Format

P02. Social Equity in Public Policy

INEQUALITIES AND PUBLIC POLICY
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Shahjahan Bhuiyan
American University in Cairo
Main chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
INEQUALITIES AND PUBLIC POLICY
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Although a contesting concept, equity is believed to be the core of production and dissemination of knowledge across academic disciplines. In the context of a national state, when knowledge is diverse and inclusive, it helps governments to identify problems and to seek their socially equitable solutions for the benefit of their citizens. Public Administration as an academic discipline is discharging this critical responsibility dating to the early days of the field. Dwight Waldo, a US political scientist, who first described the influence of social equity on the body of public administration as a ductless gland, a subtle but important influence in the field. George Frederickson opines that the search for social equity provides public administration with a real normative base. In this particular milieu, the definition of social equity that has been advanced by Johnson and Savara (2011, p. 282) is deemed useful, "...is the active commitment to fairness, justice, and equality in the formation of public policy, distribution of public services, implementation of public policy, and management of all institutions serving the public directly of any contract. Public administrators, including all persons involved in public governance should seek to prevent and reduce inequality and injustice based on significant social characteristics and to promote greater equality in access to services, procedural fairness, quality of services and social outcomes."

 

Empirical evidence suggests that countries across the world suffers from the lack of social equity challenges. Wooldridge and Bilharz note that in today's increasingly divisive and complex world, issues of inequity are at the center of policy debates and public frustration regarding a variety of social problems. Widening income gaps, unequal access to health and education resources, and tensions between racial and social groups are at the forefront of conversations, particularly for the public agencies looking to resolve them. By examining the context of the social equity conversation, public administrators may better understand how to reduce inequities in society and the role public policy plays to advance the agenda.

 

The objectives of this panel is to understand the critical role social equity plays in shaping public policy. In doing so, this panel attempts to explore a broader research question: How and to what extent policy debates centering social equity shapes making and implementing public policy?   

 

CALL FOR PAPERS

Submissions are welcome on all relevant thematic issues (e.g., health, education, race, gender, economic) that cross-cut between any forms of social (in)equity and public policy. Depending on the number of submissions, similar thematic papers (e.g., racial inequity) will be categorized in one group to ensure a consistent discussion. It is expected that the papers that will be presented in this panel will trigger policy debates and offer policy solutions/suggestions to contribute to make a better world where we all aspire to live in a just society.   

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Equity and Human Rights Issues in the Responses to COVID 19 in Sub-Saharan African Cities
Geoffrey Nwaka (Abia State University, Uturu)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Many planners and government officials, who have idealized  notions of the modern African city,  tend to dismiss the continent’s large informal sector as ‘a chaotic jumble of unproductive activates’ that should be removed through forced eviction and repression. But the fact is that this sector supports local livelihoods and income, and has helped to alleviate poverty and provide some degree of social protection. Sadly, the informal sector workers are vulnerable to numerous occupational hazards, and to undue harassment by state officials. COVID 19 illustrates how the traditional prejudice against the informal sector was carried over in the top-down containment measures enforced during the pandemic. This caused more harm beyond the health threat, and has raised serious equity and human rights concerns. How do we build African cities that are not disconnected from people’s needs?

The initial information about COVID 19, and the standard advice about its control were based on data from high and middle income countries. There was panic that the epidemic would spread fast and take a heavy toll in Africa because of the general health conditions in Africa, and the limited capacity of the health system. Unfortunately, the aggressive measures adopted to contain and manage the pandemic did not sufficiently take into account the local cultures and social economy in Africa, and therefore affected informal sector workers and informal settlements disproportionately. Most informal sector workers depend for their daily earnings on constant movement and interaction outside the home – be they street or market traders, cart pushers, waste pickers, cab or motorcycle operators and so on. During the pandemic, they were exposed not only to infections but also to constant harassment by the police and other state officials who enforced COVID lock-down and other restrictions on movement. Housing conditions in informal settlements are usually overcrowded, with limited access to water, sanitation and other social services needed to comply with COVID protocols for social and physical distancing, hand washing, etc.  Structural inequalities in most cities excluded informal sector operators from meaningful participation in the design and implementation of COVID-related policies, and from due access to the palliatives provided by government and humanitarian organizations.

Africa is a large and diverse continent, and there were variations in the policy responses adopted in different cities; but with  hindsight, it now appears that the official response to the pandemic in most African cities was misguided in many respects. Africa accounts for only about 2 per cent of global COVID deaths; and many more people died from hunger and damage caused by stringent COVID policies. There was widespread distrust among the poor that these top down policies served the interest of the elite oppressors.  We argue that for the future, government officials and planners, who aspire to international standards of modernity, and adopt the prescriptions of the global community, must learn to strike the right balance between the ideals of international standards, and the reality of local conditions and requirements.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Explaining the Conditions for Knowledge Co-Production Outcomes in Citizen Science Using Structural Equation Modelling
Siqing Yu (KU Leuven)
CO-AUTHORS
Trui Steen (KU Leuven)
ABSTRACT

Understanding how to produce scientifically and socially valuable knowledge is pivotal for legitimising bottom-up evidence for effective policymaking and tackling complex sustainability challenges. Built on a previous study [1] that confirmed the correlated key factors and outcomes in the knowledge co-production process in citizen science (CS), this study further clarifies the factor-outcome causal relations to understand better the conditions required for scientific and social outcomes of knowledge co-production in CS. First, we used structural equation modelling (SEM) to analyse an online survey sample of 166 citizen science projects to investigate the correlations among the confirmed factors and outcomes. Second, we used multi-group analysis (MGA) to test the potential impact of three contextual variables on the factor-outcome causal relations, including the field of science, project longevity, and type of participation. The SEM model demonstrated direct and indirect causal effects among three exogenous constructs— “openness and accessibility” (OA), “volunteer trust” (VT), “researcher-volunteer connectedness” (RVC)—and two endogenous constructs— “technoscientific outputs” (TO) and “scientific citizenship” (SC). The key findings included: 1) although project settings (OA) have the highest impact on scientific outcomes (TO), social outcomes cannot be achieved without volunteer trust and strong researcher-volunteer relationships; 2) VT is integral for achieving both scientific and social outcomes; 3) project settings are crucial for facilitating VT and RVC; 4) the factor-outcome causal effects vary between natural and social-mixed sciences and between long-term and mid-short-term projects, whereas the former shows more divergence. Our results inform the literature on knowledge management, epistemology, evidence-based policymaking, and the practices of participatory research including CS. 

 

Keywords: epistemology, knowledge co-production, participatory research, citizen science, knowledge management, structural equation modelling

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Transforming Public Sector Performance: Applying the Liberatory Public Service Framework to Address Systemic Inequities
Meghna Sabharwal (The University of Texas at Dallas)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Transforming Public Sector Performance: Applying the Liberatory Public Service Framework to Address Systemic Inequities

 

Meghna Sabharwal, The University of Texas at Dallas

Rashmi Chordiya, Seattle University

Erna Ruijer, Utrecht University

Sean McCandless, The University of Texas at Dallas

Adana Protonentis, Kindred Consulting

Imane Hijal-Moghrabi, The University of Texas Permian Basin

Shilpa Viswanath, John Jay College of Criminal Justice, CUNY

 

 

Public administrators often navigate tensions and contradictions around operationalizing values such as equity, economy, effectiveness, and efficiency, which are frequently presented as competing principles in public administration (PA) and performance management. In this article, we argue for the application and integration of the liberatory public service (LPS) framework to align these values more effectively, using four illustrative case studies to demonstrate how LPS can offer a path forward in addressing the challenges inherent in public sector performance management. The LPS framework advocates for a trauma-informed, repair-centered public service that compassionately centers marginalized communities. We suggest that LPS can reframe equity, economy, effectiveness, and efficiency as complementary rather than competing values, playing a crucial role in addressing systemic inequities that disproportionately impact historically and persistently marginalized populations.

Traditional approaches to performance management in the public sector are deeply rooted in extractive capitalism, which relies on intersectional forms of oppression, such as racism, sexism, classism, and ableism. The sophisticated control and surveillance methods of performance management, often viewed as standard, have historical ties to managerial practices from early industrial-era scientific management. These modern management techniques aimed at achieving efficiency and economies of scale for greater profits originated from systems such as settler colonialism and slave-era plantation management. Consequently, capitalist approaches to public sector performance management risk becoming tools of oppression, contributing to the reproduction of systemic inequities and harm against marginalized communities. The case studies included in this article highlight how these systemic inequities persist within public sector performance management systems and demonstrate the need for a framework like LPS to address them.

The first case study examines backlash against diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives within the U.S. Federal Secret Service. The second case explores the decision of the Society of Human Resource Management to shift its focus away from equity, reflecting a broader resistance to equity initiatives in the workplace. The third case involves King County, which, despite progress toward racial and social justice, still faces challenges such as pay and promotion disparities and discrimination against Black women. Finally, the article analyzes a case from the Netherlands, where new data exchange methods used by the Tax Authority to enhance efficiency led to systemic discrimination against vulnerable groups due to an inadequate equity analysis. These case studies underscore how systemic inequities manifest in public performance management contexts and provide a strong argument for integrating the LPS framework to address these issues.

LPS is grounded in grassroots social justice movement frameworks and aligns with existing social equity-focused approaches in public administration. It recognizes the importance of emotional labor in public service, the need for care-centered and relational approaches, and the necessity of a public ethics of care guiding all public administration functions. LPS distills the teachings from various social justice frameworks and applies them to public service through five key principles. These principles include integrating inner and collective transformation, recognizing the pervasive trauma caused by historical and institutional oppression, and creating organizational spaces for healing and repair. LPS emphasizes the importance of centering the experiences of those most impacted by systemic inequities and seeks to transform harmful conditions, ending cycles of oppression.

