Format

P06. Governing technologies in Southeast Asia: (Re)Thinking digital tech and its policies from a Southern perspective

SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY POLICY
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Stefan Bächtold
Monash University, Malaysia Campus
Main chair
Joanne Lim
University of Nottingham, Malaysia Campus
Second chair
Gayathry Venkiteswaran
University of Nottingham, Malaysia Campus
Third chair
Emma Baulch
Monash University, Malaysia Campus
Fourth chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY POLICY
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Beyond the truism that digital technologies permeate all aspects of societies, the assemblages of devices, cables, and data centres allowing for everyday connectivity are realising tremendous (geo)political, social, and economic effects. Southeast Asia is portrayed as one of the most dynamic regions (hyperconnected, datafied, and innovative) but also faces major digital challenges: In so-called ‘mobile first’ environments, both the opportunities (e.g., gig-economy, smart cities, e-government, infrastructure investment) and challenges (e.g., disinformation, surveillance, hate speech, cybercrimes, data breaches) of digital technologies shape unique policy worlds; and are producing ambiguous, complex effects on society (Bächtold et al., forthcoming 2024; Lim, 2017; Rasidi, 2023). 

As in other regions, governments struggle to produce effective policies to govern digital technology (Lim, forthcoming; Leong & Lee, 2021), but Southeast Asian policymakers face different challenges than those underpinning the Chinese, US or EU policy approaches to data sovereignty or consumer privacy protection. Often, they find themselves at a particular disadvantage vis-à-vis the economic power of international (e.g., Meta, Bytedance) and regional (Grab) Big tech companies. As a result, the (socio-technical) imaginaries and framings of technologies that are underpinning most policies targeting the digital in the region appear to uncritically accept the hyperdatafied business model of current surveillance capitalism (Zuboff, 2015) or data colonialism (Couldry & Mejias, 2018). However, recent developments like the Indonesian government’s push back against TikTok and Malaysia’s social media platform licensing complicate this picture. At the same time, attempts to regulate digital spaces to curb hate speech or misinformation are often leveraged to silence and control dissent (Rasidi, 2023).

By taking a step back to critically evaluate both the realities and imaginaries of policy targeting digital tech, this panel questions the problematisation of digital technologies in Southeast Asia’s policy worlds. It focuses on a region of strategic importance to global infrastructure; and home to idiosyncratic digital environments, practices, and knowledges. This should yield findings that are not only relevant to academia and to improve policy regionally, but invites us to re-think theoretical concepts, policies, and understandings of the digital - globally.

 

Literature:

Bächtold, S., Raghunath, P., & Lim, J. B. Y. (forthcoming 2024). Governing Technologies: Exploring Datafied Practices, Imaginaries and Digital State Assemblages in South and South East Asia. Journal of Digital Media & Policy, 15(3).

Couldry, N., & Mejias, U. A. (2018). Data Colonialism: Rethinking Big Data’s Relation to the Contemporary Subject. Television & New Media, 20(4), 336-349.

Leong, S., & Lee, T. (2021). Global internet governance: Influences from Malaysia and Singapore. Palgrave MacMillan.

Lim, J. B. Y (forthcoming 2024). Digital Media Interventions in Southeast Asia: A Decolonial Perspective. Palgrave Macmillan.

Lim, J. B. Y. (2017). Engendering Civil Resistance: Social Media and Mob Tactics in Malaysia. International Journal of Cultural Studies, 20(2), 209-227.

Rasidi, P. P. (2023). Ludic cybermilitias: shadow play and computational propaganda in the Indonesian predatory state. Communication, Culture & Critique, 16(4), 235-242.

Zuboff, S. (2015). Big Other: Surveillance Capitalism and the Prospects of an Information Civilization. Journal of Information Technology, 30(1), 75-89.

CALL FOR PAPERS

Drawing on the sensitivities of critical policy studies, international political sociology, and science and technology studies (STS), this panel seeks to discuss the space for meaningful and effective policies on digital technologies in Southeast Asia. How can we think about policies to govern the digital that respond to the specific realities of Southeast Asian societies? What approaches are needed to address the inequalities of power between Big tech and Southern governments? How can policy actors in Southeast Asia develop agencies to carve out political room for manoeuvre, including creative (mis)use, (re)design, and (re)appropriation of digital tech and its spaces? What could policies underpinned by a positive, emancipatory, progressive political vision for digital technology and data justice in Southeast Asia look like?


For this panel, we invite empirical and theoretical scholarly research on the digital policies of Southeast Asia – their possibilities, constraints, and imaginaries. We particularly encourage scholars from Southeast Asia to submit abstracts that engage with concrete policies and policy worlds in Southeast Asia by reframing and critically examining concepts and theories originating from the Global North from a Southern perspective. We also are particularly interested in research that is based on knowledge co-creation with actors outside of academia; or that crosses academic disciplines.

This could involve, but is not restricted to, the following areas of research and questions:

What can we learn from past and present policies attempting to regulate the digital in Southeast Asia?
What socio-technical imaginaries are underpinning current and past policies, and how do they problematise digital technology?
How do policy actors build their knowledge on hyped technologies (e.g., AI, blockchain); and how do these knowledges shape (and are shaped by) policy?
How do national and regional policies in Southeast Asia relate to (e.g., translate, contest, appropriate) policies from other parts of the world?
How do concepts like data justice, privacy, or digital rights travel, translate, or (re)emerge within Southeast Asia, its policies, or political contentions?
How do large (digital) infrastructure projects (re)shape the policy worlds of Southeast Asia?
How can we make sense of attempts of Southeast Asian actors to (re)appropriate, (re)interpret, or (mis)use existing policies on digital technologies?
What localised actors, institutions, movements or regional actors and for (e.g., ASEAN) shape the policy worlds that regulate the digital and its material arrangements in Southeast Asia?
What are practical strategies to critically engage with and decolonise policy discourses of digital technologies, development, and progress in Southeast Asia?

 

This panel understands itself not only as an academic discussion. It is part of a broader effort to build networks and coalitions of academics, civil society, government actors, tech developers and communities to imagine and work towards data justice in Southeast Asia. We strive to integrate the insights and reflections from the panel into our initiatives with stakeholders beyond academia, and invite paper presenters to be part of our (ongoing and future) efforts to impact national and regional policies.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Malaysia’s Fourth Industrial Revolution (4IR), Neoliberal Policy, and the Geographical-Spiritual Problematics of Digital Technologies
Sing Fei Teoh (University of Nottingham, Malaysia Campus)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Analyses of local and regional digital developments could begin from the geographical reality of global neoliberal capitalism. Acclimatisation of Western digital platforms (e.g. Instagram, WhatsApp, automated systems, et cetera) within Southeast Asia’s developmental spaces not only provided new spatial-temporal affordances for society and industry. More importantly, these platforms, as the policymakers and business communities have been quite aware, embody a new phase in the neoliberal stage (and the future) of capital accumulation. In Malaysia, the political and capitalist classes see digital technology differently from the moments and struggles of geographically variegated everyday lives. Yet, this perspectival difference is never explained to be predicated upon the future of capital, but out of a proclaimed necessity of collective adaptation to a new ‘reality’. In policy terms, Malaysia’s capitalist-political class alliance has been ‘unifying’ and guiding the country’s historically-habitually diverse communities within a neoliberal spatial standardisation strategy for digital labour transformations, called the ‘Fourth Industrial Revolution’ (4IR) Policy, but consistently within the discourse of necessity: “to enjoy the benefits of a brighter tomorrow” and “through greater productivity.” This paper argues that the 4IR Policy is not merely a discursive product, but most importantly a spatial and spiritual one. The neoliberal digital policy wipes out geographically specific ways of everyday life across Malaysian regions in promulgating a new neoliberal ideology of the brighter digital future, and it presumes that Malaysian and Southeast Asian peoples do not have their own ideas of how their own digital adaptations could work. Such are the spatial-spiritual struggles between local peoples and a ‘standardising strategy’ amidst the spatial fix of global capitalism in Southeast Asia in the digital age. Critical researchers and geographers, practitioners, and especially members of the local younger generations, are invited to (re)think carefully about the region’s supposedly next ‘industrial revolution’, for the many non-neoliberal local ways, cultures, and joys.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Regulating AI in Indonesia: Interplay of Imaginaries, Power, and Interests
Dewa Ayu Diah Angendari (Leiden University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The global race for AI regulation has intensified, with nations unveiling strategies to govern this transformative technology. Indonesia joined this race in 2020 by introducing its National Strategy on AI and a circular letter on AI Ethics. As of December 2024, the country is drafting a presidential regulation on AI Governance and developing a government regulation modeled after the EU’s Digital Markets Act and Digital Services Act. However, as previous research suggest, the global AI regulatory landscape remains dominated by resource-rich actors, raising questions about the power imbalances and imaginaries driving these regulations.

