Format

P06. Trust, Distrust, and Regulation: Exploring their Interdependencies

COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Bernardo Rangoni
University of York
Main chair
David Levi Faur
Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Second chair
KOEN VERHOEST
GOVTRUST Centre of Excellence, Politics & Public Governance research group, dep. of Politics, University of Antwerp
Third chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

This panel aims to explore the complex, evolving relationship between trust, distrust, and regulation, addressing the following key research question: whether, how, and why (dis)trust and regulation affect one another. Trust is often viewed as the acceptance of vulnerability to others' actions, while distrust reflects a state of wariness or suspicion, and regulation encompasses rulemaking, monitoring, and enforcement. In recent decades, societies have witnessed significant crises—ranging from the 2008 financial meltdown to data privacy scandals, environmental fraud, and geopolitical conflicts—each eroding public trust in various actors, including private-sector tech giants and multinational corporations as well as public institutions such as financial regulators. Amid this context of distrust, regulation has often expanded, reflecting attempts to mitigate perceived risks and abuses, but it also risks unanticipated consequences that may further erode trust.
 
Empirical examples abound: European regulatory measures to curb the power of tech companies, the tightening of financial regulations after the global financial crisis, and screening mechanisms for foreign investments, especially in strategic sectors, all reflect efforts to restore trust. Yet, these regulatory moves have sparked debates over their effectiveness and unintended side effects, such as bureaucratic overreach and policy complexity. This panel investigates not only how regulation may restore trust but also how it may, paradoxically, breed further distrust by creating perceptions of red tape, inefficiency, or bias.
 
Theoretically, the relationship between trust and regulation is often viewed as antagonistic—where trust is high, regulation can be light; where distrust is dominant, strict rules emerge to minimize discretion. However, this traditional perspective might overlook scenarios where trust and regulation reinforce each other. For example, trust may support effective regulation, while regulation might act as a catalyst for building or repairing trust. Thus, the panel examines whether these factors are rival or complementary and whether trust can indeed be rebuilt after it has been breached.
 
This investigation is timely, given the rapid evolution of – inter alia – technological, financial, and geopolitical landscapes, which continuously test the robustness of regulatory frameworks. Through comparative analyses across sectors and governance levels, the panel will probe the iterative co-evolution of trust and regulation, focusing on how different contexts shape the interplay of these forces. Key hypotheses include:
1. Mutual Reinforcement: Trust and regulation can be mutually reinforcing, where effective regulation can build trust, and trust can support regulatory compliance.
2. Distrust and Over-Regulation: High levels of distrust may lead to over-regulation, which can backfire by fostering even more distrust.
3. Trust Repair: Regulation can serve as a corrective mechanism that helps repair trust over time, suggesting that distrust cycles can be broken.
 
Ultimately, this panel will deepen the understanding of the nuanced, multifaceted ways in which (dis)trust and regulation intersect, offering insights that extend beyond single-issue areas to broader governance challenges.

CALL FOR PAPERS

We invite paper proposals that contribute to a deeper understanding of the interdependencies between trust, distrust, and regulation across various sectors, polities and governance levels. We seek theoretical and empirical studies that address questions such as: Can regulation rebuild trust once it has been eroded? Does over-regulation exacerbate distrust, or can it restore it? Papers may explore these issues through comparative case studies, historical analyses, or quantitative assessments, focusing on contexts such as technology, finance, environmental policy, or international trade.
 
