LIST OF PANELS

208 PANELS FOUND

P12. Policy Learning in Contemporary Policymaking: Theories, Practices, Methods, and Frontiers
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Radaelli
B. Zaki
ABSTRACT

Learning has become a staple of contemporary policymaking, both as a practical aspiration and as an analytical lens through which scholars understand the policy process. This is due to two distinct, yet closely connected features. First, learning carries a powerful normative promise. From Lindblom’s account of the “intelligence of democracy” to conceptions of intelligent policymaking, pragmatist democracy, experimentation, and reflexive governance, learning has been associated with governments’ ability to recognize problems, revise assumptions, mobilize knowledge and experiences and improve policy through participation and deliberation. Hence learning is integral to the capacity of political systems to identify and correct errors and respond intelligently to changing societal conditions. This acquires particular significance amid democratic backsliding, political polarization, post-truth politics, and declining trust in expertise, and contestation. Yet learning is not inherently benign. Actors may learn to resist evidence, entrench exclusionary policies, manipulate institutions, or pursue objectives that undermine public value. Hence, understanding when learning contributes to (or detracts from) better governance is itself an important contemporary question. Second, learning offers fundamental analytical leverage for explaining policy processes. Taking the policy actor as a homo discens, whose beliefs, understandings, strategies, and practices evolve through experience and interaction, directs attention toward a deceptively simple question: why do policy actors do what they do as a function of what, how, when, and from whom they learn about policy problems and possible solutions? From this perspective, learning constitutes an underlying mechanism through which actors make sense of problems, interact with knowledge and one another, adapt strategies, reproduce existing policies, or generate change. Learning’s scholarly growth also raises important conceptual, theoretical, and empirical questions. What counts as learning, and what does not? Who learns: individuals, organizations, coalitions, networks, governments, or political systems? How does learning occur and travel across levels? Under what institutional, political, emotional, and epistemic conditions is learning enabled, blocked, distorted, or strategically governed? How should it be identified and measured? This panel welcomes contributions across four broad areas: Learning across policy problems, sectors, and contexts: Contributions focusing on different domains including climate, sustainability, health, crisis governance, migration, social policy, technology and AI, security, and morality policy, including research on how problem and sector characteristics shape learning processes and outcomes. Theoretical, conceptual, and analytical advances: Contributions that develop, refine, critique, or connect concepts and theories of policy learning; investigate mechanisms and micro-foundations; examine learning across levels; or connect learning to broader approaches in policy studies and adjacent fields. Methods and measurement: Contributions that identify, observe, measure, and explain learning across qualitative, quantitative, experimental, computational, comparative, longitudinal, mixed-method, and other designs. The politics, conditions, and consequences of learning: Contributions on when learning is enabled, constrained, blocked, manipulated, or governed; the roles of power, institutions, expertise, evidence, participation, emotions, narratives, and contestation; and consequences for policy change, stability, democratic governance, and public value. We welcome different ontological, epistemological, theoretical and methodological approaches, regions, units and levels of analysis, and encourage work that challenges conventional assumptions about what policy learning is, where it occurs, and what it does.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Policy Transfer/Diffusion/Learning General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P15. Policy Feedback in Low- and Lower-Middle-Income Countries: Diverse Mechanisms, New Contexts, and Varied Experiences
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. He
P. Anand
ABSTRACT

The literature on the policy feedback theory has long established that public policies are not just outcomes of politics, but they also reshape subsequent politics. Foundational works on policy feedback show that policies can redistribute resources, structure incentives, create or weaken constituencies, and provide interpretive messages about governance, citizenship, legitimacy, and political efficacy (Mettler & Soss, 2004; Pierson, 1993). The related scholarship entails feedback among mass publics, organised interest, elites, institutions, and policy development, including self-reinforcing or self-undermining processes (Béland et al., 2022; Béland & Schlager, 2019; Jacobs & Weaver, 2015). However, the empirical foundations of this scholarship remain disproportionately concentrated in the United States, broadly North America, and other advanced industrial democracies (Béland & Schlager, 2019; Hern, 2017a). This geographical concentration is theoretically consequential. Many established expectations presume comparatively stable programmes, recognisable state authorship, programmatic delivery, and institutionalised channels connecting citizens and organised interests to government (Alik-Lagrange et al., 2021; Hern, 2017b). These conditions cannot be assumed across low-income countries (LICs) and lower-middle-income countries (Lower-MICs), although income classification itself is not treated as a proxy for state capacity or regime type. The categories instead define an intentionally underrepresented empirical domain within which feedback theory can be tested under wider institutional variation. In LICs and Lower-MICs, policies may be implemented unevenly and encountered through frontline officials, local brokers, community organisations, NGOs, donors, private providers, or through digital infrastructures (Alik-Lagrange et al., 2021). Benefits can increase material resources while political credit flows to an intermediary; policy experiences can generate efficacy, claims-making, and collective organisation, but also stigma, dependence, distrust, or countermobilization (Mettler & Soss, 2004; Moynihan et al., 2015). Emerging studies from Zambia and Ghana, together with comparative work on social protection under low and uneven state capacity, show that feedback may be attenuated, redirected, or self-undermining rather than uniformly reinforcing (Alik-Lagrange et al., 2021; Hern, 2017b; Ibrahim, 2023; Wireko et al., 2020). The panel’s central question is: How do public policies reshape politics in LICs and lower-MICs, through which mechanisms, under what institutional and social conditions, and with what consequences for political participation, state-citizen relations, organised interests, and subsequent policy development? It advances three expectations. • Expectation 1. Reliable provision is more likely to strengthen resource effects, while visibility and traceability to public authority strengthen interpretive effects and political attribution; fragmented or brokered delivery may attenuate or redirect both (Alik-Lagrange et al., 2021; Campbell, 2012; Pierson, 1993). • Expectation 2. Exclusionary design, administrative burden, stigma, and discretionary implementation can generate differentiated or self-undermining feedback, with effects shaped by state capacity, decentralisation, regime type, party competition, and inequalities of gender, caste, class, ethnicity, and place (Jacobs & Weaver, 2015; Moynihan et al., 2015). • Expectation 3. Policies embedded in associations, self-help groups, unions, or participatory institutions are more likely to generate organisational and relational resources for sustained mobilisation than individually delivered benefits (Bruch et al., 2010; Flavin & Hartney, 2015). By comparing these mechanisms and scope conditions, the panel will assess what travels from established theory, what requires modification, and what LIC and Lower-MIC cases contribute to a genuinely comparative policy-feedback research agenda.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics
P33. Bringing Individuals Back In: Politicians, Bureaucrats and Policy Dynamics
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
G. Capano
M. Galanti
O. Meza
ABSTRACT

1.1 General objectives Policies are made by people. Mayors and city councillors, regional presidents and state governors, ministers and members of parliament decide which problems deserve attention and interact with interest groups and movements. Municipal managers, regional officials and national civil servants turn broad goals into workable rules and decide how programmes work in practice. These are the main characters acting within policy dynamics to move the policy process from intentions to concrete outputs and outcomes. Yet the main theories of the policy process treat these individual actors as residual elements, while carefully defining structural factors (institutions, coalitions, ideas, external events) (Capano et al. 2025). In other words, we know that individual action matters, but we lack a systematic account of how it matters, under what conditions and with what effects. The general objective of the panel is to place the individual agency of politicians and bureaucrats at the centre of the analysis of policy dynamics: to study what these individuals actually do when shaping policy, at and across all levels of government, and to develop a common analytical language for studying their agency. 1.2 Scientific relevance Individuals have not been ignored, but they are usually studied in isolation rather than as purposive agents advancing policies across territorial levels (Mendez 2025). Public policy research has examined policy entrepreneurs who promote new solutions (Kingdon 1984; Mintrom and Norman 2009; Petridou and Mintrom 2021), brokers who mediate between opposing coalitions (Ingold and Varone 2011; Christopoulos and Ingold 2015), public leaders who steer the process ('t Hart and Uhr 2008; Peci, González and Dussauge-Laguna 2023) and experts who inform it (Weible 2008). Public administration has documented the discretion of frontline workers (Lipsky 1980), the policy work of middle-ranking officials (Page and Jenkins 2005) and the relationship between politicians and senior bureaucrats in national government (Aberbach, Putnam and Rockman 1981; Hood and Lodge 2006). Local government scholars have shown that formal institutions alone do not explain local policy change (Hernández-Bonivento, Grin and Vial Cossani 2025) or stability (Meza 2022). They have studied how leadership styles differ among European mayors (Heinelt et al. 2018), how elected officials and top administrators share influence in city governments (Mouritzen and Svara 2002), how policy entrepreneurs innovate in municipal administrations (Petridou, Becker and Sparf 2021; Gofen and Lotta 2021), how frontline workers contribute to policy design (Lavee and Cohen 2019; Gofen, Meza and Moreno-Jaimes 2024), and how local policy elites (Liu et al. 2010), state governors (Kousser and Phillips 2012) and regional politicians (Calignano and Nilsen 2024) act as agents of change. These traditions share four limits. First, they are fragmented: each tradition examines one type of actor, and they rarely speak to one another. Second, they tend to identify agency with a label. An individual is classified as an entrepreneur, a broker or a leader, and the label is then used to explain what that person did. This reasoning is circular and obscures the fact that the same person often behaves differently across phases of the same process (Capano and Galanti 2021). Third, they keep politicians and bureaucrats apart, as if formal roles determined behaviour. Fourth, policy process research has favoured national over local government (Meza and de Alba 2026), and work on municipal, regional and national actors has developed in separate fields. We do not know whether individuals act in the same ways at different levels, or how they act across levels. The Functional Theory of Agency (FTA) offers a way to address these limits (Capano and Galanti 2018; Capano et al. 2025). It shifts the question from who the actors are to what they do. It distinguishes actors, who hold formal roles such as mayor, minister, or civil servant, from agents, who act according to specific patterns regardless of their formal role. Drawing on Merton (1968), it argues that four functions must be performed in any policy process: steering, innovation, intermediation and intelligence. Individuals perform them through four patterns of action: leadership, entrepreneurship, brokerage and knowledge accumulation. Patterns are not identity traits: the same person can enact different patterns at different times. In a recent empirical application, Meza and de Alba (2026) find all four functions at work in Mexican local governments and show that political position shapes them without pre-determining unique roles: majority councillors mainly steer and broker in support of the mayor, while opposition councillors innovate, invest in knowledge and build alliances with state and federal actors, but also with the local civic society. This shows that asking what individuals do helps explain change and stability beyond formal roles, especially in multilevel settings where formal rules are weakly enforced. The panel’s scientific relevance lies in three contributions. - Theoretically, it offers a common language for research traditions that have developed separately, and it links policy process theories with public administration and with local and regional government studies. - Empirically, it brings together comparative evidence on the individual agency of politicians and bureaucrats at all levels of government. - Practically, it clarifies what individuals in public office can realistically do, which matters for the design of public organisations and the training of officials. 1.3 Research questions The panel is organised around five research questions: 1. What do politicians and bureaucrats do when they influence the policy process, and how do their patterns of action compare across roles, policy sectors, countries and levels of government? 2. Which conditions (formal mandates, institutional position, relationships of trust, expert reputation) make the patterns of action of politicians and bureaucrats viable, and do they differ between a municipality, a region or state, and a national government? 3. Why and how do politicians and bureaucrats, as individual agents, select and change their patterns of action during the same process? 4. How does the individual action of politicians and bureaucrats connect to collective actors, to action across levels of government, and to policy outcomes? 5. Which research designs and methods allow us to observe the individual agency of politicians and bureaucrats reliably? The panel welcomes papers that apply, extend or criticise the FTA, and papers that study individual agency from other perspectives. References Aberbach, J. D., Putnam, R. D., & Rockman, B. A. (1981). Bureaucrats and Politicians in Western Democracies. Harvard University Press. Calignano, G., & Nilsen, T. (2024). Political leaders as agents in regional development. Regional Studies, Regional Science, 11(1), 479-495. Capano, G., & Galanti, M. T. (2018). Policy dynamics and types of agency: From individual to collective patterns of action. European Policy Analysis, 4(1), 23-47. Capano, G., & Galanti, M. T. (2021). From policy entrepreneurs to policy entrepreneurship: Actors and actions in public policy innovation. Policy & Politics, 49(3), 321-342. Capano, G., Galanti, M. T., Ingold, K., Petridou, E., & Weible, C. M. (2025). Theorizing the functions and patterns of agency in the policymaking process. Policy Sciences, 58(1), 3-26. Christopoulos, D., & Ingold, K. (2015). Exceptional or just well connected? Political entrepreneurs and brokers in policy making. European Political Science Review, 7(3), 475-498. Gofen, A., & Lotta, G. (2021). Street-Level Bureaucrats at the Forefront of Pandemic Response: A Comparative Perspective. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice, 23(1), 3-15. Gofen, A., Meza, O., & Moreno-Jaimes, C. (2024). Frontline organizations as experimental settings for policy change: why public management matters even more. Public Management Review, 26(7), 1827–1848. Heinelt, H., Magnier, A., Cabria, M., & Reynaert, H. (Eds.) (2018). Political Leaders and Changing Local Democracy: The European Mayor. Palgrave Macmillan. Hernández-Bonivento, J. A., Grin, E. J., & Vial Cossani, C. (2025). Subnational development, state capacities, and policy implementation: A comparative analysis of Brazil, Chile, and Colombia. In L. Secchi & C. N. Cruz-Rubio (Eds.), Handbook of public policy in Latin America (pp. 257–284). Edward Elgar Publishing. Hood, C., & Lodge, M. (2006). The Politics of Public Service Bargains. Oxford University Press. Ingold, K., & Varone, F. (2011). Treating policy brokers seriously: Evidence from the climate policy. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 22(2), 319-346. Kingdon, J. W. (1984). Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies. Little, Brown. Kousser, T., & Phillips, J. H. (2012). The Power of American Governors: Winning on Budgets and Losing on Policy. Cambridge University Press. Lavee, E., & Cohen, N. (2019). How street-level bureaucrats become policy entrepreneurs: The case of urban renewal. Governance, 32(3), 475-492. Lipsky, M. (1980). Street-Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services. Russell Sage Foundation. Liu, X., Lindquist, E., Vedlitz, A., & Vincent, K. (2010). Understanding local policymaking: Policy elites' perceptions of local agenda setting and alternative policy selection. Policy Studies Journal, 38(1), 69-91. Merton, R. K. (1968). Social Theory and Social Structure. Free Press. Mendez, JL. (2025). Actor-Centered Approaches for the Study of Public Policy. In: Romero-Tarín, A., Cardozo, N.D. (eds) Public Policy and Research in Latin America. International Series on Public Policy. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. Meza, O. (2022) Punctuated equilibrium in multilevel contexts: How federal and state level forces feedback into shaping the local policy agenda in Mexico. Policy Studies Journal, 50, 575–594. Meza, O., & de Alba, A. C. (2026). Power, politics, and policy agency: Towards a Functional Theory of Agency. Policy & Politics, Early View. Mintrom, M., & Norman, P. (2009). Policy entrepreneurship and policy change. Policy Studies Journal, 37(4), 649-667. Mouritzen, P. E., & Svara, J. H. (2002). Leadership at the Apex: Politicians and Administrators in Western Local Governments. University of Pittsburgh Press. Page, E. C., & Jenkins, B. (2005). Policy Bureaucracy: Government with a Cast of Thousands. Oxford University Press. Peci, A., González, C. I., & Dussauge-Laguna, M. I. (2023). Presidential policy narratives and the (mis)use of scientific expertise: Covid-19 policy responses in Brazil, Colombia, and Mexico. Policy Studies, 44(1), 68–89. Petridou, E., Becker, P., & Sparf, J. (2021). Policy entrepreneurs in public administration: A social network analysis. Politics & Policy, 49(2), 414-445. Petridou, E., & Mintrom, M. (2021). A research agenda for the study of policy entrepreneurs. Policy Studies Journal, 49(4), 943-967. 't Hart, P., & Uhr, J. (Eds.) (2008). Public Leadership: Perspectives and Practices. ANU E Press. Weible, C. M. (2008). Expert-based information and policy subsystems: A review and synthesis. Policy Studies Journal, 36(4), 615-635.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Agency/Leadership
P57. Closing the Theory-Practice Gap: What Do Policy Process Theories Offer Policymakers?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
H. Arab
ABSTRACT

Policy process theories help us understand how policies are made, why some issues receive attention while others do not, how actors influence decisions, and why policies change or remain the same. However, an important question remains: How much do these theories actually matter in the real world, and what do they offer to the people involved in policymaking? Though policy process theories are widely used in academic research, the connection between theoretical knowledge and the practical work of policymakers and public administrators deserves further attention. The panel builds on the substantial literature on policy process theories and evidence-based policymaking. The panel considers the operationalization of policy process theories in producing lessons for policy practitioners. Weible and Cairney (2018; 2015) argue that policy scholars need to break the barrier of knowledge synthesis and move beyond paper-based discussion to communicating with practitioners and producing tangible knowledge. In their book, they apply this perspective to the Multiple Streams Framework (MSF), Narrative Policy Framework (NPF), Cultural Theory (CT), Institutional Collective Action (ICA), Punctuated Equilibrium Theory (PET), Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD), and the Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF) (Weible & Cairney, 2021). Furthermore, this panel focuses on the gap between evidence and policy in terms of policy research and policy practice. This gap has been widely discussed by Nutley and colleagues (2007), who argue that research findings cannot simply be transferred to government and utilized by policy actors. Cairney and colleagues (2016) continued this discussion by claiming that the gap cannot be mended by producing further evidence. Policymakers are boundedly rational and are required to think systematically about issues without adequate tools (Oliver et al., 2014). Junior policy scholars seem to be particularly interested in bridging this gap, but without much guidance or practical tools, they face academic hurdles regarding rigor and validity (Plümer et al., 2025). Lastly, the applicability and limits of policy process theories were also discussed by Weible and Cairney (2018) in relation to the “new policy science.” Recently, Cairney et al. (2025) and Weible (2025) discussed how contemporary policy process theories are not universally applicable tools; if they do not adapt to developments in science and society, they may become outdated. The authors also warn that these theories were not designed to transform policy or to serve as practical application guides for government agents (Cairney et al., 2016). This research thread is not highly contested, but it remains vague, because the use of theories to address real-world problems is complex. It requires non-scholars to become familiar with scholarly terminology and requires scholars to communicate their systematic findings in accessible ways without sacrificing their conceptual designs (Moyson et al., 2017). This panel aims to bring policy process scholars together to discuss how their research connects to policy practice. It seeks to explore whether and how theories inform real-world policymaking, how researchers can make their findings more useful to practitioners, and what limits the application of theoretical insights in different political and institutional contexts. Rather than assuming that theories automatically translate into better policies, the panel encourages a discussion of their actual contributions, limitations, and potential for practical application. The panel will address the following research questions: 1-How do policy process theories help us understand and address real-world policymaking challenges?2-How can researchers connect theoretical insights to the needs and experiences of policymakers and practitioners?3-Where can we observe the influence of policy process theories on policymaking, and what 4-happens when these theories have limited practical application?5-What challenges prevent the application of policy process theories across different political and institutional contexts?6-How can researchers and practitioners work together to make policy process research more relevant to practice? The scientific relevance of this panel lies in its focus on the relationship between theoretical knowledge and real-world policymaking. It encourages scholars to reflect not only on what policy process theories explain, but also on their practical value and limitations. By bringing together different perspectives and experiences, the panel aims to identify opportunities to make policy process research more accessible and useful to practitioners. Ultimately, it seeks to encourage a more meaningful connection between the development of policy process theories and the challenges faced by those working in policymaking and public administration. References Cairney, P., & Jones, M. D. (2016). Kingdon’s Multiple Streams Approach: What is the empirical impact of this universal theory? Policy Studies Journal, 44(1), 37–58. Cairney, P., Oliver, K., & Wellstead, A. (2016). To bridge the divide between evidence and policy: Reduce ambiguity as much as uncertainty. Public Administration Review, 76(3), 399–402. Cairney, P., Fullerton, A. H., Denny, E. S., & Weible, C. M. (2025). Policy process theories in Europe: A survey of who uses them, where, and why. European Policy Analysis, 11(2), 1237–1256. Moyson, S., Scholten, P., & Weible, C. M. (2017). Policy learning and policy change: Theorizing their relations from different perspectives. Policy and Society, 36(2), 161–177. Nutley, S. M., Walter, I., & Davies, H. T. O. (2007). Using evidence: How research can inform public services. Policy Press. Oliver, K., Innvar, S., Lorenc, T., Woodman, J., & Thomas, J. (2014). A systematic review of barriers to and facilitators of the use of evidence by policymakers. BMC Health Services Research, 14, 2. Plümer, K. D., Mock, M., & Brokqvist, H. (2025). Policy process theory development: Perspectives from European junior scholars. European Policy Analysis, 11(2), 271–292. Weible, C. M. (2025). The relevance of policy process theories in Europe. European Policy Analysis, 11(2), 144–153. Weible, C. M., & Cairney, P. (2018). Practical lessons from policy theories. Policy & Politics, 46(2), 183–197.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Methods & Research Design Other
P44. Multiple Streams, National Settings, and Entrepreneurial Agency: Advancing Method and Theory
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Petridou
N. Zahariadis
R. Zohlnhöfer
ABSTRACT

Since Kingdon's 1984 Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies, the Multiple Streams Framework (MSF) has become one of the most widely applied approaches to understanding policy change under ambiguity, with tens of thousands of citations spanning governance levels, policy sectors, and political systems. The framework is still relevant, especially when it comes to understanding wicked problems, because of its ability to incorporate ambiguity and extraordinary events in the policy process (Herweg et al., 2023). All frameworks develop over time to meet the needs of societal (and policy) grand challenges and the MSF is not an exception. Two trajectories are fruitful. First, MSF has undertheorized the specification of hypotheses that adapt policy making to various democratic, developing, and autocratic settings. Second, while policy entrepreneurs have become the central vehicle for theorizing agency in the policy process (Mintrom and Norman 2009; Petridou and Mintrom 2021), their relationship to institutional structure — the degree to which entrepreneurial strategy is enabled, constrained, or reshaped by institutional configuration — remains only partially specified. What is more the relationship between policy entrepreneurs and other types of agency remains underdeveloped. This panel brings these threads together through the lens of method. Building on methodological pluralism within MSF scholarship (Zahariadis et al. 2023; DeLeo et al. 2024) and for more standardized measurement of core constructs, we invite work that tests, refines, or synthesizes MSF hypotheses using transparent, rigorous designs — quantitative, qualitative, comparative, or mixed. Papers addressing settings beyond Western democracies — including the Global South and autocracies — are particularly encouraged, as are papers placing MSF in dialogue with institutionalist theory more broadly. ReferencesDeLeo, Rob A., Reimut Zohlnhöfer, and Nikolaos Zahariadis. 2024. "Multiple Streams and Policy Ambiguity." Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. https://www.cambridge.org/core/product/FBA20248D4A359D38AF7083D00F5149E. Herweg, N., Zahariadis, N., & Zohlnhöfer, R. (2023). The Multiple Streams Framework Foundations, Refinements, and Empirical Applications. In C.M. Weible (Ed.) Theories of the Policy Process (pp. 29-64). Taylor and Francis. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003308201-3Mintrom, M., & Norman, P. (2009). Policy Entrepreneurship and Policy Change. Policy Studies Journal, 37(4), 649-667. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1541-0072.2009.00329.xPetridou, E., & Mintrom, M. (2021). A Research Agenda for the Study of Policy Entrepreneurs. Policy Studies Journal, 49(4), 943-967. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1111/psj.12405 Zahariadis, N., Herweg, N., Zohlnhöfer, R., & Petridou, E. (Eds.). (2023). A modern guide to the multiple streams framework. Edward Elgar.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Agency/Leadership General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P49. Talking across lenses: Comparing, combining, and synthesizing perspectives, concepts, and theories of the policy process
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Goyal
N. Bandelow
D. Béland
ABSTRACT

The study of public policy processes is characterized by conceptual pluralism. The field includes established concepts and theories, but also ‘lenses’ developed in public administration, comparative public policy, critical and interpretive policy studies, political sociology and social psychology. Various perspectives (such as argumentative policy analysis or social identities), concepts (such as policy capacity, policy feedback, and policy learning), and frameworks (such as the multiple streams framework and the programmatic action framework) have been used to illuminate different dimensions of policymaking. These lenses are typically treated as distinct, since they rest on different assumptions, for example, about actors, institutions, meaning, power and the role of knowledge. Consequently, most work in the field proceeds within existing concepts and theories rather than at their intersection. While this diversity is a source of analytical strength, it can also hinder dialogue and the exchange of knowledge among different theoretical traditions: insights generated within one perspective seldom inform another, and scholars working on the same policy problem may talk past each other. The panel aims to foster dialogue at the intersection of lenses. It does so by focusing on substantive engagement with two or more lenses, i.e., perspectives, concepts, frameworks, theories, or models. Such engagement may take the form of parallel application to test them against one another or to study different stages, levels, or aspects of policymaking; use of one to illuminate the underlying mechanisms of another; or a synthesis of the core elements of two or more lenses to create a new one. Where the perspectives are difficult to reconcile, even identifying the limits to their substantive engagement would constitute a meaningful dialogue. The central research question is: what can be gained from a substantive debate between two or more lenses of the policy process, and under what conditions can such a debate enhance analytical insight and/or practical relevance? 1. Insightful engagement requires clarity about the research objectives, the underlying assumptions of the selected lenses, and the form the engagement could take. The added value may be conceptual, interpretive, explanatory, or normative.2. Dialogue across disciplinary or national traditions can reveal blind spots created by treating a limited canon of theories as universally representative.3. Engagement may be especially productive when lenses illuminate different aspects of policymaking, such as actors (and their networks), institutional trajectories, meanings and narratives, power dynamics, or policy outputs and outcomes.4. The dialogue is more likely to be meaningful when methodological choices follow ontological and epistemological commitments. Comparative methods, computational techniques, discourse analysis, ethnographic studies, longitudinal analysis, process tracing, mixed methods analysis can all contribute when used appropriately.The panel therefore welcomes conceptual, methodological and empirical work across descriptive, explanatory, interpretive, and normative traditions. Its broader aim is to move beyond theoretical silos while preserving conceptual and epistemological richness in order to identify whether, when, and how parallel application, translation, combination, or synthesis of lenses of policymaking can enhance their analytical power and/or practical relevance.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics
P145. Advocacy Coalitions and Policy Outputs/Outcomes
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
W. Li
T. Heinmiller
A. Fullerton
H. Peterson
ABSTRACT

This panel calls for papers related to advocacy coalitions, policy processes and policy outputs/outcomes, including both policy change and policy stability. Particular topics of interest are collective advocacy, coalition opportunity structures, policy venues, and policy learning, with broad focus on their influence on policy outputs/outcomes. The Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF) literature is relevant to a puzzling modern phenomenon: in the age of generative AI and wide access to social media, expanded information availability does not necessarily empower resource-constrained communities. Instead, belief and affective polarization alongside institutional and social distrust persist, with important implications for policy development (Jenke 2024;Algan et al. 2025; White and Shah 2025;Van Prooijen et al. 2021). At the same time, on policy issues involving different social identities and philosophical worldviews, opposing coalitions can share deep-core beliefs, implying opportunities for policy learning (Crawford & Weible, 2024).The Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF) literature on policy advocacy, learning and change has examined the dynamics of conflicts within policy subsystems shaped by cognitive, psychological, political and emotional use of information and resources (Sabatier, 1987; Heintz,Jr. and Jenkins-Smith 1988; Leach and Sabatier 2005; Fullerton et al. 2024). Cross-country comparative scholarship within this tradition has yielded fruitful findings and continues to advance: the assumptions, hypotheses and theories of the framework have been tested and revised across diverse institutional and issue contexts (Weible and Sabatier 2009; Jonathan et al. 2017; Nohrstedt et al. 2023; Li and Weible 2021). Still, empirical research on the conditions affecting learning, intra‑coalition and inter‑coalition dynamics is an ongoing project. This panel proposes that, by studying the effects of collective participation, voices and learning on policy changes, and the contextual and contingent factors mediating these processes, Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF) research holds substantial explanatory potential to inform solutions to challenging policy issues. References: Algan, Yann, Corin Blanc and Claudia Senik (2025) Trusting Others: How unhappiness and social distrust explain populism? World Happiness Report. Crawford, Anna M., Christopher M. Weible. (2024) The Political Polarization over abortion: An analysis of advocacy coalition belief systems. Policy Sciences, 57: 599-620. Sabatier, Paul (1987) Knowledge, Policy-Oriented Learning and Policy Change: An Advocacy Coalition Framework. Science Communication, 8:649. Fullerton, Allegra H., Kayla M. Gabehart and Christopher M. Weible. (2024) Emotional Expressions and Advocacy Coalitions. International Review of Public Policy, 6(1):5-22. Gabehart, Kayla, Aerang Nam and Christopher M. Weible (2022) Lessons from the Advocacy Coalition. Framework for climate change policy and politics. Npj Climate Action. 13. Heintz Jr., H. Theodore and Hank C. Jenkins-Smith. (1988) Advocacy Coalitions and the Practice of Policy Analysis. Policy Sciences, 21: 263-277. Leach, William D and Paul A. Sabatier. (2005) To Trust an Adversary: Integrating Rational and Psychological Models of Collaborative Policymaking. American Political Science Review, 99(4):492-503. Pierce, Jonathan J., Holly L. Peterson, Michael D. Jones, Samantha P. Garrard and Theresa Vu. (2017) There and Back Again: A Tale of the Advocacy Coalition Framework. The Policy Studies Journal.45(S1):S13-S46. Weible, Christopher M. and Paul A. Sabatier (2009) Coalitions, Science,and Belief Change: Comparing Adversarial and Collaborative Policy Subsystems. The Policy Studies Journal, 37(2): 195-212. Weible, Christopher M., Karin Ingold, Daniel Nohrstedt, Adam Douglas Henry and Hank C. Jenkins-Smith (2019) Sharpening Advocacy Coalitions. Policy Studies Journal. Weible, Christopher M., Anna M. Crawford, Allegra H. Fullerton, Kayla M. Gabehart, Katherine E. Imhoff and Giulia Mariani (2025) Deep core advocacy coalitions. Policy and Society, 44(2):184-199. Nohrstedt, Daniel, Karin Ingold, Christopher M. Weible, Elizabeth A. Koebele, Kristin L. Olofsson, Keiichi Satoh and Hank C. Jenkins-Smith (2023) The Advocacy Coalition Framework-Progress and Emerging Areas. In Christopher M. Weible(Ed.) Theories of the Policy Process. Pp. 130-160. Van Prooijen, Jan-Willem, Giuliana Spadaro and Haiyan Wang (2022) Suspicion of institutions: How distrust and conspiracy theories deteriorate social relationships. Current Opinion in Psychology, 43:65-69. Jenke, Libby (2024) Affective Polarization and Misinformation Belief. Political Behavior, 46: 825-884.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories
P186. Beyond Westminster and the North: Policy Advisory Systems Across Administrative Traditions and Political Regimes
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Real-Dato
L. Chaqués Bonafont
ABSTRACT

Since Halligan’s (1995) seminal work, research on policy advisory systems (PAS) has flourished. Yet its core concepts – the location of advisers, the externalisation and politicisation of advice, and the management and quality of advisory systems – were largely forged in Westminster democracies (Craft & Halligan, 2020) and, later, in Northern and Central European systems (Hustedt & Veit, 2017). The result is a ‘Westminster bias’ (Hustedt, 2019), and the call to compare PAS ‘beyond the OECD’ (Howlett, 2019) has been only partially answered. A growing body of work on Southern and Central-Eastern Europe, Latin America, Asia, Africa and the Middle East shows that advisory systems there are shaped by different administrative traditions, uneven policy analytical capacity, the weight of international organisations and donors and, in non-democratic contexts, regime-driven control over expertise (e.g. Albert & Manwaring, 2019; Bakir, 2023; Belyaeva, 2019; Costa et al., 2026; Di Mascio & Natalini, 2016; Emamian & Bagheripour, 2024; Galanti & Lippi, 2023; Goyal & Saguin, 2019; Koga et al., 2026; Marchevska & Steen, 2022; Meert et al., 2023; Zaytsev, 2019). Yet this literature remains fragmented and has had limited feedback on the field’s core theory (Hustedt, 2025). These systems also face epistemic transformations common to all governments – artificial intelligence (AI), the contestation of expertise and polarisation – from very different starting points in state capacity, regime type and institutional trust. The panel pursues three objectives: to map and compare PAS outside this core across sectors, levels of government and regime types; to examine how epistemic transformations affect these systems; and to use these cases to refine PAS concepts and typologies, treating advisory systems also as an explanatory factor of policy processes and outcomes. Guiding research questions include: 1. Do core PAS concepts travel to these contexts, and what adjustments do they require? 2. How do administrative traditions, regime type and state capacity shape the composition, dynamics and management of PAS? 3. How do PAS configurations influence policy formulation, change and implementation? 4. What role do international organisations, donors and transnational networks play in domestic advisory systems? 5. How are AI and the contestation of expertise transforming advisory relationships? Empirically, the panel brings together evidence on a heterogeneous set of countries – including hybrid and authoritarian regimes – underrepresented in PAS research. Theoretically, these cases test the scope conditions of concepts developed in a few advanced democracies and help build a comparative theory of policy advice.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process
P68. Narrative Policy Framework: Developments, Discoveries, and Challenges
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Shanahan
J. Ksinsik
B. Stauffer
ABSTRACT

The Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) is a theory of the policy process that investigates how policy narratives shape policymaking across policy stages, levels of analysis (micro, meso, and macro), institutional settings, and governance regimes. The primary research question for the NPF is how policy narratives shape the policy process. As NPF research has expanded across policy fields, countries, and methodological traditions, the framework has generated important theoretical developments, empirical discoveries, and methodological challenges. The purpose of this panel is to gather NPF scholars around the world to share their research questions, discoveries, and challenges. By bringing together scholars working with diverse research designs, policy contexts, and methodological traditions, the panel aims to foster discussion on the current state and future development of NPF research. Its broader objective is to advance understanding of how policy narratives matter in policy processes and how the NPF can be methodologically strengthened to study them. Over the past two decades, NPF scholarship has established a growing body of theoretical and empirical research examining the power of policy narrative structure, content, and strategies that shape the policy process. NPF research has focused on (i) understanding narratives shape the policy process in particular contexts, (ii) exploring the interaction of narrative elements within and between policy narratives, (iii) advancing precision in the NPF by exploring the validity of how different narrative components (structure, content, and strategies) are operationalized, and (iv) investigating methodological innovations in content analysis, experimental designs, comparative research, and computational approaches to analyze textual data. Some investigations focus on one of these areas, while others address all three. Recent NPF scholarship has strengthened the framework's theoretical foundations while contributing to deeper understandings of the mechanisms through which narratives influence policy processes, the relationships among levels of analysis, and the generalizability of findings across policy and cultural contexts.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories
P244. The Ideological and Philosophical Foundations of Public Policy: Challenging Libertarian Political Principles Through Alternative Philosophical Frameworks
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
R. Queiroz
C. Leone
ABSTRACT

Contemporary policy formulation, deliberation, and policy research are increasingly framed around narrow financial calculations, impact metrics, and monetary gains, seemingly requiring nothing more than technical expertise. This technical authority obscures the underlying ideological and philosophical foundations of these processes, creating the illusion that policy solutions and policy scholarship are fundamentally detached from philosophical and ideological premises. Far from being decoupled, however, both public policies and policy research remain grounded in specific philosophical principles. For example, the marketisation of scientific and policy research through corporate funding metrics and impact agendas, the commodification of healthcare systems via managerial efficiency models, the casualisation of labour platforms, the financialization of community sports, and the design of geopolitical strategies and security frameworks tailored to protect transnational capital flows are deeply rooted in neoliberalism. While prioritising negative liberty, property rights, market competition, and the entrepreneurial state, neoliberalism systematically excludes social justice and political solidarity. In this context, while extensive scholarship in critical policy studies and international political economy—which has long scrutinised the rise of neoliberal technocratic management by focusing on the hegemony of indicators, the regulatory state, and New Public Management—has paid less attention to how these technical instruments, policy designs, and research evaluation regimes are deeply embedded in specific ideological and philosophical ontologies, philosophy in general, and political philosophy in particular, contributes crucially to uncovering these underlying frameworks. Therefore, this panel aims to bridge political philosophy with both applied policy analysis and policy research, asking not just what fails, but how specific philosophical ontologies dictate what is even considered a 'feasible' policy solution or 'impactful' research. Furthermore, it examines how policy research itself is increasingly instrumentalised through marketisation and the politicisation of impact. We invite contributors to address the following core research frontiers: How does the reduction of policy to financial metrics actively delegitimise demands for social justice, framing them as ‘inefficient’ or ‘unfeasible’? How do the marketisation of policy research and the politicisation of 'impact' agendas instrumentalise scholarship and narrow the epistemic horizon of critical policy inquiry? In what ways does the marketisation of non-economic sectors (such as science, higher education, and sports) erode the vocabulary of political solidarity among citizens? To what extent do civil servants, policy analysts, and policy researchers internalise these premises, viewing them as objective economic constraints rather than ideological choices? How can applied policy analysis and policy research be redesigned to evaluate policies based on normative principles (e.g., dignity, equity) rather than financial efficiency? How can communities and social movements use political philosophy to reframe ‘feasible’ policy solutions from below? How do geopolitical strategies and security frameworks operationalise these axioms, translating the protection of property rights and transnational capital flows into neutral matters of state survival and technical necessity? By focusing on the structural intersection of political philosophy, policy instrumentation, and the political economy of policy research, this panel offers a cutting-edge contribution to ICPP8. It provides a platform for scholars to analyse current paradigms and the institutional architecture required for socially just policy and research alternatives.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments General Public Policy (no specific sector) Economic and Financial Policy
P288. Understanding conflict and polarisation in public policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Wolf
V. Novotny
ABSTRACT

Background Conflict is an inherent feature of public policymaking. Whether it concerns climate transitions, migration, housing or public health, conflict brings competing perspectives on the nature, and sometimes the very existence, of public problems and their possible solutions into sharp relief. Policy conflicts may generate stalemates, erode trust and deepen societal divisions. At the same time, they can bring neglected issues and perspectives to the fore, stimulate learning and create opportunities for policy change. Understanding policy conflicts is therefore essential to explaining how public policies develop and what their effects are. Yetconflictsarenotstaticoruniform.Theyemergeindifferentinstitutionalandpolitical contexts, involve a variety of actors, and change in intensity, scope and meaning over time. A disagreement over a specific proposal may expand into a broader struggle over identities or trust in government. Conversely, seemingly entrenched disputes may open up space for dialogue, compromise or the reconsideration of established policy goals. Such dynamics connect policy conflict to processes of polarisation, yet how the two relate remains underexplored. Positioning the panel Conflict is hardly new to the study of public policy. Established policy process approaches typically examine it within broader explanations of agenda setting, policy stability and change (e.g., Weible, 2023), while planning scholars have long studied conflict and mediation in planning processes (e.g., Forester, 2009; Laws et al., 2014). Morerecently,policyscholarshavebeguntotreatconflictasanobjectofstudyinitsown right. Examples are the Policy Conflict Framework (Weible & Heikkila, 2017; Heikkila & Novotný, 2026), interpretive approaches to conflict development (Wolf & Van Dooren, 2017;Verhoeven&Metze,2022;DeRoeck&VanDooren,2024)andresearchonconflict within collaborative governance (Torfing et al., 2026; Boon & Wolf, 2025). These approaches explain policy conflict differently,for instance through competing interests and beliefs, diverging perspectives and meanings, emotions, institutional arrangements and the interactions among actors. They also differ in what they recognise as conflict, where they draw its boundaries, and how they explain its development and consequences. Across these traditions, however, policy conflicts are often not explicitly defined or systematically identified (Schröder & Wolf, 2026). This makes it difficult to compare findings,assessexplanationsandbuildcumulativeknowledge. The panel adds to existing work in two ways. First, it makes conflict itself the primary object of analysis, rather than a background condition or an intermediate step in explainingpolicychange.Second,itbuildsoncallsfordialoguebetweenmainstream and interpretive policy studies (Durnová & Weible, 2020). It brings different traditions together and asks how their conceptual and methodological choices shape what they can observe and explain: where findings are comparable, where they complement each other, and what each overlooks. The panel addresses two linked questions. How do different approaches conceptualise andexplainpolicy conflicts?Andhowdothese choices shape ourunderstandingofhow conflicts emerge and develop, and of the conditions under which they deepen divisions or create opportunities for learning and change?

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics
P84. Nothing new under the sun? Continuity, adaptation, and transformation of policy-making theories in the digital era
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. BERUT
S. Saurugger
ABSTRACT

Digitalization, understood as the transformation of human activities through the use of digitized information and information technologies (Frenzel et al. 2021), is now ubiquitous, with profound effects on policy-making dynamics. First, digitalization has provoked the emergence of new policy areas to regulate, from online commerce to hate speech on social media, to the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in sensitive domains. Beyond the creation of these new sectors, digitalization has also transformed many “traditional” sectors, where digitalized instruments now operate side-by-side with analogue or real-life tools. For instance, in healthcare, in-person consultations coexist with the growing digitalization and sharing of health data. In this context, policy-making in the digital era does not only refer to the regulation of new sectors, but also to the use of new, digitalized policy instruments by public authorities. Furthermore, digitalization has been accompanied by the emergence of new actors in the policy process, such as firms known as “tech giants”, digital rights activists, or even regular citizens. whose voice can now be channelled through various online consultations. Last but not least, the timing of policy-making has changed, digitalization has led to a spectacular acceleration of digital availability of information and disinformation that creates pressures on decision makers and experts. In view of these multiple transformations, a crucial question arises: are current policy-making theories equipped to integrate these changes in a systematic way? Or, in other words, does digitalization create new patterns in policy-making dynamics, and are these patterns adequately grasped by the theoretical lenses researchers use today? Answering this question is particularly challenging, as transformations induced by digitalization are multifold and operate simultaneously in varied sectors. As a result, digitalization-related dynamics are most of the time tackled through sectoral approaches, preventing the production of more general accounts of the specific dynamics generated by this phenomenon (Bérut 2026). In this light, the goal of this panel is to gather researchers interested in reflecting on how the theoretical approach they use might need to adapt (or not) to the digital age. It will question the possible cross-sectoral nature of changes induced by digitalization, as well as the way to integrate these peculiarities within policy-making theories. In doing so, it will ask whether existing theoretical approaches can be applied as they stand, need to be adapted, or should be fundamentally transformed to account for policy-making in the digital era. By bringing together scholars working on different sectors, levels of government and theoretical traditions, the panel aims to move beyond the current fragmentation of research on digitalization and policy-making, and to contribute to a cumulative research agenda on the topic.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy
P114. From Participation to Co-Production: Interrogating Collaboration, Power and Influence in the Policy Process
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
O. Elemo
M. Manga
H. Agyekum
ABSTRACT

Participation, collaboration and co-production have become central concepts in contemporary public policy, reflecting a shift from government-centred policymaking towards more interactive forms of governance involving citizens, civil society, communities, service users, professionals and other non-state actors. Yet these concepts are frequently used interchangeably, although they capture potentially different relationships between state and societal actors and different degrees of influence over policy processes. The literature on participation has long shown that the presence of citizens does not translate into meaningful influence. Arnstein’s (1969) ladder of citizen participation conceptualised participation in terms of citizen power over decisions; Fung (2006, 2015) showed that participatory arrangements vary according to who participates, how they communicate and decide, and how participation connects to public action; and research on collaborative governance has identified institutional design, leadership, trust, power and resources as conditions of effective collaboration (Ansell & Gash, 2008). Co-production extends these debates by positioning societal actors as contributors to the design, delivery and assessment of policies and services (Ostrom, 1996; Nabatchi, Sancino & Sicilia, 2017), while systematic reviews point to persistent conceptual and empirical gaps, notably on outcomes (Voorberg, Bekkers & Tummers, 2015). Critical scholarship adds that co-production is not inherently empowering: it can reproduce inequalities and power asymmetries when its political dimension is neglected (Farr, 2018; Turnhout et al., 2020). Two questions remain unresolved. First, whether participation, collaboration and co-production are distinct forms of policy engagement, points along a continuum, or alternative analytical lenses on state–society relations. Second, how far these concepts, largely developed from North American and European experiences, travel. In much of the Global South, co-production involves customary authorities, religious organisations, informal providers and donors rather than, or alongside, the citizen–agency dyad; participation unfolds in hybrid regimes where consequential influence rarely runs through formal institutional design; and the “state” that co-produces is itself plural and contested. These settings are not merely additional cases: they test the assumptions built into the concepts. The panel therefore asks: how, when and under what conditions do participatory and collaborative arrangements produce substantive co-production and meaningful influence over public policy, and what do experiences from the Global South change in the way we answer this question? It explores three propositions. P1: formal participatory arrangements that do not redistribute decision rights or resources tend to produce symbolic legitimacy rather than policy influence, whatever their design; P2: collaboration becomes co-production only where actors hold interdependent resources and where joint decision-making is institutionalised – including through non-state and customary institutions; and P3: the transformative potential of co-production depends less on the participatory format than on the prior distribution of political, institutional and material power, which such arrangements may conceal as much as correct. The panel aims to advance conceptual clarity and empirical understanding of these modes of policymaking by bringing comparative and Global South perspectives into the core of the debate rather than at its margins.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy
P163. Narrative Policy Analysis in Critical and Interpretative Perspectives
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Sacramento
P. Boossabong
ABSTRACT

Narratives are a crucial element in the dynamics of the policy process and in the underlying rationalities of decision-making. A policy narrative is a story that frames a policy problem, stabilises the assumptions behind it, and justifies the policy decision. Scholars whose works speak to narrative and interpretive policy analysis show that policy narratives can be stories about the policy problem, about the alternatives for addressing it, about the consequences associated with each alternative, and about the trade-offs between those alternatives (Rhodes, 2018; Roe, 1994; Stone, 2011; Yanow, 2000). In diverse, highly unequal, and uncertain contexts, public policy is never a purely technical exercise. Narrative policy analysis is particularly valuable in such settings because it acknowledges the plurality of policy stories. It looks past political motivations, expert opinion, and the hyped appreciation of numbers and technical computation used to support and legitimise decisions. We acknowledge that narratives, as popularly operationalised in public policy studies, most prominently through the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF), are approached by classifying a story's characters (heroes, villains, and victims), setting, plot, and moral (the proposed policy solution) at the macro, meso, and micro levels. This approach is appealing because its scientific conceptualisation of stories makes it user-friendly and amenable to hypothesis testing with measurable variables. Its underlying logic, however, may leave the normative, ideological, and emotional elements of policy narratives largely unexamined. A critical and interpretive lens directs attention to how policy narratives are political, foregrounding the power of storytellers and the knowledge politics of silenced and untold stories. We therefore turn to the deeper layers of narrative, which concern various modes of knowing and are best understood within the realm of knowledge politics. Policy narratives are never value-neutral, and inequalities run through who tells them and whose stories are heard. Whose stories become authoritative policy narratives, and whose are silenced, marginalised, or left untold? How are contextual experiences and local, situated knowledges accounted for in the empirical and factual dimensions of policy narratives? What normative assumptions and ideological commitments animate the narratives through which advocacies are pushed? And what emancipatory potential lies in understanding emotional expression as a source of authentic perspective in policy analysis? Guided by these questions, the panel aims to expand the understanding of the policy narrative as a meaning-unit embedded in policy discourse and tied to specific policy frames. It seeks to extend narrative analysis from the classification of story elements to an account of the power relations and knowledge politics that shape whose stories count. It also brings the normative, ideological, and emotional dimensions of narratives into the core of policy analysis. Finally, it fosters methodological reflection on how critical and interpretive approaches can surface situated knowledges, particularly from the Global South.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Methods & Research Design General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P174. One Health: From Agenda-Setting to Implementation and Evaluation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Ksinsik
A. van den Dool
E. Shanahan
ABSTRACT

The One Health approach has emerged as a collaborative, multi-disciplinary approach that recognizes the interconnectedness of human, animal, and environmental health. This concept promotes comprehensive public health strategies, through the understanding that disease prediction, prevention, and response requires an integrated examination of diseases at the human-animal-environment interface, thereby improving medical, veterinary, and ecological health outcomes globally and contributing to pandemic prevention. Issues often associated with One Health are antimicrobial resistance, zoonotic diseases, vector-borne diseases, and food safety. While One Health is considered a promising approach to human, animal, and environmental health, moving from theory to practice through agenda setting, policy making, implementation, and evaluation is lagging behind. To better understand the complexities and advancements in the governance of One Health, this panel approaches One Health from a policy process perspective. The aim of the panel is to generate insights into how policy process research can advance putting One Health into practice, as well as discussing how studying One Health advances policy process research. The overall research questions are: · How can the policy process facilitate the translation of One Health from theory into practice? · How can studying One Health in the policy process advance policy process research? Studying these questions is of practical as well as theoretical relevance. Practically, a policy process perspective on One Health can contribute to a better understanding of how and why the approach is or is not adopted, contributing to policymaking practice in human, animal, and environmental health. Theoretically, studying One Health and its adoption in policymaking is also of interest for policy process research as One Health issues are inherently multisectoral, requiring stakeholders from different sectors to align across the policy process. Such collaboration is increasingly important as policymakers around the world are navigating urgent and complex societal shifts such as ageing, climate change, and AI. Examining One Health through the policy process perspective provides fertile ground for advancing existing theories about e.g., narratives, focusing events, and advocacy networks.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Health and Well-Being Policy Agriculture and Food Policy
P175. Bringing together the theories of public policy and political economy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Coban
ABSTRACT

