Format

P01. Perceptions on Redistributive Policies, Justice and Inequalities

INEQUALITIES AND PUBLIC POLICY
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Carolina Raquel Justo
Federal University of São Carlos - UFSCar (universidade Federal de São Carlos)
Main chair
Camila De Mario
Universidade Candido Mendes
Second chair
Carla Tomazini
University of Warwick
Third chair
Osmany Porto de Oliveira
Universidade Federal de São Paulo
Fourth chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
INEQUALITIES AND PUBLIC POLICY
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

It is important to understand perceptions about inequalities and ways to combat them, since public policies are an important point of contact between the State, government and citizens, through which they inform and are informed about demands, preferences and political interests. Since the opinions expressed affect and are affected by the actions of the State, in a two-way street, they interfere in the social and substantive dimension of equality in democracy. And although voting is the main mechanism for representing interests and legitimizing the actions of the State in relation to the preferences of the majority of the population, the fact is that citizens do not choose policies, but rather politicians, and the decisions that they make, the measures and actions that they adopt, in terms of public policies, do not respond to preferences that could supposedly be homogeneous, of a majority, but to the first preference or, at most, sets of interests of larger minorities, as Dahl (1956) rightly warns in his argument in defense of the pluralist perspective. Hence the special interest in population perceptions in terms of their priorities in public policies, which cannot be inferred from electoral results. As Howlett (2000) adds, public opinion, whether generic or majority, cannot be considered the independent variable that defines the production of public policies (whether due to Dahl's justification above or due to the various political and institutional factors that affect decisions about their formulation and implementation); government actions, directly and intentionally or not, also influence public opinion, in a process that feeds back dialectically. Therefore, the interest in research on perceptions of social policies is justified, notably those aimed at combating hunger, poverty and inequality, to the extent that they have been affected, differently for different social groups, as they have expanded and contracted throughout history in different contexts.

CALL FOR PAPERS


What do social policies, combating hunger, poverty and inequality policies say about democracy? And what kind of support do they receive from citizens? What do the comparative analises say about the legitimacy bases for more egalitarian and redistributive policies implementation, following the social democratic lines of Welfare-State, in different countries? It matters to know the perceptions of different social groups about inequalities and ways to combat them, since public policies are an important point of contact between the State and citizens, through which both inform each other about demands, preferences and political interests. Since the expressed opinions affect and are affected by the State actions, they interfere with the social and substantive dimension of equality in democracy. Views and perceptions about poverty, justice, social inequalities, social assistance, conditional cash transfer policies and about their origins and justifications vary among social groups. Knowing them may help to understand how to improve democracy.

Comparative, qualitative and quantitative studies are welcome, including groups such as elites, street-level and high-ranking bureaucrats, policy beneficiaries and sociodemographic strata. 
The analysis of public policies has benefited from cognitive approaches and the sociology of public action inspired by France, from which the notion of “State in Action” comes. Emphasizing the role of ideas, values, references, beliefs, knowledge and worldviews - and of action - such approaches dialogue with the theory of Political Culture, an approach that has been little explored. The panel aims to contribute to this debate. Papers may be concerned on: a) perspectives such as bureaucratic cultures, epistemic communities, advocacy coalitions, networks, the three “i”s (ideas, interests and institutions), historical and discursive neoinstitutionalism; b) objects such as councils, civil society, participatory, sectoral, intersectoral and intersectional policies; c) analyses of change, diffusion, implementation, the role of institutions, actors, social movements, political parties, bureaucracies at different levels; d) normative themes such as democracy, citizenship, justice and political projects. Interdisciplinary in nature, the panel encompasses quantitative and empirical-qualitative methodologies: analysis of surveys and indicators, interviews, case and comparative studies, ethnographic studies, instrumentation studies, etc.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Bridging the Gap: How Youth Behaviors Influence the Density of Youth Nonprofits in U.S. Counties
Vernise Estorcien (Indiana University Indianapolis)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Nonprofit organizations play a critical role in addressing community challenges, yet limited research examines how youth safety and risky behaviors influence the density of youth-serving nonprofits. This research addresses a key public management issue: the alignment between nonprofit presence and localized youth-specific needs, particularly in addressing service gaps left by local governments. 


The primary research question is: How do youth safety and risky behaviors at the county level influence the density of youth development nonprofits?  Combining insights from two frameworks, this study puts forth a model to explain the presence of youth-serving nonprofits. According to Government Failure Theory, nonprofits emerge to fill gaps left by insufficient or ineffective public systems (Weisbrod, 2009; Smith & Grønbjerg, 2006), whereas Demand Heterogeneity Theory suggests that communities with diverse socioeconomic profiles drive nonprofit density due to varied needs (Grønbjerg & Paarlberg, 2001). While the government at every level has consistently tried to prevent and reduce youth crime and delinquency, this remains a pressing issue in local municipalities across the U.S. The correlates of such behavior often include racial and socioeconomic diversity (cite). 