Contributions may investigate one part of the trust-regulation sequence (e.g., how regulation affects trust or vice versa) or adopt a dynamic approach that examines the feedback loops between the two. We encourage diverse methodological approaches and welcome inter- and multi-disciplinary perspectives, including but not limited to political science, sociology, economics, and legal studies. Papers that address underexplored aspects, such as citizens' trust in regulatory actors, inter-agency trust, or the role of institutional design, will be particularly appreciated. The goal is to foster a dialogue that challenges traditional views of trust and regulation as mutually exclusive and explores new avenues for understanding their co-evolution.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Trust and the Regulation of Automated Decision-Making Systems in the Public Sector: Explorative Insights from the Swiss Case
Martino Maggetti (University of Lausanne)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Automated decision-making (ADM) systems are becoming increasingly pervasive in the public sector, influencing many policy areas such as the distribution of unemployment benefits, taxation, law enforcement, and urban planning. The literature presents mixed results regarding their impact on trust: while ADM systems are often criticized for perpetuating biases or lacking transparency, studies also indicate that individuals targeted by these systems may place considerable trust in their outputs, particularly when they harbor distrust toward traditional government institutions. Against this background, the role of regulation applied to ADM in the public sector stands out as ambivalent, oscillating between two poles: as a mechanism for reinforcing trust and as a risky intervention that may interfere with trust-building processes. This paper addresses these issues by offering a conceptual discussion of ADM regulation as well as an empirical mapping of its implementation and potential implications for trust, drawing on explorative insights from the Swiss case. Switzerland, with its highly decentralized political-administrative system and governance structure, provides an ideal context to analyze within-case variations in ADM deployment and regulation.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Enhancing Public Trust in the Australian and Indonesian Police (AFP & POLRI) through Procedural Justice and Reconciliation Models
Ilham Hatmawan (Australian National University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Public trust in law enforcement is crucial to the establishment and maintenance of police institutional legitimacy. In turn, police legitimacy is fundamental to community cooperation and compliance with laws. However, the Australian Federal Police (AFP) and Indonesian National Police (POLRI) have experienced significant declines in public trust due to allegations of misconduct, inefficiencies, and violations of laws. This research investigates the potential and challenges of enhancing procedural justice and reconciliation models to enhance public trust. Using comparative analysis, this research explores how procedural justice, the fair and respectful treatment of citizens, can build and maintain trust in law enforcement alongside the adoption of reconciliation strategies that exercise sincere public apologies in its practice. Through the social-ecological model (SEM), there are five key actors identified in these efforts, including police officers, the police force, the police ombudsman and commissioners, the criminal justice system institutions, and the media. While procedural justice has shown promise in some legal jurisdictions in improving police-community relations, the paper argues that combining it with culturally tailored reconciliation practices could offer a more holistic solution to restoring public confidence. Limitations of the study include reliance on secondary data and a lack of insight into the perspectives of police officers themselves, which may introduce bias. The findings underscore the necessity of sustained and culturally adaptive efforts to enhance legitimacy and improve policing practice.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Assessing Public Trust in AI-Assisted Robotic Surgery: A Comparative Study of India's National AI Strategy and Liability Legislation
DIKSHA PUNDIR (Panjab University)
CO-AUTHORS
Rita Ghial (Christ University)
Rajinder Kaur (Panjab University)
Sonika Bhardwaj (Christ University)
ABSTRACT

With the era of Industrial Revolution 5.0 gaining traction in the 21st century, the symbiotic relationship of human-machine collaboration is set to reach its zenith by paving way to increase efficiency and effectiveness across different fields and stakeholders. One such collaboration is between AI (Artificial Intelligence) and Healthcare sector that set to revolutionise the complex nitty-gritty of disease diagnosis, prevention, treatment, monitoring and palliative care. Within the Healthcare sector, the adoption of AI will have a profound impact on the surgeries. AI assisted robotic surgery is set to transform the ability of human surgeons to respond to complex problems by enhancing precision and accuracy i.e. real time response, perform micro-movements, minimize unintended surgical invasion etc. Thus, AI assisted robotic surgery can facilitate enhanced precision and accuracy, minimize invasive procedures, reduce surgeon fatigue and improve efficiency, provide real time analytics and decision support, short recovery time and enhanced patient outcomes etc. In India, it can help to address critical challenges such as shortage of skilled surgeons, overcrowded hospitals and inequitable access to advanced healthcare facilities.  AI assisted robotic surgeries are thus ready to revolutionize Indian patient’s healthcare journey from diagnosis to post-operative care. But, one critical conjuncture for the success of these AI assisted robotic surgery is public’s trust towards adoption of these developments. A crucial confidence-building measure in India depends on the effective implementation of trust and distrust legislation governing AI and healthcare practices. This research study employs a mixed-methods approach to examine the trust and distrust regulations governing AI-assisted robotic surgery in India. It aims to analyze the critical interplay among three key stakeholders—patients, healthcare practitioners, and the government—while comparing India’s regulatory framework with global best practices, including those established by the EU, USA, and WHO. Further, this research study will incorporate a survey to analyse public confidence/trust on these trust and distrust regulations and the legal, ethical and social issues that shape their confidence in AI assisted robotic surgery.

