gap by interrogating public policy processes that combat corruption in devolved systems of government in Kenya, through the lenses of John Kingdon’s framework. The paper is the result of an empirical study that interviewed 126 participants and held two focus group discussions involving nine key stakeholders from the counties of Kiambu and Nairobi City, which are two devolved systems of government in Kenya. The paper examines how state, business and civil society are intertwined within the organisational cultures, bureaucratic procedures, information processing, public awareness and county level policy instruments of these two counties. The results illuminate the complex relationships between state, business and civil society within the anticorruption policy making space and demonstrate the extent to which John Kingdon’s theory may be considered appropriate in the analysis of such policy making processes. The findings further reveal complex relationships between the state, business and civil society, as they switch roles from being facilitators (enablers) of anticorruption to accomplices (through convergence of mutual interests) in thwarting anticorruption efforts. The results also discuss several pathways through which Kingdon’s problem, policy and political streams may lead to the creation of policy windows that may be useful in combatting corruption in devolved systems of governments. The paper calls for further research utilizing this conceptual model and the multiple streams framework in Africa.

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - Re-understanding and re-packing the family as a collective socio-economic actor in China
Xinide Xinide (University of York)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

From the familialism and de-familialization thesis (Lister, 1994; Mclaughlin and Glendinning, 1994 ) in the original tripolar typology of welfare regimes (Esping-Andersen, 1999) to the introduction of genderisation and degenderisation (Saxonberg, 2013), within the majority of the comparative social policy literature, the family is often tended to be primarily approached as the provider of care. Also within the East Asian welfare exceptionalism discussion, from ‘Oikonomic welfare states’ (Jones, 1990) highlighting the key role of the family, to the strong conception of the family underlined as the unique and contingent feature of productivist welfare capitalism (Holliday, 2000), the apparently central role of the family playing among the welfare societies in this region are widely recognized (Wilding, 1997; 2000; Walker and Wong, 2005; Papadopoulos and Roumpakis, 2017). However, given that these studies normally isolate the role of the family as an economic actor, this study argues, reconceptualises, and rearticulates the family as a collective socio-economic actor by adopting a new conceptual and analytical framework created by Papadopoulos and Roumpakis (2017), to further re-pack and re-map Chinese families to understand how they as a strategic coordinator consolidate, mobilise and redistribute their welfare and financial resources over time. By analysing the empirical evidence from the China Family Panel Study (CFPS) social survey, it examines Chinese families over time both as an economic actor and welfare provider by manipulating longitudinal data in terms of family assets, family income, family expenditure, family debts and intergenerational supports etc.  In so doing, this study attempts to empirically contribute to the existing literature by adding the financial aspects of the family into the dimension by focusing on the Chinese context, which is a good case to study, thereby extending the cultural and welfare thesis theoretical framework approaching to the family in the existing welfare regime debate. It discovers an elastic interpretation for the connotation of the family in China under the economic actor dimension – a close family notion confined to direct blood ties (such as parents and children) v.s. an extended family notion stretched to non-coresident relatives and even trusted friends. Meanwhile, it contrasts both the Chinese households’ dependence on and independence from their family network by revealing how the family plays as an unstructured subsidy when it comes to capital turnover and how this sometimes turns into ‘giving’ and ‘taking’ rather than ‘borrowing’ and ‘repaying’. To go a step further, this study also brings the ambition to contribute to the understating of the state and the family within the family-related policy process by observing how the emphasis is transferred and balanced between the two dimensions of the family in the country.

ACCEPTED
Format
11 - Where lies the power? The interplay of multiple levels of governance of the AU-EU managed migration cooperation programme
Simon Roberts (University of Nottingham)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The joint AU-EU policy statement recognises that “migration is a shared and common responsibility of countries of origin, transit and destination.” (The Africa-EU Partnership: https://www.africa-eu-partnership.org/en/strategic-priority-areas/migration-and-mobility). An important deliverable from the 5th AU-EU Summit in Abidjan in November 2017 is a Continent-to-Continent dialogue on migration and mobility which was initiated in 2018. The overall joint objective is “to save and protect the lives of people, to offer alternatives to irregular migration and fight its root causes.” (The Africa-EU Partnership). The European Commission’s legal migration pilot project aims to reduce migration to Europe from Africa by investing in infrastructure, job creation and education in African partner countries. The project partners are Morocco, Nigeria, Senegal and Tunisia. This paper, which will be based on documentary analysis and interviews with stakeholders in the participating countries (national and local policy makers, administrators, educators and academics, business community, NGOs, and service users) and at the European Commission, will examine the interplay of multiple levels – EU, national, local – of governance and decision making in the conception, design and delivery of the programme. The theoretical framework will include multilevel governance, and power and social justice in post-colonial relationships between Africa and Europe. The paper will include consideration of whether concepts developed in Europe, such as multilevel governance, can provide a framework to understand governance relationships in Africa and between Africa and Europe.

