CATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
Despite its limitations, “what governments do” has served to be an enduring definition for public policy. Among the many things that governments do as they try to “tame wicked problems” (Rittel and Webber 1973; Crowley and Head 2017), they also look away (Mander 2015), exclude and reinforce inequalities (Schneider and Ingram 2005). Although not limited to them, feminist, dalit, black and other voices have drawn attention to experiences of being invisibilized (Star & Straus, 1999; Hatton, 2017; Daniels, 1987; Singh, 2014). Accounts of being devalued and dehumanised via (in)action (McConnell and ’t Hart 2019) are often central to these accounts; accounts that have also come to the forefront from an anthropological turn in public policy (Wedel et al. 2005) that have pointed to the deliberateness of policy (in)action and not just spaces of oversight or ignorance.
Talking (to and about) policy is important to jolting policy decisions out of (in)action. Contemporary policy landscape of (in)action is rife with dilemmas of (in)action (Howlett, 2009). For example, several discussions on worker safety, substance abuse, sex-selective abortions, dowry, pollution, climate change, have been wicked and often fall into easy framings of deviant, normalise, disillusionment. Unlike the global north, where formal governmental committees, formal hearings and appeals may be invited even from dissenting voices, several regions across the world dissenting voices are actively punished.
In some contexts, it might be particularly important yet difficult to bring on board those who are being invisibilized through (in)action. For example, in problems like Climate Change, conversations with the most important stakeholders, future entities, like the future biodiversity (including animals, plants and humans) does not seem possible. How does one challenge inaction, with the current stakeholders without encouraging dystopian disillusionment. As boundaries between truth and falsehood are blurred, in times defined by a ceaseless access to information, poses further challenges to policy inaction (Fisher, 2020, 2021; Boullosa, 2022).
CALL FOR PAPERS
Entering and challenging spaces of policy (in)action poses unique theoretical, epistemic, methodical and empirical challenges and we invite work that several questions around (in)action in policy:
- What are the origins of (in)action? In what forums and how can accountability be ascribed for the absence of action that lacked articulated responsibility in the first place?
- How and where do voices speak when they are not recognized? How can issues come to matter when they are assumed to not exist?
- What strategic communication choices do those working towards challenging inaction?
We invite academic as well as practical accounts grounded in the pursuit of promoting ideas of justice, fairness and equity in public policy. Recognizing the sustenance of (in)action to be situated in existing ways of knowing and colonised forms of understanding, we are particularly keen to bring together work that attempts to critically challenge dominant reference frames. While we would like to emphasise rigour, we advocate for benchmarks that are defined by the resistance – epistemic and practical – the work poses to exclusions rather than conformity to privileged forms of inquiry. We specifically encourage conversations with a diverse and creative use of methodology. For example, action research projects may help us understand the horizon of possibilities. While questioning norms around what constitutes good evidence, the panel encourages reflective papers on what good bars might be when discussing methodological questions, like causality in complex systems.
The panel invites conversations on methods not only in policy spaces, but also in social purpose organisations where funders may demand capturing different kinds of data, raising important questions of what should count as data.
References:
Boullosa, R. (2022): Truth and post-truth in public policy: interpreting the arguments. Critical Policy Studies.
Crowley, Kate, and Brian W. Head. 2017. “The Enduring Challenge of ‘Wicked Problems’: Revisiting Rittel and Webber.” Policy Sciences 50 (4): 539–47. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-017-9302-4.
Daniels, A. K. (1987). Invisible work. Social Problems, 34(5), 403-415.
Fischer, F. (2021). Truth and post-truth in public policy. Cambridge University Press.
Fischer, F. (2020). Post-truth politics and climate denial: Further reflections. Critical Policy Studies, 14(1), 124-130.
Hatton, E. (2017). Mechanisms of invisibility: rethinking the concept of invisible work. Work, employment and society, 31(2), 336-351. Orient BlackSwan.
Howlett, M. (2009). Government communication as a policy tool: A framework for analysis. Canadian Political Science Review, 3(2), 23-37.
Mander, Harsh. 2015. Looking Away: Inequality, Prejudice and Indifference in New India. 1st edition. Speaking Tiger Books.
McConnell, Allan, and Paul ’t Hart. 2019. “Inaction and Public Policy: Understanding Why Policymakers ‘Do Nothing.’” Policy Sciences 52 (4): 645–61. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-019-09362-2.
Rittel, Horst W. J., and Melvin M. Webber. 1973. “Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning.” Policy Sciences 4 (2): 155–69. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01405730.
Singh, B. (2014). Unseen: The Truth about India’s Manual Scavengers (R. Talwar, Trans.). Penguin Books.
Star, S. L., & Strauss, A. (1999). Layers of silence, arenas of voice: The ecology of visible and invisible work. Computer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW), 8(1–2), 9–30.
Wedel, Janine R., Cris Shore, Gregory Feldman, and Stacy Lathrop. 2005. “Toward an Anthropology of Public Policy.” The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 600 (1): 30–51. https://doi.org/10.1177/0002716205276734.
