Format

P20. Nature Policies and Protected Areas: regulatory, governance and evidence perspectives

ENVIRONMENT, SDGs, ENERGY
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Valentina Dinica
Victoria University of Wellington
Main chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
ENVIRONMENT, SDGs, ENERGY
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Biodiversity persistence and ecological quality are critical for the achievement of many  Sustainable Development Goals. They are a central focus to SGD 14 and 15, while contributing to SDG 13. The challenge to implement the SGDs, and wider concerns with climate change, biodiversity loss, the deterioration of critical ecosystem services and environmental public health, have led to a better appreciation of the potential roles of Protected Areas (PAs) as tools for nature policies and instruments for sustainable development (Aubertin and Rodary 2011, Ritzel et al. 2023). National and transnational regulatory reform processes have been initiated in some jurisdictions, to enhance the ecological representativeness of PA networks and transform them in integrated and functional ecological and socio-ecological systems (Cabin 2013, CBD Secretariate 2009).

 

The functional ecological representativeness principle of policy-making is incorporated in numerous decisions, implementing the 1992 UN Convention on Biological Diversity (Soutullo and Gudynas 2006). E.g., the 2004 Program of Work on Protected Areas requires signatory states to develop “comprehensive, effectively managed and ecologically representative national and regional systems of protected ideas” (CBD Secretariate 2004). The emphasis has shifted from the static and fragmented representation of culturally-valued landscapes and habitats (as ‘open-air-museum items’; Dinica 2022), to ecological functionality attributes and holistic indicators of ecosystem health, sustainable critical ecosystem services, and biotic persistence in the context of climate change (Mingarro and Lobo 2021, Pörtner et al. 2021, Thackway and Cresswell 1997).

 

Public policy and public administration perspectives to the study of PAs are essential, because PAs are spaces where human access is regulated by special rules. They may be grounded in legal frameworks and/or in strategies, policies or management plans for biodiversity/conservation/nature protection. The legal and policy frameworks may be  generic or PA-specific; they are often multi-level, extensive, complex and - due to variable ages - conflicting and incoherent. 

 

Currently, conceptual understandings and practitioner-focused policy insights remain severely under-developed, with respect to the fitness-for-purpose of PA designations and regulations to contribute to SDGs and to support the PAs' transition towards ecologically functional systems; likewise for the challenge to better integrate policy programs across related policy domains: nature policy programs, climate change mitigation and adaptation policies; land use, regional development and sustainable agricultural policies; and policies for urban parks or sustainable tourism.

 

The number of studies adopting policy perspectives remains limited (e.g. Bastmeijer 2016, Capotorti et al. 2012, Ferraro and Hanauer 2015, Kegamba et al. 2024, Lima and Ranieri 2018, Selman 2009). In the context of limited attention by public policy scholars, significant contributions have been made by natural scientists and geographers (e.g. Araújo et al. 2007, Çoruhlu and Çelik 2022, Dimitrakopoulos et al. 2004, Evans 2012, Ferraro 2013, Fuller et al 2010, Iojă et al. 2010, Nichiforel et al. 2021, Niedziałkowski et al. 2014, Svancara et al. 2005, Wang et al. 2021).

 

In so far as the regulation of human activities and infrastructures/facilities within PAs is concerned, scholars have occasionally researched the effectiveness of tourism regulations, usually in specific PAs or countries (Dinica 2017, Estima et al. 2014, Goodwin 2002, Thede et al. 2014). However, a wider range of human access options and socio-economic activities are often permitted, depending on the PA designation type (e.g. Nature/Scientific/Recreation Reserves, Nature Parks, National Parks; see Chape et al. 2008, Cumming et al. 2015).  

 

This panel welcomes conceptual, methodological and empirical contributions, adopting public policy or interdisciplinary perspectives that advance scholarship on the following themes: 

1) the interface between science and policies on nature protection generally, and on Protected Areas, specifically

2) the ecological effectiveness of nature policies, PA designations and regulations

3) the governance of Protected Areas

 

Selected References

 

Aubertin, C., Rodary E. (Ed). (2011). Protected Areas, Sustainable Land? Ashgate Publishing

 

Araújo, M.B., Lobo J.M., Moreno J.C. (2007). The effectiveness of Iberian protected areas in conserving terrestrial biodiversity. Conservation Biology 21(6):1423-32

 

Bastmeijer, K. (2016). Ecological restoration in international biodiversity law: a promising strategy to address our failure to prevent? In M Bowman, P Davies, E Goodwin (Eds), Research Handbook on Biodiversity and Law. Edward Elgar Publishing.

 

Capotorti, G., et al. (2012). Do National Parks play an active role in conserving the natural capital of Italy? Plant Biosystems - An International Journal Dealing with All Aspects of Plant Biology, 146(2):258–265. 

 

CBD Secretariate. (2019). Post-2020 Global Biodiversity Framework. Discussion Paper. 

 

Chape, S, Spalding M, Jenkins M. (2008). The world's protected areas: status, values and prospects in the 21st century. University of California Press

 

Coruhlu, Y.E., Çelik, M.Ö. (2022). Protected area geographical management model from design to implementation for specially protected environment area, Land Use Policy, 122:106357 

 

Dimitrakopoulos, P.G., Memtsas D, Troumbis A.Y. (2004). Questioning the effectiveness of the Natura 2000 species areas for conservation strategy: the case of Crete. Global Ecology and Biogeography 13: 199–207.

 

Dinica, V. (2022). Protected Area Regulation and Tourism: Science-Informed Ecological Transitions. Edward Elgar Publishing.

 

Dinica V. (2017). Tourism concessions in National Parks: neo-liberal governance experiments for a Conservation Economy in New Zealand. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 25(12):1811-1829

 

Evans, D. (2012). Building the European Union’s Natura 2000 network. Nature Conservation 1:11-26. 

 

Ferraro P.J., Hanauer M.M. (2015). Through what mechanisms do protected areas affect environmental and social outcomes? Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B 370:20140267. 

 

Kegamba, J.J., et al. (2024). The influence of conservation policies and legislations on communities in Tanzania. Biodiversity Conservation 33:3147–3170. 