ACCEPTED
Format
12 - Public policies in the media: the Bolsa Família program in the national and international press
Camila Sales (Universidade Federal de Uberlândia)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper aims to analyze the role of mass media in the policy decision-making process focusing on how the “Bolsa Família” Program (BFP), from Brazil, was reported by Brazilian and international press. Two important media agents were chosen, trying to understand how business and civil society see public policy and how this can influence the decision-making process: Folha de S. Paulo (FSP) and The Economist. BFP was created in 2003 as a conditional cash transfer scheme with three dimensions: income transfer, conditionalities, and complementary actions. In Political Science most studies about the influence of the media on politics cover electoral periods. Normally, long-term analysis and other themes, such as the role of media in the decision-making process, are set aside. However, public representation of collective interests has a direct influence on the focus of public attention and, consequently, on the elaboration and implementation of public policies. The press conforms to limits, emphases, and silences that constitute the public debate, publicizing and editing discursive flows (Marques, 2010; Fonseca, 2011). We hypothesized that approaches to the program vary by newspaper and time. The approaches, in the first spectrum, are linked to discourses on dependence and populism and, on the other hand, correspond to a discourse of emancipation and inclusion. The methodology applied was qualitative content analysis (Bardin, 2007), following the steps of selecting the corpus in the newspapers databases from 2003 to 2019. The result of this was 63 editorials from FSP and 42 articles and editorials from The Economist. The next steps were: the complete reading of texts in two steps, the search and selection of commonly used arguments, and finally the categorization of them. The key findings about FSP can be summarized as it is slow to consider BSP as an important editorial agenda. The first editorial appears only in 2009. In the beginning, dominates the understanding that it is an assistant and paternalistic policy with electoral bias. The effectiveness and importance of the program began to be highlighted in 2011. It has since then been described as important in reducing inequality. Moreover, the budget discussion was almost constant. At The Economist the importance of the program to reduce poverty and inequality was highlighted from the outset. The program is also often used by the newspaper as an example and source of inspiration for other countries. It is also raised as an important part of the electoral debate, but on a different basis from those brought by FSP. The Economist deals with budget issues too but is more focused on the costs and scope of the program itself. It is possible to say that the Brazilian press, unlike the British, mobilized the idea that “Bolsa Família” beneficiaries biased their vote. In common, the newspapers report that the program was successful and important for reducing poverty and inequality. It is relevant to note how the debate about costs, budget, and scope are part of both coverages. In this sense, the emancipatory and inclusive character of the program is predominant in both newspapers even though the assistant and electoral bias were raised, mainly by Folha de S. Paulo.

ACCEPTED
Format
13 - Evidence-Based Decision-Making in India: Influencing the Policy Process through Evidence
Yashas P R (Christ University)
CO-AUTHORS
PRERNA YADAV (Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay)
ABSTRACT

There is an increased emphasis on data collection and assimilation in order to provide evidence for informed decision-making to resolve identified problems. While evidence-based decision-making has largely been used in the field of STEM, its importance is increasingly recognised for decision-making in public policy field as well. Identification of a problem as a policy problem involves the presence of multiple stakeholders with divergent perspectives and conflicting interests making it a value-laden process. Once a problem has been identified as a policy problem, different stakeholders work towards the decision-making process. In India, the stakeholders which have determined the decision-making belong to the state, business, and civil society. These three stakeholders have largely been responsible for policy making in varying capacity. With evidence-based decision-making, an attempt is being made to make the policy process more transparent and rationalize the decision-making. The problem with this approach to decision-making in a setting like India is that the evidence is the result of value-laden choices made by the stakeholders and these choices are mostly to further their interests. This paper discusses the problems with evidence-based decision-making with two case studies from India. The first case study discusses the water policy of the country which has failed to address the issues of inequity, and environmental degradation despite the data pertaining to these issues. It is found that the government, business and non-government stakeholders with the neoliberal paradigm which classifies water as an economic resource and its use to maximize profits are able to push forth their agendas in the decision-making as opposed to others. The second case study discusses the media policy wherein the government, business and non-government stakeholders with similar vested interests have been able to influence the policy to further their interests.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
14 - Cultural Policies and Policies with Culture: Assessing Policy Decision-Making in Saint Lucia
Jenna Koumantaros (Toronto Metropolitan University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

At first glance, economic public policy development in the Caribbean Island of Saint Lucia may appear to employ positivist rational models of decision-making. As a middle-income country, Saint Lucia’s economy is highly dependent on foreign capital from sectors such as tourism, export and investment. However, due to the COVID19 pandemic halting tourism and rising inflation, Saint Lucia has recently had to implement more policies with the goal of stimulating its national economy. This includes the amendment of the Citizenship by Investment Programme among other fiscal policies. With its focus strictly on national development via economic recovery, one could assume that Saint Lucia’s decision-making regarding economic public policy mirrors the formula used by its high-income counterparts where capital accumulation is the goal and conducting economic cost-benefit analyses and evidence-based policy making will determine if the chosen policy will be the best means for achieving that end.

This, however, does little to accurately conceptualize the extent to which culture impacts public policy decision-making processes in Saint Lucia. As a result, this paper aims to fill in this gap by illustrating how culture is one of the main determinates of public policy decision-making in Saint Lucia by focusing on the area of economic policies specifically. This paper will use a case study research design and collect qualitative data from government policies and documents. It will adopt Botterill and Fenna’s (2019) political values perspective on decision-making theory by conducting a post-positivist argumentative discourse analysis of the language used within the policies and documents to demonstrate how and to what extent cultural considerations influence economic policy decisions. It will examine the language of the National Cultural Policy of Saint Lucia (2000), how ‘culture’ is defined and the definition’s impact on subsequent economic policies including the Citizenship by Investment Programme and policies regarding Saint Lucia’s recent shift to an Orange/Creative Economy.

This study advances an argument that is two-fold: that although capital accumulation is important, culture is the appropriate gauge with which to assess public policy decision-making in Saint Lucia as culture, both implicitly and explicitly, is interwoven into all economic policy decisions, and, therefore, adherence to traditional theories of public policy will skew research findings to favour high-income countries’ decision-making models by failing to account for the non-monetary, value-laden motivation behind economic policy decisions that influence middle-income countries such as Saint Lucia.

