P07. The Impact of Public Policy on Political Participation: Comparing Evidence from around the World
POLICY, POLITICS AND POLITICAL REGIMECATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
How does public policy shape the political participation of those most affected by its implementation? We know that policy can often have feedback effects through which individuals may be motivated to advocate for the continuation, modification, or cancellation of the policy based on its effect on their lives. But we have very little evidence from around the world about what kinds of policies tend to motivate or depress participation towards other claims and how individuals choose to get involved in various contexts. This panel seeks to bring together researchers from diverse parts of the world to foster a comparative discussion on the effects of public policies on politics to enhance our understanding of the factors that generate participation, particularly among those who are the direct targets or beneficiaries of policies.
The concept of policy feedback gained traction in the 1980’s and 90’s as part of the wave to situate policy making and politics within the framework of historical institutionalism (Pierson 1993; 1994; Skocpol 1992; Weir, Orloff and Skocpol 1988). This framework brought in the dimension of time and how policies reshape politics, and then in turn politics reshape policies (Béland and Schlager 2019; Mettler and SoRelle 2014). The question of how policies impact the politics of beneficiaries has then been explored by a number of scholars in the United States (for example, Soss and Schram 2007; Mettler 2002, 2005; Campbell 2002, 2003, 2012) who find that the direction of attitudes and participation is very much conditioned by the type of policy. More recently research has expanded in a comparative direction, though like the United States more work is needed to identify how different types of policies shape political participation across diverse contexts.
The genesis for this panel comes not only from this previous literature but from the chair’s research on how social programs shape the empowerment of beneficiaries to make further claims of the state across the Global North and South. The direction of the effects of policy on political participation are particularly important for social policies meant to reduce inequalities, contribute to poverty alleviation, and rectify structural discrimination. We want to know whether social policies are achieving the outcomes they are meant to produce. In other recent research, scholars have asked whether conditional cash transfer programs engender political loyalty to those most responsible for implementing the policy and under what circumstances that loyalty endures.
In this panel we seek additional examples of research on political preferences as well as the range of behavior from active claims-making to greater alienation that may result from the implementation of diverse social policies, in particular. However, other types of policy also have political effects, such as those involving climate change, immigration, and economic development and these papers are also quite welcome. For example, how might development policies that aim to prevent flooding shape the politics of those most directly at risk? Empirical evidence is needed to understand the broad political effects of such policies and the aim of this panel is to bring scholars together to further this effort.
For this panel I hope to bring together scholars of various thematic, academic, methodological, and geographic orientations. The call for papers is open to anyone who would like to contribute to our knowledge of the feedback effects of public policy on individuals’ political preferences and engagement. Both in-person and virtual participation are welcome. Papers may explore issues areas including, but not limited to: housing, conditional cash transfers, climate change, immigration, healthcare, education, transportation, and infrastructure. All papers should reflect evidence-based research.
References:
Béland, D., Schlager, E., 2019. Varieties of Policy Feedback Research: Looking Backward,
Moving Forward. Policy Studies Journal 47, 184–205.
Campbell, Andrea Louise. 2002. “Self-Interest, Social Security, and the Distinctive
Participation Patterns of Senior Citizens.” American Political Science Review 96 (3): 565–74.
. 2003. How Policies Make Citizens: Senior Political Activism and the American
Welfare State. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
. 2012. “Policy Makes Mass Politics.” Annual Review of Political Science 15: 331
51.
Mettler, Suzanne. 2005. Soldiers to Citizens: The G.I. Bill and the Making of the Greatest Generation. New York: Oxford University Press.
. 2002. “Bringing the State Back In to Civic Engagement: Policy Feedback Effects of
the G.I. Bill for World War II Veterans.” American Political Science Review 96 (2): 351–65.
Mettler, Suzanne, and Mallory SoRelle. 2014. “Policy Feedback.” In Theories of the Policy
Process, 3rd ed., ed. Paul A. Sabatier, and Christopher M. Weible. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 151–81.
Pierson, Paul. 1993. “When Effect Becomes Cause: Policy Feedback and Political Change.”
World Politics 45 (4): 595–628.
. 1994. Dismantling the Welfare State? Reagan, Thatcher, and the Politics of
Retrenchment. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Skocpol, Theda. 1992. Protecting Soldiers and Mothers: The Political Origins of Social Policy
in the United States. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press.
