Format

P02. The Role of Policy Actors in the Territorialization and Regionalization Processes of Healthcare Systems

HEALTH POLICY
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Patrick Hassenteufel
Université Paris-Saclay
Main chair
Nils Bandelow
Technische Universität Carolo-Wilhelmina Braunschweig
Second chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
HEALTH POLICY
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Recent developments in health policy literature have increasingly highlighted the substantial role that local, regional, and national actors play in the structuring and adaptation of healthcare services (Terlizzi, 2019; Terlizzi & Esposito, 2021; Bandelow et al., 2024). These policies include not only the classic objectives for healthcare such as affordability, quality and equal access and provision of services for the entire population. They also address new health policy issues like shortage of skilled healthcare workers and strengthening of public health. Public health is especially of interest with the integration of the health system not only with regard to different parts of the health sector but also to other policy sectors such as education, food, environment, housing or transport, for which local authorities have some competencies. The perspectives of integrated care and public health also address the recent multiple crises such as the COVID 19 pandemic, populism and climate change.
 
Using the notion of territorialization to analyze these transformation processes is a way to go beyond the dominant comparative perspective on subnational dimensions of health systems based on the more institutional notions of regionalization, decentralization and federalism and less bottom-up oriented. Current research on regionalization in healthcare is dominated by health sciences and not by policy process research. The aim of this panel is to contribute to the development of policy process research on how territorial reforms are designed, circulate and are implemented.
 
This panel focuses on how policy actors—including political entrepreneurs, advocacy coalitions, and programmatic groups—drive the territorialization of health systems. Such policy studies perspectives offer insights into the conditions and processes shaping health reforms to address the unique social, economic, and political landscapes of different regions.
Programmatic groups, typically comprised of specialists and policymakers, can play an essential role in the design and implementation of local healthcare strategies. These groups leverage specialized expertise and resources to craft programs tailored to regional needs. Programmatic groups also facilitate the adaptation of national health directives by designing solutions specific to diverse political and social settings (Bandelow et al., 2021; Hassenteufel & Genieys, 2021). Policy entrepreneurs emerge as key actors in health policy, often driving regional reforms by capitalizing on "windows of opportunity" to adapt existing systems to better align with local demands. Entrepreneurs build coalitions and secure the backing of local authorities, making use of regional resources and aligning with interest groups to support their objectives (Petridou & Mintrom, 2020; Hand & Birkhead, 2023; Herweg et al., 2023). The Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF) serves as a valuable lens for understanding cooperation and competition among interest groups advocating for regional health reforms  (Bogumil-Uçan & Klenk, 2021; Nohrstedt et al., 2023).
 
This panel also aims to delve into both the substantive aspects and the contextual conditions underpinning the territorialization of health systems. Regarding the content of territorialization strategies, an important focus is on the discursive and narrative framing. Examining the conditions that frame territorialization processes, we also consider the institutional contexts of both political and healthcare systems.

CALL FOR PAPERS

This panel focuses on how actors—including political entrepreneurs, advocacy coalitions, and programmatic groups—drive the territorialization and regionalization of health systems. It  also aims to delve into both the substantive aspects and the contextual conditions underpinning the territorialization of health systems. Regarding the content of territorialization strategies, an important focus is on the discursive and narrative framing: Are these strategies driven by a commitment to strengthening a public health perspective? Do they seek to enhance quality by targeting region-specific health needs? Territorialization might also aim to improve system efficiency, potentially enabling more seamless interactions across subsystems within local healthcare delivery. Furthermore, do these discourses address external factors, such as regional autonomy movements?
Examining the conditions that frame territorialization processes, we consider the institutional contexts of both political and healthcare systems. How do territorialization strategies unfold within federal or centralized states? Are there differences between types of health systems?
These themes bridge the study of health system territorialization with broader public policy debates and allow for interdisciplinary inquiry that incorporates welfare state research and comparative politics.
 