LPS values love, courage, repair, healing, joy, efficacy, solidarity, and transformation. It offers a vision and a practice aimed at liberating public service from exclusionary and harmful systems, replacing them with inclusive, nourishing, and life-affirming systems that foster collective work, shared accountability, transparency, and care. In public performance management, LPS can guide the development of accountability and performance measurement systems that are trauma-informed, repair-oriented, and centered on the needs of those most impacted by inequitable systems. By integrating LPS, public performance management systems can mitigate harm caused by systemic disparities and advance the goals of efficiency, economy, effectiveness, equity, and collective liberation. We conclude by highlighting implications for future research and practice that integrate LPS into public performance and management at all levels.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Beyond Numbers: Consumption Expenditure Inequality Among Social Groups in India
Pushpendra Singh (Somaiya Vidyavihar University, Vidya Vihar East, Mumbai, India)
CO-AUTHORS
Archana Singh (International Institute for Population Sciences)
ABSTRACT

The deeply entrenched caste system in India is evident not only through visible social markers but also through practices that regulate consumption patterns, aligning individuals with their ascribed caste-based class status. Therefore, the objective of this study is to analyse the patterns of consumption expenditure among caste/social groups over the decade from 2011-12 to 2022-23. Additionally, it focuses on examining food and non-food expenditures to understand how caste-based disparities influence resource accessibility and consumption behaviour. Furthermore, it investigates the extent and dynamics of consumption inequality across socio-economic groups, with a particular focus on caste-based disparities and fractile classes.

 

To address these issues, the study uses household consumer expenditure surveys from the 2011-12 and 2022-23. First, the average consumption expenditure across all households was calculated and then broken down by social groups. Second, consumption inequality was measured and analysed using Theil Decomposition Indices and the Lorenz Curve. Finally, quantile regression was applied to examine how household consumption expenditure differs across various points in the income distribution for each social group.

 

The study reveals that per capita expenditure increased across all social groups over the decade from 2011-12 to 2022-23, with a noticeable shift from food to non-food spending. However, disadvantaged groups remain limited in their access to high-quality foods, highlighting persistent consumption inequality. Furthermore, inequality metrics, such as Theil indices and Gini coefficients, indicate that intra-group disparities are the primary drivers of inequality, particularly among higher-income households.

 

Keywords: Household Consumer Expenditure, Caste, Social Inequality, food to non-food spending, India.

 

 

JEL Classification : D11, D13, D19, E21 

 

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Social equity, policy, and public views on parents’ right to opt children out of curriculum content in schools
Nevbahar Ertas (University of Alabama at Birmingham)
CO-AUTHORS
Andrew McKnight (University of Alabama at Birmingham)
ABSTRACT

Aim: Increasing divisions regarding curriculum and instruction have resulted in calls for authority to opt children out of specific lessons, censorship of books, and removal of content from public school curriculums in the United States. As the call for this panel notes, “unequal access to educational resources, and tensions between racial and social groups” lie at the heart of critical policy debates and public frustration regarding various social issues. To address these challenges, public administrators and policymakers must consider the present nature of public opinion that may hamper effective civics education, specifically regarding the history of marginalized groups. Yet, the research literature on perceptions of parental opt-out is scarce. The purpose of this study is to address this gap by examining public opinion regarding parents opting their children out of learning about content they find objectionable.

 

Research questions: The study focuses on the following research questions: How prevalent is the view that parents should be able to opt-out their children from lessons at school in the United States? Do parents and non-parents differ in their opinion? Do these opinions vary by political affiliation and opinions about other education policy issues? To investigate the last question, we specifically focused on three key factors: Preference for parental authority over curriculum; Opinions regarding whether schools should teach the history and consequences of race and income inequality; and attitudes about inclusion of books on race and socio-economic inequality in curriculum.

 

Methodology: First, we will clarify the notion of social equity in education by relying on public administration and critical cultural theory. This discussion will critically reflect on the social equity implications of diminishing representation of diverse perspectives, histories, and voices in the curriculum. After our theoretical inquiry, we will present analysis of a large and nationally representative survey data collected in 2022 as part of the Understanding America Study to provide empirical insight into beliefs and attitudes regarding curricular control in U.S. schools.

 

How it fits with the panel's research questions: The call for papers states that the pursuit of social equity provides public administration with a “normative base.” In the case presented here, that base is represented by a culturally inclusive and historically accurate public school curricula that fosters effective social citizenship toward an equitable democracy. Public education is a key context for the social equity conversation, since exclusion of certain histories, cultures, or ideas restrict representation, perpetuate systemic inequities, and deny students the opportunity to engage with diverse, accurate, and critical knowledge necessary for an inclusive society. Recognizing the challenges and understanding public education as a key context for the social equity conversation is vital for identifying strategies to advance equity through effective public policy.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Operationalizing Equity for Education in the Budgeting Process
Sean McCandless (University of Texas at Dallas)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Social equity is a pillar of public administration alongside efficiency, effectiveness, and economy. It enshrines the value that the government serves should be fair for all. However, despite the seeming ease of defining equity as “fairness for all,” it becomes more complex when both conceptual and operational factors behind defining equity are considered. For instance, regarding conceptual definitions, “fairness for all” evokes questions of “fair for whom? Who and what deserves fairness? How do definitions of fairness arise from cultural contexts?” Regarding operational definitions, answers to conceptual questions lead to enduring issues of how to define equity for the purposes of measuring it, especially in terms of inputs, throughputs, and outputs. 

Governments all over the world are endeavoring to ask and answer these questions, especially within budgetary processes. As the quintessential administrative decision, budgeting decisions are reflective of power structures’ “answers” to questions of “who and what matter.” Social equity budgeting is a growing area of research, but work remains regarding how societal-conceptual definitions of fairness then link to operational definitions of fairness, especially in budgetary processes. 

The present work builds on previous social equity budgeting pieces and presents a collective case study examining how nine (9) intentionally selected governments at multiple levels–King County, Washington, USA; the Texas state government; the US national government; the UK national government; The French national government; the South African national government; the South Korean national government; the Australian national government; and the Colombian national government)--have addressed both the conceptual and operational dimensions of defining social equity in the budgetary process. As an analytical focus, each government will be analyzed not only in terms of stated overall definitions of equity but principally regarding equity definitions within education, a key dimension of social equity’s theoretical and normative mandate to “level the playing field” for all through fostering equal opportunity. 

Initial findings showcase how discourses–longitudinal debates over who and what matter for public policy–shape the content of both conceptual and operational definitions, especially regarding how “progress toward equity” is defined. These discourses lead to vastly different definitions of fairness, and, thus, government approaches to educational equity in the budgeting process. Some approaches de-emphasize the demographic nature of social equity (e.g., in France); or adopt contested notions of demographics and disproportionate inequities (e.g., in Colombia); or struggle to achieve outcomes despite an extensive social equity programme (e.g., King County, USA); and more. Still, all governments show some progress at improving educational outcomes, highlighting how the pursuit of social equity, while difficult, is an organic, multi-faceted endeavor.

Attendees will leave with a better understanding not only of what social equity means in terms of public administration theory but principally how conceptual and operational definitions matter and how governments across the world have addressed these important dimensions in educational budgeting. 

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Gender Justice in Indian Policy: Analyzing the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, and the POSH Act, 2013
swarna singh (National Human Rights Commission, India )
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Framed within the broader discourse on social equity in public policy, this research uses the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act of 2005 and the Prevention of Sexual Harassment (POSH) Act of 2013 as case studies to examine how policy reforms addressing systemic gender inequality are designed, implemented, and experienced in practice. These legislative measures reflect India’s commitment to constitutional values of fairness, justice, and equality and serve as key examples of public policy efforts aimed at advancing gender equity and social justice.

The Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, sought to rectify gender disparities in inheritance by granting daughters equal coparcenary rights, challenging patriarchal norms embedded in the Hindu Mitakshara property system. Similarly, the POSH Act was introduced to ensure safe and equitable workplaces for women, addressing systemic issues of harassment and gender-based violence. While these laws signify progressive legislative intent, the research reveals persistent challenges, including cultural resistance, social stigma, procedural inefficiencies, and lack of awareness, which hinder their effective implementation.

This study critically analyzes these factors, highlighting the gap between the legal provisions and their practical realization. It underscores the importance of bridging this divide through targeted interventions such as improving awareness campaigns, streamlining enforcement mechanisms, and fostering cultural shifts to support gender-sensitive governance. By exploring the legislative and societal dynamics surrounding these two landmark reforms, this paper aims to contribute to the understanding of how public policy can promote social equity and address gender-based inequities in India.

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Climate change adaptation policy and the issues of social inequality of climatic displaced people in Bangladesh
Tasnuva Habib Zisan (University of Dhaka)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In recent years climate change and its multidimensional consequences have been in discussions over the world. Bangladesh remained in this discussion due to its vulnerability and recent climatic extreme events. Consequences of climate change like migration is also much discussed in literature. Yet, recent literature hardly analyzes the policies and strategies adopted by the government and less focus is given on the role of these policies in mitigating the inequalities and vulnerabilities of migrants. Bangladesh as a deltaic country faces climatic events frequently. It is acknowledged that cyclone related death and hazard have been reduced 100 times than 1970s in Bangladesh and recognized as a global leader in climate change adaptation and disaster preparedness. Despite this development in resilience mechanism it continues to face climatic issues and very high risks. Such risks lead to social, political, economic and other vulnerabilities. Therefore, this study looks into the social dynamics of the post-migration contexts. The internal migration is considered here as most of the climatic migration happens within the country. Social inequalities and discriminations experienced by climatic migrants, especially in the cities are discussed in this study.  This study aims to explore the specific vulnerabilities of climatic displaced people and the existing policy framework that addresses the migrants’ needs. It also tries to find out the policy gaps in integration, inclusion and ensuring equity in climate adaptation frameworks. To address the research gap the study asks what are the fundamental challenges migrants face in adapting to climate change and migration? How do the existing climate change adaptation policy and strategies account for migrants? What policy changes are necessary to ensure equitable access to climate adaptation resources for migrants? This paper is a qualitative study and analysis is based on secondary data from the policy papers, project reports and available literature in this field.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - The Pathway of Digital Transformation to Social Equity: An Institutional Analysis of TPMAP in Thailand
Charoon Ponghan (Yonsei University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The convergence of digital transformation and social equity has become a critical area of governance, particularly in addressing systemic poverty and inequity. This study explores the pathway of digital transformation to social equity through an institutional analysis of the Thai People Map and Analytics Platform (TPMAP) in Thailand. It investigates how TPMAP, a government-initiated big data platform, leverages digital technologies to address poverty and reduce social inequity. The research is guided by three key questions: (1) How does TPMAP use big data to tackle poverty and inequity in Thailand? (2) What institutional factors enable or constrain the TPMAP’s impact on social equity? (3) What are the challenges and policy implications for enhancing TPMAP’ s effectiveness? To address these questions, the study employs the Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD) framework to analyze TPMAP’s institutional arrangements, stakeholder interactions, and outcomes. Using a qualitative case study approach, the research combines content analysis and descriptive analysis of secondary data sources including government reports, official statements, academic studies, and media reports, and semi-structured interviews with relevant stakeholders involved in TPMAP’s implementation at national, provincial, and local levels. The IAD framework allows for a comprehensive examination of how contextual factors, action arenas, and patterns of interaction shape TPMAP’s role in promoting social equity. The findings reveal that TPMAP has transformed Thailand’s approach to poverty alleviation by enabling multi-dimensional poverty analysis, data-driven decision-making, and targeted resource allocation. However, challenges such as political transitions, data accuracy issues, and the need for sustained stakeholder collaboration highlight the complexities of implementing digital transformation initiatives for social equity. The study concludes with recommendations for institutionalizing TPMAP as a non-partisan tool, strengthening data governance, and fostering broader stakeholder engagement to ensure long-term sustainability and equity impact. This paper aligns with the panel’s research question by demonstrating how social equity considerations have influenced the design, implementation, and governance of TPMAP. It highlights the role of digital transformation in addressing systemic inequities and provides insights into the institutional dynamics that enable or constrain equitable policy outcomes. By examining TPMAP as a case study, the paper contributes to broader discussions on how digital governance can advance social equity in developing countries.