Using longitudinal county-level data on youth risk indicators, socioeconomic conditions, and public funding, the study employs hierarchical linear modeling (HLM) to explore relationships between these factors and nonprofit density. Using counties as the unit of analysis enables a detailed understanding of nonprofit distribution, given their alignment with public service administration and their reflection of socioeconomic diversity across urban, suburban, and rural areas (Allard, 2009; Lecy & Van Slyke, 2013). Preliminary findings indicate that higher nonprofit density is associated with counties experiencing elevated juvenile crime, substance abuse, and school dropout rates, especially where traditional public systems show resource constraints or limited effectiveness.


These findings have significant implications for public management and policy. They suggest that nonprofits play a pivotal role in filling service gaps, but whether nonprofit service provision reduces youth’s risky behaviors is yet to be seen. This study advances nonprofit and public management literature by refining theoretical frameworks and offering actionable insights for policymakers and practitioners seeking to improve youth outcomes and community well-being.

 

 

References 

 

Allard, S. W. (2009). Out of reach: Place, poverty, and the new American welfare state. Yale University Press.


Grønbjerg, K. A., & Paarlberg, L. (2001). Community variations in the size and scope of the nonprofit sector: Theory and preliminary findings. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 30(4), 684–706.


Guo, C., & Acar, M. (2005). Understanding collaboration among nonprofit organizations: Combining resource dependency, institutional, and network perspectives. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 34(3), 340–361.


Hwang, H., & Powell, W. W. (2009). The rationalization of charity: The influences of professionalism in the nonprofit sector. Administrative Science Quarterly, 54(2), 268–298.


Lecy, J. D., & Van Slyke, D. M. (2013). Nonprofit sector growth and density: Testing theories of government support. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 23(1), 189–214.


Pfeffer, J., & Salancik, G. (2015). External control of organizations—Resource dependence perspective. In Organizational behavior 2 (pp. 355-370). Routledge.


Smith, S. R., & Grønbjerg, K. A. (2006). Scope and theory of government-nonprofit relations. In W.W. Powell & R. Steinberg (Eds.), The nonprofit sector: A research handbook (2nd ed., pp. 221–242). Yale University Press.


Weisbrod, B. (2009). The nonprofit economy. Harvard university press.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Determining support for a more equal society: evidence from natural hazards
Abu Bakkar Siddique (Florida Atlantic University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Understanding public support for redistribution is crucial for designing and implementing effective equality-enhancing public policies. This paper examines support for income equality versus individual efforts in response to exposure to natural hazards. Natural hazards, as unexpected events, significantly influence individuals' views, expectations, and attitudes toward government intervention. Using multi-level hierarchical modeling on individual-level data from various countries and regions, the findings support the hypothesis that experiences of natural disasters—events beyond individual control that deeply impact livelihoods—heighten support for collective action while reducing support for individualistic efforts or market-driven solutions.

 

Perceptions of fairness in societal outcomes are central to this shift. When individuals observe that natural disasters disproportionately harm some people while sparing others, they become more aware of the limitations of relying solely on market outcomes or individual efforts. Such realizations foster greater support for government intervention aimed at equalizing social outcomes and mitigating disadvantages caused by uncontrollable circumstances.

 

The study also highlights that while rational economic behavioral hypotheses—favoring individual efforts—generally hold, exposure to natural hazards triggers a marked reversal in these attitudes. Similarly, individuals who typically prioritize hard work as the key to success show increased support for collective action after experiencing natural disasters. These findings emphasize the need to tailor public policies to align with evolving public attitudes in the aftermath of natural disasters. Insights from this study contribute to a deeper understanding of how external events shape public policy preferences and support for redistributive measures.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Technological Change, Public Opinion, and Inequality: The Fourth Industrial Revolution in South Africa
Zama Mthombeni (University of Pretoria)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The Fourth Industrial Revolution (4IR) has been promoted globally as a transformative force promising economic growth, technological innovation, and societal progress. However, its implementation in developing contexts such as South Africa has raised significant concerns about its implications for inequality, justice, and redistributive policies. This study investigates public perceptions of the 4IR, using data from the South African Social Attitudes Survey (SASAS), to explore the socio-demographic and economic factors that shape attitudes toward automation and technological advancement. It addresses critical questions: What shapes public perceptions of 4IR technologies? How do these perceptions reflect broader societal inequalities? And what are the implications for redistributive policies aimed at mitigating technological disruption?

The research employs a quantitative methodology, leveraging regression-based analysis to examine variables such as age, race, income, education, and employment status. Key findings reveal significant disparities in attitudes: marginalized groups express heightened skepticism due to fears of job displacement and inadequate governmental intervention, while more affluent individuals exhibit optimism tied to their relative security. Additionally, a generational divide is evident, with younger, tech-savvy individuals more accepting of automation than older cohorts, who fear obsolescence. Most respondents also lack confidence in the government’s ability to mitigate the adverse effects of automation, underscoring a critical trust deficit.

