P01. Greening state governance: a policy process perspective
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Green state governance has raised increased attention in the context of the environmental crisis (Bäckstrand and Kronsell 2015, Duit et al. 2016, Eckersley 2004 and 2020). However, the “green(ing the) state” literature applies more a polity- than a policy-centred approach. As for the policy studies, there is an imbalance: while the content of sustainable (energy-, transportation, agricultural etc.) policies has been extensively studied, the procedural and institutional aspects of the policy process enabling the formulation of those policy measures has received much less attention. Much has also been written on the “super wickedness” of such problems (Levin et al., 2009 ; Head 2019) as well as on the specific role of within-state “climate change makers” and to innovations in governance (Jordan et al. 2018), emphasizing the role of “new” discourses, actors, and policy tools (Hajer 1995; Jordan et al. 2003). However, less attention has been given to the policy process itself, in terms of governing resources, the preparedness of the central administration, the choice and selection of public policy instruments etc. Yet taking stock from the literature on public policy processes and acknowledging its political nature whether at policy formulation or at policy implementation stages (Zittoun et al., 2021), the process by which green state governance is made material through policy analytics, budgetary planning, enforcement procedures, is expected to come up against several barriers and to give rise to conflicts, both within and beyond the state apparatus. In addition, questioning whether the classic state apparatus is fit for meeting a challenge of unprecedented scale and delivering on large-scale, transformative changes, also led some authors to questioning the relevance of public policy research concepts and tools (Hausknost, 2020; Berglund et al., 2022). Moreover, others have highlighted potential contradictions with existing state-market-society relations, whether in democratic societies (Fischer 2019), in the context of democratic backsliding (Gomide et al. 2022), and in capitalist societies (Meadowcroft 2005; Hausknost 2023). Taking stock from this burgeoning literature and acknowledging the need for more systematic and comparative work, this panel first proposes to identify 1) the challenges in the governance process that may hinder the formulation and implementation of green policies, 2) the possible institutional and/or organizational solutions to meet those challenges. Second, specific attention will be given to the governing of such processes, whether at policy formulation or policy implementation stages, by either giving specific attention to governing resources and capacities, or to the choice and selection of specific public policy tools.
POLICY TOPICS
P02. Bringing the voices in: emotions, vulnerablity and new modes of governance in public policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel highlights the essential role of emotions and vulnerability in shaping public policy, examining their impact on policy formulation and policy implementation across a range of governance contexts. By exploring current understandings of emotions in public policy, this panel aims to bring into conversation diverse approaches to how emotions—often an underexamined yet powerful element—drive and shape policy processes. Addressing the emotional dimensions of governance, this session will create a space for innovative discussions on the transformative potential of emotionally informed and inclusive policymaking. Panel Objectives and Scope The primary objective of this panel is to recognize emotions not only as influencing factors but as conceptual tools fostering a deeper understanding of how affective dimensions impact governance structures and policy frameworks. By emphasizing vulnerability, this panel seeks to illuminate the processes through which emotions shape and reshape policy, potentially allowing for a more inclusive and empathetic approach to policy processes. This panel is designed to embrace diverse perspectives and research stages. We encourage contributions that explore emotions through various policy theory orientations, methodologies, and research experiences. A key objective is to create a collaborative and reflexive environment, one where scholars feel comfortable discussing both the successes and challenges encountered in their work. Contributions need not present fully established methods; instead, we value the openness to explore innovative approaches and to critically reflect on methodologies that enhance our understanding of emotions in public policy. This panel seeks to bring together research that addresses emotions across different policy domains, with an emphasis on critical insights into governance and vulnerability. Key areas of focus include: - Emotions from Individual to Collective: Examining the transition from personal emotional responses to collective affective phenomena, such as how individual privacy concerns aggregate into broader political movements or social concerns. - Emotions and Expertise: Exploring the role of emotions in the age of "postfactual politics" and questioning how expertise interacts with emotional narratives in public decision-making. - Emotions as Knowledge: Delving into the role of emotions as a distinct form of knowledge, where affective responses provide insights that are different from, yet complementary to, traditional expert knowledge. We invite scholars from diverse backgrounds and career stages to foster a dynamic exchange of ideas and methodologies that enhance our collective understanding of emotions in policy and governance. This panel promises to enrich the conference’s objectives by opening space for new insights and collaborative learning on the role of emotions in creating responsive, inclusive, and empathetic public policies.
POLICY TOPICS
P03. Transnational Policy Process Research: Issues, Concepts and Cases
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Policy Process is related to the “interactions that occur over time between public policies and surrounding actors, events, contexts, and outcomes” (Weible 2018, 2). In the 21st century, policymaking processes have increasingly become transnational. Regardless of this comprehensive definition, mainstream theories of the process have treated domestic policy change in isolation as if developments in other countries, other sectors, or at the global level are of little relevance for domestic policy processes. A growing community of scholars has been dedicated to conceptual developments that address the transnational in policymaking, such as studies on policy transfer, global policy and transnational administration (Stone, Moloney, 2019), international public policies (Petiteville, Smith 2006) and europeanization (Radaelli, 2008). The transnational Policy Process refers to “the transnational interactions that occur over time between public policies and the surrounding agents, events, contexts and outcomes” (Morais de Sá e Silva, Porto de Oliveira, 2023). Investigations of the global/local nexus and, more broadly, the relational methods of inquiry are perhaps best exemplified in studies that pay close attention to the processes of internationalization of domestic best practices, the localization of global policies, the development of bottom-up civil society led policy instruments, the coordination of national responses to crises, the evaluation of peacekeeping operations, and goal-setting global agendas. Domestic policies can deeply involve transnational dynamics, such as ministries seeking for technical assistance from the OECD or international private consultancies serving as advisors to governments. These are only a few of the examples of public policy processes involving a transnational dimension. The Panel seeks to advance scholarship on the transnational policy process, both drawing on and further advancing the policy transfer literature and global public policies literatures. We expect to provide answers to questions such as: How can the transnational policy process be further theorized? What concepts are useful in analyzing transnational dimensions in policy making? What are the conceptual challenges in capturing multilevel, multinational, multi-agent processes? Which methodological approaches can be applied to assess policy processes beyond the nation state? What empirical evidence can be used in such studies? Does the transnational policy process vary across policy subsystems and across space? References: Petiteville, Franck; Andy Smith. “Analyser les politiques publiques internationales”. Revue française de science politique 56, nº 3 (2006): 357. Morais De Sá e Silva, Michelle; Porto de Oliveira, Osmany. Incorporating Time into Policy Transfer Studies: A Comparative Analysis of the Transnational Policy Process of Conditional Cash Transfers and Participatory Budgeting. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice, v. 25, n. 4, p. 418–438, 4. 2023. Radaelli, C. M. Europeanization, Policy Learning, and New Modes of Governance. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice, v. 10, n. 3, p. 239–254, 2008. Stone, Diane L.; Moloney, Kim. The Oxford Handbook of Global Policy and Transnational Administration. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019. Weible, Christopher. “Introduction: The Scope and Focus of Policy Process Research and Theory.” In Theories of the Policy Process, edited by Christopher Weible and Paul Sabatier, 4th ed., 1–13. New York, USA: Routledge, 2018.
POLICY TOPICS
P04. The Policy Transaction Perspective: The Drame of Policy in an Agonistic and Turbulent Time
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel proposed to develop a new perspective on the policy process based on pragmatism and constructivism. By combining American and French conceptions of pragmatism with traditional constructivist insights, the panel advances a relational, situational and dramaturgical approach to understanding the policy process. The unifying theme is the concept of a “policy transaction,” an interaction that co-constructs actors and policies. By taking us beyond a “billiard ball” perspective that views the policy process as a clash of fixed interests and values shaken by external events, a policy transaction approach provides a better understanding of the policy process and yields insights into the role and meaning of policy in an increasingly agonistic and turbulent world. From a policy transaction perspective, public policy is not simply “what governments choose to do or to not do” (Dye, 1972). Instead, it is a dialectic between state and society that we call a “transaction” where their respective roles and responsibilities are situationally co-constructed. Whereas most theoretical perspectives on public policy treat state-society relations as an exogeneous variable, the policy transaction approach begins with the assumption that this relationship is continually renegotiated inside policy processes. As a result, the policy process is never simply about instrumentally designing or selecting policies to achieve certain goals; it is understood as a drama that constitutes the meaning of the polity and its publics.
POLICY TOPICS
P05. Policy Process Analysis of Long-term Changes in Policies: Visualising Applicability of Two or More Existing Frameworks, Theories or Models of Policy Process Studies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Objective: This panel seeks to encourage scholars to present their work on policy process analysis of long-term changes in policies through policy process elements in which two or more existing frameworks, theories, and models in policy process studies are able to explain the process of change. A comprehensive presentation of works included in this panel can offer some insight in moving towards a uniform generalised theory augment that remains elusive so far. Background and Scientific Relevance: How and why public policies are made have been a subject of study ever since Harold Lasswell laid down his ambitious idea of ‘policy sciences’ in 1951 in his book ‘The Policy Sciences: Recent Developments in Scope and Methods’. From thereon, public policy has emerged as an important academic arena and its formal study can be said to have originated with the multi-disciplinary approach of Lasswell (Dunn, 2018). However, Lasswell himself described ‘policy sciences’ as an area with two distinct but interwoven purposes concerning ‘knowledge of the policy process’ and ‘knowledge in the process’ (Lasswell, 1970). While the former is creation of knowledge about the process of policymaking, the latter is about the knowledge created in the process of policymaking, which can be used to improve the process itself. Scholars and academicians have embarked upon several frameworks, theories and models to understand and describe policy-making process or what may be seen as knowledge of the policy process. Some of such models have also attempted to analyse the long-term changes and evolution of policies under different contexts and settings creating knowledge in the policy process to improve the process itself. Nonetheless, in its last seven decades of development as an academic stream and even after a proliferation of frameworks, theories and models in the field of policy process studies, there is a lack of uniform generalised theory (Smith and Larimer, 2009) that can together explain all the causal relationships falling within the arena of policy studies. Several scholars have attempted to compare such frameworks, theories and models of the policy process to find commonality among them and their ability to explain the policy process. A study by Heikkila and Cairney (2018) on comparison of important existing frameworks, theories and models figures out six policy process elements (actors, institutions, networks, ideas, context and events) that may explain the ‘knowledge of the process’. Similarly, Hall’s theory on levels of changes bring out three more policy process elements i.e. policy background, policy goals, and policy tools along with settings of the tools to explain the changes in policies. Thus, an analysis of long-term changes in a policy through these nine policy process elements may offer insight into the applicability of existing frameworks, theories and models and also help in developing a generalised theory that can be uniformly applied to policy changes as an outcome of ‘knowledge in the process’.
POLICY TOPICS
P06. One Health: From Agenda-Setting to Implementation and Evaluation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The One Health approach has emerged as a collaborative, multi-disciplinary approach that recognizes the interconnectedness of human, animal, and environmental health. This conceps promotes comprehensive public health strategies, through the understanding that disease prediction, prevention, and response requires an integrated examination of diseases at the human-animal-environment interface, thereby improving medical, veterinary, and ecological health outcomes globally and contributing to pandemic prevention. While One Health is considered a promising approach to human, animal, and environmental health, moving from theory to practice through agenda setting, policy making, implementation, and evaluation is lagging behind. To better understand complexities and advancements in the governance of One Health, this panel approaches One Health from a policy process perspective. The panel examines the challenges and opportunities in agenda setting, policy formulation, policy implementation, and policy evaluation regarding One Health. Topics of interest include but are not limited to infectious diseases, antimicrobial resistance, and food safety in relation to One Health. We welcome submissions that engage with the following policy process themes: Agenda-setting: How has the One Health approach been framed in policy narratives? How has framing changed over time? Who are the policy actors that promote this approach? What are the drivers and obstacles that put or prevent One Health to the forefront of policy making?Policy formulation and decision-making: How do different policy actors (including scientists) negotiate and resolve disagreement among human, animal, and environmental health stakeholders?Policy implementation and operational challenges: How can different interventions improve One Health awareness and practices?Policy evaluation: What methods and criteria can be used for measuring effectiveness of One Health policies, including multi-sectoral coordination and policy outcomes?Policy change and the dynamics of policy learning: How does the One Health concept and related policies travel between different policy levels (i.e., global, supranational, national to local) and political systems?We especially welcome papers that use existing theories of the policy process to examine One Health, including the Advocacy Coalition Framework, Institutional Analysis and Development framework, Multiple Streams Framework, Narrative Policy Framework, Policy Feedback Theory, Policy Diffusion and Innovation, Ecology of Games Framework, the Programmatic Action Framework, and the Punctuated Equilibrium Theory.
POLICY TOPICS
P07. Studying policy process innovation: Why, by whom, how, and to what effect?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Innovations in public policy are essential for addressing grand challenges like biodiversity loss and climate change. Despite their importance, existing policies often struggle with credibility, effectiveness, and legitimacy. While much attention has been given to innovation in policy design, less focus has been placed on innovations in the policy process itself. These innovations involve novel ways of organizing or structuring the processes of agenda setting, policy formulation, decision-making, implementation, and evaluation to enhance policy outcomes. Examples of policy process innovations include technology foresight committees, crowdsourcing initiatives, behavioural insights teams, policy innovation labs, algorithmic governance, participatory decision-making, digital governance, co-implementation strategies, randomised control trials, and participatory evaluations. Although these innovations have gained prominence, questions remain about why they are adopted in certain policy domains and jurisdictions, how they spread, and their impact on policy outputs and outcomes. This panel aims to address these gaps by: - examining the origins and features of policy process innovations- understanding how they diffuse across different jurisdictions and policy areas- assessing their impact on policy outputs and outcomes, particularly credibility, effectiveness, and legitimacy- bridging research on policy innovation with that on related concepts such as democratic innovation, governance innovation, institutional innovation, and public sector innovation The research questions include: - what drives the adoption of policy process innovation?- to what extent do mainstream theories of the policy process explain process innovation?- how do the dynamics of policy process innovation compare with policy design innovation?- how do policy process innovations influence policy outputs and outcomes?- in what ways do they affect the credibility or legitimacy of the policy (process)? By exploring these, the panel seeks to advance scholarship on policy innovation, policy studies, and governance, contributing to a deeper understanding of how innovative policy processes can effectively address complex societal challenges.
POLICY TOPICS
P08. Evidence-Based Policy Making in Africa
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Evidence-Based Policymaking in Africa General Objective The objective of this panel is to explore the dynamics of evidence-based policy making in Africa, focusing on how empirical research, data, and evidence can be more effectively utilized in the policymaking process across the continent. The panel seeks to address the structural, institutional, and political factors that impact the adoption and application of evidence-based policymaking in various sectors, such as health, education, economic development, and environmental policy. The panel will bring together interdisciplinary insights from political science, public administration, economics, and development studies. Research Question This panel will investigate the following research question: How can African governments improve the uptake of evidence in the policy-making process? We will explore several hypotheses: Institutional Capacity Hypothesis: Governments with stronger research institutions and data infrastructure will have higher levels of evidence integration in policy processes. Political Economy Hypothesis: The degree to which evidence is used in policymaking is influenced by political incentives and power structures. International Influence Hypothesis: Donor influence and international development organizations play a critical role in shaping evidence-based policymaking in African countries, but this may sometimes skew priorities. Community Knowledge Hypothesis: Indigenous and local knowledge systems, if integrated with formal research evidence, can lead to more culturally relevant and accepted policies. Through these hypotheses, the panel will aim to uncover key factors that promote or hinder evidence-based policymaking in Africa and highlight best practices that can be scaled or adapted to different contexts. Scientific Relevance This topic is of high scientific relevance given the increasing global emphasis on evidence-based policymaking as a tool for improving policy outcomes. In Africa, where development challenges are profound, evidence-based policymaking holds significant potential for transforming governance and service delivery. However, the region faces unique challenges, including weak data infrastructure, political economy factors, and limited research capacities. This panel seeks to contribute to the scholarly debate by exploring how these barriers can be overcome, drawing on African case studies to provide a rich understanding of both the obstacles and potential pathways to success. Context and Brief State of the Art on this Topic In recent years, global trends have pushed for the integration of evidence in policy making, with international organizations such as the World Bank and the United Nations advocating for data-driven decision-making (Parkhurst, 2017). In Africa, the rise of institutions like the African Evidence Network and the adoption of frameworks like the African Union’s Agenda 2063 reflect this growing interest in evidence-based policymaking (Langer et al., 2016). Despite these efforts, however, the use of research evidence in policymaking remains inconsistent, with many African governments relying on ad-hoc decision-making processes, often driven by political expediencies or donor priorities (Newman et al., 2012). Limited resources, lack of reliable data, and political resistance further complicate the integration of evidence into policy frameworks. References: Langer, L., Tripney, J., & Gough, D. (2016). The science of using science: Researching the use of research evidence in decision-making. London: EPPI-Centre. Newman, K., Fisher, C., & Shaxson, L. (2012). Stimulating demand for research evidence: What role for capacity-building? IDS Bulletin, 43(5), 17-24. Parkhurst, J. (2017). The politics of evidence: From evidence-based policy to the good governance of evidence. London: Routledge.
POLICY TOPICS
P09. Public Policymakig in the Global South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Public Policymaking in the Global South Most of the theorizing and research on public policy has been centered in the so-called “Global North”. Even studies that proclaim themselves to be comparative may only compare the policies and politics of the wealthy and primarily democratic countries of the North. This excessively narrow vision of public policy has limited its vision and analytical capacity to study developments in the “Global South”. The domination of ideas from the Global North is especially apparent in the theories and approaches used to understand and explain public policy. The most common frameworks for analysis (e.g. the Advocacy-Coalition Framework, Multiple Streams, Institutional Analysis and Development), shape a good deal of the research on public policy and were developed in the North. While appearing to be generally applicable, the ideas that undergird them may be based on assumptions that are not in fact valid for policy across the remainder of the world. Colonial, institutional, cultural, political, and economic differences that exist between Global North and Global South countries may have a significant impact on the suitability and functioning of policy models, both intellectually and empirically. This panel will attempt to address the broad question of the suitability of the now conventional policy frameworks for research in the countries of Africa, Latin America, Asia and most of Oceania. Building on this, we want to encourage debates about specific questions such as, what it means for a policy model to work; what makes policymaking in the Global South different from that in the Global North; to what extent do models and frameworks developed in the Global North are applicable to cases from the Global South; which alternative models (both theoretical and empirical) have been developed throughout the Global South; and how does policy learning happens between the Global North and the Global South, in both directions, and within countries from the Global South.
POLICY TOPICS
P10. Putting policy diffusion (further) in process
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel’s goal is to leverage our understanding of policy diffusion encapsulating the processes by which policy-making in one government affects policy-making in other governments (Gilardi et al., 2021). Despite generations of research, we are still short of knowledge about what policy diffusion exactly is, why and how it occurs and can be studied. There are several reasons for this, beginning with the intrinsic complexity of policy. First generation studies until 1980 managed to operationalize policy diffusion clearly by emphasizing adoption of policy from one jurisdiction to another as key in the process(es), thus setting it apart from other well-established concepts in policy sciences including policy transfer and circulation (de Oliveira, 2021; Soremi, 2016). Initially, the essence of policy was mainly limited to single instruments and ideas as well as closely interwoven with innovation and success in change. Today, however, policy mixes and/in failure are widely recognized as inherent to governments’ work, thus urging to (re)-conceptualize (their) diffusion (Howlett & Rayner, 2008; Volden, 2016). In their turn, second generation studies of policy diffusion prior to 2000 have identified and thoroughly compared its basic mechanisms. Up until today, imitation and learning have been studied the most whilst others were left more out of analysis including competition, coercion and harmonization as well as diffuse networks as more communicative mechanisms (Danaeefard & Mahdizadeh, 2022; Shipan & Volden, 2008). Moreover, what happens when multiple mechanisms coexist? Do these mechanisms complement or inhibit each other's effects? In studies of the third and recent generation, theorizing has already come a way. Leader-laggard, convergence and other models were constructed, thus primarily covering the so-called external determinant factors to explain diffusion processes in governments (Berry & Berry, 2018). Still, the long-term neglect of typical factors that are internal to the adopting organization calls upon further theorization and also left us with a methodological challenge. After all, quantitative large-N studies ruled the policy diffusion field for long and should be supplemented towards a plurality of methods including thick descriptions, policy narrative case studies and qualitative, small-N studies based on in-depth interviews with elite policymakers and frontline workers as well (Howlett & Rayner, 2008). Moreover, institutional or process designs (e.g., performance management) may not only spread across jurisdictions but also across policy domains, highlighting the need for further research on cross-domain policy diffusion. Firing these what, why and how (to study) -questions upon policy diffusion, several research challenges thus come to the fore. Its underlying processes are complicated and are likely to become even more so. After all, whilst operating in a poly-crisis environment, governments of all levels/sectors/countries are pushed to constant policy evolution and change today. Diffusion processes can then hinder or facilitate their innovation and are essential for moving forward efficiently, effectively and democratically all across the globe. The goal of this panel is to further explore how and under what conditions policies are diffused and spread. The key question underpinning the panel is: how can we better understand and explain diffusion processes in the public sector? References Berry, F. S., & Berry, W. D. (2018). Innovation and diffusion models in policy research. Theories of the policy process, 253-297. Danaeefard, H., & Mahdizadeh, F. (2022). Public policy diffusion: A scoping review. Public Organization Review, 22(2), 455-477. Gilardi, F., Shipan, C. R., & Wüest, B. (2021). Policy diffusion: The issue‐definition stage. American Journal of Political Science, 65(1), 21-35. Howlett, M., & Rayner, J. (2008). Third generation policy diffusion studies and the analysis of policy mixes: Two steps forward and one step back?. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis, 10(4), 385-402. de Oliveira, O. P. (Ed.). (2021). Handbook of policy transfer, diffusion and circulation. Edward Elgar Publishing. Shipan, C. R., & Volden, C. (2008). The mechanisms of policy diffusion. American journal of political science, 52(4), 840-857. Soremi, T. (2016). Policy Transfer: Revisiting Concept and Process. International Journal of Arts & Sciences, 9(3), 377. Volden, C. (2016). Failures: Diffusion, learning, and policy abandonment. State Politics & Policy Quarterly, 16(1), 44-77.
POLICY TOPICS
P11. Adopting Anticipatory Governance- Systems Perspective
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
As the world is learning to live in meta-crisis or poly-crisis due to radical shifts in multiple domains, namely wars and refugees, climate change, extremism, and the rise of Artificial Intelligence (AI) (Wong et al., 2024), anticipating change has become a critical skill for organizations and governments worldwide. Anticipatory governance (referred to as AG hereafter) emerged as an idea from the felt need to assimilate the concept of anticipation into governance to enhance system resilience (Boyd et al, 2015). Resilience, as described by Folke (2016), is ‘the capacity of a system to absorb disturbance and recognize while changing so as to still retain essentially the same function, structure, and feedbacks, and therefore identity, that is, the capacity to change to sustain identity’. The degree of change across socio-technical-politico and cultural scales demands anticipatory capabilities that lead to innovative solutions before the problem goes out of hand. The literature on anticipation has existed within the frameworks of foresight and planning, while governance has traversed from public administration to New Public Administration. Assimilating anticipation with governance would perhaps need a flavor of systems thinking as well since the scale under consideration goes up to national and international systems. Defining governance as ‘decision-making rules and processes which determine stakeholders’ rights and responsibilities through coordination’ (Bevir, 2012) and anticipatory as an organization’s capacity ‘to deal with new situations and realize accepted values, changing the focus from forecasting to being ready for future challenges’ (Fuerth, 2013). In other words, this culminates in AG's capability to create decision-making processes based on a consensus around a preferred or desired future through the participation of various stakeholders including the government, the market, the public, and academics (Heo and Seo, 2021). The gap, though, exists in understanding how policymakers operationalize AG. What are the processes by which complex problems and radical shifts can be understood well and AG can be practiced as well as implemented? What are the enablers and barriers to adopting AG at a systemic level?
POLICY TOPICS
P12. Policy Learning: Who, how, where, and ‘what for’?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel aims to bring together scholars from different fields of policy analysis and policy process theories to advance the research agenda revolving around policy learning. This proceeds across three main lines: Conceptual, analytical, and empirical. Conceptually, policy learning has been deployed as ontology, analytical approach, and lens to explain the policy process and its outcomes (Dunlop & Radaelli, 2013; Kamkhaji, 2022; Zaki, 2024). While significant advances have been made in this area, conceptual ambiguity and fragmentation has also been a hallmark of policy learning research (see Goyal & Howlett, 2018; Zaki, Wayenberg, & George, 2022). This panel calls for contributions that discuss different conceptual approaches to policy learning, aiming to bring clarity to the field’s vast array of conceptual approaches, illustrating the utility of these different conceptualizations, and the optimal conditions under which they can be utilized. Analytically, the panel will explore two promising pathways. One is the interplay between policy learning within and across theories of the policy process – to illustrate, the narrative policy framework refers to ‘narrative learning’ (Shanahan, Jones, & McBeth, 2011), the advocacy coalition framework to ‘cross-coalition learning’ (Sabatier, 1988), and recent developments in the multiple streams framework refer to learning as key to argumentative coupling of streams (Blum, 2017). In this panel, we pursue contributions that build on this agenda. Yet, we also go beyond what is conventionally classified as theories of the policy process (see Weible, 2023). This is by inviting papers that also address other theoretical perspectives where learning plays a key role yet remains under-explored. For example, in areas such as knowledge utilization, evaluation, and implementation theories. Although evaluation and implementation are often seen as ‘stages’ – an argument has been made for their theoretical status (For example, think of the classic Foundations of Program Evaluation: Theories of Practice, by Shadish, Cook, & Leviton (1990)). The second pathway covers the who and how of policy learning. Specifically, how learning is undertaken by different actor groups, whether the relatively well-researched ones (e.g., policymakers, politicians), or those who are significantly under-researched (e.g., civil servants, scientific experts, citizens, and marginalized groups), the multilevel structures in which learning occurs (e.g., microfoundations including cognitive structures, biases, emotions). Then, turning to the where question, we call for contributions that address learning fora and their different characteristics. For example, ranging from high-level structures such as advisory bodies, to different governance and institutional settings where factors such as the interplay between participatory / deliberative settings and mechanisms of learning can provide novel theoretical insights into policymaking processes and outcomes. This is an important politics-policy connection that has not been explored sufficiently, especially empirically. To conclude, there is a substantive body of research in each of these categories – which the panel aims to connect under the theme of policy learning. Empirically, the field is marred with the problem of measurement. However, a recent paper (Zaki & Radaelli, 2024) suggests several good practices. The panel will host empirical papers that will demonstrate how learning is identified and measured. We also invite critical papers on the dimensions of learning that are problematic to pin down in a measure or indicator – often, these are the most subtle and interesting dimensions. Finally, there is the questions about the beneficiaries of learning, or, if you wish, winners and losers. Here we invite papers that re-connect policy learning to some classic ideas in political economy about the incentives for learning, the interplay between policy learning and political objectives of elected policymakers and non-elected bureaucrats and regulators, and the outcomes of learning for societies. Our research questions revolve around the following broad, yet interrelated themes: - How to bring clarity of the ontological and epistemological assumptions of policy learning? - How can policy learning be used in conjunction with other theoretical approaches to advance policy analysis? - How do so-called evidence-informed “tools” like risk analysis, evaluation studies, and impact assessment of proposed legislation bring learning in empirically observed policy processes? - How does policy learning occur across different contexts and settings? - How can the interplay between institutional settings, sites and fora of learning advance our understanding of policy processes and outcomes? - What is the social quality of learning, how does learning fare in relation to our normative standards? As for the panel’s intended outcomes, some papers presented at ICPP7 will be included in a book for which we already have a contract. Some of our contributing authors have already been contacted and confirmed their interest in presenting in this panel – if accepted, they will come and present. Depending on the number of papers participating in the panel, we will also consider a special issue of a journal, to be identified with the participants. The panel is open to contributions from various methodological approaches (qualitative, quantitative, reviews, interpretivism, critical policy studies, philosophy of knowledge, and conceptual development). Supporting literatureBlum, S. (2017). The Multiple-Streams Framework and Knowledge Utilization: Argumentative Couplings of Problem, Policy, and Politics Issues. European Policy Analysis, 4(1), 94-117. doi:10.1002/epa2.1029 Dunlop, C. A., & Radaelli, C. M. (2013). Systematising policy learning: From monolith to dimensions. Political Studies, 61(3), 599–619. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9248.2012.00982.x Goyal, N., & Howlett, M. (2018). Framework or metaphor? Analysing the status of policy learning in the policy sciences. Journal of Asian Public Policy, 12(3), 257-273. doi:10.1080/17516234.2018.1493768 Kamkhaji, J. C. (2022). Policy learning and the Euro: The EU's responses to the sovereign debt crisis. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan. doi:10.1007/978-3-031-04264-5 Sabatier, P. A. (1988). An Advocacy Coalition Framework of Policy Change and the Role of Policy-Oriented Learning Therein. Policy Sciences, 21, 129-168. doi:10.1007/BF00136406 Shadish, W. R., Cook, T. D., & Leviton, L. C. (1990). Foundations of Program Evaluation. London: Sage. Shanahan, E. A., Jones, M. D., & McBeth, M. K. (2011). Policy Narratives and Policy Processes. Policy Studies Journal, 39(3), 535-561. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1541-0072.2011.00420.x Weible, C. (2023). Theories Of The Policy Process. NY: Routledge. Zaki, B. L. (2024). Policy Learning Governance: A new perspective on agency in policy learning theories. Policy & Politics, 52(3), 412–429. doi:10.1332/03055736Y2023D000000018 Zaki, B. L., & Radaelli, C. M. (2024). Measuring policy learning: Challenges and good practices. Perspectives on Public Management and Governance, 7, 37–46. doi:10.1093/ppmgov/gvae001 Zaki, B. L., Wayenberg, E., & George, B. (2022). A Systematic Review of Policy Learning: Tiptoeing through a Conceptual Minefield. Policy Studies Yearbook, 12(1), 1-52. doi:10.18278/psy.12.1.2
POLICY TOPICS
P13. Consolidating our understanding of policy paradigms: conceptualization, uses, extensions, and limitations
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The objective of the proposed panel is to advance the research programme on policy paradigms: one currently fragmented across disciplinary and epistemological groups within the scholarly community. The need for a panel on policy paradigms is motivated by the fact that the concept’s usefulness has been subject to numerous critiques over the years, culminating in a recent call for scholars to dispense with the paradigm construct (Jabko & Schmidt, 2021). Yet, many policy scholars continue to invoke policy paradigms in their research (Alons, 2020; Daigneault et al., 2021; Daugbjerg & Feindt, 2017; Hogan & Howlett, 2015; Sewerin et al., 2022). Moreover, the language of paradigm change continues to feature prominently in the popular literature on social, economic and technological transitions, which is largely separate and distinct from the public policy literature (Kaplinsky, 2021; Perez, 2002; Swilling, 2020). A key question for discussion and debate is whether paradigms retain analytical purchase for explaining policy stability and change following significant revisions to Peter Hall’s classic theory on the role of policy paradigms in processes of social learning (Hall, 1993). If paradigms transcend mere descriptive heuristics, additional questions arise concerning how paradigms constitute causal variables in policy processes, including those which underlie social, economic and technological transitions. Methodological questions regarding how paradigms may be operationalized and measured must also be answered for hypothesis testing to proceed (Daigneault, 2015). Notwithstanding the intuitive appeal and popularity of the concept, a theory of policy paradigms is notably absent from major public policy textbooks (Cairney, 2012; Capano & Howlett, 2020; Weible & Sabatier, 2018). One possibility is that theory on policy paradigms need not stand alone, but may rather be subsumed by other theories of the policy process and political economy (Baumgartner, 2013; Cairney & Weible, 2015; John, 2018; Streeck & Thelen, 2005). In any case, precisely how paradigms fit in the policy scholar’s analytical toolbox is an open question that warrants serious attention. The panel will address questions like the following. Does the paradigm concept serve an analytical purpose beyond shorthand for widely held and institutionalized ideas? If paradigms are causal, how and when are they causal vis-à-vis other determinants of policy change and stability? Relatedly, in what ways is theory on policy paradigms useful for policy practitioners? What is the relationship between policy paradigms and other paradigms (e.g., scientific paradigms, techno-economic paradigms)? Is the paradigm construct useful only for studying public policy or is it useful for analyzing and understanding any social choice situation? Can paradigms be integrated into other theories of political economy and/or the policy process? How/can we better integrate the policy feedback and policy paradigm literatures? How can we operationalize and measure policy paradigms, as well as their impacts on policy-making? How do policy paradigms in different policy areas connect with one another in reinforcing or undermining ways?
POLICY TOPICS
P14. Generative policymaking for robust societies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
General objective: We live in turbulent times and political scientists and public administration scholars have for some time now discussed how the public sector can advance its ability to make and implement robust policy solutions under turbulent circumstances characterized by high degrees of uncertainty, irregularity and unpredictability (Capano & Toth, 2023; Howlett & Ramesh, 2023; Ansell et al., 2024; Sørensen & Warren, 2024). This panel aims to take theory development and empirical inquiry one step further by inviting papers that contribute to answering the following research question: How can public policies contribute to making societies more robust? The scientific relevance of this research question is that it shifts the perspective in the research from what robust policymaking and governance looks like to how and when public policies and policy making processes contribute to building robust societies. The latter can be defined as societies that possess the ability to change what they do and/or how they do it when disruptive events render existing ways of thinking and acting ineffective and illegitimate. The basic idea guiding the inquiry is that societal robustness is a product of policies that allow for, and maybe even encourage, continuous adaptation and innovation of perceptions of what it entails to promote effectiveness and legitimacy (re-articulation of policy purposes) and/or of the ways they seek to do so in practice (re-structuration of governance institutions and processes). As such the panel encourages researchers to take part in developing a generative perspective on policy and policymaking (Ansell & Torfing, 2021) that asks how policies can release a society’s transformative capacity and guide and deploy it in ways that support the promotion of effective and legitimate governance. There are already interesting literatures considering how generative AI government policies guiding and encouraging a purposeful use of AI can enable situated societal responses to change, how metagovernance tools and reflexive law can facilitate collaborative governance and co-creation of solutions to challenging demands and events. Another interesting and potentially relevant literature is discussing how social capital can enhance the stamina of societies (Young, 2017; Terrinham, 2021; Hubbard et al., 2022; Cheng & Wu, 2024). These strands of research have hitherto not been fully deployed in discussions about how to build robust societies. References: Ansell, C., Sørensen, E., Torfing, J., & Trondal, J. (2024). Robust Governance in Turbulent Times. Cambridge University Press. Ansell, C., & Torfing, J. (2021). Public governance as co-creation. Cambridge University Press. Capano, G., & Toth, F. (2023). Thinking outside the box, improvisation, and fast learning. Public Administration, 101(1), 90-105. Cheng, K., & Wu, H. (2024). Policy framework for the utilization of generative AI. Critical Care, 28(1), 128. Howlett, M., & Ramesh, M. (2023). Designing for adaptation. Public Administration, 101(1), 23-35. Hubbard, R., Paquet, G., & Wilson, C. (2022). Stewardship. University of Ottawa Press. Sørensen, E., & Warren, M. E. (2024). Developing a theory of robust democracy. Policy & Politics, 1-20.
POLICY TOPICS
P15. Multiple Streams Framework: The View from 40
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The year 2024 marked the 40th anniversary of the publication of Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies, John Kingdon’s landmark study that heralded the era of the Multiple Streams Framework as one of the most accessible and widely applied theories of the policy process. Indicatively, in a recent study, Rob DeLeo and colleagues (2024) found that a simple Google Scholar search yielded over 30,000 citations of Kingdon’s 1984 (2003) volume and its subsequent editions. These include a wide array of applications at all levels of governance and stages of the policy process (except for evaluation), and a variety of political and country contexts and policy sectors. Further, another recent review (Petridou et al., forthcoming) revealed that a significant number of MSF applications have theoretical ambitions beyond the mere explanation of an empirical policy phenomenon. Part of what has contributed to MSF’s broad appeal has also constituted criticism leveled against it: that MSF’s language is metaphorical and that concepts often function as heuristics, two conditions that lower the entry barrier for using MSF and therefore have resulted in imprecise research. Having said this, the theoretical robustness of the framework is indisputable (Dolan, 2021; van den Dool, 2023) and a changing world has placed a premium on the concept of ambiguity (Zahariadis, 2007; 2014; Zahariadis et al., 2023; Rob DeLeo et al., 2024). So, where do we go from here? During an MSF roundtable at the ECPR general conference in Dublin in 2024, we identified fruitful trajectories for the future. In terms of method, MSF research must remain pluralistic in its methodological preferences, test existing hypotheses, and use quantitative approaches to complement small-N studies, where justification of research design and methodology are transparent and rigorous. Additionally, MSF research must move towards a more standardized definition and measurement of common terms. Theoretically, it would be beneficial for future research to synthesize lessons learnt and in turn make these lessons more relevant to practitioners. References DeLeo, Rob A., Reimut Zohlnhöfer, and Nikolaos Zahariadis. 2024. "Multiple Streams and Policy Ambiguity." Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. https://www.cambridge.org/core/product/FBA20248D4A359D38AF7083D00F5149E. Dolan, Dana A. 2021. "Multiple Partial Couplings in the Multiple Streams Framework: The Case of Extreme Weather and Climate Change Adaptation." Policy Studies Journal 49: 164-89.van den Dool, Annemieke. 2023. "The Multiple Streams Framework in a Nondemocracy: The Infeasibility of a National Ban on Live Poultry Sales in China." Policy Studies Journal 51: 327-49.Kingdon, John W. 2003. Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies. 2nd ed. Boston: Longman.Petridou, Evangelia, Jörgen Sparf and Nikolaos Zahariadis. (forthcoming). “The Policy Entrepreneur as a Crosscutting Concept in Theories of the Policy Process: A Scoping Review of European Empirical Applications” European Policy AnalysisZahariadis, Nikolaos. 2014. "Ambiguity and Multiple Streams." In Theories of the Policy Process, eds. Paul A. Sabatier and Christopher M. Weible. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. 25-58.Zahariadis, Nikolaos. 2007. "The Multiple Streams Framework: Structure, Limitations, Prospects." In Theories of the Policy Process, ed. Paul A. Sabatier. Boulder, CO: Westview. 65-92.Zahariadis, Nikolaos, Nicole Herweg, Reimut Zohlnhöfer, Evangelia Petridou, and Novotný Vilém. 2023. "Advancing the Multiple Streams Framework." In A Modern Guide to Multiple Streams Framework, eds. Nikolaos Zahariadis, Nicole Herweg, Reimut Zohlnhöfer and Evangelia Petridou. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar. 1-24.
POLICY TOPICS
P16. Narrative Policy Framework: Developments, Discoveries, and Challenges
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) is a theory of the policy process that investigates the role of narratives in all stages of the policy process. The purpose of this panel is to gather NPF scholars around the world to share their research questions, discoveries, and challenges. The primary research question for the NPF is how policy narratives shape the policy process. The power of policy narratives occurs across levels of analysis (micro, meso, macro), at all stages of the policy process, and amongst varying governance regimes. At ICPP7, we welcome NPF scholarship that advances the framework and/or gives insight into complex policy issues.
POLICY TOPICS
P17. Navigating the Nexus of Public Policy & Diplomacy: National and International Innovations for Global Challenges
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The interplay between diplomacy and public policy is central not only to transnational governance but also in confronting the cross-border policy problems that impact on local communities and national jurisdiction, especially when addressing challenges like climate change, pandemics, poverty, and the Sustainable Development Goals. Each challenge exposes the limitations of the traditional categories in inter-state diplomacy. There are also widening ‘public’ and ‘plural’ dimensions of diplomacy that come with a range of nonstate actors. These actors seek not merely to influence international public opinion or inform policy development but also to sit at the diplomatic table. Informal agents – individuals like celebrities, business actors, philanthropists, ‘sherpas’ and organizations like museums, NGOs, think tanks, cities, and cultural associations – act as open channels or ‘alternative’ diplomats. So-called ‘new diplomats’ also find opportunity to enter the diplomatic terrain when government capacity is weak or as technology enables diplomatic actors to engage new or wider audiences via new mechanisms (digital, media and public diplomacy). The diplomatic field has not only diversified but policy sectors once considered the sovereign realm of national policy and/or welfare provision have become new fields of diplomacy. Today, health, science and innovation, sport, culture and education policy sectors have a ‘diplomatic face’. The Research Questions that frame this panel include the following:· What can Policy Studies offer Diplomatic Studies and vis-à-vis, how can diplomatic studies inform the study of public policy?· What are the interfaces between diplomacy and public policy at the different levels of governance, and how and why might they differ?· What policy concepts can be adopted to re-interpret contemporary diplomatic practices and processes as an evolution of public policy development and administrative competencies? Similarly, what diplomatic concepts may help reinterpret the policy interface of informal actors with global policy and transnational governance?· What are the organisational and ‘policy network’ dimensions of the new diplomatic activity?· Do the chosen policy tools and instruments of informal non-state actors differ from the policy tools commonly used by inter-state diplomatic efforts?· With what policy authority (if any) and legitimacy do informal (or non-state or non-traditional) diplomats have? This panel seeks contributions that conceptualize and/or empirically research evolving diplomatic practice within the public policy domain and other crucial areas of policy research, such as policy evaluation and implementation. The panel systematizes diplomacy not as an autonomous theoretical field but one that is influenced by development studies, cultural studies and mostly importantly for ICPP, increasingly informed by public policy studies. The objective of the panel is to discuss public policy responses to global challenges as one that has national and local dimensions but where public policy can sometimes blur and merge with diplomacy. Considerations span the impact of digital diplomacy, the evolving role of non-state actors, and the influence of public opinion on diplomatic decision-making. Accordingly, the proposed panel contributes to understanding how “informal” diplomacy and public policy shape one another. This will foster interdisciplinary discussions and help bridge the gap between diplomatic studies and public policy.
POLICY TOPICS
P01. What can be done? Comparing public policy responses and climate change-issues across regions as two sides of the same challenge
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The panel aims at addressing the complexities of policy analysis from a comparative cross-perspective and from the specific standing point of the discipline and the most recent developments in the field of environmental research. The issue of the governance of climate change gravitates around specific dedicated objects, like the policy transfer (Alibasic 2023) or diffusion of grand accords, specific related policies that are critical to mitigation strategies (like transportation and energy transitions (Artigas & Mouton 2017) or specific levels (Grin 2024) concerned by environmental strategies (like national plans or specific local governmental responses at the city§metro level) and their corresponding capacity-building dynamics. More novel research has pinpointed specific issues pertaining to policy dismantling of specific related policies, zombi policies (Peters & Nagel 2020) politicization/mobilization/and conflictuality in regards to specific issues that remain low in the policy agenda, the increasing intersection of environmental technologies regulation, among others. Cutting across these different issues and research objects, fundamental dimensions of multi-level governance (considering the rapport between levels within supranational entities, cities and national governments or specific regional administrative constructs) have become relevant as per coordination imperatives of climate based policies.
POLICY TOPICS
P02. Artificial Intelligence, Data-driven Technologies, and Comparative Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The rapid development of emerging data-driven technologies, such as artificial intelligence (AI), has had a profound impact on social behaviors, necessitating urgent government regulation, which, in turn, brought significant changes to the field of policy analysis, both in terms of theory and methodology. Practically, the velocity of AI developments, the complexity of what to regulate, and the question of who regulates and how, all pose significant challenges for AI oversight. Theoretically, to design policies and ensure that AI is applied in an ethical, secure, transparent, and human-centric manner across all sectors are often unclear. Both policy design, implementation and policy analysis can be facilitated by AI, but this requires careful consideration of the aforementioned challenges. Given that AI-related policies have been designed and adopted across various policy fields in numerous countries and regions, it would be beneficial to explore these policy challenges from comparative perspectives. The panel is sponsored by the ICPA Society and the Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis (JCPA), Routledge.
POLICY TOPICS
P03. Policy Analysis and Policy Research in Latin America
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The objective of the panel is to study the production of public policy research and public policy analysis in Latin American countries. This panel aims to cover the subject area of Public Policy in Latin America, a world region that share similar socio-cultural, political, institutional, and administrative characteristics. This panel wants to bring in an overview of public policy analysis and research in Latin America, convening a host of scholars and practitioners from the region. The proposed panel aims to discuss an overview of public policymaking, institutions, and comparative studies on PP themes. As noted by Jreisat (2005, 2011) most internationally published scholarship in Public Administration focus on countries from Europe, Asia, and North America. The same point was made by Geva-May, Hoffmann and Muhleisen (2018) about policy research. The authors explicitly indicate a lack of comparative publications from the Global South, in general, and from the Latin American region, specifically. This shortage of publications hinders the diffusion of knowledge and administrative solutions between the Global North and the Global South. The expected benefit from this panel is the availability of a high-quality articles on policy analysis and research in the Latin American region, with a straightforward scope in providing the current state of PP in the region, its challenges and recommendations for policy and further research. This panel can be of interest for researchers and practitioners interested in public policy research and policy analysis in the region, as well as for those working with comparative Public Analysis in non-Spanish and non-Portuguese speaking countries. Adopting a comparative perspective on public policy analysis and research (Geva-May et al., 2018; Walle & Brans, 2018), the panel proposes the following research question: What are the prevalent public policy analysis methods adopted by policymakers in the region? What are the prevalent policy research theories and frameworks adopted by scholars in the regions? What examples of idiosyncratic or genuine methods/frameworks of policy analysis or policy research have emerged in Latin America?
POLICY TOPICS
P04. Global South approaches to resilience policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The objective of this panel is to explore comparative policy approaches across the Global South towards building resilience, writ large. Resilience policies have grown in popularity across international and sectoral bounds (e.g., climate, economic, supply chain, cyber resilience, and so on). However, much is yet to be understood about the emergence and nature of resilience policies from the Global South. Echoing theoretical debates between policy transfer versus policy diffusion, this panel seeks to bring together a diversity of empirical cases to enable more nuanced, comparative analyses of the kinds of resilience policies emerging in the Global South. To what extent are they unique or original relative to Global North policy counterparts? What kind of domestic and international drivers can be identified (e.g., policy funders, academic discourses, domestic politics, etc)? What do resilience policy discourses and policy-making dynamics look like when shifting across spatial levels (e.g., local, national, regional, global)? In bringing together these diverse perspectives, this panel seeks to make three contributions to the current literature. First is in convening a more concerted view of resilience policy approaches from the Global South, in contrast to prior emphasis on Northern actors (e.g., the European Union, the United States). Second is in unpacking the black box of resilience policy-making to examine the extent to which Southern actors exhibit political agency over policy-making processes. Third is in feeding specific insights from the recent rise of resilience policy into general debates surrounding policy transfer versus policy mobility in international policy.
POLICY TOPICS
P05. Policy Transfer in the Global South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
In the past 10 years, policy transfer studies have increasingly accommodated Southern approaches and views on the transnational movement of policies. The notion of South-South cooperation (SSC) is built on the idea that policies are deliberately circulated within and among nations of Africa, Asia and Latin America. South-North policy transfer (SNPT) is also intensifying but often happening unnoticed because of asymmetries in power, resources and authority that privilege Northern countries as the legitimate sources of innovative policies (Kemmerling 2023). Incorporating knowledge generated from Southern experiences can not only challenge these asymmetries but it can also transform the understanding of policy transfer, more specifically and public policy, more broadly (Stone et al 2020). Central to expanding the epistemic coverage of policy transfer studies is the understanding of how ‘reference societies’ or “a nation from which to borrow elements” are created (Waldow 2019, 2). Traditionally, reference societies are constructed as Northern countries based largely on historical, colonial and cultural affiliation. However, recent studies shed light on new patterns of constructing reference societies. The use of large-scale performance-based metrics has established Singapore and Shanghai as a source of successful education policies because they topped global quantitative rankings. Elites from Northern countries express negative reception or ‘shock’ against being ranked below their Southern counterparts, prompting a contentious reform process. These developments present new forms of contestations. Recently, Brazil and China emerged as a powerful source of new instruments, knowledge, ideas (Waisbich et al. 2021). They come as the ‘two main protagonists in the context of SSC’ as they actively peddle their different policy paradigms undergirded by different political systems (Oliveira and Romano 2022, 5). China has exerted influence in the Global South on environmental policies through varying strategies including conventional development aid (Ray et al 2015, Weins et al 2023). Brazil has served as inspiration for many social policy innovations largely through SSC with the help of many international organizations (de Oliveira 2022). More recently, less economically and politically powerful countries have also become ‘reference societies’, holding power and capacity to transfer policies within specific domains. Bangladesh’ anti-poverty policies like microfinance and graduation of the ultra-poor has spread through SSC (Halder and Mosley 2004). The Philippines is the primary source of innovation on labour migration policy (Saguin and Shivakoti 2023). Similarly, there is a decidedly local element to the construction of reference societies (Saguin and Sha 2023). Best practices are often experimented on and mastered by local governments and scaled up for transfer to the transnational level (Montero 2016). This panel seeks to bring together researchers who examine old and new reference societies in the Global South at the local, national and transnational levels. It aims to build an interdisciplinary conversation around the multi-scalar contestations that occur around the reconstitution of reference societies. It hopes to invigorate studies that unravels the theoretical foundations of the factors that drive for policies to be constructed as successful, and for nations, cities or localities to be perceived as legitimate sources of policy lessons in the Global South.
POLICY TOPICS
P06. Trust, Distrust, and Regulation: Exploring their Interdependencies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel aims to explore the complex, evolving relationship between trust, distrust, and regulation, addressing the following key research question: whether, how, and why (dis)trust and regulation affect one another. Trust is often viewed as the acceptance of vulnerability to others' actions, while distrust reflects a state of wariness or suspicion, and regulation encompasses rulemaking, monitoring, and enforcement. In recent decades, societies have witnessed significant crises—ranging from the 2008 financial meltdown to data privacy scandals, environmental fraud, and geopolitical conflicts—each eroding public trust in various actors, including private-sector tech giants and multinational corporations as well as public institutions such as financial regulators. Amid this context of distrust, regulation has often expanded, reflecting attempts to mitigate perceived risks and abuses, but it also risks unanticipated consequences that may further erode trust. Empirical examples abound: European regulatory measures to curb the power of tech companies, the tightening of financial regulations after the global financial crisis, and screening mechanisms for foreign investments, especially in strategic sectors, all reflect efforts to restore trust. Yet, these regulatory moves have sparked debates over their effectiveness and unintended side effects, such as bureaucratic overreach and policy complexity. This panel investigates not only how regulation may restore trust but also how it may, paradoxically, breed further distrust by creating perceptions of red tape, inefficiency, or bias. Theoretically, the relationship between trust and regulation is often viewed as antagonistic—where trust is high, regulation can be light; where distrust is dominant, strict rules emerge to minimize discretion. However, this traditional perspective might overlook scenarios where trust and regulation reinforce each other. For example, trust may support effective regulation, while regulation might act as a catalyst for building or repairing trust. Thus, the panel examines whether these factors are rival or complementary and whether trust can indeed be rebuilt after it has been breached. This investigation is timely, given the rapid evolution of – inter alia – technological, financial, and geopolitical landscapes, which continuously test the robustness of regulatory frameworks. Through comparative analyses across sectors and governance levels, the panel will probe the iterative co-evolution of trust and regulation, focusing on how different contexts shape the interplay of these forces. Key hypotheses include:1. Mutual Reinforcement: Trust and regulation can be mutually reinforcing, where effective regulation can build trust, and trust can support regulatory compliance.2. Distrust and Over-Regulation: High levels of distrust may lead to over-regulation, which can backfire by fostering even more distrust.3. Trust Repair: Regulation can serve as a corrective mechanism that helps repair trust over time, suggesting that distrust cycles can be broken. Ultimately, this panel will deepen the understanding of the nuanced, multifaceted ways in which (dis)trust and regulation intersect, offering insights that extend beyond single-issue areas to broader governance challenges.
POLICY TOPICS
P07. The Global Politics of the Implementation of Migrants' Rights: Policy Instruments and Controversies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Global migration governance is a normative and sociopolitical challenge which materialises in transnational policymaking processes. By transnational policymaking, we mean policymaking process that emerges from transnational mobilisation of various states and non states agents around common concerns such as immigration, health, poverty, environment, among others or the resolution of common problems which do not respect national jurisdictions and need to involve more than one nation or domestic actors (De Oliveira, 2022). In this panel, we invite proposals that bring into the discussion the transnational migration policy settings and their instruments brought up by different historical contexts of the collective management of human migrations. These instruments may include, but are not limited to the uses of conventional and non-conventional policies and strategic arrangements put in place by states or governments to address the international movements of populations and their human rights, all categories and varieties considered. Most specifically, panel would like to invite papers that focus on, but are not limited to the following questions: - What kind of transnational arrangements characterise the global governance of migration across regions and over time? - Which migrants' rights are promoted and secured across States' borders and transnational juridictions, regional and national legislations? - Does economic sovereignty influence the structuration of the global governance of international migration? - What methods and policy research approaches can be used to study and interpret the emerging types of policy arrangements? - Who frames policies and who fails to comply? - Do controversies emerge from the global governance of international migrations ? - Do migration global policy instruments vary across regions? and how? This panel is an opportunity to question the relevance of traditional and emerging theories and methodologies of the policymaking process research and their capacity to advance intersdisciplinary and transdisciplinary approaches.
POLICY TOPICS
P08. The content and dynamics of Policy Change: Stages, Dimensions, Measures and Drivers
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Understanding policy dynamics requires an analytical focus on change. As Heraclitus said, "everything flows": change is a feature of human development and of social and political phenomena. The same is true of public policies: they are "moving events, routines, strategies and adjustments" (Heclo, 1972: 83). Yet, despite its pivotal relevance and a huge bulk of studies on policy change, the concept of policy change is still underdeveloped from theoretical and analytical points of view. It is the elephant in the room – everyone knows it is there, but everyone somehow avoids discussion about it. When searching the research literature, it becomes evident that the definitions of policy change vary tremendously. For example, Béland and Waddan (2012: 16) define policy change “primarily in institutional terms in the sense that we focus on how […] policy rules and institutions change or are reproduced over time”. Other studies define it “as a major shift (as distinguished from an incremental shift) in public policy reflected in the enactment of new measures” (Burnett, 2005: 227). Empirical applications sometimes “define policy change as whether or not a policy is actually implemented” (Chhokar et al., 2015: 1080). The challenge of defining policy change equally touches upon the levels of policy change that are even possible and under which conditions they are. Peter Hall (1993) has proposed his widely acknowledged differentiation that inspired Cashore and Howlett's (2007) taxonomy, which extends Hall's tripartition not only by distinguishing three types of change in both objectives and instruments, but also by considering endogeneity and exogeneity of change. While paradigmatic (or third-order changes) are endogenous shifts in goals, exogenous factors can change goals and settings or instruments. (see also: Howlett and Cashore, 2009). The reference to existing typologies overlooks two essential problems in this regard. Firstly, what is considered policy change is highly dependent on the theoretical lens through which one looks at it. Secondly, even if classified as minor or major change – on whatever grounds – it cannot be ruled out that an apparent major change has a minor impact and vice versa. This leads us to the general idea that the study of policy change is more complex and requires more conceptual reflection and empirical criteria than current research provides. Therefore, it is essential to start distinguishing between the substantive content of policy change (which may refer to changes in policy outputs and changes in policy outcomes) and changes that may concern the processual elements of policies (such as the distribution of powers among actors, their interactions, the characteristics of the procedures involved). Thus, we perceive an urgent need for re-establishing a debate on policy change from an epistemological, theoretical, and methodological perspective. This panel, then, is committed to advancing the study of public policy on how to investigate what types of policy change occur where, on what dimensions, with what timing, and whether this differs across contexts. Thus, the proposed panel will be focused on deepening our theoretical and empirical knowledge on: · Whether and how policy change has different meanings at different stages of the policy cycle; · What are the different possible dimensions of policy change both in terms of changes in policy outputs and policy outcomes; · How to operationalize and measure the different types of policy change; · Identifying different drivers of the different types of policy change.