This panel examines the complex interplay among diverse actors and theoretical perspectives related to health system territorialization. Policy process research delivers essential insights into how regional health policies are designed and implemented. These perspectives aim to deepen our understanding of actor dynamics and analyze how subnational bottom-up processes impact health system development across various territorial contexts.
We invite submissions to explore the territorial and regional aspects of health systems all over the world. Papers focusing on the role of programmatic groups, policy entrepreneurs, interest groups, political parties, advocacy coalitions, narratives and institutional dynamics as drivers or obstructors of regional health policy development are especially welcome. This panel seeks to understand how these actors shape the processes that allow healthcare systems to adapt to the distinct health, social, economic, and political realities of various regions.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Obstacles to multisectoral maternal and child healthcare financing in Uganda: insights from policy bureaucrats
Maureen Sylvia Kusiima (University of Pretoria)
CO-AUTHORS
Gerda Van Dijk (University of Pretoria)
ABSTRACT

Title: Obstacles to multisectoral maternal and child healthcare financing in Uganda: insights from policy bureaucrats

 

Dr. Maureen Sylvia Kusiima,a Prof. Gerda van Dijk,b Dr. Mary S Mangai,c Prof. & Olanrewaju Olaniyan,d

 

a Postdoctoral Fellow, School of Public Management and Administration, University of Pretoria, South Africa (Corresponding Author).

 

b Director, School of Public Management and Administration, University of Pretoria, South Africa.

 

c Senior Lecturer, School of Public Management and Administration, University of Pretoria, South Africa.

 

d Professor of Economics, Dean, Faculty of Economics and Management Sciences, University of Ibadan, Nigeria.

 

Abstract

Maternal and child healthcare (MCH) financing is a global priority, and it is one of the core components of the health systems building blocks. Ensuring adequate MCH financing is critical for better MCH outcomes, but it remains a challenge for most developing countries, including Uganda. This research explores the obstacles to multisectoral MCH financing in Uganda. To deepen the understanding of MCH financing 8 in-depth interviews were held with MCH stakeholder which means that the study adopted a qualitative approach to collect data through interviews and document reviews. The study employed thematic analyses to comprehensively present the data. The study identifies several challenges to multisectoral MCH financing, including the absence of a specific and explicit MCH framework on MCH financing, poor understanding of the meaning of multisectoral collaboration in MCH financing, low acceptance of prepayment forms of financing, and failure to fulfill pledges and government commitments. Moreover, the lack of clear and streamlined stakeholders’ roles and responsibilities, failure to prioritise and include MCH issues in all national policies, and the fragmentation and vertical funding limit the leveraging of MCH resources. Delays in approving the financing frameworks have hindered the implementation of the financing instruments, thus affecting the pooling of MCH funds in Uganda. This study concludes that, considering the diminishing MCH financial resources due to gaps in current financing frameworks, the Government of Uganda should strengthen and enhance its legal and policy financing instruments.

 

Keywords: Collaboration, maternal and child health, healthcare financing, instruments, stakeholder responsibilities and roles, policy bureaucrats


 

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - The territorial policies of healthcare coordination facing ageing issues in France
Marine Boisson (Institut d'Etudes Politiques de Paris (Sciences Po))
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper presents the research carried out by the Health Chair of Sciences Po Paris since October 2023 on the territorialization and coordination of the French healthcare system in response to ageing issues. The French healthcare system is facing main challenges, linked to the ageing of the population and of medical professionals, especially GPs. They have led to the development of more coordinated practices between health professionals so as between the healthcare and the medico-social sectors. Observable on a national scale, these dynamics are also at work in sub-national territories. The study examines these dynamics and the relationships between the institutions involved, whether health insurance funds, healthcare professionals (CPTS, URPS) and institutions (ARS, local authorities, DAC, old-age insurance funds), in six metropolitan départements (Meurthe-et-Moselle, Lot, Seine-Saint-Denis, Yvelines, Ille-et-Vilaine and Cher). In this paper, we analyze the local issues of healthcare coordination, its levels of governance, its main policy players, its degree of structuring and its development or slowdown factors.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Navigating Regionalization in Brazil’s Health System: Challenges, Institutional Responses, and Policy Innovations
Andreza Davidian (FGV - EPPG School of Public Policy and Government)
CO-AUTHORS
Marco Antonio Catussi Paschoalotto (Universidade do Minho)
Alessandro Bigoni (Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health)
Adriano Massuda (Sao Paulo School of Business Administration)
ABSTRACT

The Brazilian Unified Health System (SUS) provides comprehensive services across a vast and unequal territory. Since its inception in 1988, SUS has undergone profound transformations, shaped mainly by public health experts (sanitaristas), who have played a central role in structuring its governance, financing, and territorial organization through: i) the decentralization of services and responsibilities, and ii) the organization of healthcare by the regionalization directive.

