Format

P14. The “public-void policy”: how systemic corruption affects the policy process, and how theories could accommodate it

POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Oliver Meza
Tecnologico de Monterrey
Main chair
Irma del Carmen Guerra Osorno
Universidad Veracruzana
Second chair
Miguel Guajardo
El Colegio Mexiquense
Third chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

The “public-void policy”: how systemic corruption affects the policy process, and how theories could accommodate it.

 

Oliver Meza, Elizabeth Perez-Chiques, Irma Guerra, Miguel Guajardo

 

Policy process theories have clearly addressed the many factors involved in the policy process. From an agent-driven perspective, politics is widely studied through the actions of interest groups and advocacy coalitions (e.g., Sabatier & Jenkins-Smith, 1988, 1993; Weible, 2007), bureaucracies at many levels, including street-level and front-line officials (e.g., Lipsky, 1980, 2010; Brodkin, 2003, 2011), parties (e.g., Schmidt, 1996), politicians (e.g., Arnold, 1990; Kingdon, 1993) and office incumbents (e.g., Svara, 2006). Policy processes have also been explained through other more intangible factors such as public opinion (e.g., Page & Shapiro, 1983; Monroe, 1998; Burstein, 2003), discourse and policy narratives (e.g., Shanahan, Jones, & McBeth, 2011; Jones, 2021), social construction of policy targets (e.g., Ingram & Schneider, 1991, 1993, 1995; Schneider & Ingram, 1993), problem definition (e.g., Bardach, 1981; Rochefort & Cobb, 1993; Baumgartner & Jones 2015) among other technical factors featuring the intricacies of specific policies such as ambiguity in policy objectives (e.g., Matland, 1995; Cairney, Oliver, & Wellstead, 2016), measuring indicators (e.g., De Neufville, 1978; Innes, 1990; Bovaird & Loffler, 2003), evaluation schemas (e.g., Smith & Larimer, 2013). With varying degrees, however, an idea that has traditionally guided these streams of literature rests upon the premise that a functional democracy is working. Therefore, while fully acknowledging that politics play in policies, this game is played within the frame of a democratic governance.

CALL FOR PAPERS

In this panel we are interested in exploring what happens to the policy processes when a democratic frame is jeopardized. This could mean many things, however, the panel is mostly interested in understanding what is the effect over public policy and its processes when for instance, the “public interest” is systematically withdrawn from the scenery, when systemic or political corruption plays a key role in the policy process and/or when democratic values have faded against a more autocratic set of principles. Work in other areas such as public administration, sociology, and political economy has realized that systemic corruption and public-void policy decisions severely impact the quality of governance and government (e.g., Rothstein, 2018; Mungiu-Pippidi, 2006; Jancsics, 2019; Marquette & Peiffer, 2017); this panel invites to reflect in the understanding of how it affects the policy process. More importantly, the panel will contribute by bringing insights to the mainstream theoretical accounts of the policy process that could and should integrate their explanatory frame in order to accommodate different governance contexts.  

The panel is open to a diverse set of methodological approaches. However, the authors should be prepared to make a critical review and to offer theoretical contributions to any of the many existing streams that currently explain the policy processes or policies.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - The paths of corruption in Brazilian municipalities: where they come from and where they are going
Eduardo Grin (Fundaçao Getulio Vargas- Brazil)
CO-AUTHORS
Marco Marco Antonio Carvalho Teixeira (Fundação Getúlio Vargas )
ABSTRACT