 

Against this backdrop, this study aims to examine how policies on AI are made in Indonesia. It explores the interplay between imaginaries, power, and the political and economic interests of key policy actors. This research contributes to non-Eurocentric perspectives on technology regulation, particularly by exploring a young democratic state, but is frequently criticized for adopting authoritarian practices in digital governance

 

The research reveals three initial findings through interviews, observations, and document analysis. First, the imaginaries of Indonesian policy actors regarding AI reflect the dual nature of emerging technologies, simultaneously evoking hopes and fears. On one hand, AI is envisioned as a driver of innovation and economic growth. On the other hand, concerns persist about job displacement and the emergence of economic monopolies. These competing imaginaries are not unique to Indonesia’s AI policy-making; the debate over technology versus human labor in the job sector has been a recurring global discourse. This narrative also frequently surfaces in broader discussions on Internet policy in Indonesia.

 

Second, these imaginaries are rooted in Indonesia’s socio-political history, particularly the New Order era (1965–1998), which established bureaucratic and elite-dominated governance practices. Despite democratic reforms, these practices persist, with government and elites maintaining significant control over policy-making. Emerging technologies like AI amplify these dynamics as multinational tech firms use their financial and knowledge resources to shape agendas, promoting narratives about the inevitability of technological progress and the need for innovation-driven regulation.

 

Third, power in Indonesia’s technology policy-making process is unevenly distributed. The government dominates decision-making through closed-door processes, while multinational tech companies play a key role in shaping the agenda during the early stages. Both actors frequently co-opt academics and civil society organizations (CSOs), aligning them with dominant narratives and limiting alternative imaginaries. This dynamic reinforces existing power structures, sidelining broader public interest concerns.

 

In conclusion, despite the novelty of emerging technologies, Indonesia’s policy-making processes remain rooted in elite-driven practices, heavily influenced by political and economic interests, as well as the advocacy of big tech firms. The tension between fostering innovation and imposing regulation reflects an ongoing power struggle, where economic elites push for minimal restrictions to maximize technological growth. As AI continues to evolve and Indonesia’s market expands, policy actors must critically assess the narratives surrounding regulation. AI governance should not be viewed as an end goal but as a tool to address societal challenges, balancing technological innovation with the public interest

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Understanding the Reaction of Indonesian Public towards Government Data Breaches in Indonesia
Irnasya Shafira (Monash University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper presents the findings of a PhD project that investigates the perceptions and reactions of the Indonesian public across different generations (Baby Boomers, Generation X, Millennials, and Generation Z) to persistent cyberattacks targeting citizens' personal data stored in government databases. The study aims to explore how these perceptions may influence the future of Indonesia's cybersecurity policy, particularly in terms of state conduct during relentless cyberattacks.

 

The research addresses three primary questions: (1) How do the Indonesian public perceive and react to government data breach incidents where citizens' personal data are stolen and sold on the dark web? (2) What factors drive these reactions? (3) What measures can the state take to address public concerns regarding stolen data in government data breach incidents?

 

To answer these questions, the research employs a mixed-method approach. In Phase 1, qualitative interviews were conducted with members of the Coalition for Personal Data Protection Advocacy (KA-PDP), which comprises 28 member organizations. Sixteen representatives, designated as 'experts,' were interviewed to gather in-depth insights into their perspectives on government data breaches. In Phase 2, a quantitative survey was deployed to assess whether the general public's sentiments align with those of the experts regarding reactions to government data breaches.

 

The findings reveal significant generational differences in how Indonesians perceive and react to data breaches. Baby Boomers and Generation X tend to exhibit higher levels of concern and demand stronger government action, while Millennials and Generation Z show a more nuanced understanding of digital privacy and data security issues. Factors influencing these reactions include the level of digital literacy, trust in government institutions, and previous experiences with data breaches.

 

The study also highlights the importance of transparent communication and proactive measures by the government to mitigate public concerns. Recommendations for policymakers include enhancing public awareness campaigns, improving data protection regulations, and establishing clear protocols for responding to data breaches. These measures are crucial for building public trust and ensuring the effectiveness of Indonesia's cybersecurity policies.

 

This research contributes to the broader discourse on data justice, privacy, and digital rights within Southeast Asia. By examining the Indonesian context, the study provides valuable insights into how these concepts are perceived and enacted in one of the region's largest countries. The findings offer a peripheral contextual understanding that can inform the panel's research questions on the translation and re-emergence of data justice, privacy, and digital rights in Southeast Asia's policies and political contentions.

 

In conclusion, this paper underscores the need for a comprehensive and inclusive approach to cybersecurity policy that considers the diverse perspectives of different generational cohorts. By addressing the public's concerns and fostering a culture of data protection, Indonesia can enhance its resilience against cyber threats and safeguard its citizens' personal data.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Uncertainties and ambiguities of the digital ecosystem of post-coup Myanmar
Myanmar Researcher KCL (King's College London, University of London)
CO-AUTHORS
James Burroughs (King's College London, University of London)
Thais Lobo (King's College London)
Elisa Oreglia (King's College London)
ABSTRACT

Four years after the 2021 military coup, Myanmar’s internet is characterized by persistent blackouts, prohibitive data prices, service blockages, censorship, and pervasive state surveillance imposed by the ruling regime. These challenges are further compounded by widespread economic hardship and declining public services, including frequent electricity shortages. Access to and use of digital services under these conditions have been analysed mostly from afar by media, civil society, and academia, focusing on shutdowns, ownership of infrastructure, laws and their implementation, and social media (e.g., Coppel & Chang, 2024; Faxon et al., 2023; Khine, 2023). Limitations to engagement with local communities and the lack of transparency in the digital sector—created by the country’s political instability, international sanctions, and ongoing civil war—have made it difficult to study both the hidden realities of ordinary citizens’ daily struggles to go online on the one hand, and of the back-end changes in ownership and operation of digital services on the other. Using a mixed-method approach, this paper proposes a ground-up understanding of how the invisible networks of technological materials and infrastructures and of geopolitical forces govern the digital experience of ordinary people. We argue that the layers of hidden material governance of digital lives are inscribing into digital technologies a set of values and biases that are tightly aligned with the current regime in power, but that will need to be better understood and unravelled when more democratic systems of governance can emerge in the country. Top-down understandings of the current situation fail to capture the nuances of the constraints users face, underscoring the need to bridge the gap between future policymakers and the realities of users. We illustrate the invisible governance of daily digital life with two examples from our project that studies the expansion of Chinese digital technologies outside of China. The first example draws from a year-long ethnography to study mobile phone practices of low-income users in Mandalay, examining how they navigate various barriers to maintain internet access, and the moral dilemmas that arise from wanting to boycott specific services, but being unable to access alternatives to services that introduce a high level of surveillance into their lives. Discussing the examples of MyTel, or the boycott of Chinese apps and devices, and of KBZPay use, we show how little choice, control, and knowledge ordinary users have over the tools they need to carry on with their lives. The second example draws from an exploration of the back-end connectivity of Myanmar’s most popular apps using a custom-made software, which showed an increasing presence of Chinese back-end services in apps that do not appear outwardly to have any connection with China or Chinese companies. Our work contributes to emerging discourses on digital governance in the Global South (Jiang & Belli, 2025) by taking a ground-up perspective on the effects of state and corporations’ governance and reflecting on the spaces for agency of both individuals and states that do not have sufficient capacity to influence global debates.