 

Lima, E.A.C.F., Ranieri V.L.M. (2018). Land use planning around protected areas: Case studies in four state parks in the Atlantic forest region of southeastern Brazil, Land Use Policy: 453-458 

 

Mingarro, M., Lobo, J.M. (2021). Connecting protected areas in the Iberian peninsula to facilitate climate change tracking. Environmental Conservation 48: 182–191

 

Nichiforel, N., et al. (2021). Forest ecosystem services in Romania: Orchestrating regulatory and voluntary planning documents, Ecosystem Services 49:101276, 

 

Niedziałkowski, K., Blicharska, M., Mikusiński, G., Jędrzejewska, B. (2014). Why is it difficult to enlarge a protected area? Ecosystem services perspective on the conflict around the extension of the Białowieża National Park in Poland, Land Use Policy 38:314-329

 

Pörtner, HO, Scholes RJ, Agard J, Archer E, Arneth et. al. (2021). Scientific Outcome of the IPBES-IPCC co-sponsored workshop report on biodiversity and climate change. IPBES Secretariat, Bonn, Germany

 

Ritzel, C. et al. (2023). Swiss Parks of National Importance as model regions of sustainable development – An economic success story for farmers?, Land Use Policy 124:106441

 

Soutullo, A., Gudynas E. (2006). How effective is the MERCOSUR's network of protected areas in representing South America's ecoregions? Oryx 40:112–116

 

Svancara, L.K., et al. (2005). Political policy driven versus evidence-based conservation: a review of political targets and biological needs. Bioscience 55:989–995

 

Thackway, R, Cresswell ID. (1997). A Bioregional Framework for Planning the National System of Protected Areas in Australia. Natural Areas Journal, 17(3):241-247

 

Thede, AK, Haider W, Rutherford M. (2014). Zoning in national parks: are Canadian zoning practices outdated? Journal of Sustainable Tourism. 22(4):626-645

 

Wang, Y., et al. (2021). Efficacy and management challenges of the zoning designations of China's national parks, Biological Conservation 254:108962 

CALL FOR PAPERS

This panel invites public policy scholars to contribute to the growing inter-disciplinary fields of nature policies and Protected Area policies, by means of case-studies, comparative research, syntheses, meta-analyses or integrative conceptual research. Exploratory and exploratory contributions are welcome. The key questions/topics examined in this panel address the following themes:

 

1) The interface between science and policies on nature protection generally, and Protected Areas, specifically:

· How do historical and contemporary scientific paradigms influence nature policies and PA designations, network structures and regulations (e.g. aspects such as the protected ecological values, management objectives and regulations on human access)?

· How to better incorporate contemporary scientific insights in the reform of nature policies and PA designations and the regulation of human access, for more ecologically-effective PA systems?

 

2) The ecological effectiveness of nature policies, PA designations and regulations:

· What is the evidence on the effectiveness of current nature policies and PA network structures, designations and regulations, for ecological objectives and SDGs? What roles does evidence play in policy-making processes? How do institutional structures and processes influence an evidence-informed policy approach?

· How to reform nature policy design and PA systems, to enhance biotic persistence and resilience to climate change?

· How to regulate and manage human – wildlife interactions more effectively, for species in different protection categories? Special attention will be paid to interactions with large carnivores.

 

3) The governance of Protected Areas:

· Policy coordination / integration: conceptual approaches and empirical evidence on the synergies of policies across relevant domains, to facilitate ecological outcomes and SDGs  across PA

· What participatory processes, methods and design features help enhance public support for ecologically-effective PA systems? How can public engagement enhance the implementation of SDGs 13, 14 and 15 across PAs?

· Which regulatory approaches facilitate synergies between the rights of indigenous peoples, the wellbeing of local communities and ecologically-sound outcomes in PAs?

· How to operationalise the concepts of adaptive governance and policies, for climate resilient socio-ecological systems in PAs?
· What patterns of policy leadership help initiate and sustain successful transitions towards ecologically-effective PA systems, in multi-level governance systems?

 

The panel encourages analyses that help enhance the empirical-base on geographic regions hosting numerous multiuse Protected Areas as well as PAs located in the Global South and the Asia Pacific regions.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Stakeholders’ perception of the implementation of logging prohibition in National Parks and the protection of endangered flora (Pterocarpus Erinaceus) in Nigeria
Henry Ufomba (Flinders University of South Australia)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Deforestation and forest degradation as a result of illegal logging are the prime drivers of the loss of biodiversity in Nigeria. As of 2024, Nigeria has lost over 90% of its forest areas. In response, using the framework of the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), the Nigerian government established National Parks for the conservation of biodiversity with strict prohibition on logging and imposed CITES certification requirements for the export of Pterocarpus Erinaceus (Rosewoods). However, data from the Nigerian Federal Ministry of Environment revealed that from 1990 to 2020, the protected forest areas (PFAs) in Nigeria reduced from 10% to 6% of the country’s landmass, also Nigeria remains the biggest source of illegally logged endangered Pterocarpus Erinaceus in Sub-Saharan Africa. This signifies regulatory failure and the ineffectiveness of the PFAs to limit access to forest resources and conserve the biodiversity within it. Armed with this observation, this study addresses the panel question- How to better incorporate contemporary scientific insights in the reform of nature policies and Protected Areas (PA) designations and the regulation of human access, for more ecologically effective PA systems? To answer this question, we surveyed 221 stakeholders of the Old Oyo National Park in the Southwestern region of Nigeria, which was followed up with 22 in-depth interviews. Additional data was drawn from secondary sources.  The findings of this study reveal that forest officers' use of discretion, influenced by limited resources, insecurity, prebendalism, and corruption, often undermines regulatory effectiveness. The key findings further reveal that loggers’ compliance with logging regulations is inconsistent, and enforcement of penalties often lacks a deterrence effect. It is therefore important for policymakers to mitigate these constraints through interventions at the policy, organisational and individual levels to initiate a positive impact on regulatory outcomes and forest sustainability.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Sacred Groves and Indigenous Knowledge: Integrating Traditional Ecological Practices into Contemporary Institutional Frameworks in the Eastern Himalayas
Kabindra Sharma (Sikkim University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Sacred groves, locally known as devithans in the Darjeeling-Sikkim Himalayas, have long been integral to the cultural and ecological practices of indigenous communities. These culturally protected forests serve as sanctuaries for deities, ancestral spirits, and sacred beings while acting as reservoirs for vital resources such as water springs, native flora, and fauna. Managed through traditional norms that restrict resource extraction and harmful activities, devithans play a vital role in conserving biodiversity, safeguarding water resources, and maintaining ecological balance. However, increasing modernization and developmental pressures have led to the degradation of sacred groves and the drying up of springs, posing severe threats to biodiversity and water security. This erosion of sacred spaces highlights the urgent need to integrate traditional ecological knowledge (TEK) into contemporary conservation and water management strategies. Indigenous practices, rooted in spiritual and cultural values, offer valuable insights for sustainable natural resource management but remain underrepresented in formal policymaking frameworks.