Whyte, K. P. (2018). Indigenous science (fiction) for the Anthropocene: Ancestral dystopias and fantasies of climate change crises. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space, 1(1-2), 224-242.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Single-mother families are among the most common yet economically vulnerable family types in Europe and beyond. They face the "triple bind" of caregiving, breadwinning, and structural discrimination, compounded by gender inequalities and inadequate policy support (Nienwenhuis & Maldonado, 2018). Policy is a critical factor in shaping the well-being of these families, who are identified as a new social risk (Bonoli, 2005). While some welfare states address the challenges faced by single-mother families more effectively, others lag behind. Lithuania, for example, has the highest poverty rate among single-mother families relative to two-parent families in Europe due to the lack of policy support (EU-SILC, 2023; Skubiejūtė, 2021).
This presentation examines how the social construction of single-mother families in Lithuania contributes to policy inaction, applying the theory of social construction and policy design (Ingram & Schneider, 1993, 2004). It also uses the concepts of decommodification and defamilialisation to explore how single mothers' lives, and those of their children, change after migrating to countries that provide policy recognition and support.
The research draws on a comprehensive analysis of Lithuanian family policy since the country’s independence in 1991, interviews with 15 Lithuanian policymakers, an analysis of current family policy in Germany, Norway, and the UK, and the lived experiences of 30 single mothers who emigrated to these countries.
The findings reveal that Lithuanian policies are heavily influenced by familialism, traditional gender norms, and Christian values. As a result, single-mother families are often constructed as "deviant," stigmatised as benefit scroungers, and labelled as destroyers of family ideals (Schneider & Ingram, 1993; 2004; Skubiejūtė, 2021). These negative perceptions lead to their being framed as "undeserving" of support, perpetuating structural discrimination, social exclusion, and material deprivation. Faced with this systemic neglect, many single mothers emigrate to countries such as Germany, Norway, and the UK, where policies are more inclusive, and single mothers are valued as contributors rather than vilified.
The study shows that welfare policies in Lithuania deliberately exclude single mothers, using policy inaction to reinforce traditional family norms. In contrast, Germany, Norway, and the UK implement policies that actively support single mothers’ economic independence, social inclusion, and well-being. These inclusive measures enable single mothers to pursue better career opportunities, engage in community activities, and reduce their reliance on welfare—challenging the fears of Lithuanian policymakers who view such support as fostering dependency.
In supportive policy environments like Norway, the UK, and Germany, single mothers experience reduced stigma, greater autonomy, and enhanced opportunities. These countries demonstrate how well-designed policies rooted in decommodification and defamilialisation can empower vulnerable groups, breaking cycles of poverty and dependency rather than perpetuating them.
This presentation contributes to the understanding of how public policies can either reinforce or challenge inequalities.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This study explores the bidirectional relationship between social service quality perceptions and subjective well-being across 33 European countries, challenging traditional unidirectional approaches. Utilizing data from the 2016 European Quality of Life Survey involving over 37,000 respondents, the research employed multilevel analysis and innovative diffusion maps to examine the effect of seven key social services on well-being, within different welfare regimes.
The findings reveal a significant dual connection between service quality perceptions and well-being, with service quality having a stronger impact on well-being. Childcare and education demonstrated the most significant association with well-being, while social housing and long-term care showed minimal influence. Social-Democratic regimes exhibited higher levels of perceived service quality and subjective well-being compared to other regime types.
A novel methodological approach using diffusion maps uncovered that individuals with higher subjective well-being display more diverse service quality perceptions, while those with lower well-being share more homogeneous views. This pattern remained consistent across welfare regimes.
The study contributes theoretically by advancing understanding of institutional arrangements' impact on well-being, empirically by providing a comprehensive analysis of social service perceptions across European countries, and methodologically by introducing diffusion maps as an innovative analytical tool.
Implications for policymakers include prioritizing services like childcare and education to enhance citizens' well-being and considering the complex, bidirectional relationship between social services and subjective well-being.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The interplay between public policy inaction and digital transformation in addressing educational inequities forms the crux of this study. Focusing on Early Childhood Care and Education (ECCE) within Anganwadi centers in Bihar, India, this research critically examines how systemic (in)action contributes to persistent inequalities in cognitive development, parental involvement, and child nutrition. Assessing 712 children across 20 centers, the study reveals significant gaps: 7% of children consistently underperform in cognitive domains, 68.67% experience limited parental engagement, and 16% face stunted growth. These outcomes underscore the deliberate oversight and resource inequities embedded in policy implementation. Leveraging digital tools, the study proposes evidence-based interventions, including e-learning platforms for Anganwadi workers, progress-tracking applications, and parent engagement technologies, exemplified by the Poshan 2.0 tracker. By contextualizing these solutions within justice-oriented frameworks, this research highlights the potential for technology to counteract policy inaction and foster equity in ECCE outcomes. The findings contribute to the discourse on public policy inaction, advocating for inclusive, data-driven approaches that challenge systemic exclusions and promote sustainable transformations in resource-constrained settings.
