Format

P02. Politics of Development Cooperation: From North to South

POLICY, POLITICS AND POLITICAL REGIME
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Xiaoye She
California State University San Marcos
Main chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
POLICY, POLITICS AND POLITICAL REGIME
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

The United Nations defines development cooperation as activities specifically aimed at supporting national or international development goals, carried out on a non-profit basis, with a focus on developing countries, and grounded in cooperative relationships that encourage local ownership (UNECOSOC, 2015). Since the end of the Cold War, foreign aid from countries in the global North, typically in the form of official development assistance (ODA), as well as grants and loans from multilateral development finance institutions (DFIs) such as the World Bank and regional development banks, have dominated global development cooperation. However, recent shifts are challenging the longstanding dominance of the global North. These shifts include the rise of the BRICS nations and other emerging powers, the establishment of new DFIs like the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB) and the New Development Bank (NDB), the resurgence of South-South Cooperation (SSC) strategies among countries in the Global South, and new forms of triangular development cooperation (TDC) among global North and South partners.

 

This panel proposes an analysis of the expanding and increasingly diverse landscape of development cooperation, focusing on bilateral, triangular, and multilateral partnerships involving the global North, emerging donors, and the Global South. At the international level, the analysis will explore how state and non-state actors are navigating the growing complexity of development cooperation, including shifting power dynamics within these partnerships. Drawing from the concept of regime complexity in international relations, this panel builds on the idea that a regime complex is “an array of partially overlapping and non-hierarchical institutions governing a particular issue area” (Raustiala & Victor, 2004). Contributing factors to regime complexity may include misaligned power structures in existing global governance frameworks and the proliferation of new institutions in response to these imbalances (Pratt, 2018). In this context, states and non-state actors often employ strategies such as forum shopping, regime shifting, and contested multilateralism to respond to these complexities (Alter & Raustiala, 2018; Morse & Keohane, 2014). The expansion of new development cooperation partnerships provides opportunities to explore how these strategies are being applied in practice.

 

Domestically, we propose to examine the domestic context of state and non-state actors, focusing on factors such as political regimes, economic and social transformations, and prevailing development norms and discourses. While much of the existing literature has focused on the domestic politics of foreign aid in developed democracies and countries of the global North (Breuning, 1999; Dadabaev, 2016; de Felice, 2015; Faust & Koch, 2014; Gibson et al., 2005; Molenaers et al., 2015; Tingley, 2010), a growing body of work is also emerging on the domestic processes shaping bilateral development cooperation in more powerful countries in the Global South, including China, Brazil, Turkey, and others(Farias, 2019; Huang, 2014; Kavakli, 2018; Scoones et al., 2016; Shi & Hoebink, 2019; van der Westhuizen & Milani, 2019; Varrall, 2016). This panel seeks to extend these analyses beyond the traditional North-South aid framework and case studies of emerging powers, exploring the domestic political dynamics that drive development cooperation in increasingly complex and multi-actor partnerships across the North and the South.

 

This panel seeks to address the following research questions:

1.      How can we conceptualize the increasing diversity and complexity of development cooperation partnerships among the North, emerging powers, and the broader Global South?

2.      What underlying determinants lead states or non-state actors to prioritize particular development cooperation policies and partnership modalities over others?

3.      Which structural and agency-driven factors contribute to the observed proliferation and diversification of these policies and partnerships, particularly new forms of SSC and TDC?

 

Empirically, we invite papers that use comparative or case study methodologies to identify the conditions, actors, and strategies that influence the proliferation and variation of development cooperation policies and partnerships. To encourage cross-regional comparisons and potential collaborations, we welcome submissions that explore the different actors, conditions, and strategies shaping development cooperation across various regions of the world.

 

References

Alter, K. J., & Raustiala, K. (2018). The Rise of International Regime Complexity. Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 14(1), 329–349. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-lawsocsci-101317-030830

Breuning, M. (1999). Ethnopolitical Parties and Development Cooperation: The Case of Belgium. Comparative Political Studies, 32(6), 724–751. https://doi.org/10.1177/0010414099032006003

Dadabaev, T. (2016). Japan’s ODA assistance scheme and Central Asian engagement: Determinants, trends, expectations. Journal of Eurasian Studies, 7(1), 24–38. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.euras.2015.10.002

de Felice, D. (2015). Diverging Visions on Political Conditionality: The Role of Domestic Politics and International Socialization in French and British Aid. World Development, 75, 26–45. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2015.01.010

Farias, D. B. (2019). Brazil’s South–South development cooperation: Principles and experiences of the domestic bureaucracy. Public Administration and Development, 39(4–5), 174–181. https://doi.org/10.1002/pad.1825

Faust, Jj., & Koch, S. (2014). Foreign Aid and the Domestic Politics of European Budget Support. SSRN Electronic Journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2476316

Gibson, C. C., Andersson, K., Ostrom, E., & Shivakumar, S. (2005). The Samaritan’s Dilemma: The Political Economy of Development Aid (1st ed.). Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/0199278857.001.0001