Corruption in municipal governments is a characteristic of the Brazilian reality. There are many factors that lead to this situation which, for this reason, cannot be approached in a unidimensional way. Thus, the theoretical, empirical and methodological challenges to address this issue are not trivial. The present work presents the partial results of an investigation organized according to the Consolidation Corruption Framework (CCF) analytical model. The research is organized in two phases. The quantitative stage seeks to identify variables in the local context that may be associated with the occurrence of corruption. Based on multivariate OLS regressions for a sample of 824 municipalities having corruption as dependent variable, and control variables  from public bases in three different categories: demographic characteristics, public funding and social capability. Municipalities were randomly chosen – experimental data – by a federal body responsible for oversees the municipal application of federal transfers. The measure of corruption is the number of irregularities classified as either moderate or severe from the audit's discoveries. Results, however, are surprising because none of independent variables is statistically significant. Available qualitative data is not enough to explain corruption. In general, data on corruption is scarce and with poor quality even if Brazilian General Controllership audit are an exception. However, no relations were found. There is a clear case for a qualitative approach based on a grounded analytical framework. This preliminary inference is due to the lack of general results after running OLS regressions. An initial inference is that corruption is very influenced by each local context, and perhaps it would be harder to get general explanatory factors for the whole country. The second phase is the qualitative and based on interviews with municipal civil servants in one city. We tested the hypotheses proposed by the CCF model and in doing so it was possible to identify three complementary results: the confirmation of the hypothesis provided by the model, the complementation with additional issues, and the proposition of new ones. In this case, the research produces a dialogue with the proposed model as well as advance to new empirical and theoretical paths in order to expand the possibilities for understanding how corruption can be analyzed at the local level. We conclude this preliminary version of the research having two major issues in mind: a) the relevance of using quantitative methods even if it’s for to conclude that it was not possible to find empirical evidence capable of relating municipal characteristics with the occurrence of corruption; b) the relevance of in-depth qualitative studies to uncover the nudges and bolts of local corruption.

 

 

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Intermittent networks of corruption in real estate developments in a Mexican municipality
Miguel Guajardo (El Colegio Mexiquense)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper analyzes the granting of a permit for real estate development in a Mexican municipality, without the construction project taking into account all public services; specifically the lack of connection of the drainage to the municipal network, which is mandatory in accordance with the corresponding regulations. The event occurs in a semi-urban Mexican municipality with low population density, close to large cities, located in an area with high ecotourism potential. These conditions have made it an attractive area for the real estate development of new subdivisions with medium to high prices. It is a municipality that has been governed by municipal presidents from three different parties in the last decade.

 

The theoretical framework from which the phenomenon is studied is the Framework for the Consolidation of Corruption in Local Governments (MCC), which establishes that the consolidation of corruption is achieved in local governments when the presence of networks is combined for selfish with the establishment of the necessary conditions for their efficient and effective performance (Meza and Pérez -Chiqués, 2021).

 

The question that guides this work is how systematic acts of corruption are produced in environments with a high turnover of potential members of the network, in which they have a discontinuous participation? The hypothesis that is proposed is that: corruption can consolidate even in volatile environments in the form of intermittent networks as long as the actors perceive that there is a high probability that their acts remain unpunished. The nature of these networks makes it difficult to detect them, as well as to implement actions to undermine them. In addition, in the case studied, it was found, in agreement with the literature, that when they are activated they have two elements that facilitate their performance: opacity in the procedures; as well as a weak set of checks and balances (Meza and Pérez -Chiqués, 2021).

 

The networks that facilitate corruption have as nodes individuals who obtain a benefit for participating in them, or who do so to avoid potential retaliation by the other actors who participate in the criminal act. For their part, intermittent networks are those that do not function stably, they are only activated when the opportunity to commit an act of corruption arises, but they are deactivated when it has concluded. One factor that promotes the existence of this type of network is the high turnover among municipal officials, a situation that intensifies when there is political alternation (Carrillo et al, 2015; Unda, 2018; Cañez, 2019). Another factor that induces the existence of intermittent networks is the discontinuous nature of certain types of acts of corruption. This occurs when non-governmental actors that are part of a corruption network are unlikely to do so on more than one occasion, that is, they are unique opportunities.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Fighting corruption intermittently: the role of the municipal comptroller's office
Irma del Carmen Guerra Osorno (Universidad Veracruzana)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Most of the literature on corruption has focused on identifying the causes of this phenomenon, analyzing it from an individual, organizational and/or societal level; but little has been explored on how this phenomenon seems to self-reproduce and become embedded, in such a way that reversing it becomes a titanic task. In this regard, the Corruption Consolidation Framework (CCF), published by Meza and Pérez-Chiqués (2020), is very useful because it seeks to account for the mechanisms through which corruption is consolidated in local governments, using four dimensions of analysis: networks, organization, opacity and systems of checks and balances.