Research Questions:

1. What specific aspects and provisions of India's National AI Strategy are relevant to AI-assisted robotic surgery?

2.  What data protection and liability legislation exists in India concerning AI and medical malpractice in specific context of AI assisted robotic surgery?

3. How do these policies affect public trust in AI-assisted robotic surgery?

4. What are the gaps in the policy framework that needs to be addressed?

Research Methodology:

This study will include mixed methods approach utilizing comparative analysis to assess India's policies against international best practices in AI-assisted robotic surgery. It will also conduct a legal analysis to evaluate how liability laws address AI-related malpractice in the healthcare sector. Additionally, a public perception study will be undertaken using surveys, expert interviews, and case studies to gauge trust levels towards AI assisted robotic surgery. Data will be collected from various primary and secondary sources, including government reports, white papers, case laws, policies and legal provisions, and surveys and interviews conducted with the public.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Rebuilding Trust in Regulation: Lessons from Finance in Europe
Bernardo Rangoni (University of York)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Trust is essential to regulatory governance but prone to breakdowns from scandals and failures. Despite its importance, trust repair remains underexplored in regulatory scholarship. This paper addresses this gap by examining trust repair in European financial regulation—an unlikely case given the severity of the financial and eurozone crises. Drawing on stakeholder surveys, it finds significant trust recovery in the European regulatory regime, and thus tests explanations for this pattern. Building on nascent management literature, it highlights three mechanisms. Investigation, epitomized by the de Larosière report, diagnosed systemic vulnerabilities. Rehabilitation and reform enhanced rules and centralized supervision through the Single Supervisory Mechanism, addressing problematic incentives. Transparency and transference, via stress tests and asset quality reviews, demonstrated renewed trustworthiness. Regulation is vulnerable to crises of trust. Yet the study shows that even after profound trust breakdowns, trust in regulation can be rebuilt through mechanisms of investigation, reform, and transparency. 

 

 

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Dispute Settlement in e-Commerce and Regulatory Options
Supruet Thavornyutikarn (Thammasat University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

e-Commerce expands sizeable transactions of commodities worldwide; it magnifies markets of virtually every product to the global level. Many are transacted through multi-sided platforms, such as e-marketplace; many others are performed through social media. Successful e-commerce relies heavily on trust between participants.

One common problem for transactions that cover a large distance – likely being cross-border involving many jurisdictions – is an exponentially-increasing probability of dispute as a result of distrust among participants. As distance and myriads of jurisdictions offer shrouds for mala fide agents, fueling distrust, and bona fide agents may be tangled in misunderstanding between each other, due to languages, cultures, and backgrounds, these give a rise to dispute between contracting parties ex post, and, simultaneously, deter many potential transactions to occur if those agents are sufficiently risk-averse ex ante, hindering the chance of building trust between themselves and contribution of e-commerce to the world economy.

Regulatory authorities are compelled to take action to prevent and fix such dispute. A lot of regulations are devised – registration of e-commerce businesses and identity confirmation included before the transaction or state-mediated dispute settlement mechanism when the transaction has gone sour. However, this is likely to create more transaction costs for participants rather than facilitating the trade for them.


This paper argues that disputes shall be responsible by participants and/or digital platforms that they are participating in. Some platforms may offer no protection for their participation at all – leaving them under caveat emptor and caveat venditor regimes – suitable for participants who are extremely vigilant and sophisticated may choose to participate in these platforms to fully use their expertise possible to get their surpluses. But repeatedly successful transactions would build their trust.

On the other hand, risk-averse participants may prefer platforms that offer dispute settlement mechanisms of various degrees, corresponding with their respective degree of trouble tolerance. There is no one-size-fits-all mechanism for dispute settlement since transactions are different in value and intrinsic probability of non-fulfillment. It is going to be a waste of resources trying to protect participants from any dispute.


Our suggestion would allow each platform to devise its own optimal dispute settlement mechanism. e-Commerce platforms will offer different mechanisms to participants to choose. Concurrently, participants will select suitable platforms associated with their concern about potential disputes. Therefore, participants may be active on more than one platform, depending on what products/services they want to trade. Moreover, this offers a chance for platforms to continuously develop their dedicated and tailor-made dispute settlement mechanism based on artificial intelligence using big data obtained from their participants in order to keep their participants and attract new ones, as well as becoming trusted platforms for their satisfied participants.


