Format

P11. Democratic Resistance: Domestic and International Policy Strategies

COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Rachel Riedl
Cornell University, US
Main chair
Dan Slater
University of Michigan
Second chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Domestic and foreign policy are powerful tools to arrest democratic backsliding and support democratic resilience.  The panel emphasizes policy responses in the following domains in moments of democratic backsliding: legislative and executive lawmaking and candidate eligibility rules, judicial appointments and domains of jurisprudence, regulatory agencies (particularly tax, audit, and communications/ media sectors) of the state, political party registration, candidate selection, and competitive activity policies, labor and private sector rights and regulations, and foreign intervention rules. To create opportunities for democratic resistance and recovery, policy interventions will generally focus on the subsectors within the ”democracy, rights and governance” frameworks.  The panel participants will specify the theory of change which connects the pathways of democratic backsliding with the policy programming responses (foreign and/or domestic) that identifies how these changes can support democratic goals and practice.  The general framework of the panel suggests that these theories of change lie in the power of vertical responsibility (the masses putting limits and accountability on the rulers, either through elections or contentious politics), horizontal accountability (checks and balances of other institutional sites of power), and diagonal accountability (formal civil society and media audits and investigations) (Riedl et al 2024).   Such policy interventions have the potential to recover or even deepen democracy in the face of such specific threats to civil liberties and political rights. 

 

Existing research has tended to focus on either the drivers of democratic erosion, or the strategies that key actors – such as judiciaries and civil society groups – can employ to resist this process (Levitsky and Ziblatt 2018; Waldner and Lust 2018; Arriola, Rakner, and van de Walle 2022; Elischer and Lawrance 2022). This panel will identify the policy responses and which policy actors/ institutional sites can undertake such reforms given the particular pathways of democratic backsliding underway. 

 

CALL FOR PAPERS

We welcome papers that use empirical assessments of policy responses to democratic backsliding, to assess the mechanisms of policy reform and their relative efficacy across different contexts. 

 

●      How should we conceptualise or categorize the policy menu of programming responses to democratic backsliding, and how do they relate to theories of change for democratic resistance and sources of resilience?

●      What, if anything, is distinctive about policy targeted to address democratic backsliding in cases that have eroded to competitive autocracies, versus those that remain (limited) democracies ?

●      What policies can pre-emptively support democracies to more resilient to future authoritarian threats?

●      What particular policy challenges and opportunities do episodes of re-democratisation generate, given the tensions inherent in pro-democracy coalitions, governance expectations, and a need to reform institutionalized sites of autocratic capture? 

●      How does democratic backsliding and resistance relate to other intersecting policy priorities, such as reducing corruption and enhancing state capacity?

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - From Classrooms to Ballot Boxes: Student Activism and Policies to Ensure Electoral Competitiveness
Fidel Arevalo (Universidad de San Carlos de Guatemala)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Democracies worldwide face growing threats from authoritarian tendencies that undermine civil liberties and political rights. Guatemala’s recent electoral challenges and democratic erosion highlight the urgency of building resilience to protect democratic institutions. This paper explores how student activism, guided by policies rooted in academic spaces, can safeguard democracies against future authoritarian threats. It focuses on social sciences students, identifying actionable strategies for proactive engagement in defending democratic principles.

The proposed framework is grounded in a theory of change linking education and civic participation to democratic accountability: vertical accountability (citizens demanding transparency through voting and activism), horizontal accountability (institutional checks and balances), and diagonal accountability (civil society and media oversight). These dimensions inform a suite of educational, political, and institutional policies aimed at fostering democratic resilience.

1. Educational Policies to Foster Democratic Culture

Mandatory curricula: Courses on civic engagement, ethics, and human rights should be integral to university programs.
Hands-on workshops: Students should lead activities such as electoral observation and scenario simulations to prepare for democratic backsliding.
2. Promoting Youth Political Participation

Voter registration incentives: Policies that encourage youth participation as voters, candidates, and observers.
Collaborations with electoral bodies: Universities should partner with election authorities to design campaigns promoting informed voting and accountability.
3. Strengthening Civic Monitoring Networks

Student coalitions: Support for groups that monitor party registration and campaign financing to anticipate anti-democratic practices.
4. Building Resilience through Capacity Development

Academic simulations: Case studies on democratic erosion enable students to recognize authoritarian warning signs.
Reform debates: Involvement in discussions and proposals to reinforce institutional safeguards against backsliding.
This research employs qualitative and participatory methods, engaging Guatemalan university students to identify scalable interventions. Higher education institutions emerge as catalysts for democratic resilience, capable of amplifying civic responsibility and electoral integrity.