Theories of policy process, in broad terms, explores and examines policy (in)action, under what conditions policies may(not) change, whether and how policy instruments are formulated, mixed and implemented, among other puzzles. In parallel, political economy scholarship, in broad terms, aims to explore and understand the economic bases of political (in)actions, the power dynamics and struggles based on material and/or ideational grounds. Both literatures tend to remain disconnected despite several attempts in the public policy scholarship (Coban 2023; Higgott et al. 2021; John 2018; Vannoni 2022). This disconnection invites studies that bridge political economy and theories of public policy given that both seek to understand “who gets what, when, how” (Laswell 1936). Bridging this disconnect and bringing these two major fields is necessary and timely. The rapidly changing and transforming global and domestic policy processes through geopolitical and geoeconomic tensions, inter- and intra-state conflict, entrenching populism and authoritarianism, securitization of public policies are not from political economic drivers and structures. Yet when we discuss policy instabilities, ad hoc or placebo policy implementation, instrument calibrations, policy designs, or even policy successes, public policy rarely engages with the political economic drivers, motives or structures. Since both fields tend to be isolated in their own silos despite potential cross-fertilization and synthesis, the connection is very rare, this disconnect needs to change with more dialogue and more systematic engagements. This panel invites scholars to engage more with the two fields and endogenise the political economic factors more in the theories of public policy. To this end, this panel invites colleagues to explore and examine the following non-exhaustive list of questions: 1. How could we better theorise public policy processes by endogenizing the political economic bases of policy (in)action? 2. Whether and how do international political economic factors and dynamics shape and structure domestic policy processes? 3. How do international political economic and domestic political economic structure interact and regulate domestic policy processes? 4. Whether, how and why economic constraints determine policy and instrument choices? 5. Why and how are policy or instrument calibrations regulated by political economic structures and determinants? 6. How do political economic structures shape different dimensions of policy capacity? 7. Which political economic factors and under which political economic structures do actors form advocacy coalitions, push for punctuations, or policy entrepreneurs gain or lose their leverage? References Coban, M. Kerem. 2023. The political economic sources of policy non-design, policy accumulation, and decay in policy capacity. Administration & Society 55(6). 1035-1065. Higgott, Richard, JJ Woo, and Tim Legrand. 2021. The demand for IPE and public policy in the governance of global policy design. Policy and Society 40(4): 449-466. John, Peter. 2018. Theories of policy change and variation reconsidered: A prospectus for the political economy of public policy. Policy Sciences 51(1): 1-16. Laswell, Harold D. 1936. Politics: Who gets what, when, how. Whittlesey House. Vannoni, Mattia. 2022. A political economy approach to the grammar of institutions: Theory and methods. Policy Studies Journal 50(2): 453-471.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P207. Connecting Public Policy Theories and Concepts to Realities Beyond the West
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
O. Porto de Oliveira
M. Manga
O. El-Taliawi
S. Nair
ABSTRACT

Classic frameworks are essential for analysing public policy. The Advocacy Coalition Framework, the Multiple Streams Framework and Lowi's typology of policies provide valuable general guidance on understanding policy phenomena. However, their explanatory power diminishes when we consider the more context-specific dynamics that characterise policymaking in the Global South. The field's founding questions, concepts, and theories were based on a limited geography. Public policy, as a discipline, was largely constructed in and for Western liberal democracies (El-Taliawi et al., 2021) and presupposes a specific institutional configuration. This includes professionalised bureaucracies, party systems, formalised interest groups and a clear boundary between the state and the market. Such conditions are mostly found in wealthy, secular, and electorally stable democracies in North America and Western Europe. Public policy frameworks often fail to adequately explain policymaking in the Global South, where conditions often include poverty, inequality, international dependency, informality, economic instability, and low administrative capacity. The policy process in these regions can also be influenced by context-specific factors such as informal settlements, armed conflict, authoritarian rule and organised crime. While these characteristics are not unique to the Global South, they were largely absent from the empirical settings in which classic approaches were developed. Some effort has been made to innovate, revise and adjust policy concepts. The idea of 'guanxi' has been used to analyse Chinese foreign policy tools (Xu & Mawdsley, 2025), the notion of 'policy ambassadors' has been used to address human agency in policy diffusion in Brazil (Porto de Oliveira, 2019), and the concept of 'government by default' has been used to study Cameroon. However, more work is needed. This panel emphasises the importance of research connecting established theories with locally grounded knowledge outside the West (Nair & Varma, 2022). Three questions are addressed: 1. In what ways do classic policy studies concepts and theories fall short in their understanding of the Global South? 2. How can concepts, theories, approaches, and empirical evidence from the Global South expand policy studies? 3. How do concepts born in the Global South travel and become established elsewhere, and what can we learn from this process about the creation of policy theory itself? We are seeking innovative contributions that are empirically robust, methodologically sound and conceptually strong. A publication resulting from the panel is envisaged. References El-Taliawi, O., Nair, S., & Van der Wal, Z. (2021). Public policy schools in the global south: a mapping and analysis of the emerging landscape. Policy Sciences, 54(2), 371-395. Manga Edimo, M. 2026. “Quand l’Etat se retire: qui gouverne la terre”, Afrique contemporaine, Vol. 282, no. 2. forthcoming. Nair, S. and Varma, N. eds., 2022. Emerging pedagogies for policy education: insights from Asia. Springer Nature. Porto de Oliveira, O. International Policy Diffusion and Participatory Budgeting: Ambassadors of Participation, International Organizations and Transnational Actors. Palgrave Macmillan, 2017. Xu, M.; Mawdsley, E. 2025. “Understanding China in the BRICS+: From Domestic to Foreign Policy Experimentation”. In: The BRICS+ and Gulf Cooperation Council Countries: Public Policies, Foreign Policy and Geopolitics, (Orgs.). Porto de Oliveira, O.; Zaidan, E.. Springer Nature.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories
P221. Bridging Policy Process and Project Management Research: The Strategic Organization of Major Public Projects
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Terlizzi
G. Esposito
ABSTRACT

Major public projects—including high-speed rail networks, cross-border transport corridors, renewable energy infrastructure, large-scale digital transformation programmes, and urban regeneration projects—are central to governments' responses to contemporary grand challenges. Through investments in physical infrastructure and technological systems, they translate policy objectives into concrete interventions addressing public needs and priorities. Yet their development entails more than technical planning and managerial execution. Major public projects are embedded in policy processes shaped by political conflict, institutions, competing interests, and uncertainty. Research on policy processes and project management has developed along distinct trajectories. Project management scholarship has traditionally emphasized project design, planning, delivery, and performance, while public policy research has examined how ideas, interests, institutions, and power relations shape collective decisions. Recent studies demonstrate the potential of integrating policy and project perspectives to explain project development and governance (Hudon & Floricel, 2023; Brunet & Choinière, 2025; Esposito, Hudon, & Terlizzi, 2026). This integration can advance public policy research by providing insights into how political, institutional, and organizational dynamics shape agenda-setting, policy design, implementation, and policy change over time. Building on these developments, this panel seeks to bridge policy process and project management research by focusing on the strategic organization of major public projects. Strategic organization is understood as a politically embedded process through which actors define policy objectives and instruments, mobilize resources, build policy capacities, coordinate collective action, and navigate competing objectives over time. This perspective moves beyond conventional strategic planning by integrating anticipatory governance, context-sensitive policy design, and stakeholder coordination (Esposito & Terlizzi, 2026). The overarching research question is: How do policy processes and project-level governance interact in shaping the strategic organization of major public projects? The panel invites contributions exploring interconnected questions. How do political and institutional dynamics influence policy design, project shaping, and governance? Under what conditions do policy capacities facilitate collective action? How do institutions and narratives contribute to strategic alignment or conflict? How do policy instruments and governance arrangements adapt to changing political priorities and unexpected events? Can anticipatory and participatory approaches reconcile long-term strategic objectives with democratic accountability and competing societal interests? The panel aims to identify complementary explanatory mechanisms and advance public policy research on the strategic organization of complex, long-term interventions. References Brunet, M., & Choinière, O. (2025). Governance framework trajectory for major public projects: The case of Canada. Project Management Journal, 56(1), 74–89. Esposito, G., & Terlizzi, A. (2026). Introduction to the special issue: Megatrends and grand challenges: The strategic organization of long-term and large-scale policy interventions. International Review of Administrative Sciences, 92(2), 196–212. Esposito, G., Hudon, P.-A., & Terlizzi, A. (2026). Theories of the policy process meet project management: Insights for megaproject shaping. International Journal of Project Management, 44, 102906. Hudon, P. A., & Floricel, S. (2023). The development of large public infrastructure projects: Integrating policy and project studies models. Policy and Society, 42(2), 148–163.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments
P231. Informality and the Analysis of Policy Processes in the Global North: Beyond the formal/informal dichotomy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
F. Infantino
L. Barrault-Stella
ABSTRACT

This panel seeks to investigate the role of informality in public policymaking in the Global North. It concerns all stages of the policy cycle and in different policy domains. Informality has had a prominent role in the study of international governance. Students of policy processes have well documented the long-term existence of informal processes involved in governing (Zittoun, Chailleux, 2021). In particular, this was developed in the study of the European Union decision-making processes, to consider the role of non-state actors and systematize forms of informality (Peters, 2006), to put forward the formalization of informal practices that underline the making of the EU (Farrell & Héritier, 2007), and to reveal the hidden influence of some Member States on supranational actors (Kleine, 2014). Other analyses have shed light on the informal role of private companies in policy-making from below (Infantino, 2023), beyond lobbying at the level of legislative policymaking and for agenda setting, a topic that has deservingly received much analytical attention, also in the context of the European Union (Beyers et al., 2008; Calvo Rufanges, 2016; Coen, 2007). These analyses have shown how informal processes underline organizational change and the decision processes of public organization in the Global North. This panel follows the lines of those scholars that juxtapose informal governance and formal institutions (Dittmer et al., 2000), dismiss the views of informality as pertaining to developing countries or a synonym of un-rule of law (Conrad, 2006) and consider informal governance unavoidable to understand the behavior of organizations in international governance (Stone, 2013). The “informal governance” approach has come to describe public and private actors’ regular though non-codified and not publicly sanctioned exchanges (Christiansen & Neuhold, 2012, p. 7) which lead to public decisions. In effect, informality rests on dynamics that tend to unfold behind the scenes, therefore posing fundamental methodological challenges. This panel focuses on the role of informality in public policymaking at both the legislative/design and implementation stages by putting forward how non-codifed and not publicly sanctioned exchanges lead to public decisions. In doing so, this panel aims at adressing the continuities between formal and informal processes, an aspect that has been discussed for the works of diplomats performing “international practices” (Adler & Pouliot, 2011).

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Methods & Research Design
P255. Power and Politics in the Policy Process
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
K. Taylor
E. Koebele
C. Dunlop
O. Berglund
A. Fullerton
ABSTRACT

Politics and power are the under-theorised in much policy process research. The dominant frameworks – the Advocacy Coalition Framework (Sabatier and Jenkins-Smith 1993), the Multiple Streams Framework (Kingdon 1984) and the Narrative Policy Framework (Jones and McBeth 2010) – all carry implicit theories of power: coalitions deploy resources, entrepreneurs couple streams, narratives mobilise. Yet these mechanisms are rarely connected explicitly to the political science literature on power, from Schattschneider's (1960) mobilisation of bias and Bachrach and Baratz's (1962) non-decisions to Lukes's (1974) three dimensions and later work on policy feedback and drift (Pierson 1993; Hacker and Pierson 2010). The result is a field that explains how policy changes while remaining comparatively silent on who is able to make it change, who is kept out, and why. Without examining the politics of policy making, scholars may be missing critical explanations for core questions in policy process research, such as: 1. To what extent does political polarization influence policymaking, particularly non-majoritarian politics? 2. How does an advocacy coalition actually leverage politics affect policy change?3. How do marginalized actors leverage political power to trigger punctuations in the policy equilibrium to disrupt policy monopolies?4. How do policy actors use formal or informal power to deny agenda space to opponents when the streams of policy activity would ordinarily foster agenda change? The panel's research question is therefore: how does political power in its decisional, agenda-setting and ideational forms shape the mechanisms that policy process theories use to explain stability and change, and how should those theories be revised to account for it explicitly? The objective is a cumulative body of work in which these propositions are specified, tested across political systems and sectors, and fed back into framework development, so that politics and power become explicit rather than assumed elements of policy process theory. The panel is linked to a forthcoming Policy & Politics special issue on Power and Politics in the Policy Process; papers accepted to the panel may be considered for that issue through the journal's regular peer review.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics
P292. Developments in the Science of Policy Success: Dimensions, Dangers and Diversity
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
B. Peters
M. Flinders
ABSTRACT

In recent years a seam of scholarship has emerged with an explicit focus on the identification and investigation of dimensions of policy success. Variously termed either ‘positive public administration’ or ‘positive public policy’ this approach seeks to challenge the dominance of the pathology model within the policy sciences (i.e. an emphasis on the analysis of crises, catastrophes, failures, and fiascos) and seeks to focus attention on ‘the bright side of public governance’ (policy successes, effective leadership, public value, etc.). This approach can be traced to Bovens, Peters and ‘t Hart’s Success and Failure in Public Governance (2001), through McConnell’s Understanding Policy Success (2010) and to ‘t Hart and Compton’s Great Policy Successes (2019). Since then, a series of international volumes have explored policy success in different parts of the world including Australia and New Zealand (Luetjens, et al., 2019), the Nordic Countries (de la Porta et al., 2022), Canada (Lindquist et al., 2022), South America and Africa (Lucas t al., 2024), and Central Asia and the Caucasus (Janenova and Mussagulova, 2027). This panel seeks a stress test of the intellectual and practical value of positive public policy through a focus on dimensions, dangers, and diversity.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Process Theories
P26. Interdisciplinarity in Public Policy Analysis : Tacit Practices, Explicit Foundations
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Manga
M. OWONA NGUINI
ABSTRACT

This panel takes seriously an intriguing contrast in how public policy analysis relates to its neighbouring disciplines. Mainstream Anglophone policy scholarship increasingly draws on American pragmatist philosophy and classical sociology — the pragmatist turn, the uses of Dewey, the sociologies of action and problem definition (Dewey, 1927; Ansell, 2011; Zittoun, 2014) — yet this borrowing is rarely thematised as a practice of interdisciplinarity: concepts travel, are naturalised and settle into policy frameworks without the work of translation between disciplines being made visible. In Africa, by contrast, interdisciplinarity has been the field's explicit foundation since its emergence: as Laakso (2022) shows, it developed at the crossroads of anthropology, political economy, development studies and political science, and this plural genealogy is openly claimed as constitutive of the discipline. A similar explicitness is found in much policy scholarship elsewhere in the Global South. The panel invites reflection on this asymmetry. Why is interdisciplinarity an assumed and theorised foundation in some scholarly traditions, and a tacit, uncommented practice in others? What does it reveal about the geography of knowledge in the discipline, about its hierarchies, and about what counts as “theory” and what counts as “context”? The panel’s central research question is therefore: how is interdisciplinarity practised, claimed, or left implicit in public policy analysis — in the construction of research objects, fieldwork, the making of data and the writing of results — and what does this (in)visibility do to the discipline’s theoretical frameworks and to the relations between scholarly traditions? The panel works from three propositions. P1: the invisibility of disciplinary borrowings in mainstream policy scholarship is not an absence of interdisciplinarity but a mode of its naturalisation: concepts enter the field as “theory” once their disciplinary origin is forgotten — a forgetting all the more striking as the policy sciences were founded as an explicitly multidisciplinary project (Lasswell, 1951). P2: where interdisciplinarity is openly claimed, as in African policy scholarship, it tends to be read as “context” rather than as theoretical contribution; the asymmetry is one of recognition, not of practice. P3: some policy objects — customary policy capacity (Manga Edimo, forthcoming), natural resource governance — impose explicit interdisciplinarity whatever the tradition; the difference lies less in what analysts do than in what the discipline says about itself. The panel’s relevance is twofold. First, while interdisciplinarity has become an injunction of funding agencies and international programmes, it remains under-studied as a research practice (Frodeman, Klein & Pacheco, 2017); the panel treats it as an object of inquiry attentive to the genealogy and career of the concepts that travel across disciplines. Second, objects such as customary policy capacity — the ability of customary institutions to advise, design and carry public action — or natural resource governance in the Congo Basin cannot be grasped without crossing political science, anthropology, law and environmental sciences. By examining how such crossings are performed, the panel contributes to debates on the globalisation and decolonisation of policy analysis and on South-South circulations of governmental knowledge.

POLICY TOPICS
Methods & Research Design Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments
P108. Configurational and Mechanistic Public Policy Analysis
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Thomann
G. Bazzan
G. Fontaine
J. Hornung
ABSTRACT

Public policy problems are complex, involving multiple interacting conditions, context-dependent causal relationships, and processes that unfold through different pathways. Theories of the policy process mirror this complexity, modelling both the causal processes and the complex, context-dependent combinations of factor that bring about policy outcomes. Understanding how policies emerge, are implemented, and produce their effects therefore requires analytical approaches that move beyond assumptions of simple, uniform causal relationships. Set-theoretic approaches offer one way of doing so. They conceive of causal relationships in terms of necessity and sufficiency and are designed to capture causal complexity in its main forms: conjunctural causation, where conditions produce an outcome only in combination; equifinality, where different combinations lead to the same outcome; and causal asymmetry, where the explanation of an outcome does not simply mirror the explanation of its absence. Set relations, however, tell us which conditions and combinations are linked to an outcome, not how they bring it about. Connecting cross-case configurational findings with within-case analysis of causal mechanisms, for instance through process tracing in cases selected on the basis of set-theoretic results, is one way to address this gap. This panel invites contributions that apply, advance, or consolidate configurational and mechanistic approaches to public policy analysis. We welcome papers theorizing complex and mechanistic causation in public policy, papers applying or innovating methods such as Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) and related configurational approaches, contributions that develop or refine methods for investigating causal mechanisms and the processes through which policy outcomes come about, as well as work that combines the two. The panel aims to bring together scholars working on methodological innovation, consolidation, and empirical application. We are particularly interested in contributions that explore how configurational and mechanistic perspectives can capture causal complexity, account for contextual variation, and advance our understanding of public policy processes and outcomes. By putting these perspectives into dialogue, the panel seeks to strengthen methodological approaches to studying causal complexity in public policy research.

POLICY TOPICS
Methods & Research Design Policy Process Theories Other
P202. Critical applied policy evaluation? Methods and manners of incorporating critical perspectives into mainstream policy evaluation (and vice versa)
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
R. Glover
A. Pacho
ABSTRACT

Applied policy evaluation and critical policy research are often artificially siloed, with the former sometimes caricatured as a technocratic measurement of narrow programmatic outcomes, and the latter occasionally dismissed as abstract textual deconstructions lacking nous. This conceptual dichotomy obscures a deep, shared foundation (Gates, 2025; van den Berg, 2019). Cairney (2023) asserted three general shared reference points between the approaches: (1) neither is objective or ‘rationalist’, (2) neither assumes the policy development process is orderly or fair, and (3) neither ignores politics' role in policymaking. Furthermore, methodologies and theories are shared between the two approaches (Durnová, a et al, 2020). Close readings, gap analyses, discourse analyses, and policy analyses are readily used across both traditions, though for different questions (Apgar, 2024; van Uffelen, 2025). Moreover, while academic policy evaluations are often expected to deliver mainstream evaluations replete with actionable evidence, researchers frequently find themselves grappling with the underlying politics, framing, and discursive gaps of the policies they evaluate. In practice, many academic evaluators 'smuggle' critical sensibilities into mainstream evaluation designs, even sometimes producing one mainstream academic article, and another, subsequent critical output from the same evaluation, data, or even research question (Pacho, Mays, and Glover, 2024; Pacho and Glover, 2025). This panel explores how both perspectives can be intentionally integrated into a single evaluation lifecycle, from scoping and logic-model design to fieldwork, data analysis, and the formulation of recommendations, and asks how we can better navigate this dual identity. The aim of this panel is to create dialogue between scholars who have trodden this line in evaluation across any domain of public policy. Ultimately, the panel seeks to establish a shared vocabulary for critical applied evaluation grounded in the idea that critical insights facilitate evaluations seeking to explain why programs succeed or fail structurally, while remaining sensitised to the funding realities that privilege mainstream evaluation over critical research lines. Apgar, M et al. Rethinking rigour to embrace complexity in peacebuilding evaluation. Evaluation, 31(1), 1–26. (2024) https://doi.org/10.1177/13563890241232405 Cairney, P. The politics of policy analysis: theoretical insights on real world problems. JEPP, 30(9), 1820–1838. (2023) https://doi.org/10.1080/13501763.2023.2221282 Durnová, A.P., Weible, C.M. Tempest in a teapot? Toward new collaborations between mainstream policy process studies and interpretive policy studies. Policy Sci 53, 571–588 (2020) https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-020-09387-y Gates, E. F. et al. A critical, integrative review on evaluating systems change and transformation, Part One: 2011–2021. Evaluation, 31(4), 482-506. (2024) https://doi.org/10.1177/13563890251363232 Pacho A, Mays N, Glover RE. The appropriateness of self-care policy for urinary tract infections among women from racialised minorities and low-income households in the United Kingdom: A qualitative study. JHSRP 30(3):189-197. (2025) 10.1177/13558196251313736 Pacho, A., & Glover, R. E. (2025). Learning from self‐care practices among marginalised women: Towards embedding health justice in the UK health policy. SHI, https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9566.70112 Van den Berg, R. D., Magro, C., & Mulder, S. S. (Eds.). (2019). Evaluation for transformational change: Opportunities and challenges for the Sustainable Development Goals. International Development Evaluation Association (IDEAS). van Uffelen N, Goyal N, Martinez-Reyes A. (Not) just policy success: Incorporating justice in policy evaluation. Policy Sci. 2025;58(3):449-468. 10.1007/s11077-025-09588-3.

POLICY TOPICS
Methods & Research Design Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P217. Natural language processing and large language models in policy research
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Goyal
N. Albrecht
S. Sewerin
ABSTRACT

The growing availability of digitised policy texts, combined with rapid advances in natural language processing (NLP), has opened new avenues for public policy research. These texts include executive orders, legislation, parliamentary debates, public consultation submissions, evaluation reports, media coverage, and social media. Further, large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being used for information extraction, summarisation, and annotation, alongside dictionaries, supervised techniques, and unsupervised learning. These tools hold promise across three connected areas of the field. For policy process research, they enable large-scale measurement of attention, frames, narratives, coalitions, and diffusion. For policy design research, they make it possible to identify and compare instruments, instrument mixes, and design features across thousands of policies. For policy evaluation, they can help synthesise evaluation reports and analyse stakeholder and citizen feedback. Tasks that once required several annotators can now be attempted at scale. However, the application of these techniques also faces challenges, such as distinct vocabularies, complex language, and information sparsity. Further, the use of proprietary models with stochastic outputs can create additional issues, and ethical questions about bias, costs, and data protection need to be considered. Existing scholarship reflects this mix of promise and caution. Research on text as data has shown that automated methods can augment, but not replace, careful reading, and that their outputs must be validated against the research question at hand. More recent studies suggest that LLMs can perform well on many (simpler) annotation tasks, yet their performance varies across prompts, model versions, languages, and domains. There is also the danger of dataset generation being driven by what LLMs currently are good at (e.g. coding high-level policy design characteristics such as instrument use) rather than what would be needed from a conceptual or theoretical point of view (e.g. a comprehensive assessment of policy design characteristics). The panel’s main research question is: under what conditions can NLP, including LLM-based approaches, produce reliable, valid, and theoretically relevant insights into policy processes, policy designs, and policy evaluation? We aim to bring together methodological, empirical, and critical contributions that facilitate the creation of a community, reusable outputs, and shared infrastructure for public policy research.

POLICY TOPICS
Methods & Research Design
P274. Big and Creative Data in Public Policy and Public Administration Research: Opportunities, Methods and Practices
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
V. Karokis-Mavrikos
M. Patouna
ABSTRACT

The data available for studying public policy and public administration have changed fundamentally in scale, variety and accessibility, and with them the questions the field can ask. Governments publish legislation, consultations, parliamentary records, budgets and procurement data in machine-readable form; administrative records are increasingly accessible for research; and technology firms and digital platforms are releasing large datasets on how citizens, organisations and officials behave online and use new technologies. At the same time, computational tools, from text-as-data methods and machine learning to open-source transformer and large language models, make it feasible to analyse such material at a scale and granularity previously out of reach (Lazer et al., 2009; Grimmer, Roberts & Stewart, 2022). Much of this is repurposed, or “readymade”, data, generated for purposes other than research, which invites creativity in connecting it to the questions that matter to the field (Salganik, 2018).Political science has embraced these developments for some time (Wilkerson & Casas, 2017), and public policy and public administration scholarship is increasingly doing so, such as through applications of text analysis and machine learning to agency priorities and organisational reputation (Hollibaugh, 2019; Anastasopoulos & Whitford, 2019). Advances in large language models open further possibilities, from automated text annotation (Gilardi, Alizadeh & Kubli, 2023) to the study of how citizens and officials themselves use AI in their dealings with the state. As these opportunities multiply, there is value in bringing together researchers working with big and creative data across policy and administration research to share approaches, compare designs and reflect on what these data make newly visible.The panel asks: What new questions about public policy and public administration can big and creative data help answer? How can such data be connected to established theories, concepts and debates in the field? Which data sources, research designs and computational tools are proving most productive, and under what conditions? And what ethical, practical and epistemological considerations accompany their use?The panel explores four propositions. First, big and creative data bring into view actors, interactions and stages of policymaking and administration that have been difficult to observe at scale, from citizen-state encounters to implementation and service delivery. Second, these data allow established theories and concepts in policy process, public management and governance research to be examined in a new light, while also opening avenues for new theorising. Third, open models and data repositories lower the barriers to computational research, supporting broader participation, replication and comparison across countries and languages, and the building of shared, systematic knowledge bases for the field. Fourth, big and creative data can strengthen the dialogue between research and practice, providing timelier and more granular evidence for policymakers and public managers.The panel’s scientific relevance lies in creating a dedicated forum at IPPA for data-intensive research in public policy and public administration, and in building a community of practice around its opportunities, methods and responsibilities.

POLICY TOPICS
Methods & Research Design
P191. Sport Policy as Crossroads with other Public Policies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
H. Kudo
T. ABE
G. Antonucci
T. Hiratsuka
M. NAITO
ABSTRACT

Background After our first successful presence as panel at ICPP7, we would like to create opportunities for researchers of public policy to “encounter, rethink, and redefine” sport policy. Sport Policy has attracted researchers interested in sport; however, our panel at ICPP7 was eye-opening experience, as researchers with other research interests, such as healthcare, environment, inclusion, and youth/elderly, participated in the panel with interesting works related on sport policy from different perspectives. We would like to repropose the panel on sport policy, but from different angle: offering opportunities for researchers who worked on sport from various perspectives to redefine their works and refine the value under sport policy. Thus, our panel proposal would like to address to those who have worked on sport related issues from different perspectives and reposition their work with sport policy. Starting from the post WW2 “rebirth” of the London Olympic Games in 1948 (IOC, 2024), the link between sport and public policy has been evolving fast, having nowadays, most of the countries in the world, with specific Sport Acts to manage both elite and amateur sport (Dowling et al., 2018). Since new millennium, public sector bodies are having an always increasing direct and/or indirect involvement in the provision of sport (Houlihan & Green, 2007) even invoking the principle of political neutrality by Sports Governing Bodies (Grix & James, 2024). For direct involvement, public bodies ought to be proactive, in sustaining local communities, by encouraging engagement through sport activities (Morgan et al. 2026), thus related in favouring physical activities for health, and social interactions for inclusion and wellbeing (COM, 2007). These actively contribute to the improvement of citizen’s health (Geidne et al., 2025); to the creation of safer and stronger communities (Coyle et al., 2026); and in improving youngsters’ education (Simwanza, 2026). It can even be useful in addressing social and economic inequalities within different localities (Skinner et al., 2008). The indirect involvement sees them engaged in assuring proper implementation of both professional and amateur sport events, dealing with several responsibilities, including safety, security for traffic management, and collaboration on the construction of institutional facilities for events (Hossain, 2026). These deal also with aspects related to social, economic, and environmental sustainability, being all these factors linked to the general theme of the legacy of the sport events, especially international ones, first of all Olympic Games (Thomson et al., 2019). Moreover, grassroot sport could be considered as a lever for public policy to support citizens’ relationships and their quality of life. Just to make an example, according to the Council of Europe (2006), sport is the largest voluntary non-governmental organisational activity throughout Europe, with more volunteers than any other activity. To address all these aspects related to nowadays public role of sport it is therefore required to investigate and implement new models in public administration (Figus & Pisaniello, 2025). General Objectives Above mentioned features of sport policy show fundamental issues and unlimited possibilities of sport policy itself: many of you have worked on one of the above cited policy issues from various perspectives, but not from sport policy point of view, and thus, if you encounter “sport policy” as crossroads of what you have studied and rethink and redefine sport policy from different perspectives, we can build an interesting new community of sport policy. Sport policy is not yet well established as a public policy research topic. However, several themes – from the governance of sport through hybrid organisations, to the creation of public value and its measurement (from people wellbeing through sport to the legacy of big sport events), not forgetting aspects related to sustainability – should be handled by public policy researchers. That is why we decided to propose this panel, which specific, but not exclusive, themes are reported below. Scientific relevance The panel’s scientific relevance its not only in the above reported aspects but especially in the aim of creating debate within the panel participants, engage public policy researchers, in both theory and in practice.

POLICY TOPICS
Agenda-Setting/Problem Definition Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition General Public Policy (no specific sector) Other
P124. The Agenda-Setting Morality Policies: Specific Dynamics or Politics as Usual?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Jacquot
J. Damaso-Biesmans
L. LARTIGOT-HERVIER
ABSTRACT

Morality policies constitute a distinctive mode of governing: public authorities intervene in individual conduct and help define collective values to be imposed (Meier, 1999; Mourão Permoser, 2019). They can be defined as policies that regulate individual behaviour and provoke intense value conflicts rooted in fundamental moral convictions, which are often difficult to reconcile. They regulate concerns such as life and death (abortion, reproduction, euthanasia, death penalty), gender and sexuality (sexual preferences, prostitution, consent, gender identity) or addictions (drug decriminalization or legalization, addictive behavior). Yet, whether this mode of intervention makes morality policies a distinct category of public policy remains unresolved. This panel addresses the debate through an analytical entry point: agenda-setting. Its objective is to determine whether morality issues reach, remain on, or disappear from public and governmental agendas through mechanisms that differ from those identified by mainstream policy analysis scholarship. The literature offers competing answers, notably focusing on three dimensions. The first strand relates to framing in agenda-setting (Mooney and Schuldt 2008; Mucciaroni, 2011). Framing is particularly important because it shapes the scope of the ensuing debate: when a problem is framed as a matter of sin that the state must combat, a more permissive policy becomes much harder to defend publicly (Mooney, 1999; Mooney and Schuldt, 2008; Meier, 1994). It revolves around binary oppositions (just – unjust, good – evil, virtue – vice). Thus, invoking moral principles restricts choices and possesses real coercive capacity (Dufournet, 2015, p. 264). A gap may emerge between citizens' actual preferences and the demand for regulation in political debate. The second strand emphasizes the role of institutional constraints, electoral processes, and partisan dynamics, particularly in highly polarized societies, where the moral dimension of almost any issue can become more salient (Dombrink, 2015; Putnam, 2020; Kreitzer et al., 2019). This question arises in increasingly polarized Western societies, some of which have seen far-right parties come to power. The third strand insists on religion's impact on public policy (Engeli, Green-Pedersen, & Thorup Larsen, 2012; Engeli & Rothmayr Allison, 2013; Fink, 2008, 2009; Minkenberg, 2002 and 2003). For some scholars, the religious dimension is central to the definition of moral values, which are often experienced as private and non-negotiable. Yet the role of religion in shaping moral controversies remains insufficiently theorized (Mourão Permoser, 2019). However, these insights have not resolved whether morality policies require a separate analytical toolkit – a question this panel aims to assess. The panel asks: Does the moral character of an issue generate specific agenda-setting dynamics? If so, through which mechanisms and under what conditions? Or are morality policies, policies like any other? Three hypotheses will structure the discussion. First, moral framing redistributes agenda-setting power by enabling some actors to capture the debate while delegitimizing others. Second, moralization narrows policy alternatives and may either constrain state action or open opportunities for intervention in private conduct. Third, these effects are conditional rather than intrinsic to issues framed as “moral”: they vary with religious-secular cleavages, party competition, polarization, or issue trajectories.

POLICY TOPICS
Agenda-Setting/Problem Definition State and Policy Capacity Other
P23. Policy Experimentation Revisited: Sandboxes, Adaptive Instruments, and the Frontiers of Experimental Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Giest
A. He
ABSTRACT

Topic and rationale Policy experimentation is a well-established concept in policy science, anchored in traditions ranging from Campbell’s “experimenting society” to Heilmann’s “experimentation under hierarchy,” and Sabel and Zeitlin’s “experimentalist governance”. Yet in the past decade, a qualitatively new wave of experimental policy instruments has emerged and proliferated at remarkable speed. Regulatory sandboxes, experimentation clauses, policy labs, regulatory testbeds, and adaptive licensing regimes now span dozens of jurisdictions and policy domains. These instruments share resemblance with earlier forms of piloting and trial, but they also exhibit distinct institutional logics, governance architectures, and political rationalities that sit uneasily with received theoretical frameworks. In this panel, we aim to take stock of this new wave and ask what it means for our understanding of policy experimentation, policy design, and governance under uncertainty. Technological disruption is a major catalyst of this new wave in two ways: First, emerging technologies are often the object of experimentation, and second, digital data infrastructures, modelling and automated monitoring increasingly shape how experiments themselves are observed, evaluated and adapted. This latter development alters the conditions of experimentation and expands the scope for real-time and granular learning, while also raising questions about data access, measurement bias, opacity and whose outcomes become visible in experimental evidence. The new wave is also marked by its multi-level character: while regulatory authority may sit nationally or supranationally, experimentation is frequently organized, implemented and evaluated in subnational settings, where administrative capacities, political mandates and relations with affected communities vary. We identify four areas of theoretical significance: (1) The meaning of “experiment” requires conceptual clarification. Unlike RCTs or controlled policy pilots, sandboxes and labs are better understood as structured regulatory interactions or institutionalized learning processes. What analytical work does the concept of experimentation perform in these contexts? (2) The pilot-evaluate-scale model presumes linearity. Many new instruments operate differently: some function as permanent infrastructure; others produce incremental regulatory adaptation rather than discrete scaling decisions. The relationship between experimental episodes and institutional change remains under-theorized. (3) The rapid global diffusion of specific formats - especially the sandbox - invites examination through lenses of policy transfer, mobility, and institutional isomorphism, including attention to the role of international organizations in standardizing and promoting particular templates. (4) Experimental instruments do not generate learning autonomously. Their effects depend on the capacities and infrastructures through which experimentation is organized.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P159. Policy Blindness: Blind Spots, Institutional Inaction, and Structural Erasure in Public Policy Design
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Mwangi
ABSTRACT

General Objective The primary objective of this panel is to critically interrogate the conceptual, structural, and institutional dimensions of "Policy Blindness"—the systematic failure of policy instruments, administrative frameworks, and decision-making bodies to perceive, evaluate, or respond to critical socioeconomic realities, marginalized social groups, or emerging systemic threats. The panel seeks to examine policy blindness across three critical vectors—identity/neutrality traps (e.g., gender, race, or class-blind policymaking), epistemic and cognitive blind spots (e.g., algorithmic bias, reliance on Western-centric models, and technocratic myopia), and structural institutional inaction (e.g., intentional or systemic turning a blind eye to regulatory failure). The aim is to diagnose how policy "blind spots" are engineered, sustained, and contested within modern governance architectures (Jordan & Huitema, 2023) and discuss future directions. Research Question The panel seeks to investigate the following core research question: How are policy blind spots structurally produced and perpetuated within institutional design, and how can public policy scholarship operationalize new analytical toolkits to expose, unlearn, and correct institutional blindness in hyper-complex, diverse, and fast-changing societies? Scientific Relevance Analyzing policy blindness carries urgent theoretical and empirical relevance for contemporary public policy and administrative science for three reasons: Deconstructing the Myth of Policy "Neutrality": Conventional public policy frameworks frequently operate under the assumption that universal, "blind" policy instruments (such as procedural color-blindness or gender-neutral administrative delivery) guarantee equal treatment. However, empirical evidence demonstrates that procedural neutrality applied across structurally unequal contexts actively reinforces social stratification and marginalization (Richeson & Nussbaum, 2004; Cairney, et al, 2022; Abbott & Teti, 2022). Policy scholarship needs to unpack how "neutrality" functions as a form of institutional blindness. Epistemic Injustice and Algorithmic Blindness: The rapid incorporation of artificial intelligence, big data, and automated decision-making into street-level administration has created novel, codified blind spots. Algorithms trained on historically biased data (such as racially biased data, e.g Perez, Beam & Small, 2026) encode institutional blindness into invisible, high-speed automated policy instruments, requiring new frameworks for public accountability and governance design. Explaining Policy Failure and Systematic Inaction: Studies show that policy failure is not always the result of bad implementation or sudden exogenous shocks but that it is frequently rooted in foundational blind spots where state apparatuses misread, under-measure, or actively ignore complex socio-ecological and structural problems until catastrophic breakdown occurs (McConnell & ’t Hart, 2019). Context and Brief State of the Art Public policy literature has long analyzed cognitive and organizational limitations in decision-making—ranging from Simon’s bounded rationality to Lindblom’s incrementalism and Kingdon’s agenda-setting frameworks. However, the contemporary study of policy blindness shifts the focus from individual cognitive constraints to institutional, epistemic, and political architectures that systematically blind state actors. Recent governance scholarship divides policy blindness into three interrelated traditions: Socio-Political Neutrality Traps: Grounded in critical policy studies, feminist political economy, and critical race theory, scholars demonstrate how "identity-blind" policies (e.g., color-blindness, gender-neutral budgeting, or class-blind urban planning) erase the lived realities of marginalized populations, resulting in policies that entrench existing power asymmetries (Richeson & Nussbaum, 2004; Perez, Beam & Small, 2026). Institutional and Epistemic Blind Spots: Administrative literature (e.g., McConnell & 't Hart, 2019; Cairney et al., 2022) explores how dominant analytical tools (such as cost-benefit analyses, econometrics, or top-down key performance indicator systems) create "epistemic blinders" that censor indigenous knowledge, qualitative field insights, and complex socio-ecological feedback loops. Strategic and Bureaucratic Inaction: Work on policy inaction (McConnell & 't Hart, 2019) highlights that policy blindness is often not an accidental oversight but a strategic, institutional choice—a calculated "willful blindness" designed to depoliticize contentious issues, avoid fiscal obligations, or defer responsibility. This panel bridges these complementary traditions to establish a state-of-the-art research agenda on how institutional vision is constructed, distorted, or purposefully obscured in contemporary public policy, and discuss future directions.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments
P162. Rethinking Policy Design: Innovation, Expertise, and Emerging Approaches
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Hoss Golan
M. Maor
ABSTRACT

Policy design is undergoing significant changes as public sector innovation introduces new actors, forms of expertise, organizational arrangements, and methods into policymaking. Policy innovation labs, behavioral insights teams, design and technology units, participatory approaches, experimentation, and data- and AI-enabled methods increasingly influence how policy problems are framed, alternatives are developed, and evidence is mobilized. Yet these developments are often examined separately, leaving important questions about their collective implications for policy design insufficiently explored. This panel addresses a central question: How and under what conditions do emerging forms of innovation, expertise, and organization substantively reshape policy design rather than merely introduce new tools or actors into established processes? Substantive change is understood as a consequential alteration in problem framing, alternative generation and evaluation, knowledge mobilization, or the distribution of authority over design decisions. The panel brings together scholarship on policy design, public sector innovation, institutional change, and the politics of expertise to examine the mechanisms and conditions underlying such transformations. Three interrelated analytical dimensions structure the discussion. First, the panel examines the redistribution of expertise and authority. Emerging approaches may broaden participation, incorporate experiential and technical knowledge, and challenge established professional hierarchies. However, they may also privilege particular forms of expertise, reinforce existing power relations, or create new exclusions. Second, it investigates institutional mediation. The consequences of innovation depend on administrative capacities, organizational routines, political authority, and institutional constraints. Accordingly, similar innovations may produce substantive transformation, incremental adaptation, symbolic change, or additional coordination burdens across different contexts. Third, the panel explores the relationship between innovation in design processes and innovation in policy content and outcomes. Novel design practices do not necessarily generate innovative policy solutions, while substantively innovative policies may emerge through conventional design arrangements. The panel's scientific relevance lies in addressing fragmented scholarship, distinguishing procedural novelty from substantive institutional change, and clarifying how political and institutional conditions shape innovation in policy design. It advances an understanding of innovation as a politically mediated and institutionally embedded process, encouraging theoretical and empirical contributions that identify underlying mechanisms and explain variation across political systems, administrative contexts, and policy sectors. The panel welcomes comparative, cross-national, multilevel, and single-case research employing qualitative, quantitative, mixed-methods, or conceptual approaches. References Hoss-Golan, et al. (2026). The role of institutional logic: a new dynamic typology for policy innovation labs. Policy Design and Practice, 9(2), 135-146. Lewis, J. M., et al. (2020). When design meets power. Policy & Politics, 48(1), 111-130. Maor, M. (2026). Towards a minimal definition of policy innovation labs. Policy Sciences, 59(1), 225-244. Zambrano-Gutiérrez, J. C., & Puppim de Oliveira, J. A. (2022). The dynamics of sources of knowledge on the nature of innovation in the public sector. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 32(4), 656-670.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments
P43. Understanding the Explanatory Value of Policy Micro-Design
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
G. Capano
M. Howlett
ABSTRACT

General objectives The panel aims to advance the study of micro-design by shifting the focus from description to explanation. While research on policy details has grown rapidly, it is scattered across policy design, policy mix studies, institutional analysis, legislative studies and sectoral research. Much of this research describes how instruments are constructed rather than testing the explanatory power of these details. The panel has three objectives. Firstly, the panel will assess the explanatory value of micro-design in relation to the effects of policies, in particular, whether the specifications and calibrations can account for differences in implementation, compliance, outputs, and outcomes that cannot be explained by the type and number of instruments adopted. Secondly, it incorporates micro-design into the study of policy mixes by asking whether the consistency and performance of a mix depend on how its instruments are designed at the micro level. Thirdly, it examines micro-design as a source of policy change by asking whether small adjustments to existing instruments can produce changes that would be missed if only the goals and the types of adopted instruments were observed. By bringing together scholars from different fields who study policy details using varied approaches, the panel aims to compare evidence across sectors and countries and assess whether micro-design should become a central factor in explaining policy outcomes and dynamics. Scientific relevance The idea that details matter is not new. Hall (1993) distinguished among instrument settings, instruments themselves, and goals. Cashore and Howlett (2007) placed calibrations at the most concrete level of a taxonomy of policy components. Research on tools has shown that the same tool can rest on different assumptions about how its targets behave (Schneider and Ingram, 1990). Subsequent research has examined details in various ways: - Through the intensity of instruments, such as the strictness of a standard or the number of actors covered (Knill et al., 2012; Schaffrin et al., 2015; Schmidt and Sewerin, 2019). - Through the institutional grammar, which breaks rules down into their components (Crawford and Ostrom, 1995; Siddiki et al., 2011), and through more detailed classifications of rule types (Arahuetes-de la Iglesia et al., 2026). - Through the level of detail and restrictiveness of legal provisions (Thomann, 2015; Hurka et al., 2025). Capano and Howlett (2024, 2026) combined these features by distinguishing between specifications (target population, expected outcome, and timeframe) and calibrations (coercion, visibility, automaticity, resources, implementing agencies, and monitoring and accountability). A growing number of studies now analyse the micro-level of design in fields such as EU forest policy (Galicia Cruz et al., 2026), payments for ecosystem services (Sainz-Santamaria, 2024), public subsidies for private schools (Zancajo and Fontdevila, 2026), energy-efficiency rebates (Scott et al., 2026), urban transport (Pham, 2026), and net metering laws in US states (Ambrose and Gregoire-Zawilski, 2026). Taken together, these studies suggest that: - the same instrument can take very different forms; - vague targets and undefined calibrations can hinder implementation; - rules hidden in the small print can change whom a policy actually targets; - each step through which an instrument is expected to work depends on specific design choices; - much policy change occurs through small adjustments to existing instruments rather than new ones. Micro-design is especially important for policy mixes. Instruments in a mix can support or undermine each other (Gunningham and Sinclair, 1999; Flanagan et al., 2011). Mixes are judged by their consistency, coherence and credibility (Howlett and Rayner, 2013; Rogge and Reichardt, 2016; Kern et al., 2019), yet they are often described in terms of the number of instruments, goals and levels of government (Howlett and del Río, 2015), which tells us little about their content (Migone and Howlett, 2024). Several studies, including some of the recent ones mentioned above, highlight the importance of design details in how mixes work (del Río, 2010; Rogge and Schleich, 2018). Grohmann and Feindt (2024), for example, show that in the German implementation of the EU Common Agricultural Policy, instruments linking farm support to environmental behaviour were calibrated with low stringency and specificity, which weakened the integration of environmental goals. Micro-design may therefore be the missing link between individual instruments and the performance of the entire mix. However, there is still limited systematic evidence linking micro-design to implementation, compliance, outputs, outcomes, and performance. Most of the studies cited above describe how instruments are built or examine single cases, and some explicitly call for tests to determine what these details explain. Such tests require a clear causal argument. Rather than acting directly on outcomes, instruments trigger mechanisms that alter the behaviour of targets and implementers (Capano and Howlett, 2021). The specifications and calibrations determine whether and to what extent these mechanisms are triggered. For instance, a subsidy will only be effective if it is substantial enough to influence choices, and an obligation will only be effective if it is monitored. Therefore, the causal claim is conditional: micro-design only explains outcomes to the extent that it activates, weakens or blocks the mechanisms on which an instrument depends. Testing this claim raises two problems. Firstly, the effect of the design must be separated from the effect of the context, since the same calibration may be effective in one setting but ineffective in another. Secondly, designs are not random: governments may select calibrations in response to conditions that influence outcomes. Comparisons of the same policy intervention across countries or over time and process tracing from design to behaviour can address these issues. This panel addresses these gaps by asking whether micro-design adds explanatory power to policy design research or merely descriptive detail. Research questions 1. Do specifications and calibrations explain implementation, compliance, outputs and outcomes beyond the type and number of instruments? Through which mechanisms? 2. How does the micro-design of individual instruments influence the consistency and performance of policy mixes? Can tensions within a mix be traced back to the way its instruments are calibrated? 3. Do changes in calibration reveal forms of policy change that would be missed if only goals and instruments were observed? Can changes in calibration lead to changes in goals and instruments? References Ambrose, G. and Gregoire-Zawilski, M. (2026). Mapping measurement to theory in policy evolution: a case of net metering policies of the United States. Policy Studies Journal, e70133. Arahuetes-de la Iglesia, D., Tenza-Peral, A., Estévez-Moreno, L. X., Martín-Suárez, A., Lacosta-García, F. J., Lare-David, I. and Pérez-Ibarra, I. (2026). A comprehensive taxonomy of rules for nuanced analysis of governance systems. Policy Studies Journal, 54(3), e70143. Capano, G. and Howlett, M. (2021). Causal logics and mechanisms in policy design: how and why adopting a mechanistic perspective can improve policy design. Public Policy and Administration, 36(2), 141-162. Capano, G. and Howlett, M. (2024). Calibration and specification in policy practice: micro-dimensions of policy design. Policy Design and Practice, 7(2), 115-128. Capano, G. and Howlett, M. (2026). The Politics of Detail: The Micro-Dimension of Policy Design. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan. Cashore, B. and Howlett, M. (2007). Punctuating which equilibrium? Understanding thermostatic policy dynamics in Pacific Northwest forestry. American Journal of Political Science, 51(3), 532-551. Crawford, S. E. S. and Ostrom, E. (1995). A grammar of institutions. American Political Science Review, 89(3), 582-600. del Río, P. (2010). Analysing the interactions between renewable energy promotion and energy efficiency support schemes: the impact of different instruments and design elements. Energy Policy, 38(9), 4978-4989. Flanagan, K., Uyarra, E. and Laranja, M. (2011). Reconceptualising the 'policy mix' for innovation. Research Policy, 40(5), 702-713. Galicia Cruz, A., Lieberherr, E., Fischer, M. and Ohmura, T. (2026). Design matters: the micro-dimensions of EU forest-related policies. Forest Policy and Economics, 188, 103787. Grohmann, P. and Feindt, P. H. (2024). The importance of calibration in policy mixes: environmental policy integration in the implementation of the European Union's Common Agricultural Policy in Germany (2014-2022). Environmental Policy and Governance, 34(1), 16-30. Gunningham, N. and Sinclair, D. (1999). Regulatory pluralism: designing policy mixes for environmental protection. Law and Policy, 21(1), 49-76. Hall, P. A. (1993). Policy paradigms, social learning, and the state. Comparative Politics, 25(3), 275-296. Howlett, M. and del Río, P. (2015). The parameters of policy portfolios: verticality and horizontality in design spaces and their consequences for policy mix formulation. Environment and Planning C, 33(5), 1233-1245. Howlett, M. and Rayner, J. (2013). Patching vs packaging in policy formulation: assessing policy portfolio design. Politics and Governance, 1(2), 170-182. Hurka, S., Rueß, C., Cowburn, M. and Kaplaner, C. (2025). Laws as blades: a conceptual framework of legislative design. Policy Sciences, 58(4), 733-752. Kern, F., Rogge, K. S. and Howlett, M. (2019). Policy mixes for sustainability transitions: new approaches and insights through bridging innovation and policy studies. Research Policy, 48(10), 103832. Knill, C., Schulze, K. and Tosun, J. (2012). Regulatory policy outputs and impacts: exploring a complex relationship. Regulation and Governance, 6(4), 427-444. Migone, A. and Howlett, M. (2024). The purpose of policy portfolios: design, intention, and logic. Journal of Public Policy, 44(4), 809-825. Pham, T. N. A. (2026). Small steps matter: the contribution of policy calibration to more sustainable mobility planning. Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, online first. https://doi.org/10.1080/1523908X.2026.2686970 Rogge, K. S. and Reichardt, K. (2016). Policy mixes for sustainability transitions: an extended concept and framework for analysis. Research Policy, 45(8), 1620-1635. Rogge, K. S. and Schleich, J. (2018). Do policy mix characteristics matter for low-carbon innovation? A survey-based exploration of renewable power generation technologies in Germany. Research Policy, 47(9), 1639-1654. Sainz-Santamaria, J. (2024). Calibrating payment for ecosystem services: a process-oriented policy design approach. Policy Design and Practice, 7(2), 158-175. Schaffrin, A., Sewerin, S. and Seubert, S. (2015). Toward a comparative measure of climate policy output. Policy Studies Journal, 43(2), 257-282. Schmidt, T. S. and Sewerin, S. (2019). Measuring the temporal dynamics of policy mixes. Research Policy, 48(10), 103557. Schneider, A. and Ingram, H. (1990). Behavioral assumptions of policy tools. Journal of Politics, 52(2), 510-529. Scott, R. P., Messer, C. M., Mayer, A. and Bond, T. C. (2026). Calibration in policy design: rethinking targets of energy-efficiency rebates. Policy and Politics, 54(2), 298-319. Siddiki, S., Weible, C. M., Basurto, X. and Calanni, J. (2011). Dissecting policy designs: an application of the institutional grammar tool. Policy Studies Journal, 39(1), 79-103. Thomann, E. (2015). Customizing Europe: transposition as bottom-up implementation. Journal of European Public Policy, 22(10), 1368-1387. Zancajo, A. and Fontdevila, C. (2026). The micro-level design of public subsidies for private schools: a typological approach. European Policy Analysis, 12(4), e70059.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics
P130. Why Policies Succeed or Fail: Institutional Capacity, Organizational Change and Human Capabilities
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Elrefai
ABSTRACT