POLICY TOPICS
P09. Comparative Policy and Governance for Sustainable Development in Asia
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
One of the major objectives of this panel is to bring together scholars and practitioners from diverse public policy fields and countries to explore various policy and management issues in Asian countries from a comparative perspective. Given Asia's global share in terms of population, GDP, energy consumption, and CO2 emissions, it is clear that resolving Asia's policy challenges is crucial for building a sustainable future. Asian countries face a wide range of complex policy and management challenges, many of which require innovative solutions tailored to their specific contexts. Furthermore, each country in Asia faces unique challenges. For example, more than 29.3% of Japan's population is aged 65 years and above, the highest proportion in the world. This places a heavy policy and financial burden on the Japanese government to cover rising costs related to healthcare, pensions, and long-term care, while its financial and administrative capacity is shrinking due to a declining working-age population. China also confronts significant issues. Its economic growth has been heavily reliant on exports and investment, but a shrinking labor force, declining birthrate, and aging population pose major challenges to its industrial structure, consumer market, and social security systems. Environmental and resource concerns also loom large: rapid economic development has led to environmental degradation, inefficient resource use, and severe air and soil pollution, all of which threaten China's sustainable development. Many experts and practitioners have studied Asian policy issues from a comparative perspective. Sharing these comparative policy studies is valuable not only for the academic community but also for the development of the Asian region and the world at large. In particular, focusing on sustainable development policy across different Asian contexts is critical for advancing solutions to global challenges. In addition, we aim to contribute to developing future research issues by deepening the discussion on the specificity or universality of sustainability concept, governance theory, and democracy that arise from the historical and socio-cultural background of the region. The panel aims to offer a valuable opportunity to discuss various policy and management issues in Asian countries from a comparative perspective. We welcome conceptual, methodological, and empirical contributions that address policy and management issues in Asian countries at the managerial, organizational, institutional, and specific policy levels, with a special focus on comparative research into sustainable development policies. Case studies that adopt a comparative approach are also encouraged. This panel is hosted and organized by the Public Policy Studies Association Japan (PPSAJ).
POLICY TOPICS
P10. Policy Capacity, Governance Arrangements, and Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the Global South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Implementing the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) poses complex challenges for Global South nations, where state capacities, policy effectiveness, and implementation arrangements tend to be considered fragile. However, they are essential for achieving the 2030 Agenda. This panel explores the intersection between policy capacity, implementation arrangements, and SDG success, focusing on how governments in the Global South mobilize resources, build institutions, and navigate political and institutional complexities to ensure effective and sustainable policy outcomes.Drawing on frameworks from public administration and policy scholars, the panel examines how policy capacity deployment and implementation arrangements—involving diverse actors, resources, and instruments—activate policy capacities for SDG implementation. Their approach underscores that policy capacity skills and resources are not static but depend on dynamic governance arrangements and political deployment to ensure effective implementation.The overarching research question is: How can policy capacity and governance arrangements in the Global South be optimized to enhance the effective implementation of the SDGs? Sub-questions include:• What are the critical factors that influence the success or failure of SDG policies?• How do public sector innovation, dynamic capabilities, and decentralization contribute to the progress of SDG implementation?• How can policy capacity be politically deployed across different levels of government to align national strategies with SDG?This panel's scientific relevance lies in its focus on bridging theoretical discussions of state policy capacity with the practical realities of SDG governance implementation. By emphasizing the political and relational dynamics between politics, administrative resources, and policy instruments, the panel addresses a gap in understanding how state capacity is activated through governance arrangements and how these arrangements influence the success of SDG policies. This panel will cover:• Governance structures and the role of public sector innovation in supporting SDG implementation.• The importance of dynamic capabilities in adapting and reconfiguring resources to meet development challenges.• The impact of political leadership, intergovernmental coordination, and collaboration with civil society and private sector actors in achieving SDG goals.The panel format will be onsite, allowing for in-person and virtual participation.
POLICY TOPICS
P11. Democratic Resistance: Domestic and International Policy Strategies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Domestic and foreign policy are powerful tools to arrest democratic backsliding and support democratic resilience. The panel emphasizes policy responses in the following domains in moments of democratic backsliding: legislative and executive lawmaking and candidate eligibility rules, judicial appointments and domains of jurisprudence, regulatory agencies (particularly tax, audit, and communications/ media sectors) of the state, political party registration, candidate selection, and competitive activity policies, labor and private sector rights and regulations, and foreign intervention rules. To create opportunities for democratic resistance and recovery, policy interventions will generally focus on the subsectors within the ”democracy, rights and governance” frameworks. The panel participants will specify the theory of change which connects the pathways of democratic backsliding with the policy programming responses (foreign and/or domestic) that identifies how these changes can support democratic goals and practice. The general framework of the panel suggests that these theories of change lie in the power of vertical responsibility (the masses putting limits and accountability on the rulers, either through elections or contentious politics), horizontal accountability (checks and balances of other institutional sites of power), and diagonal accountability (formal civil society and media audits and investigations) (Riedl et al 2024). Such policy interventions have the potential to recover or even deepen democracy in the face of such specific threats to civil liberties and political rights. Existing research has tended to focus on either the drivers of democratic erosion, or the strategies that key actors – such as judiciaries and civil society groups – can employ to resist this process (Levitsky and Ziblatt 2018; Waldner and Lust 2018; Arriola, Rakner, and van de Walle 2022; Elischer and Lawrance 2022). This panel will identify the policy responses and which policy actors/ institutional sites can undertake such reforms given the particular pathways of democratic backsliding underway.
POLICY TOPICS
P12. Bridging East and West through comparative analyses of the internationalization of higher education policies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
With the rise to power of neoliberal governments in the United Kingdom (UK) and the United States (USA) in the late 1970s and early 1980s, a new world era began in higher education with the new public management practices and reforms on the agenda of most countries (Gruening 2001), positioning universities as responsive to the economy (Chan, 2016). In this context, the IHE idea emerged and has influenced countries worldwide as a capitalist approach intended to improve the quality of higher education. However, it is neither a natural nor neutral idea; it has been influenced and strengthened in world society by the core capitalist countries, the UK and the USA, and their understanding and management of higher education. In the case of developing countries, the IHE is mostly seen to advance their transition to a capitalist economy (Yeom, 2019). The core of the capitalist world-economy directs the economic, labor, and educational trends to strengthen itself and keep the semi-peripheric and peripheric countries the same (Wallerstein, 1974, 2011). Even though the global capitalist structure permeates internationally by spreading ideas and restructuring national institutions, the timing and aims in each country must be considered to understand the social, political, and institutional contexts in which the development of policies to achieve IHE occurs. In this regard, this panel addresses the need highlighted by IHE leading scholars for studying national policies concerning the IHE based on comparative analyses (Kehm & Teichler, 2007; Mittelmeier & Yang, 2022; Knight & De Wit, 2018) and critical reflections on power relations and dominance issues (Mittelmeier & Yang, 2022; Buckner, 2019). The world-systems analysis perspective (Wallerstein, 2012) emerges as a key framework for such analyses by providing the core-periphery schema to build better arguments in a “moment at which capitalism has become more totalizing than ever” (el-Ojeili, 2015: 695). This panel aims to address and seek explanations of the differences and commonalities among semi-peripheral and peripheral countries and regions with emphasis on East-West comparisons, as an attempt to deepen our understanding and explain policies aimed at the IHE worldwide based on the world-systems analysis as a framing perspective. The research questions guiding this panel are as follows: 1) What are the main similarities and differences between higher education policies developed in semi-peripheral and peripheral East and West to achieve IHE in the actual capitalist world-economy? 2) What institutional and political challenges arise and must be considered when developing IHE policies in those areas? 3) What academic and practical non-hegemonic lessons can be learned from such policies developed in both hemispheres?
POLICY TOPICS
P13. Teaching and Learning of Comparative Health Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel on public policy aims to explore international best practice models of teaching and learning in comparative public policy (CPP) analysis. The general objectives are as follows: · To identify and explore the application of new theoretical models and practices in comparative policy analysis pedagogy. · To advance the public policy teaching and learning community of excellence. As Engeli and Allison (2024) state “teaching CPP methods contributes to forming researchers that advance theoretical and methodological knowledge” and graduates that “acquire the essential skills to critically assess and evaluate comparative policy studies as they work and live in a globalized and interdependent world where comparisons are ubiquitous and often serve specific political and economic interests in public and international affairs”. They then go on to state that “consideration of how to teach CPP methods is of critical importance for educating the next generation of scholar-practitioners.” (p212). This panel calls on teachers of CPP to share new and innovative models of teaching comparative public policy analysis.
POLICY TOPICS
P01. Theories and Dynamics of Ethnic Violence in Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The complex dynamics of ethnic diversity, inclusion, and multiculturalism in public policy play a central role in either fostering stability or exacerbating intergroup tensions. This call for papers seeks contributions that advance understanding of policies for ethnic management, examining how government policies impact both inclusion and exclusion in multicultural contexts. In particular, we aim to explore how policies addressing ethnic diversity affect the successes, challenges, and failures in achieving a cohesive and just society. Building on theories of ethnic violence, this issue will explore how marginalization, resource allocation, and state behavior contribute to intergroup tensions. Ethnic violence is seldom spontaneous; it often stems from deep-rooted socio-political and economic disparities. Consequently, public policy shaped by dominant power structures can either mitigate or intensify these inequalities, impacting how resources are allocated and how diverse communities engage with state mechanisms. Key Research Areas and Questions: We invite papers that address the following critical areas: 1. Ethnic Marginalization and Conflict in Public PolicyHow do power structures in public policy formulation influence ethnic inclusion or exclusion, and to what extent does ethnic marginalization trigger societal conflicts? This theme invites contributions that analyze how policies shaped by central powers impact ethnic groups, exploring whether these policies promote inclusiveness or foster marginalization and conflict. 2. Decentralization as a Tool for InclusionWhat role does decentralized governance play in managing ethnic diversity? Decentralization has been a key strategy in mitigating ethnic conflict by providing local autonomy and power-sharing opportunities. Papers under this theme should explore whether and how local democratization, autonomy, and inclusive incentives contribute to peace and unity in multi-ethnic societies. 3. Comparative Perspectives: Global North and Global SouthHow does the relationship between public policy access and ethnic conflict vary between the Global South and the Global North? We seek studies that examine ethnic marginalization in public policy access across these contexts, exploring whether patterns differ between and within these regions. Special attention will be given to case studies from the Global South to understand unique approaches to ethnic diversity and conflict management. 4. Policy Frameworks for Inclusion, Successes, and FailuresWhat strategies and frameworks have shown success or failure in managing ethnic diversity within governmental and organizational settings? Papers that analyze the implementation of multicultural policies, inclusion and exclusion tactics, and their social impacts are particularly welcome. Additionally, we encourage case studies that shed light on both effective and problematic approaches to multicultural governance. Submission Focus and Expectations: We welcome contributions from diverse disciplines—including political science, public policy and administration, and economics—that analyze the interaction of public policy and ethnic diversity. Submissions should offer empirical research, comparative studies, or theoretical insights into how policies around ethnic diversity shape social cohesion, ethnic management, and conflict dynamics. The issue aims to contribute to a nuanced understanding of ethnic diversity policy, informing policymakers, scholars, and practitioners about the impacts of inclusion, exclusion, and decentralization on social stability and peace.
POLICY TOPICS
P02. Politics of Development Cooperation: From North to South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The United Nations defines development cooperation as activities specifically aimed at supporting national or international development goals, carried out on a non-profit basis, with a focus on developing countries, and grounded in cooperative relationships that encourage local ownership (UNECOSOC, 2015). Since the end of the Cold War, foreign aid from countries in the global North, typically in the form of official development assistance (ODA), as well as grants and loans from multilateral development finance institutions (DFIs) such as the World Bank and regional development banks, have dominated global development cooperation. However, recent shifts are challenging the longstanding dominance of the global North. These shifts include the rise of the BRICS nations and other emerging powers, the establishment of new DFIs like the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB) and the New Development Bank (NDB), the resurgence of South-South Cooperation (SSC) strategies among countries in the Global South, and new forms of triangular development cooperation (TDC) among global North and South partners. This panel proposes an analysis of the expanding and increasingly diverse landscape of development cooperation, focusing on bilateral, triangular, and multilateral partnerships involving the global North, emerging donors, and the Global South. At the international level, the analysis will explore how state and non-state actors are navigating the growing complexity of development cooperation, including shifting power dynamics within these partnerships. Drawing from the concept of regime complexity in international relations, this panel builds on the idea that a regime complex is “an array of partially overlapping and non-hierarchical institutions governing a particular issue area” (Raustiala & Victor, 2004). Contributing factors to regime complexity may include misaligned power structures in existing global governance frameworks and the proliferation of new institutions in response to these imbalances (Pratt, 2018). In this context, states and non-state actors often employ strategies such as forum shopping, regime shifting, and contested multilateralism to respond to these complexities (Alter & Raustiala, 2018; Morse & Keohane, 2014). The expansion of new development cooperation partnerships provides opportunities to explore how these strategies are being applied in practice. Domestically, we propose to examine the domestic context of state and non-state actors, focusing on factors such as political regimes, economic and social transformations, and prevailing development norms and discourses. While much of the existing literature has focused on the domestic politics of foreign aid in developed democracies and countries of the global North (Breuning, 1999; Dadabaev, 2016; de Felice, 2015; Faust & Koch, 2014; Gibson et al., 2005; Molenaers et al., 2015; Tingley, 2010), a growing body of work is also emerging on the domestic processes shaping bilateral development cooperation in more powerful countries in the Global South, including China, Brazil, Turkey, and others(Farias, 2019; Huang, 2014; Kavakli, 2018; Scoones et al., 2016; Shi & Hoebink, 2019; van der Westhuizen & Milani, 2019; Varrall, 2016). This panel seeks to extend these analyses beyond the traditional North-South aid framework and case studies of emerging powers, exploring the domestic political dynamics that drive development cooperation in increasingly complex and multi-actor partnerships across the North and the South. This panel seeks to address the following research questions: 1. How can we conceptualize the increasing diversity and complexity of development cooperation partnerships among the North, emerging powers, and the broader Global South? 2. What underlying determinants lead states or non-state actors to prioritize particular development cooperation policies and partnership modalities over others? 3. Which structural and agency-driven factors contribute to the observed proliferation and diversification of these policies and partnerships, particularly new forms of SSC and TDC? Empirically, we invite papers that use comparative or case study methodologies to identify the conditions, actors, and strategies that influence the proliferation and variation of development cooperation policies and partnerships. To encourage cross-regional comparisons and potential collaborations, we welcome submissions that explore the different actors, conditions, and strategies shaping development cooperation across various regions of the world. References Alter, K. J., & Raustiala, K. (2018). The Rise of International Regime Complexity. Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 14(1), 329–349. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-lawsocsci-101317-030830 Breuning, M. (1999). Ethnopolitical Parties and Development Cooperation: The Case of Belgium. Comparative Political Studies, 32(6), 724–751. https://doi.org/10.1177/0010414099032006003 Dadabaev, T. (2016). Japan’s ODA assistance scheme and Central Asian engagement: Determinants, trends, expectations. Journal of Eurasian Studies, 7(1), 24–38. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.euras.2015.10.002 de Felice, D. (2015). Diverging Visions on Political Conditionality: The Role of Domestic Politics and International Socialization in French and British Aid. World Development, 75, 26–45. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2015.01.010 Farias, D. B. (2019). Brazil’s South–South development cooperation: Principles and experiences of the domestic bureaucracy. Public Administration and Development, 39(4–5), 174–181. https://doi.org/10.1002/pad.1825 Faust, Jj., & Koch, S. (2014). Foreign Aid and the Domestic Politics of European Budget Support. SSRN Electronic Journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2476316 Gibson, C. C., Andersson, K., Ostrom, E., & Shivakumar, S. (2005). The Samaritan’s Dilemma: The Political Economy of Development Aid (1st ed.). Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/0199278857.001.0001 Huang, Y. (2014). Domestic Politics and China’s Health Aid to Africa. China: An International Journal, 12(3), 176–198. https://doi.org/10.1353/chn.2014.0031 Kavakli, K. C. (2018). Domestic Politics and the Motives of Emerging Donors: Evidence from Turkish Foreign Aid. Political Research Quarterly, 71(3), 614–627. https://doi.org/10.1177/1065912917750783 Molenaers, N., Dellepiane, S., & Faust, J. (2015). Political Conditionality and Foreign Aid. World Development, 75, 2–12. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2015.04.001 Morse, J., & Keohane, R. (2014). Contested Multilateralism. The Review of International Organizations, 9. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11558-014-9188-2 Pratt, T. (2018). Deference and Hierarchy in International Regime Complexes. International Organization, 72(3), 561–590. Cambridge Core. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0020818318000164 Raustiala, K., & Victor, D. G. (2004). The Regime Complex for Plant Genetic Resources. International Organization, 58(2), 277–309. Scoones, I., Amanor, K., Favareto, A., & Qi, G. (2016). A New Politics of Development Cooperation? Chinese and Brazilian Engagements in African Agriculture. China and Brazil in African Agriculture, 81, 1–12. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2015.11.020 Shi, X., & Hoebink, P. (2019). From Chengdu to Kampala: The Role of Subnational Actors in China’s Foreign Aid. Journal of Contemporary China, 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1080/10670564.2019.1621534 Tingley, D. (2010). Donors and domestic politics: Political influences on foreign aid effort. The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 50(1), 40–49. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.qref.2009.10.003 UNECOSOC. (2015). 2016 Development Cooperation Forum Policy Briefs. United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs. https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=2ahUKEwiTpp2BjcTzAhUsDjQIHU3QCJ0QFnoECAkQAw&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.un.org%2Fen%2Fecosoc%2Fnewfunct%2Fpdf15%2F2016_dcf_policy_brief_no.1.pdf&usg=AOvVaw2sGn0ScBwfgbELw7VK8Kee van der Westhuizen, J., & Milani, C. R. S. (2019). Development cooperation, the international–domestic nexus and the graduation dilemma: Comparing South Africa and Brazil. Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 32(1), 22–42. https://doi.org/10.1080/09557571.2018.1554622 Varrall, M. (2016). Domestic actors and agendas in Chinese aid policy. The Pacific Review, 29(1), 21–44. https://doi.org/10.1080/09512748.2015.1066414
POLICY TOPICS
P03. Politics, Politicization and Public Policy: Grasping the different epistemological and ontological perspectives
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
While the link between politics and public policy has been a persistent research question in the field of politics since its inception, there is no clear mapping of the different perspectives and approaches. In this panel, we would like to discuss the possibility of better understanding the different perspectives. More specifically, we would like to discuss how the different perspectives can change our understanding of what a public policy is and how to understand the policy process. We proposed to discuss three different categories 1) Considering that these two concepts are ontologically different, each with its own logic, its own configuration of actors and its own field of activity, some authors approach this question in terms of the relationship between two different systems, the political system and the public policy system. 2) Other authors favour an epistemological distinction, arguing that while there is indeed an autonomous political system with its own logic, this time public policies are considered as objects that can be politicised, i.e. that can become political objects. 3) Other authors have argued that public policy is ontologically a political object and consider its design and implementation as political activities.
POLICY TOPICS
P04. Navigating post-conflict Myanmar: Institutions and Policies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel assesses potential post-conflict scenarios in Myanmar, a nation embroiled in a prolonged civil war following the 2021 military coup. As Myanmar’s political, social, and economic landscapes remain deeply fractured, a forward-looking analysis is essential to support post-conflict governance planning. This panel is grounded in an interdisciplinary project involving the UBC Myanmar Initiative and the Asia Pacific Foundation of Canada, which collectively examine Myanmar’s potential pathways post-conflict across critical policy and institutional domains. The panel will specifically address how Myanmar can transition from military rule to a more stable and inclusive state by focusing on areas pivotal to public policy and institutional transformation. The primary research question driving this panel is: What institutional, constitutional, and economic frameworks are viable in a post-conflict Myanmar to ensure stability and inclusiveness? Within this question, the panel explores hypotheses regarding the effects of institutional and constitutional reforms, the role of federalism, shifts in civil-military relations, and the stabilization of Myanmar’s economy. Each hypothesis addresses scenarios where anti-junta forces or the military consolidate power, achieve negotiated settlements, or entrench along territorial lines, influencing the nation’s path toward or away from inclusive governance and democratization. A review of recent literature highlights gaps in conflict and post-conflict governance studies, specifically around Myanmar’s unique ethnic dynamics, institutional complexities, and persistent economic instability. While existing literature emphasizes ethnic divisions and civil-military tensions, fewer studies focus on sustainable governance models in the context of Myanmar's resistance-led federalist movements. The format of this panel is onsite, fostering dynamic discussions among policy scholars, analysts, and practitioners on public policy applications in transitioning states. Each presentation in the panel will advance a scenario-based analysis grounded in empirical research, exploring various pathways for post-conflict institutional stability and development. The panel’s scientific relevance lies in its interdisciplinary approach, blending political science, economics, and conflict studies, and its potential contributions to understanding how institutional and constitutional restructuring can promote stability in fragile states.
POLICY TOPICS
P05. Populism and Bureaucracy – Institutional and Ideological Dynamics in Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
General Objective This panel examines the multifaceted interaction between populist movements and bureaucratic institutions, focusing on how institutional structures and populist ideologies jointly shape this relationship. While populism often challenges bureaucratic stability, the impact of populism varies significantly based on both the ideological leanings of the movement (right-wing, left-wing, or otherwise) and the specific political-institutional frameworks—such as federal versus unitary, presidential versus parliamentary systems, and centralised versus decentralised administrative structures. By investigating how populist movements with distinct ideological aims interact with various institutional settings, the panel seeks to understand how these combined factors influence bureaucratic integrity, adaptability, and resistance. This dual approach will clarify the conditions under which populist movements either reshape or reinforce bureaucratic norms and practices across different national contexts. Research Question The central research question guiding this panel is: How do the combined effects of institutional configurations and ideological orientations of populist movements influence the interaction between populism and bureaucracy, and what implications do these dynamics hold for governance and administrative resilience? Key sub-questions include: - How do federal and unitary systems affect the pathways through which populist movements, depending on their ideological orientations, interact with and challenge bureaucratic institutions? - In what ways do presidential and parliamentary regimes influence the strategies used by left- and right-wing populists in their engagements with bureaucracies? - How does administrative centralisation or decentralisation mediate the influence of ideologically varied populist movements on the stability and adaptability of bureaucratic institutions? - How do party system structures (single-party vs. multi-party) impact populist engagement with bureaucracy, and do these effects differ between left- and right-wing populists? Justification of Scientific Relevance The recent global surge in populism has highlighted the vulnerability of bureaucratic institutions to political disruption, yet the role of ideological and institutional factors in shaping this vulnerability remains under-explored. Right-wing populists often seek to minimize bureaucratic intervention, emphasizing deregulation and nationalism, while left-wing populists may advocate for reforms aimed at promoting social equity through bureaucracy. However, these ideological aims are conditioned by the specific institutional settings in which populists operate, influencing whether they can bypass, reshape, or co-opt bureaucratic structures to align with their agendas. This panel brings a comparative perspective to this under-researched area, examining how the interplay between institutional structures and ideological orientations affects the populism-bureaucracy relationship. By integrating ideological and institutional factors, this panel aims to identify patterns that explain the resilience or susceptibility of bureaucracies to populist influence. The findings are pertinent for both scholars and policymakers, offering insights on how institutional design can either buffer or amplify the effects of ideologically varied populist movements.
POLICY TOPICS
P06. Digital Social Media in Policymaking Process
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Is there any way social media can influence the policymaking process or contribute to policy change? How do politicians and citizens use social media to transform policies or control the policymaking process? These are some of the questions this panel intends to answer. Digital social media are defined as online technological platforms which coexist with "concrete" public spaces (Chambat, 1995) controlled by governments. Unlike Habermas' definition of public space, we extend the definition of public space to "common space", a place of "connection" where political power comes to realise (Arendt et al., 1995, pp. 7–8; Zittoun, 2013). Additionally, public spaces operate as strategic tools used by politicians and their public struggling to structure policies, transform them or control their normative orientation. Based on constructivist and pragmatist perspectives of policy studies and policymaking process, we define public policies as sets of interactions created by governments' outputs and effects on their publics who struggle to change or transform the policies using deliberative public and private spaces over time (Zittoun, 2013; Durnovà, 2019; Fischer, 2009; Weible, 2019; Edimo, 2021). The public policy literature identifies several stages of the public policymaking process (definition of the problem, formulation of solutions, agenda-setting, implementation, evaluation, etc.). Many contemporary approaches to policy studies also highlight subjective, intersubjective and pragmatist policy processes, including enunciation, formulation of the problem, planning, expertisation, and advocacy as social and political practices and activities that structure public action. They have also offered new perspectives on which to rely to enhance the study of domestic policy processes and their interactions with international or different stages of the transnational deliberative policymaking process (see, for example, Edimo, 2021). Since the works of Christopher Hood & Helen Margetts (Hood & Margetts, 2007), very few studies have focused on the role of digital technologies in transforming public action, particularly with regard to the ability of governments' publics to use and disseminate flows of information; government capacity to continue to control citizens’ behaviours, and the sociopolitical structure of processes of government, etc. While it is well known that government activities affect the citizens' behaviours, how they change according to contexts or environment where they operate.
POLICY TOPICS
P07. The Impact of Public Policy on Political Participation: Comparing Evidence from around the World
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
How does public policy shape the political participation of those most affected by its implementation? We know that policy can often have feedback effects through which individuals may be motivated to advocate for the continuation, modification, or cancellation of the policy based on its effect on their lives. But we have very little evidence from around the world about what kinds of policies tend to motivate or depress participation towards other claims and how individuals choose to get involved in various contexts. This panel seeks to bring together researchers from diverse parts of the world to foster a comparative discussion on the effects of public policies on politics to enhance our understanding of the factors that generate participation, particularly among those who are the direct targets or beneficiaries of policies. The concept of policy feedback gained traction in the 1980’s and 90’s as part of the wave to situate policy making and politics within the framework of historical institutionalism (Pierson 1993; 1994; Skocpol 1992; Weir, Orloff and Skocpol 1988). This framework brought in the dimension of time and how policies reshape politics, and then in turn politics reshape policies (Béland and Schlager 2019; Mettler and SoRelle 2014). The question of how policies impact the politics of beneficiaries has then been explored by a number of scholars in the United States (for example, Soss and Schram 2007; Mettler 2002, 2005; Campbell 2002, 2003, 2012) who find that the direction of attitudes and participation is very much conditioned by the type of policy. More recently research has expanded in a comparative direction, though like the United States more work is needed to identify how different types of policies shape political participation across diverse contexts. The genesis for this panel comes not only from this previous literature but from the chair’s research on how social programs shape the empowerment of beneficiaries to make further claims of the state across the Global North and South. The direction of the effects of policy on political participation are particularly important for social policies meant to reduce inequalities, contribute to poverty alleviation, and rectify structural discrimination. We want to know whether social policies are achieving the outcomes they are meant to produce. In other recent research, scholars have asked whether conditional cash transfer programs engender political loyalty to those most responsible for implementing the policy and under what circumstances that loyalty endures. In this panel we seek additional examples of research on political preferences as well as the range of behavior from active claims-making to greater alienation that may result from the implementation of diverse social policies, in particular. However, other types of policy also have political effects, such as those involving climate change, immigration, and economic development and these papers are also quite welcome. For example, how might development policies that aim to prevent flooding shape the politics of those most directly at risk? Empirical evidence is needed to understand the broad political effects of such policies and the aim of this panel is to bring scholars together to further this effort. For this panel I hope to bring together scholars of various thematic, academic, methodological, and geographic orientations. The call for papers is open to anyone who would like to contribute to our knowledge of the feedback effects of public policy on individuals’ political preferences and engagement. Both in-person and virtual participation are welcome. Papers may explore issues areas including, but not limited to: housing, conditional cash transfers, climate change, immigration, healthcare, education, transportation, and infrastructure. All papers should reflect evidence-based research. References: Béland, D., Schlager, E., 2019. Varieties of Policy Feedback Research: Looking Backward, Moving Forward. Policy Studies Journal 47, 184–205. Campbell, Andrea Louise. 2002. “Self-Interest, Social Security, and the Distinctive Participation Patterns of Senior Citizens.” American Political Science Review 96 (3): 565–74. . 2003. How Policies Make Citizens: Senior Political Activism and the American Welfare State. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. . 2012. “Policy Makes Mass Politics.” Annual Review of Political Science 15: 331 51. Mettler, Suzanne. 2005. Soldiers to Citizens: The G.I. Bill and the Making of the Greatest Generation. New York: Oxford University Press. . 2002. “Bringing the State Back In to Civic Engagement: Policy Feedback Effects of the G.I. Bill for World War II Veterans.” American Political Science Review 96 (2): 351–65. Mettler, Suzanne, and Mallory SoRelle. 2014. “Policy Feedback.” In Theories of the Policy Process, 3rd ed., ed. Paul A. Sabatier, and Christopher M. Weible. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 151–81. Pierson, Paul. 1993. “When Effect Becomes Cause: Policy Feedback and Political Change.” World Politics 45 (4): 595–628. . 1994. Dismantling the Welfare State? Reagan, Thatcher, and the Politics of Retrenchment. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press. Skocpol, Theda. 1992. Protecting Soldiers and Mothers: The Political Origins of Social Policy in the United States. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press. Soss, Joe, and Sanford F. Schram. 2007. “A Public Transformed? Welfare Reform as Policy Feedback.” American Political Science Review 101 (1): 111–27. Weir, Margaret, Ann Shola Orloff, and Theda Skocpol. 1988. “Introduction: Understanding American Social Politics.” In The Politics of Social Policy in the United States, ed. Margaret Weir, Ann Shola Orloff, and Theda Skocpol. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1–36.
POLICY TOPICS
P08. Sociopolitical consequences of digital and data policies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel investigates how different stakeholders influence, and are affected by, digital and data policies in different political and institutional contexts. Contributions under this theme will reflect on the heterogeneity of governmental approaches to the rise of digital data and the resulting sociopolitical consequences. We understand digital data as a deeply political issue for the power it wields to those who control it. Questions of power are tightly linked to the creation, uses, governance and impacts of digital data, as reflected by the expanding fields of critical data studies (Burns et al., 2018; Iliadis & Russo, 2016), data politics (Ruppert et al., 2017) and data justice (Taylor, 2017). The unprecedented availability of digital data and data capacities creates new kinds of value for all actors (Mejias & Couldry, 2019) and intensifies the struggles over its access and control. The scope of digital and data policies covered in this call include data-based innovations deployed by governments to fulfill their tasks and responsibilities towards their citizens, like online platforms and communication channels, digitized services, digital identification and surveillance systems. It also covers new laws and regulations that result from the governments’ mandate to legislate the unprecedented volumes of continuous and ubiquitous digital data prompted by the datafication logic (Sadowski, 2019; van Dijck, 2014), which include personal data protection, data localization and international data transfers. Based on this, relevant topics for this panel encompass the democratic quality of policy-making processes, the factors that enable or constraint stakeholder engagement, and the public values, motivations and governance principles that shape data policies and regulations. In addition, the far-reaching socio-political consequences of emerging data governance may include data rights and protection, dataveillance, mass surveillance, repression, and discrimination. Critical approaches that identify the political and policy deficiencies and challenges in the governance of digital data are strongly encouraged. We therefore welcome papers that examine how stakeholders influence, and are affected by, digital and data policies in different political regimes, especially in contexts with prevailing democratic deficiencies and/or authoritarian practices. Relevant stakeholders include governments and other state actors, international organizations, civil society, activists and citizens. References Burns, R., Dalton, C. M., & Thatcher, J. E. (2018). Critical Data, Critical Technology in Theory and Practice. The Professional Geographer, 70(1), 126–128. https://doi.org/10.1080/00330124.2017.1325749 Iliadis, A., & Russo, F. (2016). Critical data studies: An introduction. In Big Data and Society (Vol. 3, Issue 2). SAGE Publications Ltd. https://doi.org/10.1177/2053951716674238 Mejias, U. A., & Couldry, N. (2019). Datafication. INTERNET POLICY REVIEW Journal on Internet Regulation, 8(4). https://doi.org/10.14763/2019.4.1428 Ruppert, E., Isin, E., & Bigo, D. (2017). Data politics. In Big Data and Society (Vol. 4, Issue 2). SAGE Publications Ltd. https://doi.org/10.1177/2053951717717749 Sadowski, J. (2019). When data is capital: Datafication, accumulation, and extraction. Big Data and Society, 6(1). https://doi.org/10.1177/2053951718820549 Taylor, L. (2017). What is data justice? The case for connecting digital rights and freedoms globally. Big Data and Society, 4(2). https://doi.org/10.1177/2053951717736335 van Dijck, J. (2014). Datafication, dataism and dataveillance: Big Data between scientific paradigm and ideology. Surveillance & Society, 12(2), 197–208. https://doi.org/10.24908/ss.v12i2.4776
POLICY TOPICS
P09. The Policy Process in China: Formulation, Implementation, and Evaluation in Contemporary Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The policy process in China provides an insightful perspective into how public policies are formulated, implemented, and evaluated within a unique socio-political system. This panel aims to explore these aspects by focusing on the factors influencing decision-making, the complexities of policy implementation, and the mechanisms of outcome assessment. Through examining each phase of the policy cycle, the panel will uncover how governance in China operates, reflecting the interplay between central authority, local actors, and emerging societal demands. The study of policy-making in China has gained significant attention due to the country’s rapid economic transformation and social change. Historically, the policy process in China has been viewed as highly centralized, with the Communist Party of China (CPC) playing a dominant role. However, contemporary research reveals a far more intricate system characterized by both top-down directives and bottom-up experimentation. In addition, the growing emphasis on pilot programs and experimental governance highlights an adaptive policy approach that combines control with flexibility, allowing the government to manage complexity and uncertainty in an evolving environment. The research question guiding this panel is: How do various factors shape the policy formulation, implementation, and evaluation processes within the context of contemporary Chinese governance? To address this question, the panel will explore several hypotheses: (1) Policy formulation in China is characterized by a hybrid approach, blending centralized planning with local-level experimentation. This hypothesis suggests that while the central government sets overarching priorities, local governments have substantial discretion in adapting policies to suit regional contexts; (2) Successful policy implementation relies on incentive alignment, particularly through cadre evaluation systems that tie officials’ career advancement to policy outcomes. This highlights the importance of compliance mechanisms and the performance-based incentives that drive implementation at the local level; (3) Policy evaluation serves dual purposes of accountability and legitimacy, where the emphasis often leans towards showcasing positive achievements to reinforce the CPC’s legitimacy, which may lead to selective assessments and overreporting of success. These hypotheses will be contextualized through empirical examples from key policy areas such as environmental regulation, poverty alleviation, public health, etc. The scientific relevance of this panel lies in its potential to enhance our understanding of public policy processes in China’s context, where governance combines central authority with a level of local adaptability. By drawing on established theoretical frameworks and presenting case studies from contemporary China, the panel aims to bridge the gap between abstract models and real-world policy practices. This approach will contribute valuable insights for scholars and practitioners seeking to comprehend the complexities of governance in China, providing lessons that may be applicable in other contexts of rapid socio-economic transformation.
POLICY TOPICS
P01. New Frontiers in Digital Citizen Engagement - Exploring the Future of Democracy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The rapid development of digital technologies and their transformation have greatly expanded the forms and possibilities of citizen and civic engagement. This panel seeks to explore new forms of both citizen and civic engagement that go beyond traditional representative or participatory democracy. We focus on innovative approaches such as citizen science and civic technology, discussing the potential of these digital tools to transform social and political processes. Digital tools could bring about new ways of interacting, making decisions, and shaping society and politics in a more effective, participatory, and inclusive manner. We aim to examine how technological advancements are influencing democracy and civil society, and how we can leverage these technologies to foster more inclusive and effective forms of citizen and civic engagement, from both theoretical and practical perspectives. This includes evaluating how tools such as social media and digital platforms can enhance democratic participation, transparency, and accountability. Additionally, we will consider how technology can be used to bridge gaps between governments and communities, empowering marginalized voices and fostering a more participatory, responsive governance.
POLICY TOPICS
P02. Sustainable Development and Backlash Politics: Which Implications for Public Policies?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The terms “backlash” and “backlash politics” are essential elements of the contemporary political landscape. They are often used to denote conservative mobilization against policies supporting human rights, feminism, and LGBTQ+ rights. The Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) have not been left unscathed: they are perceived as a hegemonic global political program, constituting an increasingly questioned and even contested agenda (Munro, 2023). In various contexts, the movements against the SDGs have expressed their disagreement through a multitude of channels, ranging from citizens taking to the streets to officials at the highest level taking a stand, including presidents. Their opposition appears through the explicit rejection of certain institutional notions and recommendations that are currently considered predominant at different levels, whether locally, nationally, regionally, or internationally (Alter & Zürn, 2020). These movements question fundamental principles such as human rights, the importance of protecting the environment and ecosystems, and the necessity of vaccines for public health, as well as social advances such as gender parity and women’s rights. More important, they also challenge the policies and measures implemented under the 2030 Agenda, often arguing that these initiatives compromise national sovereignty, hinder economic development, or threaten cultural and traditional values. This panel aims to explore the dynamics of backlash and to understand its implications and its effects on public policies in terms of sustainable development. It will contribute, both theoretically and empirically, to this emerging literature (Alter & Zürn, 2020; Patashnik, 2019; Paternotte, 2021; Patterson, 2023; Snyder, 2020), by focusing at the same time on the analysis of backlash actors, their mobilizing forces and their ideas, as well as on the policies they dismantle, circumvent, or adopt when they come to power. These analyses will consider the constraints and requirements of sustainable development, addressing issues related to family farming, agroecological practices, climate change adaptation, biodiversity preservation, and the fight against inequalities regarding gender, education, health, and the recognition of traditional communities and indigenous knowledge. Above all, this issue aims to examine the contextual specificities of the emergence of these backlash actors, movements, and policies, as well as their crystallization and diffusion.
POLICY TOPICS
P01. Strategic Foresight and Policy Design: Applying Foresights Towards Disruptive Transformations
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
General objectives This panel explores the role of strategic foresight in public policy, emphasizing the application of foresight tools to examine and shape public policies in response to disruptive transformations. Strategic foresight, as a forward-looking approach, helps policymakers anticipate future scenarios, enabling them to proactively develop policies that are both resilient and adaptive to change. The panel aims to explore the use of strategic foresight in identifying and understanding disruptive dynamics, thereby providing policy recommendations with critical insights into emerging opportunities and risks. In today’s rapidly evolving landscape, characterized by technological breakthroughs and global challenges, the ability to foresee disruptive changes is crucial for informed decision-making. Foresight methodologies serve as powerful instruments for analyzing trends, envisioning multiple future pathways, and preparing strategic responses that mitigate potential risks while taking advantage of new opportunities. One key focus of this panel is enhancing foresight methodologies to equip researchers/policymakers with the tools to address both technological and societal challenges effectively. By integrating foresight into policy development, governments can anticipate and respond to issues ranging from technological innovations to socio-economic shifts. This proactive approach helps bridge the gap between policy formulation and the evolving needs of society, ensuring that public policies are agile, inclusive, and responsive to disruptive transformations. Research question A key research question guiding this exploration is: How can strategic foresight be enhanced to design policies that effectively address disruptive transformations? As global challenges and technological innovations continue to evolve at an unprecedented pace, understanding how to adapt foresight practices to design forward-looking policies becomes crucial. The enhancement of strategic foresight involves refining methodologies, incorporating new analytical tools, and developing more inclusive approaches that consider diverse societal needs and values. By answering this research question, this panel aims to identify pathways for making foresight practices more integral to the policymaking process, ensuring they can effectively guide responses to emerging disruptions. Scientific relevance The scientific relevance of this panel lies in advancing the understanding of how foresight can contribute to improved public policy design and implementation in an increasingly volatile and complex environment. Effective foresight involves not only predicting future trends but also understanding the potential implications of these changes for policy and governance. As technological disruptions become more pervasive, foresight tools, such as scenario analysis, horizon scanning, and trend monitoring, offer enhanced predictive capabilities. These tools enable policymakers to prepare more effectively for a wide range of potential future scenarios, reducing uncertainty and supporting more informed decision-making.
POLICY TOPICS
P02. Public policies for hybrid governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The governance of societal activities, institutions and work has always been ubiquitous but never self-explanatory. With respect to addressing global problems and pursuing important societal aims, such as combating climate change, easing up urban congestion, advancing welfare or providing education, it is difficult to disentangle public policies and agencies from private efforts, economic institutions and civic activities. With hybridity the panel refers to the interaction among public, private and civil society via distinct modes of ownership, parallel but often competing institutional logics, diverse funding bases and various forms of social and institutional control. This panel “Public policies for hybrid governance” investigates the dynamic and intricate relationships, rationalities (implicit and/or explicit), tensions and dilemmas among public, private and civic domains contributing to policy outcomes at the level of societies. There is a paradox in addressing the hybridity of policy endeavours. Societies and governments may acknowledge that governing hybridity poses a problem in how important societal impacts and forms of value are created, yet they face fundamental dilemmas with understanding why, through what mechanisms and with what impacts governing hybridity takes place. For better understanding, the panel proposes three general questions for the panel: 1) How are public policies influenced by hybridity and hybrid forms of governance? 2) To what extent and via what mechanisms do governments influence (foster or hamper) hybridity? 3) How does hybridity shape the agenda-setting, implementation and evaluation of public policies? We acknowledge hybridity both as part of policy formation, which includes goals and actors other than those of the government (hybridity of policies) and policies as a medium to govern hybridity in societies (policies for hybridity). The former view relates to grand policy challenges, for instance, in achieving sustainability, combating poverty and providing security through multilateral and multifaceted combinations of contributions. The latter refers to the reorganising and reshaping of public-private-civil society interactions through privatisation, outsourcing and other types of collaborative arrangements which increasingly require new forms of oversight and intervention. This panel invites both conceptual and empirical contributions that explore various facets of the policies on hybridity and hybridization of societies, in view of their implications on public policy analysis. Many ideas of governance acknowledge the variety of public, private and community actors in policy networks, but the significance and implications of this diversity to either public policy or to participating actors has not attracted enough attention. This gives rise to a number of questions that are explored in the panel.
POLICY TOPICS
P01. How Can Governments Deal with Mis- and Disinformation?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The harms of mis- and disinformation are shared by scholars, practitioners, and more recently, by governments around the world and the United Nations (UN 2022). Many governments are working on or have already introduced regulatory frameworks to combat this issue and prevent societal harms (e.g. EU’s approach considered to be most comprehensive legislative response in fight against disinformation (Peukert 2024; Schlag 2023) while Canada’s approach combines government regulation of online harms with promoting media literacy and working on equipping citizens with tools and skills to critically assess content they are consuming (Government of Canada 2023, 2024). Despite this mis-and disinformation continue to pose significant challenges to governance and democratic processes in the digital age and several international organizations, including UN and the World Economic Forum, have emphasized the potential of disinformation to promote social unrest, undermine electoral systems, and reinforce echo chambers and polarization. Part of the problem is that mis- and disinformation spread through complex online and offline networks by multinational actors (Stepney and Lally 2024). Finally, to date, there is no single “silver bullet” policy instrument that can counter or significantly curb its spread. Despite burgeoning research on dis- and misinformation from the political science on public trust and democracy, there is still ample debate regarding appropriate policy responses that balance between protecting free speech and introducing regulatory frameworks and other measures (Peukert 2024). The panel aims to foster a comprehensive dialogue on several critical dimensions regarding government responses to mis-and disinformation. First, despite the agreed upon definitions of mis- and disinformation, there is currently a lack of agreement on when government should interfere and what is “awful but lawful” (Hrynyshyn 2024). Second, while social media is the primary source of mis- and disinformation , its origins and dissemination include a combination of online and offline networks (Stepney and Lally 2024). Finally, while AI can play promising role in detecting mis- and disinformation and analyzing the intent behind a particular claim (WEF 2024), there is still ample debate in the scholarly community to determine how well-established definitions of mis-and disinformation can be operationalized for detection purposes. References Government of Canada. 2024. Bill C-63. https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/csj-sjc/pl/charter-charte/c63.html#:~:text=The%20Online%20Harms%20Act%20would%20impose%20a%20duty%20to%20act,exposed%20to%20harmful%20content%20online. Government of Canada. 2023. Digital Citizen contribution program. https://www.canada.ca/en/canadian-heritage/services/online-disinformation/digital-citizen-contribution-program.html Hrynyshyn, Derek. 2024. The Online Harms Act doesn’t go far enough to protect democracy in Canada. The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/the-online-harms-act-doesnt-go-far-enough-to-protect-democracy-in-canada-224929 Peukert, Alexander. 2024. “The Regulation of Disinformation: A Critical Appraisal.” Journal of Media Law 16 (1): 1–7. Schlag, Gabi. 2023. “European Union’s Regulating of Social Media: A Discourse Analysis of the Digital Services Act.” Politics and Governance 11(3): 168-177. Stepney, Eva S. and Lally Clare. 2024. Disinformation: sources, spread and impact https://post.parliament.uk/research-briefings/post-pn-0719/ WEF. 2024. Stopping AI disinformation: Protecting truth in the digital world. https://www.weforum.org/stories/2024/06/ai-combat-online-misinformation-disinformation/ UN. 2022. Countering disinformation for the promotion and protection of human rights and fundamental freedoms. Report of the Secretary General. Available at https://documents.un.org/doc/undoc/gen/n22/459/24/pdf/n2245924.pdf
POLICY TOPICS
P02. Public Policy and the fragmentation of the bureaucracy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
One of the key methods used to understand the policy process is to first identify a configuration of policy makers from several organisations that have an influence on the government decision. Whether called "iron triangle", "subgovernment", "policy subsystem", "policy network", "policy community", "policy stream" or "whirlpool", this configuration is generally considered as "the primary unit of analysis for understanding the policy process" (Sabatier and Weible 2007, 189), more or less autonomous and also part of a fragmented political system (Freeman and Stevens 1987). These concepts allow the researcher to focus on a "cluster of individuals who effectively make most of the routine decisions in a given substantive policy area" (Ripley and Franklin 1980, 8). As Charles Jones suggested, "the precise label is not important (...) what is important is the frequent observation that the politics of policy making is characterised by inter-institutional communication within a particular policy or issue area" (Jones, 1982)[1]. If these concepts are heuristics to develop most of the main classical positivist theories of the policy process, they have been met with many criticisms about their limitations, their framing and the bias they generate, even by authors who have used them and considered them "increasingly inadequate" to understand the complexity of the policy processes (McGee et Jones 2019) and, more precisely, the fragmentation of the bureaucracy, between the department, the offices, but also the conflictual dimension associated with this fragmentation, between ministries, departments, offices. The aim of this panel is to interrogate the relevant level of fragmentation of the policy field.
POLICY TOPICS
P03. Contemporary Perspectives on Political Advisers, Advisory Systems and Executive Relationships
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
There is a growing international literature on political advisers, their agency and influence, their relationships and their systemic significance, documented in a number of comparative books (Eichbaum and Shaw 2010, Shaw and Eichbaum 2018) and most recently a Handbook on Ministerial and Political Advisers (2023, ed Richard Shaw). This panel aims to capture the variety and range of new research occurring on these topics across many different political contexts and geographic spaces. There is a need to develop the field in terms of greater description, more comparative analysis, methodological sophistication, and theoretical elaboration. The panel seeks to bring together researchers working on the many different parts of this project to help understand, advance and integrate new scholarly developments.
POLICY TOPICS
P04. Public Policy Implementation and Public Organizations Management. Bringing together research traditions and professional practice
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The panel seeks to build on the work initiated at the Guadalajara workshop (IPPW 2024) focused on Implementation Studies. It aims to create a welcoming environment for dialogue on the significant research strands related to state action emerging from Political Science (specifically Policy Implementation Studies) and Public Administration (particularly Public Management Studies). We view the policy implementation literature as a segment of policy analysis that primarily draws from political science, focusing on what occurs during the realization phase of policies. In contrast, we see public management as the aspect of public administration that emphasizes the design and organizational dimensions of policies as intentional artifacts. While both fields are undoubtedly offspring of 20th-century policy sciences, they have developed in distinct environments shaped by academic research and professional practice. Our goal is to create a platform for both traditions to engage in meaningful exchanges, potentially leading to the convergence of shared knowledge. Both traditions share a foundational interest in policy sciences, particularly in exploring what occurs during the typical phases of the public policy process: problem identification, design, implementation, and the evaluation of effects. However, for reasons that have yet to be fully documented and understood, they have diverged since the late 20th century and have remained notably separate. While Policy Analysis models focus on the comparative description, explanation, and prediction of public policies, Public Management has tended to emphasize understanding policies as design artifacts and examining their functional mechanisms. Both traditions face certain challenges. Policy sciences often oversimplify complex issues, sacrificing uniqueness for the sake of comparability and, either explicitly or implicitly, neglecting the practical needs of professional knowledge. Conversely, professionally oriented disciplines tend to establish superficial research agendas based on standardized concepts, placing excessive emphasis on practice and treating practitioners' insights as privileged source of validation. We believe that fostering dialogue between these traditions could provide a clearer perspective on key issues and open the door to new knowledge grounded in shared understanding. This could lead to policy analysis models with enhanced explanatory power, as well as professional design and implementation tools informed by scientific evidence.
POLICY TOPICS
P02. Assessing Policy Implementation Performance – The Role of Context
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
General Objective This panel seeks to advance the theoretical and empirical understanding of the drivers of policy implementation performance, with a particular focus on the role of context. Building on a long-standing tradition in public policy research, this panel will explore how varying contexts impact the significance and interplay of implementation drivers, such as policy characteristics, stakeholder roles, and local administrative capacities. Our objective is to facilitate discussions that not only deepen our comprehension of existing determinant frameworks but also encourage scholars to explore under-researched areas of context-sensitive implementation. By fostering new perspectives, we aim to identify pathways for developing refined, contextually adaptive frameworks to improve policy outcomes across different domains and geographic settings. Research Question The panel addresses the central research question: How do contextual factors shape the significance and interaction of drivers in policy implementation? While decades of research have identified numerous factors that contribute to successful or failed policy implementation (O'Toole, 1986; Brynard, 2009; Winter, 2012; Bullock et al., 2021; Ambang, 2023), there remains limited empirical knowledge about the conditions under which these drivers apply. Specifically, we aim to examine whether specific contextual factors, such as political stability, administrative capacity, and social dynamics, modulate the influence of key implementation variables. Addressing these gaps may lead to more robust and predictive frameworks that are attuned to the diversity of implementation environments globally. Justification of Scientific Relevance The study of policy implementation has produced an impressive array of determinant frameworks and models, yet there are limitations. Early frameworks, including those of Sabatier and Mazmanian (1980) and subsequent models (e.g., Alexander 1985; Goggin 1986; Winter 2012), offer valuable structures but often lack systematic integration of contextual dimensions (deLeon, 1999; Pülzl & Treib, 2007). Recent advances, like Bullock et al.'s (2021) determinant framework, have enhanced comprehensiveness but still miss the contextual nuance critical to predicting implementation outcomes across different settings. Matland’s (1995) ambiguity/conflict model is one of the few examples of contextually informed frameworks, providing a parsimonious, adaptable approach. However, significant potential remains for expanding contingent theories that incorporate complex, multi-dimensional contexts. By focusing on context as an integral factor, this panel aims to address a recognized gap in the literature and offer insights into when, where, and why certain explanatory factors take precedence in the implementation process.
POLICY TOPICS
P03. The Digital Turn in Public Services: Innovation, Repackaging, and the Shifting Nature of Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
For over two decades policy scholars have researched the impact of ICT, e-government and more recently the digitalisation and use of AI in the transformation of public sector services and what this means for relations between the state, organisations, communities and individuals (Viana 2021). E-government and the digital transformation of government services was seen to herald in new forms of deliberation, engagement and transform modes of access to services and transactions with agencies (Katsonis and Botros 2015). These reforms spoke to neoliberal goals of improved service responsiveness, timely and convenient access, higher levels of diversification allowing the tailoring and individualisation of services, as well as greater competition and efficiency through the use of online provider platforms. Data collection, monitoring, surveillance, and the analysis of behaviour, demand and the environment has provided higher levels of granulised information services. This includes real time data provision (eg, transport users) which has strengthened regulation and enforcement (electronic monitoring of transactions and behaviour), and supported timely safety warnings and responses (eg, hazardous weather alerts and public health warnings). Change and development in this field is rapid and continuous and the advent of AI has accelerated the capacity of digitalisation to seep into public sector analysis and decision making across a range of issues that might otherwise have been subject to higher levels of human supervision, intervention and determination. Increasingly, expertise, knowledge and product development is occurring outside the public sector with agencies purchasing digital services that assist with the progression of public policy objectives. This points to the complex multiorganizational arrangements that now constitute public service delivery and governance arrangements. This panel provides a timely opportunity to take stock of how the impact of digital transformation is not only reshaping the provision of services but also the decision making processes that impact how public governance occurs. We take a broad approach to the topic and are interested to explore how digitalisation has driven service innovation, the barriers and exclusions that such innovations might unintentionally create (O’Sullivan and Walker 2018), the role of third party providers and how their expertise and interests may reshape service provision and the direction of state policy objectives. And while more than a decade ago authors pointed to the opportunities for higher levels of deliberation, participation and engagement in policy and governance processes (OECD 2009), we are interested in observations of current practice to test the extent to which this has actually occurred or do such goals remain constrained, and why is this the case? References: Katsonis, M. and A. Botros (2015). "Digital government: A primer and professional perspectives." Australian Journal of Public Administration 74(1): 42-52. O’Sullivan, S. and C. Walker (2018). "From the interpersonal to the internet: social service digitalisation and the implications for vulnerable individuals and communities." Australian Journal of Political Science 53(4): 490-507. OECD (2009). Rethinking E-Government Services: User-Centred Approaches. Paris, OECD Publishing. Viana, A. C. A. (2021). "Digital transformation in public administration: from e-Government to digital government." International Journal of Digital Law 2(2): 29-46.
POLICY TOPICS
P04. Active labour market policies: new challenges between governance and implementation.
