Format

P10. Policy Capacity, Governance Arrangements, and Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the Global South

COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Alexandre Gomide
National School of Public Administration (ENAP)
Main chair
Alketa Peci
Getulio Vargas Foundation, Brazil
Second chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Implementing the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) poses complex challenges for Global South nations, where state capacities, policy effectiveness, and implementation arrangements tend to be considered fragile. However, they are essential for achieving the 2030 Agenda. This panel explores the intersection between policy capacity, implementation arrangements, and SDG success, focusing on how governments in the Global South mobilize resources, build institutions, and navigate political and institutional complexities to ensure effective and sustainable policy outcomes.
Drawing on frameworks from public administration and policy scholars, the panel examines how policy capacity deployment and implementation arrangements—involving diverse actors, resources, and instruments—activate policy capacities for SDG implementation. Their approach underscores that policy capacity skills and resources are not static but depend on dynamic governance arrangements and political deployment to ensure effective implementation.
The overarching research question is: How can policy capacity and governance arrangements in the Global South be optimized to enhance the effective implementation of the SDGs?
Sub-questions include:
• What are the critical factors that influence the success or failure of SDG policies?
• How do public sector innovation, dynamic capabilities, and decentralization contribute to the progress of SDG implementation?
• How can policy capacity be politically deployed across different levels of government to align national strategies with SDG?
This panel's scientific relevance lies in its focus on bridging theoretical discussions of state policy capacity with the practical realities of SDG governance implementation. By emphasizing the political and relational dynamics between politics, administrative resources, and policy instruments, the panel addresses a gap in understanding how state capacity is activated through governance arrangements and how these arrangements influence the success of SDG policies.
This panel will cover:
• Governance structures and the role of public sector innovation in supporting SDG implementation.
• The importance of dynamic capabilities in adapting and reconfiguring resources to meet development challenges.
• The impact of political leadership, intergovernmental coordination, and collaboration with civil society and private sector actors in achieving SDG goals.
The panel format will be onsite, allowing for in-person and virtual participation.

CALL FOR PAPERS

Implementing the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) poses complex challenges for Global South nations, where state capacities, policy effectiveness, and implementation arrangements tend to be considered challenging. However, they are essential for achieving the 2030 Agenda. This panel explores the intersection between policy capacity, implementation arrangements, and SDG success, focusing on how governments in the Global South mobilize resources, build institutions, and navigate political and institutional complexities to ensure effective and sustainable policy outcomes.

The panel examines how policy capacity deployment and implementation arrangements—involving diverse actors, resources, and instruments—activate policy capacities for SDG implementation. Their approach underscores that policy capacity skills and resources are not static but depend on dynamic governance arrangements and political deployment to ensure effective implementation.

The overarching research question is: How can policy capacity and governance arrangements be optimized to enhance the effective implementation of the SDGs in the Global South?

This panel invites empirical, theoretical, and methodological papers addressing the following themes:

·         Governance Arrangements and Policy Capacity Deployment: How do the configuration of actors, resources, and instruments in governance arrangements activate or obstacle administrative skills and resources for SDG implementation?

·         Policy Capacity Deployment for SDG Success: How can different forms of policy capacity (administrative, technical, and political) be deployed to align national strategies with SDG goals? Papers analyzing political leadership, coordination mechanisms, and institutional reforms in this process are highly encouraged.

·         Public Sector Innovation and Dynamic Capabilities: The role of innovation and adaptability within public sector organizations in overcoming SDG challenges and promoting sustainable development.

· Multi-level governance and Coordination: How do national, regional, and local governments coordinate to ensure effective SDG implementation? Papers exploring the role of decentralization and local governance in delivering SDG outcomes are encouraged.

·         Collaborative Governance and Stakeholder Engagement: Research on the involvement of civil society, the private sector, and international organizations in the collaborative governance models necessary for SDG success is welcome. Contributions analyzing cross-sectoral partnerships to overcome barriers in policy implementation are also welcome.

·         Political Economy and Power Relations: How do political priorities, vested interests, and the broader political economy shape the capacity of states in the Global South to implement the SDGs? Papers analyzing power dynamics and their impact on SDG policy processes are invited.

 

We encourage submissions employing diverse methodological approaches—such as case studies, comparative analyses, and policy evaluations—to enrich the discussion on state capacity, governance arrangements, policy instruments, and SDG implementation in the Global South.

 

The panel will be divided into multiple sessions for diverse perspectives and interdisciplinary dialogue.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Exploring Governance Models of State-Owned Enterprises: a tentative typology and its determinants
Pedro Cavalcante (Brazilian Institute of Education, Development and Research (IDP))
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

State-owned enterprises (SOEs) play a critical role in the global economy, serving as key drivers in delivering public services, fostering economic growth, and addressing societal challenges, such as those related to the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). These entities, governed through diverse ownership and coordination models, differ widely across countries in terms of structure, operational capacity, funding mechanisms, and contributions to socioeconomic progress. Despite their significance, the governance frameworks for SOEs vary greatly, reflecting unique national contexts.

This paper aims to propose a tentative typology for SOE governance worldwide by examining existing governance models, comparing the performance of SOEs across developed and developing nations, and evaluating their impact on corporate governance and broader economic outcomes. By analyzing these models, the study seeks to identify the factors that influence governance choices in different countries and their implications for SOE performance.

The paper begins by examining the primary state ownership models discussed in the literature, including the "dual ownership" model, the "centralized ownership" model, and the "coordinating agency" model, as well as hybrid approaches like the "dual-track" model. Drawing on the work of Mazzucato et al. (2024), it integrates OECD governance classifications to evaluate the degree of coordination within each model, ranging from low to high levels of state intervention (OECD, 2024). Despite the availability of these theoretical frameworks, there is no clear consensus on how to classify countries into specific models or establish standardized criteria for such classifications. This lack of clarity hampers a comprehensive understanding of how SOEs operate across diverse political and economic contexts, especially regarding their contributions to achieving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). To address this gap, additional criteria are crucial for capturing the diversity of SOE governance models worldwide. These criteria include their significance within the national economy, market share, financial dependence, budget size, role in advancing national political priorities, and whether they have publicly traded capital.

The paper also addresses several central research questions: How do different state ownership governance models influence SOEs’ policy capacity and performance? What criteria should guide the classification of countries into these models? How does state ownership impact corporate governance, including decision-making, transparency, and accountability? To answer these questions, the study employs a comparative methodology, analyzing governance models across countries at varying stages of development, with a focus on both advanced economies and nations in the Global South. Through detailed case studies of prominent SOEs, the paper highlights best practices, common challenges, and critical lessons that can inform future governance frameworks. It also considers contextual factors such as economic size, institutional history, political systems, and specific challenges related to development in its broader sense.

Ultimately, this research seeks to contribute to academic and policy discussions by offering empirical evidence and practical insights for policymakers, practitioners, and scholars. It aims to provide a structured typology for understanding SOE governance, evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of various models, and propose recommendations for enhancing SOE performance, transparency, and accountability.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Strengthening Institutional Capacity and Governance Frameworks for Advancing Sustainable Development Goals in the Global South
Benedicta Neysa Nathania (Universität Hamburg)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Title:
"Strengthening Institutional Capacity and Governance Frameworks for Advancing Sustainable Development Goals in the Global South"

 

Abstract

 

Policy capacity and governance arrangements are critical determinants of progress toward achieving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), particularly in the Global South, where systemic challenges such as weak institutions, resource constraints, and socio-economic disparities are prevalent. Policy capacity encompasses the ability of governments and institutions to formulate, implement, and evaluate policies effectively, while governance arrangements define the structures and processes that enable inclusive, transparent, and accountable decision-making. Strengthening these elements is essential for addressing complex and interlinked SDG targets, from poverty eradication and climate action to education and health improvements.  

 

In the Global South, limited policy capacity often results from institutional fragmentation, lack of technical expertise, and inadequate resource mobilization (Howlett, 2019). This capacity deficit hinders the development and implementation of policies aligned with the SDGs, leading to uneven progress across sectors and regions. For example, low-income countries often struggle to integrate environmental sustainability into national policies while addressing pressing socio-economic priorities, such as poverty reduction and employment generation (Grindle, 2007). Moreover, governance arrangements in many countries remain constrained by centralized decision-making, weak accountability mechanisms, and insufficient stakeholder participation, exacerbating inequalities and undermining trust in public institutions.  

 

A critical pathway to overcoming these challenges involves enhancing policy capacity through capacity-building initiatives, knowledge sharing, and technology transfer. Programs that provide training for policymakers, facilitate South-South cooperation, and promote multi-stakeholder partnerships can strengthen institutional capabilities to address SDG targets. For instance, capacity-building programs supported by international organizations, such as the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), have demonstrated positive outcomes in improving governance and policy design in areas like climate adaptation and social protection (UNDP, 2022).  

 

Governance arrangements also play a pivotal role in determining the effectiveness of SDG implementation. Decentralization and participatory governance models have been identified as promising approaches for fostering inclusive decision-making and empowering local communities. In Brazil, for instance, participatory budgeting initiatives have enhanced transparency and accountability while enabling marginalized populations to influence resource allocation (Avritzer, 2012). Similarly, Kenya’s devolved governance system has improved access to essential services, such as healthcare and education, in previously underserved regions (Cheeseman et al., 2016). However, the success of these arrangements depends on the presence of robust institutions, effective leadership, and mechanisms for conflict resolution.  

 

Furthermore, the integration of the SDGs into national and subnational planning frameworks requires coherence and alignment across policy domains. Policy coherence ensures that efforts to achieve one SDG do not undermine progress toward others, particularly in contexts where trade-offs between social, economic, and environmental goals are unavoidable. For example, policies promoting industrial growth must simultaneously address environmental sustainability and social equity to avoid exacerbating climate change or displacing vulnerable communities (Nilsson et al., 2016).  

 

This research contributes to the understanding of policy capacity and governance arrangements by analyzing their role in accelerating SDG implementation in the Global South. It highlights successful case studies and identifies best practices for overcoming governance challenges and building resilient policy systems. The study also underscores the importance of fostering global partnerships and leveraging international support to bridge capacity gaps and enhance governance effectiveness.  

 

Strengthening policy capacity and improving governance arrangements are imperative for achieving the SDGs in the Global South. These efforts must prioritize inclusivity, accountability, and resilience, ensuring that no one is left behind. By addressing institutional weaknesses and fostering collaborative approaches, governments and stakeholders can unlock transformative pathways for sustainable development.  

 

Keywords: Policy capacity, governance arrangements, Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), Global South, policy coherence, decentralization, participatory governance, institutional capacity, sustainable development, global partnerships  

 

References

Avritzer, L. (2012). The two faces of institutional innovation: Promises and limits of democratic participation in Latin America. Kellogg Institute for International Studies.  

Cheeseman, N., Lynch, G., & Willis, J. (2016). Decentralization in Kenya: The governance of governors. The Journal of Modern African Studies, 54(1), 1-35.  

Grindle, M. S. (2007). Good enough governance revisited. Development Policy Review, 25(5), 553-574.  

Howlett, M. (2019). Designing public policies: Principles and instruments. Routledge.  

Nilsson, M., Griggs, D., & Visbeck, M. (2016). Policy: Map the interactions between Sustainable Development Goals. Nature, 534(7607), 320-322.  