Recognizing the efficacy of these practices, this paper emphasizes the importance of embedding traditional systems within institutional governance structures. Such integration would bridge the gap between modern conservation approaches and age-old sustainable practices, fostering inclusive policy processes that respect cultural heritage while addressing pressing environmental challenges. This paper explores the multifaceted significance of sacred groves in the Eastern Himalayas, emphasizing their role in biodiversity conservation, water resource management, and cultural preservation. Drawing on field data from the Darjeeling-Sikkim Himalayas, supplemented by secondary sources, the paper examines the current state of sacred groves, their role in resource management, and the challenges posed by environmental and cultural transformations. It advocates for the incorporation of indigenous knowledge systems into institutional frameworks to empower communities, ensure sustainable resource management, and mitigate the ecological impacts of modernization and climate change.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Collaborative Governance in Mexico's Sierra Occidental Biocultural Landscape
Alfonso Langle (University of Guadalajara)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This study delves into the complexities of collaborative governance within the Sierra Occidental Biocultural Landscape (SOBL) in western Mexico, a region specifically designed to promote the coexistence of biodiversity conservation and sustainable development. This research employs a mixed-methods approach, combining Social Network Analysis (SNA) with in-depth qualitative interviews to examine the collaborative network of 22 key stakeholders representing diverse sectors, including government agencies, tourism operators, local producers, and grassroots organizations.  


Furthermore, the study assesses the SOBL's adherence to the critical elements of successful collaborative governance as defined by Ansell and Gash (2008): starting conditions (including power dynamics and pre-existing conflict), institutional design (inclusivity and established rules), leadership (facilitation and trust-building), and the collaborative process itself (communication and shared understanding).  This detailed examination of the SOBL's governance structure provides valuable insights into the governance of emerging models of land protection and management in the Global South.     


The SNA revealed a network characterized by moderate density and centralization, suggesting a foundation for collaborative efforts, but also highlighting areas for improvement.  Specifically, the analysis revealed low reciprocity in stakeholder relationships, indicating potential power imbalances, particularly with the prominent role of state government agencies.  Limited connectivity among non-governmental stakeholders may restrict inclusivity and the equitable distribution of benefits derived from conservation initiatives.  


Qualitative data gathered through interviews with key stakeholders underscored the need to address these power imbalances, bolster the project’s credibility among local communities, establish clearer rules, and foster trust. These insights are crucial for enhancing public support for ecologically effective protected areas systems.


While the SOBL holds considerable promise for achieving collaborative conservation goals, strategic interventions are necessary to unlock its full potential and effectively contribute to broader biodiversity targets.  By integrating SNA with rich qualitative insights, this research offers a comprehensive understanding of the complex collaborative dynamics at play within this biocultural landscape, providing valuable lessons for similar initiatives in Mexico and overseas.    

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Transitioning Protected Areas towards functional ecologically-representative systems: policy challenges and options in New Zealand
Valentina Dinica (Victoria University of Wellington)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The 1992 Conventional Biological Diversity and its implementation decisions include commitments by Member States to improve not only the land and marine coverage of Protected Areas (PA) but also the functional ecological representativeness of national PA networks. To ensure functionality, each native ecosystem type should be adequately (restored and) protected over at least 20% of its original cover, while considering potential impacts of climate changes. This study evaluates the policy-related challenges faced by New Zealand in meeting these commitments for the land-based Protected Areas.
The evaluation integrates multiple disciplinary and actor perspectives. First, it presents the findings of ecological studies regarding the over-representation and under-representation of native ecosystems in the largest network, managed by the government’s Department of Conservation. Second, it examines the legal, institutional and cultural settings that affect the current ecological performance of PAs. Third, it presents the findings of a nation-wide survey among public sector officials, scientists and Protected Area stakeholders, regarding actor perceptions on the need for, priorities and approaches to such transitions. This includes analyses of survey results regarding the potential roles of scientists in transitions to more ecologically-representative and functionally-sustainable PAs.
These perspectives are integrated to discuss progress options and to articulate policy, institutional and law reform recommendations, to futureproof the persistence of native biodiversity, by using PA as key policy tools.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Regulatory Governance and Participation in the District Conservation Unit System (DCUS) of the Federal District, Brazil
Jessica de Oliveira (University of Brasilia, Brazil)
CO-AUTHORS
Marcos Tito (Center for Sustainable Development/University of Brasília)
Andre Cunha (Universidade de Brasília)
ABSTRACT

The District Conservation Unit System (DCUS), known in Portuguese as the Sistema Distrital de Unidades de Conservação (SDUC), established by Complementary Law No. 827/2010, is a set of protected areas in the Federal District, Brazil, aimed at protecting biodiversity and natural resources. It promotes sustainable use, social participation, environmental education, scientific research, and the restoration of degraded areas. Additionally, the system seeks to enhance the region's natural and cultural resources, consolidating a legal framework for local environmental conservation. However, despite its importance, the DCUS faces challenges related to its implementation, management, and participatory governance. This research aims to analyze the evolution and challenges of the DCUS, with a particular focus on regulatory governance and the role of public, private, and civil society actors in the system's development and management. The central research question is: how have regulation and governance processes influenced the design and management of the District Conservation Unit System (DCUS) in the Federal District, Brazil? A qualitative approach will be employed, using a case study as the investigation strategy. Data collection will involve document analysis (e.g., meeting minutes, legislative bills, public actions) and in-depth semi-structured interviews with actors involved in the creation and management of the DCUS. The collected data will be categorized using content analysis, with special attention given to the legislative process of Complementary Law No. 827/2010, exploring the inspirations, motivations, and levels of influence of the system's key formulators and implementers. The expected results aim to highlight gaps and opportunities in the DCUS’s management model, contributing to the improvement of mechanisms for participation and regulatory coherence. This study aligns with central themes of the panel by exploring the interaction between environmental regulations, social participation, and the effectiveness of public policies for protected areas. In this context, the experience of the DCUS provides insights into the challenges of decentralized environmental governance in metropolitan regions. Additionally, this research contributes to understanding how historical and contemporary scientific paradigms shape nature policies, protected area designations, and regulatory frameworks. By examining the formulation and implementation of the DCUS, the findings help contextualize the role of legal frameworks and stakeholder dynamics in balancing conservation goals and sustainable use, enriching the debate on adaptive and participatory approaches to environmental governance.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - The applicability of Smart Regulation Design Principles for commercial tourism in marine protected areas
Marisha Ewart (Southern Cross University)
CO-AUTHORS
Pascal Scherrer (Southern Cross University)
Kay Dimmock (Southern Cross University)
ABSTRACT