Theory of Change

Universities equip students with democratic competencies, fostering long-term resilience through accountability dimensions:

Vertical accountability: Empowering youth to demand transparency through informed voting and activism.
Horizontal accountability: Strengthening institutional oversight via university collaborations.
Diagonal accountability: Mobilizing student networks for social audits and political process monitoring.
Guatemala’s recent struggles illustrate the importance of student engagement in resisting democratic backsliding. Applied research and active student participation can address structural weaknesses in electoral systems, ensuring transparency in party registration and campaign financing. Activities like electoral observation, social auditing, and collaboration with policymakers contribute to a democratic ecosystem capable of preempting authoritarian threats.

Academic-driven policies offer sustainable change by fortifying normative frameworks and promoting inclusive democratic participation. Training in social auditing and electoral regulation equips students as critical analysts, while university-policymaker platforms foster reforms that safeguard rights and limit election interference.

In the long term, this approach positions students as agents of change, strengthening democratic practices through innovation, activism, and civic education. Academic interventions not only counteract democratic erosion but also build a foundation for participatory and resilient democracies.

Key Components:

Surveys to assess student trust and interest in political processes.
Strategies engaging students in electoral participation and oversight activities.
This study contributes a replicable model that integrates education, youth activism, and democracy to reinforce democratic resilience globally.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Examining Educational Development in Taiwan: A Reform Phase Analysis
Warangkana Lin (I-Shou University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Taiwan’s education system has undergone a significant transformation shaped by global trends and local socio-political contexts. This study examines Taiwan’s educational development and reforms, analyzing education policies and identifying priorities across distinct phases. Specifically, it investigates how Taiwan’s education policies have evolved in response to shifting global paradigms and domestic socio-political forces. These phases are explored within the broader context of liberal, neoliberal, and post-neoliberal paradigms. It analyzes over 500 policy documents from 1929 to 2023, including acts, specific laws, presidential decrees, and K-12 school-related regulations. The analysis applies a ten-dimension policy framework encompassing access, evaluation, finance, governance, equity, teachers, resources, curriculum, improvement, and learning standards, derived from the integration of Overbey’s (2023) framework and OECD Education GPS. Data coding, conducted using MAXQDA with inter-rater reliability check, identified three reform phases: establishment and early access (1928–1993), regulation and equal access (1994–2009), and consolidation and inclusivity (2010–2024). The findings underscore the significant influence of public advocacy, particularly from parents and scholars, on reform initiatives, culminating in milestones such as the enactment of the Educational Fundamental Law in 1999 and repeated amendments to key legislation, including the Private School Law (16 times), the Primary and Junior School Act (16 times), and the Teacher Education Act (15 times). While global trends of post-neoliberalism emphasize increased public reinvestment and school autonomy with accountability, Taiwan’s reforms have instead prioritized heightened regulation and state oversight. This divergence underscores the intricate interplay between Taiwan’s centralized Confucian government and its democratic evolution. The study contributes to understanding the process of policy reform and state resilience, offering insights into how democratic societies with centralized traditions, such as Taiwan, navigate the challenges of sustaining democratic principles amidst evolving global and local constraints.

 

Keywords: Reform, Confucian government, post-neoliberalism, policy, Taiwan, democratic society

 

References

 

Overbey, L. (2023). What's in a Wave? The Content of Neoliberal Education Reforms, 1970–2018. In Wiseman, A.W. (Ed.), Annual Review of Comparative and International Education 2022 (International Perspectives on Education and Society, Vol. 46A) (pp. 91-105). Emerald Publishing Limited. https://doi.org/10.1108/S1479-36792023000046A007

 

The OECD Education GPS. (n.d.). Review education policies.  Retrieved Jan 30, 2025, from https://gpseducation.oecd.org/revieweducationpolicies/

 

 

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Reigniting enthusiasm:Polarization and political participation in the U.S
Muxi Li (Nankai University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Political participation is a fundamental component of democratic governance, and its fluctuations are often regarded as a key indicator of the effectiveness of democratic institutions. This study aims to analyze the mechanisms through which party polarization drives institutional political participation, with a particular focus on the dynamic changes in electoral participation. Since the 2016 election cycle, Western democracies, particularly the United States, have experienced a notable resurgence in institutional political participation, as evidenced by the steady rise in voter turnout for both presidential and midterm elections. This trend stands in stark contrast to the persistently low electoral participation in several Western European countries, challenging the theoretical validity of existing explanations that attribute participation trends to the proliferation of internet technologies (technological dimension) and the rise of populism (ideological dimension) as universal factors.
This study focuses on party polarization as a key explanatory variable and constructs a "polarization-participation" theoretical model to systematically examine the mechanisms underlying the resurgence of institutional political participation in contemporary democracies. Utilizing a multidimensional dataset from the U.S. federal election cycles between 2012 and 2024, the research investigates the dynamic relationship between the intensity of party polarization and institutional political participation. The findings reveal that: (1) party polarization exerts a structural incentive effect on institutional participation by shaping voters' sense of political efficacy and issue salience perception; (2) within the context of polarization, technological and ideological variables, which have been central to existing explanatory frameworks, primarily function as moderating factors rather than independent explanatory variables.
This study seeks to deepen our understanding of the factors influencing institutional political participation.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Metropolitan City Administrations and Democratic Resistance in Turkey
Yeseren Elicin (Galatasaray University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Due to the country’s pursuit of European Union membership, a comprehensive administrative reform agenda emerged in Turkey during the early 2000s. However, an abrupt reversal of the decentralizing reforms followed the 2010 constitutional referendum. The democratic reform agenda of the 2000s has been overturned, leading to an increasingly authoritarian and centralized rule.

