Format

P07. The Global Politics of the Implementation of Migrants' Rights: Policy Instruments and Controversies

COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Mireille Manga
International Relations Institute of Cameroon (IRIC), University of Yaoundé II
Main chair
Oluwasegun David Yusuf
University of Pretoria
Second chair
TSALA Ezéchiel
Université de Ngaoundéré
Third chair
Jean Emmanuel Minko À Bitegni
Université de Maroua
Fourth chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Global migration governance is a normative and sociopolitical challenge which materialises in transnational policymaking processes. By transnational policymaking, we mean policymaking process that emerges from transnational mobilisation of various states and non states agents around common concerns such as immigration, health, poverty, environment, among others or the resolution of common problems which do not respect  national jurisdictions and need to involve more than one nation or domestic actors (De Oliveira, 2022). In this panel, we invite proposals that bring into the discussion the transnational migration policy settings and their instruments brought up by different historical contexts of the collective management of human migrations. These instruments may include, but are not limited to the uses of conventional and non-conventional policies and strategic arrangements put in place by states or governments to address the international movements of populations and their human rights, all categories and varieties considered.

 

Most specifically, panel would like to invite papers that focus on, but are not limited to the following questions:

 

- What kind of transnational arrangements characterise the global governance of migration across regions and over time?

 

- Which migrants' rights are promoted and secured across States' borders and transnational juridictions, regional and national legislations?

 

 - Does economic sovereignty influence the structuration of the global governance of international migration?

- What methods and policy research approaches can be used to study and interpret the emerging types of policy arrangements? 

 

- Who frames policies and who fails to comply? 

 

 - Do controversies emerge from the global governance of international migrations ? 

 

- Do migration global policy instruments vary across regions? and how?

 

This panel is an opportunity to question the relevance of traditional and emerging theories and methodologies of the policymaking process research and their capacity to advance intersdisciplinary and transdisciplinary approaches.

CALL FOR PAPERS

This panel will expect papers using an exploration of mixed research methods, quantitative and qualitative research that focus on discussions and research on the many conversations around migrants protection and their legal rights along with how these arguments and conversations lead to policy instruments which are innovatively used for the protection of migrants legal rights by citizen groups, migrant groups, CSOs and the state agencies. Across various perspectives and contexts, authors may examine different stages of public policy in migration governance and migrants legal rights, including agenda-setting, policy formulation, analysis, decision, implementation, evaluation and post-implementation

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Non-Governmental Organizations Advocacy Role within Inclusive Migration Policies in The European Union
Gabriele Masiulyte (Kaunas University of Technology)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The increasing role of non-governmental organizations in advocating for inclusive migration policies in the European Union highlights the need for a deeper understanding of their influence, strategies, and challenges. This research examines the complexities of NGO advocacy, aiming to explore the strategies used by these organizations to amplify the voices of migrants in EU policymaking processes. Through a combination of literature review and semi-structured interviews and policy analysts, the study identifies the challenges that non-governmental organizations face, such as legal restrictions, financial challenges. The findings of the research will contribute to the development of more effective strategies that enhance NGO influence on migration policies.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Enhancing Migrant group rights and protection through dialogue
Oluwasegun David Yusuf (University of Pretoria)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The main objective is to focus and take stock of various conversations and discourses around public policy targeted at legal engagement and dialogue on migrants’ protection and rights across the globe. Given that migrants are many atimes on the receiving end of migration policies which are focused on intensive securitisation, protectionism, and fortress building rather than managing migration.


Global migration management and policy has received political and foreign policy attention with follow-up actions by global and continental frameworks. The United Nations Global Compact on Safe, Orderly and Regular Migration, the 2015 European Union (EU) border hotspot externalisation regime and the African Union (AU) Migration Policy and Development Framework 2006 are a few examples.