The landscape of existing literature on the topic of public policy decision-making in the Caribbean is particularly scarce, with even less dedicated to Saint Lucia specifically. Additionally, there is a plethora of literature that addresses the prominent debate between rational and argumentative policy theories. Though these perspectives are valuable for shaping the overall understanding of public policy decision-making, the approaches employed by either side of the debate fall short of effectively conceptualizing culture as a political value outside of the Canadian or American perspective. As such, this study aims to contribute to the scholarship of public policy theory by exemplifying decision-making through a country, culture and perspective rarely accounted for in the literature.

ACCEPTED
Format
15 - The shift away from coal-based power in India: Understanding policy processes and agendas
Pooja Ramamurthi
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Effectively tackling climate change requires countries to decarbonize their power sectors, particularly moving away from coal-fired power plants. Energy transitions require a fundamental disruption of political and institutional mechanisms that enable present carbon lock-ins. To understand what enables or constrains an energy transition policy, it becomes important to identify the policy processes, their networks and the goals that they prioritize within the sector. Theoretical and empirical understanding of policy networks and institutional arrangements governing energy transitions tend to be dominated by evidence from industrialized countries.

   The dominant lens to understand environmental related policy processes have been explained through a coalition lens, particularly the advocacy coalition framework (ACF). Under ACF, actors with similar beliefs align within subsystems to advocate policies, often against competing other interests. Further, the role of non-governmental and international organisations is often highlighted in enabling policy change in the environmental sector. Using the case study of the Indian power policy subsystem, I ask whether the existing ways of understanding  policy processes can be extended to Indian context and if not, what policy process is the most applicable? 

     I apply free recall to conduct primary network surveys of the interaction and influence of elite policy actors in the Indian electricity subsystem. I survey actors’ beliefs and perceptions about the continued use of coal-based power and the goals of the Indian power sector. Results show no clustering of actors with similar beliefs and actors within the network couldn’t accurately perceive how strongly others support the continued use of coal-based power. Further, sectoral beliefs around coal transitions were uniform, with no groups opposing beliefs present in the network. Through my analysis, I show that a coalition framework may not be the right policy process that drives renewable policy in India. 

   Rather, I find an extremely centralised network structure with government organisations ( Ministry of Power) and business conglomerates showing the highest centrality. This may indicate that policy is driven by state-directed development with civil society playing a peripheral role in guiding the government to carry outs its agenda. Publicly and privately-owned companies work hand-in-hand with sub-national governments to implement “top-down” national government policy directives. 

    Affordability, access and reliability of electricity supply remain priorities for the Indian power sector. However, actors do prioritize decarbonization and sustainability as well. The results indicate that in India, that when the goal of decarbonization aligns with national priorities in the energy sector, there is a dedicated state-directed push towards an energy transition.

ACCEPTED
Format
16 - The challenges of establishing a robust policy on human trafficking: The case study of Zimbabwe.
Roda Madziva (University of Nottingham)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The global prevalence of human trafficking has resulted in the critical need for concerted efforts to eradicate the scourge by 2030 as highlighted by the UN Sustainable Development Agenda SDG 8.7 thereby making it a significant development issue requiring governments’ attention. At the international level, the legal framework for addressing human trafficking is primarily constructed by the United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime through one of its protocols: The Protocol to Prevent, Suppress, and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children (hereafter referred to as the Palermo Protocol). Individual government legislation draws from this legal document, with each government making its own specific provisions in accordance with the local situation and needs.

This presentation focuses on Zimbabwe, a Southern African country that is known as a source, transit and destination country for people subjected to various forms of exploitation that are associated with human trafficking. Zimbabwe ratified the Convention on Transnational Organised Crime (TOC) in 2007 and proceeded to domesticate the Palermo Protocol through the enactment of the Trafficking in Persons Act in 2014. However, according to a recent USA Trafficking in Persons Report which ranks governments based on their perceived efforts to combat human trafficking, Zimbabwe does not fully comply with the international standards for elimination of human trafficking.  

In this presentation we will discuss the findings from a two-year ESRC-GCRF funded project entitled “Combating Human Trafficking: The role of Non-Governmental Organisations (NGOs) in the fight against human trafficking in Zimbabwe”. The project sought to map the human trafficking phenomenon in Zimbabwe and involved working in partnership with three NGOs, including carrying out secondary analysis of the human trafficking data that these partner organisations held. The research has also benefited from workshops with different stakeholders involved in anti-trafficking work, survivors of human trafficking and parliamentarians as a step towards establishing a strong evidence-base with the hope to influence policy. Findings reveal a complex interaction of socio-economic, political, structural and cultural factors and how this complicates the development of anti-trafficking policies that criminalize all forms of trafficking and even the establishment of community structures and multi-stakeholder partnerships that are sustainable for an effective response to human trafficking in Zimbabwe. We will end the presentation by discussing how the Zimbabwe situation mirrors the challenges in other African countries.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

State building has been an intricate task African states that experienced conflict must grapple with since the era of decolonization. This continues to be the case in South Sudan that was born in July 2011 following a prolonged civil war. Although the world’s newest nation problem emanates from the policy of SPLM-led regime towards social forces, South Sudan’s success or failure in state building has largely been explained in relations to inexperienced personnel and weak institutions. Post-conflict state building mainly includes the state’s policy and action involving social forces that work side-by-side or contradicting state actors. This article explores South Sudan’s state building from the perspective of the state’s policy towards social forces. It uncovers the legal and institutional obstacles that have impacted on the state and role of civil society, political parties, and ethnic relations in South Sudan’s state building. The finding shows that CSOs working on service delivery appear to have contributed a lot in filling the gap in state institutions. However, generally, CSOs in South Sudan are weak to impact significantly on the multi-faceted state building challenges. This is mainly because of the dominance of interest driven INGOs, dependency syndrome, financial and capacity limitations among national and local CSOs, their growing partisanship, and restrictive government measures. Dominated by increasingly fragmented and militarized political groups under the SPLM party state, competitive party politics is non-existent in South Sudan. Ethnic division and violence due to an inherited social structure and SPLM’s exclusionary practices have also negatively affected South Sudan’s state building process.