 

This retrogression has undermined democratic institutions, resulting in a patrimonial, clientelist, and authoritarian recentralization. One of the most pronounced effects of this democratic backsliding in Turkey is evident in local governance, characterized by a decline in local autonomy, the dismissal of elected mayors and city council members, financial restrictions, and the threat of a politicized judiciary.

 

Nevertheless, the metropolitan municipalities won by social democrats in the 2019 and 2024 local elections have become key actors in resisting democratic regression. They have begun to develop strategies to withstand pressure from the central government. Support from civil society groups and media (diagonal accountability) has also become an important tool in this struggle. This paper tries to assess the policies and strategies adopted by metropolitan city administrations, particularly the Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality, to oppose democratic erosion and arbitrary interference from the central government.

 

In this study, a qualitative research methodology is employed to explore the policies and strategies adopted by metropolitan city administrations in Turkey. Content analysis of policy documents, official statements, and media coverage is conducted to contextualize the findings within the broader landscape of local governance. Also, in-depth interviews with municipal officials in Istanbul allows for a comprehensive understanding of the dynamics at play in resisting central government interference and upholding local autonomy.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Multilateral decentralized cooperation for bettering democratic resilience. The case of the European Association for Local Democracy (ALDA) and the LDAs.v
Francesca Gelli (Università Iuav di Venezia)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The paper presents an interesting case-experiment in the challenge to redemocratize and
strengthen democratic resilience in countries shaken by wars, authoritarian regimes, and periods
of crisis for the quality of democracy: the European Association for Local Democracy (ALDA) and
its operational network of 17 Local Democracy Agencies (LDAs). Established in the 1990s by the
initiative of the Council of Europe, the first LDAs were active in the Balkans in 1993 as part of the
Democratization Table to support the recovery of civil society and municipalities after the conflict;
ALDA has worked since 1999 as an umbrella organization for coordinating LDAs’ activities. In thirty
years of activity, ALDA and LDAs have acted as key stakeholders and strategic partners in building
local democratic resilience in the target territories of intervention. The focus of our analysis is on
their innovative method of decentralized multilateral cooperation, which is based on ongoing local
and international partnership between local governments, civil society associations, NGOs,
universities and research centres that share projects and initiatives, in many policy areas and on
central issues, to foster citizen participation, mobilise civil society organizations, and strengthen
the administrative and governance capacities of local institutions. Over the years their role has
expanded, mediating with the institutions of the European Union and spreading a bottom-up
approach, which gives importance to cities and territories (the reference is to the different vision of
construction of Europe, of the European Council and the EU), stimulating mutual learning with
those territories where democracy is stable; but there is also an awareness that the quality of
democracy must be constantly nurtured and improved. Today ALDA is a platform for dialogue and
cooperation that brings together over 300 partners, including several Mediterranean countries;
LDAs were also established in Ukraine, Georgia, Armenia, Moldova. The study offers a diachronic
comparison, taking advantage of previous research on LDAs carried out in the Balkans between
2002-2006 and ongoing research commissioned by ALDA itself to evaluate the impact of ALDA's
actions in target territories, with the goals of strengthening local capacities for democratic resilience
and better understanding conditions that facilitate successful redemocratization.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Pheu Thai’s digital wallet policy: Recultivating voter linkages after the military regime
Illan Nam (Colgate University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

During the past 18 years, Thailand experienced two coups – the first in 2006 and the second in 2014 – that removed the democratically elected government of Thaksin Shinawatra and subsequently, that of his sister, Yingluck Shinawatra, and replaced them with military-led regimes. After a long interlude, during which the military regime rewrote the constitution twice and dissolved Thaksin’s Thai Rak Thai Party and its successor parties – it permitted relatively open elections to be held in May 2023. But in a shocking post-election twist, the Pheu Thai party forged an unlikely coalition with the military parties to form a government. As a result of this mesalliance, the Pheu Thai party, whose executives had been banned from politics on numerous occasions by its current political bedfellows, found itself back in power. Yet, this Faustian bargain put the party between a rock and a hard place. By allying with the military parties, Pheu Thai tarnished its hard-earned democratic credentials, which its principal competitor and main opposition party, the People’s Party (formerly Move Forward), readily assumed. At the same time, its coalition with its frenemies inevitably has been fraught with mistrust.