Huang, Y. (2014). Domestic Politics and China’s Health Aid to Africa. China: An International Journal, 12(3), 176–198. https://doi.org/10.1353/chn.2014.0031

Kavakli, K. C. (2018). Domestic Politics and the Motives of Emerging Donors: Evidence from Turkish Foreign Aid. Political Research Quarterly, 71(3), 614–627. https://doi.org/10.1177/1065912917750783

Molenaers, N., Dellepiane, S., & Faust, J. (2015). Political Conditionality and Foreign Aid. World Development, 75, 2–12. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2015.04.001

Morse, J., & Keohane, R. (2014). Contested Multilateralism. The Review of International Organizations, 9. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11558-014-9188-2

Pratt, T. (2018). Deference and Hierarchy in International Regime Complexes. International Organization, 72(3), 561–590. Cambridge Core. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0020818318000164

Raustiala, K., & Victor, D. G. (2004). The Regime Complex for Plant Genetic Resources. International Organization, 58(2), 277–309.

Scoones, I., Amanor, K., Favareto, A., & Qi, G. (2016). A New Politics of Development Cooperation? Chinese and Brazilian Engagements in African Agriculture. China and Brazil in African Agriculture, 81, 1–12. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2015.11.020

Shi, X., & Hoebink, P. (2019). From Chengdu to Kampala: The Role of Subnational Actors in China’s Foreign Aid. Journal of Contemporary China, 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1080/10670564.2019.1621534

Tingley, D. (2010). Donors and domestic politics: Political influences on foreign aid effort. The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 50(1), 40–49. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.qref.2009.10.003

UNECOSOC. (2015). 2016 Development Cooperation Forum Policy Briefs. United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs. https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=2ahUKEwiTpp2BjcTzAhUsDjQIHU3QCJ0QFnoECAkQAw&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.un.org%2Fen%2Fecosoc%2Fnewfunct%2Fpdf15%2F2016_dcf_policy_brief_no.1.pdf&usg=AOvVaw2sGn0ScBwfgbELw7VK8Kee

van der Westhuizen, J., & Milani, C. R. S. (2019). Development cooperation, the international–domestic nexus and the graduation dilemma: Comparing South Africa and Brazil. Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 32(1), 22–42. https://doi.org/10.1080/09557571.2018.1554622

Varrall, M. (2016). Domestic actors and agendas in Chinese aid policy. The Pacific Review, 29(1), 21–44. https://doi.org/10.1080/09512748.2015.1066414

CALL FOR PAPERS

The landscape of development cooperation—including traditional North-South aid, South-South Cooperation (SSC), and Triangular Development Cooperation (TDC)—has grown increasingly complex. This complexity arises from a proliferation of state and non-state actors, intensifying geopolitical rivalries, and the dynamic and expanding roles of Global South countries, often driven by a combination of strategic self-interest and solidarity. This panel proposes an analysis of the expanding and increasingly diverse landscape of development cooperation, focusing on structures, agencies, and strategies of states and non-state actors in bilateral, triangular, and multilateral partnerships involving the global North, emerging donors, and the Global South.

 

We seek to address the following research questions:

1.      How can we conceptualize the increasing diversity and complexity of development cooperation partnerships among the North, emerging powers, and the broader Global South?

2.      What underlying determinants lead states or non-state actors to prioritize particular development cooperation policies and partnership modalities over others?

3.      Which structural and agency-driven factors contribute to the observed proliferation and diversification of these policies and partnerships, particularly new forms of SSC and TDC?


