Format

P164. Comparing Knowledge Governance: Policies, Politics, and Processes

Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process / Other
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Jens Jungblut
University of Oslo
Main chair
Meng Hsuan Chou
Nanyang Technological University
Second chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Other
SECTOR
Research and Higher Education Policy
KEYWORDS
Knowledge Governance
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Knowledge, long identified as the foundation on which societies and economies flourish (Erkkilä et al. 2023), has now again been linked to global competition and even human extinction (Gates 2026). While previously a mainstay of science fiction, these two opposing paradigms of knowledge use—as a gift but also a threat—have been competing for governance attention and solutions recently. How knowledge is, and should be, governed is driving multiple change processes around the world at a transformative pace (Martini and Robertson 2026; Stranger et al. 2024). This is, for example, visible in how governments are now pursuing science diplomacy: Traditionally framed in cooperative terms, it has become an avenue for addressing competition and geopolitical conflicts (Huang and Meng 2026; Pinna 2025, 2026). Similarly, knowledge and research security have been transformed from technical policy concerns into central organising principles in research governance. We also observe a pivot in how governments are exploiting the migration-higher education policy nexus: Migration policies have been previously used to internationalise higher education; today, we see higher education practices contributing to migration control (Brunner 2025; Cerna and Chou 2023). Indeed, universities and faculty are currently employed as new security institutions and agents, poised at the forefront of detecting and preventing knowledge espionage.

 

These developments can be observed globally, but regional responses differ (Christensen et al. 2014). In the US, the potential for power projection and economic gain inherent in the application of new knowledge is used to secure or expand a hegemonic position through attempted control and exclusivity in access. In Europe, the focus is on the one hand on cooperation among European countries and with interested parties, but also on norms and values such as academic freedom (Maassen et al. 2025); for example, visible in the “Choose Europe for Science” strategy of the European Union. In Asia, the picture is even more diverse. On the one hand, China acts as the main competitor to the US (Landwehr-Matlé et al. 2026) that employs different and, at a first glance, less coercive strategies in their knowledge policies, while on the other hand the countries in the region have to position themselves between the two competing powers, carefully choosing how and when to cooperate with both (Capano et al. 2025).

 

This panel brings together scholars working on the politics and policies of knowledge around the world. Specifically, the contributions from this panel examine one or several of the following three overarching themes. First, the politics of knowledge governance focusses on how governments steer knowledge governance and the tools used to ensure that key sectors and institutions (e.g., universities) meet state and societal expectations. Second, the framing of knowledge governance over time explores how governments talk about knowledge use and the linkages they create between knowledge and other issue areas (e.g., economic growth, social mobility, national security). Third, the varieties of knowledge governance identify the forms and mechanisms driving scientific and scholarly collaboration. Together, the contributions explain how knowledge governance has evolved over time and under conditions of uncertainty, test the robustness of existing analytical frameworks and concepts of knowledge governance through comparative case studies, and identify knowledge governance specificities concerning the role(s) of key actors, discourses, and structures in policy processes.

CALL FOR PAPERS

Knowledge, long identified as the foundation on which societies and economies flourish (Erkkilä et al. 2023), has now again been linked to global competition and even human extinction (Gates 2026). The two opposing paradigms of knowledge use—as a gift but also a threat—have been competing for governance attention and solutions recently. How knowledge is, and should be, governed is driving multiple change processes around the world at a transformative pace (Martini and Robertson 2026; Stranger et al. 2024).  This is, for example, visible in how governments are now pursuing science diplomacy: Traditionally framed in cooperative terms, it has become an avenue for addressing competition and geopolitical conflicts (Huang and Meng 2026; Pinna 2025, 2026). Similarly, knowledge and research security have been transformed from technical policy concerns into central organising principles in research governance. We also observe a pivot in how governments are exploiting the migration-higher education policy nexus (Brunner 2025; Cerna and Chou 2023). These developments can be observed globally, but regional responses differ (Christensen et al. 2014).

 

This panel brings together scholars working on the politics and policies of knowledge around the world. Specifically, the contributions from this panel examine one or several of the following three overarching themes. First, the politics of knowledge governance focusses on how governments steer knowledge governance and the tools used to ensure that key sectors and institutions (e.g., universities) meet state and societal expectations. Second, the framing of knowledge governance over time explores how governments talk about knowledge use and the linkages they create between knowledge and other issue areas (e.g., economic growth, social mobility, national security). Third, the varieties of knowledge governance identify the forms and mechanisms driving scientific and scholarly collaboration. Together, the contributions explain how knowledge governance has evolved over time and under conditions of uncertainty, test the robustness of existing analytical frameworks and concepts of knowledge governance through comparative case studies, and identify knowledge governance specificities concerning the role(s) of key actors, discourses, and structures in policy processes.

 

 

References:

 

Brunner, Lisa (2025) Canadian international student policy at a crossroads. Policy Brief No. 1, October 2025. Institute for Research on Public Policy.

 

Capano, Giliberto, He, Alex Jingwei, and Sean McMinn (2025) “Riding the tide of generative artificial intelligence in higher education policy: an Asian perspective”, Journal of Asian Public Policy 18(2): 245-259.

 

Christensen, Tom, Gornitzka, Åse, & Maassen, Peter (2014) “Global Pressures and National Cultures. A Nordic University Template?” In: Paola Mattei (Ed.), University Adaptation in Difficult Economic Times (pp. 30–51). Oxford University Press.

 

Cerna, Lucie and Meng-Hsuan Chou (2023) “Politics of internationalisation and the migration-higher education nexus”, Globalisation, Societies and Education 21(2): 222-235.

 

Erkkilä, Tero, Chou, Meng-Hsuan, and Nillo Kauppi (2023) Knowledge Alchemy: Models and Agency in Global Knowledge Governance. Bristol: Bristol University Press.

 

Gates, Bill (2026) “The turbulent AI era is here. The choices we make now are critical”, GatesNotes. Available here: https://www.gatesnotes.com/work/make-ai-work-for-everyone/reader/a-turbulent-ai-era-and-critical-choices-to-make (accessed 03 November 2026).

 

Huang, Zhao Alexandre and Xiang Meng (2026) “China’s Strategic Approach to Tech Diplomacy in a time of Global Uncertainty”, Global Policy 17(54): 22-S33.

 

Landwehr-Matlé, Jakob, Kai Oppermann, and Daniel Lambach. 2026. “Great Power Competition for Global Leadership in Artificial Intelligence (AI): Reconstructing AI Narratives of the United States, China, and the European Union.” Review of International Studies online first: 1–19.

 

Maassen, Peter, Elken, Mari, & Jungblut, Jens (2025). “De facto Academic Freedom in the European Union – Threats and Trends.” European Review, 33(S1): 28–S43. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1062798725000134

 

Martini, Michele and Susan Robertson (2026) “Turning schools into AI testing grounds and sites of extraction: The strategic selectivities of IOs AI literacy frameworks”, European Educational Research Journal, https://doi.org/10.1177/14749041261473066.

 

Pinna, Cristina (2025) “Navigating knowledge and research security in EU-China relations: The case of Hungary, Italy and the Netherlands”, Journal of Studies in International Education 29(2): 319-343.

 

Pinna, Cristina (2026) “Governing knowledge, shaping Europe: research security in the EU’s geopolitical turn”, European Security, https://doi.org/10.1080/09662839.2026.2680646.

 

Stranger, Allison, Kraus, Jakub, Lim, Woojin, Millman-Perlah, Georgia, and Mitchell Schroeder (2024) “Terra Incognita: The Governance of Artificial Intelligence in Global Perspective”, Annual Review of Political Science 27: 445-465.