 

Keywords: State building, public policy, social forces, civil society, political parties, ethnicity, South Sudan

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The gulf between theory, concept, policy, and outcome about poverty eradication in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) remains wide, congested, and contentious, witnessing many prescriptions, diverse successes, and an even wider scholarship. This study aims at creating an understanding of civil society’s integral role in poverty eradication in Sub-Saharan Africa through its participation in public policy. The study begins by discussing the poverty situation in the continent and continues to describe how markets and government have dominated this domain, critically analyzing both market-based structural and government-based institutional reform interventions in the quest for poverty eradication. In this aspect, political systems, institutions, and economic policies are analyzed considering their successes in addressing poverty. The study introduces and demonstrates civil society and its participation in public policy as a critical factor that enhances pro-poor policies and poverty reduction.

While civil society participation in public policy processes and its effect on poverty eradication remains an amorphous phenomenon in many existing debates and literature, I argue that it is indeed the missing link in the fight against poverty in the continent. In an attempt at a formal explanatory analysis of the role of civil society in pro-poor policies, the study discusses mechanisms that sustain the causal relationship between civil society and pro-poor policies. Through a multiple comparative panel regression analysis of 43 African countries between 2000 and 2020, results show that by interacting civil society participation in public policy with institutional factors namely public administration, local government, and democracy, countries experienced reduced out-of-pocket health expenditure per capita, one of the leading causes of household poverty in SSA. This demonstrates how civil society participation in public policy is instrumental and strategic for pro-poor policies; the increase in attaining increased pro-poor policy outcomes may only be accounted for in terms of enhanced civil society participation in public policy. The study discusses the empirical evidence needed to establish the indispensability of and desire to support civil society and institutionalize civil society participatory processes in public policy for the effective and efficient eradication of poverty in Sub-Saharan Africa. The future of poverty eradication and participatory democracy in Sub-Saharan Africa is tied to the ability to expand civil society participation in public policy.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Nigeria has the eleventh highest incidence of early marriage – marriage before the age of 18 – in the world. This is problematic because early marriage has been shown to have significant health and socioeconomic disadvantages for girls. In 2003, the Child Rights Act (CRA) was adopted by the federal government of Nigeria. One of its provisions was a prohibition of early marriage. As of 2022, 25 of Nigeria’s 36 states had adopted the CRA. However, only 23 adopted its minimum marriageable age provision without exception. This paper discusses the factors affecting the adoption of the CRA’s minimum marriageable age policy, arguing that although religion provides a legitimate perspective on adoption decisions, women policy actors have also played a significant role. This paper therefore both presents a more comprehensive approach to understanding this policy process and provides support for the presence and participation of women in policymaking as an effective approach to the problem of early marriage.

CO-AUTHORS
Panu Suppatkul (Khon Kaen University)
Thanapauge Chamaratana (Khon Kaen University)
ABSTRACT

   This study is based on the shortcomings we observed in Thailand’s state welfare scheme in four rural and urban areas of Thai villages in Khon Kaen province through a mixed methods approach. This study asks two simple questions: how does the state government influence the state welfare scheme? and what are the pitfalls of the state welfare scheme? The Thai government has attempted to reduce poverty in the country by providing social welfare scheme known as “the poor card (state welfare card)” to those unable to meet their basic needs across the nation. Problems arose, however, when the government was unable to precisely identify those who were desperately poor and in need of assistance within the recruitment system, placing the greatest strain on the government's limited budget to allocate resources to non-target groups. Practically, the extremely poor are powerless because their voices are never heard in the public sphere and they are not involved in policy decision-making; consequently, they are subject to neglect and abuse, which is an indication of poor state governance.                             

     The findings of this study indicate that central government agencies have formulated and made decisions regarding the state welfare scheme. In addition, the state welfare scheme is administered and managed by the central government via provincial administration assigned to provincial offices or districts. This state welfare scheme has evolved into a political campaign to mobilize government supporters for voting, rather than a nationwide effort to eradicate poverty, resulting in an increase in the number of poor people. Consequently, one lesson to be learned from the pitfalls of the state welfare scheme is that an effective policy to reduce poverty requires good governance practices, such as accountability, transparency, and public participation. In particular, the state government must delegate authority to local administrative organizations to alleviate poverty within their jurisdictions, as well as engage other sectors, such as civil society, in the policy formulation, decision-making, and monitoring processes.

CO-AUTHORS
Sony Pellissery (National Law School of India University)
ABSTRACT

‘It is economy, stupid’, a phrase that found popularity in the US elections in 1992 holds true for public policy theories too. The literature on public policy has kept economics and economic rationality at the centre of all decision-making. The paper aims to show how the explanation has numerous flaws in the Indian context, and a better understanding can be gained if the phrase is changed to ‘It is identity. stupid’. The scholarly work on policy decision-making in the Global North has failed to comprehend the decision-making in the Global South. The paper will depict through a case study in India why theories that are used to explain or predict the process from agenda setting to decision making such as the advocacy coalitions, punctuated equilibrium, the policy window, etc. will find it difficult to explain the decision-making in the Global South.