Soss, Joe, and Sanford F. Schram. 2007. “A Public Transformed? Welfare Reform as Policy
Feedback.” American Political Science Review 101 (1): 111–27.
Weir, Margaret, Ann Shola Orloff, and Theda Skocpol. 1988. “Introduction: Understanding
American Social Politics.” In The Politics of Social Policy in the United States, ed. Margaret Weir, Ann Shola Orloff, and Theda Skocpol. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1–36.
CALL FOR PAPERS
For this panel I hope to bring together scholars of various thematic, academic, methodological, and geographic orientations. The call for papers is open to anyone who would like to contribute to our knowledge of the feedback effects of public policy on individuals’ political preferences and engagement. Both in-person and virtual participation are welcome. Papers may explore issues areas including, but not limited to: housing, conditional cash transfers, climate change, immigration, healthcare, education, transportation, and infrastructure. All papers should reflect evidence-based research.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
ABSTRACT
CITIZENS’ AWARENESS AND DISSEMINATION OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNIT (LGU) PROCESSES IN GENERAL SANTOS CITY. This study investigates citizens' awareness of Local Government Unit (LGU) processes and the extent of their dissemination in General Santos City. The primary objective is to identify gaps in citizen awareness and uncover challenges in disseminating LGU processes. Specifically, the research aims to assess the current level of citizen awareness across various barangays, determine the extent of LGU process dissemination, and propose recommendations for improving awareness and dissemination efforts. A descriptive correlational research design was utilized, employing quantitative methods to gather data from 390 randomly selected respondents across 26 barangays. Data were collected through structured questionnaires using a 5-point Likert scale to measure awareness levels and a 4-point Likert scale to assess the extent of dissemination. The findings revealed high overall awareness of basic services and facilities, land management and rights, and revenue generation. The effectiveness of disseminating LGU processes to citizens was rated as moderately high. Significant positive correlations were identified between the extent of dissemination and citizen awareness, with strong correlations for basic services and facilities, and moderate correlations for land reclassification and revenue generation. The study concludes that enhancing citizen awareness through more effective dissemination of LGU processes is crucial for fostering informed and engaged communities. Recommendations include adopting targeted, community-specific, and technology-driven communication strategies to bridge the awareness gap, thereby promoting transparency, accountability, and active citizen participation in local governance. These improvements are essential for more effective and responsive governance in General Santos City.
Keywords: Citizen Awareness, LGU Processes, Dissemination, Local Governance, Public Participation, Community Engagement, Transparency, Accountability.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Non-institutional political participation (NiPP) is rising in Southern Europe. Self-rated health, age and levels of education have been regarded as relevant predictors for political participation. There are studies evidencing that young people who have poorer health tend to participate more in non-traditional forms of political participation (NiPP) and that education produces a social stratification of emerging forms of political participation. However, the impact of factors like age and education on the relationship between health and political participation remains underexplored. This study examined how age and education moderate the relationship between subjective general health (SGH) and NiPP in Southern Europe. A sample of 8,995 participants from the European Social Survey (wave 10) in Portugal, Spain, Italy, and Greece was analysed. A regression analysis was applied to explore the relationship between SGH and NiPP and two moderation models were utilized to understand the role of age and years of education in moderating the relationship between the SGH and the NIPP.
Results showed that as SGH increases, the likelihood of NiPP decreases. Both age and education moderated this relationship. For younger individuals and those with higher education, increased SGH led to reduced NiPP. Conversely, for older individuals and those with lower education, the decline in NiPP participation was less pronounced as SGH increased. Future research should focus on specific modes of participation and specific health conditions and investigate whether age and education continue to moderate NiPP involvement.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
India, the world's largest democracy, has always been known for its vibrant and complex electoral system. With elections at various levels of government occurring frequently, the idea of ‘One Nation, One Election’ (ONOE) has been a topic of discussion and debate for quite some time. This proposal aims to synchronize all elections in the country to be held simultaneously, thereby revolutionizing India's electoral landscape. Recent establishment of high-level committee under chairmanship of former president Ramnath Kovind has given more deliberation points on the topic. In this chapter we will delve into the concept of One Nation, One Election, its advantages and its broader concerns by analysing state assembly elections and general (Loksabha) election data post 2019.