Nevertheless, participants shall be more digitally literate, more vigilant, and more sophisticated to keep building trust with their respective contracting parties and platforms they are using because they are the least-cost avoider of dispute. Regulations for solving e-commerce disputes shall be geared towards empowerment of participants in general, rather than regulating platforms.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Trust and Economic Governance of the Sharing Economy in the Accommodation Sector: A Transaction Cost Economics Analysis
Vorapat Chutima (Chiang Mai University School of Public Policy)
CO-AUTHORS
Pairach Piboonrungroj (Chiang Mai University School of Public Policy)
Warattaya Chinnakum (Chiang Mai University School of Public Policy)
ABSTRACT

The peer-to-peer (P2P) accommodation sector, a subset of the sharing economy, has emerged as a result of advancements in internet technology and mobile applications. This sector consists of multiple stakeholders, including the platform providers, hosts, guests, regulatory authorities, and the wider community. Platforms such as Airbnb offer competitive advantages over the traditional hotel industry, including shared common spaces, kitchen facilities, and laundry services. However, challenges persist, particularly in terms of service responsiveness compared to licensed hotels with dedicated guest services. Moreover, the legal status of P2P accommodation remains ambiguous in several jurisdictions, including Thailand.

 

From a transaction cost economics (TCE) perspective, Airbnb presents additional benefits, notably in terms of localized knowledge. Hosts, as property owners, often possess superior insights into local contexts compared to hotel staff. TCE comprises three key cost components: search and information costs, negotiation costs, and enforcement costs. These costs vary across hosts and guests, with trust serving as a significant moderating factor. Due to its P2P nature, Airbnb necessitates regulatory frameworks that balance its competitive positioning against the traditional hotel industry while maximizing benefits for guests, governments, and local communities. The risk of opportunistic behavior in unregulated markets is notably higher in Airbnb than in traditional hotel operations, given that transaction costs associated with seeking legal recourse are often higher for hosts and guests compared to the formal lodging sector. These concerns directly impact trust within the ecosystem.

 

This study aims to address the research question: How can economic governance in the P2P accommodation sector facilitate effective regulations that foster trust among all stakeholders while promoting sectoral growth? The study employs the extended Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) and Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to analyze key determinants of trust and regulatory compliance. Eight constructs are examined: Actual Use (AU), Behavioral Intention (BI), Attitude toward Use (AT), Perceived Ease of Use (EU), Perceived Usefulness (PU), Trust (TRU), Transaction Cost (TC), and Public Policy Support (PPS). Data collection will be conducted via online surveys targeting 300 Airbnb hosts in key Thai tourist destinations, including Bangkok, Chiang Mai, Koh Samui, Krabi, and Phuket. The collected data will be analyzed using SEM techniques.

 

The study contributes to the literature by integrating transaction cost economics into the regulatory discourse on sharing accommodation. The findings are expected to inform policy recommendations that mitigate opportunistic behavior, enhance regulatory compliance, and facilitate the legalization of Airbnb and similar platforms in various national contexts.

 

Keywords: sharing economy, public policy governance, transaction cost economics, trust, Thailand

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Trust in regulatory regimes: the interplay of trustworthy actors, regulatory content and regulatory procedures
KOEN VERHOEST (GOVTRUST Centre of Excellence, Politics & Public Governance research group, dep. of Politics, University of Antwerp)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Trust in regulation and in the actors that define, implement, enforce and judge the regulation - what we call the regulatory regime - is crucial. Regulatees’ rule compliance depends on their level of trust and so does the uptake of services by beneficiaries, which is often put to the test due to high-impact events.

 

This paper lays the foundation to study how trust in three key dimensions—regulatory actors, regulatory content, and enforcement procedures—influences overall trust in regulatory regimes. Trust in regulatory regimes is critical for addressing contemporary challenges such as financial stability, data protection, and food safety, all of which require effective governance frameworks. Drawing on a cross-country, cross-sector survey conducted across nine countries and three regulatory domains (data protection, finance, and food safety), two critical questions are aimed to be explored: (1) How does trust in individual components of a regulatory regime contribute to overall regime trust? and (2) Do these effects vary across stakeholder groups, such as regulatees and public actors?

