CATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
The objective of this panel is to explore comparative policy approaches across the Global South towards building resilience, writ large. Resilience policies have grown in popularity across international and sectoral bounds (e.g., climate, economic, supply chain, cyber resilience, and so on). However, much is yet to be understood about the emergence and nature of resilience policies from the Global South. Echoing theoretical debates between policy transfer versus policy diffusion, this panel seeks to bring together a diversity of empirical cases to enable more nuanced, comparative analyses of the kinds of resilience policies emerging in the Global South. To what extent are they unique or original relative to Global North policy counterparts? What kind of domestic and international drivers can be identified (e.g., policy funders, academic discourses, domestic politics, etc)? What do resilience policy discourses and policy-making dynamics look like when shifting across spatial levels (e.g., local, national, regional, global)?
In bringing together these diverse perspectives, this panel seeks to make three contributions to the current literature. First is in convening a more concerted view of resilience policy approaches from the Global South, in contrast to prior emphasis on Northern actors (e.g., the European Union, the United States). Second is in unpacking the black box of resilience policy-making to examine the extent to which Southern actors exhibit political agency over policy-making processes. Third is in feeding specific insights from the recent rise of resilience policy into general debates surrounding policy transfer versus policy mobility in international policy.
CALL FOR PAPERS
Papers are welcomed on resilience policy discourses and/or resilience policy-making processes in the Global South. The geographical and sectoral scope remains otherwise intentionally open-ended. Three further specifications to guide potential contributions include the following:
(1) Papers with empirical insights centred on resilience policies as emerging from Global South actors, organisations, and/or processes.
(2) Papers are welcome to include analyses incorporating the Global North, so long as they do not remain exclusive or centred on Northern dynamics.
(3) Papers with theoretical implications that respond (either directly or implicitly) to debates surrounding policy transfer versus policy mobility.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The North-South divide in resilience knowledge production is not only quantitative but also evident in the core of models and tools. This is primarily because the policy transfer literature emphasizes the importance of knowledge and the role of intentional processes (agency). In contrast, structural, interest-based, and unintentional processes are frequently a part of diffusion. Post-2014 foreign policy framework of India has seen vivid application and inculcation of ancient Indian philosophy of 'Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam' in climate diplomacy strategies. This phase emphatically determines the consistency of political agency over policy-making processes in a structured overview of the state of the art in policy diffusion. As climate change intensifies and natural disasters become more frequent, especially the global south is susceptible to its severe consequences & effects.
Further, India's take on global climate resilience policies based on an all-embrassing outlook that embodies collective progress as one universal family, transcending borders, cultures, and ideologies, has ushered principles and values in supporting multilateral action on climate catastrophe. Though globally more than 3500 climate policies are in action, rarely do they embrace earth as a global family outlook in its application. For the past decade, India’s climate diplomacy has been based on five major determinants: Geography, Population, Outlook, Application and Impacts with a Clear, Consistent and Coordinated strategy. The triple gem of India's effective climate diplomacy discourse since 2014 includes the International Solar Alliance (ISA), launched in 2015; the Coalition for Disaster Resilient Infrastructure (CDRI), launched at the 2019 UN Climate Action Summit; and the Global Biofuel Alliance (GBA), one of the priorities under India’s G20 Presidency, announced during the G20 New Delhi summit, September 2023. This indigenous policy approach signifies specific insights from the recent rise of resilience policy into general debates surrounding policy transfer versus policy mobility in international policy.
In the above context, the present study investigates an evolving approach from an Indian diplomacy perspective in addressing global climate concerns leading the way for the global south. The study makes cross-sectional analysis to understand climate sustainability and resilience configuration in India’s resilience policy framework. It draws on the notion of a multi-level approach by using the resilience policy matrix. By using secondary data sources, the study looks into the compatibility outlook of ISA-CDRI-GBA in epitomizing India’'s role as a catalytic platform to act as a robust repository of knowledge to meet inclusive climate action imperatives in pursuit of strategic objectives in Indian climate diplomacy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This study examines the influence of national cultural characteristics on the management of infectious disease disasters. Focusing on the COVID-19 pandemic, this study examines cultural factors across countries including South Korea, Indonesia, and the Philippines. This research also investigates the impact of cultural dimensions conceptualized by Hofstede’s cultural dimensions such as power distance, individualism, uncertainty avoidance, and long-term orientation on public health responses. The analysis utilizes the COVID-19 Stringency Index and pandemic indicators including death rates, testing, vaccination coverage to assess the effects of these cultural variables. The findings indicate that higher levels of individualism and uncertainty avoidance are associated with increased death rates. Additionally, power distance significantly affects COVID-19 testing leading to lower testing rates. Furthermore, the effectiveness of stringent government policies is found to be contingent upon cultural context. While stricter policies were solely associated with negative COVID-19 outcomes, the interaction between policy stringency and cultural dimensions produced more nuanced effects. This study provides theoretical and practical implications of designing culturally tailored strategies to improve the effectiveness of infectious disease disaster management.