The One Nation, One Election proposal suggests holding all elections in India—whether for the Lok Sabha (the lower house of parliament), state assemblies, or local bodies—simultaneously at regular intervals, typically once every five years. This would mean that citizens would cast their votes for all levels of government on a single election day. The idea is to reduce the frequency of elections and streamline the electoral process, leading to potential benefits for both the government and the electorate.
Emergence of idea for electioneering efficacy
Proponents of the ‘one nation one election’ have given various rationales. One of the major arguments in favour of ONOE is it would reduce in election cost, including security arrangements, manpower, and logistics. Next bigger argument is, continuous elections across the states disrupt normal governance and economic activities. Model code of conduct prevents rolling out of new schemes. Hence one nation one election could reduce administration pause time. ONOE also could promote political stability by providing governments with longer terms in office. This may allow elected representatives more time to focus on policy implementation rather than continuous election campaigning. (India 2015) However the proposal is not uncontested one and it hovers around various challenges.
Challenges and Concerns of one nation one election proposal
There are philosophical, federal, administrative and constitutional challenges in implementation of the proposal of ‘one nation one election’. One of the foremost issues is the potential erosion of federalism, as simultaneous elections could centralize power and undermine the autonomy of state governments. Critics argue that this might overshadow state-level concerns with national ones. This concern can be well highlighted through the data analysis through Pearson corelation coefficient and scatter plot analysis.
Political unawareness about federal structure and monolith political outcome
Powers and functions of Union and States have well distributed in our constitution in the seventh schedule. Subjects such as banking, insurance, railways, international affairs, defence are listed in Union List where Parliament has power to make laws. Whereas subjects such as law & order, public health, agriculture, fisheries, theatres, etc. are elaborated in State List where only state legislatures can make laws. Moreover, some subjects are mentioned in Concurrent List where parliament and state legislature both can make laws, such as forest and environment, education, labour, etc.
The distinguishments between the roles of centre and states are not understood by the common citizens fully, which tend to result in voting for a party than for an issue and constitutional position. This can be understood with the analysis of following data.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This study assessed citizen participation in social accountability mechanisms within the Ngqushwa Local Municipality using Arnstein’s Ladder of Participation as a theoretical lens. This study uses a qualitative research design, incorporating structured interviews with 12 participants from Ngqushwa Local Municipality and data analysed thematically. The findings indicate that citizen participation is largely tokenistic, characterised by low levels of engagement and a significant disconnect between citizen involvement and actual municipal decision-making. Specifically, citizen participation mostly occurs in the lower rung of Arnstein’s ladder (tokenism), such as informing, consultation, and placation, reflecting a limited impact on policy and service delivery outcomes. The Municipality must move beyond mere token engagement and foster deliberative, transparent, and empowering processes in which citizens are not just informed but actively involved in shaping local policies and service delivery. This includes empowering ward committees, enhancing transparency in public meetings, and reforming participatory budgeting to ensure that public input is meaningfully integrated into final decisions. The research findings will inform the development of robust social accountability mechanisms, promoting a more profound and genuine form of citizen participation that is adaptable and applicable to other municipalities within and beyond South African borders.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Agropastoral Politics: How Climate Violence Affects Voting Behaviour in Nigeria
Climate change heavily impacts agrarian communities in Africa, leading to scarcity and conflicts. The loss of vegetation in Northern Nigeria has intensified violent clashes between farmers and Fulani herders migrating southward and encroaching into farmlands in Nigeria’s Middlebelt, in search of forage for their cattle. These conflicts, though well-documented, have an understudied impact on political behaviour. While Nigeria's federal elections have seen only one electoral turnover, states in the Middlebelt have experienced significantly more turnovers. I hypothesize that the states most affected by these climate-induced clashes witness closer elections and incumbent backlash due to voter dissatisfaction with local representatives over the farmer-herder clashes. Additionally, I posit that the electoral backlash is influenced by whether state governors are aligned with the central government: aligned governors face tighter races as they cannot deflect blame for security lapses and conflict escalation. Utilizing data from the Armed Conflict Location and Event Data Project (ACLED), I employ an instrumental variable approach to demonstrate how the loss of vegetation in Northern Nigeria engenders southward migration of herders and eventual clashes with farmers in the Middlebelt with electoral consequences. Overall, I aim to demonstrate the relationship between climate-induced violence and voting behaviour in Nigeria.