The paper will argue that to analyse the policies in the Global South, there is a need to look beyond the captive mindset. Captive mind is a concept that says that an uncritical acceptance of all constituents of scientific activity of the West will not help the scholarly work in the Global South. It denotes a hierarchical ordering of knowledge and the impossibility of creating a knowledge system relevant to one. The paper will show why there is a need for an independent theoretical, analytical, and empirical perspective to better analyse policy decision-making in the Global South.


The paper will take up the case of reservation policy in India. It is a strong form of affirmative action that provides reservation in government services, educational institutes, and legislatures to groups that are socially and economically backward, where the identity of caste has played a critical role. Special socio-historical circumstances have taken India on a social policy path where the decision-making process has been pivotal. By discussing the evolution and decision-making process on reservation policy in India, the paper aims to depict how social policy is designed to target communities based on identity. Decisions on such targeting are politically inherent. Once targeted, there are the repercussions- advantages and disadvantages- of the decision on the larger policy framework.


The paper will emphasise that there is a need to take a clear break from Western thinking. The first part is moving beyond economic rationality and recognising the importance of identity from the perspective of benefactors of the policy. There is also a need to look at the culture of institutionalisation in the Global South. The practice of decision-making in the Global South has not imitated how decisions are made in the Global North. Despite borrowing similar kinds of democratic institutions, the decision-making culture differs. The paper will argue that there are lesser checks and balances to decision-making in the Global South, making it difficult to make sense of the decisions made. What our captive minds see as absurd decisions are rationally taken risks with instrumental goals in mind.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

 

Since 2003, Iraq’s policies towards the third sector transformed dramatically from implicitly banning the formation of civil society organisations (CSOs) to arguably encouraging their formation. Simultaneously, major developments in the field of Iraq’s social policies raised fundamental consideration on the state’s role in the provision of social welfare. Both policy shifts are illustrated in the second article of the new permanent constitution titled, “rights and freedoms”.  On the one hand, the state places the responsibility for providing a wide array of welfare services, from housing, to health, to education, to the guarantee of basic livelihood firmly upon itself. On the other hand, the state allows for associations and groups to form and to participate in welfare provision. Though these general ideals have been codified into law, we have little empirical knowledge about the actual development of the third sector in Iraq and its relationship to government social policy. Specifically examining Iraq’s anti-poverty and social service policies, this paper asks how do civil society organizations (CSOs) currently engage in Iraq's anti-poverty and social service provision policies? 

 

Using a detailed literature review of the academic discussion within Iraq and the broader discussion generally, this paper traces the historical development of the third sector in modern Iraq within the greater context of the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region. It examines the factors and conditions following the political transition in 2003 which brought about the mixed economies of welfare.  It discusses the status of the third sector in Iraq and its relationship to Iraq's social policies. Finally, it discusses a future research agenda to better understand how Iraq’s social policies help or hinder the development of a vibrant third sector as a potentially important partner in its current anti-poverty strategies.

 

CO-AUTHORS
Grace Ho (Hong Kong Polytechnic Univeristy )
Clement Yu (Sheffield Hallam University)
K. C. Franco Ho (University of Sheffield)
ABSTRACT

Authors (adding here only because the online registration system does not allow the entry of the name of the fifth author): Iris Po Yee Lo, Grace Ho, Clement Yu, K. C. Franco Ho, Sam Wai Kam Yu

 

This paper aims to explore important health policy decisions made by low- and middle-income countries concerning health care from a comparative perspective. Our focus is on Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand. We carry out three analytical tasks. The first is to develop a health index covering these three countries. This health index is composed of both input elements (the proportion of private health expenditure to GDP, proportion of private hospital beds to total bed stock, and public health care system coverage) and output elements (the infant mortality rate, life expectancy at birth, and maternal mortality rate). The input elements are intended to show the government’s commitment to the development of health care. Such commitment is manifested in the government’s decisions concerning not only the allocation of financial resources and hospital bed resources to the development of health care but also the proportion of the population served by public health resources. The output elements are intended to show the impacts of these government decisions on people’s health. 

 

The second task is to compare the similarities and differences in the government’s commitment to health care between the three low- and middle-income countries and richer countries/territories in East Asia. To carry out this task, we compare the data drawn from the above-mentioned health index with data drawn from the health index covering four other countries/territories (Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea, and Taiwan). This comparison will be conducted by developing a health care typology using the statistical techniques of cluster analysis.  

 

Using the same research method (cluster analysis for building a health care typology), the third task is to compare the similarities and differences in the government’s commitment to health care between the three low- and middle-income countries and 18 OECD countries (Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland, the UK, and USA). These OECD countries have been studied in Esping-Andersen’s research on the ‘three worlds of welfare capitalism’. 

 

This paper will contribute to the debates on the uniqueness of the ‘three worlds of welfare capitalism’ and the ‘East Asian world of welfare capitalism’. Through the inclusion of Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand into analysis, this paper will not only enhance our understanding of the development of health care in the three low- and middle-income countries from a comparative perspective, but it will also build a dialogue between the studies of low- and middle-income countries and those of the existing worlds of welfare capitalism.