Author : Sung Min Park
Co-Authors :
JungHwan Ryu,
Gabeen Lee,
Jian Lee,
Chaeyoon Kim.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Disaster risk management (DRM) is an important aspect of governance, requiring defined legal frameworks to ensure preparedness, mitigation, and response. India’s Disaster Management Act (DMA), 2005, transitioned the country’s approach from reactive relief-based measures to a structured, multi-dimensional system for disaster governance. Evolving disaster risks, including climate change, urban vulnerabilities, and socioeconomic disparities, have necessitated revisions to the existing legal framework. The Disaster Management (Amendment) Bill, 2024, introduces significant updates aimed at addressing these challenges. This study provides a comprehensive analysis of the original Act and its 2024 Amendment through a multiparametric sentiment evaluation involving disaster management professionals, policymakers, and researchers.
The study employs a mixed-method approach, integrating qualitative thematic analysis and quantitative Likert-scale-based responses from 25 experts. Eighteen key variables were identified to assess the clarity, feasibility, and alignment of the Amendment Bill with international frameworks such as the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction. Statistical correlation analysis reveals strong linkages between well-defined legal provisions and their practical implementation, while weaker correlations were observed in areas like urban disaster management and risk assessment methodologies.
Key findings highlight both strengths and limitations of the Amendment. Positive aspects include the incorporation of modern disaster risk concepts, enhanced urban risk governance through the proposed Urban Disaster Management Authority, and the introduction of a systematic disaster database and risk register. These additions align India’s framework with global best practices, fostering a proactive approach to disaster resilience. Additionally, the Bill emphasizes decentralized governance by empowering district councils and mandating periodic updates to disaster management plans.
Despite these advancements, several concerns emerge. Ambiguities persist in terminology, particularly in defining “disaster assessment” and “risk register,” which could lead to inconsistent implementation. The proposed database lacks standardization in data collection, undermining its effectiveness in risk-informed decision-making. Moreover, while decentralization is encouraged, capacity-building measures and financial mechanisms for district and local bodies remain unclear. The Amendment also retains a top-down approach, limiting the autonomy of state and local governments in disaster response planning.
Comparative analysis with international frameworks reveals gaps in India’s disaster governance approach. While the Amendment aligns with the Sendai Framework’s emphasis on risk reduction, it falls short in mainstreaming disaster risk considerations into broader development planning. The study recommends refining definitions, integrating risk assessment frameworks with real-time data analytics, and establishing clear funding mechanisms for local disaster management authorities. Additionally, annual reviews of disaster management plans should be mandated to ensure adaptability to evolving risks.
In conclusion, while the 2024 Amendment marks a progressive shift in India’s disaster governance landscape, its effectiveness hinges on addressing identified gaps. A more inclusive, standardized, and decentralized approach is necessary to strengthen resilience at all levels. Future legislative efforts should prioritize cross-sectoral integration, enhanced community participation, and robust institutional mechanisms to create a truly comprehensive disaster risk management framework.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The importance of Micro Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) in creating livelihood opportunities and fostering socio-economic development is significant, especially in developing economies. Micro and Small enterprises contribute substantially in stirring socio-economic growth in India.
However, enterprises do not run in isolation. Their growth enormously depends on ties with other firms and individuals which include interaction, knowledge sharing, access to resources and other factors, together forming an entrepreneurial cluster, where all those entities work collectively towards an economic goal. Thus, entrepreneurial clusters have gained increasing significance as potential drivers of growth in recent years.
Existing Cluster Development policies include soft interventions such as technical assistance, capacity building, market development etc. and hard interventions such as common facility center, R&D center etc. Policies also include credit support, infrastructure development, need based support etc. But the entrepreneurial process solely doesn’t depend on these interventions.
Entrepreneurial networks play a central role in nurturing innovation, accessing resources and mitigating uncertainty. The socio-cultural and socio-economic background of the entrepreneurs, various characters of the cluster and the embeddedness of the firms into that influence the evolution of enterprises. Intensity of diversification of enterprises and reciprocity influence indirectly yet significantly the growth trends of a cluster.