Drawing on case studies from countries and regions around the world, the panel examines how states and non-state actors navigate the intensifying complexity of development cooperation, shaped by factors including but not limited to domestic political considerations, economic imperatives, foreign policy objectives, and prevailing development norms and discourses.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Bridging Nations through Governance: A Network Perspective on the Belt and Road Initiative
Xinwei Chen (Zhengzhou Normal University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Since its launch in 2013, China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has been analysed primarily through geopolitical and geo-economic lenses, emphasising its role in reshaping global power dynamics and promoting economic integration. However, such views often overlook the governance dynamics that are central to the implementation of the BRI in partner countries. This paper adopts a governance perspective and examines the complex network of actors -- including non-state entities, local stakeholders and private sector participants -- involved in BRI projects. Through an analysis of transport-related BRI projects, we show that the BRI operates within a flexible, network-based governance model, in contrast to China's traditional hierarchical approach. This study highlights the BRI not only as an instrument of state influence, but also as a platform for inclusive engagement and adaptive policymaking.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Triangular Cooperation in Southeast Asia: Juggling between North and South
Xiaoye She (California State University San Marcos)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Triangular development cooperation (TDC) is a growing form of development assistance that involves a traditional donor, an emerging country, and a beneficiary or recipient. While much research has focused on the power dynamics within TDC partnerships and the role of emerging countries, the analysis often centers on BRICS nations and TDC trends in Latin America, the Middle East, and Africa. This paper explores the evolving TDC patterns in Southeast Asia, highlighting middle powers and smaller states such as Indonesia, Thailand, Malaysia, and the Philippines. I argue that emerging Southeast Asian countries have played a significant role in expanding TDC efforts both within and beyond the region. They have also diversified their TDC strategies by engaging in multilateralism, traditional North-South partnerships, and newer South-South Cooperation platforms. However, their TDC agency is sometimes limited by shifting domestic political landscapes and foreign policy priorities.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Shifting Power Dynamics in Development Cooperation: The Rise of the Global South
AKM Ullah (Institute of Policy Studies, Universiti Brunei Darussalam)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The traditional paradigm of development cooperation, dominated by North-South aid flows, is undergoing a significant transformation with the rise of emerging economies from the Global South. Countries like China, India, and Brazil have increasingly positioned themselves as key players in development cooperation, challenging the monopoly of traditional donors from the Global North. This research examines the shifting power dynamics in development cooperation, focusing on the strategies, priorities, and impacts of South-South cooperation compared to North-South frameworks. It explores how emerging donors leverage economic partnerships, infrastructure investments, and conditionality-free aid to redefine the norms and practices of global development.
Using case studies from Africa and Asia, the research analyzes the geopolitical implications of this shift, particularly in regions where Northern and Southern donors compete for influence. It critically evaluates whether South-South cooperation represents a more equitable and sustainable model or perpetuates new forms of dependency. Additionally, the study considers how these changing dynamics impact multilateral institutions, development financing, and recipient countries' agency. By addressing the growing complexities of development cooperation, this research aims to provide insights into the evolving roles and relationships within the global development landscape, highlighting the implications for policy and practice in the 21st century.
Keywords: Development Cooperation, South-South Cooperation, Global South, Power Dynamics, Geopolitical Influence

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - EU-Africa Relations and the Coloniality of Money: Analysing funding and financing
Anissa Bougrea (Universiteit Gent)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The status of coloniality in EU-Africa relations is ambivalent. Scholars and some practitioners agree on the persistent vestiges of colonialism in this relationship, while diplomats commit to the idea of an ‘equal partnership’. While overt coloniality has become marginalised, this paper focuses on the elusive dynamics of coloniality: funding and financing. This paper theorises the coloniality of money in EU-Africa relations, focusing on how colonial legacies shape power dynamics, decision-making, and institutional practices, using a decolonial lens centred on the ‘coloniality of power’. We scrutinise how EU institutions reproduce Eurocentric worldviews and power imbalances, despite EU rhetoric advocating for equity and pragmatism. We illustrate how Eurocentric practices legitimise ongoing colonial projects and perpetuate racial and economic hierarchies through money-based partnerships. It investigates the strategies employed by African states and institutions to assert agency, and how African countries leverage alternative partnerships, exploit institutional overlaps, and renegotiate rules and standards to challenge Eurocentric financial practices. The paper combines decolonial theory with an empirical analysis of three aspects of EU-Africa relations: institutions, rules and standards, and diplomatic practices. Case studies include the Organization of African, Caribbean, and Pacific States (OACPS), the EU-African Union (EU-AU) partnership, the European Investment Bank (EIB), and the European Peace Facility. By combining detailed empirical case studies with a close re-reading of debates on coloniality and decolonization, we argue that understanding the interplay of money, power, and coloniality is vital.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - RETHINKING THE EUROPEAN PROJECT THROUGH PAN-AFRICAN NARRATIVES
Jan Orbie (Ghent University )
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Official history and historiography of European integration – let alone of Europe as a social, geographical, cultural entity –, has long-time been polished through a selection of conventional narratives (Manners and Murray 2016). Such narratives have until recently omitted to account for the specific experiences of Europe by Africans and people of African descent (Afro-descendants). Yet the historical development of Europe, and of the European integration process leading to the European Union (EU) today, happened in strong relation to political, economic and social processes in the African continent, in triangulation with developments in the Americas (Rodney 1973; Hansen and Jonsson 2014; Dimier 2014).
In connection with works aiming to decentre Europe (Fisher Onar and Nikolaïdis 2013; Keukeleire & Lecocq 2018) and EU narratives about its own history and historiography, and to propose a decolonial project for Europe (Bhambra 2022), we focus here on Pan-Africanism as a (diverse) political and philosophical movement whose links with Europe have been largely neglected. If Pan-Africanism has the purpose for Africans and Afro-descendants to claim back centrality in their political, economic, social choices – reclaiming full democratic sovereignty over African countries –, this endeavour comes in reaction against historical and current actions by other political and social entities, particularly “EUrope”, with its specific ties (euphemistically called “special relationship”) with the African continent. Taking stock of McEachrane’s work on Pan-Africanism in a European context (McEachrane 2020), we aim here to critically understand and ‘provincialize’ the EUropean project by engaging with Pan-African activists and thinkers. Our research question then reads, how do Pan-African narratives conceive of the EUropean project?
Our analysis follows a two-pronged approach. First, we analyze ‘Pan-Africanism from below’ (Mampilly 2024), focusing on activists within the Pan-African League Umoja (LP-U). Pan-Africanism from below is being revived among African diasporas in Europe, in connection with Africans on the continent, since the beginning of the 2010s, through the creation of new Pan-Africanist organisations. Second, we analyze ‘Pan-Africanism from above’ in terms of the key thinkers that continue to inform current activism. This is connected to the LP-U analysis, as their narratives are remarkably similar to, and nurtures itself abundantly of, iconic historical Pan-Africanist thinkers. Such a nurtured presence shows the continued relevance of these figures and their ideas, some of which are being rediscovered (ex: Diop): LP-U analyses of current African issues are often proposed in direct conjunction with the analyses made by key Pan-Africanists in different historical contexts.
 

