Format

P17. Rethinking and Assessing Policy Change

POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Norma Munoz del Campo
Universidad de Santiago de Chile
Main chair
Melina de Souza Rocha Lukic
York University
Second chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

The main factors to explain policy change that have been discussed in the last decades have been related to different dimensions and approaches: advocacy coalitions, belief, and ideas; narratives and frames; policy networks, institutions, crises, and external shocks. In particular, the cognitive approach of public policies proposes a model based on a radical paradigm change to explain how a policy changes over time (Hall,1993). However, an analysis based only on the cognitive criteria has demonstrated its limits to explain gradual changes and to deal with more uncertain and messy dynamics. In the other hand, neo-institutionalism approaches have proposed a much more refined model to explain the policy change by transcending the notion of critical junctures and proposing a model based on incremental changes. This approaches also offer ways to overcome dualist views that separate periods of institutional stability and change. Nevertheless, the lack of precision, the static character of the agency model, and the overall low-explanatory power are the critics that have been made to this model (Van der Heijden and Kuhlmann, 2017 in Munoz-del-Campo and Rocha, 2020).
In addition, Knill, Schulze and Tosun (2010) state that the studies of change do not represent a coherent body of research and do not enshrine a concrete understanding concept of policy change. However, we stress here that these studies do provide ways to systematize and shape methods of measuring policy change that can be replicated. As such, we propose in this panel to discuss the explanatory power of the theories used so far to explain stasis and policy change.
This debate considers two dimensions of study: a first one regarding the meaning of change, which aims to contribute to specifying what change really means today and how it occurs. The second dimension refers to the different stages of change (such as: change in process, in the outputs, and in the outcomes): its real or transitory condition without neglecting the results of change that do not always contribute to strengthening public policies but also (and as we have seen strongly during the last decade) to dismantle it.
Finally, this panel aims to contribute to clarify a systematic and empirically concrete understanding of policy change as such and observe the real possibilities of measuring it and establishing causality.

CALL FOR PAPERS

In order to advance the understanding of how public policies evolve, this panel encourages papers that discuss the methodological and theoretical approaches which imply both conceptualizing the dependent variable of the policy change and independent variables to explain policy change.
More specifically, we propose a systematic way to assess policy change using an analytical grid of three levels (Munoz-del-Campo, 2021): 1. Scope: changes in a whole system or only part of the system; 2. Pace: fast or slow; 3. Mode: Gradual, incremental, radical, or brutal.  We also consider integrating the state of change: such as a change in process, the outputs, and the outcomes. And, finally, we propose a debate about the factors explaining, supporting, or impeding policy change and its "real" impact.

The panel invites papers contributing to the study of public policy change processes through analysis that connects ideas, institutions, interests, and context promoting the mixed-theory and mixed-factor frameworks to shape the analysis trying to measure change. Moreover, we are interested in understanding the role of the ambiguities faced to change public policy.
The panel is open to methodological and theoretical perspectives based on institutional and/or cognitive approaches and welcomes empirical papers related to all types of policies and all regions of the world.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Political Economy of Fishery Policy Reversal in Ayeyarwady region in Myanmar
Aung Thein (Chiang Mai University School of Public Policy)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This applied political economy study assesses the fisheries policy reversal in Ayeyarwady Region in Myanmar by reviewing the literature and combining it with the author's personal experiences. The study finds that the fisheries policy reversal (U-Turn) from fishery co-management and resource user participation to authoritarian resulted in mixed disadvantages among small-scale fishers. Most small-scale fishers in Ayeyarwady Region in Myanmar have suffered from loss of fishery access and other costs such as their livelihoods and social and environmental disruptions. The study makes three distinctive contributions to the literature. It contributes to understanding, firstly, the concept of ‘policy reversal’, secondly, to what extent are the politics surrounding the reversal of public policy distinct from the initial adoption of the policy, and thirdly, why the reversal occurred and its impact. The overall findings suggest that understanding the impact of policy reversals can be critical for preventing destructive policymaking and caution for consequences of reversal in the context of policy reforms for policymakers and scholars.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Understanding family policy change: under the trap of policy legacies
Martin Gurín (Universität Bremen)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Family policy has been in the process of updating. The ideas of marketization (of services), free choice, social investment, work-family balance and equal distribution of family-related tasks between women and men have proven influential across welfare states, even in those which have traditionally supported different or contradictory arrangements.

 

One of the most interesting and at the same time important aspects of this family policy change is the fact that it proceeded differently among welfare states. Thus we observe that these policies came to the agenda more forcefully in certain countries earlier than in others, distinguishing between ‘early birds’ and ‘latecomers’. Some countries have been more active in the involvement of care, with some countries undertaking moderate adjustments while others remain highly hesitant to do so. Consequently, there have been differences in the pace and the extent of family policy updates.

 

These differences have been found not only between the early birds and latecomers, but also among the early birds and latecomers themselves. Thus, for example, we see South Korea among the best achievers, undertaking a significant turnabout in the family policy paradigm; whereas countries such as the Czech Republic not yet successfully embarked on the agenda toward activist and successful reconciliation policies.

 

We did not yet arrive at the destination of a convincing explanation of why these differences exist. We are interested in how far does the concept of policy legacy help us explain the developments of childcare in different latecomer countries.

 

Our analysis focuses on one of the key policy options in addressing work-family reconciliation and social investment: childcare. This enables us, in addition, more space for in-depth investigation of the role of policy legacies in stability and change. We conduct a longitudinal analysis, covering a period between 2000 and 2022, recording successful reforms, as well as reform attempts (without approval) and withdrawals. The intended results of political intervention, as well as the reasons put forward in decision procedures, and reform decisions, are drawn from parliamentary discussions, government statements, strategic documents, TV debates, and media reports. To better understand the role of policy legacies, expert interviews are utilized: these we did with policy experts who write the rules and regulations and share the reality of childcare policy.