CO-AUTHORS
Saba Hinrichs-Krapels (Delft University of Technology)
ABSTRACT

Aiming to make medical care more accessible to individuals in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), frugal innovation (FI), and digital health technology in the form of telemedicine, can provide a resource-efficient solution. However, its application and maintenance can be challenging for decision- and policymakers. Too little is understood about the implementation and adoption barriers of telemedicine, impacting effective decision-making in policy-design, and the allocation of resources in complex health systems. This can be addressed by analysing the socio-technical and complex multi-actor environment in which telemedicine operates. Considering the uncertain, dynamic, conflicting, and cohesive environment in which digital health technology operates in many LMICs, there is value in examining FI and telemedicine within policy processes. In this paper, we aim to present a conceptual framework for addressing these challenges for LMICs. Our analysis is based on a scoping review of implementation barriers and facilitators of telemedicine in LMICs, complemented by exploring potential policy analysis and implementation frameworks. An interdisciplinary approach will evaluate best practices from various knowledge domains, aiming to overcome these challenges. The conceptual framework will inform a future research plan where we address implementation challenges using telemedicine in Togo as a case study. The aimed results will first identify potential gaps in the decision-making process of the policy design, and second indicate policy design elements, to improve the implementation and adoption of telemedicine in LMICs.

CO-AUTHORS
Wilson Muna (Kenyatta University)
ABSTRACT

Although John Kingdon’s multiple streams framework has been utilized by scholars to explain public policy processes in the U.S, and western countries, there is little empirical evidence of its applicability in Africa. This paper addresses this knowledge gap by interrogating public policy processes that combat corruption in devolved systems of government in Kenya, through the lenses of John Kingdon’s framework. The paper is the result of an empirical study that interviewed 126 participants and held two focus group discussions involving nine key stakeholders from the counties of Kiambu and Nairobi City, which are two devolved systems of government in Kenya. The paper examines how state, business and civil society are intertwined within the organisational cultures, bureaucratic procedures, information processing, public awareness and county level policy instruments of these two counties. The results illuminate the complex relationships between state, business and civil society within the anticorruption policy making space and demonstrate the extent to which John Kingdon’s theory may be considered appropriate in the analysis of such policy making processes. The findings further reveal complex relationships between the state, business and civil society, as they switch roles from being facilitators (enablers) of anticorruption to accomplices (through convergence of mutual interests) in thwarting anticorruption efforts. The results also discuss several pathways through which Kingdon’s problem, policy and political streams may lead to the creation of policy windows that may be useful in combatting corruption in devolved systems of governments. The paper calls for further research utilizing this conceptual model and the multiple streams framework in Africa.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