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Why Do Collaborative Arrangements Fail? A Multi-Method Analysis of Public-Private Partnerships in Development Cooperation
Angela Samuel (Vienna University of Economics and Business)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Public-private partnerships (PPPs) have become a prominent strategy for delivering public goods and infrastructure, often seen as a mechanism to enhance efficiency, innovation, and resource mobilization. They are increasingly used in development cooperation, where collaboration between governments and private sector actors addresses key challenges, particularly in the development of public infrastructure. However, despite their potential, many PPPs encounter significant obstacles and fail to deliver intended outcomes.

 

This study investigates the factors that contribute to the failure of PPPs, particularly in development cooperation contexts involving North-South partnerships, using a mixed-method approach. More specifically, it addresses the following research question: "What are the key political, governance, and institutional barriers undermining the success of collaborative arrangements like PPPs?" By combining quantitative and qualitative methods, this study provides a comprehensive view of the operational and contextual challenges faced by such partnerships.

           

The quantitative analysis draws from an integrated dataset that includes the World Bank's Private Participation in Infrastructure (PPI) project database, the World Governance Index (WGI), and regime classifications from Our World in Data. Additional data on failed projects is gathered from media reports, court documents, and official company statements to identify reasons for cancellations. In parallel, qualitative insights are obtained through interviews with experts and practitioners involved in the planning and oversight of PPPs. These interviews provide context-specific knowledge that complements the quantitative findings, shedding light on governance dynamics and operational challenges that are difficult to capture through archival data alone.

           

Preliminary results suggest that political barriers often arise from the tradeoffs inherent to different political regimes. For example, authoritarian regimes struggle with high levels of corruption, while democratic regimes experience regulatory delays to more extensive oversight – both of which hinder collaborations. In democracies, project cancellations often stem from regulatory delays such as land acquisition or environmental clearances. Across political regimes, financial constraints consistently affect project viability.

       

This study contributes to the literature on development cooperation by offering a novel perspective that highlights specific pathways through which governance, economic stability, and institutional quality collectively shape PPP outcomes. The combination of quantitative data and qualitative insights enriches our understanding of how political and institutional structures influence collaboration viability across different regimes. This study provides practical insights for policymakers, development practitioners, and private sector actors aiming to design more resilient and sustainable collaborative partnerships. By identifying key barriers to success, it offers actionable recommendations for strengthening governance structures and mitigating risks in PPPs, particularly in contexts marked by diverse and evolving development cooperation arrangements between the North, South, and emerging economies.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Donors and the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights: Insights from Indonesia
Andrew Rosser (University of Melbourne)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In 2011, the United Nations (UN) Human Rights Council (HRC) endorsed the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (UNGPs) to combat corporate abuses of human rights. Emphasising ‘a proactive role for the state’ (Ramasastry 2015: 247), they call on states to foster measures to cultivate business respect for human rights and, in particular, to formulate and implement laws, regulations, and policies on business and human rights (BHR). The HRC has actively promoted this agenda, supported by many donor governments and international organisations, including the European Union, Scandinavian governments and UNDP. Yet assessments suggest that states have moved slowly and inconsistently to adopt and implement the UNGPs, especially in the Global South, while in some cases donors themselves have been accused of facilitating breaches of the UNGPs. What explains this outcome? What have been the obstacles to state adoption and implementation of the UNGPs? Under what conditions have states adopted and implemented the UNGPs? What can government, business, and civil society actors do to compel states to go further in implementing these norms? And why have some donors been accused of enabling breaches of the UNGPs? This paper seeks to address these questions focusing on the case of Indonesia. It argues that the primary obstacle to UNGP implementation in Indonesia has been power asymmetries between politico-business and technocratic elites, on the one hand, and rights coalitions, on the other. At the same time, the latter have been able to make some headway in promoting UNGP implementation where they have leveraged market forces in their favour. This has served to narrow power asymmetries, albeit with different effects on the form of implementation depending on the history of struggle over business and human rights in the relevant domain and the extent of high-level political support. Donors have attracted criticism for facilitating breaches of the UNGPs when they have backed dominant politico-business coalitions in struggles with poor and marginalised elements and rights coalitions over the social or environmental impact of the projects they have funded. In terms of strategy for promoting UNGP implementation, the paper thus argues that Indonesia’s experience suggests that donors’ and others’ efforts to promote UNGP implementation need to go beyond measures of socialization and learning to focus on enabling rights coalitions to confront corporate power. This approach includes ensuring supporting the monitoring and mobilizational capacities of these coalitions over time and, to the extent that hard law responses by states are considered desirable, facilitating their ability to forge alliances with sympathetic elements in the state apparatus. Donors also need to maximise independence from elite coalitions.