Keywords: Public policy inaction, ECCE, Digital transformation, Educational inequities, Anganwadi
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Introduction
The Pradhan Mantri Matru Vandana Yojana (PMMVY) is a conditional maternity benefit programme that aims to provide financial assistance to pregnant and lactating mothers and improve maternal and child health outcomes in India.However, despite its ambitious objectives, the scheme has encountered significant policy inaction, particularly in rural India, where digital infrastructure and bureaucratic hurdles limit access. The dependence on digital infrastructure for application processes, online registrations, Aadhaar-linked verification, and direct benefit transfers has disproportionately affected women in marginalised communities with limited digital literacy and inadequate access to internet services. Thepaper aims to explore how digital inaccessibility, compounded by bureaucratic hurdles, structural inequities, and inadequate policy responsiveness, creates barriers to PMMVY access in rural Himachal Pradesh, a state known for its challenging terrain, difficult geographic conditions and unreliable Internet connectivity and how strategic communication is playing a vital role in overcoming these hurdles.
Research Questions
This study projects to answer the following key research questions:
1. How does the digital divide impact rural women's access to PMMVY benefits in Himachal Pradesh?
2. What administrative and systemic barriers exist due to digital dependency in the scheme's implementation?
3. What is the role played by various stakeholders to enhance the strategic communication for addressing the digital divide?
Methodology
This study employs a mixed-methods research design, combining qualitative and quantitative approaches to provide a comprehensive analysis.
Quantitative Analysis- A survey of 100 women across select villages in Himachal Pradesh will be conducted to assess their awareness, accessibility, and experiences with the PMMVY online application process. Key variables will include access to digital devices, internet connectivity, Aadhaar linkage issues, delays in benefit receipt, and maternal health indicators such as antenatal care visits, nutritional intake, and birth outcomes.
Qualitative Analysis: In-depth interviews with 30 beneficiaries and 10 frontline health workers (Accredited Social Health Activists—ASHAs & Anganwadi Workers (AWWs)) will be conducted to capture lived experiences, bureaucratic hurdles, and coping mechanisms in navigating the digital landscape. Additionally, interviews with gram panchayat members and government officials will shed light on the extent of policy inaction in addressing digital exclusion.
Policy Analysis: A review of government reports, policy documents, and existing literature will be undertaken to analyse policy responses (or lack thereof) in mitigating digital barriers to PMMVY implementation.
Expected Outcomes and Implications
The study is expected to reveal that digital inaccessibility is a significant barrier to PMMVY benefit utilisation, with rural women facing delays or outright exclusion due to technical and bureaucratic inefficiencies. It is also anticipated that policy inaction, such as the lack of alternative application mechanisms (offline support, simplified verification, local assistance), exacerbates these challenges.
Alignment with the panel’s Research Questions
The abstract fits the panel research questions by exploring the origins of inaction in PMMVY, where policy inaction around digital barriers remains unaddressed. It also highlights strategic communication choices, such as community advocacy and local empowerment, used by stakeholders to challenge these barriers and push for reform.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The insertion of Article 21A in the Indian Constitution transformed education from a welfare measure to a fundamental right, with the Right to Education Act (2009) providing its legislative framework. Section 12(1)(c) of the Act mandates private schools to reserve 25% seats for socio-economically disadvantaged children, advancing constitutional aspirations of inclusive education. Yet, by 2023, eleven Indian states had failed to implement this provision, exemplifying systematic policy inaction that deprives marginalized children of their constitutional right. This paper examines how judicial advocacy can challenge such policy inaction through a case study of public interest litigation in Assam, initiated by the author in 2020. Drawing on primary documentation and participant observation, the study traces how judicial intervention transformed state inaction into implementation in Assam, benefiting over 100,000 children in two years. The analysis focuses on three key aspects: (a) the anatomy of state inaction in implementing the 25% reservation in Assam, (b) the four-year litigation process challenging this inaction, including state resistance and eventual compliance, and (c) the potential and limitations of judicial advocacy in enforcing policy implementation. A critical finding emerges from the analysis of public interest litigation patterns: most cases challenging state inaction in RTE implementation are initiated by public-spirited organizations and individuals rather than the direct beneficiaries - the children and parents themselves. This pattern raises important questions about voice, representation, and access to justice. The study concludes by proposing a framework for integrating judicial advocacy with grassroots mobilization, contributing to broader discussions about accountability mechanisms in policy implementation and the role of affected communities in challenging state inaction.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Inhalants are considered one of the most dangerous drugs abused mostly by children (Koposov et al., 2018), with higher rates of abuse among street-involved children due to their legal and widespread availability, easy accessibility, and low price (Ford et al., 2014; MacLean et al., 2011; Manikandan et al., 2020). Woan et al. (2013, p. 318) observe that “there is an inhalant use epidemic in low-and middle-income countries.” The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) and the Sustainable Developmental Goals(SDGs) have outlined specific policy measures to ensure the protection of children from substance abuse and provide treatment for it (UN, 1989; UNSTATS, n.d.). Likewise, the Indian state has also committed itself to protecting children from substances. Yet despite this acknowledgment, policy against inhalant abuse among street adolescents can, at best, be characterized as expressing inaction (Shaikh & Sarin, 2024).