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Active labour market policies (ALMPs) should address the so-called ‘new risks’ that have prevailed since the 90s as well as new challenges, for example those emerging from technological change, population aging and climate change. In these respects, ALMP represent a crucial field to cushion the impact structural changes have had on employment by providing training, counselling and (subsidised) access into the labour market. However, ALMPs have recently attracted criticism for several reasons. Since they are subjected to fiscal pressures and performance targets, the access to ALMPs can be biased towards (unemployed) labour market insiders with better employment prospects. These biases, known as ‘Matthew effects’, result in insiders’ accumulation of advantages, leaving those most disadvantaged behind. Scholars are then questioning whether ALMPs promote sustainable employment or, rather, the expansion of low-skill short-term jobs. New concerns are rising as digital processes and artificial intelligence are being implemented within public employment services (PES). The use of more digitalised service can be unsuitable, complicated and estranging for the most vulnerable groups, which are at the core of ALMPs. At the same time, digitalisation affects substantial policy tools, as well as organisational conditions and governance regimes in PES. Policy tools typically utilised to reform welfare-to-work, such as performance-based contracting, have already been driven by attempts to discipline frontline discretion. In several countries, these tools are now evolving towards new modes of digital governance that seek to reshape the delivery of services using algorithms and machine learning. From a welfare-to-work perspective, digital technologies become part of the process of making it easier for clients to be quickly re-employed. The logic is to standardise and automatise relatively routinised services and thereby free frontline employees to deal with the more complex tasks that require human interaction and discretion. In building a culture of data collection and performance monitoring, new concerns may be raised among frontline staff about a further potential reduction of their discretion in delivering ALMPs. This does not exclude that it is possible to see new types of coping strategies emerging among frontline workers as they seek to deal not only with performance management but also with the technology. The aim of this panel is to provide an account of the role played by ALMPs and PES in recent times. The panel welcomes both theoretical and empirical contributions that offer new insights on: how ALMP interventions are designed as well as on their impact; the role of frontline discretion on service delivery; the ways in which governance systems could shape street-level delivery; the potential and limits of replacing human-to-human assistance with digital tools.
POLICY TOPICS
P05. The Role of Inefficient Bureaucracy in the Failure of Public Service Delivery in Sub-Saharan Africa
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
General Objective The object of the research is to explain how inefficient bureaucracies help undermine the delivery of public services in Sub-Saharan Africa. It will trace the historical trajectories and extant dynamics of administrative structures of the African state in order to identify the political forces and processes that sustain bureaucratic inefficiency in public institutions. The research will thus identify the linkages between the various manifestations of bureaucratic inefficiency – labour management, graft and corruption, cost structures– and the deleterious consequences of such inefficiency on the delivery of public services, ranging from education and health to infrastructure and other public goods. Furthermore, it will identify opportunities for systems with the view to improving service delivery and governance in the subregion. Research Questions 1. How did inequality of effort in the administration of public service provision in Sub-Saharan Africa historically become a source of its failure? 2. What is it, about the institutional makeup of bureaucracies, such as corruption, red-tape or political interference, that leads to low levels of efficiency prevalent in Sub-Saharan Africa? 3. How does poor governance in the form of inefficient bureaucracy impede vital public services, such as health, education and infrastructure development in nations in Sub-Saharan Africa? 4. How much do lost productivity and cumbersome service delivery cost the state and society, and to what extent does this problem diminish the fiscal and administrative capacity of central and local authorities? These and other related questions continue to be under-researched. Unfortunately, the issues in seminar rooms will not simply vanish. Failing to address this issue would be a colossal waste – literally. What institutional strategies or reforms can be undertaken to improve the efficiency and quality of public service delivery by bureaucracies in Sub-Saharan Africa? Scientific Relevance This research holds significant scientific relevance for several reasons. Filling intermittent research lacunae: Though there is a substantial body of literature on governance, corruption and economic challenges for Sub-Saharan Africa, there is a critical gap in our understanding of how bureaucratic inefficiency leads to public service delivery failure. By focusing on managerial challenges to labour management and cost considerations, this line of query opens new ground for exploration in an understudied area of African governance. Historical and Institutional Lesson: Since the historical development of labour management in Sub-Saharan Africa illustrates how taxation, labour exploitation, and state-administered labour: 1) led to the descent of well-situated labourers into abject poverty while existing outside the political sphere, and 2) decreased economic efficiency and induced wasteful consumption, comprehending these features can inform us why public administration is presently so dysfunctional and what is needed to reform these practices. Policy Implications: In addition to generating insights of theoretical interest, this research also has direct policy relevance. Sub-Saharan Africa faces great difficulties in delivering basic services to its citizens. The goal of this research is to inform the policies toward bureaucratic reform that have the potential to enable significant improvements in constructive citizen engagement in public service delivery, governance and the quality of state performance. Contribution to Development Studies: Effective support for development relies on the provision of public services. Determining whether bureaucracy facilitates or impedes sustainable development on the African continent, as Africa moves closer to meeting its development objectives, is a vital empirical question for the development studies literature generally and for the growing body of literature on the relationship between the nature of governance and the role of public administration and economic growth. In short, there are strong academic reasons for conducting this study, as well as practical ones aimed at improving governance and service delivery throughout Sub-Saharan Africa. The findings from this study can help to inform decision-makers, streamline administrative processes and build a better future for millions of African citizens.
POLICY TOPICS
P03. Building a Transformative Agenda for Health through Responsive Policy Design
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Context and Objectives: Global migration health remains critically under-researched, especially in low- and middle-income regions like South Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa, where complex migration patterns leave the health needs of migrants unmet. Time constraints further limit responsive policy design due to persistent evidence gaps. The Migration Health South Asia Network (MiHSA) has developed a standardized multi-method protocol, MigPolX, to bridge this policy-practice gap and support migration-aware and migrant-sensitive health policies, tested by GEMMS, an NIHR-funded global-health research group that aims to disrupt cycles of gendered violence and poor mental health among migrants in precarious settings. This panel will discuss insights from the development, application and GEMMS’ site experiences of MigPolX. Scientific Relevance: Migrants’ health and the field of migration health is affected by decision making at multiple levels from global to local, across the health and non-health sectors(Onarheim et al., 2021). These decisions inform policies that impact service provisions, entitlements and access and knowledge production on migration health(Kapilashrami et al., 2023). Experts have been calling for adopting rights-based approaches while developing migration policy (Kapilashrami, et al., 2020). However, there are limited tools available to benchmark integration or equitability of policies on migrant health. A range of tools have been developed to assess the adequacy of provision, and the extent of inclusiveness of policies in meeting the needs of vulnerable populations. However, tools like MIPEX (Migrant Integration Policy Index) largely stems from EU’s need to effectively manage as well as protect border while managing migration and asylum due to displacement prompted by the events of political and military unrest in Southern Mediterranean (European Commission, 2011). The IMPEX adaptation focuses on intra-country policy integration for India (Manatschal, 2011) (Aggarwal, Solano, Singh, & Singh, 2020). There is the JAHEE country profile and frameworks like Equiframe, all lacking local adaptation, contextualization and considerations in design and results. Research Questions and Hypotheses: The panel will address the following research questions: 1. How do local contexts influence the responsiveness and adaptability of migration health policies? 2. What are the comparative benefits of using tools like CHNRI, MigPolX, Delphi, MIPEX, and EQUIFRAME for policy appraisal and reforms? 3. How can participatory protocols align global and local migration health needs to foster system-wide improvements? The panel will open with an overview of MigPolX’s development, rationale, and practical implications, drawing on lessons from implementation in diverse regions including Cambodia, Nepal, and South Africa, followed by a discussion on how other indices and tools like MIPEX, IMPEX, JAHEE and EQUIFRAME have informed its design—detailing each nation’s experiences implementing MigPolX and adapting standardized tools to local migration health contexts. The panel will include Prof Kapilashrami (Chair), Prof Vearey (Co-Chair) and Dr Aziz (Co-Chair). They will discuss the practical considerations of how standardized policy tools, when adapted to diverse national contexts, can reveal insights into the adaptability and limitations of current policy responses to migration health, and how a participatory protocol can lead to forward-thinking, migration-responsive health agendas that meet the evolving needs of migrants, especially in low- and middle-income countries.
POLICY TOPICS
P04. Transforming policy capacities: understanding development through learning initiatives
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Public administrations worldwide face ever increasing pressures to develop new policy capacities in response to complex challenges. While substantial financial and human resources are invested in learning and development (L&D) programs to build these capacities, we lack systematic understanding of how such interventions transform policy capacities in practice. This set of panels examines the mechanisms through which different forms of learning initiatives contribute to policy capacity development in public administration. The literature on policy capacities (Wu, Ramesh, Howlett 2015) has proposed frameworks for understanding analytical, operational, and political dimensions of capacity. Simultaneously, research on organisational learning and professional development has identified various mechanisms for capability building (e.g. Goah, Elliott, Quano 2012). These streams remain largely disconnected, however, leaving critical gaps in our understanding of how, and whether, learning interventions result in changed and improved policy capacity. This set of panels responds to questions covering: 1. Conceptual - How can we theorise the mechanisms through which L&D initiatives transform policy capacities? What different explanatory frameworks frame policy capacity development? 2. Empirical – What evidence exists about the effectiveness of different learning interventions in developing policy capacities across various contexts? What conditions enable or constrain successful capacity development? 3. Methodological – What innovative approaches can advance our understanding of how policy capacities are transformed through learning initiatives? References Goh, S. C., Elliott, C., & Quon, T. K. (2012). The relationship between learning capability and organizational performance: A meta‐analytic examination. The learning organization, 19(2), 92-108. Wu, X., Ramesh, M., & Howlett, M. (2015). Policy capacity: A conceptual framework for understanding policy competences and capabilities. Policy and society, 34(3-4), 165-171.
POLICY TOPICS
P05. Bringing Law (back) in: Contributions of the Law and Public Policy Approach to Public Policy Analysis
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel starts from the assumption that legal knowledge provides crucial contributions to the multidisciplinary analysis of public policies, both from descriptive and prescriptive perspectives. The law and public policy (LPP) approach focuses on the role of law and legal experts in public policies, recognizing the theoretical, methodological, and empirical relevance of legal issues in policy formulation, implementation, evaluation, and control. Current scholarship in this field emphasizes three main analytical dimensions: 1) substantive law, focused on studying the institutionalization of rights and the organizational dimensions of policies; 2) legal control mechanisms exercised by judicial and oversight bodies; and 3) the interaction with legal disciplines to develop innovative categories for structured legal operations. Descriptive analyses of public policies are enriched by technical understanding of the normative frameworks that shape policies, as laws materialize decisions and procedures that constitute public policies. The LPP approach particularly values discussions on: the State's role in public policies; relations between State and civil society in policy-building processes; the interplay between legal and political elements; and the importance of institutional contexts in decision-making and legal innovations. We are particularly interested in studies describing elements of sectoral policy arrangements, whether focused on substantive law (such as education, health, social assistance, public security, environment, and culture), on the legal control of public policies by the Judiciary, the Public Prosecutor's Office, Audit Courts, and comptrollers, or on the interaction between public policy issues and legal disciplines (constitutional, administrative, tax, procedural, criminal law, among others). Understanding these processes enables the development of learning repertoires that could be replicated across contexts, sectors, and government levels. This approach emphasizes activities related to institutional engineering and policy design, particularly focusing on how different legal-institutional arrangements influence policy outcomes. Research Questions: 1. What legal elements ensure the sustainability and resilience of public policies in unfavorable political contexts? 2. How does law shape the coordination of government agents in federal contexts? 3. What is law's role in coordinating governmental and non-governmental agents in governance contexts? 4. Which regulatory instruments best address the challenges of multi-level governance in public policies? The central hypothesis is that policy success - measured through outcomes, organizational processes, and democratic legitimacy - is significantly determined by legal-institutional arrangements. These arrangements vary in their normative flexibility, hierarchical levels, and stakeholder participation in policy processes. The panel aims to strengthen the interface between law and public policy analysis through three main objectives: (1) enhancing legal experts' participation in academic discussions of public policy; (2) fostering theoretical and practical knowledge accumulation in the field; and (3) building an academic network focused on this intersection, promoting experience sharing and future collaborations.
POLICY TOPICS
P06. Governance of Intersectoral Policies with the Population - Capturing novelties: new citizens, new technologies, new truths
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Intersectoral policies are often regarded as necessary to cope with contemporary population demands. However, as Ingram, De Leon and Schneider (2016) alert, neither policy studies are always engaged with democratic debates nor democratic theories are reflecting policy studies. This panel proposal goes beyond participation and intersectoral action as normative horizons to observe the nexuses among cross-cutting emerging issues, participatory forums and complex public policies. The panel will access different lenses to study the logics of democratic and robust governance (Ansell, Sorensen & Torfing, 2021) and its instrumentation (Halpern, Lascoumes & Le Galès, 2014), observing the new citizenries, new technologies and new truths. Issues such as the post pandemic sanitary crisis, basic need for homeless or violence against women have given impetus for stronger connections between front line workers and managers in collaborative governance networks. At the same time, the voice of the population calling for more equity, pragmatism and doubting the effectiveness of governmental measures became louder. Along the political agenda, we observe the emergence of social truths and artificial intelligence (Patel et al, 2021). Social truths encompasses the opinions from often historically disadvantaged or less visible groups in decision-making processes. This Panel recognizes contemporary changes in our societies that are reframing the State, and observes emerging participatory-deliberative arrangements (Fung, Cohen, 2004; Cruz, 2020). Furthermore, we are interested to address how novelties help in capturing citizens' needs to adjust and improve complex intersectorial policies (Smits et al, 2016; Smits, 2018; Cruz; Daroit, 2023). Challenges to identify, integrate and manage divergent new voices are numerous. We intend to generate debate around empirical and/or theoretical advances with respect to structural/cognitive/ethical aspects of governing intersectoral policies with the population, sharing arguments on a new axis for research. Therefore, the panel questions are: 1.Who are the game changers in the governance of complex policies with the population? for instance, Are historically disadvantaged or less visible groups relevant? What is the role of new technologies and artificial intelligence in shaping complex intersectoral policies? Are there undesirable outcasts (or unexpected actors) participants in these instances to shape complex intersectoral policies? 2. What are the consequences of the introduction of game changers in the governance of complex policies with the population? for instance, Which kind of relations are produced among the decision makers and population, new technologies and new actors involved in intersectoral management policies? How? Which results have risen up from the mobilization of the population, new technologies and new actors in intersectoral initiatives? What has changed in the research agenda on intersectoral policy governance with the population, new technologies and new actors? 3. Are the participatory forums, instruments and new technologies regarding intersectoral action oriented towards deepening democracy? for instance, In which settings are complex policies proposals being designed with the population? Are there criterias to allow social diversity and distinct techno-political substracts in new forms of representation? Are the instruments and technologies organizing participatory institutions dialogically established? 4. What theories are informative to understand the governance of intersectoral policies with the population?
POLICY TOPICS
P07. Policy Analysis in the Philippines
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Public policy in the Philippines – as a distinct subject of research and teaching – is still at its infancy. The development of a public policy discipline has largely intersected with (and marginalized by) the development of political science and public administration (Torneo 2020)1. It is thus not surprising that there is no public policy school in the country and the field only operates as a cognate of the broader disciplines (Nair et al. 2021). Policy research, to some extent, can rival other countries in the region but the research largely remains practical without sufficient engagement with theoretical developments (Dressel and Stern 2021). To what extent has the country advanced with its systematic approach to policymaking remains an (unanswered) empirical question. The legacy of colonial rule has inevitably stirred these developments. Approaches to studying how the government makes its decision often adopt the Western notion of policy sciences that diminished the ability of the discipline to take root and establish its own indigenous approaches (Reyes 1979)2. More recent scholarly works suggest that many of the Western concepts are still adopted but there are theoretical insights generated. For instance, the use of knowledge in political discourse appears to be more conceptual and instrumental than political, contrary to what is believed in popular discourse (Tabuga 2015). Policy consultants have a growing influence but in a more procedural manner (Saguin 2018). These select studies point to the ways in which expanding knowledge production into underexplored contexts like the Philippines can unlock new ways of thinking about public policy in general. The study and practice of public policy lies in a theoretically insightful context. Policy analysis in the Philippines as a practice entails cognizance of various focuses, perspectives, and approaches intertwined with the long-standing traditional political culture and social dynamics. Policy analysis may have been deployed to legitimize contentious use of power for political domination particularly since international organizations and neo-colonial powers exercise disproportionate influence over domestic policy processes, although adoption of such policies have been slow and selective (Saguin 2013). More recently, it features a more deliberate search for transfer of policies from the Global South but such processes are intermediated by colonial and imperial legacies (Ramesh et al 2018). These are significant manifestations to unpack from the Philippines' case. Our broad concern is to answer the question: How does policy analysis work in a country with a long history of colonial, imperial, and authoritarian regimes? This panel in concerned with examining the study and practice of policy analysis in the Philippines. First, it hopes to historicize the developments of policy analysis in the country to bring a substantial understanding of fundamental paradigms, normative assumptions, and traditional practices instrumental to the evolution of policy analysis. Second, the panel seeks to examine the country's existing landscapes of policy analysis by pointing out approaches utilized by both private and public sectors, local and national governments. Lastly, the panel will articulate emerging contestations to the mainstream approaches from constructivist and post-structuralist epistemologies grounded from real-world experiences and practices.
POLICY TOPICS
P08. Ethical Principles for AI in Policy Design
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The increasing prevalence of AI is potentially transforming policy design. Yet much recent normative discussion on principles governing AI remains largely assumed, highly general, overlapping, and/or conflicting (Whittlestone et al., 2019). What normative principles are relevant to the incorporation of AI in the process and content of policy design? Are these principles well-justified? How different principles may be realized and potentially reconciled in governing the use of AI in policy design? A review of the literature has identified the most prevalent ethical principles for AI as transparency, privacy, accountability, and fairness (Khan et al., 2022). An “ethics by design” approach proposes that AI should align with human moral values in achieving functional goals and solving problems (Brey & Dainow, 2020). More concrete proposal includes a human-centered approach (Chrisley, 2020), with the deployment of the international human rights framework to guide ethical principles development (Yeung et al., 2020). Others propose the development of rigorous and practically relevant frameworks and guidelines for AI ethics by explicitly recognizing the tension among AI-governing principles (Whittlestone et al., 2019). Practical judgement is also emphasized to build and maintain “structures and policies that help to avert, limit or resolve tension and conflicts between enactments of normative principles” (O’Neill, 2018: 207). The logic of design thinking provides a good theoretical foundation to engage with these discussions, addressing AI challenges with innovative approaches and concrete solutions. Apart from an instrumental account focused on clear objectives and means to achieve them, a process account of “collective managing” emphasizes mutual recognition and shared discourse. Scholars of “new policy design” takes account of the “context” and consider the range of “feasible” options possible in a given circumstance (Howlett 2014; Colebatch, 2022). Discussion on normative principles and their guidance to policy design may be incorporated into these contexts. This panel hopes to galvanize these endeavors and facilitate a more in-depth discussion on relevant normative principles governing the incorporation of AI in policy design, so that suitable principles and correspondingly practical arrangements may be developed. Proposals addressing ethical problems, both theoretical and applied, at different stages of the policy process in various policy areas and settings, are welcome. The panel is interested in discussions and proposals of relevant principles derived from diverse philosophical traditions, as well as practical proposal such as political-administrative institutional designs for facilitating the application of these principles. References Brey, P., & Dainow, B. (2020). Ethics by design and ethics of use approaches for artificial intelligence, robotics and big data. SIENNA. In. Chrisley, R. (2020). A human-centered approach to AI ethics. The Oxford handbook of ethics of AI, 463-474. Colebatch, H. K. (2022). Making sense of (and with) policy design. In Research Handbook of Policy Design (pp. 120-134). Edward Elgar Publishing. Howlett, M. (2014). From the ‘old’ to the ‘new’ policy design: Design thinking beyond markets and collaborative governance. Policy sciences, 47, 187-207. Khan, A. A., Badshah, S., Liang, P., Waseem, M., Khan, B., Ahmad, A., Fahmideh, M., Niazi, M., & Akbar, M. A. (2022). Ethics of AI: A systematic literature review of principles and challenges. Proceedings of the 26th International Conference on Evaluation and Assessment in Software Engineering, O'Neill, O. (2018). From principles to practice: Normativity and judgement in ethics and politics. Cambridge University Press. Whittlestone, J., Nyrup, R., Alexandrova, A., & Cave, S. (2019). The role and limits of principles in AI ethics: Towards a focus on tensions. Proceedings of the 2019 AAAI/ACM Conference on AI, Ethics, and Society, Yeung, K., Howes, A., & Pogrebna, G. (2020). AI governance by human rights–centered design, deliberation, and oversight. The Oxford handbook of ethics of AI, 77-106.
POLICY TOPICS
P09. Governing with complexity: Addressing policy challenges of technology adoption in cities.
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Research objective & scientific relevance: Cities today face a range of complex and interconnected challenges in their efforts to become environmentally safe, economically productive, sustainable, and inclusive. Issues such as rapid urbanisation, climate change, socio-spatial inequality, and ageing infrastructure are inherently difficult to address. Compounding these challenges is the fact that urban environments are complex adaptive systems with emergent properties accompanied by uncertainties, driven by both internal dynamics and external influences (Batty, 2009). To tackle these challenges while pursuing sustainability goals amid competing resource demands, cities are increasingly embracing technology as a development and governance strategy. This shift is particularly evident in adoption of smart city strategies in urban development models (Hollands 2008, Albino et al. 2015, De Jong et al. 2015, Schraven at al. 2021), which emphasise the key role of technological innovation. While advanced technologies offer significant advantages, they also introduce new technical, societal, and governance challenges (Taeihagh et al. 2021), requiring enhanced government capacity and strategic planning. In this context, complexity-informed approaches offer a valuable framework for understanding and managing the intricacies of tech-driven urban environments (Sengupta et al. 2017). Yet, despite their benefits, the use of complexity-informed approaches remains limited in policy and governance settings (Eppel, 2017; Šucha, 2017, Nel and Taeihagh 2024). This panel aims to identify and explore governance structures and policy frameworks that can effectively address the challenges and complexity in tech-driven cities. We will also examine how complexity-informed approaches and methods can be utilised to enhance urban governance and policymaking. Research Questions: 1. What are the policy challenges presented by the adoption of advanced technologies in cities? 2. How can governments build policy capacities to manage the policy challenges of tech-driven urban environments such as smart cities? 3. How can complexity-informed approaches be used in policy design to facilitate better governance of smart cities? 4. How can adaptive and anticipatory governance strategies help cities manage advanced technologies in complex evolving urban environments? 5. What policy capacities are needed to take advantage of complexity-informed approaches for smart city governance?
POLICY TOPICS
P10. Governance of digital information and building trust: Examining the role of policy design in the era of Generative AI
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Remarkable progress and access to digital technology has led to substantial increase in creation, distribution and consumption of digital information (Jaidka et al., 2024; Ng & Taeihagh, 2021). Consumers now have curated and personalized access to information and opinions. The transformation in digital information ecosystem, while has democratised information, it has also enabled unchecked growth of unverifiable, false, deceitful, and at times, harmful information. Classified as misinformation, disinformation, and mal-information (MDM), its proliferation has led to a ‘digital information paradox’- a situation of unbridled access to information accompanied by low levels of trust in such information (Jaidka et al., 2024). Beyond trust in information, proliferation of MDM been associated with substantial public harm arising from decline in social trust and trust in political and administrative institutions (Saurwein & Spencer-Smith, 2020). Recent cases where MDM were extensively used to influence electoral and democratic outcomes have manifested such concerns in real time and increased urgency amongst governments to address concerns related to MDM. The emergence of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) has further exacerbated these issues (Khanal et al., 2024). The ability of GenAI to mass-produce synthetic digital information that mimics the features of human-generated content has raised concerns about exacerbation of MDM and its impact on building a digitally resilient society (Jaidka et al., 2024). While there has been a widespread acknowledgement about the issue of MDM, there are significant divergences in problem definition. An emerging body of literature focuses on MDM as a technical problem and focuses on identifying issues related to information consumption and information lifecycle (Jaidka et al., 2024). It seeks to identify processes and mechanisms associated within digital ecosystems that incentivize and facilitate growth of MDM and identify processes to design robust information systems (Abbas & Taeihagh, 2024; Ng & Taeihagh, 2021). A more common set of studies approach this issue politically, focusing on specific micro-, meso-, and macro-level drivers of creation, distribution and consumption of MDM. Studies here focus on relationship between issues such as income, political orientation, voting behavior, and changing geopolitical and socio-economic landscapes and consequences of MDM (Corner, 2017; Farkas & Schou, 2018; Lazer et al., 2018; Pennycook & Rand, 2021). Finally, the last set of studies considers MDM to be a crucial element of a larger socio-technical assemblage on information. MDM’s growth is situated within an ecosystem of declining trust in existing political systems, misaligned incentives of information creation that encourages clickbait, rise in digital platforms, and crisis of traditional journalism (Cassar, 2023). Differences in approaches to problem definition has also led to divergence in arguments for governance approaches. Significant differences can be noticed in terms of urgency and comprehensiveness of the problem, in governance of information, and in extent and nature of participation of different actors involved in the digital ecosystem (Cassar, 2023; Jaidka et al., 2024; Kozyreva et al., 2024; Ulnicane, 2024). There is also a recognition that extensive control on information can come at the cost of fundamental democratic rights such as freedom of information (Kozyreva et al., 2023; Neo, 2021). This panel will explore some of these challenges and approaches taken to build trust in digital information. Papers in the panel will discuss the potential and existing regulatory and policy approaches available to the policymakers to address the governance challenges and build trust in digital information systems. More specifically, the papers in the panel will answer the following research questions: What are the technical, social, ethical, and governance challenges associated with digital information in the age of GenAI? What are the existing policy and regulatory frameworks adopted by governments to combat the challenges brought on by MDM? How can governments build trust in the stages of digital information lifecycle? How can trust in digital information contribute to building a digitally resilient society?
POLICY TOPICS
P11. Doing policy design differently: what do designers do for policy-making?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The following panel is focussed on the interaction of design as a process oriented approach within the context of public policy development. The relationship between design and public policy has existed for quite some time within the context of both the field of policy studies as well as design studies respectively. The organizers of this panel intend to explore the role, contribution and limitations of ‘design for policy’ to public policy development. Distinguishing between traditional views on ‘policy design’ as goal-oriented, analytical, knowledge-based, and departing from a given problem definition versus more contemporary ‘design for policy’ approaches as goal-seeking, creative, empathy-based, and aimed at reframing public issues, we focus on the latter. While complimentary on paper, these two design orientations are often difficult to unite in practice. Public organizations generally have a long history of following the traditional policy design logic. Over years, this has become a ‘design legacy’, deeply embedded in the DNA of public organizations. This also means that introducing design for policy approaches creates tensions and difficulties. Consequently, design for policy is often only used as an instrumental or symbolic intervention in a process guided by other principles. The question then is how a productive interaction between these two design orientations can be realized. Further, we seek to transcend the models of ‘design for policy’ and ‘policy design’ by seeking new forms of systems thinking when applied to the confluence of policy and design. In other words, we are attempting to find new ways of understanding this merger that have not yet been identified. Overall, when and how should policyand design be integrated to or separated from one another in order to avoid frictions and realize synergies? What does this mean for the capabilities, roles, and interplay between the people involved in this interaction? And what does this imply for future policy-making processes, as well as its governance?
POLICY TOPICS
P12. Public Policy Frames, Water Governance and Policy Choices in a Climate-Impacted World
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Specific public policy frames shape water governance, policy designs, and determine policy choices. These considerations shape decision-making for managing the landscape, water quality, food production, and are undertaken at multiple levels. The management of water in its many dimensions must consider a range of valuations that are based on economic value, social and human value, administrative enforcement, legal substantiation, and political considerations. Public policy provides the necessary framing for identifying and evaluating such valuations. Policy choices depend on how policy frames prioritize various stakeholders' motives in designing solutions. The manner in which different stakeholders in governments and societies address water has become more significant with growing scarcity, competing usages, and distributive challenges due to climate change. It becomes even more pressing to analyse the different public policy frameworks adopted by states, cities, and varied local contexts. For instance, states would like to enhance their share of water rights, municipalities would prefer financial sustainability, and local contexts would try to address challenges of extreme climate fluctuations - increasing aridity and flooding - that they are impacted by. Such public policy frames shape policy responses, policy designs, and decision-making. A perspective that centers policy frames adds value to our discussion on water governance, for it identifies the path of policy choices that emerge from these frames. Various governance decisions vary across states and societies concerning the organization of extraction, provision, financing, use, distribution, and disposal of water. Examining these policy frames would create the crucial policy question of how different responses on account of a range of actors — government organisations, community organisations, and companies — can collectively address climate-induced considerations. An appreciation of varying policy frames and their paths to mitigate the effects of climate change could lead to developing new policy perspectives that attempt to harmonize the existing competing frames. A second research question is how to identify the knowledge held by each of these actors regarding the forms and processes of power and politics in shaping water governance. This makes framing public policy design and policy choices explicit to address the production and reproduction of class, gender, ethnic, and political inequalities in water access and usage. These themes are relevant when many states, cities, and local contexts have insufficient water for all usages, including food production, municipal services, and biodiversity conservation. Water quality is also threatened by intensive land use and industrial and domestic wastewater production. Consequently, addressing research questions regarding the framing of public policy around different responses and types of knowledge will be necessary to manage disputes between stakeholders with diverging interests. The answers to the research questions will also make explicit the differences in institutional, economic, geographic, ideological and social positions on the valuation of water. Thirdly, it will show the relationship between water decisions and governance and the imaginaries, narratives, and values identified by different agents and stakeholders from various perspectives, case studies, and contexts.
POLICY TOPICS
P13. Regenerating Collaborations in Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel seeks to explore the relationship between the different forms of public policy collaborations and the governance of the commons through the lens of commoning. Collaboration has become a key policy for addressing wicked problems and complexity (e.g. Bianchi, 2021; Hofstad et al., 2021). It has also been recognized as an essential means for achieving public values, democratizing the civil service, and diversifying it (e.g., Wagenaar & Wenninger, 2020; Ansell et al., 2017; Sher-Hadar et al., 2021). However, despite the many types of collaborations developed and the vast research on them (e.g., cross-sector partnerships, private-public partnerships, co-creation, collaborative governance: Almog-Bar and Zichlinsky, 2010; Sher-Hadar et al., 2021; Ansell & Torfing, 2021; Torfing et al., 2021), it seems that a different approach should be taken amidst the accelerating polycrises. We believe that integrating the vast knowledge gathered from research on collaborations with contemporary literature on commoning may offer valuable insights for developing powerful new policy tools or enhance policy methods (such as DPA, Hajer and Wagenaar, 2003) that can help mitigate these worrying trends by regenerating the governance of the commons (Bollier, 2024). "Commoning" originated from the word "commons" and refers to the creation of peer-governed, context-specific systems for free, fair, and sustainable lives (Bollier & Helfrich, 2019, pp. 97-98). It entails the capacity of people to self-organize to meet their needs and solve problems independently of the state or market (Ibid, 2019, p.15). The commoning worldview is built on shared responsibility, deep communion with nature, and mutual care and reciprocity. Commoning can effectively enhance the deliberative and practice capacities of policy systems – key tools in DPA 2.0 (Wagenaar, 2022). Recent insights from commoning and commons-based approaches to public policy (Bollier, 2024) point to two core issues that may help us understand this shortcoming: (1) Commoning views collaboration as much more than an instrumental tool for solving collective problems. It is a vital practice in and of itself for cultivating fertile ground for strengthening democracy and fostering trust in institutions and across diverse groups. (2) Commoning treats the commons (both physical and cultural) not as private goods or resources to be exploited instrumentally and effectively. They are recognized as integrative socio-ecological systems that sustain and regenerate life.
POLICY TOPICS
P14. Policy integration and integrative capacity
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Integration is a process that involves multiple actors, government agencies and policy domains addressing complex problems that exceed the scope of individual sectoral goals (Cejudo and Michel 2017). Integrated approaches can be the drivers for overcoming policy overlap, conflict, inefficiencies and inconsistencies (Briassoulis 2004, Candel 2019). However, they have complex designs due to their multidimensional characteristics which may include multiple governments, multiple levels, different policy contexts and diverse goals (Howlett and Del Rio 2015). Integrated policies become further complicated by cross boundary and cross field/sectoral issues (Trein and Maggetti 2020, Coban and Bali 2022). As a result of this complexity, failure is common in policy integration attempts (Rayner and Howlett 2009, Vince 2015). However, integration is still being pursued by governments and is seen as a process that is continuously adjusted (Tosun and Lang 2017, Biesbroek and Candel 2020, Biesbroek 2021). This need for continuous adjustment and coherence across sectors and jurisdictions raises important questions about whether the actors involved in the process have ‘integrative capacity’ (Vince et al., 2024). Integrative capacity refers to the strategies, approaches, norms, resources, and organizational practices required for cross-sectoral collaboration and coherence, distinct from those required for single-sector policy development (Vince et al., 2024). It involves mechanisms to coordinate efforts, manage inter-sectoral trade-offs and synergies, and harmonize between multiple policy objectives. Consequently, policy makers in government and public agencies involved in integrated policy design and implementation need to develop integrative capacity to improve their chances of achieving policy success. By identifying and building integrative capacity public agencies can work to leverage certain pre-existing organizational resources, competencies and institutional arrangements as foundations for policy integration. This panel will explore the following research questions: · What is required of governments to develop and implement integrated policies? · How can integrative capacity be achieved? · What are the roles, impacts and legitimacy of stakeholders involved in policy integration? · What are the practical implications of achieving integrative capacity? The aim of this panel is to address the following topics arising from the scholarship on policy integration. These topics include: · The evolving nature of policy integration · The diversity of theoretical approaches and terminology used to describe the phenomena · The roles, impacts and legitimacy of stakeholders · The nature and significance of partnerships between government agencies and stakeholders · The role of politics in the integration process · The impact of multilevel governance on the policy making and implementation process There has been a growing focus on policy integration over the last two decades in public policy scholarship, however, further research is needed to understand integrative capacity and the practical implications for governments. The key scientific relevance of this panel lies in further understanding why governments continue to pursue policy integration; what political and system structures enable them to develop the integrated policies despite underlaying sectoral legal frameworks; and the limits and possibilities of achieving integration by improving integrative capacity. It aims to provide insights into the conditions under which policy integration can be effective and sustainable, thereby advancing both theoretical and practical knowledge in public policy.
POLICY TOPICS
P15. Evidence use: empirical insights on practices and impact of knowledge mobilisation on decision-making
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Interest in the role that evidence, knowledge and expertise can play in decision-making (by which we mean public policy and public service practice decisions) is growing worldwide, with many countries trialing infrastructure for mobilising evidence in policy and practice at national, regional and local levels (MacKillop & Downe, 2023). And yet, there is still little research outside of health which demonstrates what aids evidence utilization and whether evidence has a positive impact on decision-making. In particular, examples of good quality empirical research illustrating how, why and which forms of research-policy engagement or knowledge mobilisation/brokerage practices work in particular contexts are needed in order for governments to determine whether to invest further into such initiatives and approaches (Bornbaum et al, 2015; Durrant et al, 2024; Neal et al, 2023). Another key area needing more research is the impact of knowledge mobilisation and evidence on decision-making and outcomes, and the challenges, implications and limitations involved (Oliver et al, 2022; Smith & Stewart, 2017). This panel will draw together research from different contexts and perspectives (e.g., policy fields, geographical areas, and methodological approaches) to examine knowledge mobilisation and build better understanding of the practices it involves and impact it has. We welcome papers that advance understanding of these topics, providing either new empirical, theoretical, methodological, or comparative insights. The two research questions at the heart of this panel are:o What is the impact of knowledge mobilisation on evidence use in decision-making? o What are the key practices of knowledge mobilisation that lead to impact on decision-making? Other related questions include:o What practices of knowledge mobilisation have been developed and implemented in different countries or contexts?o Who is involved in developing and implementing different practices of knowledge mobilisation?o What does the evaluations of knowledge mobilisation practices tell us about whether they work in informing policy and practice? o What can we learn from knowledge mobilisation across different policy areas or geographical areas? In other words, how do practices of knowledge mobilisation relate to the context in which they are implemented? o How do different political systems and cultures influence what counts as evidence and how evidence is used? o What innovative methods are currently being used in different countries to measure the impact of evidence use?o What methods exist that can help make sense of how evidence/knowledge mobilisation interacts with decision-making? E.g., theory of change, models of impact, tools and processes? References:Bornbaum, C.C., Kornas, K., Peirson, L. et al. (2015). Exploring the function and effectiveness of knowledge brokers as facilitators of knowledge translation in health-related settings: a systematic review and thematic analysis. Implementation Sci, 10: 162. Durrant, H., Havers, R., Downe, J., and Martin, S. (2024). Improving evidence use: a systematic scoping review of local models of knowledge mobilisation. Evidence & Policy, 20 (3): 370-392. MacKillop, E., and Downe, J. (2023). Knowledge brokering organisations: a new way of governing evidence. Evidence & Policy, 19 (1): 22-41. Neal, J. W., Posner, S., and Brutzman, B. (2023). Understanding brokers, intermediaries, and boundary spanners: a multi-sectoral review of strategies, skills, and outcomes. Evidence & Policy, 19(1): 95-115. Oliver, K., Hopkins, A., Boaz, A., Guillot-Wright, S., and Cairney, P. (2022). What works to promote research-policy engagement?. Evidence & Policy, 18 (4): 691-713. Smith, K.E. and Stewart, E. (2017). We Need to Talk about Impact: Why Social Policy Academics need to Engage with the UK’s Research Impact Agenda, Journal of Social Policy, 46(1): 109–127.
POLICY TOPICS
P16. Industry Regulation and Governance in the Age of Re-Emerging Industrial Policy: Self-Regulation, Co-Regulation, and Government Oversight
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel aims to explore the evolving relationship between industry regulation and governance in the context of the re-emergence of industrial policy. As state-driven industrial policy gains renewed prominence globally – exemplified by initiatives such as the European Union’s state aid programs and the US CHIPS and Science Act – governments are increasingly shaping market outcomes through regulatory interventions. However, alongside this resurgence of regulatory interventions, there has also been a rise in self-regulation and hybrid co-regulatory frameworks, especially in sectors characterized by rapid technological change. This panel seeks to critically examine how self-regulation interacts with formal government interventions, and whether hybrid governance models can enhance regulatory effectiveness. The intent is to generate insights into how regulatory frameworks can be adapted to ensure both innovation and accountability in industries ranging from manufacturing to emerging technologies. The panel will focus on these research questions: 1. What are the roles of self-regulation and co-regulation with respect to state-driven industrial policies? 2. How do targeted industrial policies, such as those seen in the EU and the US, influence the scope and effectiveness of industry self-regulation? 3. What are the most effective mechanisms for ensuring compliance within self-regulatory frameworks, particularly in industries experiencing rapid technological change? 4. What role do governments and regulatory agencies play in supporting or overseeing self-regulatory frameworks, and how does this vary across sectors and regions? 5. What challenges and risks arise from self-regulation in industries that also receive significant government support or state aid? This panel’s focus on the intersection of industrial policy, self-regulation, and co-regulation is of high scientific relevance for several reasons. While there is a copious literature on state-driven interventions and the regulatory state, comparatively less attention has been paid to how these policies interact with industry self-governance. This panel seeks to bridge that gap by offering a comprehensive analysis of self-regulation as a critical component of modern industrial governance. Moreover, the increasing complexity of industries, especially those driven by emerging technologies (e.g., AI, green energy, semiconductors, gene editing), calls for flexible regulatory approaches. Self-regulation has often been viewed as an efficient alternative to government-led frameworks, particularly in fast-moving sectors. However, the challenges of accountability, conflicts of interest, and regulatory capture remain key concerns. This panel will generate insights into the conditions under which self-regulation can serve as a viable tool for ensuring compliance, innovation, and ethical standards in highly dynamic industries. Finally, by examining the role of industrial policy in shaping regulatory outcomes, this panel contributes to a broader understanding of how states can use regulatory frameworks to support innovation and industrial growth.
POLICY TOPICS
P17. Linking policy capacity and the theories of policy process: Discoveries and new frontiers
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Since the publication of Wu, Ramesh and Howlett’s (2015; 2018) seminal paper and the edited volume, the multi-dimensional and multi-level framework of policy capacity has proved to be a useful lens through which to understand the effectiveness of policy design and delivery (Mukherjee et al. 2021). The usefulness of this framework has been demonstrated in three distinct ways: diagnostic (in the sense of examining capacity deficits), prescriptive (suggesting a normative, functional-institutional outlook of policy systems), and/or modelistic (testing and revising the individual capacity elements) (Yan et al. forthcoming). Despite its widespread use, a theoretical challenge faced by the literature of policy capacity is yet to be aptly tackled. That is, it remains an unfinished project to identify and delimit “the proper place of policy capacity among alternative theories of policy outcomes” (Brenton et al. 2023, 308). Put differently, policy capacity framework should be employed beyond its diagnostic, prescriptive, and/or modelistic use to also scrutinise the role and impact of policy capacity at various levels in understanding policy process outcomes and policy change/statis. Such understanding has long been accumulated through the developments in the theories of policy process. Early theories such as IAD, MSF, PET, ACF, Policy Transfer and Diffusion, Policy Feedback, Policy Regimes, NPF are traditionally concerned with understanding “which governmental policies get formulated and implemented, as well as the effects of those actions on the world” (Sabatier 1991, 148). Developed, refined and applied to numerous areas and policy sectors over the years (e.g., social identity, policy conflict, institutional grammar), these frameworks have significantly expanded our theoretical and empirical horizons regarding the “complex interactions involving people and organizations, events, contexts, and outcomes over time” (Weible 2023: 1). However, the heterogeneity of the frameworks, theories and concepts indicate the field’s “infancy” in its theoretical consolidation “and may yet be subject to tantrums and teething troubles” (Heikkila and Cairney 2018, 383). Linking policy process theories with emerging concepts like policy capacity has the potential to both extend the utilisation of the policy capacity framework and help overcome the pitfall of the policy process theories. Despite that, little efforts have been made for these concepts to speak to each other. To illustrate, we tend to treat policy entrepreneurship without much emphasis on the policy entrepreneurs’ individual capacity resources, along with organisational and/or systemic resources from which they might be benefitting to materialise policy changes. Likewise, sense-making of why and how programmatic action or collective institutional action could (not) be successful or effective can be limited when the mediating role of policy capacity is insufficiently appreciated and elucidated. The lack of such a dialogue is in contrast to the recent linkages of policy transfer and policy capacity (Porto de Oliveria and Koga 2023), policy entrepreneurship and policy process theories (Petridou and Mintrom 2020) and political economy and policy process theories (John 2018). In this regard, this panel proposes to address this missing link and the theoretical challenge by facilitating a much-needed dialogue between the policy capacity literature and the established theories of the policy process and their recent refinements and encouraging the exploration of such connections. With this, we seek to address the theoretical challenge the policy capacity framework faces and incorporate policy capacity within the theories of policy process to better understand the capacity requisites of policy change/stasis. The more complete and holistic understanding thus generated will be of great value in both improving the relevant theories and informing policy practices.
POLICY TOPICS
P01. Rethinking Evaluation for a Multipolar World: Pathways to Resilience, Equity, and Global South Perspectives
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The proposed panel explores critical, emerging challenges in evaluation theory and practice in the Global South. As the international community confronts a rapidly evolving global order, with heightened multipolarity and shifting power dynamics, there is a growing need to rethink traditional evaluation paradigms. Standard evaluation frameworks, often developed in the Global North, may fail to capture the intricacies of social, economic, and environmental challenges specific to Global South contexts. This panel aims to address this gap by examining context-specific evaluation methodologies that are grounded in Global South epistemologies and adapted to the complex realities of today’s world. In recent years, the impacts of climate change, ongoing conflicts, growing economic inequalities, and health system fragilities have converged, placing heightened strain on Global South nations. To address these intersecting issues, the proposed panel will address how evaluation can evolve into a dynamic tool that not only assesses outcomes but also contributes to shaping resilient and equitable development trajectories. The scientific relevance of this panel lies in its potential to bridge evaluation theory and practice, offering new models that actively support resilience, equity, and sustainability in the Global South. The panel will address the following research questions: 1. How can evaluation in a multipolar world capture the nuances of diverse Global South contexts while adhering to ethical rigor?2. What role can emerging technologies, such as artificial intelligence and big data, play in transforming evaluation practices for inclusivity and sustainability?3. How can decolonized evaluation methodologies contribute to epistemic justice and foster more equitable evaluation frameworks?4. What innovative approaches can integrate indigenous knowledge systems, youth perspectives, and community-led insights into mainstream evaluation frameworks?5. How does systems thinking and complexity theory reshape our understanding of causality and impact in Global South evaluations, and what are the implications for methodology? This panel will also explore hypotheses on (1) the potential for systems thinking and complexity theory to capture non-linear development impacts, (2) the role of decolonized evaluation methodologies in promoting epistemic justice, and (3) the integration of indigenous knowledge and youth perspectives into mainstream evaluation frameworks. By bringing together Global South scholars, practitioners, and policymakers, this panel aligns with the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and seeks to reposition evaluation as a tool for driving adaptive capacity and innovation within diverse communities.
POLICY TOPICS
P02. Policy Side Effects
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
How do the consequences of a policy become a source of another social problem? This inquiry has been enduring in the social sciences, forming a long line of research. In an idealized version of the policy process, policies are typically regarded as a solution purposefully designed to address social problems or benefit certain groups without harming others. However, policies oftentimes become a source of new problems, unintentionally or even intentionally. This paradox is so common that we can find rich examples: e.g., stricter policy enforcement that increases social disparities in the justice system, raising the minimum wage increasing unemployment, and increasing the legal drinking age leading to riskier alcohol consumption. Side effects of government measures are not a novel occurrence; social science scholars have long recognized this problem. For example, Robert K. Merton in 1936 and Aaron Wildavsky in 1980 already pointed to the problems of policy side effects (labeled as unintended/unanticipated consequences). Economic and policy analysis studies have developed sophisticated tools for assessing policy trade-offs, which are widely used in policymaking practice today, including cost-benefit analysis and cost-effectiveness analysis, to quantify policy side effects as costs and build a common ground to control the costs with respect to the benefits. In political science, policy feedback theory explains how policies intentionally or unintentionally shape politics and structure political behaviors and decisions. However, these early insights have yet to be incorporated into public policy scholarship to address practical challenges in dealing with policy side effects. This gap becomes especially evident in responses to national emergencies—such as the COVID-19 pandemic, financial crises, and natural disasters—where governments implement strong, wide-reaching policies that significantly impact people and society across various dimensions. How do public policies become a source of social problems? Recognizing this gap in the policy literature, this panel opens an academic discussion on policy side effects by calling for papers that theoretically or empirically investigate issues of policy side effects. Example questions of interest may include, but are not limited to: - What are predictable policy side effects and how can we better anticipate them? - How and when do policies produce side effects? - What are the social and political ramifications of policy side effects? - Are policy side effects socially constructed? - What are the types of moral dilemmas in implementing policies with expected side effects?
POLICY TOPICS
P03. Evaluation in the Age of Artificial Intelligence and Populism: Which Role and Strategies to Support Public Discourse and Policies?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The role of public policy evaluation is undergoing a profound transformation in today’s fast-paced and interconnected world. The evaluation is at a crossroads, confronted by significant challenges that compel a rethinking of its role to improve the methods and conditions of public discourse at all levels and stages of policy-making (Majone 1989). Other than the recognized, growing complexity of policy issues (Bundi& Trein, 2021; Stame, 2022; Zimmerman et al., 2023), new challenges stand out: the convergence of generative artificial intelligence (genAI) (Ballestar et al., 2019, Zuiderwijk et al., 2021; Margalit& Raviv, 2023, Reid, 2023) and the rise of populism (Head& Banerjee, 2019; Batory&Svensson 2019; Robert et al. 2021; Mira et al., 2024). The enormous quantity and speed of information circulating through the social media downsize the importance of accuracy and challenge the role and reputation of experts. This is at odds with the fact that, especially the most complex problems can only be tackled by understanding their fundamentally ambiguous and unpredictable elements. Grasping these forms of complexity in public issues is the core of evaluation and the only way to design actions that are not only accurate but also actionable (Zimmerman et al., 2023). These are not merely disruptive forces but rather catalysts for change that demand our reflection and drive to innovative approaches. It also means reflecting on the role that evaluation can or should play in identifying and mitigating the negative effects of these dynamics in the policy process, such as over-simplification, intolerance of ambiguity, and reductionism. In particular: genAI offers new capabilities for data analysis, but its introduction into evaluation raises significant concerns and requires careful consideration of the ethical and methodological implications. One of the key challenges is the increasing use of AI by government officials themselves, potentially bypassing professional evaluators altogether. AI-driven tools like machine learning algorithms can process large amounts of data, offering speed and scope that human evaluators cannot match (Ballestar et al., 2019), and challenging traditional ways to analyze causal relations (Cowls and Schroeder 2015). Excessive simplification and misinterpretation of information pose a significant risk in the careless use of AI and the judgements that could derive from it. The rise of populism has also significantly influenced policy evaluation. Populist politics often emphasize emotionally resonant narratives and social expectations over in-depth, rigorous, evidence-based decision-making (Batory&Svensson 2019; Robert et al. 2021). The trend toward simplified, emotive communication can marginalize the role of in-depth evaluations, particularly in complex areas like the migration policy, social inclusion or (in case of EU) Green Deal strategy. As short-term political gains take precedence, evaluators are left with the challenge of maintaining the integrity of evidence-based findings.
POLICY TOPICS
P04. Evaluation use in the policy process
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Evidence-based policy is becoming common practice in many areas of public policy. Evidence is generated through policy evaluations, the results of which must be relevant to the policy process. However, this requires the implementation of evaluation recommendations, which often occurs only partially or not at all. The aim of this panel is to better understand the barriers to implementation of evaluation findings and to identify potential for improvement. Our basic theoretical understanding is that the use of evaluation is a political process, driven by institutional frameworks as well as actor preferences and constellations. The regulatory, organisational and normative context of an evaluation system affects the use of evaluation results (Højlund, 2014), as does the political acceptance of evaluation results, issue polarization (Contandriopoulos & Brousselle, 2012), the nature of evaluative information (King & Alkin, 2019) or the prevailing view of what can be considered valid evaluation evidence. The panel's key questions are who commissions evaluations, who formulates evaluation questions and objectives, what form of empirical evidence is valued by actors, how evaluation results can be processed politically, what institutional structures are conducive to the use of evaluation results, what types of evaluation use are predominantly used in the policy process - instrumental, conceptual, symbolic, process use (Saunders, 2012)? Can we observe tactical, ritual, and constitutive product uses (Vedung 2021) and if so, what determines the type of use? How does evaluation use and product use contribution to organisational learning? The scientific contribution of the panel is thus to improve our understanding of a crucial step in the policy process, but also to explore evaluation use as a systematic component of evaluation designs. As a possible impact in research, we hope that the concept of evaluation use, which has so far been discussed primarily in evaluation research, will also be increasingly taken up in the debate on evidence-based policy by increasingly focusing on the institutional and political contextual conditions of evaluation use. Furthermore, we hope that research will increasingly focus on the institutional and political contextual conditions of evaluation use. It would be desirable if not only evaluation use, but also the 'usability' (Saunders, 2012) of evaluations in the policy process were studied more. On the practitioner side, a desirable impact would be to bring the emancipatory potential of evaluation use more to bear by involving stakeholder groups in evaluation use (Johnson et al., 2009).
POLICY TOPICS
P02. Critical Policy Studies in Africa
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Africa is experiencing growth in critical policy scholars through publications and networks, but the rate is very low. The continent is dominated by technocratic rationalistic policy outlook of neoliberal governance and its associated policy implementation challenges (Boossabong, 2024). Departing from a rationalistic and technocratic orientation is to embrace critical epistemologies grounded in deliberative, argumentative, and discursive (policy framing). Promoting networks of scholars provide resources and interconnections for core critical policy studies in Africa who are interdisciplinary, problem oriented across specific sectors and countries. Moreover, there are few contributions on critical policy studies coming from Africa. Funke et al (2023) study environmental policy in South Africa. Cramer et al. (2024) study climate change in the pastoral systems in East Africa in the context of science-policy interface. Peters (2019) empirically conducted study in Angola on workforce in community development sector presenting implementation challenges arising from inadequate support and resources. Manga Edimo (2022) reviewed critical theory of ‘connectivity’ to explain the success and failure of liberal democratic repairs in the global south in which democracy was portrayed as a social struggle. Ayana, Vandenabeele, and Arts (2015) study forest governance in Ethiopia. Wood (2019) study was conducted on the regulatory policy of birth registration as a basic human right in the field of international development and global health. Others have contributed to the participatory turn inspired by evolutionary governance theory using evolving rural governance of the Ethiopian Agricultural extension systems observing dependencies and interdependencies (Leta, Kelboro, Van Assche, Stellmacher and Hornidge, 2019). Olanya, Pedersen, and Lassen (2021) study nature policy in Uganda. These contributions are skewed to Eastern and Southern Africa leaving out the rest of the continent. This panel contributes to the development of critical policy scholars in Africa by exploring platforms for emerging and young scholars who are interested in critical epistemologies in Africa. References Ayana, A. N., Vandenabeele, N., & Arts, B. (2015). Performance of participatory forest management in Ethiopia: institutional arrangement versus local practices. Critical Policy Studies, 11(1), 19–38. https://doi.org/10.1080/19460171.2015.1024703 Boossabong, P. (2024). Mapping networks of critical policy studies. Critical Policy Studies, 18(2), 343–355. https://doi.org/10.1080/19460171.2024.2345893. Cramer, L., Dewulf, A., & Crane, T. (2024). Livestock and climate change frames and interaction strategies in East Africa: exploring tensions between adaptation and mitigation options. Critical Policy Studies, 1–23. https://doi.org/10.1080/19460171.2024.2331706 Funke, N., Huitema, D., & Petersen, A. (2022). Impending doom or unnecessary panic? The struggle for discursive hegemony in South Africa’s acid mine drainage policy problem. Critical Policy Studies, 17(2), 276–296. https://doi.org/10.1080/19460171.2022.2092523 Lawrence, M., Homer-Dixon, T., Janzwood, S., Rockstöm, J., Renn, O., & Donges, J. F. (2024). Global polycrisis: the causal mechanisms of crisis entanglement. Global Sustainability, 7, e6. https://doi.org/10.1017/sus.2024.1 Leta, G., Kelboro, G., Van Assche, K., Stellmacher, T., & Hornidge, A. K. (2019). Rhetorics and realities of participation: the Ethiopian agricultural extension system and its participatory turns. Critical Policy Studies, 14(4), 388–407. https://doi.org/10.1080/19460171.2019.1616212 Manga Edimo, R. M. (2022). Mending Democracy: Lessons from the Global South democracies? Critical Policy Studies, 16(2), 233–236. https://doi.org/10.1080/19460171.2022.2032233 Olanya, D. R., Pedersen, A. G. J., & Lassen, I. (2021). Capitalizing on nature: a critical discourse study of nature policy concerning the Murchison Falls Conservation Area of Uganda. Critical Policy Studies, 16(4), 405–423. https://doi.org/10.1080/19460171.2021.1999838 Peters, R. W. (2019). Front-line work and interpretive labor in an Angolan development program. Critical Policy Studies, 13(4), 414–431. https://doi.org/10.1080/19460171.2019.1630658 Wood, S. (2019). The bureaucracy of birth registration in Tanzania. Critical Policy Studies, 13(4), 379–395. https://doi.org/10.1080/19460171.2019.1672573
POLICY TOPICS
P03. Critical perspectives on global AI policy and governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The panel aims to bring together an interdisciplinary set of scholars exploring artificial intelligence (AI) policy and governance from across the globe. It seeks to push the frontiers of the state-of-the-art with critical research inquiries across four dimensions: (1) Conceptually, the panel addresses scholarly complacency with "techno-solutionist" ideology (Morozov 2014; Paul 2022). It explores how, and to what effect, notions of rational problem-solving and discourses proposing technical fixes for ethical questions such as algorithmic bias, explainability, or undemocratic surveillance depoliticise AI governance. How can we apply, inter alia, normative democracy theory, gender studies, decolonial lenses, critical political economy, or studies on grassroots movements most fruitfully to explore the hidden politics of governing (with) AI and inequalities resulting from it? (2) Analytically speaking, the panel draws on the – so far rare – work of policy analysts and science and technology scholars focusing on the concrete practices of governing AI beyond “the letter of the law”, for example by using ethnographic methods to generate data (i.e. in the case of predictive policing ‘on the ground’: Sandhu and Fussey 2021; Selten et al. 2023). How do public authorities across the world use chatbots or algorithmic scoring systems in their daily operations, how do they concretize existing AI policies when doing so (Liu, Lin and Chen 2019)? How do actors in regulatory sandboxes or standardization fora struggle over meanings of “responsible AI”? How do such policy concretizations vary across space, why so, and to what effect for global AI governance? How do Big Tech corporations tap into the data wealth of marginalized communities in their increasing involvement in the humanitarian sector? (3) Empirically, the panel enrichens existing analyses on European and North American cases. Based on our experience in running the Surveillance in the Majority World Network (Akbari), we aim to explore articulations of AI policy and governance in usually marginalized places, all while contextualizing them in geopolitical power struggle over AI between the US, China and Europe (Bradford 2023). For example, how do Asian jurisdictions negotiate a common AI governance framework or facilitate normative interactions when faced with the rise of China as a regulatory power? How do diverse political, economic, and cultural contexts in Asian or Latin American jurisdictions shape AI governance regimes at multiple levels? How do global autocratisation tendencies affect efforts for “human-centric” AI governance? How do colonial legacies shape tech diplomacy interactions between African countries and Europe and what strategies emerge to counteract hegemonic global AI governance (Birhane 2020; Omutobora and Basu 2024)? (4) The panel aims to unfold societal impact by going beyond a "desk-based critique" of contemporary AI governance. Inspired by critical AI studies (Pasquinelli 2023), surveillance studies (Akbari 2022) and critical policy studies (Fischer 2016), we ask: how can our joint research, engaging critically with ideology and power in contemporary AI policy and governance, help generate alternative pathways for more democratic and sustainable AI futures? How can collaborative interdisciplinary work and policymaking address the complex global nature of AI governance in an intersectional and situated way?