 

We believe that the role of policy legacies and their importance depends on two important aspects: the life span and number of policy legacies. Inherited policy legacies may be in place for a long time and be deeply-rooted, such as those institutionalized in well-established European welfare states. These may cause the policy change more problematic, welfare states appearing as ‘frozen landscapes’ trapped in their policy legacies. Young welfare states, instead, have a relatively recent tradition and experience with policy legacy and be thus more willing to change. In addition, welfare states may have one, but also several inherent policy legacies. All of them may, in one way or another, limit or impede the introduction of new ideas and their solutions – making the update of existing policy instruments particularly difficult.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Stability and Change: Multi-Streams and Ideational Explanation of Fee-Free Education Policy Adoption in Ghana
Mohammed Ibrahim (University of Manchester)
CO-AUTHORS
Owuraku Kusi-Ampofo (University of Alberta)
Abdul Karim Ibrahim (University of Ghana)
ABSTRACT

After decades of implementing neoliberally-induced cost-sharing senior secondary education, Ghana made a path-departing move to introduce a comprehensively free universal education. Although much has been written about the country’s free senior high school policy, little is known about how the issue of education access rose to the status of a national problem requiring a major policy shift. We combine insights from Kingdon’s Multiple Streams Framework, and ideational perspectives to investigate and explain the political factors and the agenda setting dynamics that led to the paradigmatic shift in high school financing in Ghana. The paper draws from elite interviews with government officials, members of parliaments, former ministers, civil society groups, and education experts and extensive review of secondary materials, including media publications, media interviews with key policy officials, legal and policy documents. We find that a change in government in 2016, the first time an incumbent President had lost power to an opposition candidate since the return to constitutional rule in 1992, created a ‘policy window’ for the New Patriotic Party (NPP) to actualise the free SHS idea. This was, however, made possible by the rise of new policy entrepreneurs with political commitment and the institutional leverage to provide a solution to an existing policy problem as well as financial capacity made possible through the country’s status as a new oil producing country.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Information Systems in the Service of Adaptive Climate Regulatory Response
Sivan-Sevilla Ido (University of Maryland)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Regulatory initiatives are an essential tool in contending with the unprecedented onslaught of extreme climate events, including wildfires, tsunami, hurricanes, heat waves and droughts. Yet regulatory systems tend to be static and slow, making it difficult to revise regulatory measures in response to dynamic conditions (Esty 2019, Marchant 2011). Consequently, current regulatory systems cannot match the pace and uncertainty of the climate crisis (Marchau et al. 2019, Mormann, 2021). In this paper, we suggest that information systems can provide crucial support to the agility of regulatory processes, promoting a resilient, adaptive regulatory approach that learns and updates in response to environmental triggers.

 

Notably, the capacity of technological tools to contribute to regulatory processes is often overlooked in broader efforts to understand how digital technologies can improve the safety of the planet (Boh et al. 2020, Rai 2020). In general, when policy change does occur, it tends to be crisis-driven, inspired by ‘focusing events’ (Birkland 1998) that successfully capture the limited attention of policymakers in bounded-rationality policymaking arenas (Lindblom 1959). The occurrence of a crisis, however, usually indicates that change is already overdue. Moreover, in practice, regulations formulated in times of crisis—in many cases, without preparation or sufficient analysis—may be excessive or ineffectually designed (Bennear & Wiener 2019).

 

Indeed, regulators commonly lack industry knowledge, and may produce regulatory measures that are hard to comply with and require constant correction (McCray et al. 2010). The latter shortcoming is particularly prominent in the domain of climate change, where we observe that regulators not only struggle to respond to uncertainties but also wrestle with designing proper measures for known complex climate problems (Wiener, 2002; Keohane and Victor, 2011)

In light of the weaknesses of current regulatory systems, regulatory science researchers are increasingly seeking to develop models of adaptive regulation, a much-needed mechanism for regulating in the face of uncertainty and complexity (International Risk Governance Council 2015, Mormann 2021, Walker et al. 2001).

 

To address the problem of climate change, we propose augmenting the notion of adaptive regulation by integrating technology as a fundamental element of the regulatory design process. Specifically, building on principles of adaptive regulation put forward by regulatory scholars across different regulatory domains (Bennear & Wiener 2019, Brass & Sowell 2021, McCray et al. 2010, Swanson et al., 2010), we outline a model for a digitally driven adaptive regulatory process, a model that is well suited to climate-related regulatory challenges. In this model, technology informs the regulatory process by facilitating real-time data collection and analysis, and by providing concrete thresholds, rules, and guidelines for application and enforcement. This model comprises three types of digitally-enabled learning cycles: (1) identification of new risks, (2) real-time monitoring of key known indicators of risk, and (3) enforcement guidance, i.e., assessment of the practical validity of regulations and of the likelihood and impact of non-compliance. These three cycles are described in detail in the paper and are illustrated with simple examples to produce informed & fast policy change.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Paradiplomacy as an instrument of policy change: the case of Brazilian states during the Covid-19 pandemic.
Mauricio Fronzaglia ( Mackenzie Presbyterian University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This article presents the study of the phenomenon of paradiplomacy as a vector for change in public policies, taking as an example the paradiplomatic performance of Brazilian subnational units, mainly the states of Maranhão and São Paulo, and their approaches to combat the COVID-19 pandemic.
International relations have been studying subnational units' actions for a long time. Its definition would be the international performance of subnational units that do not seek to form a new state. The action aimed at the independence of a subnational unit is known as protodiplomacy. In paradiplomacy, action can be in agreement and or conflict with the interests and guidelines of the national government. The focuses of studies are concentrated on the areas of international activities of the subnational units and in the federative organization of these actions. Paradiplomacy is a political strategy of a particular party in search of greater national and international projection. However, the study of paradiplomacy through public policy theories is still incipient. This work intends to fill part of this gap. This work also wants to understand the option for paradiplomacy as a vector of changes for local public policies.
The theoretical approach will be from the political sociology of public action from its three basic principles for understanding public policy: the sectoral-global relationship, the reference, and the interaction dynamics between the actors involved. The first key element concerns the relationship of a given sectoral policy with other public policies. This paper will approach the sectoral-global question for the federative levels. We want to explore federative issues of paradiplomacy through the sectoral-global relationship. The sectoral will be at the subnational level and the global at the federal level. About the reference, we want to know if paradiplomacy can be a vector for the paradigm shift in public policies of subnational units. Adopting an international insertion policy would present a degree of change for local public policies. Paradiplomacy brings the participation of new actors in the formulation and implementation of local public actions. This way, a new interaction dynamic has to be established between the actors involved.
COVID-19 presented several problems for constructing public policies that could combat the spread of the virus and its effects. Different federal entities took divergent actions for this task. Divergent steps led to a conflict between the federal government's indecision and the protagonism of some subnational units. Therefore, we intend to study the subnational units that opted for adopting paradiplomacy as a public policy in this specific pandemic scenario of adaptation and changes in public policies.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Three archetypical pathways for governing transformative change
Robbert Biesbroek (Wageningen University)
CO-AUTHORS
Catrien Termeer (Wageningen University)
Dewulf Art (Wageningen University)
ABSTRACT

Sustainability issues like climate change, biodiversity loss and land degradation are becoming increasingly critical and urgent across the globe [1]. Governments are expected to steward, prepare and drive change towards sustainability. But what do transformational change processes look like, what are possible governance interventions  for achieving sustainability transformations, and how can governments anticipate critical junctures or cherish its opportunities?

 

It is often assumed that transformational change is at the same time in-depth (doing things in a radically different way), system-wide (change with a broad scope), and quick (in the form of sudden or abrupt  change) [2]. Normative arguments strengthen these assumptions; global challenges call for an in-depth change of systems that are entrenched in a status quo and the lock-ins of undesirable practices, system-wide is needed because of the cross scaling urgencies, and only quick responses can help to prevent dangerous tipping points and critical junctions. We contend in previous work [2] that of the three transformational change characteristics, only two can be achieved simultaneously. When change is in-depth and system-wide, it is probably slow. When change is in-depth and quick, it probably has a narrow scope. When change is system-wide and quick, it is probably superficial.