 

The paper develops a theoretical framework that conceptualizes trust as a multifaceted construct and situates it within the broader context of regulatory regimes. Preliminary hypotheses are formulated to guide future empirical analysis, focusing on the potential hierarchical influence of trust components and variations across stakeholder groups. The study highlights the relevance of trust in shaping perceptions of legitimacy and the effectiveness of regulatory regimes, while emphasizing the importance of tailoring regulatory approaches to the distinct priorities of diverse stakeholders. By advancing these theoretical and empirical foundations, this paper aims to contribute to a deeper understanding of trust dynamics in governance systems, offering practical implications for policy design, stakeholder engagement, and the fostering of resilient regulatory regimes. “

 

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Automated decision-making (ADM) systems are becoming increasingly pervasive in the public sector, influencing many policy areas such as the distribution of unemployment benefits, taxation, law enforcement, and urban planning. The literature presents mixed results regarding their impact on trust: while ADM systems are often criticized for perpetuating biases or lacking transparency, studies also indicate that individuals targeted by these systems may place considerable trust in their outputs, particularly when they harbor distrust toward traditional government institutions. Against this background, the role of regulation applied to ADM in the public sector stands out as ambivalent, oscillating between two poles: as a mechanism for reinforcing trust and as a risky intervention that may interfere with trust-building processes. This paper addresses these issues by offering a conceptual discussion of ADM regulation as well as an empirical mapping of its implementation and potential implications for trust, drawing on explorative insights from the Swiss case. Switzerland, with its highly decentralized political-administrative system and governance structure, provides an ideal context to analyze within-case variations in ADM deployment and regulation.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Public trust in law enforcement is crucial to the establishment and maintenance of police institutional legitimacy. In turn, police legitimacy is fundamental to community cooperation and compliance with laws. However, the Australian Federal Police (AFP) and Indonesian National Police (POLRI) have experienced significant declines in public trust due to allegations of misconduct, inefficiencies, and violations of laws. This research investigates the potential and challenges of enhancing procedural justice and reconciliation models to enhance public trust. Using comparative analysis, this research explores how procedural justice, the fair and respectful treatment of citizens, can build and maintain trust in law enforcement alongside the adoption of reconciliation strategies that exercise sincere public apologies in its practice. Through the social-ecological model (SEM), there are five key actors identified in these efforts, including police officers, the police force, the police ombudsman and commissioners, the criminal justice system institutions, and the media. While procedural justice has shown promise in some legal jurisdictions in improving police-community relations, the paper argues that combining it with culturally tailored reconciliation practices could offer a more holistic solution to restoring public confidence. Limitations of the study include reliance on secondary data and a lack of insight into the perspectives of police officers themselves, which may introduce bias. The findings underscore the necessity of sustained and culturally adaptive efforts to enhance legitimacy and improve policing practice.

CO-AUTHORS
Rita Ghial (Christ University)
Rajinder Kaur (Panjab University)
Sonika Bhardwaj (Christ University)
ABSTRACT

With the era of Industrial Revolution 5.0 gaining traction in the 21st century, the symbiotic relationship of human-machine collaboration is set to reach its zenith by paving way to increase efficiency and effectiveness across different fields and stakeholders. One such collaboration is between AI (Artificial Intelligence) and Healthcare sector that set to revolutionise the complex nitty-gritty of disease diagnosis, prevention, treatment, monitoring and palliative care. Within the Healthcare sector, the adoption of AI will have a profound impact on the surgeries. AI assisted robotic surgery is set to transform the ability of human surgeons to respond to complex problems by enhancing precision and accuracy i.e. real time response, perform micro-movements, minimize unintended surgical invasion etc. Thus, AI assisted robotic surgery can facilitate enhanced precision and accuracy, minimize invasive procedures, reduce surgeon fatigue and improve efficiency, provide real time analytics and decision support, short recovery time and enhanced patient outcomes etc. In India, it can help to address critical challenges such as shortage of skilled surgeons, overcrowded hospitals and inequitable access to advanced healthcare facilities.  AI assisted robotic surgeries are thus ready to revolutionize Indian patient’s healthcare journey from diagnosis to post-operative care. But, one critical conjuncture for the success of these AI assisted robotic surgery is public’s trust towards adoption of these developments. A crucial confidence-building measure in India depends on the effective implementation of trust and distrust legislation governing AI and healthcare practices. This research study employs a mixed-methods approach to examine the trust and distrust regulations governing AI-assisted robotic surgery in India. It aims to analyze the critical interplay among three key stakeholders—patients, healthcare practitioners, and the government—while comparing India’s regulatory framework with global best practices, including those established by the EU, USA, and WHO. Further, this research study will incorporate a survey to analyse public confidence/trust on these trust and distrust regulations and the legal, ethical and social issues that shape their confidence in AI assisted robotic surgery.