POLICY TOPICS
P04. ROOM B3_Author-Meets-Critics: Doing Interpretive Research. Learning and Teaching Imagination in Social Research
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel will discuss an important advance in interpretive policy analysis and the social sciences. Using an Author-Meets-Critics format, three ‘critics’ will offer their perspective on the new book ‘Doing Interpretive Research. Learning and Teaching Imagination in Social Research’. The authors, Koen Bartels and Hendrik Wagenaar, will share their reflections on the critics’ comments and invite the audience to participate in the discussion. The aim of the panel is to introduce a radically new approach to how we learn and teach methods and bridge methodological divides for the sake of more imaginative and impactful research. The book is based on experiential and pragmatist learning theories. It departs from the thesis by the political scientists Mark Bevir and Jason Blakely that interpretation is an explanatory logic and form of inquiry that is at the root of all social science research, including quantitative research. In learning and teaching interpretive social research, the authors take the key maxim of experiential learning theory, that learning involves the whole person, seriously. It not only places the student’s prior experiences center stage, but also the student’s emotions. The book draws on psychoanalysis and on Nussbaum’s theories of emotions. The book shows that negative emotions can block effective learning. Using extended empirical examples from the authors’ own experiences with research, teaching and supervision, it shows how learning to use open-ended heuristics instead of methods is an effective method to deal with negative emotions and acknowledge the researcher’s prior life experiences. This approach is embedded in the pragmatist conception of the research process as problem solving in which all human faculties play a role. The purpose of the book is to guide social researchers and instructors in better understanding and improving the experience of doing interpretive research. It demonstrates how emotions can be leveraged in the learning process to uncover surprising new insights about social reality and unlock social researchers’ imaginations. The panel discussion will enable practising interpretive researchers, those drawn to but confused by it, and those who see little relevance of it to their research practice, to gain new insight into how learning and teaching interpretation will lead to more enjoyable, productive, and imaginative research.
POLICY TOPICS
P05. Conflict and collaboration in the energy transition: social dynamics and justice questions
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Policy making and policy implementation of energy transitions often face conflict between governmental actors, residents and market players and at the same time rely heavily on their cooperation. Yet, there is a strict separation between literature on energy conflicts and on energy governance, when in practice energy transitions reflect complex interactions in which cooperation and conflict coexist. On one hand, policy conflict literature emphasizes social dynamics related to clashing or overlapping cultural meanings, and conflicting framing of problems and solutions, collective emotions, knowledge claims, moral positions, and identities (Dodge and Metze 2017; Verhoeven and Metze 2022). Policy, in these cases, is often the result of a struggle for dominance. Conflict can be productive, however, in generating important and far-reaching policy results for environmental protection and for social, environmental and economic justice. On the other hand, a body of literature examines possibly transformative collaborations in which new imaginary and just futures are being prototyped and tested, such as energy cooperatives or communities living off-grid (e.g., Fischer 2017), while there is also a boom in literature on collaboration between governments, market players and residents in the renovation of the existing housing stock (Van der Schoor and Sanders 2022). Both streams of literature test new forms of (action)research to support innovation that fosters dialogue between governments, residents and market players. While conflict literature aims to understand how conflicts can be ‘productive’ by contributing to a more fair and deeper transition, collaboration literature focuses on how innovative collaborations can contribute to transformative change. This panel aims to bridge the gap by bringing conflict and cooperation researchers in conversation with each other, in order to arrive at more common understanding of the social dynamics behind conflict and collaboration and in order to develop a joint analytical vocabulary. The recent proliferation of energy justice literature (Sovacool and Dworkin 2015, Heffron 2022) addresses distributive, procedural, recognition and epistemic justice, which can serve to reduce conflict and further promote cooperation and can thus begin to bridge these two literatures. Justice can reduce conflict when residents see more benefits than burdens from a wind farm, when they participate in the planning of a data center, when they feel recognized by authorities that want to renovate their homes, or when their local knowledge on fracking impacts is taken seriously. Justice can strengthen cooperation if governments and market players develop a shared framing of burdens and benefits, are transparent to each other, recognize and involve other players as stakeholders, and reflect on knowledge sources strengthening their cooperation. The main questions of this panel thus are: 1) Which social dynamics underly conflict and collaboration in the energy transition?; 2) What are the commonalities and differences in these social dynamics; 3) What social dynamics contribute to transformative change, and in what ways? 4) In which ways do aspects of justice play a role in these social dynamics; and 5) What kind of justice-related philosophical, theoretical and empirical vocabulary can we develop to bridge the gap between conflict and collaboration literatures?
POLICY TOPICS
P06. Exploring counter hegemony on climate change (and other policy problems)
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The world is in transition. The polycrisis (Morin & Kern 1999) confronting modern democracies combines inter-related crises such as climate change, poverty, economic inequality, health crises and increasingly visible racial injustices, among others. These crises have exposed weaknesses of contemporary forms of governance, resulting in deep challenges to their legitimacy. The polycrisis, thus, suggests a fundamental challenge underlying many policy arenas: the ability to adequately address policy problems. This failure of governing institutions in our present moment can be likened to a period that Gramsci famously called an interregnum (Gramsci/Hoare & Smith 1971/2022) whereby the old ill-adapted system of governance will not die and the new system that could address contemporary problems cannot be born, leaving a vacuum in leadership and governance. In this vacuum, many “morbid symptoms” appear, including possible ascendence of authoritarian rulers and other illiberal groups seeking to fill the vacuum, and who may exacerbates the polycrisis. This panel poses that climate change and other major policy problems must be seen within this context to fully grasp the challenges of the present moment. Global warming then does not only constitute an isolated “wicked problem”, which is difficult to solve. It is rather turned into a wicked problem due to the predominant focus on natural science and climate dimensions and its isolation from broader ecological, social and political transformations. These problems are emblematic of the difficulty policy makers face today precisely because they are consequences of the failures of (neo)liberal democracy; that is, they share a common root in the failures of market centered governance. Gramsci’s theory of hegemony offers important analytical tools to address the interregnum period from a long-term strategic point of view, to not only understand the interregnum, but also strategies to fill the leadership vacuum to avoid the “morbid symptoms” of authoritarian rule, among others. A “new hegemony” in Gramsci’s terms would need to offer an alternative ideology and set of corresponding institutional arrangements to regulate the political economy – including well-articulated policy instruments – that become broadly supported as legitimate and, at least partially, implemented. The purpose of this panel is to bring together theoretical and empirical research that uses critical theoretical and methodological tools to addresses the following research questions: · How do specific policy challenges (e.g., climate change) relate to the polycrisis or interregnum? How should those policy challenges be addressed (theoretically) – or how are they being addressed (empirically) – within that broader understanding? · How should scholars characterize the present interregnum period, as it relates to specific policy challenges? · What would it take for there to be a new hegemony for climate change (or other policy crisis)? What is a new possible hegemony for organizing the political economy generally, or for organizing a specific policy issue? What governing institutions are needed? What ideology or new “common sense”? Who should lead them? What key alliances – or new “historic bloc” – are needed? · What are current efforts to create a new hegemony, even if partial, and what forms do they take? Where are their successes and limits?
POLICY TOPICS
P07. Knowledge and Power in Public Policy: Perspectives from Asia
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
As a region home to multiple rising global powers, Asia plays an increasingly pivotal role in shaping global public policies. Distinctive patterns emerge in Asian policymaking practices (Mukherjee and Howlett 2015), indicating that Asian public policy warrants focused study. Yet scholars have identified a persistent gap in the engagement with and understanding of public policy dynamics across Asia (Bice et al. 2018). Studying public policy in Asia extends beyond merely comprehending political systems, governance structures, and administration frameworks. It requires an examination of the unique and complex interplay between various forms of knowledge, authority, and power that inform policy development and implementation (such as Curaming 2020, Nugroho et.al. 2018). Knowledge and power matter in public policy. Knowledge plays a critical role in addressing policy problems, but it is also a way of exerting power, influencing which issues are prioritised and how they are understood (Jasanoff 1987; Fischer 2000; Yanow 2004, Rakhmani and Sakhiyya 2024). This panel asks how studies of knowledge and power in policymaking in Asia can advance theoretical discourses and/or inform us about distinct methodological approaches and commitments? Asia may be a site of data collection, but it is not often a source of theorising or knowledge sharing. Theorising and universalities remain largely developed in the West and then applied to the rest of the world, including Asia (Takayama 2016, Santos 2016, Connell 2020). This panel will contribute to broader theoretical advancements in public policy from the region and deepen our understanding of the region's unique policy landscape. This panel invite papers that investigate the relationship between knowledge and power in policymaking processes in Asia. Topics of interest include, but are not limited to, evidence-based policymaking, knowledge transfer, policy translation, the role of policy entrepreneurs, and the challenges of policy implementation. This hybrid panel is open to PhD students and early career researchers, as well as more experienced and established academics. Our goal is to create constructive and engaging dialogues. We welcome contributions that are empirical, methodological and theoretical in nature.
POLICY TOPICS
P08. Towards Public Encounters 2.0: Relational Dynamics of Citizens and the State in Diverse Contexts
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Since the advent of the policy implementation literature in the 1980s, there has been a sustained focus on interaction at the frontline. Whether couched in the language of ‘street-level bureaucracy’, ‘policy feedback loops’, or ‘administrative burdens’, influential streams of scholarship have advanced understanding of how public officials and citizens experience their interactions and give shape to their discretionary practices. However, this scholarship tends to elide or ignore what that interaction actually entails and how it matters. Over the past decade, we have observed a steady increase in the number and diversity of studies of public encounters: interactions between citizens and the State (cf. Bartels, 2013; Hupe, 2023). This growing literature reveals much more about how these relational dynamics unfold, and with what consequences for policy-making and democratic citizenship. In a world where multiple sustainability crises put relationships between citizens and the State to the test, it is imperative we learn what happens in public encounters and how their relational dynamics can be improved. As an emerging field, public encounters has expanded into new empirical and theoretical terrains and surfaced conflicting perspectives on how to conceptualise and analyse relational dynamics. Three developments are noteworthy. First, a move beyond the traditional focus on service delivery encounters to participatory, digital, and emotional encounters. Second, broad agreement on the need to understand the relational dynamics of public encounters, both in terms of the ‘in-between’ and ‘the bigger picture’. Third, dividing lines between conceptual and methodological approaches that echo wider disciplinary concerns with the influence of relational philosophy (Bartels & Turnbull, 2020), the agency of public officials or citizens (Boswell & Smedley, 2022), and the connection between micro-level relational practices and macro-level structural issues of democracy, social justice, and sustainability (Verloo, 2023). The aim of this panel is to advance conceptual and empirical understanding of public encounters in diverse contexts. It builds on recent collective efforts to advance the field towards a more inclusive, coherent, and impactful agenda: public encounters 2.0. While this shared agenda is informed by a diversity of conceptualizations, methods, and contexts, we seek to involve a wider range of voices that will broaden and deepen understanding of the meaning and impact of public encounters. We especially note the need for conceptual framings and empirical contexts from the Global South to supplement and challenge existing studies of public encounters which are predominantly from the Global North. The panel will contribute to developing a more diverse and inclusive understanding of the language, approaches, and added value underpinning public encounters in research and practice.
POLICY TOPICS
P09. Relational dimensions of public policy: towards a shared agenda
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
A focus on the relational dimensions of public policy constitutes a key development in our field. Over the past decade, we have observed significant growth in the number and variety of studies of how networks of interactions and relationships take shape and impact policy. We now have robust conceptual and methodological foundations to guide us in understanding what relationality means, how it matters to policy processes and outcomes, and how we can analyse it (e.g., Bartels and Turnbull, 2020; Lejano & Kan, 2022; Selg et al., 2024; Wilson et al., 2024). At the same time, relational public policy is not mainstream and continues to face fundamental divides. Relationships might be widely recognized as an important factor, but often in a substantialist and instrumental way – what we call relationalism. Fewer scholars operate from a relational mindset that sees the world as interactive, dynamic, and emergent, or seek to transform relational dynamics towards greater democracy, social justice, and sustainability. In addition, the topic of relationality seems to be taken up mainly by scholars from Europe and the U.S., whereas it would seem that diversifying this community (e.g., across the Global South) would have great potential to challenge and expand our understanding of the meaning, impact, and analysis of relationality. Finally, there continues to be a need for greater interaction between scholars who have embraced relationality and practitioners who have been advancing a relational reform agenda. The aims of this panel are to: 1. Trace the development of relational public policy over the past years; 2. Increase inclusion and synergies across conceptual, methodological and geographical boundaries; 3. Set an agenda for the future development of relational policy theory and practice. We will build on discussions at panels at ICPP 2019 and 2021 about relational public policy. These discussions surfaced diverse relational approaches, opportunities for conceptual and methodological cross-fertilization, and ways to evaluate and co-produce relational change. We aim to break new ground in advancing relational public policy by critically exploring possibilities for further developing shared language, mutual understanding, and common goals (Bartels et al., 2024). It is our ambition to develop a special issue from the panel that will serve as a stimulus for and key reference point in the development of relational public policy. References Bartels, K.P.R., & Turnbull, N. (2020). Relational public administration: A synthesis and heuristic classification of relational approaches. Public Management Review, 22(9), 1324–1346. Bartels, K.P.R., Von Heimburg, D., Jordan G. & Ness, O. (2024). Debate: A relational agenda for changing public administration research and practice, Public Money & Management, DOI: 10.1080/09540962.2024.2402873 Lejano, R.P. & Kan, W.S. (2022). Relationality. The Inner Life of Public Policy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Selg, P., Sootla, G. & Klasche, B. (2024) A Relational Approach to Governing Wicked Problems: From Governance Failure to Failure Governance. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan. Wilson, R., French, M., Hesselgreaves, H., Lowe, T., & Smith, M. (2024). New development: Relational public services—reform and research agenda. Public Money & Management, 44(6), 553–558.
POLICY TOPICS
P10. Participatory Governance and Deliberative Empowerment for a Democratically Just and Sustainable Transition
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The climate crisis and the search for environmental sustainability constitute the primary challenge of our century. Despite all of the rhetoric about the need to deal with the coming crisis, the actions to mitigate the crisis thus far have fallen far short of those which needed to put humanity on a sustainable course. Most of the efforts have focused on attempts to find scientific technological market-oriented solutions, typically known as “technical fixes.” This has largely taken place at the expense of democratic environmental policymaking and citizen involvement, despite the fact that from early on the sustainability literature and key documents have presented broad citizens participation as an essential component for the successful pursuit of sustainable development goals. Underlying this reluctance to involve ordinary citizens, however, is the belief, often more latent than manifest, that the citizenry is not up to the task. Citizens are seen to be not intelligent and informed enough to be trusted with the challenge. This panel aims to explore real-world practices that can illustrate how citizens can help to put us on a path to sustainability.
POLICY TOPICS
P11. Discourse Analysis for Policy Framing in the ‘Asian Century’
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
In the evolution of the critical policy studies paradigm at the end of the 20th century (Forester, 1993; Fischer, 1993), policy scholarship has witnessed a progressive shift that decentered and expanded the onto-epistemological orientation of approaches to policy studies, moving away from the mainstream empiricism of policy science to a more argumentative and critical turn in policy analysis (Fischer & Forester, 1993; Fischer & Gottweis, 2012). Several works have argued that these traditional methods lack the ability to capture the complexity of policy-making processes (Taylor, 1997); hence, others have advocated for a critical approach that focuses not just on surface-level understanding of policy content but also on an in-depth analysis of policy meaning and the context in which policies are constructed and the consequences they create (Fairclough, 2013; Taylor, 1997). Contemporary scholars of critical policy studies have posited that policymaking is a struggle over meaning and interpretation, where language (or, better yet, discourse), knowledge, and power are intertwined. Thus, policies are the product of such struggles, reflecting ideologies in the formulation of policy alternatives. The epistemological evolutions and developments brought about by the influence of critical policy studies in the West have addressed the major debate of that time—decentering decision-making from technocrats, elites, and power, and recentering the ‘public’ into deliberation, decision-making, and action. The ‘Asian Century,’ as described by Bice and Sullivan (2014), refers to the 21st century, which is dominated by Asia’s economic, cultural, and political influence, in contrast to the 20th century, dominated by Western powers. They articulated unique public policy challenges and developments in Asia, focusing on the region’s rapid economic growth and its emergence as a global powerhouse. The diversity in governance and political systems (ranging from democracies, centralized systems, monarchies, and authoritarian regimes), diversified levels of economic development, and differences in social structures across various countries all pose significant challenges to inclusive, coherent, and effective policies. These developments are also accompanied by challenges related to urbanization, environmental sustainability, climate change, social safety nets, government efficiency and decentralization, and national security, among others. On a separate note, we also maintain skepticism and challenge the claim by raising the inquiry: Have we even reached the so-called ‘Asian Century’? All of this brings an interesting question to the panel: How and where can we situate discourse analysis in policy framing in the ‘Asian Century’? Taking note of the lessons from the emergence of policy science and the rise of the critique of critical policy studies, it is now timely to examine what is being claimed as public policy in the 'Asian Century' and build on these lessons as we advance an inclusive and citizen-centered approach to policy framing. This panel notes that technocratic norms in Asia are strongly interwoven with its social, political, and economic norms. As a result, technocratic solutions from experts are often considered the default approach to addressing policy issues. While we acknowledge the significance of technocratic agendas in highly scientific issues, we also need to draw lessons from past developments and anticipate the directions of application, particularly in the context of the ‘Asian Century.’ Given the long and strong history of technocracy in Asia, this panel challenges scholars to go beyond empiricist and solutionist norms and keep an open platform for exploring discourses, critical perspectives, and alternative approaches to policy framing and analysis. This panel aims to draw lessons from existing works and ongoing projects by scholars inside and outside of Asia that build on discursive and critical paradigms in policy research. With the ‘Asian Century’ introducing new norms, policy scholars must brace themselves for conducting critical policy research with a participatory and inclusive agenda for the public’s interest. References: Bice, S., & Sullivan, H. (2014). Public policy studies and the “Asian Century”: New orientations, challenges, and opportunities. Governance, 27(4), 539-544. Fairclough, N. (2013). Critical discourse analysis and critical policy studies. Critical Policy Studies, 7(2), 177-197. Fischer, F., & Forester, J. (Eds.). (1993). The argumentative turn in policy analysis and planning. Duke University Press. Fischer, F. (1993). Citizen participation and the democratization of policy expertise: From theoretical inquiry to practical cases. Policy sciences, 26(3), 165-187. Fischer, F., & Gottweis, H. (2012). The argumentative turn revisited. Public policy as communicative practice. Forester, J. (1993). Critical theory, public policy, and planning practice. State University of New York Press. Taylor, S. (1997). Critical policy analysis: Exploring contexts, texts and consequences. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education, 18(1), 23-35.
POLICY TOPICS
P12. Using post-structural policy analysis to disrupt knowledge and power hierarchies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
WPR, or ‘Whats the Problem Represented to be’ is an approach developed by Carol Bacchi that aims to challenge the conventional view that public policies are responses or reactions to problems that sit outside the policy process, waiting to be discovered and solved. Public policy decisions are assumed to be part of larger societal discourse that construct reality in particular ways. These discourses thus help maintain certain power structures by legitimizing some knowledges and marginalizing others. The key question Bacchi asks is: "What's the problem represented to be?". Central to this question is unpacking the ways solutions and problems are framed. By limiting the range of possible solutions, and constraining possible evidence bases, traditional policy approaches can encourage a policymaking space that may end up reproducing the same problems it seeks to ‘solve’. By questioning ‘taken for granted’ assumptions and mapping the history of the present, WPR aids in the examination of policy ‘problems’ and offers alternative ways of thinking. Grounded in ideas of governmentality and knowledge-power systems, in particular discussed by poststructuralist and feminist thinkers such as Foucault, Latour and Haraway, WPR conceptualizes power as not merely a repressive force held by a sovereign or state. Rather, it is a productive and diffuse network of relations that operates through institutions, practices, and discourses. Power and knowledge are closely linked, and policies canreproduce and subjugate knowledges. This panel aims to surface the ways in which WPR can be used and actioned to disrupt these hierarchies and surface these conversations. WPR can be described as a collective project, or “work-in-progress”; this panel aims to explore this concept in more depth and unpack its complexity, as well as explore how it could work in varying policy contexts.
POLICY TOPICS
P13. Framing the Futures: How Discourses Shape Public Policy Agendas
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
How do discourses shape the identification and framing of policy issues, and what implications do they hold for setting policy agendas in various contexts? This panel thoroughly examines this question by exploring the interplay between discourses, policy agenda-setting, and strategies or agencies in contemporary policymaking. Discourses shape agenda-setting and policy outcomes by constructing realities, influencing public perceptions, and guiding how actors frame policy issues (Rein & Schön, 1996). Thus, discourse is intrinsically associated with the saliency of issues and policy agendas and mobilizing coalitions. This panel’s focus was ushered by the growing dissatisfaction with the techno-oriented, instrumental policy approach, which led scholars to focus on the role of language in policy analysis. The objectivism implied by the rationally mainstreamed policy analysis was criticized as drained of emotion and having deadened moral sensibility (Hajer, 2005). The discursive analysis shaped the landscape of policy studies, where stories people tell are regarded not merely as “raw” data but, per se, the principal subject of investigation. Discourses—defined by Hajer (2005) as the “ensemble of ideas, concepts, and categories through which meaning is given to phenomena”—have now become the focal unit of analysis. Along these lines, pioneering scholars focused on diverse and specific theoretical facets, including, but not limited to, the discourse coalition framework on the formation of coalitions where shared narratives are used to pin specific policy trajectories (Hajer, 2005), the narrative policy framework with emphasis on the mechanisms of storylines and how narratives with moral and emotional resonance drive policy action (Shanahan et al., 2011), the discursive institutionalism on examining how discourse operates within and across institutions and the discourse’s role in how policy ideas are communicated and coordinated among policy actors (Schmidt, 2008), the embeddedness of policy frames with paradoxical values and biases (Stone, 2012), and finally, the discursive approach on advocacy coalition framework, digging into the strategic use of discourse in coalition building where belief systems are resiliently maintained over time (Sabatier, 1998). From these seminal theories and other scholarly developments on the intersection of discourse and agenda-setting, this panel advances the understanding of how discourse is associated with the salience of public policy agendas in both theoretical and practical dimensions. The panel will specifically: Investigate the role of narrative strategies and agencies, discursive coalitions, and framings in shaping public perceptions and policy agenda. Explore mechanisms by which discourse constructs policy realities, impacting the selection of problem definitions and solutions. Examine comparative and context-specific case studies that highlight the interaction of discourse, institutions, and policy outcomes in different policy domains, including, but not limited to, health, gender, migration, education, social justice, and environmental policies.
POLICY TOPICS
P14. Roundtable: Diverse approaches to relational public policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The aim of this roundtable is to discuss the differences and similarities between diverse relational approaches for studying public policy and administration. It will allow leading scholars to compare notes and reflect on what the distinct nature, value and identity of relational public policy is and what dividing lines exist and which need to be traversed. We will, for example, have a conversation about what constitutes the relational as compared to relationalism, differences between critical-interpretivist and (post-)positivist approaches, the role of teleological and ontological assumptions. Do scholars from different sub-disciplines (public policy, public administration, political science) appropriate and employ the concept of relationality in different ways, and why? Can there be a conversation with social network scholars who see the relational from a positivist lens?
POLICY TOPICS
P02. The financialization of public policies: actors, knowledge and tools
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The objective of this panel is to analyze the role of financial players and interests in shaping public policy. The financialization of the economy is a complex mutation, articulating the growing transfer of income from labor to capital, the domination of shareholders in companies, and the financialization of everyday life (Van der Zwan, 2014). Reversing the idea that states are the “victims” of finance, economic sociology and political economy emphasize the decisive role of regulators and states in the process of financialization (Krippner, 2011; Benquet, et al, 2019). Beyond financial regulation per se, a recent research program aims to analyze more generally the “financialization of public policies” (Chiapello, 2017), i.e. the way in which public policies incorporate financialized reasoning and visions in a growing number of sectors, from development (Ducastel, 2016) to social policies (Buffa et al., 2021). Symmetrically, social studies of finance show that financial players integrate the regulatory environment into their investment strategies, and carry out political work to shape regulation to their interests. The panel calls for an increased dialogue between public policy analysis and social studies of finance, esp. STS (Doganova et al., 2014; Muniesa et al., eds, 2017) and political economy (Blyth 2009; Smith, Hay, 2018; John 2018). Existing research in political economy often overcomes the role of the finance industry in favor of more traditional industrial or banking sectors (Gayon, Leclerc, 2022) or only partially accounts for the role of public policy in shaping finance (Christophers, 2024; Thiemann, 2024; Gabor, 2020). To study the “boundary work” (Boussard, ed., 2018) of financialization at the interface between investors and regulators, several hypotheses can be explored. First, the study of policy instruments (Halpern, Lascoumes, Le Galès, dir., 2014; Chiapello, Gilbert, 2013) makes it possible to analyze how the tools developed by regulators tend to become imbued with financial logics; and, conversely, how public policy instruments enter into investors' calculations. This "boundary work" can also be explored through the prism of careers (François and Lemercier, 2016), as well as through lobbying practices (circulation of wordings and frameworks, policy alliances, etc.) Finally, this panel could address - but not be limited to - the counterforces to financialization within public policy, such as resistance from civil society (eg. Finance Watch) or alternative policy methods (eg. planning), quantified objectives (eg. use value), or content (eg. investment policy), while paying attention to somehow surprising ties between civil society organizations and financial actors (Bereni, Dubuisson-Quellier, 2021).
POLICY TOPICS
P04. Governing the co-creation of green transitions: A global comparative perspective
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Here halfway to the 2030-deadline, it is clear that the world still has a long way to go to achieve the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), which prominently feature goals and targets for climate action, the production of clean and affordable energy, protection of life on land and below water, and creation of environmentally sustainable cities. Fortunately, the SDGs come with helpful guidance, as Goal 17 calls for the formation of collaborative networks and partnerships that can spur the co-creation of innovative green solutions. Since no single actor, be it public, private or civic, has all the ideas, resources and authority to solve the nature and climate crisis singlehandedly, the formation of collaborative networks and partnerships seems to offer a way forward. Local networks and partnerships may spark interaction between relevant and affected actors who aim to construct a common ground for addressing key environmental problems. New research shows that collaborative governance and co-creation in networks and partnerships bringing together public, private and civic actors are potent tools for promoting green sustainability transitions at the local level based on emergent forms of learning, innovation and joint ownership (Ansell & Torfing, 2021, 2022, 2024; Szetey, 2021; Horan, 2022; Glass et al., 2023; Newig et al., 2023; Widerberg, 2023; Ohnishi et al., 2024). Still, we have limited knowledge of the different constellations of governance factors (policies, goals, platforms, financing, trust, leaderships etc.) that prompt, support and scaffold the collaborative innovation process and its green outcomes (Ansell, Sørensen and Torfing, 2024). Structural, strategic and tactical-operational governance factors may combine in different ways to support local green co-creation, but we need to know what combinations of governance factors are conducive for local green co-creation. The impactful constellations of governance factors may vary between countries, regimes and localities around the globe as socio-economic, political and cultural conditions influence the presence or absence of different governance factors. This explains why we need a global comparative perspective on the governing of local green co-creation partnerships (Ansell, Sørensen and Torfing, 2022). To that end, this panel aims to gather public administration, governance and policy scholars to conduct global comparative studies of the governance factors supporting local green co-creation to better understand how to govern local partnerships aiming to achieve the green Sustainable Development Goals. References Ansell, C., & Torfing, J. (2021). Public Governance as Co-creation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Ansell, C., Sørensen, E., & Torfing, J. (2022). Co-creation for Sustainability. Bingley: Emerald Group Publishing. Ansell, C., Sørensen, & E. Torfing, J (2024). Metagoverning the Co-Creation of Green Transitions: A Socio-Political Contingency Framework. Sustainability, 16(16), 6776. Glass, L.-M., J. Newig and S. Ruf (2023). MSPs for the SDGs – Assessing the collaborative governance architecture of multi-stakeholder partnerships for implementing the Sustainable Development Goals. Earth System Governance, 17, 100182. Horan, D. (2022). A framework to harness effective partnerships for the sustainable development goals. Sustainability Science, 17(4), 1573-1587. Newig, J., Jager, N.W., Challies, E., & Kochskämper, E. (2023). Does stakeholder participation improve environmental governance? Global Environmental Change, 82, 102705. Ohnishi, S., Osako, M., Nakamura, S., Togawa, T., Kawai, K., Suzuki, K., ... & Tsuji, T. (2024). A Framework for Analyzing Co-Creation Value Chain Mechanisms in Community-Based Approaches. Sustainability, 16(7), 2919. Szetey, K., Moallemi, E. A., Ashton, E., Butcher, M., Sprunt, B., & Bryan, B. A. (2021). Participatory planning for local sustainability guided by the Sustainable Development Goals. Ecology & Society, 26(3). Widerberg, O., Fast, C., Rosas, M. K., & Pattberg, P. (2023). Multi-stakeholder partnerships for the SDGs: is the “next generation” fit for purpose? International Environmental Agreements/International Environmental Agreements (Print), 23(2), 165–171.
POLICY TOPICS
P05. Bureaucrats, Interest Groups, and Policymaking
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The panel Bureaucrats, Interest Groups, and Policymaking is firmly anchored in the rich and evolving body of literature on bureaucratic politics, interest group influence, and policymaking processes. Drawing on foundational works in political science, public administration, and interest group studies (e.g., Lowi, 1969; Wilson, 1989; Carpenter, 2001), the panel seeks to deepen our understanding of how non-elected actors interact to shape public policy. It adopts a multidisciplinary approach integrating theoretical frameworks such as principal-agent theory, network governance, and institutional analysis alongside empirical research on lobbying, regulatory policymaking, and administrative behaviour. Objectives The panel addresses key debates in the scholarly literature by aiming to: Understand bureaucratic influence: Building on studies of bureaucratic discretion and agenda-setting (Meier & O’Toole, 2006; Bendor et al., 2001), the panel examines how bureaucrats act as intermediaries and active participants in policy formulation. It investigates the interactions between bureaucrats and other actors, emphasising their capacity to navigate political demands and technical expertise. Analyse interest group strategies: Informed by research on lobbying tactics and advocacy coalitions (Baumgartner & Leech, 1998; Sabatier & Jenkins-Smith, 1993), the panel explores how interest groups engage with bureaucrats and policymakers, including strategies of persuasion, resource exchange, and coalition-building. Examine institutional and contextual factors: Drawing from comparative studies on political systems and institutional structures (Hall & Taylor, 1996; Peters, 2013), the panel investigates how governance frameworks and contextual variables, such as the level of bureaucratic autonomy or the nature of regulatory environments, mediate these interactions. Assess outcomes and implications: Building on research into policy performance and governance quality (Howlett et al., 2009; Schneider & Ingram, 1997), the panel evaluates how bureaucrat-interest group interactions affect policy outputs and outcomes, including responsiveness, equity, and accountability. Research Questions Reflecting key themes in the academic discourse, the panel addresses the following research questions: How do bureaucrats and interest groups engage in shaping public policy, and what are the mechanisms of influence (Carpenter, 2010; Mahoney, 2007)? Which strategies employed by interest groups are most effective in different policy and governance contexts, and why (Berry, 1977; Klüver, 2013)? How do variations in political institutions, such as federalism or regulatory independence, shape the dynamics between bureaucrats and interest groups (Jordan & Maloney, 2007; Moe, 1984)? What are the implications of these interactions for the legitimacy, transparency, and accountability of policymaking (Beetham, 1991; Christensen & Laegreid, 2007)? How do conflicts or alignments between bureaucratic goals and interest group agendas impact policy design and implementation (Knill & Tosun, 2020)? Scientific Relevance This panel contributes to the literature by bridging gaps between bureaucratic politics and interest group influence, particularly focusing on the understudied role of bureaucrats as policy mediators. Research on bureaucrats has traditionally emphasised their technical and administrative roles (Simon, 1947), while interest group studies have often prioritised their engagement with elected officials. By situating bureaucrats as key nodes in the policymaking network, this panel advances understanding of their dual role as both agents and principals in the policy process. Additionally, the panel aligns with recent calls in the literature to explore cross-national comparisons and generalise findings across diverse governance contexts (Scharpf, 1997; Börzel & Risse, 2010). Its emphasis on institutional variation enhances our ability to theorise about the conditions under which bureaucrat-interest group interactions contribute to policy effectiveness, responsiveness, and legitimacy. Practical Implications In light of contemporary challenges to governance—such as the rise of populism, debates over regulatory capture, and concerns about transparency—the panel’s findings will have practical relevance. By shedding light on how bureaucrats and interest groups collaborate or conflict, the panel aims to inform policy reforms that enhance accountability and democratic legitimacy (Ostrom, 1990; Dahl, 1989). Insights generated may also contribute to ongoing discussions about the balance between stakeholder engagement and impartial governance in both democratic and non-democratic regimes. This panel promises to advance both scholarly understanding and practical solutions, engaging with critical debates on the evolving dynamics of governance and policymaking. References: Baumgartner, F. R., & Leech, B. L. (1998). Basic Interests: The Importance of Groups in Politics and in Political Science. Princeton University Press. Beetham, D. (1991). The Legitimation of Power. Macmillan Education UK. Bendor, J., Glazer, A., & Hammond, T. (2001). Theories of Delegation. Annual Review of Political Science, 4(1), 235-269. Berry, J. M. (1977). Lobbying for the People: The Political Behavior of Public Interest Groups. Princeton University Press. Börzel, T. A., & Risse, T. (2010). Governance Without a State? Policies and Politics in Areas of Limited Statehood. Columbia University Press. Carpenter, D. P. (2001). The Forging of Bureaucratic Autonomy: Reputations, Networks, and Policy Innovation in Executive Agencies, 1862-1928. Princeton University Press. Carpenter, D. P. (2010). Reputation and Power: Organizational Image and Pharmaceutical Regulation at the FDA. Princeton University Press. Christensen, T., & Laegreid, P. (2007). The Whole-of-Government Approach to Public Sector Reform. Public Administration Review, 67(6), 1059-1066. Dahl, R. A. (1989). Democracy and Its Critics. Yale University Press. Hall, P. A., & Taylor, R. C. R. (1996). Political Science and the Three New Institutionalisms. Political Studies, 44(5), 936-957. Howlett, M., Ramesh, M., & Perl, A. (2009). Studying Public Policy: Policy Cycles and Policy Subsystems (3rd ed.). Oxford University Press. Jordan, G., & Maloney, W. A. (2007). Democracy and Interest Groups: Enhancing Participation?. Palgrave Macmillan. Klüver, H. (2013). Lobbying in the European Union: Interest Groups, Lobbying Coalitions, and Policy Change. Oxford University Press. Knill, C., & Tosun, J. (2020). Public Policy: A New Introduction (3rd ed.). Macmillan International Higher Education. Lowi, T. J. (1969). The End of Liberalism: Ideology, Policy, and the Crisis of Public Authority. Norton. Mahoney, C. (2007). Lobbying Success in the United States and the European Union. Journal of Public Policy, 27(1), 35-56. Meier, K. J., & O’Toole, L. J. (2006). Bureaucracy in a Democratic State: A Governance Perspective. Johns Hopkins University Press. Moe, T. M. (1984). The New Economics of Organization. American Journal of Political Science, 28(4), 739-777. Ostrom, E. (1990). Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. Cambridge University Press. Peters, B. G. (2013). Institutional Theory in Political Science: The New Institutionalism (3rd ed.). Bloomsbury Academic. Sabatier, P. A., & Jenkins-Smith, H. C. (Eds.). (1993). Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition Approach. Westview Press. Scharpf, F. W. (1997). Games Real Actors Play: Actor-Centered Institutionalism in Policy Research. Westview Press. Schneider, A., & Ingram, H. (1997). Policy Design for Democracy. University Press of Kansas. Simon, H. A. (1947). Administrative Behavior: A Study of Decision-Making Processes in Administrative Organizations. Macmillan. Wilson, J. Q. (1989). Bureaucracy: What Government Agencies Do and Why They Do It. Basic Books.
POLICY TOPICS
P01. Global challenges and local policy: understanding local government as a site of innovation for planetary health
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The local level has emerged as an important site of policy innovation to address global climate and health challenges. Local jurisdictions are often key actors in the implementation of interventions to improve health outcomes—e.g., on air quality, active transportation, and access to nutritious food—while also advancing climate goals through measures like energy-efficient housing provision, renewable energy adoption, and transport planning. Importantly, they also serve as incubators for innovative or radical policy ideas. Cities are, for example, at the forefront of a growing movement to regulate outdoor advertising for health-harming and high-carbon products (Reeve et al., 2015). Beyond sectoral policies, locally driven governance innovations like participatory budgeting have been translated to local and national settings globally (Peck & Theodore, 2015). Many of these local-level innovations have occurred within the context of devolution of power and responsibility to the regional and local level, which has opened up possibilities for action but also introduced new burdens on local-level actors. In the United Kingdom, devolution of responsibility for several key agendas, including public health, took place in a context of increased managerial oversight, austerity, and lack of cohesive national guidance on how to integrate and reconcile priorities between policy areas (e.g., Clifford 2022). Existing scholarship, e.g., documents the role of policy entrepreneurship and learning in driving local policy innovation, as well as resistance by local publics and local, national, and transnational commercial actors (e.g., Toke, 2005; Lauber et al., 2021; Maltby, 2021). There also exists a tension between the potential for ‘bottom-up’ policy innovation and entrepreneurship at a local government level, and the institutional and political constraints which shape local decision-making in the context of multi-level governance. How policy ‘problems’ are constructed and operationalised locally impacts how such limitations are mitigated and managed, thereby having a key role in enabling or constraining policy change. Scholarship which explores the role of ‘the local’ or ‘the urban’ in addressing global challenges has emerged from different disciplines and focused on different substantive policy areas such as health, climate, and biodiversity while adopting a range of theoretical perspectives. This panel aims to foster dialogue between different perspectives on the local level as a site of policy innovation and entrepreneurship, spark comparative analyses between policy areas and discourse, and encourage nuanced and theoretically informed approaches to studies of local policy action. References Clifford, B. (2022). British local authority planners, planning reform and everyday practices within the state. Public Policy and Administration, 37(1), 84-104. Lauber, K., Hunt, D., Gilmore, A. B., & Rutter, H. (2021). Corporate political activity in the context of unhealthy food advertising restrictions across Transport for London: A qualitative case study. PLoS Medicine, 18(9), e1003695. Reeve, B., Ashe, M., Farias, R., & Gostin, L. (2015). State and municipal innovations in obesity policy: why localities remain a necessary laboratory for innovation. American journal of public health, 105(3), 442-450. Peck, J., & Theodore, N. (2015). Fast Policy: Experimental Statecraft at the Thresholds of Neoliberalism. University of Minnesota Press. Toke, D. (2005). Explaining wind power planning outcomes: some findings from a study in England and Wales. Energy Policy, 33(12), 1527-1539.
POLICY TOPICS
P03. Subnational Transportation and Sustainability Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Subnational Sustainability and Infrastructure PolicyThe urgency of addressing climate change demands political action across all levels of governance, from international and national to local contexts. At the local level, the planning of sustainable mobility – especially the transition away from motorized individual transportation – poses unique challenges, often intersecting with various political jurisdictions. Local governments face the complex task of developing and implementing policies that not only promote sustainable practices but also cater to the specific needs of their communities. These efforts necessitate a multifaceted approach, requiring vertical coordination between governmental levels and horizontal collaboration across municipalities, which is often necessary to advance sustainable infrastructure projects and reach climate objectives. Such collaboration further includes the participation of local non-governmental actors such as citizens, associations, and private sector stakeholders to identify local needs, possible barriers, and optimal solutions. In many cases, collaborative governance has been shown to help mitigate conflicts and facilitate agreements, even when the beliefs of the actors diverge (Koebele & Crow, 2023). Not only municipal coordination, however, poses challenges to local sustainability policy but also issues of financing, multilevel pressures, lacking capacity, decisions on policy instruments, and policy conflicts (Ji, 2020; Vihma & Toikka, 2021; Wolf, 2021; Kern et al., 2023; Schröder & Bandelow, 2024; Zeigermann et al., 2024). Addressing these diverse issues is evident in various studies on the implementation of policies related to the built environment (e.g., bike lanes, railroads, renewable energy infrastructure) that aim to contribute positively to the shift toward greater sustainability. As such, authors have highlighted the role of, inter alia, policy entrepreneurship (Timmermans et al., 2014; Harvey‐Scholes et al., 2023), narratives (Nagel & Schäfer, 2023; Parkkinen & Vikström, 2024), and policy diffusion (Schulze et al., 2024; Jensen et al., 2023) in local sustainability and infrastructure policymaking. These elements provide valuable insights into how policies can be crafted, promoted, and adapted to meet the unique challenges faced by local governments.This panel aims to explore these challenges, their consequences, and possible solutions for subnational sustainability and infrastructure policymaking through the lens of public policy. Investigating and comparing specific sustainability policies at different stages of the policymaking process can contribute to a deeper understanding of the institutional, political, and social factors that facilitate or hinder their design and implementation. As such, our panel calls for empirical contributions on single or multiple case studies, research on good and bad practices, comparative analyses, and systematic reviews of the current research landscape. The goal is to open a dialog that bridges the gap between theoretical frameworks and practical applications, promotes innovation in policy making and encourages collaborative research.Submissions exploring sustainability policies at the local or municipal level, especially including efforts to increase sustainable infrastructure, are encouraged even if they do not focus on vertical or horizontal coordination. For instance, by examining how different stakeholders – ranging from policymakers and urban planners to local businesses and community organizations – interact and influence policy outcomes, we can gain deeper insights into the dynamics that shape the development of sustainable mobility solutions. Understanding the interplay between actor networks and their collaboration, as well as the public narrative surrounding sustainability and infrastructure policies and the communication among policy actors, is of crucial importance. Moreover, there is a growing interest in understanding how cities and municipalities can promote specific instruments such as the integration of bike-sharing programs in urban planning to support cycling as a viable, eco-friendly mode of transport. These initiatives highlight that effective local climate action can also be driven by local initiatives, policy entrepreneurs, focusing events, or the strategic use of narratives. We are calling for submissions that highlight these or other elements of public policy research in relation to subnational sustainability and infrastructure policymaking.ReferencesHarvey‐Scholes, C., Mitchell, C., Britton, J., & Lowes, R. (2023). Citizen policy entrepreneurship in UK local government climate emergency declarations. Review of Policy Research, 40(6), 950–971. https://doi.org/10.1111/ropr.12522Jensen, A., Nielsen, H. Ø., & Russel, D. (2023). Diffusion of climate policy integration in adaptation strategies: Translating the EU mandate into UK and Danish national contexts. Regional Environmental Change, 23(4), 130. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-023-02110-6Ji, H. (2020). How Do Different Types of Local Governments’ Sustainability Programs Relate to Their Environmental Outcomes. Policy Studies Journal, 48(4), 1023–1053. https://doi.org/10.1111/psj.12363Kern, K., Grönholm, S., Haupt, W., & Hopman, L. (2023). Matching forerunner cities: Climate policy in Turku, Groningen, Rostock, and Potsdam. Review of Policy Research, 40(6), 1004–1025. https://doi.org/10.1111/ropr.12525Koebele, E. A., & Crow, D. A. (2023). Mitigating conflict with collaboration: Reaching negotiated agreement amidst belief divergence in environmental governance. Policy Studies Journal, 51(2), 439–458. https://doi.org/10.1111/psj.12496Nagel, M., & Schäfer, M. (2023). Powerful stories of local climate action: Comparing the evolution of narratives using the “narrative rate” index.Review of Policy Research, 40(6), 1093–1119. https://doi.org/10.1111/ropr.12545Parkkinen, M., & Vikström, S. (2024). Alternative policy narratives of the future of climate change: Analyzing Finland’s energy and climate strategy and news reports. Review of Policy Research, 41(4). https://doi.org/10.1111/ropr.12602Schröder, I., & Bandelow, N. C. (2024). Digital citizen participation in policy conflict and concord: Evaluation of a web‐based planning tool for railroad infrastructure. Policy & Internet, 16(3), 628–642. https://doi.org/10.1002/poi3.394Schulze, K., Schoenefeld, J. J., & Hildén, M. (2024). Adapting to climate change: Promises and pitfalls in the diffusion of solutions. Regional Environmental Change, 24(1), 4, s10113-023-02165–5. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-023-02165-5Timmermans, J., van der Heiden, S., & Born, M. P. (2014). Policy Entrepreneurs in Sustainability Transitions: Their Personality and Leadership Profiles Assessed. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions, 13, 96–108. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eist.2014.06.002Vihma, P., & Toikka, A. (2021). The limits of collaborative governance: The role of inter‐group learning and trust in the case of the Estonian “Forest War”. Environmental Policy and Governance, 31(5), 403–416. https://doi.org/10.1002/eet.1952Wolf, E. E. A. (2021). Dismissing the “Vocal Minority”: How Policy Conflict Escalates When Policymakers Label Resisting Citizens. Policy Studies Journal, 49(2), 640–663. https://doi.org/10.1111/psj.12370Zeigermann, U., Böcher, M., & Benz, J. (2024). Regionaler Klimaschutz in Zeiten der Krise? Eine vergleichende Untersuchung von zehn Landkreisen in vier Bundesländern. Raumforschung und Raumordnung | Spatial Research and Planning, 82(3), 264–279. https://doi.org/10.14512/rur.1740
POLICY TOPICS
P04. The governance of urban ecosystem/human health
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The polycrisis (climate change; pandemic; energy; violence; loss of biodiversity; etc) reaches its flashpoint in the planet’s urban systems. Those urban systems are concentrations of people, goods and services, with significant spatial, social and trade footprints. Not only are we an urban planet (with more than half of Earth’s people now living in cities), but these environments also require new and complex forms of interconnected policy and planning. Most ’local’ governments, however, lack the capability, understanding and locus of control to anticipate, prepare for, and shape such policy complexity. This is not a new phenomenon. Advocates of urban action (such as UN Habitat; United Cities and Local Governments, and a wide range of ‘Theme Cities’ such as Healthy Cities) have recognised the challenge and are ready to rise to the occasion. In particular the COVID-19 pandemic has made this realisation more acute than ever. Talk of preparedness, resilience and even ‘building back better’ has increased. Visionary statements and dreams of better futures are proliferating. However, the complexity (science) rhetoric seems to stand in the way of clear-cut analyses of the roles and opportunities for governments, civil society and the corporate sector. Exacerbating this conceptual fog is the severe techno-anthropocentric bias in the various discourses. Indeed, since the dawn of the city (some 15000 years ago), humanity has made a deliberate effort to ‘plan away’ nature and superstition from its environs. Nature has been sanitised and regulated into parks and reserves, and earth cosmologies (common among the Indigenous peoples of the world) alongside them. This ‘othering’ of ecosystems happens at our peril. Systems ecologists have demonstrated that environments with high biodiversity parameters (such as many of the Earth’s tropical zones) create more – zoonotic – pathogens. But the complex diversity of the system also affects and reduces the viability of those pathogens. On the other hand, less biodiverse systems such as cities, have lost that capability to instantly control pathogenicity. The health of urban ecosystems directly connects with the health of all city life (including people) – and should be a top priority of those very anthropocentric institutions that make up the crusts and shells of the planet’s cities. But just as we planned away nature from urban infrastructure, humans are generally left clueless as to governance arrangements and structures for urban health at the interface of ecosystems and humans. Part of the riddle, of course, is a continued conceptual confusion around ‘governance’. At its simplest and most straightforward, this notion of ‘how we do things around here’ deals with the art and science of social and political governing/government. In recent developments in the health field, in particular in global health, there is a strong recognition of notions of multi-level network governance driving change as well as permanence. But these ideas have not (yet) landed in most local (municipal) ecosystems health ideas. This panel, therefore, will invite scholars and practitioners to reflect – in practice and in theory – on forms of governance that relate to urban ecosystems health around the world.
POLICY TOPICS
P02. Using natural language processing for policy process research
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The increasing availability of digital textual data along with advancements in natural language processing (NLP) have opened new avenues for policy process research. Traditional policy studies often rely on qualitative techniques that are effort-intensive and time-consuming. In contrast, the integration of NLP could allow for systematic, large-scale analysis of textual data, potentially leading to novel insights, more robust findings, and comparative analyses. However, the application of NLP in policy process research presents several challenges. First, there is a limited understanding of whether/which NLP methods can be effectively utilized to address specific research questions in policy studies. Second, methodological issues such as data quality, specialized vocabulary, and diverse languages could pose hurdles for scholars. Third, ethical considerations related to data privacy and algorithmic biases require careful attention. The aim of this panel is to advance scholarship on the use of NLP in policy process research by addressing these challenges. We invite submissions that engage with theoretical, methodological, or empirical aspects of using NLP for policy studies. Research questions that fall within the scope of this panel include—but are not limited to—the following: - How might NLP techniques be effectively applied to analyze policy-relevant text for policy process research?- Which methodological innovations might facilitate more widespread use of NLP techniques in policy studies?- How might NLP techniques help understand the dynamics of agenda setting, policy formulation, adoption, implementation, and evaluation?- Which theories of the policy process are amenable to the use of NLP techniques?- How does the integration of NLP techniques affect the reproducibility, scalability, and transparency of policy process research? By exploring these, the panel seeks to advance scholarship in policy process research as well as computational social science.