 

The aim of this paper is to argue and demonstrate that these limitations provide the starting point for conceptualizing three archetypical pathways towards transformational change, each dealing differently with critical junctures. In-depth and system-wide changes, such as a major reorganisation of flood defense infrastructure, requires sufficient time for preparation, forming coalitions and making use of windows of opportunity [3]. In-depth and quick changes, such as radical local innovations, 'small wins' or local experiments, can be the starting point for broadening and upscaling change [4]. System-wide and quick changes, such as a mandatory energy labels for homes or appliances, can enable deepening change through increasingly profound applications and accelerate technical social and practical innovations.

 

Drawing from a range of sustainability examples we illustrate how these three pathways to transformational change have different starting assumptions, require different types of government support, policy interventions and governance capabilities, and possible side-effects.

 

References:

[1] Pörtner, H.O. et al (2021) Scientific outcome of the IPBES-IPCC co-sponsored workshop on biodiversity and climate change; IPBES secretariat, Bonn, Germany, DOI:10.5281/zenodo.4659158.

[2] Termeer, C.J.A.M. Dewulf, A. and R. Biesbroek (2017) Transformational change: governance interventions for climate change adaptation from a continuous change perspective, Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 60(4), 558-567

[3] Pot, W.D. Dewulf, A., Biesbroek, R., Van der Vlist, M., and C.J.A.M. Termeer (2018) What makes long-term investment decisions forward looking: A framework applied to the case of Amsterdam's new sea lock.  Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 132, 174-190

[4] Termeer, C. J. A. M., & Dewulf, A. (2019). A small wins framework to overcome the evaluation paradox of governing wicked problems. Policy and Society

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Green economy transition policies and governance: Explaining a punctuated socio-political regime change and causal mechanisms in South Africa, 2002-2022
Mapula Tshangela (University of Stellenbosch)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

RELEVANCE

The paper draws from policy change literature to explain punctuated policy regime shifts in sustainability transitions. The case of South Africa’s sustainability policy change is investigated within national economic cluster ministries over period 2002 to 2022.

 

QUESTION

The paper explains why government attention to sustainability policy issues takes place, how policy attention result in periodised punctuated socio-political regime change or stability and what are the underlying causal mechanisms and conditions.

 

LITERATURE

A novel punctuated socio-political regime notion is proposed for addressing knowledge gap in explaining sustainability policy dynamics and mechanisms. The notion is consistent with the required adjustments in socio-technical regime (rules and institutions), to operationalise “policies and governance structures” within the multi-level perspective (MLP) on sustainability transitions (Geels and Turnheim, 2022:9). The socio-political regime as embedded within the socio-technical regime of MLP is used in this paper to contextualise collective changes in policy regime dimensions of “power dynamics, paradigm commitments, state organisation and policy programmes” and to bring together the government sustainability policy action and political system interplay (Swilling et al, 2016:18, May, 2013, Wilson, 2000). We bring the punctuation concept to enable us “to describe and explain how public policy regimes break from patterns of marginal and incremental policy change towards more dramatic change at certain junctures” (Evert Lindquist and Adam Wellstead, 2020:23). The punctuation accounts for exogenous pressure and endogenous change in policies and governance mechanisms informed by knowledge processed during periods of government attention shifts (John and Bevan, 2012). Several causalities are at play, including institutional or structural change mechanisms through policy layering or cognitive behavioural mechanisms such as when governments act in accordance with signals from others (Beunen and Patterson, 2019, Biesbroek, G.R., Dupuis, J., and A. Wellstead, 2017).

 

METHOD

35 semi-structured interviews and 26 policy documents were qualitatively analysed in a critical realist autoethnographic approach. The lead author is part-time PhD candidate and full-time embedded within the policy venues as a senior government official.

 

PRELIMINARY FINDINGS

The South African punctuated policy attention is observed post 2008 exogenous global economic crisis in 2009, 2014 and 2019 when government administration cycles changed, following the national elections. The global crisis positive feedback mechanism triggers endogenous green economy policy ideas embedding and institutional arrangements. The peak punctuated policy attention is observed in 2011 with highest number of Cabinet policy pronouncements. 2019 is observed as the year with highest cumulative policies.

 

Policy learning mechanism is observed when policy makers learn from other countries, and also establish policy niches experiments such as the green fund. The policy layering mechanism is observed with green economy goals layered on top of existing dominant fossil fuel-based economic policies. The policy leadership and coordination mechanism are observed in 2009 when the Department of Trade and Industry and National Treasury ceased to be co-chairs of economic cluster. With cognitive behavioural mechanism, green economy ideas embedding is observed as a government response to be seen doing something by the global world. The country however periodically abandons sustainability commitments and resort to dominant economic policy stability

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Policy Paradigm Shift? Or Simply Incremental Change? : A History of Technology Policy from the First to the Fourth Industrial Revolutions in Thailand
Krityavara Wongsa (Chiang Mai University School of Public Policy)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The study of history is the study of causes, and of changes over time – and of a change that causes further changes in a continuum of time.  Technology, as in many other aspects of human life, is a cause, as well as a product, of a continuum of change.  And so is technology policy.  This paper examines the change in technology policies in Thailand from the turn of the 20th century until the present.  From a critical perspective, it discusses whether the change in technology policy and governance is a shift in its underlying paradigm or whether it is simply an incremental change, and in some cases, policy punctuation.  Although the arrival of what is deemed as modern technology from the western world to Thailand can be traced back to the arrival of the first European groups, the Portuguese, in 1511, nationwide adoption of modern technology has not taken place until the end of 19th century following the first industrial revolution; during that time Thailand was still under an absolute monarchy.  A century has flown by.  Thailand is now a democratic state, and with its national development agenda, dubbed Thailand 4.0.  The term mimics the phrase Industry 4.0—the Fourth Industrial Revolution, the German industrial strategy recently popularized by the World Economic Forum in 2016.  It has been argued that the Fourth Industrial Revolution will bring about a paradigm shift in technology policy.  How has technology policy—or a more generic term, technology governance—in Thailand changed over the period starting from the adoption of the technology of the First Industrial Revolution until the emerging technology of the Fourth Industrial Revolution at present? Is the change a paradigm shift? Or is it simply an incremental change?