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Abstract: For millions across Brazil, the first election of President Lula da Silva from the Workers’ Party (PT) promised to reshape the relationship between citizens and the state, bringing into decision making people who had long been marginalized, particularly by income and social class. Towards this objective, the administration ushered in numerous participatory institutions as well as innovations in social programs. Among these were experiments in resident-engaged housing projects for urbanization of informal settlements and construction of new units in cities across the country. The question for this paper is whether participation in these projects produced greater trust in governments and continued support for the PT among residents. Based on fieldwork in São Paulo in 2019 and 2022, I find the participatory design of housing projects provided residents with great pride and satisfaction. But the implementation of the policies often led to distrust in government when promises went unmet, funding stopped, and residents did not feel secure. After four years with virtually no new investments in housing, however, many residents returned to the PT and Lula with vigor.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In today’s polarized political climate, where trust in institutions is declining, traditional policy tools often fail to inspire broad public participation or address complex governance challenges. There is an urgent need for innovative policy approaches that can effectively mobilize collective action. This study addresses this gap by exploring the Moral Bank initiative in Yongfeng Village, Sichuan Province, China. The study is framed within a creative theoretical framework that classifies policy tools based on narrativity and interactivity—two key elements that can enhance citizen engagement. The central aim of this study is to demonstrate how policy tools, when enriched with compelling storytelling and engaging participation, can foster lasting civic involvement and reshape governance dynamics.
This study introduces a theoretical framework that combines narrative theory and political psychology theory. Narrativity involves embedding stories within policy tools that convey shared values and collective goals. These narratives evoke emotional responses and promote a sense of solidarity among citizens. Interactivity emphasizes citizen involvement in the policy process. Unlike the previous rigid models, interactive policy tools allow citizens to act as active players, as engaging as being in a game, rather than passive recipients. According to this framework, the moral bank is a typical policy tool with high narrativity and strong interactivity.
The Moral Bank initiative operates through a points-based reward system where villagers earn "moral points" for participating in activities like environmental conservation and local dispute resolution. These points can be exchanged for food, healthcare, and school supplies. What distinguishes the Moral Bank from traditional policy tools is its integration of compelling storytelling and engaging participation. The moral narratives of community duty and collective responsibility create a strong emotional connection to the policy, while the interactive aspect—where citizens actively engage with the system and benefit from their contributions—enhances their sense of ownership and investment in governance. This combination of narrativity and interactivity forms the basis of the policy's effectiveness in mobilizing civic engagement.
The results have successfully increased participation in projects like the “toilet revolution” to improve sanitation and local health initiatives. The moral bank has also fostered social trust and strengthened community cohesion through public recognition of virtuous actions and the reinforcement of positive social norms. The integration of honor and shame mechanisms, where citizens are publicly acknowledged for their good deeds and sanctioned for negative behavior, has created a cycle of sustained engagement and pro-social behavior.
In conclusion, this research emphasizes the significant role of narrativity and interactivity in shaping modern policy tools that engage citizens in promoting good governance. By embedding meaningful stories and facilitating active participation, policies can foster not only citizen engagement but also social cohesion and public trust. This study contributes to the theory of governance innovation by offering a robust framework for strategically designing policy tools that effectively address contemporary governance challenges.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In Mexico, mandate revocation was initially conceived as an instrument to legitimize government action and foster accountability, providing a direct means for citizens to evaluate the performance of the executive branch. This mechanism, as a tool for democratic oversight, has the potential to transform citizen participation and their relationship with the State.
The 2022 presidential recall exercise raised questions about its effects on political participation, especially on the interaction between the population and the government, as well as its impact on future decisions. This article examines the recall as a policy that affects citizen involvement, employing the concept of policy feedback to analyze its repercussions. The central research question is: Do recall referendums change the way citizens interact with their local governments and can they influence public policymaking?