From the familialism and de-familialization thesis (Lister, 1994; Mclaughlin and Glendinning, 1994 ) in the original tripolar typology of welfare regimes (Esping-Andersen, 1999) to the introduction of genderisation and degenderisation (Saxonberg, 2013), within the majority of the comparative social policy literature, the family is often tended to be primarily approached as the provider of care. Also within the East Asian welfare exceptionalism discussion, from ‘Oikonomic welfare states’ (Jones, 1990) highlighting the key role of the family, to the strong conception of the family underlined as the unique and contingent feature of productivist welfare capitalism (Holliday, 2000), the apparently central role of the family playing among the welfare societies in this region are widely recognized (Wilding, 1997; 2000; Walker and Wong, 2005; Papadopoulos and Roumpakis, 2017). However, given that these studies normally isolate the role of the family as an economic actor, this study argues, reconceptualises, and rearticulates the family as a collective socio-economic actor by adopting a new conceptual and analytical framework created by Papadopoulos and Roumpakis (2017), to further re-pack and re-map Chinese families to understand how they as a strategic coordinator consolidate, mobilise and redistribute their welfare and financial resources over time. By analysing the empirical evidence from the China Family Panel Study (CFPS) social survey, it examines Chinese families over time both as an economic actor and welfare provider by manipulating longitudinal data in terms of family assets, family income, family expenditure, family debts and intergenerational supports etc.  In so doing, this study attempts to empirically contribute to the existing literature by adding the financial aspects of the family into the dimension by focusing on the Chinese context, which is a good case to study, thereby extending the cultural and welfare thesis theoretical framework approaching to the family in the existing welfare regime debate. It discovers an elastic interpretation for the connotation of the family in China under the economic actor dimension – a close family notion confined to direct blood ties (such as parents and children) v.s. an extended family notion stretched to non-coresident relatives and even trusted friends. Meanwhile, it contrasts both the Chinese households’ dependence on and independence from their family network by revealing how the family plays as an unstructured subsidy when it comes to capital turnover and how this sometimes turns into ‘giving’ and ‘taking’ rather than ‘borrowing’ and ‘repaying’. To go a step further, this study also brings the ambition to contribute to the understating of the state and the family within the family-related policy process by observing how the emphasis is transferred and balanced between the two dimensions of the family in the country.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The joint AU-EU policy statement recognises that “migration is a shared and common responsibility of countries of origin, transit and destination.” (The Africa-EU Partnership: https://www.africa-eu-partnership.org/en/strategic-priority-areas/migration-and-mobility). An important deliverable from the 5th AU-EU Summit in Abidjan in November 2017 is a Continent-to-Continent dialogue on migration and mobility which was initiated in 2018. The overall joint objective is “to save and protect the lives of people, to offer alternatives to irregular migration and fight its root causes.” (The Africa-EU Partnership). The European Commission’s legal migration pilot project aims to reduce migration to Europe from Africa by investing in infrastructure, job creation and education in African partner countries. The project partners are Morocco, Nigeria, Senegal and Tunisia. This paper, which will be based on documentary analysis and interviews with stakeholders in the participating countries (national and local policy makers, administrators, educators and academics, business community, NGOs, and service users) and at the European Commission, will examine the interplay of multiple levels – EU, national, local – of governance and decision making in the conception, design and delivery of the programme. The theoretical framework will include multilevel governance, and power and social justice in post-colonial relationships between Africa and Europe. The paper will include consideration of whether concepts developed in Europe, such as multilevel governance, can provide a framework to understand governance relationships in Africa and between Africa and Europe.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper aims to analyze the role of mass media in the policy decision-making process focusing on how the “Bolsa Família” Program (BFP), from Brazil, was reported by Brazilian and international press. Two important media agents were chosen, trying to understand how business and civil society see public policy and how this can influence the decision-making process: Folha de S. Paulo (FSP) and The Economist. BFP was created in 2003 as a conditional cash transfer scheme with three dimensions: income transfer, conditionalities, and complementary actions. In Political Science most studies about the influence of the media on politics cover electoral periods. Normally, long-term analysis and other themes, such as the role of media in the decision-making process, are set aside. However, public representation of collective interests has a direct influence on the focus of public attention and, consequently, on the elaboration and implementation of public policies. The press conforms to limits, emphases, and silences that constitute the public debate, publicizing and editing discursive flows (Marques, 2010; Fonseca, 2011). We hypothesized that approaches to the program vary by newspaper and time. The approaches, in the first spectrum, are linked to discourses on dependence and populism and, on the other hand, correspond to a discourse of emancipation and inclusion. The methodology applied was qualitative content analysis (Bardin, 2007), following the steps of selecting the corpus in the newspapers databases from 2003 to 2019. The result of this was 63 editorials from FSP and 42 articles and editorials from The Economist. The next steps were: the complete reading of texts in two steps, the search and selection of commonly used arguments, and finally the categorization of them. The key findings about FSP can be summarized as it is slow to consider BSP as an important editorial agenda. The first editorial appears only in 2009. In the beginning, dominates the understanding that it is an assistant and paternalistic policy with electoral bias. The effectiveness and importance of the program began to be highlighted in 2011. It has since then been described as important in reducing inequality. Moreover, the budget discussion was almost constant. At The Economist the importance of the program to reduce poverty and inequality was highlighted from the outset. The program is also often used by the newspaper as an example and source of inspiration for other countries. It is also raised as an important part of the electoral debate, but on a different basis from those brought by FSP. The Economist deals with budget issues too but is more focused on the costs and scope of the program itself. It is possible to say that the Brazilian press, unlike the British, mobilized the idea that “Bolsa Família” beneficiaries biased their vote. In common, the newspapers report that the program was successful and important for reducing poverty and inequality. It is relevant to note how the debate about costs, budget, and scope are part of both coverages. In this sense, the emancipatory and inclusive character of the program is predominant in both newspapers even though the assistant and electoral bias were raised, mainly by Folha de S. Paulo.

CO-AUTHORS
PRERNA YADAV (Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay)
ABSTRACT

There is an increased emphasis on data collection and assimilation in order to provide evidence for informed decision-making to resolve identified problems. While evidence-based decision-making has largely been used in the field of STEM, its importance is increasingly recognised for decision-making in public policy field as well. Identification of a problem as a policy problem involves the presence of multiple stakeholders with divergent perspectives and conflicting interests making it a value-laden process. Once a problem has been identified as a policy problem, different stakeholders work towards the decision-making process. In India, the stakeholders which have determined the decision-making belong to the state, business, and civil society. These three stakeholders have largely been responsible for policy making in varying capacity. With evidence-based decision-making, an attempt is being made to make the policy process more transparent and rationalize the decision-making. The problem with this approach to decision-making in a setting like India is that the evidence is the result of value-laden choices made by the stakeholders and these choices are mostly to further their interests. This paper discusses the problems with evidence-based decision-making with two case studies from India. The first case study discusses the water policy of the country which has failed to address the issues of inequity, and environmental degradation despite the data pertaining to these issues. It is found that the government, business and non-government stakeholders with the neoliberal paradigm which classifies water as an economic resource and its use to maximize profits are able to push forth their agendas in the decision-making as opposed to others. The second case study discusses the media policy wherein the government, business and non-government stakeholders with similar vested interests have been able to influence the policy to further their interests.

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

At first glance, economic public policy development in the Caribbean Island of Saint Lucia may appear to employ positivist rational models of decision-making. As a middle-income country, Saint Lucia’s economy is highly dependent on foreign capital from sectors such as tourism, export and investment. However, due to the COVID19 pandemic halting tourism and rising inflation, Saint Lucia has recently had to implement more policies with the goal of stimulating its national economy. This includes the amendment of the Citizenship by Investment Programme among other fiscal policies. With its focus strictly on national development via economic recovery, one could assume that Saint Lucia’s decision-making regarding economic public policy mirrors the formula used by its high-income counterparts where capital accumulation is the goal and conducting economic cost-benefit analyses and evidence-based policy making will determine if the chosen policy will be the best means for achieving that end.