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - Increasing Social Inclusion for Post-secondary Students with Learning Disabilities in Ontario, Canada
Cameron McKenzie (Wilfrid Laurier University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Despite the widespread establishment of accommodation policies to ensure access to participation for students with disabilities in post-secondary institutions, barriers persist for those with Learning Disabilities (LD). More specifically, the onus is often put on students with LD to navigate the academic impact of their non-apparent disability. To understand facilitators and barriers based on their lived experience, we interviewed 40 students with LD currently enrolled in university programs in Ontario, Canada. In addition, we analyzed websites of the disability services offices of the 22 publicly-funded English-language Ontario universities. Data from the semi-structured interviews were thematically analyzed and coded in NVivo, and three themes emerged: stigma, self-advocacy and mental health. Under stigma, 30 participants referenced the non-apparent aspect of their LD as a challenge. Several reported that others had not believed that their need for accommodation (i.e., their LD) was legitimate. Some had been accused of “faking it” or being “lazy” by peers or educators. Several interviewees referred to self-advocacy as necessary to access accommodations because of the non-apparent nature of their disability. Self-advocacy was the key to academic success for students who had the confidence to use it. Finally, over half of the students interviewed cited mental health as an ongoing concern. These students described experiences with anxiety, burnout, exhaustion and stress. In some circumstances, the self-advocacy required to navigate the impact of their LD was directly named as the source of their mental health issues. This theme highlights the importance of the intersection between mental health and non-apparent disability for students in post-secondary education. By including the voices of students with LD, we are able to deepen our understanding of the impact of institutional processes and accommodation. Our findings illustrate the individualistic nature of accessibility at universities. Website analysis revealed multiple inconsistencies across institutions in policy about documentation requirements for students with LD. To improve students’ overall experiences, participants recommended increased funding to obtain formal documentation, increase staffing at disability services offices (DSOs), increase awareness of DSOs, and for better communication between DSOs and instructors. Overall, this study confirms that post-secondary students with LD face barriers to access, with many related to the non-apparent nature of their disability. Our findings and recommendations are relevant to post-secondary institutions’ policies and processes attempting to reduce accessibility barriers for students with LD. 
 This research paper fits well into the thematic issues of social inequity because it provides data to confirm lived experience of barriers to access for post-secondary students with disabilities.

ACCEPTED
Format
11 - How to reduce social inequities in the field of physical activity policy? Co-producing policy recommendations in 6 EU countries
Sven Messing (University of Limerick)
CO-AUTHORS
Leonie Birkholz (Friedrich-Alexander Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg)
Peter Gelius (University of Lausanne)
Catherine Woods (University of Limerick)
ABSTRACT

Introduction: The importance of policies to promote physical activity is increasingly recognised, as such policies have the potential to create healthier environments that encourage active lifestyles. While there is a growing body of research on the effectiveness of PA promotion policies, their impact on reducing social (health) inequities remains unclear. This perspective is also not systematically addressed by existing tools for monitoring and evaluating policies in the field of physical activity promotion.

This study aims to adapt the use of a public policy implementation assessment tool – the Physical Activity Environment Policy Index (PA-EPI), currently implemented in 6 EU countries – to better address social inequities. This includes the development of an equity module and the systematic consideration of equity in the process of using the tool. This will improve the understanding of the role of social equity in public policy in this field of research.
 
Methods: To develop an equity module, a systematic review was conducted, which included a comprehensive search of six databases, independent screening of the records by two reviewers, and synthesis of the included studies. Studies were clustered into policy domains based on ISPAH's “Eight Investments that work for Physical Activity” framework, and studies that demonstrated positive effects on reducing social inequities through the promotion of physical activity were analysed to identify good practice. Experts were consulted to finalise the equity module.
To integrate equity considerations systematically in the process of using the tool, a literature search and expert interviews were conducted.
 
Results: Based on 38 scientific studies and 8 grey literature documents, a PA-EPI Equity Module has been developed. The module includes statements for the 45 indicators of the PA-EPI and provides guidance on how to systematically integrate social equity into the process of data collection (e.g., on national health, sport, or active transport policies). To ensure that a social equity perspective is taken into account in the process of using the tool, equity councils will be established, composed of organisations representing socially disadvantaged groups. The purpose of these equity councils is to define and refine policy recommendations for physical activity promotion from a social equity perspective.
 
Discussion: The study systematically integrates social equity into a tool for assessing the implementation of public policies to promote physical activity. It has identified effective physical activity policies that reduce inequalities across various domains. These examples of good practice provide blueprints for other countries and can inform policy development, not only in the 6 EU countries currently using the tool.

The study highlights the need for researchers and policymakers to use scientific evidence to advance the policy agenda aimed at promoting social equity. In addition, the study provides insights into how policy recommendations that include a social equity perspective can be developed in a systematic and participatory process. These findings can contribute to learning between countries and support the development of more equitable public policies.

ACCEPTED
Format
12 - Eliminating petty corruption as a barrier to health equity: An Analysis of Anti-Corruption Measures in Lithuania
Vytautas Valentinavicius (Kaunas University of Technology, Lithuania)
CO-AUTHORS
Raminta Pucetaite (Kaunas University of Technology)
Donata Jovarauskiene (Kaunas University of Technology)
Rimantas Rauleckas (Kaunas University of Technology)
ABSTRACT

The fifth author – Jolanta Vaičiūnienė (Kaunas University Technology) 

 

Health equity is a cornerstone of social equity and a prerequisite at the system level for individuals to exercise agency as maintained by the human capacity approach (Braveman, 2010; Nussbaum, 2011). Ensuring accessibility to healthcare and quality of healthcare service is a moral duty of democratic states (Sen, 2002). Petty corruption defined as small-scale (e.g. 50 EUR) payment of bribes or other material and immaterial means of motivating low- and mid-level public officials such as healthcare professionals to amend their behaviour in order to facilitate higher quality or faster access to healthcare services (Graycar, 2015), is among the sociocultural barriers that distort service delivery, worsen inequalities, and reduce access to healthcare. Corruption poses a major threat to the stability and reinforcement of democracy (Mungiu-Pippidi, 2006), eroding trust in democratic structures (Jha et al. 2024). Even within democratic systems, corruption, including petty corruption, continues to diminish transparency and weaken public trust in healthcare system (Brueckner, 2021; European Commission, 2022).

 

Reducing corruption is essential for strengthening health systems, advancing health equity, and mitigating social inequalities. While previous research has examined the impact of corruption on healthcare systems, limited attention has been paid to how national and institutional policies address these challenges, particularly in post-occupational EU democracies like Lithuania, where Soviet-era legacies and European integration efforts intersect (see Weistra et al., 2017; Parvanova, 2025). Moreover, the role of policies in combatting petty corruption as a form of corruption has received far less attention in corruption studies. We address the respective gaps in academic discourse by conducting a two-level analysis. First, we examine Lithuania’s national health policies and legal frameworks to evaluate the anticorruption measures enshrined in law and the obligations of healthcare institutions to establish anticorruption measures within institutional policies. Specifically, we take a critical look at policies to identify measures for combatting petty corruption. Second, we evaluate whether and how national policies are reflected in institutional policies to guarantee health equity and address the causes of petty corruption, which is among the highest in the EU (European Commission, 2022). Using qualitative document analysis, our objective is to identify gaps between national and institutional policies and provide policymakers with recommendations on integrating anticorruption measures to strengthen health equity assurance, enhance regulatory compliance in healthcare settings, and promote greater social equity in healthcare access.

 

Bibliography
Brueckner, M. (2021). Democracy and corruption. Journal of Risk and Financial Management 14: 492.
Braveman, P. (2010). Social conditions, health equity, and human rights. Health & Human Rights, 12(2):  31-48
European Commission, Directorate-General for Migration and Home Affairs, Corruption – Report, Publications Office of the European Union, 2022, available at https://data.europa.eu/doi/10.2837/110098 Graycar, A. (2015). Corruption: Classification and analysis. Policy and Society, 34(2): 87-96.
Jha, S., and Kolev, K. (2024). How Corruption at the Top Erodes Support for Democracy. Stanford University.
Mungiu-Pippidi, A. (2006). Corruption: Diagnosis and treatment. Journal of Democracy, 17(3), 86–99. 
Nussbaum, M.C. (2011), Creating Capabilities. The Human Development Approach. Cambridge, MA; London: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press
Glynn, E.H. (2022). Corruption in the health sector: A problem in need of a systems-thinking approach. Front. Public Health 10:91007.
Parvanova, I. (2025). The effect of institutional characteristics and social norms on corruption in healthcare. Governance, e12868.
Sen A. (2002). Why health equity? Health Economics, 11(8):659–666. doi: 10.1002/hec.762
Weistra, K., Swart, L., Oortwijn, W., Raets, T. et al. (2017). Updated study on corruption in the healthcare sector – Final report, European Commission: Directorate General for Migration and Home Affairs. Publications Office.