 

This paper recovers and builds on the findings of the CCF to explore the last dimension, specifically the role played by the comptrollers' offices and the administrative capacities they have to deal with corruption. For this purpose, a case study was carried out based on interviews, information requests through the National Transparency Platform and analysis of journalistic articles. Among the main findings, it was found that, in addition to the deficient and limited state of the capacities of the municipal comptroller's office, those that were available were used at their discretion, depending on the circumstances, thus facilitating the occurrence of more acts of corruption and making it difficult to sanction those that were committed.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Systemic corruption in an Anglophone country
John Halligan (University of Canberra)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Corruption and accountability issues have become normalised in recent Australian government. These defects have been exposed in official inquiries and reviews, reflected in public debate about the quality of government and inaction with integrity issues, and dramatised by the slump in Australia’s international ranking for corruption. Public governance has declined as the use of corrupt practices multiplied, accountability deficits became rife and key precepts and conventions of responsible government were disregarded.
The advent of new paradigms since the 1980s transformed understandings about the role of the state and the operations of government. A cluster of theories and ideologies emerged for redefining the constitution and operation of the executive branch, notably neo-liberalism, principal-agent and new public management. The reshaping of politicians’ conceptions of their role provided the basis for the emergence of an overly partisan regime in an Anglophone country. The paper concentrates on the practices under the federal government (2018-22) that converted questionable precedents into a governing style.
This was first expressed through politicisation of the policy process (Halligan 2020, 2021) in which the government assumed control of all stages and policy and management roles, ranging from strategy through to implementation and management.
The analysis of malfeasance then addresses specific forms of corruption and accountability deficits. The use of pork barrelling became a cause celebre because governments blatantly engaged in the biased allocation of funds, but also notable were the extensive exploitation of a range of weaknesses in administrative procedures, and abuses of ministerial authority.
The first part addresses the framework and the Australian context. Institutional theories are drawn on in accounting for the dynamics of change and the tension between continuity and reform when a system is derailed by opportunistic political leaders. The central questions addressed are the control of the policy process, the range of corrupt practices of political leaders, and accountability issues arising from the evasion of oversight and scrutiny. Analysis of the breadth and range of malfeasance indicates the scale of the enterprise and the need for a distinctive form of partisan governance to extend and maintain control. Government cultivation of the plenitude of power through multiple means signifies systemic abuse of public office. The concluding sections consider means for addressing issues with corruption and accountability within a system of partisan governance and review the implications of the case for the viability of the Anglophone form of government.
 
References
Craft, J. and Halligan, J. (2020) Policy Advice and the Westminster Tradition: Policy Advisory Systems in Australia, Britain, Canada and New Zealand, Cambridge University Press.
Halligan, J. (2020) Reforming Public Management and Governance: Impact and Lessons from Anglophone Countries, Edward Elgar.
Halligan, J. (2021) Politicization of public services in comparative perspective. In Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. Oxford University Press. 

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Corruption in local governments in Chile, investigating its conceptualization and the experience of inequality.
Emilio Moya (Universidad Católica de Temuco )
CO-AUTHORS
Camila Mella San Martín (Universidad Catolica de Temuco)
ABSTRACT

This article aims to analyze how the social ties that generate and enable corruption operate and how they affect the processes of economic and symbolic inequality in the Southern Macro Zone of Chile.

 

This article is the product of a four-year investigation on corruption in local governments in Chile and that was developed between 2017 and 2021. A mixed qualitative methodology was used since different documents on corruption cases were reviewed and 150 interviews were conducted. in deep. Specifically, it intends to contribute to the understanding and analysis of corruption from conceptual elements of sociology, complementing the legalistic and economic visions that have been developed on this phenomenon. In this context, the chapter proposes to understand corruption as social practices that alter or interrupt the formal and standardized processes of both public and private institutions and organizations where participants obtain material or symbolic goods, generating different experiences of inequality in the citizens.