Background:

Marine protected areas in Australia are managed by government agencies tasked with balancing the long-term conservation of nature with cultural, social and economic uses, including commercial tourism. However, scholars have highlighted that commercial tourism is often incompatible with nature conservation unless it is well-planned and well-managed. To date, little academic attention has been paid to policy design and policy instrument mixes, despite calls for scholars to contribute conceptual understandings and practitioner-focused policy insights to safeguard the ecological sustainability of commercial tourism in protected areas.

 

Research question:

Smart regulation is a concept that advocates for complementary policy instrument mixes and regulatory pluralism. The concept has been operationalised into design principles. This research explored the applicability of smart regulation design principles for commercial tourism in marine protected areas by asking: “how do smart regulation design principles apply commercial tourism in marine protected areas?”

 

Methodology:

Through qualitative case studies on the Cape Byron Marine Park and the Whitsundays Planning Area of the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park, this study applied the Persuade-Enable-Constrain Framework to zoom into the behavioural responses of commercial tourism operators. Behavioural responses of policy-takers to policy implementation are underexplored in public policy studies and are critical to improving policy instrument design and goal attainment. Empirical evidence of how and why policy-takers respond to policy instruments applied in combination can improve our understanding of the relevance of policy design principles such as smart regulation.

 

How this research fits in with panel’s research questions:

Commercial tourism operator perspectives and behavioural responses highlight the critical role of procedural tools such as monitoring programs, review periods, management plans, and permit policies in safeguarding the ecological effectiveness of marine protected areas, particularly in the context of climate change. Therefore, this research contributes empirically to theme two (The ecological effectiveness of nature policies, protected designations and regulations) and theme 3 (the governance of protected areas). The research concludes that smart regulation design principles provided a useful framework for exploring policy design and instrument mixes. However, apparent specificities apply to commercial tourism in marine protected areas, particularly concerning complementary instrument mixes, minimum levels of intervention and policy instrument sequencing. The findings provide valuable insights for practice and directions for future research.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Securing customary tenure rights of indigenous and local communities in the protected areas of Cambodia through policy and practice
Antoine Deligne (GRET, France)
CO-AUTHORS
Natalia Scurrah (RCSD, Faculty of Social Science, Chiang Mai University)
ABSTRACT

The paper will discuss the lessons from the Mekong Region Land Governance project (MRLG) in supporting policy and practice change to strengthen the land and resource rights of communities affected by the expansion of protected areas (PAs) for conservation and climate change mitigation. Cambodia has designated about 38% of its territory as PAs without any form of consultation with the communities living in and nearby those areas. Indigenous people have lost access to spiritual, shifting-cultivation and forest land that they customarily used. This dispossession has created strong incentives to encroach in PAs for short-term benefits and discouraged collaborative approaches for conservation purpose.

MRLG has established an alliance of stakeholders – including conservationists, CSOs, indigenous organizations and researchers – to reflect on the main issues faced by communities in PAs and develop strategies to influence related policies and practices to strengthen community rights to land and livelihoods. The alliance has promoted the concept of customary tenure to: 1) advocate for community rights within environmental legislation, and 2) develop tools for engaging communities in a Free Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC) process to inform the zoning of PAs.

A review of the lessons learned highlights the value of multistakeholder approaches, leveraging research and evidence to feed policy dialogue, collaborative strategy design and monitoring, multi-level government engagement, learning from neighboring countries, and continuously adapting strategies in response to contextual changes. While these principles have been effective in building a strong coalition, the actual changes have been limited due to the governance context of the country, its complex political economy, the unpredictability of policy development processes, etc. The implementation of FPIC by conservation NGOs provided more promising results compared to policy level discussions. Ultimately, however, efforts to address the question of community land rights through a more inclusive process also came up against powerful interests and excluded a community-based conservation group deemed to be too ‘radical’ by the Ministry of Environment.

Besides modest victories, the challenges faced reflect the lack of progress on more substantial and persistent issues: the influence of powerful families and cronies who consolidate large estates over natural and community areas and the logic of patronage systems within the government and ministries that prevent accountability and incentivize the search for personal benefit over the public good. These logics are well described in multiple scholarly works and continue to drive environmental destruction across the country.

In such a context, we explore the significance and nature of policy change, incremental versus transformative, and confront a difficult question: Is there value in policy engagement and in maintaining the role played by international and national stakeholders to challenge the status quo? Should the policy arena be abandoned as hopeless, or worse, are these engagements legitimizing exclusionary processes? Or should we continue engaging and use international pressure on Cambodia to respect its international commitments such as the social safeguards attached to climate change action?

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Unpacking Inter-Scalar Dynamics in Mangrove Conservation and Restoration: Challenges and Pathways to Collaborative Governance
Syifa Afra (Universitas Indonesia)
CO-AUTHORS
Teguh Kurniawan (Universitas Indonesia)
Muhamad Imam Alfie Syarien (Universitas Indonesia)
Marcel Angwyn (Universitas Indonesia)
ABSTRACT

This article explores the challenges posed by jurisdictional and bureaucratic rivalries, as well as inter-scalar conflicts, that impede the effective implementation of Mangrove Conservation & Restoration (MCR) initiatives. It examines the complex governance landscape of MCR, where overlapping jurisdictions across coastal management, forest management, aquaculture policies, and regional planning can create tensions both horizontally (between different agencies) and vertically (across administrative tiers). Horizontal conflicts arise as agencies seek to assert control over their designated domains, while vertical conflicts emerge between local, regional, and provincial governments with differing priorities regarding mangrove development. Utilizing a process tracing methodology, the article investigates how these inter-scalar dynamics have evolved, identifying key events, decisions, and interactions that have shaped the trajectory of mangrove management in Banyuwangi. Process tracing allows for a detailed analysis of the causal mechanisms behind the moderation of inter-scalar conflicts and the identification of factors that have contributed to more cooperative governance. The article examines whether the reduction of conflicts can be attributed to collaborative governance strategies, such as co-creation and joint decision-making, which foster trust and coordination among various stakeholders. By tracing these processes, the article sheds light on how such mechanisms have contributed to the success of Banyuwangi's MCR efforts and the broader implications for improving multi-jurisdictional environmental governance. 

