P04. Public Policy Interventions for Increasing Health Insurance Coverage in Developing Countries
HEALTH POLICYCATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
Despite global progress in healthcare accessibility, substantial gaps remain, particularly in lower-income regions such as Africa, Latin America and the Caribbean, and East Asia and the Pacific, where health insurance coverage is still limited. In these countries private insurance penetration is extremely low, while public insurance mechanisms (where they exist) are woefully inadequate, despite the pursuit of universal health coverage (UHC). This panel will examine public policy interventions that have been successful or show potential for increasing health insurance coverage in developing countries.
The papers submitted will evaluate current and past interventions, identify gaps, and propose policy directions for governments, international agencies, and non-governmental organisations (NGOs) to increase health insurance coverage, ensuring greater resilience and equity in health outcomes. For example, can the policy of employer and/or employee insurance mandates used in some US states be useful in developing countries? Can a model similar to the national insurance system in Canada be applied in African or Caribbean countries? What lessons can these countries learn about health insurance from Europe?
Increasing health insurance coverage in developing countries is a critical issue with substantial implications for public health, economic resilience, and social equality. Studies consistently show that health insurance coverage can improve health outcomes, protect against catastrophic health expenditures, reduce economic disparities, and improve a country's economic performance. However, many developing countries continue to face low coverage rates, largely due to financial constraints, lack of state interventions, undiversified risk pools, inter alia. Moreover, with the significant increases in older segments of the populations expected in these regions over the next two decades, health insurance coverage is coming into sharp focus.
This panel seeks to address the gap in the literature by focusing on public policy as a vehicle for improving health insurance coverage. While much research addresses healthcare interventions, less is available on the policy structures that support sustained insurance coverage expansion in lower-income countries. Comparative analysis of successful models and data-driven approaches from countries which have successfully expanded coverage can prove instructive for those countries which are lagging. Specifically, the panel will address the following areas of enquiry:
1. What public policy interventions have been most successful in increasing health insurance coverage in developed or developing countries, and what lessons can be drawn from these efforts?
2. What are the primary socioeconomic, cultural, or systemic barriers to health insurance uptake in these regions, and how can policy measures specifically address these challenges?
3. How can emerging financing mechanisms, such as microinsurance or digital health platforms, contribute to extending coverage to underserved populations?
4. What role can international agencies and private-sector partnerships play in scaling effective health insurance programs, and what challenges are associated with these partnerships?
5. How can public policies better target vulnerable groups, such as low-income populations, rural communities, and informal workers, who often face limited access to health insurance?
This session aligns with the conference's focus on actionable strategies to tackle pressing global challenges in public health and will provide insights into policy interventions that support sustainable health system strengthening in developing countries.
CALL FOR PAPERS
As part of the 7th International Conference on Public Policy, the International Public Policy Association invites submissions for the for the panel ‘Public Policy Interventions for Increasing Health Insurance Coverage in Developing Countries’. We welcome submissions of abstracts or completed papers which explore the policy interventions for developing countries across the world to address the issue of limited health insurance coverage. While some nations have made significant progress toward comprehensive health insurance coverage, many in developing regions such Africa, Latin America and the Caribbean, and East Asia and the Pacific continue to face challenges, including limited resources, economic constraints, and the need for policy reforms to achieve universal health coverage.
Studies consistently show that health insurance coverage can improve health outcomes, protect against catastrophic health expenditures, reduce economic disparities, and improve a country's economic performance. However, many developing countries continue to face low coverage rates, largely due to financial constraints, lack of state interventions, undiversified risk pools, inter alia. Moreover, with the significant increases in older segments of the populations expected in these regions over the next two decades, health insurance coverage is coming into sharp focus.
Suggested Themes
Submitting authors can prepare theoretical, empirical or applied policy papers and case studies relevant to any of the areas of enquiry below. Papers can utilise any methodology deemed appropriate but must reflect academic best practices. Final submissions should follow the journal submission guidelines of the International Review of Public Policy. Topics/themes of interest include but are not limited to:
1. Public policy interventions that have been successful in increasing health insurance coverage in developed or developing countries, and the lessons which can be drawn from these efforts.
2. Investigating the primary socioeconomic, cultural, or systemic barriers to health insurance coverage (such as income levels, rural versus urban disparities, and employment status) in these regions, and the policy measures which can address these challenges.
3. Emerging financing mechanisms, such as micro-insurance, community health funds, mobile-based health insurance, and digital health platforms, and how they can contribute to extending coverage to underserved populations.
4. The role that international agencies and private-sector partnerships can play in scaling effective health insurance programs and fostering collaborative approaches to address gaps, and the challenges are associated with these partnerships.
