Format

P16. Agency in the Policy Process: Policy Entrepreneurs, Leaders, and Brokers

POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Evangelia Petridou
NTNU Social Research and Mid Sweden University
Main chair
Christopher Weible
University of Colorado Denver
Second chair
Maria Tullia Galanti
Università degli Studi di Milano
Third chair
Giliberto Capano
Università di Bologna
Fourth chair
Karin Ingold
University of Bern
Fifth chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Recent advances in policy process research have highlighted the empirical imperative and theoretical relevance of actor-centered approaches and the salience of agency in the policy process. Agency in social sciences has often been regarded as a residual variable to make sense of patterns of change and stability that do not fit with expectations coming from more general theories and structural approaches. While leadership studies, organizational theory, public management and sociology have studied agency both theoretically and empirically, public policy scholars tend to focus on how agency unravels in the policy process (Capano and Galanti 2018). Understanding how actors initiate, frame, support, legitimate, and implement change may provide the tools for driven policy actors to engage with the wicked problems of our time, including climate change and deep-seated social inequities, or more ‘mundane’ issues such as community development at the local level.
       Concomitantly, it is theoretically fruitful to explore actors in the policy process research, especially
as they relate to each other conceptually. The scholarship in policy process research has paid increased attention to a distinct kind of political actor, the policy entrepreneur (Petridou and Mintrom 2021; Mintrom 2020). Policy entrepreneurs are energetic actors aimed at affecting policy change and in doing so disrupt the status quo policy landscape. Policy entrepreneurial strategies are multidimensional and they include, inter alia, forming coalitions, developing convincing arguments, leading by example, and not only managing, but also developing networks. These are strategies that may be observed in leaders as well as brokers, who constitute political actors (and concepts) distinct to policy entrepreneurs (Christopoulos and Ingold, 2015). At the same time, policy leaders may show different goals, strategies or resources that impact on the policy process and shape patterns of change and stability, but have never been extensively theorized. All these agents have been discussed in some of the theories of the policy process such as the Advocacy Coalition Framework, the Multiple Stream Approach, and the Punctuated Equilibrium Framework (Weible et al. 2017) Although significant work has been done to conceptually disentangle the policy entrepreneur from the leader and the broker, often times these terms are conflated or used uncritically in the literature resulting in conceptual fuzziness and the perpetuation of a lack of a sharp distinction between policy entrepreneurship, leadership, and brokerage.
Therefore, this panel has a twofold objective. First, it aims at examining the theoretical differences and similarities that exist among the concepts of the policy entrepreneur, the broker, and the leader in the broader context of public policy making. It also seeks to highlight the empirical implications these theoretical convergences and divergences have in the way we understand policy change.

CALL FOR PAPERS

In this panel, the chairs welcome papers that develop the concepts of the policy entrepreneur, the leader, and the broker; starting from these broad research questions: What is the relationship between the concepts of policy entrepreneurs, brokers, and leaders in public policy making? What implications do they have for the policy making process? Do entrepreneurs, leaders and brokers adapt their roles, strategies and resources in the different phases of the policy process?
The panel will welcome theoretical papers aimed at disentangling the differences in the concepts of entrepreneurs, brokers and leaders also by looking at the different roles that these actors might play in the agenda setting, policy formulation, decision making, implementation and evaluation phases. Papers showing how the different concepts are conceptualized and discussed in established and new framework and theories of the policy process will be appreciated. Papers discussing the methodological challenges for the study of the different agency concepts will also be welcomed, with particular attention to process tracing, network analysis, the analysis of policy narratives. Though theoretical papers are more encouraged, also empirical papers are also welcomed. Particular attention will be dedicated to papers that try to apply these concepts to wicked problems and emerging issues, both in traditional policy fields (such as energy policy, environment policies, urban development, education policies),and in more integrated policies (such as crisis management, sustainable development, digitalization, smart cities, green and energetic transition, health and wellbeing, work-life-balance, migrations, food and agriculture, and others).

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Technocratic Policy Entrepreneurship in Comparison: A Systematic Review
Alex Jingwei He (The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Since its inception, the concept of policy entrepreneurs has been a very important analytical heuristic to explain policy change. In the past three decades, policy entrepreneurship has evolved from a loose metaphor to more sophisticated theoretical treatment. When considering bureaucrats as policy entrepreneurs, the literature mainly focuses on high-ranking officials and generally does not characterize ordinary government employees who deliver administrative services as entrepreneurs. The innovative behaviours of rank-and-file bureaucrats have received far less analytical attention. A major theoretical development in the recent years is the recognition of entrepreneurial technocrats as change agents in the policy process. Some recent studies in multiple national and sectoral contexts have illustrated that more than the creative use of administrative discretion, these individuals at the middle and lower echelon of the bureaucratic hierarchy can drive meaningful policy innovations.

