CATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
Is there any way social media can influence the policymaking process or contribute to policy change? How do politicians and citizens use social media to transform policies or control the policymaking process? These are some of the questions this panel intends to answer.
Digital social media are defined as online technological platforms which coexist with "concrete" public spaces (Chambat, 1995) controlled by governments. Unlike Habermas' definition of public space, we extend the definition of public space to "common space", a place of "connection" where political power comes to realise (Arendt et al., 1995, pp. 7–8; Zittoun, 2013). Additionally, public spaces operate as strategic tools used by politicians and their public struggling to structure policies, transform them or control their normative orientation. Based on constructivist and pragmatist perspectives of policy studies and policymaking process, we define public policies as sets of interactions created by governments' outputs and effects on their publics who struggle to change or transform the policies using deliberative public and private spaces over time (Zittoun, 2013; Durnovà, 2019; Fischer, 2009; Weible, 2019; Edimo, 2021).
The public policy literature identifies several stages of the public policymaking process (definition of the problem, formulation of solutions, agenda-setting, implementation, evaluation, etc.). Many contemporary approaches to policy studies also highlight subjective, intersubjective and pragmatist policy processes, including enunciation, formulation of the problem, planning, expertisation, and advocacy as social and political practices and activities that structure public action. They have also offered new perspectives on which to rely to enhance the study of domestic policy processes and their interactions with international or different stages of the transnational deliberative policymaking process (see, for example, Edimo, 2021).
Since the works of Christopher Hood & Helen Margetts (Hood & Margetts, 2007), very few studies have focused on the role of digital technologies in transforming public action, particularly with regard to the ability of governments' publics to use and disseminate flows of information; government capacity to continue to control citizens’ behaviours, and the sociopolitical structure of processes of government, etc. While it is well known that government activities affect the citizens' behaviours, how they change according to contexts or environment where they operate.
CALL FOR PAPERS
This panel invites papers that explore the relationship between digital social media and policymaking from various perspectives and contexts. Authors may examine different stages of public policy, including agenda-setting, policy formulation, and implementation. Topics of interest include policy advocacy, contestation, governance, environmental politics, climate change, migration governance, migrants' rights, and employment issues.
References
Ansell, C., Hassenteufel, P., & Zittoun, P. The policy transaction perspective: A pragmatist‐constructivist approach to the policy process. European Policy Analysis.
Yordy, J., Durnová, A., & Weible, C. M. (2024). Exploring emotional discourses: the case of COVID-19 protests in the US media. Administrative Theory & Praxis, 46(1), 35-54.
Edimo, M. M. (2021). Expertise on the Anglophone crisis in Cameroon: A hybrid cultural boundary approach. International Review of Public Policy, 3(3.3), 345-363.
Hassenteufel, P. (2021). Sociologie de l'action publique. Armand Colin.
Hood, C. C. (1983). The tools of government. (No Title).
Hood, C., & Margetts, H. (2007). The tools of government in the digital age. Bloomsbury Publishing.
Weible, C. M., & Workman, S. (Eds.). (2022). Methods of the policy process. Taylor & Francis.
Zittoun, P. (2013). La fabrique politique des politiques publiques. Une approche pragmatique de l’action publique, Paris, Presses de Sciences Po.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper discusses the recent European regulatory developments affecting commercial advertising disseminated via linear audiovisual programs, video-sharing platforms, and social networks, shedding light on the effects of public policy on marketing and consumer protection. It provides a general assessment of the Directives included in the Digital Services Act package—the Audiovisual Media Services Directive, the Digital Services Act, and the Digital Markets Act—looking at the new set of rules and provisions applicable to audiovisual media services providers, video-on-demand, video-sharing, and large online platforms, ensuring enhanced protection of minors from harmful content, redefining the limits of commercial communications, and increasing the protection of consumer data by prohibiting the usage of personal data of children for commercial purposes, like direct marketing, profiling, or behaviorally targeted advertising. Based on a qualitative analysis, the study maps out the specific rules and obligations introduced by the Digital Services Act package. Data is taken from multiple publicly available sources, such as central government information, ministerial data, and regional agencies. This preliminary study provides several insights, contributing to recent research on regulatory developments at the EU level.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The aim of this article is to analyse the bidirectional relationship between digital public governance and corruption, with a view to filling three gaps in the literature. First of all, studies have mainly focused on a unidirectional relationship. However, the facts show that a number of developing countries are finding it difficult to mitigate the level of corruption and keep up with the prospects for digitalisation, despite the digital transition. Furthermore, digitalisation has perverse effects on the operational and governing nature of government, which may lead decision-makers to limit its implementation on the basis of digital sovereignty. Governments may also lose rents through the digitisation of procedures such as procurement and spending processes. To this end, public decision-makers can put the brakes on the digitisation process. Next, we test the importance of democracy on the two-way relationship. We find that the least corrupt countries are the most democratic. Moreover, countries and democrats can be more successful in the process of implementing digital governance than those that are hybrid or outright authoritarian. Finally, we are working on DCs in three regions and will carry out evaluations by sub-block.