 

REFERENCES

 

Coppel, N., & Chang, L. Y. C. (2024). Myanmar’s Digital Coup: How the World Responded (1st ed. 2024). Springer International Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-58645-3

 

Faxon, H. O., Kintzi, K., Tran, V., Wine, K. Z., & Htut, S. Y. (2023). Organic Online Politics: Farmers, Facebook, and Myanmar’s Military Coup. Big Data & Society, 10(1), 205395172311681. https://doi.org/10.1177/20539517231168101

 

Jiang, M., & Belli, L. (Eds.). (2025). Digital Sovereignty in the BRICS Countries: How the Global South and Emerging Power Alliances Are Reshaping Digital Governance (1st ed.). Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009531085

 

Khine, N. K. (2023). Digital Rights in Post-coup Myanmar: Enabling Factors for Digital Authoritarianism. Journal of Human Rights and Peace Studies, 9(2), 186–216.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Enhancing Internet and Web Standards to address DNS Tampering
Siti Nurliza Samsudin (Sinar Project, Malaysia)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The Internet Monitoring Action Project (iMAP) releases annual reports on the state of internet censorship covering 9 countries in Southeast Asia (Burma, Cambodia, Indonesia, Philippines, Malaysia, Thailand, Vietnam), Hong Kong (China) and India using data from OONI (Open Observatory Network Interference). Findings from the report revealed that DNS tampering is the most commonly used method of blocking of websites in the region, whereby ISPs (internet service providers) would redirect the DNS to a blockpage. The findings also revealed that these blockpages are either empty, ‘NXDOMAIN’, or come with a written notice from a government authority about the website being blocked. In most of the cases, the blocking is conducted in a non-transparent manner without notification to either the website owners or users. From a security and internet engineering point of view, DNS tampering without any errors raised for host queries or visible notification in client interfaces such as web browsers may pose a security or engineering issue to clients and services, as they are redirected unexpectedly to an unknown address or page. This paper aims to discuss the potential solutions via extensions or updates to internet and web standards and implementations for DNS hijacking and tampering, specifically through RFCs documentation of the IETF.

 

In relation to the panel, the paper would depict some of the problems of current and past policies of technologies used for censorship in the region, as well as discuss possible solutions recommended by the IETF and to be implemented by policy actors.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - The mobilities of things on Shopee and Lazada: A study of logistics
Emma Baulch (Monash University, Malaysia Campus)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper studies the evolution of supply chains management and logistics models for e-commerce platforms, Shopee and Lazada. In it, I identify a focus on logistics as a entry point for understanding e-commerce platforms historically (in context of a long duree of mobilities of consumer goods along China-Southeast Asia, and inter-Southeast Asia, trade routes), political-economically (in context of changes to the political landscape of cross border trade and the nature of institutions implicated) and sociologically (in context of the social relations brought into focus by contestations and conflicts that irritate the smooth flow of capital).
 
Lazada and Shopee are business to business (B2B) and business to consumer (B2C) online marketplaces established in Singapore in 2012 and 2015 respectively. They vie for regional dominance commonly measured in terms of Gross Merchandise Value (GMV), with Shopee as the frontrunner across Southeast Asia since 2021. In recent years, both platforms have focussed their efforts to develop competitive advantage by building in-house logistics arms, involving significant property and equipment procurement across the region.
 
Logistics appears front and centre of trade journal literature on e-commerce, where it is presented as a simple problem of time and space management - most importantly the race to reduce delivery times and to address problems associated with last mile delivery, especially to remote areas. The threat presented by newcomer PRC-based platforms such as Shin and TEMU is also often treated as a logistical challenge. TEMU provides wrap around logistical support to traders - an option that may be limited for Southeast Asia based platforms due to regulatory push-back. For example, while consumers on Shopee and Lazada may still opt to select from a suite of third-party logistics providers, in May 2024 the Indonesian Competition Commission investigated both platforms for monopolistic acts, with respect to their preferential treatment of in-house logistics options.
 
Critical logistics scholarship, however, challenges the notion of logistics as an instrumental part of business processes, as it is presented in the trade press. In their introduction to the special issue of Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, titled Turbulent Circulation: Building a Critical Engagement with Logistics, Chua et al (2019) state:
 
                   “Logistics is not  reducible to a mundane science of cargo movement or a discrete industry among others. Rather,  as we argue below, it is better understood as a calculative rationality and a suite of spatial  practices aimed at facilitating circulation…. [L]ogistics….has profound social and spatial underpinnings and consequences…  [and contains]…  fragilities and unintended consequences of circulatory systems that are often understood as  unified and coherent.”
 
In this paper, I apply a critical logistics framework to explore the evolution of logistical models on Lazada and Shopee.  Using walk-throughs on both platforms that simulate the experiences of both traders and experiences, an in-depth analysis of the platforms’ websites and detailed guides, and an analysis of the trade press, the paper seeks to locate the evolution of Shopee and Lazada’s logistical models within a broader landscape of logistics in the region.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Digital identity, policy and rights in South/ Southeast Asia: A comparative analysis of India and Malaysia
Khetrimayum Monish Singh (Monash University, Malaysia Campus)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Digital technologies once began as experimental initiatives to support governance throughout Asia. Through several intermediary practices and third-party interests, it has now become a strategy and a critical component to transform the entire spectrum and experience of how governments and citizens interact with each other. The ubiquitous and pervasive use of the digital – devices, applications, platforms, biometrics, online transactions – has far reaching and significant social, political and policy implications for the region.

For instance, the current regime in India – through the ‘Digital India’ programme – has ambitious plans for a digital public infrastructure (DPI) using Aadhaar and Unified Payments Interface (UPI) to promote not only social development, but economic growth and the private sector as well. Similarly, several countries in South Asia (Nepal, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka), and South East Asia are either in the process of transitioning to, or implementing digital ID systems (Cambodia, Laos, Vietnam, etc.); or already have existing ones (Thailand, Philippines, Malaysia, Singapore, etc.) to promote social security, financial inclusion, foster regional trade and connectivity, and boost the digital economy. This is indicative not only of the digital transitions within governance and economy in the region, but also of emerging developmental policies, concerns and challenges around access and participation; and the converging dynamics between law and digital technology through regulation, legal debates around digital rights and data safeguards.

So, while mobile phones, platforms and apps have changed the entire experience of government public services, social interactions and financial transactions, it is equally important to critically engage and highlight what this political economy of the digital means – in terms of digital rights, data protection and privacy, and policy formulation – for the countries in South/ South East Asia. This also allows for a moment to rethink and explore the role of government and CSO led initiatives and programmes for S&T communication, digital literacy and awareness, tech advocacy, and collaborative technology policy formulation and implementation with local actors and communities.

Building on this framework and through empirical data, this paper will explore ongoing experiments of digital ID systems in India (Aadhaar) and Malaysia (MyKad, NDID/IDN, MyDigital ID app) to draw comparative linkages of digital technology adoption, implementation and the subsequent challenges of digital ID systems, to help elucidate the co-construction of socio-technical digital infrastructural developments through the everyday practices of data, data governance, tech advocacy and alliances around digital rights, and collaborative socio-technical work and efforts around technology policy in the contexts of South/ Southeast Asia.

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Who is afraid of Deep Seek? Imagined global AI futures, geopolitics, and data infrastructure projects in Malaysia
Stefan Bächtold (Monash University, Malaysia Campus)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In 2024, several Western big tech companies promised significant investments into Malaysia’s infrastructures for data centres, cloud computing, and artificial intelligence (AI) services. The Malaysian government has enthusiastically framed these investments in a policy discourse that imagines them as stepping stones to make the country into ‘Southeast Asia’s data centre’ – a techno-optimistic socio-technical imaginary that positions Malaysia as a regional hub for the current version of Silicon Valley-controlled global digital development and AI futures. This currently globally dominant version of AI futures relies on endless datafication of societies, intensive (and expensive) computing, and massive server farms. For countries like Malaysia, subscribing to this model of digital development and becoming part of the necessary data infrastructures comes with promises for significant investments, but also the promise to create thousands of jobs and to help local industry move up the global value chain by enhancing their AI capabilities.

