Format

P01. Asymmetric Neighbours and International Relations: Living in the Shadow of Elephants

COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Thomas Klassen
York University
Main chair
Ian Roberge
York University
Second chair
Nara Park
Yonsei University
Third chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

 

Relations between neighbours dominate the history of civilization, and likely even before the invention of writing and record keeping. The most ancient records describe the struggles and interaction between neighbouring tribes, settlements, villages, clans, houses, dynasties, city-sates, empires and others.

 

In the past two centuries the nation-state proliferated across the globe and replaced other forms of political actors. Today relationships are nearly always between sovereign national governments. A new academic discipline – international relations – has arisen to study and explain the relations between modern nations.

 

After the end of the First World War multilateral relationships have become more important than in the past, and it seemed that bilateral relations would become minor.  The creation of the League of Nations and its successor the United Nations and the rivalry of the Cold War decades made multilateral relations more central than ever. Multilateral trade agreements proliferated, often supported by the World Trade Organization, and a plethora of agencies, such as the World Health Organization, came into existence, along with other multilateral fora such as the World Bank. In addition, regional agreements and organizations, most notably the European Union, arose on every continent. It appeared that bilateral relations might gradually but eventually be subsumed by global or at least regional forms of governance. 

 

Yet, the fall of the Soviet Union, a less powerful United States on the world stage and increasing nationalism, and the failure of the multilateral arrangement to deliver on promises, heralded an increase or resurgence in the role of bilateral relationships between neighbours. Arguably during the first quarter century of the 21st millennium bilateral dynamics have increased in importance and their impact remains paramount.

 

The most prominent recent example is the Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022. Civil wars, such as in Syria, Yemen, Ethiopia and in other nations have taken on bilateral or multilateral dimensions as neighbouring countries intervene. Notwithstanding the global supply chain, the majority of trade remains between neighbouring nations. The United States exports more to, and imports more from, its two neighbours (Canada and Mexico) than it does with China. Similarly, China trades more with its regional neighbours than it does with the United States. 

 

Notwithstanding the rise of multilateral and regional groups (most notably is the European Union), bilateral relations remain at the core of many of the current multilateral forums, whether regional or international organizations.

 

Relationships – whether bilateral, that is between two nations, or multilateral – take any number of forms: from warfare to cooperation on a specific project of development. Almost by definition relationships are asymmetrical in that no two or three or more nations are entirely equal in all regards.

CALL FOR PAPERS

The rise and return of populism and nativism, the intensity of the competition between the United States, China and Russia, the lack of coordination and collaboration between states in response to the pandemic, all highlight the challenges of international and bilateral relations in the third decade of the twenty-first century.

 

Smaller states, in particular, living beside a larger country are affected by the politics and priorities of their neighbors. This timely panel will examine and compare asymmetrical bilateral relations between states sharing a border from the perspective of the smaller of the two neighbors. The panel is not anchored in a particular theoretical tradition but rather seeks to explore what is most significant in the relationship from the standpoint of the smaller state, whether that be political, economic, social, or cultural.

 

Questions and topics to be analyzed include: What are the implications of living in the shadow of an elephant? How are smaller states influenced by their neighbor, and how do they manage that relationship?

 

Drawing from multiple illustrative cases from around the world, the panel will highlights the complexity of asymmetrical bilateral relations as well as the implications for smaller countries regarding policymaking, including foreign policy, and for citizens in general.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - The Asymmetric India Pakistan Relations: A Theoretical Insight
Muhammad Arif Khan
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In 1947, the decolonization process of south Asia paved for the emergence of India Pakistan as separate nations. Since their inception as nation states they locked their horn into an enduring rivalry. Kashmir remained an unfinished plan and rather a bone of contention between both states. India called Kashmir as its 'integral part', however, Pakistan as its ‘jugular vein’. Throughout history, their relations remained bumpy and have been marred by the elements of trust deficit, bitter memories and enemy formation-identity issues. Evidently, there is a huge power asymmetry between both states in terms of economy, military, landmass and population but still they fought three full fledge and one limited war in Kargil, in 1999. Moreover, the ‘Pokhran I’ paved way for the nuclearisation of South Asia and a continuous missile and nuclear arms race between both nations. Their relations is not only affecting them but also the whole South Asia region. This study will address and analyze the following questions; Why India-Pakistan have enduring rivalry? How power politics, identity and bitter memories are affecting the relations of both states? What are the core issues between them?  Why they could not manage their conflict?

