CATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
There is a paradox about decision in Policy Studies. Indeed, “decision” has progressively disappeared as a research question since 1970 and the focus has shifted from decision-making to policy-making studies (Lowi et Olson 1970). This shift followed controversies about the notion of decision-making in the 1960s, which was criticised for being a myth, rationalized a posteriori, which implied neglecting the processes preceding it including the definition of the problem at stake, the formulation of alternative solutions, the plurality of actors involved in multi-level processes, etc. (Schattschneider 1975; Bachrach et Baratz 1963; Cobb et Elder 1971; Rochefort et Cobb 1994). Yet, the actors involved in the policy process consider themselves as “decision-makers and see the “decision” as the essential moment in the policy process.
There is a second paradox in policy studies, which involves the neglect of the symbolic dimension of policies. Symbols are everywhere in politics – they are in fact more visible or at least more noticeable now than they had been in previous years : political actors and the media frequently use the adjective “symbolic” to characterize decisions. However, analysts of the policy process has neglected it for a long time.
To go beyond this double paradox, we would like to question in this panel why the myth of the “decision” and of the “decision-maker” continues to be so important for the actors involved in the policy process and how this myth is built, framed, and staged by policymakers. Indeed, the notion of a “decisive” moment is constructed through discourse and gestures throughout all the policy process. This symbolic work also concerns the “decision-makers”, which are defined / identified by other actors - those who will develop their strategy in relation to the “decision-makers” they want to influence or fight against.
CALL FOR PAPERS
The panel will focus on the uses of the concept of “decision” and of "decision-makers" in the policy process and explore three main hypotheses. The first one considers that the “decision” and “decision-makers” can be analyzed as symbols, as mentioned above. Following Edelman’s argument about the symbolic uses of politics, we would like to consider them as a “meaning creation through political languages” which contributes to the political spectacle and the legitimacy of the government. The second hypothesis considers that the symbolic uses of language are not only a justification for the publicization and the legitimation of a policy a posteriori but also play an important role during the pre-decision processes (agenda-setting, policy formulation, etc.). The third hypothesis consider that the construction of the decision as the key moment in policy-making is also important for decision-makers as well as for the other actors involved. This panel will thus reflect on regimes of justification, on the importance of rationality and of political responsibility.
This panel welcome all empirical and theoretical papers which propose to better understand the symbolic uses of the "decision" in the policy process.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Announcements of border closures suggest that an actor, at some point, decides to close ‘the asylum floodgates’. However, my research shows that the temporality, the impermeability of the border, and the uniqueness of the actor making the decision do not actually reflect the reality of the decision-making process. Instead, this announcement and spectacle of the border-related decision seeks an audience, both within the state and beyond - directed at the state's foreign policy. Based on four years of fieldwork in Greece, Hungary and Jordan, with interviews conducted with diplomatic, donor, humanitarian and military actors, this paper will theorize the decision to close borders as a symbolic tool used for positioning the state’s in question. The paper will focus on questioning the decision as a moment of institutional change: ones which research has shown that formal, dramatized announcements always need to be placed in a broader policy history, but where the announcement itself nevertheless marks a real shift in the politics of the border. We then demonstrate why such announcements functions as a symbolic tool directed at different audiences, depending on the border regime and the means of legitimizing power. The article will conclude by presenting the closure decision as a reaffirmation of the vertical nature of power in migration matters, a verticality that runs through different political regimes. This contribution will present simultaneously the symbolic nature of the announcement of the decision and its value for legitimizing and reaffirming power. My comparison between different political regimes will enable reasoned generalizations to be engendered as regards the different uses of ‘the decision’ as a symbolic tool.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In his seminal book The Symbolic Uses of Politics (1964), Edelman argues that there is a symbolic dimension of politics resulting from how politics are maintained and conducted. Inspired by this notion, this presentation will discuss the symbolic dimension of decision-making and the myths of the decision-making process it has inspired. The main argument to be presented is threefold: First, the symbolic dimension of decision-making consists of a triangle of elements: the perception of decision-making, the action of deciding, and the knowledge about the decision-making process. Second, all three of these are inconsistent with each other. And third, together all three symbolic elements build myths about decision-making processes. Defining preliminary myths of this kind—which might change in different contexts—is the goal of the study which this presentation reports on. It is important to define these myths because they have such great impact on the way in which governments are perceived, and play an important role in the growing public distrust in government’s capacity to decide. Thus, they have large potential for promoting public value.
The Covid-19 pandemic is an interesting case via which to study this issue, as it brought decision-making theory back to prominence after being out of fashion for many years, during which it was studied mostly as a byproduct of other interesting subjects and issues. The pandemic provoked three important developments: first, uncertainty was rediscovered; second, decision-making was once again at the center of attention; and third, the basic question of what can be done to improve the decision-making process was asked anew.