Who can submit
Contributions are invited from established and emerging scholars, public intellectuals, post-graduate students and public policy practitioners in the foregoing areas of enquiry.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Abstract
The quality of a country’s human capital is essential to its economic growth and development and this is no different in the eight-member Eastern Caribbean Currency Union (ECCU). Unfortunately, during colonialism, health policy in the Caribbean was not aimed at improving its human capital, but instead centered on upholding and maintaining the country’s status as a colonial outpost of the British Empire. Pioneering government health policy was non-existent, and hence, health was greatly influenced by poverty and inequality (Downes 2001). The legacy of limited access to quality healthcare, socioeconomic inequalities, and cultural dissonance persists. Modern healthcare challenges in the Caribbean can be traced back to the colonial era, highlighting the need for decolonization efforts and culturally sensitive health interventions.
As the Caribbean focuses on the ongoing cost-of-living crisis associated with high levels of inflation and lagging salary increases, one important issue that tends to fall through the cracks is the cost of healthcare, particularly as many countries are confronted with aging populations and rising prevalence of non-communicable diseases. While Caribbean governments tend to be the main provider of basic healthcare services funded primarily through taxation, the increasing out of pocket cost for ECCU nationals has highlighted the significant gaps in health insurance coverage in the sub-region.
Using public policy analysis techniques, this chapter explores how the legacies of colonialism has left the healthcare systems in the ECCU undeveloped and unable to properly cater to the needs of the population. It will highlight weaknesses in the provision and funding of healthcare, explore how public policy can be used as a tool to boost health insurance coverage, reduce the financial burden on the state to provide healthcare, and increase health outcomes in the ECCU. Specifically, it will model how increased state-issued health insurance and private insurance policies can foster socio-economic development in the sub-region.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Health insurance is considered to be very crucial in India due to the rising burden of non-communicable diseases and injuries, the growing private health sector, poor public health spending, and high out-of-pocket expenditure. There has been rapid expansion of publicly funded health insurance scheme in India in recent times. Here, focus has been given to the expansion of health insurance in West Bengal which experienced a recent surge in enrollment under health insurance schemes.
National Family Health Survey 4 (2015-16) and 5 (2019-20) has been used to understand the expansion of state health insurance scheme (SHIs), associated factors behind the enrollment under the scheme and the existing socio-economic inequality.
Probit model has been used to understand the determinants behind the enrollment under the health insurance schemes. Concentration index proposed by Wagstaff is implied to analyze the distribution among different socio-economic categories.
Place of residence, wealth and social status, family size, age, education, having BPL care or not are the significant determinants of enrollment under the SHIs. Concentration index shows that in general the distribution of SHIs is pro-poor. It is found to be pro-rich in rural area while concentration of enrollment is pro-poor in urban area.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The Brazilian Sistema Único de Saúde (SUS) is the world’s most extensive public health system, providing free primary, secondary, and tertiary medical assistance at the point of care for at least 160 million people. This is a significant achievement, even more so when considering developing countries' fiscal constraints in the Global South. Indeed, in its more than three decades of existence, Brazil has struggled to establish a stable and robust financing framework for the SUS, hindering the country’s ability to deliver quality public health services to its entire population. Alongside the development of the SUS, a sizable private insurance industry has thrived in Brazil, which is substantially better funded than the country’s national health service despite covering only 25% of the population. The financial gap between the SUS and the private health insurance sector is a puzzling outcome, given that the 1988 Constitution, which ushered in Brazil's democratic era, explicitly called for a publicly funded, universal health system while allowing private health insurance and assistance to operate.
The study I aim to present at the 7th International Conference in Public Policy investigates the political economy dynamics that could explain the SUS’s difficulties in establishing a stable and sufficient funding framework, vis a vis the robustness and expansion of private health insurance. More specifically, it aims to understand the political and institutional effects of early decisions regarding the financing arrangement of the SUS, particularly in terms of funding integration between universalistic and noncontributory policies—such as health and social assistance—with contributory policies, i.e., social insurance. It aims to investigate how this integration shapes different patterns of interest organization, coalition building, and mobilization, defining distinct health politics patterns that ultimately hinder adequate funding for the SUS.
Moreover, it aims to discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the strategy undertaken in Brazil to extend health coverage to people experiencing poverty. The Brazilian case provides important lessons to other Global South countries that seek to achieve UHC or improve the coverage they already universally provide. Considering the fiscal constraints that often hinder Global South countries in their efforts to provide public health coverage, mixed schemes that integrate private health insurance with public options may offer viable solutions. However, Brazil serves as a cautionary tale of this approach's significant challenges and the risk of offering inadequate services to the poor while delivering generous benefits to the wealthy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In India, Out-of-Pocket (OOP) expenditure remains the dominant source of healthcare financing, constituting approximately 63% of total health expenditure (Ranjan et al., 2018). Catastrophic health expenditures push millions of Indians below the poverty line every year (Garg et al., 2022; Kurian, 2015; Prinja et al., 2012). To address this, the Indian government launched the Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY) in 2008, a centrally sponsored Publicly Funded Health Insurance Scheme (PFHI) aimed at reducing OOP expenditure and universalizing healthcare. Many states, including Maharashtra, subsequently introduced state-specific PFHIs designed to provide cashless treatment to economically vulnerable populations.