 

In relation to the fundamental legal compliance on the legalities of migration and the treatment of migrants, the United Nations’ 1990 global conventions and protocols outline the protection of migrants everywhere globally from forceful expulsion and human rights abuses while specifying the migrants’ rights to diplomatic protection, legal assistance and equal legal treatment. In many receiving societies, soft tensions and dialogues do continuously exist among migrants’ group with citizens and the state to rightly establish the rights of migrants.

 

Migrants are a special interest group which influence relations in the sending and receiving society to create a sort of push and pull, enabling and restraining force field, where the more powerful, supreme, exerting and influential group, who can lobby, do greatly influence public policy decisions. Group theory in Public Policy and Public administration, explains that (organised, protection or special interest group theory) interest groups shape and change public policy due to the force field of continuous struggle among each other. When there is a good balance of interest groups influence, there is a net gain equal to the net loss of influence for each group (state and migrant group), per time. (Anderson 2014, Anyebe 2018, Dye 2016).
To contribute to the migrants’ protection and dialogue conversations which expand the diverse frontiers of migration management knowledge and the participatory process of global change in shaping global migration and public policy trajectories. This research uses both quantitative and qualitative research to  focus on migrants’ protection dialogues among various country stakeholders which will influence and impact on migration policy in both the sending countries and receiving countries globally.
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
•Why are migrants unprotected and experiencing unequal rights?
•What new policy engagements and phenomena are created among various public policy actors as a result of migrants right and inter country dialogue?
•How can intercountry migration dialogues and engagements be made to protect the legal rights of migrants?
•How does the intercountry dialogue to protect migrants rights shape relations between state, citizen and noncitizen actors.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Popular-nationalism and Indonesia’s Humanitarian Foreign Policy: Case of Rohingya Refugee Rejection
MIRZA FANZIKRI (Universitas Islam Internasional Indonesia)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In the nation-state era, the settlement of Rohingya refugees in Indonesia has become a significant challenge for the country. From the Indonesian perspective, some constraints impede the country's capacity to accommodate Rohingya refugees. Conversely, Indonesia is becoming increasingly prominent as a proponent of democratic principles and a defender of human rights, both within the Southeast Asia region and on the global stage. This dilemma gives rise to the question of how Indonesia should respond to the Rohingya refugee crisis in a manner that is also consistent with international norms. The paper delineates the phenomenon of community rejection as a popular nationalism phenomenon that is deployed by the state as a strategic tool to circumvent international norms due to domestic security concerns. Despite the contradiction between the rejection of Rohingya refugees and Indonesia's humanitarian principles and international norms, the framing of mass mobilization allows Indonesia to justify the rejection of Rohingya refugees as a domestic security matter in its foreign policy. These phenomena will be described using Putnam's two-level game theory to analyze and identify social phenomena at the domestic level that affect foreign policy internationally. This paper will examine how Indonesia deems community rejection a viable strategy to circumvent international norms and ASEAN commitments, particularly in the context of a domestic contest concerning stability, security, and public order – all of which are crucial domestic interests for the state to consider. It thus unpacks how Indonesia maintains its position and status as a promoter of democracy and a defender of human rights in the region and globally while dealing with domestic Rohingya refugees rejection.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - TRANSNATIONAL NETWORKS AND REPARATION POLICIES: THE CASE OF ACTIONS FOR COLOMBIAN VICTIMS ABROAD
Melba Revelo Osorio (Universidade de Brasília)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

TRANSNATIONAL NETWORKS AND REPARATORY POLICIES: THE CASE OF THE ACTIONS UNDERTAKEN ON BEHALF OF COLOMBIAN VICTIMS ABROAD.
 