However, in early 2025, the release of the Chinese company DeepSeek’s open-source large language model has created significant cracks in the dominant global imaginary for AI futures; as its model shows a similar performance to Western models, but for a fraction of the cost and computing power necessary to develop and run the former. This has not only burst the AI bubble of Western tech companies in terms of their stock value. It also points to alternative possibilities of AI futures that are not relying on the computing-intensive, Silicon Valley controlled model.

This paper uses the DeepSeek shock as an entry point to decentre the underpinning power relations of the currently (formerly?) dominant, computing-intensive, Western model of global digital development; as well as the socio-technical imaginaries it enables for countries like Malaysia. This is achieved by pointing out the discursive parallels of the Silicon-Valley-centric model of digital development to traditional Western development cooperation. My analysis of policy documents, company statements, and government press releases shows that both create and normalise a specific, techno-optimistic version of development that ties progress to an integration of the target country into global capitalist value chains – all while glossing over contradictions and rendering alternative, decentralised notions of development unthinkable.

Against this analysis, DeepSeek can not only be read as a shock to the hegemony of the current Silicon-Valley centric model of global digital development; but also as an event opening alternative paths for countries like Malaysia to navigate, balance, and hedge their position in the global geopolitical order – and to imagine and enact alternative, decentralised, AI futures.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Believe in Malaysia: (Re)negotiating trust on social media and chat apps
Niki Cheong (King's College London)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Countries like Malaysia have a tendency to adopt policy to manage and regulate digital content (particularly in online spaces such as social media and chat apps) borrowing from long-standing semi-authoritarian playbooks where zero-sum games reign supreme – what is allowed and what isn’t. These policies are often justified through the patriarchal lens of protecting its citizens from inappropriate and bad actors perceivably being a threat to both nation and individual citizens. However, scholars have argued that the state in itself have taken on these roles through hegemonic approaches in crafting policies where the media (digital and otherwise) is concerned.

 

In response, citizens have taken it upon themselves – whether personally or as part of civil society – to attempt to navigate said policies. One such approach is through the regaining of a sense of control (perceived or otherwise) through the ways they navigate digital spaces, including by relying on the features and affordances of social media and chat platforms. However, as the popular platforms – mostly developed and run in the Global North, such as Meta’s Facebook and Whatsapp, and Elon Musk’s takeover of Twitter and rebranding as X – increasingly adopt and adapt policies (and making changes at short notice) that are increasingly authoritarian, the nature of the discourse around this topic too needs addressing.

 

This paper draws on interviews conducted as part of several research projects between 2018 and 2025 related to the digital practices of Malaysian social media and chat app users across different generations to offer an empirical vantage point to some pertinent points of discussion. This includes young LGBTQ+ people’s reliance on platforms (which they already know are not always conducive to their needs but is the only resource available in the absence of familial and state support, as per platform capitalism); the use of “verified ticks” on social media accounts by first time voters as part of fact-checking processes; and how older users (e.g. Baby Boomers) renegotiate trust where information exchange is concerned on chat apps.

 

These examples highlight the importance of centring the practices and experiences of online users from a cultural and geo-political perspective in policy discourse – whether state-initiated or by tech platforms – particularly where citizens from the Global South are reliant on platforms from the Global North.

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - The Predatory Pricing Impact Analysis on E-Commerce Platforms towards the MSMEs in Indonesia
Dikara Alkarisya (Universitas Gadjah Mada)
CO-AUTHORS
Media Askar (Universitas Gadjah Mada)
Zakiya Pramestri (Norwegian University of Science and Technology)
ABSTRACT

The presence of e-commerce has the potential to provide opportunities for micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs) to develop their businesses, and it is the backbone of economic development because it can provide jobs and simultaneously facilitate inclusive growth (Owalla et al., 2022). In Indonesia, e-commerce is dominated by MSMEs at 98.2 percent. Of this percentage, MSMEs that are producers or active in producing goods are only around 6.28 percent. Meanwhile, MSMEs that act as resellers amount to 93.72 percent of the total number of MSMEs in Indonesia (Indef, 2024).

 

Behind the benefits offered by e-commerce, especially in developing countries, e-commerce does not always provide direct benefits for MSMEs. Businesses run by MSMEs often lag behind large companies, especially in maximizing e-commerce and other technologies ((Ahi et al., 2023); (Wijaya et al., 2025)). In addition to limitations in maximizing e-commerce platforms, MSMEs are also faced with the problem of a flood of foreign products sold in e-commerce at very low prices, or what is known as predatory pricing. Although the issue of predatory pricing is not new in the market, the presence of predatory pricing amid the increasing use of e-commerce in Indonesia is a challenge for MSME players.

 

The research framework departs from the problem when online predatory pricing events are rampant, resulting in losses for MSMEs, especially the productive sector. MSMEs submitted their complaints to the government that their merchandise on e-commerce platforms and offline stores did not experience an increase in sales or even lost money.

 

Two research questions are raised in this research: (1) how does predatory pricing in e-commerce impact the competitiveness of MSMEs in Indonesia? (2) Who are the e-commerce beneficiaries? This research is relevant to panel T15P06 and answers the panel’s research question: “What can we learn from past and present policies attempting to regulate the digital in Southeast Asia?”. Thus, a research focus emerged to analyze the impact of e-commerce on the competitiveness of MSMEs. Therefore, in formulating the theoretical framework for this study, the author adopts the e-commerce diffusion theory by Kraemer et al. (2006), Meier et al. (2025), which connects the impact of digital technology on competitiveness, and Baumann et al. (2019), which defines competitiveness for micro businesses. The competitiveness factors are MSMEs' capability, reducing cost, increasing the advantage, and expanding the business scope.

 

This research uses a qualitative method with a case study approach to analyze the impact of e-commerce based on the direct experience of MSMEs. Impact studies with a case study approach have an important role in understanding the conditions and events of an organization, institution, agency, or society. The data collection process is primarily done by directly visiting the MSME sites in several cities in Indonesia, particularly Java Island, filling out questionnaires, and conducting in-depth interviews with several sectors. The main sectors of this research are food and beverages, fashion, skincare, makeup, home furniture or tools, and kids’ toys.

 

The research aims to identify MSMEs’ e-commerce use process and its impact on their competitiveness. Furthermore, analyzing these stages will help analyze predatory pricing practices in Indonesia, which are considered detrimental to local businesses, and map who benefits from e-commerce platforms.

 

References

 

Ahi, A. A., Sinkovics, N., & Sinkovics, R. R. (2022). E-commerce policy and the global economy: A path to more inclusive development?. Management International Review, 63, 27–56. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11575-022-00490-1

 

Baumann, C., Cherry, M., & Chu, W. (2019). Competitive productivity (CP) at macro– meso–micro levels. Cross Cultural & Strategic Management, 26(2), 118-144. https://doi.org/10.1108/CCSM-08-2018-0118

 

Bingham, A. J. (2023). From data management to actionable findings: A five-phase process of qualitative data analysis. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 22, 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1177/16094069231183620

 

Indef. (2024). Laporan final: Peran platform digital terhadap pengembangan UMKM di Indonesia. https://indef.or.id/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Laporan-Final-Peran- Platform-Digital-Terhadap-Pengembangan-UMKM-di-Indonesia-INDEF.pdf

 

Kraemer, Kenneth & Dedrick, Jason & Melville, Nigel & Zhu, K.. (2006). Global e-commerce: Impacts of National Environment and Policy. 10.1017/CBO9780511488603.