Due to significant deficiencies in the public health system, India’s PFHI schemes predominantly rely on for-profit private providers under public-private partnership (PPP) models. These schemes are funded by the government, while healthcare services are delivered by both public and private hospitals, with private providers playing the dominant role (Mahapatra et al., 2022).
Maharashtra, with its population of 112 million, is one of India’s largest and most industrialized states. However, its health system is heavily privatized, with the private sector being twice the size of the public sector in service provision (Mahapatra et al., 2022). This imbalance contributes to high OOP expenditure. To address these challenges, the state government launched the Mahatma Jyotiba Phule Jan Arogya Yojana (MJPJAY) in 2012, aimed at improving healthcare access, particularly inpatient care, for the poorer population. Despite its success in expanding access, the scheme has struggled to significantly reduce OOP expenditure (Rent & Ghosh, 2015; Sriram & Khan, 2020).
One major factor driving persistent OOP expenditure is the lack of awareness among beneficiaries, which often results in unnecessary payments to private providers. To address this, an Information and Communication Technology (ICT)-based intervention—a Short Message Service (SMS)—was introduced under the MJPJAY scheme. This initiative aimed to reduce information asymmetry, increase transparency, and empower beneficiaries to make informed healthcare decisions.
This study evaluates the impact of the SMS intervention on OOP expenditure by leveraging variations in SMS awareness to create treatment and control groups. Differences in OOP expenditure were analyzed across a matched sample, revealing that the highest reductions occurred for surgical and medical procedures, followed by medicines, with the least impact observed for diagnostic services (lab tests and radiology).
The findings indicate that the SMS intervention effectively reduced total OOP expenditure for MJPJAY beneficiaries by an average of INR 17,185 [USD 206.4]. These results are robust across various estimation techniques, including entropy balancing and alternative matching approaches.
By highlighting how ICT-based interventions can improve the accountability of private providers and reduce financial burdens on beneficiaries, this study underscores the potential of such strategies to enhance the effectiveness of PPP arrangements and contribute to universal health coverage
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the Caribbean, access to health insurance remains critically low, largely due to significant barriers faced by vulnerable groups, including low-income populations, rural communities, and informal workers, whose socio-economic realities limit their ability to participate in existing health insurance schemes. These challenges are further exacerbated by the region’s unique economic and geographic constraints, such as limited resources, high debt levels, weak human capital, systemic inefficiencies, high rates of informal employment, small and dispersed populations, and vulnerability to natural disasters. Collectively, these factors create a complex web of issues that threaten the achievement of Sustainable Development Goal 3: ensuring good health and well-being for all.
This paper employs econometric methods to identify and analyse the barriers to health insurance access in the Caribbean. It also explores the potential of innovative solutions such as government-subsidized insurance, community-based health financing (CBHF), public-private partnerships (PPPs), and technological advancements like telemedicine in addressing these challenges. Public policy plays a critical role in mitigating health disparities in Small Island Developing States (SIDS) through the implementation of targeted, evidence-based strategies to expand health insurance coverage. To ensure effective interventions, however, sound technical analysis must guide policy formulation, aligning solutions with the specific contexts of each country.
By examining case studies from Jamaica, the Eastern Caribbean Currency Union, and Trinidad and Tobago, this study provides actionable recommendations for policymakers to promote equitable health insurance coverage, advance universal health coverage (UHC), and reduce health disparities across the region.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Abstract
The Implementation and Further Development of Universal Health Insurance Coverage in Curaçao
In 2013, Curaçao, an autonomous Dutch Caribbean island, undertook a significant reform by transitioning from a fragmented health insurance system to a single-payer universal health coverage scheme, known as Basisverzekering Ziektekosten (BVZ). This initiative aimed to enhance equity, efficiency, and financial sustainability in healthcare access. Now, more than a decade later, the Social Insurance Bank of Curaçao (SVB) administers the BVZ, providing coverage to approximately 85% of the population. This paper evaluates the reform’s implementation, impact, and future directions, offering lessons for other developing nations considering universal health coverage.
Prior to the reform, Curaçao operated under a two-tier system that divided the population into multiple public and private insurance schemes. Public insurance covered three groups: low-income formal workers under a payroll-based system, government employees under separate pools, and the poor through tax-funded healthcare. Meanwhile, private insurance, largely risk-rated, covered self-employed individuals and higher-income earners, leaving a segment of the population uninsured. This fragmented model led to disparities in healthcare access, risk segmentation, and inefficiencies in resource allocation.
The BVZ reform consolidated these disparate pools into a unified system, improving risk pooling, purchasing power, and administrative efficiency. The reform aligned with World Health Organization (WHO) strategies for universal coverage, focusing on broadening revenue collection, increasing risk pooling, and optimizing expenditure efficiency. The BVZ is primarily financed through payroll contributions (55-60%) and general taxation (40-45%), reflecting a hybrid funding model that balances solidarity with economic sustainability.