POLICY TOPICS
P03. Governing the ungovernable? What critical data studies and critical policy studies can contribute to AI policy and practice
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
General Objective: The social impacts of national AI public administration failures and the international urgency to regulate AI make national news, daily (Heikkilä, 2022; Kleinman, 2023). The shortcomings of these AI policy concerns often reach journalists from critical data studies (CDS) research (Murgia, 2024). Despite this, CDS scholars and approaches are under-represented in critical policy studies (Oman, 2022). This panel will reflect on how approaches from critical data studies can be better incorporated into the field of critical policy studies. We argue this is vital to inform impact on this dynamic area of policy and practice. Scientific relevance: There is an urgency to adopt AI to meet aspirations for innovation and efficiency, whilst also acknowledging the need to legislate against potential harms (i.e., UK Government, 2024; EU, 2024), and nations differ in approach. For example, from 2021 to 2024 Mexico created 43 AI-related laws, mostly sanctions to protect human rights, but without due consideration of the governance, institutions or investment required for AI (Peña Mendoza de la 2024). It is therefore important to learn from across national contexts and what has constituted policy success. Data-driven (or evidence-based) approaches to policy-making have long been seen as too simplistic to capture the ‘wicked problems’ of complex social issues (Rittel and Webber 1973; Head 2019). Policy studies, however, has undervalued the wicked problem of data-driven decision-making in and of itself (Oman, 2022). Alongside this, social policy scholarship has overlooked digital policy (Henman, 2022) as have domain-specific policy contexts (Oman, 2024). Meanwhile, the proliferation of AI-enabled systems in welfare (Eubanks, 2019), justice and education judgements (O’Neill, 2016) continue to lead to high-profile public administration and legislative failures that impact most negatively on marginalised populations (Heikkilä, 2022; Murgia, 2024). Gaps in understanding across policy, practice and research therefore have scientific and social implications that policy studies should urgently address. AI policy-makers and commentators are increasingly acknowledging the need for social science and humanities research to ascertain the social impacts of AI innovations and the importance of different approaches (Tassioulas, 2024). For example, participatory decision-making has gained popularity in data governance, owing to its reliance on personal data, alongside the social impacts of data privacy (e.g. Ada Lovelace, n.d). This has also seen pressures to include attitudes research to inform AI policy and practices, but the default survey methodologies that inform policy insufficiently capturing affective responses (Taylor et al., 2023). Methods also don’t often incorporate issues of making data and AI systems legible to all publics, which are vital to democracy (Bates et al., 2023). The evidence informing AI policy-making and regulation is, therefore, often limited. It is clear, then, that policy studies must address AI as another wicked problem for policy-making and there is a clear role for interdisciplinary approaches to policy studies. Critical Data Studies scholars are increasingly focussed on AI policy and practice, but are not often incorporated into policy studies (Oman, 2022), despite these scholars’ approaches as contributions to understanding policy failures (e.g. Fahimi et al., 2024). This panel will contribute to the field of policy studies by reflecting on CDS approaches, including methods, case studies and theoretical developments. Research Question: What can critical data studies approaches bring to policy studies on the subject of AI? We aim to address hypotheses regarding the benefits and challenges of interdisciplinary study in AI policy. We expect these to include: 1, concerns regarding power asymmetries in international collaborative policy, practice and research; 2, discourse on including public voices into AI policy-making; 3, methods to understand the complexity of AI policy and governance from specific contexts and case studies to national and international standards and frameworks. References Ada Lovelace (n.d.) Participatory data governance. Available at: https://www.adalovelaceinstitute.org/project/participatory-data-governance/ Bates, J., Kennedy, H., Medina Perea, I., Oman, S. & Pinney, L. (2023) Socially meaningful transparency in data-based systems: reflections and proposals from practice. Journal of Documentation. 80(1). DOI:/10.1108/JD-01-2023-0006. EU (2024). Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 June 2024 laying down harmonised rules on artificial intelligence. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX:32024R1689 Eubanks, V. (2019). Automating Inequality: How High-Tech Tools Profile, Police, and Punish the Poor. New York: Picador, St Martin’s Press Fahimi, M., Falk, P., Gray, J. W. Y., Jarke, J., Kinder-Kurlanda, K., Light, E., McGeachey, E., Medina Perea, I., Poechhacker, N., Poirier, L., Röhle, T., Sharon, T., Stevens, M., Gastel, B. van, White, Q., & Zakharova, I. (2024). 3: In/visibilities in Data Studies: Methods, Tools, and Interventions. In Dialogues in Data Power: Shifting Response-abilities in a Datafied World. Bristol University Press. https://bristoluniversitypressdigital.com/edcollchap-oa/book/9781529238327/ch003.xml Head, B. (2022). Wicked Problems in Public Policy: Understanding and Responding to Complex Challenges. Palgrave Macmillan. Heikkilä, M. (2022, March 29). Dutch scandal serves as a warning for Europe over risks of using algorithms. POLITICO. https://www.politico.eu/article/dutch-scandal-serves-as-a-warning-for-europe-over-risks-of-using-algorithms/ Henman, P.W.F. (2022). ‘Digital Social Policy: Past, Present, Future’, Journal of Social Policy, 51(3), pp. 535–550. doi:10.1017/S0047279422000162. Kleinman, Z. (2023). Can Rishi Sunak’s big summit save us from AI nightmare?. 28 October 2023. BBC news. Available at: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-67172230 Murgia, M. (2024). Code Dependent: Living in the Shadow of AI. London: Pan Macmillan. O’Neill, C. (2016). Weapons of Math Destruction: How Big Data Increases Inequality and Threatens Democracy. London: Penguin. Oman, S. (2022). ‘Re-performance: a critical and reparative methodology for everyday expertise and data practice in policy knowledge’, International Review of Public Policy, 3(3), pp. 291-313. DOI:/10.4000/irpp.1833. Oman, S. (2024). ‘Digital culture - a review of evidence and experience, with recommendations for UK policy, practice and research.’ London: UK Government. Peña Mendoza de la, S., Ibarra Sánchez, E., Santoyo De Jesús, C. (2024). Panorama de la inteligencia artificial en México: hacia una estrategia nacional. Available at: https://cdnusers3ros.s3.amazonaws.com/public/9e3213120ef1ec5246ed316117908803/47ddfa6a29074e2b1426d394295660281717889675_1717889675.pdf Rittel, H. W. J., & M. M. Webber. (1973). Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning. Policy Sciences, 4(2): 155–169. doi:10.1007/BF01405730. Tasioulas, J. (2021). The role of the arts and humanities in thinking about artificial intelligence (AI). Ada Lovelace. Available here: https://www.adalovelaceinstitute.org/blog/role-arts-humanities-thinking-artificial-intelligence-ai/ Taylor, M., Kennedy, H. & Oman, S. (2024). Challenging assumptions about the relationship between awareness of and attitudes to data uses amongst the UK public, The Information Society, 40(1). 32-53, DOI: 10.1080/01972243.2023.2283729. UK Government (2024). A pro-innovation approach to AI regulation: government response. Command Paper: CP 1019 presented to Parliament by the Secretary of State for Science, Innovation and Technology by Command of His Majesty on 6 February 2024. Available here: https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/ai-regulation-a-pro-innovation-approach-policy-proposals/outcome/a-pro-innovation-approach-to-ai-regulation-government-response
POLICY TOPICS
P04. Advanced Computational Methods for Public Policy: NLP, ML, and LLMs
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Context Natural Language Processing (NLP) is a subfield of computer science and linguistics that focuses on enabling computers to understand and interact with human language. It uses techniques from Machine Learning (ML), a branch of artificial intelligence that allows computers to learn from data and improve their performance. In the context of policy analysis, ML-driven NLP can be used for a variety of tasks, such as automatically categorizing policy documents or identifying policy change. Recently, the development of Large Language Models (LLMs), such as GPT-4, has further advanced NLP capabilities. LLMs are models trained on vast amounts of text data, allowing them to comprehend and generate human-like language. LLMs can assist in many tasks both in policy analysis and policy advice through their ability to process large quantities of data. Natural Language Processing (NLP) and Machine Learning (ML) are becoming a powerful tool in policy analysis. With the increasing digitization of policy documents, these methods have been applied to various types of texts—ranging from legislative documents and regulations to policy briefs and political debates—enhancing the efficiency and scope of policy analysis. However, while NLP and ML show potential in automating routine tasks, debates continue about whether it can fully replace human policy analysts, especially when it comes to the interpretation of context or complex policy document and ethical considerations (Safaei & Longo, 2024; Bol & Bono, 2024). How can NLP, enriched by ML and LLMs, enhance public policy analysis, and what are their limitations? This panel aims to critically examine the (1) types of data used, (2) the methods employed—including the roles of ML and LLMs—and (3) the applications of these technologies in public policy, exploring both their current use and future potential. (1) Types of textual data The effectiveness of NLP and ML in policy analysis depends on the availability and quality of textual data. Current efforts include large corpora of parliamentary proceedings, such as the ParlaMint dataset, which contains transcriptions of European parliamentary debates (Erjavec et al., 2023). Similarly, RegCan, a database of Canadian federal regulations, provides data for studying regulations (Tremblay-Faulkner et al., 2018). Policy briefs, party manifestos, and political speeches are also being analyzed using NLP techniques (Orellana & Bisgin, 2023). These textual datasets provide the raw material for NLP and LLMs, but they also present challenges due to the complexity of legal and political language, preprocessing, or inherent bias, requiring advanced methods and controls to use and analyze these documents accurately. (2) Types of methods used Various NLP methods are applied to analyze these textual data. Text classification techniques categorize documents into policy areas such as health, education, or climate (Jin & Mihalcea, 2023). Topic modeling is another common method, which identifies latent themes within large corpora, analyzing trends in policy debates (Singh et al., 2024). Sentiment analysis measures the emotional tone in parliamentary speeches (Rheault et al., 2016). More advanced methods, such as causal mapping and graph analytics, allow for the extraction of cause-effect relationships from policy documents, enabling the visualization of policy impacts and interdependencies (Hooper et al., 2024). Machine Learning algorithms can enhance these methods by enabling predictive analysis and pattern recognition. LLMs also can perform tasks like summarization, question-answering, and even drafting policy documents. However, despite these advancements, concerns about model interpretability, ethical use, and biases persist (Rodriguez et al., 2024). (3) Types of applications in policy analysis and policymaking The applications of NLP for policy are broad, ranging from policy evaluation to the production of policy briefs. Automated systems and LLMs now generate policy briefs by summarizing legislative texts (Safaei & Longo, 2024). NLP tools are also used to monitor and evaluate the implementation of international climate agreements (Singh et al., 2024). Furthermore, sentiment analysis of public opinion data—such as social media—enables policymakers to assess public reactions to policy changes (Rodriguez et al., 2024). Despite these advances, the idea that LLMs could entirely replace human policy analysts remains controversial (Bol & Bono, 2024).
POLICY TOPICS
P01. Policy Feedback Effects of Reproductive Health Laws on Attitudes, Sexual Behaviors and Political Behavior
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The past five years have seen tremendous upheavals in reproductive health laws around the globe. Numerous longstanding restrictions on abortion access in Latin America and other countries have been relaxed (e.g., Chile, Argentina & Mexico) while the U.S. has adopted unprecedented abortion restrictions in the wake of the overturning of Roe v Wade. These upheavals have been spurred by different and somewhat competing trends. Whereas powerful social movements centered on women’s rights in Argentina and Mexico recently succeeded in making salient and passing landmark abortion liberalizations, growing right-wing movements have pushed alarmist concern about population decline and pronatalist policies geared at restricting access to reproductive health services. Research on policy feedback effects has demonstrated that while politics creates policies, policies, in turn, can reshape public opinion (Barabas, 2009), can reduce or generate political mobilization (Campbell, 2002; Mettler, 2002; Soss and Schram, 2007) and can even produce behavioral adaption that can either support or undermine policies’ intended goals (Pacheco, 2013). Research on the mechanisms underlying policy feedback effects have centered on two primary explanations: resource effects of policy and interpretive effects. Whereas resource effects are more closely tied to self-interest, for instance, the effect of earning or losing a benefit, interpretive effects occur through messages construed via policy design (Campbell, 2014) that can either empower beneficiaries or demobilize individuals. However, research to date on policy feedback effects has concentrated more on redistributive or economic policies, which are often hidden, submerged, or not as immediately salient in people’s lives (Mettler, 2011). This call for submissions builds on emerging policy feedback research in the domain of “highly tangible policies” (Pacheco, 2013) and “morality politics” (Kreitzer, 2015) that exhibit low complexity and high visibility. These issues are generally easy for the public to grasp, commonly experienced and are frequently high-profile in media and politics. Highly tangible, morality policies affect mass attitudes by educating the public about what is socially acceptable, influencing support for analogous policies and impacting directly on self-reinforcing behaviors in ways that can entrench policy. This latter mechanism is an important alternative to previous research, as it implies that the goal of policies is not to narrowly influence behavior in response to a particular policy, but rather to more broadly reshape cultural norms and expectations. For instance, policies banning indoor smoking sent powerful signals about the harms of combustible cigarettes and its social acceptability that ultimately denormalized the behavior, producing dramatic reductions in combustible cigarette smoking rates (Pacheco, 2013). By contrast, Prohibition in the 1930s failed because the policy did not succeed in changing mass attitudes or cultural norms towards drinking. In the context of restrictive abortion and reproductive health policies, the broader goal of proponents is arguably not limited to ceasing the practice of abortion, but rather is the production of a cultural transformation to reshape gender norms and a broader set of sexual and reproductive health behaviors in ways that will further entrench the policy. Yet, despite the critical importance of abortion and other reproductive rights issues as a cultural flashpoint (Kimport & Kreitzer, 2023), relatively little literature exists on how changes in reproductive health laws have affected public attitudes towards abortion and reproductive rights or behavioral changes, political participation, and the social citizenship of the people affected by these policy changes the most.
POLICY TOPICS
P02. Creating a new generation of intersectionality-informed policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Relevance: Addressing intersecting health and social inequities is a pressing policy priority, particularly as brought to light by the growing awareness of interlocking global challenges including COVID-19 pandemic recovery, climate change, and geopolitical instability. Interest in intersectionality has grown internationally and across all sectors in the last decade with a growing number of examples of intersectionality-informed policy research emerging. Despite the progress, misunderstandings persist on how to operationalize an intersectional approach, largely due to multiple and contrasting interpretations of intersectionality; lack of training of policymakers; siloed government structures; and a lack of appropriate data. This has no doubt created confusion and frustration over how intersectionality can be drawn upon to ensure the best and most transformative outcomes in policy work. As a result, there are growing international calls for accurate and effective uses of intersectionality that transcend the shortcomings of efforts to date. Specifically, these calls focus on the need for clear and context relevant guidance and tools on how to operationalize intersectionality to realize its full potential (e.g. Ghasemi et al. 2021; Yam et al. 2021, Christofferson & Hankivsky 2021; Hawkes & Allotey 2020; Sasser et al. 2020; Bowleg 2020; Scottish Government 2022; La Barbera et al 2022; USAID 2022; Tavenner et al 2022; IPPN 2022). The proposed panel responds to these calls, with the objective of helping to address barriers and obstacles to operationalizing intersectionality, and to identify strategies and approaches to advance intersectionality-informed policy work by both state and non-state actors. Further objectives include the promotion of engagement and knowledge exchange, to highlight promising and new intersectionality-informed frameworks and guidance, to share insights and lessons learned based on experience and expertise. The panel is motivated by the following research question: what knowledge generation is needed for the next generation of approaches that can address the growing calls for improving the precision and ease with which intersectionality is operationalized? In proposing this panel, we hope to advance discussions that will focus on exploring tensions between existing approaches to operationalizing intersectionality, barriers and enablers, and how to move the work in the field forward through case studies and illustration. The panel will bring together multi-sectoral and multijurisdictional experts and scholars who have worked with international organizations, different levels of governments and community groups to develop specific toolkits, especially in the last three years, during which time there has been a marked increase in the production of intersectionality-informed guidance. We especially seek contributions from the Global South. Contributing paper presenters will be invited to contribute to a special journal issue on the topic.
POLICY TOPICS
P03. Public Policies and Moral Issues in Latin America
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
General objectives. Research questions and scientific relevance (from 300 to 500 words) Write the general description of the panel in the text box. It should explain the context of the topic, contain a brief state of the art, present the research question, and the different hypotheses the panel can explore. Also, you need to indicate what would the format of your panel: onsite or online. In Latin America, as in other regions over the last decade, there has been a growing presence of ultra-conservative groups in politics, advocating positions typically linked to religious values. Campaigns such as "Don´t mess with our kids" and demonstrations against the so-called "gender ideology" have moralised public issues, hindering reforms and subsequent backlashes in various contexts. Extant literature, especially in Europe and the US, studies these processes under the term "Morality Politics" (Mourao, 2019). Some scholars, like Engeli et al. (2013) and Hurka et al. (2018), have sought explanations for how moral issues have entered the political agenda and policy-making process. Hurka et al. (2018) propose the "four worlds of moral politics," considering contexts characterised by the presence of religious cleavages within party systems and those where decisions are made individually in Parliament or institutionally within political parties. There are also studies in Europe on the interaction between political and social actors in defining the moral policy agenda (Knill, 2013; Mourão, 2019), with so many case studies and applying a variety of methodologies. In Latin America, the study of morality politics and its relationship with the political system and public policy formulation is still an on-going process. Some initial studies have analysed the link between sexuality, religion, and politics in Latin America (Vaggione, 2009). Others have studied the link between religion, political actors, and social mobilisation in Mexico (Martinez, 2016). Tabbush and Caminotti (2020) studied the expansion of conservative opposition to gender equality policies in the region, alongside other studies that appeared in the LASA Dossier on Anti-Gender Offensives in Latin America. Latin American morality policies have also been applied to the Mexican case (Martínez Carmona, 2021). Vaggione (2022) has studied the neoconservative network in Latin America based on gender ideology. More recently, Alza (2024) has studied morality politics in Latin America, finding combinations of conditions present when public policy on same-sex marriage does not change. In this context, this panel seeks to delve deeper into the analysis of the complex nature of morality politics in Latin America. Its main objective is to explore how factors such as religiosity, the influence of conservative actors, and the structure of political systems impact the formulation and evolution of policies in the region. In particular, the panel will focus on the dynamics and challenges faced by public policies when addressing moral issues such as abortion, same-sex marriage, and reproductive rights. The discussion is expected to consider, for example, understanding how religious cleavages within political parties, the mobilisation of conservative groups facilitate or hinder the introduction of more permissive public policies, as well as the role played by parties and ideologies in these processes (Alza, 2024; Engeli et al., 2013). It is hoped that this panel will contribute to the debate on the factors and causal mechanisms that condition the feasibility of public policy change on moral issues, especially in contexts where religiosity exerts a considerable influence on political decisions.
POLICY TOPICS
P04. Gender Inclusive Urban Development Planning: Issues and Challenges
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The primary objective of this panel is to explore and analyze the issues and challenges associated with gender-inclusive urban development planning. It seeks to understand how urban spaces can be designed and managed to be more inclusive, equitable, and responsive to the needs of all genders. Specifically, the study aims to identify barriers that prevent the effective participation and representation of women and marginalized genders in urban planning processes, assess the impact of gender-blind urban policies, and propose actionable strategies to promote gender equity in urban development. Additionally, this panel seeks to examine the intersectionality of gender with other factors such as class, race, and disability to develop a more comprehensive understanding of inclusive urban environments. Research Questions: 1. What are the key challenges and barriers to achieving gender-inclusive urban development planning in contemporary cities?2. How do gender-blind urban policies and designs affect women and marginalized genders in terms of safety, accessibility, mobility, and economic participation?3. In what ways can urban development planning be restructured to integrate gender equity and inclusivity at all levels of decision-making?4. How does the intersection of gender with other social categories (e.g., race, class, disability) shape the experience of urban spaces for different groups?5. What best practices and policy recommendations can be drawn from global examples of gender-inclusive urban development?Scientific Relevance: The relevance of this topic lies in its contribution to a growing body of scholarship that critiques traditional urban development models for their gender-blindness. Most urban planning paradigms have historically been designed with a bias towards male experiences, often neglecting the specific needs of women, non-binary, and marginalized gender groups. Gender-inclusive urban development is crucial for ensuring that cities serve all residents equitably.
POLICY TOPICS
P05. Disability Inclusive Policy Development in the Asia Pacific Region
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
State policy is often utilised as a mechanism to implement international conventions within local contexts. 185 countries internationally have ratified the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD), including all countries in the Asia-Pacific region. The UNCRPD provides a set of principles that state parties are to adopt to ensure the rights of people with disability and the UN monitors the establishment of legislation and policies which support these rights. However, implementation often falls short of policy expectations. Both mechanistic and interpretive reasoning has been applied to understand continued policy failure and offer solutions (e.g. Steele, 2019; Verdugo et al, 2017). Disabled people and disability representative organisations have consistently noted that despite signing up to international expectations for disability inclusion, such as those expressed through the UNCRPD, local experiences do not match this. Further, in many cases the voices of people with disability are not central in policy design or implementation processes. All too often this means that the priorities for people with disability are not reflected in policy. Disability is an under-acknowledged cause of marginalisation and poverty in developing and developed countries alike but is not always a core focus of current public policy research (Grech, 2009). This panel specifically focuses on centring discussions of disability as a case through which we can explore policy implementation for marginalised populations more broadly. This panel will focus on the ways that policies in countries in the Asia Pacific region foster the inclusion of people with disability and the barriers and enablers to implementation. We centre the discussion in the Asia Pacific region as a way of drawing attention to policy realities of countries outside of the existing Europe-North America contexts that dominate the policy research landscape. Papers will focus on the following research questions to explore which circumstances impact disability policy implementation: 1. What strategies are most effective in creating policies that lead to effective implementation for disability inclusion? 2. How can people with disability be best included in policy implementation? 3. How can disability inclusion be prioritised in policy in low-resource settings? 4. What barriers exist to implementation of the UNCRPD goals in policy? 5. How does a focus on disability help us better understand policy design and implementation for marginalised populations? References: Steel, E. J. (2019). The duplicity of choice and empowerment: disability rights diluted in Australia’s policies on assistive technology. Societies, 9(2), 39. Verdugo, M. A., Jenaro, C., Calvo, I., & Navas, P. (2017). Disability policy implementation from a cross-cultural perspective. Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities, 55(4), 234-246. Grech, S. (2009). Disability, poverty and development: Critical reflections on the majority world debate. Disability & Society, 24(6), 771-784.
POLICY TOPICS
P01. Artificial Intelligence and Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The exceptional growth and rapid development of artificial intelligence technologies (AITs) is transforming governance landscapes globally, with nations increasingly adopting AI for both public and private sectors. From digital imaging to public health and from cybersecurity to education, AITs are reshaping processes and national governments are continually pursuing AI strategies to assert technological leadership. In parallel, multilateral bodies like the United Nations, European Commission, and World Bank are working to establish global AI standards, trying to promote the safe and inclusive development and equitable access to AITs. Nevertheless, despite these efforts, implementing AI-driven policies raises complex challenges and policy implementation poses profound challenges in addressing political, legal, ethical, and socio-economic issues across diverse contexts. Central to these challenges is also data, which sits at the core of every AI technology. Accuracy, timeliness, completeness, and consistency are some of the data-quality related concerns that can significantly impact AI outcomes. With surge in generative AI, there is a continuous fear and issue of accuracy, bias, and discrimination inherent in LLMs. Similarly, in many countries of the Global South, the adoption and regulation of AI are marked by distinct socio-political and economic challenges that differ substantially from those of the Global North. Limited access to technological infrastructure, a shortage of specialized skills, and scarce financial resources often hinder AI development. The absence of comprehensive national AI policies can leave these countries vulnerable to unregulated technology imports, raising concerns about data sovereignty and privacy. This panel aims to critically examine the policy frameworks that guide AI’s integration into public sectors, exploring how AI is shaping governance structures and impacting public trust, transparency, and accountability. The goal of this panel is to create a comprehensive dialogue on AI’s role in public policy, aiming to identify pathways for balanced and inclusive AI governance. The panel aims to address several research questions, including: - How can policy and technology circuit collaborate to [co]create regulatory frameworks that ensure safe, effective, and fair AI implementation? - How can countries in the Global South develop AI policies that address their unique socio-political contexts, and what role can global standards play in supporting this? - In what ways or can public sector AI initiatives from the Global North serve as reference points for countries in the Global South, and how can policy frameworks adapt to the unique socio-political contexts of these regions? - What governance structures and regulatory approaches are most effective in building public trust in AI technologies, especially within contexts where AI-driven decisions impact citizen welfare and rights? - What policy measures can mitigate the potential job displacement caused by automation, and how can governments ensure that workforce transitions are equitable? - How can collaboration between policymakers, technologists, and civil society increase an ethical AI framework that balances innovation with societal values and norms? - How can national and global data governance frameworks improve data quality dimensions such as accuracy, timeliness, and consistency?
POLICY TOPICS
P02. Understanding ‘valuable’ research: Emerging forms of worth in national science policies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Governments around the world have made significant investments in the assessment of publicly funded research. Research policy in the UK, Australia, Hong Kong and several other nations, now includes a focus on the ‘impact’ of research (i.e. relevance to external actors, public value or societal benefit). This is an expansion to assessments of ‘quality’ or excellence, which prioritise academic merit and attempt to capture the value of new knowledge. What is regarded as valuable research has been shifting in science policy and research practice, driven by multiple factors, including the desire to demonstrate ‘value for money’ in funding universities and research institutes, rising scepticism about the worth of the research they produce, and increasing levels of populism which question science and expertise and portray research and researchers as elite and irrelevant. These changes are producing significant changes in national research policy trajectories and reducing the autonomy of individual universities in terms of their strategy, and more tightly directing academics in terms of the research they pursue.
POLICY TOPICS
P03. AI Governance and Regulation: Emerging Approaches through a Comparative Lens
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Objectives As artificial intelligence (AI) becomes increasingly integral to various sectors of the global economy, the imperative to establish effective governance and regulatory frameworks has never been more pressing. Governments around the world are striving to navigate the complex landscape of AI regulation, balancing the promotion of innovation with the protection from potential risks while maintaining ethical integrity. This panel aims to provide a comprehensive analysis of diverse approaches to AI governance and regulation, with a focus on strategies adopted by emerging economies. Research Question How do emerging economies navigate the balance between innovation and regulation in AI governance, and what role do regulatory frameworks from major jurisdictions (EU, US, China) play in shaping their approaches? Literature Review Recent scholarship has revealed a complex landscape of AI governance dominated by three distinct regulatory approaches. These approaches reflect fundamentally different philosophies: China's state-driven development model, the US's market-driven approach, and the EU's rights-driven framework (Bradford, 2023). This panel is interested in how these jurisdictions compete not only for technological dominance but also for regulatory supremacy, seeking to project their models globally (Smuha, 2021). The concept of regulatory influence is particularly evident in what has been termed the "Brussels Effect," whereby the EU's market power enables it to set de facto global standards (Bradford, 2012, 2020). In the realm of digital governance, this phenomenon is exemplified by the GDPR's impact on global data protection standards (Mahieu et al., 2021). However, AI's rapid evolution and geopolitical significance complicate the establishment of uniform global standards (Almada & Radu, 2024). Parallel to this, research identifies an emerging "Beijing Effect," where China's regulatory framework, emphasizing pro-growth and developmental priorities, particularly influences emerging economies (Erie & Streinz, 2021; Migliorini, 2024). This panel aims to address a critical gap in current discussions of AI governance by bringing together experts studying how emerging economies develop hybrid regulatory models(Chan et al., 2024; Migliorini & Neuwirth, 2023; Papyshev & Yarime, 2023). While most academic discussions on AI governance focus on the EU, US, and China’s approaches, our panel will be especially interested in examining how other countries navigate between these established frameworks while developing context-specific approaches. Scientific Relevance This panel will adopt a comparative analysis approach, examining case studies from various emerging economies to understand their unique regulatory challenges and opportunities. This panel will contribute to the academic discussions by shedding light on the under-explored area of AI regulation in emerging economies. It aims to generate comprehensive insights into the dynamic interplay between national priorities and international standards, ultimately informing policymakers and stakeholders engaged in crafting effective AI governance frameworks. Through interdisciplinary dialogue, this panel aspires to enhance our understanding of the multifaceted landscape of AI governance and its implications for global cooperation and innovation.
POLICY TOPICS
P05. Regulating AI: Governance Challenges and Policy Implications
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The governance of artificial intelligence (AI) is witnessing rapid developments with the passage of the EU-AI Act, the world’s first comprehensive law on AI. As a disruptive technology, AI has the potential to solve global challenges like climate change, improve efficiency in various sectors like manufacturing, health, education, and transportation. However, there are socio-technical, ethical, and safety challenges of AI adoption that have been discussed extensively (Agrawal et al., 2019; Burton et al., 2020; Calo, 2017; Etzioni & Etzioni, 2017; Ruschemeier, 2023; Sood & Lim, 2023; Tan & Taeihagh, 2021). The proliferation of generative AI along with general and narrow AI has led to distinctive and unique challenges to this landscape. In this backdrop, governance of AI has received considerable attention with governments following varied approaches ranging from self-regulation and market-based approaches and a mix of entrepreneurial and regulatory governance (Djeffal et al., 2022). For instance, while the EU follows a horizontal approach without differentiating sectors for harmonization, the US adopts a sectoral approach (Haie et al., n.d.). The EU-AI Act delineates AI systems on the basis of their risks—unacceptable, high, limited, and minimal risk, while the UK government classifies risks of AI as societal harms, misuse risks, and autonomy risks (ibid.). Such differences will have ramifications for global governance of AI and the impact of the actions of different actors like the big tech (e.g. OpenAI, Meta, Google, Microsoft) involved in developing and integrating AI technologies in products and services (Khanal et al. 2024). With the pace of innovations of such companies moving faster than legislations and policies, insights into the governance of AI systems to balance innovation and regulation will be imperative for policymaking. The panel will explore facets related to regulation of AI focusing on the following (not limited to) questions: · What are the different frameworks used to understand the risks and formulate governance mechanisms for AI? · How are governments balancing the innovation across sectors with the risks of AI? · To what extent do the current governance mechanisms for AI in the global north and south address the challenges of adoption of AI? · What are the challenges associated with implementation of existing AI governance mechanisms in the global north and south? · What is the role of policy learning in adoption and governance of AI, especially for middle and low income countries?
POLICY TOPICS
P06. Governing technologies in Southeast Asia: (Re)Thinking digital tech and its policies from a Southern perspective
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Beyond the truism that digital technologies permeate all aspects of societies, the assemblages of devices, cables, and data centres allowing for everyday connectivity are realising tremendous (geo)political, social, and economic effects. Southeast Asia is portrayed as one of the most dynamic regions (hyperconnected, datafied, and innovative) but also faces major digital challenges: In so-called ‘mobile first’ environments, both the opportunities (e.g., gig-economy, smart cities, e-government, infrastructure investment) and challenges (e.g., disinformation, surveillance, hate speech, cybercrimes, data breaches) of digital technologies shape unique policy worlds; and are producing ambiguous, complex effects on society (Bächtold et al., forthcoming 2024; Lim, 2017; Rasidi, 2023). As in other regions, governments struggle to produce effective policies to govern digital technology (Lim, forthcoming; Leong & Lee, 2021), but Southeast Asian policymakers face different challenges than those underpinning the Chinese, US or EU policy approaches to data sovereignty or consumer privacy protection. Often, they find themselves at a particular disadvantage vis-à-vis the economic power of international (e.g., Meta, Bytedance) and regional (Grab) Big tech companies. As a result, the (socio-technical) imaginaries and framings of technologies that are underpinning most policies targeting the digital in the region appear to uncritically accept the hyperdatafied business model of current surveillance capitalism (Zuboff, 2015) or data colonialism (Couldry & Mejias, 2018). However, recent developments like the Indonesian government’s push back against TikTok and Malaysia’s social media platform licensing complicate this picture. At the same time, attempts to regulate digital spaces to curb hate speech or misinformation are often leveraged to silence and control dissent (Rasidi, 2023). By taking a step back to critically evaluate both the realities and imaginaries of policy targeting digital tech, this panel questions the problematisation of digital technologies in Southeast Asia’s policy worlds. It focuses on a region of strategic importance to global infrastructure; and home to idiosyncratic digital environments, practices, and knowledges. This should yield findings that are not only relevant to academia and to improve policy regionally, but invites us to re-think theoretical concepts, policies, and understandings of the digital - globally. Literature: Bächtold, S., Raghunath, P., & Lim, J. B. Y. (forthcoming 2024). Governing Technologies: Exploring Datafied Practices, Imaginaries and Digital State Assemblages in South and South East Asia. Journal of Digital Media & Policy, 15(3). Couldry, N., & Mejias, U. A. (2018). Data Colonialism: Rethinking Big Data’s Relation to the Contemporary Subject. Television & New Media, 20(4), 336-349. Leong, S., & Lee, T. (2021). Global internet governance: Influences from Malaysia and Singapore. Palgrave MacMillan. Lim, J. B. Y (forthcoming 2024). Digital Media Interventions in Southeast Asia: A Decolonial Perspective. Palgrave Macmillan. Lim, J. B. Y. (2017). Engendering Civil Resistance: Social Media and Mob Tactics in Malaysia. International Journal of Cultural Studies, 20(2), 209-227. Rasidi, P. P. (2023). Ludic cybermilitias: shadow play and computational propaganda in the Indonesian predatory state. Communication, Culture & Critique, 16(4), 235-242. Zuboff, S. (2015). Big Other: Surveillance Capitalism and the Prospects of an Information Civilization. Journal of Information Technology, 30(1), 75-89.
POLICY TOPICS
P07. Exploring the final frontier: Emerging Trends and Interdisciplinary approaches in Space Policy and Governance Research
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Space policy and governance is an expansive, multidisciplinary field encompassing diverse research agendas. Scholars explore the rapid diversification of policy actors (European Space Policy Institute, 2017; Paladini & Castellucci, 2023), technological advancements (Krelina, 2023; RAND Corporation, 2024), the expanding space economy (Aldrin, 2013; Whealan, 2019), and rising challenges like space congestion (Moltz, 2019) and space debris (Gorman, 2019; Migaud, 2020; Miller, 2021). Additionally, the field addresses critical issues of international collaboration (Jiang and Zhao, 2021) and strategic competition among powers (Ruff et al., 2022; Brose, 2020; Johnson-Freese, 2017). Researchers from public policy, international relations, public administration, sociology, and political economy now contribute to this evolving discipline (Pomeroy, 2019). This panel convenes scholars and practitioners to address key questions at the intersection of space policy and interdisciplinary research. As space becomes an ever-diverse field with significant intersections in energy, governance (both domestic and international), and its critical role in addressing global challenges such as climate change through satellite technology, space policy research and theory building is now central to understanding these complex issues. We seek to foster collaboration among policy scholars and practitioners, aiming to answer the following research questions: 1. What are the common practices used among various disciplines, such as policy process, public administration, international relations, and political economy, in space policy research agendas? 2. How are these common practices for topical, methodological, and theoretical research agendas influencing the direction of space policy studies? The relevance of space policy has never been greater - yet, space policy research remains isolated within academic disciplines. This panel intends to bridge the gap between disciplines by encouraging interdisciplinary conversations that explore the growing relevance of space policy and governance in both national and international agendas. Potential hypotheses/topics: - The evolution of the space policy subsystem, driven by the emergence of new coalitions, actors, and market incentives that shape policy preferences. Purpose: re-examining coalition typologies and their impact on the policy landscape using the Advocacy Coalition Framework (Jenkins-Smith and Sabatier, 1994). - The construction of narratives within space policy influences public and political discourse about space as a frontier for technological innovation, security concerns, and environmental monitoring. Purpose: developing deeper understandings of the trends in narrative discourse surrounding space policy and governance using the Narrative Policy Framework (Shanahan, Jones, and McBeth, 2015). - Partisan rationales shape the priorities of domestic space programs, with a focus on economic development, national security, and the framing of space exploration as a symbol of political and technological prowess. Purpose: discussing the partisan and moral rationales which shape priorities of domestic and international space programs. - Political agendas in domestic and international space governance have shifted over time. Domestically, space policy may be driven by economic growth and defense strategies, while internationally, there is increasing focus on collaboration and peaceful governance to ensure the sustainable use of space as a global commons. Purpose: describing the advancement of space policy in domestic and international governance agenda-setting. These topics underscore the growing importance of space policy as an interdisciplinary area of research. By examining these dynamics, the panel will shed light on space as a crucial arena for national and global policy, offering insights into the adaptation of policy to the evolving realities of space exploration, utilization, and regulation. References Aldrin, A. J. (2013). Space economics and commerce in a strategic context. In E. Sadeh (Ed.), Space strategy in the 21st century: Theory and policy. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203098288 European Space Policy Institute. (2017). “The Rise of Private Actors - Executive Summary.” https://www.espi.or.at/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/ESPI-report-The-rise-of-private-act ors-Executive-Summary-1.pdf Gorman, A. (2019). Dr. Space Junk vs the Universe. Sydney, NSW, Australia: New South Wales Publishing. Jenkins-Smith, H. C., & Sabatier, P. A. (1994). Evaluating the Advocacy Coalition Framework. Journal of Public Policy, 14(2), 175–203. http://www.jstor.org/stable/4007571 Jiang, S. and Zhao Y. (2021). “China’s National Space Station: Opportunities, Challenges, and Solutions for International Cooperation.” Space Policy 57: 101439. doi:10.1016/j.spacepol.2021.101439. Krelina, M. (2023). “The Prospect of Quantum Technologies in Space for Defence and Security.” Space Policy 65: 101563. doi:10.1016/j.spacepol.2023.101563. Migaud, M. R. (2020). “Protecting Earth’s Orbital Environment: Policy Tools for Combating Space Debris.” Space Policy 52: 101361. doi:10.1016/j.spacepol.2020.101361. Miller, G. D. (2021). “Deterrence by Debris: The Downside to Cleaning up Space.” Space Policy 58: 101447. doi:10.1016/j.spacepol.2021.101447. Moltz, J. C. (2019). The Politics of Space Security: Strategic Restraint and the Pursuit of National Interests, Third Edition. Redwood City: Stanford University Press. Paladini, S., and Castellucci I. (2022). “Sovereign States, Private Actors, and (National) Space Laws. A Rapidly Evolving Landscape.” In The Institutions of Extraterrestrial Liberty, ed. Charles S. Cockell. Oxford University PressOxford, 366–83. doi:10.1093/oso/9780192897985.003.0022. Pomeroy, Caleb. (2019). “The Quantitative Analysis of Space Policy: A Review of Current Methods and Future Directions.” Space Policy 48 (May):14–29. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spacepol.2018.08.001. RAND Corporation. (2024). “Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning for Space Domain Awareness: The Development of Two Artificial Intelligence Case Studies.” doi:10.7249/RRA2318-2. Ruff, J. W. A., Stelmach, G., & Jones, M. D. (2022). Space for stories: Legislative narratives and the establishment of the US Space Force. Policy Sciences, 55(3), 509–553. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-022-09455-5 Shanahan, Elizabeth A., Michael D. Jones, and Mark K. McBeth. 2015. “Narrative Policy Framework.” Melvin Dubnick and Domonic Bearfield, eds. The Encyclopedia of Public Administration and Public Policy, 3rd Edition. New York, New York: Taylor and Francis.:http://www.crcnetbase.com/doi/10.1081/E-EPAP3-120053656 Whealan G. K. (2019). “The Economic Impacts of the Commercial Space Industry.” Space Policy 47 (February):181–86. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spacepol.2018.12.003.
POLICY TOPICS
P08. Defining Digital Public Policy and Its Role in Shaping Governance and Society
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Digital Public Policy (DPP) is an evolving field, encompassing wide ranging issues, e.g., digital infrastructure and inclusion, data governance, and AI-enabled systems and decision-making. It intersects numerous disciplines with limited consensus on its scope and definition (Servon, 2002, Bernholtz et al., 2020, Califano and Becerra, 2024, Milutinovic, 2022), and is notably missed from areas of policy studies (Henman 2022). Concurrently, the proliferation of Information and communication technologies (ICTs) creates increasingly interdependent and interconnected systems for public management (Fenger and Bekkers, 2012), making policy-making itself increasingly fragmented, yet interconnected. Improved coordination and collaboration between levels of governance are essential to address DPP’s complexity (Servon, 2002 Oman , 2022, 2024) and the social justice issues of the digital divide (Schwab and Davis, 2018) and asymmetries in data power. Increasing reliance on digital technologies and infrastructures makes the closing of the digital divide within and across countries an urgent as power may flow to those who already hold geographical, educational, and economic advantages while billions of others could be further excluded on the basis of income, infrastructure, language or content relevance (Schwab and Davis, 2018, p. 53). Through addressing these challenges, preferred digital futures which are equitable, inclusive and sustainable may be envisioned, invented, implemented, continuously evaluated, revised and re-envisioned (Dator, 2019). By addressing the social justice dimensions of DPP, particularly regarding the digital divide, the panel will contribute to ongoing efforts to ensure that digital technologies serve the public good, promoting equity and inclusivity in the digital transformation. This panel has three objectives: 1. critically examine DPP: its definitions, applications, and role in shaping governance frameworks for digital societies; 2. understand context-specific uses across regions and domain applications; 3. reflect on how public policy can foster inclusive, ethical, and sustainable digital futures, whilst acknowledging negative impacts on vulnerable populations and the planet. Research Questions What constitutes Digital Public Policy? This question aims to clarify the key components of DPP, exploring national and regional differences. What is DPP’s role in shaping digital futures? With increasing digital dependence, we would imagine responses to this question focus on DPP’s role in equitable and sustainable digital futures, addressing critical issues such as digital literacy, data privacy, and internet governance. How do nations and stakeholders approach DPP? This question explores the varying approaches to DPP across regions and governance structures, examining how governments, private actors, and civil society collaborate to develop effective DPP frameworks. What are the key challenges and opportunities in DPP? This question identifies the main barriers to implementing DPP, such as regulatory fragmentation and the global nature of digital platforms, while also highlighting opportunities for innovation and the protection of digital rights. Understanding DPP is critical to designing governance frameworks for the complexities of the digital age (Bloom, 2024), but is under-researched in policy contexts (Oman 2024) and policy studies (Henman 2022), and this has social justice implications (Schwab and Davis, 2018). This panel will address the theoretical and empirical gaps through exploration of theoretical frameworks and case studies that clarify DPP’s role in shaping digital governance. It welcomes insights into best practices and challenges in DPP implementation and global perspectives, aiming to highlight DPP as a dynamic concern that is globally differentiated, but with a need for international cooperation on issues such as AI regulation, disinformation, cybersecurity, data sovereignty, and digital inclusion. References Bernholtz, L. et al. (2020) Integrated Advocacy: Paths Forward For Digtial Civil Society. Stanford Center on Philanthropy and Civil Society Digital Civil Society Lab, pp. 1–51. Available at: https://pacscenter.stanford.edu/publication/integrated-advocacy-paths-forward-for-digital-civil-society/ (Accessed: 16 December 2023). Birkland, T. (2015) An introduction to the policy process: theories, concepts, and models of Public policy making. Fourth. Routledge. Bloom, P. (2024) Envisioning a Just and Sustainable Digital Future: Expanding Policy Horizons for a Good Digital Society. Discussion Paper. The British Academy. Cairney, P. (2020) Understanding Public Policy Theories and Issues. Second. Bloomsbury Academic. Available at: https://www.google.co.uk/books/edition/Understanding_Public_Policy/9Zt1EAAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=defining+public+policy&pg=PR1&printsec=frontcover. Califano, B. and Becerra, M. (2024) ‘Policy Interventions to Address Digital Inequalities in Latin America in the Face of the Pandemic’, in Digital Inclusion: International Policy and Research. 1st edn. Palgrave MacMillan (Palgrave Studies in Digital Inequalities (PSDI), 2), pp. 39–61. Available at: https://link-springer-com.bris.idm.oclc.org/book/10.1007/978-3-031-28930-9#bibliographic-information. Dator, J., 2019. Governing the Futures: Dream or Survival Societies?, in: Jim Dator: A Noticer in Time : Selected Work, 1967-2018. p. 395. Fenger, M. and Bekkers, V. (2012) ‘Creating Connective Capacities in Public Governance: Challenges and Contributions’, pp. 3–16. Available at: https://doi.org/10.3233/978-1-60750-998-1-3. Henman, P.W.F. (2022) ‘Digital Social Policy: Past, Present, Future’, Journal of Social Policy, 51(3), pp. 535–550. doi:10.1017/S0047279422000162. Hogwood, B.W. (1995) ‘PUBLIC POLICY’, Public Administration, 73(1), pp. 59–73. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9299.1995.tb00817.x. Lasswell, H. (1970) ‘The Emerging Conception of the Policy Sciences’, Policy Sciences, 1, pp. 3–14. Milutinović, P. (2022) ‘Digital Public Policy and E-Governance as Factors of the Enhanced Socio-Economic Cohesion in the European Union’, Kultura polisa, 19(4), pp. 146–163. Available at: https://doi.org/10.51738/kpolisa2022.19.4r.146m. Oman, S. (2022) ‘Re-performance: a critical and reparative methodology for everyday expertise and data practice in policy knowledge’, International Review of Public Policy, 3(3), pp. 291-313. DOI:/10.4000/irpp.1833. Oman, S. (2024) ‘Digital culture - a review of evidence and experience, with recommendations for UK policy, practice and research’ London: HMGO Parsons, W. (1995) Public Policy: An Introduction to the Theory and Practice of Public Policy. Edward Elgar Publishing, Inc. Schwab, K. and Davis, N. (2018) Shaping the future of the Fourth Industrial Revolution: a guide to building a better world. First American edition. New York: Currency. Servon, L.J. (2002) ‘Bridging the Digital Divide: Technology, Community, and Public Policy’.
POLICY TOPICS
P09. Democratizing Artificial Intelligence: Putting People at the Centre
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Regulation has historically played catch-up with emerging technologies. Awareness is often raised post-facto and in a manner of dealing with risks and benefits emanating from the application of the technology to society at large (Jasanoff 1997, 2016; Law & McCall 2024). The promise of technology alleviating developmental problems often ends up exacerbating them, such as in the case of the Aadhar project in India – envisaged to uniquely identify beneficiaries of transfer services, it has instead resulted in exclusionary effects (Khera 2017). This case in point proves, technology widens the chasms of social, political, and economic inequities, especially for the marginalized, in the name of whom these technological interventions are justified in the first place (Benjamin 2019; Barocas et al., 2017; Moran-Thomas 2020). The story of development and deployment of Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies in various walks of life has arguably not been much different. As a technology largely accrued to the future and increasingly permeating the present, AI is often coupled with spectacular promises of both saving mankind as much as posing the risk of rendering it extinct (Future of Life Institute 2023, Stilgoe 2020). Hence, questions of understanding, regulating, and harnessing the technology becomes a critical policy issue. This panel will dive into various policy concerns surrounding AI with an aim to put human developmental objectives at the center of the conversation. Scientific relevance The current swathe of AI technologies has proven to be discriminating on grounds of race, class, gender, and even zip codes, a phenomenon popularly known as algorithmic bias (Akter et al., 2021, Stilgoe 2020, Future of Life Institute 2023). They have been proven to further systemic biases encoded in the historical data they’re trained on (Nazer et al., 2023, Gaonkar et al., 2020). Critically analyzing the design, development and deployment of AI technologies across the full stack of this technology, upstream and downstream, and opening this discussion for a wider discussion can help enrich the design of these technologies by making them more inclusive, equitable and accessible and thus enriching democratic values. Research questions 1. How are jurisdictions over the world dealing with evolving AI technology? 2. How can regulatory frameworks be designed to proactively manage the societal risks and benefits of AI-based technologies to ensure equitable outcomes? 3. How can historical cases of technological regulation be deployed to inform the development of effective policies for the governance of AI technologies? 4. How are narratives of hype around the technology influencing policymaking? 5. How are Governments and the private sector negotiating authority and legitimacy over regulatory aspects of AI technology? 6. How does geopolitics influence the governance of AI in India and other jurisdictions?
POLICY TOPICS
P10. The Political Economy of Global Digital Data Flows: Access, Opportunites and Constraints
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Digital data, unsurprisingly, has become a core concern of the rapidly growing digital economy. How is such digital data extracted, stored, processed, brokered, monetised and valued is an area of considerable and growing research interest? The governance of such big data is acquiring increasing global salience. Given the worldwide accumulation of data at a rapid pace, the large-scale extraction, processing, and monetization of such data by powerful entities, both corporations and governments, both for profit and control, is truly astonishing. There are enabling conditions that are shaping the contours of big data. Governments appear to be competing against each other to lure big data centers and processing companies. Intelligence gathered from aggregate digital data has now become a compelling part of the business model for digital platforms. Data controllers, data processors, and data brokers are getting organized around the process of collection, processing, and leveraging of data at a global level. The varying interests of such entities (controllers, processors, and brokers) in setting up practices, rules and norms, is shaping big data development. Data brokerage has emerged as a cornerstone of the modern data infrastructure, occupying a critical space between the roles of data fiduciaries and data processors. This intermediary role is indispensable as data brokerage facilitates data monetisation while simultaneously enabling its movement through complex ecosystems. Programmatic advertising, an example of efficient data utilization, highlights the monetization of user information in real-time bidding systems. The growing sophistication of data-brokering platforms reveals a stark tension: while their mechanisms fuel economic innovation and value extraction, they often circumvent users' informed consent, exposing them to privacy violations. Policy frameworks such as the GDPR (EU), the DPDPA (India), and PADFA (US) aim to govern these complex dynamics. However, these frameworks still struggle to address the evolving nature of data ecosystems. Another unfolding dynamic is within the Indian digital platforms such as Swiggy and Zomato. The digital data generated from the food and restaurant business is being used to create a ‘new digital supply chain’ beneficial to several participants in the business value chain. Such dominant Indian platforms leverage their digital supply chain and extract value from various stakeholders, including restaurant businesses, cloud kitchens, grocery suppliers, delivery partners, payment platforms/gateway, and consumers. Platform aggregators, based on the data acquired, optimise procurement, order fulfilment, pricing and delivery through algorithmic based decision making. These platforms collect real-time customer data that includes, search behaviour, past orders, location, time of purchase, price sensitivity, among others. In this data-oriented supply chain, there is an evident power asymmetry and platform aggregators clearly have an advantage over data they gather 24/7. They can rank restaurants based on pricing, quality of food, and the commissions paid. Those businesses that do not meet the platform demands for promotion and advertisement tend to get lower visibility. Such is the power of the overall business intelligence that is gleaned from the several stakeholders. The question to be asked how is the data extraction exercise (‘data flows’) allowing such digital platforms to leverage their data domination and increase their market share. Finally, the increasing importance of legally vetted (copyright consent) digital data flows has caught the AI industry rather unaware. With reports stating that AI models could run out of training data as early as 2026, the stakes are, unsurprisingly, rather high. Extracting data from individuals from their social media accounts did not prove to be legally constraining because the permission to extract was already baked into the individual’s attempt to sign onto the platforms consent form. However, such consent is a non-starter and legally not admissible when it comes to large swathes of already copyrighted content. Given this legal and now judicial hurdle (with several court cases the world over), with plaintiffs such as New York Times, ANI, Concord Music Group, Getty Images, having already taken different AI engines to court, the question to ask is how does the ‘legal’ use of large databases portend for AI training and for data flows. Through an extended literature review and case-based analysis, we intend to examine the emergence of such dominant players, both platform and other Big Tech goliaths, and to reflect upon the institutional arrangements that are contributing to big data flow and the growing concerns around data access, opportunities of growth and the constraints faced. How are these emerging entities jostling for power over continuous data flow and how is their relative influence shaping the very contours of the political economy of big data? References: · Evelyn Ruppert, Engin Isin, and Didier Bigo, Data politics, in Big Data and Society, July 3, 2017 · M Paterson, M McDonagh, ‘Data protection in an era of big data: The challenges posed by big personal data’ in Monash University Law Review, 2018. · Mark Coté, Paolo Gerbaudo and Jennifer Pybus, ‘Politics of Big Data’ in Digital Culture and Society, December 24, 2016. · Choi, J. P., Jeon, D. & Kim, B. (2019). Privacy and Personal Data Collection with Information Externalities. Journal of Public Economics, Vol 173, 113-124. · Faroukhi, A. Z., Alaoui, I. E., Gahi, Y. & Amine A. (2020). Big data monetization throughout Big Data Value Chain: a comprehensive review. Journal of Big Data, 7:3. · Pinchot, J., Chawdry, A. A. & Paullet, K. (2018). Data Privacy Issues in the Age of Data Brokerage: An Exploratory Literature Review, Issues in Information Systems, Volume 19, Issue 3, pp. 92-100 · Jenny Quang, ‘Does Training AI Violate Copyright Law?’, 36 Berkeley Tech. L. J. 1407, 2021. · K Hristov, ‘Artificial Intelligence and the Copyright Dilemma’, 57 IDEA 431, 2017.
POLICY TOPICS
P01. A Climate Policy Design Lab for Asia and the Southeast: Advancing Climate Solutions for Tomorrow
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Two paradoxical global environmental trends have emerged since the 1992 Rio Earth Summit: the proliferation of well-intended policies designed to address climate change, and the acceleration of global heating, carrying with it a myriad of climate-related challenges including water scarcity, food insecurity, and poverty alleviation. Understanding, and overcoming, this paradox is important, since reversing current global trends is required to avoid catastrophic social, economic, and ecological outcomes. The Institute for Environment and Sustainability (IES) at the National University of Singapore’s (NUS) Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy (LKYSPP) is proposing a panel on papers devoted to generating, and applying, “policy design capacity building” with which to generate insights for identifying policy mix innovations capable of produced durable and effective results. To do this, we are seeking papers that target “micro-level” policy levers capable of producing macro level policy change. The papers can be conceptual, theoretical, historical, as well as engaging in “anticipatory policy design” insights with which to foster multistakeholder policy learning processes. The panel will integrate the papers around identifying and building a climate policy design lab for Asia and Southeast Asia, which stands at a critical juncture moment in the potential to accelerate a range of decarbonization pathways on which government, the private sector, and NGOs are currently embarked. Details: One of the most important questions facing policy makers and sustainability scientists is how to build lasting and effective climate solutions. While there has been no shortage of climate related technological, market, and finance initiatives over the last 30 years, there is widespread frustration among governments, the private sector, and non-governmental organizations over the pace and scale of change. These questions are of particular importance in Asia and the Southeast, where governments, following the Paris Accord, have unleashed an array of initiatives designed to develop transition pathways towards a low-carbon economy and achieve their nationally determined contributions (NDCs). The purpose of this panel to shed light on the puzzle of the failure to accelerate climate outcomes alongside sustained policy attention on climate targets. This panel is devoted to deliberating over and uncovering- How to design durable, effective, ‘fit-for-purpose’ policies that can sustain political, governance and socio-economic challenges, to ensure effective decarbonisation pathways in Southeast Asia? By doing so, the panel aim to generate design insights for traveling climate related sustainability policy pathways.
POLICY TOPICS
P04. Public policies responses to climate risks and adaptation for the habitability of territories
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The panel calls for critical reflection and data driven social science responses within the overlapping political themes of climate risks and adaptation. While droughts and other severe natural phenomena are historically nothing new, the scale of global warming is evidenced by their recurrent intensity over recent years, during which record-breaking temperatures have consistently been experienced worldwide. In all scenarios for greenhouse gas emissions produced by human activities, the sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) estimated last year that the global surface temperature will increase by 1.5°C by the early 2030s (IPCC, 2023). Research has also shown that, even if individuals adopt eco-friendly practices, production of greenhouse gases would only fall by 30%1. This call for papers aims to understand how public policies, the practices and representations of stakeholders can be or not adjusted to ensure better governance (prevention, anticipation, reduction of environmental and socio-economic consequences). The objective is to develop and capitalise on knowledge about strategies for reducing climate vulnerabilities. The relevance of this virtual panel is also to shed light on the policies for dealing with this major risk to the habitability of territories by addressing the many issues they raise. Who is calling for the issue to be dealt with? How are environmental crisis thresholds and socioeconomic damage indicators determined and discussed? In which arenas does this take place and what kind of knowledge and metrics are used? How does it affect organisations, professional practices and individuals? To what extent are different options and responses compared? In particular, the call for papers seeks to critically explore the public policies metamorphosis taking place, the possibilities of coping and adaptation, and how societies confront evolving risks and growing insecurity. The proposals should provide a title and a brief abstract with information on the topic, format and contributors (200-300 words, plus names of proponents, affiliations and email addresses). 1 https://www.carbone4.com/files/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Doing-your-fair-share-for-the-climate-Carbone-4.pdf
POLICY TOPICS
P05. Public policies on energy. Public-Private and Intergovernmental Synergies to Promote Energy Efficiency
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
As the world grapples with the urgent need to transition towards a more sustainable energy systems, the role of effective public policies becomes paramount. This proposal seeks to explore innovative strategies to improve energy efficiency through the dynamic interplay of public-private partnerships and intergovernmental collaboration. Through the analysis of successful case studies and best practices, this panel aims to identify actionable policies that can drive energy savings, promote economic development, and mitigate environmental impacts. The objective of this panel is to address the challenges, changes, and perspectives concerning energy policies influenced both government and private sectors. It will focus on the role of public policies in improving energy efficiency and fostering synergies between public and private sectors, along with different governmental levels. In the context of growing concerns about climate change and the need for diverse energy sources, the discussion will focus on collaborative models that optimize energy resource use and promote sustainability. The objectives include the identification of best practices, evaluation of the current policies’ impact, and exploring new strategies to achieve the energy efficiency goals established by international organizations. Improving energy efficiency is essential for addressing global warming and attaining the Sustainable Development Goals outlined by United Nations. Additionally, it represents economic and social benefits. This involves the utilizing technologies that are more energy-efficient, increasing of renewable energy use, and the mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions (AbdulKarim et al., 2021). Enhancements in energy efficiency can be achieved across various sectors, such as residential, commercial, industrial, transportation, agriculture, and public services (Heshmati, A.,2021). According to research conducted on the overall factor energy efficiency of ten major energy- consuming countries by Xuan et al. (2023), the United States and Germany occupied the top position in energy efficiency, whereas China and India positioned at the bottom. Considering different sectors, it is evident that industrial sector has experienced a significant improvement in energy efficiency over the past two decades. In contrast, sectors such agriculture, mining and transport have not shown a remarkable change in this regard. The Energy Efficiency 2020 report (IEA, 2023) highlights a significant change in energy efficiency, driven by increased use of clean energy sources. Government policies promoting energy-saving programs are accelerating the development of efficient technologies, thus contributing to the decrease in reliance on fossil fuels within the energy sector. Policymakers should asses the effectiveness of diverse policy tools to promote the adoption of green technologies. Economic incentives as well as direct regulations can both facilitate the adoption of energy-saving technologies (Jaffe & Stavins, 1994; Caillé, Castro, Bundgaard-Jensen, Fall & Doucet, 2008). An assessment of energy efficiency policies is essential to address elevated oil prices, industrial competitiveness, climate change, and energy security in both the short and long term. Cooperation and information exchange are vital for the successful implementation of efficient measures and advising decision-makers on selection of appropriate strategies. The panel will focus on two main questions: 1. How can the enhancement of energy efficiency can be facilitated through collaboration among the public, private, and intergovernmental sectors? 2. How can different government levels cooperate to implement effective energy efficiency policies? Hypothesis to Explore Regulatory Framework: A well-defined regulatory framework boosts private sector investment in energy efficiency, thereby resulting in improved sustainability outcomes. Multilateral Collaboration: Collaborative efforts among governments create standards and best practices, thereby enhancing the adoption of energy-efficient technologies. Innovation and Investment: Public-private partnerships encourage innovation, leading to accessible energy solutions that narrow the disparity between developed and developing nations. Education and Awareness: Collaborative initiatives between of governments and businesses raise public awareness regarding energy efficiency, thus stimulating interest and support policies that promote efficiency. In conclusion, this panel function as an important forum for the discussion of how cross-sector collaborations can enhance a sustainable energy future, providing innovative insights and public policies that benefit to society. References AbdulKarim, A., Tawfik, M., Hasan, A. and El-Awady. Review of improving energy efficiency technologies. Journal of Environmental Sciences. Volume 50. Pages 239-286. ISSN 2636-3178 International Energy Agency [IEA]. Energy Efficiency 2023. Available in: https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/dfd9134f-12eb-4045-9789-9d6ab8d9fbf4/EnergyEfficiency2023.pdf Caillé, A., Al-Moneef, M., de Castro, F. B., Bundgaard-Jensen, A., Fall, A., de Medeiros, N. F., ... & Doucet, G. (2008). Energy efficiency policies around the world: Review and evaluation. World Energ Counc, 2008, 9-36. Heshmati, A. Energy use Efficiency. Energies. 2021. https://doi.org/10.3390/books978-3-0365- 0355-4 Available in: https://mdpi-res.com/bookfiles/book/3585/Energy_Use_Efficiency.pdf?v=1715648494 Jaffe, A. B., & Stavins, R. N. (1994). Energy-Efficiency Investments and Public Policy. The Energy Journal, 15(2), 43-65. https://doi.org/10.5547/ISSN0195-6574-EJ-Vol15-No2-3 United Nations [UN]. Sustainable Development Goals. https://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/ Wang, X., Lu, Y., Chen, Ch., Yi, X. and Ciu, H. Total factor energy efficiency of ten major global energy-consuming countries. Journal of Environmental Sciences. 2023. Volume 137. Pages 41-52. ISSN 1001-0742. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jes.2023.02.031
POLICY TOPICS
P06. Measuring and Framing Sustainable Development: Data and Indicators for the Sustainable Development Goals
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Ever since their inception, the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) have gone beyond a simple to-do list for action-oriented development policies. They have become a global frame for a desirable development trajectory that puts a human-centred perspective at the heart of policy interventions, acknowledges human dependence on nature and highlights the interrelation of economic activities, planetary boundaries and equity among people and peoples around the world. For the delivery on the SDGs, data and indicators have become a global reference frame that defines development priorities. Their impact on policy design defines sustainable development as much as their use in progress assessment impacts on the concrete implementation of the SDGs. In data-driven policy-making for the SDGs, they are hence key tools to quantify, qualify and compare complex processes, structures and performances to define meaning and frame political action for the SDGs. As every contemporary policy design for the SDGs starts and ends with data, the influence of data in SDG-related policy-making has substantially grown over the past decade. The overarching objective of the panel is therefore to understand the use and power of data and indicators for the SDGs. It will focus on how using and understanding statistics, working with data, analysing and arguing through data have become essential challenges for the SDGs. Moreover, the ecosystem of data sources within and beyond the UN as well as the ways of using them in SDG-related policy-making are of vital interest for the panel as both have grown significantly and became easily confusing for any non-statistician engaged in public policy. Against this backdrop, the following research questions are at the centre of the panel’s analytical interest and serve as guiding questions for the paper proposals: · What role do data and indicators play in the delivery of the SDG? · How do data and indicators impact on the delivery of the SDG? · How can the quality of data for the SDG be assessed and operationalised? · What lessons can be drawn for the production of data and indicators for the SDG? · What is the role of data ethics and literacy in implementation of SDG? The scientific relevance of the panel lies in its focus on the methods, politics, and ethics of measuring progress towards the SDG at the moment of the 2025 SDG Comprehensive Review, which offers a window of opportunity for science advice for policy-making to improve the delivery on the SDGs. The panel zooms into data and indicators as central instruments of SDG-related evidence-informed policy-making within the global development agenda. It focuses on the central role of data in policy-making and discusses pertinent questions of data ethics, literacy, and skills for measuring SDG progress. Finally, it offers a forum to discuss and understand the relevance, impact and presence of data and indicators for the delivery of the SDG. The panel is informed by the forthcoming ‘Elgar Companion on data and indicators for the Sustainable Development Goals’ edited by G. Umbach and I. Tkalec with the assistance of M. Tiwari.