 

Key Words: India, Pakistan, Power Asymmetry, Conflict, Identity Issues

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - “Zeitenwende”: Sudden Change or Tipping Point of a Long-term Trend of Changing Perceptions?
Julian Plottka (Universität Passau)
CO-AUTHORS
Florence Reiter
ABSTRACT

The Russian war on Ukraine and its consequences for foreign policy are associated with the term “Zeitenwende”. It describes European actors’ changing perception of Russia. More precisely, a rejection of the concept of cooperation and a shift towards considering Russia a competitor or antagonist.

The paper examines whether this change began with the Russian attack against Ukraine in February 2022 or whether it can be considered a long-term development. As the Russian aggression is also affecting the EU’s relations with most states in the post-Soviet region, the paper does not exclusively focus on EU-Russia relations, but includes an analysis of the EU’s relations with the Eurasian Economic Union (EEU) and its member states.

 

The conceptual framework of the analysis is the “role theory” approach (Kirste/Maull), especially the conceptual division of “alter part” and “ego part” for the constitution of role understandings of foreign policy actors. Therefore, the paper will apply blended reading by combining distant reading (quantitative algorithm-based analysis) with close reading ( qualitative content analysis) to examine to what degree the EU’s self-perception in its relations with the EEU has changed during the decade before 2/24 and to what extend the perception of the EEU and its member states has changed during the same period. The corpus of documents includes all official EU documents containing the term “Eurasian” between 2011 and 2021.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - The Ties that Tangle: Is the Canada-US Co-Existence a Symbiotic Relationship or Complex Asymmetrical Entanglement?
Charles Conteh (Brock University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This proposed paper will examine the asymmetrical relationship between Canada and the United States, shedding light on the broad contours of their differences and focusing on the implications for Canada, the smaller of the two neighbours. While highlighting historical, cultural, institutional, and political differences, and their spillovers into Canada’s foreign and domestic policies, a large part of the discussion will focus on the economic relations between the two countries. Canada and the United States are economically intertwined with trade relations that represent the second largest globally (after US-China trade). However, economic entanglement does not always mean reciprocity or shared interests. This proposed paper will thus examine the existential crossroads of the two countries’ bilateral economic ties along with the historical, political, and geopolitical elements of their geographically interwoven coexistence. The discussion will interrogate whether these bonds of shared existence constitute a symbiotic relationship or a complex entanglement of asymmetry when viewed from the vantage point of Canada.

In addressing the above, the paper will first provide a broader context of the asymmetrical relationship between the two countries. This will involve viewing the relationship from Canada’s lens, offering a panoramic portrait of the two neighbours’ historical, demographic, geographic, political, social, and economic differences. The discussion will also provide a few examples to shed light on several prisms of the interwoven complexity of proximity, differences, and interdependence in the context of asymmetrical bilateral relations. Finally, the discussion will highlight the implications of asymmetry for Canada, the smaller and more vulnerable of the two countries. It will elucidate how Canada has, throughout its history since its founding years and up to the present day, managed and continues to manage the relationship with its assertive neighbour. In particular, the paper will highlight cases of Canadian border regions in several provinces sharing binational economic corridors with the US. The aim is to illustrate how they navigate this complex bilateral relationship to blunt the effect of asymmetry and advance their socioeconomic interests.

The discussion will conclude by encapsulating the asymmetrical contours of the relationship between the two neighbours and highlighting what they mean for Canada and countries in a similar position worldwide. It will argue that while Canada’s experience may be unique in some respects, especially given its middle-power status and global influence, nevertheless, the challenges of living next door to the world’s largest economic and military superpower offer critical lessons for other countries that find themselves tethered and bound by the chains of geography to a larger neighbour under whose overarching shadow they exist.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Non-Following Russia, China, and the EU: Kazakhstan’s Vision to Leadership Claims of the Three Big Elephants
Zhanibek Arynov (Nazarbayev University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Kazakhstan's geopolitical location is challenging. In the north, it shares a 7000 km-long border with Russia, and in the east, its border with China stretches for 1700 km. These two ‘elephants’ have become increasingly assertive in their external affairs, especially in the course of the last decade. If, in the case of China, such assertiveness can be tied to the promotion of the BRI first announced in Kazakhstan in 2013, Russia’s assertiveness became more visible with Vladimir Putin reassuming presidential power in 2012, which later led to the annexation of Crimea in 2014 and the full-fledged war against Ukraine in 2022. In such a challenging geopolitical environment Kazakhstan has to look for other non-regional actors like the EU to balance against Moscow and Beijing. All these big players claim to have something to ‘offer’ to Central Asians and to a certain degree compete for a leadership role in the region.