The study method is a causality test of Dumitrescu & Hurlin. The results indicate a bidirectional relationship between corruption and the development of digital governance in developing countries. Indeed, corruption negatively affects the development of digital governance and digital governance negatively affects governance. These results are in line with the orthodox thesis that corruption is ‘a grain of sand in the wheel’. We also find that the level of democracy affects the results obtained. For countries with weak democracies, corruption unilaterally affects the level of digitalisation of public procedures. The poor quality of institutions in developing countries with weak democracies means that public decision-makers are unable to limit the level of corruption in both public and private sector economies.
In the light of the various results obtained, we can recommend that public institutions in developing countries develop digital governance systems to mitigate the risk of corruption and ensure that the modernisation of public institutions progresses. Less democratic countries need to put in place political systems that make it possible to assess the public decision-makers in place and the dynamics of public sector reforms. To limit the influence of corruption on the digitalisation of public governance, public decision-makers can increase civil servants' incomes and grant compliance bonuses to motivate them to replace corruption. Nonetheless, quality assurance of institutions in developing countries remains relevant in order to capture the benefits of digital governance and use them as strategic weapons as in developed countries. As a limitation of the research, we have not taken into account the mediation of democracy on the relationship between corruption and the digitalisation of public governance. Bidirectional studies on corruption and public phenomena must take into account the level of democracy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Climate change is posing an enormous challenge to socio-economic and environmental wellbeing, globally. The Climate Risk Index statistics shows that Nepal falls under the ten most affected countries in the world. Prioritization of media stories through front page coverage using big-size images, cartoons, and provocative headlines makes a significant difference on how incidents are perceived and re-prioritized. When social media platforms deliberately prioritize a particular incident, it results in agenda-setting or otherwise public debates will be centered around only particular perspective.
Though the role of social media in climate change messaging has been understood in academic and public spheres, limited studies have been conducted and published, especially in the context of Nepal. Most of the coverage has been confined to direct association with rapid onset of disaster and less attention towards whether and how sustainable energy utilization can be promoted.
A qualitative study was conducted following in-depth review of the social media posts and audience interactions using Critical Discourse Analysis method. Likewise, key informant interview and focus group discussion tools were also used to understand the coverage frequency and pattern, document perspectives of the media professionals and journalists.
Study findings highlight social media interventions focus on behavior change communication than media advocacy; lack of innovation scope in funded media projects; absence of empirical research on processes of depoliticization regarding climate change in public and media discourses; lack of ideological analysis of climate change coverage; lack of proper distinction on journalistic take on climate change as incidental event or structural development. The study recommends for comprehensive study of social media interactions on climate change in Nepal particularly through framing and factor analysis to identify reasons and incentives for certain media coverage trends when it comes to covering climate change.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper aims to analyze social media as a form of relay in the formulation of the microbe problem in the city of Douala, Cameroon. Microbes, which appeared in Cameroon's economic capital in late November 2022, are considered to be a gang made up of young, often under-age males armed with machetes, knives, axes and gourds. At nightfall, they attack men and women, taking phones and money as they go, and beating, wounding and sometimes killing those who resist. Such was the case of their recent attack on a drinking establishment in the city of palms district on October 6, 2024, exposing the population to all kinds of physical and mental harm. Faced with the recurrence of this gang's violent practices and the chaos left in the public space, the people of Douala have taken to social media to draw the attention of government authorities. Facebook, Instagram, twitter and many others were used as relays, with the aim of making this phenomenon a public problem and getting it on the government's agenda. A fact that has been observed by the popularization of the practices of this gang through various videos and images sometimes amateur. As a result, public action has been taken. Fifteen fixed surveillance points have been set up in high-risk neighborhoods. It's fair to say, then, that social media, which have long been seen as a weave of diverse actors and interests, have reinvented themselves. What role do social media play in formulating microbes as a public problem in Douala? To answer this question, this study will be based on interviews and a collection of
accounts from key players in the digital field, as well as Internet users who have closely followed the popularization of the rise of this gang on social media.