 

Despite significant advancements, the regionalization of SUS continues to face structural and political challenges that hinder its full consolidation. Persistent inequalities in healthcare provision across regions, exacerbated by fiscal constraints and varying administrative capacities, lead to disparities in access and quality of care. Decentralization introduces specific coordination challenges in decision-making among federal, state, and municipal entities. At the same time, intergovernmental negotiations often expose power imbalances, with wealthier regions exerting greater influence over resource allocation. Moreover, political instability and shifting government priorities at all three levels further disrupt the continuity of long-term strategies, undermining institutional efforts to strengthen regionalized governance.

 

On the other hand, incremental adjustments have been implemented to enhance SUS’s intergovernmental governance and strengthen regionalization. Measures such as (a) the formalization of inter-management commissions as forums for negotiation and agreement between managers on SUS operations and (b) the institutionalization of councils of health secretaries as representative entities of state and municipal governments have helped improve technical and managerial support for federal-level decision-making. Recent evidence suggests that these actors can even function as a system of checks and balances. For instance, a data consortium led by the National Council of Health Secretaries (CONASS), in partnership with media, researchers, and universities, became a reliable source for monitoring COVID-19 in Brazil, countering the federal government's inadequate data reporting.

 

To contribute to the discussion on health system regionalization, this study examines how Brazil has responded to these challenges from the perspective of collective actors that represent local and subnational health managers and their interactions within federal decision-making arenas. It explores how decentralization and federal oversight have been combined in designing institutional reforms, financial instruments, and governance arrangements to guide regionalization. To achieve this objective, the research employs a qualitative approach, including document analysis, literature review, and interviews with public health managers.  The authors also discuss some of the findings in the light of the effects that the changes had in healthcare resource utilization in the territory. The findings suggest a progressively structured regionalization of SUS, driven by institutional adjustments and strengthened intergovernmental coordination. The engagement of collective actors representing local health managers has reinforced governance, mitigated inequalities, and expanded healthcare access. However, persistent political and managerial challenges continue to hinder the full consolidation of regionalized health governance.

 

This case study aims to contribute to the panel by offering insights into the mechanisms shaping health regionalization in Brazil, highlighting both obstacles and policy innovations that have emerged in response to these challenges.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Territorialization as reframing and alignment: the case of primary care in France
Patrick Hassenteufel (Université Paris-Saclay)
CO-AUTHORS
Daniel Benamouzig (Institut d'Etudes Politiques de Paris (Sciences Po))
ABSTRACT

The aim of this paper is to move forward in the conceptualization of the notion of territorialization, which is a way to go beyond the dominant comparative perspective on subnational dimensions of health systems based on the more institutional notions of regionalization, decentralization and federalism and less bottom-up oriented. It focuses more on two dimensions: the reframing of policy issues through territorial lenses and the horizontal connection of institutions, actors, processes and results to improve health on a subnational level by a better coordination in the health sector and with other sectors having an impact on the health of the population. These connections can be analyzed by using the notion of alignment which has a cognitive (sharing the definition of problems and of policy solutions), an institutional (transformation of institutional settings) and an organizational dimension (coordination of policy actors in the policy process). The way actors and institutions align (or not) is also a helpful sociological tool to compare different local territories.
The paper is based on empirical evidence in the case of France (ongoing comparison of local reorganization of primary care processes).