This paper argues that uncritically adopting 4IR technologies risks exacerbating existing inequalities unless accompanied by inclusive redistributive policies. It proposes measures such as universal basic income, targeted skills development, and enhanced STEM education to promote equitable participation. Moreover, the study highlights the necessity of engaging public opinion in policy formulation to ensure alignment between state actions and citizen priorities. This two-way relationship, where government decisions shape and are shaped by public perceptions, is crucial for advancing substantive equality and justice in a technology-driven democracy.

By addressing the intersection of public perceptions, redistributive policies, and inequality, this research contributes to the broader discourse on justice and the role of public opinion in shaping policy outcomes. It aligns with the panel’s objective to explore how societal demands, shaped by perceptions of fairness and inequality, inform and are informed by public policies. The findings underscore the importance of integrating public concerns into the design and implementation of 4IR policies, ensuring that technological progress benefits all, rather than entrenching socio-economic divides.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - IMPLEMENTATION OF SOCIAL POLICIES: CHALLENGING OR GENERATING POVERTY AND INEQUALITY IN COLOMBIA?
Cristian Rodríguez Olaya (Universidad Nacional de Colombia)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The objective of this project is to analyze the possibility that public policies to combat poverty and inequality may produce, in their implementation, possible unexpected effects that are contrary to their social purpose established in the design. Thus, the project has as its central question: can significant social inequalities be generated in the implementation of social policies, when in their design they seek exactly the opposite? Therefore, the study addresses two public policies (which are part of the Colombian social protection system) and analyzes their execution in a region of Colombia called Llanos Orientales.

Methodologically, the research is of a mixed nature. In this order, in the qualitative field, information gathering techniques are used, such as semi-structured interviews with both bureaucrats in charge of implementing the policies and their beneficiaries. Likewise, these interviews are analyzed according to coding and categorization techniques. Quantitative surveys are also conducted on the two population groups mentioned above. Therefore, the results of these surveys are analyzed with evaluation techniques, such as Pearson or Spearman.

The aim is to determine whether the implementation of the two public policies analysed generates inequalities or negative social impacts on the beneficiaries, as well as the reasons for this, if such impacts are confirmed. In this sense, issues such as the technical and political components inherent to the implementation of public policies are analytically explored, including variables such as the technical knowledge of bureaucrats, their values ​​and discretion regarding decisions on the beneficiaries of social policies (or even on potential beneficiaries), or the perception of the beneficiaries on the objective, structure and impact of the public policies studied, within the framework of the social protection system of Colombia.

 

Keywords: public policies, inequality, poverty, bureaucracy, implementation.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Retrenchment and Resilience: A comparative study of Brazil’s PES programs
Tomás Borges (Universidade do Estado do Rio de Janeiro)
CO-AUTHORS
Ana Paula Santos (Universidade do Estado do Rio de Janeiro, Brazil)
ABSTRACT

This article aims to discuss the retrenchment strategies employed in two of Brazil's leading payment for environmental services programs (PES), Bolsa Floresta and Bolsa Verde. The goal is to identify the reasons behind the endurance of the former and the dissolution of the latter during crisis times. In general, the study frames the transformations in Bolsa Floresta and Bolsa Verde at two distinct levels: (1) the role of legal and fiscal centralization in shaping budget cuts, particularly during years of economic crisis, and (2) the drift mechanisms embedded in these policies from their inception. These issues are also assessed in light of the institutional changes that occurred during the transition from the Dilma government to the Temer government. As a result, we find that building a dedicated bureaucracy whose sole purpose was to finance the program was crucial for Bolsa Floresta's sustainability during Brazil’s severe economic and political crisis. However, both programs underwent distinct retrenchment strategies since their creation, which were intensified in 2014 and 2015. By situating PES within the broader discussion on social policies, inequality, and democracy, this study contributes to comparative debates on the legitimacy and political feasibility of redistributive policies, particularly in contexts of crisis. Moreover, it highlights the vulnerabilities of Bolsa Verde and Bolsa Floresta regarding retrenchment and proposes future research directions that integrate political culture and institutional change into the analysis of environmental social policies.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Gender (In)Equality in Authoritarian Settings: Evidence from the Russian Academic Environment
Marina Pilkina (National Research University Higher School of Economics)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Russian women are less represented in the higher academic ranks and in academic management. Women, who dominate in the first stages of their careers, are significantly less represented in the subsequent ranks. These indicators of gender inequality have a direct impact on the general role of women in the Russian academic system. This trend of similar career paths for women is characteristic of the Russian public sector as a whole.
There are currently no national initiatives to promote the status and advancement of women in Russian science. This could be because the elitist class is currently more concerned with women as mothers than women as leaders and academics. In fact, all gender issues are now considered political and polarized according to the political ideology of elite actors. This paper therefore analyses gender issues, how they are perceived and how they are (un)resolved by state actors, using the academic environment as a case study. The author examines this case to answer the following research questions: (1) How is gender politics positioned in authoritarian settings? (2) To what extent are gender issues and women’s advancement part of social policy in authoritarian settings?
This study applies Feminist Institutionalism which considers gender balance as a feature of the institution and social structures. It focuses on the relationship between institutions and actors to eliminate gender misbalance. Such a theoretical approach provides considering gender equality as an integral element of institutional development. Feminist institutionalism may potentially become more applicable in academia, especially among gender researchers, as it emphasizes the importance of gender equality with consideration of women’s empowerment. In terms of methodology, it is a mixed-method study with quantitative and qualitative assessment of gender inequality, its perception and ways of dealing with it.
 