In this way, an approximation of corruption from a local level is proposed since, as Meza and Pérez-Chiqués (2020) propose, corruption studies are dominated by transnational and national studies, neglecting the corrupt practices that can be observed through contextual studies.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Bad influences: malign policy transfer and the erosion of democratic legitimacy
Tim Legrand (University of Adelaide)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The policy transfer literature has extensively detailed how democracies draw positive and negative lessons from the policy experiences of their peers, but do states adopt ‘malign’ lessons too? It has been a long-standing assumption in the policy studies literature that policy development - including learning and transfer - occurs as a matter of public interest decision-making.  Yet, a recent wave of research in policy studies is increasingly drawing attention to the ‘dark side’ of policy-making (Howlett & Leong, 2022), and calls on policy scientists to be attuned to decision-making that harms the public interest: ‘malign policy’ is argued (Legrand, 2022) to erode democratic institutions and legitimacy and, ultimately, prove ‘volatile’ to policy outcomes (Howlett & Legrand, 2022). Scholarly attention to the spread of illiberal practices and policies between authoritarian states has revealed already how such regimes readily learn from one another (e.g. Heydemann et al, 2011; Hall & Ambrosia, 2017), yet whether and how ‘malign’ policies are transferred between democracies remains to be explored. This paper tackles these questions, and specifically seeks to uncover the legitimising policy transfer mechanisms by which malign policies are introduced and justified in democracies. It draws together the literatures on policy malignity and policy transfer to develop a conceptual analysis of peer policy legitimisation. It applies this conceptual framing to  the case of the policy transfer of immigration policy from Australia to the United Kingdom, and adduces empirical findings from the legal, agential and rhetorical dimensions of the transfer.  In so doing, the paper shows, first, how overseas exemplars operate to legitimise the introduction of malign policies and, second, that doing so emanates from both the legitimising predicates of cultural propinquity, and the rhetorical construction of common challenges or threats to the public interest. 

CO-AUTHORS
Marco Marco Antonio Carvalho Teixeira (Fundação Getúlio Vargas )
ABSTRACT

Corruption in municipal governments is a characteristic of the Brazilian reality. There are many factors that lead to this situation which, for this reason, cannot be approached in a unidimensional way. Thus, the theoretical, empirical and methodological challenges to address this issue are not trivial. The present work presents the partial results of an investigation organized according to the Consolidation Corruption Framework (CCF) analytical model. The research is organized in two phases. The quantitative stage seeks to identify variables in the local context that may be associated with the occurrence of corruption. Based on multivariate OLS regressions for a sample of 824 municipalities having corruption as dependent variable, and control variables  from public bases in three different categories: demographic characteristics, public funding and social capability. Municipalities were randomly chosen – experimental data – by a federal body responsible for oversees the municipal application of federal transfers. The measure of corruption is the number of irregularities classified as either moderate or severe from the audit's discoveries. Results, however, are surprising because none of independent variables is statistically significant. Available qualitative data is not enough to explain corruption. In general, data on corruption is scarce and with poor quality even if Brazilian General Controllership audit are an exception. However, no relations were found. There is a clear case for a qualitative approach based on a grounded analytical framework. This preliminary inference is due to the lack of general results after running OLS regressions. An initial inference is that corruption is very influenced by each local context, and perhaps it would be harder to get general explanatory factors for the whole country. The second phase is the qualitative and based on interviews with municipal civil servants in one city. We tested the hypotheses proposed by the CCF model and in doing so it was possible to identify three complementary results: the confirmation of the hypothesis provided by the model, the complementation with additional issues, and the proposition of new ones. In this case, the research produces a dialogue with the proposed model as well as advance to new empirical and theoretical paths in order to expand the possibilities for understanding how corruption can be analyzed at the local level. We conclude this preliminary version of the research having two major issues in mind: a) the relevance of using quantitative methods even if it’s for to conclude that it was not possible to find empirical evidence capable of relating municipal characteristics with the occurrence of corruption; b) the relevance of in-depth qualitative studies to uncover the nudges and bolts of local corruption.