 

Yet, the received wisdom is predominantly located in hundreds of case studies and there is a paucity of synthesized scholarly knowledge regarding the processes and mechanisms of this distinctive form of policy entrepreneurship. This current study seeks to fulfil this gap through a systematic review of the empirical literature. A thorough search of the academic literature published in SSCI-indexed journals was undertaken in multiple databases between September and November 2022. Using a set of keyword identifiers, we have collected about 100 empirical studies that document case studies reporting local policy reforms and/or innovations led by technocratic bureaucrats.

 

We follow the PRISMA protocols in systematic review and develop a comprehensive codebook to analyse these case studies. Aside from bibliographic information, the review mainly focuses on: 1) the identity, personal attributes, and motivations of technocratic entrepreneurs, 2) context and structural conditions of the reform/innovation, 3) the entrepreneurial strategies used, and 4) outcome of the reform/innovation. Coding is in progress and we expect preliminary results in February 2023 and a full paper in May. Upon completion, this paper will offer a comprehensive synthesis of technocratic entrepreneurship in the international literature, highlight key theoretical progress, and identify gaps for subsequent research.  

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - LGBTQ Policy Entrepreneurship in the United Kingdom
Chris Pepin-Neff (University of Sydney)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Policy entrepreneurship is an important aspect of public policy analysis for communities on the margins. This paper reports on a survey (n=226) of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer (LGBTQ) political actors in the United Kingdom. Policy entrepreneurship is defined as those actors that serving as a relevant actor, attach their solution to a problem, biasing political outcomes, gain something from their engagement and change the emotional habitus of socio-political structures. Little research to date has focused on the role of LGBTQ policy entrepreneurs in the UK. The research question motivating this study asks what factors influence activism and entrepreneurship among LGBTQ actors in the UK. Data from the survey show only 18.5% strongly agree with the concept of emotional taxation, 22% state their LGBTQ work is not emotionally taxing and UK actors had the lowest average for question about emotional taxing in the LGBTQ movement, as well as the lowest average taxation for tweeting, facebooking, lobbying, and for marching in a parade. I argue that UK presents a unique case because the LGBTQ political community does not appear to experience high levels of emotional taxation for entering into entrepreneurial actions. I suggest that the UK disproves the assertions made about connections between emotional habitus and entrepreneurship because many in the LGBTQ community work for government institutions or LGBTQ groups. Data from the survey shows that in the UK 31% of respondents currently or previously worked for an LGBTQ organization. This constitutes the highest percentage of those surveyed across the UK, Australia, South Africa, and the U.S. This change in operating venue is an important aspect of policy entrepreneurship and may influence the nature of LGBTQ political activity in the UK. Greater LGBTQ infrastructure in the UK provides greater emotional support for activism and entrepreneurial activity. In all, this study suggests that emotional considerations may be better placed as an indicator of success rather than as a qualifying variable in the definition of policy entrepreneurship.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Humanitarian actors and changing border policies: an empirically and analytically difficult form of agency
Emma Empociello (Sciences Po Bordeaux)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In 2015 and 2016, border closures to migrants coming from the Middle East were announced in Greece, Hungary and Jordan. These concomitant decisions shaped a similar change in borderlands. Indeed, they resulted in the thickening of the border through militarization and the creation of asylum seekers’ camps. The latter brought a new kind of actor to militarized zones: humanitarian ones. By examining the implementation phase of these policies, this article aims at showing how humanitarian actors can take on the role of brokers or even entrepreneurs, but struggle to position themselves as leaders. The existing literature has shown a humanitarian role as oscillating between taking part in control and challenging border regimes. This article aims at nuancing the role of humanitarian actors, theorizing their role through the way they influence, or not, the institutional change happening in borderlands during this specific period of time in three different contexts. I argue that they are brokers first, as they follow and act under state’s decisions and are constrained by these decisions and existing and changing border regimes. Political decisions use them as an adjustment variable, indeed as a buffer to contain asylum seekers placed in the hands of carers, but also criminalizing their action when they tend to be too contentious. Humanitarian actors sometimes evolve into entrepreneurs when trying to document abuses in asylum camps in borderlands and challenging border practices and policies, sometimes through advocacy, sometimes through illegality. However, I analyze the balance they seek between participating in and challenging each existing regime by arguing that they struggle to position themselves as leaders. This is because their action is constantly restricted by their own humanitarian principles, which, when applied to the border, endorse containment in borderlands. Consequently, humanitarian principles are a limitation upon their potential role as leaders, thereby diminishing their potential agency in policy making. Hence, humanitarian actors do have a minimum of agency in their decision making within the existing framework of their action, but they fail to challenge institutional change that goes on around them.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Policy networks during crisis: Case of Singapore’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic
Lili Li (Auburn University)
CO-AUTHORS
Kritika Sha (National University of Singapore)
Araz Taeihagh (National University of Singapore)
ABSTRACT