The Pheu Thai’s position illuminates the challenges facing political parties competing in a redemocratizing political society after a period of democratic backsliding. On one hand, the competitive electoral arena generates considerable pressure upon the party to deliver policies that demonstrate its responsiveness to citizens’ needs and to rebuild its identity among voters. On the other, it has to contend with institutional constraints that are a legacy of preceding authoritarian rule. These competing pressures have bedeviled Pheu Thai’s flagship program, the digital wallet, which was designed to deliver a one-time cash transfer of $275 to Thais whose incomes in 2023 fell below $23,300. Those eligible can spend this subsidy at any shop within their locality registered with the program. Designed to achieve several objectives – to spur consumer spending and GDP growth, stimulate small- and medium-sized enterprises, especially in provincial areas, and to demonstrate its ability to deliver to voters – the program has been dogged by considerable resistance from the opposition party as well as bureaucrats aligned with the military parties.

In this paper, I highlight the Pheu Thai’s digital wallet policy as a significant tool through which the party is attempting to reshape the party system after a long period of electoral dormancy. To enable redemocratization to take place in Thailand, Pheu Thai had to compromise with the military regime, thereby muting some of the challenges it had posed earlier to conservative interests. But at the same time, its survival depends upon reclaiming its position as a pro-democracy party that can deliver to citizens and distinguishing its policy linkages from those created by the preceding military government’s rural subsidies. Hence, this study of Pheu Thai’s policy sheds light on the opportunities and challenges.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Democratic Resilience in Lithuania: Perspectives of Academic to Civic Communities
Egle Butkeviciene (Kaunas University of Technology)
CO-AUTHORS
Vytautas Valentinavicius (Kaunas University of Technology, Lithuania)
Egle Vaidelyte (Kaunas University of Technology)
ABSTRACT

Democratic resilience, the ability of democratic systems, institutions, political actors, and citizens to withstand and respond to internal and external challenges, has never been more critical in times of geopolitical instability, particularly in regions facing hybrid threats and democratic backsliding. Merkel and Lührmann (2021) argue that the more democracies exhibit resilience at all four levels of the political system: the political community, institutions (including universities and research performing organizations), actors, and citizens, the less vulnerable they are to crises, now and in the future. Research on citizenship (Martini & Quaranta, 2020) underscores that active civic participation strengthens decision-making processes, producing outcomes that benefit society at large. Furthermore, informed and engaged citizens are more likely to collaborate, make rational decisions, and hold governments accountable, all of which contribute to a society’s ability to endure and recover from crises. In an era of increasing digital misinformation, the ability to critically assess information, understand scientific data, and use technology responsibly has become a crucial component of democratic resilience (Doyle et al., 2020; Yacoubian, 2017).
In the broader academic discourse, social resilience refers to a community’s ability to absorb, adapt to, and recover from adverse events (Alessi et al., 2020; Dewaele & Lucas, 2022). A resilient society values cultural diversity and promotes the political, economic, and social inclusion of all individuals, thus strengthening social cohesion (Norris et al., 2008). Comparative research suggests that key drivers of social resilience include civic participation, social capital, inclusive governance, and citizens’ capacity to critically engage with social issues within their local context (Carmen et al., 2022). Universities are also might take an active role in building resilience through political and administrative science study programmes, science communication and citizen science (Levac et. al., 2018). However, existing studies often fail to explore how democratic and social resilience interact in contexts facing high geopolitical pressure and external threats.
This study employs a mixed methods approach to examine how Lithuanian citizens perceive and engage with democracy, civic participation, and societal resilience in the face of growing domestic and international challenges. The quantitative component analyses public attitudes toward democratic institutions, political engagement, and citizen science, offering insight into how these factors contribute to overall democratic resilience. The qualitative component examines the extent to which local governments facilitate or impede civic participation, evaluating the responsiveness of institutions to grassroots engagement.
Initial outcomes suggest a significant enhancement in public pride concerning Lithuania’s democratic achievements. Nonetheless, notwithstanding this favorable development, persistent apprehensions about societal readiness for crises, such as military threats, political instability, and disinformation campaigns, continue to exist. The results imply that although institutional trust has seen improvements, there remains a fragile public confidence in the society’s capacity to effectively mobilize during times of crisis. This study seeks to delineate the principal factors impacting democratic resilience and to formulate policy recommendations aimed at augmenting institutional trust, university role in enhancing community resistance to external and internal threats, and bolstering civic participation amidst contemporary challenges.