 

This paper analyzes how different domestic actors in Kazakhstan relate to the leadership claims of these three external actors: Russia, China, and the EU. The theoretical premise of the paper is that leadership is a social role, which needs to be recognized by potential followers. In that sense, no external player can unilaterally claim leadership in Central Asia because such a claim is subject to the acceptance of Central Asians. The paper focuses on how the potential leadership of Russia, China, and the EU is interpreted by the official, expert, and public discourses in Kazakhstan. Such an approach will reveal the complexity of the domestic dynamics of recognizing or rejecting leadership claims of big external powers in small countries like Kazakhstan. The paper argues that acceptance/rejection of external powers’ leadership claims in Kazakhstan is actor- and issue-specific. In other words, the acceptance/rejection of leadership may vary across different domestic actors, as well as across issue-areas at stake. But in general terms, Kazakhstan should be classified rather as a non-follower of the mentioned external actors, which tries to balance against the pressure of external 'elephants', and has its own ambitions to lead the other countries of Central Asia.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Living in the Shadow of Elephants: The Case of Timor-Leste
Nicholas Morris (La Trobe University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The indigenous population of Timor-Leste has lived on the island for over 40,000 years. The first elephant, Portugal, saw them as a source of slaves and then colonized, waging war against local kingdoms and killing around 5% of the local population. Even as an ‘overseas province’ little investment was made in healthcare, education or infrastructure. The second elephant, Japan, invaded during World War II, killed 10-15% of the population, and used the Timorese women as “comfort women” for its troops. The third elephant, Indonesia, invaded in 1975 after Portugal abandoned its colony and undertook systematic genocide and displacement of the population, killing up to 30% of the population. It was only in 2002 that Timor-Leste achieved independence. The fourth elephant, Australia, abandoned Timor-Leste to the Japanese, turned a blind eye to human rights abuses in the 1975-1999 period, and sought to extract oil and gas resources from the infant nation in underhand ways. The fifth elephant, China, has provided support in the post-independence period.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Sri Lanka: Indo-Sino Competition, Rise of Sinhala Buddhist Majoritarianism, Democratic Backsliding – A Public Policy Crisis
Jawad Hussain Qureshi (Privy Council Office, Government of Canada)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Since the early 2000’s, Sri Lanka has seen the rise members of the Rajapaksa family who have served as PMs, Presidents and family members in key civil, bureaucratic and political positions, built a personality cult, used the civil war which ended in 2009, and Sinhalese Buddhist majoritarianism to cement their permanence in the island nations politics. The Rajapaksas used deepening ties with China to play against India, a longstanding regional dominant force, to extract political and economic benefits. The strategy worked for some time until populist, unworkable public and economic policy measures brought Sri Lanka into an economic crisis in 2022, resulting in Sri Lanka to default on its foreign debt for the first time in its history since independence. The paper will provide a concise review of literature and analytical frameworks for addressing policy change in the context of democratic backsliding and illiberal populism. This paper examines the rise of Sinhala Buddhist chauvinism in Sri Lanka and democratic backsliding in the country, how the domestic politics got wedded into an Indo-Sino contestations, and the public policy measures and processes that brought Sri Lanka into economic ruin and political disarray.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - The Middle-Power Diplomacy of South Korea: Four Strategic Choices vis-à-vis Japan and China
Nara Park (Yonsei University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This chapter examines the determinants of South Korean foreign policy and outlines its prospects. Due to South Korea’s geographical location, it has historically been a battleground between land and sea powers. Japan, the closest sea power, and China, the closest land power, have had the most significant influence. Additionally, although the United States is not geographically adjacent, it has had a special impact on South Korea by forming the liberal democratic camp that includes Japan. Similarly, Russia has had an influence on South Korea, although it has played a much smaller role. With its economy growing and democratization advancing, South Korea’s presidents have placed a greater emphasis on projecting the country’s self-image as an autonomous, middle-power nation. Specifically, a four-type approach has been observed: tilting, hedging, balancing, and status quo, depending on the level of foreign policy proactivity and independence exhibited. Success from these strategies has provided temporary stability and peace, but when the balance of power has been disrupted, there has been an increase in uncertainty, if not a definite crisis. South Korea’s geopolitical conditions and path-dependent choices will continue to influence its foreign policy, creating a dynamic and multidimensional relationship with the elephants whose shadow South Korea may or may not eventually move beyond.