Given various challenges stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic, different countries and jurisdictions deployed an expansive range of policy actors across health, workforce, education, finance, trade, tourism, building, and information and communication sectors. These actors were instrumental in formulating and implementing a wide variety of policy measures, including lockdown, testing, vaccination, safe distancing rules, and economic support for affected businesses (Capano et al., 2020). Policy networks, in particular, played a key role in shaping these policy issues, at times altering the position of their components and their interactions given the rapid development of the pandemic (Weible et al., 2020). We explore the characteristics and interactions with policy networks during a crisis, using Singapore’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Previous studies on Singapore’s relative success in managing the COVID-19 pandemic focused on its application of technology solutions and leveraging public trust and policy capacity (Capano et al., 2020; Goggin, 2020; Lee and Lee, 2020; Liew et al., 2020; Das and Zhang, 2021; Woo, 2020; Woo, 2021). However, there is a lack of a systematic investigation of the various policy actors, their interactions, and networks across sectors during the pandemic. To address the above research gap, we investigate the role of the different policy actors, their issued policies, their target sector, and the interaction within and between different policy clusters for managing the COVID-19 pandemic in Singapore between January 2020 and February 2022. Our research questions include: What are the structures of policy networks during the COVID-19 pandemic? Learning from COVID-19, how can governments design/organise policy networks to manage future crises or pandemics? We answer the above research questions by investigating - Who are the key actors involved in policy formulation and implementation for managing COVID-19 in Singapore? What is the pattern of information exchange between key actors throughout the pandemic? How do these actors collaborate and cluster with each other across the various stages of the pandemic? This systematic policy network analysis will empirically contribute to understanding the cross-sectoral policy landscape in Singapore, drawing lessons for other jurisdictions and countries to manage future crises or events. Theoretically, this article will contribute a temporal perspective to understand policy networks as a crisis evolves.

Keywords: policy networks, policy subsystems, crisis management, COVID-19 pandemic

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Does Audit Institution in China Combine the Roles of Policy and Institutional Entrepreneur? A Phenomenological Perspective
Fei Liao (Nanjing Audit University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Policy entrepreneur and institutional entrepreneur both are change agents, but not all change agents are policy entrepreneur, or institutional entrepreneur. The promising theoretical questions are: Why and under what circumstances does an agent combine the roles of policy and institutional entrepreneur (Baki, Akgunay, & Coban, 2021)? How? And what are the outcomes? in China, audit institution is under the steering of Central Audit Committee of the Communist Party of China (CPC), which means that it's a powerful independent oversight and external change agent. This article explores the efforts on promoting system-wide changes and answers the question: does audit institution combine the roles of policy and institutional entrepreneur?

After performing a phenomenological approach on the audit practices and their impacts, and then referring to the definition of policy and institutional entrepreneurs in the literature,the author probes into the roles of audit institution. This article suggests: (1) In the top-level design of China's national governance, audit institution is endow with dual roles to improve public policy and institutional system. (2) By connecting the problems in policy implementation and design, audit institution makes great efforts to promote policy and institutional changes simultaneously. (3) Audit institution actively coordinates with other change agents (policy and institutional entrepreneurs) to facilitate the desired changes. The author believes that more studies on the roles of audit institution will enrich the understanding on policy and institutional entrepreneurs in China, which maybe contribute to the literature.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Taking Agency Seriously in the Policy Process
Evangelia Petridou (NTNU Social Research and Mid Sweden University)
CO-AUTHORS
Christopher Weible (University of Colorado Denver)
Maria Tullia Galanti (Università degli Studi di Milano)
Giliberto Capano (Università di Bologna)
ABSTRACT

Taking Agency Seriously in the Policy Process

 

Chris Weible, Evangelia Petridou, Karin Ingold, Tullia Galanti, Giliberto Capano

 

Theories of the policy process are tools that help us navigate the complexities of the repeated interactions among actors, contexts, events, contexts, and previous public policies that comprise the public policy making process (Weible, 2018). For a theory to have explanatory value, it must adequately tackle both the agentic power of actors and the structural conditions that foster or hinder the actions of these actors. In this conceptual paper, we argue that extant theories of the policy process, though to varying degrees of focus and emphasis account for agency, they suffer from three shortfalls: first, they treat agency as an independent variable, without clearly theorizing their emergence; second, labels attached to agents suffer from conceptual stretching and overlap, translation errors, and a general fuzziness, and third, agency tends to be treated as a residual variable. In this conceptual paper, we depart sharply from rational choice explanations of agentic behavior and instead we take stock of agentic action and theorize agency predicated on the concept of functions (Lasswell, 1956). These are tasks in the policy making process, which involve activities performed for the purpose of maintaining stability or inducing change. They are embedded in structures, but activated through actors, allowing us to differentiate between different agency types. We conclude with suggestions for operationalization and measurement.
 
References
Lasswell, Harold.D. 1956. “The Decision Process: Seven Categories of Functional Analysis.” College Park, MD: University of Maryland
Weible, Christopher M.  2018.  "Introduction: The Scope and Focus of Policy Process Research."  In Theories of the Policy Process, eds.  Christopher M. Weible and Paul A. Sabatier, 4th ed.  New York: Routledge.  1-13.
 