The fact that the 2022 mandate revocation did not reach the 40% participation threshold raises fundamental questions about its ability to mobilize citizens and its implications for the legitimacy of subsequent government decisions. This article employs the process tracing method to trace the causal mechanisms linking the referendum to changes in political participation, citizen involvement in decision making, and the legitimacy of public policies. By focusing on feedback effects, it examines whether these mechanisms generate lasting transformations in political behavior or whether they only represent a temporary form of participation.
The study also assesses the potential implications for local governments, especially in light of recent electoral reforms that have opened up the possibility of implementing recall mechanisms at the subnational level. An example of this is that in Hidalgo, Mexico, by the end of 2025, such an exercise may be requested to evaluate the work of the Governor. We also analyze the broader impact of voting on citizen trust in government institutions and the programs they implement.
Finally, this article aim to contribute to the growing literature on policy feedback by examining how the implementation of mandate revocation in Mexico shapes political attitudes, voting behavior, and turnout at both the national and local levels. Through empirical evidence and comparative analysis, we assess the potential of these mechanisms to strengthen a more participatory democratic system.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Today, the term “Smart City” has emerged as a catchphrase in the mission and vision of many countries, especially in developing countries such as those in the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries, including Dubai and Kuwait. While public political engagement is one of the smart city initiatives, the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) aspect is mostly emphasized in smart city discourses. This paper examines the role of public participation in decision-making as an important yet neglected initiative of the smart city concept. It also explores how the Kafala (sponsorship) system in Dubai and Kuwait City has influenced the political engagement of expatriates, who comprise four-fifths of these countries' population, during the COVID-19 era, as a critical period to assess the policy. Grounded in the policy feedback literature, the study investigates how this labor governance framework shaped expatriates' political discourse, indifference, and stagnation in claims-making during the pandemic.
Research Question: How did the Kafala sponsorship system affect expatriates' political engagement and discourse within the framework of policy feedback effects in Dubai and Kuwait City during COVID-19?
Methodology:
Social network analysis of Twitter discourse to examine patterns of engagement and disengagement.
Analysis of policy documents, government reports, and sponsorship regulations.
Findings and Contribution: This study enhances the overall understanding of how labor governance policies influence political engagement in non-Western contexts, particularly in Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries. Preliminary findings indicate that while digital platforms have created spaces for expatriate discussions, the restrictive nature of the Kafala system has reinforced patterns of exclusion, dependency, and suppressed political claims-making among expatriate workers. Even the Diwaniyas in Kuwait, as a public sphere, could not foster expatriates' political engagement or empower civil society as effectively as in Dubai. This paper underscores how governance structures shape both political engagement and disengagement by situating the Kafala system within the policy feedback framework.
The findings will provide comparative insights into how labor policies influence political outcomes in Kuwait and Dubai, especially in relation to historical institutionalism and policy feedback theories.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
ABSTRACT
CITIZENS’ AWARENESS AND DISSEMINATION OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNIT (LGU) PROCESSES IN GENERAL SANTOS CITY. This study investigates citizens' awareness of Local Government Unit (LGU) processes and the extent of their dissemination in General Santos City. The primary objective is to identify gaps in citizen awareness and uncover challenges in disseminating LGU processes. Specifically, the research aims to assess the current level of citizen awareness across various barangays, determine the extent of LGU process dissemination, and propose recommendations for improving awareness and dissemination efforts. A descriptive correlational research design was utilized, employing quantitative methods to gather data from 390 randomly selected respondents across 26 barangays. Data were collected through structured questionnaires using a 5-point Likert scale to measure awareness levels and a 4-point Likert scale to assess the extent of dissemination. The findings revealed high overall awareness of basic services and facilities, land management and rights, and revenue generation. The effectiveness of disseminating LGU processes to citizens was rated as moderately high. Significant positive correlations were identified between the extent of dissemination and citizen awareness, with strong correlations for basic services and facilities, and moderate correlations for land reclassification and revenue generation. The study concludes that enhancing citizen awareness through more effective dissemination of LGU processes is crucial for fostering informed and engaged communities. Recommendations include adopting targeted, community-specific, and technology-driven communication strategies to bridge the awareness gap, thereby promoting transparency, accountability, and active citizen participation in local governance. These improvements are essential for more effective and responsive governance in General Santos City.