 

Meier, A., Eller, R., & Peters, M. (2024). Creating competitiveness in incumbent small- and medium-sized enterprises: A revised perspective on digital transformation. Journal of Business Research, 186, 115028. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2024.115028

 

Owalla, B., Gherhes, C., Vorley, T. et al. Mapping SME productivity research: a systematic review of empirical evidence and future research agenda. Small Bus Econ 58, 1285– 1307 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-021-00450-3

 

Wijaya, L. I., Zunairoh, Z., Izharuddin, M., & Rianawati, A. (2025). Scope of e-commerce use, innovation capability, and performance: Food sector MSMEs in Indonesia. Journal of Open Innovation: Technology, Market, and Complexity, 11(100459). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joitmc.2024.100459

 



ACCEPTED
Format
11 - The institutionalization of open data in Cambodia: power, synergies and tensions between policy actors
Júlia García-Puig (Leiden University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Open data initiatives emerged as democratic innovations in Western democracies, praised for their potential to improve government transparency, accountability and democratic control, empower citizens and increase social participation (OECD, 2018; Ruijer et al., 2024; Ubaldi, 2013). However, open data policies and initiatives have been adopted in recent years by governments across Asia that do not abide by those same values or are reluctant to enhancing transparency and accountability, and hence, have prioritize other goals such as attracting foreign investment or improving international legitimacy (O’connor et al., 2019).

Amidst such a backdrop, I critique that the predominant Western-centric approach to open data overlooks other relevant factors and rationalities specific to the political and institutional contexts of Southeast Asia. In response, I propose a power lens to address the question of how the synergies and tensions between state and non-state policy actors shape the development of the open data policy in Cambodia. By building on Barnett & Duvall (2005), I define power as the capacity of an actor to influence the design and implementation of the open data policy. The analytical utility of power appears particularly relevant considering that data in the digital era has become a deeply political issue for the new kinds of value it brings to many actors (Mejias & Couldry, 2019). 

Cambodia’s first open data policy is currently underway as part of the Digital Economy and Society Policy Framework (2021–2035). Grassroots and civil society organizations in Cambodia have been particularly active at cultivating open data initiatives for over a decade, both locally and regionally. Therefore, there are now high expectations on the upcoming law that will institutionalize open data, and the potential public value it will generate. However, concerns exist related to the opportunities and capacities of non-state actors to effectively engage in policy-making. Such concerns are due to the poor transparency and accountability of the government, and the recent deteriorations in freedoms. The paper identifies i) the interests and preferences of national government, local civil society organizations, and national/international development organizations; ii) and the engagement strategies and mechanisms employed by them to influence the policy. The findings are based on the evidence gathered by conducting field research in Phnom Penh (semi-structured interviews, observation and document analysis). In addition, the findings seek to make a theoretical contribution by advancing the operationalization of the notion of power to study stakeholders' struggles around data policies. 

 

References

Barnett, M., & Duvall, R. (2005). Power in international politics. In International Organization (Vol. 59, Issue 1, pp. 39–75). https://doi.org/10.1017/S0020818305050010

Mejias, U. A., & Couldry, N. (2019). Datafication. INTERNET POLICY REVIEW Journal on Internet Regulation, 8(4). https://doi.org/10.14763/2019.4.1428

O’connor, K., Janenova, S., & Knox, C. (2019). Open government in authoritarian regimes. International Review of Public Policy, 1(1), 65–82. https://doi.org/10.4000/irpp.325

OECD. (2018). Open Government Data Report Enhancing Policy Maturity for Sustainable Impact. https://www.oecd.org/gov/digital-government/open-government-data-report-9789264305847-en.htm

Ruijer, E., Dymanus, C., van Kesteren, E. J., Boeschoten, L., & Meijer, A. (2024). Open data work for empowered deliberative democracy: Findings from a living lab study. Government Information Quarterly, 41(1). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.giq.2023.101902

Ubaldi, B. (2013). Open Government Data: Towards Empirical Analysis of Open Government Data Initiatives (22; OECD Working Papers on Public Governance). https://doi.org/10.1787/5k46bj4f03s7-en

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Analyses of local and regional digital developments could begin from the geographical reality of global neoliberal capitalism. Acclimatisation of Western digital platforms (e.g. Instagram, WhatsApp, automated systems, et cetera) within Southeast Asia’s developmental spaces not only provided new spatial-temporal affordances for society and industry. More importantly, these platforms, as the policymakers and business communities have been quite aware, embody a new phase in the neoliberal stage (and the future) of capital accumulation. In Malaysia, the political and capitalist classes see digital technology differently from the moments and struggles of geographically variegated everyday lives. Yet, this perspectival difference is never explained to be predicated upon the future of capital, but out of a proclaimed necessity of collective adaptation to a new ‘reality’. In policy terms, Malaysia’s capitalist-political class alliance has been ‘unifying’ and guiding the country’s historically-habitually diverse communities within a neoliberal spatial standardisation strategy for digital labour transformations, called the ‘Fourth Industrial Revolution’ (4IR) Policy, but consistently within the discourse of necessity: “to enjoy the benefits of a brighter tomorrow” and “through greater productivity.” This paper argues that the 4IR Policy is not merely a discursive product, but most importantly a spatial and spiritual one. The neoliberal digital policy wipes out geographically specific ways of everyday life across Malaysian regions in promulgating a new neoliberal ideology of the brighter digital future, and it presumes that Malaysian and Southeast Asian peoples do not have their own ideas of how their own digital adaptations could work. Such are the spatial-spiritual struggles between local peoples and a ‘standardising strategy’ amidst the spatial fix of global capitalism in Southeast Asia in the digital age. Critical researchers and geographers, practitioners, and especially members of the local younger generations, are invited to (re)think carefully about the region’s supposedly next ‘industrial revolution’, for the many non-neoliberal local ways, cultures, and joys.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The global race for AI regulation has intensified, with nations unveiling strategies to govern this transformative technology. Indonesia joined this race in 2020 by introducing its National Strategy on AI and a circular letter on AI Ethics. As of December 2024, the country is drafting a presidential regulation on AI Governance and developing a government regulation modeled after the EU’s Digital Markets Act and Digital Services Act. However, as previous research suggest, the global AI regulatory landscape remains dominated by resource-rich actors, raising questions about the power imbalances and imaginaries driving these regulations.

 

Against this backdrop, this study aims to examine how policies on AI are made in Indonesia. It explores the interplay between imaginaries, power, and the political and economic interests of key policy actors. This research contributes to non-Eurocentric perspectives on technology regulation, particularly by exploring a young democratic state, but is frequently criticized for adopting authoritarian practices in digital governance

 

The research reveals three initial findings through interviews, observations, and document analysis. First, the imaginaries of Indonesian policy actors regarding AI reflect the dual nature of emerging technologies, simultaneously evoking hopes and fears. On one hand, AI is envisioned as a driver of innovation and economic growth. On the other hand, concerns persist about job displacement and the emergence of economic monopolies. These competing imaginaries are not unique to Indonesia’s AI policy-making; the debate over technology versus human labor in the job sector has been a recurring global discourse. This narrative also frequently surfaces in broader discussions on Internet policy in Indonesia.

 

Second, these imaginaries are rooted in Indonesia’s socio-political history, particularly the New Order era (1965–1998), which established bureaucratic and elite-dominated governance practices. Despite democratic reforms, these practices persist, with government and elites maintaining significant control over policy-making. Emerging technologies like AI amplify these dynamics as multinational tech firms use their financial and knowledge resources to shape agendas, promoting narratives about the inevitability of technological progress and the need for innovation-driven regulation.

 

Third, power in Indonesia’s technology policy-making process is unevenly distributed. The government dominates decision-making through closed-door processes, while multinational tech companies play a key role in shaping the agenda during the early stages. Both actors frequently co-opt academics and civil society organizations (CSOs), aligning them with dominant narratives and limiting alternative imaginaries. This dynamic reinforces existing power structures, sidelining broader public interest concerns.