This paper aims at tackling these questions by identifying the policy elements and determining how those elements have changed over time.  The policy elements include (i) policy strategies; (ii) policy goals; (iii) policy coherence; (iv) policy instruments; (v) institution; (vi) policy actors; (vii) policy design process; (viii) policy implementation; and (ix) policy evaluation.  A critical assessment is applied in the study of the changes in the aforementioned policy elements by employing literature and document analysis, historical analysis, and in-depth interviews as the main methods.  How and to what extent a policy change needs happening to be classified as a paradigm shift is critically analyzed broadly based on the literature on policy change, policy punctuation, and policy paradigm shift.  Using the case of technology policy change in Thailand, this paper develops a framework for identifying different types of policy changes along with their characteristics.  This framework would, by and large, contribute to the literature on policy change and critical policy study as well as policy practice in the real world.  The framework would help shading light on whether, when, and how a novel practice of policy design is deemed necessary.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Opportunities and barriers in the application of local policies in Mexico of the UN Women, Peace and Security Agenda
Dainzú López de Lara E. (Universidad de las Américas Puebla, Mexico)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In 2000, the publication of Security Council Resolution 1325 officially placed the role of women in peace processes on the political agenda. Each of the countries that ratified this document launched its own National Action Plan (but not all of them) to implement public policies related to this issue. The case of Mexico is the most recent and innovative, since it seeks to make visible and provide tools to women who are already carrying out peacebuilding processes in their communities, by creating local networks called "Mujeres Constructoras de Paz - MUCPAZ" (Women Peace Builders). This implies a change in the traditional security policy where women are no longer seen only as victims in conflicts, and where their agency is recognized.

This is an alternative strategy for achieving security and peace in the country, and that the activities carried out vary from place to place, it is imperative to conduct a study of this federal policy and its implementation at the local level. For this purpose, it is necessary to consider the factors that could influence the actions performed. Thus, through a comparative study of two MUCPAZ networks, one in Oaxaca and the other in Puebla. This article seeks to identify the extent to which the feminist movement, local institutions, and the level of insecurity influence the implementation of this public policy. The foreign feminist policy was selected because, according to Reverter Bañón (2012), Bashevkin (2018) and Ducanson (2016), it is of great importance in the creation of feminist policies and their impact on women public officials. In the case of institutions, they are included given that most of them have a masculinist character (Aggestam and E. Towns, 2018), and being a fundamental part of the definition of a public policy, they can represent an obstacle in its implementation. Finally, insecurity is analyzed because its eradication requires a policy of recognition and redistribution (Ducanson, 2016, and Fraser and Butler, 2017). Therefore, depending on the level of insecurity in which the community finds itself, certain types of policies will be implemented.

To perform such analysis, the proposed tool is a matrix that integrates the scope, pace, and mode of each of the variables described above. The aim is to identify those factors that support and those that hinder the implementation of the policy. To obtain the appropriate data, a mixed methodology will be used, with official and non-governmental statistics for the level of security, and interviews with officials and women involved in the MUCPAZ networks in Oaxaca and Puebla, Mexico. With the interviews with women peacebuilders, we will be able to measure the impact of this federal policy and the training that the government gives to these women.

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - Tracing the Process of Institutional Change: Racial Equality Public Policies in the Brazilian Federal Government between 2000 and 2014
TATIANA SILVA (Instituto de Pesquisa Econômica Aplicada - IPEA)
CO-AUTHORS
Suylan Midlej (University of Brasilia )
Paulo Calmon (Universidade de Brasília)
ABSTRACT

The purpose of this paper is to analyze the process of agenda setting and institutional change of policies aimed to combat structured racism and racial discrimination in Brazil. Only recently, this issue has entered the public agenda. Until then, authorities downplayed the existence of any trace of structured racism, arguing that Brazil was a harmonious racial democracy. Affirmative actions were restricted only to a set of specific initiatives aimed to preserve the cultural heritage of Afro-Brazilians or as a part of a rhetoric targeted to avoid bursts of racial violence.

Brazil has a long history of racial discrimination. Even after the official end of slavery in 1888, racism has continued to spread all over society. Despite the fact that the large majority of the Brazilian population declares itself as non-whites, the need for affirmative action policies were recognized as an issue only in the early 2000s, mainly as the result of the pressure coming from society, specially through the advocacy efforts of the Brazilian black movement as its allies, that resulted in the creation of the Department of Racial Equality Policies, in the year 2003.

Given this scenario, this paper attempts to describe and analyze the process that  led to this new policy agenda. In other words: how were racial equality policies inserted and integrated within the federal government in Brazil between the years 2000 and 2014? This period begins with the preparatory discussions and arrangements for Brazil’s participation in the III World Conference Against Racism, Racial Discrimination, Xenophobia and Related Intolerances, promoted by the United Nations, and that took place in Durban (South Africa) in the year 2001, until the end of the first governmental period of the Brazilian president Dilma Rousseff.

As a longitudinal case study, this paper adopts the tenets of process tracing to analyze the process of agenda setting and institutional change involving policies related to combat structured racism in Brazil. Therefore, a timeline was developed, divided into three periods and a background section. The first (2000 to 2002) refers to the pre-conference period and its immediate aftermath. In the second period (2003-2009), is when the first attempts to implement racial equality policies were institutionalized. The last period (2010-2014) incorporates the policy consolidation phase, when regulations allowed an expansion process. Documental and bibliographical research and interviews were used as the research base.

As a conclusion, the paper maintains that the process of insertion of racial equality policies in Brazilian policy agenda can be understood as the result of a set of causal mechanisms that includes factors such as international pressure, institutional tension and normative validation. As a result, there was a trajectory of gradual institutional change, combining different modes: layering, conversion and drifting. (Mahoney and Thelen, 2010). This research is linked to the panel's research questions as it also focuses on the debate about gradual institutional change, related to a combination of different frameworks and methodologies to analyze how ideas, interests, and institutions shaped policies to combat structured racism and promote affirmative actions in Brazil.

ACCEPTED
Format
11 - An analysis of policy change of health care governance in Sweden
Emma Bergstedt (Linköping University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In Sweden, health care is formally politically governed on several governance levels. The regional authorities, governed by elected politicians, are responsible for the main part of the financing as well as the provision of health care. The regional politicians’ main responsibilities are to decide on taxation, allocate the public resources and to formulate political goals and strategies. Their democratic assignment means that citizens can influence health care policy through the politicians and hold them accountable.

Governing authorities in Sweden have however during the last two decades increasingly relied on a form of management which is called “knowledge-driven management” when regulating health care. The primary method for implementing knowledge-driven management in health care organizations is different kinds of expert guidelines specifying “best practices”. In Sweden, both the guidelines and the national organizations for the production of guidelines have become increasingly comprehensive and complex. In 2018 an encompassing and complex organisation called “The national system for knowledge-driven management” was established.

Previous research indicates that national knowledge-driven management is part of a process of centralisation, standardization and technocratization of health care governance in Sweden. Very little is however known about this policy change of health care governance in Sweden.

The overall aim of the study is to analyze policy narratives about an organization for national knowledge-driven management in Sweden and how the narratives have developed historically. An analysis of policy documents authored by different actors in the time period 1999-2022 and subsequent interviews with key actors will be carried out.