ACCEPTED
Format
13 - Analysis of decentralized expenditure on spatial inequality in Mexico
Brenda Coutiño (Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Analysis of decentralized expenditure on spatial inequality in Mexico

 

Decentralization plays a key role in the provision of public goods and services, primarily through the distribution of federalized spending. This mechanism serves as one of the main instruments through which the federal government transfers resources to states and municipalities. In Mexico, decentralization continues to raise questions regarding its effectiveness in strengthening the responsiveness of subnational governments to the demands of their populations, as well as in promoting financial autonomy and investment in social infrastructure (López-Acevedo & Webb, 2006).

 

This article examines the relationship between income inequality among federal entities and federalized spending through the spatial Gini index, which measures inequality in this dimension. The objective of this analysis is to determine whether federalized spending effectively compensates and/or remedies disparities in revenue-generating capacity among states or whether it exacerbates budgetary gaps, considering that federal entities have varying levels of agency, administrative, institutional, and operational capacity to provide quality public goods and services to their population.

 

At the subnational level, the spatial Gini index is typically calculated based on per capita gross domestic product (GDP) without accounting for potential spatial relationships among the data (Panzera & Postiglione, 2019). Meanwhile, income inequality analyses are generally conducted using household- or individual-level data, often overlooking the spatial dimension of income inequality in terms of the revenues received by subnational governments.

 

From an economic perspective, traditional economic convergence models assign a minimal role to state intervention, arguing that market forces alone can reduce inequality. In contrast, new regional models emphasize the importance of state intervention, as it can trigger processes of concentration and increasing returns through public investment and infrastructure development (Cuenca-López & Torres, 2020). Consequently, measuring spatial inequality is a complex task, as it requires accounting for the interactions that occur across neighboring regions.

 

Using data from the Federal Expenditure Budgets for the years 2021 to 2024 for Mexico’s 32 federal entities (PEF, 2021–2024), this study employs the spatial Gini index proposed by Rey and Smith (2013), which incorporates neighborhood effects primarily through spatial weight matrices and Moran’s indices. This approach aims to determine the relative position of federal entities in relation to both neighboring and non-neighboring states, assessing whether a spatial spillover effect exists among them or whether greater inequality is observed among non-adjacent states (Anselin, 2006). The findings are expected to reveal an increase in spatial inequality as a result of higher spatial autocorrelation, suggesting the expansion of the spatial structure of inequality.

 

 

References

 

Anselin, L. (2006). Spatial econometrics. En T. Mills y K. Patterson (Eds.), Econometric theory. Palgrave Handbook of Econometrics (vol. 1, pp. 901–969). Palgrave McMillan.

 

Cuenca-López, A. D., & Torres, D. E. (2020). Impacto de la inversión en infraestructura sobre la pobreza en Latinoamérica en el período 1996-2016. Población y desarrollo, 26(50), 5-18. https://doi.org/10.18004/pdfce/2076-054x/2020.026.50.005-018

 

Lopez-Acevedo, G. C., & Webb, S. B. (2006).Decentralized service delivery for the poor: core report. World Bank Group. https://documents. worldbank.org/en/publication/documents-reports/documentdetail/599781468045052393/core-report

 

Panzera, D. y Postiglione, P. (2019). Measuring the spatial dimension of regional inequality: an approach based on the Gini Correlation Measure. Social Indicators Research, 148, 379-394.

 

Rey, S. J. y Smith, R. J. (2013). A spatial decomposition of the Gini coefficient.  Letters in Spatial and Resource Sciences, 6, 55-70.

 

Secretaría de Hacienda y Crédito Público (2008), Presupuesto de Egresos de la Federación, México, SHCP. Retrieved from https://www.finanzaspublicas.hacienda.gob.mx/es/Finanzas_Publicas/Paquete_Economico_y_Presupuesto

ACCEPTED
Format
14 - Limits to Social Equity in Public Policy: Evidence from Affordable Housing in Urban Bangladesh
Aaqib Zahid (University of Dhaka)
CO-AUTHORS
Nusrat Chowdhury (University of Dhaka)
ABSTRACT

The term social equity has been considered one of the fundamental pillars of Public Administration, although the interpretation of the same is somehow catered according to the ethos and practices of administration in a particular context. However, compared to other pillars of public administration, such as efficiency, effectiveness, and economy (Gooden and Portillo, 2011), the normative nature of equity provides the scope for narrative-based qualitative analysis in social equity research to understand the intricate factors that shape social equity in public administration and policy. With this understanding and opportunity, this paper intends to explore how social equity is perceived and prioritized in the affordable urban housing projects in The National Housing Policy of Bangladesh (2016) and explore the political, administrative, and cultural context that impacts the social equity in these projects. To be more specific, this paper focuses on the National Housing Authority (NHA), under the Ministry of Housing and Public Works, that envisions providing affordable housing access to all strata of society and undertakes various housing projects and allocates plots throughout Bangladesh. However, to what extent these projects ensure social equity remains largely unexplored. The guiding question of this paper is how social equity, as outlined in the National Housing Policy 2016, translated into the implementation of affordable urban housing projects and practices by NHA? To explore social equity, this research uses Johnson and Svara's (2011) framework that measures social equity through four dimensions, namely- procedural fairness (equal process for all), access (no barrier to participation), quality (same level of treatment) and outcomes (reduction of inequality). This research will follow a comparative case study approach by examining four selected projects by NHA in Dhaka City that have been targeted for different socio-economic groups and cater to the largest number of people. The study area has been chosen for two reasons: first, Dhaka is one of the overly populated cities in the world with a surge of migration and unplanned settlements, and second, NHA has the highest number of projects in Dhaka that cater to the highest number of people. The data will be collected from primary and secondary sources: secondary data from documents related to the projects and primary data from narratives of policymakers, implementers, project supervisors, experts, as well as the beneficiaries of the projects. The narratives or primary data will be collected through in-depth interviews following a purposive sampling technique to have a diverse perspective. This paper is expected to unpack further how the concept of social equity is translated into policy implementation, especially in the context of a developing country, which has not been studied widely. Based on the findings and the analysis, the research would provide input to make such projects more socially equitable, and it aspires to add more depth to Svara and Johnson's Framework.

This paper fits this panel because it aligns its core theme through empirical research that aspires to provide policy solutions and advance theoretical understanding.

ACCEPTED
Format
15 - Uneven Green Spaces in a Megacity: Investigating Environmental Inequalities in Shanghai's Urban Development
Hanzhi REN (Hong Kong University of Science and Technology)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This study examines how land use policies and zoning regulations in Shanghai have shaped environmental inequalities in access to green spaces and recreational areas, highlighting the complex interplay between urban development, socio-demographic factors, and environmental justice. Shanghai, as China's largest metropolis with over 30 million residents, presents a compelling case study of how rapid urbanization and historical planning decisions have created disparities in green space accessibility across different social groups and districts.

Using spatial analysis and demographic data from 2010-2023, this research investigates the distribution of parks, community gardens, and recreational facilities across Shanghai's 16 districts, revealing significant disparities between the city's core and peripheral areas. The study finds that while Shanghai's overall green space per capita has increased from 7.6 square meters in 2010 to 9.2 square meters in 2023, this growth has been uneven, with historically advantaged central districts like Xuhui and Jing'an enjoying substantially better access to quality green spaces compared to outer districts like Jiading and Minhang.

The research also reveals how Shanghai's recent urban planning initiatives, such as the "15-Minute Community Life Circle" policy and the "Sponge City" program, have attempted to address these inequities. However, implementation challenges, including limited land availability and competing development pressures, have complicated efforts to achieve more equitable green space distribution. The study identifies specific zoning mechanisms, such as floor area ratio bonuses for developers who provide public green spaces and mandatory green space requirements for new developments, that have shown promise in improving access in underserved areas.

The research concludes that addressing environmental inequality in Shanghai requires not only technical planning solutions but also a fundamental reconsideration of how land use policies can better serve environmental justice goals. This calls for more inclusive planning processes, stronger regulatory frameworks for green space provision, and targeted investments in historically underserved communities.

ACCEPTED
Format
16 - Fertility vs. Equality: The Unintended Labor Market Consequences of China’s Paid Family Leave Expansion
Chenling Wan (LKY School of Public Policy, National University of Singapore)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper examines how China’s 2016 reforms extending paid maternity leave and paternity leave have shaped women’s labor market outcomes, with a particular focus on social equity and gender disparities. Drawing on six waves of the China Family Panel Studies (CFPS) from 2010 to 2020, I use a difference-in-differences approach to exploit temporal and provincial variations in paid family leave. My research question is twofold: (1) How do extended maternity and newly introduced paternity leave policies affect women’s labor force participation and weekly working hours? and (2) Do these policies produce unintended spillover effects on women without children and on young men?

Methodologically, I leverage provincial-level policy data on maternity and paternity leave—collected from official documents—and merge them with individual-level survey responses on employment status, income, working hours. This allows us to estimate the causal impact of policy changes while controlling for individual characteristics, province-specific trends, and year fixed effects. The findings highlight a substantial negative effect of longer maternity leave on female labor market engagement, including for nulliparous (childless) women. Younger women, in particular, bear the largest penalties in terms of reduced workforce participation and working hours. By contrast, the introduction and expansion of paternity leave—even though relatively short—mitigate these adverse impacts and improve outcomes for women. Importantly, a higher paternity-to-maternity leave ratio correlates strongly with higher labor force participation and longer weekly work hours for women, suggesting that shared caregiving responsibilities can lessen labor market inequalities.

These findings carry clear implications for T17 P02: Social Equity in Public Policy, demonstrating how well-intentioned family leave reforms may inadvertently shift employers’ expectations, thus limiting women’s employment opportunities and widening gender gaps. Such pressures can also suppress fertility intentions, undermining the very goals of pro-natal policies.

In contributing to the panel’s exploration of how public policies shape social equity outcomes, this paper underscores the need to look beyond the apparent friendliness of family leave policies to understand their potential unintended consequences. It shows that when businesses need to bear the costs associated with employees' childbirth, shared parental leave is crucial in promoting equitable labor market participation and can serve as a model for other contexts seeking to reconcile fertility policies with broader commitments to social equity and gender parity.