Keywords: Citizen Awareness, LGU Processes, Dissemination, Local Governance, Public Participation, Community Engagement, Transparency, Accountability.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Non-institutional political participation (NiPP) is rising in Southern Europe. Self-rated health, age and levels of education have been regarded as relevant predictors for political participation. There are studies evidencing that young people who have poorer health tend to participate more in non-traditional forms of political participation (NiPP) and that education produces a social stratification of emerging forms of political participation. However, the impact of factors like age and education on the relationship between health and political participation remains underexplored. This study examined how age and education moderate the relationship between subjective general health (SGH) and NiPP in Southern Europe. A sample of 8,995 participants from the European Social Survey (wave 10) in Portugal, Spain, Italy, and Greece was analysed. A regression analysis was applied to explore the relationship between SGH and NiPP and two moderation models were utilized to understand the role of age and years of education in moderating the relationship between the SGH and the NIPP.
Results showed that as SGH increases, the likelihood of NiPP decreases. Both age and education moderated this relationship. For younger individuals and those with higher education, increased SGH led to reduced NiPP. Conversely, for older individuals and those with lower education, the decline in NiPP participation was less pronounced as SGH increased. Future research should focus on specific modes of participation and specific health conditions and investigate whether age and education continue to moderate NiPP involvement.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
India, the world's largest democracy, has always been known for its vibrant and complex electoral system. With elections at various levels of government occurring frequently, the idea of ‘One Nation, One Election’ (ONOE) has been a topic of discussion and debate for quite some time. This proposal aims to synchronize all elections in the country to be held simultaneously, thereby revolutionizing India's electoral landscape. Recent establishment of high-level committee under chairmanship of former president Ramnath Kovind has given more deliberation points on the topic. In this chapter we will delve into the concept of One Nation, One Election, its advantages and its broader concerns by analysing state assembly elections and general (Loksabha) election data post 2019.
The One Nation, One Election proposal suggests holding all elections in India—whether for the Lok Sabha (the lower house of parliament), state assemblies, or local bodies—simultaneously at regular intervals, typically once every five years. This would mean that citizens would cast their votes for all levels of government on a single election day. The idea is to reduce the frequency of elections and streamline the electoral process, leading to potential benefits for both the government and the electorate.
Emergence of idea for electioneering efficacy
Proponents of the ‘one nation one election’ have given various rationales. One of the major arguments in favour of ONOE is it would reduce in election cost, including security arrangements, manpower, and logistics. Next bigger argument is, continuous elections across the states disrupt normal governance and economic activities. Model code of conduct prevents rolling out of new schemes. Hence one nation one election could reduce administration pause time. ONOE also could promote political stability by providing governments with longer terms in office. This may allow elected representatives more time to focus on policy implementation rather than continuous election campaigning. (India 2015) However the proposal is not uncontested one and it hovers around various challenges.
Challenges and Concerns of one nation one election proposal
There are philosophical, federal, administrative and constitutional challenges in implementation of the proposal of ‘one nation one election’. One of the foremost issues is the potential erosion of federalism, as simultaneous elections could centralize power and undermine the autonomy of state governments. Critics argue that this might overshadow state-level concerns with national ones. This concern can be well highlighted through the data analysis through Pearson corelation coefficient and scatter plot analysis.
Political unawareness about federal structure and monolith political outcome
Powers and functions of Union and States have well distributed in our constitution in the seventh schedule. Subjects such as banking, insurance, railways, international affairs, defence are listed in Union List where Parliament has power to make laws. Whereas subjects such as law & order, public health, agriculture, fisheries, theatres, etc. are elaborated in State List where only state legislatures can make laws. Moreover, some subjects are mentioned in Concurrent List where parliament and state legislature both can make laws, such as forest and environment, education, labour, etc.