Ambitious public policies often produce uneven implementation outcomes. Governments may adopt comparable policy objectives, allocate substantial resources and announce similar reforms, yet differ significantly in their capacity to translate policy commitments into sustained administrative practices and measurable public outcomes. Explaining this variation remains a central challenge in public policy research. Existing scholarship highlights the importance of policy design, administrative capacity, institutional arrangements and implementation structures (Brenton et al., 2023; Sager & Gofen, 2022). Recent research further demonstrates that policy implementation depends on the alignment between institutional capacities, policy integration and organizational responses (Capano & Lepori, 2024; Vince et al., 2024; Yang et al., 2024). Studies on organizational learning and change also emphasize the importance of adaptive capabilities, employee commitment and professional competencies in enabling public organizations to respond effectively to policy demands (Anand & Brix, 2022; Edelmann et al., 2023; Pircher Verdorfer & van Ginkel, 2024). Building on these developments, this panel examines how institutional capacity, organizational change and human capabilities interact in shaping policy implementation outcomes. Rather than treating these dimensions as independent determinants, it investigates their complementarities, tensions and context-dependent effects. The panel addresses four interconnected research questions: Under what institutional and political conditions do administrative capacity, coordination and accountability facilitate effective policy implementation? How do leadership, organizational learning and adaptive change mechanisms translate institutional mandates into operational practices? To what extent do professional, analytical, digital and adaptive competencies strengthen implementation, and under what conditions are these capabilities constrained? How do institutional, organizational and human capabilities interact to influence policy effectiveness, equity, sustainability and institutional resilience? Policy implementation outcomes may be assessed through multiple dimensions, including implementation effectiveness, service delivery quality, equity of access and outcomes, policy sustainability, and institutional adaptability. Contributions are encouraged to identify context-appropriate indicators and explain how these dimensions are operationalized and evaluated. The panel advances three analytical propositions. First, institutional coordination, policy coherence and accountability can strengthen implementation when supported by adequate resources and enabling governance arrangements. Second, organizational learning, leadership and adaptive change can mediate the relationship between institutional capacity and implementation performance. Third, human capabilities generate greater value when organizational structures, incentives and decision-making authority enable their effective deployment. These relationships may vary across political systems, administrative traditions, policy sectors and levels of governance. The panel therefore welcomes contributions that test, refine or challenge these propositions. Contributions may address education, climate and energy, digital government, labour-market reform, public administration, health, industrial transformation and social policy. Comparative and single-case studies from all world regions are welcome, provided they identify clear implementation mechanisms and offer theoretically grounded empirical evidence. The panel welcomes theoretically informed empirical contributions employing qualitative, quantitative or mixed-methods approaches, including comparative case studies, process tracing, survey-based research and institutional analysis. Submissions should demonstrate a clear analytical connection between implementation mechanisms and observable policy outcomes. Priority will be given to contributions that offer clear theoretical advancement, robust empirical evidence and transferable insights into the institutional, organizational and human conditions shaping policy implementation across different governance contexts. Ultimately, the panel seeks to advance comparative public policy scholarship by explaining not only whether policies succeed or fail, but also how institutional, organizational and human capabilities combine to produce implementation effectiveness, adaptation and sustainable public outcomes. References Anand, A., & Brix, J. (2022). The learning organization and organizational learning in the public sector: A review and research agenda. The Learning Organization, 29(2), 129–156. https://doi.org/10.1108/TLO-05-2021-0061 Brenton, S., Baekkeskov, E., & Hannah, A. (2023). Policy capacity: Evolving theory and missing links. Policy Studies, 44(3), 297–315. https://doi.org/10.1080/01442872.2022.2043266 Capano, G., & Lepori, B. (2024). Designing policies that could work: Understanding the interaction between policy design spaces and organizational responses in public sector. Policy Sciences, 57, 53–82. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-024-09521-0 Edelmann, N., Mergel, I., & Lampoltshammer, T. (2023). Competences that foster digital transformation of public administrations: An Austrian case study. Administrative Sciences, 13(2), Article 44. https://doi.org/10.3390/admsci13020044 Pircher Verdorfer, A., & van Ginkel, G. (2024). Adapting to organizational change in a public sector high-reliability context: The role of negative affect and normative commitment to change. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 34(3), 465–479. https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/muae009 Sager, F., & Gofen, A. (2022). The polity of implementation: Organizational and institutional arrangements in policy implementation. Governance, 35(2), 347–364. https://doi.org/10.1111/gove.12677 Vince, J., Fudge, M., Fullbrook, L., & Haward, M. (2024). Understanding policy integration through an integrative capacity framework. Policy and Society, 43(3), 381–395. https://doi.org/10.1093/polsoc/puae027 Whitsel, L. P., Honeycutt, S., Radcliffe, R., Johnson, J., Chase, P. J., & Noyes, P. (2024). Policy implementation and outcome evaluation: Establishing a framework and expanding capacity for advocacy organizations to assess the impact of their work in public policy. Health Research Policy and Systems, 22, Article 27. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12961-024-01110-0 Yang, L., Wu, Y., Yue, Q., & Ma, Y. (2024). Working together: An RACM model of policy implementation capacity. Global Public Policy and Governance, 4, 56–85. https://doi.org/10.1007/s43508-024-00087-4

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process General Public Policy (no specific sector) Administration and Civil Service Policy
P149. PUBLIC POLICIES, JUST TRANSITION AND COOPERATION IN AFRICA AFTER 2030 :OPPORTUNITIES AND CHALLENGES
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
F. Mekongo Mballa
ABSTRACT

Which public policies are required to implement Just Transition in Africa? Just Transition as a necessity to adapt to the consequences of climate change is of capital importance for the continent. Indeed, it is the most vulnerable to this phenomenon, whereas the less responsible of its occurrence, with only 4% of greenhouse gases (GHG) emissions that cause global warming according to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). However, it suffers the most from its consequences: unpredictable weather patterns leads to forced migration and less predictable harvests, endangering food security and further complicating the implementation of food sovereignty in a continent where agriculture is the livelihood of no less than 60% of its adult population (IPCC). Additionally, more than 600 million Africans don’t have access to a clean and affordable source of energy on a daily basis. The consequences of climate change justify the need to implement Just Transition within Africa. Yet, most of the energy transition projects in the continent are focused on the implementation of just transition out of Africa. For example, one of the rare projects within the scope of just transition in Africa is to provide green hydrogen to Europe, hence reproducing the pattern of colonial extractivism, through ‘predatory foreign direct investment and invasive profit-driven green extractivism’ ( Kaboub and Adow , 2026,3) (among others) endeavor to secure supply chains, raw materials and strategic minerals in Africa to implement Just transition within their own countries. This new scramble for Africa’s natural resources makes the continent ‘a focal point of contention’ in the global restructuring process occurring at the global level ( Kaboub and Adow , 2026,4), and keeps Africa a passive actor in the implementation of Just transition, at the expense of global powers. From an inward perspective, the attempts to implement just transition in the continent failed to live up to the expectations. The Framework and Action Plan of the Africa Renewable Energy Initiative (AREI) conceived under the aegis of the African Union (AU) ‘were soon eroded through numerous overlapping forces, involving both non-African and African actors’ (Sokona et al.2023, 63), which raises the issue of translation of Just transition in the African context. Practically, the rare Just Energy Transition Partnerships (JETP) actually implemented in Africa, as in South Africa, are in forms of loans and reputed to lack transparency (Farand and Chloé , 2022). Efforts made by some African countries to put a cap on the exportation of their critical mining to promote their transformation locally are yet to bear their fruits. Africa remains at the bottom of the global value chain related to energy transition. Hence the purpose of this panel is justified. It aims among others to answer the following questions: How to make the ownership of Just transition policies in Africa as highlighted by the AREI effective? Which policy instruments ( Lascourmes and Simard , 2011) would be conducive to Just Transition within Africa? How does Just transition translates in the agendas at the regional, national or local levels in Africa ?

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Energy Policy Regional Policy
P276. Public Acceptance of Policy Reforms: Behavioral Mechanisms and Policy Communication
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
H. Dib Slamani
ABSTRACT

Public policy reforms are important instruments through which governments respond to economic, social, and institutional challenges. Their implementation, however, often depends on public acceptance, particularly when they alter established arrangements or impose immediate costs in anticipation of longer-term benefits (Ostry et al., 2009). How citizens understand these changes and evaluate their consequences is therefore central to the reform process. Public responses reflect both the consequences of a reform and the processes through which people form judgments about them. Prior beliefs, perceptions of fairness, institutional trust, and social norms can shape how citizens assess expected costs and benefits. Policy communication enters this process through the information provided, the framing of reform objectives, and the presentation of accompanying measures. Understanding how these factors interact - and how their influence varies across cultural and institutional contexts - can help explain differences in public acceptance and inform reform design and implementation. Energy-sector reforms provide a particularly relevant setting for examining these relationships because changes in prices, subsidies, and transition measures raise distributional concerns. Experimental research on energy subsidy reform shows that information provision and framing can influence policy preferences (Vieites et al., 2022; Hoy et al., 2023; Bharadwaj & Innocenti, 2025). Responses also depend on the proposed use of fiscal savings and accompanying measures (Harring et al., 2023; Bez et al., 2026). These findings invite closer examination of how communication and substantive reform arrangements jointly shape public evaluations. Increased expressed support does not, by itself, establish improved understanding or informed acceptance. This panel seeks to examine the behavioral mechanisms through which perceptions of reforms are formed and how policy communication interacts with cultural, institutional, and policy-specific conditions. It encompasses public policy reforms generally, with particular attention to energy-sector reforms. The central research question is: Through which behavioral mechanisms does policy communication shape public acceptance of reforms, and how do these processes vary with cultural, institutional, and policy-specific factors? How are perceptions of reform costs, benefits, and fairness formed? How do prior beliefs, institutional trust, reference points, and cultural orientations condition responses to reform messages? How do social norms and expectations about government responsibilities influence these evaluations? When does communication improve understanding, and how does this relate to acceptance? Which mechanisms recur across reform settings, and which depend on context? Contributions may test whether institutional trust conditions information effects, whether cultural orientations moderate responses to distributional framing, and whether changes in beliefs help explain changes in acceptance. The panel connects research on perception formation with policy design and implementation. Experimental, quasi-experimental, theoretical, comparative, and mixed-methods contributions can clarify mechanisms, distinguish communication effects from responses to substantive reform arrangements, and assess the transferability of findings. Such evidence can inform credible communication and policy designs that address public concerns across diverse populations and settings. References Bez, C. S., Bonilla, J. A., Castañeda Rodríguez, B., García, J. H., Missbach, L., Mohammadzadeh Valencia, F., & Steckel, J. C. (2026). Reforming fossil fuel subsidies with citizens’ approval: The case of Colombia (CESifo Working Paper No. 12583). CESifo. Bharadwaj, P., & Innocenti, S. (2025). Securing public support for fuel subsidy reform: Experimental and policymaker insights from Malaysia (INET Oxford Working Paper No. 2025-03). Institute for New Economic Thinking, University of Oxford. Harring, N., Jönsson, E., Matti, S., Mundaca, G., & Jagers, S. C. (2023). Cross-national analysis of attitudes towards fossil fuel subsidy removal. Nature Climate Change, 13, 244–249. Hoy, C., Kim, Y. S., Nguyen, M., Sosa, M., & Tiwari, S. (2023). Building public support for reducing fossil fuel subsidies: Evidence across 12 middle-income countries (Policy Research Working Paper No. 10615). World Bank. Ostry, J. D., Prati, A., & Spilimbergo, A. (2009). Structural reforms and economic performance in advanced and developing countries (Occasional Paper No. 268). International Monetary Fund. Vieites, Y., Weiss, M., Andretti, B., Jacob, J., & Hallack, M. (2022). Increasing the acceptance of energy subsidy reforms: Behavioral insights for Latin America and the Caribbean (Technical Note No. IDB-TN-2488). Inter-American Development Bank.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Methods & Research Design Energy Policy
P296. Overcoming Problem Conception Biases in Sustainability Policy and Governance: Towards an Integrative Research Program
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
B. Cashore
L. He
C. Ye
ABSTRACT

We propose a panel to identify an integrated research program with which to uncover, and overcome, problem conception biases in sustainability policy and governance. The panel seeks to integrate existing and future contributions from scholars who work on problem constructions and policy design. It will draw on Cashore’s individual and collaborative research including his manuscript The Environmental Policy Paradox: Why Sustainability Governance is Failing our Planet and What to Do About It {Cashore, Forthcoming #104857} The problem conceptions component will focus on promising research applying qualitative and quantitative research methods to better document four distinct kinds of problem-solving logics (PSLs) that underpin, and narrow, applied sustainability research: Commons (Type 1); Optimization (Type 2); Compromise (Type 3) and Prioritization (Type 4). We seek to identify those most pressing in-depth case studies and large-N data-sets to identify the processes for change in problem conceptions (Cashore et al. 2024; Visseren-Hamakers et al. 2023; Cashore and Bernstein 2022). We will focus especially on how to apply, and revise, V.2 of the 4 problem types (4PT) code book (Cashore and Liuyang 2026) to academic publications and syllabi, as well as practitioner policy outcomes including policy briefs, formal and informal communiques for action, and mission statements of private and public organizations. The policy design component will focus on integrating existing and future research (He and Cashore 2026) around how to identify, and anticipate, policy interventions capable of producing durable and effective Type 4 outcomes (Cashore, He, and Ye 2025; Ye, Sun, and Cashore 2026; He, Azziz, and Cashore 2026; Cashore 2026). We especially welcome those efforts that explicitly integrate theories of agency and structure into sparking progressive paradigmatic change, including the role of deliberative policy learning processes (Cashore et al. 2019).

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Environment and Climate Policy
P87. Governing Return, Reintegration and Recovery: Public Policy after Forced Displacement
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
V. Rossikhin
H. Rossikhina
I. Popovich
ABSTRACT

Forced displacement confronts governments with interconnected decisions about emergency assistance, housing, employment, education and longer-term recovery. Governments may make similar commitments while people encounter very different conditions when trying to obtain support. The panel asks: under what institutional conditions do similar policy commitments to support displaced people lead to different levels of access to services across places and population groups? The panel connects three strands of public policy scholarship. Research on policy mixes examines how objectives and instruments fit together and how inherited arrangements constrain that fit (Howlett and Rayner, 2007). Policy-capacity research identifies analytical, operational and political capacities at individual, organisational and systemic levels (Wu, Ramesh and Howlett, 2015). Administrative-burden research explains how learning, compliance and psychological costs shape people’s encounters with public institutions and how policy choices distribute those costs (Moynihan, Herd and Harvey, 2015). The panel brings these perspectives together by tracing how public commitments become services, how people gain access to those services and how evidence about barriers shapes subsequent policy decisions. Three propositions guide the comparison. First, coherent instruments are more likely to sustain service delivery where funding, staffing and intergovernmental coordination match implementation demands. Where local capacity varies, similar national commitments can produce uneven service availability across territories. Second, among people who can in principle use an available service, differences in information, documentation requirements and frontline discretion can produce unequal take-up. This directs attention to how rules and administrative practices affect different groups within the same programme. Third, evidence about access barriers is more likely to prompt adjustments where public authorities have channels for receiving feedback from affected groups and frontline organisations and the capacity to act on it. Unequal representation may influence which barriers are addressed. Ukraine offers an important setting for investigating these mechanisms, including during ongoing conflict. The panel welcomes research across regions and periods on internal and cross-border displacement, reception, return, local integration and recovery. Studies can compare territories or groups, or trace change within a single case. Livelihood security and public legitimacy can also be examined where contributions explain how they relate to service access. By comparing the availability, take-up and adaptation of services across institutional settings, the panel will examine where and why the link between public commitments and access breaks down. This comparison can help identify which explanations travel across settings and which depend on local conditions.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Multilevel Governance and Local Policy Migration and Asylum Policy Social Policy
P95. Measuring policy design dimensions: Effectiveness, capacity, and robustness
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. De Rosa
L. Eaco
ABSTRACT

Policy design scholarship has shifted from individual instruments to the quality of design itself (Howlett, 2019): not only whether policies are adopted, but whether they can be implemented, can work, and remain functional as conditions change. In an era of crises and uncertainty, performance can no longer be inferred from initial adoption or formal features alone. Three dimensions are central to this debate, touching on different aspects, time stages, and actors captured by the overarching literature on policy design. Effectiveness concerns the extent to which a policy achieves its goals and addresses the targeted problem over time (Bali et al., 2019). Policy capacity refers to the analytical, operational, and political skills and resources required to perform policy functions (Wu et al., 2015). Robustness refers to the ability of policy and institutional arrangements to remain functional while adapting to surprise and changing conditions (Howlett et al., 2018; Capano & Woo, 2017). Despite these advances, two limitations persist. First, measurement: consolidated frameworks and comparable indicators are still scarce, and empirical studies often rely on adoption, statutory content, or single-case assessments, which are necessary but insufficient evidence of realized performance. Recent work points to the need to move from single instruments to policy portfolios, from design at enactment to post-enactment “policy life”, and from capacity as background condition to capacity as causal mechanism. Second, interaction: effectiveness, capacity, and robustness are typically studied separately, so little is known about how they reinforce or constrain one another. The panel is therefore guided by the following research question: how can effectiveness, policy capacity, and robustness be conceptualized and measured in comparable ways, and how do they interact in shaping the quality of policy design? Contributions may engage with four research propositions. P1 (measurement): indicators incorporating realized outputs and post-enactment dynamics assess design quality more accurately than indicators based solely on formal features. P2 (complementarity): higher policy capacity increases both effectiveness and robustness. P3 (trade-offs): greater reliance on established capacities increases rigidity, while flexibility supporting robustness reduces short-term effectiveness. P4 (contingency): robustness contributes more strongly to effectiveness under greater turbulence and over longer time horizons. The panel brings theoretical, methodological, and empirical work into one conversation, aiming to clarify the mechanisms through which policy design works and how its dimensions can be compared across context. Sessions will close with a collective discussion on a cumulative research agenda. References: Bali, A. S., Capano, G., & Ramesh, M. (2019). Anticipating and designing for policy effectiveness. Policy and Society, 38(1), 1-13. Capano, G., & Woo, J. J. (2017). Resilience and robustness in policy design: A critical appraisal. Policy Sciences, 50(3), 399-426. Howlett, M. (2019). Designing public policies: Principles and instruments (2nd ed.). Routledge. Howlett, M., Capano, G., & Ramesh, M. (2018). Designing for robustness: Surprise, agility and improvisation in policy design. Policy and Society, 37(4), 405-421. Wu, X., Ramesh, M., & Howlett, M. (2015). Policy capacity: A conceptual framework for understanding policy competences and capabilities. Policy and Society, 34(3-4), 165-171.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments
P122. Public policies for hybrid governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Johanson
J. Vakkuri
R. Pinheiro
ABSTRACT

Contemporary societies are increasingly characterised by hybridity. Public, private and community actors participate in policy processes through networks, partnerships, public-private organisations and other arrangements that cross established sectoral and institutional boundaries. Although governance research has examined these developments extensively, their implications for public policy formation remain insufficiently understood. This panel addresses this gap by distinguishing between two related but analytically different perspectives: the hybridity of policies and policies for hybridity. The hybridity of policies refers to the ways in which public policies themselves become hybrid. Policies may combine different and potentially competing goals, institutional logics, instruments, modes of coordination and principles of accountability. Instead of relying on a single policy instrument or mode of governance, contemporary policies are often implemented through policy mixes that combine regulation, economic incentives, information, contracting, partnerships and self-regulation. Policy formulation and implementation may consequently involve multiple actors whose interests, resources and understandings of public value differ. From this perspective, hybridity is an internal characteristic of policy design, policy processes and policy practices. Policies for hybridity, by contrast, concern public interventions that intentionally create, regulate, support or transform hybrid arrangements. Governments may establish public-private partnerships, encourage cross-sectoral collaboration, outsource public services, support social enterprises, or introduce co-production and collaborative governance mechanisms. Such policies do not simply operate in hybrid environments. They actively shape the conditions under which hybridity emerges and determine how authority, ownership, risks, resources and responsibilities are distributed among participating actors. The distinction is analytically important because hybrid policies do not necessarily promote hybrid organisational or governance arrangements, while policies intended to foster hybridity may rely on relatively conventional policy instruments. The two processes may nevertheless intersect and reinforce one another. Policies for hybridity can generate new policy mixes and practices, while the hybridity of policies can alter the composition, behaviour and accountability of participating organisations. The panel therefore asks: How can the hybridity of policies and policies for hybridity be conceptualised and distinguished? How do hybrid policy goals, instruments and practices influence policy formation and implementation? Through which mechanisms do public policies create, maintain or transform hybrid governance arrangements? How do these developments affect accountability, legitimacy, coordination and public value creation? Finally, what tensions and paradoxes arise when different institutional logics and sectoral interests are combined? The panel’s scientific objective is to connect public policy research with the study of hybrid organisations and hybrid governance. By developing the distinction between the hybridity of policies and policies for hybridity, the panel provides a framework for comparative conceptual and empirical analysis. It also contributes to research on policy design, policy mixes, implementation and policy practices by explaining how hybridity simultaneously constitutes an attribute of policies and an object of public intervention.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P127. Proportionality for whom? The process and politics of designing proportionate public policies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
G. Bazzan
C. Daugbjerg
ABSTRACT

Policy design is a long-standing research field within the policy sciences. It is widely recognised that public policy design is not a technocratic and rational process aimed at finding an optimal balance or fit between the ends and means of government intervention. Rather, it is a political process in which multiple dimensions of policy design are at play, such as competing understandings of the policy problem, the availability of evidence and of feasible solutions. Maor’s pioneering work on disproportionality in public policy over more than a decade has highlighted that proportionality is a crucial dimension of policy design. Perhaps nowhere were challenges of proportionality more evident than during the COVID-19 pandemic, in which it was widely debated which measures were proportionate to contain the spread of the disease. However, proportionality is not confined to pandemics, epidemics, or one-off crises such as the global financial crisis of the late 2000s. Disputes about proportionality are evident in many other policy fields and even in much routine policy-making, such as food safety regulation. A particular merit of Maor’s research is its insights into policy-makers’ motivations for over- and underreaction. Yet, we still lack a complete picture of the role that proportionality plays in policy processes, let alone how policy-makers conceive of proportionality and disproportionality in specific policy contexts. Policy actors often hold divergent views on the severity of policy problems, and these differences influence which measures they regard as proportionate responses. For instance, a climate activist and a climate sceptic are likely to disagree fundamentally on the scale and urgency of measures needed to address global warming. What appears proportionate to one may appear excessive to the other. This raises the question of proportionality for whom. Whose perception of proportionality eventually prevails in the policy process, and how does that influence the design of policy? Answering these questions requires attention to how policy processes unfold and provide opportunities for certain perspectives on proportionality to prevail. Institutions play a key role in defining standards of proportionality within a policy domain. Institutional research has highlighted how institutions shape policy formulation and design. They embody standard understandings of the policy problems they were formed to address and shape perceptions of what are considered proportionate responses to policy problems. Policy process theories offer analytical frameworks and concepts that can help explain why particular actors and their perceptions of proportionality influence policy. Bearing in mind that many policies are compromises (sometimes uneven compromises), a key question is how coalitions are formed, what role perceptions of proportionality play in coalition formation, and how different perceptions may be traded off in pursuit of a majority coalition. The panel starts from the expectation that what counts as proportionate is not given but shaped by institutions and coalition dynamics, and asks how far this holds across different theoretical lenses. This panel invites contributions that explore these questions and advance our understanding of the role of proportionality in policy processes and policy design.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Policy Process Theories
P140. Policy mix design for wicked problems
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Kirschke
H. Kosow
T. Bolognesi
ABSTRACT

Wicked problems characterized by conflicts, complexity and uncertainty abound across policy fields, from climate change and natural resources to public health and artificial intelligence (Head 2022). As no single instrument can address these problems, policy design scholars have turned to policy mixes and to criteria for their effectiveness and legitimacy (Capano & Howlett, 2020). Often, both scholars and practitioners call for policy mixes that are coherent across sectors and levels, robust under uncertainty, and adaptable as problems and knowledge change (e.g., Kirschke and Kosow 2022). These criteria are usually treated as goals to be maximised. For coherence, for example, recent debates have focused on optimizing coherence across policy fields to avoid trade-offs and to generate synergies between sectors (Batkhuyag, 2026). Yet striving for coherence involves trade-offs, e.g., regarding the costs and effort of coordination between different interests and goals. Pursued too far, coherence may lock in a single problem framing and reduce the diversity that makes a mix effective and acceptable. The relationship between design criteria and policy outcomes is thus unlikely to be linear (Bolognesi and Fischer 2025). Yet, how far each criterion should be pursued for which type of problem, and how governance enables suitable mixes, remains poorly understood. This panel proposes to move from maximization to calibration. It conceives of good policy mix design as finding a ‘corridor’ within a triangle of coherence, robustness, and adaptability to be both effective and acceptable. This corridor likely differs between types of wicked problems, for instance depending on whether they are driven mainly by complexity, uncertainty or conflict. The panel is guided by three research questions: 1. Which policy mixes, and which balance of coherence, robustness and adaptability, suit which types of wicked problems? 2. To what degree must these criteria be fulfilled, i.e., where do corridors lie, and how do the criteria reinforce or trade off against each other and against further criteria such as effectiveness and acceptability? 3. Which governance conditions enable such mixes? More specifically, how do science-policy-society interactions help actors to assess and reach suitable corridors? By addressing these questions, the panel advances debates on policy design and good governance for wicked problems. It connects the policy mix literature with research on the governance of wicked problems, and offers decision-makers orientation on how much coherence, robustness and adaptability is ‘enough’. References Batkhuyag, M. (2026). Policy Coherence in Climate Governance: A Systematic Review of Empirical Research. Environmental Policy and Governance. Bolognesi, Thomas, and Manuel Fischer. 2025. Policy Design and Governance Effectiveness: The Role of Non-Linearities in Urban Water Management Governance: e70064. Capano, G., & Howlett, M. (2020). The knowns and unknowns of policy instrument analysis: Policy tools and the current research agenda on policy mixes. Sage Open, 10(1), 2158244019900568. Kirschke, S., & Kosow, H. (2022). Designing policy mixes for emerging wicked problems. The case of pharmaceutical residues in freshwaters. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 24(5), 486-497. Head, B. W. (2022). Wicked problems in public policy: Understanding and responding to complex challenges (p. 176). Springer Nature.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Crises, Risks and Wicked Problems General Public Policy (no specific sector) Other
P148. Governing mis- and disinformation: Responses to emerging challenges
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Gintova
T. Nochta
A. Lawlor
ABSTRACT

Mis- and disinformation have become a recurring concern for governments and public institutions across elections, public health, climate change, migration, security and emergency management. International bodies have warned that false and misleading content can fuel social unrest, undermine electoral integrity and deepen societal polarization (UN 2022). Part of the difficulty is structural: mis- and disinformation circulate through complex online and offline networks involving actors and infrastructures that often sit beyond any single jurisdiction (Stepney and Lally 2024). Public authorities are nonetheless expected to identify emerging information threats, assess their consequences, coordinate a response and communicate credibly with diverse publics. This raises a question central to public policy and administration: how do governments respond to mis- and disinformation effectively and legitimately? A substantial body of research has examined how mis- and disinformation are produced, spread and exert effects, along with the potential contribution of regulation, fact-checking, strategic communication, media literacy and collaboration with digital platforms and civil society. Governments have adopted markedly different approaches: the European Union has built an extensive regulatory framework for digital platforms (Peukert 2024; Schlag 2023), while Canada has emphasised detecting foreign interference, securing elections and building citizen resilience through media literacy (Government of Canada 2026a, 2026b). Yet no single policy instrument functions as a “silver bullet” (Bateman and Jackson 2024), and the effectiveness of any given intervention remains uncertain and highly dependent on context (Mendy et al. 2024). This panel aims to foster a comprehensive dialogue on several critical dimensions of government responses to mis-and disinformation. For instance, existing literatures pay limited attention to, first, the inclusion of diverse perspectives in developing policies and responses, especially those of youth as digital natives (Bendo et al. 2026). Second, to the institutional and organizational conditions that allow governments to develop, implement and sustain these responses. Existing work points to recurring difficulties with expertise, access to information, coordination, implementation, public trust and accountability (Matasick et al. 2020), but these findings have rarely been connected to the broader literature on capacity in public policy and administration. Third, analytically and politically, there is little agreement on when government should intervene, and what remains "awful but lawful" (Hrynyshyn 2024). Fourth, to the contested nature of responsibility between platforms and governments in the context of social media's role in spreading disinformation (Bateman and Jackson 2024). Fifth, artificial intelligence, while promising for detection, also raises questions about trust, judgment and the safeguards needed to govern its use (WEF 2024). References Bateman, J. and D. Jackson (2024) https://carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/01/countering-disinformation-effectively-an-evidence-based-policy-guide Bendo, D. et al. (2026) https://doi.org/10.1080/14733285.2026.2673856 Government of Canada (2026a) https://www.canada.ca/en/democratic-institutions/news/2026/03/government-of-canada-introduces-measures-to-further-protect-canadas-electoral-processes-and-strengthen-democracy.html Government of Canada (2026b) https://www.canada.ca/en/canadian-heritage/services/online-disinformation/digital-citizen-contribution-program.html Hrynyshyn, D. (2024) https://theconversation.com/the-online-harms-act-doesnt-go-far-enough-to-protect-democracy-in-canada-224929 Matasick, C. et al. (2020) https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/2020/08/governance-responses-to-disinformation_6285c78a.html Mendy, L. et al. (2024) https://doi.org/10.1177/09636625231223425 Peukert, A. (2024) https://doi.org/10.1080/17577632.2024.2362485 Schlag, G. (2023) https://doi.org/10.17645/pag.v11i3.6735 Stepney, E.S. and C. Lally (2024) https://post.parliament.uk/research-briefings/post-pn-0719/ UN (2022) https://documents.un.org/doc/undoc/gen/n22/459/24/pdf/n2245924.pdf WEF (2024) https://www.weforum.org/stories/2024/06/ai-combat-online-misinformation-disinformation/

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy
P151. WHAT DO GOVERNMENTS WANT? POLICY GOALS IN POLICY DESIGN, IMPLEMENTATION AND CHANGE
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Kovacic
ABSTRACT

Governments increasingly govern through goals. National strategies, the Sustainable Development Goals, EU headline targets, climate neutrality pledges, mission-oriented innovation policies and performance-based funding schemes such as the EU's National Recovery and Resilience Plans all ask policymakers to state, often in numbers, what they want to achieve. Yet policy goals remain one of the least examined elements of public policy. Classic policy analysis took goals as given, as the starting point for choosing among alternatives or evaluating results, and policy design research has invested far more in instruments and policy mixes (Hood, 1983; Lascoumes and Le Galès, 2007; Capano and Howlett, 2020) than in the aims they are meant to serve. Knowledge about goals exists, but it is scattered across communities that rarely talk to each other. Policy design scholars treat goals as levels of aims, objectives and specifications (Howlett, 2009) and as markers of deeper policy change (Hall, 1993). Public administration research has measured goal ambiguity and studied the effects and pathologies of performance targets (Chun and Rainey, 2005; Bevan and Hood, 2006). Implementation research shows how ambiguous goals shape what happens on the ground (Matland, 1995), political scientists have long noted the symbolic uses of policy aims (Edelman, 1964), and global governance scholars study governance by goal-setting (Biermann, Kanie and Kim, 2017). More recently, empirical work has begun to classify and measure goals in strategic documents (Petek et al., 2021, 2022, 2026). What is missing is a shared conversation that connects these strands. The panel offers a space for that conversation around a broad question: what are policy goals, how are they made, and what difference do they make for the design, implementation and outcomes of public policy? Rather than testing a single theory, it invites papers that examine, support or challenge competing expectations, for example: H1 (design or politics): goals are specified to guide the choice of instruments, or they are kept deliberately vague to build coalitions and avoid blame. H2 (precision): more precise and measurable goals improve implementation and accountability, or they invite gaming and the displacement of aims by indicators. H3 (diffusion): international goal frameworks lead to convergence in national goals, but the convergence stays in words rather than in instruments and practice (Meyer and Rowan, 1977). H4 (change): goals change more slowly than instruments, and new goals are added to old ones rather than replacing them (Streeck and Thelen, 2005). The panel has three aims: to bring together scholars of policy design, public administration, implementation, comparative politics, global governance and specific policy fields who study goals under different names; to build shared concepts and methods for analysing goals across countries, sectors and levels of government; and to lay the ground for a collaborative research agenda on policy goals. We particularly hope to attract early career researchers and colleagues working outside Europe.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments
P273. Learning by Doing: Adaptive, Iterative and Agile Approaches to Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
V. Karokis-Mavrikos
M. Patouna
ABSTRACT

Public policy is increasingly made under conditions of complexity, deep uncertainty and turbulence, in which problems shift faster than conventional policy cycles can respond. A family of approaches has emerged that treats policy as a working hypothesis to be revised through experience. Adaptive governance (Dietz, Ostrom & Stern, 2003; Folke et al., 2005; Chaffin, Gosnell & Cosens, 2014), adaptive policymaking and dynamic adaptive policy pathways (Walker, Rahman & Cave, 2001; Haasnoot et al., 2013), experimentalist governance (Sabel & Zeitlin, 2010), problem-driven iterative adaptation (Andrews, Pritchett & Woolcock, 2017), agile government (Mergel, Gong & Bertot, 2018) and robust governance (Ansell, Sørensen & Torfing, 2023) all emphasise iteration, feedback and learning, and several also favour greater discretion for actors closer to delivery. These principles are also becoming increasingly commonplace in practice, as governments across jurisdictions adopt experimental, iterative, and agile ways of working within policy programmes.As these principles become embedded in both scholarship and practice, there is value in fostering dialogue between these literatures, which span environmental governance, policy analysis, EU and regulatory studies, development studies, digital government and public management, as well as between them and policy process theory. The panel pursues three directions for this dialogue. The first is conceptual: clarifying how adaptive, iterative, agile and experimentalist approaches relate to one another and to established concepts such as policy learning, design, capacity and change, as a foundation for more cumulative and impactful theorising (Janssen & van der Voort, 2016). The second is explanatory: treating adaptiveness both as an outcome, asking how and why governments come to work in these ways, and as a driver of outcomes, asking what difference it makes to policy effectiveness, accountability and legitimacy. Both matter for practitioners seeking to embed these approaches. The third concerns measurement: developing robust ways to observe adaptive ways of working within organisations and adaptive policymaking more broadly, linking both to outcomes.The panel asks: How can adaptive, iterative and agile governance be conceptualised, distinguished and compared? Under what conditions do governments adopt and sustain these ways of working? With what consequences for policy outcomes, accountability and democratic legitimacy? And how can they be measured?The panel explores four propositions. First, greater conceptual clarity across these approaches enables stronger connections with policy process theories and more transferable lessons across sectors. Second, the adoption and institutionalisation of adaptive approaches are shaped by the interplay between agency, including leadership and entrepreneurship, and the institutional settings, instruments and accountability regimes within which they operate. Third, the effects of adaptiveness on policy outcomes vary with the nature of the policy problem, organisational capacities and levels of uncertainty. Fourth, systematic observation and measurement of adaptiveness enable comparison across sectors and countries and help link adaptive ways of working to their outcomes.The panel’s scientific relevance lies in bringing a growing and diverse body of work into conversation with policy process theory, and in building a shared comparative agenda on how governments learn, adapt and change the way they govern.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition
P158. Collaboration for What? How Collaborative Governance Shapes Policy Design
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Casula
N. Goyal
ABSTRACT

Collaborative governance has become an increasingly important feature of contemporary policymaking. Public authorities routinely engage civil society organizations, private actors, experts, communities, users, and other stakeholders in consultation, deliberation, co-creation, and joint decision-making. These arrangements increasingly extend beyond implementation and service delivery to earlier stages of the policy process, including agenda setting, problem definition, policy formulation, and the selection and calibration of policy instruments. Despite this development, an important question remains insufficiently explored: what difference does collaboration actually make to the policies that are designed? Existing research has generated extensive knowledge about the conditions that enable collaborative governance, the organization of collaborative arenas, and the factors that foster participation, trust, deliberation, innovation, and consensus. However, the substantive effects of collaboration on policy design outputs remain much less understood. The panel therefore shifts attention from the design of collaborative arrangements to the effects of collaboration on policy design. The main objective is to investigate whether, how, and under what conditions collaborative policymaking generates policy designs that differ from those emerging from less collaborative or more conventional policymaking processes. Particular attention will be paid to how collaboration may affect problem definitions and policy objectives; the selection, calibration, and combination of policy instruments; the construction of target populations; the distribution of benefits, costs, resources, authority, and responsibilities; and the coherence, robustness, and adaptability of policy mixes. The Panel will address questions such as: - How does collaborative governance during agenda setting and policy formulation shape policy problems and objectives? - Does collaboration alter instrument choice and calibration? - How does it affect the construction of target populations and the allocation of policy benefits and burdens? - Does collaboration generate more coherent and adaptable policy designs, or can bargaining among multiple actors create ambiguity and inconsistency? - How do the composition of collaborative arenas, institutional conditions, policy capacities, and the motivations for initiating collaboration condition these effects? Scientifically, the workshop seeks to connect research on collaborative governance, co-design, policy innovation, and policy design more systematically. Its central contribution is to treat the presumed relationship between changes in policymaking processes and changes in substantive policy design as an empirical question rather than an assumption. Ultimately, it asks: when multiple actors collaborate in making policy, what do they end up designing differently, why, and with what implications for the architecture of public policies?

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P166. AI Governance Systems and Regulatory Choices: Institutions, Politics and Policy Design
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Chaqués Bonafont
D. García-García
X. Fernández-i-Marín
ABSTRACT

The governance of artificial intelligence (AI) has become an increasingly important area of public policymaking, raising fundamental questions about how political authorities, regulatory institutions, private actors and other stakeholders organize and exercise authority over emerging technologies. Across countries and policy sectors, different governance systems are taking shape, reflecting variations in institutional arrangements, regulatory traditions, political interests and relationships between public and private actors. Understanding why these systems differ, how they evolve and how they influence regulatory choices constitutes an important challenge for public policy research. This panel aims to explain the emergence, configuration, and evolution of AI governance systems and examine how their institutional and political characteristics shape the development of AI regulation. The panel pursues three interconnected objectives. First, it seeks to identify the political, institutional and sectoral factors that explain variation in AI governance systems. It pays particular attention to institutional legacies, regulatory traditions, political coalitions, economic interests, and the relationships between public authorities and private actors. Second, it aims to characterize and compare the institutional configurations of AI governance, examining how authority and responsibilities are distributed among actors, how governance arrangements are structured across levels of government, and how established sectoral institutions adapt to the challenges posed by AI. Third, it investigates how these governance configurations influence regulatory policymaking, including the definition of regulatory priorities, the selection of policy instruments, the scope of regulation and the distribution of regulatory authority. The panel adopts a comparative perspective, welcoming research on AI governance across different policy sectors and institutional contexts. Contributions may examine governance arrangements within particular sectors or compare their development across sectors, jurisdictions and periods. Particular interest is given to explaining how sectoral characteristics, established institutional arrangements and regulatory traditions shape AI governance systems and their influence on regulatory choices. Comparative and longitudinal studies are encouraged alongside theoretically informed single-case studies. By bringing together research on comparative governance, institutional analysis, regulatory politics and policy design, the panel seeks to advance the conceptualization and systematic comparison of AI governance systems. Its broader contribution is to strengthen explanations of how governance arrangements emerge and develop, and how their characteristics condition regulatory choices across different policy contexts. In doing so, the panel aims to connect the study of AI governance to wider theoretical debates in public policy research.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy Health and Well-Being Policy
P190. Policy Design, State Capacity, and Local Governance for Water and Climate Resilience
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Singh
N. Chindarkar
ABSTRACT

Effective and efficient policy actions require consideration to be given to the constraints and challenges of implementation—preferably even as the policy is formulated. The design of good policy and implementation failure has been a dominant theme in the policy design literature. Some argue that policy design alone cannot facilitate behavioral change and achieve effective outcomes. To address design and implementation concerns, the state capacity literature offers pertinent insights. Using concrete examples, it clarifies mismatches in policy design and implementation, as well as in policy transfer, replication, and diffusion. It also helps us understand that a “best practice” (of policy design and implementation) in a specific context is not replicable in another setting or can be taken to scale. This literature shows that design must be accompanied by capacity development. A broader concept of demand-based capacity development (as opposed to supply-driven training) works in a circular manner, incorporating inputs from the vertical state structure, as well as horizontal linkages with key stakeholders, non-state actors, and private service providers. Further, rather than a static, one-time exercise, policy design, implementation, and capacity development form a dynamic cycle that incorporates local institutional and capacity specificities, as well as uncertainties arising from social, economic, and climate change upheavals. The recent focus on empowering citizens offers an important juncture for designing innovative, inclusive, participatory, and bottom-up institutions for local governance. Institutions should be democratic rather than prioritizing administrative hierarchy in policy prioritization and design. Climate change mitigation and adaptation require innovative policy designs to make local governments more effective. They provide a platform to bring together water-related administrative departments that work in silos, share local expertise and knowledge with line departments, and develop innovative mechanisms to integrate climate responses by bringing existing water and climate policies together. In addition, they are tied to a fiscal transfer structure that can ensure sustainable financing and capacity support for community-led water initiatives. Concerns about water and climate highlight how worsening water scarcity and distress affect livelihoods, threaten the poor's survival, and harm biodiversity. The combination of water stress and climate change drives significant hydrological changes, creating major economic and societal risks. It increases vulnerability across agro-climatic zones, particularly among the most disadvantaged. It affects many aspects of life and livelihoods, including drinking water, sanitation, health, irrigation, and agriculture, aquaculture, forests, and commons. Given this wide range of water-related problems, centralized governance structures are overburdened. It therefore makes sense to move certain aspects of policymaking to the last mile, giving local constituents a greater role in articulating their policy needs and in designing and implementing strategies. Apart from effective governance, local governments are better equipped to provide stronger safeguards for the most vulnerable and marginalized social groups (indigenous populations, women, the landless, among others) who are most affected by climate change, climate-induced uncertainty, and disasters.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy Development Policy Administration and Civil Service Policy
P196. Governing with data: a political sociology of data in local public policies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Courmont
P. Le Galès
O. Steiner
ABSTRACT

This panel examines data as a political and sociological object of urban governance. Over the past two decades, urban governments have faced a sustained injunction to digitise and to ground their action in data. From the smart city to urban digital twins and now artificial intelligence, these developments have come with a discourse on evidence-based policy that presents data as a resource for steering, evaluating and legitimising public action. The empirical record is uneven: dashboards are abandoned, platforms remain underused, and expected gains often fail to materialise. Meanwhile, data have become a central medium for four sets of relations: those between central and local administrations, those between public authorities and private actors producing data and digital services for them, those internal to local administrations between different departments and elected officials, and relations between local bureaucracies and citizens. This panel takes data as an empirical entry point into transformations of urban governance and policymaking. It asks three questions: 1) how does the governance of data redistribute capacities, and modify resources and power relations in public policies and 2) under what conditions do data become instruments of government and 3) how do attempts to govern data implicate transformations in broader governance arrangements? A first line of inquiry concerns multilevel governance. Data can operate as instruments through which central states observe, evaluate, incentivise or discipline local authorities. Indicators, reporting obligations, benchmarking exercises, national platforms and algorithmic targeting may strengthen the steering capacity of central administrations. Conversely, local governments may use data to demonstrate performance, negotiate resources, defend autonomy or contest central categorisations. The panel welcomes papers analysing how data reshape central–local relations, including tensions between standardisation and territorial differentiation, accountability and autonomy, measurement and discretion. A second line concerns public–private relations. Data infrastructures depend on technology firms, platform companies, consultancies, cloud providers, data brokers and civic-tech actors. Local authorities may procure data, negotiate access to privately generated data, outsource analytics, or enter into partnerships to develop digital services. These arrangements raise questions of dependency, sovereignty, accountability and value distribution. Papers may examine how municipalities negotiate with private providers, how public interests are defined and defended in data contracts, and how private data become enrolled in public policy. A third line concerns state capacity and the situated conditions of data actionability. Data do not automatically produce knowledge or govern action, and not for all actors equally. They must be collected, cleaned, standardised, secured, interpreted and embedded in organisational routines. This work depends on professional expertise, technical infrastructures, legal frameworks, budgetary resources and political support. The panel invites contributions on the practices through which data become meaningful—or remain inert—for different actors within local administrations. Fourth, urban governments develop platforms to rationalise access to services, to organise consultation or to enable citizens to report problems, hence changing relations between citizens and urban governments and enabling more reactive policy interventions. By combining these perspectives across cities, sectors and types of data, the panel aims to strengthen the political sociology of data in local public policies.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Multilevel Governance and Local Policy
P234. Grasping the Future, Governing the Present: Anticipatory Governance in Practice across Administrative Contexts
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Calina
E. Florano
ABSTRACT

Anticipation has become an expected function of government. Foresight units, parliamentary committees for the future and long-term national visions are now common, and a practitioner consensus defines what integration requires: a senior mandate, links to planning and budgeting, distributed focal points and skilled staff (OECD, 2025; United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs [UN DESA], 2026). Far less is known about what foresight does once inside government. The literature holds both that foresight remains detached from core decisions and that embedded foresight yields better strategic choices, yet both claims rest largely on a few exemplary cases (Choo & Fergnani, 2022) and self-assessment. Unlike corporate foresight, where longitudinal performance evidence exists (Rohrbeck & Kum, 2018), public-sector foresight is seldom studied as knowledge in use. Because policy knowledge often influences conceptually and cumulatively rather than instrumentally (Weiss, 1979), the "impact gap" may partly reflect how impact is defined. The question sharpens as turbulent problems compress the time between signal and decision (Ansell et al., 2021) and artificial intelligence makes futures cheap to produce. Most administrations also differ from the exemplars: where capability is stretched, best-practice reforms risk reproducing institutional form without function (Pritchett et al., 2013). The panel asks: How is strategic foresight used in public administration, under what conditions does it shape policy and organizational behavior, and how do these conditions vary across contexts and under accelerating change? It invites contributions that test or contest five propositions: P1. Foresight’s influence may depend as much on organizations’ capacity to absorb futures as on producing them.P2. Foresight may contribute by reframing problems, informing deliberation and preparing options, not only by shaping discrete decisions.P3. Foresight’s position within government may shape both how often it is used and how freely it questions prevailing assumptions.P4. Where administrative capacity is stretched, foresight may take root more readily when linked to existing planning and budgeting systems.P5. Artificial intelligence may shift foresight work toward interpretation, judgment and translation by public servants.Understanding how foresight is used, by whom and to what effect, is a precondition for governments that seek to anticipate rather than react. References List

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process Administration and Civil Service Policy Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy
P252. Governing for Future Generations: Institutional Designs from the Global to the Indigenous Level
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
K. Nsah
ABSTRACT