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Legacies of a Trans-Tasman relationship The evolution of asymmetry between New Zealand and Australia
Jennifer Curtin (University of Auckland)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

When British explorer James Cook came searching for a southern continent, it was both New Zealand and the New South Wales of Australia that he mapped in 1769-1770.  This initial journey was followed rapidly by British colonization of six Australian colonies and New Zealand.  One hundred years later, intercolonial conferences were held to discuss trade, defence, communications, and a federation of the Australasian colonies. Ultimately, New Zealand chose to remain independent of Australia, although the Australian Constitution of 1901 included clauses to allow for a later accession for colonies such as New Zealand.  A review of these early Trans-Tasman conversations reveals a desire for cooperation as well as competing political interests and the emergence of two distinct nationalisms. Over time there have been ebbs and flows in the degree of asymmetry and connectedness, with growing differences in size and scale interpreted to mean the relationship has always been more important to New Zealand than Australia. For the most part, studies of the Trans-Tasman relationship have focused on foreign affairs, trade, and people. They make a case that the exogenous factors that pull these geographically contiguous countries together overshadow asymmetrical dependency and the inevitable tensions that arise as a result.  We review whether the merits of these arguments still hold, given recent divergence in approaches to immigration, human rights, and engagement with Asia.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Russia-Ukraine War: Understanding the Global South’s Vote at the UN
Mahama Tawat
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Although geographically confined to Europe, the war between Russia and Ukraine has reverberated around the world. The emergency special session of the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) that took place on 02 March 2022 - the first one in 40 years - shortly after Russia's invasion was the earliest of these manifestations. Arguably, it was also the biggest stress test of geopolitical and strategic alliances since the end of the Cold War. Using tenets of conflict analysis, this paper seeks to explain the behaviour of the Global south in light of the Emergency special session's four voting rounds. It argues that the liberal-illiberal divide explains better support and opposition to the resolutions. Interests, however defined, was a complementary factor.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In 1947, the decolonization process of south Asia paved for the emergence of India Pakistan as separate nations. Since their inception as nation states they locked their horn into an enduring rivalry. Kashmir remained an unfinished plan and rather a bone of contention between both states. India called Kashmir as its 'integral part', however, Pakistan as its ‘jugular vein’. Throughout history, their relations remained bumpy and have been marred by the elements of trust deficit, bitter memories and enemy formation-identity issues. Evidently, there is a huge power asymmetry between both states in terms of economy, military, landmass and population but still they fought three full fledge and one limited war in Kargil, in 1999. Moreover, the ‘Pokhran I’ paved way for the nuclearisation of South Asia and a continuous missile and nuclear arms race between both nations. Their relations is not only affecting them but also the whole South Asia region. This study will address and analyze the following questions; Why India-Pakistan have enduring rivalry? How power politics, identity and bitter memories are affecting the relations of both states? What are the core issues between them?  Why they could not manage their conflict?

 

Key Words: India, Pakistan, Power Asymmetry, Conflict, Identity Issues

CO-AUTHORS
Florence Reiter
ABSTRACT

The Russian war on Ukraine and its consequences for foreign policy are associated with the term “Zeitenwende”. It describes European actors’ changing perception of Russia. More precisely, a rejection of the concept of cooperation and a shift towards considering Russia a competitor or antagonist.

The paper examines whether this change began with the Russian attack against Ukraine in February 2022 or whether it can be considered a long-term development. As the Russian aggression is also affecting the EU’s relations with most states in the post-Soviet region, the paper does not exclusively focus on EU-Russia relations, but includes an analysis of the EU’s relations with the Eurasian Economic Union (EEU) and its member states.