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Situating the Public in Public Policies: The UNDP’s Role in Humanizing Development
vipul verma (Jawaharlal Nehru University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The paper examines the transformative role of the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) in shifting the development discourse from traditional macroeconomic indicators to a human-centred approach, as exemplified by the Human Development Report (HDR). UNDP's HDR interventions primarily focused on the vital aspects of human well-being: health, education, and standard of living(Conceição, 2020). Later, the Millennium Development Goals and Sustainable Development Goals were formulated, building on the Human-centric development discourse.  The introduction of the HDR marked a pivotal change, positioning people at the core of development strategies and influencing governments worldwide, including India, to re-evaluate their policy frameworks.

 

This study aims to analyze the following research questions:

 

1. How did the UNDP's HDR influence the redefinition of development among international organizations and member states, including India?


2. In what ways have the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) evolved from the principles established by the HDR, and what role has the UNDP played in this transition?


3. How do contemporary public policies in various countries, including India, reflect the impact of UNDP's human development approach on global governance and responses to pressing issues such as poverty, health, and climate change?


By exploring these questions, this paper particularly highlights the UNDP's pivotal role in promoting people-centred development, the continued relevance of the HDR framework in guiding policy formulation worldwide, and the relevance of such International Organizations in general in today's world. 

 

Keywords: UNDP, human development, HDR, SDGs, global governance.
 
 

References:

 

Conceição, P. (2020). Human development report 2020-the next frontier: Human development and the Anthropocene. United Nations Development Programme: Human Development Report.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - The reception of development aid policies in sub-Saharan Africa: from cyclical to structural
Antoine Thierry MVONDO OLONGO (Pan African University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

       The aim of this study is to analyze a very specific sequence in the circuit of development aid policies for sub-Saharan Africa: The reception of these policies within African states. The reception of public policies can be understood as a set of processes by which a public policy is appropriated and co-constructed by its constituents, and by which it produces its effects on them. It is therefore an active process of co-production and learning. Since the end of the Second World War, an international governance system for development aid has been established. “Donor countries” and other financial backers, generally from the northern hemisphere, transfer resources and aid flows to “recipient” countries in the southern hemisphere. This North-South development cooperation has been widely criticized for its inefficiency. Since 2005, for example, with the Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness, the principles of coordination, harmonization, alignment and mutual accountability have been integrated into the implementation of development aid policies, with the aim of achieving more positive results. This has not prevented the rise of South-South cooperation, which is supposed to be more effective, less costly and, above all, more sincere in its desire to make a significant contribution to the development of weaker economies.

      Il these two configurations of development cooperation, African states are “multi-situated”, i.e they are involved in co-production and implementation processes at different scales. Similarly, they are the main recipients and beneficiaries of these multiple development initiatives. Thus, at territorial level, we can distinguish several types of stakeholders: public administrations civil society organizations and local communities. We are thus in the presence of a differentiated reception of development aid, which becomes even denser when it takes concrete form in specific sectors of public life. In this article, we take a closer look at the differentiated reception of aid policies in the education and health sectors in Cameroon. Analyzing these reception processes through the lens of comprehensive sociology seems relevant to us, as we are increasingly witnessing the strong integration of these development projects and programs into the public policy matrix of states in Sub-Saharan Africa. In this way, international development initiatives that are supposed to be part of a specific timeframe end up structuring African public policies over the long term.

 

Key words: Reception of public policies, development policy, development aid, Sub-Saharan Africa, education, Health

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - Development Cooperation for the Circular Economy in the Agri-Food Sector: Perspectives from India and VietNam
Camelia Adriana Bucatariu (University of Bucharest)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper examines the role of development cooperation in advancing the circular economy (CE) in the agri-food sector, focusing on collaboration between the European Union (EU) and two Asian countries—India and Vietnam. The research question is: How can EU-Asia development cooperation foster the adoption of circular economy practices in the agri-food sector? To address this question, the study employs a mixed-methods approach, combining policy analysis and case studies. Case studies of EU-funded projects, such as SWITCH-Asia programs in India and Vietnam, are examined to assess their socio-economic impacts.

 

The findings indicate that while the European Union's expertise in policy design and technology transfer has, to some extent, facilitated the adoption of circular economy (CE) practices in Asia, significant barriers remain, including fragmented policies, limited connection to the private sector to facilitate investments, and cultural and institutional resistance.

 

The paper underscores the necessity of aligning regulatory frameworks, increasing public-private partnerships for investment, and clarifying how digital technologies can support scalability for circular economy practices.