 

Bibliography
 
Alessi, L., Benczur, P., Campolongo, F. et al. (2020). The Resilience of EU member states to the Financial and Economic Crisis. Soc Indic Res. 148, 569–598.
Carmen, E., Fazey, I., Ross, H. et al. (2022). Building community resilience in a context of climate change: The role of social capital. Ambio 51, 1371–1387. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13280-021-01678-9
Dewaele, L., Lucas, R. (2022). Policymaking to support resilience in democratic countries: an examination of Sweden, Israel, and Australia. Eur J Futures Res 10, 13 (2022).
Doyle, E. E. H., Lambie, E., Orchiston, C., Becker, J. S., McLaren, L., Johnston, D., & Leonard, G. (2020). Citizen science as a catalyst for community resilience building: A two-phase tsunami case study. Australasian Journal of Disaster and Trauma Studies, 24(1), 23-49.
Levac, L., Parizeau, K., Varghese, J., Morton, M., Jackson, E., & Hawkins, L. (2018). Towards a Framework for Building Community-University Resilience Research Agendas. Social Sciences, 7(12), 260. https://doi.org/10.3390/socsci7120260
Martini, S., & Quaranta, M. (2020). Citizens and democracy in Europe: contexts, changes and political support. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Merkel, W., & Lührmann, A. (2021). Resilience of democracies: responses to illiberal and authoritarian challenges. Democratization, 28(5), 869–884.
Norris, F.H., Stevens, S.P., Pfefferbaum, B. et al. Community Resilience as a Metaphor, Theory, Set of Capacities, and Strategy for Disaster Readiness. Am J Community Psychol 41, 127–150 (2008).

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Democracies worldwide face growing threats from authoritarian tendencies that undermine civil liberties and political rights. Guatemala’s recent electoral challenges and democratic erosion highlight the urgency of building resilience to protect democratic institutions. This paper explores how student activism, guided by policies rooted in academic spaces, can safeguard democracies against future authoritarian threats. It focuses on social sciences students, identifying actionable strategies for proactive engagement in defending democratic principles.

The proposed framework is grounded in a theory of change linking education and civic participation to democratic accountability: vertical accountability (citizens demanding transparency through voting and activism), horizontal accountability (institutional checks and balances), and diagonal accountability (civil society and media oversight). These dimensions inform a suite of educational, political, and institutional policies aimed at fostering democratic resilience.

1. Educational Policies to Foster Democratic Culture

Mandatory curricula: Courses on civic engagement, ethics, and human rights should be integral to university programs.
Hands-on workshops: Students should lead activities such as electoral observation and scenario simulations to prepare for democratic backsliding.
2. Promoting Youth Political Participation

Voter registration incentives: Policies that encourage youth participation as voters, candidates, and observers.
Collaborations with electoral bodies: Universities should partner with election authorities to design campaigns promoting informed voting and accountability.
3. Strengthening Civic Monitoring Networks

Student coalitions: Support for groups that monitor party registration and campaign financing to anticipate anti-democratic practices.
4. Building Resilience through Capacity Development

Academic simulations: Case studies on democratic erosion enable students to recognize authoritarian warning signs.
Reform debates: Involvement in discussions and proposals to reinforce institutional safeguards against backsliding.
This research employs qualitative and participatory methods, engaging Guatemalan university students to identify scalable interventions. Higher education institutions emerge as catalysts for democratic resilience, capable of amplifying civic responsibility and electoral integrity.

Theory of Change

Universities equip students with democratic competencies, fostering long-term resilience through accountability dimensions:

Vertical accountability: Empowering youth to demand transparency through informed voting and activism.
Horizontal accountability: Strengthening institutional oversight via university collaborations.
Diagonal accountability: Mobilizing student networks for social audits and political process monitoring.
Guatemala’s recent struggles illustrate the importance of student engagement in resisting democratic backsliding. Applied research and active student participation can address structural weaknesses in electoral systems, ensuring transparency in party registration and campaign financing. Activities like electoral observation, social auditing, and collaboration with policymakers contribute to a democratic ecosystem capable of preempting authoritarian threats.

Academic-driven policies offer sustainable change by fortifying normative frameworks and promoting inclusive democratic participation. Training in social auditing and electoral regulation equips students as critical analysts, while university-policymaker platforms foster reforms that safeguard rights and limit election interference.

In the long term, this approach positions students as agents of change, strengthening democratic practices through innovation, activism, and civic education. Academic interventions not only counteract democratic erosion but also build a foundation for participatory and resilient democracies.