POLICY TOPICS
P07. Policy analysis for shifting development pathways towards climate change mitigation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
=Development pathways, or the way in which countries or regions develop, drive not only outcomes such as economic growth and employment, but also outcomes related to sustainability and climate change. The IPCC Working Group III Sixth Assessment Report (AR6) argues that strengthening the capability of societies’ to mitigate emissions in an accelerated manner, as well as, achieving sustainable development would require the shifting of development pathways towards sustainability (SDPS). This argument take sharp significance in the case of low-income or middle-come countries, where developmental aspirations play the more important role in driving policy decisions relative to sustainability considerations. Existing literature demonstrates that multiple channels – such as the nature of economic activity or the economic structure, spatial patterns of development, degree of inequality, and population growth – have important direct and indirect implications for GHG emissions. Furthermore, literature also suggests that integrating mitigation considerations require non-marginal shifts in countries’ developmental pathways; shifts which address interlinkages across sectors, classes, and the economy. However, there is limited empirical research on how policy levers and governance strategies can be used to exploit synergies between developmental aspects such as employment, education, mobility, housing and mitigation or sustainability outcomes in different contexts. Finally, analytical approaches also need improvements. Models often only account for development as an exogenous input, which does not enable the exploration of interlinkages between development and sustainability considerations; when developmental factors are considered endogenously, they are usually done in a limited manner. Models and scenarios often also overlook important social scientific considerations such distributional consequences, power differentials, and aspirations of affected stakeholders, at the risk of recommending strategies which may reproduce existing injustices. There is also a need to better incorporate issues related to uncertainty, innovation, inertia and irreversibility within broad development contexts. Accordingly, some of the key research questions that this panel seeks to address are the following. What enabling conditions related to governance make shifting development pathways possible? What lessons, applicable in other contexts, can be extracted from successful examples of SDPS? Which enablers are context-specific, and which are more broadly applicable? What analytical approaches can be used to analyse shifting of development pathways towards sustainability and mitigation through policy levers?
POLICY TOPICS
P08. Access to clean energies in developping countries by the year 2030 : How to increase access by the year 2030 and beyond in the context of climate change?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Access to clean and affordable energy is a necessity in developing countries because energy consumption is the main cause of climate change. Even though developing countries (DCs) are not historically responsible for anthropogenic greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions that have led to climate change, legal instruments, particularly the Paris Agreement on climate change, recognize that the share of GHG emissions from DCs will increase to allow them to develop. According to the United Nations, at the current pace, around 660 million people will still not have access to electricity and nearly 2 billion people will still depend on polluting fuels and technologies for cooking by 2030. The issue of access to clean energy has sparked numerous research efforts. They focused on the opportunities that such access could provide in terms of employment (Petrie, 2013), the various plans aimed at enabling access to clean energy on the African continent (Boa, 2016), the issue of their governance on a global scale (Luomi, 2020), and the main challenges faced by both old and new actors in the energy transition (Henderson et al., 2021). Overall, all these questions do not address, or only partially address, the issue of how to increase access to electricity and clean fuels and technologies for the greatest number by 2030.The importance of this issue is paramount in the context of the effective implementation of SDG 7, which aims to ensure access to clean and affordable energy for all by this deadline. The purpose of this panel is to highlight the different approaches that can contribute to the achievement of SDG 7.
POLICY TOPICS
P09. Regional cooperation for the energy transition: steps towards renewable-based regional energy planning
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Cross-border electricity trade has become a key enabler to facilitate the integration of renewables in large shares, and therefore, a milestone to achieve the energy transition. Countries across the globe are looking at connecting their electricity grids and establishing power trade agreements to support achieving their goals of moving towards sustainable energy systems. Indeed, cross border electricity trade and the benefits of interconnections between large electrical systems are generally found across all regions and continents, including also some global initiatives. Some examples are Northern Europe, United States, Western and Southern Africa, and South Asia (Agostini et al., 2019). Nonetheless, many regions are encountering difficulties in moving beyond limited exchanges based on dedicated contracts. This represents an important bottleneck towards the goal of sustainable energy planning, as this limits the trade of electricity to large scale (in case mega-) projects that can justify the extraordinary investments by themselves. However, these projects are usually associated with higher environmental and social costs. This can include large scale dams flooding extensive inhabited areas or hydrogen generation projects in areas with limited water resources, among many others. This has led to big controversies around cross border electricity projects that, eventually, could cause strong public opposition to these projects leading to a delay on the sustainable energy transition. Regional (supra or international) energy planning approaches are considered a suitable alternative to facilitate better coordination, harmonization, and integration of national electricity systems. As such, initiatives such as regional coordination committees, regional regulatory forums, regional capacity building programs are being proposed and experiences in many countries. However, these experiences and the knowledge derived from them remains scattered, with little capacity for generalization. This panel aims to set a step towards the development of theories and frameworks for the analysis of renewable based regional energy planning. · Institutional options to facilitate regional planning, operation, and/or regulation · Financial mechanisms for supranational projects (generation and transmission) · Innovative technological options for regionally oriented renewables (e.g. offshore energy islands) · Empirical analyses on cooperation · Sociotechnical imaginaries · Geopolitical and energy security drivers for cooperation · Energy justice and just transition implications of regional energy initiatives (both positive and negative) References Agostini, C. A., Guzmán, A. M., Nasirov, S., & Silva, C. (2019). A surplus based framework for cross-border electricity trade in South America. Energy Policy, 128, 673-684. Delina, L. L. (2021). Promises and pitfalls of China-Southeast Asia energy connectivity. Energy Strategy Reviews, 33, 100574. Thaler, P., & Hofmann, B. (2022). The impossible energy trinity: Energy security, sustainability, and sovereignty in cross-border electricity systems. Political Geography, 94, 102579. Andrews-Speed, P. (2016). Applying institutional theory to the low-carbon energy transition. Energy Research & Social Science, 13, 216-225. Hancock, Kathleen J., Stefano Palestini, and Kacper Szulecki, 'The Politics of Energy Regionalism', in Kathleen J. Hancock, and Juliann Emmons Allison (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Energy Politics (2021; online edn, Oxford Academic, 7 Nov. 2018), https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780190861360.013.5, Geels, F. W. (2004). From sectoral systems of innovation to socio-technical systems: Insights about dynamics and change from sociology and institutional theory. Research policy, 33(6-7), 897-920. Kucharski, J. B., & Unesaki, H. (2018). An institutional analysis of the Japanese energy transition. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions, 29, 126-143. Puka, L., & Szulecki, K. (2014). The politics and economics of cross-border electricity infrastructure: A framework for analysis. Energy Research & Social Science, 4, 124-134.
POLICY TOPICS
P10. ACHIEVING JUST TRANSITION IN ASIA PACIFIC - POLICY DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The process of a Just Transition – achieving sustainability transitions in a way that is “just" to the workers and communities involved, ensuring no one is left behind – is rapidly becoming a guiding concept for the transformation that is occurring in many sectors across economies including in energy, industry and natural resource management. A Just Transition ensures that while working towards a more ecologically sound economy, we also plan for positive outcomes for those communities and people negatively affected by our global efforts to decarbonise. The unequal distribution of positive and negative effects means that just transition ‘hotspots’ will exist, and that the policy mix to address a just transition will need to be specific to these contexts (ASEAN, 2021). This process will be policy-driven and across multiple levels to ensure: · business and sectors are encouraged to become more sustainable · that we have sufficient skills development and an adequate workforce to deliver the transition · that women’s and other marginalised groups unequal participation in labour markets and skills acquisition is addressed · that social protection is available to workers and communities that are negatively affected by transition The policy mix for promoting just transition, is broad, encompassing many policy fields including development and employment policy, energy policy, industry policy, training and skills development, as well as sectoral level policies and policies at different jurisdictional levels. This means that policy coherence and coordination are also critical issues. The objective of the special session is to contribute to a better understanding of the context and drivers of transition and the factors of ‘just’ transition in the Asia Pacific region. With many of the countries in the region also pursuing sustainable development agendas to achieve quality employment (decent work), adequate social protection systems and poverty reduction alongside decarbonisation goals. At the same time the Asia-Pacific region – particularly low and middle incomes countries and Small Island Developing States are also managing increasing climate impacts, with the region one of the most climate vulnerable areas in the world. Just transition planning is a new skill set for policy makers (ASEAN 2021). Just transition planning and implementation are emerging policy issues in many countries in Asia-Pacific region. New policy models and combinations of policy mechanisms will be required. This Panel aims to identify what policy elements are needed and what is already in place to support just transition and how just transition can be operationalised to address social development goals and remedy longstanding inequalities in labour markets and livelihoods.
POLICY TOPICS
P11. Just energy transitions in Southeast Asia: How to put “justice” into policy- and regulatory frameworks?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Even though the “just” element of energy transition research and practice has increased in popularity recently, definition of what constitutes a just transition are still being debated (Heffron et al. 2024). Indeed, stakeholders in the Southeast Asian region often have diverging visions about how to implement energy transitions (Bößner, Fauzi, and Rimal 2023) and sometimes lack a good understanding about the “just” element of energy transitions (IESR 2024). Moreover, it is unclear how elements of justice and equity are reflected in current ASEAN energy policy and regulatory frameworks. This panel’s objective is to bring clarity to the conceptual ambiguity of just energy transition and investigate how elements of justice and equity are reflected (or not) in current ASEAN energy policies. As a second objective, this panel will discuss how energy transition policies and regulatory frameworks can be made more robust and effective by integrating justice and equity considerations, with a view to identifying policy provisions that would be needed to facilitate a truly just energy transition. In doing so, the panel will assemble a variety of stakeholders including the private sector in order to discuss both policy needs but also showcase local, bottom-up solutions for just energy transitions. The research questions are therefore as follows 1) What are the necessary ‘just’ elements of energy transitions in the Southeast Asian region? 2) Do current policies adequately reflect those elements of justice and equity in energy transition pathways? If not, what is missing? 3) And if not, how can elements of justice be mainstreamed into regional policy- and regulatory frameworks to facilitate a truly just energy transition? 4) What kind of success stories can we tell, of localized, bottom-up just energy solutions? The fossil fuel-based energy sector is by far the largest emitter of greenhouse gases (GHG) and arguably the most important sector to decarbonize in order to meet the objectives enshrined in international law such as the Paris Agreement. However, decarbonizing the energy sector is only possible if a large coalition of stakeholders, including the private sector and civic society organizations (CSOs),is brought on board due to the decentralized nature of low-carbon alternatives. This can only be done with just and equitable approaches to energy transitions but understanding those approaches is still in its infancy. Therefore, bringing conceptual clarity to the issue of just energy transitions and designing policy and regulatory frameworks that support such a just and equitable approach is of utmost importance thus making this panel highly relevant not only from a scientific perspective but also from an implementation perspective.
POLICY TOPICS
P13. Food Security and Global South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Food security in the Global South remains a critical concern, as these regions are home to the majority of the world’s undernourished population. The Global South, encompassing Africa, Latin America, and parts of Asia, faces a myriad of challenges, including climate change, inadequate agricultural policies, economic inequality, and geopolitical disruptions. Climate change and environmental degradation directly impact agricultural productivity, exacerbating food insecurity by affecting crop yields and livestock health (Sultan & Gaetani, 2016). In addition, socio-economic inequalities, such as income disparity and gender inequity, limit access to nutritious food, deepening hunger and malnutrition in vulnerable communities (Von Braun & Gatzweiler, 2014). The role of Global South is crucial in achieving the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goal 2: Zero Hunger, contributing to the global fight against poverty and hunger. This call seeks to explore critical issues affecting food security across the Global South, focusing on the complex interactions of resource distribution, agricultural policies, climate change, and socio-economic inequalities. 1. General Objectives: The conference aims to bring together researchers, policymakers, and practitioners to discuss the challenges and opportunities surrounding food security in the Global South. The objective is to generate actionable insights into strengthening food systems in the region to achieve sustainable development and alleviate hunger. Specific Objectives: - Emphasize the analysis of policy frameworks and their effectiveness in addressing food security in Global South. - Discuss how regional policies, governance structures, and institutional mechanisms contribute to or hinder food accessibility. - To assess the current state of food security policies in various regions of the Global South. - To analyze the role of governance, policies, and international trade in enhancing food security in Global South. - To identify socio-economic barriers that exacerbate food insecurity in vulnerable populations. - To propose sustainable strategies for improving agricultural productivity and food distribution systems. 2. Key Research Questions: The submissions should focus on one or more of the following research questions: - What are the most effective policy frameworks currently in place in the Global South for ensuring food security, and what lessons can be learned from their successes and limitations? - How do different policy approaches between countries in the Global South compare in terms of outcomes for food security? - What are the challenges and barriers to implementing effective food security policies in regions with diverse socio-political landscapes? - What are the main factors contributing to food insecurity in the Global South, and how do these factors differ across regions? - How do climate change and environmental degradation affect food production, availability, and accessibility in the Global South? - How do socio-economic inequalities, such as income disparity and gender inequity, influence food security? 3. Scientific Relevance: This call is motivated by the urgent need to address the global challenge of food insecurity. A specific focus on the Global South is vital because these regions host the majority of the world’s undernourished population. Understanding the dynamics of food security in these countries is essential to achieving the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goal 2: Zero Hunger. Additionally, this theme offers the opportunity to delve into the broader issues of climate change, governance, and socio-economic inequalities and their impact on food systems. The panel aims to contribute to the scientific literature by offering an interdisciplinary platform that integrates insights from economics, environmental science, political science, and social studies. The findings could help inform the policy agendas of international organizations and governments seeking to enhance food security and promote sustainable development in the Global South.
POLICY TOPICS
P14. Understanding Climate Obstruction in Southeast Asia
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Southeast Asia is critical to efforts to combat climate change. Yet most countries in the region, including Indonesia, the Philippines, and Thailand, have rising populations, rising emissions, and rising energy demand, not to mention a continued reliance on coal. In this context climate change action remains a pressing challenge in the region, but efforts to limit greenhouse gas emissions continue to confront political failure. One reason for poor policy outcomes is because of the limited understanding of the oppositional groups determined to protect the fossil fuel dependent status quo. While there is a growing body of literature across political science, sociology, public policy, and legal studies, among other fields, on climate obstruction in North America and Europe, much less is known about climate obstruction in other regions of the world. This panel aims to explore climate obstruction in Southeast Asia. Climate obstruction refers to intentional actions and efforts to slow or block policies on climate change that are commensurate with the current scientific consensus of what is necessary to avoid dangerous anthropogenic interference with the climate system. The shape and form of such efforts vary depending on whether it occurs in electoral democracies or autocracies, pluralist or corporatist interest group systems, economies dominated by extractive industries or service industries, among other factors. This panel seeks to encourage empirical and theoretical research papers on the actors, political activities, and institutions that shape climate obstruction in Southeast Asia. Questions might include: · What actors are obstructing climate action, such as government agencies, state-owned enterprises, corporations, industry trade associations, and think tanks? · What types of resources do these actors have at their disposal, including financial resources? · What strategies and tactics are these actors using, such as lobbying, political donations, coalition building, public relations, or legal challenges? · How do political, economic and social institutions shape climate obstruction in the region? · And how are other actors, including social movements, seeking to counter climate obstruction?
POLICY TOPICS
P17. Towards Just and Sustainable Land Allocation for Displaced Farmers: Climate Change Adaptation in Southeast Asia
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Panel Overview:Climate change poses a severe threat to Southeast Asia’s agricultural sector, with farmers in facing increasing displacement due to extreme weather events like floods and droughts. These changes not only jeopardize agricultural productivity but also threaten the livelihoods of millions of small-scale farmers. As the backbone of rural economies, the displacement of these communities has far-reaching consequences, both economically and socially. Current adaptation efforts, such as Climate-Smart Agriculture (CSA) in Thailand and Ecosystem-based Adaptation in Cambodia, are steps in the right direction, but the harsh reality remains: many farmers are forced to abandon unviable lands. This panel seeks to address the urgent need for a just and sustainable framework for land allocation for displaced farmers, which goes beyond humanitarian aid and focuses on long-term solutions to support their livelihoods. The discussion will focus on policy innovation and strategies for ensuring climate-resilient agricultural systems through equitable land distribution. Key issues such as environmental suitability, market access, and social integration will be explored, alongside how to address land rights conflicts and incorporate the needs of marginalized groups such as women, children, ethnic minorities, and disabled individuals. General Objectives:The panel aims to explore how land allocation can serve as a vital strategy for fostering resilience among climate-displaced farmers. Specifically, it will: Investigate the key elements of a just and sustainable land allocation framework.Propose inclusive policies to address the needs of vulnerable groups within displaced farming communities.Discuss the alignment of land allocation with broader climate adaptation strategies and development plans.Provide policy recommendations that promote the long-term sustainability and self-sufficiency of resettled farming communities.Key Research Questions: What are the essential components of a land allocation framework that ensures justice and sustainability for displaced farmers?How can land allocation policies be inclusive and address the needs of vulnerable groups such as women, children, the elderly, and ethnic minorities?How can land allocation strategies align with national and regional climate adaptation and development plans, while addressing conflicts over land rights?What lessons can be drawn from current adaptation efforts in Southeast Asia for developing policies that promote resilient, climate-smart agricultural communities?Scientific Relevance:This panel contributes to the ongoing discourse on climate adaptation by providing a comprehensive examination of land allocation as a strategy for climate-displaced farmers. It addresses the intersection of land rights, environmental sustainability, and social justice, with a focus on vulnerable populations. As Southeast Asia is a key agricultural region, the discussions in this panel will not only provide context-specific insights but also offer lessons applicable to other regions facing similar climate challenges. The panel aims to fill critical knowledge gaps by advancing innovative policy approaches that integrate climate resilience, agricultural sustainability, and social equity, particularly for marginalized communities.
POLICY TOPICS
P18. Environmental Policy and Polarisation: Pathways, Futures and Strategies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Environmental policies have sparked a wide range of polarising debates, from critical scepticism of capitalism and growth to depoliticised techno-optimism, green growth advocacy, and calls for moderate regulatory reform (Bäckstrand & Lövbrand 2006; Leipold et al. 2023). These discussions are further complicated by the need for global cooperation among diverse actor groups with varying perspectives on sustainability and environmental justice (Lenzi et al. 2023; Luo et al. 2021). At the local level, polarising issues include public outcry over wind turbines or solar farms, as well as opposition to restrictions on consumer choices, such as plastic straws. In this context, our panel focuses on the politics of sustainability transformations across time and scale, and how they shape imaginaries of future opportunities and challenges for environmental cooperation and reconciliation. We are particularly interested in longitudinal and cross-case empirical analyses, as well as theoretical and methodological work that provide guidance and orientation for such work. With this perspective, the guiding questions for this panel include, but are not limited to: ● (How) Do stakeholders — policy-makers, industry representatives, civil society or academics — imagine transformational pathways toward resource sustainability in policy fields such as energy, waste, chemicals, or circular economy? ● How do such imaginaries influence policy interventions today? ● How can long-term (historical) policy analysis help us assess strategies and pathways for approaching environmental challenges amidst polarisation? ● What can such analyses tell us about myriad dimensions of environmental justice? ● (How) Can short-term environmental policies address current challenges while connecting to future societal imaginaries, visions, and transformations? Within this panel, we invite both empirical studies and theoretical contributions, with disciplinary as well as interdisciplinary work welcome. References: Bäckstrand, K., & Lövbrand, E. (2006). Planting trees to mitigate climate change: Contested discourses of ecological modernization, green governmentality and civic environmentalism. Global Environmental Politics, 6(1), 50-75. Leipold, S., Petit-Boix, A., Luo, A., … Xue, B. (2023). Lessons, narratives, and research directions for a sustainable circular economy. Journal of Industrial Ecology, 27, 6–18. Lenzi, D., Balvanera, P., Arias-Arévalo, P., ... Pascual, U. (2023). Justice, sustainability, and the diverse values of nature: why they matter for biodiversity conservation. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 64, 101353. Luo, A., Mehwish, Z., Liu, J., … Leipold, S. (2021). Why common interests and collective action are not enough for environmental cooperation – Lessons from the China-EU cooperation discourse on circular economy. Global Environmental Change, 71, 102389.
POLICY TOPICS
P19. Just and Justice guided energy transitions – beyond rhetoric and single cases
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
In recent times there has been an outstanding growth in the academic and practical interest on “Just Transition” and “Energy Justice”. Both reflect on the idea that the transition to sustainable energy systems is not only a technological change (towards decarbonization) but, rather, a socio-technological system, one in which the broader social impacts need to be considered. And aim to incorporate moral concerns of not leaving anyone behind and creating new opportunities, as well as practical issues such as avoiding unfair negative impacts on those more vulnerable and possible social backlash against this change. Governments and international organizations across the globe have embraced both concepts, and, as a result, it is relatively common to be these associated to an increasing number of energy policies, such as the Just Transition Energy Partnerships, to name a few. However, the concepts of just and justice are, at times, very open and include cultural aspects, making them challenging to (i) operationalize beyond rhetoric and (ii) generalize beyond specific sectors or geographies. Furthermore, as with any sociotechnical change, the energy transition brings winners and losers, within local and national contexts but also internationally. Also, to ensure a Just or Justice based energy transition may require a slower pace, which might be incompatible with the emergency of Climate and Sustainable Development targets. What lead to (iii) conflicts between just, justice, and other strategic priorities. To address these, researchers across disciplines and geographies are conducting theoretical and empirical numerous studies to guide energy transition policy makers in this endeavor. For example, several frameworks have been proposed in the literature. This session aims to provide a platform for researchers to discuss these issues and propose a way forward. Specific topics of interest include · Identification and measurement of synergies and trade-offs across the multiple dimensions and issues of Just and Justice Energy Transition frameworks · Innovative approached to incorporate Just and Justice elements into the energy policy making and planning processes, examining the roles of different stakeholders (government, private sector, civil society) in co-creating these policies. · Merits and perils of Just Transition and Energy Justice to achieve the Climate Goals and the Sustainable Development Goals (on time) · Integrating Gender Equality, Disability and Social Inclusion (GEDSI) in Energy policy design and implementation, examining intersectionality—exploring how different social categories overlap and intersect in the energy transition context. · Policy instruments to implement Just Transition and Energy Justice, incorporating multi-level governance, i.e., the role/authorities of each different levels of governments in designing and implementing each policy instrument · Developing new framework to measure and evaluate Just Transition and Energy Justice policy · Drawback or concern of having pursue Just Transition and Energy Justice i.e. discussing on potential conflicts between rapid transitions and justice goals could spark a more nuanced debate. Other beyond these will be also considered, in particular when helping to answer the specific question
POLICY TOPICS
P20. Nature Policies and Protected Areas: regulatory, governance and evidence perspectives
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Biodiversity persistence and ecological quality are critical for the achievement of many Sustainable Development Goals. They are a central focus to SGD 14 and 15, while contributing to SDG 13. The challenge to implement the SGDs, and wider concerns with climate change, biodiversity loss, the deterioration of critical ecosystem services and environmental public health, have led to a better appreciation of the potential roles of Protected Areas (PAs) as tools for nature policies and instruments for sustainable development (Aubertin and Rodary 2011, Ritzel et al. 2023). National and transnational regulatory reform processes have been initiated in some jurisdictions, to enhance the ecological representativeness of PA networks and transform them in integrated and functional ecological and socio-ecological systems (Cabin 2013, CBD Secretariate 2009). The functional ecological representativeness principle of policy-making is incorporated in numerous decisions, implementing the 1992 UN Convention on Biological Diversity (Soutullo and Gudynas 2006). E.g., the 2004 Program of Work on Protected Areas requires signatory states to develop “comprehensive, effectively managed and ecologically representative national and regional systems of protected ideas” (CBD Secretariate 2004). The emphasis has shifted from the static and fragmented representation of culturally-valued landscapes and habitats (as ‘open-air-museum items’; Dinica 2022), to ecological functionality attributes and holistic indicators of ecosystem health, sustainable critical ecosystem services, and biotic persistence in the context of climate change (Mingarro and Lobo 2021, Pörtner et al. 2021, Thackway and Cresswell 1997). Public policy and public administration perspectives to the study of PAs are essential, because PAs are spaces where human access is regulated by special rules. They may be grounded in legal frameworks and/or in strategies, policies or management plans for biodiversity/conservation/nature protection. The legal and policy frameworks may be generic or PA-specific; they are often multi-level, extensive, complex and - due to variable ages - conflicting and incoherent. Currently, conceptual understandings and practitioner-focused policy insights remain severely under-developed, with respect to the fitness-for-purpose of PA designations and regulations to contribute to SDGs and to support the PAs' transition towards ecologically functional systems; likewise for the challenge to better integrate policy programs across related policy domains: nature policy programs, climate change mitigation and adaptation policies; land use, regional development and sustainable agricultural policies; and policies for urban parks or sustainable tourism. The number of studies adopting policy perspectives remains limited (e.g. Bastmeijer 2016, Capotorti et al. 2012, Ferraro and Hanauer 2015, Kegamba et al. 2024, Lima and Ranieri 2018, Selman 2009). In the context of limited attention by public policy scholars, significant contributions have been made by natural scientists and geographers (e.g. Araújo et al. 2007, Çoruhlu and Çelik 2022, Dimitrakopoulos et al. 2004, Evans 2012, Ferraro 2013, Fuller et al 2010, Iojă et al. 2010, Nichiforel et al. 2021, Niedziałkowski et al. 2014, Svancara et al. 2005, Wang et al. 2021). In so far as the regulation of human activities and infrastructures/facilities within PAs is concerned, scholars have occasionally researched the effectiveness of tourism regulations, usually in specific PAs or countries (Dinica 2017, Estima et al. 2014, Goodwin 2002, Thede et al. 2014). However, a wider range of human access options and socio-economic activities are often permitted, depending on the PA designation type (e.g. Nature/Scientific/Recreation Reserves, Nature Parks, National Parks; see Chape et al. 2008, Cumming et al. 2015). This panel welcomes conceptual, methodological and empirical contributions, adopting public policy or interdisciplinary perspectives that advance scholarship on the following themes: 1) the interface between science and policies on nature protection generally, and on Protected Areas, specifically 2) the ecological effectiveness of nature policies, PA designations and regulations 3) the governance of Protected Areas Selected References Aubertin, C., Rodary E. (Ed). (2011). Protected Areas, Sustainable Land? Ashgate Publishing Araújo, M.B., Lobo J.M., Moreno J.C. (2007). The effectiveness of Iberian protected areas in conserving terrestrial biodiversity. Conservation Biology 21(6):1423-32 Bastmeijer, K. (2016). Ecological restoration in international biodiversity law: a promising strategy to address our failure to prevent? In M Bowman, P Davies, E Goodwin (Eds), Research Handbook on Biodiversity and Law. Edward Elgar Publishing. Capotorti, G., et al. (2012). Do National Parks play an active role in conserving the natural capital of Italy? Plant Biosystems - An International Journal Dealing with All Aspects of Plant Biology, 146(2):258–265. CBD Secretariate. (2019). Post-2020 Global Biodiversity Framework. Discussion Paper. Chape, S, Spalding M, Jenkins M. (2008). The world's protected areas: status, values and prospects in the 21st century. University of California Press Coruhlu, Y.E., Çelik, M.Ö. (2022). Protected area geographical management model from design to implementation for specially protected environment area, Land Use Policy, 122:106357 Dimitrakopoulos, P.G., Memtsas D, Troumbis A.Y. (2004). Questioning the effectiveness of the Natura 2000 species areas for conservation strategy: the case of Crete. Global Ecology and Biogeography 13: 199–207. Dinica, V. (2022). Protected Area Regulation and Tourism: Science-Informed Ecological Transitions. Edward Elgar Publishing. Dinica V. (2017). Tourism concessions in National Parks: neo-liberal governance experiments for a Conservation Economy in New Zealand. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 25(12):1811-1829 Evans, D. (2012). Building the European Union’s Natura 2000 network. Nature Conservation 1:11-26. Ferraro P.J., Hanauer M.M. (2015). Through what mechanisms do protected areas affect environmental and social outcomes? Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B 370:20140267. Kegamba, J.J., et al. (2024). The influence of conservation policies and legislations on communities in Tanzania. Biodiversity Conservation 33:3147–3170. Lima, E.A.C.F., Ranieri V.L.M. (2018). Land use planning around protected areas: Case studies in four state parks in the Atlantic forest region of southeastern Brazil, Land Use Policy: 453-458 Mingarro, M., Lobo, J.M. (2021). Connecting protected areas in the Iberian peninsula to facilitate climate change tracking. Environmental Conservation 48: 182–191 Nichiforel, N., et al. (2021). Forest ecosystem services in Romania: Orchestrating regulatory and voluntary planning documents, Ecosystem Services 49:101276, Niedziałkowski, K., Blicharska, M., Mikusiński, G., Jędrzejewska, B. (2014). Why is it difficult to enlarge a protected area? Ecosystem services perspective on the conflict around the extension of the Białowieża National Park in Poland, Land Use Policy 38:314-329 Pörtner, HO, Scholes RJ, Agard J, Archer E, Arneth et. al. (2021). Scientific Outcome of the IPBES-IPCC co-sponsored workshop report on biodiversity and climate change. IPBES Secretariat, Bonn, Germany Ritzel, C. et al. (2023). Swiss Parks of National Importance as model regions of sustainable development – An economic success story for farmers?, Land Use Policy 124:106441 Soutullo, A., Gudynas E. (2006). How effective is the MERCOSUR's network of protected areas in representing South America's ecoregions? Oryx 40:112–116 Svancara, L.K., et al. (2005). Political policy driven versus evidence-based conservation: a review of political targets and biological needs. Bioscience 55:989–995 Thackway, R, Cresswell ID. (1997). A Bioregional Framework for Planning the National System of Protected Areas in Australia. Natural Areas Journal, 17(3):241-247 Thede, AK, Haider W, Rutherford M. (2014). Zoning in national parks: are Canadian zoning practices outdated? Journal of Sustainable Tourism. 22(4):626-645 Wang, Y., et al. (2021). Efficacy and management challenges of the zoning designations of China's national parks, Biological Conservation 254:108962
POLICY TOPICS
P21. Integrating Public Policy and Energy Resilience: Tackling Climate Change Amid Global Turbulence
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel aims to convene leading experts in public policy and energy studies to explore the complex interplay between climate change mitigation, energy resilience, and global geopolitical shifts. We will critically examine the need for a more integrated approach to public policy, addressing both the urgent need to decarbonize our economies while simultaneously strengthening energy security and resilience in a volatile world. The global energy landscape is undergoing rapid transformation. The urgency of climate change mitigation demands a rapid transition to renewable energy sources. However, this transition is complicated by geopolitical tensions, economic instability, and the need to ensure reliable and affordable energy access for all. Traditional energy security models are insufficient in this new context, demanding innovative public policy solutions that foster energy resilience, promote sustainable development, and consider the wider social and economic impacts of the energy transition. The research questions of the panel involve but are not limited to: How can public policy effectively integrate climate change mitigation goals with energy security and resilience in a rapidly changing global context? What are the key policy instruments and regulatory frameworks needed to facilitate the deployment of renewable energy technologies while ensuring system reliability and affordability? How can public policies address the social, economic, and geopolitical challenges associated with the energy transition, particularly in developing countries? What role can international cooperation play in promoting energy resilience and ensuring a just and equitable energy transition? The panel will explore various hypotheses, including: Interconnectedness: Public policy solutions for climate change and energy resilience are deeply interconnected and cannot be tackled in isolation. Innovation and Diversification: Promoting innovation in renewable energy technologies, alongside diversification of energy sources and supply chains, is crucial for energy resilience. Equity and Inclusion: Energy policies must prioritize equity and social justice, ensuring access to affordable and reliable energy for all, particularly in marginalized communities. Global Cooperation: International collaboration and knowledge sharing are essential for building resilient energy systems and achieving global climate goals. This panel is highly relevant to the growing body of research on energy policy, climate change, and global development. By fostering interdisciplinary dialogue and exploring innovative policy solutions, it will contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of the challenges and opportunities presented by the energy transition in a turbulent world.
POLICY TOPICS
P22. Energy Justice and Climate Resilience: A Pathway to Equitable and Sustainable Energy Transitions
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Energy Justice and Climate Resilience: A Pathway to Equitable and Sustainable Energy Transitions 1. Background Energy justice and climate resilience are emerging yet crucial concepts in the debate on sustainable development and environmental governance. The term energy justice refers to equitable access to, distribution of, and decision-making about energy resources—so that all communities, particularly those that are vulnerable and marginalized, have access to affordable, clean energy. This notion aims to rectify the historical and rising systemic inequalities amidt growing climate change adversities within traditional energy systems, which disproportionately affect low-income and marginalised communities (Jenkins et al., 2016). Climate resilience focuses improving the ability of energy infrastructures and local communities to adapt, recover, and prosper amidst climate change-driven derangements such as extreme weather conditions and energy supply disruptions (Meerow et al., 2016). 2. Significance Integrating energy justice principles with climate resilience strategies is essential to ensure a just transition toward low-carbon energy systems. Conventional approches to energy transitions often prioritize economic growth and technological advancement without adequately addressing the socioeconomic disparities they create. Disadvantaged and low-income communities are often excluded or not even accounted for before undertaking these advancements— thus, bear the brunt of environmental degradation and energy poverty at the same time. By incorporating energy justice into climate resilience frameworks, policymakers can address these inequities, making energy systems not only more sustainable but also inclusive and equitable. This combined approach aligns closely with the SDGs, specifically SDG-7 (Affordable and Clean Energy) and SDG-13 (Climate Action), by promoting inclusive access to clean energy solutions while enhancing societal resilience to climate impacts. Addressing these issues at the public policy levels is critical to mitigation and as well as adpaptation to climate change effects, and promoting sustainable economic development. 3. Potential Research Questions i. How can principles of energy justice be effectively integrated into national and regional energy policies to ensure equitable access to clean energy resources?ii. What are the socio-economic and structural barriers to achieving climate resilience in energy systems, particularly in marginalized and low-income communities?iii. In what ways do decentralized renewable energy systems contribute to the dual goals of energy justice and climate resilience in vulnerable regions?iv. How can smart grid technologies and innovations in energy storage enhance resilience and promote fair access to energy across diverse populations?v. What role do social and political frameworks play in shaping energy justice outcomes in the face of climate-related disruptions? 4. Scientific Relevance Research at the crossroads of energy justice and climate resilience has profound implications for advancing both scientific inquiry and public policy imperative. By examining how socio-economic inequalities intersect with energy access and climate vulnerabilities, scholars can develop frameworks to foster more just and resilient energy systems (McCauley et al., 2019). The growing body of literature argues that without a focus on social equity, energy transitions risk exacerbating existing injustices and creating new forms of socio-economic exclusion (Sovacool et al., 2021). This research area has broader relevance to innovations in renewable energy technologies. A focus on decentralized, community-based energy solutions can enhance the adaptation startegies and reduce the vulnerability of marginalized groups and communities (Heffron et al., 2018). Furthermore, the integration of smart grids and energy storage technologies plays a crucial role in enabling more equitable distribution of energy resources, enhancing system reliability, and reducing the carbon footprint (Caramizaru & Uihlein, 2020). Since this research domain helps to addresses not only the technical and economic aspects of energy transitions, but also the ethical and socio-political dimensions essential for achieving a sustainable future. As the impacts of climate change intensify, adopting a framework that integrates energy justice with climate resilience will be crucial in guiding public policy, scientific research, and community-driven initiatives towards more inclusive and sustainable energy practices. References: 1. Caramizaru, E., & Uihlein, A. (2020). Energy communities: An overview of energy and social innovation. Publications Office of the European Union.2. Heffron, R. J., & McCauley, D. (2017). The concept of energy justice across the disciplines. Energy Policy, 105, 658-667.3. Heffron, R. J., McCauley, D., & Sovacool, B. K. (2018). Resolving society's energy trilemma through the Energy Justice Metric. Applied Energy, 223, 119-131.4. Jenkins, K., McCauley, D., Heffron, R., Stephan, H., & Rehner, R. (2016). Energy justice: A conceptual review. Energy Research & Social Science, 11, 174-182.5. McCauley, D., Heffron, R. J., Stephan, H., & Jenkins, K. (2019). Advancing energy justice: The triumvirate of tenets and systems thinking. Applied Energy, 239, 598-608.6. Meerow, S., Newell, J. P., & Stults, M. (2016). Defining urban resilience: A review. Landscape and Urban Planning, 147, 38-49.7. Sovacool, B. K., Martiskainen, M., Hook, A., & Baker, L. (2021). Decarbonization and its discontents: A critical energy justice perspective on four low-carbon transitions. Climatic Change, 164(1), 1-18.
POLICY TOPICS
P25. Centering Community in Climate Change Resilience, Water Governance and Policy Innovation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Public policy scholars and practitioners have long espoused the benefits of involving communities directly in decision-making and policy development – not only for the communities themselves but also with the goal of making better decisions, designing implementation and improving outcomes. Effective policy-making and policy outputs require a deeper understanding and direct involvement of the targets of policy – most often communities – and diverse scholarship has interrogated and challenged how to think about the appropriate scales for real policy change, with considerable hope focused on the community level (Luluquisen & Pettis 2016). Indeed, there is a well-established body of public policy and public administration scholarship which advocates for inclusive policy processes that can bring ‘street-level’ knowledge and experience into decision-making and redress power imbalances for the purpose of attaining better outcomes (e.g., Freudenberg & Tsui 2014; Rijal 2023). More recently, public policy scholars and practitioners are focusing their analytical lenses on how communities are responding to the myriad impacts of climate change, which are rapidly becoming evident at the local level, particularly as water governance challenges (Ross et.al.2016; OECD 2024). Here, the focus is on how communities can adapt and how resilient they need to be as conditions transform around them, but also how we might harness community knowledge and practices on the ground to improve our policy and governance responses to accelerating climate change (Burton & Mustelin 2013). Of particular concern are significant changes to water resource quality and availability, which pose existential threats to livelihoods, safety and security, as well as cultural and social cohesion. Indeed, local communities are seen as key to achieving sustainable water management since they are closest to, and most able to, influence individual values, activities and behaviours (Warburton & Yoshimura 2005). The primary objective of this panel is to explore the role of communities in policy and governance responses to climate impacts, particularly (but not exclusively) in respect to water resources. We invite papers that explore several research questions: First, what is the state of our understanding of community resilience and adaptation in the face of climate change? Given the in many communities climate change is manifesting as water challenges, what role do communities play in policy innovation in response? Second, given their critical importance to the success of managing resources under conditions of accelerating climate change, how might we move local communities to a more central position in our conceptual, theoretical and methodological approaches to understanding and enhancing policy-making and governance frameworks – in spite of scholarship and empirical work that portray local communities as "vulnerable", “marginalized”, “underrepresented”, and “disempowered” (Espindola & Villar 2023). Third, how much do we know about the mechanisms that exist to channel and support community engagement in climate change and water policy-making, including across scales and across borders? Given that 40% of the world's population lives in river and lake basins that comprise two or more countries and are generally governed by institutionalized policies and policy actors, how can we ensure that scholarship focuses on the key roles that local communities play in climate change and water governance? In addition, what is the role of communities vis-à-vis the whole range of public and private users involved in inter-state management arrangements? We are particularly interested in what innovative research approaches might be used to exploring community roles and resilience vis-a-vis climate policy and governance responses. Further, what is the potential yet also the challenges associated with community-based and community-engaged research in this area?
POLICY TOPICS
P01. Perceptions on Redistributive Policies, Justice and Inequalities
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
It is important to understand perceptions about inequalities and ways to combat them, since public policies are an important point of contact between the State, government and citizens, through which they inform and are informed about demands, preferences and political interests. Since the opinions expressed affect and are affected by the actions of the State, in a two-way street, they interfere in the social and substantive dimension of equality in democracy. And although voting is the main mechanism for representing interests and legitimizing the actions of the State in relation to the preferences of the majority of the population, the fact is that citizens do not choose policies, but rather politicians, and the decisions that they make, the measures and actions that they adopt, in terms of public policies, do not respond to preferences that could supposedly be homogeneous, of a majority, but to the first preference or, at most, sets of interests of larger minorities, as Dahl (1956) rightly warns in his argument in defense of the pluralist perspective. Hence the special interest in population perceptions in terms of their priorities in public policies, which cannot be inferred from electoral results. As Howlett (2000) adds, public opinion, whether generic or majority, cannot be considered the independent variable that defines the production of public policies (whether due to Dahl's justification above or due to the various political and institutional factors that affect decisions about their formulation and implementation); government actions, directly and intentionally or not, also influence public opinion, in a process that feeds back dialectically. Therefore, the interest in research on perceptions of social policies is justified, notably those aimed at combating hunger, poverty and inequality, to the extent that they have been affected, differently for different social groups, as they have expanded and contracted throughout history in different contexts.
POLICY TOPICS
P02. Social Equity in Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Although a contesting concept, equity is believed to be the core of production and dissemination of knowledge across academic disciplines. In the context of a national state, when knowledge is diverse and inclusive, it helps governments to identify problems and to seek their socially equitable solutions for the benefit of their citizens. Public Administration as an academic discipline is discharging this critical responsibility dating to the early days of the field. Dwight Waldo, a US political scientist, who first described the influence of social equity on the body of public administration as a ductless gland, a subtle but important influence in the field. George Frederickson opines that the search for social equity provides public administration with a real normative base. In this particular milieu, the definition of social equity that has been advanced by Johnson and Savara (2011, p. 282) is deemed useful, "...is the active commitment to fairness, justice, and equality in the formation of public policy, distribution of public services, implementation of public policy, and management of all institutions serving the public directly of any contract. Public administrators, including all persons involved in public governance should seek to prevent and reduce inequality and injustice based on significant social characteristics and to promote greater equality in access to services, procedural fairness, quality of services and social outcomes." Empirical evidence suggests that countries across the world suffers from the lack of social equity challenges. Wooldridge and Bilharz note that in today's increasingly divisive and complex world, issues of inequity are at the center of policy debates and public frustration regarding a variety of social problems. Widening income gaps, unequal access to health and education resources, and tensions between racial and social groups are at the forefront of conversations, particularly for the public agencies looking to resolve them. By examining the context of the social equity conversation, public administrators may better understand how to reduce inequities in society and the role public policy plays to advance the agenda. The objectives of this panel is to understand the critical role social equity plays in shaping public policy. In doing so, this panel attempts to explore a broader research question: How and to what extent policy debates centering social equity shapes making and implementing public policy?
POLICY TOPICS
P03. (In)action in Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Despite its limitations, “what governments do” has served to be an enduring definition for public policy. Among the many things that governments do as they try to “tame wicked problems” (Rittel and Webber 1973; Crowley and Head 2017), they also look away (Mander 2015), exclude and reinforce inequalities (Schneider and Ingram 2005). Although not limited to them, feminist, dalit, black and other voices have drawn attention to experiences of being invisibilized (Star & Straus, 1999; Hatton, 2017; Daniels, 1987; Singh, 2014). Accounts of being devalued and dehumanised via (in)action (McConnell and ’t Hart 2019) are often central to these accounts; accounts that have also come to the forefront from an anthropological turn in public policy (Wedel et al. 2005) that have pointed to the deliberateness of policy (in)action and not just spaces of oversight or ignorance. Talking (to and about) policy is important to jolting policy decisions out of (in)action. Contemporary policy landscape of (in)action is rife with dilemmas of (in)action (Howlett, 2009). For example, several discussions on worker safety, substance abuse, sex-selective abortions, dowry, pollution, climate change, have been wicked and often fall into easy framings of deviant, normalise, disillusionment. Unlike the global north, where formal governmental committees, formal hearings and appeals may be invited even from dissenting voices, several regions across the world dissenting voices are actively punished. In some contexts, it might be particularly important yet difficult to bring on board those who are being invisibilized through (in)action. For example, in problems like Climate Change, conversations with the most important stakeholders, future entities, like the future biodiversity (including animals, plants and humans) does not seem possible. How does one challenge inaction, with the current stakeholders without encouraging dystopian disillusionment. As boundaries between truth and falsehood are blurred, in times defined by a ceaseless access to information, poses further challenges to policy inaction (Fisher, 2020, 2021; Boullosa, 2022).
POLICY TOPICS
P04. Bridging Divides: Comprehensive Public Policy Approaches for Addressing Inequalities
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Inequality has been and continues to be a matter of concern for the global community. Addressing the diverse inequalities has moved to the forefront of global policy debate with the objective of realizing equality for all. It features as the rallying point of the 2030 agenda for sustainable development as well. A variety of factors determine inequalities such as income, gender, age, origin, ethnicity, sexual orientation, class, and religion. The United Nations in its report has found that these divides are becoming more pronounced in some parts of the world. Amongst the several divides, socio-economic inequalities have become increasingly prominent in many societies around the world. In this backdrop, the panel proposes to explore comprehensive public policy measures aimed at bridging socio – economic divides with a focus on structural interventions, economic reforms, and social justice initiatives specifically targeting gender and income. This panel aims to foster an interdisciplinary dialogue that brings together scholars, policymakers, and practitioners to discuss innovative and effective policy solutions. The objective is to identify the key drivers of socio – economic inequalities with respect to wage distribution, health facilities, education and workforce development, and democratic participation; discuss comprehensive policy approaches; explore intersectionality in policy design and promote discussion on case studies and global perspectives. Research Questions: To guide the discussion, the panel will focus on the following research questions: a. What are the primary drivers of economic and social inequalities in different contexts (e.g., developed vs. developing countries)? b. What is the role of public policy in reducing these inequalities, and what are the most effective strategies? c. How do historical legacies and institutional frameworks influence current levels of these inequalities? d. What are the impacts of these inequalities on social cohesion, economic growth, and political stability? e. How can public policy be designed to address the needs of the most vulnerable populations without exacerbating existing disparities? f. What lessons can be learnt from successful policy interventions in different parts of the world? Scientific Relevance: The scientific relevance of this panel lies in its potential to contribute to the ongoing academic and policy debates on socio – economic inequalities. Despite significant research in this area, gaps remain in our understanding of the mechanisms driving these inequalities and the effectiveness of different policy responses. The panel’s interdisciplinary approach will draw on perspectives from economics, sociology, political science, and public health, among other fields. This holistic view is crucial for understanding the complex nature of these inequalities and for designing comprehensive policy interventions. Additionally, the panel will highlight the importance of evidence – based policymaking, showcasing studies that utilize rigorous methodologies to assess the impact of policies on these inequalities. Moreover, this panel will address the urgent need for policies that not only reduce socio – economic inequalities but also promote sustainable and inclusive development. By examining the drivers, consequences, and policy responses to these inequalities, the panel seeks to contribute to the creation of fairer and more inclusive societies.
POLICY TOPICS
P05. Social Inclusion in Transition: A Crossroads of Conceptualization, Measurement, and Policy in Global Contexts
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: The workshop aims to explore and redefine the conceptualization, measurement, and operationalization of social inclusion and exclusion within the context of comparative social policy. In the face of contemporary challenges such as climate change, pandemics, shifts in the global order, and geopolitical tensions, social exclusion has become increasingly prevalent both within and between nations. This workshop seeks to synthesize existing literature, identify gaps, and propose novel frameworks to address the complex dynamics of social in/exclusion in the era of transitional times.RESEARCH QUESTIONS:· What are the theoretical, conceptual, and definitional frameworks for social inclusion and exclusion, and how have they evolved over time?· How have social inclusion and exclusion been measured, and what are the implications for developing effective social policy?· How do conceptual and measurement approaches to social in/exclusion vary in comparative contexts?· What developments in these frameworks would enhance the effectiveness of social inclusion policies in addressing contemporary global challenges?· How can social in/exclusion be analyzed in the context of specific global challenges, such as climate change, pandemics, changes in the global order, and war?STATE OF THE ART: Contemporary challenges, including political instability, polarization, and exclusionary policies, necessitate a critical reexamination of social inclusion and exclusion concepts. While there has been relative consistency in their conceptual use, rapid developments in measurement underscore the need for a reexamination of the concepts. The workshop will explore the theoretical history, conceptualization, and operationalization of social in/exclusion, considering its dynamic and multidimensional nature.HYPOTHESES:· Social in/exclusion is a dynamic spectrum influenced by individual vulnerabilities, structural conditions, and discrimination.· Measurement approaches need to account for the multidimensional, multilevel, dynamic, and relational essence of social in/exclusion.· Novel conceptual and measurement frameworks are required to align with the realities of transitional times. CONTEXT:In the face of unprecedented global challenges, ranging from climate change and pandemics to shifts in the global order and geopolitical tensions, our societies are undergoing significant transitions. These transformative times have not only shaped the trajectory of nations but have also given rise to increased social exclusion, both within countries and across international borders. As our world grapples with these multifaceted challenges, social exclusion has emerged as a pervasive issue, manifesting in diverse forms and impacting individuals and communities on a global scale. Within this context, our understanding of social inclusion and exclusion becomes crucial. These concepts, integral to the fabric of social policy, demand careful examination and refinement to address the evolving nature of contemporary challenges. Political instability, polarization, and the implementation of exclusionary policies in various nations have further underscored the urgency of revisiting the conceptualization, measurement, and operationalization of social in/exclusion. Globally, numerous nations are grappling with exclusionary policies, signaling a need for a collective reevaluation of how social inclusion is conceptualized and practically implemented in the face of such transitional times.Recognizing the complex interplay between social in/exclusion and the broader challenges confronting our world, this workshop seeks to provide a platform for scholars, researchers, and practitioners to come together. By delving into the theoretical underpinnings, measurement methodologies, and comparative perspectives on social inclusion and exclusion, the workshop aims to offer insights that can inform the development of effective social policies. The overarching goal is not only to understand the historical development and current state of social in/exclusion but also to propose innovative conceptual and measurement frameworks. These frameworks, grounded in the multidimensional, multilevel, dynamic, and relational essence of social in/exclusion, aim to contribute to the design and evaluation of social inclusion policies that can effectively counteract the trends towards exclusion observed in our transitional era.Against this backdrop, we invite scholars from diverse disciplines to actively engage in this workshop. By critically examining existing knowledge, identifying gaps, and proposing novel approaches, participants can contribute to the ongoing discourse on social inclusion and exclusion. Through collaborative efforts, we aim to foster a deeper understanding of these complex concepts and develop actionable frameworks that will guide policymakers in addressing social in/exclusion amidst the challenges of our times.This workshop is not only an intellectual exploration but also a call to action—a collective effort to reshape the narrative on social inclusion and exclusion in a world undergoing profound transformations. We look forward to your participation and contributions to this timely and essential dialogue.AGENDAThe workshop agenda is thoughtfully curated to facilitate an insightful exploration of the reconceptualization of social inclusion and exclusion in transitional times. It kicks off with an introduction that sets the stage by highlighting the pressing need for revisiting these concepts amid contemporary challenges. The theoretical underpinnings of social inclusion and exclusion are thoroughly examined, tracing their evolution over time and considering the implications for effective social policy. A dedicated session follows, focusing on the measurement approaches to these dynamic concepts, considering their multidimensional, multilevel, and relational essence. The workshop then shifts gears to propose novel conceptual and measurement frameworks, drawing from a synthesis of existing literature. Participants will engage in group discussions to explore practical applications of these frameworks. This workshop aims to provide a holistic understanding of social inclusion and exclusion, offering both theoretical insights and practical applications for scholars and practitioners engaged in the field. POSSIBLE PAPERS:Participants are invited to submit papers that offer significant contributions to the discourse on reconceptualizing social inclusion and exclusion in transitional times. The workshop encourages papers that align with the following themes, each explored through key questions: · How have theoretical frameworks for social inclusion and exclusion evolved over time? · What cultural variations exist in these theoretical foundations, and how do they shape our understanding of these concepts in diverse societies?· What are the historical approaches to measuring social in/exclusion, and how have they evolved? · What challenges exist in current measurement methodologies, and how can we innovate to capture the dynamic and multidimensional nature of these concepts?· How do different nations approach social inclusion policies in response to contemporary challenges? · What successes and challenges have been observed in the implementation of social inclusion policies within various cultural and political contexts?· How does social inclusion or exclusion impact health outcomes at both individual and societal levels? · What strategies can be implemented to integrate health considerations into the development of effective social inclusion policies?· How do political instability and polarization influence social inclusion policies? · What recent policy changes in specific geopolitical contexts have implications for marginalized groups, and how can policies be reformed?· How do social inclusion, social capital, and social citizenship intersect and influence each other? · Can a more integrated framework be developed that considers the dynamic and relational essence of these concepts?· What are examples of successful social inclusion policies in addressing contemporary challenges? · How have these policies effectively mitigated social exclusion, and what lessons can be learned for future policy development?· How can existing literature be synthesized to propose novel conceptual and measurement frameworks for social inclusion and exclusion? · In what ways can these frameworks address the multidimensional, multilevel, and relational aspects of these concepts? Authors are encouraged to submit papers that engage deeply with these themes, addressing the key questions to enrich the workshop's discussions and contribute to the ongoing dialogue on reconceptualizing social inclusion and exclusion in transitional times.