 

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper analyzes the granting of a permit for real estate development in a Mexican municipality, without the construction project taking into account all public services; specifically the lack of connection of the drainage to the municipal network, which is mandatory in accordance with the corresponding regulations. The event occurs in a semi-urban Mexican municipality with low population density, close to large cities, located in an area with high ecotourism potential. These conditions have made it an attractive area for the real estate development of new subdivisions with medium to high prices. It is a municipality that has been governed by municipal presidents from three different parties in the last decade.

 

The theoretical framework from which the phenomenon is studied is the Framework for the Consolidation of Corruption in Local Governments (MCC), which establishes that the consolidation of corruption is achieved in local governments when the presence of networks is combined for selfish with the establishment of the necessary conditions for their efficient and effective performance (Meza and Pérez -Chiqués, 2021).

 

The question that guides this work is how systematic acts of corruption are produced in environments with a high turnover of potential members of the network, in which they have a discontinuous participation? The hypothesis that is proposed is that: corruption can consolidate even in volatile environments in the form of intermittent networks as long as the actors perceive that there is a high probability that their acts remain unpunished. The nature of these networks makes it difficult to detect them, as well as to implement actions to undermine them. In addition, in the case studied, it was found, in agreement with the literature, that when they are activated they have two elements that facilitate their performance: opacity in the procedures; as well as a weak set of checks and balances (Meza and Pérez -Chiqués, 2021).

 

The networks that facilitate corruption have as nodes individuals who obtain a benefit for participating in them, or who do so to avoid potential retaliation by the other actors who participate in the criminal act. For their part, intermittent networks are those that do not function stably, they are only activated when the opportunity to commit an act of corruption arises, but they are deactivated when it has concluded. One factor that promotes the existence of this type of network is the high turnover among municipal officials, a situation that intensifies when there is political alternation (Carrillo et al, 2015; Unda, 2018; Cañez, 2019). Another factor that induces the existence of intermittent networks is the discontinuous nature of certain types of acts of corruption. This occurs when non-governmental actors that are part of a corruption network are unlikely to do so on more than one occasion, that is, they are unique opportunities.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Most of the literature on corruption has focused on identifying the causes of this phenomenon, analyzing it from an individual, organizational and/or societal level; but little has been explored on how this phenomenon seems to self-reproduce and become embedded, in such a way that reversing it becomes a titanic task. In this regard, the Corruption Consolidation Framework (CCF), published by Meza and Pérez-Chiqués (2020), is very useful because it seeks to account for the mechanisms through which corruption is consolidated in local governments, using four dimensions of analysis: networks, organization, opacity and systems of checks and balances.

 

This paper recovers and builds on the findings of the CCF to explore the last dimension, specifically the role played by the comptrollers' offices and the administrative capacities they have to deal with corruption. For this purpose, a case study was carried out based on interviews, information requests through the National Transparency Platform and analysis of journalistic articles. Among the main findings, it was found that, in addition to the deficient and limited state of the capacities of the municipal comptroller's office, those that were available were used at their discretion, depending on the circumstances, thus facilitating the occurrence of more acts of corruption and making it difficult to sanction those that were committed.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Corruption and accountability issues have become normalised in recent Australian government. These defects have been exposed in official inquiries and reviews, reflected in public debate about the quality of government and inaction with integrity issues, and dramatised by the slump in Australia’s international ranking for corruption. Public governance has declined as the use of corrupt practices multiplied, accountability deficits became rife and key precepts and conventions of responsible government were disregarded.
The advent of new paradigms since the 1980s transformed understandings about the role of the state and the operations of government. A cluster of theories and ideologies emerged for redefining the constitution and operation of the executive branch, notably neo-liberalism, principal-agent and new public management. The reshaping of politicians’ conceptions of their role provided the basis for the emergence of an overly partisan regime in an Anglophone country. The paper concentrates on the practices under the federal government (2018-22) that converted questionable precedents into a governing style.
This was first expressed through politicisation of the policy process (Halligan 2020, 2021) in which the government assumed control of all stages and policy and management roles, ranging from strategy through to implementation and management.
The analysis of malfeasance then addresses specific forms of corruption and accountability deficits. The use of pork barrelling became a cause celebre because governments blatantly engaged in the biased allocation of funds, but also notable were the extensive exploitation of a range of weaknesses in administrative procedures, and abuses of ministerial authority.
The first part addresses the framework and the Australian context. Institutional theories are drawn on in accounting for the dynamics of change and the tension between continuity and reform when a system is derailed by opportunistic political leaders. The central questions addressed are the control of the policy process, the range of corrupt practices of political leaders, and accountability issues arising from the evasion of oversight and scrutiny. Analysis of the breadth and range of malfeasance indicates the scale of the enterprise and the need for a distinctive form of partisan governance to extend and maintain control. Government cultivation of the plenitude of power through multiple means signifies systemic abuse of public office. The concluding sections consider means for addressing issues with corruption and accountability within a system of partisan governance and review the implications of the case for the viability of the Anglophone form of government.
 