Key Components:

Surveys to assess student trust and interest in political processes.
Strategies engaging students in electoral participation and oversight activities.
This study contributes a replicable model that integrates education, youth activism, and democracy to reinforce democratic resilience globally.

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Taiwan’s education system has undergone a significant transformation shaped by global trends and local socio-political contexts. This study examines Taiwan’s educational development and reforms, analyzing education policies and identifying priorities across distinct phases. Specifically, it investigates how Taiwan’s education policies have evolved in response to shifting global paradigms and domestic socio-political forces. These phases are explored within the broader context of liberal, neoliberal, and post-neoliberal paradigms. It analyzes over 500 policy documents from 1929 to 2023, including acts, specific laws, presidential decrees, and K-12 school-related regulations. The analysis applies a ten-dimension policy framework encompassing access, evaluation, finance, governance, equity, teachers, resources, curriculum, improvement, and learning standards, derived from the integration of Overbey’s (2023) framework and OECD Education GPS. Data coding, conducted using MAXQDA with inter-rater reliability check, identified three reform phases: establishment and early access (1928–1993), regulation and equal access (1994–2009), and consolidation and inclusivity (2010–2024). The findings underscore the significant influence of public advocacy, particularly from parents and scholars, on reform initiatives, culminating in milestones such as the enactment of the Educational Fundamental Law in 1999 and repeated amendments to key legislation, including the Private School Law (16 times), the Primary and Junior School Act (16 times), and the Teacher Education Act (15 times). While global trends of post-neoliberalism emphasize increased public reinvestment and school autonomy with accountability, Taiwan’s reforms have instead prioritized heightened regulation and state oversight. This divergence underscores the intricate interplay between Taiwan’s centralized Confucian government and its democratic evolution. The study contributes to understanding the process of policy reform and state resilience, offering insights into how democratic societies with centralized traditions, such as Taiwan, navigate the challenges of sustaining democratic principles amidst evolving global and local constraints.

 

Keywords: Reform, Confucian government, post-neoliberalism, policy, Taiwan, democratic society

 

References

 

Overbey, L. (2023). What's in a Wave? The Content of Neoliberal Education Reforms, 1970–2018. In Wiseman, A.W. (Ed.), Annual Review of Comparative and International Education 2022 (International Perspectives on Education and Society, Vol. 46A) (pp. 91-105). Emerald Publishing Limited. https://doi.org/10.1108/S1479-36792023000046A007

 

The OECD Education GPS. (n.d.). Review education policies.  Retrieved Jan 30, 2025, from https://gpseducation.oecd.org/revieweducationpolicies/

 

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Political participation is a fundamental component of democratic governance, and its fluctuations are often regarded as a key indicator of the effectiveness of democratic institutions. This study aims to analyze the mechanisms through which party polarization drives institutional political participation, with a particular focus on the dynamic changes in electoral participation. Since the 2016 election cycle, Western democracies, particularly the United States, have experienced a notable resurgence in institutional political participation, as evidenced by the steady rise in voter turnout for both presidential and midterm elections. This trend stands in stark contrast to the persistently low electoral participation in several Western European countries, challenging the theoretical validity of existing explanations that attribute participation trends to the proliferation of internet technologies (technological dimension) and the rise of populism (ideological dimension) as universal factors.
This study focuses on party polarization as a key explanatory variable and constructs a "polarization-participation" theoretical model to systematically examine the mechanisms underlying the resurgence of institutional political participation in contemporary democracies. Utilizing a multidimensional dataset from the U.S. federal election cycles between 2012 and 2024, the research investigates the dynamic relationship between the intensity of party polarization and institutional political participation. The findings reveal that: (1) party polarization exerts a structural incentive effect on institutional participation by shaping voters' sense of political efficacy and issue salience perception; (2) within the context of polarization, technological and ideological variables, which have been central to existing explanatory frameworks, primarily function as moderating factors rather than independent explanatory variables.
This study seeks to deepen our understanding of the factors influencing institutional political participation.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Due to the country’s pursuit of European Union membership, a comprehensive administrative reform agenda emerged in Turkey during the early 2000s. However, an abrupt reversal of the decentralizing reforms followed the 2010 constitutional referendum. The democratic reform agenda of the 2000s has been overturned, leading to an increasingly authoritarian and centralized rule.

 

This retrogression has undermined democratic institutions, resulting in a patrimonial, clientelist, and authoritarian recentralization. One of the most pronounced effects of this democratic backsliding in Turkey is evident in local governance, characterized by a decline in local autonomy, the dismissal of elected mayors and city council members, financial restrictions, and the threat of a politicized judiciary.