ACCEPTED
Format
17 - Bridging the Gap: Analyzing Social Equity and Representation in Indian Higher Education Institutions
Kiran Kumar Gowd (Center for Politics and Policy Studies (CPPS))
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Abstract

Diversity and inclusion are critical to ensuring equitable access to education and addressing historical socio-economic inequalities in Indian Higher Education Institutions (HEIs). However, despite constitutional mandates and affirmative action through reservation policies, the representation of Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST), and Other Backward Classes (OBCs) in HEIs remains alarmingly disproportionate. This paper examines the implementation and impact of reservation policies on social equity in HEIs, drawing on data collected through the Right to Information (RTI) Act to assess the representation of various social categories in faculty positions, student enrollments, and administrative roles.

The initial part of the paper situates the issue within the broader context of social justice and educational equity. A review of relevant literature highlights the transformative potential of reservation policies as envisioned by scholars such as B. R. Ambedkar and other proponents of affirmative action. However, existing studies also underscore systemic challenges, including institutional resistance, discriminatory practices, and inadequate implementation of quotas, which hinder the realization of social justice goals. Recent works, such as Thorat and Attewell (2007) and Sukhadeo Thorat’s studies on exclusion in HEIs, provide critical insights into the persistence of caste-based inequalities despite policy interventions.

The findings of this paper, based on RTI responses from leading HEIs, reveal stark disparities in the representation of SCs, STs, and OBCs. The data reflects an underrepresentation of these groups in faculty positions, PhD programs, and high-ranking administrative roles, highlighting a significant gap between policy and practice. Moreover, the paper identifies trends of overrepresentation among dominant social groups, indicating systemic biases and limited institutional accountability. These findings underline the urgent need for comprehensive reforms to ensure effective implementation of reservation policies, transparency in recruitment and admissions, and mechanisms to monitor compliance with affirmative action mandates.

The paper argues that fostering genuine diversity and inclusion in HEIs requires a paradigm shift in institutional culture and governance. It concludes by recommending policy measures, such as the periodic public disclosure of diversity metrics, capacity-building programs for marginalized groups, and enhanced oversight by regulatory bodies, to bridge the gap between constitutional ideals and on-ground realities. This study contributes to the ongoing discourse on social equity in Indian education, emphasizing the critical role of HEIs in creating a more inclusive and just society.

Keywords: Diversity and Inclusion, Higher Education Institutions (HEIs), Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST), Other Backward Classes (OBCs), Reservation Policy, Social Equity, Caste-based Inequalities, Right to Information (RTI), Affirmative Action, Educational Justice, Institutional Discrimination, Policy Implementation.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Many planners and government officials, who have idealized  notions of the modern African city,  tend to dismiss the continent’s large informal sector as ‘a chaotic jumble of unproductive activates’ that should be removed through forced eviction and repression. But the fact is that this sector supports local livelihoods and income, and has helped to alleviate poverty and provide some degree of social protection. Sadly, the informal sector workers are vulnerable to numerous occupational hazards, and to undue harassment by state officials. COVID 19 illustrates how the traditional prejudice against the informal sector was carried over in the top-down containment measures enforced during the pandemic. This caused more harm beyond the health threat, and has raised serious equity and human rights concerns. How do we build African cities that are not disconnected from people’s needs?

The initial information about COVID 19, and the standard advice about its control were based on data from high and middle income countries. There was panic that the epidemic would spread fast and take a heavy toll in Africa because of the general health conditions in Africa, and the limited capacity of the health system. Unfortunately, the aggressive measures adopted to contain and manage the pandemic did not sufficiently take into account the local cultures and social economy in Africa, and therefore affected informal sector workers and informal settlements disproportionately. Most informal sector workers depend for their daily earnings on constant movement and interaction outside the home – be they street or market traders, cart pushers, waste pickers, cab or motorcycle operators and so on. During the pandemic, they were exposed not only to infections but also to constant harassment by the police and other state officials who enforced COVID lock-down and other restrictions on movement. Housing conditions in informal settlements are usually overcrowded, with limited access to water, sanitation and other social services needed to comply with COVID protocols for social and physical distancing, hand washing, etc.  Structural inequalities in most cities excluded informal sector operators from meaningful participation in the design and implementation of COVID-related policies, and from due access to the palliatives provided by government and humanitarian organizations.

Africa is a large and diverse continent, and there were variations in the policy responses adopted in different cities; but with  hindsight, it now appears that the official response to the pandemic in most African cities was misguided in many respects. Africa accounts for only about 2 per cent of global COVID deaths; and many more people died from hunger and damage caused by stringent COVID policies. There was widespread distrust among the poor that these top down policies served the interest of the elite oppressors.  We argue that for the future, government officials and planners, who aspire to international standards of modernity, and adopt the prescriptions of the global community, must learn to strike the right balance between the ideals of international standards, and the reality of local conditions and requirements.

CO-AUTHORS
Trui Steen (KU Leuven)
ABSTRACT

Understanding how to produce scientifically and socially valuable knowledge is pivotal for legitimising bottom-up evidence for effective policymaking and tackling complex sustainability challenges. Built on a previous study [1] that confirmed the correlated key factors and outcomes in the knowledge co-production process in citizen science (CS), this study further clarifies the factor-outcome causal relations to understand better the conditions required for scientific and social outcomes of knowledge co-production in CS. First, we used structural equation modelling (SEM) to analyse an online survey sample of 166 citizen science projects to investigate the correlations among the confirmed factors and outcomes. Second, we used multi-group analysis (MGA) to test the potential impact of three contextual variables on the factor-outcome causal relations, including the field of science, project longevity, and type of participation. The SEM model demonstrated direct and indirect causal effects among three exogenous constructs— “openness and accessibility” (OA), “volunteer trust” (VT), “researcher-volunteer connectedness” (RVC)—and two endogenous constructs— “technoscientific outputs” (TO) and “scientific citizenship” (SC). The key findings included: 1) although project settings (OA) have the highest impact on scientific outcomes (TO), social outcomes cannot be achieved without volunteer trust and strong researcher-volunteer relationships; 2) VT is integral for achieving both scientific and social outcomes; 3) project settings are crucial for facilitating VT and RVC; 4) the factor-outcome causal effects vary between natural and social-mixed sciences and between long-term and mid-short-term projects, whereas the former shows more divergence. Our results inform the literature on knowledge management, epistemology, evidence-based policymaking, and the practices of participatory research including CS. 

 

Keywords: epistemology, knowledge co-production, participatory research, citizen science, knowledge management, structural equation modelling

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Transforming Public Sector Performance: Applying the Liberatory Public Service Framework to Address Systemic Inequities

 

Meghna Sabharwal, The University of Texas at Dallas

Rashmi Chordiya, Seattle University

Erna Ruijer, Utrecht University

Sean McCandless, The University of Texas at Dallas

Adana Protonentis, Kindred Consulting

Imane Hijal-Moghrabi, The University of Texas Permian Basin

Shilpa Viswanath, John Jay College of Criminal Justice, CUNY

 

 

Public administrators often navigate tensions and contradictions around operationalizing values such as equity, economy, effectiveness, and efficiency, which are frequently presented as competing principles in public administration (PA) and performance management. In this article, we argue for the application and integration of the liberatory public service (LPS) framework to align these values more effectively, using four illustrative case studies to demonstrate how LPS can offer a path forward in addressing the challenges inherent in public sector performance management. The LPS framework advocates for a trauma-informed, repair-centered public service that compassionately centers marginalized communities. We suggest that LPS can reframe equity, economy, effectiveness, and efficiency as complementary rather than competing values, playing a crucial role in addressing systemic inequities that disproportionately impact historically and persistently marginalized populations.

Traditional approaches to performance management in the public sector are deeply rooted in extractive capitalism, which relies on intersectional forms of oppression, such as racism, sexism, classism, and ableism. The sophisticated control and surveillance methods of performance management, often viewed as standard, have historical ties to managerial practices from early industrial-era scientific management. These modern management techniques aimed at achieving efficiency and economies of scale for greater profits originated from systems such as settler colonialism and slave-era plantation management. Consequently, capitalist approaches to public sector performance management risk becoming tools of oppression, contributing to the reproduction of systemic inequities and harm against marginalized communities. The case studies included in this article highlight how these systemic inequities persist within public sector performance management systems and demonstrate the need for a framework like LPS to address them.

The first case study examines backlash against diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives within the U.S. Federal Secret Service. The second case explores the decision of the Society of Human Resource Management to shift its focus away from equity, reflecting a broader resistance to equity initiatives in the workplace. The third case involves King County, which, despite progress toward racial and social justice, still faces challenges such as pay and promotion disparities and discrimination against Black women. Finally, the article analyzes a case from the Netherlands, where new data exchange methods used by the Tax Authority to enhance efficiency led to systemic discrimination against vulnerable groups due to an inadequate equity analysis. These case studies underscore how systemic inequities manifest in public performance management contexts and provide a strong argument for integrating the LPS framework to address these issues.

LPS is grounded in grassroots social justice movement frameworks and aligns with existing social equity-focused approaches in public administration. It recognizes the importance of emotional labor in public service, the need for care-centered and relational approaches, and the necessity of a public ethics of care guiding all public administration functions. LPS distills the teachings from various social justice frameworks and applies them to public service through five key principles. These principles include integrating inner and collective transformation, recognizing the pervasive trauma caused by historical and institutional oppression, and creating organizational spaces for healing and repair. LPS emphasizes the importance of centering the experiences of those most impacted by systemic inequities and seeks to transform harmful conditions, ending cycles of oppression.

LPS values love, courage, repair, healing, joy, efficacy, solidarity, and transformation. It offers a vision and a practice aimed at liberating public service from exclusionary and harmful systems, replacing them with inclusive, nourishing, and life-affirming systems that foster collective work, shared accountability, transparency, and care. In public performance management, LPS can guide the development of accountability and performance measurement systems that are trauma-informed, repair-oriented, and centered on the needs of those most impacted by inequitable systems. By integrating LPS, public performance management systems can mitigate harm caused by systemic disparities and advance the goals of efficiency, economy, effectiveness, equity, and collective liberation. We conclude by highlighting implications for future research and practice that integrate LPS into public performance and management at all levels.