The scope, pace and mode of the policy change will be analysed by employing tools from narrative policy analysis and frameworks from previous research about rationales in the construction of public policies for health care. In research about the construction of target groups of health care policy and the underlying rationales, different types of reasoning for the justification and legitimation of the different policies have been identified. Rationales can for example be technocratic/scientific, cultural, social, or political. This taxonomy of categories of rationales has illustrated how reasoning about the same target groups can change over time and contexts.

Exploring policy narratives in this way is especially useful for mapping connections between actors, ideas, institutions, and contexts. The scope, pace and mode of the policy change of health care governance can be explained by identifying the narrative elements, how they are labelled and what values and rationales that are attached to them by what actor and in what context or time period. By extension, this study can contribute to the understanding of public policy change processes in more general terms.

ACCEPTED
Format
12 - Revisiting stability and change: An evaluation of approaches to measurement under Punctuated Equilibrium Theory
Corinne Connor (West Virginia University)
CO-AUTHORS
Samuel Workman (West Virginia University)
ABSTRACT

Scholars of the policy process have systematically compared the budgetary dynamics of countries, states, and local governments and found overwhelming empirical support that consistently depicts policy change as disjoint and episodic over time (Jones et al. 2009; Breunig and Koski 2006). While proponents of Punctuated Equilibrium Theory have used a stochastic processes approach to studying policy change for over two decades, attention has recently been drawn to potential issues of sensitivity and reliability when using l-kurtosis scores to measure these punctuations. The l-kurtosis measure has additionally been criticized due to difficulties in its interpretability – while scholars can compare l-kurtosis values between change distributions, we cannot determine whether or not these observed differences are statistically significant. Kaplaner and Steinebach (2022) suggest using the Gini coefficient as an alternative measure to assess the dispersion between change values of different budgetary categories. They argue that the Gini coefficient is useful in allowing scholars to determine where these large punctuations occur in a way that demonstrates the “inequality”, or disjointedness, of policy change as the theory suggests. Other scholars produce measures for both punctuated and incremental policy change using an estimation-based modeling approach using the t-distribution (Fernández-i-Marín et al. 2022). This paper aims to revisit and evaluate the stochastic processes approach in direct comparison to alternative measures. We test all three measures of policy change using county-level expenditure data from Kentucky, Ohio, and West Virginia between 2012-2022. Our findings suggest that the appropriateness of the measures and methods used in the context of Punctuated Equilibrium Theory are determined by the scope of the research question(s) being addressed, the level of analysis, and number of observations within the dataset.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This applied political economy study assesses the fisheries policy reversal in Ayeyarwady Region in Myanmar by reviewing the literature and combining it with the author's personal experiences. The study finds that the fisheries policy reversal (U-Turn) from fishery co-management and resource user participation to authoritarian resulted in mixed disadvantages among small-scale fishers. Most small-scale fishers in Ayeyarwady Region in Myanmar have suffered from loss of fishery access and other costs such as their livelihoods and social and environmental disruptions. The study makes three distinctive contributions to the literature. It contributes to understanding, firstly, the concept of ‘policy reversal’, secondly, to what extent are the politics surrounding the reversal of public policy distinct from the initial adoption of the policy, and thirdly, why the reversal occurred and its impact. The overall findings suggest that understanding the impact of policy reversals can be critical for preventing destructive policymaking and caution for consequences of reversal in the context of policy reforms for policymakers and scholars.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Family policy has been in the process of updating. The ideas of marketization (of services), free choice, social investment, work-family balance and equal distribution of family-related tasks between women and men have proven influential across welfare states, even in those which have traditionally supported different or contradictory arrangements.

 

One of the most interesting and at the same time important aspects of this family policy change is the fact that it proceeded differently among welfare states. Thus we observe that these policies came to the agenda more forcefully in certain countries earlier than in others, distinguishing between ‘early birds’ and ‘latecomers’. Some countries have been more active in the involvement of care, with some countries undertaking moderate adjustments while others remain highly hesitant to do so. Consequently, there have been differences in the pace and the extent of family policy updates.

 

These differences have been found not only between the early birds and latecomers, but also among the early birds and latecomers themselves. Thus, for example, we see South Korea among the best achievers, undertaking a significant turnabout in the family policy paradigm; whereas countries such as the Czech Republic not yet successfully embarked on the agenda toward activist and successful reconciliation policies.

 

We did not yet arrive at the destination of a convincing explanation of why these differences exist. We are interested in how far does the concept of policy legacy help us explain the developments of childcare in different latecomer countries.

 

Our analysis focuses on one of the key policy options in addressing work-family reconciliation and social investment: childcare. This enables us, in addition, more space for in-depth investigation of the role of policy legacies in stability and change. We conduct a longitudinal analysis, covering a period between 2000 and 2022, recording successful reforms, as well as reform attempts (without approval) and withdrawals. The intended results of political intervention, as well as the reasons put forward in decision procedures, and reform decisions, are drawn from parliamentary discussions, government statements, strategic documents, TV debates, and media reports. To better understand the role of policy legacies, expert interviews are utilized: these we did with policy experts who write the rules and regulations and share the reality of childcare policy.

 

We believe that the role of policy legacies and their importance depends on two important aspects: the life span and number of policy legacies. Inherited policy legacies may be in place for a long time and be deeply-rooted, such as those institutionalized in well-established European welfare states. These may cause the policy change more problematic, welfare states appearing as ‘frozen landscapes’ trapped in their policy legacies. Young welfare states, instead, have a relatively recent tradition and experience with policy legacy and be thus more willing to change. In addition, welfare states may have one, but also several inherent policy legacies. All of them may, in one way or another, limit or impede the introduction of new ideas and their solutions – making the update of existing policy instruments particularly difficult.

CO-AUTHORS
Owuraku Kusi-Ampofo (University of Alberta)
Abdul Karim Ibrahim (University of Ghana)
ABSTRACT

After decades of implementing neoliberally-induced cost-sharing senior secondary education, Ghana made a path-departing move to introduce a comprehensively free universal education. Although much has been written about the country’s free senior high school policy, little is known about how the issue of education access rose to the status of a national problem requiring a major policy shift. We combine insights from Kingdon’s Multiple Streams Framework, and ideational perspectives to investigate and explain the political factors and the agenda setting dynamics that led to the paradigmatic shift in high school financing in Ghana. The paper draws from elite interviews with government officials, members of parliaments, former ministers, civil society groups, and education experts and extensive review of secondary materials, including media publications, media interviews with key policy officials, legal and policy documents. We find that a change in government in 2016, the first time an incumbent President had lost power to an opposition candidate since the return to constitutional rule in 1992, created a ‘policy window’ for the New Patriotic Party (NPP) to actualise the free SHS idea. This was, however, made possible by the rise of new policy entrepreneurs with political commitment and the institutional leverage to provide a solution to an existing policy problem as well as financial capacity made possible through the country’s status as a new oil producing country.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Regulatory initiatives are an essential tool in contending with the unprecedented onslaught of extreme climate events, including wildfires, tsunami, hurricanes, heat waves and droughts. Yet regulatory systems tend to be static and slow, making it difficult to revise regulatory measures in response to dynamic conditions (Esty 2019, Marchant 2011). Consequently, current regulatory systems cannot match the pace and uncertainty of the climate crisis (Marchau et al. 2019, Mormann, 2021). In this paper, we suggest that information systems can provide crucial support to the agility of regulatory processes, promoting a resilient, adaptive regulatory approach that learns and updates in response to environmental triggers.