UNDP. (2022). Capacity development for the SDGs. United Nations Development Programme.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Decentralization and Health Governance in Rajasthan: Insights from India’s Aspirational Districts Program
Isha Sharma (Indian Institute of Technology, Jodhpur)
CO-AUTHORS
Alok Ranjan (Indian Institute of Technology-Jodhpur)
Atul Pandey (Indian Institute of Technology Jodhpur)
Anindita Dey (Indian Institute of Technology Jodhpur (India))
ABSTRACT

Decentralization has been widely recognized as a critical governance strategy for improving service delivery and achieving sustainable development in resource-constrained settings. In India the Aspirational Districts Program (ADP) serves as a flagship initiative aimed at transforming underdeveloped districts across multiple dimensions, including health, to align with Sustainable Development Goal 3 (SDG 3). Rajasthan being one of India’s largest and socio-economically diverse states, offers a compelling backdrop for analyzing the effectiveness of decentralization in health governance. Therefore, this paper explores the role of decentralization in health governance within the ADP framework, analyzing its impact on improving health outcomes in Rajasthan. The study aligns with the panel’s overarching research question on optimizing governance arrangements and policy capacity to enhance SDG implementation in the Global South.

Against this background this study addresses two key questions; how has decentralization under the ADP influenced health governance structures in Rajasthan’s underdeveloped districts? and what lessons can be drawn from the ADP in Rajasthan for strengthening decentralized governance models in similar contexts? This paper leverages secondary data including progress reports from the ADP, health indicators from the Demographic and Health Survey (DHS), referred to as the National Family Health Survey (NFHS) in India and Health Management Information System (HMIS), and policy documents issued by NITI Aayog. The study used the third, fourth and fifth rounds of NFHS data collected in 200-06, 2015–16 and 2019–21 respectively. The third and fourth rounds serve as the pre-treatment and fifth round serve as post-treatment data for our analysis.

Preliminary findings highlight both successes and challenges. High-performing districts have demonstrated significant improvements in health indicators, while low-performing districts face persistent challenges, including capacity gaps among local officials, inadequate financial autonomy, and limited technical support. These disparities underscore the critical role of capacity building, financial decentralization, and participatory governance in achieving health equity. Additionally, the findings underscore the importance of fostering participatory governance to enhance accountability and service uptake. By examining the ADP’s decentralized health governance model in Rajasthan, this paper provides valuable lessons for policymakers and development practitioners aiming to leverage decentralization as a tool for achieving SDG 3 in underdeveloped regions.

This study contributes to the panel’s discourse on governance arrangements and policy capacity by illustrating how decentralization activates administrative and technical capacities at the district level. It aligns with the panel’s emphasis on dynamic governance arrangements and multi-level coordination, offering actionable insights for optimizing decentralized governance in the Global South.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Leveraging public engagement to improve healthcare quality: The role of community and stakeholder engagement in Colombia’s National Quality of Care Strategy
Kayla Benjamin (University of Toronto)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Abstract: Public engagement, also referred to as community and stakeholder engagement (CSE), and high-quality care are core components of strategies to achieve universal health coverage (UHC), one of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals. As part of the movement toward achieving UHC, Colombia has developed one of the first national quality-of-care strategies in the Latin America and Caribbean region. However, the degree to which public engagement was considered in the development and implementation of Colombia’s national quality of care strategy is not clearly understood. With a growing global consensus on the importance of public engagement in health systems and policy, this article reports on a qualitative case study comprising a document analysis followed by qualitative interviews to explore how CSE has been considered in the design and implementation of Colombia’s National Quality of Care Strategy. In an analysis guided by the Lavery framework for CSE, we address the following three research objectives: 1) describe how community and stakeholder engagement is reflected in Colombia’s National Quality of Care Strategy; 2) explore approaches undertaken to engage community and stakeholders in the development and implementation of the National Quality of Care Strategy and their perceived effectiveness; and 3) report on strengths and opportunities for improving CSE in health policymaking in Colombia. The study findings demonstrate a strong commitment to CSE in the development of national quality of care policies in Colombia. However, engagement approaches have received inconsistent political and financial support and have been poorly tracked, creating barriers to the meaningful engagement of the Colombian public in the development of the National Quality of Care Strategy. These findings hold important implications for Colombia and other jurisdictions. The article concludes with considerations for the design of effective and meaningful community and stakeholder engagement strategies in public policy relevant to this region and beyond.

 

Alignment with the T02P10 panel: This paper is relevant for the T02P10 panel as the present case study centers on two core components of strategies to achieve SDG Target 3.8 in Colombia: community and stakeholder engagement (CSE) and high-quality care. As WHO Director-General, Dr. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, wrote in his Lancet Global Health commentary, “Without quality, universal health coverage remains an empty promise.” In addition, this case study aligns with the panel theme ‘Collaborative Governance and Stakeholder Engagement,’ as we explore methods of CSE in the design and implementation of national health policy. We conclude this paper with considerations for the design of effective and meaningful CSE strategies that lend value to interdisciplinary discussions around improving the implementation of the SDGs in the Global South.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Understanding Policy Design and Integration to Enhance SDGs Implementation in the Global South
Bushra Faizi (Hamad Bin Khalifa University)
CO-AUTHORS
Evren Tok (Hamad Bin Khalifa University)
Mohamed Eskandar Shah (Hamad Bin Khalifa University)
ABSTRACT

Countries in the Global South (developing nations) face significant challenges in achieving the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). According to UN estimates, the Asia-Pacific region alone could fail to meet 90% of the 116 measurable SDG targets if current trends persist. This is particularly alarming for the poorest and most vulnerable communities, including women, children, and indigenous people. Given this urgency, a comprehensive review of existing policies is essential to ensure more innovative policy design and effective implementation. Strengthening policy capacity is crucial not only for advancing SDG achievements but also for benchmarking against the successful policies of the Global North. 
Another critical issue is the ambiguity surrounding the transformative potential of the SDGs. Despite years of implementation, many SDGs drive change primarily at the discursive level but fail to translate into substantive allocative and legislative policy reforms (Biermann et al., 2022).Recent research by Kidjie and Howlett (2024) highlights that the SDGs face challenges in policy integration due to the complex, “super-wicked” nature of the problems they address. Addressing these challenges requires capacity-building and improved coordination among stakeholders to better align policy goals. Furthermore, policy integration strategies must be designed in conjunction with the necessary policy capacities to ensure the effective implementation of the SDGs (Biermann et al., 2009). 
The objective of this research is to assess the existing policy landscape, evaluate effective policy design, and identify gaps in policy integration to advance the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the Global South. This assessment is crucial, as disparities in the region stem from various challenges, including financial constraints, limited institutional capacity, insufficient technology, climate change vulnerability, and a lack of resources and international support. To address these issues, this study examines the design, integration, and implementation of existing policies in the context of the UN’s 2030 SDG agenda. Specifically, it evaluates policy frameworks in Global South nations and their impact on SDG performance. Furthermore, this research evaluates the capacity of these nations to implement SDG policies by analyzing key metrics such as institutional, policy, administrative, governance, implementation, and innovation capacity, as derived from public policy theory and literature.  
Building on this assessment, the study aims to highlight critical areas requiring innovation and scaling. Using a mixed-methods approach, it will analyze policy documents, policy evaluation metrics, SDG performance reports, and macro-level data from the UN SDG Partnership Platform. The more specific objective is to provide a broad exploration of sustainable development policy design and examines regional and national case studies to illustrate policy formulation, decision-making, implementation, and evaluation. To conclude, this study directly addresses the panel’s key research question: How can policy capacity and governance arrangements in the Global South be optimized to enhance the effective implementation of SDGs? 
 

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - State Capacities for the Decarbonization of the Brazilian Agricultural Sector
Ana Pereira (Universidade de Brasília)
CO-AUTHORS
Rafael Cabral (Universidade de Brasília)
ABSTRACT

This paper examines the asymmetries in state capacity within Brazil regarding the implementation of climate change policies focused on the decarbonization of the agricultural sector. Specifically, it investigates the development of capacities and their variances within the federal bureaucracy as they relate to the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), particularly Goal 2 (Zero Hunger and Sustainable Agriculture) and Goal 13 (Climate Action).


The analysis of state capacities within agencies responsible for agricultural decarbonization is crucial, given Brazil's national and international commitments to mitigate climate change and reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. In the context of the Paris Agreement, Brazil has set ambitious targets in its Nationally Determined Contributions (NDC), aiming for a net GHG emission reduction of 48.4% from 2005 levels by 2025, targeting an absolute total of 1.32 GtCO2e (Brazil, 2023).


The agricultural sector is a significant contributor to Brazil’s emissions, accounting for approximately 27% of the country's total, second only to land-use changes (Observatório do Clima, 2022). As a result, this sector has become a focal point for discussions and policies aimed at promoting more sustainable production practices. Notable initiatives include the Low Carbon Agriculture Plan (ABC Plan) and the Minimum Price Guarantee Policy for Socio-Biodiversity Producers (PGPM-Bio) (Câmara et al., 2022).


However, the decarbonization policies within the agricultural sector encounter numerous challenges. One primary issue is the diversity of the sector itself, which necessitates policies that address both conventional agriculture and family farming, including agroecological practices. Additionally, the state's capacity to navigate this diversity and design effective public policy instruments that provide adequate incentives for transitioning to sustainable practices remains a significant hurdle. Literature on state capacity in Brazil highlights an asymmetry within public administration (Pereira, Mertens, and Abers, 2023; Cavalcante and Pereira, 2022). Research specific to agricultural decarbonization reveals evidence of heterogeneous capacities and insufficient coordination among key institutions, including the Ministry of Agricultural Development (MDA), the Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Supply (MAPA), and the Ministry of Environment and Climate Change (MMA) (Pereira et al., 2023).


In light of these challenges, this paper explores capacity asymmetries across three dimensions: 1) mapping the structures responsible for agricultural decarbonization within the MDA, MAPA, and MMA; 2) cataloging the policies and actions undertaken by each ministry in this domain; and 3) assessing the capabilities of each ministry concerning bureaucratic quality, budgetary resources, stakeholder engagement, and coordination at both sectoral and federal levels.
 
To operationalize the research, we used textual analysis of the ordinances and normative actions of these ministries; policy analysis based on the Integrated Budget and Planning System (SIOP); budget mapping of each ministry for actions to decarbonize agriculture, systematizing data from the public budget and international cooperation; mapping the quality of bureaucracy; mapping participatory institutions to deal with the issue in each ministry and analyzing their effectiveness; mapping instruments for federative and sectoral coordination.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Boundary-crossing strategies and climate change: issues of coordination - a case study of Local Climate Change Policy in Belo Horizonte, Brazil
Mariana Borges (Fundação João Pinheiro, Brazil)
CO-AUTHORS
Bruno Costa (Fundação João Pinheiro )
ABSTRACT

Climate change has been discussed and predicted for nearly half a century. Despite this, decisions to reverse global greenhouse gas emissions and rising extreme climate events remain pending. In Brazil, many issues tied to climate change fall under municipal responsibility, yet few local policies exist. Climate change can be characterized as a complex issue, for which boundary-crossing strategies offer a potential institutional solution. Normatively, this strategy relies on five pillars: a shared and integrated vision of the problem; dual, linked governance; articulation and identity among actors; an institutional arena; and stable legal and financial parameters (Abrucio, 2023). The first three pillars directly affect the logic of segmented organizational structures and imply changes that may provoke uncertainty and resistance, particularly in a context of diversity and asymmetry among actors, characterized by power imbalances and variations in resources, interests, and roles (Costa & Bronzo, 2012). So how are these policies being developed locally, considering their complexity? Does the government employ boundary-crossing management strategies to address climate change's multidimensional nature? More importantly, which sectors cooperate more, which resist, and what explains these differences?