Despite its successes, challenges remain. The reliance on payroll-based funding creates an unequal burden between formal and informal workers. Alternative financing models, such as indirect taxation or health-specific levies (e.g., sin taxes on tobacco and alcohol), could provide a more equitable solution while reinforcing social solidarity. Additionally, continuous efforts are needed to enhance provider reimbursement mechanisms, ensure adherence to treatment protocols, and strengthen regulatory oversight to sustain the system’s long-term viability.
The case of Curaçao demonstrates that universal health coverage is achievable even within small-scale economies when strategic policy choices, effective financial mechanisms, and strong regulatory frameworks are in place. The insights gained from this reform offer valuable guidance for other developing countries seeking to implement or refine their own universal health insurance models.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
PUBLIC POLICY INTERVENTIONS FOR INCREASING HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
ADOPTING SOCIAL HEALTH INSURANCE IN THE CARIBBEAN
Anton Cumberbatch, Stanley Lalta and Karl Theodore
ABSTRACT
The paper begins with the rationale for increasing health insurance in the Caribbean and points to the fact that the similarity of the epidemiological profiles in both developed and developing countries today suggests that the rationale is essentially the same in both sets of countries: to take the countries closer to the Universal Health Coverage (UHC) goal of equitable and comprehensive coverage, without financial distress. The paper highlights three policy instruments: 1) fiscal policy, to ensure adequate space for healthcare, 2) the social security organization, the potential manager of the health insurance system, and 3) sustained communication with the public about the importance of protecting their health status, by the choices they are making. With the mandatory social insurance emphasis on preventative health care aimed at keeping the morbidity burden on the health system as low as possible, the paper then discusses the main public policy challenges, including the need for a modern health information system and the need to have the health insurance designed to foster efficiency in the delivery of healthcare. The discussion closes with a few recommendations on the way forward.
Key words: equity, efficiency, sustainability
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Women’s access to healthcare is an important public health and human rights issue. India has been at the forefront of efforts for Universal Health Coverage (UHC) via publicly funded health insurance (PFHI) programs. However, the rapid rise of non-communicable diseases (NCDs) signals a need to re-examine and reorient health policy priorities. Our working paper examines the changing burden of NCDs which include cardiovascular diseases (CVDs), cancer, diabetes and kidney disorders, and chronic respiratory diseases for women in India. Using the India State-level Burden of Disease Study, we examined gender differences in the changing mortality and morbidity in India between 2000 and 2018, to understand key areas of concern and where interventions are urgently needed. In contrast to men, women reported higher mortality from cancer, neurological diseases, and diarrheal diseases, but reported equivalent rates of CVDs, chronic diseases, diabetes and kidney diseases, respiratory infections, and tuberculosis (TB), unintentional injuries, and HIV. For morbidity, measured in DALYs, women’s burden was higher for cancer, nutritional deficiencies, musculoskeletal diseases, and diarrheal diseases. We used the National Family Health Survey 2019-21 to report rates of health insurance and found wide variation across states. We then examined determinants of access to health insurance, in particular the role of women’s agency and socioeconomic status. Our findings show that women who demonstrated greater self-control in their life choices, including financial decision-making, health-related decision-making, and their movement reported higher access to insurance. However, within this pathway, having access to financial decision-making was associated with a greater likelihood of employment-related insurance, while healthcare decision-making and mobility were associated with access to state/community health insurance. Self-reported barriers to health seeking for women including health systems determinants such as lack of doctors, particularly female doctors, and lack of drugs, followed by other factors such as permission from family, financial resources, distance and transport. Using a case study of insurance data use from Meghalaya between 2019 and 2022, we found that women reported greater use of secondary health services compared to tertiary and super specialized care among men. We utilized Thaddeus and Maine’s Three Delays Framework (1994) to unpack issues in access for health care among women. Our work recognizes that the need for state and context specific policies and practices to address the burden of NCDs among women and to understand the NCD burden based on risk profiles and further disaggregations.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Research, policy, and practice in the domains of public health have historically recognized environmental health and occupational health and safety as distinct subfields. From a policy perspective, macro-level policy settings also have an impact on the relationship between work, environment and health, and it interacts with individual characteristics such as socioeconomic status, gender, age, location of residence, and race/ethnicity. The present study looks at the street vendors as the particularly vulnerable subgroup of informal workers who face the twin burden of occupational and environmental health risks. As a significant part of the floating population in India, the street vendors face hurdles in navigating the health policy processes in accessing and using the health services in India. Because of their informal employment status, low income, and lack of knowledge about health insurance, street vendors in India are frequently excluded from Universal Health Coverage (UHC) schemes like PMJAY. The study adopts a mixed methods approach to collect data from street vendors in the city of Bhubaneswar in India. This rapidly urbanizing city hosts a significant population of street vendors, whose livelihoods are intricately tied to the local environment and the state leadership has its own health insurance coverage scheme pitted against the national universal coverage scheme. Quantitative data has been collected using a structured survey questionnaire, the qualitative strands of data have been gathered using Focus Group Discussions and In-depth interviews with key informants. Participants include a diverse sample of street vendors selected through random sampling, ensuring variation in demographics, product types, and vending locations, across high density and low-density zones of the city. The findings give insight into the socioeconomic challenges and coping strategies of street vendors in informal work spaces and the lack of health policy awareness that leads to their exclusion from public healthcare. The study underlines the need for measures to spread health policy awareness among the street vendors who face exacerbated health inequalities. The interplay of occupational and environmental health risks for the informal workers calls for designing of preferential policy frameworks to address their specific healthcare needs and promote effectiveness of national health policies. The study will contribute to the equity lens in the health policy literature by identifying and contextualizing the barriers to health insurance coverage faced by the street vending community in the global south.