Keywords: Public action, social networks, relays, microbes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The paper explores a centralized system that ensures the processing of opinions and claims against regional and municipal officials expressed by citizens in social media, which began in 2020 in Russia. Previous authors’ studies of Russian systems that ensure the interaction of authorities with citizens made it possible to identify six channels of electronic participation at the regional and municipal levels. However, the development of social media and the emergence of new technologies for involving citizens in public politics have created the prerequisites for the transformation of electronic participation systems. This was reflected both in scientific research and in practice. For example, in the Russian Federation in 2020 a new channel of electronic participation was launched. A network of Regional Control Centers (RCCs) has been created and is being developed, one of the components of which is the Incident Management system, which allows real-time monitoring of the reaction of users in social media and ensuring the processing of messages or claims of citizens to the authorities as well as responding to citizens via social media. The paper presents the results of a pilot study that made it possible to identify the heterogeneity of new structures in terms of institutional affiliation and data from monitoring e-participation channels in the context of centralization processes. The authors as a part of research team of e-Governance Center at ITMO University carried out the tree stages of e-participation monitoring in Russia carried out in 2020, 2021 and 2022. The basic methodology and tools of the monitoring study have not undergone significant changes, which makes it possible to compare the results over time. The channels of e-participation of citizens created by the regional authorities and local governments were identified and evaluated according to 15 indicators, divided into 5 logical blocks. Six types of channels were considered: Open Budgeting, Proactive Budgeting, Problem Reporting, E-Initiatives, E-voting, and Crowdsourcing. The monitoring results showed a significant reduction of e-participation channels created and maintained at the initiative of the executive bodies of regions and municipalities, which indicates the strengthening of centralization trends. Moreover, we provide a bibliometric analysis of e-participation research in order to reveal publication patterns and trends. The main findings are as follows. First, starting from 2020, the e-participation system in Russia is being transformed. New channels of interaction with citizens are being developed (a centralized feedback platform, etc., which are provided as part of the functioning of the RCC system, which in some cases causes duplication of channels at the regional level). Second, we can see three stages of e-participation evolution in Russia: initiative-public (2010-2012), initiative-regional (2012–2020), centralized-federal (from 2020). Third, the success of solving the problems of integrating digital resources of electronic participation largely depends on the powers of the vice-governors - curators of the RCCs in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Relevance of the paper
As social media usage has spread worldwide, interactions between stakeholders and government have become multidimensional, moving beyond traditional models of ‘government-to-citizen’ (G2C) and ‘citizen-to-government’ (C2G). This shift has led to the emergence of various models, such as network governance, which promote co-creation among different stakeholders (Ly & Ly, 2023). Studies have found that government-citizen interactions through social media help build trust, encourage citizen participation, shape usage attitudes, and improve information quality between the government and citizens in e-government development. This study develops a theoretical model of social presence on online social networks and its role in the context of e-government intention to examine empirically. Simultaneously, we integrated two mediators: citizen engagement and trust in government. This model examines the interconnections of both direct and indirect effects of social presence, online social network usage, and e-government intention among municipal users, highlighting the role of these two mediators
Research purpose
This research highlights the growing importance of digital platforms in citizen engagement, particularly through social media. Few studies have examined whether citizen-to-citizen interaction through online social spaces impacts citizen engagement. We argue that studies need to examine how citizen-to-citizen interactions among themselves through various social networks impact trust in government and citizen engagement, ultimately affecting the intention to use e-government. This study conceptualizes citizen engagement as citizens' active participation and interaction through online social networks, where they share resources, participate electronically, and assist each other in accessing quality e-government services. The intensity of social presence influences warmth, sociability, personalization, and sensitivity in their communications. Interestingly, we found no significant literature on online social presence in the context of e-government.