This is a case study investigating Belo Horizonte’s climate action policy through the lens of boundary-crossing strategies. This policy is coordinated by the Secretariat for the Environment (SMMA) and supported by the Committee on Climate Change and Ecoefficiency (CMMCE), which brings together several public agencies. The research is descriptive and analytical and employs qualitative research methods. Relevant documents include the policy plans and the meeting minutes of CMMCE. Fieldwork was conducted at events related to the theme, using participant observation. Interviews were conducted with actors from municipal policy sectors involved in the policy, aiming to analyze the variety of boundary-crossing strategy levels and the related explanatory factors. An analytical model was developed to identify factors influencing sectoral propensity to engage in the boundary-crossing strategy. sectors are analyzed based on their specificities as professional fields and considering their trajectory of interaction with their main public problems. Through these dimensions, sectors weigh the potential costs and benefits of adopting boundary-crossing strategies using their own criteria.

Fieldwork revealed this policy targets medium levels of boundary-crossing strategies — characterized by joint planning and monitoring but sectoral implementation. Progress in stable legal and financial parameters and creating an institutional arena has been modest and recent. Power and legitimacy resources are limited yet growing, and there is no provision for hierarchical coordination mechanisms in its implementation. There is significant variation in sectoral commitment to boundary-crossing strategies, as sectors cooperate or defect based on their own cost-benefit assessments. Belo Horizonte has an ongoing climate policy and is one of the first Brazilian municipalities to develop specific actions on this theme. Analyzing the sectoral propensity to adopt this strategy is crucial to understanding the opportunities and challenges in developing climate action policies and other policies addressing complex public issues.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Civil Society Organizations and novel networks in food system governance during Covid-19 pandemic: insights for adaptive governance capacity
Guswin de Wee (University of the Western Cape)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

South Africa, like other countries in the Global South struggle to contend with goal 2 of the SDGs, which is to end hunger and achieve food insecurity. Households in South Africa was already food insecure, and the covid-19 lockdowns could have pushed more people into a food crisis to food price increases, loss of jobs and various essential services such as the school nutrition feeding program being halted (Knoll and Adelle, 2022). State-led innovations were inadequate to prevent food insecurity, and essentially the need for food relief outstripped the state capacity to deliver (Zhong et al., 2021).

   

This paper employs a case study approach, focusing on the City of Cape Town to explore the role of Civil Society Organisations (CSOs) [1]and novel networks in food governance during the Covid-19 pandemic, and how they contributed to governance capacity. [2]The City of Cape Town municipality in South Africa is selected due to its unique position prior to the lockdown, where regulations initially excluded CSOs from delivering food relief, presenting a distinctive scenario to study the evolution and impact of CSO involvement and novel networks in crisis response. Intervention of CSOs and novel networks presents a critical avenue for exploration in enhancing adaptive governance capacity.

 

The paper finds that CSOs and novel networks during the pandemic demonstrated adaptive capacity through adaptive governance arrangements which contributed to enhanced organisational operational capacity of the CoCT. Novel networks such as the Food Security Communities of Practice, the Food Forum and the Cape Town Together Community Action Network in the City of Cape Town pioneered ways to improve food access through coordinated partnerships. These social innovations enabled collective action, coordination and technological innovations, social learning, resources mobilisation, and resilience. Understanding the role of CSOs and novel networks in enhancing governance capacity is critical not only for addressing immediate crises such as the Covid-19 pandemic but also for informing long-term strategies to achieve SDGs in South Africa and beyond. Future research should focus on how CSOs and novel networks such as CoPs can be important cascading and integrating structures in adaptive governance capacity to achieve SDGs.



[1] This paper will adopt the definition for Civil Society Organisations from Adelle and Haywod (2021: 11) as non-State, not-for-profit, voluntary entities formed by people in the social sphere that are separate from the State and the market.
[2] Focusing on CSOs and novel networks in food system governance during Covid-19, this study examines organizational operational capacity within the larger policy capacity framework (Wu et al., 2015), which includes non-state actors and emphasizes implementation capacity. Due to the ongoing debate on ‘state capacity’ vs. ‘policy capacity,’ this paper uses ‘governance capacity’ (Brenton et al., 2022) to emphasize the ability of interorganizational networks to (1) cope with societal shocks and (2) reflect on and adapt their actions (Van Popering-Verkerk et al., 2022: 1774).

 

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Civil Society Organizations and novel networks in food system governance during Covid-19 pandemic: insights for adaptive governance capacity
Guswin de Wee (University of the Western Cape)
CO-AUTHORS
Amina Jakoet (Nelson Mandela University)
ABSTRACT

South Africa, like other countries in the Global South struggle to contend with goal 2 of the SDGs, which is to end hunger and achieve food insecurity. Households in South Africa were already food insecure, and the covid-19 lockdowns could have pushed more people into a food crisis due to food price increases, loss of jobs, and various essential services such as the school nutrition feeding program being halted (Knoll and Adelle, 2022). State-led innovations were inadequate to prevent food insecurity, and essentially the need for food relief outstripped the state capacity to deliver (Zhong et al., 2021).    

This paper employs a case study approach, focusing on the City of Cape Town to explore the role of Civil Society Organisations (CSOs)[1] and novel networks in food governance during the Covid-19 pandemic, and how they contributed to governance capacity.[2] The City of Cape Town municipality in South Africa is selected due to its unique position prior to the lockdown, where regulations initially excluded CSOs from delivering food relief, presenting a distinctive scenario to study the evolution and impact of CSO involvement and novel networks in crisis response. Intervention of CSOs and novel networks presents a critical avenue for exploration in enhancing adaptive governance capacity.

The paper finds that CSOs and novel networks during the pandemic demonstrated adaptive capacity through adaptive governance arrangements which contributed to enhanced organisational operational capacity of the CoCT. Novel networks such as the Food Security Communities of Practice, the Food Forum and the Cape Town Together Community Action Network in the City of Cape Town pioneered ways to improve food access through coordinated partnerships. These social innovations enabled collective action, coordination and technological innovations, social learning, resources mobilisation, and resilience. Understanding the role of CSOs and novel networks in enhancing governance capacity is critical not only for addressing immediate crises such as the Covid-19 pandemic but also for informing long-term strategies to achieve SDGs in South Africa and beyond. Future research should focus on how CSOs and novel networks such as CoPs can be important cascading and integrating structures in adaptive governance capacity to achieve SDGs.

Keywords: civil society organisations; food governance; governance capacity; sustainable development goals; resilience.

[1] This paper will adopt the definition for Civil Society Organisations from Adelle and Haywod (2021: 11) as non-State, not-for-profit, voluntary entities formed by people in the social sphere that are separate from the State and the market.
[2] Focusing on CSOs and novel networks in food system governance during Covid-19, this study examines organizational operational capacity within the larger policy capacity framework (Wu et al., 2015), which includes non-state actors and emphasizes implementation capacity. Due to the ongoing debate on ‘state capacity’ vs. ‘policy capacity,’ this paper uses ‘governance capacity’ (Brenton et al., 2022) to emphasize the ability of interorganizational networks to (1) cope with societal shocks and (2) reflect on and adapt their actions (Van Popering-Verkerk et al., 2022: 1774).

Cited Sources

Brenton, S., Baekkeskov, E. and Hannah, A., 2023. Policy capacity: Evolving theory and missing links. Policy Studies, 44(3), pp.297-315.

Kroll, F. and Adelle, C., 2022. Lockdown, resilience and emergency statecraft in the Cape Town food system. Cities, 131, p.104004.

Van Popering-Verkerk, J., Molenveld, A., Duijn, M., van Leeuwen, C. and van Buuren, A., 2022. A Framework for governance Capacity: A broad perspective on steering efforts in society. Administration & Society, 54(9), pp.1767-1794.

Wu, X., Ramesh, M. and Howlett, M., 2015. Policy capacity: A conceptual framework for understanding policy competences and capabilities. Policy and society, 34(3-4), pp.165-171.

Zhong, T., Crush, J., Si, Z. and Scott, S., 2021. Emergency food supplies and food security in Wuhan and Nanjing, China, during the COVID‐19 pandemic: Evidence from a field survey. Development Policy Review, 40(3), p.e12575.



 

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - Philanthropic foundations’ engagement in governance for nutrition in India: Collaborative governance approaches and dynamics of power in the context of state capacity limitations
Megan Arthur (Australian National University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The persistent burden of malnutrition in India, particularly child undernutrition, presents significant challenges for progress on the Sustainable Development Goals, including Goals 2 and 3, among others that are indirectly impacted. Governance failures within public services are highlighted as a significant contributor to inadequate improvements in child undernutrition, particularly due to  inadequate inter-sectoral coordination across government ministries and vertical integration through the levels of government. These public sector policy capacity limitations are understood as an important impetus for the involvement of non-state actors in governance for development, including social and health outcomes. Amid the rise of non-state actors in global policy processes for development, in the domain of health it has been argued that philanthropic foundations have experienced the most significant growth in their roles within governance processes. The focus of this study emerges from debates within the literature about the roles of philanthropic foundations within the contemporary crowded landscape of actors in which health and development issues are governed, and their contested implications for the balance of power among state and non-state actors.

 

This study examines these issues based on case studies of two philanthropic foundations involved in governance processes for nutrition at the national level in India, Tata Trusts and the Gates Foundation, through document analysis and qualitative interviews. The vast majority of study participants framed these philanthropies’ engagement as providing technical assistance in support of the state, often characterised as necessary due to limitations in the government’s capacity. Through funding the generation and mobilisation of evidence, as well as through the expertise of their staff, these philanthropies are understood to contribute ‘techno-managerial know-how’ to compensate for gaps due to inadequate training, the generalist civil service in India, and multi-level implementation challenges. Among the landscape of non-state actors, however, the financial resources held by these philanthropic foundations, alongside political dynamics of state hostility to civil society engagement, are understood by many to create power asymmetries with important implications for the nutrition governance environment.

 

Indeed, the de-politicising language of technical assistance is understood to obscure the political nature of the evidence generation and mobilisation functions that these philanthropies perform, and how these contribute to dynamics of power in the context of imbalances in financial resources. Empowered by their material resources, these philanthropies are understood to shape the ideational politics of governance for nutrition in this context. Generating particular types of evidence implicitly mobilises these within the governance arena given EBP norms. Moreover, these philanthropies’ material power is understood to allow them to focus funds in specific domain areas in a way that ‘overwhelms others’. Less well-resourced researchers, often community-based, have limited scope to generate alternative evidence, with implications for their legitimisation, and narrowing the scope for dissent within governance debates. Thus, this paper illuminates dynamics of power in relation to philanthropic foundations’ engagement in collaborative governance for nutrition in India in the context of state capacity limitations.

ACCEPTED
Format
11 - SHARED SERVICES CENTERS IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR: AN INTERNATIONAL COMPARATIVE STUDY IN GLOBAL SOUTH
Thaís Villela (Ministry of Management and Innovation in Public Services)
CO-AUTHORS
Joao Glass (MGI)
Wanessa Oliveira (University of Brasília (Brazil))
ABSTRACT

In the public sector, a Shared Services Center (SSC) refers to a government unit providing support services to more than one agency/ministry. Units that serve only a single agency/ministry are not considered SSCs (OECD, 2010). In a comparative study of SSCs in the public sector, Souza and Silva (2020) define SSCs as "a practice in which Public Administration shares a set of public services and activities, avoiding duplicated functions within their structures, aiming at cost reduction, improved service quality, and increased transparency." SSCs allow governments to focus their efforts on high-impact activities for their core mission, rather than on routine administrative tasks.