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - L'action publique de la lutte contre la COVID-19 dans la région de l'extrême nord :cas de la ville de Maroua.
Monique Helwar Ngnacir (Université de Maroua)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

 

Résumé

Comment appréhender l’action publique de la lutte contre la covid-19

dans la région de l’Extrême-Nord Cameroun ? Telle est la question à laquelle

cette étude s’ordonne de répondre. C’est une étude qualitative basée sur des

entretiens avec les acteurs clés dont les autorités locales, professionnels de la

santé, représentants de la société civile, des observations de terrain et l’analyse

de documents officiels. Les résultats de cette étude montrent que l’action

publique de la lutte contre la covid-19 dans la région de l’extrême-nord du

Cameroun a été caractérisée par une réaction tardive et une coordination

insuffisante entre les acteurs. Les autorités locales ont mis en place des mesures

de préventions et de contrôle mais celles-ci se sont révélées inadaptés aux

besoins de la population. La société civile a joué un rôle important dans la

sensibilisation de la population aux risques de la covid-19 et aux mesures de

préventions. Les résultats sur le terrain révèlent que la ville de Maroua a

enregistré un taux de contamination relativement faible par rapport à d’autres

régions du Cameroun. L’étude a mis en évidence les limites de l’action publique

de lutte contre la covid-19 dans la région de l’Extrême-Nord du Cameroun,

notamment en termes de coordination, de réactivité et d’adaptabilité. Elle

souligne également l’importance du rôle de la société civile dans la

sensibilisation de la population et la promotion de mesures de prévention et la

nécessite de renforcer la coordination et la réactivité de l’action publique pour

lutter efficacement contre la covid-19.

Mots clés : l’action, publiques, politiques publiques, lutte contre la covid-19.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Belonging to a landscape of care supporting exiles - A self-analysis of a programmatic group in Brussels
Céline Mahieu (Université Libre de Bruxelles)
CO-AUTHORS
Jennifer Foucart (Université Libre de Bruxelles)
Ana Bengoetxea (Université Libre de Bruxelles)
ABSTRACT

In her book “Apprendre à bien parler des sciences. La Vierge et le neutrino” (2023), Isabelle Stengers rises the question: ”What potential do scientists hold because of their affiliations? She encourages those who “read the IPCC reports” (2022) “to learn how to build connections with those who have been marginalized”, and to “discover ways to allow themselves to be impacted by a scenario that demands they move beyond the role of the scientist who ‘presents the facts’ ”. The scenario she refers to is the climate crisis, but it is closely related to the topic we are discussing in this paper: the health of exiles. Through asylum processes, which involve local physicians assessing what has happened elsewhere, and through the troubled bodies and minds requesting a breaking down of care and support barriers, this issue connects the regions that these exiles have fled from, those they have traversed, and those they are attempting to settle in.

 

Exiles (refugees, asylum seekers, and others) are likely to face a multitude of social, legal, and health challenges, necessitating the collaboration of various professions, organizations, and sectors, which are often still sealed off from each other and poorly equipped by existing professional and academic training to address these vulnerabilities. Brussels, at the core of migratory patterns, is particularly impacted.

 

Building on our disciplinary expertise, while also aiming to surpass it, we, as teacher-researchers in public health, law, medicine, osteopathy, physiotherapy, pharmacy, psychology, nursing, social work, and midwifery at the Université libre de Bruxelles, have endeavored to go beyond the scientific approach that “presents the facts” and have tried to connect with key Brussels stakeholders who work with exiles: professionals (hospitals, medical centers, etc.), associations (le Ciré, Médecins du monde, Sister House, Maison Babel), and judicial and administrative entities (Conseil du Contentieux des étrangers, Federal public planning service for Social Integration, etc.).

 

The territorial “teaching-action” project that we co-developed four years ago and continues to progress aims to cultivate, in actual practice, among students and educators in health, law, and social support, the mindsets, practices, and skills necessary to enhance both disciplinary and interdisciplinary support for vulnerable populations and to combat health-related social inequalities. Ensuring access to health care, as well as civil and social rights, by preparing future professionals to work collaboratively through interdisciplinary means and engaging with the associative network, aligns with the university's dedication to social responsibility.