 

The conceptual framework of the analysis is the “role theory” approach (Kirste/Maull), especially the conceptual division of “alter part” and “ego part” for the constitution of role understandings of foreign policy actors. Therefore, the paper will apply blended reading by combining distant reading (quantitative algorithm-based analysis) with close reading ( qualitative content analysis) to examine to what degree the EU’s self-perception in its relations with the EEU has changed during the decade before 2/24 and to what extend the perception of the EEU and its member states has changed during the same period. The corpus of documents includes all official EU documents containing the term “Eurasian” between 2011 and 2021.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This proposed paper will examine the asymmetrical relationship between Canada and the United States, shedding light on the broad contours of their differences and focusing on the implications for Canada, the smaller of the two neighbours. While highlighting historical, cultural, institutional, and political differences, and their spillovers into Canada’s foreign and domestic policies, a large part of the discussion will focus on the economic relations between the two countries. Canada and the United States are economically intertwined with trade relations that represent the second largest globally (after US-China trade). However, economic entanglement does not always mean reciprocity or shared interests. This proposed paper will thus examine the existential crossroads of the two countries’ bilateral economic ties along with the historical, political, and geopolitical elements of their geographically interwoven coexistence. The discussion will interrogate whether these bonds of shared existence constitute a symbiotic relationship or a complex entanglement of asymmetry when viewed from the vantage point of Canada.

In addressing the above, the paper will first provide a broader context of the asymmetrical relationship between the two countries. This will involve viewing the relationship from Canada’s lens, offering a panoramic portrait of the two neighbours’ historical, demographic, geographic, political, social, and economic differences. The discussion will also provide a few examples to shed light on several prisms of the interwoven complexity of proximity, differences, and interdependence in the context of asymmetrical bilateral relations. Finally, the discussion will highlight the implications of asymmetry for Canada, the smaller and more vulnerable of the two countries. It will elucidate how Canada has, throughout its history since its founding years and up to the present day, managed and continues to manage the relationship with its assertive neighbour. In particular, the paper will highlight cases of Canadian border regions in several provinces sharing binational economic corridors with the US. The aim is to illustrate how they navigate this complex bilateral relationship to blunt the effect of asymmetry and advance their socioeconomic interests.

The discussion will conclude by encapsulating the asymmetrical contours of the relationship between the two neighbours and highlighting what they mean for Canada and countries in a similar position worldwide. It will argue that while Canada’s experience may be unique in some respects, especially given its middle-power status and global influence, nevertheless, the challenges of living next door to the world’s largest economic and military superpower offer critical lessons for other countries that find themselves tethered and bound by the chains of geography to a larger neighbour under whose overarching shadow they exist.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Kazakhstan's geopolitical location is challenging. In the north, it shares a 7000 km-long border with Russia, and in the east, its border with China stretches for 1700 km. These two ‘elephants’ have become increasingly assertive in their external affairs, especially in the course of the last decade. If, in the case of China, such assertiveness can be tied to the promotion of the BRI first announced in Kazakhstan in 2013, Russia’s assertiveness became more visible with Vladimir Putin reassuming presidential power in 2012, which later led to the annexation of Crimea in 2014 and the full-fledged war against Ukraine in 2022. In such a challenging geopolitical environment Kazakhstan has to look for other non-regional actors like the EU to balance against Moscow and Beijing. All these big players claim to have something to ‘offer’ to Central Asians and to a certain degree compete for a leadership role in the region.

 