Melba M. Revelo Osório
University of Brasília (UnB)
 
Dr. Fernanda Natasha Bravo Cruz
University of Brasília (UnB)
 

At present, there are several national and international instruments that obligate the Colombian State to guarantee full reparation to the victims of the armed conflicts, such as: Colombian Law on Victims and Land Restitution (Law 1.448 of 2011), Peace Agreement (Colombia, 2016), Judgments of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (C-370 of 2006 and T-025 of 2004) and the Final Report of the Truth Commission (2022).
According to what is set in those instruments, the reparation must integrate economic, social, cultural and symbolic actions. Although plenty of these reparation actions have been carried out by the Colombian State along more than 10 years with the victims who reside in the Colombian territory, it has only been 5 years that the measures have started reaching those who were forcedly moved overseas. Moreover, that change could only be possible due to the role played by transnational social movements, particularly those led by directly impacted victims. (Coraza,   2020) In addition, the efforts have also been undertaken in coordination with international Non-Governmental Organizations, that have been actively designing public actions. (Lascoumes & Le Galès, 2012)
 

Upon the significant challenge involving actions on behalf of the Colombian forced migrant population, who are dispersed in more than 25 countries, it is the objective of this study to search and analyze the related phenomena, with special focus on the articulation between the State and the civil society networks. It is also taken ino account that the transnational networks play a fundamental role in connecting actors across national borders and offering greater precision in the identification and generation of proposals to meet the specific needs of the population (Scherer-Warren, 2006; Bringel and Falero, 2008). This qualitative analysis proposal will be performed through a documentary review and also based on a personal witness interview, withof one of the women, who is a current members of the Colombian Exile Network. The results of this analysis will allow the authors to recognize the diversity of instruments of public action (Halpern, Lascoumes & Le Galès, 2014) involved in one of the emotional reparation measures implemented in Brazil, in December 2023. It will also endeavor the dynamics identified in the interaction amongst the actors, as well as it foresees a balanced reflection over the contributions provided by the articulation of these actors in the reparation actions.
 
Keywords: Transnational Networks, Public Action, Forced Migration, Reparation Measure

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Immigration, Migration, and the Rise of Tribalism: Examining the Past to Inform the Future
Carolyn Geiser (Colorado Technical University)
CO-AUTHORS
Gregory Geiser (Sinclair College)
ABSTRACT

Immigration, Migration, and the Rise of Tribalism:  Examining the Past to Inform the Future

 

Today, divisions based on partisanship, ideology, ethnicity, gender, nation, class, religion, and generation define polarization within society; a major point of contention is immigration and migration from people changing places of residence.  In this paper, we tease apart immigration and migration as both result in a form of tribalism.  Here, immigration is the movement from one government-controlled place to another, whether granted permission to do so or not.  Migration is movement from one space to another, regardless of geopolitical boundaries and legal stipulations.  Tribalism, a form of nationalism, is the reaction to perceived irreconcilable differences between the “in” group, the majority inhabitants of a geographic and social area, and the “out” group, the newcomers to this area.  This is a burgeoning crisis for governments, societies, and the economy of nations which all receive the benefits and pitfalls of the immigration/migration/tribalism spectrum.

There are diverse reasons for people to immigrate or migrate, yet the impact on the resident population of an area creates social, legal, and economic challenges that result in tribalistic and nationalistic behaviors.  Exploration, explanation, and interpretation of the political and social policies of the past lead to ways that can alleviate tensions in immigration, pressures of migration, and potentially reduce tribalism in society.   An examination of historic immigration policy in Canada and the United States can inform future stakeholder decision making.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - AU’s Migration Policy Framework and Its Implementation Challenges in North Africa States
Chigozie Udensi (University of Johannesburg)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Migration governance in North Africa is shaped by a complex interplay of regional policies, national interests, and external influences. The African Union’s (AU) Migration Policy Framework for Africa (MPFA) aims to provide a continental blueprint for managing migration, promoting legal pathways, protecting migrants' rights, and enhancing regional integration. However, its implementation in North African states – particularly Morocco, Tunisia, and Libya – faces significant challenges due to political instability, security concerns, and external migration pressures from Europe.

 

This study examines how these three countries engage with the MPFA, assessing the extent to which national migration policies align with AU guidelines. Morocco has positioned itself as a regional migration hub, adopting policies that regularize migrants while maintaining security-focused border controls. Tunisia, despite progressive constitutional protections, struggles with policy implementation due to political volatility and economic constraints. Libya, serving as both a transit and destination country, presents the most severe challenges, as its fragile governance structures and armed conflicts hinder the application of migration policies, often leading to human rights violations against migrants.