References
Craft, J. and Halligan, J. (2020) Policy Advice and the Westminster Tradition: Policy Advisory Systems in Australia, Britain, Canada and New Zealand, Cambridge University Press.
Halligan, J. (2020) Reforming Public Management and Governance: Impact and Lessons from Anglophone Countries, Edward Elgar.
Halligan, J. (2021) Politicization of public services in comparative perspective. In Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. Oxford University Press. 

CO-AUTHORS
Camila Mella San Martín (Universidad Catolica de Temuco)
ABSTRACT

This article aims to analyze how the social ties that generate and enable corruption operate and how they affect the processes of economic and symbolic inequality in the Southern Macro Zone of Chile.

 

This article is the product of a four-year investigation on corruption in local governments in Chile and that was developed between 2017 and 2021. A mixed qualitative methodology was used since different documents on corruption cases were reviewed and 150 interviews were conducted. in deep. Specifically, it intends to contribute to the understanding and analysis of corruption from conceptual elements of sociology, complementing the legalistic and economic visions that have been developed on this phenomenon. In this context, the chapter proposes to understand corruption as social practices that alter or interrupt the formal and standardized processes of both public and private institutions and organizations where participants obtain material or symbolic goods, generating different experiences of inequality in the citizens.

In this way, an approximation of corruption from a local level is proposed since, as Meza and Pérez-Chiqués (2020) propose, corruption studies are dominated by transnational and national studies, neglecting the corrupt practices that can be observed through contextual studies.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The policy transfer literature has extensively detailed how democracies draw positive and negative lessons from the policy experiences of their peers, but do states adopt ‘malign’ lessons too? It has been a long-standing assumption in the policy studies literature that policy development - including learning and transfer - occurs as a matter of public interest decision-making.  Yet, a recent wave of research in policy studies is increasingly drawing attention to the ‘dark side’ of policy-making (Howlett & Leong, 2022), and calls on policy scientists to be attuned to decision-making that harms the public interest: ‘malign policy’ is argued (Legrand, 2022) to erode democratic institutions and legitimacy and, ultimately, prove ‘volatile’ to policy outcomes (Howlett & Legrand, 2022). Scholarly attention to the spread of illiberal practices and policies between authoritarian states has revealed already how such regimes readily learn from one another (e.g. Heydemann et al, 2011; Hall & Ambrosia, 2017), yet whether and how ‘malign’ policies are transferred between democracies remains to be explored. This paper tackles these questions, and specifically seeks to uncover the legitimising policy transfer mechanisms by which malign policies are introduced and justified in democracies. It draws together the literatures on policy malignity and policy transfer to develop a conceptual analysis of peer policy legitimisation. It applies this conceptual framing to  the case of the policy transfer of immigration policy from Australia to the United Kingdom, and adduces empirical findings from the legal, agential and rhetorical dimensions of the transfer.  In so doing, the paper shows, first, how overseas exemplars operate to legitimise the introduction of malign policies and, second, that doing so emanates from both the legitimising predicates of cultural propinquity, and the rhetorical construction of common challenges or threats to the public interest.