Methodology
This study employed a questionnaire-based survey method conducted among 590 urban e-government users. Structural equation modeling using AMOS was employed to test the theoretical model. The study performed a confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) and assessed the reliability, discriminant, and convergent validity of the constructs. Then the study explored the relationship through structural models. The study employed age, gender, education, employment, and income as control variables and examined the effect by linking them to all endogenous variables.
Findings
We uncovered several significant findings contributing to both theory and policy in e-government development. While previous studies have shown a positive relationship between government social media usage and e-government development, our study reveals that merely using social networks among citizens does not necessarily lead to adopting e-government in practice. Instead, we found that social presence on social media has a much stronger positive effect on e-government usage. Additionally, our findings highlight the mediating roles of citizen engagement and trust in government, which bridge the relationship between social network usage, social presence, and e-government adoption.
References
Ly, B., & Ly, R. (2023). Emerging trends in social media for E-governance and citizen engagement: A case study of Telegram in Cambodia. Computers in Human Behavior Reports.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Social media has evolved into a central force in handling national and local crises. This prompts the question: Do all stakeholders in a local crisis grasp its significance when it predominantly unfolds in the digital realm of online social media? This article investigates this issue through a case study of the Roman Zadorov justice movement in Israel. Despite Zadorov's wrongful imprisonment for Tair Rada's murder, social media support grew, reshaping perceptions of Katsrin, the town where the murder took place. The four-fold analysis draws on social media content, youth interviews, municipal officials' perspectives, and a population survey. It reveals how Tair Rada's case became central to Katsrin's image, fueled by social media's influence. However, local officials failed to recognize social media's crisis significance, highlighting a disconnect. The article concludes by exploring this dissonance, shedding light on crisis management challenges in the social media era and their impact on local governance.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
ROLE OF MEDIA IN POLICY EDUCATION
NAYAH GAZELLE ABANG
(Senior lecturer)
gazelle5000@yahoo.com
The University of Maroua
Faculty of Law and Political Sciences
Department of Political Sciences
ABSTRACT
Most of the studies on democracy in Africa specifically and generally reveals that at the dawn of independence, 1980-1990 being the period of democratization, In the CEMAC (Economic and Monetary Community of Central Africa) sub-region, several countries have grappled with domestic conflicts, affecting peace, stability, and economic development. Within the CEMAC sub-region, and specifically in Cameroon, different measures have been used such as multipartism, regular elections yet democratic practices still remain questionable. This study therefore examines the influence of media on policy education in Cameroon, focusing on how media platforms educates the public about policy issues and the implications for democratic participation. Through a mixed-methods approach, including surveys, interviews, and content analysis, the research explores the effectiveness of various media channels, such as television, radio, newspapers, and social media, in disseminating policy-related information. The findings suggest that while traditional media remains a significant source of policy education, social media platforms are increasingly playing a crucial role in engaging younger audiences and fostering interactive discussions. The study highlights the challenges faced by media in maintaining accuracy and impartiality in policy reporting and recommends strategies for enhancing media's role in policy education to promote informed citizen participation in the democratic process.