The relevance of the study lies in the analysis of gender use in the Russian academic community and in authoritarian settings, which is the Russian case. In addition, this research applies feminist institutionalism to point out how gender has been politicized in a combination of state policy and practice. The expected results will present the innovative application of feminist institutionalism for gender studies in the authoritarian context.
 
 

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - The Double Bind of Inclusion and Exclusion: Comparative Policy Feedback Effects of Administrative Errors in Welfare Programs
Peijie Wang (Tsinghua University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Administrative errors in policy implementation have attracted growing attention, particularly in the realm of welfare programs. Drawing on policy feedback theory, this study proposes a novel comparative policy feedback framework, highlighting two key mechanisms: the relative welfare loss arising from exclusion errors and the mistaken acceptance of benefits resulting from inclusion errors, both of which generate distinct resource and interpretive effects. Using data from China’s minimum living standard welfare scheme and a nationally representative survey, the study finds that, compared with accurate inclusion, both exclusion and inclusion errors reduce public trust in cadres and lower satisfaction with the government. Exclusion errors foster feelings of relative deprivation due to perceived welfare loss, while inclusion errors amplify perceptions of corruption by revealing information about ineligibility. Furthermore, previous negative experiences in citizen–state interactions intensify the impact of these administrative errors. Overall, the findings illuminate the complex dynamics of administrative errors and their broader feedback effects on the public.

 
ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Health Equity and Distributive Justice: Views of high-level African policymakers
Michelle Amri (University of British Columbia)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Health equity matters, but there is no universally accepted definition of this or associated terms, such as inequities, inequalities, and disparities. Given the flexibility of these terms, investigating how policymakers understand them is important to observe priorities and perhaps course correct. Accordingly, this study analyzed the perceptions high-level policymakers within the WHO African Region. An online survey was distributed to attendees of the WHO’s Fifth Health Sector Directors’ Policy and Planning Meeting for the WHO African Region by email. After responses were collected, both inductive and deductive coding were applied. Inductive coding was undertaken to glean central concepts from free-form responses on understandings of health equity and deductive coding was used to assess alignment with four theories of distributive justice using a coding framework. In analyzing central concepts, three became apparent: access to health services and/or health care, financial protection, and recognizing subgroups. And when we investigated alignment with theory, most respondents’ understandings of health equity aligned with Rawls’ ‘Theory of Justice’ (95%). Of these responses, 70% were exclusively aligned with Rawls’ ‘Theory of Justice’ and 30% aligned also with another theory (this 30% was split 55% utilitarianism and 45% Sen’s Capabilities Approach). Respondent understandings of health equity showed limited alignment with other theories of distributive justice, which were: utilitarianism (n=7/39; 17.95%), Sen’s Capabilities Approach (n=5/39; 12.82%), and libertarianism (n=2/39; 5.13%). This study demonstrates that alignment with certain theories is tied to specific themes (i.e., theoretical underpinnings may guide policymakers to favour certain policy approaches). For instance, a utilitarian-minded policymaker may be focused on a widespread vaccination campaign, whereas a Rawlsian-aligned policymaker may focus on a targeted approach to reach communities that have lower vaccination rates, and a Senian-aligned policymaker may focus on health literacy programs targeted at addressing vaccine-hesitant individuals within communities with lower vaccination rates. These findings can guide high-level policymakers and international organizations to optimize decision-making by clarifying ethical alternatives.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Interaction and Transformation: The Impact of UnB's Extension Projects at the Ceilândia Campus in the Context of REUNI
Edson Silva (Universidade de Brasília)
CO-AUTHORS
SAULO DE ARAUJO (Universidade de Brasília)
ABSTRACT

This essay aims to understand how the expansion policies of access to public higher education in Brazil and in the Federal District have created new ways of interaction between the academic community and the urban contexts where the new campuses were established. Specifically, we will explore how the installation of the University of Brasília (UnB) campus in Ceilândia (FCE) – designed for various health-related fields – has facilitated specific conditions for interaction between students, professors, and certain segments of Ceilândia's population.

The focus of this essay will be on the relationships between the extension projects/programs of FCE and the Ceilândia community. More specifically, we will conduct a quantitative and exploratory study of the continuous action extension project 'Integral Health in Needy Families of the Federal District' and the Extension Program 'Prevention and Rehabilitation of Elderly and Young Adults – Cardiac Patients or Not – and Their Integration into Sports,' with the goal of demonstrating the contribution to the local community based on these extension actions.

The establishment of the UnB campus in Ceilândia represents a significant milestone in the policy of expanding higher education in Brazil, especially in peripheral and underserved areas. This movement not only democratizes access to higher education but also promotes closer interaction between the university and the local community. Extension projects play a crucial role in this process, as they allow academic knowledge to be directly applied for the benefit of the population.