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Women and Children First: Street-level policy entrepreneurship within secondary health care in Minas Gerais, Brazil.
James Melo (Federal University of Viçosa)
CO-AUTHORS
Josiel Valadares (Universidade Federal de Viçosa)
Magnus Emmendoerfer (Universidade Federal de Viçosa - UFV / UNESCO CHAIR CEPPBRASIL )
ABSTRACT

The literature on policy entrepreneurs has mainly focused on high-level decision-makers, ignoring low and middle-level bureaucrats. However, in light of their close position to citizens and the nature of activity, some recent works have been linking street-level bureaucrats (SLBs) with policy entrepreneurship. They highlight the use of entrepreneurial strategies by SLBs to influence policy via implementation practices and/or policy design. Immersed in a broad network that provides health services to children and women in all three levels of health assistance in Minas Gerais (MG), Brazil, Viva Vida Centers' (CVV) SLBs are in a very similar context to those normally approached in literature. Thus, this works main objective was to investigate the engagement of SLBs within CVVs Viçosa and Manhuaçu in entrepreneurial strategies to shape policy through implementation practices and/or directly influence policy design. Data collection was carried out through semi-structured interviews with bureaucrats from Cvvs Viçosa and Manhuaçu from 2020 to 2021. The results report the case of CVV Manhuaçu's former manager (I3). The case is chronologically divided into two distinct moments, considering the policy process literature. In the first moment, the manager of CVV Manhuaçu from 2010 to 2017, prompted by a lack of guidance for implementation and a high level of discretion, framed problems, planned processes, diffused her vision and actively led her team, successfully outlining the Center’s prototype, securing smooth implementation through consolidating strategies. Years later, when when a top-down change in policy struck, leaving hundreds unassisted, she ultimately acted to reinsert the issue of sexual violence and abuse victims into the official government agenda, aiming to promote policy change at the institucional level. It is argued that the use of entrepreneurial strategies can increase the chances of success for street-level bureaucrats in influencing policy outcomes, thus it is important to promote proactivity among the street-level bureaucracy, and place at their reach, political and governance instruments for political participation, once just favorable personal traits might not be enough.

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - The Dark Side of Universities’ Participation in Smart Specialisation Strategy Processes: tensions, policy traps and lessons
Liliana Fonseca (University of Strathclyde)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Smart Specialisation has been a pivotal concept in EU Cohesion Policy over the last decade, arguably transforming innovation policy since its adoption in the 2014-20 programming period (Hassink & Gong, 2019). It has been characterised as the “largest innovation policy experiment in the world” (Radosevic & Stancova, 2018), by being implemented as an ex-ante conditionality for access to Cohesion funds, and by placing an emphasis on a place-based, collaborative, and bottom-up approach to the strategy and policy process (Uyarra, 2018). The framework of smart specialisation has also put innovation, entrepreneurship, and knowledge-based policies at the core of EU policy and regional development strategies (Marinelli & Perianez-Forte, 2017), with the goal to build on local assets and strengthen the regional innovation ecosystem. This has heightened the role of higher education and research institutions in the strategy process (Fonseca & Nieth, 2021).

 

This paper explores the role of universities as leaders, agents, and brokers in the smart specialisation strategy process and examines the impact of the high demands placed upon these institutions when navigating this policy space. The study compares the participation of three European universities - the University of Aveiro (Portugal), the Autonomous University of Barcelona (Spain), and the University of Twente (The Netherlands)  - in their regions' smart specialisation strategies as part of the researcher’s doctoral work (Fonseca, 2022). The conceptual framework draws on existing academic critiques of universities’ regional role and of smart specialisation (e.g., Sotarauta, 2018; Hassink & Gong, 2019; Kristensen et al., 2022), to understand current challenges in inter-institutional collaboration and innovation governance and provide insights for the new Cohesion Policy period.

 

The methodology employs a qualitative approach, using desk-based research of policy and institutional strategy documents and 88 in-depth interviews across the three case studies, as well as content and thematic analysis. The findings highlight the advantages and difficulties of universities' engagement in smart specialisation strategy processes and suggest alternative frameworks to navigate the policy traps. The paper concludes that universities play a crucial role in innovation and regional governance, but it is important to understand the limitations and challenges of their participation. Still, universities are emphasised as change agents critical to smart specialisation implementation. Findings also suggest there are dimensions in the implementation of smart specialisation that need to be further developed in the new period, such as capacity-building, inter-institutional and cross-region collaboration, policy implementation and innovation diffusion.