Democratic policymaking is widely criticised for its "presentism." Electoral cycles, organised interests and the discounting of distant costs systematically disadvantage people who cannot yet vote or speak. Climate change, biodiversity loss, pension sustainability and technological risk all show how policies made today shift burdens onto future generations. In September 2024, UN Member States adopted the Pact for the Future and its annexed Declaration on Future Generations, committing them to take the interests of future generations into account in decision-making. Implementation, however, now depends on national, regional and local institutions whose designs vary greatly. A growing literature examines these institutions: commissioners and ombudspersons for future generations, parliamentary committees for the future, statutory well-being frameworks, government foresight units, and deliberative or "future design" mechanisms (e.g., Jacobs 2011; González-Ricoy and Gosseries 2016; Boston 2017; MacKenzie 2021; Hale 2024). This scholarship has three main limitations. First, it concentrates on state institutions in the Global North, especially Wales, Finland and Hungary. Second, it focuses on institutional design more than on diffusion and implementation, so we know little about whether these bodies actually change policy decisions. Third, it largely overlooks customary and indigenous authorities. Yet in much of Africa, Asia, Oceania and the Americas, these authorities govern land, natural resources, public health and cultural practices, often under explicit intergenerational norms. Polycentric governance and legal pluralism suggest that such actors may be important, and sometimes more legitimate, venues for long-term governance than the state. The panel therefore asks: how are institutions for future generations designed, diffused and implemented across governance levels, from global commitments to national, local, customary and indigenous institutions, and under what conditions do they shape actual policy decisions? The panel will explore several hypotheses. First, institutions with formal mandates, resources and review or veto powers influence policy more than purely advisory or symbolic bodies. Second, global commitments such as the Pact for the Future spread mainly through transnational networks, policy entrepreneurs and epistemic communities rather than through formal intergovernmental mechanisms. Third, customary and indigenous authorities can be effective venues for long-term governance where state capacity is limited or state legitimacy is contested, because they draw on established intergenerational norms and social legitimacy. Fourth, participatory foresight affects policy mainly when it is connected to identifiable decision points. Finally, whether state and customary institutions complement or compete with each other shapes the outcomes of long-term policies. By combining comparative public policy, foresight studies and research on customary governance, the panel aims to expand both the empirical scope and the theoretical tools of research on long-term policymaking.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Administration and Civil Service Policy
P258. Social assistance systems across South-East Europe
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Narazani
ABSTRACT

Social assistance systems across South-East Europe have undergone significant reforms over the past two decades, driven by fiscal pressures, demographic change, EU integration processes, and the pursuit of more efficient poverty-reduction mechanisms. Despite these reforms, evidence suggests that social assistance schemes in the region continue to face persistent challenges related to benefit adequacy, coverage, and fiscal commitment. While many programmes are relatively successful in targeting resources towards low-income households, their overall effectiveness in reducing poverty and social exclusion remains limited. As a result, social assistance often functions primarily as a poverty-mitigation instrument rather than as a pathway towards sustainable social inclusion. This panel aims to examine the evolution, performance, and future direction of social assistance systems in South-East Europe, including both Western Balkan countries and EU Member States in the region. It seeks to bring together researchers, policymakers, international organisations, and practitioners working on social protection, poverty measurement, labour market transitions, and fiscal policy. Particular attention will be paid to recent reforms, including digitalisation of benefit administration, proxy means-testing mechanisms, activation policies, minimum income schemes, and policy responses to the COVID-19 crisis and subsequent cost-of-living pressures. The panel will address several interrelated research questions: To what extent do current social assistance systems succeed in reducing poverty, inequality, and material deprivation?How do countries balance the trade-off between targeting accuracy and broad coverage of vulnerable populations?What are the distributional consequences of recent reforms in eligibility rules, benefit design, and administrative procedures?How have digitalisation and data-driven targeting tools affected inclusion and exclusion errors?What lessons can be drawn from comparative experiences across South-East Europe and the European Union?How can social assistance systems be redesigned to respond to emerging challenges such as informal employment, population ageing, migration, and changing labour market conditions? The scientific relevance of this panel lies in its contribution to a growing international debate on the adequacy and effectiveness of social protection systems in middle-income and transition economies. Although a substantial body of research has examined poverty and social expenditure in European welfare states, comparative evidence on the functioning of social assistance schemes in South-East Europe remains relatively limited. By bringing together empirical studies, microsimulation analyses, impact evaluations, administrative data research, and policy assessments, the panel seeks to advance understanding of how social assistance can better contribute to poverty reduction and social inclusion.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Policy Evaluation
P270. Education Policy and Multi-Level Governance for Contemporary Democracy: Design, Participation and Implementation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Kalev
ABSTRACT

This panel examines how policy is designed, discussed, and implemented across levels of governance, from national authorities to municipalities, schools, and community organisations. It brings together three connected areas: the organisation of citizenship education; the role of interest groups and professional organisations in policymaking; and the allocation of school places when demand exceeds capacity. These areas offer a way to examine how public responsibilities are divided, how decisions are made, and how policy arrangements affect institutions, families, and communities. The panel asks how authority and responsibility are distributed among national, local, and school-level actors. How do these actors coordinate when their roles overlap or their priorities differ? How do national rules interact with local needs and school-level practice? What opportunities do interest groups, professionals, families, and community organisations have to contribute to policy discussions? How do decision-makers weigh competing considerations, explain their choices, and respond when decisions are challenged? What can appeals, court cases, or changes in administrative practice reveal about the relationship between formal rules and their implementation? The panel considers democracy both as an aim of education and as a feature of the policy process. It focuses on practical questions: who is involved in decisions, how responsibilities are accounted for, and whether rules are applied clearly and consistently. Citizenship education provides a perspective on how schools and other organisations prepare young people for public life. Interest-group participation raises questions about how decision-makers receive and balance policy advice. School-place allocation shows how general rules are applied to particular cases and how families can seek review. By connecting policy design, participation, and implementation, the panel contributes to research on multi-level governance and contemporary democracy. It will help clarify how education policies move between levels, what supports coordination, and where tensions can arise between national direction and local practice. The discussion also connects education research with wider work in public administration and policy studies on institutional responsibility, stakeholder involvement, administrative decisions, and public accountability.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Other Education Policy Other
P36. Implementing Sustainability Transitions: Capacity, Coordination, and Contestation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Goritz
A. Ludot
J. von Pfister
ABSTRACT

Governments across the world have adopted increasingly ambitious agendas for climate neutrality, green industrial transformation, circular and bio-based economies, and just transitions. These agendas seek not merely incremental policy change but the transformation of production systems, infrastructures, technologies, institutions, and social practices. Their implementation therefore poses distinctive challenges: transition policies typically span multiple sectors and levels of government, combine interacting policy instruments, trigger social conflicts around the allocation of costs and benefits, require sustained administrative and political commitment, and unfold under substantial uncertainty over long time horizons. Research on sustainability transitions has generated influential perspectives on transformative innovation policy, transformational system failures, policy mixes, and mission-oriented governance (Weber & Rohracher, 2012; Rogge & Reichardt, 2016; Haddad et al., 2022; Janssen et al., 2023). Yet this literature has paid comparatively greater attention to transition pathways, policy design, and governance architectures than to the processes through which transition-oriented policies are put into practice. Conversely, implementation research offers a rich body of knowledge on policy design, administrative capacity, inter-organizational coordination, political support, implementer behaviour, target-group responses, learning, and contextual conditions (O'Toole, 1986; Winter, 2012; Bullock et al., 2021; Sager, Mavrot & Keiser, 2024), but has only begun to engage systematically with the distinctive demands of sustainability transitions. This panel brings these literatures into dialogue around the central research question: How and under what conditions are ambitious sustainability-transition policies translated into implementation outputs and outcomes? It invites work examining several related hypotheses. First, the cross-sectoral and multi-level character of transition policies makes coordination, responsibility allocation, and implementation capacity especially consequential. Second, implementation is shaped by the tension between transformative policy demands and existing organizational mandates, routines, resources, and institutional arrangements; misfit may generate adaptation, layering, resistance, or non-implementation. Third, political commitment, policy legitimacy, opposition of target groups, and distributional contestation condition whether administrative capacities can be mobilized and sustained. Fourth, because transitions unfold under uncertainty and over extended periods, learning, feedback, and adaptive implementation will gain greater importance for success, while also creating risks of drift from original objectives. Finally, similar transition policies may generate divergent implementation trajectories across places and sectors because these mechanisms interact with context. By connecting implementation scholarship with sustainability-transition research, the panel seeks to develop more cumulative explanations of when, how, and why transformative policy ambitions are realized, modified, or frustrated in practice. Such endeavor is in line with the recent interest of socio-technical transition studies for public policy theory, which may help find practical answers to long-term policy challenges (Sewerin et al., 2020; Geels and Ayoub, 2025).

POLICY TOPICS
Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy Crises, Risks and Wicked Problems Economic and Financial Policy Other
P214. The policy work of intermediaries: a relational perspective on the role of non-state actors in street-level implementation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Miaz
N. Rentsch
ABSTRACT

Lipsky’s seminal book on street-level bureaucracy (Lipsky 1980) highlighted the policymaking role of street-level bureaucrats, whose discretionary practices not merely implement policies but actively shape their content and effects in practice. In this sense, street-level organizations (SLOs) are crucial sites where policy is translated into concrete experiences, structuring access to public services, rights, justice, welfare benefits, and institutional arrangements designed to address public problems. The concept of SLOs reflects broader transformations of public policies as both for-profit firms (Dias and Maynard-Moody 2006) and nonprofits (Fyall 2017; Smith and Lipsky 1993) have become increasingly directly involved in policy implementation and service provision on behalf of the state (Brodkin 2013). Street-level research also emphasizes the relational nature of implementation, which emerges through interactions among multiple actors and organizations (Achermann, Borrelli, and Pfirter 2023; Halliday et al. 2009; Infantino 2023; Miaz and Achermann 2022). Within a given policy sector, these actors are embedded in distinct social fields and institutional logics. Street-level bureaucrats operate within the bureaucratic field, judges and lawyers within the juridical one, while other professionals, such as social workers, mediators, and health practitioners, are rooted in distinct professional and policy fields (Dubois 2012). As they engage in implementation, their respective logics overlap, compete and are continually negotiated (Halliday et al. 2009). Such hybridization can generate tensions among multiple accountability regimes, including political-administrative, vocational, charity- or activist-oriented, clients- and shareholders-oriented, as well as participatory (Thomann, Hupe, and Sager 2018). In this context, street-level managers, alongside frontline workers, play key role in mediating these tensions and reconciling plural accountabilities (Gassner and Gofen 2018). Building on this body of research, this panel focuses on non-state street-level actors who serve as policy intermediaries in shaping access to rights, justice, public services, benefits, policy provisions, and more broadly to the state. Positioned between individuals, public institutions, regulations, legal frameworks, and policy programs, these actors influence implementation processes, despite not being always formally mandated or contracted by the state to carry out public policy tasks. Through social and legal support, they help individuals understand their rights, identify the benefits to which they are entitled, challenge administrative decisions, and navigate complex institutional and legal procedures. For instance, organizations supporting victims of domestic violence, sexual harassment, or state violence may help individuals interpret their experiences through legal categories and assess potential avenues for redress. Similarly, trade union representatives may assist workers in recognizing discriminatory treatment, framing it as a legal grievance, and identifying appropriate procedures and institutions through which to pursue a claim, while also informing them of the practical and legal obstacles such claims may entail. In doing so, these intermediaries often participate in the process of “naming, blaming, and claiming” (Felstiner, Abel, and Sarat 1980). At the same time, they can function as gatekeepers, filtering, selecting, or directing potential claimants and welfare recipients according to legal, strategic, moral, or political considerations (Hamidi 2017).

POLICY TOPICS
Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy Citizens, Participation and Social Movements
P77. Effectiveness and Legitimacy of Street-Level Bureaucracy in the Global South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Chakrabarty
P. Raghunath
D. David
B. Mohapatra
E. St Denny
ABSTRACT

Panel Objective Policy implementation in the Global South takes place through complex interactions among different levels of government, frontline public servants, civil society organisations, community institutions, and citizens. Research from these contexts has significantly expanded our understanding of how institutional arrangements, social inequalities, and local power relations shape policy delivery. Yet an important analytical question remains insufficiently explored: why do similar implementation mechanisms generate different forms of frontline agency and, different outcomes for policy effectiveness and legitimacy? Research Question This panel brings together scholarship on street-level bureaucracy (SLB) in the Global South to examine how frontline actors interpret, negotiate, adapt, and sometimes depart from formal policy objectives. The panel seeks to understand how bureaucratic practices emerge within specific political, administrative, and social contexts, and how these practices shape citizens’ experiences of the state. The panel is organised around the central research question: "How do frontline actors shape policy effectiveness and legitimacy in Global South contexts?" Scientific Relevance Street-level bureaucracy theory establishes that public policies are also shaped through the everyday decisions of frontline implementers. These actors interpret rules, exercise discretion, allocate resources, and interact directly with citizens, thereby influencing how policies operate in practice. As Brodkin (2008: 326) suggests, street-level discretion can become a “wild card of policy delivery.” Scholarship has identified distinct patterns of frontline agency, including informal privatization (Blundo, 2006), policy improvisation (Campos and Peeters, 2022), and alienative commitment (Usman et al., 2021). These patterns illustrate how frontline bureaucrats may respond differently to institutional pressures, sometimes facilitating service delivery and sometimes contributing to exclusion, informal appropriation, or withdrawal from policy objectives. However, much of the SLB scholarship has developed through experiences associated with the Global North. Approaches that assess bureaucratic institutions primarily against assumptions of administrative stability, formalisation, and organisational capacity risk interpreting resource scarcity, fragmented governance, and political volatility as symptoms of institutional underdevelopment (Bierschenk and Olivier de Sardan, 2014; Koivisto, 2013; Pepinsky, Pierskalla, and Sacks, 2017). Such deficit-oriented interpretations may obscure how bureaucratic practices are organised within unequal societies and how they are shaped by local power relations, social identities, and everyday negotiations between citizens and state actors (Lotta and Eiró, 2023). Recent scholarship from the Global South have examined these assumptions. Peters and Campos (2023) demonstrate that adverse institutional conditions may produce contrasting responses, ranging from policy improvisation to informal privatization and withdrawal from policy objectives. Eiró and Lotta (2024) further caution against relying uncritically on categories such as “weak” or “dysfunctional” institutions, which can conceal variation within states and the significance of historically embedded inequalities and power relations. Building on these contributions, the panel seeks to emphasize the relationship between bureaucratic discretion, policy effectiveness, and legitimacy. Effectiveness is understood as how frontline practices influence policy delivery, responsiveness, access, and substantive outcomes. Legitimacy concerns how citizens experience and evaluate public authority, including the fairness, accountability, and credibility of implementation processes. By examining these dimensions, the panel aims to advance a more context-sensitive understanding of everyday bureaucratic encounters in the Global South.

POLICY TOPICS
Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy General Public Policy (no specific sector) Social Policy
P98. (Inter)dependent Implementers: Capacity, Incentives, and the Management of Mutual Dependence
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
R. Triculescu
K. Goetz
ABSTRACT

Implementers rarely act alone. Municipalities deliver services that work only if neighbouring jurisdictions deliver theirs, agencies apply rules that take effect only after other agencies act, and states meet international obligations that pay off only if other states meet theirs. Governments also adopt policies in packages, where officials can apply one instrument only once colleagues have applied a linked one. In each setting, implementers hold only part of what they need to deliver. Implementers depend on one another in different forms. An agency that needs another to act first, without being needed in return, depends unilaterally. Neighbouring municipalities depend on each other bilaterally, and states under a common obligation depend on one another multilaterally. We use the term interdependence for these mutual forms. Implementation scholars have addressed these phenomena from different angles. Some locate the causes of success inside the implementing unit, in its capacity, preferences, discretion and domestic politics, and scholars of differentiated implementation have refined that view (Princen et al. 2024; Thomann and Sager 2017). Others study the relation between implementers and a centre, and explain performance through monitoring, sanctions, guidance and support (Kelemen and Pavone 2023). Where researchers address horizontal relations, they mostly treat them as a design problem that centres settle in advance (Cabane and Lodge 2024), through centralisation, coordination bodies or experimentalist review cycles (Zeitlin and Rangoni 2026). Few researchers treat dependence among implementers as a cause of outcomes, and fewer ask what central actors do once that dependence surfaces during delivery. We see two reasons why this matters. First, researchers who compare jurisdictions usually treat them as independent observations, so where one implementer’s performance rests on another’s, we risk crediting capacity or domestic politics with what follows from the structure of the obligations. Second, designers and central administrators work on the same assumption, so they supply capacity where the problem is unwillingness and apply pressure where the problem is sequence. Scholars who take dependence seriously can also connect implementation research to three largely separate literatures, on compliance in international relations, on coordination and policy mixes, and on weakest-link collective action problems. We therefore ask how implementing actors behave when their performance depends on what others deliver, whether they behave differently across forms of dependence, and how central actors manage it. Participants in this panel can explore four propositions. First, implementers experience dependence through at least two channels, a lack of capacity to reach an outcome alone and a loss of willingness despite capacity as others hold back, and central actors need different instruments for each. Implementers should face the second channel mainly under interdependence, where each can condition its effort on what others deliver. Second, central actors answer the first channel by aligning timing, through deadlines, sequences and recurring cycles, and the second by prescribing, funding or enforcing, with uneven success. Third, implementers who cannot withhold performance openly condition their effort quietly through administrative practice. Fourth, implementers feel dependence most where deadlines bind, where they must share burdens or resources, and where the centre enforces weakly or slowly.

POLICY TOPICS
Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy
P133. Analysing the emotions of policy design and implementation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
I. Verhoeven
E. Hejzlarová
S. Blum
ABSTRACT

Research on emotions in public policy Recent scholarship has demonstrated that emotions influence attention to policy problems, advocacy, judgment, and policy change (Pierce, 2021). At the same time, policy scholars have argued that policy process theories have yet to fully integrate insights about emotions and affect into explanations of policymaking (Cairney & Weible, 2017). Calls have therefore emerged for a deeper understanding of emotional dynamics in public policy (Maor & Capelos, 2023). Extant studies have examined emotions in policy formulation and policy design (Boossabong 2025; Durnova & Hejzlarová 2018; Verloo 2026), policy implementation by street-level bureaucrats (Levitats 2024), policy conflicts (Verhoeven & Metze 2022; Fullerton et al. 2025), policy responsiveness and protests (Kuhlmann & Starke, 2025; Wenzelburger, 2026), as well as policy communication and narratives (Blum et al., 2026; Habelitz et al., 2026). In all these studies, a broad range of approaches and methods have developed, ranging from quantitative analysis of emotions expressed by advocacy coalitions, to more qualitative approaches, employing the narrative policy framework or interpretive policy analysis. In summary, research on emotions in public policy has predominantly examined communicative and deliberative aspects of policy processes, including agenda-setting, policy conflicts, public consultations, and advocacy activities (Stempel, 2025), while emotions in policy design and implementation remain comparatively underexplored. By focusing on these dimensions of policy processes, this panel seeks to advance our understanding of emotions in policymaking and governance. Panel objectives and questions As knowledge on methods for how to study emotions in policies has advanced considerably, our objective with this panel is to shift the focus to the substantive, procedural and relational aspects of policy processes. More specifically, we aim to bring together theoretical, conceptual, and empirically-informed work on processes of policy formulation and design, policy implementation, and the interplay between the two. Policy design processes may for instance not take into account citizens feelings about implementation of a policy, or policy designs may be very politicized and emotional while citizens are pragmatically looking for a good solution. Many of the misfits between policy design and -implementation may also relate to the role that emotions play in translating policy goals into real life practices. Also, we would like to focus on how emotions interact with the intricate interplay between collaboration and conflict (Boon & Wolf 2025) that may affect policy formulation, -design, - implementation and their interplay. Against that backdrop, guiding questions for the panel are: · How do emotions play into processes of policy formulation and policy design? · In which ways do emotions affect processes of policy implementation? · What is the role of emotions in the interplay between policy design and policy implementation? · How do emotions involved in collaboration and conflict affect policy formulation/design, implementation, and their interplay?

POLICY TOPICS
Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments
P155. From Rights on Paper to Rights in Practice: Human Rights Implementation through Public Policy and Administration.
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Gasparyan
ABSTRACT

Human rights are formally recognised through international conventions, constitutions and national legislation, yet their practical realisation depends on public policies and the administrative institutions responsible for implementing them. Access to education, healthcare, housing, social protection, justice and other fundamental rights is shaped by policy design, resource allocation, administrative capacity, organisational routines and the discretion exercised by public officials. Consequently, the existence of formal rights does not necessarily guarantee their effective implementation or equitable enjoyment. Despite the centrality of public policy to human rights realisation, scholarship on these subjects has developed along relatively separate trajectories. Human rights research has traditionally emphasised legal obligations, normative frameworks, compliance and accountability, while public policy and administration scholarship has focused on policy processes, implementation, performance, public values and social equity. Recent contributions to the emerging field of Administration and Human Rights have highlighted the importance of connecting these perspectives. Nevertheless, further theoretical and empirical research is needed to explain how policy processes and administrative arrangements influence the translation of human rights commitments into substantive outcomes. This panel seeks to advance this research agenda by examining human rights implementation as a public policy problem. Its overarching research question is: How do policy design, implementation arrangements and administrative institutions shape the realisation of human rights across different governance contexts? The panel invites contributions exploring several complementary propositions. First, rights-sensitive policy design, incorporating participation, equity, transparency and accountability, may improve the responsiveness and inclusiveness of public programmes. Second, administrative capacity, institutional coordination and resource availability may mediate the relationship between formal rights commitments and implementation outcomes. Third, frontline discretion and administrative burdens may generate inequalities in rights enjoyment, even where legal entitlements are formally universal. Fourth, decentralisation and multilevel governance may facilitate context-sensitive implementation while simultaneously producing territorial disparities in access to rights. Finally, political institutions, democratic accountability and civil society participation may influence the resilience of rights-based policies under conditions of political and institutional change. Rather than assuming these relationships, the panel encourages research that critically examines their underlying mechanisms, contextual conditions and potential contradictions. It welcomes perspectives from policy process theories, implementation studies, institutionalism, public management, comparative public policy and human rights scholarship. The panel aims to contribute to public policy research by establishing human rights realisation as an analytically distinct dimension of policy outcomes, identifying the mechanisms through which public institutions enable or constrain rights implementation, and fostering comparative dialogue across policy sectors, administrative systems and political contexts. Ultimately, it seeks to move beyond the recognition of rights towards a more systematic understanding of how public policies make rights effective in practice.

POLICY TOPICS
Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P178. Public Health Policy to Practice: Navigating the Complexities and Challenges of Implementation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Barui
D. Goswami
A. Das
ABSTRACT

Public Health Policy to Practice: Navigating the Complexities and Challenges of Implementation Public health policies are among the most important instruments through which states pursue equity, well-being and social protection. In developing and underdeveloped countries, a large share of the population depends on welfare schemes sponsored by central and state governments, because high out-of-pocket expenditure places adequate treatment beyond their means. Such programmes are commonly assessed against several criteria, including accessibility, affordability, quality of care, equity, financial protection and responsiveness to beneficiaries. Universal health coverage (Target 3.8 of Sustainable Development Goal 3) is one such important benchmark among these. In recent years, governments have also introduced digital health infrastructure to improve registration, service delivery and feedback. Despite the operation of these health policies and frameworks, policy design and lived experience frequently diverge. Field studies show a notable contrast between the intended objectives of health programmes and the accounts of beneficiaries, particularly at the grassroots level. Several factors contribute to this implementation gap: constrained public financing, corruption, a shortage of trained health personnel, weak institutional foundations, and inadequate coordination among administrators, bureaucrats and beneficiaries. Street-level bureaucrats, in Lipsky’s sense, occupy a pivotal position in this process. They translate policy into practice, yet heavy workloads and limited managerial support often hinder consistent delivery. This panel invites papers that examine both the aspects and the challenges of implementing public health policies. The aspects under discussion include policy design, institutional arrangements, financing, human resources, digital infrastructure and the role of frontline implementers. The challenges include administrative bottlenecks, accountability deficits, coordination failures and barriers to access faced by marginalised groups. We welcome empirical, comparative and mixed-methods contributions, especially those drawing on primary surveys that use both open- and closed-ended questions to capture beneficiary perspectives. The panel is guided by a simple principle: the effectiveness of a policy should be judged by the benefits that actually reach its intended recipients, not by the soundness of its design alone. Contributors are encouraged to evaluate programme outcomes against multiple criteria, identify the points at which implementation falters, and propose evidence-based remedies. By bringing beneficiary experience into conversation with administrative perspectives, the panel aims to inform more responsive, accountable and equitable public health governance.

POLICY TOPICS
Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy
P215. Contentious Implementation: How Interest Groups and Social Movements Shape Policy Implementation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Cailleux
J. Pollard
ABSTRACT

Adopting a policy rarely settles the conflicts it has stirred. Once a law is passed, firms, NGOs, professional bodies or citizen groups can keep mobilizing over how it is specified, delivered and enforced. They sit on participatory councils, take agencies to court, protest against the siting of projects, or press local authorities to bend the rules. Opponents can try to reopen the battle by other means, and new actors may emerge (Anria et al., 2026). These dynamics have been examined across several strands of scholarship that have rarely been brought into systematic dialogue. Implementation research has recognized the political nature of implementation (Sager & Gofen, 2022; Sager & Hinterleitner, 2022) and increasingly calls for attention to conflict and contestation (Mavrot, 2024; Zhang & Rosenbloom, 2024), yet remains largely centered on public actors. Interest group research has begun to examine more systematically how organized interests influence implementation (Truijens & Hanegraaff, 2024). Social movement scholarship has also documented how movements shape implementation, from the translation of movement demands by bureaucracies to the role of mobilization in securing policy gains (Andrews, 2001; Anyidoho et al., 2021; Chartock, 2011; Harrison, 2016; Silva, 2015). In parallel, the literature on legal mobilization has shown how collective actors use legal norms and institutions, within and beyond courts, to contest the interpretation and enforcement of rights and policies (Vanhala, 2010; Colli, 2024). Yet these insights remain dispersed across research traditions, policy sectors and institutional arenas. Existing studies have examined different actors, strategies and sites of contention, but less attention has been paid to how these dynamics intersect throughout implementation: how conflicts unfold across implementation venues, how non-state actors combine repertoires of action, and how these struggles reshape policies after adoption. Rather than treating litigation, administrative lobbying, participation and protest as separate phenomena, we propose to examine them as dimensions of contentious implementation. Drawing on the concept of contentious politics (Tilly & Tarrow, 2007), we use contentious implementation to designate episodes in which non-state actors make claims about whether and how an adopted policy should be (re)interpreted, delivered or enforced, involving governments as targets, allies or mediators. Such contention may rely on (or combine) inside strategies with outside ones such as media campaigns or protest (Beyers, 2004). It spans implementation venues, i.e. the institutional and non-institutional settings where post-adoption decisions are made or can be challenged (Baumgartner & Jones, 1993): administrative, judicial, consultative or territorial, among others. Which venues matter, and how actors engage with them, is itself at stake. The panel addresses the following overarching questions: How do non-state actors contest policies once they have been adopted? How do they select, combine and move between different implementation venues and repertoires of action? How do the opportunities and constraints of the implementation process shape these strategies and the outcomes of contention? The panel thus aims to build a shared research agenda on contentious implementation across diverse sectors and countries.

POLICY TOPICS
Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy Interest Groups/Lobbying
P220. Uneven data, uneven policy? Spatial inequality in data-driven and AI-enabled policymaking
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Giest
B. Klievink
ABSTRACT

Governments increasingly use administrative data, predictive models and AI to define policy problems, target interventions and allocate resources. Research on data-driven and algorithmic governance has examined accountability, transparency, administrative capacity and public values, and has shown that institutional and political contexts shape how data are turned into policy decisions (Vydra & Klievink, 2019). The spatial side of these developments has received much less attention: where data are produced, where systems are deployed, and how their effects differ between places. Digital systems are typically designed to work the same way everywhere. In practice, they are built, implemented and experienced in places with very different institutions, infrastructures and social networks (Ash et al., 2018; Giest, 2025). This panel connects public policy scholarship with work on data gaps (Giest & Samuels, 2020), data justice (Heeks & Shekhar, 2019) and digital spatial justice (Tedeschi, 2024). Our starting point is that spatial inequality affects more than who has access to digital technology. It also determines what data exist about a place and how those data are read. Places and populations are unevenly represented in administrative and digital infrastructures, including official statistics, where choices about spatial units, indicators and disclosure rules determine what can be seen at which scale. A neighbourhood can be highly visible through indicators of risk or deprivation while its informal networks, social infrastructure and local capacities barely register. These partial pictures then feed into predictive models and AI-supported decisions: a welfare fraud risk model deployed only in selected low-income neighbourhoods, a deprivation index that steers regional funding, satellite-based poverty maps used for targeting. In doing so, they can entrench existing biases and produce new territorial inequalities. The panel asks: how do spatial inequalities shape data-driven and AI-enabled policymaking, and how do these technologies in turn reshape the governance of places and the distribution of public resources? We organise the panel around three dimensions: Visibility and representation: Looking at data infrastructures, models and AI systems that represent places, populations and problems selectively, for example: uneven data coverage shaping territorial needs; Differentiated implementation: Standardised digital systems that are implemented in very different local contexts, linked to, for example, local institutional capacity, digital and social infrastructure, and intermediaries such as frontline organisations, municipalities and civil society that shape how data-driven policies work; Redistribution and feedback: Related to data-driven classifications that affect territorial prioritisation, resource allocation and relations between levels of government. The panel’s theoretical contribution is to treat place as both an input to and an outcome of data-driven governance. It links this recursive relationship to core public policy concepts: policy design, implementation, governance capacity, policy feedback, and the distribution of authority and resources. References Ash, J., Kitchin, R., & Leszczynski, A. (2018). Digital turn, digital geographies? Progress in Human Geography, 42(1), 25-43. https://doi.org/10.1177/0309132516664800 Giest, S. (2025). The intersection of digital and social infrastructures in (a)spatial policymaking. Policy Sciences, 58(2), 369–384. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-025-09569-6 Giest, S., & Samuels, A. (2020). ‘For good measure’: Data gaps in a big data world. Policy Sciences, 53(3), 559–569. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-020-09384-1 Heeks, R., & Shekhar, S. (2019). Datafication, development and marginalised urban communities: An applied data justice framework. Information, Communication & Society, 22(7), 992–1011. https://doi.org/10.1080/1369118X.2019.1599039 Tedeschi, M. (2024). Datafication and urban (in)justice: Towards a digital spatial justice. Geography Compass, 18(6), e12763. https://doi.org/10.1111/gec3.12763 Vydra, S., & Klievink, B. (2019). Techno-optimism and policy-pessimism in the public sector big data debate. Government Information Quarterly, 36(4), 101383. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.giq.2019.05.010

POLICY TOPICS
Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy Urban Policy and Planning
P281. Who Delivers Net Zero? Policy Intermediaries, State Capacity, and the Politics of Evidence
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Mammadzada
ABSTRACT

Governments may announce net-zero targets, convene transition partnerships, and produce detailed roadmaps without changing investment decisions, industrial assets, or emissions. Conversely, observed emissions reductions may reflect economic shocks or falling technology costs rather than the institutions credited with delivering them. The resulting public-policy puzzle is not simply the familiar gap between ambition and action: it concerns who influences implementation, who defines evidence of success, and how institutional contributions can be distinguished from declarations of progress. Existing scholarship offers complementary explanations. Meadowcroft and Rosenbloom (2023) present net zero as politically contested, sector-specific transitions; Rosenbloom et al. (2025) show why promising interventions may create dead-end pathways. Schott and Schreurs (2021) reveal how fossil-fuel legacies shape different political settings. Policy-capacity research distinguishes analytical, operational, and political capabilities (Wu, Ramesh, and Howlett, 2015), while Kivimaa et al. (2019) and Arcand (2025) examine intermediaries and the tensions between flexibility and government control. Ryan (2022) demonstrates that judgments about facts and policy values cannot be neatly separated. Recent ex-post reviews of climate policies document heterogeneous impacts (OECD, 2025). Yet the institutional mechanisms linking these literatures to the evidence used to judge delivery remain open to debate. Our central question is: Under what conditions do policy intermediaries strengthen public capacity to implement net-zero transitions, and when do they instead create fragmented authority or misleading accounts of progress? The panel introduces a shared comparative heuristic, the “implementation evidence chain”: commitments; binding instruments; budgetary and administrative decisions; material changes in projects and practices; and environmental and distributional outcomes. This is not a linear theory or an attribution technique. It provides common points at which to investigate the actions of intermediaries, observable bottlenecks, and rival explanations. Four propositions invite scrutiny. First, intermediaries complement state capacity when mandates, financing, and political authority align, but may produce dependency where those conditions are absent. Second, autonomy facilitates experimentation under credible public accountability, yet can enable capture or goal displacement without it. Third, intermediaries act as evidence brokers as well as implementation brokers: control over indicators, reporting, and expertise may create a divergence between visible activity and independently verifiable change. Fourth, workers, Indigenous peoples, and affected communities may reshape both delivery pathways and the standards by which success is judged, with consequences for legitimacy, distribution, and durability. None of these effects is assumed; policy phase, elections, prices, and technology costs offer alternative explanations. We welcome studies across energy, industrial decarbonization, transport, and place-based transitions, including resource-dependent, northern, and lower-income contexts. Evidence may combine fieldwork, administrative records, expenditure, network data, or evaluation designs. Human-validated AI-assisted coding can help assess large policy corpora, but cannot independently establish causal impact or replace situated knowledge. The goal is a genuinely comparative debate over how net-zero policy is implemented, contested, measured, and held accountable.

POLICY TOPICS
Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Energy Policy Environment and Climate Policy
P03. The Politics of Rescaling: Democratic Backsliding, Local Governance and Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
G. YILDIRIM
ABSTRACT

The general objective of this panel is to examine how processes of territorial rescaling reshape democratic governance, political power relations, and public policy across different political systems. Building on established scholarship on state rescaling, multilevel governance, and territorial politics (Brenner, 2004; Hooghe and Marks, 2003; Keating, 1997; King & Le Galès, 2017), the panel approaches territorial scales not as fixed institutional levels but as politically constructed and continuously reconfigured spaces. It starts from the premise that centralization and decentralization are not necessarily mutually exclusive processes: they may coexist, overlap, and be selectively combined through institutional reforms, administrative practices, fiscal arrangements, and political strategies. While existing research has extensively examined the political construction of territorial scales and the changing distribution of authority across levels of government, this panel seeks to further investigate the democratic implications of these transformations. In particular, it places the relationship between territorial rescaling and democratic backsliding at the centre of its inquiry. It explores how central governments may use institutional, administrative, fiscal, and regulatory instruments to constrain local autonomy, reshape political competition, and strengthen executive control. Conversely, it also considers how local governments and subnational institutions may contribute to democratic resilience by defending political pluralism, accountability, and alternative forms of policy-making. The panel addresses three interconnected research questions: Political and institutional mechanisms: Under what political and institutional conditions do processes of centralization, decentralization, and territorial rescaling reshape the distribution of power and authority between central and subnational governments? Democratic implications: How do these processes interact with democratic backsliding, executive aggrandizement, political competition, and the erosion or resilience of local democratic institutions across different political systems? Public policy consequences: How do territorial transformations affect local autonomy, democratic accountability, policy-making capacity, and policy implementation? Under what conditions can subnational governments preserve or strengthen their capacity to act in the face of increasing central control? The scientific relevance of the panel lies in connecting established debates on territorial rescaling and multilevel governance with research on democratic backsliding and democratic resilience. Rather than assuming that decentralization necessarily promotes democratization or that centralization inevitably undermines democracy, the panel examines the political conditions and institutional mechanisms through which territorial reorganization produces different democratic outcomes. Research on decentralization has already demonstrated that the transfer of responsibilities and resources does not automatically translate into greater subnational autonomy, as outcomes depend on political actors, institutional arrangements, and the sequencing of reforms (Falleti, 2010). Similarly, recent scholarship has drawn attention to the changing forms of democratic backsliding, particularly executive aggrandizement and the strategic use of formally democratic institutions to weaken democratic constraints (Bermeo, 2016). Recent contributions have also begun to examine the relationship between recentralization and democratic erosion, particularly in countries experiencing an illiberal turn and in contexts where national governments seek to constrain opposition-led local authorities (O'Dwyer and Stenberg, 2022; Heinelt and Lackowska, 2026; Tan and Özer, 2026). Building on these emerging debates, this panel seeks to broaden the comparative scope of the discussion by examining territorial transformations across established democracies, countries experiencing democratic backsliding, and authoritarian or hybrid political systems (Ohemeng et al.2026). It also seeks to connect these debates more explicitly to public policy by investigating how territorial reorganization affects policy autonomy, institutional accountability, and the capacity of subnational governments to formulate and implement public policies. Recentralization may serve as a means of strengthening executive power and weakening opposition-led local governments, but it may also be justified or implemented through institutional arrangements that do not necessarily entail democratic erosion. Similarly, decentralization may expand local policy capacities and political participation while simultaneously reproducing central control through fiscal dependence, administrative supervision, or regulatory constraints. The panel therefore seeks to identify the mechanisms through which territorial rescaling affects the balance between central authority and local autonomy, as well as the conditions under which these transformations contribute to democratic erosion or resilience. By bringing together comparative and empirically grounded research from different political and institutional contexts, it aims to advance the study of territorial politics and public policy. Particular attention will be paid to how these transformations affect democratic representation, institutional accountability, and the capacity of subnational governments to formulate and implement public policies.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Politics, Institutions and Political Regimes
P78. Capturing policy changes and diversity related to climate change policies: issues, concepts and cases
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Wokuri
J. Tosun
ABSTRACT

Whilst Robert Keohane lamented in 2015 the slow response of political science to climate change, the past decade has seen substantial progress, notably in conceptualizing the state’s role in climate policy. Scholars have identified distinct climate and environmental policy styles and varieties of environmental and climate governance (Dubash, 2021; Tosun and Debus, 2021), state strategies to counter opposition to these policies (Meckling and Nahm, 2022), the double representation of polluting interests in policymaking and implementation (Mildenberger, 2020), and new state roles in decarbonization, such as the green developmental (Thurbon et al., 2023), catalytic (Prontera, 2023) and electro-state (Daley and Newell, 2026). This proliferation of concepts (Larsen and Jackson, 2025) is a sign of vitality, but it also raises three fundamental challenges: 1. The travelling problem (Sartori, 1970). Can these concepts travel beyond the region or category of states where they emerged, such as the green developmental state in East Asia (Dent, 2018) or the double representation of polluting interests in carbon-intensive democracies (Mildenberger, 2020), without conceptual stretching?2. The policy change problem. How can we capture the multiple dimensions of change in climate policy, including goals, instruments, stringency, institutions and implementation, as well as the factors driving them?3. The “old wine, new bottles” problem. Can established concepts such as policy paradigms (Hall, 1993; Kern et al., 2014) explain change and diversity in climate policy, or do its distinctive features create new state capacity challenges (Collington, 2026) that require new theoretical tools? This panel addresses these challenges by: -examining what facilitates and hinders comparison between countries of the Global South and the Global North (Hochstetler, 2021);-bringing together new conceptual tools for capturing the multiple dimensions and drivers of climate policy change;-assessing whether existing theories of policy change remain adequate for climate policy, or where they fall short;-evaluating the contributions and limits of different methods, such as process-tracing, mixed methods and large-N comparison.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics State and Policy Capacity
P126. Rethinking Education Privatization : Conceptual and Contextual Challenges
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Gervais
T. Ingrao
ABSTRACT

Context of the panel The privatization of education on a global scale has become a central object of study in educational policy research, mirroring the growth of the private sector since the 1990s (Ball, 2012). While early research focused primarily on North American, South American, and British contexts—where educational markets emerged as a key issue in the 1960s for the former and at the end of the 20th century for the latter—studies have since expanded to other national and international contexts. This evolution reflects both the advancement of theoretical frameworks and the increasing reliance on market mechanisms within education, in the context of the worldwide implementation of neoliberal policies. Across primary, secondary and higher education, many countries are experiencing changes that are reshaping the boundaries between the public and private sectors. These transformations take a variety of forms, including the expansion of private schooling, the diversification of funding sources, the delegation of responsibilities to private actors, and the introduction of market-oriented and managerial practices within public institutions (Ball & Youdell, 2007; Verger et al., 2016; Zancajo et al., 2025). However, privatization is not a homogeneous process. It takes different forms depending on national contexts, levels of education and institutional arrangements. The term may refer to the transfer of certain activities to private actors, changes in funding and governance arrangements, or the development of market mechanisms within public education systems. Comparative research highlights the diversity of privatization trajectories and the importance of political and institutional contexts in understanding them (Chevaillier & Pons, 2020; Zancajo et al., 2022). Research question This diversity raises a fundamental conceptual and methodological question: how can a single analytical category encompass phenomena that differ in both their underlying characteristics and their historical trajectories? To what extent does the concept of privatization help us understand these transformations without artificially homogenizing the configurations under examination? More broadly, what does it mean to compare education systems through a category whose manifestations and uses vary across contexts? Objectives This panel seeks to explore these questions through three main lines of inquiry. First, what characterizes privatization processes across different education systems and levels of education? Second, what are the contributions and limitations of the concept of privatization in analyzing this diversity and developing meaningful international comparisons? Finally, how can observed variations be explained considering the historical trajectories of education systems, political ideas, and competing understandings of the role of the state in funding, organizing and regulating education?Bringing together historical, sociological, geographical, political and comparative perspectives, the panel welcomes theoretical, empirical and methodological contributions focusing on different spatial contexts and levels of education. It aims to deepen our understanding of national configurations of privatization, the conditions under which they emerge, and the conceptual tools through which they can be compared. Ultimately, the panel seeks to contribute to a context-sensitive analysis of the changing relationships between public and private actors in education, while critically examining the analytical scope of privatization as a concept in international research.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Multilevel Governance and Local Policy Education Policy
P52. From Policy Design to Household Adoption: Behavioural and Structural Determinants of Rural Energy Transitions in the Global South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Balogun
T. Ojo
S. Maxwell
ABSTRACT

Background Achieving universal access to affordable, reliable, and sustainable energy remains a major challenge across the Global South, where many rural households continue to rely on traditional biomass fuels for cooking and heating. These practices contribute to environmental degradation, greenhouse gas emissions, health risks, and deforestation. In response, governments, development agencies, and private-sector actors have promoted renewable and decentralized energy technologies such as improved cookstoves, biogas systems, solar home systems, and mini-grids to support energy security, poverty reduction, climate resilience, and sustainable development. However, adoption and sustained use of these technologies often remain below expectations despite substantial investments and policy support. This gap raises important policy questions regarding the factors influencing technology adoption and the effectiveness of intervention strategies. Emerging research suggests that technological solutions alone cannot explain adoption patterns. Instead, energy decisions are shaped by a combination of social, cultural, economic, political, and institutional factors, including infrastructure availability, financing, governance, gender relations, social norms, risk perceptions, and local knowledge systems. Understanding rural energy transitions therefore requires attention to both behavioural and structural determinants. This panel seeks to advance scholarly understanding of how public policy can facilitate sustainable and equitable rural energy transitions across the Global South by contributing to debates concerning policy design, implementation, governance, sustainability transitions, and development outcomes. To address the concerns raised here, the panel focuses on these four objectives: 1. First, it aims to advance theoretical debates regarding the relationship between behavioural dynamics, structural conditions, and policy outcomes in rural energy transitions. 2. Second, it seeks to identify empirical evidence on the effectiveness of policy interventions promoting renewable energy adoption among rural households. 3. Third, it aims to foster interdisciplinary dialogue among scholars working in public policy, energy governance, environmental studies, development studies, economics, sociology, behavioural science, and sustainability transitions. 4. Fourth, it seeks to generate policy-relevant insights that can inform future efforts to design, implement, and evaluate renewable energy programs in developing-country contexts. These objectives will address the following overarching questions: 1. What behavioural factors influence the adoption and sustained use of renewable energy technologies among rural households in the Global South? 2. How do structural factors, including institutions, governance arrangements, market conditions, infrastructure, and socio-economic inequalities, shape rural energy transitions? 3. How do behavioural and structural determinants interact to facilitate or constrain technology adoption? 4. Which public policy instruments and governance mechanisms most effectively support renewable energy transitions in rural communities? 5. How can policymakers design context-sensitive interventions that promote equitable and inclusive adoption of clean energy technologies? 6. What lessons can be drawn from comparative experiences across countries and regions in the Global South? Scientific Relevance of the Panel to the Conference This panel advances public policy scholarship by examining how governance, institutions, and policy interventions shape sustainable energy transitions in the Global South. It foregrounds context-specific challenges, behavioural and structural determinants of adoption, supports evidence-based policymaking, and contributes to achieving multiple SDGs, including energy access, climate action, health, gender equality, and poverty reduction.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Policy Transfer/Diffusion/Learning Development Policy Social Policy
P53. Governance in the Anthropocene: What are the Prospects for Planetary Public Policy?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
D. Stone
ABSTRACT

Concepts surrounding ‘Planetary Thinking’ have entered the social sciences and humanities – notably History, Law and International Relations (IR). By contrast, the fields of Policy Studies and Public Administration have had limited engagement with Earth Systems Science, ecological or multi-species ontologies, concepts of the ‘global commons’ that present different imaginaries of policy making to that of the nation-state cartographies of administrative sovereignty. Anthropocentric policy making is not inevitable. Other ways of composing the Earth exist and can provide additional ways of creating and conducting policy and administration. The challenge is not simply to add in the non-human or other-than-human agency or structures to policy comprehension of existing legal-administrative frameworks. Instead, a planetary approach to administrative and policy studies posits that the scale and composition of the world transforms when humans are no longer presumed to be its sole authors and governing agents. With the intensification of climate crisis, the language of the planetary has emerged as an important conceptual alternative to the ‘global’ -- a term which had already emerged as challenge to the conceptual limitations of the term ‘international’. Accordingly, the idea of ‘Planetary Public Policy’ goes far beyond the methodological nationalism of existing policy scholarship that has been built within and evolved from the governance contexts of national systems of decision making and implementation. The body of scholarly work on The Planetary has grown significantly. Landmark publications have been generated inter alia, by Spivak (2015), Chakrabarty (2021), and Blake & Gilman (2024). Environmental studies has been at the forefront of this endeavour (Dalby 2024). International Relations as a field has engaged with the planetary as disruptions of ‘the international’ and ‘the global’ (Ramel, 2025) or raising new questions about democracy (Nikolaidis 2024). The idea of ‘Planetary Health’ has made significant strides challenging the human centric understandings of traditional public health paradigms and of OneHealth paradigm of the WHO and other international actors. Clearly, the planetary idea is shaping our understandings of ‘politics’ (Or, 2025; Lind & Friis, 2025). But what does Policy Studies have to say? This panel seeks to address what ‘the planetary’ may mean in policy scholarship and administrative praxis, including examining the limitations of this approach. How have Public Policy and Administration, in conjunction with related disciplines, understood and imagined the category of the planet as a subject and space of governance. That is, the vocabularies, assumptions, and imaginaries through which planetary problems are framed with the legacy of inherited legal and political languages of world-ordering. That is, dominant ideational and institutional constructions of the nation-state where public authority has been stabilised. An Earth-centred conception of Public Policy & Administration potentially shifts policy care and responsibilities alongside regulatory and administrative action to a new conceptual locus. This can occur even if power and authority remain tightly hinged to existing state-based institutional structures.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Multilevel Governance and Local Policy General Public Policy (no specific sector) Global and Transnational Policies
P58. The Transformation of Policy Process under Digitalization
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
H. Inatsugu
J. Nishide
A. SATO
ABSTRACT

Digitalization is transforming not only the means by which citizens and stakeholders participate in policymaking, but also the venues in which policy interactions take place. Traditionally, much citizen participation and stakeholder engagement has been organized around geographically bounded communities and administrative jurisdictions. Digital technologies, however, may facilitate the emergence of forums organized around specific policy problems, issues, and interests that cut across conventional territorial and institutional boundaries. Online platforms, civic tech initiatives, and issue-specific digital networks now allow geographically dispersed and institutionally unconnected actors to deliberate, share information, and coordinate action on common problems.This transformation raises important questions for the study of policy processes. How does digitalization affect the formation, structure, and evolution of policy forums? Under what conditions do issue-based forums emerge and persist? How do actors participate in multiple forums simultaneously, and how do interactions among these forums shape policy coordination, learning, conflict, and change? Moreover, does digitalization create genuinely new policy venues, or does it merely reproduce existing institutional and political structures in a new technological environment?These questions matter, first, for theory. A growing body of policy process research, including the Ecology of Games Framework (Lubell 2013) and the literature on policy forums (Fischer and Leifeld 2015), conceptualizes governance as a system of multiple interdependent decision-making venues. Yet these frameworks have largely been developed and tested in settings where forums are defined by jurisdictional, sectoral, or resource boundaries, such as regional environmental and water governance. Whether their core assumptions about forum boundaries, actor participation, and inter-forum spillovers hold when venues are constituted digitally and organized around issues remains an open empirical question. Digitalization therefore provides a critical test case for refining, extending, or challenging existing theories of the policy process.Second, these questions matter for practice. Governments in many countries are investing in digital participation platforms and collaboration with civic tech communities, often on the assumption that digital channels broaden and deepen participation. Understanding how such channels reshape the configuration of policy forums, and whether they connect to or bypass formal decision-making institutions, is essential for assessing their democratic legitimacy and effectiveness. At the same time, digital forums may privilege actors with greater resources, technical skills, or network centrality, reproducing rather than mitigating existing inequalities.Finally, the panel seeks to foster comparative dialogue. Administrative traditions, central-local relations, and levels of digital government maturity are likely to condition how issue-based forums emerge and interact with territorial institutions. By bridging theories that conceptualize policymaking as taking place across multiple, overlapping venues of interaction with empirical studies from diverse national and policy contexts, the panel aims to identify the conditions under which digitalization generates new policy venues and to clarify how the architecture of policymaking is changing in the digital age.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy Administration and Civil Service Policy
P205. Pathways to Institutional and Policy Changes: Structure and Agency
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
W. Li
ABSTRACT