 

Notably, the capacity of technological tools to contribute to regulatory processes is often overlooked in broader efforts to understand how digital technologies can improve the safety of the planet (Boh et al. 2020, Rai 2020). In general, when policy change does occur, it tends to be crisis-driven, inspired by ‘focusing events’ (Birkland 1998) that successfully capture the limited attention of policymakers in bounded-rationality policymaking arenas (Lindblom 1959). The occurrence of a crisis, however, usually indicates that change is already overdue. Moreover, in practice, regulations formulated in times of crisis—in many cases, without preparation or sufficient analysis—may be excessive or ineffectually designed (Bennear & Wiener 2019).

 

Indeed, regulators commonly lack industry knowledge, and may produce regulatory measures that are hard to comply with and require constant correction (McCray et al. 2010). The latter shortcoming is particularly prominent in the domain of climate change, where we observe that regulators not only struggle to respond to uncertainties but also wrestle with designing proper measures for known complex climate problems (Wiener, 2002; Keohane and Victor, 2011)

In light of the weaknesses of current regulatory systems, regulatory science researchers are increasingly seeking to develop models of adaptive regulation, a much-needed mechanism for regulating in the face of uncertainty and complexity (International Risk Governance Council 2015, Mormann 2021, Walker et al. 2001).

 

To address the problem of climate change, we propose augmenting the notion of adaptive regulation by integrating technology as a fundamental element of the regulatory design process. Specifically, building on principles of adaptive regulation put forward by regulatory scholars across different regulatory domains (Bennear & Wiener 2019, Brass & Sowell 2021, McCray et al. 2010, Swanson et al., 2010), we outline a model for a digitally driven adaptive regulatory process, a model that is well suited to climate-related regulatory challenges. In this model, technology informs the regulatory process by facilitating real-time data collection and analysis, and by providing concrete thresholds, rules, and guidelines for application and enforcement. This model comprises three types of digitally-enabled learning cycles: (1) identification of new risks, (2) real-time monitoring of key known indicators of risk, and (3) enforcement guidance, i.e., assessment of the practical validity of regulations and of the likelihood and impact of non-compliance. These three cycles are described in detail in the paper and are illustrated with simple examples to produce informed & fast policy change.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This article presents the study of the phenomenon of paradiplomacy as a vector for change in public policies, taking as an example the paradiplomatic performance of Brazilian subnational units, mainly the states of Maranhão and São Paulo, and their approaches to combat the COVID-19 pandemic.
International relations have been studying subnational units' actions for a long time. Its definition would be the international performance of subnational units that do not seek to form a new state. The action aimed at the independence of a subnational unit is known as protodiplomacy. In paradiplomacy, action can be in agreement and or conflict with the interests and guidelines of the national government. The focuses of studies are concentrated on the areas of international activities of the subnational units and in the federative organization of these actions. Paradiplomacy is a political strategy of a particular party in search of greater national and international projection. However, the study of paradiplomacy through public policy theories is still incipient. This work intends to fill part of this gap. This work also wants to understand the option for paradiplomacy as a vector of changes for local public policies.
The theoretical approach will be from the political sociology of public action from its three basic principles for understanding public policy: the sectoral-global relationship, the reference, and the interaction dynamics between the actors involved. The first key element concerns the relationship of a given sectoral policy with other public policies. This paper will approach the sectoral-global question for the federative levels. We want to explore federative issues of paradiplomacy through the sectoral-global relationship. The sectoral will be at the subnational level and the global at the federal level. About the reference, we want to know if paradiplomacy can be a vector for the paradigm shift in public policies of subnational units. Adopting an international insertion policy would present a degree of change for local public policies. Paradiplomacy brings the participation of new actors in the formulation and implementation of local public actions. This way, a new interaction dynamic has to be established between the actors involved.
COVID-19 presented several problems for constructing public policies that could combat the spread of the virus and its effects. Different federal entities took divergent actions for this task. Divergent steps led to a conflict between the federal government's indecision and the protagonism of some subnational units. Therefore, we intend to study the subnational units that opted for adopting paradiplomacy as a public policy in this specific pandemic scenario of adaptation and changes in public policies.

CO-AUTHORS
Catrien Termeer (Wageningen University)
Dewulf Art (Wageningen University)
ABSTRACT

Sustainability issues like climate change, biodiversity loss and land degradation are becoming increasingly critical and urgent across the globe [1]. Governments are expected to steward, prepare and drive change towards sustainability. But what do transformational change processes look like, what are possible governance interventions  for achieving sustainability transformations, and how can governments anticipate critical junctures or cherish its opportunities?

 

It is often assumed that transformational change is at the same time in-depth (doing things in a radically different way), system-wide (change with a broad scope), and quick (in the form of sudden or abrupt  change) [2]. Normative arguments strengthen these assumptions; global challenges call for an in-depth change of systems that are entrenched in a status quo and the lock-ins of undesirable practices, system-wide is needed because of the cross scaling urgencies, and only quick responses can help to prevent dangerous tipping points and critical junctions. We contend in previous work [2] that of the three transformational change characteristics, only two can be achieved simultaneously. When change is in-depth and system-wide, it is probably slow. When change is in-depth and quick, it probably has a narrow scope. When change is system-wide and quick, it is probably superficial.

 

The aim of this paper is to argue and demonstrate that these limitations provide the starting point for conceptualizing three archetypical pathways towards transformational change, each dealing differently with critical junctures. In-depth and system-wide changes, such as a major reorganisation of flood defense infrastructure, requires sufficient time for preparation, forming coalitions and making use of windows of opportunity [3]. In-depth and quick changes, such as radical local innovations, 'small wins' or local experiments, can be the starting point for broadening and upscaling change [4]. System-wide and quick changes, such as a mandatory energy labels for homes or appliances, can enable deepening change through increasingly profound applications and accelerate technical social and practical innovations.

 

Drawing from a range of sustainability examples we illustrate how these three pathways to transformational change have different starting assumptions, require different types of government support, policy interventions and governance capabilities, and possible side-effects.

 

References:

[1] Pörtner, H.O. et al (2021) Scientific outcome of the IPBES-IPCC co-sponsored workshop on biodiversity and climate change; IPBES secretariat, Bonn, Germany, DOI:10.5281/zenodo.4659158.