 

This paper addresses the formation and evolution of a programmatic group rooted in the Brussels area and the actors impacting the health of exiles there. Through comprehensive reflexivity instruments, and utilizing resources from the Science studies (Callon 1986), we examine various stages (problematisation, incentivization, enrolment, mobilization of allies, and dissidence) in the development, setbacks, and successes of this group which we initiated ourselves.

 

In this context, we will explore the conditions under which a landscape of care –according to social geographers Milligan &Wiles (2010) “both a product and a creator of social and political-institutional frameworks for care [that] integrates contextualized politics and policies as well as resources for care provision, from local communities to the macro-global scale” – can or cannot be more effectively deployed to support the health of exiles. This analysis relies on a thorough examination of documents (project descriptions, meeting minutes, email excerpts, etc.) and individual interviews with the principal participants in the plan. This “self-analytical” approach and its implications will also be addressed.

CO-AUTHORS
Gerda Van Dijk (University of Pretoria)
ABSTRACT

Title: Obstacles to multisectoral maternal and child healthcare financing in Uganda: insights from policy bureaucrats

 

Dr. Maureen Sylvia Kusiima,a Prof. Gerda van Dijk,b Dr. Mary S Mangai,c Prof. & Olanrewaju Olaniyan,d

 

a Postdoctoral Fellow, School of Public Management and Administration, University of Pretoria, South Africa (Corresponding Author).

 

b Director, School of Public Management and Administration, University of Pretoria, South Africa.

 

c Senior Lecturer, School of Public Management and Administration, University of Pretoria, South Africa.

 

d Professor of Economics, Dean, Faculty of Economics and Management Sciences, University of Ibadan, Nigeria.

 

Abstract

Maternal and child healthcare (MCH) financing is a global priority, and it is one of the core components of the health systems building blocks. Ensuring adequate MCH financing is critical for better MCH outcomes, but it remains a challenge for most developing countries, including Uganda. This research explores the obstacles to multisectoral MCH financing in Uganda. To deepen the understanding of MCH financing 8 in-depth interviews were held with MCH stakeholder which means that the study adopted a qualitative approach to collect data through interviews and document reviews. The study employed thematic analyses to comprehensively present the data. The study identifies several challenges to multisectoral MCH financing, including the absence of a specific and explicit MCH framework on MCH financing, poor understanding of the meaning of multisectoral collaboration in MCH financing, low acceptance of prepayment forms of financing, and failure to fulfill pledges and government commitments. Moreover, the lack of clear and streamlined stakeholders’ roles and responsibilities, failure to prioritise and include MCH issues in all national policies, and the fragmentation and vertical funding limit the leveraging of MCH resources. Delays in approving the financing frameworks have hindered the implementation of the financing instruments, thus affecting the pooling of MCH funds in Uganda. This study concludes that, considering the diminishing MCH financial resources due to gaps in current financing frameworks, the Government of Uganda should strengthen and enhance its legal and policy financing instruments.

 

Keywords: Collaboration, maternal and child health, healthcare financing, instruments, stakeholder responsibilities and roles, policy bureaucrats


 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper presents the research carried out by the Health Chair of Sciences Po Paris since October 2023 on the territorialization and coordination of the French healthcare system in response to ageing issues. The French healthcare system is facing main challenges, linked to the ageing of the population and of medical professionals, especially GPs. They have led to the development of more coordinated practices between health professionals so as between the healthcare and the medico-social sectors. Observable on a national scale, these dynamics are also at work in sub-national territories. The study examines these dynamics and the relationships between the institutions involved, whether health insurance funds, healthcare professionals (CPTS, URPS) and institutions (ARS, local authorities, DAC, old-age insurance funds), in six metropolitan départements (Meurthe-et-Moselle, Lot, Seine-Saint-Denis, Yvelines, Ille-et-Vilaine and Cher). In this paper, we analyze the local issues of healthcare coordination, its levels of governance, its main policy players, its degree of structuring and its development or slowdown factors.

CO-AUTHORS
Marco Antonio Catussi Paschoalotto (Universidade do Minho)
Alessandro Bigoni (Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health)
Adriano Massuda (Sao Paulo School of Business Administration)
ABSTRACT

The Brazilian Unified Health System (SUS) provides comprehensive services across a vast and unequal territory. Since its inception in 1988, SUS has undergone profound transformations, shaped mainly by public health experts (sanitaristas), who have played a central role in structuring its governance, financing, and territorial organization through: i) the decentralization of services and responsibilities, and ii) the organization of healthcare by the regionalization directive.