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Enhancing Competences for Effective Management of Protected Areas in the Brazilian Federal District
Marcos Tito (Center for Sustainable Development/University of Brasília)
CO-AUTHORS
Jessica de Oliveira (University of Brasilia, Brazil)
Andre Cunha (Universidade de Brasília)
ABSTRACT

To manage the 83 protected areas under its jurisdiction in the Federal District of Brazil, the Instituto Brasília Ambiental (IBRAM) relies on 93 employees affiliated with the Superintendence of Protected Areas (SUCON). Together, these protected areas cover approximately 34% of the Federal District's territory, resulting in a ratio of one SUCON employee per 2,115 hectares of protected land. This scenario imposes a significant burden on employees, who hold analyst and technician positions in the fields of environmental management, urban planning, infrastructure, public policy, and governance. District Law No. 4.302/2009, which established positions related to environmental activities, defined the eligibility criteria for these careers but failed to specify the duties and responsibilities of each position. This gap was only partially addressed 13 years later with the publication of District Decree No. 41/2022, which still provided incomplete guidelines. As a result, there is a significant overlap of functions and responsibilities among employees in different career tracks. Additionally, salary disparities of up to 61% between analysts and technicians exacerbate a sense of disharmony in the workplace, hindering team management and performance. The research was driven by the following central question: What are the essential competencies for the effective management of district protected areas? To identify gaps, redundancies, and excessive workload in competencies associated with the management of protected areas within IBRAM, semi-structured interviews were conducted with 22 SUCON employees (including directors, advisors, and department heads) directly responsible for decision-making. These interviews, held between May and June 2024, combined open-ended and closed-ended questions. The collected data were analyzed using a qualitative approach, focusing on the administrative and technical competencies of IBRAM employees. The evaluation began with the mapping of 420 technical competencies listed in the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) competency framework (Appleton, 2020) against the different job categories within IBRAM. In a second stage, the 1,340 individual technical competencies defined by the General Coordination for Human Resource Management (CGGP, 2023) of ICMBio—the federal agency responsible for protected area administration—were analyzed and linked to IBRAM units, differentiating them by type of activity. Based on the interview findings and comparative analyses, proposals for the essential competencies required for the effective management of district-level protected areas were developed. These proposals were presented and validated with SUCON employees to support the revision and expansion of legal frameworks governing job roles and career structures. Additionally, the study aimed to strengthen biodiversity conservation efforts carried out by IBRAM, aligning them with Target 3 of the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework (CBD). The exposition of this research seeks to contribute to the debate on enhancing patterns of policy leadership help initiate and sustain successful transitions towards ecologically-effective PA systems, in multi-level governance systems.

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - Monitoring and evaluation of service concessions for supporting visitation in Brazilian national parks
Grislayne Lopes (University of São Paulo (Brazil))
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This research focuses on monitoring and evaluation (M&E) practices in the service concession for supporting visitation in Brazilian national parks (NPs). This study is situated within the context of the federal government’s environmental policy agenda, in which partnerships, through concession contracts between the public and private sectors, were established as one of the possibilities for providing services in public-use areas of NPs. These partnerships aim to stimulate visitation in contact with nature, with the potential to enhance natural and cultural heritage, promote local socioeconomic development and democratize access to protected areas (PAs). However, this agenda has drawn criticism from society due to its advancement amidst shortcomings in institutional governance, limitations in planning and management of partnerships, difficulties in monitoring contracts and effectiveness of public policy. Given this scenario and considering that M&E practices are incipient in the context of Brazilian public policies, this study aimed to analyze M&E practices in service concession for supporting visitation in Brazilian NPs, reinforcing that such actions enhance a quality standard of the provision of tourism and leisure services to society and contribute to achieving PAs' objectives. This exploratory study employs a mixed-methods approach, combining bibliographic and documental research with quantitative data analysis and content analysis of interviews conducted with specialists, public authority technical team (ICMBio) and concessionaires. It sought to answer the following questions: What M&E practices exist in public policy of concession? Are the resources and processes planned sufficient? What are the obstacles to implementing M&E strategies and tools in public policy of concession? The study identified existing M&E practices and tools in the NPs; investigated the M&E governance structure in concession policy; analyzed how the subject is addressed in seven national park concession contracts; and collected the perceptions of interviewees, observing causes and effects, based on components of resources and processes required to generate services and/or products, results and impacts. The study noted a lack of: effective guidelines within the institutional scope of the public authority; application of good governance principles; human resources and equipment for monitoring concession contracts, policy results and impacts; standardized contractual frameworks; and M&E plans, with indicators for monitoring and instruments for evaluating the results and impacts of public concession policy. It was concluded that integrating M&E practices into public policy of concession can generate evidence for informed decision-making, serve as a strategy for institutional learning and identify problems requiring solutions. Furthermore, it strengthens transparency and accountability from both public and private sectors to stakeholders. It is suggested that the public sector initiate discussions and develop M&E practices for concessions, incorporated into a broad and innovative national M&E policy for SNUC, integrating all M&E systems and tools of PAs. Contributions of this study include bridging the fields of tourism, environment and M&E of public policies, as well as systematizing information to support M&E in public policy of concession. Thus, this study fits with the panel's research as it addresses the evaluation of a public policy in protected area, highlighting the importance of M&E concessions in national parks.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Deforestation and forest degradation as a result of illegal logging are the prime drivers of the loss of biodiversity in Nigeria. As of 2024, Nigeria has lost over 90% of its forest areas. In response, using the framework of the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), the Nigerian government established National Parks for the conservation of biodiversity with strict prohibition on logging and imposed CITES certification requirements for the export of Pterocarpus Erinaceus (Rosewoods). However, data from the Nigerian Federal Ministry of Environment revealed that from 1990 to 2020, the protected forest areas (PFAs) in Nigeria reduced from 10% to 6% of the country’s landmass, also Nigeria remains the biggest source of illegally logged endangered Pterocarpus Erinaceus in Sub-Saharan Africa. This signifies regulatory failure and the ineffectiveness of the PFAs to limit access to forest resources and conserve the biodiversity within it. Armed with this observation, this study addresses the panel question- How to better incorporate contemporary scientific insights in the reform of nature policies and Protected Areas (PA) designations and the regulation of human access, for more ecologically effective PA systems? To answer this question, we surveyed 221 stakeholders of the Old Oyo National Park in the Southwestern region of Nigeria, which was followed up with 22 in-depth interviews. Additional data was drawn from secondary sources.  The findings of this study reveal that forest officers' use of discretion, influenced by limited resources, insecurity, prebendalism, and corruption, often undermines regulatory effectiveness. The key findings further reveal that loggers’ compliance with logging regulations is inconsistent, and enforcement of penalties often lacks a deterrence effect. It is therefore important for policymakers to mitigate these constraints through interventions at the policy, organisational and individual levels to initiate a positive impact on regulatory outcomes and forest sustainability.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Sacred groves, locally known as devithans in the Darjeeling-Sikkim Himalayas, have long been integral to the cultural and ecological practices of indigenous communities. These culturally protected forests serve as sanctuaries for deities, ancestral spirits, and sacred beings while acting as reservoirs for vital resources such as water springs, native flora, and fauna. Managed through traditional norms that restrict resource extraction and harmful activities, devithans play a vital role in conserving biodiversity, safeguarding water resources, and maintaining ecological balance. However, increasing modernization and developmental pressures have led to the degradation of sacred groves and the drying up of springs, posing severe threats to biodiversity and water security. This erosion of sacred spaces highlights the urgent need to integrate traditional ecological knowledge (TEK) into contemporary conservation and water management strategies. Indigenous practices, rooted in spiritual and cultural values, offer valuable insights for sustainable natural resource management but remain underrepresented in formal policymaking frameworks.