According to Ferreira et al. (2010), New Public Management (NPM) has encouraged the adoption of shared services in the public sector by incorporating advancements from private sector business management practices. The first formal SSCs in the public sector were identified in the 1990s, with notable examples in Australia and Canada. Since then, SSCs have become more common globally, with some labeling them as a "global megatrend" (Elston & MacCarthaigh, 2014 apud European Commission & Thijis, 2022). Numerous studies on SSCs in the public sector have been published, particularly in Europe, Australia, the United States, and Canada – the Global North.

This study addresses the gap in research on SSCs in Latin America and Africa by exploring practical examples in these regions. With a focus on the recent Brazilian federal government SSC (ColaboraGov), several questions are raised: Is the model adopted by Global South countries similar to that of the Global North? Which countries' models resemble the Brazilian federal government model (ColaboraGov)? In what aspects is Brazil innovating? What is ColaboraGov's potential impact on achieving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)?

The comparative analysis follows a methodology in three stages: 1) Gathering information on SSCs in Latin America and Africa, identifying key characteristics and services; 2) Comparative analysis to identify similarities and differences between SSCs in Latin America and Africa and those in developed countries from the Global North; 3) Specific analysis of ColaboraGov compared to other countries. The selection of cases for this study was made based on the official language of their government websites, restricted to Portuguese, Spanish, or English.

SSCs, known for over 20 years in the public sector, offer several advantages, including cost reduction and better allocation of resources, allowing agencies to focus on their core missions. However, in the Global South, except for Brazil, SSCs tend to be focused on specific areas (e.g., Information Technology or Human Resources). In the Global North, there are specialized SSCs, but it is also possible to find diverse SSC models offering a broader range of services. Initially treated as a “collaborative arrangement”, ColaboraGov formally became as an SSC in 2023. Nowadays it serves 13 ministries, which are directly aligned with 8 of the 17 SDGs from the UN 2030 Agenda - and indirectly supports the others. By relieving agencies of auxiliary services, ColaboraGov enhances their capacity to achieve their institutional missions, contributing to the global implementation of the SDGs.

ACCEPTED
Format
12 - Collaborative Citizen Centric Model of Governance: A Disruptive Innovation to resolves the Wicked Problem of Public Services Delivery in Delhi
AVANISH KUMAR (Management Development Institute, Gurgaon)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Cities and towns with robust governance structures were ideally positioned to deliver catalytic changes in people's lives by transforming the global SDG agenda into concrete action. These age-old governance structures became futile, irrespective of their reach and resources. Across the world, the governance structure collapsed due to Covid-19. Counties are still struggling to find appropriate alternatives to respond to the economic and social impact of COVID-19. It disrupted the access and utilization of physical structures to deliver public services, affecting millions of lives and livelihoods. However, South Delhi developed and adopted a mobile-based resilient citizen-centric collaborative governance model (e-Mohalla Sabha) during the COVID crisis. It could withstand social distancing and the virulence of COVID-19. The gap between the citizens and public services was reduced. Post-COVID-19, it has continued to make public services available without delay. The model serves citizens' needs and, at the same time, remains inclusive, resilient, and sustainable.

 

Based on interviews with decision-makers and users, the paper explores how this resilient governance model was designed and continues to deliver using a virtual platform. The interviews focused on conceptualizing the model and coordination between internal and external organizational structures and public service providers. Additionally, it builds upon analyzing users' lived experiences as participant observation as a member of e-Mohalla Sabha. The analysis overlaps lessons from theory and practice on the effectiveness of citizen centricity and efficiency of collaborative governance of public service design, development, and delivery as a resilient model.

 

Unlike Ansel and Gash's (2008) model, the findings suggest face-to-face collaborative governance. In the era of digital access, the state-society gap, the WhatsApp-based e-mohalla governance model overcomes notable and administrative exclusion. The ease of access to a citizen-centric model promotes trust with improved lateral (within government departments) and horizontal (with government and citizens) integration. The lateral and horizontal integration in the e-mohalla (e-neighborhood) model further enriches trust over existing social capital with the common interest of the neighborhood.

 

It concludes that timely, accountable stakeholder engagement coupled with access to responsible political leadership in the model can resolve the ‘wicked problems’ of high government administrative costs and low utilization of public services, resulting in high out-of-pocket expenditures. The paper recommends that the e-Mohalla Sabha model of urban governance provides an alternative model to millions of communities and settlements that remain excluded due to poor access to and low utilization of public services to achieve several programs addressing SDGs.  

 

ACCEPTED
Format
13 - Multi-level governance of Brazilian national policy systems: legal innovation in supporting SDG implementation
Isabela Ruiz (Université Panthéon-Assas (Paris II))
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In Brazil, the 1988 Constitution determined the structuring of a welfare state, aiming to guarantee social rights to all citizens. Those constitutional objectives are now strengthened by the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) of the 2030 Agenda.

To achieve those goals, some of the Brazilian social policies are currently organized in the legal-institutional form of systems, that is, with legal instruments designed to split the financing of state activities between the three levels of the federation, coordinate those actions, and ensure arenas and instruments for multi-level governance, with the participation of civil society and government representatives of federated entities in the decision-making process.

This mix of policy instruments was first implemented in the health system and then replicated in other sectoral policies, such as education and social assistance and, more recently, environmental protection, culture, and public security. Even though the policy design is very similar, for some of those sectoral policies, the results in terms of policy capacity, outcomes, and even the federative coordination have not been as effective.

This presentation discusses an ongoing study that compares the policy instruments of six national systems: Unified Health System (SUS), Unified Social Assistance System (SUAS), National Education System (SNE), National Environmental System (SISNAMA), Unified Public Security System (SUSP), and National Culture System (SNC). The main objective is to categorize the policy instruments of these systems into six dimensions of policy structuring: organizational (state capacity and managing agencies), substantive (the content of social provisions), participatory (state permeability to civil society demands), financial (economic sustainability of the policy), intergovernmental (relations between different levels of government), and instrumental (policy implementation mechanisms). Additionally, the study examines how legal and institutional frameworks shape the adaptability and responsiveness of these systems to emerging challenges, identifying mechanisms that enhance flexibility and innovation in governance.

Until now, the results show that the legacy of legal-institutional structuring of the different sectoral policies is an explanatory factor for variations in implementation outcomes. While the federal government has been successful in decentralizing programs through financial transfers to subnational entities in health and social assistance, the legacy of local provision of education and public security has posed challenges for federal coordination.

The research analyzes the difference in political capacity when it comes to citizen participation and multi-level governance arrangements across systems. The governance arrangements, constrained by rules, procedures, and institutions, can only be optimized when the institutional and political legacy of each sectorial policy is taken seriously.

This research highlights how legal studies on policy instruments can contribute to the discussion about political capacity, based on the types of norms and the sequence of approval of these norms, and also on the range of actors involved in the decision-making process.

The findings suggest that the legal arrangement of national systems contains policy instruments for intergovernmental coordination and collaboration with civil society and private sector actors that are crucial in organizing policy provision. More importantly, these instruments must be adapted to the specific context of each sector to effectively activate policy capacity and ensure the guarantee of constitutional rights and achievement of the SDG.

ACCEPTED
Format
14 - The Sustainable Development Goals as a Challenge and a Solution? Bridging Capacity Gaps at the Subnational Level
Cristhian Seiler (Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas (CONICET) (Argentina))
CO-AUTHORS
Mario Siede (Universidad Nacional de Entre Ríos)
ABSTRACT

Governments and public administrations share a growing concern about the conditions and requirements necessary to align and integrate public policies and programs that contribute to development outcomes. In federal countries, subnational levels face the challenge of mediating between society’s economic, social, and environmental demands and the territorialization of actions that provide substantive responses.

Within this framework, the adoption and implementation of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) present challenges to both technical and political capacities at different levels of state management, as they clash with the fragmented and uncoordinated nature of public policies. However, the logical, methodological, instrumental, and strategic aspects underlying the SDGs can serve as a key tool to enhance and catalyze public planning processes, helping to address these challenges.

This paper explores the opportunities and challenges that the 2030 Agenda and the SDGs present to public administrations as they engage in new interactions. It highlights that the SDGs not only provide direction and establish horizons for public action but also challenge administrations to bridge capacity gaps in coordination and articulation for their effective implementation.

The study seeks to contribute conceptual insights and empirical evidence to the literature on state capacities, SDG implementation, and coordination at the subnational (provincial or state) level. Without aiming for generalization, it presents evidence from three Argentine provinces suggesting that the SDGs trigger or catalyze processes that strengthen public planning, identify the public value added by provincial administrations, and, in particular, bridge capacity gaps to strategically address the traditionally fragmented and sectoral functioning of public administrations.

The analysis of provincial experiences, based on interviews and documentary materials, reveals significant institutional advancements that go beyond the mere adoption of the goals. The increasing focus on the 2030 Agenda and the SDGs has created a window of opportunity for learning, the development of structures, and institutional innovation in the coordination and articulation of provincial public administration. These advancements have strengthened strategic planning, public action, and the value it generates for territorial development.

ACCEPTED
Format
15 - Need for Policy Design, Institutional Development, and Community Empowerment for Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs): A Case Study from India
D.N. Gupta (National Institute of Advanced Studies)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Among others, sustainable development is contingent upon how government agencies deliver; how social system organizes citizens; and how people respond to, participate in and contribute to the development process and, thus, avail benefits to raise their quality of life, thereby achieving sustainable development goals (SDGs). The research studies highlight that resources are important but can be optimally and efficiently utilized through sound policies, robust institutions, and empowered citizens. The policies are necessary for efficient management of resources; right institutions can enhance the trust in the community and sustain the interventions; and empowered citizens can ensure effective implementation of programs. And, together they will provide sustainability to the development. 

 

In the context of SDGs, the UN Sustainable Development Report 2024 has underscored several concerns for developing countries, highlighting that only 16 percent of the SDG targets are on track, with the remaining 84 percent show poor progress. Against this backdrop, it calls for examining the policy system, institutional mechanisms, and role of community in realizing the SDG targets.

 

For the case study, the paper has chosen Kerala state in India. The methodology makes use of literature review together with the field research. It involves consultations with stakeholders, especially with citizens and elected members at the level of local institutions. It attempts to study critical factors, like efficacy of public policies, institutional reforms, capacity building of local implementing agencies, and community empowerment, which have contributed to the success of achieving SDGs in Kerala state. For policymaking, it observes that there is a bottom-up approach. The policies related to school education, health and sanitation, drinking water, and waste management have been studied. These take into consideration the feedback from citizens, local needs, ground realities, and implementation capacity of local institutions.

 

For over three decades, in Kerala, there has been emphasis on institutional reforms in terms of defining rules and structures for decision-making, transparency, efficiency, improving reach to grassroots, and accountability. There is devolution of power for decision-making on one hand and strengthening of transparency and accountability to people on the other. There is perceptible strengthening of decentralization of power through various such measures. The decentralization program has laid stress on capacity building of local institutions. It has resulted in many notable features like: political vision for local development planning; new work culture in local administration to promote people’s participation; enhanced competence; evolution of network of communities; innovative projects; and improved last-mile reach to vulnerable sections. The political parties involve themselves in local development, and there is a sense of ownership in them.

 

It presents a framework to examine how public policies, institutions, and community empowerment can add value to sustainability and to explore how these three aspects can contribute to sustainable development.

 

 

 

Select references:

-  Dovers S. (2005). Policy assessment for sustainability: institutional issues and options.

-  Connor and Dovers (2004). Institutional Change for Sustainable Development. Edward Elgar Publishing.

-  Sachs et. al. (2024). The SDGs and the UN Summit of the Future. Sustainable Development Report 2024.