 

Despite significant advancements, the regionalization of SUS continues to face structural and political challenges that hinder its full consolidation. Persistent inequalities in healthcare provision across regions, exacerbated by fiscal constraints and varying administrative capacities, lead to disparities in access and quality of care. Decentralization introduces specific coordination challenges in decision-making among federal, state, and municipal entities. At the same time, intergovernmental negotiations often expose power imbalances, with wealthier regions exerting greater influence over resource allocation. Moreover, political instability and shifting government priorities at all three levels further disrupt the continuity of long-term strategies, undermining institutional efforts to strengthen regionalized governance.

 

On the other hand, incremental adjustments have been implemented to enhance SUS’s intergovernmental governance and strengthen regionalization. Measures such as (a) the formalization of inter-management commissions as forums for negotiation and agreement between managers on SUS operations and (b) the institutionalization of councils of health secretaries as representative entities of state and municipal governments have helped improve technical and managerial support for federal-level decision-making. Recent evidence suggests that these actors can even function as a system of checks and balances. For instance, a data consortium led by the National Council of Health Secretaries (CONASS), in partnership with media, researchers, and universities, became a reliable source for monitoring COVID-19 in Brazil, countering the federal government's inadequate data reporting.

 

To contribute to the discussion on health system regionalization, this study examines how Brazil has responded to these challenges from the perspective of collective actors that represent local and subnational health managers and their interactions within federal decision-making arenas. It explores how decentralization and federal oversight have been combined in designing institutional reforms, financial instruments, and governance arrangements to guide regionalization. To achieve this objective, the research employs a qualitative approach, including document analysis, literature review, and interviews with public health managers.  The authors also discuss some of the findings in the light of the effects that the changes had in healthcare resource utilization in the territory. The findings suggest a progressively structured regionalization of SUS, driven by institutional adjustments and strengthened intergovernmental coordination. The engagement of collective actors representing local health managers has reinforced governance, mitigated inequalities, and expanded healthcare access. However, persistent political and managerial challenges continue to hinder the full consolidation of regionalized health governance.

 

This case study aims to contribute to the panel by offering insights into the mechanisms shaping health regionalization in Brazil, highlighting both obstacles and policy innovations that have emerged in response to these challenges.

CO-AUTHORS
Daniel Benamouzig (Institut d'Etudes Politiques de Paris (Sciences Po))
ABSTRACT

The aim of this paper is to move forward in the conceptualization of the notion of territorialization, which is a way to go beyond the dominant comparative perspective on subnational dimensions of health systems based on the more institutional notions of regionalization, decentralization and federalism and less bottom-up oriented. It focuses more on two dimensions: the reframing of policy issues through territorial lenses and the horizontal connection of institutions, actors, processes and results to improve health on a subnational level by a better coordination in the health sector and with other sectors having an impact on the health of the population. These connections can be analyzed by using the notion of alignment which has a cognitive (sharing the definition of problems and of policy solutions), an institutional (transformation of institutional settings) and an organizational dimension (coordination of policy actors in the policy process). The way actors and institutions align (or not) is also a helpful sociological tool to compare different local territories.
The paper is based on empirical evidence in the case of France (ongoing comparison of local reorganization of primary care processes).

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

 

Résumé

Comment appréhender l’action publique de la lutte contre la covid-19

dans la région de l’Extrême-Nord Cameroun ? Telle est la question à laquelle

cette étude s’ordonne de répondre. C’est une étude qualitative basée sur des

entretiens avec les acteurs clés dont les autorités locales, professionnels de la

santé, représentants de la société civile, des observations de terrain et l’analyse

de documents officiels. Les résultats de cette étude montrent que l’action

publique de la lutte contre la covid-19 dans la région de l’extrême-nord du

Cameroun a été caractérisée par une réaction tardive et une coordination

insuffisante entre les acteurs. Les autorités locales ont mis en place des mesures