Recognizing the efficacy of these practices, this paper emphasizes the importance of embedding traditional systems within institutional governance structures. Such integration would bridge the gap between modern conservation approaches and age-old sustainable practices, fostering inclusive policy processes that respect cultural heritage while addressing pressing environmental challenges. This paper explores the multifaceted significance of sacred groves in the Eastern Himalayas, emphasizing their role in biodiversity conservation, water resource management, and cultural preservation. Drawing on field data from the Darjeeling-Sikkim Himalayas, supplemented by secondary sources, the paper examines the current state of sacred groves, their role in resource management, and the challenges posed by environmental and cultural transformations. It advocates for the incorporation of indigenous knowledge systems into institutional frameworks to empower communities, ensure sustainable resource management, and mitigate the ecological impacts of modernization and climate change.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This study delves into the complexities of collaborative governance within the Sierra Occidental Biocultural Landscape (SOBL) in western Mexico, a region specifically designed to promote the coexistence of biodiversity conservation and sustainable development. This research employs a mixed-methods approach, combining Social Network Analysis (SNA) with in-depth qualitative interviews to examine the collaborative network of 22 key stakeholders representing diverse sectors, including government agencies, tourism operators, local producers, and grassroots organizations.  


Furthermore, the study assesses the SOBL's adherence to the critical elements of successful collaborative governance as defined by Ansell and Gash (2008): starting conditions (including power dynamics and pre-existing conflict), institutional design (inclusivity and established rules), leadership (facilitation and trust-building), and the collaborative process itself (communication and shared understanding).  This detailed examination of the SOBL's governance structure provides valuable insights into the governance of emerging models of land protection and management in the Global South.     


The SNA revealed a network characterized by moderate density and centralization, suggesting a foundation for collaborative efforts, but also highlighting areas for improvement.  Specifically, the analysis revealed low reciprocity in stakeholder relationships, indicating potential power imbalances, particularly with the prominent role of state government agencies.  Limited connectivity among non-governmental stakeholders may restrict inclusivity and the equitable distribution of benefits derived from conservation initiatives.  


Qualitative data gathered through interviews with key stakeholders underscored the need to address these power imbalances, bolster the project’s credibility among local communities, establish clearer rules, and foster trust. These insights are crucial for enhancing public support for ecologically effective protected areas systems.


While the SOBL holds considerable promise for achieving collaborative conservation goals, strategic interventions are necessary to unlock its full potential and effectively contribute to broader biodiversity targets.  By integrating SNA with rich qualitative insights, this research offers a comprehensive understanding of the complex collaborative dynamics at play within this biocultural landscape, providing valuable lessons for similar initiatives in Mexico and overseas.    

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The 1992 Conventional Biological Diversity and its implementation decisions include commitments by Member States to improve not only the land and marine coverage of Protected Areas (PA) but also the functional ecological representativeness of national PA networks. To ensure functionality, each native ecosystem type should be adequately (restored and) protected over at least 20% of its original cover, while considering potential impacts of climate changes. This study evaluates the policy-related challenges faced by New Zealand in meeting these commitments for the land-based Protected Areas.
The evaluation integrates multiple disciplinary and actor perspectives. First, it presents the findings of ecological studies regarding the over-representation and under-representation of native ecosystems in the largest network, managed by the government’s Department of Conservation. Second, it examines the legal, institutional and cultural settings that affect the current ecological performance of PAs. Third, it presents the findings of a nation-wide survey among public sector officials, scientists and Protected Area stakeholders, regarding actor perceptions on the need for, priorities and approaches to such transitions. This includes analyses of survey results regarding the potential roles of scientists in transitions to more ecologically-representative and functionally-sustainable PAs.
These perspectives are integrated to discuss progress options and to articulate policy, institutional and law reform recommendations, to futureproof the persistence of native biodiversity, by using PA as key policy tools.