 

In conclusion, despite the novelty of emerging technologies, Indonesia’s policy-making processes remain rooted in elite-driven practices, heavily influenced by political and economic interests, as well as the advocacy of big tech firms. The tension between fostering innovation and imposing regulation reflects an ongoing power struggle, where economic elites push for minimal restrictions to maximize technological growth. As AI continues to evolve and Indonesia’s market expands, policy actors must critically assess the narratives surrounding regulation. AI governance should not be viewed as an end goal but as a tool to address societal challenges, balancing technological innovation with the public interest

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper presents the findings of a PhD project that investigates the perceptions and reactions of the Indonesian public across different generations (Baby Boomers, Generation X, Millennials, and Generation Z) to persistent cyberattacks targeting citizens' personal data stored in government databases. The study aims to explore how these perceptions may influence the future of Indonesia's cybersecurity policy, particularly in terms of state conduct during relentless cyberattacks.

 

The research addresses three primary questions: (1) How do the Indonesian public perceive and react to government data breach incidents where citizens' personal data are stolen and sold on the dark web? (2) What factors drive these reactions? (3) What measures can the state take to address public concerns regarding stolen data in government data breach incidents?

 

To answer these questions, the research employs a mixed-method approach. In Phase 1, qualitative interviews were conducted with members of the Coalition for Personal Data Protection Advocacy (KA-PDP), which comprises 28 member organizations. Sixteen representatives, designated as 'experts,' were interviewed to gather in-depth insights into their perspectives on government data breaches. In Phase 2, a quantitative survey was deployed to assess whether the general public's sentiments align with those of the experts regarding reactions to government data breaches.

 

The findings reveal significant generational differences in how Indonesians perceive and react to data breaches. Baby Boomers and Generation X tend to exhibit higher levels of concern and demand stronger government action, while Millennials and Generation Z show a more nuanced understanding of digital privacy and data security issues. Factors influencing these reactions include the level of digital literacy, trust in government institutions, and previous experiences with data breaches.

 

The study also highlights the importance of transparent communication and proactive measures by the government to mitigate public concerns. Recommendations for policymakers include enhancing public awareness campaigns, improving data protection regulations, and establishing clear protocols for responding to data breaches. These measures are crucial for building public trust and ensuring the effectiveness of Indonesia's cybersecurity policies.

 

This research contributes to the broader discourse on data justice, privacy, and digital rights within Southeast Asia. By examining the Indonesian context, the study provides valuable insights into how these concepts are perceived and enacted in one of the region's largest countries. The findings offer a peripheral contextual understanding that can inform the panel's research questions on the translation and re-emergence of data justice, privacy, and digital rights in Southeast Asia's policies and political contentions.

 

In conclusion, this paper underscores the need for a comprehensive and inclusive approach to cybersecurity policy that considers the diverse perspectives of different generational cohorts. By addressing the public's concerns and fostering a culture of data protection, Indonesia can enhance its resilience against cyber threats and safeguard its citizens' personal data.

CO-AUTHORS
James Burroughs (King's College London, University of London)
Thais Lobo (King's College London)
Elisa Oreglia (King's College London)
ABSTRACT

Four years after the 2021 military coup, Myanmar’s internet is characterized by persistent blackouts, prohibitive data prices, service blockages, censorship, and pervasive state surveillance imposed by the ruling regime. These challenges are further compounded by widespread economic hardship and declining public services, including frequent electricity shortages. Access to and use of digital services under these conditions have been analysed mostly from afar by media, civil society, and academia, focusing on shutdowns, ownership of infrastructure, laws and their implementation, and social media (e.g., Coppel & Chang, 2024; Faxon et al., 2023; Khine, 2023). Limitations to engagement with local communities and the lack of transparency in the digital sector—created by the country’s political instability, international sanctions, and ongoing civil war—have made it difficult to study both the hidden realities of ordinary citizens’ daily struggles to go online on the one hand, and of the back-end changes in ownership and operation of digital services on the other. Using a mixed-method approach, this paper proposes a ground-up understanding of how the invisible networks of technological materials and infrastructures and of geopolitical forces govern the digital experience of ordinary people. We argue that the layers of hidden material governance of digital lives are inscribing into digital technologies a set of values and biases that are tightly aligned with the current regime in power, but that will need to be better understood and unravelled when more democratic systems of governance can emerge in the country. Top-down understandings of the current situation fail to capture the nuances of the constraints users face, underscoring the need to bridge the gap between future policymakers and the realities of users. We illustrate the invisible governance of daily digital life with two examples from our project that studies the expansion of Chinese digital technologies outside of China. The first example draws from a year-long ethnography to study mobile phone practices of low-income users in Mandalay, examining how they navigate various barriers to maintain internet access, and the moral dilemmas that arise from wanting to boycott specific services, but being unable to access alternatives to services that introduce a high level of surveillance into their lives. Discussing the examples of MyTel, or the boycott of Chinese apps and devices, and of KBZPay use, we show how little choice, control, and knowledge ordinary users have over the tools they need to carry on with their lives. The second example draws from an exploration of the back-end connectivity of Myanmar’s most popular apps using a custom-made software, which showed an increasing presence of Chinese back-end services in apps that do not appear outwardly to have any connection with China or Chinese companies. Our work contributes to emerging discourses on digital governance in the Global South (Jiang & Belli, 2025) by taking a ground-up perspective on the effects of state and corporations’ governance and reflecting on the spaces for agency of both individuals and states that do not have sufficient capacity to influence global debates.

 

REFERENCES

 

Coppel, N., & Chang, L. Y. C. (2024). Myanmar’s Digital Coup: How the World Responded (1st ed. 2024). Springer International Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-58645-3

 

Faxon, H. O., Kintzi, K., Tran, V., Wine, K. Z., & Htut, S. Y. (2023). Organic Online Politics: Farmers, Facebook, and Myanmar’s Military Coup. Big Data & Society, 10(1), 205395172311681. https://doi.org/10.1177/20539517231168101

 

Jiang, M., & Belli, L. (Eds.). (2025). Digital Sovereignty in the BRICS Countries: How the Global South and Emerging Power Alliances Are Reshaping Digital Governance (1st ed.). Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009531085

 

Khine, N. K. (2023). Digital Rights in Post-coup Myanmar: Enabling Factors for Digital Authoritarianism. Journal of Human Rights and Peace Studies, 9(2), 186–216.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The Internet Monitoring Action Project (iMAP) releases annual reports on the state of internet censorship covering 9 countries in Southeast Asia (Burma, Cambodia, Indonesia, Philippines, Malaysia, Thailand, Vietnam), Hong Kong (China) and India using data from OONI (Open Observatory Network Interference). Findings from the report revealed that DNS tampering is the most commonly used method of blocking of websites in the region, whereby ISPs (internet service providers) would redirect the DNS to a blockpage. The findings also revealed that these blockpages are either empty, ‘NXDOMAIN’, or come with a written notice from a government authority about the website being blocked. In most of the cases, the blocking is conducted in a non-transparent manner without notification to either the website owners or users. From a security and internet engineering point of view, DNS tampering without any errors raised for host queries or visible notification in client interfaces such as web browsers may pose a security or engineering issue to clients and services, as they are redirected unexpectedly to an unknown address or page. This paper aims to discuss the potential solutions via extensions or updates to internet and web standards and implementations for DNS hijacking and tampering, specifically through RFCs documentation of the IETF.

 

In relation to the panel, the paper would depict some of the problems of current and past policies of technologies used for censorship in the region, as well as discuss possible solutions recommended by the IETF and to be implemented by policy actors.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper studies the evolution of supply chains management and logistics models for e-commerce platforms, Shopee and Lazada. In it, I identify a focus on logistics as a entry point for understanding e-commerce platforms historically (in context of a long duree of mobilities of consumer goods along China-Southeast Asia, and inter-Southeast Asia, trade routes), political-economically (in context of changes to the political landscape of cross border trade and the nature of institutions implicated) and sociologically (in context of the social relations brought into focus by contestations and conflicts that irritate the smooth flow of capital).
 