de préventions et de contrôle mais celles-ci se sont révélées inadaptés aux

besoins de la population. La société civile a joué un rôle important dans la

sensibilisation de la population aux risques de la covid-19 et aux mesures de

préventions. Les résultats sur le terrain révèlent que la ville de Maroua a

enregistré un taux de contamination relativement faible par rapport à d’autres

régions du Cameroun. L’étude a mis en évidence les limites de l’action publique

de lutte contre la covid-19 dans la région de l’Extrême-Nord du Cameroun,

notamment en termes de coordination, de réactivité et d’adaptabilité. Elle

souligne également l’importance du rôle de la société civile dans la

sensibilisation de la population et la promotion de mesures de prévention et la

nécessite de renforcer la coordination et la réactivité de l’action publique pour

lutter efficacement contre la covid-19.

Mots clés : l’action, publiques, politiques publiques, lutte contre la covid-19.

CO-AUTHORS
Jennifer Foucart (Université Libre de Bruxelles)
Ana Bengoetxea (Université Libre de Bruxelles)
ABSTRACT

In her book “Apprendre à bien parler des sciences. La Vierge et le neutrino” (2023), Isabelle Stengers rises the question: ”What potential do scientists hold because of their affiliations? She encourages those who “read the IPCC reports” (2022) “to learn how to build connections with those who have been marginalized”, and to “discover ways to allow themselves to be impacted by a scenario that demands they move beyond the role of the scientist who ‘presents the facts’ ”. The scenario she refers to is the climate crisis, but it is closely related to the topic we are discussing in this paper: the health of exiles. Through asylum processes, which involve local physicians assessing what has happened elsewhere, and through the troubled bodies and minds requesting a breaking down of care and support barriers, this issue connects the regions that these exiles have fled from, those they have traversed, and those they are attempting to settle in.

 

Exiles (refugees, asylum seekers, and others) are likely to face a multitude of social, legal, and health challenges, necessitating the collaboration of various professions, organizations, and sectors, which are often still sealed off from each other and poorly equipped by existing professional and academic training to address these vulnerabilities. Brussels, at the core of migratory patterns, is particularly impacted.

 

Building on our disciplinary expertise, while also aiming to surpass it, we, as teacher-researchers in public health, law, medicine, osteopathy, physiotherapy, pharmacy, psychology, nursing, social work, and midwifery at the Université libre de Bruxelles, have endeavored to go beyond the scientific approach that “presents the facts” and have tried to connect with key Brussels stakeholders who work with exiles: professionals (hospitals, medical centers, etc.), associations (le Ciré, Médecins du monde, Sister House, Maison Babel), and judicial and administrative entities (Conseil du Contentieux des étrangers, Federal public planning service for Social Integration, etc.).

 

The territorial “teaching-action” project that we co-developed four years ago and continues to progress aims to cultivate, in actual practice, among students and educators in health, law, and social support, the mindsets, practices, and skills necessary to enhance both disciplinary and interdisciplinary support for vulnerable populations and to combat health-related social inequalities. Ensuring access to health care, as well as civil and social rights, by preparing future professionals to work collaboratively through interdisciplinary means and engaging with the associative network, aligns with the university's dedication to social responsibility.

 

This paper addresses the formation and evolution of a programmatic group rooted in the Brussels area and the actors impacting the health of exiles there. Through comprehensive reflexivity instruments, and utilizing resources from the Science studies (Callon 1986), we examine various stages (problematisation, incentivization, enrolment, mobilization of allies, and dissidence) in the development, setbacks, and successes of this group which we initiated ourselves.

 

In this context, we will explore the conditions under which a landscape of care –according to social geographers Milligan &Wiles (2010) “both a product and a creator of social and political-institutional frameworks for care [that] integrates contextualized politics and policies as well as resources for care provision, from local communities to the macro-global scale” – can or cannot be more effectively deployed to support the health of exiles. This analysis relies on a thorough examination of documents (project descriptions, meeting minutes, email excerpts, etc.) and individual interviews with the principal participants in the plan. This “self-analytical” approach and its implications will also be addressed.