Keywords: health insurance, health policy, informal workers, street vendors, occupational and environmental health
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Social Health Protection (SHP) is a human right to health, and India’s Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (PM-JAY) is one of the world’s largest informal sector-based SHP Policy (SHPP). Unlike other Indian states/UTs, PM-JAY was made “Completely Universal” in Jammu and Kashmir (J&K) in December–2020. This paper examines the health care and socio-economic impact multipliers of this SHPP, based on a Mixed–Methods field study of 300 Households and 30 Secondary-Stakeholders from two districts of Kashmir region of J&K.
The paper argues that PM-JAY has significantly increased the availability of healthcare services across districts – hospitals, doctors, medicine, equipment and diagnostic-testing facilities. Provided treatment with respect and dignity and changed the utilization pattern towards specialized healthcare. While the private sector has contributed, the availability and reliance is more on public hospitals. All socio-economic, geographical and gender diversities have accessed PM-JAY, with higher proportion of vulnerable groups among benefitted, and no signs of access inequality. Out-of-pocket expenditure has significantly reduced, and people have been able to make comfortable spending in household consumption and children education. Notwithstanding, some scattered issues continue to persist. The paper contends that PM-JAY as a universal SHPP has demonstrated wider coverage, inclusivity and impact in J&K. However, for large-scale and sustained availability and equitable access, strengthening registration system, deeper awareness generation and CSO engagement, quality control, and expansion of empanelled hospitals, public transport and ambulance service in far-flung Rural and Tribal areas needs to be prioritized.
Keywords: Social Health Protection, availability, impact, impact multipliers, challenges.
Acknowledgement: This paper is extracted from a major research project on social health protection in Jammu and Kashmir, funded by Indian Council of Social Science Research (ICSSR), New Delhi.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Abstract
The quality of a country’s human capital is essential to its economic growth and development and this is no different in the eight-member Eastern Caribbean Currency Union (ECCU). Unfortunately, during colonialism, health policy in the Caribbean was not aimed at improving its human capital, but instead centered on upholding and maintaining the country’s status as a colonial outpost of the British Empire. Pioneering government health policy was non-existent, and hence, health was greatly influenced by poverty and inequality (Downes 2001). The legacy of limited access to quality healthcare, socioeconomic inequalities, and cultural dissonance persists. Modern healthcare challenges in the Caribbean can be traced back to the colonial era, highlighting the need for decolonization efforts and culturally sensitive health interventions.
As the Caribbean focuses on the ongoing cost-of-living crisis associated with high levels of inflation and lagging salary increases, one important issue that tends to fall through the cracks is the cost of healthcare, particularly as many countries are confronted with aging populations and rising prevalence of non-communicable diseases. While Caribbean governments tend to be the main provider of basic healthcare services funded primarily through taxation, the increasing out of pocket cost for ECCU nationals has highlighted the significant gaps in health insurance coverage in the sub-region.
Using public policy analysis techniques, this chapter explores how the legacies of colonialism has left the healthcare systems in the ECCU undeveloped and unable to properly cater to the needs of the population. It will highlight weaknesses in the provision and funding of healthcare, explore how public policy can be used as a tool to boost health insurance coverage, reduce the financial burden on the state to provide healthcare, and increase health outcomes in the ECCU. Specifically, it will model how increased state-issued health insurance and private insurance policies can foster socio-economic development in the sub-region.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Health insurance is considered to be very crucial in India due to the rising burden of non-communicable diseases and injuries, the growing private health sector, poor public health spending, and high out-of-pocket expenditure. There has been rapid expansion of publicly funded health insurance scheme in India in recent times. Here, focus has been given to the expansion of health insurance in West Bengal which experienced a recent surge in enrollment under health insurance schemes.
National Family Health Survey 4 (2015-16) and 5 (2019-20) has been used to understand the expansion of state health insurance scheme (SHIs), associated factors behind the enrollment under the scheme and the existing socio-economic inequality.
Probit model has been used to understand the determinants behind the enrollment under the health insurance schemes. Concentration index proposed by Wagstaff is implied to analyze the distribution among different socio-economic categories.