CO-AUTHORS
Marcos Tito (Center for Sustainable Development/University of Brasília)
Andre Cunha (Universidade de Brasília)
ABSTRACT

The District Conservation Unit System (DCUS), known in Portuguese as the Sistema Distrital de Unidades de Conservação (SDUC), established by Complementary Law No. 827/2010, is a set of protected areas in the Federal District, Brazil, aimed at protecting biodiversity and natural resources. It promotes sustainable use, social participation, environmental education, scientific research, and the restoration of degraded areas. Additionally, the system seeks to enhance the region's natural and cultural resources, consolidating a legal framework for local environmental conservation. However, despite its importance, the DCUS faces challenges related to its implementation, management, and participatory governance. This research aims to analyze the evolution and challenges of the DCUS, with a particular focus on regulatory governance and the role of public, private, and civil society actors in the system's development and management. The central research question is: how have regulation and governance processes influenced the design and management of the District Conservation Unit System (DCUS) in the Federal District, Brazil? A qualitative approach will be employed, using a case study as the investigation strategy. Data collection will involve document analysis (e.g., meeting minutes, legislative bills, public actions) and in-depth semi-structured interviews with actors involved in the creation and management of the DCUS. The collected data will be categorized using content analysis, with special attention given to the legislative process of Complementary Law No. 827/2010, exploring the inspirations, motivations, and levels of influence of the system's key formulators and implementers. The expected results aim to highlight gaps and opportunities in the DCUS’s management model, contributing to the improvement of mechanisms for participation and regulatory coherence. This study aligns with central themes of the panel by exploring the interaction between environmental regulations, social participation, and the effectiveness of public policies for protected areas. In this context, the experience of the DCUS provides insights into the challenges of decentralized environmental governance in metropolitan regions. Additionally, this research contributes to understanding how historical and contemporary scientific paradigms shape nature policies, protected area designations, and regulatory frameworks. By examining the formulation and implementation of the DCUS, the findings help contextualize the role of legal frameworks and stakeholder dynamics in balancing conservation goals and sustainable use, enriching the debate on adaptive and participatory approaches to environmental governance.

CO-AUTHORS
Pascal Scherrer (Southern Cross University)
Kay Dimmock (Southern Cross University)
ABSTRACT

Background:

Marine protected areas in Australia are managed by government agencies tasked with balancing the long-term conservation of nature with cultural, social and economic uses, including commercial tourism. However, scholars have highlighted that commercial tourism is often incompatible with nature conservation unless it is well-planned and well-managed. To date, little academic attention has been paid to policy design and policy instrument mixes, despite calls for scholars to contribute conceptual understandings and practitioner-focused policy insights to safeguard the ecological sustainability of commercial tourism in protected areas.

 

Research question:

Smart regulation is a concept that advocates for complementary policy instrument mixes and regulatory pluralism. The concept has been operationalised into design principles. This research explored the applicability of smart regulation design principles for commercial tourism in marine protected areas by asking: “how do smart regulation design principles apply commercial tourism in marine protected areas?”

 

Methodology:

Through qualitative case studies on the Cape Byron Marine Park and the Whitsundays Planning Area of the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park, this study applied the Persuade-Enable-Constrain Framework to zoom into the behavioural responses of commercial tourism operators. Behavioural responses of policy-takers to policy implementation are underexplored in public policy studies and are critical to improving policy instrument design and goal attainment. Empirical evidence of how and why policy-takers respond to policy instruments applied in combination can improve our understanding of the relevance of policy design principles such as smart regulation.

 

How this research fits in with panel’s research questions:

Commercial tourism operator perspectives and behavioural responses highlight the critical role of procedural tools such as monitoring programs, review periods, management plans, and permit policies in safeguarding the ecological effectiveness of marine protected areas, particularly in the context of climate change. Therefore, this research contributes empirically to theme two (The ecological effectiveness of nature policies, protected designations and regulations) and theme 3 (the governance of protected areas). The research concludes that smart regulation design principles provided a useful framework for exploring policy design and instrument mixes. However, apparent specificities apply to commercial tourism in marine protected areas, particularly concerning complementary instrument mixes, minimum levels of intervention and policy instrument sequencing. The findings provide valuable insights for practice and directions for future research.

CO-AUTHORS
Natalia Scurrah (RCSD, Faculty of Social Science, Chiang Mai University)
ABSTRACT

The paper will discuss the lessons from the Mekong Region Land Governance project (MRLG) in supporting policy and practice change to strengthen the land and resource rights of communities affected by the expansion of protected areas (PAs) for conservation and climate change mitigation. Cambodia has designated about 38% of its territory as PAs without any form of consultation with the communities living in and nearby those areas. Indigenous people have lost access to spiritual, shifting-cultivation and forest land that they customarily used. This dispossession has created strong incentives to encroach in PAs for short-term benefits and discouraged collaborative approaches for conservation purpose.

MRLG has established an alliance of stakeholders – including conservationists, CSOs, indigenous organizations and researchers – to reflect on the main issues faced by communities in PAs and develop strategies to influence related policies and practices to strengthen community rights to land and livelihoods. The alliance has promoted the concept of customary tenure to: 1) advocate for community rights within environmental legislation, and 2) develop tools for engaging communities in a Free Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC) process to inform the zoning of PAs.

A review of the lessons learned highlights the value of multistakeholder approaches, leveraging research and evidence to feed policy dialogue, collaborative strategy design and monitoring, multi-level government engagement, learning from neighboring countries, and continuously adapting strategies in response to contextual changes. While these principles have been effective in building a strong coalition, the actual changes have been limited due to the governance context of the country, its complex political economy, the unpredictability of policy development processes, etc. The implementation of FPIC by conservation NGOs provided more promising results compared to policy level discussions. Ultimately, however, efforts to address the question of community land rights through a more inclusive process also came up against powerful interests and excluded a community-based conservation group deemed to be too ‘radical’ by the Ministry of Environment.

Besides modest victories, the challenges faced reflect the lack of progress on more substantial and persistent issues: the influence of powerful families and cronies who consolidate large estates over natural and community areas and the logic of patronage systems within the government and ministries that prevent accountability and incentivize the search for personal benefit over the public good. These logics are well described in multiple scholarly works and continue to drive environmental destruction across the country.

In such a context, we explore the significance and nature of policy change, incremental versus transformative, and confront a difficult question: Is there value in policy engagement and in maintaining the role played by international and national stakeholders to challenge the status quo? Should the policy arena be abandoned as hopeless, or worse, are these engagements legitimizing exclusionary processes? Or should we continue engaging and use international pressure on Cambodia to respect its international commitments such as the social safeguards attached to climate change action?