 

By identifying synergies and gaps in EU-Asia cooperation through the cases of India and VietNam, this paper provides actionable recommendations for strengthening the governance coherence for sustainable agri-food systems in both regions.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Since its launch in 2013, China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has been analysed primarily through geopolitical and geo-economic lenses, emphasising its role in reshaping global power dynamics and promoting economic integration. However, such views often overlook the governance dynamics that are central to the implementation of the BRI in partner countries. This paper adopts a governance perspective and examines the complex network of actors -- including non-state entities, local stakeholders and private sector participants -- involved in BRI projects. Through an analysis of transport-related BRI projects, we show that the BRI operates within a flexible, network-based governance model, in contrast to China's traditional hierarchical approach. This study highlights the BRI not only as an instrument of state influence, but also as a platform for inclusive engagement and adaptive policymaking.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Triangular development cooperation (TDC) is a growing form of development assistance that involves a traditional donor, an emerging country, and a beneficiary or recipient. While much research has focused on the power dynamics within TDC partnerships and the role of emerging countries, the analysis often centers on BRICS nations and TDC trends in Latin America, the Middle East, and Africa. This paper explores the evolving TDC patterns in Southeast Asia, highlighting middle powers and smaller states such as Indonesia, Thailand, Malaysia, and the Philippines. I argue that emerging Southeast Asian countries have played a significant role in expanding TDC efforts both within and beyond the region. They have also diversified their TDC strategies by engaging in multilateralism, traditional North-South partnerships, and newer South-South Cooperation platforms. However, their TDC agency is sometimes limited by shifting domestic political landscapes and foreign policy priorities.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The traditional paradigm of development cooperation, dominated by North-South aid flows, is undergoing a significant transformation with the rise of emerging economies from the Global South. Countries like China, India, and Brazil have increasingly positioned themselves as key players in development cooperation, challenging the monopoly of traditional donors from the Global North. This research examines the shifting power dynamics in development cooperation, focusing on the strategies, priorities, and impacts of South-South cooperation compared to North-South frameworks. It explores how emerging donors leverage economic partnerships, infrastructure investments, and conditionality-free aid to redefine the norms and practices of global development.
Using case studies from Africa and Asia, the research analyzes the geopolitical implications of this shift, particularly in regions where Northern and Southern donors compete for influence. It critically evaluates whether South-South cooperation represents a more equitable and sustainable model or perpetuates new forms of dependency. Additionally, the study considers how these changing dynamics impact multilateral institutions, development financing, and recipient countries' agency. By addressing the growing complexities of development cooperation, this research aims to provide insights into the evolving roles and relationships within the global development landscape, highlighting the implications for policy and practice in the 21st century.
Keywords: Development Cooperation, South-South Cooperation, Global South, Power Dynamics, Geopolitical Influence

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The status of coloniality in EU-Africa relations is ambivalent. Scholars and some practitioners agree on the persistent vestiges of colonialism in this relationship, while diplomats commit to the idea of an ‘equal partnership’. While overt coloniality has become marginalised, this paper focuses on the elusive dynamics of coloniality: funding and financing. This paper theorises the coloniality of money in EU-Africa relations, focusing on how colonial legacies shape power dynamics, decision-making, and institutional practices, using a decolonial lens centred on the ‘coloniality of power’. We scrutinise how EU institutions reproduce Eurocentric worldviews and power imbalances, despite EU rhetoric advocating for equity and pragmatism. We illustrate how Eurocentric practices legitimise ongoing colonial projects and perpetuate racial and economic hierarchies through money-based partnerships. It investigates the strategies employed by African states and institutions to assert agency, and how African countries leverage alternative partnerships, exploit institutional overlaps, and renegotiate rules and standards to challenge Eurocentric financial practices. The paper combines decolonial theory with an empirical analysis of three aspects of EU-Africa relations: institutions, rules and standards, and diplomatic practices. Case studies include the Organization of African, Caribbean, and Pacific States (OACPS), the EU-African Union (EU-AU) partnership, the European Investment Bank (EIB), and the European Peace Facility. By combining detailed empirical case studies with a close re-reading of debates on coloniality and decolonization, we argue that understanding the interplay of money, power, and coloniality is vital.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Official history and historiography of European integration – let alone of Europe as a social, geographical, cultural entity –, has long-time been polished through a selection of conventional narratives (Manners and Murray 2016). Such narratives have until recently omitted to account for the specific experiences of Europe by Africans and people of African descent (Afro-descendants). Yet the historical development of Europe, and of the European integration process leading to the European Union (EU) today, happened in strong relation to political, economic and social processes in the African continent, in triangulation with developments in the Americas (Rodney 1973; Hansen and Jonsson 2014; Dimier 2014).
In connection with works aiming to decentre Europe (Fisher Onar and Nikolaïdis 2013; Keukeleire & Lecocq 2018) and EU narratives about its own history and historiography, and to propose a decolonial project for Europe (Bhambra 2022), we focus here on Pan-Africanism as a (diverse) political and philosophical movement whose links with Europe have been largely neglected. If Pan-Africanism has the purpose for Africans and Afro-descendants to claim back centrality in their political, economic, social choices – reclaiming full democratic sovereignty over African countries –, this endeavour comes in reaction against historical and current actions by other political and social entities, particularly “EUrope”, with its specific ties (euphemistically called “special relationship”) with the African continent. Taking stock of McEachrane’s work on Pan-Africanism in a European context (McEachrane 2020), we aim here to critically understand and ‘provincialize’ the EUropean project by engaging with Pan-African activists and thinkers. Our research question then reads, how do Pan-African narratives conceive of the EUropean project?
Our analysis follows a two-pronged approach. First, we analyze ‘Pan-Africanism from below’ (Mampilly 2024), focusing on activists within the Pan-African League Umoja (LP-U). Pan-Africanism from below is being revived among African diasporas in Europe, in connection with Africans on the continent, since the beginning of the 2010s, through the creation of new Pan-Africanist organisations. Second, we analyze ‘Pan-Africanism from above’ in terms of the key thinkers that continue to inform current activism. This is connected to the LP-U analysis, as their narratives are remarkably similar to, and nurtures itself abundantly of, iconic historical Pan-Africanist thinkers. Such a nurtured presence shows the continued relevance of these figures and their ideas, some of which are being rediscovered (ex: Diop): LP-U analyses of current African issues are often proposed in direct conjunction with the analyses made by key Pan-Africanists in different historical contexts.
 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Public-private partnerships (PPPs) have become a prominent strategy for delivering public goods and infrastructure, often seen as a mechanism to enhance efficiency, innovation, and resource mobilization. They are increasingly used in development cooperation, where collaboration between governments and private sector actors addresses key challenges, particularly in the development of public infrastructure. However, despite their potential, many PPPs encounter significant obstacles and fail to deliver intended outcomes.