 

This study fits well with the conference panel titled "Agency in the Policy Process: Policy Entrepreneurs, Leaders, and Brokers," as it develops the concepts of policy entrepreneurs, leaders, and brokers in relation to universities and in the context of the smart specialisation strategy process, a widespread innovation and regional development policy process in the European Union and increasingly internationally. The paper contributes to the panel's discussions by providing insights into the engagement of a relevant regional stakeholder in the policy process, and by examining the challenges they face in adapting their roles, strategies, and resources in different phases of the policy process.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - The agency role: a comparative study on the role of policy entrepreneurs in Barcelona and Dutch municipalities
Bruno Oliveira (Iscte - Instituto Universitário de Lisboa)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In 2017, several innovative basic income inspired policies (BIIP) were implemented in different cities of the world. Being this policy implemented, mainly, at the local level it raised the question about the factors for why a policy like this implemented at the local level? What were the key elements that triggered this policy? Many studies on policy innovation have focused their attention on the role of policy entrepreneurs and political leadership (Guldbrandsson and Fossum, 2009 and Rosas-Satizàbal and Rodriguez-Valencia, 2018). Policy entrepreneurs such as Mayors and city council members "advocate policy innovations and transform political arenas" (Mintröm, 2000). A theory that has its roots in John Kingdon’s multiple streams, which defined the policy entrepreneurs as "individuals or groups of individuals who propose alternative solutions to certain problems at key moments" (Kingdon, 1995 [1984]). They can be actors in the political communities (e.g., experts, mayors, aldermen), who work on promoting specific solutions to the problem (Araújo and Rodrigues, 2017).

                     This paper tries to relate the role of agency elements such as the leadership of entrepreneurs with the municipalistic projects by comparing two case studies. We used qualitative methods (semi-strutured interviews, focus group and documental analysis) to trace the policy-making process in both cases.

                     The Barcelona case acknowledges the idea of ‘new municipalism’, in which cities are seen as institutional actors and is an example of the connection between ‘new municipalism’ and European union in policy innovation in the social domain. The social position of policy entrepreneurs in the governance structure of city council was essential to promote social innovation. A new political organization with a municipalitistic project (agenda for change) characterized by a leftist ideology of putting themes like housing and municipal income onto the agenda and wanting to change European politics towards the citizens and the common good. Under this leadership it was possible for Barcelona to promote social innovation in two ways: leading the European networks of municipalism EUROCITIES and calling knowledge-based actors to design and implement an income policy for the city. Although the institutional settings were there for both municipalities – the Dutch with a new social assistance law (83º PA act/2015) which enabled them to innovate in the social domain and Barcelona with European policy instrument which allowed innovation in urban areas (delegated regulation of 522/2014 and ERDF article 8 of 2014) – the truth is that the difference in social innovation was due to the role of the policy entrepreneurs in city council.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Since its inception, the concept of policy entrepreneurs has been a very important analytical heuristic to explain policy change. In the past three decades, policy entrepreneurship has evolved from a loose metaphor to more sophisticated theoretical treatment. When considering bureaucrats as policy entrepreneurs, the literature mainly focuses on high-ranking officials and generally does not characterize ordinary government employees who deliver administrative services as entrepreneurs. The innovative behaviours of rank-and-file bureaucrats have received far less analytical attention. A major theoretical development in the recent years is the recognition of entrepreneurial technocrats as change agents in the policy process. Some recent studies in multiple national and sectoral contexts have illustrated that more than the creative use of administrative discretion, these individuals at the middle and lower echelon of the bureaucratic hierarchy can drive meaningful policy innovations.

 

Yet, the received wisdom is predominantly located in hundreds of case studies and there is a paucity of synthesized scholarly knowledge regarding the processes and mechanisms of this distinctive form of policy entrepreneurship. This current study seeks to fulfil this gap through a systematic review of the empirical literature. A thorough search of the academic literature published in SSCI-indexed journals was undertaken in multiple databases between September and November 2022. Using a set of keyword identifiers, we have collected about 100 empirical studies that document case studies reporting local policy reforms and/or innovations led by technocratic bureaucrats.

 

We follow the PRISMA protocols in systematic review and develop a comprehensive codebook to analyse these case studies. Aside from bibliographic information, the review mainly focuses on: 1) the identity, personal attributes, and motivations of technocratic entrepreneurs, 2) context and structural conditions of the reform/innovation, 3) the entrepreneurial strategies used, and 4) outcome of the reform/innovation. Coding is in progress and we expect preliminary results in February 2023 and a full paper in May. Upon completion, this paper will offer a comprehensive synthesis of technocratic entrepreneurship in the international literature, highlight key theoretical progress, and identify gaps for subsequent research.  