In this paper, we draw on a close review of policy documents, discussions with the key stakeholders, and on-ground action research to probe the nature of policy inaction at different levels. Adopting the principles of participatory action research (PAR), we got directly involved in five case studies of attempted rescue and rehabilitation of eight inhalant-abusing street-involved children (n=8) by the authorities in a large metropolitan city in Western India. These cases emerged as we engaged with the formal government policy on "rescue and rehabilitation," following the prescribed procedures as closely as possible. Given the author's affiliation with a well-regarded institution, these cases could be seen as representing a "best-case" scenario, where better outcomes might have been expected. Concurrently, we conducted semi-structured interviews with 15 key stakeholders, including policy implementers, elected representatives, and NGO workers working closely with street-involved children.
Despite being considered an epidemic in low and middle-income countries, the issue of inhalant abuse is neglected as we found no mention of ‘inhalants’ in Article 33 of the UNCRC that deals with substance abuse among children. It is also unclear whether the term ‘substance abuse’ encompasses ‘inhalant abuse’ in the SDGs. Consequently, domestic policies, laws, programs, and schemes also fail to acknowledge the problem and deny the most vulnerable children their right to protection against one of the “most dangerous” drugs.
While discussing the nature and types of policy inaction and defining it, McConnell and Hart (2019) provide a framework to investigate, capture, explain, and evaluate policy inaction. Using the framework, the present paper describes the origins and sites of policy inactions at different tiers of policymaking. In addition to identifying the origins of the policy inactions, the paper discusses possible ways, including action research methodologies, to overcome those inactions for future research and practice. The paper contributes to public policy research on substance abuse beyond the Global North and highlights the importance of changing the dominant frame of reference for better global and local policy actions.
References
Ford, J. B., Sutter, M. E., Owen, K. P., & Albertson, T. E. (2014). Volatile substance misuse: an updated review of toxicity and treatment. Clinical Reviews in Allergy & Immunology, 46(1), 19–33. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12016-013-8371-1
Koposov, R., Stickley, A. & Ruchkin, V. (2018). Inhalant use in adolescents in northern Russia. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 53, 709–716. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-018-1524-z
MacLean, S., Cameron, J., Harney, A., & Lee, N. K. (2012). Psychosocial therapeutic interventions for volatile substance use: a systematic review. Addiction (Abingdon, England), 107(2), 278–288. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1360-0443.2011.03650.x
Manikandan, K. & Balasubramanian, S. (2020). An uprising health concern of inhalant abuse among adolescents: A Mini Review. Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences & Research, 12(1), 151-155. https://www.jpsr.pharmainfo.in/Documents/Volumes/vol12issue01/jpsr12012028.pdf
McConnell, A., ’t Hart, P. (2019). Inaction and public policy: understanding why policymakers ‘do nothing’. Policy Sci 52, 645–661. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-019-09362-2
Shaikh, A., & Sarin, A. (2024). Inhalant Abuse among Street Involved Children and Adolescents in India: Case for Epistemic Recognition and Reorientation. Journal of Research on Adolescence 00, 1-14. https://doi.org/10.1111/jora.12946.
UN. (1989). Convention on the rights of the child. General Assembly Resolution 44/25, United Nations. Available at: https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/convention-rights-child
UNSTATS. (n.d.). Global indicator framework for the Sustainable Development Goals and targets of the 2030 agenda for sustainable development. United Nations Statistics Division. Available at UNITED
Woan, J., Lin, J., & Auerswald, C. (2013). The health status of street children and youth in low- and middle-income countries: A systematic review of the literature. Journal of Adolescent Health, 53(3), 314-321. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jadohealth.2013.03.013
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Education reforms aimed at fostering mindset shifts—from rote learning to holistic development—encounter persistent systemic barriers. These challenges stem from deeply entrenched beliefs, pedagogical practices, and institutional structures that resist transformation. Such reforms, often framed as technical solutions through curriculum revisions, pedagogical innovations, or assessment changes, fail to address the underlying structural and ideological inertia within education systems. Consequently, these interventions reinforce existing rigidity and policy misalignments rather than fostering meaningful change.
A critical limitation of prevailing education policies is the absence of student voices in decision-making. The lived experiences of young learners, particularly those from marginalized communities, remain largely unrecognized within mainstream policy discourse. The issues that shape their educational trajectories—ranging from socio-emotional learning needs to structural inequities—are often rendered invisible, perpetuating a gap between policy intent and ground realities.
This presentation draws on insights from Dream a Dream’s work in reimagining education ecosystems through a systemic lens. Our research highlights the disconnect between top-down policy frameworks and localized educational needs, illustrating how policy inaction—or misplaced action—can sustain rather than disrupt inequities.
Through case studies and empirical evidence, we explore how systemic reforms can move beyond superficial technical fixes to drive meaningful, context-specific transformations. The discussion underscores the importance of recognizing education as a dynamic ecosystem where reform is not merely about changing policies but about shifting mindsets, power structures, and institutional norms. Ultimately, we argue that addressing these wicked problems requires participatory approaches that center young people’s voices, dismantle entrenched hierarchies, and foster collective agency in shaping the future of education.