Research Questions:

1. What specific aspects and provisions of India's National AI Strategy are relevant to AI-assisted robotic surgery?

2.  What data protection and liability legislation exists in India concerning AI and medical malpractice in specific context of AI assisted robotic surgery?

3. How do these policies affect public trust in AI-assisted robotic surgery?

4. What are the gaps in the policy framework that needs to be addressed?

Research Methodology:

This study will include mixed methods approach utilizing comparative analysis to assess India's policies against international best practices in AI-assisted robotic surgery. It will also conduct a legal analysis to evaluate how liability laws address AI-related malpractice in the healthcare sector. Additionally, a public perception study will be undertaken using surveys, expert interviews, and case studies to gauge trust levels towards AI assisted robotic surgery. Data will be collected from various primary and secondary sources, including government reports, white papers, case laws, policies and legal provisions, and surveys and interviews conducted with the public.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Trust is essential to regulatory governance but prone to breakdowns from scandals and failures. Despite its importance, trust repair remains underexplored in regulatory scholarship. This paper addresses this gap by examining trust repair in European financial regulation—an unlikely case given the severity of the financial and eurozone crises. Drawing on stakeholder surveys, it finds significant trust recovery in the European regulatory regime, and thus tests explanations for this pattern. Building on nascent management literature, it highlights three mechanisms. Investigation, epitomized by the de Larosière report, diagnosed systemic vulnerabilities. Rehabilitation and reform enhanced rules and centralized supervision through the Single Supervisory Mechanism, addressing problematic incentives. Transparency and transference, via stress tests and asset quality reviews, demonstrated renewed trustworthiness. Regulation is vulnerable to crises of trust. Yet the study shows that even after profound trust breakdowns, trust in regulation can be rebuilt through mechanisms of investigation, reform, and transparency. 

 

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

e-Commerce expands sizeable transactions of commodities worldwide; it magnifies markets of virtually every product to the global level. Many are transacted through multi-sided platforms, such as e-marketplace; many others are performed through social media. Successful e-commerce relies heavily on trust between participants.

One common problem for transactions that cover a large distance – likely being cross-border involving many jurisdictions – is an exponentially-increasing probability of dispute as a result of distrust among participants. As distance and myriads of jurisdictions offer shrouds for mala fide agents, fueling distrust, and bona fide agents may be tangled in misunderstanding between each other, due to languages, cultures, and backgrounds, these give a rise to dispute between contracting parties ex post, and, simultaneously, deter many potential transactions to occur if those agents are sufficiently risk-averse ex ante, hindering the chance of building trust between themselves and contribution of e-commerce to the world economy.

Regulatory authorities are compelled to take action to prevent and fix such dispute. A lot of regulations are devised – registration of e-commerce businesses and identity confirmation included before the transaction or state-mediated dispute settlement mechanism when the transaction has gone sour. However, this is likely to create more transaction costs for participants rather than facilitating the trade for them.


This paper argues that disputes shall be responsible by participants and/or digital platforms that they are participating in. Some platforms may offer no protection for their participation at all – leaving them under caveat emptor and caveat venditor regimes – suitable for participants who are extremely vigilant and sophisticated may choose to participate in these platforms to fully use their expertise possible to get their surpluses. But repeatedly successful transactions would build their trust.

On the other hand, risk-averse participants may prefer platforms that offer dispute settlement mechanisms of various degrees, corresponding with their respective degree of trouble tolerance. There is no one-size-fits-all mechanism for dispute settlement since transactions are different in value and intrinsic probability of non-fulfillment. It is going to be a waste of resources trying to protect participants from any dispute.


Our suggestion would allow each platform to devise its own optimal dispute settlement mechanism. e-Commerce platforms will offer different mechanisms to participants to choose. Concurrently, participants will select suitable platforms associated with their concern about potential disputes. Therefore, participants may be active on more than one platform, depending on what products/services they want to trade. Moreover, this offers a chance for platforms to continuously develop their dedicated and tailor-made dispute settlement mechanism based on artificial intelligence using big data obtained from their participants in order to keep their participants and attract new ones, as well as becoming trusted platforms for their satisfied participants.