Keywords: Media, policy, public policy, policy education, democracy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Background: Hashtag activism has emerged as a global phenomenon within digital public discourse, extending its influence to the realm of public policy. Given the wealth of data it generates, understanding the characteristics of hashtag activism that engages with policy issues presents a valuable opportunity to inform evidence-based policy processes in the era of “cliquepolitik,” despite the challenges posed by its often “rebellious” and “messy” nature. Gap: However, there remains a gap in the attention given by policy scholars and researchers to conceptualising the features of policy-related hashtag activism, as well as in exploring how the data derived from it can be effectively applied as evidence for practical policy development. Aim: The main objective of this paper is to demonstrate how the rebellious and messy discourse within hashtag activism can serve as a potential form of evidence for policy process. Method: In achieving so, this study analysed hashtag of the year 2020 “#GagalkanOmnibusLaw” (‘FailTheOmnibusLaw’) on Twitter (now “X”), which was formed by digital counterpublics during the formulation of controversial Job Creation Bill in Indonesia. A total of 14,191 tweets containing 189,175 words were successfully collected. Based on the postpositivist paradigm and Fischer’s “argumentative turn”, this study applies corpus-assisted discourse analysis by integrating corpus linguistics (CL) with the dialectical-relational approach to critical discourse analysis (CDA). Key findings: The application of the methods resulted in a “structured discourse” that was categorised into four types: relational, substantial, normative, and procedural. Relational discourse reveals the power dynamics between policy actors (government, oligarch, and labour). Substantial discourse highlights the objections of digital counterpublics to specific points within the policy. Normative discourse uncovers the underlying motives behind the policy’s formation. Procedural discourse exposes the unfair decision-making processes involved. Discussions: This study presents at least three implications worthy of discussion. First, based on the assumption that a hashtag is not merely a “medium” but rather an “actor” in itself, this study proposes that a hashtag can act as an “agent of policy problematisation,” with unstructured and contentious characteristics that often leading to dissent. Second, drawing on Hendriks’ concept of a “mixed discursive sphere”, this study proposes the role of the policy analyst as a “structuring agent,” bridging the digital counterpublics sphere (with its messy and contentious nature) and the administrative sphere (which is rational and technocratic). Third, based on the researcher’s experience in analysing the data for this study, it is proposed that the synergy of corpus linguistics (CL) and critical discourse analysis (CDA) be employed by policy analysts to structure the messy discourse of hashtag activism, positioning the hashtag as credible evidence to inform the policy process.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper discusses the recent European regulatory developments affecting commercial advertising disseminated via linear audiovisual programs, video-sharing platforms, and social networks, shedding light on the effects of public policy on marketing and consumer protection. It provides a general assessment of the Directives included in the Digital Services Act package—the Audiovisual Media Services Directive, the Digital Services Act, and the Digital Markets Act—looking at the new set of rules and provisions applicable to audiovisual media services providers, video-on-demand, video-sharing, and large online platforms, ensuring enhanced protection of minors from harmful content, redefining the limits of commercial communications, and increasing the protection of consumer data by prohibiting the usage of personal data of children for commercial purposes, like direct marketing, profiling, or behaviorally targeted advertising. Based on a qualitative analysis, the study maps out the specific rules and obligations introduced by the Digital Services Act package. Data is taken from multiple publicly available sources, such as central government information, ministerial data, and regional agencies. This preliminary study provides several insights, contributing to recent research on regulatory developments at the EU level.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The aim of this article is to analyse the bidirectional relationship between digital public governance and corruption, with a view to filling three gaps in the literature. First of all, studies have mainly focused on a unidirectional relationship. However, the facts show that a number of developing countries are finding it difficult to mitigate the level of corruption and keep up with the prospects for digitalisation, despite the digital transition. Furthermore, digitalisation has perverse effects on the operational and governing nature of government, which may lead decision-makers to limit its implementation on the basis of digital sovereignty. Governments may also lose rents through the digitisation of procedures such as procurement and spending processes. To this end, public decision-makers can put the brakes on the digitisation process. Next, we test the importance of democracy on the two-way relationship. We find that the least corrupt countries are the most democratic. Moreover, countries and democrats can be more successful in the process of implementing digital governance than those that are hybrid or outright authoritarian. Finally, we are working on DCs in three regions and will carry out evaluations by sub-block.
The study method is a causality test of Dumitrescu & Hurlin. The results indicate a bidirectional relationship between corruption and the development of digital governance in developing countries. Indeed, corruption negatively affects the development of digital governance and digital governance negatively affects governance. These results are in line with the orthodox thesis that corruption is ‘a grain of sand in the wheel’. We also find that the level of democracy affects the results obtained. For countries with weak democracies, corruption unilaterally affects the level of digitalisation of public procedures. The poor quality of institutions in developing countries with weak democracies means that public decision-makers are unable to limit the level of corruption in both public and private sector economies.