 

 

 

ACCEPTED
Format
16 - Service-Specific Administrative Capacity and collaborative service delivery in Achieving SDGs: A Study of Water, Sanitation, and Waste Management in Peruvian local governments
Mariana Ballen (Pontificia Universidad Católica del Peru)
CO-AUTHORS
edgardo Cruzado (Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú)
ABSTRACT

Achieving the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development in the Global South, particularly in Latin America, faces major challenges, with progress stagnating or reversing in some areas (UN DESA, 2024). Meeting SDG targets on public service access and quality, such as water, sanitation (SDG 6), and waste management (SDG 11), is particularly difficult due to varying capacities of local governments.
In Peru, access to public water has slightly declined, and 24% of households lack sanitation services. In solid waste management, 40% face inadequate waste disposal. A particular aspect of the 20-year decentralization process is the creation of 70 additional local governments, based on the premise that this will contribute to a greater allocation of resources and improved well-being of citizens in the new local governments. In 2024 alone, regulatory initiatives have been proposed to create 37 additional local governments, but its impact on service delivery remains unclear.
The research question investigates the extent to which local-level, service-specific administrative capacity influences service performance, and how territorial conditions and the creation of new local governments impact service provision. A local government service delivery capacity index will be developed, providing a tool to identify opportunities for collaborative service delivery between local governments and other stakeholders, thereby contributing to the advancement of SDG targets.
To support the results, we use a panel database of Peruvian local governments for the period 2015-2023. The methodological approach consists of two stages:
i) Estimation and analysis of local government efficiency through the construction of an index using principal component analysis, with inputs from variables related to public services. The dynamics over time will also be assessed to analyze progress or limitations throughout the study period, considering the typology of local governments and their territorial behavior. This will help identify patterns related to local or geographical conditions through spatial autocorrelation measures.
ii) Analysis of the explanatory factors of local government efficiency: This stage aims to understand which factors—such as territorial, economic, or social aspects—may affect or condition improvements (or lack thereof) in efficiency. Special attention will be given to the time of creation of local governments to understand the impact of their increase. Spatial models will be used to capture potential dependencies between territories, accounting for unobservable factors that come with working with spatial units, due to the marked heterogeneity within the national territory.
This paper addresses how local administrative capacity impact service performance, particularly in water, sanitation, and waste management and exploring how new local governments may struggle to meet SDG targets, offering insights into governance arrangements and policy capacity deployment. The study also provides a means to collaborative governance to overcome lack of administrative skills at the local level with the aim of enhancing SDG outcomes in the Global South.

ACCEPTED
Format
17 - State capacity at municipal and state level and student achievement differences the case of Brazil
Natália Sátyro (Federal University of Minas Gerais)
CO-AUTHORS
Pedro Cunha (Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais)
Filipe Recch (University of Pittsburgh)
Bruno Costa (Fundação João Pinheiro )
ABSTRACT

Natália Sátyro – Federal University of Minas Gerais

Filipe Reech – Pittsburg University

Pedro Cunha – Câmara Municipal de Belo Horizonte

Bruno Lazarotti Diniz – Fundação João Pinheiro

 

Public primary and middle schools (1st  to 9th  grades) in Brazil's complex education system are managed in each state by both state and municipal administrations, noting that we have 5570 municipalities and 26 states). These variety and parallel school administrations in the same school districts generate differences in the quality of schooling. The familiar background and teacher and school characteristics, as well the characteristics of the head of school impact on student performance have a considerable accumulation in Brazilian literature. However, much less has been analyzed about the state capacity at the municipal and state secretariat level and the state capacity of the municipality as a whole. This paper intends to evaluate the effects of state capacity within the municipal and state secretariat and the state capacity of the municipality beyond the educational area on student performance. Econometric models that consider the hierarchy of data were used and our findings show that specific characteristics of the departments (at municipal and state level), as well as the municipality's planning capacity, influence student proficiency.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

State-owned enterprises (SOEs) play a critical role in the global economy, serving as key drivers in delivering public services, fostering economic growth, and addressing societal challenges, such as those related to the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). These entities, governed through diverse ownership and coordination models, differ widely across countries in terms of structure, operational capacity, funding mechanisms, and contributions to socioeconomic progress. Despite their significance, the governance frameworks for SOEs vary greatly, reflecting unique national contexts.

This paper aims to propose a tentative typology for SOE governance worldwide by examining existing governance models, comparing the performance of SOEs across developed and developing nations, and evaluating their impact on corporate governance and broader economic outcomes. By analyzing these models, the study seeks to identify the factors that influence governance choices in different countries and their implications for SOE performance.

The paper begins by examining the primary state ownership models discussed in the literature, including the "dual ownership" model, the "centralized ownership" model, and the "coordinating agency" model, as well as hybrid approaches like the "dual-track" model. Drawing on the work of Mazzucato et al. (2024), it integrates OECD governance classifications to evaluate the degree of coordination within each model, ranging from low to high levels of state intervention (OECD, 2024). Despite the availability of these theoretical frameworks, there is no clear consensus on how to classify countries into specific models or establish standardized criteria for such classifications. This lack of clarity hampers a comprehensive understanding of how SOEs operate across diverse political and economic contexts, especially regarding their contributions to achieving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). To address this gap, additional criteria are crucial for capturing the diversity of SOE governance models worldwide. These criteria include their significance within the national economy, market share, financial dependence, budget size, role in advancing national political priorities, and whether they have publicly traded capital.

The paper also addresses several central research questions: How do different state ownership governance models influence SOEs’ policy capacity and performance? What criteria should guide the classification of countries into these models? How does state ownership impact corporate governance, including decision-making, transparency, and accountability? To answer these questions, the study employs a comparative methodology, analyzing governance models across countries at varying stages of development, with a focus on both advanced economies and nations in the Global South. Through detailed case studies of prominent SOEs, the paper highlights best practices, common challenges, and critical lessons that can inform future governance frameworks. It also considers contextual factors such as economic size, institutional history, political systems, and specific challenges related to development in its broader sense.

Ultimately, this research seeks to contribute to academic and policy discussions by offering empirical evidence and practical insights for policymakers, practitioners, and scholars. It aims to provide a structured typology for understanding SOE governance, evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of various models, and propose recommendations for enhancing SOE performance, transparency, and accountability.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Title:
"Strengthening Institutional Capacity and Governance Frameworks for Advancing Sustainable Development Goals in the Global South"

 

Abstract

 

Policy capacity and governance arrangements are critical determinants of progress toward achieving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), particularly in the Global South, where systemic challenges such as weak institutions, resource constraints, and socio-economic disparities are prevalent. Policy capacity encompasses the ability of governments and institutions to formulate, implement, and evaluate policies effectively, while governance arrangements define the structures and processes that enable inclusive, transparent, and accountable decision-making. Strengthening these elements is essential for addressing complex and interlinked SDG targets, from poverty eradication and climate action to education and health improvements.  

 

In the Global South, limited policy capacity often results from institutional fragmentation, lack of technical expertise, and inadequate resource mobilization (Howlett, 2019). This capacity deficit hinders the development and implementation of policies aligned with the SDGs, leading to uneven progress across sectors and regions. For example, low-income countries often struggle to integrate environmental sustainability into national policies while addressing pressing socio-economic priorities, such as poverty reduction and employment generation (Grindle, 2007). Moreover, governance arrangements in many countries remain constrained by centralized decision-making, weak accountability mechanisms, and insufficient stakeholder participation, exacerbating inequalities and undermining trust in public institutions.  

 

A critical pathway to overcoming these challenges involves enhancing policy capacity through capacity-building initiatives, knowledge sharing, and technology transfer. Programs that provide training for policymakers, facilitate South-South cooperation, and promote multi-stakeholder partnerships can strengthen institutional capabilities to address SDG targets. For instance, capacity-building programs supported by international organizations, such as the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), have demonstrated positive outcomes in improving governance and policy design in areas like climate adaptation and social protection (UNDP, 2022).  

 

Governance arrangements also play a pivotal role in determining the effectiveness of SDG implementation. Decentralization and participatory governance models have been identified as promising approaches for fostering inclusive decision-making and empowering local communities. In Brazil, for instance, participatory budgeting initiatives have enhanced transparency and accountability while enabling marginalized populations to influence resource allocation (Avritzer, 2012). Similarly, Kenya’s devolved governance system has improved access to essential services, such as healthcare and education, in previously underserved regions (Cheeseman et al., 2016). However, the success of these arrangements depends on the presence of robust institutions, effective leadership, and mechanisms for conflict resolution.  

 

Furthermore, the integration of the SDGs into national and subnational planning frameworks requires coherence and alignment across policy domains. Policy coherence ensures that efforts to achieve one SDG do not undermine progress toward others, particularly in contexts where trade-offs between social, economic, and environmental goals are unavoidable. For example, policies promoting industrial growth must simultaneously address environmental sustainability and social equity to avoid exacerbating climate change or displacing vulnerable communities (Nilsson et al., 2016).  

 

This research contributes to the understanding of policy capacity and governance arrangements by analyzing their role in accelerating SDG implementation in the Global South. It highlights successful case studies and identifies best practices for overcoming governance challenges and building resilient policy systems. The study also underscores the importance of fostering global partnerships and leveraging international support to bridge capacity gaps and enhance governance effectiveness.  

 

Strengthening policy capacity and improving governance arrangements are imperative for achieving the SDGs in the Global South. These efforts must prioritize inclusivity, accountability, and resilience, ensuring that no one is left behind. By addressing institutional weaknesses and fostering collaborative approaches, governments and stakeholders can unlock transformative pathways for sustainable development.  

 

Keywords: Policy capacity, governance arrangements, Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), Global South, policy coherence, decentralization, participatory governance, institutional capacity, sustainable development, global partnerships  

 

References

Avritzer, L. (2012). The two faces of institutional innovation: Promises and limits of democratic participation in Latin America. Kellogg Institute for International Studies.  

Cheeseman, N., Lynch, G., & Willis, J. (2016). Decentralization in Kenya: The governance of governors. The Journal of Modern African Studies, 54(1), 1-35.  

Grindle, M. S. (2007). Good enough governance revisited. Development Policy Review, 25(5), 553-574.  

Howlett, M. (2019). Designing public policies: Principles and instruments. Routledge.  

Nilsson, M., Griggs, D., & Visbeck, M. (2016). Policy: Map the interactions between Sustainable Development Goals. Nature, 534(7607), 320-322.  

UNDP. (2022). Capacity development for the SDGs. United Nations Development Programme.

CO-AUTHORS
Alok Ranjan (Indian Institute of Technology-Jodhpur)
Atul Pandey (Indian Institute of Technology Jodhpur)
Anindita Dey (Indian Institute of Technology Jodhpur (India))
ABSTRACT

Decentralization has been widely recognized as a critical governance strategy for improving service delivery and achieving sustainable development in resource-constrained settings. In India the Aspirational Districts Program (ADP) serves as a flagship initiative aimed at transforming underdeveloped districts across multiple dimensions, including health, to align with Sustainable Development Goal 3 (SDG 3). Rajasthan being one of India’s largest and socio-economically diverse states, offers a compelling backdrop for analyzing the effectiveness of decentralization in health governance. Therefore, this paper explores the role of decentralization in health governance within the ADP framework, analyzing its impact on improving health outcomes in Rajasthan. The study aligns with the panel’s overarching research question on optimizing governance arrangements and policy capacity to enhance SDG implementation in the Global South.