Place of residence, wealth and social status, family size, age, education, having BPL care or not are the significant determinants of enrollment under the SHIs. Concentration index shows that in general the distribution of SHIs is pro-poor. It is found to be pro-rich in rural area while concentration of enrollment is pro-poor in urban area.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The Brazilian Sistema Único de Saúde (SUS) is the world’s most extensive public health system, providing free primary, secondary, and tertiary medical assistance at the point of care for at least 160 million people. This is a significant achievement, even more so when considering developing countries' fiscal constraints in the Global South. Indeed, in its more than three decades of existence, Brazil has struggled to establish a stable and robust financing framework for the SUS, hindering the country’s ability to deliver quality public health services to its entire population. Alongside the development of the SUS, a sizable private insurance industry has thrived in Brazil, which is substantially better funded than the country’s national health service despite covering only 25% of the population. The financial gap between the SUS and the private health insurance sector is a puzzling outcome, given that the 1988 Constitution, which ushered in Brazil's democratic era, explicitly called for a publicly funded, universal health system while allowing private health insurance and assistance to operate.
The study I aim to present at the 7th International Conference in Public Policy investigates the political economy dynamics that could explain the SUS’s difficulties in establishing a stable and sufficient funding framework, vis a vis the robustness and expansion of private health insurance. More specifically, it aims to understand the political and institutional effects of early decisions regarding the financing arrangement of the SUS, particularly in terms of funding integration between universalistic and noncontributory policies—such as health and social assistance—with contributory policies, i.e., social insurance. It aims to investigate how this integration shapes different patterns of interest organization, coalition building, and mobilization, defining distinct health politics patterns that ultimately hinder adequate funding for the SUS.
Moreover, it aims to discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the strategy undertaken in Brazil to extend health coverage to people experiencing poverty. The Brazilian case provides important lessons to other Global South countries that seek to achieve UHC or improve the coverage they already universally provide. Considering the fiscal constraints that often hinder Global South countries in their efforts to provide public health coverage, mixed schemes that integrate private health insurance with public options may offer viable solutions. However, Brazil serves as a cautionary tale of this approach's significant challenges and the risk of offering inadequate services to the poor while delivering generous benefits to the wealthy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In India, Out-of-Pocket (OOP) expenditure remains the dominant source of healthcare financing, constituting approximately 63% of total health expenditure (Ranjan et al., 2018). Catastrophic health expenditures push millions of Indians below the poverty line every year (Garg et al., 2022; Kurian, 2015; Prinja et al., 2012). To address this, the Indian government launched the Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY) in 2008, a centrally sponsored Publicly Funded Health Insurance Scheme (PFHI) aimed at reducing OOP expenditure and universalizing healthcare. Many states, including Maharashtra, subsequently introduced state-specific PFHIs designed to provide cashless treatment to economically vulnerable populations.
Due to significant deficiencies in the public health system, India’s PFHI schemes predominantly rely on for-profit private providers under public-private partnership (PPP) models. These schemes are funded by the government, while healthcare services are delivered by both public and private hospitals, with private providers playing the dominant role (Mahapatra et al., 2022).
Maharashtra, with its population of 112 million, is one of India’s largest and most industrialized states. However, its health system is heavily privatized, with the private sector being twice the size of the public sector in service provision (Mahapatra et al., 2022). This imbalance contributes to high OOP expenditure. To address these challenges, the state government launched the Mahatma Jyotiba Phule Jan Arogya Yojana (MJPJAY) in 2012, aimed at improving healthcare access, particularly inpatient care, for the poorer population. Despite its success in expanding access, the scheme has struggled to significantly reduce OOP expenditure (Rent & Ghosh, 2015; Sriram & Khan, 2020).
One major factor driving persistent OOP expenditure is the lack of awareness among beneficiaries, which often results in unnecessary payments to private providers. To address this, an Information and Communication Technology (ICT)-based intervention—a Short Message Service (SMS)—was introduced under the MJPJAY scheme. This initiative aimed to reduce information asymmetry, increase transparency, and empower beneficiaries to make informed healthcare decisions.
This study evaluates the impact of the SMS intervention on OOP expenditure by leveraging variations in SMS awareness to create treatment and control groups. Differences in OOP expenditure were analyzed across a matched sample, revealing that the highest reductions occurred for surgical and medical procedures, followed by medicines, with the least impact observed for diagnostic services (lab tests and radiology).
The findings indicate that the SMS intervention effectively reduced total OOP expenditure for MJPJAY beneficiaries by an average of INR 17,185 [USD 206.4]. These results are robust across various estimation techniques, including entropy balancing and alternative matching approaches.
By highlighting how ICT-based interventions can improve the accountability of private providers and reduce financial burdens on beneficiaries, this study underscores the potential of such strategies to enhance the effectiveness of PPP arrangements and contribute to universal health coverage
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the Caribbean, access to health insurance remains critically low, largely due to significant barriers faced by vulnerable groups, including low-income populations, rural communities, and informal workers, whose socio-economic realities limit their ability to participate in existing health insurance schemes. These challenges are further exacerbated by the region’s unique economic and geographic constraints, such as limited resources, high debt levels, weak human capital, systemic inefficiencies, high rates of informal employment, small and dispersed populations, and vulnerability to natural disasters. Collectively, these factors create a complex web of issues that threaten the achievement of Sustainable Development Goal 3: ensuring good health and well-being for all.