Lazada and Shopee are business to business (B2B) and business to consumer (B2C) online marketplaces established in Singapore in 2012 and 2015 respectively. They vie for regional dominance commonly measured in terms of Gross Merchandise Value (GMV), with Shopee as the frontrunner across Southeast Asia since 2021. In recent years, both platforms have focussed their efforts to develop competitive advantage by building in-house logistics arms, involving significant property and equipment procurement across the region.
 
Logistics appears front and centre of trade journal literature on e-commerce, where it is presented as a simple problem of time and space management - most importantly the race to reduce delivery times and to address problems associated with last mile delivery, especially to remote areas. The threat presented by newcomer PRC-based platforms such as Shin and TEMU is also often treated as a logistical challenge. TEMU provides wrap around logistical support to traders - an option that may be limited for Southeast Asia based platforms due to regulatory push-back. For example, while consumers on Shopee and Lazada may still opt to select from a suite of third-party logistics providers, in May 2024 the Indonesian Competition Commission investigated both platforms for monopolistic acts, with respect to their preferential treatment of in-house logistics options.
 
Critical logistics scholarship, however, challenges the notion of logistics as an instrumental part of business processes, as it is presented in the trade press. In their introduction to the special issue of Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, titled Turbulent Circulation: Building a Critical Engagement with Logistics, Chua et al (2019) state:
 
                   “Logistics is not  reducible to a mundane science of cargo movement or a discrete industry among others. Rather,  as we argue below, it is better understood as a calculative rationality and a suite of spatial  practices aimed at facilitating circulation…. [L]ogistics….has profound social and spatial underpinnings and consequences…  [and contains]…  fragilities and unintended consequences of circulatory systems that are often understood as  unified and coherent.”
 
In this paper, I apply a critical logistics framework to explore the evolution of logistical models on Lazada and Shopee.  Using walk-throughs on both platforms that simulate the experiences of both traders and experiences, an in-depth analysis of the platforms’ websites and detailed guides, and an analysis of the trade press, the paper seeks to locate the evolution of Shopee and Lazada’s logistical models within a broader landscape of logistics in the region.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Digital technologies once began as experimental initiatives to support governance throughout Asia. Through several intermediary practices and third-party interests, it has now become a strategy and a critical component to transform the entire spectrum and experience of how governments and citizens interact with each other. The ubiquitous and pervasive use of the digital – devices, applications, platforms, biometrics, online transactions – has far reaching and significant social, political and policy implications for the region.

For instance, the current regime in India – through the ‘Digital India’ programme – has ambitious plans for a digital public infrastructure (DPI) using Aadhaar and Unified Payments Interface (UPI) to promote not only social development, but economic growth and the private sector as well. Similarly, several countries in South Asia (Nepal, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka), and South East Asia are either in the process of transitioning to, or implementing digital ID systems (Cambodia, Laos, Vietnam, etc.); or already have existing ones (Thailand, Philippines, Malaysia, Singapore, etc.) to promote social security, financial inclusion, foster regional trade and connectivity, and boost the digital economy. This is indicative not only of the digital transitions within governance and economy in the region, but also of emerging developmental policies, concerns and challenges around access and participation; and the converging dynamics between law and digital technology through regulation, legal debates around digital rights and data safeguards.

So, while mobile phones, platforms and apps have changed the entire experience of government public services, social interactions and financial transactions, it is equally important to critically engage and highlight what this political economy of the digital means – in terms of digital rights, data protection and privacy, and policy formulation – for the countries in South/ South East Asia. This also allows for a moment to rethink and explore the role of government and CSO led initiatives and programmes for S&T communication, digital literacy and awareness, tech advocacy, and collaborative technology policy formulation and implementation with local actors and communities.

Building on this framework and through empirical data, this paper will explore ongoing experiments of digital ID systems in India (Aadhaar) and Malaysia (MyKad, NDID/IDN, MyDigital ID app) to draw comparative linkages of digital technology adoption, implementation and the subsequent challenges of digital ID systems, to help elucidate the co-construction of socio-technical digital infrastructural developments through the everyday practices of data, data governance, tech advocacy and alliances around digital rights, and collaborative socio-technical work and efforts around technology policy in the contexts of South/ Southeast Asia.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In 2024, several Western big tech companies promised significant investments into Malaysia’s infrastructures for data centres, cloud computing, and artificial intelligence (AI) services. The Malaysian government has enthusiastically framed these investments in a policy discourse that imagines them as stepping stones to make the country into ‘Southeast Asia’s data centre’ – a techno-optimistic socio-technical imaginary that positions Malaysia as a regional hub for the current version of Silicon Valley-controlled global digital development and AI futures. This currently globally dominant version of AI futures relies on endless datafication of societies, intensive (and expensive) computing, and massive server farms. For countries like Malaysia, subscribing to this model of digital development and becoming part of the necessary data infrastructures comes with promises for significant investments, but also the promise to create thousands of jobs and to help local industry move up the global value chain by enhancing their AI capabilities.

However, in early 2025, the release of the Chinese company DeepSeek’s open-source large language model has created significant cracks in the dominant global imaginary for AI futures; as its model shows a similar performance to Western models, but for a fraction of the cost and computing power necessary to develop and run the former. This has not only burst the AI bubble of Western tech companies in terms of their stock value. It also points to alternative possibilities of AI futures that are not relying on the computing-intensive, Silicon Valley controlled model.

This paper uses the DeepSeek shock as an entry point to decentre the underpinning power relations of the currently (formerly?) dominant, computing-intensive, Western model of global digital development; as well as the socio-technical imaginaries it enables for countries like Malaysia. This is achieved by pointing out the discursive parallels of the Silicon-Valley-centric model of digital development to traditional Western development cooperation. My analysis of policy documents, company statements, and government press releases shows that both create and normalise a specific, techno-optimistic version of development that ties progress to an integration of the target country into global capitalist value chains – all while glossing over contradictions and rendering alternative, decentralised notions of development unthinkable.

Against this analysis, DeepSeek can not only be read as a shock to the hegemony of the current Silicon-Valley centric model of global digital development; but also as an event opening alternative paths for countries like Malaysia to navigate, balance, and hedge their position in the global geopolitical order – and to imagine and enact alternative, decentralised, AI futures.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Countries like Malaysia have a tendency to adopt policy to manage and regulate digital content (particularly in online spaces such as social media and chat apps) borrowing from long-standing semi-authoritarian playbooks where zero-sum games reign supreme – what is allowed and what isn’t. These policies are often justified through the patriarchal lens of protecting its citizens from inappropriate and bad actors perceivably being a threat to both nation and individual citizens. However, scholars have argued that the state in itself have taken on these roles through hegemonic approaches in crafting policies where the media (digital and otherwise) is concerned.

 

In response, citizens have taken it upon themselves – whether personally or as part of civil society – to attempt to navigate said policies. One such approach is through the regaining of a sense of control (perceived or otherwise) through the ways they navigate digital spaces, including by relying on the features and affordances of social media and chat platforms. However, as the popular platforms – mostly developed and run in the Global North, such as Meta’s Facebook and Whatsapp, and Elon Musk’s takeover of Twitter and rebranding as X – increasingly adopt and adapt policies (and making changes at short notice) that are increasingly authoritarian, the nature of the discourse around this topic too needs addressing.

 

This paper draws on interviews conducted as part of several research projects between 2018 and 2025 related to the digital practices of Malaysian social media and chat app users across different generations to offer an empirical vantage point to some pertinent points of discussion. This includes young LGBTQ+ people’s reliance on platforms (which they already know are not always conducive to their needs but is the only resource available in the absence of familial and state support, as per platform capitalism); the use of “verified ticks” on social media accounts by first time voters as part of fact-checking processes; and how older users (e.g. Baby Boomers) renegotiate trust where information exchange is concerned on chat apps.

 

These examples highlight the importance of centring the practices and experiences of online users from a cultural and geo-political perspective in policy discourse – whether state-initiated or by tech platforms – particularly where citizens from the Global South are reliant on platforms from the Global North.