 

Nevertheless, the metropolitan municipalities won by social democrats in the 2019 and 2024 local elections have become key actors in resisting democratic regression. They have begun to develop strategies to withstand pressure from the central government. Support from civil society groups and media (diagonal accountability) has also become an important tool in this struggle. This paper tries to assess the policies and strategies adopted by metropolitan city administrations, particularly the Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality, to oppose democratic erosion and arbitrary interference from the central government.

 

In this study, a qualitative research methodology is employed to explore the policies and strategies adopted by metropolitan city administrations in Turkey. Content analysis of policy documents, official statements, and media coverage is conducted to contextualize the findings within the broader landscape of local governance. Also, in-depth interviews with municipal officials in Istanbul allows for a comprehensive understanding of the dynamics at play in resisting central government interference and upholding local autonomy.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The paper presents an interesting case-experiment in the challenge to redemocratize and
strengthen democratic resilience in countries shaken by wars, authoritarian regimes, and periods
of crisis for the quality of democracy: the European Association for Local Democracy (ALDA) and
its operational network of 17 Local Democracy Agencies (LDAs). Established in the 1990s by the
initiative of the Council of Europe, the first LDAs were active in the Balkans in 1993 as part of the
Democratization Table to support the recovery of civil society and municipalities after the conflict;
ALDA has worked since 1999 as an umbrella organization for coordinating LDAs’ activities. In thirty
years of activity, ALDA and LDAs have acted as key stakeholders and strategic partners in building
local democratic resilience in the target territories of intervention. The focus of our analysis is on
their innovative method of decentralized multilateral cooperation, which is based on ongoing local
and international partnership between local governments, civil society associations, NGOs,
universities and research centres that share projects and initiatives, in many policy areas and on
central issues, to foster citizen participation, mobilise civil society organizations, and strengthen
the administrative and governance capacities of local institutions. Over the years their role has
expanded, mediating with the institutions of the European Union and spreading a bottom-up
approach, which gives importance to cities and territories (the reference is to the different vision of
construction of Europe, of the European Council and the EU), stimulating mutual learning with
those territories where democracy is stable; but there is also an awareness that the quality of
democracy must be constantly nurtured and improved. Today ALDA is a platform for dialogue and
cooperation that brings together over 300 partners, including several Mediterranean countries;
LDAs were also established in Ukraine, Georgia, Armenia, Moldova. The study offers a diachronic
comparison, taking advantage of previous research on LDAs carried out in the Balkans between
2002-2006 and ongoing research commissioned by ALDA itself to evaluate the impact of ALDA's
actions in target territories, with the goals of strengthening local capacities for democratic resilience
and better understanding conditions that facilitate successful redemocratization.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

During the past 18 years, Thailand experienced two coups – the first in 2006 and the second in 2014 – that removed the democratically elected government of Thaksin Shinawatra and subsequently, that of his sister, Yingluck Shinawatra, and replaced them with military-led regimes. After a long interlude, during which the military regime rewrote the constitution twice and dissolved Thaksin’s Thai Rak Thai Party and its successor parties – it permitted relatively open elections to be held in May 2023. But in a shocking post-election twist, the Pheu Thai party forged an unlikely coalition with the military parties to form a government. As a result of this mesalliance, the Pheu Thai party, whose executives had been banned from politics on numerous occasions by its current political bedfellows, found itself back in power. Yet, this Faustian bargain put the party between a rock and a hard place. By allying with the military parties, Pheu Thai tarnished its hard-earned democratic credentials, which its principal competitor and main opposition party, the People’s Party (formerly Move Forward), readily assumed. At the same time, its coalition with its frenemies inevitably has been fraught with mistrust.

The Pheu Thai’s position illuminates the challenges facing political parties competing in a redemocratizing political society after a period of democratic backsliding. On one hand, the competitive electoral arena generates considerable pressure upon the party to deliver policies that demonstrate its responsiveness to citizens’ needs and to rebuild its identity among voters. On the other, it has to contend with institutional constraints that are a legacy of preceding authoritarian rule. These competing pressures have bedeviled Pheu Thai’s flagship program, the digital wallet, which was designed to deliver a one-time cash transfer of $275 to Thais whose incomes in 2023 fell below $23,300. Those eligible can spend this subsidy at any shop within their locality registered with the program. Designed to achieve several objectives – to spur consumer spending and GDP growth, stimulate small- and medium-sized enterprises, especially in provincial areas, and to demonstrate its ability to deliver to voters – the program has been dogged by considerable resistance from the opposition party as well as bureaucrats aligned with the military parties.

In this paper, I highlight the Pheu Thai’s digital wallet policy as a significant tool through which the party is attempting to reshape the party system after a long period of electoral dormancy. To enable redemocratization to take place in Thailand, Pheu Thai had to compromise with the military regime, thereby muting some of the challenges it had posed earlier to conservative interests. But at the same time, its survival depends upon reclaiming its position as a pro-democracy party that can deliver to citizens and distinguishing its policy linkages from those created by the preceding military government’s rural subsidies. Hence, this study of Pheu Thai’s policy sheds light on the opportunities and challenges.