This paper employs econometric methods to identify and analyse the barriers to health insurance access in the Caribbean. It also explores the potential of innovative solutions such as government-subsidized insurance, community-based health financing (CBHF), public-private partnerships (PPPs), and technological advancements like telemedicine in addressing these challenges. Public policy plays a critical role in mitigating health disparities in Small Island Developing States (SIDS) through the implementation of targeted, evidence-based strategies to expand health insurance coverage. To ensure effective interventions, however, sound technical analysis must guide policy formulation, aligning solutions with the specific contexts of each country.
By examining case studies from Jamaica, the Eastern Caribbean Currency Union, and Trinidad and Tobago, this study provides actionable recommendations for policymakers to promote equitable health insurance coverage, advance universal health coverage (UHC), and reduce health disparities across the region.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Abstract
The Implementation and Further Development of Universal Health Insurance Coverage in Curaçao
In 2013, Curaçao, an autonomous Dutch Caribbean island, undertook a significant reform by transitioning from a fragmented health insurance system to a single-payer universal health coverage scheme, known as Basisverzekering Ziektekosten (BVZ). This initiative aimed to enhance equity, efficiency, and financial sustainability in healthcare access. Now, more than a decade later, the Social Insurance Bank of Curaçao (SVB) administers the BVZ, providing coverage to approximately 85% of the population. This paper evaluates the reform’s implementation, impact, and future directions, offering lessons for other developing nations considering universal health coverage.
Prior to the reform, Curaçao operated under a two-tier system that divided the population into multiple public and private insurance schemes. Public insurance covered three groups: low-income formal workers under a payroll-based system, government employees under separate pools, and the poor through tax-funded healthcare. Meanwhile, private insurance, largely risk-rated, covered self-employed individuals and higher-income earners, leaving a segment of the population uninsured. This fragmented model led to disparities in healthcare access, risk segmentation, and inefficiencies in resource allocation.
The BVZ reform consolidated these disparate pools into a unified system, improving risk pooling, purchasing power, and administrative efficiency. The reform aligned with World Health Organization (WHO) strategies for universal coverage, focusing on broadening revenue collection, increasing risk pooling, and optimizing expenditure efficiency. The BVZ is primarily financed through payroll contributions (55-60%) and general taxation (40-45%), reflecting a hybrid funding model that balances solidarity with economic sustainability.
Despite its successes, challenges remain. The reliance on payroll-based funding creates an unequal burden between formal and informal workers. Alternative financing models, such as indirect taxation or health-specific levies (e.g., sin taxes on tobacco and alcohol), could provide a more equitable solution while reinforcing social solidarity. Additionally, continuous efforts are needed to enhance provider reimbursement mechanisms, ensure adherence to treatment protocols, and strengthen regulatory oversight to sustain the system’s long-term viability.
The case of Curaçao demonstrates that universal health coverage is achievable even within small-scale economies when strategic policy choices, effective financial mechanisms, and strong regulatory frameworks are in place. The insights gained from this reform offer valuable guidance for other developing countries seeking to implement or refine their own universal health insurance models.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
PUBLIC POLICY INTERVENTIONS FOR INCREASING HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
ADOPTING SOCIAL HEALTH INSURANCE IN THE CARIBBEAN
Anton Cumberbatch, Stanley Lalta and Karl Theodore
ABSTRACT
The paper begins with the rationale for increasing health insurance in the Caribbean and points to the fact that the similarity of the epidemiological profiles in both developed and developing countries today suggests that the rationale is essentially the same in both sets of countries: to take the countries closer to the Universal Health Coverage (UHC) goal of equitable and comprehensive coverage, without financial distress. The paper highlights three policy instruments: 1) fiscal policy, to ensure adequate space for healthcare, 2) the social security organization, the potential manager of the health insurance system, and 3) sustained communication with the public about the importance of protecting their health status, by the choices they are making. With the mandatory social insurance emphasis on preventative health care aimed at keeping the morbidity burden on the health system as low as possible, the paper then discusses the main public policy challenges, including the need for a modern health information system and the need to have the health insurance designed to foster efficiency in the delivery of healthcare. The discussion closes with a few recommendations on the way forward.