CO-AUTHORS
Teguh Kurniawan (Universitas Indonesia)
Muhamad Imam Alfie Syarien (Universitas Indonesia)
Marcel Angwyn (Universitas Indonesia)
ABSTRACT

This article explores the challenges posed by jurisdictional and bureaucratic rivalries, as well as inter-scalar conflicts, that impede the effective implementation of Mangrove Conservation & Restoration (MCR) initiatives. It examines the complex governance landscape of MCR, where overlapping jurisdictions across coastal management, forest management, aquaculture policies, and regional planning can create tensions both horizontally (between different agencies) and vertically (across administrative tiers). Horizontal conflicts arise as agencies seek to assert control over their designated domains, while vertical conflicts emerge between local, regional, and provincial governments with differing priorities regarding mangrove development. Utilizing a process tracing methodology, the article investigates how these inter-scalar dynamics have evolved, identifying key events, decisions, and interactions that have shaped the trajectory of mangrove management in Banyuwangi. Process tracing allows for a detailed analysis of the causal mechanisms behind the moderation of inter-scalar conflicts and the identification of factors that have contributed to more cooperative governance. The article examines whether the reduction of conflicts can be attributed to collaborative governance strategies, such as co-creation and joint decision-making, which foster trust and coordination among various stakeholders. By tracing these processes, the article sheds light on how such mechanisms have contributed to the success of Banyuwangi's MCR efforts and the broader implications for improving multi-jurisdictional environmental governance. 

CO-AUTHORS
Jessica de Oliveira (University of Brasilia, Brazil)
Andre Cunha (Universidade de Brasília)
ABSTRACT

To manage the 83 protected areas under its jurisdiction in the Federal District of Brazil, the Instituto Brasília Ambiental (IBRAM) relies on 93 employees affiliated with the Superintendence of Protected Areas (SUCON). Together, these protected areas cover approximately 34% of the Federal District's territory, resulting in a ratio of one SUCON employee per 2,115 hectares of protected land. This scenario imposes a significant burden on employees, who hold analyst and technician positions in the fields of environmental management, urban planning, infrastructure, public policy, and governance. District Law No. 4.302/2009, which established positions related to environmental activities, defined the eligibility criteria for these careers but failed to specify the duties and responsibilities of each position. This gap was only partially addressed 13 years later with the publication of District Decree No. 41/2022, which still provided incomplete guidelines. As a result, there is a significant overlap of functions and responsibilities among employees in different career tracks. Additionally, salary disparities of up to 61% between analysts and technicians exacerbate a sense of disharmony in the workplace, hindering team management and performance. The research was driven by the following central question: What are the essential competencies for the effective management of district protected areas? To identify gaps, redundancies, and excessive workload in competencies associated with the management of protected areas within IBRAM, semi-structured interviews were conducted with 22 SUCON employees (including directors, advisors, and department heads) directly responsible for decision-making. These interviews, held between May and June 2024, combined open-ended and closed-ended questions. The collected data were analyzed using a qualitative approach, focusing on the administrative and technical competencies of IBRAM employees. The evaluation began with the mapping of 420 technical competencies listed in the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) competency framework (Appleton, 2020) against the different job categories within IBRAM. In a second stage, the 1,340 individual technical competencies defined by the General Coordination for Human Resource Management (CGGP, 2023) of ICMBio—the federal agency responsible for protected area administration—were analyzed and linked to IBRAM units, differentiating them by type of activity. Based on the interview findings and comparative analyses, proposals for the essential competencies required for the effective management of district-level protected areas were developed. These proposals were presented and validated with SUCON employees to support the revision and expansion of legal frameworks governing job roles and career structures. Additionally, the study aimed to strengthen biodiversity conservation efforts carried out by IBRAM, aligning them with Target 3 of the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework (CBD). The exposition of this research seeks to contribute to the debate on enhancing patterns of policy leadership help initiate and sustain successful transitions towards ecologically-effective PA systems, in multi-level governance systems.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This research focuses on monitoring and evaluation (M&E) practices in the service concession for supporting visitation in Brazilian national parks (NPs). This study is situated within the context of the federal government’s environmental policy agenda, in which partnerships, through concession contracts between the public and private sectors, were established as one of the possibilities for providing services in public-use areas of NPs. These partnerships aim to stimulate visitation in contact with nature, with the potential to enhance natural and cultural heritage, promote local socioeconomic development and democratize access to protected areas (PAs). However, this agenda has drawn criticism from society due to its advancement amidst shortcomings in institutional governance, limitations in planning and management of partnerships, difficulties in monitoring contracts and effectiveness of public policy. Given this scenario and considering that M&E practices are incipient in the context of Brazilian public policies, this study aimed to analyze M&E practices in service concession for supporting visitation in Brazilian NPs, reinforcing that such actions enhance a quality standard of the provision of tourism and leisure services to society and contribute to achieving PAs' objectives. This exploratory study employs a mixed-methods approach, combining bibliographic and documental research with quantitative data analysis and content analysis of interviews conducted with specialists, public authority technical team (ICMBio) and concessionaires. It sought to answer the following questions: What M&E practices exist in public policy of concession? Are the resources and processes planned sufficient? What are the obstacles to implementing M&E strategies and tools in public policy of concession? The study identified existing M&E practices and tools in the NPs; investigated the M&E governance structure in concession policy; analyzed how the subject is addressed in seven national park concession contracts; and collected the perceptions of interviewees, observing causes and effects, based on components of resources and processes required to generate services and/or products, results and impacts. The study noted a lack of: effective guidelines within the institutional scope of the public authority; application of good governance principles; human resources and equipment for monitoring concession contracts, policy results and impacts; standardized contractual frameworks; and M&E plans, with indicators for monitoring and instruments for evaluating the results and impacts of public concession policy. It was concluded that integrating M&E practices into public policy of concession can generate evidence for informed decision-making, serve as a strategy for institutional learning and identify problems requiring solutions. Furthermore, it strengthens transparency and accountability from both public and private sectors to stakeholders. It is suggested that the public sector initiate discussions and develop M&E practices for concessions, incorporated into a broad and innovative national M&E policy for SNUC, integrating all M&E systems and tools of PAs. Contributions of this study include bridging the fields of tourism, environment and M&E of public policies, as well as systematizing information to support M&E in public policy of concession. Thus, this study fits with the panel's research as it addresses the evaluation of a public policy in protected area, highlighting the importance of M&E concessions in national parks.