 

CO-AUTHORS
Archana Singh (International Institute for Population Sciences)
ABSTRACT

The deeply entrenched caste system in India is evident not only through visible social markers but also through practices that regulate consumption patterns, aligning individuals with their ascribed caste-based class status. Therefore, the objective of this study is to analyse the patterns of consumption expenditure among caste/social groups over the decade from 2011-12 to 2022-23. Additionally, it focuses on examining food and non-food expenditures to understand how caste-based disparities influence resource accessibility and consumption behaviour. Furthermore, it investigates the extent and dynamics of consumption inequality across socio-economic groups, with a particular focus on caste-based disparities and fractile classes.

 

To address these issues, the study uses household consumer expenditure surveys from the 2011-12 and 2022-23. First, the average consumption expenditure across all households was calculated and then broken down by social groups. Second, consumption inequality was measured and analysed using Theil Decomposition Indices and the Lorenz Curve. Finally, quantile regression was applied to examine how household consumption expenditure differs across various points in the income distribution for each social group.

 

The study reveals that per capita expenditure increased across all social groups over the decade from 2011-12 to 2022-23, with a noticeable shift from food to non-food spending. However, disadvantaged groups remain limited in their access to high-quality foods, highlighting persistent consumption inequality. Furthermore, inequality metrics, such as Theil indices and Gini coefficients, indicate that intra-group disparities are the primary drivers of inequality, particularly among higher-income households.

 

Keywords: Household Consumer Expenditure, Caste, Social Inequality, food to non-food spending, India.

 

 

JEL Classification : D11, D13, D19, E21 

 

CO-AUTHORS
Andrew McKnight (University of Alabama at Birmingham)
ABSTRACT

Aim: Increasing divisions regarding curriculum and instruction have resulted in calls for authority to opt children out of specific lessons, censorship of books, and removal of content from public school curriculums in the United States. As the call for this panel notes, “unequal access to educational resources, and tensions between racial and social groups” lie at the heart of critical policy debates and public frustration regarding various social issues. To address these challenges, public administrators and policymakers must consider the present nature of public opinion that may hamper effective civics education, specifically regarding the history of marginalized groups. Yet, the research literature on perceptions of parental opt-out is scarce. The purpose of this study is to address this gap by examining public opinion regarding parents opting their children out of learning about content they find objectionable.

 

Research questions: The study focuses on the following research questions: How prevalent is the view that parents should be able to opt-out their children from lessons at school in the United States? Do parents and non-parents differ in their opinion? Do these opinions vary by political affiliation and opinions about other education policy issues? To investigate the last question, we specifically focused on three key factors: Preference for parental authority over curriculum; Opinions regarding whether schools should teach the history and consequences of race and income inequality; and attitudes about inclusion of books on race and socio-economic inequality in curriculum.

 

Methodology: First, we will clarify the notion of social equity in education by relying on public administration and critical cultural theory. This discussion will critically reflect on the social equity implications of diminishing representation of diverse perspectives, histories, and voices in the curriculum. After our theoretical inquiry, we will present analysis of a large and nationally representative survey data collected in 2022 as part of the Understanding America Study to provide empirical insight into beliefs and attitudes regarding curricular control in U.S. schools.

 

How it fits with the panel's research questions: The call for papers states that the pursuit of social equity provides public administration with a “normative base.” In the case presented here, that base is represented by a culturally inclusive and historically accurate public school curricula that fosters effective social citizenship toward an equitable democracy. Public education is a key context for the social equity conversation, since exclusion of certain histories, cultures, or ideas restrict representation, perpetuate systemic inequities, and deny students the opportunity to engage with diverse, accurate, and critical knowledge necessary for an inclusive society. Recognizing the challenges and understanding public education as a key context for the social equity conversation is vital for identifying strategies to advance equity through effective public policy.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Social equity is a pillar of public administration alongside efficiency, effectiveness, and economy. It enshrines the value that the government serves should be fair for all. However, despite the seeming ease of defining equity as “fairness for all,” it becomes more complex when both conceptual and operational factors behind defining equity are considered. For instance, regarding conceptual definitions, “fairness for all” evokes questions of “fair for whom? Who and what deserves fairness? How do definitions of fairness arise from cultural contexts?” Regarding operational definitions, answers to conceptual questions lead to enduring issues of how to define equity for the purposes of measuring it, especially in terms of inputs, throughputs, and outputs. 

Governments all over the world are endeavoring to ask and answer these questions, especially within budgetary processes. As the quintessential administrative decision, budgeting decisions are reflective of power structures’ “answers” to questions of “who and what matter.” Social equity budgeting is a growing area of research, but work remains regarding how societal-conceptual definitions of fairness then link to operational definitions of fairness, especially in budgetary processes. 

The present work builds on previous social equity budgeting pieces and presents a collective case study examining how nine (9) intentionally selected governments at multiple levels–King County, Washington, USA; the Texas state government; the US national government; the UK national government; The French national government; the South African national government; the South Korean national government; the Australian national government; and the Colombian national government)--have addressed both the conceptual and operational dimensions of defining social equity in the budgetary process. As an analytical focus, each government will be analyzed not only in terms of stated overall definitions of equity but principally regarding equity definitions within education, a key dimension of social equity’s theoretical and normative mandate to “level the playing field” for all through fostering equal opportunity. 

Initial findings showcase how discourses–longitudinal debates over who and what matter for public policy–shape the content of both conceptual and operational definitions, especially regarding how “progress toward equity” is defined. These discourses lead to vastly different definitions of fairness, and, thus, government approaches to educational equity in the budgeting process. Some approaches de-emphasize the demographic nature of social equity (e.g., in France); or adopt contested notions of demographics and disproportionate inequities (e.g., in Colombia); or struggle to achieve outcomes despite an extensive social equity programme (e.g., King County, USA); and more. Still, all governments show some progress at improving educational outcomes, highlighting how the pursuit of social equity, while difficult, is an organic, multi-faceted endeavor.

Attendees will leave with a better understanding not only of what social equity means in terms of public administration theory but principally how conceptual and operational definitions matter and how governments across the world have addressed these important dimensions in educational budgeting. 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Framed within the broader discourse on social equity in public policy, this research uses the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act of 2005 and the Prevention of Sexual Harassment (POSH) Act of 2013 as case studies to examine how policy reforms addressing systemic gender inequality are designed, implemented, and experienced in practice. These legislative measures reflect India’s commitment to constitutional values of fairness, justice, and equality and serve as key examples of public policy efforts aimed at advancing gender equity and social justice.

The Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, sought to rectify gender disparities in inheritance by granting daughters equal coparcenary rights, challenging patriarchal norms embedded in the Hindu Mitakshara property system. Similarly, the POSH Act was introduced to ensure safe and equitable workplaces for women, addressing systemic issues of harassment and gender-based violence. While these laws signify progressive legislative intent, the research reveals persistent challenges, including cultural resistance, social stigma, procedural inefficiencies, and lack of awareness, which hinder their effective implementation.

This study critically analyzes these factors, highlighting the gap between the legal provisions and their practical realization. It underscores the importance of bridging this divide through targeted interventions such as improving awareness campaigns, streamlining enforcement mechanisms, and fostering cultural shifts to support gender-sensitive governance. By exploring the legislative and societal dynamics surrounding these two landmark reforms, this paper aims to contribute to the understanding of how public policy can promote social equity and address gender-based inequities in India.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In recent years climate change and its multidimensional consequences have been in discussions over the world. Bangladesh remained in this discussion due to its vulnerability and recent climatic extreme events. Consequences of climate change like migration is also much discussed in literature. Yet, recent literature hardly analyzes the policies and strategies adopted by the government and less focus is given on the role of these policies in mitigating the inequalities and vulnerabilities of migrants. Bangladesh as a deltaic country faces climatic events frequently. It is acknowledged that cyclone related death and hazard have been reduced 100 times than 1970s in Bangladesh and recognized as a global leader in climate change adaptation and disaster preparedness. Despite this development in resilience mechanism it continues to face climatic issues and very high risks. Such risks lead to social, political, economic and other vulnerabilities. Therefore, this study looks into the social dynamics of the post-migration contexts. The internal migration is considered here as most of the climatic migration happens within the country. Social inequalities and discriminations experienced by climatic migrants, especially in the cities are discussed in this study.  This study aims to explore the specific vulnerabilities of climatic displaced people and the existing policy framework that addresses the migrants’ needs. It also tries to find out the policy gaps in integration, inclusion and ensuring equity in climate adaptation frameworks. To address the research gap the study asks what are the fundamental challenges migrants face in adapting to climate change and migration? How do the existing climate change adaptation policy and strategies account for migrants? What policy changes are necessary to ensure equitable access to climate adaptation resources for migrants? This paper is a qualitative study and analysis is based on secondary data from the policy papers, project reports and available literature in this field.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The convergence of digital transformation and social equity has become a critical area of governance, particularly in addressing systemic poverty and inequity. This study explores the pathway of digital transformation to social equity through an institutional analysis of the Thai People Map and Analytics Platform (TPMAP) in Thailand. It investigates how TPMAP, a government-initiated big data platform, leverages digital technologies to address poverty and reduce social inequity. The research is guided by three key questions: (1) How does TPMAP use big data to tackle poverty and inequity in Thailand? (2) What institutional factors enable or constrain the TPMAP’s impact on social equity? (3) What are the challenges and policy implications for enhancing TPMAP’ s effectiveness? To address these questions, the study employs the Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD) framework to analyze TPMAP’s institutional arrangements, stakeholder interactions, and outcomes. Using a qualitative case study approach, the research combines content analysis and descriptive analysis of secondary data sources including government reports, official statements, academic studies, and media reports, and semi-structured interviews with relevant stakeholders involved in TPMAP’s implementation at national, provincial, and local levels. The IAD framework allows for a comprehensive examination of how contextual factors, action arenas, and patterns of interaction shape TPMAP’s role in promoting social equity. The findings reveal that TPMAP has transformed Thailand’s approach to poverty alleviation by enabling multi-dimensional poverty analysis, data-driven decision-making, and targeted resource allocation. However, challenges such as political transitions, data accuracy issues, and the need for sustained stakeholder collaboration highlight the complexities of implementing digital transformation initiatives for social equity. The study concludes with recommendations for institutionalizing TPMAP as a non-partisan tool, strengthening data governance, and fostering broader stakeholder engagement to ensure long-term sustainability and equity impact. This paper aligns with the panel’s research question by demonstrating how social equity considerations have influenced the design, implementation, and governance of TPMAP. It highlights the role of digital transformation in addressing systemic inequities and provides insights into the institutional dynamics that enable or constrain equitable policy outcomes. By examining TPMAP as a case study, the paper contributes to broader discussions on how digital governance can advance social equity in developing countries.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Despite the widespread establishment of accommodation policies to ensure access to participation for students with disabilities in post-secondary institutions, barriers persist for those with Learning Disabilities (LD). More specifically, the onus is often put on students with LD to navigate the academic impact of their non-apparent disability. To understand facilitators and barriers based on their lived experience, we interviewed 40 students with LD currently enrolled in university programs in Ontario, Canada. In addition, we analyzed websites of the disability services offices of the 22 publicly-funded English-language Ontario universities. Data from the semi-structured interviews were thematically analyzed and coded in NVivo, and three themes emerged: stigma, self-advocacy and mental health. Under stigma, 30 participants referenced the non-apparent aspect of their LD as a challenge. Several reported that others had not believed that their need for accommodation (i.e., their LD) was legitimate. Some had been accused of “faking it” or being “lazy” by peers or educators. Several interviewees referred to self-advocacy as necessary to access accommodations because of the non-apparent nature of their disability. Self-advocacy was the key to academic success for students who had the confidence to use it. Finally, over half of the students interviewed cited mental health as an ongoing concern. These students described experiences with anxiety, burnout, exhaustion and stress. In some circumstances, the self-advocacy required to navigate the impact of their LD was directly named as the source of their mental health issues. This theme highlights the importance of the intersection between mental health and non-apparent disability for students in post-secondary education. By including the voices of students with LD, we are able to deepen our understanding of the impact of institutional processes and accommodation. Our findings illustrate the individualistic nature of accessibility at universities. Website analysis revealed multiple inconsistencies across institutions in policy about documentation requirements for students with LD. To improve students’ overall experiences, participants recommended increased funding to obtain formal documentation, increase staffing at disability services offices (DSOs), increase awareness of DSOs, and for better communication between DSOs and instructors. Overall, this study confirms that post-secondary students with LD face barriers to access, with many related to the non-apparent nature of their disability. Our findings and recommendations are relevant to post-secondary institutions’ policies and processes attempting to reduce accessibility barriers for students with LD. 
 This research paper fits well into the thematic issues of social inequity because it provides data to confirm lived experience of barriers to access for post-secondary students with disabilities.