Keywords: Education reform, Wicked problems, Mindset shift, Policy changes,Voice and recognition
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Liquor prohibition in India has been a subject of debate, with states implementing it under the Directive Principles of State Policy (Article 47 of the Indian Constitution). Gujarat has maintained a successful prohibition policy since 1949, whereas Bihar implemented prohibition in 2016 with mixed results. This research paper critically examines the formulation and implementation of liquor prohibition policies in both states, highlighting the challenges faced in Bihar.The study explores the socio-economic and public health impacts of prohibition, comparing Gujarat’s long-term success with Bihar’s struggles. Bihar’s policy, despite its noble intent, has led to unintended consequences such as the rise of illicit liquor trade, increased judicial burden, and economic losses. In contrast, Gujarat has effectively enforced prohibition through strict governance, alternative revenue sources, and public participation.The paper also presents alternative policy approaches, including a regulated alcohol sales model, harm reduction strategies, and rehabilitation-focused programs. Lessons from Gujarat and global best practices suggest that Bihar needs a more dynamic and adaptive policy framework to achieve the intended social benefits.
By analyzing the comparative success and failures of liquor prohibition in both states, this research aims to provide constructive recommendations for better policy formulation and implementation in Bihar. The findings emphasize the need for a balanced approach that prioritizes public welfare while addressing enforcement challenges and economic concerns.
Keywords: Public Policy, Liquor Prohibition, Bihar, Gujarat Policy Implementation, Socio-Economic Impact, Governance, Harm Reduction
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
India has a long history of condemning specific communities to waste work. Although outlawed (in 1950), untouchability and social exclusion of waste workers are social practices that persist. Urban India, often celebrated as a site for ‘caste’ liberation is no exception. Of various forms of waste work, workers dealing with human excreta - manual scavenging - are one of the most marginalized. Several forms of this work have been made illegal, and government policies have repeatedly promised ‘improvements’. However, workers continue to die and their deaths often remain under-reported.
We examine a seventy-five year history of policies and policy artefacts directed at the well-being of manual scavengers and the elimination of the practice. We analyse policy documents that include laws, committee reports and government schemes to understand the contours of policy since India’s independence. The policy story of manual scavenging in India cannot be reduced to that of a failed state. Instead, the Indian state’s failure to eradicate manual scavenging needs to be understood in the context of a state that has demonstrated a range in its capacity to act – “from woefully inadequate to surprisingly impressive” (Kapur 2020: 1). Drawing conceptually from several scholars who work on negatives like omission (Bathran, 2016), (un)knowing (Alexander and O’Hare, 2020), (in)action (McConnell and ‘t Hart, 2019), policy disasters (Gray, 1996), we describe the policy journey of manual scavenging by anchoring it in the practices of (in)visibilization that enable inaction by an otherwise ‘active’ state.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Single-mother families are among the most common yet economically vulnerable family types in Europe and beyond. They face the "triple bind" of caregiving, breadwinning, and structural discrimination, compounded by gender inequalities and inadequate policy support (Nienwenhuis & Maldonado, 2018). Policy is a critical factor in shaping the well-being of these families, who are identified as a new social risk (Bonoli, 2005). While some welfare states address the challenges faced by single-mother families more effectively, others lag behind. Lithuania, for example, has the highest poverty rate among single-mother families relative to two-parent families in Europe due to the lack of policy support (EU-SILC, 2023; Skubiejūtė, 2021).
This presentation examines how the social construction of single-mother families in Lithuania contributes to policy inaction, applying the theory of social construction and policy design (Ingram & Schneider, 1993, 2004). It also uses the concepts of decommodification and defamilialisation to explore how single mothers' lives, and those of their children, change after migrating to countries that provide policy recognition and support.
The research draws on a comprehensive analysis of Lithuanian family policy since the country’s independence in 1991, interviews with 15 Lithuanian policymakers, an analysis of current family policy in Germany, Norway, and the UK, and the lived experiences of 30 single mothers who emigrated to these countries.
The findings reveal that Lithuanian policies are heavily influenced by familialism, traditional gender norms, and Christian values. As a result, single-mother families are often constructed as "deviant," stigmatised as benefit scroungers, and labelled as destroyers of family ideals (Schneider & Ingram, 1993; 2004; Skubiejūtė, 2021). These negative perceptions lead to their being framed as "undeserving" of support, perpetuating structural discrimination, social exclusion, and material deprivation. Faced with this systemic neglect, many single mothers emigrate to countries such as Germany, Norway, and the UK, where policies are more inclusive, and single mothers are valued as contributors rather than vilified.
The study shows that welfare policies in Lithuania deliberately exclude single mothers, using policy inaction to reinforce traditional family norms. In contrast, Germany, Norway, and the UK implement policies that actively support single mothers’ economic independence, social inclusion, and well-being. These inclusive measures enable single mothers to pursue better career opportunities, engage in community activities, and reduce their reliance on welfare—challenging the fears of Lithuanian policymakers who view such support as fostering dependency.
In supportive policy environments like Norway, the UK, and Germany, single mothers experience reduced stigma, greater autonomy, and enhanced opportunities. These countries demonstrate how well-designed policies rooted in decommodification and defamilialisation can empower vulnerable groups, breaking cycles of poverty and dependency rather than perpetuating them.