CO-AUTHORS
Media Askar (Universitas Gadjah Mada)
Zakiya Pramestri (Norwegian University of Science and Technology)
ABSTRACT

The presence of e-commerce has the potential to provide opportunities for micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs) to develop their businesses, and it is the backbone of economic development because it can provide jobs and simultaneously facilitate inclusive growth (Owalla et al., 2022). In Indonesia, e-commerce is dominated by MSMEs at 98.2 percent. Of this percentage, MSMEs that are producers or active in producing goods are only around 6.28 percent. Meanwhile, MSMEs that act as resellers amount to 93.72 percent of the total number of MSMEs in Indonesia (Indef, 2024).

 

Behind the benefits offered by e-commerce, especially in developing countries, e-commerce does not always provide direct benefits for MSMEs. Businesses run by MSMEs often lag behind large companies, especially in maximizing e-commerce and other technologies ((Ahi et al., 2023); (Wijaya et al., 2025)). In addition to limitations in maximizing e-commerce platforms, MSMEs are also faced with the problem of a flood of foreign products sold in e-commerce at very low prices, or what is known as predatory pricing. Although the issue of predatory pricing is not new in the market, the presence of predatory pricing amid the increasing use of e-commerce in Indonesia is a challenge for MSME players.

 

The research framework departs from the problem when online predatory pricing events are rampant, resulting in losses for MSMEs, especially the productive sector. MSMEs submitted their complaints to the government that their merchandise on e-commerce platforms and offline stores did not experience an increase in sales or even lost money.

 

Two research questions are raised in this research: (1) how does predatory pricing in e-commerce impact the competitiveness of MSMEs in Indonesia? (2) Who are the e-commerce beneficiaries? This research is relevant to panel T15P06 and answers the panel’s research question: “What can we learn from past and present policies attempting to regulate the digital in Southeast Asia?”. Thus, a research focus emerged to analyze the impact of e-commerce on the competitiveness of MSMEs. Therefore, in formulating the theoretical framework for this study, the author adopts the e-commerce diffusion theory by Kraemer et al. (2006), Meier et al. (2025), which connects the impact of digital technology on competitiveness, and Baumann et al. (2019), which defines competitiveness for micro businesses. The competitiveness factors are MSMEs' capability, reducing cost, increasing the advantage, and expanding the business scope.

 

This research uses a qualitative method with a case study approach to analyze the impact of e-commerce based on the direct experience of MSMEs. Impact studies with a case study approach have an important role in understanding the conditions and events of an organization, institution, agency, or society. The data collection process is primarily done by directly visiting the MSME sites in several cities in Indonesia, particularly Java Island, filling out questionnaires, and conducting in-depth interviews with several sectors. The main sectors of this research are food and beverages, fashion, skincare, makeup, home furniture or tools, and kids’ toys.

 

The research aims to identify MSMEs’ e-commerce use process and its impact on their competitiveness. Furthermore, analyzing these stages will help analyze predatory pricing practices in Indonesia, which are considered detrimental to local businesses, and map who benefits from e-commerce platforms.

 

References

 

Ahi, A. A., Sinkovics, N., & Sinkovics, R. R. (2022). E-commerce policy and the global economy: A path to more inclusive development?. Management International Review, 63, 27–56. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11575-022-00490-1

 

Baumann, C., Cherry, M., & Chu, W. (2019). Competitive productivity (CP) at macro– meso–micro levels. Cross Cultural & Strategic Management, 26(2), 118-144. https://doi.org/10.1108/CCSM-08-2018-0118

 

Bingham, A. J. (2023). From data management to actionable findings: A five-phase process of qualitative data analysis. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 22, 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1177/16094069231183620

 

Indef. (2024). Laporan final: Peran platform digital terhadap pengembangan UMKM di Indonesia. https://indef.or.id/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Laporan-Final-Peran- Platform-Digital-Terhadap-Pengembangan-UMKM-di-Indonesia-INDEF.pdf

 

Kraemer, Kenneth & Dedrick, Jason & Melville, Nigel & Zhu, K.. (2006). Global e-commerce: Impacts of National Environment and Policy. 10.1017/CBO9780511488603.

 

Meier, A., Eller, R., & Peters, M. (2024). Creating competitiveness in incumbent small- and medium-sized enterprises: A revised perspective on digital transformation. Journal of Business Research, 186, 115028. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2024.115028

 

Owalla, B., Gherhes, C., Vorley, T. et al. Mapping SME productivity research: a systematic review of empirical evidence and future research agenda. Small Bus Econ 58, 1285– 1307 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-021-00450-3

 

Wijaya, L. I., Zunairoh, Z., Izharuddin, M., & Rianawati, A. (2025). Scope of e-commerce use, innovation capability, and performance: Food sector MSMEs in Indonesia. Journal of Open Innovation: Technology, Market, and Complexity, 11(100459). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joitmc.2024.100459

 



CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Open data initiatives emerged as democratic innovations in Western democracies, praised for their potential to improve government transparency, accountability and democratic control, empower citizens and increase social participation (OECD, 2018; Ruijer et al., 2024; Ubaldi, 2013). However, open data policies and initiatives have been adopted in recent years by governments across Asia that do not abide by those same values or are reluctant to enhancing transparency and accountability, and hence, have prioritize other goals such as attracting foreign investment or improving international legitimacy (O’connor et al., 2019).

Amidst such a backdrop, I critique that the predominant Western-centric approach to open data overlooks other relevant factors and rationalities specific to the political and institutional contexts of Southeast Asia. In response, I propose a power lens to address the question of how the synergies and tensions between state and non-state policy actors shape the development of the open data policy in Cambodia. By building on Barnett & Duvall (2005), I define power as the capacity of an actor to influence the design and implementation of the open data policy. The analytical utility of power appears particularly relevant considering that data in the digital era has become a deeply political issue for the new kinds of value it brings to many actors (Mejias & Couldry, 2019). 

Cambodia’s first open data policy is currently underway as part of the Digital Economy and Society Policy Framework (2021–2035). Grassroots and civil society organizations in Cambodia have been particularly active at cultivating open data initiatives for over a decade, both locally and regionally. Therefore, there are now high expectations on the upcoming law that will institutionalize open data, and the potential public value it will generate. However, concerns exist related to the opportunities and capacities of non-state actors to effectively engage in policy-making. Such concerns are due to the poor transparency and accountability of the government, and the recent deteriorations in freedoms. The paper identifies i) the interests and preferences of national government, local civil society organizations, and national/international development organizations; ii) and the engagement strategies and mechanisms employed by them to influence the policy. The findings are based on the evidence gathered by conducting field research in Phnom Penh (semi-structured interviews, observation and document analysis). In addition, the findings seek to make a theoretical contribution by advancing the operationalization of the notion of power to study stakeholders' struggles around data policies. 

 

References

Barnett, M., & Duvall, R. (2005). Power in international politics. In International Organization (Vol. 59, Issue 1, pp. 39–75). https://doi.org/10.1017/S0020818305050010

Mejias, U. A., & Couldry, N. (2019). Datafication. INTERNET POLICY REVIEW Journal on Internet Regulation, 8(4). https://doi.org/10.14763/2019.4.1428

O’connor, K., Janenova, S., & Knox, C. (2019). Open government in authoritarian regimes. International Review of Public Policy, 1(1), 65–82. https://doi.org/10.4000/irpp.325

OECD. (2018). Open Government Data Report Enhancing Policy Maturity for Sustainable Impact. https://www.oecd.org/gov/digital-government/open-government-data-report-9789264305847-en.htm

Ruijer, E., Dymanus, C., van Kesteren, E. J., Boeschoten, L., & Meijer, A. (2024). Open data work for empowered deliberative democracy: Findings from a living lab study. Government Information Quarterly, 41(1). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.giq.2023.101902

Ubaldi, B. (2013). Open Government Data: Towards Empirical Analysis of Open Government Data Initiatives (22; OECD Working Papers on Public Governance). https://doi.org/10.1787/5k46bj4f03s7-en