The distinguishments between the roles of centre and states are not understood by the common citizens fully, which tend to result in voting for a party than for an issue and constitutional position. This can be understood with the analysis of following data.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This study assessed citizen participation in social accountability mechanisms within the Ngqushwa Local Municipality using Arnstein’s Ladder of Participation as a theoretical lens. This study uses a qualitative research design, incorporating structured interviews with 12 participants from Ngqushwa Local Municipality and data analysed thematically. The findings indicate that citizen participation is largely tokenistic, characterised by low levels of engagement and a significant disconnect between citizen involvement and actual municipal decision-making. Specifically, citizen participation mostly occurs in the lower rung of Arnstein’s ladder (tokenism), such as informing, consultation, and placation, reflecting a limited impact on policy and service delivery outcomes. The Municipality must move beyond mere token engagement and foster deliberative, transparent, and empowering processes in which citizens are not just informed but actively involved in shaping local policies and service delivery. This includes empowering ward committees, enhancing transparency in public meetings, and reforming participatory budgeting to ensure that public input is meaningfully integrated into final decisions. The research findings will inform the development of robust social accountability mechanisms, promoting a more profound and genuine form of citizen participation that is adaptable and applicable to other municipalities within and beyond South African borders.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Agropastoral Politics: How Climate Violence Affects Voting Behaviour in Nigeria
Climate change heavily impacts agrarian communities in Africa, leading to scarcity and conflicts. The loss of vegetation in Northern Nigeria has intensified violent clashes between farmers and Fulani herders migrating southward and encroaching into farmlands in Nigeria’s Middlebelt, in search of forage for their cattle. These conflicts, though well-documented, have an understudied impact on political behaviour. While Nigeria's federal elections have seen only one electoral turnover, states in the Middlebelt have experienced significantly more turnovers. I hypothesize that the states most affected by these climate-induced clashes witness closer elections and incumbent backlash due to voter dissatisfaction with local representatives over the farmer-herder clashes. Additionally, I posit that the electoral backlash is influenced by whether state governors are aligned with the central government: aligned governors face tighter races as they cannot deflect blame for security lapses and conflict escalation. Utilizing data from the Armed Conflict Location and Event Data Project (ACLED), I employ an instrumental variable approach to demonstrate how the loss of vegetation in Northern Nigeria engenders southward migration of herders and eventual clashes with farmers in the Middlebelt with electoral consequences. Overall, I aim to demonstrate the relationship between climate-induced violence and voting behaviour in Nigeria.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Abstract: For millions across Brazil, the first election of President Lula da Silva from the Workers’ Party (PT) promised to reshape the relationship between citizens and the state, bringing into decision making people who had long been marginalized, particularly by income and social class. Towards this objective, the administration ushered in numerous participatory institutions as well as innovations in social programs. Among these were experiments in resident-engaged housing projects for urbanization of informal settlements and construction of new units in cities across the country. The question for this paper is whether participation in these projects produced greater trust in governments and continued support for the PT among residents. Based on fieldwork in São Paulo in 2019 and 2022, I find the participatory design of housing projects provided residents with great pride and satisfaction. But the implementation of the policies often led to distrust in government when promises went unmet, funding stopped, and residents did not feel secure. After four years with virtually no new investments in housing, however, many residents returned to the PT and Lula with vigor.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In today’s polarized political climate, where trust in institutions is declining, traditional policy tools often fail to inspire broad public participation or address complex governance challenges. There is an urgent need for innovative policy approaches that can effectively mobilize collective action. This study addresses this gap by exploring the Moral Bank initiative in Yongfeng Village, Sichuan Province, China. The study is framed within a creative theoretical framework that classifies policy tools based on narrativity and interactivity—two key elements that can enhance citizen engagement. The central aim of this study is to demonstrate how policy tools, when enriched with compelling storytelling and engaging participation, can foster lasting civic involvement and reshape governance dynamics.
This study introduces a theoretical framework that combines narrative theory and political psychology theory. Narrativity involves embedding stories within policy tools that convey shared values and collective goals. These narratives evoke emotional responses and promote a sense of solidarity among citizens. Interactivity emphasizes citizen involvement in the policy process. Unlike the previous rigid models, interactive policy tools allow citizens to act as active players, as engaging as being in a game, rather than passive recipients. According to this framework, the moral bank is a typical policy tool with high narrativity and strong interactivity.
The Moral Bank initiative operates through a points-based reward system where villagers earn "moral points" for participating in activities like environmental conservation and local dispute resolution. These points can be exchanged for food, healthcare, and school supplies. What distinguishes the Moral Bank from traditional policy tools is its integration of compelling storytelling and engaging participation. The moral narratives of community duty and collective responsibility create a strong emotional connection to the policy, while the interactive aspect—where citizens actively engage with the system and benefit from their contributions—enhances their sense of ownership and investment in governance. This combination of narrativity and interactivity forms the basis of the policy's effectiveness in mobilizing civic engagement.