 

This study investigates the factors that contribute to the failure of PPPs, particularly in development cooperation contexts involving North-South partnerships, using a mixed-method approach. More specifically, it addresses the following research question: "What are the key political, governance, and institutional barriers undermining the success of collaborative arrangements like PPPs?" By combining quantitative and qualitative methods, this study provides a comprehensive view of the operational and contextual challenges faced by such partnerships.

           

The quantitative analysis draws from an integrated dataset that includes the World Bank's Private Participation in Infrastructure (PPI) project database, the World Governance Index (WGI), and regime classifications from Our World in Data. Additional data on failed projects is gathered from media reports, court documents, and official company statements to identify reasons for cancellations. In parallel, qualitative insights are obtained through interviews with experts and practitioners involved in the planning and oversight of PPPs. These interviews provide context-specific knowledge that complements the quantitative findings, shedding light on governance dynamics and operational challenges that are difficult to capture through archival data alone.

           

Preliminary results suggest that political barriers often arise from the tradeoffs inherent to different political regimes. For example, authoritarian regimes struggle with high levels of corruption, while democratic regimes experience regulatory delays to more extensive oversight – both of which hinder collaborations. In democracies, project cancellations often stem from regulatory delays such as land acquisition or environmental clearances. Across political regimes, financial constraints consistently affect project viability.

       

This study contributes to the literature on development cooperation by offering a novel perspective that highlights specific pathways through which governance, economic stability, and institutional quality collectively shape PPP outcomes. The combination of quantitative data and qualitative insights enriches our understanding of how political and institutional structures influence collaboration viability across different regimes. This study provides practical insights for policymakers, development practitioners, and private sector actors aiming to design more resilient and sustainable collaborative partnerships. By identifying key barriers to success, it offers actionable recommendations for strengthening governance structures and mitigating risks in PPPs, particularly in contexts marked by diverse and evolving development cooperation arrangements between the North, South, and emerging economies.

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In 2011, the United Nations (UN) Human Rights Council (HRC) endorsed the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (UNGPs) to combat corporate abuses of human rights. Emphasising ‘a proactive role for the state’ (Ramasastry 2015: 247), they call on states to foster measures to cultivate business respect for human rights and, in particular, to formulate and implement laws, regulations, and policies on business and human rights (BHR). The HRC has actively promoted this agenda, supported by many donor governments and international organisations, including the European Union, Scandinavian governments and UNDP. Yet assessments suggest that states have moved slowly and inconsistently to adopt and implement the UNGPs, especially in the Global South, while in some cases donors themselves have been accused of facilitating breaches of the UNGPs. What explains this outcome? What have been the obstacles to state adoption and implementation of the UNGPs? Under what conditions have states adopted and implemented the UNGPs? What can government, business, and civil society actors do to compel states to go further in implementing these norms? And why have some donors been accused of enabling breaches of the UNGPs? This paper seeks to address these questions focusing on the case of Indonesia. It argues that the primary obstacle to UNGP implementation in Indonesia has been power asymmetries between politico-business and technocratic elites, on the one hand, and rights coalitions, on the other. At the same time, the latter have been able to make some headway in promoting UNGP implementation where they have leveraged market forces in their favour. This has served to narrow power asymmetries, albeit with different effects on the form of implementation depending on the history of struggle over business and human rights in the relevant domain and the extent of high-level political support. Donors have attracted criticism for facilitating breaches of the UNGPs when they have backed dominant politico-business coalitions in struggles with poor and marginalised elements and rights coalitions over the social or environmental impact of the projects they have funded. In terms of strategy for promoting UNGP implementation, the paper thus argues that Indonesia’s experience suggests that donors’ and others’ efforts to promote UNGP implementation need to go beyond measures of socialization and learning to focus on enabling rights coalitions to confront corporate power. This approach includes ensuring supporting the monitoring and mobilizational capacities of these coalitions over time and, to the extent that hard law responses by states are considered desirable, facilitating their ability to forge alliances with sympathetic elements in the state apparatus. Donors also need to maximise independence from elite coalitions.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The paper examines the transformative role of the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) in shifting the development discourse from traditional macroeconomic indicators to a human-centred approach, as exemplified by the Human Development Report (HDR). UNDP's HDR interventions primarily focused on the vital aspects of human well-being: health, education, and standard of living(Conceição, 2020). Later, the Millennium Development Goals and Sustainable Development Goals were formulated, building on the Human-centric development discourse.  The introduction of the HDR marked a pivotal change, positioning people at the core of development strategies and influencing governments worldwide, including India, to re-evaluate their policy frameworks.