However, it has been observed that cluster development policies have disproportionately focused on direct determinants of growth. Hence, the present research has identified following research questions – (i) How do locational circumstances regulate the spatial and temporal determinants? (ii) How do spatial and temporal context contribute in establishing healthy and strong enterprises?
The study compares locational dynamics of two clusters, in two different peri-urban contexts in eastern India. The study has utilized data, collected through two key techniques systematic field survey and focus group survey.
Key findings indicate that various attributes like age of cluster, density and diversification of enterprises, land use, land value, local governance, natural setting, socio-cultural and socio-economic trends etc. influence the growth of clusters. In addition to that present exercise has attempted to identify (i) location specific forces, and (ii) spatial and temporal dynamics of gains and losses. Findings further indicate formulation of strategic vision and action plan based on the cluster specific diagnostic study instead of adopting an overarching cluster development policy, to aid effective socio-economic development.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The pandemic and its policy repercussions have undeniably affected diverse aspects of life globally, extending beyond health. Numerous businesses worldwide were compelled to shut down or curtail operations, due to constraints imposed by governments. Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) are no exceptions; they have gained prominence in discussions about the pandemic due to their noticeable susceptibility. This has raised the importance of examining determinants of MSMEs’ resilience towards shocks, as these businesses play significant roles in many economies. Empirical evidence which examine factors affecting MSMEs’ resilience tends to be limited, particularly in Indonesia. This study aims to investigate characteristics of MSMEs which support their resilience in Indonesia, in order to act as an evidence-base for policies which aim to increase the probability of MSME “survival” in times of economic shock. We examine how classical measures of “resilience”, in particular MSME liquidity and asset holdings, are catalyzed by their ability to “digitalize” their operations as a proxy to being able to adapt to the challenges that COVID-19 and its lockdown policies brought to the market economy. We use the 2020 Micro and Small Enterprise Survey (VIMK) of MSMEs in Indonesia, which was conducted at the start of the pandemic to explore MSME characteristics and classical indicators pertaining to economic resilience, i.e., MSME liquidity, cash holdings, asset holdings, business size, among others. We then employ pseudo-experimental methods to examine how “coping mechanisms”, such an MSME’s ability to digitalize affects resilience. Our findings show that policymaking in times of economic shock should not only include efforts to increase MSME access to sources of funds, however, boosting resilience should also include support for increasing skills related to diversifying business practices, such as those offered by digital tools.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper maps the growth of ASEAN resilience policies from roughly 2004 to 2023. Prior studies have emphasised Western-led resilience policy agendas, with particular focus on the European Union (EU) in the case of regional organisations. In contrast, this paper examines the resilience policies emerging from the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) as a Southern regional organisation. Based on document analysis of ASEAN Annual Reports and ASEAN Chairperson's Statements, it traces the uses of resilience across ASEAN's three pillars: the ASEAN Political-Security Community (APSC), the ASEAN Economic Community (AEC), and the ASEAN Socio-Cultural Community (ASCC). It finds significant evidence of both expansion and substantive heterogeneity in policy agendas over organisational space and time. In particular, it highlights examples of resilience within the contexts of policy mobility, as the operational contexts, actors, and meanings associated with resilience unfold across ASEAN organisational space and time.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The North-South divide in resilience knowledge production is not only quantitative but also evident in the core of models and tools. This is primarily because the policy transfer literature emphasizes the importance of knowledge and the role of intentional processes (agency). In contrast, structural, interest-based, and unintentional processes are frequently a part of diffusion. Post-2014 foreign policy framework of India has seen vivid application and inculcation of ancient Indian philosophy of 'Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam' in climate diplomacy strategies. This phase emphatically determines the consistency of political agency over policy-making processes in a structured overview of the state of the art in policy diffusion. As climate change intensifies and natural disasters become more frequent, especially the global south is susceptible to its severe consequences & effects.
Further, India's take on global climate resilience policies based on an all-embrassing outlook that embodies collective progress as one universal family, transcending borders, cultures, and ideologies, has ushered principles and values in supporting multilateral action on climate catastrophe. Though globally more than 3500 climate policies are in action, rarely do they embrace earth as a global family outlook in its application. For the past decade, India’s climate diplomacy has been based on five major determinants: Geography, Population, Outlook, Application and Impacts with a Clear, Consistent and Coordinated strategy. The triple gem of India's effective climate diplomacy discourse since 2014 includes the International Solar Alliance (ISA), launched in 2015; the Coalition for Disaster Resilient Infrastructure (CDRI), launched at the 2019 UN Climate Action Summit; and the Global Biofuel Alliance (GBA), one of the priorities under India’s G20 Presidency, announced during the G20 New Delhi summit, September 2023. This indigenous policy approach signifies specific insights from the recent rise of resilience policy into general debates surrounding policy transfer versus policy mobility in international policy.