Israel’s State Comptroller (the supreme auditing body in Israel) published (in 2020 and 2022) two major special reports on how the Israeli government handled the pandemic, and also referred to it indirectly in a short report on disease outbreaks in general produced during the first days of the Covid-19 pandemic (2020). The presentation will present the findings of an interpretive narrative analysis of these audit reports as they relate to the first two symbolic elements in the triangle described above (the perception of decision-making and the action of deciding) and compare between those two and between them and the third symbolic element (knowledge about the decision-making process). The presentation will conclude by surveying a number of myths on decision-making and their implications for the perceptions of government as a decision-maker.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Decision, understood as the decisive moment of choice by a decision-maker, has been considered as a "myth" for a long time in policy studies. In other words, it was seen as an illusion rather than as a fact and, as a consequence, it has been largely overlooked by analysts, if not dismissed or denigrated. In this paper, we take seriously into account the idea that "the decision" is a myth (a narrative, which relation to factual truth is questioned by some and believed by others) in order to reflect about the symbolic work it performs in the policy process. This, we argue, allows us to show that it is a useful category and to draw attention to the symbolic dimension of politics. Against the artificial, yet sometimes heuristic, distinction between the material and the ideational, we advocate reinvestigating the role of the symbolic in policy-making: decision, as a myth plays a crucial role in the power relationships involving the actors involved in the process; it contributes to the legitimation claims of policy-maker and in the endorsement of political responsibility.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Announcements of border closures suggest that an actor, at some point, decides to close ‘the asylum floodgates’. However, my research shows that the temporality, the impermeability of the border, and the uniqueness of the actor making the decision do not actually reflect the reality of the decision-making process. Instead, this announcement and spectacle of the border-related decision seeks an audience, both within the state and beyond - directed at the state's foreign policy. Based on four years of fieldwork in Greece, Hungary and Jordan, with interviews conducted with diplomatic, donor, humanitarian and military actors, this paper will theorize the decision to close borders as a symbolic tool used for positioning the state’s in question. The paper will focus on questioning the decision as a moment of institutional change: ones which research has shown that formal, dramatized announcements always need to be placed in a broader policy history, but where the announcement itself nevertheless marks a real shift in the politics of the border. We then demonstrate why such announcements functions as a symbolic tool directed at different audiences, depending on the border regime and the means of legitimizing power. The article will conclude by presenting the closure decision as a reaffirmation of the vertical nature of power in migration matters, a verticality that runs through different political regimes. This contribution will present simultaneously the symbolic nature of the announcement of the decision and its value for legitimizing and reaffirming power. My comparison between different political regimes will enable reasoned generalizations to be engendered as regards the different uses of ‘the decision’ as a symbolic tool.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In his seminal book The Symbolic Uses of Politics (1964), Edelman argues that there is a symbolic dimension of politics resulting from how politics are maintained and conducted. Inspired by this notion, this presentation will discuss the symbolic dimension of decision-making and the myths of the decision-making process it has inspired. The main argument to be presented is threefold: First, the symbolic dimension of decision-making consists of a triangle of elements: the perception of decision-making, the action of deciding, and the knowledge about the decision-making process. Second, all three of these are inconsistent with each other. And third, together all three symbolic elements build myths about decision-making processes. Defining preliminary myths of this kind—which might change in different contexts—is the goal of the study which this presentation reports on. It is important to define these myths because they have such great impact on the way in which governments are perceived, and play an important role in the growing public distrust in government’s capacity to decide. Thus, they have large potential for promoting public value.
The Covid-19 pandemic is an interesting case via which to study this issue, as it brought decision-making theory back to prominence after being out of fashion for many years, during which it was studied mostly as a byproduct of other interesting subjects and issues. The pandemic provoked three important developments: first, uncertainty was rediscovered; second, decision-making was once again at the center of attention; and third, the basic question of what can be done to improve the decision-making process was asked anew.
Israel’s State Comptroller (the supreme auditing body in Israel) published (in 2020 and 2022) two major special reports on how the Israeli government handled the pandemic, and also referred to it indirectly in a short report on disease outbreaks in general produced during the first days of the Covid-19 pandemic (2020). The presentation will present the findings of an interpretive narrative analysis of these audit reports as they relate to the first two symbolic elements in the triangle described above (the perception of decision-making and the action of deciding) and compare between those two and between them and the third symbolic element (knowledge about the decision-making process). The presentation will conclude by surveying a number of myths on decision-making and their implications for the perceptions of government as a decision-maker.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Decision, understood as the decisive moment of choice by a decision-maker, has been considered as a "myth" for a long time in policy studies. In other words, it was seen as an illusion rather than as a fact and, as a consequence, it has been largely overlooked by analysts, if not dismissed or denigrated. In this paper, we take seriously into account the idea that "the decision" is a myth (a narrative, which relation to factual truth is questioned by some and believed by others) in order to reflect about the symbolic work it performs in the policy process. This, we argue, allows us to show that it is a useful category and to draw attention to the symbolic dimension of politics. Against the artificial, yet sometimes heuristic, distinction between the material and the ideational, we advocate reinvestigating the role of the symbolic in policy-making: decision, as a myth plays a crucial role in the power relationships involving the actors involved in the process; it contributes to the legitimation claims of policy-maker and in the endorsement of political responsibility.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)