Against this background this study addresses two key questions; how has decentralization under the ADP influenced health governance structures in Rajasthan’s underdeveloped districts? and what lessons can be drawn from the ADP in Rajasthan for strengthening decentralized governance models in similar contexts? This paper leverages secondary data including progress reports from the ADP, health indicators from the Demographic and Health Survey (DHS), referred to as the National Family Health Survey (NFHS) in India and Health Management Information System (HMIS), and policy documents issued by NITI Aayog. The study used the third, fourth and fifth rounds of NFHS data collected in 200-06, 2015–16 and 2019–21 respectively. The third and fourth rounds serve as the pre-treatment and fifth round serve as post-treatment data for our analysis.

Preliminary findings highlight both successes and challenges. High-performing districts have demonstrated significant improvements in health indicators, while low-performing districts face persistent challenges, including capacity gaps among local officials, inadequate financial autonomy, and limited technical support. These disparities underscore the critical role of capacity building, financial decentralization, and participatory governance in achieving health equity. Additionally, the findings underscore the importance of fostering participatory governance to enhance accountability and service uptake. By examining the ADP’s decentralized health governance model in Rajasthan, this paper provides valuable lessons for policymakers and development practitioners aiming to leverage decentralization as a tool for achieving SDG 3 in underdeveloped regions.

This study contributes to the panel’s discourse on governance arrangements and policy capacity by illustrating how decentralization activates administrative and technical capacities at the district level. It aligns with the panel’s emphasis on dynamic governance arrangements and multi-level coordination, offering actionable insights for optimizing decentralized governance in the Global South.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Abstract: Public engagement, also referred to as community and stakeholder engagement (CSE), and high-quality care are core components of strategies to achieve universal health coverage (UHC), one of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals. As part of the movement toward achieving UHC, Colombia has developed one of the first national quality-of-care strategies in the Latin America and Caribbean region. However, the degree to which public engagement was considered in the development and implementation of Colombia’s national quality of care strategy is not clearly understood. With a growing global consensus on the importance of public engagement in health systems and policy, this article reports on a qualitative case study comprising a document analysis followed by qualitative interviews to explore how CSE has been considered in the design and implementation of Colombia’s National Quality of Care Strategy. In an analysis guided by the Lavery framework for CSE, we address the following three research objectives: 1) describe how community and stakeholder engagement is reflected in Colombia’s National Quality of Care Strategy; 2) explore approaches undertaken to engage community and stakeholders in the development and implementation of the National Quality of Care Strategy and their perceived effectiveness; and 3) report on strengths and opportunities for improving CSE in health policymaking in Colombia. The study findings demonstrate a strong commitment to CSE in the development of national quality of care policies in Colombia. However, engagement approaches have received inconsistent political and financial support and have been poorly tracked, creating barriers to the meaningful engagement of the Colombian public in the development of the National Quality of Care Strategy. These findings hold important implications for Colombia and other jurisdictions. The article concludes with considerations for the design of effective and meaningful community and stakeholder engagement strategies in public policy relevant to this region and beyond.

 

Alignment with the T02P10 panel: This paper is relevant for the T02P10 panel as the present case study centers on two core components of strategies to achieve SDG Target 3.8 in Colombia: community and stakeholder engagement (CSE) and high-quality care. As WHO Director-General, Dr. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, wrote in his Lancet Global Health commentary, “Without quality, universal health coverage remains an empty promise.” In addition, this case study aligns with the panel theme ‘Collaborative Governance and Stakeholder Engagement,’ as we explore methods of CSE in the design and implementation of national health policy. We conclude this paper with considerations for the design of effective and meaningful CSE strategies that lend value to interdisciplinary discussions around improving the implementation of the SDGs in the Global South.

CO-AUTHORS
Evren Tok (Hamad Bin Khalifa University)
Mohamed Eskandar Shah (Hamad Bin Khalifa University)
ABSTRACT

Countries in the Global South (developing nations) face significant challenges in achieving the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). According to UN estimates, the Asia-Pacific region alone could fail to meet 90% of the 116 measurable SDG targets if current trends persist. This is particularly alarming for the poorest and most vulnerable communities, including women, children, and indigenous people. Given this urgency, a comprehensive review of existing policies is essential to ensure more innovative policy design and effective implementation. Strengthening policy capacity is crucial not only for advancing SDG achievements but also for benchmarking against the successful policies of the Global North. 
Another critical issue is the ambiguity surrounding the transformative potential of the SDGs. Despite years of implementation, many SDGs drive change primarily at the discursive level but fail to translate into substantive allocative and legislative policy reforms (Biermann et al., 2022).Recent research by Kidjie and Howlett (2024) highlights that the SDGs face challenges in policy integration due to the complex, “super-wicked” nature of the problems they address. Addressing these challenges requires capacity-building and improved coordination among stakeholders to better align policy goals. Furthermore, policy integration strategies must be designed in conjunction with the necessary policy capacities to ensure the effective implementation of the SDGs (Biermann et al., 2009). 
The objective of this research is to assess the existing policy landscape, evaluate effective policy design, and identify gaps in policy integration to advance the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the Global South. This assessment is crucial, as disparities in the region stem from various challenges, including financial constraints, limited institutional capacity, insufficient technology, climate change vulnerability, and a lack of resources and international support. To address these issues, this study examines the design, integration, and implementation of existing policies in the context of the UN’s 2030 SDG agenda. Specifically, it evaluates policy frameworks in Global South nations and their impact on SDG performance. Furthermore, this research evaluates the capacity of these nations to implement SDG policies by analyzing key metrics such as institutional, policy, administrative, governance, implementation, and innovation capacity, as derived from public policy theory and literature.  
Building on this assessment, the study aims to highlight critical areas requiring innovation and scaling. Using a mixed-methods approach, it will analyze policy documents, policy evaluation metrics, SDG performance reports, and macro-level data from the UN SDG Partnership Platform. The more specific objective is to provide a broad exploration of sustainable development policy design and examines regional and national case studies to illustrate policy formulation, decision-making, implementation, and evaluation. To conclude, this study directly addresses the panel’s key research question: How can policy capacity and governance arrangements in the Global South be optimized to enhance the effective implementation of SDGs? 
 

CO-AUTHORS
Rafael Cabral (Universidade de Brasília)
ABSTRACT

This paper examines the asymmetries in state capacity within Brazil regarding the implementation of climate change policies focused on the decarbonization of the agricultural sector. Specifically, it investigates the development of capacities and their variances within the federal bureaucracy as they relate to the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), particularly Goal 2 (Zero Hunger and Sustainable Agriculture) and Goal 13 (Climate Action).


The analysis of state capacities within agencies responsible for agricultural decarbonization is crucial, given Brazil's national and international commitments to mitigate climate change and reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. In the context of the Paris Agreement, Brazil has set ambitious targets in its Nationally Determined Contributions (NDC), aiming for a net GHG emission reduction of 48.4% from 2005 levels by 2025, targeting an absolute total of 1.32 GtCO2e (Brazil, 2023).


The agricultural sector is a significant contributor to Brazil’s emissions, accounting for approximately 27% of the country's total, second only to land-use changes (Observatório do Clima, 2022). As a result, this sector has become a focal point for discussions and policies aimed at promoting more sustainable production practices. Notable initiatives include the Low Carbon Agriculture Plan (ABC Plan) and the Minimum Price Guarantee Policy for Socio-Biodiversity Producers (PGPM-Bio) (Câmara et al., 2022).


However, the decarbonization policies within the agricultural sector encounter numerous challenges. One primary issue is the diversity of the sector itself, which necessitates policies that address both conventional agriculture and family farming, including agroecological practices. Additionally, the state's capacity to navigate this diversity and design effective public policy instruments that provide adequate incentives for transitioning to sustainable practices remains a significant hurdle. Literature on state capacity in Brazil highlights an asymmetry within public administration (Pereira, Mertens, and Abers, 2023; Cavalcante and Pereira, 2022). Research specific to agricultural decarbonization reveals evidence of heterogeneous capacities and insufficient coordination among key institutions, including the Ministry of Agricultural Development (MDA), the Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Supply (MAPA), and the Ministry of Environment and Climate Change (MMA) (Pereira et al., 2023).


In light of these challenges, this paper explores capacity asymmetries across three dimensions: 1) mapping the structures responsible for agricultural decarbonization within the MDA, MAPA, and MMA; 2) cataloging the policies and actions undertaken by each ministry in this domain; and 3) assessing the capabilities of each ministry concerning bureaucratic quality, budgetary resources, stakeholder engagement, and coordination at both sectoral and federal levels.
 
To operationalize the research, we used textual analysis of the ordinances and normative actions of these ministries; policy analysis based on the Integrated Budget and Planning System (SIOP); budget mapping of each ministry for actions to decarbonize agriculture, systematizing data from the public budget and international cooperation; mapping the quality of bureaucracy; mapping participatory institutions to deal with the issue in each ministry and analyzing their effectiveness; mapping instruments for federative and sectoral coordination.

CO-AUTHORS
Bruno Costa (Fundação João Pinheiro )
ABSTRACT

Climate change has been discussed and predicted for nearly half a century. Despite this, decisions to reverse global greenhouse gas emissions and rising extreme climate events remain pending. In Brazil, many issues tied to climate change fall under municipal responsibility, yet few local policies exist. Climate change can be characterized as a complex issue, for which boundary-crossing strategies offer a potential institutional solution. Normatively, this strategy relies on five pillars: a shared and integrated vision of the problem; dual, linked governance; articulation and identity among actors; an institutional arena; and stable legal and financial parameters (Abrucio, 2023). The first three pillars directly affect the logic of segmented organizational structures and imply changes that may provoke uncertainty and resistance, particularly in a context of diversity and asymmetry among actors, characterized by power imbalances and variations in resources, interests, and roles (Costa & Bronzo, 2012). So how are these policies being developed locally, considering their complexity? Does the government employ boundary-crossing management strategies to address climate change's multidimensional nature? More importantly, which sectors cooperate more, which resist, and what explains these differences?

This is a case study investigating Belo Horizonte’s climate action policy through the lens of boundary-crossing strategies. This policy is coordinated by the Secretariat for the Environment (SMMA) and supported by the Committee on Climate Change and Ecoefficiency (CMMCE), which brings together several public agencies. The research is descriptive and analytical and employs qualitative research methods. Relevant documents include the policy plans and the meeting minutes of CMMCE. Fieldwork was conducted at events related to the theme, using participant observation. Interviews were conducted with actors from municipal policy sectors involved in the policy, aiming to analyze the variety of boundary-crossing strategy levels and the related explanatory factors. An analytical model was developed to identify factors influencing sectoral propensity to engage in the boundary-crossing strategy. sectors are analyzed based on their specificities as professional fields and considering their trajectory of interaction with their main public problems. Through these dimensions, sectors weigh the potential costs and benefits of adopting boundary-crossing strategies using their own criteria.

Fieldwork revealed this policy targets medium levels of boundary-crossing strategies — characterized by joint planning and monitoring but sectoral implementation. Progress in stable legal and financial parameters and creating an institutional arena has been modest and recent. Power and legitimacy resources are limited yet growing, and there is no provision for hierarchical coordination mechanisms in its implementation. There is significant variation in sectoral commitment to boundary-crossing strategies, as sectors cooperate or defect based on their own cost-benefit assessments. Belo Horizonte has an ongoing climate policy and is one of the first Brazilian municipalities to develop specific actions on this theme. Analyzing the sectoral propensity to adopt this strategy is crucial to understanding the opportunities and challenges in developing climate action policies and other policies addressing complex public issues.

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

South Africa, like other countries in the Global South struggle to contend with goal 2 of the SDGs, which is to end hunger and achieve food insecurity. Households in South Africa was already food insecure, and the covid-19 lockdowns could have pushed more people into a food crisis to food price increases, loss of jobs and various essential services such as the school nutrition feeding program being halted (Knoll and Adelle, 2022). State-led innovations were inadequate to prevent food insecurity, and essentially the need for food relief outstripped the state capacity to deliver (Zhong et al., 2021).