Scholarship studying policy change and innovation has been informed by historical institutionalist approaches, such as Institutional Analysis and Development, Policy Diffusion and Innovation, Punctuated Equilibrium Framework, Policy Feedback Theory, and Ecology of Games Framework (Weible 2023). Debates centre on the drivers of institutional change: whether these stem from exogenous shocks at critical junctures, or from endogenous incremental mechanisms such as policy conversion, layering, and drift that unfold during long periods of stability (Beland, 2007). Scholars also have different views on whether the incremental or drastic mode of policy change is inevitable and preferable given the prevailing political contexts, or whether such change can be deliberately shaped by the agency and ideational work of policy actors. In competitive multiparty systems, incrementalism is framed as a pluralistic process in which proposals depart only modestly from the status quo, accumulating over time to produce substantial policy transformation. This mode facilitates consensus-building around policy goals and enables the development of a robust knowledge base amid partisan polarisation (Hayes, 2022). By contrast, disruptive policy change—theorised by Baumgartner and Jones within punctuated equilibrium theory—entails paradigm shifts arising from interactions between policy images and policy venues. Such interactions can unravel entrenched interest configurations and enable responses to urgent systemic crises (Baumgartner & Jones, 1991). Radical reforms nonetheless carry considerable implementation risks, high transaction costs, and unanticipated side effects; they tend to become viable when policy windows open (Kingdon, 2014). This panel welcomes contributions to unpack how dynamics of institutional and policy change unfold across diverse issue domains, where different ideas and policy instruments may shape the trajectories of positive and negative feedback (Daugbjerg and Kay 2020). Illustrative contested topics include, but are not limited to: trade-offs between ecosystem conservation and economic development (Glavina et al., 2025); tensions between cultural diversity and social integration (Bloemraad & Wright, 2018); and the benefits and harms associated with disruptive technological advancement (Coninx & Lohr, 2026). Reference: Baumgartner, F. R., & Jones, B. D. (1991) Agenda dynamics and policy subsystems. The Journal of Politics, 53(4), 1044–1074. Bloemraad, Irene & Matthew Wright. (2018) “Utter Failure” or Unity out of Diversity? Debating and Evaluating Policies of Multiculturalism. International Migration Review, 48:292-334. Coninx, Sabrina and Guido Lohr (2026) Rethinking Disruptive Technologies: Benefits, Harms and Injustice of Human Niche Construction. Philosophy and Technology, 39(58): 1-25. Daugbjerg, Carsten and Adrian Kay (2020) Policy Feedback and Pathways: When Change Leads to Endurance and Continuity to Change. Policy Sciences, 53: 253-268. Glavina, Ana, Katarina Misic, Jakov Baleta, Jin Wang and Hrvoje Mikulcic. (2025) Economic Development and Climate Change: Achieving a Sustainable Balance. Cleaner Engineering and Technology. Hayes, Michael (2022) Incrementalism and Public Policy-making. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics (In Progress). Erin Hannah (editor in chief).Kingdon, J. W. (2014). Agendas, alternatives, and public policies (2nd ed.). Pearson Education Limited.Weible, M. Christopher edit (2023) Theories of the Policy Process. Routledge. Beland, Daniel (2007) Ideas and institutional change in social security: Conversion, Layering and Policy Drift. Social Science Quarterly, 88(1):20-38.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics
P251. Policy Reform Without Institutional Consolidation: Political Disruption and Interrupted Development in the Post-Independence Global South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
H. Ali
M. Farag
S. Bhuiyan
T. Qarmout
ABSTRACT

Panel Description Since independence, many countries across the Global South have pursued ambitious economic, political, administrative, and institutional reforms aimed at accelerating development, strengthening state capacity, and overcoming colonial legacies. These initiatives have included national development plans, industrialization strategies, agricultural modernization, public-sector expansion, fiscal reforms, infrastructure investment, and efforts to build professional public administrations. Yet the development trajectories of many of these countries are frequently characterized as histories of persistent policy failure, institutional weakness, and economic underperformance. Such interpretations often overlook an important distinction between policy reform, institutional progress, and development outcomes. The inability to achieve sustained economic growth or long-term institutional effectiveness does not necessarily imply that earlier reforms were poorly conceived, inadequately implemented, or entirely unsuccessful. In many cases, governments made measurable progress in expanding productive capacity, developing public institutions, improving infrastructure, and introducing administrative reforms. However, these achievements were subsequently interrupted, reversed, or undermined by political instability, military coups, civil conflicts, changes in political leadership, external economic shocks, and competing elite interests. This panel advances the argument that interrupted development, rather than continuous policy failure, may provide a more accurate explanation of the post-independence experience of many countries in the Global South. It seeks to examine why promising episodes of reform and institutional development frequently failed to consolidate into durable economic and social outcomes. The panel also challenges the assumption that developing countries necessarily lacked the institutional capacity or political commitment to initiate meaningful reforms. Instead, it invites closer examination of the political and institutional conditions that determine whether reform achievements survive changes in government, shifts in development strategies, and periods of economic or political crisis. A central concern is the relationship between institutional continuity and political instability. Development policies often require sustained investment, administrative learning, policy coordination, and long-term political commitment. Yet institutions in many postcolonial states have operated within environments characterized by contested political authority, limited bureaucratic autonomy, patronage networks, and recurrent struggles over the distribution of public resources. Under such conditions, institutions may possess sufficient capacity to initiate reforms but lack the political protection, organizational autonomy, and institutional embeddedness necessary to sustain them. The panel further considers how colonial institutional legacies, external dependencies, natural resource rents, international financial institutions, and global economic conditions have shaped the continuity or disruption of national development strategies. Particular attention will be given to the interaction between domestic political institutions and external pressures, including structural adjustment programs, debt crises, commodity-price volatility, and geopolitical interventions. Rather than treating development as a linear progression from reform to successful outcomes, the panel encourages historical and comparative approaches that identify distinct episodes of policy initiation, institutional expansion, political disruption, reform reversal, and attempted reconstruction. This perspective allows researchers to distinguish between the original effectiveness of a reform, the institutional conditions necessary for its survival, and the long-term consequences of repeated disruption. Key Questions The panel welcomes theoretical, empirical, historical, and comparative contributions addressing questions such as: Policy progress versus development outcomes: How can researchers distinguish genuine policy and institutional progress from long-term development outcomes? Under what conditions might reforms initially succeed but subsequently fail to produce lasting results?Political instability and institutional continuity: How do military coups, regime changes, civil conflicts, political exclusion, and elite competition interrupt development strategies and undermine institutional learning?Colonial legacies and institutional fragility: To what extent have colonial administrative structures constrained institutional consolidation and the continuity of post-independence development policies?Economic reform and external dependency: How have foreign borrowing, structural adjustment, international financial institutions, natural resource dependence, and external economic shocks contributed to reform reversals or interrupted development?State capacity and reform sustainability: Why are some states capable of initiating ambitious development programs but unable to sustain them? What roles do bureaucratic autonomy, political accountability, institutional legitimacy, and administrative professionalism play?Comparative development trajectories: Why have some countries managed to protect reform achievements across political transitions while others have experienced repeated cycles of institutional expansion and collapse?Policy implications: What institutional arrangements and political conditions can protect development policies from political disruption? How should reform sequencing, institution-building, and long-term development planning be reconsidered?Scope and Contributions We invite papers examining experiences from Africa, the Middle East, Asia, Latin America, and other regions of the Global South. Contributions may focus on individual countries, comparative case studies, cross-national quantitative analysis, or historical institutional approaches. Particularly welcome are studies using longitudinal evidence on economic growth, fiscal balances, public investment, industrial development, state capacity, governance indicators, political instability, and institutional performance. Papers that trace policy reforms across successive political regimes, identify critical moments of institutional disruption, or compare countries with contrasting reform trajectories are especially encouraged. We also welcome contributions that engage critically with established explanations of development failure, including institutionalist theories, the political economy of reform, historical institutionalism, state-capacity approaches, dependency theory, and the political economy of conflict.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Policy Transfer/Diffusion/Learning Development Policy Regional Policy
P76. Frugal and Robust Policy Innovations and Their Global Diffusion
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Kemmerling
N. Goyal
M. Dussauge
ABSTRACT

We face numerous grand challenges that call for innovative policy solutions, such as affordable housing, climate change, economic inequality, energy transition, and technological disruption. Increasingly, these solutions must also work amid eroding credibility, contested legitimacy, and persistent resource scarcity. Governments worldwide have responded with a wide range of innovations, such as new problem framings (e.g., modifying the social contract), novel policy instruments (e.g., carbon pricing or nudges), or changes in policy processes and practices (e.g., behavioral insights teams, cocreation, or digital governance). Much research on policy innovation has focused on innovations in the Global North and their diffusion to other countries around the world. Recent research has, however, documented many innovations from the Global South that may be appropriate for other countries in the South and in the North. Even as some innovations—such as conditional cash transfers and participatory budgeting—have diffused widely, many others do not receive the recognition they deserve. Policy learning, transfer, and diffusion from the South to the North face persistent barriers. This panel asserts that innovations developed under scarcity may have characteristics that make them effective elsewhere. Specifically, we focus on robust and frugal policy innovations. We define robust policy innovations as those that perform well despite context variation and resource scarcity. Meanwhile, we conceive frugal policy innovations are those that build governing capacity under persistent resource constraints, rather than merely cutting costs or substituting for missing capacity. They prioritize sufficiency over optimality and are adapted to local institutional and social contexts. The key questions addressed by this panel are: (i) Which characteristics make policy innovations robust and/ or frugal? (ii) Which governing capacities do frugal policy innovations create, and through which policy designs? (iii) Under which conditions do policy innovations travel between world regions? When does cross-border learning happen, and when does it fail? The panel puts forth several propositions: - Innovations designed under persistent resource constraints are more robust to contextual variation than those designed under abundance. - Frugal innovations build governing capacity primarily by drawing on societal capacities rather than by expanding state resources. - Cross border learning, diffusion and transfer (including from South to North) is impeded less by the technical fit than by asymmetries of status, power and epistemic authority. - As fiscal pressure and crises intensify in the Global North, demand for robust and frugal solutions will grow, increasing the likelihood of adopting frugal and robust solutions. The panel advances research on policy innovation theoretically by deepening its synthesis with research on policy capacity, policy design, and policy learning; and empirically by focusing on policy innovations in understudied contexts (such as those in the Global South). Further, it also strengthens the practical relevance of research on policy innovation by identifying robust and frugal policy innovations as well as characteristics that can facilitate their diffusion.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Policy Transfer/Diffusion/Learning
P81. Policy Analysis and Policy Dynamics in Japan
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Tanke
H. Takahashi-Romanelli
ABSTRACT

In October 2025, in a historical moment, Sanae Takaichi became the first female prime minister of Japan. Since then, her leadership has raised questions about the relationship between political change and policy continuity in Japan. In this panel, we aim at examining policy developments under her administration and contributing to a broader understanding of Japanese public policymaking, building on existing research on policy analysis in Japan (Adachi, Hosono and Iio, 2015). This panel pursues two main objectives: to assess whether and where policy has changed, and to explain what accounts for change or continuity. First, regarding change, this can be of first order (adjust policy instruments and targets), second order (alter policy instruments but not the hierarchy of policy goals), or third order (change policy settings, hierarchy of goals and set of instruments) (Hall 1993). In this sense and in the Japanese context, is there anything special to Takaichi’s governing style, in terms of prime ministerial leadership, decision-making processes, relations with the Diet and public opinion, discourse and narratives on public policy, or the definition and framing of policy problems? Can we compare her to influential former prime minister Shinzo Abe (Minohara 2025)? This panel is interested in a variety of policy domains, both domestically and internationally, such as, but not limited to, environmental policy, nuclear policy, economic policy, education policy, culture policy, social policy, employment policy, migration policy, security policy, foreign policy, development policy, etc. In particular, we encourage studies for this panel concerning gender, diversity and inclusion during Takaichi’s administration, for instance on the relationship between descriptive and substantive representation. Demographic changes are a major issue for Japanese politics. In this context, who is included (foreign workers, employment of women…) and under what conditions (policies of care…)? Secondly, we also wonder about the causes of policy dynamics in Japan. In this context, we can distinguish different types of main actors of public policy (Muller 2009), such as the first circle (prime minister and close collaborators), second circle (administration in charge of specific sectors), third circle (non state actors, interest groups), and possibly a fourth circle (political organs). Policy change can be linked here for instance to change in actors’ cognitive and normative structures and beliefs (Muller 2005). Advocacy coalitions can be an interesting framework to explain important changes (Sabatier 1998) and impact (deep) core beliefs of secondary beliefs. In the Japanese case, if there are major changes, where do they come from, who are the central actors, who takes the lead in the policy process? We are interested in explanations linked to relations between interest groups, citizens and the bureaucracy, to multilevel governance and local policy, among others. If there is very little evolution in public policy and policy processes, despite major changes in the political landscape, why is that? Overall, we could imagine at least three different hypotheses: substantial change across policy domains since Takaichi’s access to power, selective change confined to specific areas, and considerable continuity in policies and policymaking processes. By investigating these patterns and the mechanisms underlying them, the panel aims to advance understanding of contemporary Japanese public policy.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics
P119. Developing “good” evidence for system reform in health, disability, and mental health policy landscapes: challenges, opportunities, and impact.
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Hollier
J. Smith-Merry
ABSTRACT

Globally, health, mental health, and disability systems are routinely described as “fractured”, “stretched” and “underfunded”. While international levers such as the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disability (UNCRPD) and Article 25 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (the right to health) have garnered widespread support, there remains sharp disparities in accessibility, availability, and quality of supports. This dynamic is true of both the (so-called) Global South, where resource scarcity is a lived reality, and the Global North, where funding allocation decisions result in thin care infrastructure. Concurrently, governments and policy makers range widely in their openness to new models of care, willingness to engage with emerging evidence, and desire to implement change. Academics, practitioners, advocates, and people with lived experience all seek to influence change, but find themselves behest to systems which often don’t recognise their knowledge as valid or influential. This panel critically engages with diverse disciplines, geographies and political settings to explore what constitutes “good” evidence for informing health, mental health, and disability system reform. We welcome critical and interpretive approaches to the topic. We would encourage papers that consider critically the following topics: 1) What forms of evidence constitute “good” evidence for reform? 2) How do governments utilise different forms of evidence developed and disseminated to identify unmet needs and priorities across health, mental health, and disability system reform? 3) What methods of evidence gathering or knowledge dissemination lead to perceived policy impact? 4) How do communities, care and support recipients, and persons with disability participate in the evidence collection, analysis, and dissemination processes for policy evidence? How is the knowledge from these ‘lived experience’ voices included in policy design? By exploring these questions, this panel aims to contribute to ongoing discourse regarding the shaping of evidence-informed-policy making in health, mental health, and disability. We hypothesise that diverse disciplines bring diverse ways of understanding what constitutes “good” evidence. We also hypothesise that “good” is contextually bound, and that policy players seeking to influence outcomes actively modify their research modes in response to what policy makers desire. This panel’s scientific relevance lies in its drawing together of diverse disciplines, contexts, and policy landscapes to synthesis insights regarding the creation of evidence for policy. By giving voice to interdisciplinary insights, we hope to provide critical insights into the ongoing task of shaping impactful research that can be utilised to inform policy.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Methods & Research Design Health and Well-Being Policy
P125. Policy Integration and Artificial Intelligence in the Public Sector
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Trein
C. CRESPY
M. Maggetti
D. Schiff
ABSTRACT

Artificial intelligence (AI) has become a central topic for policymakers around the world. It offers potentially important technological possibilities but also poses significant regulatory challenges for decision-makers. The public sector faces the task of integrating a variety of AI tools into existing public services and governance processes. At the same time, an extensive body of scholarly literature is emerging that addresses various aspects of AI in the public sector. Some studies aim to conceptualize and assess empirically how AI should be and is used in public administration, balancing risks and opportunities. Other research focuses on the politicization of AI in the policy process, including social acceptance of AI. The role of AI in the public sector is a cross-cutting issue. It transcends jurisdictional boundaries within countries, spans multiple policy sectors—such as health, energy, mobility, and public security—and even extends across national borders. Effective AI regulation, therefore, requires coordination across policy sectors, levels of government and potentially across countries. Nevertheless, the cross-sectorality of AI remains underexplored in the current empirical research. In order to be able to effectively regulate AI and harness its benefits for the public sector, it is of utmost importance to understand the challenges and realities of how it can be governed across and within policy sectors and jurisdictions. This panel proposes to examine the topic of artificial intelligence from the perspective of policy integration. In very general terms, the concept of policy integration aims at analyzing governance across sectors. In other words, it refers to the process of incorporating complex and cross-cutting issues into various sectoral policies and across different levels of government. Policy integration can be combined with other concepts for the analysis of complexity in public policy, such as policy coordination, policy mixes, boundary spanning policy regimes, multilevel governance, and polycentric governance. In this workshop, we seek to apply this broad policy integration perspective to the analysis of AI policymaking, implementation and regulation across policy sectors, levels of government, types of policy instruments, as well as across countries. Specifically, we invite papers addressing questions, such as the following: How and why is AI conceptualized as a cross-cutting or sector-specific policy problem, and how do these framings influence whether AI governance becomes centralized, fragmented, or coordinated across sectors and levels of government? Which types of policy mixes (e.g., soft law, regulation, incentives, capacity-building) exist in AI governance and how can these instruments arrangements be explained? How does AI governance build on existing policy domains such as data protection, digital government, or labor policy, and what tensions or synergies arise from these overlaps? What institutional mechanisms facilitate or hinder coordination in AI policymaking at different scales, and how do different governance arrangements balance design considerations like centralization and decentralization? Under what conditions does greater policy integration or coordination improve (or undermine) the coherence, accountability, legitimacy, or effectiveness of AI governance? To what extent could AI policies constitute a model for the governance of other emerging technologies such as quantum technologies?

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Regulation and Regulatory Governance Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy Administration and Civil Service Policy
P143. Culture and Territories: Attractiveness, Inequalities and Power Relations in Local Cultural Policies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Polo
L. Arnaud
T. Kernalegenn
ABSTRACT

Local cultural policies involve a wide range of actors (elected officials, public institutions, cultural professionals, associations, artistic collectives, citizen initiatives), from neighborhood projects to flagship international events. This panel examines how local cultural action helps produce and transform territories, identities and social relations, by bringing together three purposes often studied separately: - culture as a tool for territorial promotion, through marketing, attractiveness and the showcasing of heritage that builds territorial identity (García, 2004);- culture as a factor of social cohesion and a space for mobilization and collective capacities to act (Arnaud, 2018);- culture as a stake in ecological transformation, through adapting facilities to climate constraints and the emergence of new priorities, funding criteria and inequalities (Oakley & Ward, 2018). These purposes are not simply juxtaposed: actors mobilize them differently depending on the arenas and audiences they address. They may also compete, notably when cultural promotion strengthens attractiveness without benefiting those who produce a territory’s wealth, or when environmental requirements change access to public resources. How do local cultural actors reconcile artistic, heritage and social objectives with the imperatives of development and attractiveness? What power relations structure these trade-offs, and with what consequences for resource distribution, territorial inequalities and residents’ capacity to act? The panel is organized around three axes: 1.Legitimation. How are the same cultural initiatives justified in terms of attractiveness, cohesion, territorial identity or ecological transition, depending on the audience (elected officials, economic and tourism stakeholders, residents, European funders)? We hypothesize that this versatility lets sometimes contradictory objectives coexist, at the cost of ambiguous evaluation.2.Trade-offs, governance and territorial inequalities. Under budgetary constraint, which actors and priorities shape the allocation of cultural resources? Are projects enhancing metropolitan prestige favored, at the risk of reinforcing territorial inequalities (Bianchini and Parkinson, 1993)?3.Participation, cultural rights and collective capacities to act. Beyond participatory discourse, to what extent can residents define their priorities and control their resources (Carrel, 2013)? How do associations and collectives build their capacities for action, between institutional cooperation and autonomy? Scientific relevance. By combining research on territorial attractiveness, social cohesion, cultural rights and ecological transition, the panel examines the power relations running through local cultural action and how public, private and voluntary-sector actors manage contradictory objectives. Open to qualitative, quantitative and comparative approaches, it aims to contribute to a political sociology of cultural action attentive to tensions between institutional logics, territorial transformations and actors’ autonomy. References -Arnaud, L. (2018). Agir par la culture : Acteurs, enjeux et mutations des mouvements culturels. Éditions de l'Attribut. -Bianchini, F., Parkinson, M. (dir.). (1993). Cultural Policy and Urban Regeneration: The West European Experience, Manchester, Manchester University Press. -Carrel, M. (2013). Faire participer les habitants ? Citoyenneté et pouvoir d'agir dans les quartiers populaires, Lyon, ENS Éditions. -García, B. (2004). Cultural policy and urban regeneration in Western European cities: Lessons from experience, prospects for the future. Local Economy, 19(4), 312–326. -Oakley, K., & Ward, J. (2018). The art of the good life: Culture and sustainable prosperity. Cultural Trends, 27(1), 4-17.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Citizens, Participation and Social Movements Cultural Policy Urban Policy and Planning
P171. Securitising the policy process: Re-orienting and re-structuring public policymaking and policy processes?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Coban
A. Asquer
ABSTRACT

National security has become a fundamental concern around the world, which influences multiple policy areas. After the 9/11 in 2001, security and survival emerged in political and policy agendas both in the Western countries and elsewhere. More recently, the dominance of security in policy discourse and policy actions have grabbed the headlines: securing access to critical minerals, enforcing border control such as against adversary ships or migrant boats, exerting control over chokepoints such as the Strait of Hormuz or the Panama Canal, attaining digital sovereignty, and intensifying domestic extraction and mining (Calvo et al. 2025; Edwards 2026), among others, have (re-)ignited the economic and political survival instincts and logics. Security, as a theme and the way policy problems are framed and approached, is increasingly occupying governmental agendas. The gradual dominance of security in governmental and political agendas is shaping policymakers’ approach to policy problems, including how they frame problems and which policies and policy instruments are offered to address security concerns. In other words, policymaking and the policy process are becoming increasingly securitised. For instance, surveillance instruments (e.g., algorithms, face recognition, AI) tend to securitise state-society relations (Cugurullo and Xu 2025), social policy can be approached from a security logic than its welfare-oriented tenets (Ragazzi 2017), and global security and defence firms re-structure state-business relations, whilst leading to collaborative arrangements between states and security or technology firms (Khanal et al. 2026), not only for domestic security concerns, but also to address those at the international level by suspending global firms’ operations due to security concerns. As a result of the increasingly securitised policymaking and policy processes, actors’ ideational and material positions and their influence over the policy processes are re-defined: new actors may emerge and exert influence over public administration and public policymaking (Batora and Konikova 2025), the rise of military as an influential actor over public administration in different parts of the world through appointments in civil bureaucracy and policy implementation among other roles (Cunha et al. 2026), public procurement processes are subject to lobbying and/or processual changes in line with securitisation, public expenditure priorities and policies can transform states (Kruck and Weiss 2023), and can even cause conflicts within cabinets. This Panel invites manuscripts that contribute to our understanding of the drivers and consequences of securitisation of policymaking and re-orientation and re-structuring of policy processes. References Batora, Jozef, and Kamila Konikova. 2025. Private military and security companies and the European Union as an enmeshed security and defence actor. Journal of Common Market Studies 63(6): 1783-1804. Croissant, Aurel et al. 2024. Remilitarization in Asia: Trends and implications. GIGA Focus Asia, Number 2. Cugurullo, Federico, and Ying Xu. 2025. When AIs become oracles: Generative artificial intelligence, anticipatory urban governance, and the future of cities. Policy and Society 44(1): 98-115. Cunha, Bruno Q., Felix G. Lopez, and M. Kerem Coban. 2026. The unexpected actor? Civil-military relations and regulatory agency control in Brazil. Governance 39(1):e70106. Edwards, Nico. 2026. The military green transition: Decarbonisation as warfighting opportunity. Political Geography 129:103573. Khanal, Shaleen, Hongzhou Zhang, and Araz Taeihagh. 2026. The rise of Big Tech as super policy entrepreneurs. Policy and Society. DOI: 10.1093/polsoc/puag005 Kruck, Andreas, and Moritz Weiss. 2023. The regulatory security state in Europe. Journal of European Public Policy 30(7): 1205-1229. Ragazzi, Francesco. 2017. Countering terrorism and radicalisation: Securitising social policy? Critical Social Policy 37(2): 163-179.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Policy Process Theories General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P180. Morality Politics in Times of Backlash and Backsliding: Preventing, Reversing and Dismantling Moral Policies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Alza
C. Tomazini
J. del Cid Castro
ABSTRACT

Over the past decade, advances in LGBTIQ+ rights, gender equality and sexual and reproductive rights have met organised, transnationally connected opposition, while governments across Europe, the Americas and beyond have made hostility to these rights a political resource. Political science has responded with a vocabulary of regression that is itself under debate. Backlash names the mobilisation of those who feel their power threatened by a policy change, which undermines its support and constrains its institutionalisation (Mansbridge and Shames, 2008; Patashnik, 2019). Democratic backsliding names the gradual, often state-led erosion of democratic institutions, although critics argue that the paradigm flattens trajectories into progress, stagnation or regression and conceals the exclusions on which apparently stable democracies rest (Cianetti and Hanley, 2021). Policy dismantling names the reduction of policies, their instruments or the capacities to implement them (Bauer and Knill, 2012), and research on gender and social policy shows that regression proceeds less through repeal than through delegitimation, hollowed-out implementation and drift (Roggeband and Krizsán, 2018). Morality politics offers a privileged but underused terrain for these debates. Moral policies are those in which conflict turns on first principles rather than on means (Engeli, Green-Pedersen and Larsen, 2013). Understood as a process, moralisation can reach almost any policy, since actors strategically moralise or de-moralise issues (Mucciaroni, 2011) and anti-gender campaigns have turned ostensibly instrumental fields such as education into moral battlegrounds (Tomazini, 2025). Yet this literature was built largely on cases of permissive change in Western Europe and North America, and has paid little attention to the long periods in which moral policies do not change, to what becomes of their defenders once they change, or to how recognised rights are later eroded. Recent research on Latin America points in that direction: the agenda-setting dynamics that keep abortion decriminalisation off the table in Central America (del Cid Castro and del Castillo Alemán, 2025) and the conditions and mechanisms through which same-sex unions have been blocked for decades (Alza Barco, 2025, forthcoming). This panel brings these literatures into dialogue. Its research question is: how are moral policies prevented, reversed or dismantled, by which actors and mechanisms, and what does this reveal about the relationship between policy regression and democratic regression? Three lines of inquiry organise the discussion: whether preventing a right and undoing it are phases of a single process sustained by the same actors and moral repertoires; whether coalitions defeated on one moral policy displace their activity to adjacent policies, including digital platforms and the governance of artificial intelligence; and whether regression in moral policies operates mainly through ideational and administrative means that leave formal rules intact and escape existing indicators of backsliding. The panel welcomes contributions from all regions and methodological traditions. Its relevance lies in distinguishing stasis, backlash, reversal and dismantling as different outcomes with different mechanisms, and in offering the study of democratic regression a policy-level account of how rights are lost, or never won, within formally intact democracies.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition General Public Policy (no specific sector) Other
P92. Policy Transfer and Diffusion beyond North-to-South Flows
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Sacramento
B. Ahn
ABSTRACT

One of the most compelling questions in the study of policy transfer and diffusion is how we can bring the discourse beyond the mainstream North-to-South flows. Policy transfer and diffusion scholarship gives considerable attention to policy issues, particularly in a time of high complexity and uncertainty, when we cannot help but look at how policies work elsewhere and consider their potential when brought into our own context. On the one hand, policy transfer concerns more deliberately the micro-level processes by which policy knowledge, governance structures, and best practices generated in one context or political environment are actively imported and used in another. On the other hand, policy diffusion is broader, covering macro-level processes in which policy innovations, ideas, and norms spread, and in which decisions in one government or political environment are influenced or conditioned by the prior actions, choices, and decisions of other governments. Contemporary scholarship on policy transfer and diffusion has largely concentrated on, if not given immense attention to, the movement of policies from developed, OECD, and affluent countries, broadly described as the Global North. We take these works as our point of departure in arriving at a critical response, questioning in turn how policy knowledge from the Global South also travels to, and is mobilized in, the North. Policies also move between Southern cities, among Northern cities, within regions, and across scales, and they are reworked at each stop. Our goal is not to remain within a dichotomous framing, the usual North-South binary, as such a geographic framing may be too limiting once we take seriously the diversity, complexity, and uncertainty of policymaking across countries and cities. We therefore ask: how are policies transferred and diffused beyond the common North-South flows? One of the key topical areas in policy transfer and diffusion work is urban policy and planning, where much of the borrowing, adaptation, and localization of policy happens at the urban and regional levels. Ideas travel, practices that work are taken note of, and these bring usable, adoptable, and transferable ideas to implementation elsewhere. However, there are added layers of consideration to take note of, such as shifting political currents that affect not only national centers but also local governance, planning, and policy implementation. Likewise, the changing world order, the uncertainties of our time, and the complexity of public problems influence how policy actors make and reshape decisions, and how they draw insights from policies and practices elsewhere. This panel therefore pursues a sharp and specific aim: to examine how policies are transferred and diffused, how they travel to and from elsewhere, and how they move in different directions beyond North-South flows, informing decision makers with critical insights for addressing policy issues or concerns in other contexts. In problematizing this, the panel organizes its inquiry around three dimensions: policy process, policy context, and policy type. First, policy process brings together the actors, instruments, and agendas or objectives that move policies and policy issues. As a policy is transferred and diffused, process raises questions of power: who is recognized as a legitimate source or bearer of knowledge, which actors are connected and at which stages, and under what conditions the concrete components of a policy actually move. Second, policy context sharpens the panel’s core argument for looking beyond North-South flows of policy transfer and diffusion. How policy components travel often depends on conditions specific to each case. We therefore ask what kinds of institutional support and coordination mechanisms are in place, what problems a policy is meant to address, and how well it fits the context into which it is being adapted. Third, beyond procedural and contextual considerations, policy type draws attention to how different kinds of policy involve different actors, instruments, and dynamics. What travels, what is left behind, and how it is rebuilt may therefore look quite different from one policy type to another. Taken together, these intersecting dimensions may offer a comprehensive explanation of why policy flows need to be seen beyond the North-South assumption, clarifying the need to view them as moving in multiple directions and showing how they matter for decision making and local implementation. Call for Paper: This panel invites conceptual, theoretical, methodological, and empirical papers on how policies are transferred and diffused in more than one direction. Both comparative and single-case studies are welcome. We are especially interested in papers that trace how policies are adapted, contested, and remade as they move across places, scales, and political contexts. In this way, the panel asks how policy knowledge travels beyond the common North-South flows, and what this means for decision making and local implementation. The panel gives particular attention to urban and regional policy and planning, as much of the borrowing, adaptation, and localization of policy happens at these levels. We are also open to papers from other policy sectors, provided they engage with one or more of the panel’s three dimensions: policy process, policy context, and policy type. Possible topics include, but are not limited to: - City-to-city and inter-urban policy transfer, including South-South, North-North, and South-North exchanges - The role of intermediaries, networks, consultants, and international organizations in moving policies, and the stages at which these actors become connected - Power and legitimacy in policy transfer: whose knowledge travels, and whose knowledge is left behind - Policy learning by publics, institutions, and the state in times of political change and uncertainty - Institutional support, coordination mechanisms, and implementation structures in the receiving context - How urban governance innovations and planning instruments are translated and localized in other cities and regions - The fit between a transferred policy and the problems it is meant to address in a new setting - The movement of policies across local, national, regional, and global levels - Failures, resistance, and unintended consequences, including policies that do not travel - How different policy types shape what travels, what is left behind, and how policies are rebuilt in new settings - Digital platforms, data, and technologies as channels for, and objects of, policy transfer - Conceptual and methodological approaches that move beyond the North-South binary We also invite reflexive papers from scholars and practitioners who facilitate or study policy exchanges, as well as papers that bring the literatures on policy transfer, diffusion, learning, and mobilities into closer dialogue. Submissions from early-career researchers and from scholars based in the Global South are strongly encouraged.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Transfer/Diffusion/Learning Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Urban Policy and Planning General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P70. From policy transfer to the transnational policy process: research agendas and emerging concepts
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Morais de Sa e Silva
O. Porto de Oliveira
C. Osorio Gonnet
G. Steiner-Khamsi
D. Dolowitz
C. Milhorance
ABSTRACT

Thirty years ago, Dolowitz and Marsh (1996) published their seminal review on policy transfer. Their work has been widely cited not only for highlighting the concept and phenomenon of policy transfer, but also for convening related concepts, such as policy learning (Rose, 1991) and convergence (Bennet,1991). Their 1996 review and their 2000 article that define policy transfer (Dolowitz and Marsh, 2000) laid the foundations upon which a community of scholars began working not only on policy diffusion, which emerged as a US-based concept (Berry & Berry, 1990), but on international policy transfer. Numerous books and articles have been since dedicated to update the debate (Hadjiisky, Pal, Walker, 2018; Baker, Walker, 2019; Porto de Oliveira, 2021) and push the frontiers of knowledge on policy transfer, diffusion, circulation and related concepts, as global policy, transnational public administration, multilevel governance (i.e. Osorio, 2020; Moloney e Rosenbloom, 2020; Stone, 2019; Milhorance, 2018; Morais de Sa e Silva, 2017; Porto de Oliveira, 2017; Steiner-Khamsi, 2004). Work on policy mobilities and translation has further shown that policies rarely travel intact, since they are reinterpreted and reassembled by the actors and institutions that receive them (Peck & Theodore, 2010; Stone, 2012; Mukhtarov, 2014). Through conference panels and scholarly exchanges, this agenda evolved into the transnational approach to the policy process (Morais de Sa e Silva & Porto de Oliveira, 2023). In this approach, the policy process is embedded in a transnational policy space, meaning that policy problems, agents and solutions exist and interact beyond national boundaries (Stone, 2008; Porto de Oliveira and Osorio, 2021). Policy transfer remains central as it enables the study of traveling policies. Context also remains essential, revealing the spatial, political, and temporal dimensions of interactions between the domestic and the international (Steiner-Khamsi and Morais de Sa e Silva, 2024). However, the geography of these flows has changed, as countries of the Global South increasingly act as exporters of policy models through South-South cooperation. At the same time, polarization and democratic backsliding now require attention to how traveling policies are politicized, contested or dismantled. Comparative policy research adds a complementary angle. Domestic actors and coalitions often initiate reforms and invoke external models selectively to support choices made at home (Steiner-Khamsi, 2004). National policy regimes, institutional legacies and veto configurations also condition whether traveling policies are adopted and what they become once layered onto existing arrangements (Falleti and Lynch, 2009; Mahoney and Thelen, 2010; May and Jochim, 2013). In sectors such as education, this often produces convergence in policy talk and formal adoption alongside durable divergence in policy design and practice (Pollitt, 2001). This divergence is easy to miss when analysis stops at formal adoption. Choices are rarely purely technical: they reflect the political forces that design, contest and use instruments (Lascoumes and Le Galès, 2007). Bringing transnational and comparative perspectives into dialogue can explain not only how policies travel, but also why some do not, and why formally similar instruments may serve different purposes across countries.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Transfer/Diffusion/Learning Policy Process Theories
P229. Knowledge in Motion: Water Governance and Nature-based Solutions Across Places
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Ensenado
E. Minkman
D. Dolowitz
ABSTRACT

A growing body of scholarship has examined how policy ideas, knowledge, and practices travel and transform as they move across institutional, political, and socio-ecological contexts. Research on policy mobility, policy transfer, and city-to-city learning, particularly in climate adaptation and water governance, has highlighted the importance of distinguishing between knowledge acquisition, application, and institutionalization (Ensenado, et al., 2023, 2024, 2025). Rather than being adopted unchanged, policies often undergo processes of translation, adaptation, and rebranding (Raev & Minkman, 2020; Mukhtarov, 2022). Examples include the international circulation of Dutch water expertise, the diffusion of China's River Chief System, and the transfer of Nature-based Solutions (NbS). This movement involves more than the circulation of technical expertise or best practices (e.g. Dolowitz, & Babamaragana, 2026; Bakker et al, 2024). It frequently entails the co-production of knowledge, as ideas originating elsewhere interact with local ecological knowledge, institutional arrangements, political priorities, path dependencies, and governance practices in interconnected socio-ecological-technical systems. However, important questions remain regarding the political and social dynamics shaping these transformations, the conditions under which transferred approaches become institutionalized, and the extent to which successful policy transfer translates into effective, equitable, and environmentally beneficial outcomes. The panel’s guiding question is: How does knowledge about water governance and NbS travel, transform, and become embedded within different socio-ecological and governance contexts? The panel aims to advance theoretical and empirical understanding of these processes by inviting contributions that explore dimensions related to: - Politics and water diplomacy: How do diplomatic relations, geopolitical interests, and political objectives shape the circulation, translation, and implementation of water governance policies; and vice versa? What role do political interests play in determining which knowledge and practices travel across contexts? - Knowledge co-production and social inclusion: How do local ecological knowledge, stakeholder participation, and power relations influence the adaptation of transferred policies? Whose knowledge is incorporated, prioritised, or marginalised during these processes, and with what consequences? - Policy translation and effectiveness: Under what conditions does successful policy translation lead to intended policy outcomes? How might successful adoption or institutionalisation conceal discrepancies between stated environmental and social objectives and underlying political or economic interests? - Legitimacy and greenwashing: How can policy transfer serve as a mechanism of political legitimation, greenwashing, or bluewashing? To what extent does the adoption of internationally recognised water governance approaches and NbS reflect substantive environmental change rather than symbolic commitments? - Institutional and socio-ecological mismatches: How do tensions between transferred policy models, and local conditions reshape implementation and outcomes? Under what circumstances do these adaptations facilitate or undermine long-term institutionalisation and effectiveness? The panel brings together scholarship on policy mobility, knowledge co-production, water diplomacy, and socio-ecological governance. By examining not only whether policies travel but also how, whose interests they serve, and with what consequences, the panel seeks to develop a more critical and context-sensitive understanding of policy transfer. In particular, it aims to identify the conditions under which the translation and institutionalisation of different approaches contribute to effective and socially just outcomes, or alternatively reinforce existing inequalities, political interests, and environmental challenges.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Transfer/Diffusion/Learning Global and Transnational Policies Urban Policy and Planning
P265. Towards a Decolonial Perspective on Policy Learning and Transfer
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Singh
V. Singh
ABSTRACT

Much of the mainstream scholarly literature on policy learning, transfer, and diffusion has privileged formal state actors and North–South transmission, often treating the Global South as a recipient of models developed elsewhere. More recent scholarship on policy mobilities, policy assemblages, and South–South cooperation has however challenged this view by emphasising movement, translation, adaptation, contestation, and mutation that policies undergo as they travel and are reassembled in new locations (Clarke et.al, 2015; Peck & Theodore, 2015; Shore, Wright, & Pero, 2011; Temenos & McCann, 2013; Ureta, 2015; McCann & Ward, 2013). This strand of scholarship has drawn attention to how policies do not simply travel intact; they are reframed by local institutions, political coalitions, bureaucratic practices, and social struggles. A decolonial perspective pushes this critique further. It asks how colonial histories continue to organise what counts as expertise, evidence, innovation, and good governance. The coloniality of knowledge privileges Western, technocratic forms of knowing while marginalising and devaluing indigenous, subaltern, community-based, and Southern epistemologies. Mainstream frameworks thus suffer from what has been called as ‘epistemicide’ (de Souza Santos, 2015) in systematically suppressing or excluding indigenous, localized, and non-Western forms of knowledge and instead positioning Western, Global North, or eurocentric policy models as universal solutions. In policymaking, this has produced a global division of intellectual labour in which the Global North is positioned as a source of theory and policy models, while the Global South is treated as a site for data collection, experimentation, or implementation. It is in this context that calls for ‘provincialization’ (Chakrabarty, 2000) so as to ‘decenter’ policy knowledge and “desuperiorization” (Freter, 2020) are made. Scholars have thus drawn attention to the “epistemological diversity of the world” which requires replacing the ‘monoculture of scientific knowledge’ by an ‘ecology of knowledges’ (De Sousa Santos et al., 2008). This panel thus seeks to advance a decolonial perspective on policy transfer, diffusion and learning by interrogating the epistemic, institutional and political hierarchies embedded in these processes. It invites critical engagement with how colonial histories continue to shape the circulation of policy ideas, the authority accorded to particular forms of expertise, and the recognition or marginalisation of situated, embodied and community-based knowledge. It also foregrounds the possibility that knowledge and innovation generated in the Global South can reshape policy theory and practice, rather than merely serving as context-specific adaptations of supposedly universal models. The panel will explore the following central research question: How can policy transfer, diffusion and learning be reconceptualised to challenge colonial hierarchies of knowledge and recognise plural, situated and historically grounded practices of policymaking? It will examine several related hypotheses: first, that decolonial policy learning requires reciprocal knowledge exchange rather than one-directional transfer from the Global North to the Global South; second, that informal institutions, indigenous knowledge systems and community practices can generate policy innovations that challenge established models of governance; and third, that meaningful decolonisation requires changes in the institutions, methodologies and evaluative criteria through which policy knowledge is produced and circulated.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Transfer/Diffusion/Learning Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Global and Transnational Policies
P280. Buying Expertise: Public Procurement, Consultancy and the Internationalisation of Policy Skills
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. ANGUISSA BEKONO
ABSTRACT

Across the world, governments increasingly buy the expertise they need to design, evaluate and implement public policies. Studies, technical assistance, feasibility analyses, project supervision and reform programmes are routinely contracted out through public tenders. In many African countries, this trend is amplified by the rules of development finance: projects funded by the World Bank, the African Development Bank, the European Union or bilateral agencies come with procurement guidelines that open national markets to international firms, consortia and individual consultants. Public tenders thus become a key channel through which expertise, professionals, standards and policy models circulate across borders, and through which states decide, or are led to decide, who is competent to think and act on their behalf. A substantial literature has examined the role of consultants in government. Work on "consultocracy" has shown how management consultants shaped public sector reforms in Western democracies (Saint-Martin, 2000; Ylönen & Kuusela, 2019), and recent critiques question the hollowing out of state capacity that heavy reliance on consultancy may cause (Mazzucato & Collington, 2023). Research on policy advisory systems has analysed the externalisation of policy advice (Craft & Howlett, 2013), while studies of policy transfer and "fast policy" have identified consultants as key transfer agents (Dolowitz & Marsh, 2000; Stone, 2004; Peck & Theodore, 2015). Yet these debates remain largely centred on the Global North and on advice rather than on procurement itself. Public tenders are seldom analysed as policy instruments that select expertise, distribute it among foreign and national actors and shape how African bureaucracies actually work (Bierschenk & Olivier de Sardan, 2014). The panel therefore asks: how do public procurement procedures organise the circulation and internationalisation of expertise, and what effects does this have on policy-making, administrative capacity and the markets for expertise, particularly in African states? Contributions may explore several hypotheses. First, tender rules (eligibility criteria, references, turnover thresholds, language requirements) may structurally favour international firms and shape a hierarchy of expertise in which national consultants act mainly as subcontractors. Second, consultancy may operate less as a substitute for state capacity than as a negotiated arrangement in which administrations use external expertise to secure funding, legitimacy or room for manoeuvre. Third, "capacity building" and "knowledge transfer" clauses may produce uneven forms of learning, depending on how contracts are designed and monitored. Fourth, the growth of local and diaspora consulting firms may reshape these markets and the politics of expertise. By bringing procurement into the study of policy advice and policy transfer, and by drawing on African and other Global South cases, the panel aims to refine general theories of state capacity, policy instruments and the transnational circulation of expertise.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Transfer/Diffusion/Learning State and Policy Capacity Development Policy Global and Transnational Policies
P106. Universities and policy entrepreneurship: shaping public policy beyond higher education
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Cino Pagliarello
A. Gunn
M. Mintrom
ABSTRACT

Universities produce policy-relevant evidence, yet their capacity to shape public policy cannot be inferred from the quality of their research alone. This panel examines when and how academics, universities and university networks exercise policy entrepreneurship beyond the higher education sector, including in climate, migration, technological governance and international cooperation. Academic research and policymaking operate under different incentives and timescales. Publications and competitive funding often carry greater career rewards than policy engagement, while policymakers may require rapid responses that research cannot readily provide. Translating knowledge into usable proposals requires time and relationships, potentially creating trade-offs for academic careers. Nevertheless, some university-based actors achieve policy influence. Explaining how they do so requires attention to individual strategies, organisational support and political context. Gunn and Mintrom (2022) provide a foundation for analysing universities–state relations through public policy theories. Policy entrepreneurship scholarship examines how actors pursue change, while recent work distinguishes entrepreneurship from other forms of agency and calls for stronger empirical identification (Capano et al., 2025; Arnold et al., 2023; Petridou et al., 2025). Network research examines the relational positions of entrepreneurs and brokers (Christopoulos & Ingold, 2015). Studies of problem definition and collective ideational agency show how actors construct problems and develop ideas that shape policy (Cino Pagliarello & Cini, 2023; Carstensen & Röper, 2025). Moreover, Jungblut (2026) finds universities as organisations have become political actors adopting strategies associated with policy entrepreneurs. These perspectives provide complementary resources for investigating university-based action without assuming that advice or research impact necessarily constitutes entrepreneurship. The central question is: under what conditions do university-based actors exercise policy entrepreneurship, and how do academic incentives, organisational arrangements and policy networks shape their strategies and outcomes? Related questions concern how individuals secure institutional support; whether some research fields offer greater opportunities for entrepreneurial action; what forms of influence emerge; and how actors manage professional trade-offs. Three provisional hypotheses guide discussion. First, scientific authority contributes more to policy influence when combined with problem framing, coalition-building and access to decision-making venues. Second, organisational recognition and support reduce the professional costs of entrepreneurial activity and enable sustained engagement. Third, university networks extend resources and access across jurisdictions, but collective action depends on reconciling divergent institutional priorities. The panel distinguishes individual academics, university leaders, institutions and networks while examining their interaction. It welcomes successful and unsuccessful initiatives and approaches capable of separating actors’ intentions and strategies from demonstrated influence. Its contribution is to assess what the university setting adds to explanations of policy entrepreneurship, including how institutional incentives shape the relationship between knowledge, agency and policy change.

POLICY TOPICS
Agency/Leadership Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Research and Higher Education Policy
P115. Business, Power, and Policy-making
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Katsaitis
ABSTRACT

Large corporations are important participants in public policymaking, contributing expertise, investment, data and implementation resources. Their involvement can help governments address complex problems, but it can also privilege particular interests, narrow policy alternatives and redistribute costs and benefits unequally. These tensions are especially visible in climate adaptation, environmental protection, digital regulation and policies affecting civil and minority rights. Understanding corporate involvement therefore requires attention to how public problems are defined, policy instruments selected and policies implemented, alongside the accountability of these processes. Research on lobbying examines how information, resources and institutional access shape business–government relations (Coen, Katsaitis and Vannoni, 2021). Political economy identifies structural and institutional forms of business power, including dependencies created when firms provide essential public functions (Busemeyer and Thelen, 2020). Research on policy capacity highlights the analytical, operational and political capabilities required to pursue public objectives (Wu, Ramesh and Howlett, 2015). Building on these contributions, the panel addresses how corporate involvement at different stages of policymaking translates into specific policy choices and outcomes, and how those choices subsequently reinforce or constrain corporate power. The panel asks: how, and under what conditions, do large corporations shape policy agendas, policy design and implementation, and with what consequences for policy effectiveness, distributional equity and democratic accountability? It focuses on large companies, multinational enterprises, digital platforms and their representative organisations, examining national, EU and multilateral policymaking. Four hypotheses provide starting points for discussion. First, greater governmental dependence on corporate investment or infrastructure increases the likelihood that policy agendas and instrument choices accommodate corporate preferences, even without active lobbying. Second, corporate expertise is more likely to improve policy design and implementation where public authorities retain sufficient analytical capacity to assess private information independently. Third, delegating policy delivery to corporations generates feedback that strengthens incumbent providers and increases the costs of policy redesign, particularly where public authorities lack alternative providers. Fourth, corporate resource advantages translate less readily into favourable policy outcomes where labour, civil society and affected communities have effective access and opportunities to challenge corporate claims. The panel will examine how lobbying regulation, conflict-of-interest rules, oversight and participatory procedures mediate these relationships. It also invites analysis of how foreign corporate actors, intermediaries and digital influence campaigns affect policy debates and decisions. Distinguishing legitimate participation from corruption and improper interference is essential. Gender-sensitive and intersectional analysis will help identify whose interests enter policy agendas and how policy consequences vary by gender, age and other intersecting inequalities. Its scientific contribution is to connect research on corporate power with policy processes, implementation and feedback, explaining variation across sectors and institutional settings and identifying arrangements that support effective, equitable and accountable public policy.

POLICY TOPICS
Interest Groups/Lobbying Regulation and Regulatory Governance General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P209. Lobbying and Public Action in the Left Hand of the State: Health and Environment Inside Government
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Munoz
D. Benamouzig
ABSTRACT

Why do some business demands become law while others quietly die? Research on lobbying has answered this question through several families of explanation. Some stress coalitions and the unity of interest groups (Tilly, 1984; Klüver, 2011; Kluger Dionigi, 2018). Others focus on framing and the capacity to present demands as legitimate (Rasch, 2018; Benoit and Coron, 2019). A third strand emphasises resources, access and proximity to decision-makers (Woll, 2011; Laurens, 2015; Behr and Michon, 2017). A fourth looks at the problem itself: low salience and technical complexity favour business, while noisy politics and opposition from citizens’ groups reduce its advantage (Culpepper, 2011; Dür, Bernhagen and Marshall, 2015). Failure, for its part, is attributed to fragmentation, to conflict between groups and to institutional systems that favour the status quo (Baumgartner et al., 2009). These approaches are productive, but they share a common design. Each factor is identified separately and its effect is assumed to be stable, while the government in which decisions are taken appears as a backdrop rather than as an object of study. The literature has also been tested mainly on the European Union, the United States and economic or trade regulation. Work on industry tactics in public health and environmental policy is rich: how tobacco, alcohol and food firms build arguments, mobilise scientific doubt and cultivate access (Benamouzig and Cortinas Muñoz, 2019, 2022). But the government side of these battles, the ministries, offices and administrations where demands are received, sorted and turned into law or abandoned, has rarely been reconstructed in its own right. Few studies have examined decisional arenas and how they function (Zittoun & Chailleux, 2021). This panel proposes to fill that gap. It asks how the social logics of decision-makers in the left hand of the state shape what becomes thinkable in public health and environmental policy, and why some industry positions gain traction while others fail. Rather than adding factors to the lists above, we propose to reconstruct the configurations where decisions take shape: who sits where, who depends on whom, which conflicts between ministries, agencies and advisers are at stake, and how earlier decisions constrain later ones.