[2] Termeer, C.J.A.M. Dewulf, A. and R. Biesbroek (2017) Transformational change: governance interventions for climate change adaptation from a continuous change perspective, Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 60(4), 558-567

[3] Pot, W.D. Dewulf, A., Biesbroek, R., Van der Vlist, M., and C.J.A.M. Termeer (2018) What makes long-term investment decisions forward looking: A framework applied to the case of Amsterdam's new sea lock.  Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 132, 174-190

[4] Termeer, C. J. A. M., & Dewulf, A. (2019). A small wins framework to overcome the evaluation paradox of governing wicked problems. Policy and Society

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

RELEVANCE

The paper draws from policy change literature to explain punctuated policy regime shifts in sustainability transitions. The case of South Africa’s sustainability policy change is investigated within national economic cluster ministries over period 2002 to 2022.

 

QUESTION

The paper explains why government attention to sustainability policy issues takes place, how policy attention result in periodised punctuated socio-political regime change or stability and what are the underlying causal mechanisms and conditions.

 

LITERATURE

A novel punctuated socio-political regime notion is proposed for addressing knowledge gap in explaining sustainability policy dynamics and mechanisms. The notion is consistent with the required adjustments in socio-technical regime (rules and institutions), to operationalise “policies and governance structures” within the multi-level perspective (MLP) on sustainability transitions (Geels and Turnheim, 2022:9). The socio-political regime as embedded within the socio-technical regime of MLP is used in this paper to contextualise collective changes in policy regime dimensions of “power dynamics, paradigm commitments, state organisation and policy programmes” and to bring together the government sustainability policy action and political system interplay (Swilling et al, 2016:18, May, 2013, Wilson, 2000). We bring the punctuation concept to enable us “to describe and explain how public policy regimes break from patterns of marginal and incremental policy change towards more dramatic change at certain junctures” (Evert Lindquist and Adam Wellstead, 2020:23). The punctuation accounts for exogenous pressure and endogenous change in policies and governance mechanisms informed by knowledge processed during periods of government attention shifts (John and Bevan, 2012). Several causalities are at play, including institutional or structural change mechanisms through policy layering or cognitive behavioural mechanisms such as when governments act in accordance with signals from others (Beunen and Patterson, 2019, Biesbroek, G.R., Dupuis, J., and A. Wellstead, 2017).

 

METHOD

35 semi-structured interviews and 26 policy documents were qualitatively analysed in a critical realist autoethnographic approach. The lead author is part-time PhD candidate and full-time embedded within the policy venues as a senior government official.

 

PRELIMINARY FINDINGS

The South African punctuated policy attention is observed post 2008 exogenous global economic crisis in 2009, 2014 and 2019 when government administration cycles changed, following the national elections. The global crisis positive feedback mechanism triggers endogenous green economy policy ideas embedding and institutional arrangements. The peak punctuated policy attention is observed in 2011 with highest number of Cabinet policy pronouncements. 2019 is observed as the year with highest cumulative policies.

 

Policy learning mechanism is observed when policy makers learn from other countries, and also establish policy niches experiments such as the green fund. The policy layering mechanism is observed with green economy goals layered on top of existing dominant fossil fuel-based economic policies. The policy leadership and coordination mechanism are observed in 2009 when the Department of Trade and Industry and National Treasury ceased to be co-chairs of economic cluster. With cognitive behavioural mechanism, green economy ideas embedding is observed as a government response to be seen doing something by the global world. The country however periodically abandons sustainability commitments and resort to dominant economic policy stability

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The study of history is the study of causes, and of changes over time – and of a change that causes further changes in a continuum of time.  Technology, as in many other aspects of human life, is a cause, as well as a product, of a continuum of change.  And so is technology policy.  This paper examines the change in technology policies in Thailand from the turn of the 20th century until the present.  From a critical perspective, it discusses whether the change in technology policy and governance is a shift in its underlying paradigm or whether it is simply an incremental change, and in some cases, policy punctuation.  Although the arrival of what is deemed as modern technology from the western world to Thailand can be traced back to the arrival of the first European groups, the Portuguese, in 1511, nationwide adoption of modern technology has not taken place until the end of 19th century following the first industrial revolution; during that time Thailand was still under an absolute monarchy.  A century has flown by.  Thailand is now a democratic state, and with its national development agenda, dubbed Thailand 4.0.  The term mimics the phrase Industry 4.0—the Fourth Industrial Revolution, the German industrial strategy recently popularized by the World Economic Forum in 2016.  It has been argued that the Fourth Industrial Revolution will bring about a paradigm shift in technology policy.  How has technology policy—or a more generic term, technology governance—in Thailand changed over the period starting from the adoption of the technology of the First Industrial Revolution until the emerging technology of the Fourth Industrial Revolution at present? Is the change a paradigm shift? Or is it simply an incremental change?

This paper aims at tackling these questions by identifying the policy elements and determining how those elements have changed over time.  The policy elements include (i) policy strategies; (ii) policy goals; (iii) policy coherence; (iv) policy instruments; (v) institution; (vi) policy actors; (vii) policy design process; (viii) policy implementation; and (ix) policy evaluation.  A critical assessment is applied in the study of the changes in the aforementioned policy elements by employing literature and document analysis, historical analysis, and in-depth interviews as the main methods.  How and to what extent a policy change needs happening to be classified as a paradigm shift is critically analyzed broadly based on the literature on policy change, policy punctuation, and policy paradigm shift.  Using the case of technology policy change in Thailand, this paper develops a framework for identifying different types of policy changes along with their characteristics.  This framework would, by and large, contribute to the literature on policy change and critical policy study as well as policy practice in the real world.  The framework would help shading light on whether, when, and how a novel practice of policy design is deemed necessary.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In 2000, the publication of Security Council Resolution 1325 officially placed the role of women in peace processes on the political agenda. Each of the countries that ratified this document launched its own National Action Plan (but not all of them) to implement public policies related to this issue. The case of Mexico is the most recent and innovative, since it seeks to make visible and provide tools to women who are already carrying out peacebuilding processes in their communities, by creating local networks called "Mujeres Constructoras de Paz - MUCPAZ" (Women Peace Builders). This implies a change in the traditional security policy where women are no longer seen only as victims in conflicts, and where their agency is recognized.

This is an alternative strategy for achieving security and peace in the country, and that the activities carried out vary from place to place, it is imperative to conduct a study of this federal policy and its implementation at the local level. For this purpose, it is necessary to consider the factors that could influence the actions performed. Thus, through a comparative study of two MUCPAZ networks, one in Oaxaca and the other in Puebla. This article seeks to identify the extent to which the feminist movement, local institutions, and the level of insecurity influence the implementation of this public policy. The foreign feminist policy was selected because, according to Reverter Bañón (2012), Bashevkin (2018) and Ducanson (2016), it is of great importance in the creation of feminist policies and their impact on women public officials. In the case of institutions, they are included given that most of them have a masculinist character (Aggestam and E. Towns, 2018), and being a fundamental part of the definition of a public policy, they can represent an obstacle in its implementation. Finally, insecurity is analyzed because its eradication requires a policy of recognition and redistribution (Ducanson, 2016, and Fraser and Butler, 2017). Therefore, depending on the level of insecurity in which the community finds itself, certain types of policies will be implemented.