In the above context, the present study investigates an evolving approach from an Indian diplomacy perspective in addressing global climate concerns leading the way for the global south. The study makes cross-sectional analysis to understand climate sustainability and resilience configuration in India’s resilience policy framework. It draws on the notion of a multi-level approach by using the resilience policy matrix. By using secondary data sources, the study looks into the compatibility outlook of ISA-CDRI-GBA in epitomizing India’'s role as a catalytic platform to act as a robust repository of knowledge to meet inclusive climate action imperatives in pursuit of strategic objectives in Indian climate diplomacy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This study examines the influence of national cultural characteristics on the management of infectious disease disasters. Focusing on the COVID-19 pandemic, this study examines cultural factors across countries including South Korea, Indonesia, and the Philippines. This research also investigates the impact of cultural dimensions conceptualized by Hofstede’s cultural dimensions such as power distance, individualism, uncertainty avoidance, and long-term orientation on public health responses. The analysis utilizes the COVID-19 Stringency Index and pandemic indicators including death rates, testing, vaccination coverage to assess the effects of these cultural variables. The findings indicate that higher levels of individualism and uncertainty avoidance are associated with increased death rates. Additionally, power distance significantly affects COVID-19 testing leading to lower testing rates. Furthermore, the effectiveness of stringent government policies is found to be contingent upon cultural context. While stricter policies were solely associated with negative COVID-19 outcomes, the interaction between policy stringency and cultural dimensions produced more nuanced effects. This study provides theoretical and practical implications of designing culturally tailored strategies to improve the effectiveness of infectious disease disaster management.
Author : Sung Min Park
Co-Authors :
JungHwan Ryu,
Gabeen Lee,
Jian Lee,
Chaeyoon Kim.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Disaster risk management (DRM) is an important aspect of governance, requiring defined legal frameworks to ensure preparedness, mitigation, and response. India’s Disaster Management Act (DMA), 2005, transitioned the country’s approach from reactive relief-based measures to a structured, multi-dimensional system for disaster governance. Evolving disaster risks, including climate change, urban vulnerabilities, and socioeconomic disparities, have necessitated revisions to the existing legal framework. The Disaster Management (Amendment) Bill, 2024, introduces significant updates aimed at addressing these challenges. This study provides a comprehensive analysis of the original Act and its 2024 Amendment through a multiparametric sentiment evaluation involving disaster management professionals, policymakers, and researchers.
The study employs a mixed-method approach, integrating qualitative thematic analysis and quantitative Likert-scale-based responses from 25 experts. Eighteen key variables were identified to assess the clarity, feasibility, and alignment of the Amendment Bill with international frameworks such as the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction. Statistical correlation analysis reveals strong linkages between well-defined legal provisions and their practical implementation, while weaker correlations were observed in areas like urban disaster management and risk assessment methodologies.
Key findings highlight both strengths and limitations of the Amendment. Positive aspects include the incorporation of modern disaster risk concepts, enhanced urban risk governance through the proposed Urban Disaster Management Authority, and the introduction of a systematic disaster database and risk register. These additions align India’s framework with global best practices, fostering a proactive approach to disaster resilience. Additionally, the Bill emphasizes decentralized governance by empowering district councils and mandating periodic updates to disaster management plans.
Despite these advancements, several concerns emerge. Ambiguities persist in terminology, particularly in defining “disaster assessment” and “risk register,” which could lead to inconsistent implementation. The proposed database lacks standardization in data collection, undermining its effectiveness in risk-informed decision-making. Moreover, while decentralization is encouraged, capacity-building measures and financial mechanisms for district and local bodies remain unclear. The Amendment also retains a top-down approach, limiting the autonomy of state and local governments in disaster response planning.
Comparative analysis with international frameworks reveals gaps in India’s disaster governance approach. While the Amendment aligns with the Sendai Framework’s emphasis on risk reduction, it falls short in mainstreaming disaster risk considerations into broader development planning. The study recommends refining definitions, integrating risk assessment frameworks with real-time data analytics, and establishing clear funding mechanisms for local disaster management authorities. Additionally, annual reviews of disaster management plans should be mandated to ensure adaptability to evolving risks.