POLICY TOPICS
Interest Groups/Lobbying Health and Well-Being Policy
P212. Corporate influence and policy obstruction: strategies, discourse and power
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
K. Lauber
D. Plehwe
G. Dix
L. Knoester
ABSTRACT

Corporate influence is a long-standing concern in the study of health, climate, and environmental policy, but scholarship remains fragmented across sub-fields. Researchers have examined the policy influence of industries such as tobacco, ultra-processed food, fossil fuels, plastics, and agriculture, mobilising related and overlapping concepts including corporate political activity, commercial determinants of health, and climate obstruction (e.g., Maani, Petticrew & Galea, 2023; Roberts et al., 2025). Drawing, to various degrees, on scholarship in political science, sociology, and policy studies in addition to specialised (sub)disciplines - for example, building on theories of power - they have documented shared practices and mechanisms ranging from traditional lobbying to indirect efforts to shape science and its use in policy, harness co- and self-regulation to prevent binding rules, and shape policy discourses (Kinol et al., 2025; Legg et al., 2021; Reed et al., 2021). Alongside corporate agency, an emergent strand of scholarship has also begun to examine how institutional context and the design of decision-making processes – such as consultation mechanisms and requirements for cost-benefit analysis – shape access and influence (e.g., Lauber & Brooks, 2022). There is, however, little comparative analysis, and key sectors such as agriculture, which matter greatly for health, climate and biodiversity, remain under-researched from this perspective. Moreover, we still have limited knowledge about (transnational) counterstrategies and regulatory approaches to counter corporate influence and safeguard the integrity of policymaking processes, such as conflict-of-interest and lobbying transparency rules, and more equitable governance of participation and access. Much of the scholarship is still focused on national settings, although scholars recognise the importance of understanding the less visible exercise of corporate power in international and supranational arenas. In this panel, we focus on common concerns across the empirical sectors: the role of corporate practices and discourses in policy delay, dilution, and reversal. The panel calls for a broader conversation on corporate influence in climate, health, and environmental policy, inviting scholars working in these fields to exchange substantive and theoretical insights. It does so by addressing the following question: How do corporate actors shape policymaking across health, climate and environmental domains? ReferencesKinol, A., Si, Y., Kinol, J., & Stephens, J. C. (2025). Networks of climate obstruction: Discourses of denial and delay in US fossil energy, plastic, and agrichemical industries. PLOS Climate, 4(1), e0000370.Lauber, K., & Brooks, E. (2023). Why meta-regulation matters for public health: the case of the EU better regulation agenda. Globalization and Health, 19(1), 70.Legg, T., Hatchard, J., & Gilmore, A. B. (2021). The science for profit model—how and why corporations influence science and the use of science in policy and practice. PLOS One, 16(6), e0253272.Maani, N., Petticrew, M., & Galea, S. (2023). The commercial determinants of health. OUP.Reed, G., Hendlin, Y., et al. (2021). The disinformation playbook: how industry manipulates the science-policy process—and how to restore scientific integrity. Journal of Public Health Policy, 42(4), 622.Roberts, T. J., Milani, C. R., Jacquet, J., & Downie, C. (2025). Climate obstruction: A global assessment. OUP.

POLICY TOPICS
Interest Groups/Lobbying Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives Global and Transnational Policies
P228. Digital environments, social media, and health: regulatory challenges and interdisciplinary policy perspectives
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Karreman
B. Hawkins
K. Kim
ABSTRACT

Digital spaces have posed significant regulatory challenges to governments since their inception, drawing attention from policy scholars and political sociologists among others. The advent, and rapid proliferations, of social media platforms have given rise to both significant policy challenges and an explosion of scholarly interest, including the need to mitigate consequences for social cohesion, democracy and health. Regulating social media, and in particular its harmful consequences for the health of children and young people, has become an increasing priority for policymakers in jurisdictions worldwide. Australia took the most significant steps to regulate social media in December 2025, banning the use of social media for children under 16. This was closely followed by similar guidance in Brazil (March 2026), Indonesia (March 2026), and Malaysia (June 2026). Restrictions have also been announced by the European Commission, Canada, New Zealand, and the UK, among others. The rationale for these bans is often framed around protecting children and young people who, an increasing body of research evidence shows, experience the most significant harms from social media during a sensitive developmental period (Purba et al. 2026). However, policy responses to online harm cannot remain limited to children. Indeed, scholars have pointed to the need to consider social media as an important determinant of health across the life course (Zenone et al. 2023). The burgeoning literature on the commercial determinants of health (CDoH) (Gilmore et al. 2023) and corporate political activity of health-harming industries (Ulucanlar et al. 2023) highlights the role that commercial actors – including both social media companies and the businesses that use these platforms to advertise – play in influencing policy debates and outcomes, and in shaping public perceptions of their platforms and the ways these should be regulated. However, our understanding of social media platforms as a CDoH remains underdeveloped and requires additional attention from scholars of political science and public policy. The aims of this panel are to foster interdisciplinary exploration of the policy problems that are generated by and in online spaces, and the attempts by commercial and other political interest groups to frame policy debates and shape regulatory outcomes. References Gilmore, Anna B., Alice Fabbri, Fran Baum, et al. 2023. ‘Defining and Conceptualising the Commercial Determinants of Health’. The Lancet, Commercial Determinants of Health, vol. 401 (10383): 1194–213. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(23)00013-2. Purba, Amrit Kaur, Mark Petticrew, S. Vittal Katikireddi, Jai Mooker, and Martin McKee. 2026. ‘Adolescent Social Media Restrictions: Are We Missing the Bigger Picture?’ Analysis. BMJ 394 (July): e100084. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj-2026-100084. Ulucanlar, Selda, Kathrin Lauber, Alice Fabbri, et al. 2023. ‘Corporate Political Activity: Taxonomies and Model of Corporate Influence on Public Policy’. International Journal of Health Policy and Management 12 (1): 1–22. https://doi.org/10.34172/ijhpm.2023.7292. Zenone, Marco, Nora Kenworthy, and Nason Maani. 2023. ‘The Social Media Industry as a Commercial Determinant of Health’. International Journal of Health Policy and Management 12 (Issue 1): 1–4. https://doi.org/10.34172/ijhpm.2022.6840.

POLICY TOPICS
Interest Groups/Lobbying Regulation and Regulatory Governance Health and Well-Being Policy Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy
P39. Governing Migrant Inclusion: Intermediaries and the Politics of Access
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Ram
ABSTRACT

Public policy for migrant inclusion must address how people secure work, housing and social protection across changing locations and employment relationships. Access may involve recruitment agents, employers, landlords, community organisations and frontline officials. These arrangements raise a policy problem: assistance with obtaining a job or benefit may also give intermediaries influence over workers’ mobility, claims and bargaining power. Scholarship on migration infrastructure examines the actors, institutions and technologies that organise mobility (Xiang and Lindquist, 2014). Research on administrative burden explains how learning, compliance and psychological costs shape interactions with government (Moynihan, Herd and Harvey, 2015). A recent systematic review identifies third-party assistance, comparisons across contexts and citizens’ experiences as important directions for further inquiry (Halling and Bækgaard, 2024). Bringing these approaches together, this panel examines how migrant participation and relationships spanning employment, residence and welfare shape access and public accountability. The central research question is: under what institutional conditions do intermediaries enable migrant workers to secure durable access to work, housing and social protection, and when do these arrangements generate dependence or exclusion? Durable access refers to people’s ability to retain support, change employers or residence, and seek redress without losing essential resources. The panel invites examination of three hypotheses. First, where a single employer or intermediary controls access across several domains, assistance with initial entry is more likely to coexist with high costs of exit and complaint. Second, portable entitlements and accessible public assistance reduce dependence when implementation permits workers to claim support independently of particular employers, addresses or brokers. Third, worker representation, opportunities to influence decisions and enforceable public oversight increase the likelihood that intermediated access remains secure during employment or residential change. Papers may test, qualify or challenge these propositions. The panel’s contribution is to examine how dependence in one domain affects access in another, and how policy redistributes responsibility among public authorities, employers, intermediaries and workers. It will also examine whose claims are represented and when participation influences decisions. Comparisons will attend to gender, caste, class, legal status and migration trajectories, alongside differences in welfare institutions and labour regulation. We welcome research on internal and international migration, particularly in the Global South, with comparative contributions from other settings. Industrial expansion, green transitions and urban redevelopment offer relevant contexts for examining changing arrangements of access. The objective is to identify mechanisms that explain variation in inclusion and derive implications for recruitment regulation, housing provision, portable social protection and grievance systems. ReferencesXiang, B. and Lindquist, J. (2014). Migration Infrastructure. International Migration Review, 48(S1), S122–S148. https://doi.org/10.1111/imre.12141 Moynihan, D., Herd, P. and Harvey, H. (2015). Administrative Burden: Learning, Psychological, and Compliance Costs in Citizen-State Interactions. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 25(1), 43–69. https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/muu009 Halling, A. and Bækgaard, M. (2024). Administrative Burden in Citizen-State Interactions: A Systematic Literature Review. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 34(2), 180–195. https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/muad023

POLICY TOPICS
Citizens, Participation and Social Movements Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Development Policy Administration and Civil Service Policy
P90. Youth and public policy: political agency, institutional conditions and reciprocal effects
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Duque
N. Munoz del Campo
ABSTRACT

Youth[1] occupy a complex position in contemporary public policy processes. On the one hand, they are frequently identified as a priority population in policy agendas addressing education, employment and social inequalities, among other issues. On the other hand, they participate in shaping, contesting and implementing public policies through social movements, advocacy organizations and institutionalized participatory mechanisms. Yet their capacity to influence policy decisions remains uneven, while the policies targeting them may reshape their opportunities for political participation. Although research on youth political participation has extensively examined activism, collective action and political engagement (e.g., Fisher, 2012; Weiss, 2020), including emerging forms of digitally mediated participation and mobilization, it has devoted comparatively less attention to their consequences for public policy processes. Conversely, public policy scholarship has developed frameworks for understanding policy change, institutional arrangements and policy feedback (e.g., Béland & Schlager, 2019; Peters & Zittoun, 2016), but young people are often approached primarily as policy beneficiaries rather than political actors capable of influencing policymaking. This panel seeks to bridge these research traditions by examining the reciprocal relationships between youth political agency and public policy processes. It addresses two interconnected questions: Under what conditions and through which mechanisms do young people influence public policies? How do public policies, in turn, shape young people's political participation, collective identities and capacities for political action? The panel explores three complementary analytical dimensions. First, it examines youth influence on public policy, investigating how young people mobilize resources, build coalitions, access decision-making arenas and influence policy agendas, design, implementation and change. Second, it investigates the effects of public policies on youth political agency, considering how policy instruments, institutional arrangements and outcomes shape young people's resources, political attitudes, collective identities and opportunities for participation. Third, the panel explores the dynamic interactions between youth participation and public policy, examining how policy decisions generate new forms of mobilization, institutional participation or contestation, potentially contributing to subsequent policy adjustments or transformations. By bringing together theoretical and empirical contributions from different policy sectors and political contexts, the panel aims to advance an integrated understanding of young people as both subjects and agents of public policy. It particularly welcomes both in-depth single-case studies and comparative research explaining variations in youth policy influence and interactions between political participation and institutional change. [1] Youth are defined as individuals aged 15 to 29, following an age range widely used in youth studies and public policies targeting this population. Nevertheless, youth are recognized as a socially and historically constructed category whose age boundaries may vary across national and sociocultural contexts. Béland, D., & Schlager, E. (2019). Varieties of policy feedback research: Looking backward, moving forward. Policy Studies Journal, 47(2), 184-205. Fisher, D. R. (2012). Youth political participation: Bridging activism and electoral politics. Annual review of Sociology, 38(1), 119-137. Peters, B. G., & Zittoun, P. (2016). Contemporary Approaches to Public Policy: Theories, Controversies and Perspectives. Springer. Weiss, J. (2020). What is youth political participation? Literature review on youth political participation and political attitudes. Frontiers in Political Science, 2, 1.

POLICY TOPICS
Citizens, Participation and Social Movements Equity, Gender, Inclusion and the Diversity in Public Policy General Public Policy (no specific sector) Other
P99. The Politics of Public Participation in Policymaking
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
V. Jacquet
ABSTRACT

Since the turn of the millennium, public authorities have established various forms of participatory arrangements, often referred to as democratic innovations, to create opportunities for citizens to participate in collective decision-making beyond electoral channels (Elstub and Escobar 2019). These include participatory budgeting, citizens’ juries, citizens’ assemblies, and popular votes. Against the backdrop of the crisis of electoral representation, these participatory arrangements have attracted considerable scholarly attention for their capacity to embody procedural democratic ideals in policymaking, such as inclusion, respectful exchange, rational justification, openness, and transparency (Dryzek et al. 2019). Empirical studies have examined both the democratic potential and the limitations of these processes, notably their capacity to reproduce existing inequalities. While this scholarship has significantly advanced our understanding of the democratic qualities of participatory arrangements, further attention is needed to understand how they are embedded in, and interact with, broader policymaking processes (Boswell et al. 2023; Jacquet et al. 2023; Pogrebinschi and Ryan 2018). Participatory arrangements are not only procedural settings; they also produce substantive output in the policymaking process. Yet, how these arrangements connect with decision-making processes, interact with political actors, and operate within prevailing power relations remains insufficiently understood (Bua and Bussu 2023; Escobar and Bua 2026). This panel brings together contributions that analyse public participation as an integral part of policymaking, embedded in interactions among political and social actors, including social movements, interest groups, political parties, and public administrations. It seeks to move beyond an understanding of participatory arrangements as merely procedural mechanisms and to examine how they operate within broader political dynamics, how they shape and are shaped by existing power relations, and the extent to which they contribute to transforming contemporary policymaking. References Boswell J, Dean R and Smith G (2023) Integrating citizen deliberation into climate governance: Lessons on robust design from six climate assemblies. Public administration 101(1), 182–200. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1111/padm.12883. Bua A and Bussu S (2023) Reclaiming participatory governance: Social movements and the reinvention of democratic innovation. London: Routledge. Dryzek JS, Bächtiger A, Chambers S, Cohen J, Druckman JN, Felicetti A, Fishkin JS, Farrell DM, Fung A, Gutmann A, Landemore H, Mansbridge J, Marien S, Neblo MA, Niemeyer S, Setälä M, Slothuus R, Suiter J, Thompson D and Warren ME (2019) The crisis of democracy and the science of deliberation. Science 363(6432), 1144–1146. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aaw2694. Elstub S and Escobar O (2019) Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing. Escobar O and Bua A (2026) Democratic innovation for change: A participatory corrective to deliberative hegemony. Politics 46(1), 15–36. https://doi.org/10.1177/02633957251349635. Jacquet V, Ryan M and van der Does R (eds) (2023) The impacts of democratic innovations. Colchester: ECPR Press. Pogrebinschi T and Ryan M (2018) Moving beyond input legitimacy: When do democratic innovations affect policy making? European Journal of Political Research 57(1), 135–152. https://doi.org/10.1111/1475-6765.12219.

POLICY TOPICS
Citizens, Participation and Social Movements Politics, Institutions and Political Regimes General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P123. Democracy, Governance, and Commons-based Approaches
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
U. KANDEL
N. Sher-Hadar
H. Wagenaar
ABSTRACT

Over the past decades, successive government reforms seeking to improve administrative processes and policy outcomes have emphasized the need to democratize both administrative practices and policymaking procedures (Ansell & Gash, 2008; Ansell & Torfing, 2021; Bryson et al., 2016). At the same time, however, democracies worldwide are struggling more than ever to sustain themselves, with governance crises becoming a routine feature of political life (Ansell, Sørensen, & Torfing, 2022; Stoker, 2006). This points to a central tension in contemporary democratic governance: democratic vocabularies of participation, inclusion, responsiveness, and collaboration have become increasingly prominent in administrative reform and policy practice just as the institutional systems through which democracies deliberate, decide, and act appear increasingly strained. This tension is especially visible in interconnected, fast-moving, mutually reinforcing wicked problems. Ecological degradation, public health emergencies, forced displacement, technological disruption, persistent inflation, and violent conflict increasingly exceed the boundaries of distinct policy domains. Democratic governments seemingly lost sovereignty over policy delivery to powerful actors and forces beyond their control: foreign countries, private equity funds and other large financial actors, transnational tech companies, well-organized right-wing movements, and social media. These interact within a polycrisis: not simply the simultaneous occurrence of multiple crises, but a condition in which crises become causally entangled and mutually reinforcing, with pressures in one domain intensifying vulnerabilities and disruptions in others (Rakowski et al., 2025). Against this background, this panel invites contributors to explore whether and how commons-based approaches can offer new ways of thinking about public policy, democracy, and collective action. Commons refer to bottom-up citizen initiatives for managing finite, shared, and/or fragile resources, such as water, fish, energy, housing, or urban space (Bollier & Helfrich, 2019). They might also refer, as recent studies describe, to a political, social, legal, ecological, and knowledge-related category spanning material resources, cultural and knowledge goods, institutional arrangements, ethical commitments, and practices of shared life (Kandel, 2026; Moroni, 2025; Dardot & Laval, 2019; De Angelis, 2017). This broader understanding shifts attention from the commons to commoning: the ongoing social practice through which commons are created, sustained, and governed. Derived from “commons,” commoning refers to creating peer-governed, context-specific systems for free, fair, and sustainable lives (Bollier & Helfrich, 2019, pp. 97–98). It highlights people’s capacity to self-organize around shared needs and problems, often irreducible to state or market (ibid., 2019, p. 15). The commoning worldview rests on shared responsibility, deep communion with the environment, horizontal governance, mutual care, and reciprocity. The panel explores commons-based approaches’ ontological and ethical dimensions: how policy tools, institutions, and everyday practices may cultivate deliberation, mutual care, shared responsibility, and collective stewardship. Rather than proposing a single model, the panel seeks to open a conversation about how policy research and analysis might connect systematic inquiry with ethical practice, positive collective action, and deeper democracy. It also asks how these approaches may enrich policy systems’ deliberative and practice capacities, contribute to Deliberative Policy Analysis (Hajer & Wagenaar, 2003; Wagenaar, 2022), and speak to wider debates on democracy, including participatory and associative democracy (Wagenaar, 2026).

POLICY TOPICS
Citizens, Participation and Social Movements
P138. Seeing Policy from Below: Everyday Life, Burdens, Emotions and Policy Feedback
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
V. DUBOIS
R. Pires
ABSTRACT

Public policy research has traditionally examined policies through an institutional lens—focusing on their design, organizational implementation, and performance relative to stated goals. This panel explores what is gained, both analytically and practically, by shifting the analytical entry point to people’s everyday lived experiences with policies. Several bodies of literature provide foundational building blocks for this approach. Research on policy feedback demonstrates that policies actively shape citizens' resources, interpretations, and political participation (Mettler and Soss 2004). Analyses of "policy targets" clarify how clients internalize the “subtle messages” embedded in policy design (Ingram and Schneider 1993), while the concept of "policy reception" captures how target publics navigate and ascribe meaning to the programs that govern them (Revillard 2024). Meanwhile, scholarship on administrative burdens documents the learning, compliance, and psychological costs of interacting with the state (Herd and Moynihan 2018), complemented by street-level bureaucracy research on frontline discretion (Lipsky 1980) and sociological studies on how these bureaucratic encounters affect individuals both materially and symbolically (Hasenfeld 1980; Dubois 1999). Yet, these approaches typically remain anchored in institutional frameworks: they tend to track a single program, organization, or professional group, often treating citizens’ experiences merely as a reactive response to policy design. Conversely, an alternative tradition begins with the everyday world of those subject to policies, tracing how institutions organize and structure that reality. Feminist and activist ethnographies have long argued that grounding analysis in everyday experience reveals how institutional relations operate in practice. This lens illuminates how individuals—particularly women and other marginalized groups—cope with, rework, and contest these overarching structures (Naples 1998). Critical policy ethnography and comparative research focusing on how lower-class individuals interact with state institutions have integrated this perspective into the analysis of welfare systems and public services (Dubois 2010, 2015; LOCI Research Network). However, these everyday-life approaches have remained largely disconnected from mainstream policy analysis and its core conceptual frameworks. Consequently, the central question of this panel is: what does an everyday-life perspective allow us to observe, explain, and improve in public policy that institution-centered approaches overlook? We explore three core propositions. First, adopting an everyday-life lens exposes the cumulative and cross-sectoral nature of policy effects; individuals navigate a complex patchwork of programs across their life courses rather than isolated policies, meaning that administrative burdens, social impacts, and emotional tolls accumulate across successive encounters. Second, emotions and political learning serve as primary channels through which these lived experiences translate into policy feedback, deeply shaping citizens' trust, sense of entitlement, and political engagement. Third, everyday experiences consistently bring to light mediating actors and processes—ranging from community organizations, unions, and legal advocates to relatives, informal brokers, and digital helpers—that remain invisible from institutional vantage points and are currently being reshaped by digitalization. Ultimately, this panel bridges the gap between well-established policy concepts and the lived reality of governance. By doing so, it expands the empirical evidence base for equitable policy design and evaluation, while fostering a vital methodological dialogue across diverse contexts and policy sectors.

POLICY TOPICS
Citizens, Participation and Social Movements Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy
P167. Mega African Trash Cans, or the death of the utopia of the African independence movements in Portuguese-speaking countries
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Khan
R. Queiroz
ABSTRACT

Mega-dumpsites in Africa, Latin America and Asia are not accidental products of rapid urbanisation; they are deeply rooted in the historical trajectories of nations that fought for their independence from a long colonial and imperial system. In the Lusophone post-colonial space—exemplified by the Hulene dumpsite in Maputo and the Mulenvos Sanitary Landfill in Luanda—as well as across Latin America and South Asia, there is a direct causal link between the structural inequalities of past empires and current urban crises. As Vanessa Melo (2015) notes, the colonial system deliberately designed fragmented cities, institutionalising spatial segregation and underdeveloping basic infrastructure for native populations. Following their independence, the new African sovereign states promised equitable development and spatial justice, drawing on revolutionary ideals. However, decades later, the exponential growth of these mega-dumpsites mirrors how the values and principles that guided the post-independence era of these countries have fallen into total public discredit. Mirroring the warnings of Frantz Fanon (1961) regarding post-colonial state fragility, contemporary regimes have often reproduced territorial neglect, leaving waste management to reflect broken historical promises. State-of-the-ArtModern policy literature and global urban political ecology increasingly view waste zones through a decolonial lens, moving past technocratic paradigms. Research demonstrates that more than places of degradation, these dumpsites are, simultaneously, a space of marginalisation and of economic and community survival. In Latin America, Kathleen Millar (2018) illustrates how historical dumpsites act as vital shadow economies that sustain vulnerable groups—unemployed youth, poor migrants, and destitute families—through informal recycling networks, a reality Melanie Samson (2020) argues is increasingly threatened by exclusionary circular economy frameworks. Similarly, Seth Schindler (2015) highlights how top-down, exclusionary environmental policies in South Asia often displace these populations rather than solving systemic poverty, a systemic failure that Nedson Sinthumule (2021) directly links to the reproduction of colonial structures within modern waste management systems. Research Questions and Hypotheses This panel seeks to address difficult questions regarding how to transform these territories through public policies capable of reversing legacy inequalities. It focuses on identifying tools for community intervention and dialogue to bridge the gap between marginalised citizens and political institutions. The central research questions are:How do colonial urban architectures and post-colonial leadership failures structurally intersect to shape the contemporary crisis of mega-dumpsites in the Global South? What policy mechanisms can formalise waste ecosystems while securing the survival and dignity of marginalised populations across formerly colonised geographies? The panel will test the following hypotheses: H1: The contemporary degradation of dumpsites is directly linked to the reproduction of colonial-style top-down decision-making, which ignores peripheral communities. H2: Public policies that incorporate co-production and grassroots participation successfully restore public trust and civic inclusion. H3: Multidisciplinary policy research provides the necessary frameworks for an improvement in the stewardship of populations, territories, and, above all, citizenship.

POLICY TOPICS
Citizens, Participation and Social Movements Politics, Institutions and Political Regimes Urban Policy and Planning Development Policy
P250. Apparent Paradoxes and Ambivalence in Citizen-State Encounters and Public Opinion
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Sautter
L. Ortiz Cabrero
ABSTRACT

Apparent paradoxes are not uncommon findings in public opinion research. However, rather than assuming that they indicate an absence of political sophistication on policy issues or indifference towards policy-making processes, a growing body of interpretivist research is arguing that so-called contradictions are built on citizens' complex sense-making around normative dilemmas and ideas (Boswell et al., 2019). Disentangling such ‘paradoxes’ in political sense-making challenges scientific expectations about how normative commitments, taken-for-granted knowledge, and everyday engagement with the state, so-called citizen-state encounters, fit together.Interpretivists typically set out to understand how citizens' attitudes and behaviour regarding state action fit into broader understandings of politics (world-making, Berger and Luckmann, 1966) by integrating ‘deep stories’ (Hochschild, 2016) and methods of active listening (Cramer, 2016). The panel brings together interpretivist public opinion research to examine, bottom-up, how political sense-making takes shape within everyday relationships and citizen-state encounters. The objective of the panel is to collect and discuss insights on how rejection of and criticism towards policies can coexist with participation in state encounters (Boswell, 2026; Soss, 1999), law-abidingness (Koch, 2018), and everyday claim-making (Hilhorst, 2025).The panel furthermore encourages methodological reflection on how researchers recognize inconsistency, distinguishing tensions experienced by participants from contradictions inferred through analytical categories and expectations. The panel treats apparent paradoxes as opportunities to revisit assumptions about political coherence and to examine unresolved tensions, which reoccur across disciplines. Its scientific contribution lies in connecting work on public opinion across policy domains.The Panel is intended as a venue to refine the concept of ambivalence. Its scientific contribution is furthermore a methodological one for the interpretivist community: by comparing approaches to data collection and interpretation, contributors can examine how others identify and elicit tensions in socio-political accounts. In particular, it provides a venue to jointly reflect on how, for example, interview prompts, researcher-interlocutor interaction and analytical choices can make ambivalence (in)visible.

POLICY TOPICS
Citizens, Participation and Social Movements Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P71. Government Orchestration and Soft Steering in Collaborative Governance: Mechanisms, Instruments, and Dynamics
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Valyan
L. Meuleman
ABSTRACT

Contemporary public administration confronts fragmented, polycentric, and “wicked” societal challenges that exceed the capacities of hierarchical or New Public Management style governance. Collaborative governance arrangements and multi-actor networks offer ways to address these challenges, but they do not necessarily emerge, coordinate, or sustain collective action on their own. This raises a central question for public administration and public policy: how can governments steer collaborative arrangements while respecting the autonomy of participating actors? Scholarship offers several starting points. Research on collaborative platforms examines how public actors can enable and sustain multiple collaborative initiatives (Ansell and Gash, 2018). Work on metagovernance considers how public authorities shape the conditions under which governance networks operate (Sørensen and Torfing, 2009), while network governance research identifies different organizational forms through which such networks are governed (Provan and Kenis, 2008). Others (Meuleman 2008, 2018; Jessop 2011) consider metagovernance as a means to combine and manage hierarchical, network and market governance styles. Within this broader field, orchestration draws attention to forms of indirect, often non-hierarchical steering that mobilize other actors toward shared governance goals (Abbott et al., 2016). Empirical research on state actor orchestration further shows how public authorities can structure coordination, encourage experimentation, and frame collective action across sectors (Myers and Kellogg, 2022). These literatures provide valuable insights, yet further work is needed to specify how distinct steering mechanisms operate, how instruments are combined, and how their effects vary across institutional settings and over time. This panel examines government steering in collaborative governance broadly, with orchestration as a particularly important—but not exclusive—analytical focus. It welcomes studies of facilitation, network management, metagovernance, implementation arrangements, and the use of policy instruments to shape collaborative action. Rather than assuming a strict divide between “soft” and “hard” steering, the panel asks how public actors combine relational and epistemic practices with formal authority, funding, regulation, and institutional design—and with what consequences for effectiveness and democratic legitimacy. The panel addresses three core research questions: Mechanisms and trajectories: What mechanisms and instruments do public actors use to initiate, coordinate, adapt, and sustain collaborative governance arrangements? How do steering roles and practices change across policy processes, network development, and different administrative traditions? Instrument mixes and network governance: How do governments combine facilitation, convening, resource support, and shared framing with formal rules, funding conditions, regulatory oversight, or the shadow of hierarchy? How do network structures and implementation arrangements shape these choices? Power, accountability, and legitimacy: How do government steering practices affect participation, power asymmetries, public value, and democratic accountability? Under what conditions do they enable collaboration, constrain actor autonomy, or risk collaborative capture? By bringing collaborative governance, network governance, metagovernance, and policy design into conversation, the panel aims to develop more precise accounts of what governments do when they steer collaboration as a way to address fragmented, polycentric, and "wicked" societal challenges, why particular approaches are adopted, and how their consequences can be assessed across policy domains.

POLICY TOPICS
Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments General Public Policy (no specific sector) Administration and Civil Service Policy
P75. Legislatures as Policy Actors: Committee Systems, Audit, Post-Legislative Scrutiny and the Governance of Implementation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Ani
E. Albanesi
H. Muzee
ABSTRACT

Policy process scholarship has examined legislatures closely and at every stage of policymaking, and the panel does not claim otherwise. As a result, punctuated equilibrium theory is constructed upon congressional hearings as its principal measure of governmental attention (Baumgartner & Jones, 2009; Jones & Baumgartner, 2005), the multiple streams framework assigns legislative actors a central part in coupling problems to solutions (Kingdon, 2011), veto player theory specifies the legislature's structural position in the production of policy change (Tsebelis, 2002), and the delegation literature treats the legislature as a principal exercising ex ante and ex post control over administration (McCubbins & Schwartz, 1984; Strøm, 2000). A panel premised on theoretical neglect would therefore be premised on an error, and this proposal advances a narrower and, we suggest, more defensible claim. Indeed, the claim concerns the level of abstraction at which the legislature enters these accounts. In each of the traditions named above the institution is represented by a single property, whether attention, veto capacity or the capacity to sanction, rather than as an organisation whose committee jurisdiction and specialisation, research and secretariat capacity, procedural repertoire and membership stability vary systematically across cases and over time. Legislative studies supplies exactly that organisational detail (Martin, Saalfeld & Strøm, 2014; Martin & Strøm, 2023), and has begun to demonstrate that organisational capacity is itself variable and in places declining (Crosson, Furnas, LaPira & Burgat, 2021), yet it has engaged comparatively little with policy outcomes as public policy scholars specify them. The two literatures consequently model the same institution at incompatible levels of abstraction, with the result that organisational variation among legislatures is rarely carried into explanations of policy outcomes. The objective of this panel is, therefore, to close that distance by treating legislative organisational capacity as an explanatory variable rather than as background, and by concentrating on the stages at which its effects are least examined, namely implementation oversight, audit and ex-post evaluation. Subsequently, the panel’s theoretical ambition is accordingly one of integration rather than discovery: it then asks, what the policy process literature would predict differently if the legislature were modelled as an organisation rather than as a property. Research Question The panel seeks to answer the question: under what conditions, and through which institutional mechanisms, do legislatures shape policy outcomes beyond the moment of enactment? Three subsidiary questions are: i) The first concerns mechanism: which legislative instruments - committee inquiry, budgetary amendment, statutory review clauses, summons and reporting requirements, audit findings and the recommendations of public accounts committees, or constituency-level feedback - actually alter implementation, and which generate activity without effect? ii) The second concerns condition: what institutional features, including committee specialisation, staff and research capacity, tenure and turnover, and the degree of executive-legislative alignment, determine whether those instruments carry force? iii) The third concerns measurement: how should legislative influence on policy outcomes be identified empirically, given that the counterfactual is rarely observable and that recorded legislative activity is a poor proxy for policy effect? iv) The fourth concerns audit: how does the relationship between supreme audit institutions and legislative accounts committees shape the detection and correction of implementation failure, and what accounts for the persistent gap between the issuing of audit-based recommendations and their implementation by administrative bodies (Matlala, 2025)? Scientific Relevance The panel addresses a gap that is theoretical, empirical and methodological at once. 1) Theoretically, the components of a fuller account already exist but have not been assembled. Hence, work on post-legislative scrutiny has established the design and rationale of ex-post review and documented its diffusion across parliaments (De Vrieze & Norton, 2020, 2021); the delegation literature has specified the control relationship between legislatures and agencies (McCubbins & Schwartz, 1984; Strøm, 2000); and comparative legislative studies has mapped the organisational variation on which both depend (Martin & Strøm, 2023). What has not been attempted is their integration into a single account in which organisational capacity is the explanatory variable and post-enactment policy outcomes the explanandum. The panel’s theoretical originality lies in that integration, and in the proposition it generates, namely that legislative influence after enactment is a function of organisational capability rather than of formal authority, which is a proposition the comparative evidence can falsify. 2) Empirically, the evidence base is heavily concentrated on a small number of well-resourced legislatures in Western Europe, North America and the Westminster tradition, a concentration visible in the cases from which the leading comparative treatments are drawn (Martin, Saalfeld & Strøm, 2014). Legislatures in Africa, Asia, Latin America and small island states operate under materially different conditions of capacity, tenure and executive dominance, and existing cross-national work on oversight tools indicates that the availability of an instrument and its effective use diverge sharply under those conditions (Pelizzo & Stapenhurst, 2014). The propositions derived from the established cases cannot be assumed to transfer to them. This panel actively seeks contributions from those settings. 3) Methodologically, the study of legislative influence on policy outcomes confronts an identification problem that the field has not resolved. Counting bills, motions, committee sittings or oversight visits measures institutional activity rather than policy effect, and the two can move in opposite directions. The panel welcomes papers that confront this problem directly, whether through process tracing, comparative case design, quantitative text analysis of legislative and administrative documents, or the construction of new indicators. The audit relationship is of particular methodological interest here, because audit findings, committee recommendations and departmental responses generate a dated documentary trail against which follow-up can be traced, which makes the activity-versus-effect distinction unusually tractable. 4) The audit dimension, which the panel now treats as a distinct line of enquiry, connects the foregoing three. Auditing is in most systems a legislative function exercised at one remove, in that a supreme audit institution reports to the legislature and a public accounts or equivalent committee determines what follows. It is through this relationship that legislatures acquire independent information about implementation, and it is therefore the principal institutional channel by which the legislature can act upon implementation failure after enactment. Comparative evidence establishes that the arrangements governing audit institutions differ widely in mandate, independence and reporting relationship (Ferry, Hamid & Hebling Dutra, 2023), and that variation supplies the panel with a natural source of comparison. Evidence from oversight practice also indicates that recommendations frequently fail to produce administrative change where enforcement authority is limited and mandates overlap (Matlala, 2025), which is precisely the activity-without-effect problem the panel is organised around. Audit accordingly belongs in this panel not as an additional topic but as the clearest case of the mechanism it seeks to explain.

POLICY TOPICS
Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Politics, Institutions and Political Regimes Administration and Civil Service Policy Other
P55. Understanding, explaining, critiquing and measuring Resilience in Public and Social Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Donoghue
ABSTRACT

Overview Resilience now organises policy thinking across an unusually wide span of domains, including social protection, climate adaptation, migration, household finance, green growth, and national security. While the surface language of resilience is common across these, the meaning of resilience can vary substantially. Likewise resilience can be seen as a governing rationality, a set of capacities, qualities or processes, or an outcome. While scholarly literature works to untangle the specificities of resilience, policy literature often conflates different understandings of resilience resulting in a tautological understanding of resilience-as-resilience. This panel engages with this heterogeneity and sets out a number of objectives: 1) to advance resilience research in public and social policy through increasing engagement with the subject and between scholars 2) To increase our understanding of what resilience is and how it operates within and across policy domains. Scholarship on resilience is well represented in policy studies, but extends far beyond this into political science, sociology, geography, economics, psychology, law, and beyond the social sciences. Descriptive analytical traditions set out to understand the components of resilience; critical approaches interrogate the use of resilience as a way of redistributing risk from the state to citizen, or as a way of individualising risk; Quantitative comparative work may seek to identify and calibrate indicators of resilience in different domains, while qualitative work may seek to understand the experiences of those attempt to become, or who are compelled to become, resilient, and what that means. Work in systems analysis and risk governance treats resilience as a measurable property of systems, and asks how it can be built into infrastructure, economies and institutions. Each tradition has developed sophisticated tools, yet dialogue between these traditions could be enhanced. The panel is organised around core questions: 1) How is resilience operationalised, or how does resilience manifest, across domains - what is made resilient, against what, and on whose authority? 2) What are the distributive consequences of resilience, whether in terms of finance, power, risk or autonomy etc.? 3) What is the future of resilience? Should it be further embedded, critiqued, jettisoned, reformed? And what should resilience look like in the future? The panel's relevance to public policy scholarship extends past resilience itself. Concepts that command cross-spectrum consensus while conflating issues or collapsing differences in principle and practice into one another have become more common. Resilience provides a strong case for studying how consensus is produced, sustained and occasionally broken. It is also an opportunity to further understand the variegation of resilience across diverse policy areas, identifying similarities and differences in content, practice and outcome. This panel draws upon an edited book entitled A Research Agenda for Resilience in Social and Public Policy (Edward Elgar, Forthcoming 2027).

POLICY TOPICS
Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives General Public Policy (no specific sector) Social Policy
P96. Contested Greening: Political Struggles over the Boundaries of Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Chailleux
R. Hourcade
J. GUERRIN
P. Zittoun
ABSTRACT

For several years, the ecological transition in public policy has faced growing political opposition in Europe: social mobilizations, anti-environmental discourse, and the dismantling of climate policies. This phenomenon is frequently labelled a "backlash" in both the media and the scholarly literature, denoting a hostile reaction to the increased visibility of environmental issues (Bosetti et al., 2025; Paterson, 2023; Patterson et al., 2026; Tallent, 2025). Processes of opposition, delay, and outright opposition to climate policies have also been interpreted as nuances of "climate obstruction" (Edwards et al., 2023; Herranen, 2023; Szulecki et al., 2024). These categories tend to portray such dynamics as new, even unprecedented, suggesting that the greening of public policy faces an exceptional and singular level of opposition. Yet, a large body of research has long established that contestation, retreat, and policy reversal are recurrent features of the often chaotic and conflictual careers of many public policies. Whether it concerns the definition of public problems or the formulation of policy proposals, governmental agenda-setting is often inseparable from the struggles, conflicts, and power relations that shape their making and implementation. Neither their influence nor their legitimacy can be taken for granted, since both are the product of complex, ongoing work, of multiple actors (Bachrach and Baratz, 1963; Felstiner et al., 1980; Gusfield, 1981; Cobb and Ross, 1997; Chailleux and Zittoun, 2022). Therefore, the panel examines whether the contestation of greening policies is truly a singular phenomenon, in nature or intensity, or simply a normal process made more visible by the success and politicization of the concepts of “backlash” and “obstruction”. To explore this question, we adopt an agonistic perspective that puts the onus on the struggles structuring policy processes. We examine these contestations as a perpetually renewed struggle, not only over the definition of problems and solutions, but also over the very political ambition of greening policies: to disrupt and redraw the boundaries of more traditional public policies in the name of a greening deemed legitimate. More specifically, the panel focuses on three types of boundaries that greening policies unsettle. The first concerns the boundaries of problems, as actors struggle to define environmental issues and the legitimate solutions to address them. The second concerns policy boundaries, as greening policies cut across established sectors and challenge the actors who claim ownership over them. The third concerns territorial and social boundaries, as these policies redraw relations between center and periphery and raise new questions of socio-territorial inequality. By examining these boundary struggles, the panel aims to better understand both what is specific to the contestation of greening policies and what it shares with the conflicts that shape policy processes more generally.

POLICY TOPICS
Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics General Public Policy (no specific sector) Environment and Climate Policy
P146. Thinking the role of the 'community' in care policies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Picard
A. Charette
C. Needham
ABSTRACT

Care research still approaches the ‘community’ as a loosely defined category (Haubner and van Dyk 2021). This panel addresses the ways in which public policies, at every level of government, practically shape the boundaries of the ‘community’, determine its resources, and ascribe specific roles to it. Teppo Kröger (2026) recently called to speak of a ‘care square’ rather than a ‘care diamond’ (Razavi 2007). The latter concept was itself brought into welfare research to overcome the limits of the welfare triangle (Esping-Andersen 1990) that includes only three provider sectors: the family, the state and the market. The ‘community’ also plays an important role — albeit less documented — in national welfare mixes (Evers 1990). It is now established that the for-profit and non-profit sectors, the state and the family are intertwined and interdependent in highly complex ways. To account for this reality, Evers et al. (1994) proposed replacing the triangle with a ‘welfare diamond’ composed of the family, the state, the market, and the ‘voluntary sector’. Against the idea that the ‘community’ only borrows its logics from the state or the market, Jenson (2015) has strongly argued in favor of a four-cornered model. It was the application of the welfare diamond concept to care research (Razavi 2007; Ochiai 2009) that led to the ‘care diamond’ model. From one author to the other, the community has different boundaries and scopes. Ochiai (2009, 63) has defined the community as ‘various relationships that are informal but not between relatives’. Tingvold and Førland (2021, 158) have underlined that ‘third associations’ not only provide professional care services but also organize voluntary work, that is, ‘unpaid contributions that are given without reward or compensation that benefit individuals or groups outside family and close friends’. Moreover, there have been very few attempts at conceptualizing the community’s role in the provision of welfare (Mumtaz and Kihner 2025) or care (Ochiai 2009). By contrast, the three corners and axes of the traditional welfare triangle have been extensively described and analyzed, for instance through concepts such as marketisation (Mitton 2009), commodification (Esping-Andersen 1990; Bertrand and Panitch 2024), familization, defamilization and refamilization (Kroger 2011) or the construction of regime typologies (Leitner 2003; Bettio and Plantenga 2004; Geissler and Pfau-Effinger 2005; Le Bihan et al. 2013; Saraceno 2016). Whereas the role of policies has been extensively documented when it comes to marketization familization and the welfare state retrenchment (Pierson 1994), the dynamics of the community in care policies must be considered as a major research gap. This panel is designed as an opportunity to address it. The panel welcomes papers on a wide range of care policies and drawing on a diversity of frameworks, methodologies and types of data. Comparative analyses and attempts at typologies will be particularly appreciated, but the organizers encourage all types of contributions.

POLICY TOPICS
Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Social Policy Health and Well-Being Policy
P199. Governance by and of Intermediaries
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
D. Levi Faur
R. Medzini
ABSTRACT

Intermediaries have become increasingly important actors in domestic, European, and transnational governance. Regulatory regimes frequently rely on third-party certifiers, auditors, accreditation bodies, accounting firms, credit-rating agencies, standard-setting organizations, reporting regimes, rankings, gatekeepers, monitors, and whistleblowers. These actors may interpret rules, provide information, monitor conduct, verify compliance, certify performance, facilitate enforcement, and mediate relations among regulators, regulatees, beneficiaries, and wider publics. This panel invites papers examining both governance by intermediaries and governance of intermediaries. Governance by intermediaries concerns the ways in which intermediary actors participate in the exercise of regulatory and governing authority. Governance of intermediaries concerns the arrangements through which intermediaries themselves are authorized, supervised, constrained, evaluated, made transparent, and held accountable. The increasing reliance on intermediaries can expand regulatory capacity, mobilize expertise, improve information, facilitate monitoring, and strengthen compliance. At the same time, it raises important questions about delegation, autonomy, conflicts of interest, capture, legitimacy, transparency, responsibility, and democratic control. Where regulatory functions are distributed among public, private, professional, and hybrid actors, it may become difficult to determine who exercises authority, whose interests intermediaries serve, and who should be held responsible when governance fails. The panel seeks theoretical, empirical, comparative, and methodological papers addressing the roles, functions, successes, failures, accountability, and transparency of intermediaries. Topics may include certification, verification, auditing, accreditation, monitoring, reporting, ranking, standard setting, delegation of regulatory tasks and authority, intermediary autonomy and discretion, conflicts of interest and capture, accountability and oversight mechanisms, and variation across countries, sectors, and regulatory regimes. We particularly welcome papers that examine the legal and institutional mechanisms through which intermediaries are created, recognized, empowered, supervised, and sanctioned, as well as work on intermediaries in areas such as digital governance, environmental protection, finance, labor regulation, health, and artificial intelligence. The panel aims to problematize rather than assume the effects of intermediation. Under what conditions do intermediaries enhance regulatory capacity, credibility, and public welfare? When do they generate opacity, dependency, or unaccountable authority? Which forms of transparency, verification, supervision, and accountability are appropriate for different intermediary functions? More broadly, we invite papers that consider how an intermediation perspective may reshape theories of regulatory governance, delegation, private authority, accountability, state capacity, and democratic public policy.

POLICY TOPICS
Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Regulation and Regulatory Governance
P201. Who Governs Mental Health? Institutions, Actors and Participation in Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Brunn
A. L'Espérance
D. Moreau
ABSTRACT

Mental health has become an increasingly prominent issue on public policy agendas worldwide. Growing recognition of mental health needs, changing models of care, the deinstitutionalization and demands for more accessible, inclusive and rights-based services have prompted governments to reconsider how mental health policies are designed, financed and implemented (WHO, 2022). Yet mental health remains a particularly fragmented policy field, spanning healthcare, social services, disability policy, education and employment, public health and prevention, and involving a wide range of public authorities, professionals, organisations and people with lived experience. This fragmentation raises important questions for public policy research. Mental health is not only a matter of healthcare provision, but also a field of political negotiation, institutional change and competing definitions of public problems. Different professional, scientific and experiential perspectives coexist, sometimes challenging established arrangements and the legitimacy of public interventions (Brunn et al., 2026). At the same time, growing recognition of patients' rights, autonomy and participation calls into question established distributions of authority within mental health systems. A central question for this panel is therefore who has the authority to define mental health problems, shape policy responses and participate in collective decisions. How is this authority distributed, negotiated or contested among public institutions, professionals, civil society organisations and people directly concerned? The panel invites contributions examining how mental health policies are formulated, governed, implemented and transformed. Two interconnected, but non-exclusive, lines of enquiry are particularly relevant: - Governance, institutions and policy instruments. How do political processes, institutional arrangements, professional interests and policy instruments shape mental health policies? Contributions may examine how mental health issues are framed, the fragmentation of responsibilities across sectors and levels of government, policy coordination, financing and regulatory arrangements, professional representation, and the conditions facilitating or constraining policy change (Lascoumes & Le Galès, 2007; Perera, 2022; Schneider and Ingram, 2005). - Participation, rights and decision-making. How do people with lived experience contribute to shaping mental health policies, services and research? Contributions may investigate collective representation and mobilization, including the role of advocacy and peer-led movements in influencing policy agendas and policy change. They may also examine the recognition and legitimacy of different forms of knowledge, the power dynamics between professional and experiential expertise, participatory arrangements, and the distribution of decision-making authority. Contributions may further address the tensions between autonomy, care and coercion, and examine how established institutional and professional hierarchies are challenged or reproduced (Moreau & Marques, 2020; Hopkins et al., 2024). These perspectives are not intended to necessarily constitute separate strands. Their intersection can raise broader questions about legitimacy, power, representation and the changing boundaries of mental health policy. The panel also welcomes contributions on other dimensions of the politics of mental health, including comparative policy analysis, agenda-setting, inequalities, policy implementation, evaluation and institutional innovation. It aims to foster dialogue between researchers from public policy analysis, political science, sociology, health policy and related disciplines, drawing on diverse empirical and national contexts.

POLICY TOPICS
Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Citizens, Participation and Social Movements Health and Well-Being Policy Social Policy
P227. Waters under climate pressure: policy innovation and cross-level coordination
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Fischer
N. Jager
ABSTRACT

Water is essential to life on our planet and the functioning of our societies and nature in many ways (water for irrigation, cooling, drinking, support for biodiversity, hydropower, etc.). These different functions are politically dealt with in different policy sectors (e.g. environment, health, energy, or agriculture) that are structurally separated or even in conflict with each other. With increasing pressures on water resources through e.g., climate change, coordination and problem-solving across sectoral demands for water is becoming increasingly important affecting a wide diversity of interests and stakeholders. For instance, demands for the protection of water resources compete with flood protection measures, while in turn having consequences for drinking water provision, agricultural land use, or the state of ecosystems. But these demands and concerned interests and stakeholders are not only spread across diverse policy sectors, but often need to be coordinated across administrative and political boundaries between countries or sub-states. Thus, spanning multiple sectorial, territorial, social and political boundaries, water governance provides a key challenge to the functioning of political coordination and problem-solving. Water has traditionally been a key policy sector for studies of the policy process, public administration, and environmental governance. Research on the governance and management of water resources has thus traditionally contributed to new developments in these broader fields. Examples for this emblematic potential of water policy and governance include several landmark studies in policy theories such as the Advocacy Coalitions Framework or the Institutional Analysis and Development Framework. More recently, for example, network approaches have been advanced in this field providing new insights in the governance of complex systems beyond the water realm. The objective of this panel is to continue this tradition and to discuss the current complexity of water governance. The panel will provide new ways of analyzing this complexity, linking these up with broader theories, approaches and methods of governance and the policy process. More specifically, this panel deals with the general question of how water governance, and governance of complex issues more generally, can find new ways to much needed policy innovation and cross-sectoral coordination. Our focus includes both, structural aspects of the design, adaptation and innovation of institutions, policies and governance structures, as well as procedural aspects of how actor interactions unfold and play out in dealing with these multi-faceted complexities and the production of innovative policies. Potential aspects to be explored include: i) the exploration and analysis of important trade-offs between different sources of complexity and their consequences for governance systems; ii) the capacity for policy innovation (or the absence thereof) in the face of increasing problem pressure and complexity; iii) the establishment of nascent, boundary-spanning policy problems and the responses of actors and policy systems; iv) the multi-scalar challenges of water spanning multiple environmental and political boundaries; v) water as a key policy sectors connecting other sectors, demanding new coalitions and new forms of collective action.