 

Additionally, European migration management strategies – such as externalized border controls and agreements like the EU-Turkey Deal and Italy-Libya Memorandum – further complicate the effectiveness of AU migration governance. These external influences often prioritize security over human rights, undermining regional migration frameworks.

 

This paper argues that while the MPFA provides a structured approach to migration governance, its success in North Africa requires stronger institutional commitment, better coordination between national and regional actors, and reduced dependency on external migration policies. Addressing these challenges could enhance the AU’s role in fostering a more cohesive and rights-based migration governance system across the region.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Sociopolitical mobilizations and the global government of immigration policies in Africa. Governing immigration online
Jean Emmanuel Minko À Bitegni (Université de Maroua)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In their desire to make their mark on digital territory, youth movements are seizing the digital to contribute to the global government of immigration. Relying on a plurality of devices and instruments in the sense of Michel Foucault in the exercise of their daily actions and activities, they are deploying themselves in cyberspace, challenging the unilaterality of African and European states. Presenting themselves as a new form of government for immigration in Africa, these various movements have established themselves as veritable whistle-blowers and watchdogs for global government action on immigration.  This reflection is based on participant observation, carried out online from July 2020 to September 2022. This gives the opportunity to observe well, to obtain explanatory and empirical elements, centered on ethnographic material, made up of life stories and mobilizing the political socio-anthropology of domination, to participate in the renewal of conceptual and analytical frameworks of global government on immigration.

 

Keywords: Global immigration government, African and European states, Youth movements, Digital and digital, Sociopolitical entrepreneurs.

 

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The increasing role of non-governmental organizations in advocating for inclusive migration policies in the European Union highlights the need for a deeper understanding of their influence, strategies, and challenges. This research examines the complexities of NGO advocacy, aiming to explore the strategies used by these organizations to amplify the voices of migrants in EU policymaking processes. Through a combination of literature review and semi-structured interviews and policy analysts, the study identifies the challenges that non-governmental organizations face, such as legal restrictions, financial challenges. The findings of the research will contribute to the development of more effective strategies that enhance NGO influence on migration policies.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The main objective is to focus and take stock of various conversations and discourses around public policy targeted at legal engagement and dialogue on migrants’ protection and rights across the globe. Given that migrants are many atimes on the receiving end of migration policies which are focused on intensive securitisation, protectionism, and fortress building rather than managing migration.


Global migration management and policy has received political and foreign policy attention with follow-up actions by global and continental frameworks. The United Nations Global Compact on Safe, Orderly and Regular Migration, the 2015 European Union (EU) border hotspot externalisation regime and the African Union (AU) Migration Policy and Development Framework 2006 are a few examples.

 

In relation to the fundamental legal compliance on the legalities of migration and the treatment of migrants, the United Nations’ 1990 global conventions and protocols outline the protection of migrants everywhere globally from forceful expulsion and human rights abuses while specifying the migrants’ rights to diplomatic protection, legal assistance and equal legal treatment. In many receiving societies, soft tensions and dialogues do continuously exist among migrants’ group with citizens and the state to rightly establish the rights of migrants.

 