The 'Integral Health in Needy Families of the Federal District' project aims to provide comprehensive healthcare to families in vulnerable situations, addressing not only medical issues but also social and psychological aspects. Meanwhile, the 'Prevention and Rehabilitation of Elderly and Young Adults' Extension Program focuses on promoting health and rehabilitating individuals with cardiac problems, encouraging sports participation as a means to improve quality of life.

These initiatives not only directly benefit the residents of Ceilândia but also enrich the education of students, who have the opportunity to apply their knowledge in real-life situations and develop a deeper understanding of the community's needs and challenges. Thus, the presence of the UnB campus in Ceilândia and its extension projects exemplify how higher education can be a transformative agent in society.

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - From Bureaucrats to Beneficiaries? Justice, Inequalities and Income Transfer Policies Perceptions in Brazil
Carolina Raquel Justo (Federal University of São Carlos - UFSCar (universidade Federal de São Carlos))
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The paper analyzes the justice, poverty and inequalities perceptions from beneficiaries and high and street level bureaucrats linked to income transfer programs in Brazil, between the years 1995 and 2010. Through long-term interviews with both groups, we identified, on the one hand, a coincidence of perceptions between bureaucrats and beneficiaries from the same location, regarding to the concepts and references of the programs; on the other, variations in perceptions between municipalities. The coincidence of perceptions suggests the diffusion of sectoral and global references from street-level bureaucrats to the beneficiaries of the policies they implement. The research findings corroborate the argument about the relevance of these actors for identifying the core values ​​that guide the implementation of policies, their concrete meaning, which does not always coincide with that formulated by managers. This implies in recognizing the process of opinion formation and diffusion of political culture through public policies, results that researchers often do not attach much importance to, although they are the core of the political-ideological conflict. Comparative studies brought evidence of a dispute between alternative models of income transfer programs, which operate on the ground in society: Minimum Income X Basic Income.

ACCEPTED
Format
11 - A Decade of Maricá's Universal Basic Income: Insights from Its Beneficiaries
Matheus Decnop (Universidade Federal do Estado do Rio de Janeiro - UNIRIO - Brazil)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

A decade after the implementation of the Citizenship Basic Income, a public policy initiative in the municipality of Maricá (RJ), much can be discussed regarding its relationship with its beneficiaries. This study aims to examine the perceptions of Maricá residents enrolled to receive the benefit regularly, focusing on how they assess the impact of this policy on generating opportunities for their families and altering their socioeconomic status. The objective is to elucidate what beneficiaries consider to be concrete outcomes of the municipality's income distribution strategy. Supported by statistical contextualization and an extensive literature review, this research seeks to understand whether beneficiaries feel more secure and free as a result of the benefit, the extent to which its existence holds political significance for recipients, and whether it can be associated with a reduction in the local perception of poverty.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Nonprofit organizations play a critical role in addressing community challenges, yet limited research examines how youth safety and risky behaviors influence the density of youth-serving nonprofits. This research addresses a key public management issue: the alignment between nonprofit presence and localized youth-specific needs, particularly in addressing service gaps left by local governments. 


The primary research question is: How do youth safety and risky behaviors at the county level influence the density of youth development nonprofits?  Combining insights from two frameworks, this study puts forth a model to explain the presence of youth-serving nonprofits. According to Government Failure Theory, nonprofits emerge to fill gaps left by insufficient or ineffective public systems (Weisbrod, 2009; Smith & Grønbjerg, 2006), whereas Demand Heterogeneity Theory suggests that communities with diverse socioeconomic profiles drive nonprofit density due to varied needs (Grønbjerg & Paarlberg, 2001). While the government at every level has consistently tried to prevent and reduce youth crime and delinquency, this remains a pressing issue in local municipalities across the U.S. The correlates of such behavior often include racial and socioeconomic diversity (cite). 


Using longitudinal county-level data on youth risk indicators, socioeconomic conditions, and public funding, the study employs hierarchical linear modeling (HLM) to explore relationships between these factors and nonprofit density. Using counties as the unit of analysis enables a detailed understanding of nonprofit distribution, given their alignment with public service administration and their reflection of socioeconomic diversity across urban, suburban, and rural areas (Allard, 2009; Lecy & Van Slyke, 2013). Preliminary findings indicate that higher nonprofit density is associated with counties experiencing elevated juvenile crime, substance abuse, and school dropout rates, especially where traditional public systems show resource constraints or limited effectiveness.


These findings have significant implications for public management and policy. They suggest that nonprofits play a pivotal role in filling service gaps, but whether nonprofit service provision reduces youth’s risky behaviors is yet to be seen. This study advances nonprofit and public management literature by refining theoretical frameworks and offering actionable insights for policymakers and practitioners seeking to improve youth outcomes and community well-being.

 

 

References 

 

Allard, S. W. (2009). Out of reach: Place, poverty, and the new American welfare state. Yale University Press.


Grønbjerg, K. A., & Paarlberg, L. (2001). Community variations in the size and scope of the nonprofit sector: Theory and preliminary findings. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 30(4), 684–706.