This presentation contributes to the understanding of how public policies can either reinforce or challenge inequalities.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This study explores the bidirectional relationship between social service quality perceptions and subjective well-being across 33 European countries, challenging traditional unidirectional approaches. Utilizing data from the 2016 European Quality of Life Survey involving over 37,000 respondents, the research employed multilevel analysis and innovative diffusion maps to examine the effect of seven key social services on well-being, within different welfare regimes.
The findings reveal a significant dual connection between service quality perceptions and well-being, with service quality having a stronger impact on well-being. Childcare and education demonstrated the most significant association with well-being, while social housing and long-term care showed minimal influence. Social-Democratic regimes exhibited higher levels of perceived service quality and subjective well-being compared to other regime types.
A novel methodological approach using diffusion maps uncovered that individuals with higher subjective well-being display more diverse service quality perceptions, while those with lower well-being share more homogeneous views. This pattern remained consistent across welfare regimes.
The study contributes theoretically by advancing understanding of institutional arrangements' impact on well-being, empirically by providing a comprehensive analysis of social service perceptions across European countries, and methodologically by introducing diffusion maps as an innovative analytical tool.
Implications for policymakers include prioritizing services like childcare and education to enhance citizens' well-being and considering the complex, bidirectional relationship between social services and subjective well-being.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The interplay between public policy inaction and digital transformation in addressing educational inequities forms the crux of this study. Focusing on Early Childhood Care and Education (ECCE) within Anganwadi centers in Bihar, India, this research critically examines how systemic (in)action contributes to persistent inequalities in cognitive development, parental involvement, and child nutrition. Assessing 712 children across 20 centers, the study reveals significant gaps: 7% of children consistently underperform in cognitive domains, 68.67% experience limited parental engagement, and 16% face stunted growth. These outcomes underscore the deliberate oversight and resource inequities embedded in policy implementation. Leveraging digital tools, the study proposes evidence-based interventions, including e-learning platforms for Anganwadi workers, progress-tracking applications, and parent engagement technologies, exemplified by the Poshan 2.0 tracker. By contextualizing these solutions within justice-oriented frameworks, this research highlights the potential for technology to counteract policy inaction and foster equity in ECCE outcomes. The findings contribute to the discourse on public policy inaction, advocating for inclusive, data-driven approaches that challenge systemic exclusions and promote sustainable transformations in resource-constrained settings.
Keywords: Public policy inaction, ECCE, Digital transformation, Educational inequities, Anganwadi
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Introduction
The Pradhan Mantri Matru Vandana Yojana (PMMVY) is a conditional maternity benefit programme that aims to provide financial assistance to pregnant and lactating mothers and improve maternal and child health outcomes in India.However, despite its ambitious objectives, the scheme has encountered significant policy inaction, particularly in rural India, where digital infrastructure and bureaucratic hurdles limit access. The dependence on digital infrastructure for application processes, online registrations, Aadhaar-linked verification, and direct benefit transfers has disproportionately affected women in marginalised communities with limited digital literacy and inadequate access to internet services. Thepaper aims to explore how digital inaccessibility, compounded by bureaucratic hurdles, structural inequities, and inadequate policy responsiveness, creates barriers to PMMVY access in rural Himachal Pradesh, a state known for its challenging terrain, difficult geographic conditions and unreliable Internet connectivity and how strategic communication is playing a vital role in overcoming these hurdles.
Research Questions
This study projects to answer the following key research questions:
1. How does the digital divide impact rural women's access to PMMVY benefits in Himachal Pradesh?
2. What administrative and systemic barriers exist due to digital dependency in the scheme's implementation?
3. What is the role played by various stakeholders to enhance the strategic communication for addressing the digital divide?
Methodology
This study employs a mixed-methods research design, combining qualitative and quantitative approaches to provide a comprehensive analysis.
Quantitative Analysis- A survey of 100 women across select villages in Himachal Pradesh will be conducted to assess their awareness, accessibility, and experiences with the PMMVY online application process. Key variables will include access to digital devices, internet connectivity, Aadhaar linkage issues, delays in benefit receipt, and maternal health indicators such as antenatal care visits, nutritional intake, and birth outcomes.
Qualitative Analysis: In-depth interviews with 30 beneficiaries and 10 frontline health workers (Accredited Social Health Activists—ASHAs & Anganwadi Workers (AWWs)) will be conducted to capture lived experiences, bureaucratic hurdles, and coping mechanisms in navigating the digital landscape. Additionally, interviews with gram panchayat members and government officials will shed light on the extent of policy inaction in addressing digital exclusion.
Policy Analysis: A review of government reports, policy documents, and existing literature will be undertaken to analyse policy responses (or lack thereof) in mitigating digital barriers to PMMVY implementation.
Expected Outcomes and Implications
The study is expected to reveal that digital inaccessibility is a significant barrier to PMMVY benefit utilisation, with rural women facing delays or outright exclusion due to technical and bureaucratic inefficiencies. It is also anticipated that policy inaction, such as the lack of alternative application mechanisms (offline support, simplified verification, local assistance), exacerbates these challenges.