CO-AUTHORS
Vytautas Valentinavicius (Kaunas University of Technology, Lithuania)
Egle Vaidelyte (Kaunas University of Technology)
ABSTRACT

Democratic resilience, the ability of democratic systems, institutions, political actors, and citizens to withstand and respond to internal and external challenges, has never been more critical in times of geopolitical instability, particularly in regions facing hybrid threats and democratic backsliding. Merkel and Lührmann (2021) argue that the more democracies exhibit resilience at all four levels of the political system: the political community, institutions (including universities and research performing organizations), actors, and citizens, the less vulnerable they are to crises, now and in the future. Research on citizenship (Martini & Quaranta, 2020) underscores that active civic participation strengthens decision-making processes, producing outcomes that benefit society at large. Furthermore, informed and engaged citizens are more likely to collaborate, make rational decisions, and hold governments accountable, all of which contribute to a society’s ability to endure and recover from crises. In an era of increasing digital misinformation, the ability to critically assess information, understand scientific data, and use technology responsibly has become a crucial component of democratic resilience (Doyle et al., 2020; Yacoubian, 2017).
In the broader academic discourse, social resilience refers to a community’s ability to absorb, adapt to, and recover from adverse events (Alessi et al., 2020; Dewaele & Lucas, 2022). A resilient society values cultural diversity and promotes the political, economic, and social inclusion of all individuals, thus strengthening social cohesion (Norris et al., 2008). Comparative research suggests that key drivers of social resilience include civic participation, social capital, inclusive governance, and citizens’ capacity to critically engage with social issues within their local context (Carmen et al., 2022). Universities are also might take an active role in building resilience through political and administrative science study programmes, science communication and citizen science (Levac et. al., 2018). However, existing studies often fail to explore how democratic and social resilience interact in contexts facing high geopolitical pressure and external threats.
This study employs a mixed methods approach to examine how Lithuanian citizens perceive and engage with democracy, civic participation, and societal resilience in the face of growing domestic and international challenges. The quantitative component analyses public attitudes toward democratic institutions, political engagement, and citizen science, offering insight into how these factors contribute to overall democratic resilience. The qualitative component examines the extent to which local governments facilitate or impede civic participation, evaluating the responsiveness of institutions to grassroots engagement.
Initial outcomes suggest a significant enhancement in public pride concerning Lithuania’s democratic achievements. Nonetheless, notwithstanding this favorable development, persistent apprehensions about societal readiness for crises, such as military threats, political instability, and disinformation campaigns, continue to exist. The results imply that although institutional trust has seen improvements, there remains a fragile public confidence in the society’s capacity to effectively mobilize during times of crisis. This study seeks to delineate the principal factors impacting democratic resilience and to formulate policy recommendations aimed at augmenting institutional trust, university role in enhancing community resistance to external and internal threats, and bolstering civic participation amidst contemporary challenges.

 

Bibliography
 
Alessi, L., Benczur, P., Campolongo, F. et al. (2020). The Resilience of EU member states to the Financial and Economic Crisis. Soc Indic Res. 148, 569–598.
Carmen, E., Fazey, I., Ross, H. et al. (2022). Building community resilience in a context of climate change: The role of social capital. Ambio 51, 1371–1387. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13280-021-01678-9
Dewaele, L., Lucas, R. (2022). Policymaking to support resilience in democratic countries: an examination of Sweden, Israel, and Australia. Eur J Futures Res 10, 13 (2022).
Doyle, E. E. H., Lambie, E., Orchiston, C., Becker, J. S., McLaren, L., Johnston, D., & Leonard, G. (2020). Citizen science as a catalyst for community resilience building: A two-phase tsunami case study. Australasian Journal of Disaster and Trauma Studies, 24(1), 23-49.
Levac, L., Parizeau, K., Varghese, J., Morton, M., Jackson, E., & Hawkins, L. (2018). Towards a Framework for Building Community-University Resilience Research Agendas. Social Sciences, 7(12), 260. https://doi.org/10.3390/socsci7120260
Martini, S., & Quaranta, M. (2020). Citizens and democracy in Europe: contexts, changes and political support. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Merkel, W., & Lührmann, A. (2021). Resilience of democracies: responses to illiberal and authoritarian challenges. Democratization, 28(5), 869–884.
Norris, F.H., Stevens, S.P., Pfefferbaum, B. et al. Community Resilience as a Metaphor, Theory, Set of Capacities, and Strategy for Disaster Readiness. Am J Community Psychol 41, 127–150 (2008).