In the light of the various results obtained, we can recommend that public institutions in developing countries develop digital governance systems to mitigate the risk of corruption and ensure that the modernisation of public institutions progresses. Less democratic countries need to put in place political systems that make it possible to assess the public decision-makers in place and the dynamics of public sector reforms. To limit the influence of corruption on the digitalisation of public governance, public decision-makers can increase civil servants' incomes and grant compliance bonuses to motivate them to replace corruption. Nonetheless, quality assurance of institutions in developing countries remains relevant in order to capture the benefits of digital governance and use them as strategic weapons as in developed countries. As a limitation of the research, we have not taken into account the mediation of democracy on the relationship between corruption and the digitalisation of public governance. Bidirectional studies on corruption and public phenomena must take into account the level of democracy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Climate change is posing an enormous challenge to socio-economic and environmental wellbeing, globally. The Climate Risk Index statistics shows that Nepal falls under the ten most affected countries in the world. Prioritization of media stories through front page coverage using big-size images, cartoons, and provocative headlines makes a significant difference on how incidents are perceived and re-prioritized. When social media platforms deliberately prioritize a particular incident, it results in agenda-setting or otherwise public debates will be centered around only particular perspective.
Though the role of social media in climate change messaging has been understood in academic and public spheres, limited studies have been conducted and published, especially in the context of Nepal. Most of the coverage has been confined to direct association with rapid onset of disaster and less attention towards whether and how sustainable energy utilization can be promoted.
A qualitative study was conducted following in-depth review of the social media posts and audience interactions using Critical Discourse Analysis method. Likewise, key informant interview and focus group discussion tools were also used to understand the coverage frequency and pattern, document perspectives of the media professionals and journalists.
Study findings highlight social media interventions focus on behavior change communication than media advocacy; lack of innovation scope in funded media projects; absence of empirical research on processes of depoliticization regarding climate change in public and media discourses; lack of ideological analysis of climate change coverage; lack of proper distinction on journalistic take on climate change as incidental event or structural development. The study recommends for comprehensive study of social media interactions on climate change in Nepal particularly through framing and factor analysis to identify reasons and incentives for certain media coverage trends when it comes to covering climate change.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper aims to analyze social media as a form of relay in the formulation of the microbe problem in the city of Douala, Cameroon. Microbes, which appeared in Cameroon's economic capital in late November 2022, are considered to be a gang made up of young, often under-age males armed with machetes, knives, axes and gourds. At nightfall, they attack men and women, taking phones and money as they go, and beating, wounding and sometimes killing those who resist. Such was the case of their recent attack on a drinking establishment in the city of palms district on October 6, 2024, exposing the population to all kinds of physical and mental harm. Faced with the recurrence of this gang's violent practices and the chaos left in the public space, the people of Douala have taken to social media to draw the attention of government authorities. Facebook, Instagram, twitter and many others were used as relays, with the aim of making this phenomenon a public problem and getting it on the government's agenda. A fact that has been observed by the popularization of the practices of this gang through various videos and images sometimes amateur. As a result, public action has been taken. Fifteen fixed surveillance points have been set up in high-risk neighborhoods. It's fair to say, then, that social media, which have long been seen as a weave of diverse actors and interests, have reinvented themselves. What role do social media play in formulating microbes as a public problem in Douala? To answer this question, this study will be based on interviews and a collection of
accounts from key players in the digital field, as well as Internet users who have closely followed the popularization of the rise of this gang on social media.