Guo, C., & Acar, M. (2005). Understanding collaboration among nonprofit organizations: Combining resource dependency, institutional, and network perspectives. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 34(3), 340–361.


Hwang, H., & Powell, W. W. (2009). The rationalization of charity: The influences of professionalism in the nonprofit sector. Administrative Science Quarterly, 54(2), 268–298.


Lecy, J. D., & Van Slyke, D. M. (2013). Nonprofit sector growth and density: Testing theories of government support. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 23(1), 189–214.


Pfeffer, J., & Salancik, G. (2015). External control of organizations—Resource dependence perspective. In Organizational behavior 2 (pp. 355-370). Routledge.


Smith, S. R., & Grønbjerg, K. A. (2006). Scope and theory of government-nonprofit relations. In W.W. Powell & R. Steinberg (Eds.), The nonprofit sector: A research handbook (2nd ed., pp. 221–242). Yale University Press.


Weisbrod, B. (2009). The nonprofit economy. Harvard university press.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Understanding public support for redistribution is crucial for designing and implementing effective equality-enhancing public policies. This paper examines support for income equality versus individual efforts in response to exposure to natural hazards. Natural hazards, as unexpected events, significantly influence individuals' views, expectations, and attitudes toward government intervention. Using multi-level hierarchical modeling on individual-level data from various countries and regions, the findings support the hypothesis that experiences of natural disasters—events beyond individual control that deeply impact livelihoods—heighten support for collective action while reducing support for individualistic efforts or market-driven solutions.

 

Perceptions of fairness in societal outcomes are central to this shift. When individuals observe that natural disasters disproportionately harm some people while sparing others, they become more aware of the limitations of relying solely on market outcomes or individual efforts. Such realizations foster greater support for government intervention aimed at equalizing social outcomes and mitigating disadvantages caused by uncontrollable circumstances.

 

The study also highlights that while rational economic behavioral hypotheses—favoring individual efforts—generally hold, exposure to natural hazards triggers a marked reversal in these attitudes. Similarly, individuals who typically prioritize hard work as the key to success show increased support for collective action after experiencing natural disasters. These findings emphasize the need to tailor public policies to align with evolving public attitudes in the aftermath of natural disasters. Insights from this study contribute to a deeper understanding of how external events shape public policy preferences and support for redistributive measures.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The Fourth Industrial Revolution (4IR) has been promoted globally as a transformative force promising economic growth, technological innovation, and societal progress. However, its implementation in developing contexts such as South Africa has raised significant concerns about its implications for inequality, justice, and redistributive policies. This study investigates public perceptions of the 4IR, using data from the South African Social Attitudes Survey (SASAS), to explore the socio-demographic and economic factors that shape attitudes toward automation and technological advancement. It addresses critical questions: What shapes public perceptions of 4IR technologies? How do these perceptions reflect broader societal inequalities? And what are the implications for redistributive policies aimed at mitigating technological disruption?

The research employs a quantitative methodology, leveraging regression-based analysis to examine variables such as age, race, income, education, and employment status. Key findings reveal significant disparities in attitudes: marginalized groups express heightened skepticism due to fears of job displacement and inadequate governmental intervention, while more affluent individuals exhibit optimism tied to their relative security. Additionally, a generational divide is evident, with younger, tech-savvy individuals more accepting of automation than older cohorts, who fear obsolescence. Most respondents also lack confidence in the government’s ability to mitigate the adverse effects of automation, underscoring a critical trust deficit.

This paper argues that uncritically adopting 4IR technologies risks exacerbating existing inequalities unless accompanied by inclusive redistributive policies. It proposes measures such as universal basic income, targeted skills development, and enhanced STEM education to promote equitable participation. Moreover, the study highlights the necessity of engaging public opinion in policy formulation to ensure alignment between state actions and citizen priorities. This two-way relationship, where government decisions shape and are shaped by public perceptions, is crucial for advancing substantive equality and justice in a technology-driven democracy.

By addressing the intersection of public perceptions, redistributive policies, and inequality, this research contributes to the broader discourse on justice and the role of public opinion in shaping policy outcomes. It aligns with the panel’s objective to explore how societal demands, shaped by perceptions of fairness and inequality, inform and are informed by public policies. The findings underscore the importance of integrating public concerns into the design and implementation of 4IR policies, ensuring that technological progress benefits all, rather than entrenching socio-economic divides.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The objective of this project is to analyze the possibility that public policies to combat poverty and inequality may produce, in their implementation, possible unexpected effects that are contrary to their social purpose established in the design. Thus, the project has as its central question: can significant social inequalities be generated in the implementation of social policies, when in their design they seek exactly the opposite? Therefore, the study addresses two public policies (which are part of the Colombian social protection system) and analyzes their execution in a region of Colombia called Llanos Orientales.

Methodologically, the research is of a mixed nature. In this order, in the qualitative field, information gathering techniques are used, such as semi-structured interviews with both bureaucrats in charge of implementing the policies and their beneficiaries. Likewise, these interviews are analyzed according to coding and categorization techniques. Quantitative surveys are also conducted on the two population groups mentioned above. Therefore, the results of these surveys are analyzed with evaluation techniques, such as Pearson or Spearman.