POLICY TOPICS
P06. Interlocal Collaboration for Inclusive Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
General Objectives, Research Questions and Scientific Relevance Inclusive governance refers to a system in which the governing process actively engages and serves all segments of society (OECD 2020). It plays crucial roles in enhancing social welfare and equalizing public services. Key instruments for achieving inclusive governance include public involvement in decision-making, equitable resource allocation and intergovernmental collaboration. Interlocal collaboration—collaboration between two or more local governments to address shared challenges—has gained popularity in recent years. By transcending administrative and geographical boundaries, interlocal collaboration can be particularly effective in tackling disparities in public services for marginalized populations, regional welfare gaps, and power imbalances across regions (Blåka et al. 2023; Elston et al. 2018; Jing and Savas 2009; Lee and Liu 2024). Interlocal collaboration promotes inclusive governance through mechanisms, such as pooling resources for resource-constrained organizations, fostering trust via information sharing, and enhancing adaptability through communication networks (Ki et al. 2020; Yi et al. 2018). Despite its growing popularity, the role of interlocal collaboration in promoting inclusive governance remains underexplored. First, most studies tend to approach interlocal collaboration primarily from a cost-reduction perspective, while its value in promoting inclusive governance has not been fully acknowledged. For example, although shared services among neighboring regions are often viewed as a way to reduce costs through economies of scale, recent studies also highlight their ability to improve service accessibility for floating populations (Chen et al 2019; Chen 2021; Wang and Fan 2024). During the COVID-19 pandemic, many countries adopted cross-regional cooperative agreements to help migrant workers access public services provided by local governments at their destinations, despite travel restrictions (International Labour Organization 2020). Furthermore, interlocal collaboration is not limited to Western developed countries; it is also gaining traction in nations of the Global South (Consciência Silvestre et al. 2019; Luna-Reyes 2007). Comparative studies are therefore needed to fully understand its development across diverse institutional contexts. The panel invites papers that explore the value of interlocal collaboration in advancing inclusive governance, addressing the following questions: 1. How can interlocal collaborative be introduced to foster inclusiveness in different institutional contexts and policy domains? 2. What challenges do practitioners face at various stages of interlocal collaboration (e.g., entering collaboration, selecting partners and implementing agreements), and how do these challenges affect the outcomes? 3. What forms and arrangements of interlocal collaboration exist to promote inclusive governance, and what factors influence its successful implementation? 4. How do practitioners balance interlocal collaboration with other policy instruments when promoting inclusive governance? 5. In multi-level governance systems, what roles do different actors (central/local governments, citizens, social organizations and enterprises) play in collaboration, and what strategies do they employ? 6. What are the outcomes (both expected and unintended) of interlocal collaboration, and are these outcomes consistent across institutional settings? 7. How can classic public management and policy process theories be applied to gain insights into interlocal collaboration? 8. What methodological innovations, given recent advances in big data, computational social sciences, and experimental methods, can be applied to the study of interlocal collaboration? References Blåka, S., Jacobsen, D. I., & Morken, T. (2023). Service quality and the optimum number of members in intermunicipal cooperation: The case of emergency primary care services in Norway. Public Administration, 101(2), 447–462. Chen, B., Ma, J., Feiock, R., & Suo, L. (2019). Factors Influencing Participation in Bilateral Interprovincial Agreements: Evidence from China’s Pan Pearl River Delta. Urban Affairs Review, 55(3), 923–949. Chen, J. (2021). Governing collaborations: The case of a pioneering settlement services partnership in Australia. Public Management Review, 23(9), 1295–1316. Consciência Silvestre, H., Cunha Marques, R., Dollery, B., & Moraes Correia, A. (2019). Shared services in Brazilian local government: Urban development in small counties. Public Administration, 97(3), 686–702. Elston, T., MacCarthaigh, M., & Verhoest, K. (2018). Collaborative cost-cutting: Productive efficiency as an interdependency between public organizations. Public Management Review, 20, 1815–1835. International Labour Organization. 2020. “Protecting Migrant Workers During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Recommendations for Policy-Makers and Constituents.” Policy Brief. Accessed 25 Oct 2024. https://www.ilo.org/global/topics/labour-migration/publications/WCMS_743268/lang–en/index.htm Jing, Y., & Savas, E. S. (2009). Managing Collaborative Service Delivery: Comparing China and the United States. Public Administration Review, 69, S101–S107. Karimo, A., Wagner, P. M., Delicado, A., Goodman, J., Gronow, A., Lahsen, M., Lin, T.-L., Ocelík, P., Schneider, V., Satoh, K., Schmidt, L., Yun, S.-J., & Ylä-Anttila, T. (2023). Shared Positions on Divisive Beliefs Explain Interorganizational Collaboration: Evidence from Climate Change Policy Subsystems in 11 Countries. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 33(3), 421–433. Ki, N., Kwak, C., & Song, M. (2020). Strength of Strong Ties in Intercity Government Information Sharing and County Jurisdictional Boundaries. Public Administration Review, 80(1), 23–35. Lee, H., & Liu, Y. (2024). All hands on deck: The role of collaborative platforms and lead organizations in achieving environmental goals. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 34(3), 331–348. Luna-Reyes, L. F., Gil-Garcia, J. R., & Cruz, C. B. (2007). Collaborative digital government in Mexico: Some lessons from federal Web-based interorganizational information integration initiatives. Government Information Quarterly, 24(4), 808-826. OECD (2020), "What does "inclusive governance" mean? Clarifying theory and practice", OECD Development Policy Papers, No. 27, OECD Publishing, Paris. Sapat, A., Esnard, A.-M., & Kolpakov, A. (2019). Understanding Collaboration in Disaster Assistance Networks: Organizational Homophily or Resource Dependency? The American Review of Public Administration, 49(8), 957–972. Wang, X. & Fan, Z. (2024). Understanding Interlocal Collaboration for Service Delivery for Migrant Workers during the COVID-19 Pandemic: Evidence from Guangdong, China. Public Management Review, 26(4): 863-883. Weible, C. M., & Sabatier, P. A. (2009). Coalitions, Science, and Belief Change: Comparing Adversarial and Collaborative Policy Subsystems. Policy Studies Journal, 37(2), 195–212. Yi, H., Suo, L., Shen, R., Zhang, J., Ramaswami, A., & Feiock, R. C. (2018). Regional Governance and Institutional Collective Action for Environmental Sustainability. Public Administration Review, 78(4), 556–566.
POLICY TOPICS
P07. Achieving EDI as a Policy Objective: How Policy Contradictions Subvert Its Agenda?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion (EDI) through strategic policy development has been increasingly at the forefront of institutional change (Zhao et al. 2024). Yet there continues to be a disconnect between equity goals and those of other policy objectives, ultimately impacting the intended outcomes and the real-life experiences of equity-seeking individuals (AbouAssi et al., 2019; de la Riva Agüero, 2024). This disconnect between the (mis)alignment of larger policy objectives with EDI is often caused by policy contradictions, leading to subversions of EDI objectives that may emerge in policy design and/or policy implementation (Viswanath, Sabharwal & McCandless, 2024). The objective of this panel is to examine the complex relationships between Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion (EDI) initiatives and other public policy goals. It focuses on the policy contradictions that can emerge when two or more policy objectives diverge, clash or contradict in philosophy, approach or outcomes. Those contradictions can lead to both intended and unintended consequences for systematically marginalized individuals (Henry et al., 2017). The main research question that guides this panel is: How do policy contradictions emerge and how can policy makers account for and address policy contradictions to meet the EDI objectives within public policy? Policy contradictions typically occur within systems of governance especially in complex social contexts like (higher) public education, healthcare, legal services, staffing of public services and other public sector enterprises. Policy contradictions arise when policies aimed at supporting equity are undermined by other systemic practices, such as economic austerity measures, rigid bureaucratic norms, or legislative gaps (Hermele, 2021, Smith & Jacques, 2022). Critical scholars consistently point to ongoing structures of colonialism that perpetuate inequities particularly through public policy, creating skepticism regarding the authenticity of EDI policies associated with tokenism and performativity (Henry et al., 2017; McNair, et. al., 2020; Whatley & Raby, 2020). For example, policies aimed at providing equal access to education often conflict with restrictive immigration policies (O’Connor, 2018). Language policies that enforce a single official language in schools or government services can contradict with integration policies that claim to value multiculturalism and diversity (Vavrus, 2002). Health policies that promise universal care may contradict with financial policies that limit resources for vulnerable populations (Hayvon, 2024). Consequently, policy contradictions can lead to undermining EDI goals by reinforcing barriers rather than dismantling them. Our guiding theoretical and methodological framework is Critical Policy Analysis (CPA), (Allan, Iverson & Roper-Huilman 2010; Diem et al. 2014, 2015) that examines the circulation of power and the ways policy can create unequal hierarchies in society and prevent systematic structural change (Diem et al., 2014, p. 1072). This panel is grounded in the perspective that policy is not value-free but an interpretive process enacted in specific historical, geographical, social, economic, cultural and political contexts (Ball, 1997; Bowe et al., 1992; Ozga, 2000; Rizvi & Lingard, 2010). We align with Bacchi (2012) who argued that policy is something to be critiqued and troubled rather than accepted at face value. As such, this panel will explore how policy contradictions emerge, how they may infuse power dynamics and eventually shape institutional priorities and practice. Thus the focus of our panel is both on policies designed specifically to promote EDI and on different, possibly unrelated policies that may have conflicting effects on the achievement of EDI. Through various case studies panelists will reveal those contradictions and analyze how policy contradictions not only hinder progress on EDI but may also perpetuate broader systemic failures that prevent dismantling institutionalized forms of discrimination and oppression.
POLICY TOPICS
P09. Constitutional Economics for Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
With increasing economic inequality, there is an intense search among policymakers as to how the market logic could be constrained. Traditionally, constitutional values were the guiding light to advance the public interest. Yet, there is a criticism that constitutional forms were created in liberal societies to limit democratic control over economic policies. Contemporary scholar Katharina Pistor (2019) showed that laws are rigged to maintain the hegemony of one economic class over the rest, whereas Brown (2015) argues that such neo-liberal policies eventually undermine democracy. These articulations force us to search for the reasons for the disjunction between constitutional promises and policy outcomes. James Tully (2016) attempted to answer this divergence by showing the distinction between constituent power and constitutive power. First, constituent power reflects the particularistic identities within a society that often shape legal structures to their benefit, which can potentially undermine constitutional solidarity. Second, in many Global South nations, constitutive power has been influenced by the legacies of imperialism, embedding these post-colonial states into neoliberal economic orders. According to Tully, these entanglements limit the ability of constitutional frameworks to deal with economic forces and, thus, perpetuate inequality. During ICPP3 in Singapore, three panels were organised on the interface of Law and Public Policy. Selected papers presented in those panels were published as a book, Transformative Law and Public Policy (Routledge, 2019). We are very keen on how this genre of scholarship is expanding by examining the relevance of Constitutional Economics for Public Policy. We adopt a political economy framework to understand how the constitutionality of both democracy and economic decisions are intertwined. These constitutionality questions can’t be understood without an examination of how the judiciary has given verdicts on the conflicts brought in front of it. Therefore, an interdisciplinary examination of law, politics and economics comes to the centre stage of these policy analyses. In advancing justice, both philosophers and economists have examined the interface of law and economic decisions. Friedrich Hayek, Robert Nozick, and John Rawls have all expressed the centrality of law to protect property owners and to limit the power of the State, which harms individual liberty. Yet, a clear articulation of Constitutional Economics was achieved only by James Buchanan (1986) as the need to study the processes of rule-making that constrains the actors of policy making. The success of Western Capitalism is largely credited to the legal institutionalism that protects the liberty of individuals and firms, as well as the State's role in maintaining peace and order in society. This legal institutionalism has been promoted as ‘good governance’ across the world today. However, the rise of inequality has prompted a challenge to the basis of constitutional economics. Key References Brown, W. (2015) Undoing the Demos: Neoliberalism’s Stealth Revolution, MIT Press. Buchanan, J. (1986) The Constitution of Economic Policy (Nobel Prize Lecture). Pistor, K. (2019) The Code of Capital: How the Law Creates Wealth and Inequality, Princeton University Press. Tully, J. (1995) Constitutionalism in an Age of Diversity, Cambridge University Press.
POLICY TOPICS
P10. Reconstructing Public Policies: Addressing Inequities in Education, Housing, and Healthcare to Enhance Urban Planning and Sustainable Development
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Public policies demystify a constructive role in shaping the social and economic facets of spatial development trajectories, in juxtaposition; they can also inadvertently create or exacerbate inequalities. In today’s era, public policies, particularly in areas such as education, housing, healthcare, and criminal justice, often reflect and reinforce existing power dynamics and trigger socio-economic disparities. We have tried to explore the policy failures and a need of devising a restructured approach in public policy in the education, housing needs, healthcare and contesting urban planning failures.Literature reveals that educational policies have proven to induce significant disparities in school resources and quality of education between affluent and low-income neighborhoods (Attewell et al., 2013). The financial grant policy model of education inculcates diverse backgrounds and perpetuates educational inequities, disproportionately affecting marginalized communities (Rapoport & Schneck, 2018).Housing policies also contribute to social inequalities, particularly through zoning laws and land use regulations that favor single-family homes and suburban developments (Rothstein, 2017). These policies often restrict affordable housing options, forcing low-income families into under-resourced areas with limited access to essential services and amenities. Many inhabitants witness social-exclusion in education and healthcare due to disjointed and biased public policy (Rothstein, 2017). In healthcare, public policies impact marginalized groups, especially when policies do not account for socio-economic disparities as witnessed during pandemic outbreak (Kearns & O’Connor, 2020).Moreover, healthcare facilities are often concentrated in affluent areas, making it difficult for low-income populations to access services. The intersection of these policies reveals a pressing need for comprehensive reform aimed at promoting equity in healthcare access and outcomes. Public policy concerns in urban planning are crucial for creating equitable and sustainable cities. The prime concern for urban planning contestation is promoting equity and inclusiveness in spatial development process. (Attewell et al., 2013). The polarization and biasness in the urban development and micro-scale questions the current policy applicability with a reflection on re-structured approach for urban planning (Rothstein, 2017). However, there are debates embarking on contextualizing the process of localization of SDGs; however there appears to be the policy challenges in reinforcing the SDGS in developing nations (Rapoport & Schneck, 2018). We need a more nuanced understanding of how public policies are reconstructed a reinforced with a focus on education, affordable housing, healthcare; with impetus on efficient and effective urban planning. Therefore this panels focus on the plethora of following objectives, research questions and scientific relevance: pertaining to Educational Policies; Housing inequalities; health care disparities; urban planning issues community participation under the aegis of Sustainable development goals- General Objectives: Investigate how existing educational policies affect resource distribution and learning outcomes across various socio-economic groups, aiming to identify disparities and recommend equitable policy adjustments Assess the influence of zoning laws and land use regulations on the availability of affordable housing and the resultant social segregation, seeking pathways to reform for enhanced inclusivity Explore the accessibility and fairness of healthcare services in marginalized communities, particularly during and after public health emergencies, to highlight systemic gaps and propose equitable solutions Identify and evaluate urban development practices that foster social equity and sustainability, emphasizing the need for stakeholder engagement and community involvement in planning processes Investigate the local challenges and opportunities in implementing SDGs, particularly in developing nations, to understand how these global frameworks can be effectively localized to address specific urban issues. Research Questions: How do current educational policies affect resource allocation among different socio-economic groups? What are the measurable impacts of these policies on educational outcomes in under-resourced communities? In what ways do zoning laws and land use regulations contribute to or mitigate housing inequalities? How can policy reforms promote greater access to affordable housing and reduce social segregation? What barriers exist to accessing healthcare services in marginalized communities, particularly during public health crises? How do healthcare policies need to change to ensure equitable access to services for all socio-economic groups? What inclusive urban planning practices have been successfully implemented in various cities, and what lessons can be drawn from these case studies? How can urban planning integrate social equity considerations to promote sustainable development? What are the key challenges faced by developing nations in localizing the SDGs related to urban development? How can local stakeholders effectively engage in the localization of SDGs to address specific urban social and economic issues? Exploring the Scientific Relevance The conference will contribute to the existing body of knowledge by providing insights into how public policies intersect and influence various aspects of urban life, thereby affecting overall social equity and economic development. The panel will try to embark on developing evidence-based strategies for addressing inequalities in urban settings. It promotes dialogue among researchers from various disciplines of sociology, urban planning, public health, and economics to develop comprehensive approaches to urban development challenges through restorative and efficient policy design measures. The contribution of researcher will demystify research gaps from a global perspective attuned with the strategies under the aegis of sustainable development goals.
POLICY TOPICS
P11. Rethinking Poverty in context of Aligning Local Solutions with Global SDG Targets
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
There are many form of human deprivation which collectively leads to poverty. In contemporary time inclusive growth and equitable development needs to be achieved to reduce poverty and other disparities. World poverty is one of the most pressing problems faced by present world. Despite global efforts to eradicate poverty, challenges persist due to the diverse socio-economic contexts and unique local needs that are often overlooked in broad, one-size-fits-all approaches. Now time has come that policy maker to reassess and improve on the existing policies of poverty reduction considering ecological context as suggested by F.W. Riggs. Traditionally Theoretical base to measure poverty was absolute poverty in economic and calorie intake terms and which decide poverty line later on concept of relative poverty came in to existence. In present time poverty measurement is multidimensional it also include human development parameters. This Panel will explore the critical need to rethink poverty alleviation strategies by aligning local solutions with the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Present research emphasizes the importance of integrating local knowledge, cultural practices, and community-driven initiatives with global SDG targets to create more effective and sustainable outcomes to reduce poverty. Main research question in this context is: Have the SDGs implemented by governments trough policy intervenes in respected countries? What are the mechanisms developed by the governments to implement SDGs? Is there any evidence based methodology developed to evaluate the impact of SDGs in reducing poverty? Is Poverty reduction Polices are adaptive in nature in light of socio-political environment of respective county? What are the main challenges in implementation of poverty eradication strategies in light of SDGs?
POLICY TOPICS
P01. One Health and One Water
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
ABSTRACTOne Health is an integrated, unifying approach that aims to sustainably balance and optimize the health of people, animals, and ecosystems. It recognizes that the health of humans, domestic and wild animals, plants, and the wider environment (including ecosystems) are closely linked and inter-dependent. One Water is an integrated planning and implementation approach to managing finite water resources for long-term resilience and reliability, meeting both community and ecosystem needs. One Water is a transformative way of viewing, valuing, and managing water. The One Water approach manages all water—whether from the tap, a stream, a storm, an aquifer, or a sewer—in a collaborative, integrated, inclusive, and holistic manner. One Water and One Health are distinct but complimentary approaches that mobilize multiple sectors, disciplines, and communities at varying levels of society to work together to foster well-being and tackle threats to health and ecosystems. Both of these approaches address the collective need for 1) clean water, energy, and air, 2) safe and nutritious food, 3) taking action on climate change, 4) contributing to sustainable development, and 5) preventing the spread of zoonotic disease (disease spread from animals to humans). World wellness and climate security require a commitment to population health initiatives. Safe water can be sustained during climate change using a One Water and One Health strategy.
POLICY TOPICS
P02. The Role of Policy Actors in the Territorialization and Regionalization Processes of Healthcare Systems
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Recent developments in health policy literature have increasingly highlighted the substantial role that local, regional, and national actors play in the structuring and adaptation of healthcare services (Terlizzi, 2019; Terlizzi & Esposito, 2021; Bandelow et al., 2024). These policies include not only the classic objectives for healthcare such as affordability, quality and equal access and provision of services for the entire population. They also address new health policy issues like shortage of skilled healthcare workers and strengthening of public health. Public health is especially of interest with the integration of the health system not only with regard to different parts of the health sector but also to other policy sectors such as education, food, environment, housing or transport, for which local authorities have some competencies. The perspectives of integrated care and public health also address the recent multiple crises such as the COVID 19 pandemic, populism and climate change. Using the notion of territorialization to analyze these transformation processes is a way to go beyond the dominant comparative perspective on subnational dimensions of health systems based on the more institutional notions of regionalization, decentralization and federalism and less bottom-up oriented. Current research on regionalization in healthcare is dominated by health sciences and not by policy process research. The aim of this panel is to contribute to the development of policy process research on how territorial reforms are designed, circulate and are implemented. This panel focuses on how policy actors—including political entrepreneurs, advocacy coalitions, and programmatic groups—drive the territorialization of health systems. Such policy studies perspectives offer insights into the conditions and processes shaping health reforms to address the unique social, economic, and political landscapes of different regions.Programmatic groups, typically comprised of specialists and policymakers, can play an essential role in the design and implementation of local healthcare strategies. These groups leverage specialized expertise and resources to craft programs tailored to regional needs. Programmatic groups also facilitate the adaptation of national health directives by designing solutions specific to diverse political and social settings (Bandelow et al., 2021; Hassenteufel & Genieys, 2021). Policy entrepreneurs emerge as key actors in health policy, often driving regional reforms by capitalizing on "windows of opportunity" to adapt existing systems to better align with local demands. Entrepreneurs build coalitions and secure the backing of local authorities, making use of regional resources and aligning with interest groups to support their objectives (Petridou & Mintrom, 2020; Hand & Birkhead, 2023; Herweg et al., 2023). The Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF) serves as a valuable lens for understanding cooperation and competition among interest groups advocating for regional health reforms (Bogumil-Uçan & Klenk, 2021; Nohrstedt et al., 2023). This panel also aims to delve into both the substantive aspects and the contextual conditions underpinning the territorialization of health systems. Regarding the content of territorialization strategies, an important focus is on the discursive and narrative framing. Examining the conditions that frame territorialization processes, we also consider the institutional contexts of both political and healthcare systems.
POLICY TOPICS
P04. Public Policy Interventions for Increasing Health Insurance Coverage in Developing Countries
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Despite global progress in healthcare accessibility, substantial gaps remain, particularly in lower-income regions such as Africa, Latin America and the Caribbean, and East Asia and the Pacific, where health insurance coverage is still limited. In these countries private insurance penetration is extremely low, while public insurance mechanisms (where they exist) are woefully inadequate, despite the pursuit of universal health coverage (UHC). This panel will examine public policy interventions that have been successful or show potential for increasing health insurance coverage in developing countries. The papers submitted will evaluate current and past interventions, identify gaps, and propose policy directions for governments, international agencies, and non-governmental organisations (NGOs) to increase health insurance coverage, ensuring greater resilience and equity in health outcomes. For example, can the policy of employer and/or employee insurance mandates used in some US states be useful in developing countries? Can a model similar to the national insurance system in Canada be applied in African or Caribbean countries? What lessons can these countries learn about health insurance from Europe? Increasing health insurance coverage in developing countries is a critical issue with substantial implications for public health, economic resilience, and social equality. Studies consistently show that health insurance coverage can improve health outcomes, protect against catastrophic health expenditures, reduce economic disparities, and improve a country's economic performance. However, many developing countries continue to face low coverage rates, largely due to financial constraints, lack of state interventions, undiversified risk pools, inter alia. Moreover, with the significant increases in older segments of the populations expected in these regions over the next two decades, health insurance coverage is coming into sharp focus. This panel seeks to address the gap in the literature by focusing on public policy as a vehicle for improving health insurance coverage. While much research addresses healthcare interventions, less is available on the policy structures that support sustained insurance coverage expansion in lower-income countries. Comparative analysis of successful models and data-driven approaches from countries which have successfully expanded coverage can prove instructive for those countries which are lagging. Specifically, the panel will address the following areas of enquiry: 1. What public policy interventions have been most successful in increasing health insurance coverage in developed or developing countries, and what lessons can be drawn from these efforts? 2. What are the primary socioeconomic, cultural, or systemic barriers to health insurance uptake in these regions, and how can policy measures specifically address these challenges? 3. How can emerging financing mechanisms, such as microinsurance or digital health platforms, contribute to extending coverage to underserved populations? 4. What role can international agencies and private-sector partnerships play in scaling effective health insurance programs, and what challenges are associated with these partnerships? 5. How can public policies better target vulnerable groups, such as low-income populations, rural communities, and informal workers, who often face limited access to health insurance? This session aligns with the conference's focus on actionable strategies to tackle pressing global challenges in public health and will provide insights into policy interventions that support sustainable health system strengthening in developing countries.
POLICY TOPICS
P05. Mechanisms of policy change in health and social care reform
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
In a post-covid era, many countries are revisiting health and social care systems with a shift in focus from technical to distributive efficiency for equity, access and resilience. Reforms are wide reaching, from governance and financing to new models of workforce participation, role shifting and system integration. The aim of this panel is to delve into the mechanics of health and social care systems reform, by exploring mechanisms of change across system layers. Policy sciences have long been interested in theories of policy change in a bid to better understand the context in which reforms are charted and how they lead to desired outcomes. Several strands of scholarship focus on ‘mechanisms of change’ as the key unit underlying causal relationships through attending to the underlying building blocks of policy design and its unique implementation process and outcomes (van der Heijden et al., 2021). In contrast to realist evaluation approaches which aim to assess whether policies achieve their stated objectives within stable policy processes through theorising causation, less attention has been paid to discerning the discrete mechanisms of change which operate across the trajectory of system reform – at various levels of government and transcending locations of authority and modes of control (Tenbensel, 2020, p.117). Against the constant tinkering with policy design by government to optimise the achievement of policy goals, a mechanistic approach is an opportunity to delve into how policy reform operates through a focus on ‘realistic causation’ (Capano & Howlett, 2021, p.142) of what will occur when change is applied to policy tools and instruments wielded by government, and to account for the foreseeable, or unforeseeable, impacts or consequences of reform. Policy change – including the design, tools and instruments used by government, interactions and relationships that shape the achievement of policy goals – is a core issue at the centre of devising effective solutions in interconnected and complex policy systems. In this panel we aim to explore how policy reform produces behavioural changes during and after implementation, such as first- and second-order changes at the individual, group and sub-system levels (Capano & Howlett 2021), to better understand the dynamics of reform involving complex assemblages of actors, institutions and organisations with disparate motivations and interests. We aim to bring together and deepen this scholarly work to explore the potential, and the realisation of, a mechanisms of change approach to policy reform in health or social care contexts. Capano, G., & Howlett, M. (2021). Causal logics and mechanisms in policy design: How and why adopting a mechanistic perspective can improve policy design. Public Policy and Administration, 36(2), 141-162. https://doi.org/10.1177/0952076719827068 Tenbensel, Tim. (2020). How do governments steer health policy? A comparison of Canadian and New Zealand approaches to cost control and primary health care reform. Policy Sectors in Comparative Policy Analysis Studies. (pp.115-131) Routledge. van der Heijden, J., Kuhlmann, J., Lindquist, E., & Wellstead, A. (2021). Have policy process scholars embraced causal mechanisms? A review of five popular frameworks. Public Policy and Administration, 36(2), 163-186. https://doi.org/10.1177/0952076718814894
POLICY TOPICS
P06. The political determinants of health: how health policies, health governance and institutional arrangements affect health systems organization and reform in the post pandemic era
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The aim of this panel is to discuss how effective health policies, institutions and health governance could inform health systems improvements and health systems reforms in the post pandemic era. Multiple challenges affect heath systems around the world, like (among others) the ageing of the population, the technological developments, the lack of health workforce and health inequalities. While an adequate level of health expenditure is essential to develop effective and resilient health systems, that’s not enough: we need to better understand how other factors (like the roles and responsibilities of different actors, intersectoral collaborations, models of governance, regulation, etc.) contribute to build strong and effective health systems and what lessons could be shared between different countries. The panel focuses in particular on the political determinants of health (the role of different actors, their interaction, the relation with other areas of public policies, the decision-making process, the impact of contextual factors, etc.) in order to understand and investigate which elements affect health systems’ organization and which lessons have been learnt to improve health systems’ reforms and health systems’ governance around the world. The panel is also aimed at discussing and sharing experiences of health systems’ reforms that have been developed/are currently developing to improve health care systems and health policymaking around the world. While the panel is open to discuss the multiple dimensions of these lessons and experiences, its main focus is on their ‘policy’ implications and it is aimed at addressing the following questions: - How do institutional arrangements and health systems’ models of governance affect health systems reforms? - Which has been the role of different actors in shaping, developing and implementing specific health policies? - Which are the key aims of recent reforms and how these try to tackle current challenges affecting health systems? This panel will provide public policy scholars from all over the world with the opportunity to share and discuss experiences, challenges and lessons on the health policymaking process (from its formulation to its implementation) and on its impact on health systems improvement and health systems reforms. The panel welcomes papers with both a ‘single country’ or a comparative perspective, in order to facilitate reciprocal learning between different countries and to offer a contribution to the policy, societal and academic debates concerning health systems developments and health systems reforms. Papers focused on both developed and developing countries are welcome.
POLICY TOPICS
P07. How to evaluate corporate initiatives to promote access to medicines and health technologies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Affordable access to safe, effective and quality medicines, health products, and other technologies is an essential aspect of Universal Health Coverage, and an unrealized goal in many parts of the world. The United Nations’ Millennium, and then, Sustainable Development Goals, emphasized the role of the private and public sectors to contribute to Universal Health Coverage, including the need for industry engagement to improve access to essential medicines. Since that time, there has been an increase in the number and scope of initiatives and activities by pharmaceutical and medical device companies to facilitate access to medicines and health technologies within low- and middle-income country health systems (Rockers et al., 2017), and also higher-income countries (Prémont & Gagnon, 2014). These activities go beyond advertising and sales strategies and include: price reductions; medicines, device, and equipment donation; compassionate access programs; licensing agreements; service sponsorship; infrastructure investment; provider training; patient support programs; awareness campaigns; and regulatory and supply chain strengthening. However, there are no global frameworks or guidelines to inform governments or health systems interfacing with corporate initiatives despite known risks, including increased health system burden and costs, such as with many drug and device donations (McDonald et al., 2019; World Health Organization, 2017). There is a bigger question around whether and to what extent initiatives serve promotional purposes to further commercial interests, which are associated with negative public health impacts. Analyses of internal industry documents has revealed the extent of corporate influence within every aspect of the pharmaceutical sector (Gagnon & Dong, 2023), including scientific research, the media, civil society, regulatory processes, and clinical practice. However, the confidential and proprietary nature of many of these initiatives poses challenges for research. Countries continue to grapple with how to ensure affordable, equitable, and sustainable access to medicines. Pharmaceutical development is growing fastest for higher-cost, specialty medicines for chronic conditions in oncology, immunology, and diabetes; people prescribed these medicines often also require pharmacy, clinical, diagnostic, and ongoing monitoring services. In response, pharmaceutical companies have developed a suite of new promotional strategies to facilitate rapid access and uptake by directly providing such services in the form of patient support programs or funding and operating health services such as infusion clinics or diagnostic testing services. The extent to which this occurs globally is not well understood. The objective of this panel is to bring together diverse disciplinary perspectives and research methodologies to describe, analyze, and theorize the role of corporations in promoting access to health technologies within global health systems. The main research questions for this panel are: 1) What is the nature and range of corporate initiatives to promote access to health technologies within global health systems? 2) What frameworks or perspectives are useful in understanding how these initiatives operate to promote commercial, public health, or other interests? 3) What are the considerations for governance and what principles, frameworks, or policy tools might be, or are effective? References Gagnon, M.-A., & Dong, M. (2023). What did the scientific literature learn from internal company documents in the pharmaceutical industry? A scoping review. Cochrane Evidence Synthesis and Methods, 1(3), e12011. McDonald, S., et al. (2019). Medical donations are not always free: An assessment of compliance of medicine and medical device donations with World Health Organization guidelines (2009–2017). International Health, 11(5), 379–402. Prémont, M.-C., & Gagnon, M. A. (2014). Trois types de stratégies des fabricants pour la fidélisation aux médicaments de marque. Healthcare Policy, 10(2), 79–89. Rockers, P. C., Wirtz, V. J., Umeh, C. A., Swamy, P. M., & Laing, R. O. (2017). Industry-led access-to-medicines initiatives in low- and middle-income countries: Strategies and evidence. Health Affairs, 36(4), 706–713. World Health Organization. (2017). Responding to Industry Initiatives to Increase Access to Medicines and Other Health Technologies in Countries. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO.
POLICY TOPICS
P08. Shaping Tomorrow: Public Policy as a Catalyst for Fair, Sustainable, and Healthy Market Practices
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
In an era marked by global challenges such as climate change, rising inequality, technological disruption, and post-pandemic recovery, the interplay between public policy and market practices has never been more critical. This panel aims to explore the multifaceted role of public policy in steering market behaviours towards the creation of fair, sustainable, and healthy societies. By bringing together diverse perspectives from various sectors, regions, and policy domains, we seek to foster a comprehensive understanding of how market practices shape societal outcomes and how targeted policy interventions can drive positive change. The relationship between markets and society has long been a subject of academic and policy debate. Yet, continued commitment to an economic fundamentalism characterised by individualism, privatisation, and financialisation – amid complex interconnected global crises – demands re-examination of these dynamics. Current literature in public policy and economics recognises the potential for well-designed policies to shape market incentives and behaviours. Studies have demonstrated how regulatory frameworks, fiscal policies, and institutional arrangements can influence corporate decision-making, consumer behaviour, and overall market dynamics. Yet, there remains a gap in our understanding of how these policy levers can be effectively utilised to promote fairness, sustainability, and health across diverse contexts and scales. This panel seeks to address this gap by exploring several key research questions: How do different types of public policies (e.g., regulatory, fiscal, informational) influence market practices across various sectors and geographical contexts? What role does public policy play in mitigating harms from market activities while promoting positive societal outcomes? How can we effectively disrupt narratives of economic fundamentalism and economic growth with imperatives of fairness, sustainability, and human health? What innovative policy approaches are emerging to address contemporary challenges such as climate change and environmental degradation, rising wealth inequality and social disorder, and the growing burden of premature death and disease? How do processes of privatisation and financialisation impact the effectiveness of public policies in shaping market practices? By examining these questions, the panel aims to contribute to both theoretical understanding and practical policy formulation. We hypothesise that effective public policy can serve as a powerful catalyst for aligning market practices with societal goals, although the specific mechanisms and outcomes may vary significantly across different contexts. We also posit that successful policy interventions will likely require adaptive, multi-stakeholder approaches that can respond to the complex and dynamic nature of modern markets. This panel's scientific relevance lies in its potential to synthesise insights from diverse case studies, comparative analyses, and theoretical frameworks. By fostering interdisciplinary dialogue and critically examining policy impacts, we aim to advance the scholarly discourse on the role of public policy in shaping market practices that support fairer, healthier, and more sustainable social outcomes.
POLICY TOPICS
P09. From Crisis to Opportunity: Exploring the Transformation of Health Regulation and Public Health Innovation Policies Amidst Global Challenges
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
General Objectives Innovation policy plays a key role in shaping governmental actions during crises (Gross & Sampat, 2022), and it must often become more flexible to accommodate rapidly changing conditions (Fonseca et al., 2023; Lai, 2018). In this context, this panel will explore the role of regulation and public innovation within health systems during crises and their aftermath, not only the COVID-19 pandemic, but also neglected diseases like dengue, Zika, and Ebola. It will also discuss the role of regulation in the contexts of war and natural disasters, when healthcare systems face immense strain and require swift innovation to ensure continued care. Recognizing that public health innovation encompasses both incremental and radical responses, this panel seeks to examine how these approaches impact regulatory frameworks. Many regulatory approaches may require a degree of 'overdesign' to enhance their effectiveness, thus ensuring that health systems can adjust and respond flexibly to unforeseen challenges (Béland et al., 2020; Howlett et al., 2015). The panel will then examine how these adjustments may enhance or diminish health outcomes. Understanding these dynamics is essential for informing future crisis preparedness and fostering innovative capacity, enabling systems to better withstand and recover from disruptions while continuing to provide essential care. A key focus of this panel will be the roles of regulatory agencies (IRAs) alongside a diverse range of stakeholders involved in innovative health regulatory systems, such as politicians, scientific experts, healthcare providers, private companies—including the pharmacy industry—and community organizations. By examining the regulatory frameworks during and after health crises, the panel aims to uncover the factors that enable effective regulatory innovation and foster institutional responses. Additionally, it seeks to understand how innovation can serve as a pivotal tool in influencing public health and safety standards while shaping public policies. This panel is on site and is interested in the following general research questions: 1. How have regulatory frameworks and regulatory agencies (IRAs) innovated in response to health crises? 2. How have rapid regulatory innovations enhanced flexibility in healthcare systems, and what global lessons can be learned to improve future health outcomes? 3. How do political-economic factors and state capabilities influence health policy changes and stakeholder dynamics during crises and normal times? 4. How do new and existing actors, including public-private collaborations, influence regulatory responses? What are the risks of regulatory capture during health crises? Scientific RelevanceThis panel seeks to examine how health systems regulation and innovation evolve during and after health crises in global, regional, and local contexts. By analyzing the interactions between crises, regulatory frameworks, and health policy innovation, it aims to contribute to academic discussions on health policy and provide insights for improving preparedness and response strategies for current and future challenges. Health policy, regulation, and innovation play a pivotal role in establishing the framework for public health and safety, thereby influencing the functioning of health systems. Analyzing how crises and their subsequent effects impact these regulations not only enables the identification of effective strategies for addressing future challenges but also contributes to a deeper understanding of long-term adaptability within health systems. Moreover, as health systems increasingly rely on innovation, regulations must adapt to facilitate technological advancements and enhance policy designs while ensuring safety. Understanding these innovations is essential for comparing regulatory responses both across and within countries, and identifying common challenges to improve regulatory frameworks.
POLICY TOPICS
P10. Sexual and Reproductive Health (SRH) in the Global South: Navigating towards Equity and Empowerment
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel endeavors to transcend conventional approaches to Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights (SRHR) discourse by fostering critical engagement with the nuanced realities of achieving equity and empowerment within the Global South. Our objectives are multi-fold: 1. Disrupting Dominant Paradigms: We aim to challenge hegemonic, often Western-centric, SRHR frameworks that fail to adequately address the multifaceted socio-political and economic determinants impacting marginalized communities.2. Elevating Lived Experiences: Central to our approach is the prioritization of lived experiences, ensuring that the voices of individuals and communities most impacted by SRHR disparities, including youth, LGBTQ+ individuals, people with disabilities, and those facing intersecting forms of oppression, are amplified and centered.3. Interrogating Systemic Inequities: This panel seeks to deconstruct the complex interplay of power dynamics, socio-cultural norms, and structural inequalities that perpetuate SRHR inequities.4. Catalyzing Transformative Solutions: We aim to showcase and analyze the efficacy of community-driven interventions, technological innovations, and policy frameworks designed to dismantle barriers and promote SRHR justice.5. Generating Actionable Knowledge: This panel serves as a catalyst for producing impactful scholarship that can inform policy advocacy, program development, and community mobilization efforts. Research Questions: This panel welcomes submissions that engage with, but are not limited to, the following research questions: 1. How do intersecting forms of power and privilege (based on gender identity, sexual orientation, caste, class, ethnicity, etc.) shape the SRHR experiences of marginalized communities in the Global South?2. How can technological advancements and digital platforms be leveraged to bridge information gaps, improve service delivery, and empower individuals to navigate their SRHR, while also addressing potential risks and ethical considerations?3. What alternative methodologies and data collection approaches can be employed to decolonize SRHR research and ensure that knowledge production is ethical, inclusive, and culturally relevant?4. How do existing legal frameworks, policy interventions, and deeply entrenched social norms interact to either facilitate or hinder progress towards SRHR equity and justice?5. What innovative frameworks and metrics can be used to effectively measure the impact of SRHR interventions and hold stakeholders accountable for achieving equitable and sustainable outcomes? Scientific Relevance This panel occupies a critical space within the evolving landscape of global health research and practice: 1. Bridging the Knowledge-Action Gap: We address a critical need to move beyond descriptive analyses of SRHR disparities towards generating context-specific, action-oriented knowledge that can be leveraged for tangible societal transformation.2. Decolonizing SRHR Research: By challenging dominant paradigms and centering marginalized voices, we aim to contribute to the decolonization of SRHR research and practice.3. Fostering Transdisciplinary Synergies: This panel recognizes the inherent complexity of SRHR and encourages submissions from diverse fields of inquiry, fostering a synergistic and holistic understanding of the issue.4. Amplifying Impact through Dissemination: We are committed to disseminating the findings and insights generated through this panel to relevant stakeholders, including policymakers, practitioners, funders, and community organizations, to maximize real-world impact.
POLICY TOPICS
P01. New challenges to the use of force
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The changing international and regional security environment proves that many of the current policies regarding States' legitimate use of force are not enough to provide a service as securing life and no harm to citizens against different threats, both internal and external. Authors as David Weisburd in "Criminology of place" (2012) and "The future of evidence based policing" (2023), Hammes in "The Sling and the Stone: on war in 21st Century" (2006) or Luttwak and Shamir in "The art of military innovation" (2023) point out a general turnover in the security landscape, affecting citizens in diverse forms going from insecurity and crime to terrorism and asymmetric conflicts. However, current literature seems to segregate this kind of studies in different disciplines such as Criminology or International Relations, instead of providing a holistic approach. The general objectives of the panel focus on the new challenges to the legitimate use of force, from an institutional and operational perspective. The panel goals can be divided as followed: - Analysis of the new challenges to law enforcement’s use of force in new criminal environments such as violent mass gatherings, organized crime, terrorism, hybrid threats and renewed forms of classical delinquency. - Assess new challenges in the military and law enforcement’s use of force after the development of international crisis as Ukraine war, October 7 Hamas attack and the subsequent Gaza War, or the “pagers explosion” in Lebanon. - Research on the new paradigms in the use of force in proxy wars and gray areas, where hybrid threats, proxy actor and non-technological weapons coexist with innovative weapons technology at local, regional or international level. - Analysis of the challenges that any of the aforementioned areas imply in terms of accountability, transparency, or respect for the rule of law, penal and International Humanitarian Law, and other related policies such as immigration control or customs policies. - Analyzing the relation between the United Nations Sustainable Development Goal number 16, “Peace, justice and strong institutions” and security and defense public policies. Derived from these general research goals, research question is: What are the main challenges that States, governments and institutions are facing regarding the legitimate use of force in the last decade? The emerging global situation in terms of security threats implies a dual impact both in international relations and national security terms, affecting national defense policies -in its three levels of warfare, strategic, operational and tactical- as well as in law enforcement agencies and how they manage high, middle and low level security threats, from terrorism and organized crime to local or neighborhood crime policing. The rapid evolution of these emerging threats makes necessary a thorough revision of current policies and procedures and to what extent they represent an obsolete tool and, hence, an opportunity of improvement, identifying the main gaps in them, with a problem-solving approach. This line of research has the potential of providing a new light to recurrent problems as abusive use of force, how to guarantee a proportional use of the available means and training of the force, or violations and gaps in the International Humanitarian Law ruling war and other forms of international armed actors, including non-State ones.
POLICY TOPICS
P02. Comparative Innovative Financial Services Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel studies the rapidly emerging sector of innovative finance services, including open banking or open finance, ‘banking as a service’, ‘customer-driven finance’ and other related fintech developments. These new forms of financial intermediation pose important policy questions for governments around the world. Some scholars argue that these innovations foster financial inclusion and consumer choice highlighting that technological development in innovative finance expands availability, is tailored to meet growing consumer needs, and can contribute to economic development (Nicholls 2019, Rastogi et al 2023). However, others like Ferretti and Petkoff (2022) and Remolina (2023) highlight a variety of regulatory concerns that come with innovative finance. There are substantive questions related to systemic stability, as well as the credit and market risks of innovative finance providers. Given the rapid evolution of the sector and its reliance on technology, there are concerns about mechanisms for consumer protection, the economic security of individuals, privacy rights and protecting consumers’ information. What is clear is that the positive and negative externalities of advances in innovative financial services make it a worthwhile topic of public policy analysis in the Global North and the Global South. Yet, much of the academic analysis done to date has been conducted in other disciplines, particularly economics, business, and law. The objective of this panel is to serve as a focal point for a transnational discussion and comparative study of innovative financial services policy. It poses several related research questions. What is the role of governments in developing a dynamic but safe innovative financial sector? How can such an objective be attained? Are developments within the industry best understood as fundamental challenges to the structures of financial services or simply new tools in support of economic development? What are the implications of this distinction for policymakers? In recent years three broad regulatory models have emerged: the UK/EU, the Australia/Singapore and the US approach. Is this a sign of growing global or regional consensus? Are these models successful? Can effective policy programs be developed to achieve the potential gains in financial inclusion and choice while also providing effective protection for consumers? What theoretical and methodological approaches are better suited to provide a deeper understanding of policies in this sector? In essence, this panel is intended to flesh out theoretical and methodological insights into this area, to consider relevant case studies, and to delve into the opportunities and challenges governments face in dealing with innovative finance. Ferretti, F. and Petkoff, P. (2022) 'Open Finance and Consumer Protection: uneasy bedfellows', Law and Economics Yearly Review, 11(2),261-298 Nicholls, C.C. (2019) ‘Open banking and the rise of FinTech: Innovative finance and functional regulation’, Banking & Finance Law Review, 35(1), 121-151. Rastogi, S., Goel, A. & Doifode, A. (2023) ‘Open APIs in banking and inclusive growth: an innovation to support the poverty eradication programs in India’. Journal of Banking Regulation, 24, 432–444. Remolina, N. (2023) ‘Open Finance: Regulatory Challenges of the Evolution of Data Sharing Arrangements in the Financial Sector’, Banking and Finance Law Review, 40(1), 35-66.
POLICY TOPICS
P03. Sport Policy as an emerging Area of Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Background Starting from the post WW2 “rebirth” of the London Olympic Games in 1948 (IOC, 2024), the link between sport and public policy has been evolving fast, having nowadays, most of the countries in the world, with specific Sport Acts (Dowling et al., 2018). Since the new millennium, public sector is having an always increasing direct and/or indirect involvement in the provision of sport (Houlihan & Green, 2007). Regarding the direct involvement, public institutions definitively ought to be proactive, in sustaining local communities, by encouraging engagement through sport activities, thus related in favouring physical activities for health, and social interactions for inclusion and wellbeing (COM, 2007). The direct involvement of public and hybrid organizations in promoting active recreation through sport, can contribute to the improvement of citizen’s health (including those with disabilities and the elderlies); to the creation of safe, sustainable, and resilient communities; and in improving youngsters’ education. It can be useful in addressing social and economic inequalities within different localities (Skinner et al., 2008). The indirect involvement of governments in sport, sees them engaged in assuring proper implementation of sport events, dealing with several responsibilities, including safety, security, and collaboration on the construction of facilities for events. These deal also with aspects related to social, economic, and environmental sustainability, being all these factors linked to the general theme of the legacy of big sport events, especially international ones, such as Olympic Games (Thomson et al., 2019). Moreover, grassroot sport could be considered as a lever for public policy to support citizens’ relationships and their quality of life. For example, according to the Council of Europe (2006), sport is the largest voluntary non-governmental organisational activity throughout Europe, with more volunteers than any other activity. The relationship between Governments and Sport National Governing Bodies (SNGBs) may influence how sport sector is governed (De Dycker 2019) and how sport policy is designed and implemented, thus affecting the creation of public value through sport. Moreover, SNGBs face trade-off between the promotion of sport-for-all and the achievement of high-performance results in elite sport competitions (De Bock et al., 2022). General Objectives While these aspects have increasing studied by academics of sport sciences and of health sciences, investigation by public policy researchers is not systematic yet. Thus, several themes – design and implementation of sport policy, creation of public value by sport policy, measurement of sport policy through public value, sustainability – should be studied by public policy researchers. This is why we decided to propose this panel, with specific, but not exclusive, themes below (in the Call for Papers). Scientific relevance The panel’s scientific relevance can be found not only among these aspects above mentioned but especially in creating, through the debate within the panel’s participants, direct engagement of public policy academics, in both theoretical development and in addressing normative and practical issues of sport policy in relation to healthcare, diversity, inclusion, and public value.
POLICY TOPICS
P04. Mobility & Transport: New Concerns Arising from the Politics in Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
A - General objectives Integrating a political perspective into transportation and mobility policies opens new avenues for understanding diverse phenomena such as governance models, policy-making processes, political and public contestation, etc. Transportation systems are not only shaped by technical requirements, but are profoundly influenced by power relations, resource allocation conflicts, or political negotiations and contestations. In this sense, the general objective of this panel is to deepen the analysis from multiple approaches to understand how transport and mobility systems emerge as an output of public policy, who controls them, and how their management either reinforces or challenges social problems such as inequality. Reframing transport and mobility policies as inherently political issues provides critical insights into how power dynamics, public resources, or citizen participation molds transport systems and their outcomes. While the traditional framework for analyzing public policy in transport has been rooted in economics, there is an evolving trend towards more psychological, institutional, and sociological perspectives. By integrating these newer approaches and examining factors such as institutional theory, ideologies, and power relations, we can better understand the complex policy choices behind infrastructure development, policy choices, and mobility governance. Transportation is central to environmental politics and policies. The sector accounts for a significant share of global CO2 emissions, making it a critical arena in the fight for decarbonization and sustainable services. As countries struggle to align transport policies with their climate objectives, decisions in this space become inseparable from broader environmental governance challenges, raising questions about political ideologies and governance structures. Transport and mobility are key social policy issues directly impacting social inclusion and equity. While they can enhance accessibility, poorly distributed or inadequate services can exacerbate inequalities. Public policy analysis is essential to examining how mobility and transport policies are made, who benefits from them, and how marginalized groups are affected by decisions in the policy process. B - Research Questions Despite its importance, the transport and mobility sector remains underexplored within public policy research, even though it raises crucial issues of governance, resource distribution, political conflict, and accessibility. Much academic attention has primarily focused on technical, infrastructural, or planning aspects, while sidelining the public policy dynamics that shape decisions for transport and mobility policies and their outcomes [Kębłowski et al., 2018]. The implications of transport and mobility policy-making bring up several critical questions that remain untackled: How are decisions on transport policies negotiated among multiple levels of government including public authorities, private stakeholders, and civil society and how do they reflect or reinforce power dynamics? How do political ideologies and power struggles affect to mobility policies, and how do these affect marginalized communities? What governance mechanisms, regulation, and resources procurement shape transport infrastructure, and what is the role of private actors? How do social dynamics and contextual stimuli shape the decision-making structures around supply and demand for transport services? These questions highlight the inherently political nature of transport and mobility policies, encompassing issues of justice, equity, and public accountability. Urban transportation is an increasingly urgent issue that the government must address, as cities face growing demands for more efficient public transport systems, while also dealing with the challenge of congestion, pollution, and the tensions between pedestrians, cyclists, and car users. While often framed as technical or administrative, transport and mobility policies demand deeper analysis from a public policy perspective to address these intersecting governance challenges and respond to the urgent societal and environmental pressures. C - Scientific Relevance Mobility and transport policies result from a specific governance system, often involving collaborations between public and private actors [Chiapa Aguillón, 2018 ; Xu et al., 2020]. The involvement of private actors in shaping transport policies raises questions about the influence of private interest in public infrastructure and on the production and use of knowledge [Schenk, 2021 ; Molander, 2018]. Moreover, transportation infrastructure often sparks significant social mobilization and political conflict [Welzer-Lang et al., 2024 ; Obersteiner et al., 2024 ; Flonneau et al., 2021 ; Ndong-Etroit, 2016], highlighting the sector as a side of both public contestation and governance. The social dimensions of transport and mobility also demand further exploration [López-García, 2024]. Research has shown the experiences of minorities [Ivanova et al., 2024 ; Lubitow et al., 2020 ; Weintrob et al., 2021], elderly [Maresova et al., 2023] and children [Mitra et al., 2014] highlighting the ways in which the transport system can either mitigate or exacerbate inequalities. Additionally, active transport’s role in public health underscores the broader societal impacts of transport policies [Rissel et al., 2014] Understanding how mobility habits and choices are influenced by political, social, and economic factors. This panel aims to shed light on how transport and mobility policies are shaped by governance, political ideologies, and public policy struggles. By examining past and current challenges - such as innovations like autonomous vehicles [Taeihagh et al., 2019], or the crises like Covid-19 [Gkiotsalitis et al., 2021] – we can further understand the evolving public policy landscape in transport and mobility, in the context of both cities and rural areas, which faces ever-growing demands for effective mobility solutions. --- Chiapa Aguillón, Everardo. 2018. “Asociaciones Público-Privadas En Servicios Públicos Locales: Paradojas Entre Análisis de Factibilidad y Consecuencias No Previstas.” Flonneau, Mathieu, Maxime Huré, and Arnaud Passalacqua. 2021. Métropoles Mobiles. Défis Institutionnels et Politiques de La Mobilité Dans Les Métropoles Françaises. Presses universitaires de Rennes. Gkiotsalitis, K., and O. Cats. 2021. “Public Transport Planning Adaption under the COVID-19 Pandemic Crisis: Literature Review of Research Needs and Directions.” Transport Reviews 41(3):374–92. doi: 10.1080/01441647.2020.1857886. Ivanova, O., and S. O’Hern. 2024. “Mobility of Non-Binary and Gender Nonconforming Individuals: A Systematic Literature Review.” Journal of Transport Geography 121. doi: 10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2024.104008. Kębłowski, Wojciech, and David Bassens. 2018. “‘All Transport Problems Are Essentially Mathematical’: The Uneven Resonance of Academic Transport and Mobility Knowledge in Brussels.” Urban Geography 39(3):413–37. doi: 10.1080/02723638.2017.1336320. López-García, David. 2024. “Diverging Mobility Situations in Greater Mexico City: Exploring the Factors behind the Mobility Situations of Public Transport Commuters.” Urban Studies 61(10):1849–70. doi: 10.1177/00420980231214728. Lubitow, Amy, Miriam J. Abelson, and Erika Carpenter. 2020. “Transforming Mobility Justice: Gendered Harassment and Violence on Transit.” Journal of Transport Geography 82:102601. doi: 10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2019.102601. Maresova, Petra, Ondrej Krejcar, Raihan Maskuriy, Nor Azlina Abu Bakar, Ali Selamat, Zuzana Truhlarova, Jiri Horak, Miroslav Joukl, and Lucie Vítkova. 2023. “Challenges and Opportunity in Mobility among Older Adults – Key Determinant Identification.” BMC Geriatrics 23(1):447. doi: 10.1186/s12877-023-04106-7. Mitra, Raktim, Guy Ej Faulkner, Ron N. Buliung, and Michelle R. Stone. 2014. “Do Parental Perceptions of the Neighbourhood Environment Influence Children’s Independent Mobility? Evidence from Toronto, Canada.” Urban Studies 51(16):3401–19. doi: 10.1177/0042098013519140. Molander, S. 2018. “Changing Roles and New Perspectives: Towards Market Orientation in Public Transport.” Transportation 45(6):1811–25. doi: 10.1007/s11116-017-9781-3. Ndong-Etroit, Maïmouna. 2016. “La Construction Narrative Du Territoire Métropolitain à Travers Les Politiques de Transports Urbains: Les Cas de Lyon et Marseille.” P. 327 in Actes du 3e colloque du CIST-En quête de. Obersteiner, P., K. Trimmel, T. Brudermann, and M. Kriechbaum. 2024. “Beyond Polarisation and Simplified Storylines: Exploring Discursive Struggles over a Transport Infrastructure Project in Vienna, Austria.” Case Studies on Transport Policy 18. doi: 10.1016/j.cstp.2024.101293. Rissel, Chris, and Peter Mccue. 2014. “Healthy Places and Spaces: The Impact of the Built Environment and Active Transport on Physical Activity and Population Health.” Health Promotion Journal of Australia : Official Journal of Australian Association of Health Promotion Professionals 25:155–56. doi: 10.1071/HE14103. Schenk, Frithjof Benjamin. 2021. “Infrastructures.” in Doing Spatial History. Routledge. Taeihagh, A., and H. S. M. Lim. 2019. “Governing Autonomous Vehicles: Emerging Responses for Safety, Liability, Privacy, Cybersecurity, and Industry Risks.” Transport Reviews 39(1):103–28. doi: 10.1080/01441647.2018.1494640. Weintrob, Amos, Luke Hansell, Martin Zebracki, Yvonne Barnard, and Karen Lucas. 2021. “Queer Mobilities: Critical LGBTQ Perspectives of Public Transport Spaces.” Mobilities 16(5):775–91. doi: 10.1080/17450101.2021.1958249. Welzer-Lang, Daniel, and Pascal Gassiot. 2024. Observatoire Toulousain Des Pratiques Policières : Rapport Sur Les Opérations de Police et de Gendarmerie Dans Le Cadre Des Oppositions à La Constructionde l’autoroute A69, Avril 2024. Laboratoire Interdisciplinaire Solidarités, Sociétés, Territoires ; Ligue des droits de l’Homme ; Fondation Copernic ; Syndicat des Avocats de France. Xu, Guangjian, and Qianqian Lu. 2020. “Integrating the Private Economy with the Public Transport Sector in China.” in Hybrid Governance, Organisations and Society. Routledge.