Keywords: Public action, social networks, relays, microbes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The paper explores a centralized system that ensures the processing of opinions and claims against regional and municipal officials expressed by citizens in social media, which began in 2020 in Russia. Previous authors’ studies of Russian systems that ensure the interaction of authorities with citizens made it possible to identify six channels of electronic participation at the regional and municipal levels. However, the development of social media and the emergence of new technologies for involving citizens in public politics have created the prerequisites for the transformation of electronic participation systems. This was reflected both in scientific research and in practice. For example, in the Russian Federation in 2020 a new channel of electronic participation was launched. A network of Regional Control Centers (RCCs) has been created and is being developed, one of the components of which is the Incident Management system, which allows real-time monitoring of the reaction of users in social media and ensuring the processing of messages or claims of citizens to the authorities as well as responding to citizens via social media. The paper presents the results of a pilot study that made it possible to identify the heterogeneity of new structures in terms of institutional affiliation and data from monitoring e-participation channels in the context of centralization processes. The authors as a part of research team of e-Governance Center at ITMO University carried out the tree stages of e-participation monitoring in Russia carried out in 2020, 2021 and 2022. The basic methodology and tools of the monitoring study have not undergone significant changes, which makes it possible to compare the results over time. The channels of e-participation of citizens created by the regional authorities and local governments were identified and evaluated according to 15 indicators, divided into 5 logical blocks. Six types of channels were considered: Open Budgeting, Proactive Budgeting, Problem Reporting, E-Initiatives, E-voting, and Crowdsourcing. The monitoring results showed a significant reduction of e-participation channels created and maintained at the initiative of the executive bodies of regions and municipalities, which indicates the strengthening of centralization trends. Moreover, we provide a bibliometric analysis of e-participation research in order to reveal publication patterns and trends. The main findings are as follows. First, starting from 2020, the e-participation system in Russia is being transformed. New channels of interaction with citizens are being developed (a centralized feedback platform, etc., which are provided as part of the functioning of the RCC system, which in some cases causes duplication of channels at the regional level). Second, we can see three stages of e-participation evolution in Russia: initiative-public (2010-2012), initiative-regional (2012–2020), centralized-federal (from 2020). Third, the success of solving the problems of integrating digital resources of electronic participation largely depends on the powers of the vice-governors - curators of the RCCs in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Relevance of the paper
As social media usage has spread worldwide, interactions between stakeholders and government have become multidimensional, moving beyond traditional models of ‘government-to-citizen’ (G2C) and ‘citizen-to-government’ (C2G). This shift has led to the emergence of various models, such as network governance, which promote co-creation among different stakeholders (Ly & Ly, 2023). Studies have found that government-citizen interactions through social media help build trust, encourage citizen participation, shape usage attitudes, and improve information quality between the government and citizens in e-government development. This study develops a theoretical model of social presence on online social networks and its role in the context of e-government intention to examine empirically. Simultaneously, we integrated two mediators: citizen engagement and trust in government. This model examines the interconnections of both direct and indirect effects of social presence, online social network usage, and e-government intention among municipal users, highlighting the role of these two mediators
Research purpose
This research highlights the growing importance of digital platforms in citizen engagement, particularly through social media. Few studies have examined whether citizen-to-citizen interaction through online social spaces impacts citizen engagement. We argue that studies need to examine how citizen-to-citizen interactions among themselves through various social networks impact trust in government and citizen engagement, ultimately affecting the intention to use e-government. This study conceptualizes citizen engagement as citizens' active participation and interaction through online social networks, where they share resources, participate electronically, and assist each other in accessing quality e-government services. The intensity of social presence influences warmth, sociability, personalization, and sensitivity in their communications. Interestingly, we found no significant literature on online social presence in the context of e-government.
Methodology
This study employed a questionnaire-based survey method conducted among 590 urban e-government users. Structural equation modeling using AMOS was employed to test the theoretical model. The study performed a confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) and assessed the reliability, discriminant, and convergent validity of the constructs. Then the study explored the relationship through structural models. The study employed age, gender, education, employment, and income as control variables and examined the effect by linking them to all endogenous variables.
Findings
We uncovered several significant findings contributing to both theory and policy in e-government development. While previous studies have shown a positive relationship between government social media usage and e-government development, our study reveals that merely using social networks among citizens does not necessarily lead to adopting e-government in practice. Instead, we found that social presence on social media has a much stronger positive effect on e-government usage. Additionally, our findings highlight the mediating roles of citizen engagement and trust in government, which bridge the relationship between social network usage, social presence, and e-government adoption.