In conclusion, while the 2024 Amendment marks a progressive shift in India’s disaster governance landscape, its effectiveness hinges on addressing identified gaps. A more inclusive, standardized, and decentralized approach is necessary to strengthen resilience at all levels. Future legislative efforts should prioritize cross-sectoral integration, enhanced community participation, and robust institutional mechanisms to create a truly comprehensive disaster risk management framework.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The importance of Micro Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) in creating livelihood opportunities and fostering socio-economic development is significant, especially in developing economies. Micro and Small enterprises contribute substantially in stirring socio-economic growth in India.
However, enterprises do not run in isolation. Their growth enormously depends on ties with other firms and individuals which include interaction, knowledge sharing, access to resources and other factors, together forming an entrepreneurial cluster, where all those entities work collectively towards an economic goal. Thus, entrepreneurial clusters have gained increasing significance as potential drivers of growth in recent years.
Existing Cluster Development policies include soft interventions such as technical assistance, capacity building, market development etc. and hard interventions such as common facility center, R&D center etc. Policies also include credit support, infrastructure development, need based support etc. But the entrepreneurial process solely doesn’t depend on these interventions.
Entrepreneurial networks play a central role in nurturing innovation, accessing resources and mitigating uncertainty. The socio-cultural and socio-economic background of the entrepreneurs, various characters of the cluster and the embeddedness of the firms into that influence the evolution of enterprises. Intensity of diversification of enterprises and reciprocity influence indirectly yet significantly the growth trends of a cluster.
However, it has been observed that cluster development policies have disproportionately focused on direct determinants of growth. Hence, the present research has identified following research questions – (i) How do locational circumstances regulate the spatial and temporal determinants? (ii) How do spatial and temporal context contribute in establishing healthy and strong enterprises?
The study compares locational dynamics of two clusters, in two different peri-urban contexts in eastern India. The study has utilized data, collected through two key techniques systematic field survey and focus group survey.
Key findings indicate that various attributes like age of cluster, density and diversification of enterprises, land use, land value, local governance, natural setting, socio-cultural and socio-economic trends etc. influence the growth of clusters. In addition to that present exercise has attempted to identify (i) location specific forces, and (ii) spatial and temporal dynamics of gains and losses. Findings further indicate formulation of strategic vision and action plan based on the cluster specific diagnostic study instead of adopting an overarching cluster development policy, to aid effective socio-economic development.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The pandemic and its policy repercussions have undeniably affected diverse aspects of life globally, extending beyond health. Numerous businesses worldwide were compelled to shut down or curtail operations, due to constraints imposed by governments. Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) are no exceptions; they have gained prominence in discussions about the pandemic due to their noticeable susceptibility. This has raised the importance of examining determinants of MSMEs’ resilience towards shocks, as these businesses play significant roles in many economies. Empirical evidence which examine factors affecting MSMEs’ resilience tends to be limited, particularly in Indonesia. This study aims to investigate characteristics of MSMEs which support their resilience in Indonesia, in order to act as an evidence-base for policies which aim to increase the probability of MSME “survival” in times of economic shock. We examine how classical measures of “resilience”, in particular MSME liquidity and asset holdings, are catalyzed by their ability to “digitalize” their operations as a proxy to being able to adapt to the challenges that COVID-19 and its lockdown policies brought to the market economy. We use the 2020 Micro and Small Enterprise Survey (VIMK) of MSMEs in Indonesia, which was conducted at the start of the pandemic to explore MSME characteristics and classical indicators pertaining to economic resilience, i.e., MSME liquidity, cash holdings, asset holdings, business size, among others. We then employ pseudo-experimental methods to examine how “coping mechanisms”, such an MSME’s ability to digitalize affects resilience. Our findings show that policymaking in times of economic shock should not only include efforts to increase MSME access to sources of funds, however, boosting resilience should also include support for increasing skills related to diversifying business practices, such as those offered by digital tools.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper maps the growth of ASEAN resilience policies from roughly 2004 to 2023. Prior studies have emphasised Western-led resilience policy agendas, with particular focus on the European Union (EU) in the case of regional organisations. In contrast, this paper examines the resilience policies emerging from the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) as a Southern regional organisation. Based on document analysis of ASEAN Annual Reports and ASEAN Chairperson's Statements, it traces the uses of resilience across ASEAN's three pillars: the ASEAN Political-Security Community (APSC), the ASEAN Economic Community (AEC), and the ASEAN Socio-Cultural Community (ASCC). It finds significant evidence of both expansion and substantive heterogeneity in policy agendas over organisational space and time. In particular, it highlights examples of resilience within the contexts of policy mobility, as the operational contexts, actors, and meanings associated with resilience unfold across ASEAN organisational space and time.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)