Migrants are a special interest group which influence relations in the sending and receiving society to create a sort of push and pull, enabling and restraining force field, where the more powerful, supreme, exerting and influential group, who can lobby, do greatly influence public policy decisions. Group theory in Public Policy and Public administration, explains that (organised, protection or special interest group theory) interest groups shape and change public policy due to the force field of continuous struggle among each other. When there is a good balance of interest groups influence, there is a net gain equal to the net loss of influence for each group (state and migrant group), per time. (Anderson 2014, Anyebe 2018, Dye 2016).
To contribute to the migrants’ protection and dialogue conversations which expand the diverse frontiers of migration management knowledge and the participatory process of global change in shaping global migration and public policy trajectories. This research uses both quantitative and qualitative research to  focus on migrants’ protection dialogues among various country stakeholders which will influence and impact on migration policy in both the sending countries and receiving countries globally.
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
•Why are migrants unprotected and experiencing unequal rights?
•What new policy engagements and phenomena are created among various public policy actors as a result of migrants right and inter country dialogue?
•How can intercountry migration dialogues and engagements be made to protect the legal rights of migrants?
•How does the intercountry dialogue to protect migrants rights shape relations between state, citizen and noncitizen actors.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In the nation-state era, the settlement of Rohingya refugees in Indonesia has become a significant challenge for the country. From the Indonesian perspective, some constraints impede the country's capacity to accommodate Rohingya refugees. Conversely, Indonesia is becoming increasingly prominent as a proponent of democratic principles and a defender of human rights, both within the Southeast Asia region and on the global stage. This dilemma gives rise to the question of how Indonesia should respond to the Rohingya refugee crisis in a manner that is also consistent with international norms. The paper delineates the phenomenon of community rejection as a popular nationalism phenomenon that is deployed by the state as a strategic tool to circumvent international norms due to domestic security concerns. Despite the contradiction between the rejection of Rohingya refugees and Indonesia's humanitarian principles and international norms, the framing of mass mobilization allows Indonesia to justify the rejection of Rohingya refugees as a domestic security matter in its foreign policy. These phenomena will be described using Putnam's two-level game theory to analyze and identify social phenomena at the domestic level that affect foreign policy internationally. This paper will examine how Indonesia deems community rejection a viable strategy to circumvent international norms and ASEAN commitments, particularly in the context of a domestic contest concerning stability, security, and public order – all of which are crucial domestic interests for the state to consider. It thus unpacks how Indonesia maintains its position and status as a promoter of democracy and a defender of human rights in the region and globally while dealing with domestic Rohingya refugees rejection.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

TRANSNATIONAL NETWORKS AND REPARATORY POLICIES: THE CASE OF THE ACTIONS UNDERTAKEN ON BEHALF OF COLOMBIAN VICTIMS ABROAD.
 
Melba M. Revelo Osório
University of Brasília (UnB)
 
Dr. Fernanda Natasha Bravo Cruz
University of Brasília (UnB)
 

At present, there are several national and international instruments that obligate the Colombian State to guarantee full reparation to the victims of the armed conflicts, such as: Colombian Law on Victims and Land Restitution (Law 1.448 of 2011), Peace Agreement (Colombia, 2016), Judgments of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (C-370 of 2006 and T-025 of 2004) and the Final Report of the Truth Commission (2022).
According to what is set in those instruments, the reparation must integrate economic, social, cultural and symbolic actions. Although plenty of these reparation actions have been carried out by the Colombian State along more than 10 years with the victims who reside in the Colombian territory, it has only been 5 years that the measures have started reaching those who were forcedly moved overseas. Moreover, that change could only be possible due to the role played by transnational social movements, particularly those led by directly impacted victims. (Coraza,   2020) In addition, the efforts have also been undertaken in coordination with international Non-Governmental Organizations, that have been actively designing public actions. (Lascoumes & Le Galès, 2012)
 

Upon the significant challenge involving actions on behalf of the Colombian forced migrant population, who are dispersed in more than 25 countries, it is the objective of this study to search and analyze the related phenomena, with special focus on the articulation between the State and the civil society networks. It is also taken ino account that the transnational networks play a fundamental role in connecting actors across national borders and offering greater precision in the identification and generation of proposals to meet the specific needs of the population (Scherer-Warren, 2006; Bringel and Falero, 2008). This qualitative analysis proposal will be performed through a documentary review and also based on a personal witness interview, withof one of the women, who is a current members of the Colombian Exile Network. The results of this analysis will allow the authors to recognize the diversity of instruments of public action (Halpern, Lascoumes & Le Galès, 2014) involved in one of the emotional reparation measures implemented in Brazil, in December 2023. It will also endeavor the dynamics identified in the interaction amongst the actors, as well as it foresees a balanced reflection over the contributions provided by the articulation of these actors in the reparation actions.
 