POLICY TOPICS
Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments
P243. Conflict and Collaboration as Entangled Phenomena in Environmental Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
O. Temby
M. Fienitz
K. Pakizer
ABSTRACT

In research on environmental governance, conflict and collaboration have tended to be conceptualized as opposing conditions. Conflict appears either as the problem that collaboration is meant to resolve or, in more recent scholarship, as a productive force that collaborative processes can harness. In both accounts, however, the two remain analytically distinct. This framing obscures much of what occurs when collaborative and participatory processes convene actors with competing claims to shared resources and, at times, incompatible understandings of what is being governed. In such settings, collaboration may be sustained amid substantial disagreement, and the absence of collaboration need not indicate conflict. Conceptualizing conflict and collaboration as entangled rather than opposed phenomena allows these dynamics to be examined directly. Building on the 2026 Ottawa workshop, this panel brings together researchers examining these dynamics across diverse contexts and levels of administration. It gives particular attention to horizontal or diagonal conflicts, in which responsibilities and power endowments are distributed across multiple, independent actors. The central question is how conflict and collaboration become entangled in environmental governance and what this entanglement means for policy processes and democratic functioning. Six questions guide the discussion. Conceptually, the panel asks: What conditions allow for the healthy coexistence of conflict and collaboration in participatory environmental governance? How should conflict be conceptualized when power endowments are horizontal? How are policy narratives developed and transformed as conflict intensifies? How do policy networks of conflict structure collaboration patterns? Methodologically, it considers: Which methods allow researchers to study conflict without exacerbating polarization or compromising trust in research? Which methods can access and produce conflict-related data that are difficult to obtain through traditional approaches? The panel also takes up four propositions developed at the Ottawa workshop: that conflict and collaboration can coexist and catalyze one another; that conflicts can be disentangled into networks of issues; that a holistic understanding of conflict requires different methodological approaches; and that policy narratives in horizontal conflicts strongly build on interpersonal affective conflict. These propositions are open to examination and challenge.

POLICY TOPICS
Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Policy Process Theories Other
P248. Wildfires Governance in Times of Climate Change: Europe in Comparative Perspective
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
T. Aguilera
D. BALLEREAU
ABSTRACT

At the global scale, the 21st-century world is now defined as the Pyrocene. Across Europe, the risk of wildfires has expanded and intensified over the last 20 years, driven by a combination of global warming, land-use planning decisions, forestry, agricultural and civil protection policies. Large-scale wildfires are becoming more frequent and intense, increasingly closer to urban areas, causing ever-greater harm to human populations, infrastructure and environment. First in the Mediterranean areas most historically affected, and now everywhere in Europe, the discourse on wildfire risk and policies has evolved. Wildfires are increasingly framed as a structural component of climate change. Although calls for prevention are not new, experts and some institutions now place greater emphasis on prevention over suppression. They also advocate expanding governance to include stakeholders beyond the traditional scope of civil protection, such as experts, farmers, economic actors, and citizens. Yet actual policy change remains largely incremental, suppression continues to dominate strategies and budgets in most countries, and reforms are uneven across countries, territories, and communities, from regions with a long-standing fire culture to newly exposed areas where awareness and preparedness remain limited. Whether these developments amount to a genuine transformation or to marginal adjustments within a persistent suppression paradigm remains an open question. Changes are also observable at the EU level, whose involvement has moved from fire prevention under agricultural policy towards an increasingly operational role in response through the Union Civil Protection Mechanism and rescEU. In 2026, a new integrated approach to fire risk management could emerge, aimed at reintegrating the preventive dimension. The literature on wildfires is high-quality; however, it is largely dominated by ecology and the environmental sciences, which have tended to focus on fire behavior and management techniques. Such work is frequently conducted in collaboration with practitioners and forestry experts, resulting in a body of literature that is of a very high standard, yet also highly normative and evaluative. By contrast, the study of multi-level governance and public policy regarding wildfire remains emerging and fragmented, with a few rare exceptions and some recent studies that have explicitly addressed issues of governance and framing at the European level. Yet, we believe that wildfires constitute a particularly promising empirical field for public policy and governance research. Because they cut across multiple sectors, including civil protection, forestry, agriculture, land-use planning, insurance, public health, and urban development. Political science has also key role to play here, by analysing power relations, budget allocations, institutional dynamics, and policy processes. Our panel aims to explore the history, diversity, and change of wildfire governance configurations, paying attention to both policy outcomes and governance processes. We will also examine how governance arrangements, policy choices, political dynamics, and the actions of policy entrepreneurs shape wildfire risk, and drive or constrain policy change across countries, levels of government, and communities. While centred on Europe, the panel welcomes comparative contributions from other fire-prone regions that can shed light on European trajectories, and more broadly on how public policy adapts to the major risks facing 21st-century societies.

POLICY TOPICS
Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Regional Policy Environment and Climate Policy
P256. Assessing AI Infrastructures: Sovereignty, Sociotechnical Choices, and Public Value(s)
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Asquer
M. Campbell-Verduyn
M. Maia
C. Aguerre
ABSTRACT

AI consists of infrastructural dependencies including the semiconductors industry and supply chains, cloud platforms, data centres, energy systems, software ecosystems, data, and contractual and regulatory arrangements. The governance of AI infrastructure is increasingly recognized as posing issues for sovereignty, self-sufficiency, meaningful decision-making autonomy, and distribution of benefits and risks in and across countries and regions (Mügge, 2024; Tanner et al., 2026). These developments raise questions that extend beyond technological performance, competitiveness, and national self-sufficiency. How do infrastructure choices shape future technological trajectories and constrain the range of available alternatives? Who benefits from these arrangements, who bears their costs and risks, and whose values inform decisions about infrastructure development? How can competing claims concerning sovereignty, security, innovation, sustainability, and democratic accountability be assessed and reconciled? These questions call for approaches that examine AI infrastructure as a sociotechnical system and connect technological choices to their broader societal implications. These governance issues are magnified due to the material and institutional unevenness of AI infrastructures. Semiconductor policies, which have progressively shifted from a competition-oriented towards securitised industrial policy, depend on market demand, skills, and supply chain positions rather than subsidies alone (Heldt and Meunier, 2026; Raj and Wuttke, 2026). Expansion of data centres has triggered pressures on national grids, as well as increased household energy costs (Meeks et al., 2026). The concentration of AI computing in a small number of countries and firms entails complicated commercial and geo-strategic tensions (Martens and Schenk, 2026). Cloud platforms, public procurement contracts, and technical standards may embed lock-in, opacity, and weak accountability (Grohmann et al, 2025). Options to reduce technological dependency, through the likes of open weight models, may not suffice to gain autonomy from other countries and firms, especially when considering computing power, ownership of data, and availability of skilled labour (Shonubi, 2026). In this panel, we invite theoretical, empirical and policy-oriented contributions on, and not only: 1. Sovereignty and interdependence: concepts, factors, and consequences of geo-strategic dependency. 2. Geoeconomics and industrial policy: chips, cloud, compute, export controls and strategic indispensability. 3. Infrastructure, energy, and democratic participation: distributional effects of data centres, grid investment, environmental and societal impacts, and community consent. 4. Public procurement and legal governance: portability, exit rights, licensing, auditability, accountability, and vendor lock-in. 5. Regional and Global South strategies: shared compute, regional models, data governance, and collective capability-building. 6. Open ecosystems and state capacity: the sustainability and governance of open-source tools, model adaptation, standards, and public digital infrastructure. Submissions may use historical, qualitative, quantitative, legal, or mixed-methods approaches, also in comparative perspective. We particularly welcome work connecting infrastructure decisions to public value(s), rights, equity, social and environmental justice, democratic participation and institutional capacity.

POLICY TOPICS
Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Regulation and Regulatory Governance Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy
P257. Collaborative Governance in Social and Health Policies: limits, outcomes and reconceptualization
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Hassenteufel
M. ASSAF
A. Peltier
ABSTRACT

The notions of “collaborative governance” (Ansell, Gash, 2008) and “collaborative public management” (Mac Guire, 2006; Meek, 2021) have been developed in a context of growing complexity of policy issues and the diffusion of new public management (Osborne, 2010). In a broad sense collaborative policies can be defined as horizontal inter-institutional, inter-organizational, inter-professional and multi-level policies aiming to tackle wicked public problems (Head, 2022), bridging historically established sectoral boundaries, by the shaping of new boundary-crossing agencies and boundary-spanning roles (Williams, 2011). Coordination issues between different policy sectors, policy actors and policy levels are particularly relevant for health and social policies. The blurring of the historically strong compartmentalization of these policies, between sectors related to different social risks concerns especially the issue of poverty, which has been increasingly tackled in relation to unemployment policies, housing policies and family policies (with the rise of lone-parent families). More generally social (and health) policies have been coupled with anti-discrimination measures concerning gender and/or racial equality. Ageing has also become a key cross-sectional issue related to social policies (long-term care), healthcare policies (including mental health) and disability policies. The increasing intersection between social and/or health issues with environmental issues is another important trigger of collaborative policies. In this panel we are looking for papers analyzing empirically, in a relational policy process studies perspective, collaborative public policies linked to wicked problems and intersectoral issues (such as poverty and social exclusion, ageing, disability, mental health…) concerning social and/or health policies. Comparative papers (between countries and/or territories) are especially welcome. Yet, to go beyond the empirical finding of the development of collaborative institutions, instruments and networks, the focus of this panel is on three main questions: 1. What are the limits and obstacles to collaborative governance in a context of increased budgetary constraints on social and health policies and the rise of right-wing and populist oriented policies challenging these policies? This new context triggers new vertical and hierarchical (even authoritarian) dynamics opposite to the bottom-up logic of collaborative governance. 2. What are the outcomes of collaborative governance in social and health policies? Policies focused on inter-sectoral policy coordination, by giving more autonomy and a new policy role to local or private actors, can produce new inequalities (not only socio-economic, gender and racial inequalities but also territorial or generational inequalities). 3. How is it possible to reconceptualize collaborative governance by considering these limits and outcomes. We also welcome theoretical oriented papers in this panel. References Ansell, C., & Gash, A. (2008). Collaborative governance in theory and practice. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 18(4) J. W. Meek (Ed.) (2021), Handbook of Collaborative Public Management. Edward Elgar Head, B. (2022). Wicked Problems in Public Policy Understanding and Responding to Complex Challenges. PalgraveMcMillan. McGuire, M. (2006). Collaborative public management. Public Administration Review, 66(1) Osborne, S.P. (Ed.) (2010). The New Public Governance? Emerging Perspectives on the Theory and Practice of Public Governance. Routledge. Williams, P. (2012). Collaboration in Public Policy and Practice: Perspectives on Boundary Spanners. Policy Press.

POLICY TOPICS
Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Equity, Gender, Inclusion and the Diversity in Public Policy Social Policy Health and Well-Being Policy
P101. Climate Change and the Transformation of Multi-level Governance: Recentralization, Decentralization and Territorial Policy Implementation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
R. Pasquier
A. Cole
ABSTRACT

Climate change is increasingly transforming the priorities, instruments and institutional arrangements through which public policies are designed and implemented (Ostrom 2012). Although climate change is a global challenge, its consequences and many of the measures required to address them are profoundly territorial (Fuhr and al. 2018; Haupt and al. 2022). Adaptation, land-use planning, housing, mobility, energy, agriculture, biodiversity and the management of natural resources all depend heavily on regional and local governments (Pailler and al. 2026). At the same time, national governments and international institutions have strengthened climate targets, regulatory frameworks, strategic planning and monitoring mechanisms. Climate change therefore raises a fundamental question about the contemporary organisation of the state: does the growing importance of climate policy lead to recentralization, decentralization, or a transformation of multi-level governance? This panel examines in which way and how much climate change is reshaping the distribution of authority, resources, responsibilities and policy capacity between levels of government (Benz 2024; Jon and Peters 2020; Marks and al. 1996). It starts from the observation that climate governance cannot be understood simply through the traditional opposition between centralization and decentralization (Cole and al. 2015). Climate policies may simultaneously strengthen central steering while increasing the responsibilities of territorial governments. National governments may establish targets, standards and funding mechanisms, while regions, cities and other territorial actors are expected to translate these objectives into locally appropriate strategies. This can produce new forms of interdependence rather than a straightforward transfer of power (Pasquier, Simoulin and Weisbein 2025). In a way, climate change leads us to operate the same intellectual turn that did occur in European Studies thirty years ago. Whereas Europeanization was perceived as either an erosion of the Nation-State or to the contrary a rescue of it, approaches in terms of governance led to other ways of thinking. The same question is now set inside Nations States about relations between central authorities and local and regional ones. The panel consequently focuses on the relationship between climate policy, multi-level governance and territorial policy implementation. It asks under which institutional, political and territorial conditions climate change generates different configurations of authority and coordination (Bouckaert and al. 2010; Pressman, 1984; Trein and al. 2019). Particular attention will be paid to the distinction between formal competences and effective policy capacity: who formally decides may not be the same as who possesses the knowledge, resources and organizational capacities required to implement climate policies. The panel also invites contributions examining whether climate change constitutes a new phase in the transformation of the State (Pierson, 2000). Does the increasing strategic importance of climate policy reinforce national planning and coordination? Does it strengthen the autonomy and policy capacity of regional and local governments? Or does it generate hybrid governance arrangements in which national governments retain strategic control while territorial actors become increasingly important for implementation, adaptation and policy experimentation? Comparative research across countries, regions, cities or policy sectors is particularly welcome, as are studies of different State traditions and territorial governance arrangements. The panel aims to contribute to debates on multi-level governance, decentralization, policy implementation and state transformation by treating climate change not only as a policy challenge but also as a potential driver of institutional and territorial reconfiguration. The panel welcomes contributions addressing questions including: - Does the growing importance of climate policy lead to recentralization or territorialisation of public action?- How are authority, resources and responsibilities redistributed between national, regional and local governments?- Under which conditions does climate governance strengthen territorial policy capacity?- How do national climate strategies interact with local and regional priorities?- Does decentralisation improve the capacity to implement climate policies, or does it generate coordination problems?- How do different state traditions and territorial governance arrangements shape climate policy implementation?- Can national steering and territorial autonomy coexist, and under which institutional conditions?- Are climate policies producing durable transformations in multi-level governance?

POLICY TOPICS
Multilevel Governance and Local Policy State and Policy Capacity General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P134. Collaborative Public Policy Across Levels of Government: Institutions, Middle Managers, and Policy Coordination
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Barer
F. Yuval
ABSTRACT

Contemporary public policy challenges increasingly require coordination and collaboration across different levels of government, administrative institutions, and organizational boundaries. Issues such as emergency management, sustainability, urban development, public service delivery, and digital transformation cannot be effectively addressed by a single governmental actor. Instead, they require collaborative arrangements that connect national policy objectives with local knowledge, institutional capacities, and implementation practices. Existing scholarship on multilevel governance, collaborative governance, and intergovernmental relations has emphasized the importance of institutional arrangements, networks, and coordination mechanisms in shaping policy outcomes. Ansell and Gash (2008) identify institutional design, leadership, trust-building, and collaborative processes as central elements of collaborative governance, while Emerson et al. (2012) provide an integrative framework linking collaborative dynamics to broader institutional and systemic contexts. Research on multilevel governance further demonstrates how informal and procedural interactions contribute to decision-making across governmental levels (van Popering-Verkerk & van Buuren, 2016). However, important questions remain regarding how collaboration is initiated, maintained, and translated into effective policy action, particularly when formal institutional structures are fragmented or insufficient. While traditional governance perspectives frequently distinguish between top-down policy direction and bottom-up implementation, growing attention to the roles of intermediate actors suggests the need to examine the processes occurring between these levels. Originally developed in the context of energy transitions, the middle-out perspective highlights how middle actors can influence change upward, downward, and laterally through their agency and capacity (Parag & Janda, 2014). Its subsequent application to public health governance demonstrates how intermediary actors may shape policy formulation, resource allocation, and program continuity within administrative settings (Kranzler et al., 2019). Research on English subnational governance also highlights the challenges associated with intermediate territorial levels of governance, particularly regarding accountability, institutional responsibilities, and coordination (Shaw & Greenhalgh, 2010). Middle managers, regional administrators, and other intermediary actors may serve as institutional brokers, facilitating communication, negotiating competing priorities, translating policy objectives, and building trust across governmental boundaries. This panel seeks to explore how collaborative public policy emerges and operates across levels of government, with particular attention to the institutional, organizational, and individual mechanisms that enable or constrain coordination. By integrating collaborative governance scholarship with middle-out and multilevel governance perspectives, the panel aims to examine not only the institutional conditions for collaboration but also the administrative actors and practices through which coordination is achieved. The panel addresses four interconnected research questions: How do formal and informal institutional arrangements shape collaboration between national, regional, and local governments? What roles do middle managers and intermediary actors play in coordinating policy processes, translating objectives, and bridging institutional boundaries? How do transparency, information sharing, trust, and accountability influence intergovernmental collaboration and policy implementation? Under what conditions do collaborative governance arrangements contribute to more coherent, responsive, and effective public policies? The panel invites critical examination of whether intermediary actors can compensate for institutional fragmentation and whether informal coordination mechanisms complement or undermine formal accountability structures. It also encourages investigation of how administrative capacity, institutional incentives, organizational cultures, and crisis conditions affect collaborative practices. Lahat and Sher-Hadar (2020) further emphasize that collaborative governance is not universally beneficial and propose examining the values, situational considerations, and contextual conditions under which collaborative arrangements should be promoted, while research on emergency organizations in Israel demonstrates that public trust is associated with general trust in the public sector, perceived organizational readiness, and perceived threats of emergencies (Mizrahi et al., 2021). These findings provide a basis for examining how collaborative mechanisms operate under different administrative and policy conditions. By bringing together theoretical, comparative, and empirical perspectives, the panel aims to advance understanding of the mechanisms connecting institutions, administrative actors, and policy coordination. Its broader contribution is to deepen scholarly debates on collaborative governance and multilevel policymaking while identifying institutional and managerial practices that may strengthen public policy design and implementation. More specifically, the panel seeks to connect institutional explanations of collaborative governance with the middle-out perspective, thereby advancing understanding of how intermediary actors influence coordination, accountability, and policy implementation across governmental levels.

POLICY TOPICS
Multilevel Governance and Local Policy Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition
P254. Local government and policy innovation in health policy and beyond.
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
B. Hawkins
N. Karreman
A. van den Akker
ABSTRACT

Local governance systems have emerged as important sites of policy innovation in health and wider public policy debates. Importantly, they can also serve as incubators for innovative, and sometimes radical, policy ideas. For example, local jurisdictions have been key actors in the implementation of interventions to improve health outcomes (e.g., developing policies on air quality, active transportation, and access to nutritious food). Local governments have also adopted innovative approaches to local economic development and community wealth building, utilising the powers at their disposal such as public procurement, commissioning and investment) (Rose et al., 2023). On the other hand, local innovation can lead to geographical asymmetries, for example in health service provision and outcomes, raising important questions about health equity at the national level. Similarly, the possibility for local action can introduce new burdens on local-level actors and create additional calls on already constrained resources. The potential for locally-driven innovations to move beyond the status quo, or to break policy equilibria, has often exceeded that at the national level, and so can be an important vehicle for policy innovation and spillover both horizontally and vertically. At the same time, there is a tension between the potential for ‘bottom-up’ policy entrepreneurship at a local government level, and the institutional and political factors which shape and constrain local decision-making from above, including multi-level governance structures, funding streams and political cycles. Differences in mandates, structures and ways of working within local government mean that policy officers must potentially navigate both horizontal and vertical challenges. Policy innovation can occur within the context of federal systems or through other forms of devolution to the regional and local levels. Existing scholarship documents the role of policy entrepreneurship and policy learning in driving local policy innovation, and resistance to this by commercial actors and other vested interests (e.g., Daly et al., 2026; Lauber et al., 2021). Scholars have also explored the role of ‘the local’ in addressing global challenges from different disciplinary perspectives and in different substantive policy areas such as health, climate, and economic development while adopting a range of theoretical perspectives (e.g. Gaffney, 2025). This panel aims to build on previous research focused on health policy making in the UK through comparative analysis with other areas of public policy and policy contexts. It seeks to encourage nuanced and theoretically-informed approaches to the study of local policy action, to examine the local level as a site of policy innovation and entrepreneurship from different perspectives and across polities, to understand the interactions with, and constrains placed on local policy actors by, central governments, and to spark comparative analyses between policy areas beyond health. References Daly, M. P., McQuire, C., d’Apice, K., Burrows, A., Hulls, P. P., Lake, A., Boyland, E., Vamos, E. P., Cummins, S., & Vocht, F. de. (2026). Adopting and implementing local government policy restrictions on harmful commodities advertising in England: A qualitative exploration of challenges, facilitators and impacts. Research Square. https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-7808983/v2. Gaffney, A. (2025). Accelerating climate action in unfavourable local contexts: The role of policy entrepreneurship. NPJ Climate Action, 4(1), 66. https://doi.org/10.1038/s44168-025-00266-x. Lauber, K., Hunt, D., Gilmore, A. B., & Rutter, H. (2021). Corporate political activity in the context of unhealthy food advertising restrictions across Transport for London: A qualitative case study. PLoS Medicine, 18(9), e1003695. Rose, T. C., Daras, K., Manley, J., McKeown, M., Halliday, E., Goodwin, T. L., Hollingsworth, B., & Barr, B. (2023). The mental health and wellbeing impact of a Community Wealth Building programme in England: A difference-in-differences study. The Lancet Public Health, 8(6), e403–e410. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2468-2667(23)00059-2.

POLICY TOPICS
Multilevel Governance and Local Policy Policy Transfer/Diffusion/Learning Health and Well-Being Policy Administration and Civil Service Policy
P263. Circular economy as public policy: Comparing design, capacity and outcomes across waste, water, and climate
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Schreurs
N. NARAYANAN
S. Suchithra
ABSTRACT

The circular economy has moved quickly from a design idea to a policy goal. Governments now promote it in solid waste management, recycling and reuse, wastewater and sanitation, and climate mitigation. Across these sectors, policy documents promise resource recovery, reduced waste and lower emissions. Much less is known about how these ambitions work in practice, particularly when they encounter existing institutions, budgets and labour arrangements. This panel approaches the circular economy as a public policy concern, rather than treating it only as a technical or business proposition. The panel focuses on three related questions. The first concerns policy design. Governments promote circularity through regulation, extended producer responsibility, subsidies, public provision and mobilisation campaigns. How are these instruments selected, and how do they work together as policy mixes (Rogge and Reichardt 2016; Milios 2018)? The second concerns policy capacity. Circular systems often depend on the participation of dispersed units, including households, small processors and informal workers. What kinds of administrative and political capacity does this require of governments? How are responsibilities distributed across different tiers of government (Wu, Ramesh and Howlett 2015)? The third concerns policy mobility. Circular economy models have largely emerged from European policy debates but are now being adopted in very different settings. What aspects of these models travel, how are they adapted, and whose interests influence the process (Dolowitz and Marsh 2000; Peck and Theodore 2015)? The panel also draws on critical work questioning whether circularity actually reduces costs or shifts them to other actors, and who bears the consequences (Gregson et al. 2015; Corvellec, Stowell and Johansson 2022). Labour, informality and equity are therefore central concerns. We welcome papers comparing sectors, countries and levels of government, with particular interest in comparisons between the Global North and Global South. Single case studies are also welcome where they contribute to a wider public policy debate.

POLICY TOPICS
Multilevel Governance and Local Policy Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Environment and Climate Policy Social Policy
P86. Policy ‘Workarounds’ and Innovations for Climate-Impacted Water Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
D. VanNijnatten
C. Johns
ABSTRACT

Climate impacts are evident in shared water basins across the world, and magnifying these challenges is the shared nature of water resources. For over a decade, there has been an emerging consensus that the world’s water challenges related to climate change actually emerge out of governance deficiencies (UN 2008; OECD 2015). Water is governed through a patchwork of regional agreements, sector-specific initiatives, and loosely coordinated international bodies alongside extensive domestic legal and policy architectures (Pahl-Wostl 2015, 2021; Gupta et.al. 2013, Bilalova et.al. 2025). Scholars and practitioners highlight growing governance and policy gaps that are compounded by climate change (Gupta et.al. 2013; Pichis-Garcia and Cueva-Rodrigues 2026), i.e., water quality governance and water allocation provisions do not allow for flexibility to respond to changing precipitation and streamflow patterns or to resource overuse; water quality and quantity governance regimes are not well integrated; surface waters are governed separately from groundwater; and top-down political considerations stifle watershed-based and locally-driven solutions (VanNijnatten and Johns 2020). Unfortunately, the prospects for new/updated treaties, agreements or institutions to manage these problems are low, given current economic, geopolitical and domestic partisan dynamics. However, there is evidence that new policy approaches, processes, and instruments to address water challenges are emerging at all scales, and particularly at local and community levels (Shunglu et al., 2022). Public officials, water users, conservationists, Indigenous communities, scientists and other interests in shared water basins are finding new ways to collaborate through inventive policy approaches, policy processes and program delivery that transcend traditional borders (e.g., Newig et.al. 2016). They are, in essence, figuring out how to 'work around' existing governance architectures to provide shorter-term solutions and/or to innovate in ways that have the potential to fully transform old policies and governance approaches. Yet, while both policy workarounds and innovations represent goal-driven adaptations to overcome constraints, policy innovations have greater potential to alter organizations and outputs, change who is setting goals and making decisions, change decision processes, and transform our systems for managing water for the longer-term in an era of accelerating climate change (Sorensen 2017, Knagaard et.al. 2025). This panel will explore what workarounds or novel governance arrangements and policy approaches in terms of new authorities, structures, processes, knowledge, and tools are evident or emerging in water governance to build climate resilience. We are particularly interested in dialogue across papers that considers: how and under what conditions can new policy arrangements provide sufficient basis for solutions to our water governance weaknesses in an era of accelerating climate impacts?

POLICY TOPICS
Multilevel Governance and Local Policy Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Regional Policy Other
P117. Situated Preparedness: European actors, Governance and Policy implementation in the Face of Emerging Risks
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
T. Sabadel
F. Le Marcis
ABSTRACT

Preparedness has become a central principle of contemporary public policy, shaping how governments and international organizations anticipate, monitor, and respond to uncertain future threats (Lakoff, 2017). From emerging infectious diseases and vaccination programmes to environmental disruptions and climate-related hazards, preparedness policies increasingly rely on surveillance infrastructures, scientific expertise, intersectoral coordination, and anticipatory forms of governance. Within the European Union (EU), the COVID-19 pandemic revealed uneven and contrasting preparedness capacities among Member States (Eerens, Hrzic, and Clemens, 2023; Moury, Jacques, and Ben Jelili, 2025). It also showed that Member States opted for further integration in response to the pandemic (Brooks et al., 2023) and reinforced European institutions’ role in epidemic surveillance and response, particularly through a security discourse (Godziewski and Rushton, 2024). This panel aims to analyse how preparedness can serve as a valuable resource for key actors seeking either to promote their interests or to place specific issues on the European agenda. This panel focuses primarily on preparedness policies concerning emerging infectious diseases and the institutional response to epidemic outbreaks within the EU. It mobilizes the notion of “situated preparedness” to describe how transnational ambitions for disease preparedness are translated, negotiated and implemented from European institutions into Member states policies and surveillance practices. From this perspective, preparedness emerges not as a uniform technical capacity that can simply be transferred from one context to another but as a situated process which is implemented into national administrations and shaped by local epidemiological realities, institutional surveillance capacities and professional configurations. Preparedness is also shaped by power relations among several actors and it is therefore a site of competition between interests over agenda-setting and resource allocation. From a comparative perspective within the EU, and given that health remains primarily a national competence, preparedness raises questions both about Member States’ capacity to respond to epidemic threats and about the europeanisation of health issues (Guiguier, 2011; Hassenteufel, 2013). This process may take place through cooperation and Member States’ compliance with European agencies such as the ECDC, or through the funding of sectoral programmes designed to strengthen health-system resilience, such as the EU4Health programme. The panel also investigates how preparedness policies, alongside existing public health policies, are translated, adapted, and even reconfigured in response to Member States’ local institutional, administrative, and health contexts. These questions make it possible to examine both European health governance and the ways in which health crises caused by emerging epidemics may contribute to the Europeanisation of health issues, for example through the joint procurement or production of vaccines, the collection of health data, or the promotion of One Health. Drawing on research in multilevel governance, public policy analysis, agenda-setting, the sociology of expertise, and knowledge production, this panel welcomes empirical contributions from different policy fields and geographical contexts. It aims to foster discussion of how preparedness is governed, enacted, and sustained within the EU, how it reflects the transformation of the European policies and, more broadly, how this notion can be useful to analyze multilevel governance on health issues.

POLICY TOPICS
Multilevel Governance and Local Policy Interest Groups/Lobbying Health and Well-Being Policy Security, Defense and Risk Governance
P181. Governing the Urban Commons: Policy Instruments, Public Intervention and Implementation at the Local Level
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Carminucci
G. Bonazzi
L. Coube Cardoso
ABSTRACT

In rapidly urbanising societies, collaboration pacts between residents and local administrations are frequently adopted for urban regeneration, services are taken back into public hands and collective knowledge is produced. Building on Ostrom’s (1990) institutional approach, scholarship has examined how urban commons are constituted through the interaction of shared resources, communities and governing arrangements, as proximity, density and agglomeration shape how urban assets are contested and used (Foster & Iaione, 2016; Feinberg et al., 2021). Within this framework, the role of the local state cannot be overlooked. Local government is central to many examples of participation and urban commons governance, enabling and facilitating collaborative arrangements. Urban experimentation adds a learning dimension to how commons are governed, as experiences with new partnerships and forms of engagement may feed back into local policymaking. A more critical strand warns that co-production with the local state can lead to enhancement or co-optation (Bianchi et al., 2024), and that participatory commitments made during remunicipalisation may be rolled back (Turri & Vitale, 2026). This literature risks a normative bias, assuming that collective arrangements for commoning resources are intrinsically good and better suited to resolving distributional conflicts. Advancing the concept for policy studies requires examining the disputes over governing urban commons within complex local dynamics, where public authority is fragmented and nested within other levels of government. The literature has paid limited attention to how commons governance gains prominence and relates to policy design and instrumentation. For example, how urban commons claims enter agendas, become policy instruments and are reshaped or reversed in implementation. The panel proposes a policy instruments lens (Lascoumes & Le Galès, 2007; Halpern et al., 2026) to address this gap. Regulations, collaboration pacts, concessions, service contracts and partnerships are not neutral devices as each embodies a theory of the relationship between governing and governed and produces its own effects. The overarching questions are: through which policy instruments do public authorities intervene in urban commons? How are these instruments chosen, implemented and revised, and with what consequences for control, access, distribution and accountability? Bianchi, I., Pera, M., Calvet-Mir, L., Villamayor, S., Ferreri, M., Reguero, N., & Maestre Andrés, S. (2024). Urban commons and the local state: Co-production between enhancement and co-optation. Territory, Politics, Governance, 12(9), 1333–1352. https://doi.org/10.1080/21622671.2022.2108491 Feinberg, A., Ghorbani, A., & Herder, P. M. (2021). Diversity and challenges of the urban commons: A comprehensive review. International Journal of the Commons, 15(1), 1–20. https://doi.org/10.5334/ijc.1033 Foster, S. R., & Iaione, C. (2016). The city as a commons. Yale Law & Policy Review, 34(2), 281–349. https://yalelawandpolicy.org/city-commons Halpern, C., Lascoumes, P., & Le Galès, P. (Eds.). (2026). Policy instrumentation: Theoretical debates and controversies. Edward Elgar Publishing. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781035372508 Lascoumes, P., & Le Galès, P. (2007). Introduction: Understanding public policy through its instruments: From the nature of instruments to the sociology of public policy instrumentation. Governance, 20(1), 1–21. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0491.2007.00342.x Ostrom, E. (1990). Governing the commons: The evolution of institutions for collective action. Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511807763 Turri, V. M., & Vitale, T. (2026). The Politics of Participatory Rollback in Urban Water Remunicipalization: Paris and Naples. Urban Affairs Review, 0(0). https://doi.org/10.1177/10780874261441878

POLICY TOPICS
Multilevel Governance and Local Policy Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P182. Changing Policies from Below? Subnational Policy Capacity and the Multilevel Governance of Sustainability
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. pahun
L. SÉNÉGAS
ABSTRACT

Subnational governments (Sates, Regions, Local Governments) are key actors in the transition toward sustainability. They contribute in two main ways. They adopt sustainability policies, which aim to mitigate and adapt to climate change, protect biodiversity and reduce pollution (Nagel & Kammerer 2023). They integrate climate and environmental goals into other policy sectors, such as agriculture, food, mobility or housing (Rogers et al. 2023). Their role has grown for two reasons. On the one hand, national and supranational authorities increasingly recognise and empower them. For instance, the Paris Agreement brought cities and regional authorities into the core of climate governance (Hale 2016). On the other hand, many initiatives emerge from the bottom up. For example, more than 500 cities have joined city food networks (Moragues-Faus 2021). Yet we know relatively little about their policy capacity when national choices conflict with local goals or constrain subnational competences (Fenna et al. 2023). Research also tends to focus on pioneer cities, overlooking ordinary and rural places (van der Heijden 2018). In this context, the panel examines the policy capacity of subnational governments to contribute to the transition toward sustainability and to shape its national and supranational regulation. Policy capacity research, which has primarily focused on national governments, defines it as the ability to mobilise resources to make collective choices (Painter & Pierre 2005), or as the skills and resources required to perform policy functions (Wu et al. 2015). Research on subnational governments adopts a relational perspective (Eckersley 2017), stressing coalitions and the ability to influence national or supranational decision-making (Pasquier 2015) and local interest groups (Senegas 2022). We therefore define subnational policy capacity as the ability of subnational governments to define problems, choose policy orientations, partners and instruments, mobilise resources and coalitions, and influence the decisions made by higher levels of government and local interest groups. We examine both how national governments shape subnational action and how subnational governments seek to influence national policies and rules. The panel asks: how do subnational governments build and mobilise policy capacity to adopt sustainability policies and integrate environmental objectives into other policy sectors? How does this capacity differ across levels? To what extent can they use it to reshape national and international agendas, policies and frames? Papers may explore three dimensions. First, acting within multilevel constraints: support from higher levels can strengthen subnational policy capacity (Eckersley 2018), while national and supranational policies can also constrain local action and block local innovation (Enguer & Navarrete 2025). Second, subnational governments as policy entrepreneurs: beyond the well-documented role of transnational city networks (Kern 2019), other channels – associations of local governments, lobbying, litigation, and using delegated powers to resist national policy – deserve greater attention. Third, building and losing capacity over time: partisan change, emerging local issues and conflicts can reshape subnational policy capacity (Senegas 2024). The panel makes three contributions. It strengthens the application of the policy capacity framework at the subnational level. It conceptualises policy capacity as a political construct that changes over time. It places subnational policy initiatives in the wider context of national and supranational regulation, to assess what they can achieve and how they may transform this regulation.

POLICY TOPICS
Multilevel Governance and Local Policy State and Policy Capacity Regional Policy General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P192. Subnational Climate Governance Under Pressure: Shifting Coordination, State Capacity and Institutional arrangements
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Artigas
E. Grin
M. Atienza
ABSTRACT

This panel examines climate governance not merely as an environmental issue, but as a fundamental test of state capacity, institutional resilience, and governments' ability to sustain collective action under fiscal constraints, administrative fragmentation, and policy dismantling (Morais de Sa e Silva, M. 2023). Key challenges include contested expertise, weakening intergovernmental relations, and multilevel arrangements where authority and resources are unevenly distributed (Peters 2018; Radinger-Peer et al., 2025; Dombrowsky et al., 2022). Municipalities and metropolitan authorities face growing responsibilities—managing adaptation, emissions reduction, and energy transitions—while operating with dwindling resources and uncertain support from higher levels. This creates tension between their expanding roles and fragmented coordination systems (Marks & Pulliat, 2022). Research highlights relevant limitations of incomplete decentralization and persistent coordination challenges between national and subnational levels (Pizzini et al., 2025). The panel investigates how subnational governments build or lose capacity : what happens when coordination is fragmented and political support is contested,and external sources of resources and expertise become increasingly important? It also investigates whether cooperation among governments, international organizations, and civil society can offset institutional fragmentation or reproduce inequalities. Our panel explores climate governance through four interconnected dimensions: 1. Multilevel Governance and Social Participation:This dimension examines how national and subnational authorities coordinate climate objectives and how civil society, businesses, and community groups participate. Under what conditions societal networks strengthen public capacity versus generating fragmented accountability? Particular attention is paid to maintaining coordination under political polarization and institutional instability (Pierre & Peters, 2021). 2. Transnational Cooperation and External Resources: Development banks, international agencies, and transnational city networks provide funding, expertise, and policy models. The panel investigates how these resources are incorporated into local institutions, whether they strengthen administrative capabilities, and what happens when external support declines. Recent scholarship highlights the influence of transnational municipal cooperation and climate paradiplomacy in supporting local innovation beyond traditional state-centered frameworks (Acuto et al., 2024; Salazar, 2023). 3. Policy Dismantling and Climate Backlash: Moving beyond studies focused solely on policy expansion, this dimension examines institutional erosion, policy retrenchment, and declining political support. Climate transitions are shaped by both innovation and dismantling, creating pressures on long-term policy consistency and implementation capacities (Halpern & Mandelli, 2025; Schaub et al., 2024; Schaub, Tosun, & Jordan, 2024; Förell & Fischer, 2025). 4. Digital Transitions: Digital infrastructures increasingly function as governance instruments rather than just technical tools. Smart grids, AI-assisted planning, and monitoring systems can strengthen coordination but also generate new challenges, including energy pressures from AI and data centers. Digitalization may enhance state capacity while introducing new sources of complexity, dependency, and institutional vulnerability (Artigas, 2026). The panel welcomes theoretical, methodological, and empirical contributions from diverse contexts, particularly comparative research across Europe, Latin America, Southeast Asia, and Africa. By connecting these perspectives, the panel aims to advance a comparative understanding of how subnational climate governance capacity is constructed, maintained, contested, and transformed, explaining why similar challenges produce different institutional responses across contexts (Grin, 2025).

POLICY TOPICS
Multilevel Governance and Local Policy State and Policy Capacity Global and Transnational Policies Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy
P225. Territorial governance for social and sustainable development: approaches and practices from the Global South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Maia
R. Ravelo M
L. Laranja
ABSTRACT

In this panel, we explore, conceptually and empirically, how territorial governance can promote more sustainable and social development in the Global South. Our objective is to expand the discussion of governance and alternative development optics, considering social and climate justice for marginalized and vulnerable communities and territories. Presentations are accepted in English, Portuguese, and Spanish. The current international context reflects a systemic, civilizational, and socio-environmental crisis (Svampa, 2019). New wicked problems are emerging, such as digital security and climate cataclysm. At the same time, persistent problems in the Global South, such as poverty and inequality, are getting worse. In increasingly uncertain scenarios, we argue that one path forward is to strengthen territorial governance mechanisms as a bottom-up development framework. Decolonial perspectives in development studies reconstruct pluriversal thinking rather than valuing the universality of experiences (Mignolo & Walsh, 2018). They place the local community back at the center and mitigate the reproduction of domination and power. Environment, race, gender, colonialism, and modes of economic production are interconnected in understanding local realities and preserving the common good. Global environmental and climate changes affect the Global South unequally and fall more heavily on women and rural communities. Commoning, as a social relationship, becomes necessary for survival and development (e.g., Buen Vivir, ecofeminism, and postdevelopment) (Federici, 2019; Meagher, 2025; Ngcamu, 2023). Territory is a space of resilience against the threats and vulnerabilities that affect it (Maia et al., 2025). It represents the sum of place, people, identity, actions, and memories (Santos, 2006). Coloniality expresses itself here, as historical and cultural trajectories run counter to the homogenization of public problem-solving. Governance emerges from relationships between actors pursuing shared objectives. It is a practice of public action (Halpern et al., 2014) that goes beyond isolated State action. Territorial governance emphasizes community and relies on horizontal collaboration to solve public problems or plan the territory’s future (Dallabrida et al., 2022). It can operate through sociotechnical networks. These networks make the community the protagonist in identifying problems, turn diverse knowledge into action, and strengthen citizen science in dialogue with technical expertise (Maia et al., 2025). Its mechanisms include forms, instruments, and methodologies that bring actors together to improve the territory, such as technologies and solidarity economy arrangements. We welcome theoretical, methodological, and empirical papers, and we seek to build a research network that cooperates to promote development in the Global South. Proposals may address, in full or in part, three guiding questions: 1. How do territorial governance mechanisms contribute to social and sustainable development in the Global South, and under what institutional and community conditions are they effective or constrained? 2. How do sociotechnical networks and the articulation of different types of knowledge (scientific, technical, community-based, citizen) enable more effective and inclusive public policies for territories in the Global South? 3. What do decolonial approaches and community-based initiatives (e.g., Buen Vivir, ecofeminism, postdevelopment, solidarity economy) contribute to addressing public problems and reducing local and regional inequalities in the Global South?

POLICY TOPICS
Multilevel Governance and Local Policy Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Development Policy Regional Policy
P236. Tourism in Greenland and the Arctic: who decides, who benefits?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. CHOQUET
D. Thestrup
ABSTRACT

Tourism is increasingly promoted as a means of economic diversification and regional development in Greenland and across the Arctic. Tourism development is not simply a market-driven process. It is shaped by public policies, institutional decisions, investment strategies and visions of territorial development. As Arctic destinations seek to attract visitors, investment and international attention, tourism development raises fundamental questions about governance, infrastructure and logistics, economic and social benefits distribution, public authorities capacity to organise development, local communities influence over decisions affecting their territories. In Greenland, these questions are closely connected to economic diversification, political autonomy, Inuit rights and knowledge, environmental vulnerability, local resources and aspirations. The growing involvement of external investors and international tourism operators creates opportunities for economic development. It challenges also the capacity of public institutions and local communities to define and implement their own priorities. The panel connects research and community participation with public debates on policy instruments, implementation, and institutional capacity. Its analytical focus is how ownership structures and decision-making authority interact to shape the tourism landscape and the distribution of cost and benefit outcomes. This panel aims to examine tourism as a field of public policy through which competing interests and development priorities are discussed. It brings together scholars and practitioners to discuss the political, economic and social dimensions of tourism development in Greenland and more generally the Arctic. Under what conditions do local authorities create tourism policies that enable Greenlandic and other Arctic communities to shape development priorities and retain benefits locally? While Greenland provides a central point of reference, contributions addressing other Arctic and comparable peripheral regions are also welcome. The panel will address different research questions, such as: how do public authorities, private investors and international operators shape tourism policies?how do tourism policies distribute economic opportunities, costs and risks across territories, and how do they reinforce or reduce existing inequalities? how can public institutions and local communities influence tourism development and strengthen their capacity to organise territorial development?The panel will explore the hypothesis that tourism outcomes depend not only on economic dynamics but also on institutional arrangements and the decision-making power distribution. By connecting tourism studies with public policy analysis, political geography and regional development, the panel will contribute to debates on policy implementation, multilevel governance and state capacity. It will provide a space to examine how public policies can limitate tensions between economic development, external investment and local priorities. It will also provide a space to examine under what conditions tourism can support a more inclusive development in the Arctic. This panel is organised within the ANNORAAQ project (towards regenerative tourism in Greenland: sharing social, environmental and spatial qualities, led by Nicolas Escach (Sciences po Rennes). Funded by the French National Research Agency (ANR) through its France-Greenland Scientific Cooperation call, the ANNORAAQ project explores how regenerative tourism in Greenland can support more locally driven, socially acceptable and environmentally responsible tourism development in Greenland.

POLICY TOPICS
Multilevel Governance and Local Policy
P06. Climate Diasporas and Transnational Adaptation Governance: Migration, Health, and Policy Across Borders
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. NGOM
ABSTRACT

Climate change and human mobility are increasingly recognized as intertwined policy challenges (Black et al., 2011; Foresight, 2011; Adger et al., 2015), yet public policy scholarship has paid comparatively little attention to the role diaspora communities play in shaping, financing, or contesting adaptation policy in their countries of origin. Research on migration and adaptation has largely examined mobility as a household or community strategy in origin regions (Tacoli, 2009), and the migration-development literature has framed migrants and their associations as transnational development agents (Faist, 2008; for a critical review, see de Haas, 2010). Work on co-development and migrant networks in the Sahel (Scheffran et al., 2012) is a notable exception, showing how diaspora ties can support local adaptation projects. What remains largely unexamined is whether, and how, diasporas gain access to the formal processes through which adaptation policy is decided. This panel addresses that gap by examining diasporas not merely as recipients of climate-driven displacement narratives, but as active political and institutional actors: sources of remittances directed toward adaptation, participants in transnational health and environmental research, and voices increasingly present in high-level diplomatic exchanges between host and origin countries. The panel builds on the observation that transnational communities operate within transnational social fields (Levitt & Glick Schiller, 2004), navigating two simultaneous policy environments, the regulatory and health systems of their host countries and the climate vulnerabilities of their countries of origin, without a coherent governance framework connecting the two. This engages debates on cross-scale governance (Cash et al., 2006) and on the social limits to adaptation (Adger et al., 2009). It is particularly visible in transnational health-environment research examining how indoor climate, housing conditions, and migration-related environmental exposure affect wellbeing. This research connects to the migration-health agenda (Abubakar et al., 2018; Schwerdtle et al., 2018) and to the climate-health evidence base (Watts et al., 2021; Cissé et al., 2022), but remains weakly linked to adaptation policy. It is equally visible in diaspora associations that increasingly engage directly with heads of state and development agencies on climate and economic partnership agendas. The panel asks: How do diaspora communities participate in, or find themselves excluded from, the formal architecture of adaptation policy-making in their countries of origin? What institutional mechanisms, if any, translate diaspora engagement into policy influence rather than symbolic representation? And how are health and environmental risks associated with migration itself, rather than only climate risks “back home”, being addressed by current adaptation and migration policy frameworks? Hypotheses include: (1) diaspora associations function as informal policy entrepreneurs whose influence exceeds their formal recognition in national adaptation planning; (2) transnational health-environment research remains institutionally siloed from climate adaptation policy despite substantive overlap; and (3) high-level diplomatic engagement with diaspora communities rarely translates into structured policy consultation mechanisms. We welcome comparative, empirical, and theoretically oriented contributions from migration studies, public policy, health policy, and environmental governance.

POLICY TOPICS
Regulation and Regulatory Governance Policy Process Theories Health and Well-Being Policy General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P272. Private Authority and Public Regulation in Health Care
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Laugesen
ABSTRACT

This panel seeks to bring together scholars working on issues of private governance, private investment, and health care systems or health-related infrastructure. The objective of this panel is to explore two core questions: Under which conditions do states regulate, delegate, or abdicate authority to investors and nonprofit and professional associations? And what governance arrangements follow? In exploring these questions, this panel aims to apply regulatory governance theory to health care—a sector that accounts for a large share of public spending—and to use health as a demanding test case for theories of private authority and state capacity. Two example cases in the U.S. context illustrate this: Since the mid-20th century, the American Medical Association (AMA), which is the primary professional society for physicians, has maintained a federally mandated monopoly over the definition and classification of medical procedures, and retains a large level of influence over price-setting and reimbursement (Laugesen, 2016). While there is considerable heterogeneity in medical coding and billing systems internationally, the U.S. is the only high-income democracy in which this type of public medical infrastructure remains fully privatized, (Gusmano et al., 2020) which has only recently begun to garner national regulatory scrutiny. A second case is that of the development of the US health care state, which has seen privatization via private equity investors (Borsa et al., 2023) that followed a prolonged delegation of the welfare state that began in the post-war era (Grogan, 2023). These cases highlight the importance of studying private institutional embeddedness in public governance, including how particular institutional arrangements come to be durable, self-reinforcing, or otherwise difficult to reverse in potentially path dependent fashion (Pierson, 2000). As forms of neoliberal governance and public-private partnerships continue to proliferate globally, (Ilcan, 2009) it is of increasing scientific and political import to understand how, when, and why private institutions come to assume roles in public system stewardship, and by extension, what the impacts of these arrangements are for democratic function, civic engagement, and population wellbeing.

POLICY TOPICS
Regulation and Regulatory Governance Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Health and Well-Being Policy Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy
P279. Beyond the Regulatory State? Regulation, industrial policies, and new state configurations
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Dussauge-Laguna
A. Elizondo
C. González
ABSTRACT

Recent policy developments in Europe and Latin America, among other regions, seem to have transformed the foundations of regulation and the so-called Regulatory State that was predominant since the late 1980s and early 1990s. Empirically, many countries have gone back to developing new industrial policies in a variety of sectors, from culture to energy. Regulatory agencies have been reformed, either through de-delegation of authorities, agency merges, or institutional dismantling. There has been an increased call for more regulatory responsiveness and broader social engagement in regulatory policymaking. The world of regulation has thus allegedly faced a significant transformation in regulatory goals, means, and institutions. In terms of academic debates, the old consensus surrounding the central role played by the Regulatory State and its semi-independent regulatory agencies has also been called into question. From the “entrepreneurial” to the “transformational” state, new conceptualisations of the role of the state have been put forth by various scholars. The rise of populist and authoritarian governments has also flagged the need to understand what happens to regulatory institutions and policies under non-democratic conditions. Moreover, the new regulatory environment raises important questions about regulatory accountability, agency reputation, and regulatory governance broadly understood. The objective of this panel is to discuss contemporary empirical and theoretical transformations in the field of regulation and regulatory policies to deepen our empirical knowledge and broaden our theoretical understanding of such changes. Some of the questions to be addressed in the panel discussions are: How has regulation changed in the past 30 years and why? Is the era of the “Regulatory State” over? If so, how can we refer to the present regulatory era? Do regulatory transformations, both in institutional and policy terms, vary across sectors, countries, and regions? To what extent are industrial policies making a comeback around the world? Can we talk about a new “regulatory agency” model? Is it possible to observe different transformation patterns between Global North and Global South countries? When and why (or why not)?