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Policy entrepreneurship is an important aspect of public policy analysis for communities on the margins. This paper reports on a survey (n=226) of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer (LGBTQ) political actors in the United Kingdom. Policy entrepreneurship is defined as those actors that serving as a relevant actor, attach their solution to a problem, biasing political outcomes, gain something from their engagement and change the emotional habitus of socio-political structures. Little research to date has focused on the role of LGBTQ policy entrepreneurs in the UK. The research question motivating this study asks what factors influence activism and entrepreneurship among LGBTQ actors in the UK. Data from the survey show only 18.5% strongly agree with the concept of emotional taxation, 22% state their LGBTQ work is not emotionally taxing and UK actors had the lowest average for question about emotional taxing in the LGBTQ movement, as well as the lowest average taxation for tweeting, facebooking, lobbying, and for marching in a parade. I argue that UK presents a unique case because the LGBTQ political community does not appear to experience high levels of emotional taxation for entering into entrepreneurial actions. I suggest that the UK disproves the assertions made about connections between emotional habitus and entrepreneurship because many in the LGBTQ community work for government institutions or LGBTQ groups. Data from the survey shows that in the UK 31% of respondents currently or previously worked for an LGBTQ organization. This constitutes the highest percentage of those surveyed across the UK, Australia, South Africa, and the U.S. This change in operating venue is an important aspect of policy entrepreneurship and may influence the nature of LGBTQ political activity in the UK. Greater LGBTQ infrastructure in the UK provides greater emotional support for activism and entrepreneurial activity. In all, this study suggests that emotional considerations may be better placed as an indicator of success rather than as a qualifying variable in the definition of policy entrepreneurship.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In 2015 and 2016, border closures to migrants coming from the Middle East were announced in Greece, Hungary and Jordan. These concomitant decisions shaped a similar change in borderlands. Indeed, they resulted in the thickening of the border through militarization and the creation of asylum seekers’ camps. The latter brought a new kind of actor to militarized zones: humanitarian ones. By examining the implementation phase of these policies, this article aims at showing how humanitarian actors can take on the role of brokers or even entrepreneurs, but struggle to position themselves as leaders. The existing literature has shown a humanitarian role as oscillating between taking part in control and challenging border regimes. This article aims at nuancing the role of humanitarian actors, theorizing their role through the way they influence, or not, the institutional change happening in borderlands during this specific period of time in three different contexts. I argue that they are brokers first, as they follow and act under state’s decisions and are constrained by these decisions and existing and changing border regimes. Political decisions use them as an adjustment variable, indeed as a buffer to contain asylum seekers placed in the hands of carers, but also criminalizing their action when they tend to be too contentious. Humanitarian actors sometimes evolve into entrepreneurs when trying to document abuses in asylum camps in borderlands and challenging border practices and policies, sometimes through advocacy, sometimes through illegality. However, I analyze the balance they seek between participating in and challenging each existing regime by arguing that they struggle to position themselves as leaders. This is because their action is constantly restricted by their own humanitarian principles, which, when applied to the border, endorse containment in borderlands. Consequently, humanitarian principles are a limitation upon their potential role as leaders, thereby diminishing their potential agency in policy making. Hence, humanitarian actors do have a minimum of agency in their decision making within the existing framework of their action, but they fail to challenge institutional change that goes on around them.

CO-AUTHORS
Kritika Sha (National University of Singapore)
Araz Taeihagh (National University of Singapore)
ABSTRACT

Given various challenges stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic, different countries and jurisdictions deployed an expansive range of policy actors across health, workforce, education, finance, trade, tourism, building, and information and communication sectors. These actors were instrumental in formulating and implementing a wide variety of policy measures, including lockdown, testing, vaccination, safe distancing rules, and economic support for affected businesses (Capano et al., 2020). Policy networks, in particular, played a key role in shaping these policy issues, at times altering the position of their components and their interactions given the rapid development of the pandemic (Weible et al., 2020). We explore the characteristics and interactions with policy networks during a crisis, using Singapore’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Previous studies on Singapore’s relative success in managing the COVID-19 pandemic focused on its application of technology solutions and leveraging public trust and policy capacity (Capano et al., 2020; Goggin, 2020; Lee and Lee, 2020; Liew et al., 2020; Das and Zhang, 2021; Woo, 2020; Woo, 2021). However, there is a lack of a systematic investigation of the various policy actors, their interactions, and networks across sectors during the pandemic. To address the above research gap, we investigate the role of the different policy actors, their issued policies, their target sector, and the interaction within and between different policy clusters for managing the COVID-19 pandemic in Singapore between January 2020 and February 2022. Our research questions include: What are the structures of policy networks during the COVID-19 pandemic? Learning from COVID-19, how can governments design/organise policy networks to manage future crises or pandemics? We answer the above research questions by investigating - Who are the key actors involved in policy formulation and implementation for managing COVID-19 in Singapore? What is the pattern of information exchange between key actors throughout the pandemic? How do these actors collaborate and cluster with each other across the various stages of the pandemic? This systematic policy network analysis will empirically contribute to understanding the cross-sectoral policy landscape in Singapore, drawing lessons for other jurisdictions and countries to manage future crises or events. Theoretically, this article will contribute a temporal perspective to understand policy networks as a crisis evolves.