This paper analyzes how different domestic actors in Kazakhstan relate to the leadership claims of these three external actors: Russia, China, and the EU. The theoretical premise of the paper is that leadership is a social role, which needs to be recognized by potential followers. In that sense, no external player can unilaterally claim leadership in Central Asia because such a claim is subject to the acceptance of Central Asians. The paper focuses on how the potential leadership of Russia, China, and the EU is interpreted by the official, expert, and public discourses in Kazakhstan. Such an approach will reveal the complexity of the domestic dynamics of recognizing or rejecting leadership claims of big external powers in small countries like Kazakhstan. The paper argues that acceptance/rejection of external powers’ leadership claims in Kazakhstan is actor- and issue-specific. In other words, the acceptance/rejection of leadership may vary across different domestic actors, as well as across issue-areas at stake. But in general terms, Kazakhstan should be classified rather as a non-follower of the mentioned external actors, which tries to balance against the pressure of external 'elephants', and has its own ambitions to lead the other countries of Central Asia.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The indigenous population of Timor-Leste has lived on the island for over 40,000 years. The first elephant, Portugal, saw them as a source of slaves and then colonized, waging war against local kingdoms and killing around 5% of the local population. Even as an ‘overseas province’ little investment was made in healthcare, education or infrastructure. The second elephant, Japan, invaded during World War II, killed 10-15% of the population, and used the Timorese women as “comfort women” for its troops. The third elephant, Indonesia, invaded in 1975 after Portugal abandoned its colony and undertook systematic genocide and displacement of the population, killing up to 30% of the population. It was only in 2002 that Timor-Leste achieved independence. The fourth elephant, Australia, abandoned Timor-Leste to the Japanese, turned a blind eye to human rights abuses in the 1975-1999 period, and sought to extract oil and gas resources from the infant nation in underhand ways. The fifth elephant, China, has provided support in the post-independence period.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Since the early 2000’s, Sri Lanka has seen the rise members of the Rajapaksa family who have served as PMs, Presidents and family members in key civil, bureaucratic and political positions, built a personality cult, used the civil war which ended in 2009, and Sinhalese Buddhist majoritarianism to cement their permanence in the island nations politics. The Rajapaksas used deepening ties with China to play against India, a longstanding regional dominant force, to extract political and economic benefits. The strategy worked for some time until populist, unworkable public and economic policy measures brought Sri Lanka into an economic crisis in 2022, resulting in Sri Lanka to default on its foreign debt for the first time in its history since independence. The paper will provide a concise review of literature and analytical frameworks for addressing policy change in the context of democratic backsliding and illiberal populism. This paper examines the rise of Sinhala Buddhist chauvinism in Sri Lanka and democratic backsliding in the country, how the domestic politics got wedded into an Indo-Sino contestations, and the public policy measures and processes that brought Sri Lanka into economic ruin and political disarray.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This chapter examines the determinants of South Korean foreign policy and outlines its prospects. Due to South Korea’s geographical location, it has historically been a battleground between land and sea powers. Japan, the closest sea power, and China, the closest land power, have had the most significant influence. Additionally, although the United States is not geographically adjacent, it has had a special impact on South Korea by forming the liberal democratic camp that includes Japan. Similarly, Russia has had an influence on South Korea, although it has played a much smaller role. With its economy growing and democratization advancing, South Korea’s presidents have placed a greater emphasis on projecting the country’s self-image as an autonomous, middle-power nation. Specifically, a four-type approach has been observed: tilting, hedging, balancing, and status quo, depending on the level of foreign policy proactivity and independence exhibited. Success from these strategies has provided temporary stability and peace, but when the balance of power has been disrupted, there has been an increase in uncertainty, if not a definite crisis. South Korea’s geopolitical conditions and path-dependent choices will continue to influence its foreign policy, creating a dynamic and multidimensional relationship with the elephants whose shadow South Korea may or may not eventually move beyond.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

When British explorer James Cook came searching for a southern continent, it was both New Zealand and the New South Wales of Australia that he mapped in 1769-1770.  This initial journey was followed rapidly by British colonization of six Australian colonies and New Zealand.  One hundred years later, intercolonial conferences were held to discuss trade, defence, communications, and a federation of the Australasian colonies. Ultimately, New Zealand chose to remain independent of Australia, although the Australian Constitution of 1901 included clauses to allow for a later accession for colonies such as New Zealand.  A review of these early Trans-Tasman conversations reveals a desire for cooperation as well as competing political interests and the emergence of two distinct nationalisms. Over time there have been ebbs and flows in the degree of asymmetry and connectedness, with growing differences in size and scale interpreted to mean the relationship has always been more important to New Zealand than Australia. For the most part, studies of the Trans-Tasman relationship have focused on foreign affairs, trade, and people. They make a case that the exogenous factors that pull these geographically contiguous countries together overshadow asymmetrical dependency and the inevitable tensions that arise as a result.  We review whether the merits of these arguments still hold, given recent divergence in approaches to immigration, human rights, and engagement with Asia.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Although geographically confined to Europe, the war between Russia and Ukraine has reverberated around the world. The emergency special session of the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) that took place on 02 March 2022 - the first one in 40 years - shortly after Russia's invasion was the earliest of these manifestations. Arguably, it was also the biggest stress test of geopolitical and strategic alliances since the end of the Cold War. Using tenets of conflict analysis, this paper seeks to explain the behaviour of the Global south in light of the Emergency special session's four voting rounds. It argues that the liberal-illiberal divide explains better support and opposition to the resolutions. Interests, however defined, was a complementary factor.