 

This study aims to analyze the following research questions:

 

1. How did the UNDP's HDR influence the redefinition of development among international organizations and member states, including India?


2. In what ways have the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) evolved from the principles established by the HDR, and what role has the UNDP played in this transition?


3. How do contemporary public policies in various countries, including India, reflect the impact of UNDP's human development approach on global governance and responses to pressing issues such as poverty, health, and climate change?


By exploring these questions, this paper particularly highlights the UNDP's pivotal role in promoting people-centred development, the continued relevance of the HDR framework in guiding policy formulation worldwide, and the relevance of such International Organizations in general in today's world. 

 

Keywords: UNDP, human development, HDR, SDGs, global governance.
 
 

References:

 

Conceição, P. (2020). Human development report 2020-the next frontier: Human development and the Anthropocene. United Nations Development Programme: Human Development Report.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

       The aim of this study is to analyze a very specific sequence in the circuit of development aid policies for sub-Saharan Africa: The reception of these policies within African states. The reception of public policies can be understood as a set of processes by which a public policy is appropriated and co-constructed by its constituents, and by which it produces its effects on them. It is therefore an active process of co-production and learning. Since the end of the Second World War, an international governance system for development aid has been established. “Donor countries” and other financial backers, generally from the northern hemisphere, transfer resources and aid flows to “recipient” countries in the southern hemisphere. This North-South development cooperation has been widely criticized for its inefficiency. Since 2005, for example, with the Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness, the principles of coordination, harmonization, alignment and mutual accountability have been integrated into the implementation of development aid policies, with the aim of achieving more positive results. This has not prevented the rise of South-South cooperation, which is supposed to be more effective, less costly and, above all, more sincere in its desire to make a significant contribution to the development of weaker economies.

      Il these two configurations of development cooperation, African states are “multi-situated”, i.e they are involved in co-production and implementation processes at different scales. Similarly, they are the main recipients and beneficiaries of these multiple development initiatives. Thus, at territorial level, we can distinguish several types of stakeholders: public administrations civil society organizations and local communities. We are thus in the presence of a differentiated reception of development aid, which becomes even denser when it takes concrete form in specific sectors of public life. In this article, we take a closer look at the differentiated reception of aid policies in the education and health sectors in Cameroon. Analyzing these reception processes through the lens of comprehensive sociology seems relevant to us, as we are increasingly witnessing the strong integration of these development projects and programs into the public policy matrix of states in Sub-Saharan Africa. In this way, international development initiatives that are supposed to be part of a specific timeframe end up structuring African public policies over the long term.

 

Key words: Reception of public policies, development policy, development aid, Sub-Saharan Africa, education, Health

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper examines the role of development cooperation in advancing the circular economy (CE) in the agri-food sector, focusing on collaboration between the European Union (EU) and two Asian countries—India and Vietnam. The research question is: How can EU-Asia development cooperation foster the adoption of circular economy practices in the agri-food sector? To address this question, the study employs a mixed-methods approach, combining policy analysis and case studies. Case studies of EU-funded projects, such as SWITCH-Asia programs in India and Vietnam, are examined to assess their socio-economic impacts.

 

The findings indicate that while the European Union's expertise in policy design and technology transfer has, to some extent, facilitated the adoption of circular economy (CE) practices in Asia, significant barriers remain, including fragmented policies, limited connection to the private sector to facilitate investments, and cultural and institutional resistance.

 

The paper underscores the necessity of aligning regulatory frameworks, increasing public-private partnerships for investment, and clarifying how digital technologies can support scalability for circular economy practices.

 

By identifying synergies and gaps in EU-Asia cooperation through the cases of India and VietNam, this paper provides actionable recommendations for strengthening the governance coherence for sustainable agri-food systems in both regions.