To perform such analysis, the proposed tool is a matrix that integrates the scope, pace, and mode of each of the variables described above. The aim is to identify those factors that support and those that hinder the implementation of the policy. To obtain the appropriate data, a mixed methodology will be used, with official and non-governmental statistics for the level of security, and interviews with officials and women involved in the MUCPAZ networks in Oaxaca and Puebla, Mexico. With the interviews with women peacebuilders, we will be able to measure the impact of this federal policy and the training that the government gives to these women.

CO-AUTHORS
Suylan Midlej (University of Brasilia )
Paulo Calmon (Universidade de Brasília)
ABSTRACT

The purpose of this paper is to analyze the process of agenda setting and institutional change of policies aimed to combat structured racism and racial discrimination in Brazil. Only recently, this issue has entered the public agenda. Until then, authorities downplayed the existence of any trace of structured racism, arguing that Brazil was a harmonious racial democracy. Affirmative actions were restricted only to a set of specific initiatives aimed to preserve the cultural heritage of Afro-Brazilians or as a part of a rhetoric targeted to avoid bursts of racial violence.

Brazil has a long history of racial discrimination. Even after the official end of slavery in 1888, racism has continued to spread all over society. Despite the fact that the large majority of the Brazilian population declares itself as non-whites, the need for affirmative action policies were recognized as an issue only in the early 2000s, mainly as the result of the pressure coming from society, specially through the advocacy efforts of the Brazilian black movement as its allies, that resulted in the creation of the Department of Racial Equality Policies, in the year 2003.

Given this scenario, this paper attempts to describe and analyze the process that  led to this new policy agenda. In other words: how were racial equality policies inserted and integrated within the federal government in Brazil between the years 2000 and 2014? This period begins with the preparatory discussions and arrangements for Brazil’s participation in the III World Conference Against Racism, Racial Discrimination, Xenophobia and Related Intolerances, promoted by the United Nations, and that took place in Durban (South Africa) in the year 2001, until the end of the first governmental period of the Brazilian president Dilma Rousseff.

As a longitudinal case study, this paper adopts the tenets of process tracing to analyze the process of agenda setting and institutional change involving policies related to combat structured racism in Brazil. Therefore, a timeline was developed, divided into three periods and a background section. The first (2000 to 2002) refers to the pre-conference period and its immediate aftermath. In the second period (2003-2009), is when the first attempts to implement racial equality policies were institutionalized. The last period (2010-2014) incorporates the policy consolidation phase, when regulations allowed an expansion process. Documental and bibliographical research and interviews were used as the research base.

As a conclusion, the paper maintains that the process of insertion of racial equality policies in Brazilian policy agenda can be understood as the result of a set of causal mechanisms that includes factors such as international pressure, institutional tension and normative validation. As a result, there was a trajectory of gradual institutional change, combining different modes: layering, conversion and drifting. (Mahoney and Thelen, 2010). This research is linked to the panel's research questions as it also focuses on the debate about gradual institutional change, related to a combination of different frameworks and methodologies to analyze how ideas, interests, and institutions shaped policies to combat structured racism and promote affirmative actions in Brazil.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In Sweden, health care is formally politically governed on several governance levels. The regional authorities, governed by elected politicians, are responsible for the main part of the financing as well as the provision of health care. The regional politicians’ main responsibilities are to decide on taxation, allocate the public resources and to formulate political goals and strategies. Their democratic assignment means that citizens can influence health care policy through the politicians and hold them accountable.

Governing authorities in Sweden have however during the last two decades increasingly relied on a form of management which is called “knowledge-driven management” when regulating health care. The primary method for implementing knowledge-driven management in health care organizations is different kinds of expert guidelines specifying “best practices”. In Sweden, both the guidelines and the national organizations for the production of guidelines have become increasingly comprehensive and complex. In 2018 an encompassing and complex organisation called “The national system for knowledge-driven management” was established.

Previous research indicates that national knowledge-driven management is part of a process of centralisation, standardization and technocratization of health care governance in Sweden. Very little is however known about this policy change of health care governance in Sweden.

The overall aim of the study is to analyze policy narratives about an organization for national knowledge-driven management in Sweden and how the narratives have developed historically. An analysis of policy documents authored by different actors in the time period 1999-2022 and subsequent interviews with key actors will be carried out.

The scope, pace and mode of the policy change will be analysed by employing tools from narrative policy analysis and frameworks from previous research about rationales in the construction of public policies for health care. In research about the construction of target groups of health care policy and the underlying rationales, different types of reasoning for the justification and legitimation of the different policies have been identified. Rationales can for example be technocratic/scientific, cultural, social, or political. This taxonomy of categories of rationales has illustrated how reasoning about the same target groups can change over time and contexts.

Exploring policy narratives in this way is especially useful for mapping connections between actors, ideas, institutions, and contexts. The scope, pace and mode of the policy change of health care governance can be explained by identifying the narrative elements, how they are labelled and what values and rationales that are attached to them by what actor and in what context or time period. By extension, this study can contribute to the understanding of public policy change processes in more general terms.

CO-AUTHORS
Samuel Workman (West Virginia University)
ABSTRACT

Scholars of the policy process have systematically compared the budgetary dynamics of countries, states, and local governments and found overwhelming empirical support that consistently depicts policy change as disjoint and episodic over time (Jones et al. 2009; Breunig and Koski 2006). While proponents of Punctuated Equilibrium Theory have used a stochastic processes approach to studying policy change for over two decades, attention has recently been drawn to potential issues of sensitivity and reliability when using l-kurtosis scores to measure these punctuations. The l-kurtosis measure has additionally been criticized due to difficulties in its interpretability – while scholars can compare l-kurtosis values between change distributions, we cannot determine whether or not these observed differences are statistically significant. Kaplaner and Steinebach (2022) suggest using the Gini coefficient as an alternative measure to assess the dispersion between change values of different budgetary categories. They argue that the Gini coefficient is useful in allowing scholars to determine where these large punctuations occur in a way that demonstrates the “inequality”, or disjointedness, of policy change as the theory suggests. Other scholars produce measures for both punctuated and incremental policy change using an estimation-based modeling approach using the t-distribution (Fernández-i-Marín et al. 2022). This paper aims to revisit and evaluate the stochastic processes approach in direct comparison to alternative measures. We test all three measures of policy change using county-level expenditure data from Kentucky, Ohio, and West Virginia between 2012-2022. Our findings suggest that the appropriateness of the measures and methods used in the context of Punctuated Equilibrium Theory are determined by the scope of the research question(s) being addressed, the level of analysis, and number of observations within the dataset.