This, however, does little to accurately conceptualize the extent to which culture impacts public policy decision-making processes in Saint Lucia. As a result, this paper aims to fill in this gap by illustrating how culture is one of the main determinates of public policy decision-making in Saint Lucia by focusing on the area of economic policies specifically. This paper will use a case study research design and collect qualitative data from government policies and documents. It will adopt Botterill and Fenna’s (2019) political values perspective on decision-making theory by conducting a post-positivist argumentative discourse analysis of the language used within the policies and documents to demonstrate how and to what extent cultural considerations influence economic policy decisions. It will examine the language of the National Cultural Policy of Saint Lucia (2000), how ‘culture’ is defined and the definition’s impact on subsequent economic policies including the Citizenship by Investment Programme and policies regarding Saint Lucia’s recent shift to an Orange/Creative Economy.

This study advances an argument that is two-fold: that although capital accumulation is important, culture is the appropriate gauge with which to assess public policy decision-making in Saint Lucia as culture, both implicitly and explicitly, is interwoven into all economic policy decisions, and, therefore, adherence to traditional theories of public policy will skew research findings to favour high-income countries’ decision-making models by failing to account for the non-monetary, value-laden motivation behind economic policy decisions that influence middle-income countries such as Saint Lucia.

The landscape of existing literature on the topic of public policy decision-making in the Caribbean is particularly scarce, with even less dedicated to Saint Lucia specifically. Additionally, there is a plethora of literature that addresses the prominent debate between rational and argumentative policy theories. Though these perspectives are valuable for shaping the overall understanding of public policy decision-making, the approaches employed by either side of the debate fall short of effectively conceptualizing culture as a political value outside of the Canadian or American perspective. As such, this study aims to contribute to the scholarship of public policy theory by exemplifying decision-making through a country, culture and perspective rarely accounted for in the literature.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Effectively tackling climate change requires countries to decarbonize their power sectors, particularly moving away from coal-fired power plants. Energy transitions require a fundamental disruption of political and institutional mechanisms that enable present carbon lock-ins. To understand what enables or constrains an energy transition policy, it becomes important to identify the policy processes, their networks and the goals that they prioritize within the sector. Theoretical and empirical understanding of policy networks and institutional arrangements governing energy transitions tend to be dominated by evidence from industrialized countries.

   The dominant lens to understand environmental related policy processes have been explained through a coalition lens, particularly the advocacy coalition framework (ACF). Under ACF, actors with similar beliefs align within subsystems to advocate policies, often against competing other interests. Further, the role of non-governmental and international organisations is often highlighted in enabling policy change in the environmental sector. Using the case study of the Indian power policy subsystem, I ask whether the existing ways of understanding  policy processes can be extended to Indian context and if not, what policy process is the most applicable? 

     I apply free recall to conduct primary network surveys of the interaction and influence of elite policy actors in the Indian electricity subsystem. I survey actors’ beliefs and perceptions about the continued use of coal-based power and the goals of the Indian power sector. Results show no clustering of actors with similar beliefs and actors within the network couldn’t accurately perceive how strongly others support the continued use of coal-based power. Further, sectoral beliefs around coal transitions were uniform, with no groups opposing beliefs present in the network. Through my analysis, I show that a coalition framework may not be the right policy process that drives renewable policy in India. 

   Rather, I find an extremely centralised network structure with government organisations ( Ministry of Power) and business conglomerates showing the highest centrality. This may indicate that policy is driven by state-directed development with civil society playing a peripheral role in guiding the government to carry outs its agenda. Publicly and privately-owned companies work hand-in-hand with sub-national governments to implement “top-down” national government policy directives. 

    Affordability, access and reliability of electricity supply remain priorities for the Indian power sector. However, actors do prioritize decarbonization and sustainability as well. The results indicate that in India, that when the goal of decarbonization aligns with national priorities in the energy sector, there is a dedicated state-directed push towards an energy transition.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The global prevalence of human trafficking has resulted in the critical need for concerted efforts to eradicate the scourge by 2030 as highlighted by the UN Sustainable Development Agenda SDG 8.7 thereby making it a significant development issue requiring governments’ attention. At the international level, the legal framework for addressing human trafficking is primarily constructed by the United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime through one of its protocols: The Protocol to Prevent, Suppress, and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children (hereafter referred to as the Palermo Protocol). Individual government legislation draws from this legal document, with each government making its own specific provisions in accordance with the local situation and needs.

This presentation focuses on Zimbabwe, a Southern African country that is known as a source, transit and destination country for people subjected to various forms of exploitation that are associated with human trafficking. Zimbabwe ratified the Convention on Transnational Organised Crime (TOC) in 2007 and proceeded to domesticate the Palermo Protocol through the enactment of the Trafficking in Persons Act in 2014. However, according to a recent USA Trafficking in Persons Report which ranks governments based on their perceived efforts to combat human trafficking, Zimbabwe does not fully comply with the international standards for elimination of human trafficking.  

In this presentation we will discuss the findings from a two-year ESRC-GCRF funded project entitled “Combating Human Trafficking: The role of Non-Governmental Organisations (NGOs) in the fight against human trafficking in Zimbabwe”. The project sought to map the human trafficking phenomenon in Zimbabwe and involved working in partnership with three NGOs, including carrying out secondary analysis of the human trafficking data that these partner organisations held. The research has also benefited from workshops with different stakeholders involved in anti-trafficking work, survivors of human trafficking and parliamentarians as a step towards establishing a strong evidence-base with the hope to influence policy. Findings reveal a complex interaction of socio-economic, political, structural and cultural factors and how this complicates the development of anti-trafficking policies that criminalize all forms of trafficking and even the establishment of community structures and multi-stakeholder partnerships that are sustainable for an effective response to human trafficking in Zimbabwe. We will end the presentation by discussing how the Zimbabwe situation mirrors the challenges in other African countries.