References
Ly, B., & Ly, R. (2023). Emerging trends in social media for E-governance and citizen engagement: A case study of Telegram in Cambodia. Computers in Human Behavior Reports.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Social media has evolved into a central force in handling national and local crises. This prompts the question: Do all stakeholders in a local crisis grasp its significance when it predominantly unfolds in the digital realm of online social media? This article investigates this issue through a case study of the Roman Zadorov justice movement in Israel. Despite Zadorov's wrongful imprisonment for Tair Rada's murder, social media support grew, reshaping perceptions of Katsrin, the town where the murder took place. The four-fold analysis draws on social media content, youth interviews, municipal officials' perspectives, and a population survey. It reveals how Tair Rada's case became central to Katsrin's image, fueled by social media's influence. However, local officials failed to recognize social media's crisis significance, highlighting a disconnect. The article concludes by exploring this dissonance, shedding light on crisis management challenges in the social media era and their impact on local governance.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
ROLE OF MEDIA IN POLICY EDUCATION
NAYAH GAZELLE ABANG
(Senior lecturer)
gazelle5000@yahoo.com
The University of Maroua
Faculty of Law and Political Sciences
Department of Political Sciences
ABSTRACT
Most of the studies on democracy in Africa specifically and generally reveals that at the dawn of independence, 1980-1990 being the period of democratization, In the CEMAC (Economic and Monetary Community of Central Africa) sub-region, several countries have grappled with domestic conflicts, affecting peace, stability, and economic development. Within the CEMAC sub-region, and specifically in Cameroon, different measures have been used such as multipartism, regular elections yet democratic practices still remain questionable. This study therefore examines the influence of media on policy education in Cameroon, focusing on how media platforms educates the public about policy issues and the implications for democratic participation. Through a mixed-methods approach, including surveys, interviews, and content analysis, the research explores the effectiveness of various media channels, such as television, radio, newspapers, and social media, in disseminating policy-related information. The findings suggest that while traditional media remains a significant source of policy education, social media platforms are increasingly playing a crucial role in engaging younger audiences and fostering interactive discussions. The study highlights the challenges faced by media in maintaining accuracy and impartiality in policy reporting and recommends strategies for enhancing media's role in policy education to promote informed citizen participation in the democratic process.
Keywords: Media, policy, public policy, policy education, democracy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Background: Hashtag activism has emerged as a global phenomenon within digital public discourse, extending its influence to the realm of public policy. Given the wealth of data it generates, understanding the characteristics of hashtag activism that engages with policy issues presents a valuable opportunity to inform evidence-based policy processes in the era of “cliquepolitik,” despite the challenges posed by its often “rebellious” and “messy” nature. Gap: However, there remains a gap in the attention given by policy scholars and researchers to conceptualising the features of policy-related hashtag activism, as well as in exploring how the data derived from it can be effectively applied as evidence for practical policy development. Aim: The main objective of this paper is to demonstrate how the rebellious and messy discourse within hashtag activism can serve as a potential form of evidence for policy process. Method: In achieving so, this study analysed hashtag of the year 2020 “#GagalkanOmnibusLaw” (‘FailTheOmnibusLaw’) on Twitter (now “X”), which was formed by digital counterpublics during the formulation of controversial Job Creation Bill in Indonesia. A total of 14,191 tweets containing 189,175 words were successfully collected. Based on the postpositivist paradigm and Fischer’s “argumentative turn”, this study applies corpus-assisted discourse analysis by integrating corpus linguistics (CL) with the dialectical-relational approach to critical discourse analysis (CDA). Key findings: The application of the methods resulted in a “structured discourse” that was categorised into four types: relational, substantial, normative, and procedural. Relational discourse reveals the power dynamics between policy actors (government, oligarch, and labour). Substantial discourse highlights the objections of digital counterpublics to specific points within the policy. Normative discourse uncovers the underlying motives behind the policy’s formation. Procedural discourse exposes the unfair decision-making processes involved. Discussions: This study presents at least three implications worthy of discussion. First, based on the assumption that a hashtag is not merely a “medium” but rather an “actor” in itself, this study proposes that a hashtag can act as an “agent of policy problematisation,” with unstructured and contentious characteristics that often leading to dissent. Second, drawing on Hendriks’ concept of a “mixed discursive sphere”, this study proposes the role of the policy analyst as a “structuring agent,” bridging the digital counterpublics sphere (with its messy and contentious nature) and the administrative sphere (which is rational and technocratic). Third, based on the researcher’s experience in analysing the data for this study, it is proposed that the synergy of corpus linguistics (CL) and critical discourse analysis (CDA) be employed by policy analysts to structure the messy discourse of hashtag activism, positioning the hashtag as credible evidence to inform the policy process.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)