CO-AUTHORS
Leonie Birkholz (Friedrich-Alexander Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg)
Peter Gelius (University of Lausanne)
Catherine Woods (University of Limerick)
ABSTRACT

Introduction: The importance of policies to promote physical activity is increasingly recognised, as such policies have the potential to create healthier environments that encourage active lifestyles. While there is a growing body of research on the effectiveness of PA promotion policies, their impact on reducing social (health) inequities remains unclear. This perspective is also not systematically addressed by existing tools for monitoring and evaluating policies in the field of physical activity promotion.

This study aims to adapt the use of a public policy implementation assessment tool – the Physical Activity Environment Policy Index (PA-EPI), currently implemented in 6 EU countries – to better address social inequities. This includes the development of an equity module and the systematic consideration of equity in the process of using the tool. This will improve the understanding of the role of social equity in public policy in this field of research.
 
Methods: To develop an equity module, a systematic review was conducted, which included a comprehensive search of six databases, independent screening of the records by two reviewers, and synthesis of the included studies. Studies were clustered into policy domains based on ISPAH's “Eight Investments that work for Physical Activity” framework, and studies that demonstrated positive effects on reducing social inequities through the promotion of physical activity were analysed to identify good practice. Experts were consulted to finalise the equity module.
To integrate equity considerations systematically in the process of using the tool, a literature search and expert interviews were conducted.
 
Results: Based on 38 scientific studies and 8 grey literature documents, a PA-EPI Equity Module has been developed. The module includes statements for the 45 indicators of the PA-EPI and provides guidance on how to systematically integrate social equity into the process of data collection (e.g., on national health, sport, or active transport policies). To ensure that a social equity perspective is taken into account in the process of using the tool, equity councils will be established, composed of organisations representing socially disadvantaged groups. The purpose of these equity councils is to define and refine policy recommendations for physical activity promotion from a social equity perspective.
 
Discussion: The study systematically integrates social equity into a tool for assessing the implementation of public policies to promote physical activity. It has identified effective physical activity policies that reduce inequalities across various domains. These examples of good practice provide blueprints for other countries and can inform policy development, not only in the 6 EU countries currently using the tool.

The study highlights the need for researchers and policymakers to use scientific evidence to advance the policy agenda aimed at promoting social equity. In addition, the study provides insights into how policy recommendations that include a social equity perspective can be developed in a systematic and participatory process. These findings can contribute to learning between countries and support the development of more equitable public policies.

CO-AUTHORS
Raminta Pucetaite (Kaunas University of Technology)
Donata Jovarauskiene (Kaunas University of Technology)
Rimantas Rauleckas (Kaunas University of Technology)
ABSTRACT

The fifth author – Jolanta Vaičiūnienė (Kaunas University Technology) 

 

Health equity is a cornerstone of social equity and a prerequisite at the system level for individuals to exercise agency as maintained by the human capacity approach (Braveman, 2010; Nussbaum, 2011). Ensuring accessibility to healthcare and quality of healthcare service is a moral duty of democratic states (Sen, 2002). Petty corruption defined as small-scale (e.g. 50 EUR) payment of bribes or other material and immaterial means of motivating low- and mid-level public officials such as healthcare professionals to amend their behaviour in order to facilitate higher quality or faster access to healthcare services (Graycar, 2015), is among the sociocultural barriers that distort service delivery, worsen inequalities, and reduce access to healthcare. Corruption poses a major threat to the stability and reinforcement of democracy (Mungiu-Pippidi, 2006), eroding trust in democratic structures (Jha et al. 2024). Even within democratic systems, corruption, including petty corruption, continues to diminish transparency and weaken public trust in healthcare system (Brueckner, 2021; European Commission, 2022).

 

Reducing corruption is essential for strengthening health systems, advancing health equity, and mitigating social inequalities. While previous research has examined the impact of corruption on healthcare systems, limited attention has been paid to how national and institutional policies address these challenges, particularly in post-occupational EU democracies like Lithuania, where Soviet-era legacies and European integration efforts intersect (see Weistra et al., 2017; Parvanova, 2025). Moreover, the role of policies in combatting petty corruption as a form of corruption has received far less attention in corruption studies. We address the respective gaps in academic discourse by conducting a two-level analysis. First, we examine Lithuania’s national health policies and legal frameworks to evaluate the anticorruption measures enshrined in law and the obligations of healthcare institutions to establish anticorruption measures within institutional policies. Specifically, we take a critical look at policies to identify measures for combatting petty corruption. Second, we evaluate whether and how national policies are reflected in institutional policies to guarantee health equity and address the causes of petty corruption, which is among the highest in the EU (European Commission, 2022). Using qualitative document analysis, our objective is to identify gaps between national and institutional policies and provide policymakers with recommendations on integrating anticorruption measures to strengthen health equity assurance, enhance regulatory compliance in healthcare settings, and promote greater social equity in healthcare access.

 

Bibliography
Brueckner, M. (2021). Democracy and corruption. Journal of Risk and Financial Management 14: 492.
Braveman, P. (2010). Social conditions, health equity, and human rights. Health & Human Rights, 12(2):  31-48
European Commission, Directorate-General for Migration and Home Affairs, Corruption – Report, Publications Office of the European Union, 2022, available at https://data.europa.eu/doi/10.2837/110098 Graycar, A. (2015). Corruption: Classification and analysis. Policy and Society, 34(2): 87-96.
Jha, S., and Kolev, K. (2024). How Corruption at the Top Erodes Support for Democracy. Stanford University.
Mungiu-Pippidi, A. (2006). Corruption: Diagnosis and treatment. Journal of Democracy, 17(3), 86–99. 
Nussbaum, M.C. (2011), Creating Capabilities. The Human Development Approach. Cambridge, MA; London: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press
Glynn, E.H. (2022). Corruption in the health sector: A problem in need of a systems-thinking approach. Front. Public Health 10:91007.
Parvanova, I. (2025). The effect of institutional characteristics and social norms on corruption in healthcare. Governance, e12868.
Sen A. (2002). Why health equity? Health Economics, 11(8):659–666. doi: 10.1002/hec.762
Weistra, K., Swart, L., Oortwijn, W., Raets, T. et al. (2017). Updated study on corruption in the healthcare sector – Final report, European Commission: Directorate General for Migration and Home Affairs. Publications Office.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Analysis of decentralized expenditure on spatial inequality in Mexico

 

Decentralization plays a key role in the provision of public goods and services, primarily through the distribution of federalized spending. This mechanism serves as one of the main instruments through which the federal government transfers resources to states and municipalities. In Mexico, decentralization continues to raise questions regarding its effectiveness in strengthening the responsiveness of subnational governments to the demands of their populations, as well as in promoting financial autonomy and investment in social infrastructure (López-Acevedo & Webb, 2006).

 

This article examines the relationship between income inequality among federal entities and federalized spending through the spatial Gini index, which measures inequality in this dimension. The objective of this analysis is to determine whether federalized spending effectively compensates and/or remedies disparities in revenue-generating capacity among states or whether it exacerbates budgetary gaps, considering that federal entities have varying levels of agency, administrative, institutional, and operational capacity to provide quality public goods and services to their population.

 

At the subnational level, the spatial Gini index is typically calculated based on per capita gross domestic product (GDP) without accounting for potential spatial relationships among the data (Panzera & Postiglione, 2019). Meanwhile, income inequality analyses are generally conducted using household- or individual-level data, often overlooking the spatial dimension of income inequality in terms of the revenues received by subnational governments.

 

From an economic perspective, traditional economic convergence models assign a minimal role to state intervention, arguing that market forces alone can reduce inequality. In contrast, new regional models emphasize the importance of state intervention, as it can trigger processes of concentration and increasing returns through public investment and infrastructure development (Cuenca-López & Torres, 2020). Consequently, measuring spatial inequality is a complex task, as it requires accounting for the interactions that occur across neighboring regions.