The aim is to determine whether the implementation of the two public policies analysed generates inequalities or negative social impacts on the beneficiaries, as well as the reasons for this, if such impacts are confirmed. In this sense, issues such as the technical and political components inherent to the implementation of public policies are analytically explored, including variables such as the technical knowledge of bureaucrats, their values ​​and discretion regarding decisions on the beneficiaries of social policies (or even on potential beneficiaries), or the perception of the beneficiaries on the objective, structure and impact of the public policies studied, within the framework of the social protection system of Colombia.

 

Keywords: public policies, inequality, poverty, bureaucracy, implementation.

CO-AUTHORS
Ana Paula Santos (Universidade do Estado do Rio de Janeiro, Brazil)
ABSTRACT

This article aims to discuss the retrenchment strategies employed in two of Brazil's leading payment for environmental services programs (PES), Bolsa Floresta and Bolsa Verde. The goal is to identify the reasons behind the endurance of the former and the dissolution of the latter during crisis times. In general, the study frames the transformations in Bolsa Floresta and Bolsa Verde at two distinct levels: (1) the role of legal and fiscal centralization in shaping budget cuts, particularly during years of economic crisis, and (2) the drift mechanisms embedded in these policies from their inception. These issues are also assessed in light of the institutional changes that occurred during the transition from the Dilma government to the Temer government. As a result, we find that building a dedicated bureaucracy whose sole purpose was to finance the program was crucial for Bolsa Floresta's sustainability during Brazil’s severe economic and political crisis. However, both programs underwent distinct retrenchment strategies since their creation, which were intensified in 2014 and 2015. By situating PES within the broader discussion on social policies, inequality, and democracy, this study contributes to comparative debates on the legitimacy and political feasibility of redistributive policies, particularly in contexts of crisis. Moreover, it highlights the vulnerabilities of Bolsa Verde and Bolsa Floresta regarding retrenchment and proposes future research directions that integrate political culture and institutional change into the analysis of environmental social policies.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Russian women are less represented in the higher academic ranks and in academic management. Women, who dominate in the first stages of their careers, are significantly less represented in the subsequent ranks. These indicators of gender inequality have a direct impact on the general role of women in the Russian academic system. This trend of similar career paths for women is characteristic of the Russian public sector as a whole.
There are currently no national initiatives to promote the status and advancement of women in Russian science. This could be because the elitist class is currently more concerned with women as mothers than women as leaders and academics. In fact, all gender issues are now considered political and polarized according to the political ideology of elite actors. This paper therefore analyses gender issues, how they are perceived and how they are (un)resolved by state actors, using the academic environment as a case study. The author examines this case to answer the following research questions: (1) How is gender politics positioned in authoritarian settings? (2) To what extent are gender issues and women’s advancement part of social policy in authoritarian settings?
This study applies Feminist Institutionalism which considers gender balance as a feature of the institution and social structures. It focuses on the relationship between institutions and actors to eliminate gender misbalance. Such a theoretical approach provides considering gender equality as an integral element of institutional development. Feminist institutionalism may potentially become more applicable in academia, especially among gender researchers, as it emphasizes the importance of gender equality with consideration of women’s empowerment. In terms of methodology, it is a mixed-method study with quantitative and qualitative assessment of gender inequality, its perception and ways of dealing with it.
 
The relevance of the study lies in the analysis of gender use in the Russian academic community and in authoritarian settings, which is the Russian case. In addition, this research applies feminist institutionalism to point out how gender has been politicized in a combination of state policy and practice. The expected results will present the innovative application of feminist institutionalism for gender studies in the authoritarian context.
 
 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Administrative errors in policy implementation have attracted growing attention, particularly in the realm of welfare programs. Drawing on policy feedback theory, this study proposes a novel comparative policy feedback framework, highlighting two key mechanisms: the relative welfare loss arising from exclusion errors and the mistaken acceptance of benefits resulting from inclusion errors, both of which generate distinct resource and interpretive effects. Using data from China’s minimum living standard welfare scheme and a nationally representative survey, the study finds that, compared with accurate inclusion, both exclusion and inclusion errors reduce public trust in cadres and lower satisfaction with the government. Exclusion errors foster feelings of relative deprivation due to perceived welfare loss, while inclusion errors amplify perceptions of corruption by revealing information about ineligibility. Furthermore, previous negative experiences in citizen–state interactions intensify the impact of these administrative errors. Overall, the findings illuminate the complex dynamics of administrative errors and their broader feedback effects on the public.