Nevertheless, participants shall be more digitally literate, more vigilant, and more sophisticated to keep building trust with their respective contracting parties and platforms they are using because they are the least-cost avoider of dispute. Regulations for solving e-commerce disputes shall be geared towards empowerment of participants in general, rather than regulating platforms.

CO-AUTHORS
Pairach Piboonrungroj (Chiang Mai University School of Public Policy)
Warattaya Chinnakum (Chiang Mai University School of Public Policy)
ABSTRACT

The peer-to-peer (P2P) accommodation sector, a subset of the sharing economy, has emerged as a result of advancements in internet technology and mobile applications. This sector consists of multiple stakeholders, including the platform providers, hosts, guests, regulatory authorities, and the wider community. Platforms such as Airbnb offer competitive advantages over the traditional hotel industry, including shared common spaces, kitchen facilities, and laundry services. However, challenges persist, particularly in terms of service responsiveness compared to licensed hotels with dedicated guest services. Moreover, the legal status of P2P accommodation remains ambiguous in several jurisdictions, including Thailand.

 

From a transaction cost economics (TCE) perspective, Airbnb presents additional benefits, notably in terms of localized knowledge. Hosts, as property owners, often possess superior insights into local contexts compared to hotel staff. TCE comprises three key cost components: search and information costs, negotiation costs, and enforcement costs. These costs vary across hosts and guests, with trust serving as a significant moderating factor. Due to its P2P nature, Airbnb necessitates regulatory frameworks that balance its competitive positioning against the traditional hotel industry while maximizing benefits for guests, governments, and local communities. The risk of opportunistic behavior in unregulated markets is notably higher in Airbnb than in traditional hotel operations, given that transaction costs associated with seeking legal recourse are often higher for hosts and guests compared to the formal lodging sector. These concerns directly impact trust within the ecosystem.

 

This study aims to address the research question: How can economic governance in the P2P accommodation sector facilitate effective regulations that foster trust among all stakeholders while promoting sectoral growth? The study employs the extended Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) and Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to analyze key determinants of trust and regulatory compliance. Eight constructs are examined: Actual Use (AU), Behavioral Intention (BI), Attitude toward Use (AT), Perceived Ease of Use (EU), Perceived Usefulness (PU), Trust (TRU), Transaction Cost (TC), and Public Policy Support (PPS). Data collection will be conducted via online surveys targeting 300 Airbnb hosts in key Thai tourist destinations, including Bangkok, Chiang Mai, Koh Samui, Krabi, and Phuket. The collected data will be analyzed using SEM techniques.

 

The study contributes to the literature by integrating transaction cost economics into the regulatory discourse on sharing accommodation. The findings are expected to inform policy recommendations that mitigate opportunistic behavior, enhance regulatory compliance, and facilitate the legalization of Airbnb and similar platforms in various national contexts.

 

Keywords: sharing economy, public policy governance, transaction cost economics, trust, Thailand

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Trust in regulation and in the actors that define, implement, enforce and judge the regulation - what we call the regulatory regime - is crucial. Regulatees’ rule compliance depends on their level of trust and so does the uptake of services by beneficiaries, which is often put to the test due to high-impact events.

 

This paper lays the foundation to study how trust in three key dimensions—regulatory actors, regulatory content, and enforcement procedures—influences overall trust in regulatory regimes. Trust in regulatory regimes is critical for addressing contemporary challenges such as financial stability, data protection, and food safety, all of which require effective governance frameworks. Drawing on a cross-country, cross-sector survey conducted across nine countries and three regulatory domains (data protection, finance, and food safety), two critical questions are aimed to be explored: (1) How does trust in individual components of a regulatory regime contribute to overall regime trust? and (2) Do these effects vary across stakeholder groups, such as regulatees and public actors?

 

The paper develops a theoretical framework that conceptualizes trust as a multifaceted construct and situates it within the broader context of regulatory regimes. Preliminary hypotheses are formulated to guide future empirical analysis, focusing on the potential hierarchical influence of trust components and variations across stakeholder groups. The study highlights the relevance of trust in shaping perceptions of legitimacy and the effectiveness of regulatory regimes, while emphasizing the importance of tailoring regulatory approaches to the distinct priorities of diverse stakeholders. By advancing these theoretical and empirical foundations, this paper aims to contribute to a deeper understanding of trust dynamics in governance systems, offering practical implications for policy design, stakeholder engagement, and the fostering of resilient regulatory regimes. “