 

Using data from the Federal Expenditure Budgets for the years 2021 to 2024 for Mexico’s 32 federal entities (PEF, 2021–2024), this study employs the spatial Gini index proposed by Rey and Smith (2013), which incorporates neighborhood effects primarily through spatial weight matrices and Moran’s indices. This approach aims to determine the relative position of federal entities in relation to both neighboring and non-neighboring states, assessing whether a spatial spillover effect exists among them or whether greater inequality is observed among non-adjacent states (Anselin, 2006). The findings are expected to reveal an increase in spatial inequality as a result of higher spatial autocorrelation, suggesting the expansion of the spatial structure of inequality.

 

 

References

 

Anselin, L. (2006). Spatial econometrics. En T. Mills y K. Patterson (Eds.), Econometric theory. Palgrave Handbook of Econometrics (vol. 1, pp. 901–969). Palgrave McMillan.

 

Cuenca-López, A. D., & Torres, D. E. (2020). Impacto de la inversión en infraestructura sobre la pobreza en Latinoamérica en el período 1996-2016. Población y desarrollo, 26(50), 5-18. https://doi.org/10.18004/pdfce/2076-054x/2020.026.50.005-018

 

Lopez-Acevedo, G. C., & Webb, S. B. (2006).Decentralized service delivery for the poor: core report. World Bank Group. https://documents. worldbank.org/en/publication/documents-reports/documentdetail/599781468045052393/core-report

 

Panzera, D. y Postiglione, P. (2019). Measuring the spatial dimension of regional inequality: an approach based on the Gini Correlation Measure. Social Indicators Research, 148, 379-394.

 

Rey, S. J. y Smith, R. J. (2013). A spatial decomposition of the Gini coefficient.  Letters in Spatial and Resource Sciences, 6, 55-70.

 

Secretaría de Hacienda y Crédito Público (2008), Presupuesto de Egresos de la Federación, México, SHCP. Retrieved from https://www.finanzaspublicas.hacienda.gob.mx/es/Finanzas_Publicas/Paquete_Economico_y_Presupuesto

CO-AUTHORS
Nusrat Chowdhury (University of Dhaka)
ABSTRACT

The term social equity has been considered one of the fundamental pillars of Public Administration, although the interpretation of the same is somehow catered according to the ethos and practices of administration in a particular context. However, compared to other pillars of public administration, such as efficiency, effectiveness, and economy (Gooden and Portillo, 2011), the normative nature of equity provides the scope for narrative-based qualitative analysis in social equity research to understand the intricate factors that shape social equity in public administration and policy. With this understanding and opportunity, this paper intends to explore how social equity is perceived and prioritized in the affordable urban housing projects in The National Housing Policy of Bangladesh (2016) and explore the political, administrative, and cultural context that impacts the social equity in these projects. To be more specific, this paper focuses on the National Housing Authority (NHA), under the Ministry of Housing and Public Works, that envisions providing affordable housing access to all strata of society and undertakes various housing projects and allocates plots throughout Bangladesh. However, to what extent these projects ensure social equity remains largely unexplored. The guiding question of this paper is how social equity, as outlined in the National Housing Policy 2016, translated into the implementation of affordable urban housing projects and practices by NHA? To explore social equity, this research uses Johnson and Svara's (2011) framework that measures social equity through four dimensions, namely- procedural fairness (equal process for all), access (no barrier to participation), quality (same level of treatment) and outcomes (reduction of inequality). This research will follow a comparative case study approach by examining four selected projects by NHA in Dhaka City that have been targeted for different socio-economic groups and cater to the largest number of people. The study area has been chosen for two reasons: first, Dhaka is one of the overly populated cities in the world with a surge of migration and unplanned settlements, and second, NHA has the highest number of projects in Dhaka that cater to the highest number of people. The data will be collected from primary and secondary sources: secondary data from documents related to the projects and primary data from narratives of policymakers, implementers, project supervisors, experts, as well as the beneficiaries of the projects. The narratives or primary data will be collected through in-depth interviews following a purposive sampling technique to have a diverse perspective. This paper is expected to unpack further how the concept of social equity is translated into policy implementation, especially in the context of a developing country, which has not been studied widely. Based on the findings and the analysis, the research would provide input to make such projects more socially equitable, and it aspires to add more depth to Svara and Johnson's Framework.

This paper fits this panel because it aligns its core theme through empirical research that aspires to provide policy solutions and advance theoretical understanding.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This study examines how land use policies and zoning regulations in Shanghai have shaped environmental inequalities in access to green spaces and recreational areas, highlighting the complex interplay between urban development, socio-demographic factors, and environmental justice. Shanghai, as China's largest metropolis with over 30 million residents, presents a compelling case study of how rapid urbanization and historical planning decisions have created disparities in green space accessibility across different social groups and districts.

Using spatial analysis and demographic data from 2010-2023, this research investigates the distribution of parks, community gardens, and recreational facilities across Shanghai's 16 districts, revealing significant disparities between the city's core and peripheral areas. The study finds that while Shanghai's overall green space per capita has increased from 7.6 square meters in 2010 to 9.2 square meters in 2023, this growth has been uneven, with historically advantaged central districts like Xuhui and Jing'an enjoying substantially better access to quality green spaces compared to outer districts like Jiading and Minhang.

The research also reveals how Shanghai's recent urban planning initiatives, such as the "15-Minute Community Life Circle" policy and the "Sponge City" program, have attempted to address these inequities. However, implementation challenges, including limited land availability and competing development pressures, have complicated efforts to achieve more equitable green space distribution. The study identifies specific zoning mechanisms, such as floor area ratio bonuses for developers who provide public green spaces and mandatory green space requirements for new developments, that have shown promise in improving access in underserved areas.

The research concludes that addressing environmental inequality in Shanghai requires not only technical planning solutions but also a fundamental reconsideration of how land use policies can better serve environmental justice goals. This calls for more inclusive planning processes, stronger regulatory frameworks for green space provision, and targeted investments in historically underserved communities.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper examines how China’s 2016 reforms extending paid maternity leave and paternity leave have shaped women’s labor market outcomes, with a particular focus on social equity and gender disparities. Drawing on six waves of the China Family Panel Studies (CFPS) from 2010 to 2020, I use a difference-in-differences approach to exploit temporal and provincial variations in paid family leave. My research question is twofold: (1) How do extended maternity and newly introduced paternity leave policies affect women’s labor force participation and weekly working hours? and (2) Do these policies produce unintended spillover effects on women without children and on young men?

Methodologically, I leverage provincial-level policy data on maternity and paternity leave—collected from official documents—and merge them with individual-level survey responses on employment status, income, working hours. This allows us to estimate the causal impact of policy changes while controlling for individual characteristics, province-specific trends, and year fixed effects. The findings highlight a substantial negative effect of longer maternity leave on female labor market engagement, including for nulliparous (childless) women. Younger women, in particular, bear the largest penalties in terms of reduced workforce participation and working hours. By contrast, the introduction and expansion of paternity leave—even though relatively short—mitigate these adverse impacts and improve outcomes for women. Importantly, a higher paternity-to-maternity leave ratio correlates strongly with higher labor force participation and longer weekly work hours for women, suggesting that shared caregiving responsibilities can lessen labor market inequalities.

These findings carry clear implications for T17 P02: Social Equity in Public Policy, demonstrating how well-intentioned family leave reforms may inadvertently shift employers’ expectations, thus limiting women’s employment opportunities and widening gender gaps. Such pressures can also suppress fertility intentions, undermining the very goals of pro-natal policies.

In contributing to the panel’s exploration of how public policies shape social equity outcomes, this paper underscores the need to look beyond the apparent friendliness of family leave policies to understand their potential unintended consequences. It shows that when businesses need to bear the costs associated with employees' childbirth, shared parental leave is crucial in promoting equitable labor market participation and can serve as a model for other contexts seeking to reconcile fertility policies with broader commitments to social equity and gender parity.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Abstract

Diversity and inclusion are critical to ensuring equitable access to education and addressing historical socio-economic inequalities in Indian Higher Education Institutions (HEIs). However, despite constitutional mandates and affirmative action through reservation policies, the representation of Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST), and Other Backward Classes (OBCs) in HEIs remains alarmingly disproportionate. This paper examines the implementation and impact of reservation policies on social equity in HEIs, drawing on data collected through the Right to Information (RTI) Act to assess the representation of various social categories in faculty positions, student enrollments, and administrative roles.

The initial part of the paper situates the issue within the broader context of social justice and educational equity. A review of relevant literature highlights the transformative potential of reservation policies as envisioned by scholars such as B. R. Ambedkar and other proponents of affirmative action. However, existing studies also underscore systemic challenges, including institutional resistance, discriminatory practices, and inadequate implementation of quotas, which hinder the realization of social justice goals. Recent works, such as Thorat and Attewell (2007) and Sukhadeo Thorat’s studies on exclusion in HEIs, provide critical insights into the persistence of caste-based inequalities despite policy interventions.

The findings of this paper, based on RTI responses from leading HEIs, reveal stark disparities in the representation of SCs, STs, and OBCs. The data reflects an underrepresentation of these groups in faculty positions, PhD programs, and high-ranking administrative roles, highlighting a significant gap between policy and practice. Moreover, the paper identifies trends of overrepresentation among dominant social groups, indicating systemic biases and limited institutional accountability. These findings underline the urgent need for comprehensive reforms to ensure effective implementation of reservation policies, transparency in recruitment and admissions, and mechanisms to monitor compliance with affirmative action mandates.

The paper argues that fostering genuine diversity and inclusion in HEIs requires a paradigm shift in institutional culture and governance. It concludes by recommending policy measures, such as the periodic public disclosure of diversity metrics, capacity-building programs for marginalized groups, and enhanced oversight by regulatory bodies, to bridge the gap between constitutional ideals and on-ground realities. This study contributes to the ongoing discourse on social equity in Indian education, emphasizing the critical role of HEIs in creating a more inclusive and just society.

Keywords: Diversity and Inclusion, Higher Education Institutions (HEIs), Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST), Other Backward Classes (OBCs), Reservation Policy, Social Equity, Caste-based Inequalities, Right to Information (RTI), Affirmative Action, Educational Justice, Institutional Discrimination, Policy Implementation.