The results have successfully increased participation in projects like the “toilet revolution” to improve sanitation and local health initiatives. The moral bank has also fostered social trust and strengthened community cohesion through public recognition of virtuous actions and the reinforcement of positive social norms. The integration of honor and shame mechanisms, where citizens are publicly acknowledged for their good deeds and sanctioned for negative behavior, has created a cycle of sustained engagement and pro-social behavior.
In conclusion, this research emphasizes the significant role of narrativity and interactivity in shaping modern policy tools that engage citizens in promoting good governance. By embedding meaningful stories and facilitating active participation, policies can foster not only citizen engagement but also social cohesion and public trust. This study contributes to the theory of governance innovation by offering a robust framework for strategically designing policy tools that effectively address contemporary governance challenges.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In Mexico, mandate revocation was initially conceived as an instrument to legitimize government action and foster accountability, providing a direct means for citizens to evaluate the performance of the executive branch. This mechanism, as a tool for democratic oversight, has the potential to transform citizen participation and their relationship with the State.
The 2022 presidential recall exercise raised questions about its effects on political participation, especially on the interaction between the population and the government, as well as its impact on future decisions. This article examines the recall as a policy that affects citizen involvement, employing the concept of policy feedback to analyze its repercussions. The central research question is: Do recall referendums change the way citizens interact with their local governments and can they influence public policymaking?
The fact that the 2022 mandate revocation did not reach the 40% participation threshold raises fundamental questions about its ability to mobilize citizens and its implications for the legitimacy of subsequent government decisions. This article employs the process tracing method to trace the causal mechanisms linking the referendum to changes in political participation, citizen involvement in decision making, and the legitimacy of public policies. By focusing on feedback effects, it examines whether these mechanisms generate lasting transformations in political behavior or whether they only represent a temporary form of participation.
The study also assesses the potential implications for local governments, especially in light of recent electoral reforms that have opened up the possibility of implementing recall mechanisms at the subnational level. An example of this is that in Hidalgo, Mexico, by the end of 2025, such an exercise may be requested to evaluate the work of the Governor. We also analyze the broader impact of voting on citizen trust in government institutions and the programs they implement.
Finally, this article aim to contribute to the growing literature on policy feedback by examining how the implementation of mandate revocation in Mexico shapes political attitudes, voting behavior, and turnout at both the national and local levels. Through empirical evidence and comparative analysis, we assess the potential of these mechanisms to strengthen a more participatory democratic system.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Today, the term “Smart City” has emerged as a catchphrase in the mission and vision of many countries, especially in developing countries such as those in the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries, including Dubai and Kuwait. While public political engagement is one of the smart city initiatives, the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) aspect is mostly emphasized in smart city discourses. This paper examines the role of public participation in decision-making as an important yet neglected initiative of the smart city concept. It also explores how the Kafala (sponsorship) system in Dubai and Kuwait City has influenced the political engagement of expatriates, who comprise four-fifths of these countries' population, during the COVID-19 era, as a critical period to assess the policy. Grounded in the policy feedback literature, the study investigates how this labor governance framework shaped expatriates' political discourse, indifference, and stagnation in claims-making during the pandemic.
Research Question: How did the Kafala sponsorship system affect expatriates' political engagement and discourse within the framework of policy feedback effects in Dubai and Kuwait City during COVID-19?
Methodology:
Social network analysis of Twitter discourse to examine patterns of engagement and disengagement.
Analysis of policy documents, government reports, and sponsorship regulations.
Findings and Contribution: This study enhances the overall understanding of how labor governance policies influence political engagement in non-Western contexts, particularly in Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries. Preliminary findings indicate that while digital platforms have created spaces for expatriate discussions, the restrictive nature of the Kafala system has reinforced patterns of exclusion, dependency, and suppressed political claims-making among expatriate workers. Even the Diwaniyas in Kuwait, as a public sphere, could not foster expatriates' political engagement or empower civil society as effectively as in Dubai. This paper underscores how governance structures shape both political engagement and disengagement by situating the Kafala system within the policy feedback framework.
The findings will provide comparative insights into how labor policies influence political outcomes in Kuwait and Dubai, especially in relation to historical institutionalism and policy feedback theories.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)