Alignment with the panel’s Research Questions
The abstract fits the panel research questions by exploring the origins of inaction in PMMVY, where policy inaction around digital barriers remains unaddressed. It also highlights strategic communication choices, such as community advocacy and local empowerment, used by stakeholders to challenge these barriers and push for reform.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The insertion of Article 21A in the Indian Constitution transformed education from a welfare measure to a fundamental right, with the Right to Education Act (2009) providing its legislative framework. Section 12(1)(c) of the Act mandates private schools to reserve 25% seats for socio-economically disadvantaged children, advancing constitutional aspirations of inclusive education. Yet, by 2023, eleven Indian states had failed to implement this provision, exemplifying systematic policy inaction that deprives marginalized children of their constitutional right. This paper examines how judicial advocacy can challenge such policy inaction through a case study of public interest litigation in Assam, initiated by the author in 2020. Drawing on primary documentation and participant observation, the study traces how judicial intervention transformed state inaction into implementation in Assam, benefiting over 100,000 children in two years. The analysis focuses on three key aspects: (a) the anatomy of state inaction in implementing the 25% reservation in Assam, (b) the four-year litigation process challenging this inaction, including state resistance and eventual compliance, and (c) the potential and limitations of judicial advocacy in enforcing policy implementation. A critical finding emerges from the analysis of public interest litigation patterns: most cases challenging state inaction in RTE implementation are initiated by public-spirited organizations and individuals rather than the direct beneficiaries - the children and parents themselves. This pattern raises important questions about voice, representation, and access to justice. The study concludes by proposing a framework for integrating judicial advocacy with grassroots mobilization, contributing to broader discussions about accountability mechanisms in policy implementation and the role of affected communities in challenging state inaction.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Inhalants are considered one of the most dangerous drugs abused mostly by children (Koposov et al., 2018), with higher rates of abuse among street-involved children due to their legal and widespread availability, easy accessibility, and low price (Ford et al., 2014; MacLean et al., 2011; Manikandan et al., 2020). Woan et al. (2013, p. 318) observe that “there is an inhalant use epidemic in low-and middle-income countries.” The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) and the Sustainable Developmental Goals(SDGs) have outlined specific policy measures to ensure the protection of children from substance abuse and provide treatment for it (UN, 1989; UNSTATS, n.d.). Likewise, the Indian state has also committed itself to protecting children from substances. Yet despite this acknowledgment, policy against inhalant abuse among street adolescents can, at best, be characterized as expressing inaction (Shaikh & Sarin, 2024).
In this paper, we draw on a close review of policy documents, discussions with the key stakeholders, and on-ground action research to probe the nature of policy inaction at different levels. Adopting the principles of participatory action research (PAR), we got directly involved in five case studies of attempted rescue and rehabilitation of eight inhalant-abusing street-involved children (n=8) by the authorities in a large metropolitan city in Western India. These cases emerged as we engaged with the formal government policy on "rescue and rehabilitation," following the prescribed procedures as closely as possible. Given the author's affiliation with a well-regarded institution, these cases could be seen as representing a "best-case" scenario, where better outcomes might have been expected. Concurrently, we conducted semi-structured interviews with 15 key stakeholders, including policy implementers, elected representatives, and NGO workers working closely with street-involved children.
Despite being considered an epidemic in low and middle-income countries, the issue of inhalant abuse is neglected as we found no mention of ‘inhalants’ in Article 33 of the UNCRC that deals with substance abuse among children. It is also unclear whether the term ‘substance abuse’ encompasses ‘inhalant abuse’ in the SDGs. Consequently, domestic policies, laws, programs, and schemes also fail to acknowledge the problem and deny the most vulnerable children their right to protection against one of the “most dangerous” drugs.
While discussing the nature and types of policy inaction and defining it, McConnell and Hart (2019) provide a framework to investigate, capture, explain, and evaluate policy inaction. Using the framework, the present paper describes the origins and sites of policy inactions at different tiers of policymaking. In addition to identifying the origins of the policy inactions, the paper discusses possible ways, including action research methodologies, to overcome those inactions for future research and practice. The paper contributes to public policy research on substance abuse beyond the Global North and highlights the importance of changing the dominant frame of reference for better global and local policy actions.
References
Ford, J. B., Sutter, M. E., Owen, K. P., & Albertson, T. E. (2014). Volatile substance misuse: an updated review of toxicity and treatment. Clinical Reviews in Allergy & Immunology, 46(1), 19–33. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12016-013-8371-1
Koposov, R., Stickley, A. & Ruchkin, V. (2018). Inhalant use in adolescents in northern Russia. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 53, 709–716. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-018-1524-z
MacLean, S., Cameron, J., Harney, A., & Lee, N. K. (2012). Psychosocial therapeutic interventions for volatile substance use: a systematic review. Addiction (Abingdon, England), 107(2), 278–288. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1360-0443.2011.03650.x
Manikandan, K. & Balasubramanian, S. (2020). An uprising health concern of inhalant abuse among adolescents: A Mini Review. Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences & Research, 12(1), 151-155. https://www.jpsr.pharmainfo.in/Documents/Volumes/vol12issue01/jpsr12012028.pdf
McConnell, A., ’t Hart, P. (2019). Inaction and public policy: understanding why policymakers ‘do nothing’. Policy Sci 52, 645–661. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-019-09362-2
Shaikh, A., & Sarin, A. (2024). Inhalant Abuse among Street Involved Children and Adolescents in India: Case for Epistemic Recognition and Reorientation. Journal of Research on Adolescence 00, 1-14. https://doi.org/10.1111/jora.12946.