Key words: equity, efficiency, sustainability
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Women’s access to healthcare is an important public health and human rights issue. India has been at the forefront of efforts for Universal Health Coverage (UHC) via publicly funded health insurance (PFHI) programs. However, the rapid rise of non-communicable diseases (NCDs) signals a need to re-examine and reorient health policy priorities. Our working paper examines the changing burden of NCDs which include cardiovascular diseases (CVDs), cancer, diabetes and kidney disorders, and chronic respiratory diseases for women in India. Using the India State-level Burden of Disease Study, we examined gender differences in the changing mortality and morbidity in India between 2000 and 2018, to understand key areas of concern and where interventions are urgently needed. In contrast to men, women reported higher mortality from cancer, neurological diseases, and diarrheal diseases, but reported equivalent rates of CVDs, chronic diseases, diabetes and kidney diseases, respiratory infections, and tuberculosis (TB), unintentional injuries, and HIV. For morbidity, measured in DALYs, women’s burden was higher for cancer, nutritional deficiencies, musculoskeletal diseases, and diarrheal diseases. We used the National Family Health Survey 2019-21 to report rates of health insurance and found wide variation across states. We then examined determinants of access to health insurance, in particular the role of women’s agency and socioeconomic status. Our findings show that women who demonstrated greater self-control in their life choices, including financial decision-making, health-related decision-making, and their movement reported higher access to insurance. However, within this pathway, having access to financial decision-making was associated with a greater likelihood of employment-related insurance, while healthcare decision-making and mobility were associated with access to state/community health insurance. Self-reported barriers to health seeking for women including health systems determinants such as lack of doctors, particularly female doctors, and lack of drugs, followed by other factors such as permission from family, financial resources, distance and transport. Using a case study of insurance data use from Meghalaya between 2019 and 2022, we found that women reported greater use of secondary health services compared to tertiary and super specialized care among men. We utilized Thaddeus and Maine’s Three Delays Framework (1994) to unpack issues in access for health care among women. Our work recognizes that the need for state and context specific policies and practices to address the burden of NCDs among women and to understand the NCD burden based on risk profiles and further disaggregations.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Research, policy, and practice in the domains of public health have historically recognized environmental health and occupational health and safety as distinct subfields. From a policy perspective, macro-level policy settings also have an impact on the relationship between work, environment and health, and it interacts with individual characteristics such as socioeconomic status, gender, age, location of residence, and race/ethnicity. The present study looks at the street vendors as the particularly vulnerable subgroup of informal workers who face the twin burden of occupational and environmental health risks. As a significant part of the floating population in India, the street vendors face hurdles in navigating the health policy processes in accessing and using the health services in India. Because of their informal employment status, low income, and lack of knowledge about health insurance, street vendors in India are frequently excluded from Universal Health Coverage (UHC) schemes like PMJAY. The study adopts a mixed methods approach to collect data from street vendors in the city of Bhubaneswar in India. This rapidly urbanizing city hosts a significant population of street vendors, whose livelihoods are intricately tied to the local environment and the state leadership has its own health insurance coverage scheme pitted against the national universal coverage scheme. Quantitative data has been collected using a structured survey questionnaire, the qualitative strands of data have been gathered using Focus Group Discussions and In-depth interviews with key informants. Participants include a diverse sample of street vendors selected through random sampling, ensuring variation in demographics, product types, and vending locations, across high density and low-density zones of the city. The findings give insight into the socioeconomic challenges and coping strategies of street vendors in informal work spaces and the lack of health policy awareness that leads to their exclusion from public healthcare. The study underlines the need for measures to spread health policy awareness among the street vendors who face exacerbated health inequalities. The interplay of occupational and environmental health risks for the informal workers calls for designing of preferential policy frameworks to address their specific healthcare needs and promote effectiveness of national health policies. The study will contribute to the equity lens in the health policy literature by identifying and contextualizing the barriers to health insurance coverage faced by the street vending community in the global south.
Keywords: health insurance, health policy, informal workers, street vendors, occupational and environmental health
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Social Health Protection (SHP) is a human right to health, and India’s Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (PM-JAY) is one of the world’s largest informal sector-based SHP Policy (SHPP). Unlike other Indian states/UTs, PM-JAY was made “Completely Universal” in Jammu and Kashmir (J&K) in December–2020. This paper examines the health care and socio-economic impact multipliers of this SHPP, based on a Mixed–Methods field study of 300 Households and 30 Secondary-Stakeholders from two districts of Kashmir region of J&K.
The paper argues that PM-JAY has significantly increased the availability of healthcare services across districts – hospitals, doctors, medicine, equipment and diagnostic-testing facilities. Provided treatment with respect and dignity and changed the utilization pattern towards specialized healthcare. While the private sector has contributed, the availability and reliance is more on public hospitals. All socio-economic, geographical and gender diversities have accessed PM-JAY, with higher proportion of vulnerable groups among benefitted, and no signs of access inequality. Out-of-pocket expenditure has significantly reduced, and people have been able to make comfortable spending in household consumption and children education. Notwithstanding, some scattered issues continue to persist. The paper contends that PM-JAY as a universal SHPP has demonstrated wider coverage, inclusivity and impact in J&K. However, for large-scale and sustained availability and equitable access, strengthening registration system, deeper awareness generation and CSO engagement, quality control, and expansion of empanelled hospitals, public transport and ambulance service in far-flung Rural and Tribal areas needs to be prioritized.
Keywords: Social Health Protection, availability, impact, impact multipliers, challenges.
Acknowledgement: This paper is extracted from a major research project on social health protection in Jammu and Kashmir, funded by Indian Council of Social Science Research (ICSSR), New Delhi.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)