 
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Health equity matters, but there is no universally accepted definition of this or associated terms, such as inequities, inequalities, and disparities. Given the flexibility of these terms, investigating how policymakers understand them is important to observe priorities and perhaps course correct. Accordingly, this study analyzed the perceptions high-level policymakers within the WHO African Region. An online survey was distributed to attendees of the WHO’s Fifth Health Sector Directors’ Policy and Planning Meeting for the WHO African Region by email. After responses were collected, both inductive and deductive coding were applied. Inductive coding was undertaken to glean central concepts from free-form responses on understandings of health equity and deductive coding was used to assess alignment with four theories of distributive justice using a coding framework. In analyzing central concepts, three became apparent: access to health services and/or health care, financial protection, and recognizing subgroups. And when we investigated alignment with theory, most respondents’ understandings of health equity aligned with Rawls’ ‘Theory of Justice’ (95%). Of these responses, 70% were exclusively aligned with Rawls’ ‘Theory of Justice’ and 30% aligned also with another theory (this 30% was split 55% utilitarianism and 45% Sen’s Capabilities Approach). Respondent understandings of health equity showed limited alignment with other theories of distributive justice, which were: utilitarianism (n=7/39; 17.95%), Sen’s Capabilities Approach (n=5/39; 12.82%), and libertarianism (n=2/39; 5.13%). This study demonstrates that alignment with certain theories is tied to specific themes (i.e., theoretical underpinnings may guide policymakers to favour certain policy approaches). For instance, a utilitarian-minded policymaker may be focused on a widespread vaccination campaign, whereas a Rawlsian-aligned policymaker may focus on a targeted approach to reach communities that have lower vaccination rates, and a Senian-aligned policymaker may focus on health literacy programs targeted at addressing vaccine-hesitant individuals within communities with lower vaccination rates. These findings can guide high-level policymakers and international organizations to optimize decision-making by clarifying ethical alternatives.

CO-AUTHORS
SAULO DE ARAUJO (Universidade de Brasília)
ABSTRACT

This essay aims to understand how the expansion policies of access to public higher education in Brazil and in the Federal District have created new ways of interaction between the academic community and the urban contexts where the new campuses were established. Specifically, we will explore how the installation of the University of Brasília (UnB) campus in Ceilândia (FCE) – designed for various health-related fields – has facilitated specific conditions for interaction between students, professors, and certain segments of Ceilândia's population.

The focus of this essay will be on the relationships between the extension projects/programs of FCE and the Ceilândia community. More specifically, we will conduct a quantitative and exploratory study of the continuous action extension project 'Integral Health in Needy Families of the Federal District' and the Extension Program 'Prevention and Rehabilitation of Elderly and Young Adults – Cardiac Patients or Not – and Their Integration into Sports,' with the goal of demonstrating the contribution to the local community based on these extension actions.

The establishment of the UnB campus in Ceilândia represents a significant milestone in the policy of expanding higher education in Brazil, especially in peripheral and underserved areas. This movement not only democratizes access to higher education but also promotes closer interaction between the university and the local community. Extension projects play a crucial role in this process, as they allow academic knowledge to be directly applied for the benefit of the population.

The 'Integral Health in Needy Families of the Federal District' project aims to provide comprehensive healthcare to families in vulnerable situations, addressing not only medical issues but also social and psychological aspects. Meanwhile, the 'Prevention and Rehabilitation of Elderly and Young Adults' Extension Program focuses on promoting health and rehabilitating individuals with cardiac problems, encouraging sports participation as a means to improve quality of life.

These initiatives not only directly benefit the residents of Ceilândia but also enrich the education of students, who have the opportunity to apply their knowledge in real-life situations and develop a deeper understanding of the community's needs and challenges. Thus, the presence of the UnB campus in Ceilândia and its extension projects exemplify how higher education can be a transformative agent in society.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The paper analyzes the justice, poverty and inequalities perceptions from beneficiaries and high and street level bureaucrats linked to income transfer programs in Brazil, between the years 1995 and 2010. Through long-term interviews with both groups, we identified, on the one hand, a coincidence of perceptions between bureaucrats and beneficiaries from the same location, regarding to the concepts and references of the programs; on the other, variations in perceptions between municipalities. The coincidence of perceptions suggests the diffusion of sectoral and global references from street-level bureaucrats to the beneficiaries of the policies they implement. The research findings corroborate the argument about the relevance of these actors for identifying the core values ​​that guide the implementation of policies, their concrete meaning, which does not always coincide with that formulated by managers. This implies in recognizing the process of opinion formation and diffusion of political culture through public policies, results that researchers often do not attach much importance to, although they are the core of the political-ideological conflict. Comparative studies brought evidence of a dispute between alternative models of income transfer programs, which operate on the ground in society: Minimum Income X Basic Income.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

A decade after the implementation of the Citizenship Basic Income, a public policy initiative in the municipality of Maricá (RJ), much can be discussed regarding its relationship with its beneficiaries. This study aims to examine the perceptions of Maricá residents enrolled to receive the benefit regularly, focusing on how they assess the impact of this policy on generating opportunities for their families and altering their socioeconomic status. The objective is to elucidate what beneficiaries consider to be concrete outcomes of the municipality's income distribution strategy. Supported by statistical contextualization and an extensive literature review, this research seeks to understand whether beneficiaries feel more secure and free as a result of the benefit, the extent to which its existence holds political significance for recipients, and whether it can be associated with a reduction in the local perception of poverty.