UN. (1989). Convention on the rights of the child. General Assembly Resolution 44/25, United Nations. Available at: https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/convention-rights-child
UNSTATS. (n.d.). Global indicator framework for the Sustainable Development Goals and targets of the 2030 agenda for sustainable development. United Nations Statistics Division. Available at UNITED
Woan, J., Lin, J., & Auerswald, C. (2013). The health status of street children and youth in low- and middle-income countries: A systematic review of the literature. Journal of Adolescent Health, 53(3), 314-321. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jadohealth.2013.03.013
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Education reforms aimed at fostering mindset shifts—from rote learning to holistic development—encounter persistent systemic barriers. These challenges stem from deeply entrenched beliefs, pedagogical practices, and institutional structures that resist transformation. Such reforms, often framed as technical solutions through curriculum revisions, pedagogical innovations, or assessment changes, fail to address the underlying structural and ideological inertia within education systems. Consequently, these interventions reinforce existing rigidity and policy misalignments rather than fostering meaningful change.
A critical limitation of prevailing education policies is the absence of student voices in decision-making. The lived experiences of young learners, particularly those from marginalized communities, remain largely unrecognized within mainstream policy discourse. The issues that shape their educational trajectories—ranging from socio-emotional learning needs to structural inequities—are often rendered invisible, perpetuating a gap between policy intent and ground realities.
This presentation draws on insights from Dream a Dream’s work in reimagining education ecosystems through a systemic lens. Our research highlights the disconnect between top-down policy frameworks and localized educational needs, illustrating how policy inaction—or misplaced action—can sustain rather than disrupt inequities.
Through case studies and empirical evidence, we explore how systemic reforms can move beyond superficial technical fixes to drive meaningful, context-specific transformations. The discussion underscores the importance of recognizing education as a dynamic ecosystem where reform is not merely about changing policies but about shifting mindsets, power structures, and institutional norms. Ultimately, we argue that addressing these wicked problems requires participatory approaches that center young people’s voices, dismantle entrenched hierarchies, and foster collective agency in shaping the future of education.
Keywords: Education reform, Wicked problems, Mindset shift, Policy changes,Voice and recognition
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Liquor prohibition in India has been a subject of debate, with states implementing it under the Directive Principles of State Policy (Article 47 of the Indian Constitution). Gujarat has maintained a successful prohibition policy since 1949, whereas Bihar implemented prohibition in 2016 with mixed results. This research paper critically examines the formulation and implementation of liquor prohibition policies in both states, highlighting the challenges faced in Bihar.The study explores the socio-economic and public health impacts of prohibition, comparing Gujarat’s long-term success with Bihar’s struggles. Bihar’s policy, despite its noble intent, has led to unintended consequences such as the rise of illicit liquor trade, increased judicial burden, and economic losses. In contrast, Gujarat has effectively enforced prohibition through strict governance, alternative revenue sources, and public participation.The paper also presents alternative policy approaches, including a regulated alcohol sales model, harm reduction strategies, and rehabilitation-focused programs. Lessons from Gujarat and global best practices suggest that Bihar needs a more dynamic and adaptive policy framework to achieve the intended social benefits.
By analyzing the comparative success and failures of liquor prohibition in both states, this research aims to provide constructive recommendations for better policy formulation and implementation in Bihar. The findings emphasize the need for a balanced approach that prioritizes public welfare while addressing enforcement challenges and economic concerns.
Keywords: Public Policy, Liquor Prohibition, Bihar, Gujarat Policy Implementation, Socio-Economic Impact, Governance, Harm Reduction
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
India has a long history of condemning specific communities to waste work. Although outlawed (in 1950), untouchability and social exclusion of waste workers are social practices that persist. Urban India, often celebrated as a site for ‘caste’ liberation is no exception. Of various forms of waste work, workers dealing with human excreta - manual scavenging - are one of the most marginalized. Several forms of this work have been made illegal, and government policies have repeatedly promised ‘improvements’. However, workers continue to die and their deaths often remain under-reported.
We examine a seventy-five year history of policies and policy artefacts directed at the well-being of manual scavengers and the elimination of the practice. We analyse policy documents that include laws, committee reports and government schemes to understand the contours of policy since India’s independence. The policy story of manual scavenging in India cannot be reduced to that of a failed state. Instead, the Indian state’s failure to eradicate manual scavenging needs to be understood in the context of a state that has demonstrated a range in its capacity to act – “from woefully inadequate to surprisingly impressive” (Kapur 2020: 1). Drawing conceptually from several scholars who work on negatives like omission (Bathran, 2016), (un)knowing (Alexander and O’Hare, 2020), (in)action (McConnell and ‘t Hart, 2019), policy disasters (Gray, 1996), we describe the policy journey of manual scavenging by anchoring it in the practices of (in)visibilization that enable inaction by an otherwise ‘active’ state.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)