   

This paper employs a case study approach, focusing on the City of Cape Town to explore the role of Civil Society Organisations (CSOs) [1]and novel networks in food governance during the Covid-19 pandemic, and how they contributed to governance capacity. [2]The City of Cape Town municipality in South Africa is selected due to its unique position prior to the lockdown, where regulations initially excluded CSOs from delivering food relief, presenting a distinctive scenario to study the evolution and impact of CSO involvement and novel networks in crisis response. Intervention of CSOs and novel networks presents a critical avenue for exploration in enhancing adaptive governance capacity.

 

The paper finds that CSOs and novel networks during the pandemic demonstrated adaptive capacity through adaptive governance arrangements which contributed to enhanced organisational operational capacity of the CoCT. Novel networks such as the Food Security Communities of Practice, the Food Forum and the Cape Town Together Community Action Network in the City of Cape Town pioneered ways to improve food access through coordinated partnerships. These social innovations enabled collective action, coordination and technological innovations, social learning, resources mobilisation, and resilience. Understanding the role of CSOs and novel networks in enhancing governance capacity is critical not only for addressing immediate crises such as the Covid-19 pandemic but also for informing long-term strategies to achieve SDGs in South Africa and beyond. Future research should focus on how CSOs and novel networks such as CoPs can be important cascading and integrating structures in adaptive governance capacity to achieve SDGs.



[1] This paper will adopt the definition for Civil Society Organisations from Adelle and Haywod (2021: 11) as non-State, not-for-profit, voluntary entities formed by people in the social sphere that are separate from the State and the market.
[2] Focusing on CSOs and novel networks in food system governance during Covid-19, this study examines organizational operational capacity within the larger policy capacity framework (Wu et al., 2015), which includes non-state actors and emphasizes implementation capacity. Due to the ongoing debate on ‘state capacity’ vs. ‘policy capacity,’ this paper uses ‘governance capacity’ (Brenton et al., 2022) to emphasize the ability of interorganizational networks to (1) cope with societal shocks and (2) reflect on and adapt their actions (Van Popering-Verkerk et al., 2022: 1774).

 

CO-AUTHORS
Amina Jakoet (Nelson Mandela University)
ABSTRACT

South Africa, like other countries in the Global South struggle to contend with goal 2 of the SDGs, which is to end hunger and achieve food insecurity. Households in South Africa were already food insecure, and the covid-19 lockdowns could have pushed more people into a food crisis due to food price increases, loss of jobs, and various essential services such as the school nutrition feeding program being halted (Knoll and Adelle, 2022). State-led innovations were inadequate to prevent food insecurity, and essentially the need for food relief outstripped the state capacity to deliver (Zhong et al., 2021).    

This paper employs a case study approach, focusing on the City of Cape Town to explore the role of Civil Society Organisations (CSOs)[1] and novel networks in food governance during the Covid-19 pandemic, and how they contributed to governance capacity.[2] The City of Cape Town municipality in South Africa is selected due to its unique position prior to the lockdown, where regulations initially excluded CSOs from delivering food relief, presenting a distinctive scenario to study the evolution and impact of CSO involvement and novel networks in crisis response. Intervention of CSOs and novel networks presents a critical avenue for exploration in enhancing adaptive governance capacity.

The paper finds that CSOs and novel networks during the pandemic demonstrated adaptive capacity through adaptive governance arrangements which contributed to enhanced organisational operational capacity of the CoCT. Novel networks such as the Food Security Communities of Practice, the Food Forum and the Cape Town Together Community Action Network in the City of Cape Town pioneered ways to improve food access through coordinated partnerships. These social innovations enabled collective action, coordination and technological innovations, social learning, resources mobilisation, and resilience. Understanding the role of CSOs and novel networks in enhancing governance capacity is critical not only for addressing immediate crises such as the Covid-19 pandemic but also for informing long-term strategies to achieve SDGs in South Africa and beyond. Future research should focus on how CSOs and novel networks such as CoPs can be important cascading and integrating structures in adaptive governance capacity to achieve SDGs.

Keywords: civil society organisations; food governance; governance capacity; sustainable development goals; resilience.

[1] This paper will adopt the definition for Civil Society Organisations from Adelle and Haywod (2021: 11) as non-State, not-for-profit, voluntary entities formed by people in the social sphere that are separate from the State and the market.
[2] Focusing on CSOs and novel networks in food system governance during Covid-19, this study examines organizational operational capacity within the larger policy capacity framework (Wu et al., 2015), which includes non-state actors and emphasizes implementation capacity. Due to the ongoing debate on ‘state capacity’ vs. ‘policy capacity,’ this paper uses ‘governance capacity’ (Brenton et al., 2022) to emphasize the ability of interorganizational networks to (1) cope with societal shocks and (2) reflect on and adapt their actions (Van Popering-Verkerk et al., 2022: 1774).

Cited Sources

Brenton, S., Baekkeskov, E. and Hannah, A., 2023. Policy capacity: Evolving theory and missing links. Policy Studies, 44(3), pp.297-315.

Kroll, F. and Adelle, C., 2022. Lockdown, resilience and emergency statecraft in the Cape Town food system. Cities, 131, p.104004.

Van Popering-Verkerk, J., Molenveld, A., Duijn, M., van Leeuwen, C. and van Buuren, A., 2022. A Framework for governance Capacity: A broad perspective on steering efforts in society. Administration & Society, 54(9), pp.1767-1794.

Wu, X., Ramesh, M. and Howlett, M., 2015. Policy capacity: A conceptual framework for understanding policy competences and capabilities. Policy and society, 34(3-4), pp.165-171.

Zhong, T., Crush, J., Si, Z. and Scott, S., 2021. Emergency food supplies and food security in Wuhan and Nanjing, China, during the COVID‐19 pandemic: Evidence from a field survey. Development Policy Review, 40(3), p.e12575.



 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The persistent burden of malnutrition in India, particularly child undernutrition, presents significant challenges for progress on the Sustainable Development Goals, including Goals 2 and 3, among others that are indirectly impacted. Governance failures within public services are highlighted as a significant contributor to inadequate improvements in child undernutrition, particularly due to  inadequate inter-sectoral coordination across government ministries and vertical integration through the levels of government. These public sector policy capacity limitations are understood as an important impetus for the involvement of non-state actors in governance for development, including social and health outcomes. Amid the rise of non-state actors in global policy processes for development, in the domain of health it has been argued that philanthropic foundations have experienced the most significant growth in their roles within governance processes. The focus of this study emerges from debates within the literature about the roles of philanthropic foundations within the contemporary crowded landscape of actors in which health and development issues are governed, and their contested implications for the balance of power among state and non-state actors.

 

This study examines these issues based on case studies of two philanthropic foundations involved in governance processes for nutrition at the national level in India, Tata Trusts and the Gates Foundation, through document analysis and qualitative interviews. The vast majority of study participants framed these philanthropies’ engagement as providing technical assistance in support of the state, often characterised as necessary due to limitations in the government’s capacity. Through funding the generation and mobilisation of evidence, as well as through the expertise of their staff, these philanthropies are understood to contribute ‘techno-managerial know-how’ to compensate for gaps due to inadequate training, the generalist civil service in India, and multi-level implementation challenges. Among the landscape of non-state actors, however, the financial resources held by these philanthropic foundations, alongside political dynamics of state hostility to civil society engagement, are understood by many to create power asymmetries with important implications for the nutrition governance environment.

 

Indeed, the de-politicising language of technical assistance is understood to obscure the political nature of the evidence generation and mobilisation functions that these philanthropies perform, and how these contribute to dynamics of power in the context of imbalances in financial resources. Empowered by their material resources, these philanthropies are understood to shape the ideational politics of governance for nutrition in this context. Generating particular types of evidence implicitly mobilises these within the governance arena given EBP norms. Moreover, these philanthropies’ material power is understood to allow them to focus funds in specific domain areas in a way that ‘overwhelms others’. Less well-resourced researchers, often community-based, have limited scope to generate alternative evidence, with implications for their legitimisation, and narrowing the scope for dissent within governance debates. Thus, this paper illuminates dynamics of power in relation to philanthropic foundations’ engagement in collaborative governance for nutrition in India in the context of state capacity limitations.

CO-AUTHORS
Joao Glass (MGI)
Wanessa Oliveira (University of Brasília (Brazil))
ABSTRACT

In the public sector, a Shared Services Center (SSC) refers to a government unit providing support services to more than one agency/ministry. Units that serve only a single agency/ministry are not considered SSCs (OECD, 2010). In a comparative study of SSCs in the public sector, Souza and Silva (2020) define SSCs as "a practice in which Public Administration shares a set of public services and activities, avoiding duplicated functions within their structures, aiming at cost reduction, improved service quality, and increased transparency." SSCs allow governments to focus their efforts on high-impact activities for their core mission, rather than on routine administrative tasks.

According to Ferreira et al. (2010), New Public Management (NPM) has encouraged the adoption of shared services in the public sector by incorporating advancements from private sector business management practices. The first formal SSCs in the public sector were identified in the 1990s, with notable examples in Australia and Canada. Since then, SSCs have become more common globally, with some labeling them as a "global megatrend" (Elston & MacCarthaigh, 2014 apud European Commission & Thijis, 2022). Numerous studies on SSCs in the public sector have been published, particularly in Europe, Australia, the United States, and Canada – the Global North.

This study addresses the gap in research on SSCs in Latin America and Africa by exploring practical examples in these regions. With a focus on the recent Brazilian federal government SSC (ColaboraGov), several questions are raised: Is the model adopted by Global South countries similar to that of the Global North? Which countries' models resemble the Brazilian federal government model (ColaboraGov)? In what aspects is Brazil innovating? What is ColaboraGov's potential impact on achieving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)?

The comparative analysis follows a methodology in three stages: 1) Gathering information on SSCs in Latin America and Africa, identifying key characteristics and services; 2) Comparative analysis to identify similarities and differences between SSCs in Latin America and Africa and those in developed countries from the Global North; 3) Specific analysis of ColaboraGov compared to other countries. The selection of cases for this study was made based on the official language of their government websites, restricted to Portuguese, Spanish, or English.

SSCs, known for over 20 years in the public sector, offer several advantages, including cost reduction and better allocation of resources, allowing agencies to focus on their core missions. However, in the Global South, except for Brazil, SSCs tend to be focused on specific areas (e.g., Information Technology or Human Resources). In the Global North, there are specialized SSCs, but it is also possible to find diverse SSC models offering a broader range of services. Initially treated as a “collaborative arrangement”, ColaboraGov formally became as an SSC in 2023. Nowadays it serves 13 ministries, which are directly aligned with 8 of the 17 SDGs from the UN 2030 Agenda - and indirectly supports the others. By relieving agencies of auxiliary services, ColaboraGov enhances their capacity to achieve their institutional missions, contributing to the global implementation of the SDGs.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Cities and towns with robust governance structures were ideally positioned to deliver catalytic changes in people's lives by transforming the global SDG agenda into concrete action. These age-old governance structures became futile, irrespective of their reach and resources. Across the world, the governance structure collapsed due to Covid-19. Counties are still struggling to find appropriate alternatives to respond to the economic and social impact of COVID-19. It disrupted the access and utilization of physical structures to deliver public services, affecting millions of lives and livelihoods. However, South Delhi developed and adopted a mobile-based resilient citizen-centric collaborative governance model (e-Mohalla Sabha) during the COVID crisis. It could withstand social distancing and the virulence of COVID-19. The gap between the citizens and public services was reduced. Post-COVID-19, it has continued to make public services available without delay. The model serves citizens' needs and, at the same time, remains inclusive, resilient, and sustainable.