Keywords: policy networks, policy subsystems, crisis management, COVID-19 pandemic

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Policy entrepreneur and institutional entrepreneur both are change agents, but not all change agents are policy entrepreneur, or institutional entrepreneur. The promising theoretical questions are: Why and under what circumstances does an agent combine the roles of policy and institutional entrepreneur (Baki, Akgunay, & Coban, 2021)? How? And what are the outcomes? in China, audit institution is under the steering of Central Audit Committee of the Communist Party of China (CPC), which means that it's a powerful independent oversight and external change agent. This article explores the efforts on promoting system-wide changes and answers the question: does audit institution combine the roles of policy and institutional entrepreneur?

After performing a phenomenological approach on the audit practices and their impacts, and then referring to the definition of policy and institutional entrepreneurs in the literature,the author probes into the roles of audit institution. This article suggests: (1) In the top-level design of China's national governance, audit institution is endow with dual roles to improve public policy and institutional system. (2) By connecting the problems in policy implementation and design, audit institution makes great efforts to promote policy and institutional changes simultaneously. (3) Audit institution actively coordinates with other change agents (policy and institutional entrepreneurs) to facilitate the desired changes. The author believes that more studies on the roles of audit institution will enrich the understanding on policy and institutional entrepreneurs in China, which maybe contribute to the literature.

CO-AUTHORS
Christopher Weible (University of Colorado Denver)
Maria Tullia Galanti (Università degli Studi di Milano)
Giliberto Capano (Università di Bologna)
ABSTRACT

Taking Agency Seriously in the Policy Process

 

Chris Weible, Evangelia Petridou, Karin Ingold, Tullia Galanti, Giliberto Capano

 

Theories of the policy process are tools that help us navigate the complexities of the repeated interactions among actors, contexts, events, contexts, and previous public policies that comprise the public policy making process (Weible, 2018). For a theory to have explanatory value, it must adequately tackle both the agentic power of actors and the structural conditions that foster or hinder the actions of these actors. In this conceptual paper, we argue that extant theories of the policy process, though to varying degrees of focus and emphasis account for agency, they suffer from three shortfalls: first, they treat agency as an independent variable, without clearly theorizing their emergence; second, labels attached to agents suffer from conceptual stretching and overlap, translation errors, and a general fuzziness, and third, agency tends to be treated as a residual variable. In this conceptual paper, we depart sharply from rational choice explanations of agentic behavior and instead we take stock of agentic action and theorize agency predicated on the concept of functions (Lasswell, 1956). These are tasks in the policy making process, which involve activities performed for the purpose of maintaining stability or inducing change. They are embedded in structures, but activated through actors, allowing us to differentiate between different agency types. We conclude with suggestions for operationalization and measurement.
 
References
Lasswell, Harold.D. 1956. “The Decision Process: Seven Categories of Functional Analysis.” College Park, MD: University of Maryland
Weible, Christopher M.  2018.  "Introduction: The Scope and Focus of Policy Process Research."  In Theories of the Policy Process, eds.  Christopher M. Weible and Paul A. Sabatier, 4th ed.  New York: Routledge.  1-13.
 

CO-AUTHORS
Josiel Valadares (Universidade Federal de Viçosa)
Magnus Emmendoerfer (Universidade Federal de Viçosa - UFV / UNESCO CHAIR CEPPBRASIL )
ABSTRACT

The literature on policy entrepreneurs has mainly focused on high-level decision-makers, ignoring low and middle-level bureaucrats. However, in light of their close position to citizens and the nature of activity, some recent works have been linking street-level bureaucrats (SLBs) with policy entrepreneurship. They highlight the use of entrepreneurial strategies by SLBs to influence policy via implementation practices and/or policy design. Immersed in a broad network that provides health services to children and women in all three levels of health assistance in Minas Gerais (MG), Brazil, Viva Vida Centers' (CVV) SLBs are in a very similar context to those normally approached in literature. Thus, this works main objective was to investigate the engagement of SLBs within CVVs Viçosa and Manhuaçu in entrepreneurial strategies to shape policy through implementation practices and/or directly influence policy design. Data collection was carried out through semi-structured interviews with bureaucrats from Cvvs Viçosa and Manhuaçu from 2020 to 2021. The results report the case of CVV Manhuaçu's former manager (I3). The case is chronologically divided into two distinct moments, considering the policy process literature. In the first moment, the manager of CVV Manhuaçu from 2010 to 2017, prompted by a lack of guidance for implementation and a high level of discretion, framed problems, planned processes, diffused her vision and actively led her team, successfully outlining the Center’s prototype, securing smooth implementation through consolidating strategies. Years later, when when a top-down change in policy struck, leaving hundreds unassisted, she ultimately acted to reinsert the issue of sexual violence and abuse victims into the official government agenda, aiming to promote policy change at the institucional level. It is argued that the use of entrepreneurial strategies can increase the chances of success for street-level bureaucrats in influencing policy outcomes, thus it is important to promote proactivity among the street-level bureaucracy, and place at their reach, political and governance instruments for political participation, once just favorable personal traits might not be enough.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Smart Specialisation has been a pivotal concept in EU Cohesion Policy over the last decade, arguably transforming innovation policy since its adoption in the 2014-20 programming period (Hassink & Gong, 2019). It has been characterised as the “largest innovation policy experiment in the world” (Radosevic & Stancova, 2018), by being implemented as an ex-ante conditionality for access to Cohesion funds, and by placing an emphasis on a place-based, collaborative, and bottom-up approach to the strategy and policy process (Uyarra, 2018). The framework of smart specialisation has also put innovation, entrepreneurship, and knowledge-based policies at the core of EU policy and regional development strategies (Marinelli & Perianez-Forte, 2017), with the goal to build on local assets and strengthen the regional innovation ecosystem. This has heightened the role of higher education and research institutions in the strategy process (Fonseca & Nieth, 2021).