POLICY TOPICS
P06. Design, Implementation, and Challenges of Transparency Policies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The proposed panel critically examines the functioning of transparency policies, focusing on the design and implementation of instruments such as Freedom of Information (FOI) laws and Open Government Partnership (OGP) initiatives. The primary objective is to explore how these tools are structured and operationalized to promote transparency, foster citizen engagement, and strengthen democratic governance through open and accountable government practices (Howlett, 2009; Hood, 2006). By analyzing both the design and practical implementation of FOI and OGP, the panel aims to understand how these initiatives enhance government efficiency and accountability. A particular focus will be placed on FOI laws, which, despite their widespread global adoption (Michener, 2011), often fall short of achieving their intended transparency outcomes (Michener et al., 2021). A significant gap persists between formal compliance (de jure) and practical implementation (de facto), as many jurisdictions struggle to meet the transparency goals established by FOI legislation (Michener & Nitcher, 2022). The panel will assess how FOI and OGP initiatives operate in different institutional contexts and identify the factors influencing their success or failure. Research Questions: How are FOI laws and OGP initiatives designed to promote transparency and strengthen democratic governance? What are the key barriers to the effective implementation of FOI laws, and how do bureaucratic behaviors affect transparency outcomes? Why is there often a gap between the formal adoption and practical implementation of FOI laws, and what factors contribute to this discrepancy? How do political motivations and institutional pressures shape the adoption and operationalization of transparency reforms? Scientific Relevance: This panel addresses a critical gap in the study of transparency policies by focusing on the persistent challenge of bridging the divide between the formal adoption and actual implementation of FOI laws and OGP initiatives (Mabillard et al., 2024). Although these tools are designed to enhance democratic governance, they frequently fall short due to various institutional, political, and bureaucratic obstacles (Tejedo-Romero & Ferraz Esteves Araujo, 2023; Cicatiello et al., 2024; Esposito et al., 2024). By exploring the design and operational aspects of FOI and OGP across diverse political and institutional contexts, the panel will provide valuable insights into why these instruments succeed or fail in practice. Additionally, the panel will investigate the influence of political ideologies and bureaucratic behaviors on transparency outcomes, offering an interdisciplinary perspective that draws on public administration, political science, and governance studies. This inquiry is crucial for understanding how transparency reforms are not only adopted but also effectively implemented. Another relevant aspect relates to the fact that FOI and open government policies make certain government information public, sometimes conflicting with privacy laws that protect personal data. Therefore, balancing privacy and transparency is essential in these policies. FOI laws, for example, allow public access to information but often include exceptions to protect privacy. Bennett and Raab (2017) note that countries set boundaries to define what can be shared without compromising privacy, especially in sensitive areas like health or fiscality. Both transparency and privacy build public trust: privacy safeguards personal data, while FOI fosters accountability. Bennett (1992) argues that effective governance requires a careful balance to maintain confidence in both. Bennett, C. J. (1992). Regulating Privacy: Data Protection and Public Policy in Europe and the United States (Vol. 132). Cornell University Press. Bennett, C. J., & Raab, C. D. (2017). The governance of privacy: Policy instruments in global perspective. Routledge. Cicatiello, L., De Simone, E., Di Mascio, F., Gaeta, G. L., Natalini, A., & Worthy, B. (2024). Response, awareness, and requester identity in FOI law: Evidence from a field experiment. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 220, 12–30. Esposito, G., Cicatiello, L., Mabillard, V., & Gaeta, G. L. (2024). Toward a citizen science framework for public policy evaluation: Lessons from a field experiment on Freedom of Information laws in Belgium. Evaluation, 0(0). https://doi.org/10.1177/13563890241270195 Hood, C. (2006). Transparency in historical perspective. In C. Hood & D. Heald (Eds.), Transparency: The key to better governance? (pp. 3–23). Oxford University Press. Howlett, M. (2009). Government communication as a policy tool: A framework for analysis. Canadian Political Science Review, 3(2), 23–37. Mabillard, V., Esposito, G., Cicatiello, L., Gaeta, G. L., & Pasquier, M. (2024). Barriers to freedom of information: Insights from an experiment in Belgium. International Journal of Public Administration, 1–13. Michener, G. (2011). FOI laws around the world. Journal of Democracy, 22(2), 145–159. Michener, G., Coelho, J., & Moreira, D. (2021). Are governments complying with transparency? Findings from 15 years of evaluation. Government Information Quarterly, 38(2), 101565. Michener, G., & Nichter, S. (2022). Local compliance with national transparency legislation. Government Information Quarterly, 39(1), 101659. Tejedo-Romero, F., & Ferraz Esteves Araujo, J. F. (2023). Critical factors influencing information disclosure in public organisations. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 10, 315.
POLICY TOPICS
P07. Roles and Functions of Social Enterprises in Social Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
ICPP 7 – CHIANG MAI, July 2025 PANEL PROPOSAL - Roles and Functions of Social Enterprises in Social Policy Chairs: Benoît Renevey, HES-SO//University of Applied Sciences of Western Switzerland, Fribourg Emmanuel Fridez, HES-SO//University of Applied Sciences of Western Switzerland, Fribourg Social enterprises (further : SE) have become key players in shaping social policy accross the globe, blending social missions with market-driven approaches. Their primary focus is on social impact rather than profit maximization. They utilize market-based strategies to achieve social objectives (Loosemore, 2015). SEs are generally identified on the basis of nine characteristics (Draperi, 2010: 20-21): - economic characteristics: like any enterprise, SEs have a continuous activity of producing goods and services; they have a high degree of autonomy; they assume a significant economic risk; they employ employees from the first labour market. - and social characteristics: the civic nature of the SE's activity; broad stakeholder participation in decision-making; non-exclusive governance by shareholders; limited distribution of profits to owners; an explicit objective of service to the community. Thus, the social enterprise represents a hybrid economic model that lies at the intersection of the traditional enterprise and the not-for-profit organisation. It aims to respond to social or environmental issues while guaranteeing its financial viability. This model has attracted growing interest, particularly for its role in implementing and supporting social policies. Over the last few decades, humanity has faced many challenges and difficulties, even though overall well-being is tending to increase slightly. Thanks to the UN's 2030 development goals and the EU's intention to ban the sale of internal combustion engine vehicles in Europe by 2035, social and environmental concerns have gained in importance, and many public players - at least at international level - are implementing policies to improve the situation. But at the same time, the legitimacy of spending large sums of money on policies aimed at well-being and good living in developed countries has not necessarily evolved positively since it collapsed during the series of crises that followed the end of the Thirty Glorious (Ferragina, 2022). After a crisis of legitimacy, social policies have shifted towards an increase in the provision of non-monetary benefits (workfare) aimed at social reintegration, coupled with a reduction or stagnation in cash benefits (ibid.). In developing countries, the success of conditional cash transfer programs in Latin America has inspired similar initiatives in African nations, reflecting a broader shift towards social protection mechanisms. This rapid expansion of social protection programs has been characterised by Barrientos and Hulme (Kundo, 2019), who describe it as a transformative movement in social policy aimed at addressing the needs of the poor. However, most developing countries - and even nations such as the United States and European countries (knowing that universal social coverage is constitutionally guaranteed in these countries) - are unable to provide universal social protection coverage. Moreover, international interdependencies further complicate the evolution of welfare states in developing countries. Nullmeier et al (2022) argue that the development of social policies is increasingly influenced by transnational factors, moving beyond the traditional focus on the nation-state. In this context, SE are led to offer services aimed at improving the well-being of individuals or populations in difficulty or lacking means of subsistence. In itself, their objective is similar to that of social policies, which are generally deployed on a large scale, whereas SE propose solutions aimed at local beneficiaries and medium-sized communities. As with social policy, the aim is to promote positive social change and have a positive impact on people's lives. Researching the roles and functions of SE in social policies is of significant scientific relevance due to their potential to address complex social issues, foster innovation, and contribute to sustainable development. SE operate at the intersection of economic viability and social mission, making them unique agents of change within the broader socio-economic landscape. Their dual focus allows them to tackle pressing social problems while also generating economic value, which is crucial in the context of diminishing public sector resources and increasing social needs (Muñoz, 2010; Jackson et al., 2018). One of the primary contributions of SE to social policy is their ability to implement innovative solutions to "wicked" problems – issues that are complex and resistant to straightforward solutions. Research indicates that social enterprises often employ radical or transformative innovations to address these challenges effectively (Ranabahu, 2020). For instance, SE can leverage cutting-edge technologies and novel business models to create social value, thereby enhancing their role in public service delivery (Phillips et al., 2017). This innovative capacity is essential for developing sustainable social policies that can adapt to changing societal needs and conditions (Wang et al., 2021). Moreover, SE play a critical role in fostering social cohesion and addressing inequalities. They are often positioned to serve marginalized communities, providing services and opportunities that traditional businesses may overlook (Finlayson & Roy, 2019). By engaging with local communities and understanding their specific needs, SE can tailor their offerings to effectively contribute to social inclusion and empowerment (Muñoz et al., 2014). This localized approach not only enhances the effectiveness of social policies but also ensures that they are grounded in the realities of the communities they aim to serve (Domenico et al., 2010). The interplay between SE and government regulations further underscores their relevance in social policy research. Studies have shown that government support and regulatory frameworks can significantly influence the development and sustainability of SE (Wang et al., 2021). Understanding these dynamics is crucial for policymakers aiming to create an enabling environment for social enterprises to thrive, thus maximizing their potential impact on social issues (Barraket & Yousefpour, 2013). Additionally, the multi-stakeholder nature of SE necessitates a nuanced understanding of legitimacy and accountability, as they must balance diverse stakeholder expectations while pursuing their social missions (Zhong & Zhou, 2020). In conclusion, the scientific relevance of researching social enterprises in the context of social policies lies in their capacity to innovate, address social inequalities, and adapt to regulatory environments. Their unique positioning allows them to contribute significantly to the development of effective and sustainable social policies that can meet the challenges of contemporary society. Therfore, our panel aims to address the following question : How do social enterprises interact with, influence and complement social policies, in a global context of economic and societal transformations ? The aim of the panel is twofold. On the one hand, to identify the latest concrete realities and scientific productions on the links between social enterprises and social policies, in the particular context that the world has been experiencing since the last ten years. On the other hand, over and above the inventory that can be made of these realities in different contexts, the aim is to identify future research needs and opportunities on the roles and place occupied by social enterprises in the production of well-being, always in relation to the social policies implemented by states, more particularly considering the recent changes that have occurred in the world (regional wars, awareness of the dangers of climate change, need for development and sustainability, etc.). With reference to the research question, we take into account the reality of three key moments in the existence of links between SE and social policies : - Because they are rooted at the heart of small communities, SE may play a part in the construction (even per-construction) of social problems. Their activities make inappropriate situations visible and help to convince (or not) public authorities to take action by putting social policies in place ; - In addition to this role of claiming and blaming, they also may participate in the making of social policies and in the transformation of social policies, or, on the contrary, implement their own social policies, in competition with or replacing public social policies ; - And thirdly, SE may or may not participate actively in the implementation of social policies, whether public or private, in other words, whether or not in collaboration with the public authorities. As stated in the call for papers, we welcome contributions addressing various aspects of the above issues. Contributions should come from research activities (all possible types), but we as well welcome purely theoretical studies, or reports of field experience. Selected contributions may be presented online or on-site. References : Barraket, J. and Yousefpour, N. (2013). Evaluation and social impact measurement amongst small to medium social enterprises: process, purpose and value. Australian Journal of Public Administration, 72(4), 447-458. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8500.12042 Domenico, M., Haugh, H., & Tracey, P. (2010). Social bricolage: theorizing social value creation in social enterprises. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 34(4), 681-703. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6520.2010.00370.x Draperi, J.-F. (2010). L’entrepreneuriat social : du marché public au public marché. Revue internationale de l'économie sociale, (316), 18–40. https://doi.org/10.7202/1020893ar Ferragina, E. (2022). Welfare state change as a double movement: four decades of retrenchment and expansion in compensatory and employment‐oriented policies across 21 high‐income countries. Social Policy and Administration, 56(5), 705-725. https://doi.org/10.1111/spol.12789 Finlayson, E. and Roy, M. (2019). Empowering communities? exploring roles in facilitated social enterprise. Social Enterprise Journal, 15(1), 76-93. https://doi.org/10.1108/sej-04-2018-0035 Jackson, B., Nicoll, M., & Roy, M. (2018). The distinctive challenges and opportunities for creating leadership within social enterprises. Social Enterprise Journal, 14(1), 71-91. https://doi.org/10.1108/sej-03-2017-0016 Kundo, H. (2019). Dynamics of designing and implementing social safety net programmes in developing countries. Bangladesh Journal of Public Administration, 25(1). https://doi.org/10.36609/bjpa.v25i1.40 Loosemore, M., & Higgon, D. (2015). Social Enterprise in the Construction Industry: Building Better Communities (1st ed.). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315741697 Muñoz, S. (2010). Towards a geographical research agenda for social enterprise. Area, 42(3), 302-312. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1475-4762.2009.00926.x Muñoz, S., Steiner, A., & Farmer, J. (2014). Processes of community-led social enterprise development: learning from the rural context. Community Development Journal, 50(3), 478-493. https://doi.org/10.1093/cdj/bsu055 Nullmeier, F., Reufels, D., & Obinger, H. (2022). Introduction: international interdependencies and the impact on social policies., 1-10. In: Nullmeier, F., González de Reufels, D., Obinger, H. (eds) International Impacts on Social Policy. Global Dynamics of Social Policy. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-86645-7_1 Phillips, W., Alexander, E., & Lee, H. (2017). Going it alone won’t work! the relational imperative for social innovation in social enterprises. Journal of Business Ethics, 156(2), 315-331. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-017-3608-1 Ranabahu, N. (2020). ‘wicked’ solutions for ‘wicked’ problems: responsible innovations in social enterprises for sustainable development. Journal of Management & Organization, 26(6), 995-1013. https://doi.org/10.1017/jmo.2020.20 Wang, J., Cai, L., Murad, M., Shahzad, F., & Ashraf, S. (2021). Impact of social entrepreneurial factors on sustainable enterprise development: mediating role of social network and moderating effect of government regulations. Sage Open, 11(3). https://doi.org/10.1177/21582440211030636 Zhong, W. and Zhou, Y. (2020). Business model innovation, legitimacy and performance: social enterprises in china. Management Decision, 59(11), 2693-2712. https://doi.org/10.1108/md-05-2019-0678
POLICY TOPICS
P01. Polycrises and Transition in Food Policies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
In an era characterized by simultaneous and interconnected crises—ranging from climate change and economic instability to public health emergencies—food policies are undergoing significant transformations. The empirical basis of the "polycrisis concept encapsulates the multifaceted challenges that influence food systems globally, compelling policymakers to adapt and innovate. It highlights the need to consider the role of national and sub-national policymaking more closely and to not simply analyze events at the global or international relations level (Dinan, et.al., 2024). This panel aims to explore the challenging and intricate dynamics of food policies in transition, emphasizing how these policies respond on a multilevel basis, and perform and shape emerging crises. The state of the art in food policy research highlights a growing recognition of the interdependencies between food security, environmental sustainability, digital transition, local development and social equity (Galli, et. Al, 2020). In the context of an emerging research program on sustainability transitions, the case of food policies is particularly interesting because it cuts across many other sectors. Due to its high exposure to various types of crises, it is receiving increasing attention from governments. Scholars have documented how crises like the COVID-19 pandemic and the war in Ukraine disrupted supply chains and revealed vulnerabilities within food systems, prompting calls for more resilient and adaptive policy frameworks. However, there remains a critical gap in understanding how different governance modes, political, economic, digital and social contexts affect these transitions in food policy. Two questions are driving this panel. One will focus on how various crises (climate, wars, health, economic) influence food policy design and implementation and with what impact. We aim to explore the effectiveness of current food policies in addressing systemic inequalities exacerbated by crises (Busetti-Righettini, 2023). Second, we aim to investigate how innovations in food policy and governance, such as community-led initiatives, digitalization, multisectoral collaborations, and experimental and pilot policy programs, can provide pathways for sustainable food systems amidst these challenges. The panel will shed light on the role of food policies in navigating polycrises, fostering resilience, and promoting equitable outcomes. We invite contributions that delve into theoretical frameworks, case studies, and empirical research illuminating these critical intersections.
POLICY TOPICS
P02. Legitimate crisis governance in multi-level settings
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Legitimate crisis governance in multi-level settings When a crisis hits, governments need to rapidly enact responses that are effective and legitimate. Yet, the legitimacy of these policies is not easy to acquire, as the measures often entail restrictions on the personal freedoms and liberties of citizens. Legitimacy is a crucial asset for governments to possess during crises (Boin, ‘t Hart and McConnell 2021), but it is one that is increasingly difficult to retain as a crisis progresses. The challenges of legitimate crises responses are only compounded when governments have to deal with transboundary crises that have differential impact throughout their territory. A transboundary crisis (Blondin & Boin, 2020; Boin, 2019; Wolbers et al., 2021) is not restricted to one single and clearly defined geographical location, but transcends jurisdictional boundaries and impacts different towns, regions, and communities in diverging ways (Ansell et al., 2010). A transboundary crisis with territorially-differentiated impact, such as the recent COVID-19 pandemic, presents governments with difficult trade-offs between security and liberty, but also between tailored policy responses and equality. Such crises also raise important questions as to the proper level of government that should lead the response. Countries around the world differ markedly in the territorial organization of power, and the multi-level governance arrangements can have significant consequences for how states deal with crises, and how their citizens perceive the legitimacy of different measures enacted by different levels of government. Most complex crises involve interactions between local, regional, national, supranational and global levels of governance. But we know relatively little about the effects of multi-level governance arrangements and the interactions between governance levels on crisis management and the legitimacy of crises policies in particular. The purpose of this panel is to collect contributions to the study of crisis management with a focus on legitimacy, as an outcome of interest, and multi-level governance, broadly construed as the arrangements related to the territorial and functional distribution of power in states (Marks et al. 2008), as a set of potential explanatory factors. The panel will increase our understanding of the factors that can produce effective and legitimate crises responses. It will shed light on how institutions shape crises responses, what citizens expect from different governments in crisis situations, and what measures can ensure compliance and acceptance. In this way, the panel will advance the academic literatures on crises management, on multi-level governance and on legitimacy (Schoon 2022, Brummel & de Blok, 2024, De Fine Licht et al., 2022). In addition, it has the potential to deliver actionable insights that can improve the practice of crisis management.
POLICY TOPICS
P03. Local Responses to Transboundary Threats: Building Governance Arrangements in Times of Crisis
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
We are living in an era of "Black Swans" and mega-crises (Ansell and Boin, 2019), where old and new threats emerge from climate change, pandemics, interstate conflicts, technological advancements, and human behaviour. While these threats originate from different places, their consequences are most profoundly felt at the local level. Transboundary crises – (perceived) threats that cross multiple jurisdictions, policy sectors, and timeframes, and demand urgent action (Ansell et al. 2010) – exacerbate existing challenges, as they intersect with ongoing economic, environmental, and political issues that cities, towns, and regions already face. These overlapping crises vary in duration, scale, and depth, compounding the difficulties for local actors who are tasked with managing their impact on local residents. For instance, the recent Covid-19 pandemic is a good example of a crisis that affected multiple jurisdictions, spilled over into policy sectors beyond public health and had a clear start but an unclear end (Ansell et al. 2020). Its presence starkly revealed vulnerabilities at the local level, with communities bearing the brunt of the crisis. However, it also highlighted the crucial role of local actors in navigating these complex situations. State and non-state actors in municipalities and regions may mobilize resources, foster cooperation, and adapt to rapidly shifting circumstances to manage, mitigate and prevent the impact of crises. A failure to do so can expose further vulnerabilities when local actors lack the capacity to respond. Looking at the local level underscores the critical importance of local governance and its capacity to respond effectively to immediate and long-term threats. Our panel goes to the heart of the nexus between local governance and crisis management by exploring policy efforts that transcend the boundaries of the nation-state. Research from multiple approaches has precisely overlooked the extent to which local actors may contribute to managing, mitigating or preventing the implications of complex crises on local residents. Therefore, the panel builds on the different aspects of governance at the local level to study responses to threats faced by local societies. Substantively, we are interested in theoretical and empirical contributions uncovering the strategies, partnerships and governance structures that local actors develop to make local systems resilient in the quest of responding to a world full of interconnected and globalized threats. We are also interested in unravelling how local actors make sense of crises, learn from them and offer responses.
POLICY TOPICS
P01. Reconfigurations of Social Protection in Contexts of Uncertainty and Complexity
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The world is undergoing a process of intense and profound transformation, leading to radical changes across various dimensions of existence – environmental, socioeconomic, sociocultural, and political (Brugué, Ubasart, and Gomà, 2022). In a scenario marked by deep transitions, traditional approaches to social welfare prove insufficient to address the new configurations of vulnerability and exclusion. This context of uncertainty, instability, and the failure of old models reveals the limitations of unilateral or fragmented responses to complex problems. There is a disconnect between the magnitude and nature of contemporary issues—complex in essence (Alford & Head, 2017; Noordegraaf, 2019)—and outdated forms of addressing them. In moments of paradigm crisis or misalignment, there arises an opportunity to introduce emerging perspectives and new frameworks to shape desired transformations in social protection and the fight against social inequalities. How can we weave social citizenship beyond the traditional welfare state? This question emerges as we reflect on the foundations of protection and social citizenship for a new era. We argue that these new issues, reflective of an era of transition, can no longer be framed or viewed solely from a positivist, objectivist, or predominantly rational perspective. A systemic approach is required (Nguyen et al., 2023; Douglas et al., 2020), alongside interpretative, discursive, and critical perspectives in the policy-making processes. It is necessary to incorporate elements from critical public policy studies (Boullosa, Peres, and Bessa, 2021; Fischer, 2016) to alter our cognitive and normative frameworks, allowing us to more comprehensively understand and respond to contemporary phenomena. Bringing an axiological dimension to the reflection on policy models, alongside an argumentation-centered approach, can help overcome the rational-technocratic-empirical approach that has dominated the debate on social protection. Moreover, from a broader viewpoint and renewed perspective of cross-sectoral collaboration, we can consider viable paths for the transition we are experiencing. This panel aims to foster an international and interdisciplinary dialogue, highlighting the importance of critical perspectives to confront contemporary challenges. Through an approach that emphasizes cross-sectoral collaboration and inclusion, we seek to build a repertoire of public policies and practices that resonate with the profound transformations reshaping the global social landscape. References ALFORD, John; HEAD, Brian. Wicked and less wicked problems: a typology and a contingency framework. Policy and Society, [s.l.], v. 36, n. 3, p. 397-413, 2017. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2017.1361634. DOUGLAS, Scott et al. Understanding collaboration: introducing the collaborative governance case databank. Policy and Society, London, v. 39, n. 4, 2020. Available at: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14494035.2020.1794425. NOORDEGRAAF, Mirko et al. Weaknesses of wickedness: a critical perspective on wickedness theory. Policy and Society, London, v. 38, n. 2, 2019. NGUYEN, Le-Khanh-Ngan; KUMAR, Cecilia; JIANG, Bowen; ZIMMERMANN, Nici. Implementation of systems thinking in public policy: a systematic review. Systems, Switzerland, v. 11, n. 64, 2023. Available at: https://doi.org/10.3390/systems11020064. BRUGUÉ, Q., UBASART, G. and GOMÀ, R. "Facing uncertainty, projects and democracy," in Blanco, A., Chueca, A., López Ruiz, J. A., and Mora, S. (eds.), Spain Report 2022. Madrid: J. M. Martín Patino Chair of the Culture of Encounter, Pontifical Comillas University, 2022. BOULLOSA, Rosana de Freitas; Peres, Janaina Lopes Pereira; Bessa, Luiz Fernando Macedo. Inside the Field: A Reflexive Narrative of Critical Studies in Public Policy. Revista Organizações & Sociedade, 2021, 28(97), 306-332. FISCHER, F. What is critical? Connecting policy analysis to political critique. Critical Policy Studies, 10(1), 95-98, 2016.
POLICY TOPICS
P03. Mainstreaming sustainability into policy education
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
There has been a growing focus on integrating sustainability and policy education (2, 4). The Scholarship of Teaching and Learning in education for sustainable development can expand policy studies into a transdisciplinary realm of knowledge co-production and social learning1, (5,6). However, familiar pedagogical methods—like fieldwork, simulation-based learning, and service learning—face several challenges. These can include defining learning outcomes amid the complexity of understanding sustainability while allowing for new ideas, promoting collaboration within competitive evaluation structures, and encouraging mutual learning among stakeholders to achieve social impact (1,3,7,8,10). With a greater focus on real-world impact, policy researchers are now tailoring their findings to better address practical issues for practitioners (9). Simultaneously, policy education has transformed into a more diverse landscape, incorporating policy challenges into various interdisciplinary curricula, including general education, business, sciences, engineering, and community leadership (7). This panel is organized around the following central question: What guiding principles are essential for integrating the core tenets of education for sustainable development—such as mutual learning, collaborative spaces, and enabling transformation—into policy education? The panel aims to bring together educators and scholars from diverse disciplinary and cultural backgrounds to discuss the different theoretical approaches, course design principles, and emerging pedagogies for sustainability-focused policy-oriented courses across various levels of higher education, including undergraduate programs, graduate studies, and capacity-building initiatives for policy professionals. References 1. Buckley, J.B. and Michel, J.O. 2020. An examination of higher education institutional level learning outcomes. Innovative Higher Education. Vol 45, pp 201–217. 2. Fischer, F., and Miller, G. J. 2006. Handbook of Public Policy Analysis: Theory, Politics, and Methods. CRC Press. 3. Harsell, D.M., Barsky, C., and Golas, S. 2022. Simulation efficacy and applicability: Reported learning from a virtual computer-based pandemic simulation on skill-based competencies among public affairs students. Journal of Public Affairs Education. Vol 28(2), pp 182-210. 4. Jickling, B., & Wals, A. E. J. 2008. Globalization and Environmental Education: Looking Beyond Sustainable Development. Journal of Curriculum Studies. 40(1), 1-21. 5. Kelly, O., White, Peta., Butera, F., Illingworth, S., Martens, P., Huynen, M., Bailey, S., Schuitema, G., and Cowman, S. 2023. A transdisciplinary model for teaching and learning for sustainability science in a rapidly warming world. Sustainability Science. Vol 18, pp 2707-2722. 6. Loltz-Sistika, H., Wals, A.E.J., Kronlid, D., and McGarry, D. 2015. Transformative, transgressive social learning: rethinking higher education pedagogy in times of systemic global dysfunction. Current opinion in Environmental Sustainability. Vol 16, pp 73-80. 7. Nair, S. and Varma, N. 2022. Emerging Pedagogies for Policy Education-Insights from Asia. Springer, Singapore. 8. Salovaara, J.J., Soini, K., and Pietikäinen, J. 2020. Sustainability science in education: analysis of master’s programmes’ curricula. Sustainability Science. Vol 15, pp 901-915 9. St. Denny, E. and Cairney, P. 2024. ‘Learning how to learn’: Teaching policy analysis from the perspective of the new policy sciences’. In (eds) St. Denny, E and Zittoun, P. 2024. Handbook of teaching public policy. Edward Elgar Publishing. Cheltenham, United Kingdom. 10. Woo, J.J. 2019. Educating for empathy. Service learning in Public Policy education. World Scientific.
POLICY TOPICS
P04. Bringing Time and Temporality ‘Back In’: Exploring Time as a Cornerstone in Public Policy and Public Administration
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Time has been explored by many disciplines, including public policy and public administration. However, we propose that a focused exploration of time could make a more significant contribution to our field. This panel seeks to bring time ‘back in’ and highlight its relevance to understanding theories in public policy and public administration. Scholars emphasize the importance of time in these fields (e.g., Pierson, 2004; Pollitt, 2008; Murdoch et al., 2023). For example, Paul Pierson's seminal work ‘Politics in Time’ (2004) underscores the need to analyze policy over time, emphasizing that path dependence and the sequence of events are crucial to understanding policy. Similarly, a body of literature addresses policy change over time (Hacker, 2004; Béland, 2007). Christopher Pollitt’s work (2008) stresses the lack of attention to time in public management, offering a "time toolkit" that explores concepts such as duration, paths, punctuation (windows of opportunity), cycles, causal mechanisms, and multiple temporalities. Elizabeth Cohen (2015) highlights the significance of time duration in immigration policy and its impact on the meaning of citizenship for immigrants. Murdoch et al. (2023) call for a “longitudinal turn” in public administration studies. Other streams of research focus on the importance of time to well-being, examining how policies influence time use and well-being (Kahneman et al., 2004; Lahat & Sened, 2020). This panel encourages researchers to engage with time not merely as one factor in explaining public policy and processes within public administration but as a central cornerstone that influences processes, relationships, and outcomes. The main question we aim to explore is: What is the added contribution of time and temporality to research in public administration and public policy? We welcome papers that explore the following questions while remaining open to other possibilities: 1. How can focusing on time provide better insights (more than we know) into elements of policy theory, such as the Multiple Streams Framework (MSF), the Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF), and the Punctuated Equilibrium Theory (PET)? 2. What is the effect of welfare policies on time use? 3. Can time itself be a goal of social and public policy? 4. How can political theory and time be better incorporated into public policy and public administration theory? 5. How could focusing on time help uncover power relations and hidden processes within public organizations? We invite theoretical and empirical papers, including normative papers, case studies, and interdisciplinary research that shed light on the role of time and temporality in public policy and public administration. We also welcome comparative studies and case studies focusing on individual countries. Abstracts will be judged based on the clarity of the theoretical framework and methodology. References Béland, Daniel. (2007). Ideas and institutional change in social security: Conversion, layering, and policy drift. Social Science Quarterly, 88: 1, pp. 20–38. Cohen, E. F. (2015). The political economy of immigrant time: Rights, citizenship, and temporariness in the post-1965 era. Polity, 47(3), 337-351. Hacker, J. S. (2004). Privatizing risk without privatizing the welfare state: The hidden politics of social policy retrenchment in the United States. American Political Science Review, 98(2), 243-260. Kahneman, D., Krueger, A. B., Schkade, D., Schwarz, N., & Stone, A. (2004). Toward national well-being accounts. American Economic Review, 94(2), 429-434. Lahat, L., & Sened, I. (2020). Time and well-being, an institutional, comparative perspective: Is it time to explore the idea of a time policy?. Journal of European Social Policy, 30(3), 275-292. Murdoch, Z., MacCarthaigh, M., & Geys, B. (2023). It's about time! Temporal dynamics and longitudinal research designs in public administration. Public Administration Review, 83(6), 1727-1736. Pierson, P. (2004). Politics in time: history, institutions, and social analysis. Pollitt, C. (2008). Time, policy, management: Governing with the past. OUP Oxford.
POLICY TOPICS
P05. Comparing Higher Education Policy in Asia: Politics, Actors, and Processes
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Asia is an exciting region for examining contemporary higher education policies and politics. Traditionally an exporting region of international students, scholars, and scientists to established institutions in the West, the region is now transforming into an attractive global destination for academic talents. This is visible in world university rankings where flagship universities from China, Singapore, Japan, Hong Kong, or South Korea are recognised alongside top institutions from the US, UK, Europe, Canada, or Australia. Asia is also the site where new initiatives facilitating intra-, inter-, and trans-regional higher education cooperation are to be observed. These initiatives are drawing previously less- or disconnected individuals and knowledge institutions to deepen collaboration. This in turn demonstrates what Asia offers to the world and moves beyond the more common Western-centred approaches. The dynamic nature of these developments makes Asia a compelling case for research into how higher education policies and politics have been crafted, as well as how they in turn transformed societies in the region. Governments in Asia have played central roles in these developments. By steering their universities to internationalise, improving higher education access for citizens, and introducing policies to bring back skilled nationals and attract foreign talents seeking robust research supports, Asian governments crafted innovative policy solutions. These policies and practices often went beyond merely mimicking those from the West, and exhibit “Asian characteristics”. As Asian governments strive to stabilise their higher education systems, the literature tells us that non-democratic states would struggle to meet the demands of widening higher education access at the risk of system stability. Asia is home to a variety of democratic and authoritarian regimes; thus, examining the Asian experience provides an opportunity to assess this assumed relationship between higher education policies and democratic development. In the same way, demographic pressures and labour market skill shortages affect Asian countries similarly as those in the West, focussing on Asia would reveal how its governments balance local politics with the need to meet global challenges. This panel brings together scholars working on the politics and policies of higher education in Asia. Specifically, the contributions from this panel examine one or several of the following four overarching themes. First, the politics of higher education governance reforms focusses on how governments steer higher education and the tools used to ensure that universities meet state and societal expectations. Second, the politics of higher education finance covers how higher education is funded and the politics behind changes in the funding system. Third, the framing of higher education policy over time explores how governments talk about higher education policy and the linkages they create between this policy area and other issues (e.g., economic growth, social mobility). Fourth, the varieties of Asian higher education regionalism identify the forms and mechanisms driving regional institutional and policy collaboration. Together, the contributions explain how higher education policies evolved over time in a rarely compared region, test the robustness of existing higher education analytical frameworks and concepts through Asian case studies, and identify regional specificities concerning the role(s) of key actors, discourses, and structures in policy processes.
POLICY TOPICS
P06. Authors meets critics: DESIGNING RULEMAKING
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
AUTHORS MEET CRITICS: Designing Rulemaking: How Regulatory Policy Instruments Matter for Governance In today’s complex world, the process of crafting regulations is under greater scrutiny than ever before. Citizens and stakeholders demand transparency, while governments have embraced regulatory reforms aimed at improving rulemaking. But do these procedural tools — consultations, impact assessments, freedom of information acts, and Ombudsman offices — actually lead to better governance? This is the central question addressed in Designing Rulemaking: How Regulatory Policy Instruments Matter for Governance, a collaborative effort led by EUI Professor Claudio M. Radaelli, alongside Florence STG researchers Jonathan Kamkhaji and Gaia Taffoni, Claudius Wagemann (part-time Professor at the Florence STG, Full Professor at Goethe University in Frankfurt), and Claire Dunlop (Professor at the University of Exeter). The book builds on a major European Research Council (ERC) project, ‘Procedural Tools for Effective Governance’, to investigate whether the design of regulatory processes influences key outcomes such as business conditions, perception of corruption, and environmental performance. The book is published by Oxford University Press (2024) and available in open access here.
POLICY TOPICS
P07. Book Presentation: Policy Communications: How to Write an Effective Policy Brief
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Book Presentation with authors: Policy Communications: How to Write an Effective Policy Brief The essential guide to policy briefs that get noticed—and make a difference. Who is this book for? Policymakers, researchers, advocacy professionals, communications specialists, and anyone who needs to turn complex ideas into clear, compelling, and actionable policy communications. What’s inside? Strategies for cutting through the noise and capturing the attention of busy policymakers Insights on audience targeting, messaging, and policy storytelling Practical frameworks for structuring, writing, and designing impactful policy briefs A step-by-step approach to crafting effective policy briefs The role of generative AI in policy writing Why does it matter?In an era of information overload, great ideas alone aren’t enough—how you communicate them determines whether they shape decisions or get ignored. This book gives you the tools to ensure your policy briefs are read, understood, and acted upon.
POLICY TOPICS
P08. RT/Governing AI in the Global South: Balancing the Needs, Benefits and Challenges
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Regulation has historically played catch-up with emerging technologies. Awareness is often raised post-facto and in a manner of managing the risks emanating from the application of the technology to society at large (Jasanoff 1997, 2016; Law & McCall 2024). In this process, the promise of technology alleviating developmental problems often ends up exacerbating them, widening the chasms of social, political, and economic inequities, especially for the marginalized, in the name of whom these technological interventions are justified in the first place (Benjamin 2019; Barocas et al., 2017; Moran-Thomas 2020). The current swathe of AI technologies has proven to be discriminating on grounds of race, class, gender, and even zip codes, owing to systemic biases encoded in the historical data they’re trained on (Obermeyer et al., 2019; Akter et al., 2021; Future of Life Institute 2023; Stilgoe 2020). Narratives of technological inevitability and the idea of technocracy, posing regulation as an obstacle to innovation, routinely dominate conversations on AI (Jasanoff 2016). Such concerns add to the governance challenges of these technologies. Governments around the world have been grappling with actors such as technology companies that are involved in the design and manufacturing of AI systems and are significantly ahead of the curve. The deployment of AI in the Global South has been further complicated by being embedded in the underlying relations of data colonialism and data capitalism which reinforces historical patterns of colonial and capitalist exploitations of these societies (Zuboff 2019; Couldry and Mejias 2019). Furthermore, the adoption of these technologies by the national policy elites in coutries of the Global South passes through a developmental imaginary which positions them as crucial for the socio-economic development of the nation, even as it puts the rights, especially of the already marginalized, at risk (Bhattacharya & Sanasam 2024; George 2017). This roundtable discussion will take this discussion further and speak to one or more of the following research questions: Research questions 1. How can we understand the peculiar evolution of AI technologies in societies of the Global South? 2. How can historical cases of technological regulation be deployed to inform the development of effective policies for the governance of AI technologies? 3. How are countries in the Global South adopting strategies to regulate AI? 4. How are Governments and the private sector negotiating authority and legitimacy over regulatory aspects of AI technology? 5. How does global relations of capitalism and colonialism influence adoption of AI in the Global South? 6. How does geopolitics influence the governance of AI in the Global South and other jurisdictions? 7. How can governance frameworks be designed to proactively manage the societal risks and benefits of AI-based technologies while ensuring more equitable outcomes?
POLICY TOPICS
p23. TEST SOF
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Bla bla
POLICY TOPICS
C01. Social Equity in Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Social equity was adopted as the fourth pillar of public administration, along with economy, efficiency, and effectiveness. Johnson and Savara (2011) defined social equity as the active commitment to fairness, justice, and equality in the formulation of public policy, and management of all institutions serving the public directly of by contract. Public administrators, including all persons involved in public governance should seek to prevent and reduce inequality and injustice based on significant social characteristics and to promote greater equality in access to services, procedural fairness, quality of services and social outcomes. This demonstrates a unique set of opportunities and challenges to public policy study in defining, measuring and evaluating social equity in public policy. The purpose of this course is to provide participants with the knowledge and skills necessary to critically think, understand and analyze social equity and public policy. This course will introduce students to a wide range of public policy areas along with the core dimensions of race, ethnicity, gender, class, and economy. More specifically, this course advances the participants’ understanding about social equity and its relationship to public policy both from conceptual and practical perspectives. Upon the successful completion of this pre-conference course, participants will be able to: 1) Compare and analyze the conceptual underpinnings of social equity 2) Critically apply the importance of social equity within public administration/public policy 3) Discuss measurement approaches relating to social equity analysis of public policies and 4) Engage in constructive dialogues on critical concepts related to social inequities in our society. Course readings and class activities will help participants develop these competencies.
POLICY TOPICS
C02. Narrative Policy Framework: Theory, Concepts, Methods, and Practice
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) is a systematic approach to understanding the role of narratives in the policy process. Narrative text and images are ever-present in our political and social spheres, and they effectively shape the thinking and preferences of the public and decision makers. This all-day workshop will comprise of a morning session devoted to an introduction to the NPF, operational definitions of key NPF concepts, some methods, and ethical issues. Whether you are new to the NPF or a seasoned NPF scholar, the afternoon session will be devoted to your NPF research (or potential research). We will have practice exercises and consultations/brainstorming about NPF research questions, data, and methods.
POLICY TOPICS
C03. Fundamentals of Research Design
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Join this half-day course to gain the knowledge and skills to conduct ethical, culturally sensitive, and theoretically and methodologically rigorous policy research. Students will learn to: - Understand the ethics and logic of the scientific method - Make appropriate decisions regarding theory and methods - Design a rigorous policy study - Assess the quality of policy research designed by others. Students will submit a one-page design summary of their own project prior to the start of the course to be discussed during class.
POLICY TOPICS
C04. Introduction to Critical Policy Analysis
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This course explores Critical Policy Analysis (CPA), a research orientation that bridges contemporary theoretical and methodological discussions—both normative and empirical—on the analysis of public policy at local, national, and global levels. Emphasizing socially inclusive values, CPA seeks to bring social meaning back into the understanding of policy through analytical approaches like framing, narrative analysis, argumentation, reflexive critique, and the role of emotions. Rather than adhering to a single method, critical policy analysis tailors its approach to the nature of the policy being analyzed, the site of its production, the purpose of the research, and the positionality of the researcher. Grounded in interpretive social science and critical theory, CPA rejects the positivist notion of neutrality, instead focusing on understanding policymaking processes not only in terms of inputs and outputs but also through the lenses of interests, meanings, normative assumptions, and values. At its core, this approach is committed to the promotion of democratic governance and social justice. Throughout the course, participants will engage with various key frameworks and critical methodologies—such as framing, using them to interrogate and analyze public policies through a lens of social justice, equity, and democratic values.
POLICY TOPICS
C05. Critical and Interpretive Policy Methodology
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
We are pleased to announce a half-day preconference course, focusing on critical and interpretive policy analysis. This course fosters a collaborative learning environment, pairing experienced researchers with less experienced colleagues to explore methodological challenges in policy research. Following a “master-class” model, the course provides an interactive space where participants present methodological challenges as case studies for discussion. Sessions will explore discourse, framing, and narrative analysis, including connections to AI-based natural language processing, ethnography, expert interviewing, participatory action research, and policy design methodologies. This year, we are pleased to welcome Frank Fischer, Henk Wagenaar, Koen Bartels, Regine Paul, Tamara Metze, Jennifer Dodge, and Severine van Bommel as facilitators. Workshop Format Thematic Clustering (10 min): Participants briefly state their methodological challenges (1-2 sentences) while adding them to a shared board. The facilitator clusters similar questions into 2-3 overarching themes. Master-Class Discussion & Synthesis (50 min): The expert leads an interactive discussion using selected cases, encouraging all participants to engage. Proposal Submission To apply, submit a proposal (max 3 pages, 500-600 words, double-spaced) including: Full name, institutional affiliation, and email Research project title Career stage (e.g., PhD year, postdoc, etc.) Brief research project description, methodology, and key challenges for discussion Submission Guidelines: File name: Last name.Methodology Workshop Proposal We welcome researchers at all career stages and look forward to an engaging discussion on interpretive policy methodologies.
POLICY TOPICS
C06. Governing ecological transition processes : a public policy research perspective
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Objective of the course: The course will provide students with conceptual lenses and methodological insights for the study of the governing of sustainable transitions processes from a public policy research perspective. This course examines the challenges posed by the governing of ecological transition processes for public policy research. By contrast to public policy developments in well-defined domains of state intervention, it is characterized by overlapping policy frontiers, transversal public policy issues and ambiguous policy goals. The multi-actors/cross-sectoral nature of these dynamics has led to diverse heuristics that analyze the multiple interactions and the way these processes are governed, each one with different assumptions on their influencing factors. In keeping with the multidisciplinary nature of ecological transitions and how they are addressed in comparative policy research, this course will aim at: conceptualizing the role of public policies in transition processes; including this perspective into research designs and applied research; Examining what resources and capacities are draw upon in order to monitor and administer processes of change; incorporating conflicts, resistances and mobilizations; applying these concepts and tools across a range of policy areas/political contexts in order to generate new assumptions and research agendas for studying the governing of ecological transition processes.
POLICY TOPICS
C07. Analyzing the construction of policy actors in the policy process
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The aim of this lecture is to provide theoretical lenses on the role of collective actors in the policy process and methodological tools to empirically analyze them. Three main types of collective actors have been highlighted in the literature: institutional actors, organizational actors and informal actors. A key question is the understanding of how individuals belonging to institutions (especially administrations), to organizations (especially interest groups) or sharing policy orientations (like the “programmatic groups” structured around a policy change program) can form a group who participates to the policy process. The lecture starts with showing that this issue are often not directly adressed in the dominant policy processes theories, even when they stress the role of agency, especially in the advocacy coalition framework. Other theories, especially the multiple stream framework, focus more on individual actors than on collective actors. The lecture will then present the contribution of sociological approaches, especially organizational sociology, constructivism and pragmatism, for the understanding of the construction (and the deconstruction) of collective actors in the policy process, in a dynamic perspective, taking the temporality strongly into account. It will also present some methodological tools for the empirical analysis of collective actors.
POLICY TOPICS
C08. The politics of Policymaking, a pragmatist constructivist approach
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The course proposes to examine the main research question, concepts, and theory elements of a constructivist and pragmatist approach to study the Policy Process empirically. Inspired by Pragmatist Philosophy (Dewey, James), by Pragmatist Sociology (Boltanski, Latour) and by the linguistic Turn in Social Sciences, this approach proposes to observe the policymakers "in action" involved in the policy process to impose a policy solution in the policy process and to understand it as a political activity. This approach proposes to take into account the cognitive skill and the discursive capacity of the stakeholders and the policymakers not only to define a wicked problem but also to transform it as a treatable problem that can be solved and to match it to a policy solution. Ref. P. Zittoun, "The political process of Policymaking, a pragmatist approach on public policy"
POLICY TOPICS
C09. Qualitative Interview
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This workshop proposes to discuss and train participants in the art and craft of qualitative interviews of Policymakers. After discussing the qualitative interview's epistemological and methodological biases, the workshop proposes different practical exercises for participants to learn how to proceed. Ref. Becker Howard, Tricks of the Trade: How to Think about Your Research While You're Doing It, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1998
POLICY TOPICS
C10. Emotions and the policy process: a research agenda of an emerging field
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Recently, the role of emotions in defining or influencing behaviour, including political behaviour, has been acknowledged, and research is increasingly addressing how affective processes shape our attitudes, actions, and decision-making. Policy studies have also started to analyse how emotions are reflected in policy discourses and how they influence policy change and support for policies. However, we lack solid empirical evidence as well as widely accepted theoretical models on the role of emotions in almost all aspects of politics. Conceptual and methodological problems abound, e.g., How to define, categorise and measure political emotions? How do we analyse the interplay of emotions with other political variables, like ideology, values and identity? What is the analytical model that best grasps the role of emotions in political action: should we consider them dependent, independent or mediating variables? The above questions are even more pressing in the field of policy studies and most of the empirical papers on the role of emotions in policy are seriously under-theorised. With some exceptions empirical studies don’t relate to the theories of the policy process. The course aims at presenting some conceptual as well as methodological challenges concerning the research on the role of emotions in the policy process, thus contributing to the research agenda of this emerging field. The course builds on the research being done in the framework of the EU Horizon project MORES – Moral emotions in politics: how they unite, how they divide, led by Zsolt Boda.
POLICY TOPICS
C11. Using natural language processing (NLP) for policy research
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Natural Language Processing (NLP) offers transformative potential for public policy research, enabling innovative analysis of large volumes of textual data from news, official documents, social media, and other sources. This full-day introductory course provides a comprehensive overview of NLP techniques, including rule-based approaches, unsupervised and supervised learning, and the emerging capabilities of large language models (LLMs). Through real-world examples and interactive hands-on exercises, participants will learn how NLP can be applied to key areas of public policy research, including understanding policy processes, analyzing policy design, and evaluating policy outcomes. For example, attendees will explore how sentiment analysis can reveal public opinion towards a new policy and how topic modeling can uncover trends in ongoing policy debates. While this course is designed for researchers and practitioners from diverse backgrounds, a basic working knowledge of Python or R would be helpful for participating in the hands-on coding exercises. Participants with limited programming experience can leverage pre-written code templates and practical tools to implement NLP techniques, enabling them to apply these methods to their own research. Attendees will leave the course with a strong foundational understanding of NLP techniques, diverse applications across geographies and domains, and actionable insights for leveraging NLP to address complex policy challenges.
POLICY TOPICS
C12. Interpreting Emotions in Public Policy: Applying Interpretive Emotions Analysis (IEA)
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Emotions play a crucial role in shaping political discourse, public policy, and institutional legitimacy. They are not merely individual experiences but socially embedded phenomena that structure the way knowledge, power, and decision-making processes unfold. This half-day pre-conference course introduces participants to Interpretive Emotions Analysis (IEA)—a methodological approach designed to systematically analyze emotions in policy debates, institutional action, and public controversies. The session will first provide a concise theoretical overview of the role of emotions in policy studies, drawing on scholarship from political sociology, feminist epistemology, and discourse analysis. We will explore how emotions act as knowledge-producing elements (Ahmed 2013) and how they shape public legitimacy (Durnová 2019). The course will then focus on the practical application of IEA, demonstrating how interpretive methodologies allow researchers to analyze emotional language, in policy texts, media representations, and other examples of political discourse. By the end of the session, participants will be familiar with key analytical strategies, including coding emotional registers, identifying semantic clusters, and tracing the socio-political context of emotions in different types of data. The session will include hands-on exercises and discussions on how to integrate IEA into participants’ own research projects. Course Outline Introduction: Why Study Emotions in Policy Research? Emotions as socially and politically embedded (Ahmed 2013; Berlant 2004) Emotions in public policy: legitimacy, governance, and political action (Durnová 2019; Gould 2009) Theoretical Framework of IEA The interplay of emotions, power, and knowledge Emotions as discursive practices and framing tools (Foucault 1966;) Analytical Strategies for IEA Identifying emotional registers and rhetorical devices Coding semantic fields of emotions ( metaphors, analogies, hyperboles, etc.) Contextualizing emotions within policy narratives and institutional settings Hands-On Exercise: Applying IEA to Policy Texts Group activity: analyzing policy documents, political speeches, or media coverage Discussion: integrating IEA into your research design Tailoring IEA to your own research project Practical challenges and methodological limitations & Future research directions Pre-reading materials will be provided before the course. Participants are also encouraged to bring their own data materials for the hands-on exercise.
POLICY TOPICS
C13. Critical Policy Inquiry: Interpreting Knowledge and Arguments
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This course offers a comprehensive exploration of a critical approach to studying public policy and policy analysis, grounded in postpositivist foundation. Critical policy inquiry draws on Jürgen Habermas’s work on communicative action and deliberation, Michel Foucault’s writings on discourse, and the epistemics of social constructivism. The course advances deliberative policy argumentation and the logic of practical reason, exploring how this can be used as a framework for interpreting the interaction of normative and empirical arguments in policy politics. Participants will learn how to apply this approach to a diverse range of topics, including technocracy, policy expertise, deliberative democratic politics, interpretive policy analysis, post-truth, climate and Covid denialism, participatory governance, local and tacit knowledge, and the role of emotion in policy controversies. This course concludes with a look to transformative policy learning and the future of the field. Connecting social and political theory with empirical research and practical applications, it is beneficial for PhD students and scholars of public policy, politics, governance, public administration, and regulatory policy.
POLICY TOPICS
C15. How to Use the Policy Learning Framework in Policy Process Research
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
In this course you will learn how to use concepts and frameworks of policy learning to strengthen and advance your research across a wide range of topics and approaches in public policy. We will cover the conceptual foundations of policy learning, its types, and effects on public policy, and how it integrates into - and strengthens- existing theoretical approaches to policy process research. Next, we will examine in depth various ways of measuring the presence of learning in public policy and discuss how to establish the causal effects of learning in individuals, groups and complex organizations, drawing on exemplary case studies. We will finish the course with practical suggestions on how to benefit from the policy learning framework in your own research: for this reason, we invite participants to prepare a short (3-4) page description of their project, research plan, or paper drafts.
POLICY TOPICS
C16. Methodology: Think tank Network analysis
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Think tanks have become relevant participants in policy networks and policy making around the world. Broadly defined as organizations involved in policy related research and advisory efforts, think tanks are frequently presented as independent civil society actors committed to supply evidence-based knowledge, and as bridging organizations committed to speak "truth to power". The course will critically examine the history and theoretical understanding of think tanks, and introduce suitable methods to study think tanks and think tank networks. Drawing on modified approaches to the study of interest groups (Schmitter and Streeck), we will focus on top down “logics of influence” and bottom up “logics of constitutencies" (corporate, academic, civil society etc.) relevant to examine the interrelation of interests and ideas and the ways in which think tanks are embedded in the economic, political, social and cultural fabric of society. Drawing on discourse coalition theory (Hajer), we will examine some of the the ways in which think tanks have become critical agents for the creation, distribution and contestation of story lines and policy narratives. The workshop will look at the composition of think tank boards, at critical links between think tanks (interlocking board membership) and at relevant output patterns. Particular attention will be paid to the transnational dimension of think tank networks.