Keywords: Transnational Networks, Public Action, Forced Migration, Reparation Measure

CO-AUTHORS
Gregory Geiser (Sinclair College)
ABSTRACT

Immigration, Migration, and the Rise of Tribalism:  Examining the Past to Inform the Future

 

Today, divisions based on partisanship, ideology, ethnicity, gender, nation, class, religion, and generation define polarization within society; a major point of contention is immigration and migration from people changing places of residence.  In this paper, we tease apart immigration and migration as both result in a form of tribalism.  Here, immigration is the movement from one government-controlled place to another, whether granted permission to do so or not.  Migration is movement from one space to another, regardless of geopolitical boundaries and legal stipulations.  Tribalism, a form of nationalism, is the reaction to perceived irreconcilable differences between the “in” group, the majority inhabitants of a geographic and social area, and the “out” group, the newcomers to this area.  This is a burgeoning crisis for governments, societies, and the economy of nations which all receive the benefits and pitfalls of the immigration/migration/tribalism spectrum.

There are diverse reasons for people to immigrate or migrate, yet the impact on the resident population of an area creates social, legal, and economic challenges that result in tribalistic and nationalistic behaviors.  Exploration, explanation, and interpretation of the political and social policies of the past lead to ways that can alleviate tensions in immigration, pressures of migration, and potentially reduce tribalism in society.   An examination of historic immigration policy in Canada and the United States can inform future stakeholder decision making.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Migration governance in North Africa is shaped by a complex interplay of regional policies, national interests, and external influences. The African Union’s (AU) Migration Policy Framework for Africa (MPFA) aims to provide a continental blueprint for managing migration, promoting legal pathways, protecting migrants' rights, and enhancing regional integration. However, its implementation in North African states – particularly Morocco, Tunisia, and Libya – faces significant challenges due to political instability, security concerns, and external migration pressures from Europe.

 

This study examines how these three countries engage with the MPFA, assessing the extent to which national migration policies align with AU guidelines. Morocco has positioned itself as a regional migration hub, adopting policies that regularize migrants while maintaining security-focused border controls. Tunisia, despite progressive constitutional protections, struggles with policy implementation due to political volatility and economic constraints. Libya, serving as both a transit and destination country, presents the most severe challenges, as its fragile governance structures and armed conflicts hinder the application of migration policies, often leading to human rights violations against migrants.

 

Additionally, European migration management strategies – such as externalized border controls and agreements like the EU-Turkey Deal and Italy-Libya Memorandum – further complicate the effectiveness of AU migration governance. These external influences often prioritize security over human rights, undermining regional migration frameworks.

 

This paper argues that while the MPFA provides a structured approach to migration governance, its success in North Africa requires stronger institutional commitment, better coordination between national and regional actors, and reduced dependency on external migration policies. Addressing these challenges could enhance the AU’s role in fostering a more cohesive and rights-based migration governance system across the region.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In their desire to make their mark on digital territory, youth movements are seizing the digital to contribute to the global government of immigration. Relying on a plurality of devices and instruments in the sense of Michel Foucault in the exercise of their daily actions and activities, they are deploying themselves in cyberspace, challenging the unilaterality of African and European states. Presenting themselves as a new form of government for immigration in Africa, these various movements have established themselves as veritable whistle-blowers and watchdogs for global government action on immigration.  This reflection is based on participant observation, carried out online from July 2020 to September 2022. This gives the opportunity to observe well, to obtain explanatory and empirical elements, centered on ethnographic material, made up of life stories and mobilizing the political socio-anthropology of domination, to participate in the renewal of conceptual and analytical frameworks of global government on immigration.

 

Keywords: Global immigration government, African and European states, Youth movements, Digital and digital, Sociopolitical entrepreneurs.