 

This paper explores the role of universities as leaders, agents, and brokers in the smart specialisation strategy process and examines the impact of the high demands placed upon these institutions when navigating this policy space. The study compares the participation of three European universities - the University of Aveiro (Portugal), the Autonomous University of Barcelona (Spain), and the University of Twente (The Netherlands)  - in their regions' smart specialisation strategies as part of the researcher’s doctoral work (Fonseca, 2022). The conceptual framework draws on existing academic critiques of universities’ regional role and of smart specialisation (e.g., Sotarauta, 2018; Hassink & Gong, 2019; Kristensen et al., 2022), to understand current challenges in inter-institutional collaboration and innovation governance and provide insights for the new Cohesion Policy period.

 

The methodology employs a qualitative approach, using desk-based research of policy and institutional strategy documents and 88 in-depth interviews across the three case studies, as well as content and thematic analysis. The findings highlight the advantages and difficulties of universities' engagement in smart specialisation strategy processes and suggest alternative frameworks to navigate the policy traps. The paper concludes that universities play a crucial role in innovation and regional governance, but it is important to understand the limitations and challenges of their participation. Still, universities are emphasised as change agents critical to smart specialisation implementation. Findings also suggest there are dimensions in the implementation of smart specialisation that need to be further developed in the new period, such as capacity-building, inter-institutional and cross-region collaboration, policy implementation and innovation diffusion.

 

This study fits well with the conference panel titled "Agency in the Policy Process: Policy Entrepreneurs, Leaders, and Brokers," as it develops the concepts of policy entrepreneurs, leaders, and brokers in relation to universities and in the context of the smart specialisation strategy process, a widespread innovation and regional development policy process in the European Union and increasingly internationally. The paper contributes to the panel's discussions by providing insights into the engagement of a relevant regional stakeholder in the policy process, and by examining the challenges they face in adapting their roles, strategies, and resources in different phases of the policy process.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In 2017, several innovative basic income inspired policies (BIIP) were implemented in different cities of the world. Being this policy implemented, mainly, at the local level it raised the question about the factors for why a policy like this implemented at the local level? What were the key elements that triggered this policy? Many studies on policy innovation have focused their attention on the role of policy entrepreneurs and political leadership (Guldbrandsson and Fossum, 2009 and Rosas-Satizàbal and Rodriguez-Valencia, 2018). Policy entrepreneurs such as Mayors and city council members "advocate policy innovations and transform political arenas" (Mintröm, 2000). A theory that has its roots in John Kingdon’s multiple streams, which defined the policy entrepreneurs as "individuals or groups of individuals who propose alternative solutions to certain problems at key moments" (Kingdon, 1995 [1984]). They can be actors in the political communities (e.g., experts, mayors, aldermen), who work on promoting specific solutions to the problem (Araújo and Rodrigues, 2017).

                     This paper tries to relate the role of agency elements such as the leadership of entrepreneurs with the municipalistic projects by comparing two case studies. We used qualitative methods (semi-strutured interviews, focus group and documental analysis) to trace the policy-making process in both cases.

                     The Barcelona case acknowledges the idea of ‘new municipalism’, in which cities are seen as institutional actors and is an example of the connection between ‘new municipalism’ and European union in policy innovation in the social domain. The social position of policy entrepreneurs in the governance structure of city council was essential to promote social innovation. A new political organization with a municipalitistic project (agenda for change) characterized by a leftist ideology of putting themes like housing and municipal income onto the agenda and wanting to change European politics towards the citizens and the common good. Under this leadership it was possible for Barcelona to promote social innovation in two ways: leading the European networks of municipalism EUROCITIES and calling knowledge-based actors to design and implement an income policy for the city. Although the institutional settings were there for both municipalities – the Dutch with a new social assistance law (83º PA act/2015) which enabled them to innovate in the social domain and Barcelona with European policy instrument which allowed innovation in urban areas (delegated regulation of 522/2014 and ERDF article 8 of 2014) – the truth is that the difference in social innovation was due to the role of the policy entrepreneurs in city council.