 

Based on interviews with decision-makers and users, the paper explores how this resilient governance model was designed and continues to deliver using a virtual platform. The interviews focused on conceptualizing the model and coordination between internal and external organizational structures and public service providers. Additionally, it builds upon analyzing users' lived experiences as participant observation as a member of e-Mohalla Sabha. The analysis overlaps lessons from theory and practice on the effectiveness of citizen centricity and efficiency of collaborative governance of public service design, development, and delivery as a resilient model.

 

Unlike Ansel and Gash's (2008) model, the findings suggest face-to-face collaborative governance. In the era of digital access, the state-society gap, the WhatsApp-based e-mohalla governance model overcomes notable and administrative exclusion. The ease of access to a citizen-centric model promotes trust with improved lateral (within government departments) and horizontal (with government and citizens) integration. The lateral and horizontal integration in the e-mohalla (e-neighborhood) model further enriches trust over existing social capital with the common interest of the neighborhood.

 

It concludes that timely, accountable stakeholder engagement coupled with access to responsible political leadership in the model can resolve the ‘wicked problems’ of high government administrative costs and low utilization of public services, resulting in high out-of-pocket expenditures. The paper recommends that the e-Mohalla Sabha model of urban governance provides an alternative model to millions of communities and settlements that remain excluded due to poor access to and low utilization of public services to achieve several programs addressing SDGs.  

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In Brazil, the 1988 Constitution determined the structuring of a welfare state, aiming to guarantee social rights to all citizens. Those constitutional objectives are now strengthened by the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) of the 2030 Agenda.

To achieve those goals, some of the Brazilian social policies are currently organized in the legal-institutional form of systems, that is, with legal instruments designed to split the financing of state activities between the three levels of the federation, coordinate those actions, and ensure arenas and instruments for multi-level governance, with the participation of civil society and government representatives of federated entities in the decision-making process.

This mix of policy instruments was first implemented in the health system and then replicated in other sectoral policies, such as education and social assistance and, more recently, environmental protection, culture, and public security. Even though the policy design is very similar, for some of those sectoral policies, the results in terms of policy capacity, outcomes, and even the federative coordination have not been as effective.

This presentation discusses an ongoing study that compares the policy instruments of six national systems: Unified Health System (SUS), Unified Social Assistance System (SUAS), National Education System (SNE), National Environmental System (SISNAMA), Unified Public Security System (SUSP), and National Culture System (SNC). The main objective is to categorize the policy instruments of these systems into six dimensions of policy structuring: organizational (state capacity and managing agencies), substantive (the content of social provisions), participatory (state permeability to civil society demands), financial (economic sustainability of the policy), intergovernmental (relations between different levels of government), and instrumental (policy implementation mechanisms). Additionally, the study examines how legal and institutional frameworks shape the adaptability and responsiveness of these systems to emerging challenges, identifying mechanisms that enhance flexibility and innovation in governance.

Until now, the results show that the legacy of legal-institutional structuring of the different sectoral policies is an explanatory factor for variations in implementation outcomes. While the federal government has been successful in decentralizing programs through financial transfers to subnational entities in health and social assistance, the legacy of local provision of education and public security has posed challenges for federal coordination.

The research analyzes the difference in political capacity when it comes to citizen participation and multi-level governance arrangements across systems. The governance arrangements, constrained by rules, procedures, and institutions, can only be optimized when the institutional and political legacy of each sectorial policy is taken seriously.

This research highlights how legal studies on policy instruments can contribute to the discussion about political capacity, based on the types of norms and the sequence of approval of these norms, and also on the range of actors involved in the decision-making process.

The findings suggest that the legal arrangement of national systems contains policy instruments for intergovernmental coordination and collaboration with civil society and private sector actors that are crucial in organizing policy provision. More importantly, these instruments must be adapted to the specific context of each sector to effectively activate policy capacity and ensure the guarantee of constitutional rights and achievement of the SDG.

CO-AUTHORS
Mario Siede (Universidad Nacional de Entre Ríos)
ABSTRACT

Governments and public administrations share a growing concern about the conditions and requirements necessary to align and integrate public policies and programs that contribute to development outcomes. In federal countries, subnational levels face the challenge of mediating between society’s economic, social, and environmental demands and the territorialization of actions that provide substantive responses.

Within this framework, the adoption and implementation of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) present challenges to both technical and political capacities at different levels of state management, as they clash with the fragmented and uncoordinated nature of public policies. However, the logical, methodological, instrumental, and strategic aspects underlying the SDGs can serve as a key tool to enhance and catalyze public planning processes, helping to address these challenges.

This paper explores the opportunities and challenges that the 2030 Agenda and the SDGs present to public administrations as they engage in new interactions. It highlights that the SDGs not only provide direction and establish horizons for public action but also challenge administrations to bridge capacity gaps in coordination and articulation for their effective implementation.

The study seeks to contribute conceptual insights and empirical evidence to the literature on state capacities, SDG implementation, and coordination at the subnational (provincial or state) level. Without aiming for generalization, it presents evidence from three Argentine provinces suggesting that the SDGs trigger or catalyze processes that strengthen public planning, identify the public value added by provincial administrations, and, in particular, bridge capacity gaps to strategically address the traditionally fragmented and sectoral functioning of public administrations.

The analysis of provincial experiences, based on interviews and documentary materials, reveals significant institutional advancements that go beyond the mere adoption of the goals. The increasing focus on the 2030 Agenda and the SDGs has created a window of opportunity for learning, the development of structures, and institutional innovation in the coordination and articulation of provincial public administration. These advancements have strengthened strategic planning, public action, and the value it generates for territorial development.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Among others, sustainable development is contingent upon how government agencies deliver; how social system organizes citizens; and how people respond to, participate in and contribute to the development process and, thus, avail benefits to raise their quality of life, thereby achieving sustainable development goals (SDGs). The research studies highlight that resources are important but can be optimally and efficiently utilized through sound policies, robust institutions, and empowered citizens. The policies are necessary for efficient management of resources; right institutions can enhance the trust in the community and sustain the interventions; and empowered citizens can ensure effective implementation of programs. And, together they will provide sustainability to the development. 

 

In the context of SDGs, the UN Sustainable Development Report 2024 has underscored several concerns for developing countries, highlighting that only 16 percent of the SDG targets are on track, with the remaining 84 percent show poor progress. Against this backdrop, it calls for examining the policy system, institutional mechanisms, and role of community in realizing the SDG targets.

 

For the case study, the paper has chosen Kerala state in India. The methodology makes use of literature review together with the field research. It involves consultations with stakeholders, especially with citizens and elected members at the level of local institutions. It attempts to study critical factors, like efficacy of public policies, institutional reforms, capacity building of local implementing agencies, and community empowerment, which have contributed to the success of achieving SDGs in Kerala state. For policymaking, it observes that there is a bottom-up approach. The policies related to school education, health and sanitation, drinking water, and waste management have been studied. These take into consideration the feedback from citizens, local needs, ground realities, and implementation capacity of local institutions.

 

For over three decades, in Kerala, there has been emphasis on institutional reforms in terms of defining rules and structures for decision-making, transparency, efficiency, improving reach to grassroots, and accountability. There is devolution of power for decision-making on one hand and strengthening of transparency and accountability to people on the other. There is perceptible strengthening of decentralization of power through various such measures. The decentralization program has laid stress on capacity building of local institutions. It has resulted in many notable features like: political vision for local development planning; new work culture in local administration to promote people’s participation; enhanced competence; evolution of network of communities; innovative projects; and improved last-mile reach to vulnerable sections. The political parties involve themselves in local development, and there is a sense of ownership in them.

 

It presents a framework to examine how public policies, institutions, and community empowerment can add value to sustainability and to explore how these three aspects can contribute to sustainable development.

 

 

 

Select references:

-  Dovers S. (2005). Policy assessment for sustainability: institutional issues and options.

-  Connor and Dovers (2004). Institutional Change for Sustainable Development. Edward Elgar Publishing.

-  Sachs et. al. (2024). The SDGs and the UN Summit of the Future. Sustainable Development Report 2024.

 

 

 

CO-AUTHORS
edgardo Cruzado (Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú)
ABSTRACT

Achieving the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development in the Global South, particularly in Latin America, faces major challenges, with progress stagnating or reversing in some areas (UN DESA, 2024). Meeting SDG targets on public service access and quality, such as water, sanitation (SDG 6), and waste management (SDG 11), is particularly difficult due to varying capacities of local governments.
In Peru, access to public water has slightly declined, and 24% of households lack sanitation services. In solid waste management, 40% face inadequate waste disposal. A particular aspect of the 20-year decentralization process is the creation of 70 additional local governments, based on the premise that this will contribute to a greater allocation of resources and improved well-being of citizens in the new local governments. In 2024 alone, regulatory initiatives have been proposed to create 37 additional local governments, but its impact on service delivery remains unclear.
The research question investigates the extent to which local-level, service-specific administrative capacity influences service performance, and how territorial conditions and the creation of new local governments impact service provision. A local government service delivery capacity index will be developed, providing a tool to identify opportunities for collaborative service delivery between local governments and other stakeholders, thereby contributing to the advancement of SDG targets.
To support the results, we use a panel database of Peruvian local governments for the period 2015-2023. The methodological approach consists of two stages:
i) Estimation and analysis of local government efficiency through the construction of an index using principal component analysis, with inputs from variables related to public services. The dynamics over time will also be assessed to analyze progress or limitations throughout the study period, considering the typology of local governments and their territorial behavior. This will help identify patterns related to local or geographical conditions through spatial autocorrelation measures.
ii) Analysis of the explanatory factors of local government efficiency: This stage aims to understand which factors—such as territorial, economic, or social aspects—may affect or condition improvements (or lack thereof) in efficiency. Special attention will be given to the time of creation of local governments to understand the impact of their increase. Spatial models will be used to capture potential dependencies between territories, accounting for unobservable factors that come with working with spatial units, due to the marked heterogeneity within the national territory.
This paper addresses how local administrative capacity impact service performance, particularly in water, sanitation, and waste management and exploring how new local governments may struggle to meet SDG targets, offering insights into governance arrangements and policy capacity deployment. The study also provides a means to collaborative governance to overcome lack of administrative skills at the local level with the aim of enhancing SDG outcomes in the Global South.

CO-AUTHORS
Pedro Cunha (Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais)
Filipe Recch (University of Pittsburgh)
Bruno Costa (Fundação João Pinheiro )
ABSTRACT

Natália Sátyro – Federal University of Minas Gerais

Filipe Reech – Pittsburg University

Pedro Cunha – Câmara Municipal de Belo Horizonte

Bruno Lazarotti Diniz – Fundação João Pinheiro

 

Public primary and middle schools (1st  to 9th  grades) in Brazil's complex education system are managed in each state by both state and municipal administrations, noting that we have 5570 municipalities and 26 states). These variety and parallel school administrations in the same school districts generate differences in the quality of schooling. The familiar background and teacher and school characteristics, as well the characteristics of the head of school impact on student performance have a considerable accumulation in Brazilian literature. However, much less has been analyzed about the state capacity at the municipal and state secretariat level and the state capacity of the municipality as a whole. This paper intends to evaluate the effects of state capacity within the municipal and state secretariat and the state capacity of the municipality beyond the educational area on student performance. Econometric models that consider the hierarchy of data were used and our findings show that specific characteristics of the departments (at municipal and state level), as well as the municipality's planning capacity, influence student proficiency.