POLICY TOPICS
Regulation and Regulatory Governance State and Policy Capacity
P200. Trust and Regulation: Institutions, Governance and Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
D. Levi Faur
ABSTRACT

Trust and regulation are often treated as alternative mechanisms of governance: trust is associated with discretion, cooperation, and informal coordination, while regulation is associated with rules, monitoring, enforcement, and formal control. Yet in practice, the relationship between trust and regulation is considerably more complex. Regulation can generate trust by reducing uncertainty, constraining opportunism, and providing credible assurance. At the same time, extensive regulation may signal distrust, crowd out cooperative relations, or generate new forms of suspicion. Trust can facilitate regulatory compliance and reduce enforcement costs, but it can also create vulnerabilities where oversight is weak or misplaced. This panel invites papers that examine the relationship between trust, distrust, and regulation in domestic, comparative, European, and transnational governance. We are interested in the ways in which different forms of trust shape regulatory institutions and behavior, and in how regulatory arrangements in turn influence trust in governments, regulators, firms, experts, professions, and other institutions. The panel welcomes theoretical, empirical, and methodological contributions. Relevant questions include: When does regulation substitute for trust, and when does it reinforce or produce trust? Can regulation compensate for low levels of interpersonal or institutional trust? Under what conditions does regulatory intensity undermine trust? How do different forms of regulation—such as command-and-control, self-regulation, co-regulation, disclosure, auditing, certification, or risk-based regulation—interact with different forms and objects of trust? How do monitoring, verification, transparency, and enforcement affect trust and distrust? We also welcome papers examining variation across countries, sectors, institutions, and regulatory traditions. Contributions may address trust in regulators and public authorities, trust in business and markets, trust in experts and professionals, regulatory legitimacy, compliance, crisis governance, digital regulation, environmental governance, finance, health, labor regulation, artificial intelligence, and other areas of public policy. The panel is particularly interested in work that moves beyond the assumption that either trust or regulation is inherently desirable. Trust may facilitate cooperation but can also be misplaced; regulation may provide assurance but can also produce rigidity, administrative burden, or distrust. Papers that distinguish among different forms of trust, different types of regulation, and different levels of analysis are especially encouraged. More broadly, the panel seeks to develop a research agenda on the co-evolution of trust and regulation. By bringing these literatures together, we aim to better understand how societies construct credible governance arrangements, how regulatory institutions respond to changing levels of trust and distrust, and what these interactions imply for regulatory governance, institutional design, legitimacy, and democratic public policy.

POLICY TOPICS
Regulation and Regulatory Governance Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition
P203. Policy Pathways for Sustainable Agriculture: Integrating Food Security, Food Safety, and Poverty Alleviation.
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Goliaya
R. Kapila
S. machra
S. naggar
A. Chhillar
A. Bhardwaj
ABSTRACT

For dignified human life in world poverty alleviation is must and in this direction world community, international organizations, governments of countries striving to eradicate poverty through governmental interventions. Problem of Poverty is at the focal point of policy agenda of all the governments of world. SDGs of UN also mainly concern with Poverty eradication for better life of people. Recognizing the importance of food security and safety for human development, the international community has prioritised it in the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 2, titled ‘Zero Hunger’, aims to end hunger, achieve food security, improve nutrition, and promote sustainable agriculture by 2030. Despite sustained global efforts, food insecurity and malnutrition remain major development challenges. Persistent poverty undermined progress towards food security and safety. Food security is crucial in developing countries, where many people's livelihoods depend on agriculture and where socio-economic disparities affect access to adequate nutrition. governments have introduced policies to ensure food supplies and support vulnerable groups against hunger. Among the various dimensions of poverty alleviation, food security and safety are fundamental to human development and overall well-being. Recognising their significance, the international community has incorporated food security into the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. Sustainable Development Goal 2 (SDG 2), titled Zero Hunger, seeks to end hunger, achieve food security, improve nutrition, and promote sustainable agriculture by 2030. In this context, governments play a crucial role in addressing hunger and malnutrition through targeted policies of sustainable agriculture. Therefore, effective government interventions aimed at strengthening food security are indispensable for poverty alleviation, nutritional improvement, and the achievement of inclusive and sustainable development. Objectives of the Panel 1. To examine the global status of poverty and understand its major causes, dimensions, and implications for human well-being and sustainable development. 2. Explore the measures adopted by different countries to ensure food security and safety through agricultural development and related policy interventions. 3. To understand the role of sustainable agricultural practices in enhancing food security, improving nutritional outcomes, conserving natural resources, and ensuring long-term agricultural productivity. 4. Assess government interventions and policy initiatives aimed at poverty alleviation through sustainable agriculture, with particular emphasis on the livelihoods of small and marginal farmers and vulnerable communities. 5. Identify and document best practices in sustainable agriculture and food security from different countries that can be adapted, replicated, and scaled up in other national and regional contexts. Relevance of the Panel The rapid growth of the global population, coupled with increasing pressure on natural resources, poses significant challenges to governments in ensuring food security, food safety, and poverty alleviation. Despite advancements in agricultural production, millions of people continue to face hunger, malnutrition, and limited access to nutritious food. These challenges highlight the need for sustainable and inclusive approaches to agricultural development. In this context, sustainable agriculture has emerged as a crucial strategy for addressing food insecurity and reducing poverty. The proposed panel is therefore highly relevant in the contemporary global context, as it will facilitate the exchange of knowledge, experiences, and best practices among countries.

POLICY TOPICS
Regulation and Regulatory Governance Crises, Risks and Wicked Problems Agriculture and Food Policy Development Policy
P216. Governing Algorithmic State Power: Legal and Policy Frameworks for AI in Criminal Justice and Public Administration
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Ansari
A. Agrawal
ABSTRACT

Governments are adopting artificial intelligence (AI) and automated decision-making (ADM) in policing, criminal justice, welfare and regulatory enforcement. Predictive policing, facial recognition, risk scores in bail and sentencing, and algorithmic fraud detection now shape decisions about liberty, livelihoods and access to justice, often without transparency or redress. The Dutch childcare benefits scandal, Australia’s Robodebt scheme, the SyRI judgment and State v. Loomis show how automated state action can cause systemic harm, and how unevenly courts and governments respond. In India and across the Global South, facial recognition in policing and algorithmic welfare targeting are outpacing legal safeguards. Public administration research traces a shift from street-level to system-level bureaucracy, in which discretion moves into software design (Bovens & Zouridis 2002). Legal scholars call for technological due process (Citron 2008). Studies of the digital welfare state find harms fall hardest on poor and marginalized people (Eubanks 2018; Alston 2019), and work on accountable AI shows how opacity and proprietary secrecy weaken accountability (Busuioc 2021). This literature centres on North American and European cases, and policy debate often narrows to “AI ethics” or fairness. Legal frameworks such as constitutional rights, data protection law, the EU AI Act and the Council of Europe’s Framework Convention on AI are rarely studied alongside policy frameworks like national AI strategies, impact assessments, procurement standards and oversight bodies. Their fit with jurisdictions that have different administrative traditions and histories of discriminatory policing, including caste-based and colonial-era criminalization still remains under-examined. The panel asks how AI and ADM change the exercise of state power in criminal justice and public administration, and which combinations of legal and policy instruments can hold it to account. Some of the research questions and hypotheses are mentioned below: i) Accountability gaps widen when public bodies buy systems from private vendors under commercial confidentiality, spreading responsibility across “many hands”. ii) Systems built on administrative and policing data reproduce the selectivity of past state practice, concentrating harm on groups already over-policed or under-served along lines of gender, caste and class.iii)Safeguards such as mandatory human review tend to become rubber stamps (Green 2022), so procedural rights in law do not ensure meaningful contestation in practice.iv)Where independent regulators are weak, courts and civil society become the main sites of algorithmic accountability, with uneven results. The panel treats algorithmic decision-making as public policy whose design, procurement, implementation and oversight are contestable political choices. It aims to connect law, public administration and policy studies across regions, with particular attention to the Global South.

POLICY TOPICS
Regulation and Regulatory Governance Multilevel Governance and Local Policy Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy
P37. The Politics of Expertise in the Policy Process: A Comparative Perspective
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Costa
N. Albrecht
L. Arenas
ABSTRACT

General objectives The relationship between Public Administration and politics has long reflected tensions between political control and bureaucratic autonomy. Classical approaches assigned elected officials responsibility for setting political goals and ensuring democratic responsiveness, while professional administrators were expected to implement those goals based on legality and specialised knowledge (Weber 1946; Wilson 1887). In practice, however, this division is less clear-cut: bureaucrats contribute to policy formulation, interpret political priorities, and exercise discretion beyond implementation (Aberbach et al. 1981; Overeem 2005). This blurring of the politics–administration boundary suggests that technical expertise and political influence are not mutually exclusive. Bureaucrats may exercise influence precisely through the specialised knowledge and professional authority they bring to policymaking. Bureaucracies derive authority not only from their formal position within the state, but also from their capacity to produce, interpret, and communicate specialised knowledge (Carpenter 2001; Christensen 2024). In Wildavsky’s terms, bureaucratic experts may “speak truth to power” by providing professional advice even when it challenges political preferences (Wildavsky 1979; Tonon 2008). Because expertise can provide an independent basis of authority, it also creates persistent questions of political control. Research has examined politicisation, discretionary appointments, patronage, and restrictions on bureaucratic discretion, as well as how bureaucracies preserve professionalisation and autonomy (Bersch et al. 2022; Mikkelsen 2018). Relations between bureaucratic experts and elected politicians may therefore involve bargaining and conflict over the authority of knowledge itself (Christensen 2024; Dargent Bocanegra and Lotta 2025). These tensions have gained renewed relevance as bureaucratic expertise has become increasingly contested under populism, democratic backsliding, and political polarisation (Rich et al. 2024). Political leaders may challenge experts, career bureaucracies, and established administrative knowledge, raising questions about who is recognised as authoritative, what counts as legitimate evidence, and when bureaucratic expertise retains influence over public policy (Costa et al. 2026; Head 2019). Yet we know less about how bureaucrats respond when their expertise is challenged and how they seek to sustain or reconstruct expert authority. The panel therefore focuses on how bureaucrats navigate conflicts over expertise and how these responses vary across political contexts and stages of the policy process. Research Questions The panel asks: Under what conditions does expertise become a source of political influence, and how is this authority legitimised or contested? Moreover, how do bureaucrats respond when their expertise or autonomy comes under political pressure? It also examines how these dynamics unfold across problem definition, agenda-setting, policy formulation, and implementation, including how competing actors establish what counts as valid or authoritative evidence. Scientific Relevance The panel advances policy process research by treating the contestation of bureaucratic expertise as a mechanism that can alter policymaking itself. Struggles over expert authority can shape which problems gain attention, which evidence is accepted as legitimate, which policy alternatives are considered viable, and how decisions are implemented. By connecting bureaucratic politics and expertise with policy process research, the panel seeks to explain how bureaucrats defend, renegotiate, or lose authority under political pressure and how these dynamics affect policy agendas, formulation, implementation, and democratic governance.

POLICY TOPICS
Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process
P35. Negotiating Loyalties. Civil servants between legality and majority rule.
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. HAMM
C. Bonnamy
ABSTRACT

This panel examines the tensions that run through civil servants’ loyalties across levels of governance, from local and national administrations to international organisations and European Union institutions. To what does a civil servant owe loyalty: the constitution or the majority? Over the past decade, this question has acquired renewed salience with the multiplication of cases of democratic backsliding in countries such as the United States, Hungary, Argentina, Brazil, or Italy (Guedes-Neto & Peters 2025). Extreme parties have gained ground in France and Germany, as well as in the European Parliament, while disputes have also emerged over specific decisions or policy areas, such as relations with Russia or Israel. The panel examines the consequences, for bureaucrats, of stances perceived as conflicting with core liberal-democratic values. Its puzzle lies in the civil service status, which combines obligations of neutrality, loyalty and responsibility with rights to freedom of opinion and expression. Put differently, it concerns how civil servants reconcile two foundational principles, majority rule and the rule of law, in the day-to-day work of government (Bischoff, 2022). The empirical question thus becomes: when, and by whom, is bureaucratic resistance deemed justified, and how is it enacted (Bauer, 2024)? The panel addresses the following empirical questions. How do staff draw the boundary between appropriate professional conduct and political engagement? Which repertoires of voice, from the spectacular to the discreet, do they mobilise when they disagree with an institutional position, or with the absence of one? How do these repertoires vary according to agents’ positions, careers and trajectories? How are the norms of neutrality, loyalty and responsibility appropriated, contested and renegotiated in everyday practice, and with what effects on individuals, collectives and institutions? How is the role of civil servant invested, stretched or redefined at critical junctures? Particular, though not exclusive, attention will be paid to IOs and EU institutions. These face mounting ‘populist’ pressure (Clark & Carnegie, 2026), depend on member states while being grounded in international law, and are accused of double standards, for instance over Ukraine and Palestine (Oleart & Roch, 2025). Their staff work amid tensions between depoliticising frames, which cast issues in legal or technical terms (Louis & Maertens, 2021), and politicising frames, which foreground what is politically at stake (Voltolini, 2020). Yet little is known about how agents experience and manage these tensions in their daily work. Research remains scarce and fragmented across international relations and EU studies, whereas public administration scholarship has developed a rich body of work on these issues in recent years (Yesilkagit, Bauer, Peters & Pierre, 2024). The panel brings together empirical studies grounded in fieldwork, such as ethnography, interviews or archival research, conducted at local, national, European or international levels, or in comparative perspective. It particularly welcomes in-depth case studies of specific political controversies, as well as research on trade unions and on newer issue-based staff collectives as forms of mobilisation. The stakes are both theoretical and practical: how civil service duties are defined, how loyalty is interpreted, and how both are reconciled with freedom of expression at work.

POLICY TOPICS
Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process Citizens, Participation and Social Movements Administration and Civil Service Policy
P85. Emotions at the Frontline
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Vigour
A. Durance
ABSTRACT

These panels focus on how emotions concretely shape the interactions between agents and the public during public service delivery, across diverse national contexts and policy fields. Our postulate is that emotions are still underexamined in sociology, political science and public administration regarding citizen-state relations. Yet, emotions arouse a new interest in social sciences. Different works focus on the role of emotions at different stages of the public policy process. They argue that emotions contribute to the agenda setting (Baumgartner, Jones 2005) and the reframing of public problems (Durnová, Hejzlarova, 2017, 2022; Nabi et al. 2018). Emotions play a role in policy change or stability (Zahariadis 2015; see the 2024 Guadalajara IWPP workshop led by Z.Boda & C.Radaelli), by contributing to the mobilization of coalitions (Cairney, Weible 2017; Pierce 2021). As emotions impact political discourses (Szabó et al. 2026) and the deliberation process (Fink et al. 2023), they may shape policy design (Durnová, Hejzlarova, 2023), as well as policy support (Renström & Bäck 2021; Rodríguez-Sánchez et al. 2018; Verloo 2023). By contrast, these panels focus on the service delivery process and frontline interactions between citizens and the state. Indeed, emotions are still rarely at the forefront while studying public encounters (Hupe 2022), despite notable exceptions (Guy, Mastracci, Yan 2019; Dubois 2016): these works seek for instance to complete the analysis of policy feedback (Soss 1999) or administrative burdens (Nielsen, Nielsen 2024), Tummers et al.’s (2015) typology (Ricotta et al. 2025; Lequeux 2026; Lequeux et al. 2027), or the Cognitive Appraisal Theory for Public Administration (Ropes 2026). The following research questions guide the panels: · What are the theoretical frameworks in sociology, political science or public administration, as well as the methodological research designs relevant to finely grasp emotions? · What roles do emotions concretely play during public service delivery? How do positive or negative emotions shape public-professionals encounters “at the frontline”? · What are the effects of these interactions: on how citizens experience public services and policies? On how public agents perceive their job and relations with citizens? On the decisions taken? On institutional legitimacy and confidence? (Oberwittler, Roché 2018) The originality of these panels is based on three main orientations: 1)Researchers need to take into consideration both sides of the relation of service delivery: how street-level bureaucrats (Lipsky 1980) perform their work in interaction with the public and how the public experience this encounter. By contrast, the literature often focuses on one side of this relation. 2)Public service delivery encounters, as well as emotions (Durnová, Schmid 2025), are shaped by class, gender, age, race/ethnicity… As social constructions, emotions result from social relationships and are also often embedded in norms and moral values. 3)We are interested in deep empirical and qualitative studies, implying to carefully think to a relevant research design to collect data on emotions. We will also consider with great interest papers based on quantitative survey developing a research design to finely grasp emotions and the context of their emergence in service delivery. One journal issue will be submitted after the panels.

POLICY TOPICS
Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy Administration and Civil Service Policy Justice Policy
P120. In|formality, (In)formality, informality: discussions and developments in policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Mason
T. Mulherin
L. Visser
L. Garner-Knapp
ABSTRACT

Policy actors spend considerable time writing policy, advising politicians, eliciting stakeholder views on policy concerns, and implementing initiatives. Yet, they also converse in cars, meet for dinners, and have discussions in hallways. They have informal discussions before formal meetings or share a drink afterwards to make sense of what happened in formal negotiations (Stubbs, 2015). How such activities contribute to policymaking is frequently overlooked in favour of portraying policy as being rational, analytical, scientific, and developed in an orderly sequence of stages (Laswell, 1956; Simon, 1972; Stone, 2022). Informality, meanwhile, is often equated with state malfunctioning, illegitimate, or undemocratic or is described as the ‘back-stage’ to the formal ‘front-stage’ or as invisibilised from formal policy making processes (i.e., Ayres et al., 2017; Christiansen & Neuhold, 2012; Kleine, 2013; Lipsky, 2010). Public policy research has long contested this presumed order and rationality, opening up to alternative perspectives of formal and informal. Such insights are relevant today, given the interactive dimensions in contemporary policy theorising, including New Public Governance, co-production of services, and collaborative policy making (Cairney & Toomey, 2024; Durose, 2016; Osborne, 2010; Osborne et al., 2016) whereby policy emerges through relational configurations of people, places, and processes. The concept of informality garners some lustre here and important work has pointed to the informal in policy work (Bevir & Rhodes, 2001; Colebatch, 2014; Lindblom, 1959; Metze, 2010; Yanow, 1996), yet empirical studies have been limited in their explorations of how and why the informal actually matters. We argue that understanding everyday policymaking requires attention to how the informal acquires meaning, what it produces, and how formal and informal are entwined and coproduced. This panel seeks to extend the theoretical, methodological and empirical insights of the volume 'Informality in Policymaking: Weaving the Threads of Everyday Policy Work’ (Garner-Knapp et al., 2024, 2026) and asks how informality can be applied in adjacent and complementary areas within public policy, public administration and governance. In the volume, we resist a binary or fixed understanding of formality and informality and instead attend to its fluidity and trace how it is interwoven into everyday policy work and its human and non-human enactment. Informality, from this standpoint, is not a property of particular practices, materials, or spaces, but acquires meaning through enactment in situ; it is locally and historically situated. By focusing on what people do and say as a lens to understanding the meaning-making of policy actors and policy subjects, informality acquires meaning that resonates with professional practices in public administration and institutions. Thus, what is perceived to be informal in one context or situation can differ from another, and even within a context, multiple understandings of what is informal can coexist. This panel encourages authors to critically engage in theoretical debates on what informality means in context to better understand and address real-world policy processes, practices, and challenges. Garner-Knapp, L., Mason, J., Mulherin, T., & Visser, E. L. (2024). Informality in Policymaking: Weaving the Threads of Everyday Policy Work.

POLICY TOPICS
Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Administration and Civil Service Policy General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P131. Mobilising Public Officials to Change Public Policies: A Perspective on Policy Change through Professional Mobilisation Devices
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Falco
ABSTRACT

How do public authorities bring about policy change by mobilising public officials? While policy studies have developed sophisticated accounts of policy change, and political sociology has extensively investigated bureaucratic practices and public officials, the mechanisms connecting these processes remain insufficiently explored. This panel seeks to bring these perspectives into closer dialogue by examining how public authorities, whether political or administrative, mobilise administrative personnel to contribute to the transformation of public policies through professional mobilisation devices. Political science has approached policy change through a variety of theoretical frameworks. Historical institutionalism has highlighted gradual processes of institutional transformation, including layering, conversion and drift (Mahoney and Thelen, 2010). Policy process theories have examined the role of institutional configurations, advocacy coalitions, policy entrepreneurs and shifting political opportunities in explaining policy change (Kingdon, 1995; Sabatier and Weible, 2014; Mintrom and Norman, 2009). These approaches have illuminated how policy agendas emerge, how reforms gain political traction and how established policy arrangements are transformed over time. In parallel, research in public administration and political sociology has demonstrated that public officials are not merely passive implementers of decisions made elsewhere. Studies of street-level bureaucracy have shown how frontline workers exercise discretion and shape public policies through their everyday practices (Lipsky, 1980). Research on policy work has similarly highlighted the diversity of actors involved in the production of public policies and the situated practices through which policy orientations are constructed and translated into action (Colebatch, Hoppe and Noordegraaf, 2010). Research on bureaucratic organisations, administrative reforms and the sociology of the state has further explored how professional groups, organisational routines, administrative hierarchies and relations between political and bureaucratic actors shape state action (Bourdieu, 1994; Dubois, 2010; Bezes and Le Lidec, 2011). More recent work on street-level policy entrepreneurship has begun to connect bureaucratic agency with policy innovation and change (Arnold, 2021; Cohen, 2021). Building on these contributions, the panel examines how public authorities deliberately seek to mobilise public officials as agents of policy change. To provide an analytical lens, we propose the concept of “professional mobilisation devices”. We conceptualise these devices as the organisational arrangements, instruments and structured activities through which public authorities seek to activate, coordinate and orient public officials' professional capacities towards policy change. This approach also draws on scholarship on policy instruments, which has demonstrated that instruments are not neutral technical tools but embody particular forms of governing and relationships of power (Lascoumes and Le Galès, 2007). It further resonates with research on policy capacity, which highlights the individual competencies and organisational resources required for effective policymaking (Wu, Ramesh and Howlett, 2015). However, rather than examining these capacities simply as resources available to governments, we focus on the arrangements through which authorities seek to activate, develop and redirect them towards specific policy objectives. These devices may operate by developing new competencies, assigning officials specific responsibilities for advancing reforms, organising cooperation across administrative boundaries, or creating opportunities to experiment with and promote new policy approaches. The panel invites contributions examining how these devices are designed, implemented and appropriated, and how they connect the strategies of public authorities to the everyday practices of administrative personnel. References Arnold, G. (2021). “Distinguishing the Street-Level Policy Entrepreneur.” Public Administration, 99(3), 439–453. Bezes, P., and Le Lidec, P. (2011). “The Politics of Administrative Reforms in France: The State of a Discipline.” Revue française d'administration publique, 120, 651–667. Bourdieu, P. (1994). “Rethinking the State: Genesis and Structure of the Bureaucratic Field.” Sociological Theory, 12(1), 1–18. Cohen, N. (2021). Policy Entrepreneurship at the Street Level: Understanding the Effect of the Individual. Cambridge University Press. Colebatch, H. K., Hoppe, R., and Noordegraaf, M. (eds.) (2010). Working for Policy. Amsterdam University Press. Dubois, V. (2010). La vie au guichet : relation administrative et traitement de la misère. Economica. Kingdon, J. W. (1995). Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies (2nd ed.). HarperCollins. Lascoumes, P., and Le Galès, P. (2007). “Introduction: Understanding Public Policy through Its Instruments—From the Nature of Instruments to the Sociology of Public Policy Instrumentation.” Governance, 20(1), 1–21. Lipsky, M. (1980). Street-Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services. Russell Sage Foundation. Mahoney, J., and Thelen, K. (eds.) (2010). Explaining Institutional Change: Ambiguity, Agency, and Power. Cambridge University Press. Mintrom, M., and Norman, P. (2009). “Policy Entrepreneurship and Policy Change.” Policy Studies Journal, 37(4), 649–667. Sabatier, P. A., and Weible, C. M. (eds.) (2014). Theories of the Policy Process (3rd ed.). Westview Press. Wu, X., Ramesh, M., and Howlett, M. (2015). “Policy Capacity: A Conceptual Framework for Understanding Policy Competences and Capabilities.” Policy and Society, 34(3–4), 165–171.

POLICY TOPICS
Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Administration and Civil Service Policy
P233. Ministerial politics: The causes and effects of administrative capacities and preferences
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Valgermo
J. Jungblut
ABSTRACT

Governments rely on ministries to draft public policies, and while bureaucracies are expected to be loyal to their political leadership, they continue to have discretion over parts of the policy-making process. This is due to bureaucrats’ informational advantage vis-à-vis politicians stemming from their day-to-day work and specific expertise. Recent studies (see e.g. Garritzmann and Siderius, 2025) have highlighted that ministries give differing policy suggestions and emphasize different issues when tasked with drafting policies. Such differences matter due to their impact on policy output and in turn policy outcomes, such as redistributive profiles of policies or countries’ carbon emissions (Limberg et al., 2024; Siderius, 2026; Tosun, 2018). However, the preferences of ministries do not appear in a vacuum but can be manipulated by cabinet through portfolio reform or instructions to the bureaucracy in accordance with their own policy goals (Hernes, 2019). While ministerial traits and capacity shape policy outcomes, the way in which they do so are themselves the result of political preferences (see e.g. Fleischer et al., 2023). The purpose of this panel is to tackle this puzzle and explore how the interconnected dynamics of political and administrative preferences shape policy outputs. To do so, the panel seeks to answer: How does political interference into the structure and capacity of ministries alter how ministerial preferences influence public policies? The politics of bureaucracy serves as a fitting theoretical basis of the panel as it provides important insights into the political influence of bureaucratic organizations. It highlights how organizations and individuals within them have ideas about policy, but also how organizational structures hinder or help coordination (Peters, 2019, p. 471). Importantly, the politics of bureaucracy framework allows research to account for the relation between bureaucratic organizations and political preferences, as it highlights ministries’ reliance on support from politicians. The framework can thus seamlessly be supplemented by recent insights into the politics of government re-organization and strategies to control ministries, such as appointing junior ministers or cutting funding to ministries (Askim et al., 2017; Dahlström and Holmgren, 2023; Fleischer et al., 2023; Kuipers et a., 2021). Combining insights from these research traditions is also an appropriate way to account for alternative hypotheses of policy influence as it may highlight circumstances where political control trumps administrative influence, as well as which policy processes are distanced from political interference. The panel brings together scholars who investigate the influence of ministries on policy-making while acknowledging the relevance of their overarching political environment. It invites papers that explore how policy outputs or outcomes change due to ministerial restructuring. Additionally, papers that explore the consequences of shifts in bill assignments or the coupling of issues within ministries are welcome. Moreover, papers that investigate less drastic forms of political interferences into the ministerial bureaucracy, such as how the policy leeway of bureaucrats depends on the preference and profile of junior ministers, would also fit well into the panel. Finally, papers that explore how politicians adapt to different policy advice by e.g. strategically allocating ministerial responsibility are also particularly encouraged. References Askim, J., Karlsen, R. and Kolltveit, K. (2017) Political appointees in executive government: Exploring and explaining roles using a large-N survey in Norway. Public administration, 95(2), p. 342-358. doi: 10.1111/padm.12272 Dahlström, C. and Holmgren, M. (2023) Loyal Leaders, Affluent Agencies: The Budgetary Implications of Political Appointments in the Executive Branch. The Journal of politics, 85(2), 640-653. doi: 10.1086/717756 Hernes, V. (2021) Policy preferences and ministerial structures: Immigrant integration governance in Western Europe, 1997-2017. Governance, 34(1), p. 127-146. doi: 10.1111/gove.12481 Kuipers, S., Yesilkagit, K. and Carroll, B. (2021) Ministerial influence on the machinery of government: insights on the inside. West European politics, 44(4), p. 897-920. doi: 10.1080/01402382.2020.1768737 Limberg, J., Steinebach, Y and Nyrup, J. (2024) Dedicated climate ministries help to reduce carbon emissions. Climate Action, 3(1), p. 70-78. doi: 10.1038/s44168-024-00147-9 Fleischer, J., Bezes, P., James, O. and Yesilkagit, K. (2023) The politics of government reorganization in Western Europe. Governance, 36(1), p. 255-274. doi: 10.1111/gove.12670 Garritzmann, J.L. and Siderius, K. (2025) Introducing ‘ministerial politics’: Analyzing the role and crucial redistributive impacts of individual ministries in policy-making. Governance, 38(1), p. 1-22. doi: 10.1111/gove.12859 Peters, B.G. (2019) The Politics of Bureaucracy after 40 years. British journal of politics & international affairs, 21(3), p. 468-479. doi: 10.1177/1369148119866220 Siderius, K. (2026) Who benefits from public sustainable finance in the EU? Journal of European public policy, 33(6), p. 1654-1679. doi: 10.1080/13501763.2025.2452276 Tosun, J. (2018) Investigating Ministry Names for Comparative Policy Analysis: Lessons from Energy Governance. Journal of comparative policy analysis, 20(3), p. 324-335. doi: 10.1080/13876988.2018.1467430

POLICY TOPICS
Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process State and Policy Capacity Administration and Civil Service Policy General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P232. Beyond the Paperless Myth: Interoperability, Administrative Capacity, and Public Value in Digital Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Gonzalez Galindo
E. Ortiz Gutierrez
F. Sagols
ABSTRACT

The drive toward "paperless governance" is often presented as a straightforward administrative upgrade aimed at eco-efficiency, speed, and cost reduction. However, public administration scholarship demonstrates that digital transformation is deeply institutional and political, reshaping state capacity, inter-organizational dynamics, civil service routines, and public accountability (Dunleavy et al., 2006; Pollitt & Bouckaert, 2017). When public agencies digitize procedures in isolation, paperless mandates frequently reproduce bureaucratic fragmentation electronically, creating siloed platforms, redundant data requests, and informal manual workarounds. This panel places interoperability frameworks at the core of contemporary digital governance, policy implementation, and administrative reform. Defined as the legal, organizational, semantic, and technical capacity of public organizations to exchange information across institutional boundaries (European Commission, 2017), interoperability represents the critical bridge between isolated e-government tools and integrated public service delivery. Grounded in policy instrument and state capacity literature (Hood, 1986; Lascoumes & Le Galès, 2007; Peters, 2015), the panel interrogates whether interoperable paperless transitions genuinely generate public value (Moore, 1995) or simply displace bureaucratic friction into new forms of "digital red tape" and compliance burdens (Bozeman, 2000; Herd & Moynihan, 2018). To guide scholars and practitioners across diverse governance settings, the panel addresses four core research questions: 1. How are paperless directives and interoperability frameworks operationalized across distinct institutional and multi-level governance settings, and which governance mechanisms explain variations in implementation outcomes? 2. How do the legal, organizational, semantic, and technical layers of interoperability interact in practice, and which layer presents the primary bottleneck during administrative transitions? 3. To what extent do paperless transitions built on interoperable architectures and the once-only principle reduce administrative burden, as opposed to generating new compliance costs and digital friction? 4. What specific organizational capacities, civil service skills, green governance strategies, and legal safeguards are required to sustain digital reforms without compromising data preservation, democratic accountability, or equity? The scientific relevance of this panel lies in bridging public policy implementation theory with digital public administration. Rather than treating paperless government as a technical exercise, this panel frames interoperability as a fundamental reform of the administrative state that determines how public policies are designed, executed, and evaluated in the digital era. We welcome theoretical, empirical, and comparative contributions from local, national, and international contexts. References Bozeman, B. (2000). Bureaucracy and Red Tape. Prentice Hall. Dunleavy, P., Margetts, H., Bastow, S., & Tinkler, J. (2006). Digital Era Governance: IT Corporations, the State, and e-Government. Oxford University Press. European Commission. (2017). New European Interoperability Framework: Promoting seamless services and data flows for European public administrations. Publications Office of the European Union. Herd, P., & Moynihan, D. P. (2018). Administrative Burden: Policymaking by Other Means. Russell Sage Foundation. Hood, C. (1986). The Tools of Government. Chatham House Publishers. Lascoumes, P., & Le Galès, P. (2007). Understanding public policy through its instruments. Governance, 20(1), 1–21. Moore, M. H. (1995). Creating Public Value: Strategic Management in Government. Harvard University Press. Peters, B. G. (2015). Advanced Introduction to Public Policy. Edward Elgar Publishing. Pollitt, C., & Bouckaert, G. (2017). Public Management Reform: A Comparative Analysis - Into the Age of Austerity. Oxford University Press.

POLICY TOPICS
Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Administration and Civil Service Policy Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy
P259. Governance in the Age of Gen AI: Problems and Prospects of Public Service Delivery and Privacy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
R. C
F. NAZ
ABSTRACT

It is the era of Artificial Intelligence (AI). The adjectives for “governance” have transitioned from “democratic,” “participatory,” and “good” governance to “algorithmic” and AI governance. This is evident as governments globally use AI bots to interact with citizens, analyse policy evidence, determine eligibility for welfare programmes, detect fraud, redress citizen grievances, and customise public services. Further, Generative AI is now making its way into the policymaking processes, drafting and summarising documents and supporting administrative decision-making. This is a shift that earlier scholars anticipated as a move from “street-level” to system-level bureaucracy (Bovens & Zouridis, 2002). Similar to the other trends of policymaking, the dominant data-governance frameworks rest on Global North assumptions that may not be applicable in other contexts (Taylor, 2017; Milan & Trere, 2019). A critical component of AI-driven governance is the changing relationship between the state and the citizen characterised by public service delivery and privacy. The recent experience of the Dutch SyRi welfare fraud system (2020) and the Indian Supreme Court’s landmark legislation recognising privacy as a fundamental right (Justice K.S. Puttaswamy vs. Union of India, 2017) highlight how the state’s use of personal data has become a defining question of governance in the present day. The enactment and enforcement of India’s Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023, is also a case in point. Legal mechanisms and state capacity play a pivotal role in how countries balance efficiency in public service delivery against privacy. While some regions place limits on automated decision-making, many Global South countries have been adopting data protection laws only in recent times. In this context, this Panel aims to (i) examine how governments are using AI and personal data for efficient public service delivery; (ii) understand the implications of AI-driven governance for citizens' privacy and accountability in the Global South. Research Questions · How and why are governments using AI and personal data in policymaking and public service delivery? · What are the implications of AI-driven governance for citizens' privacy and accountability in the Global South? Through the integration of perspectives on public service delivery and privacy, this Panel attempts to advance the study of policymaking by treating AI and data systems as policy instruments in their own right. By bringing in inputs from the Global South, where technology is more rapid than regulation, it proposes a research agenda of privacy as an important dimension of governance quality and democratic legitimacy. As new AI and data protection regimes take shape in different countries across the Global South, this Panel attempts to extend the digital governance literature beyond the Global North.

POLICY TOPICS
Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy
P93. AI Applications in Policy Design and Practice: The Interplay of Theory and Evidence
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Bolton
R. O'Connor
M. Mintrom
ABSTRACT

Artificial intelligence (AI) is changing the informational, institutional, and political environments in which public policy is designed and implemented. Its significance extends beyond administrative efficiency. AI can shape which problems attract attention, how policy ideas are generated and evaluated, whose knowledge informs decisions, and how public managers exercise judgement. In an AI-saturated information environment, the implications for policy innovation, political influence, and public authority are profound. Yet a central gap remains between the promise of AI and evidence of its actual use. O’Connor et al. (2024), examining AI and complex sustainability policy problems, found that positive expectations about government applications far outstripped evidence of how public decision-makers were using these tools and what outcomes followed. Newman and Mintrom (2023) likewise show how AI challenges established understandings of evidence-based policy and the ethical practice of policy analysis. These concerns are consequential. Without closer empirical investigation, policy scholarship risks reproducing technological narratives instead of explaining how AI is changing policymaking. This panel asks: How is AI reshaping the ideas, actors, and processes of public policymaking, and what must policy theory do to explain these changes? The question opens several avenues for innovative scholarship. Do established frameworks, including the Multiple Streams Framework, Advocacy Coalition Framework, Narrative Policy Framework, and theories of policy entrepreneurship and street-level bureaucracy, adequately explain AI-mediated policymaking? How are public managers adopting, adapting to, or rejecting AI tools? How are policy entrepreneurs navigating new opportunities for innovation amid information abundance, misinformation, and competing claims to expertise? What capabilities will future policy analysts and public managers need? The panel welcomes theoretical, conceptual, and empirical contributions across policy domains and national contexts. We encourage researchers to test established explanations against emerging practices, develop new concepts from empirical findings, and investigate variation in how AI is used across institutions and settings. Comparative studies, detailed case studies, and theory-led empirical research are especially welcome. The scientific objective is to strengthen the connection between policy theory and policy practice. AI may create new opportunities for collaboration, analysis, and institutional learning. It may also redistribute influence, complicate judgement, and reinforce existing inequalities. Neither outcome should be assumed. Understanding what AI changes, for whom, and under what conditions is an urgent task for public policy scholarship.

POLICY TOPICS
Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process
P105. Critical Approaches to the Digital Transformation of the State (and beyond)
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. wickberg
U. Purandare
N. Albrecht
ABSTRACT

Digitalization is and has been changing state authorities, public bureaucracies and public policy-making in several ways in recent decades, to the extent that it seems relevant to speak of a digital transformation. Yet, governments still struggle to tackle some of the long-standing complexities associated with the governance of digital government and the task of digitally enabling their administrations. In parallel, the study of this fundamental transformation of the state, public bureaucracy and services has inspired great research in the social sciences, asking questions about the quality of services and policies, effectiveness, citizen engagement and transparency, but also about fairness, social justice and shifting power dynamics (Datta, 2023; Grøn and Møller, 2024; Schuilenburg and Peeters, 2021; Söderström and Datta, 2020). In a recent article on decolonization and state digitalization, Neha Gupta and Ayona Datta (2026) point to some of the contradictions inherent in state digitalization as well as the ways in which these contradictions tend to benefit and further empower the state. They argue that in the case of India, decolonization has been used as a disguise to shape technology in a way that is simultaneously futuristic and a remaking of its past. In addition to temporality, other contradictions emerge as a state digitalizes. This includes minimizing the role of the state while expanding its reach; devolving responsibilities to the individual while centralizing information and data; and the increasing unevenness of access to rights despite increasing citizen legibility. This panel build on existing critical scholarship which have long argued that technology is not neutral. But the question then arises is – what is technology infused with? By whom? How does digitalization re-shape power? And why is understanding this important? Answers to these questions depend on context, histories, and the stories states tell themselves and their citizens about digitalization. In this panel we are interested in delving deeper into the contradictions of digitalization. How can public policy balance efficiency and privacy? What are the ways in which digital technologies can be designed and deployed from the ground up? Is centralization a core feature of state digitalization? Bibliography Datta Ayona, Neha Gupta, Piecing the ‘Land puzzle’: The invisible labours of India's national land digitalisation initiative, Political Geography, 2026, 103686, ISSN 0962-6298, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2026.103686. Datta, Ayona. “The Digitalising State: Governing Digitalisation-as-Urbanisation in the Global South.” Progress in Human Geography [London, England], vol. 47, no. 1, February 2023, pp. 141–59, https://doi.org/10.1177/03091325221141798. Grøn, Caroline Howard, and Anne Mette Møller. Public Bureaucracy and Digital Transformation : Structures, Practices and Values. 1st ed. 2024., Springer Nature Switzerland, 2024, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-67864-6. Schuilenburg, Marc, and Rik Peeters, editors. The Algorithmic Society : Technology, Power, and Knowledge. 1st ed., Routledge, 2021. Söderström, Ola, & Datta, Ayona. Data Power in Action : Urban Data Politics in Times of Crisis. Edited by Ola Söderström and Ayona Datta, 1st ed., Bristol University Press, 2024, https://doi.org/10.56687/9781529233551.

POLICY TOPICS
Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics
P113. Navigating Bureaucracy and Instrument Choice: Re-evaluating Administrative Capacity and Policy Design in Contemporary Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. BINALDO-VELASCO
ABSTRACT

Contemporary public administration operates under continuous socio-political transformation, technological advancement, and complex governance challenges. Traditional administrative structures and classical policy designs face increasing pressures to adapt to multi-scalar policy environments, demanding a critical re-examination of how bureaucratic organizations formulate, select, and deploy policy instruments. While foundational public policy literature has long analyzed bureaucratic decision-making, contemporary scholars frequently point out a persistent gap between formal policy design and practical administrative implementation. Emerging studies highlight that policy design is not merely a technical exercise of matching instruments to goals; rather, it is a deeply contextual process influenced by bureaucratic politics, institutional capacity, and administrative discretion. Despite recent conceptual refinements in policy design frameworks such as smart regulation, procedural policy instruments, and administrative burden mitigation bureaucracies in both developed and emerging public administration contexts struggle to align policy formulation with operational reality.This panel aims to explore how bureaucratic structures, administrative capacity, and civil service dynamics influence the formulation, selection, and design of policy instruments across diverse public policy sectors. By bringing together scholars and practitioners, the panel seeks to bridge the theoretical divide between public administration and policy design theories, offering cross-national and comparative insights into modern governance and civil service reform. The discussion centers on an overarching research question: How do institutional constraints, bureaucratic processes, and administrative capacity shape policy design and instrument choice, and to what extent do these administrative factors influence policy success or failure?To answer this research question, the panel will specifically explore three primary hypotheses. First, we hypothesize that highly centralized or rule-bound administrative structures tend to favor procedural and command-and-control policy instruments over flexible, incentive-based, or co-design mechanisms, limiting policy responsiveness. Second, the panel proposes that administrative capacity encompassing civil service expertise, organizational learning, and resource availability directly mediates the effectiveness of innovative policy design and instrument calibration. Third, we hypothesize that political-administrative relations and civil service discretion significantly alter policy designs during the formulation and adoption stages, leading to divergent policy outcomes across public sectors. Through these inquiry paths, panel participants will examine how administrative constraints and civil service environments dictate instrument selection and policy performance across varied governance systems.

POLICY TOPICS
Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Administration and Civil Service Policy General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P136. Culture and Relational Public Policy: Examining Cross-Cultural Understandings of Relationality
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Turnbull
E. Dubey
ABSTRACT

Relationality has emerged as an important perspective for understanding public policy, challenging approaches that privilege discrete actors and linear accounts of policy processes. By foregrounding interdependence, interaction, and the relationships through which public problems are understood and addressed, relational approaches offer new ways of conceptualising governance, public service provision, and collective action (Bartels & Turnbull, 2020; Wilson et al., 2024). Over the past decade, a growing body of scholarship has sought to establish the conceptual and methodological foundations of relational public administration and relational public policy, while exploring their implications for research and practice (Lejano & Kan, 2022). Although relational approaches challenge the assumption that social and political life can be adequately understood through independent actors and bounded entities, the meaning of relationships cannot be assumed to be universal. Cultural understandings of personhood, community, authority, and interdependence may inform what counts as relationships, which relationships matter, and how relational practices are interpreted in public life. Consequently, relationality may take different forms across contexts, carrying distinct normative expectations and implications for public action. Research in relational sociology and cultural theory has already drawn attention to the relationship between networks, culture, and agency (Mische, 2011), the intersections between social networks and cultural processes (Pachucki & Breiger, 2010), Western and non-Western forms of relational thought (Kwak & Cheng, 2024) and the significance of relationality for understanding cultural difference and global cooperation (Brigg, 2014). Work examining relationality across Western and non-Western cultural contexts further invites questions about the cultural assumptions embedded in prevailing understandings of interdependence and relationships. These conversations ask how culturally situated understandings of relationality might challenge, or extend the current conceptual foundations of relational public policy to be reinterpreted through the contexts in which relationships acquire meaning. The panel therefore seeks to advance a culturally attentive and critically reflexive conversation about relationality in public policy and administration. It aims to bring together scholars working across different theoretical traditions, cultural contexts, and empirical settings to compare and contrast how culturally situated understandings of relationships shape the conceptualisation and practice of public policy. In doing so, it seeks not merely to extend the geographical reach of relational scholarship, but to explore whether and how cultural difference can challenge its assumptions, expand its analytical vocabulary, and generate new directions for theory and practice. The aims of this panel are to: 1. Interrogate the cultural assumptions of relational theory;2. Develop cross-cultural dialogue by bringing diverse conceptual, methodological, and empirical perspectives into conversation;3. Explore the cultural situatedness of relational practices and establish an agenda for culturally attentive relational scholarship.

POLICY TOPICS
Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives
P144. Education Policy in Action: Actors, Institutions, and Policy Processes
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Malandrino
ABSTRACT

Education services are the backbone of democratic societies, shaping critical thinking skills and citizens able to make informed decisions. Governing these services, education policy offers a particularly valuable setting for investigating how public policies are formulated, administered, implemented, and transformed. Reforms, in education as well as in other sectors, rarely unfold through a linear process in which political decisions are simply translated into organizational practices. Rather, their content and consequences emerge from interactions among political leaders, administrative institutions, educational organizations, professionals, and other public and private actors. These actors operate under different institutional constraints, mobilize distinct forms of knowledge and authority, and exercise varying degrees of discretion. Research on education policymaking highlights the influence of political narratives, competing interests, policy instruments, and reform design on policy choices and subsequent implementation (Capano & Lippi, 2018; Durazzi et al., 2023; Malandrino et al., 2025; Malandrino, 2025). Work on educational administration emphasizes how professional discretion, school autonomy, and managerial practices shape the translation of formal mandates into organizational outcomes (Weatherley & Lipsky, 1977; Landri, 2009; Malandrino & Sager, 2021; Mergoni et al., 2026). Research on advisory bodies further reveals how epistemic, bureaucratic, and political legitimacy interact in school reforms (Galanti, 2023). Comparative studies of higher education demonstrate the diversity of governance arrangements and policy instrument mixes (Capano & Pritoni, 2020). Policy evaluation provides evidence about the effects of educational interventions and raises questions about how such evidence feeds back into policy design and implementation (Argentin et al., 2014). At the transnational level, international organizations, indicators, and expert networks contribute to the construction of policy agendas and models (Grek, 2022; Fontdevila & Verger, 2025). Digital technologies and growing salience of scientific expertise further challenge established relationships among knowledge, professional autonomy, and administrative authority (Capano et al., 2025; Mattei et al., 2026). Yet these perspectives are often studied separately, making space to explore how their mechanisms interact across stages and levels of the policy process. Against this background, the panel asks: how do bureaucratic institutions, political and administrative actors, professional discretion, evaluation, and evolving forms of expertise interact to shape education policy design, implementation, and change? It seeks to link macro-level policy paradigms and governance structures, meso-level administrative and organizational arrangements, and micro-level practices, across school and higher education. Particular attention is paid to mechanisms connecting formal policy design, administrative behaviour, and observable policy outcomes. The panel aims to advance explanations of when educational bureaucracies and professionals sustain, reinterpret, resist, or reshape policy, and with what consequences for effectiveness, equity, and democratic legitimacy.

POLICY TOPICS
Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process Other Education Policy Research and Higher Education Policy
P168. Public Administration in Policy Implementation: Structures, Instruments, and Practices
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Proestou
H. Jörgens
ABSTRACT

Policy implementation is a central yet often challenging stage of the policy process, during which political objectives are translated into administrative practices and concrete outcomes. Public administrations play a crucial role in this process, not merely as executors of political decisions but as organizations that interpret, operationalize, coordinate, and sometimes reshape public policies. Ministries, national and international public agencies, supranational administrations, ministry-affiliated organizations, and other implementing bodies exercise varying degrees of discretion and operate within institutional and organizational arrangements that influence how policies are implemented. Over recent decades, public administration has undergone significant transformations. Traditional bureaucratic structures, characterized by hierarchical authority, formal rules, standardized procedures, and legally defined responsibilities, have increasingly coexisted with managerial approaches associated with New Public Management (NPM), including performance measurement, managerial autonomy, outsourcing, contractual arrangements, and results-oriented management. More recently, digitalization has introduced additional changes through digital administrative services, data-driven decision-making, automated procedures, and artificial intelligence. However, these developments do not necessarily represent successive or mutually exclusive administrative models. Instead, bureaucratic, managerial, and digital arrangements frequently coexist and interact within implementing organizations. Although policy implementation research has long emphasized the importance of administrative structures, organizational capacities, and bureaucratic discretion, and public administration scholarship has extensively examined administrative reforms, further research is needed on how these different administrative arrangements interact and shape implementation practices. In particular, questions remain about their implications for administrative autonomy, coordination, accountability, discretion, organizational capacity, and the effectiveness of policy implementation. This panel seeks to advance understanding of the role of public administration in policy implementation by examining how administrative arrangements, encompassing bureaucratic structures, managerial instruments associated with NPM, and digital technologies, shape the activities and capacities of implementing organizations across national, supranational, and international governance contexts. Against this background, the panel asks how do these administrative arrangements shape the practices and capacities of public policy implementers. The panel invites contributions exploring several propositions: - Traditional bureaucratic structures may provide stability, legal accountability, and procedural consistency while potentially constraining flexibility and cross-organizational coordination. In addition, multilevel administrative structures may strengthen policy implementation in times of crisis and turbulence or act as obstacles to effective implementation.- NPM instruments may enhance managerial autonomy, specialization, and performance orientation while potentially generating fragmentation, coordination challenges, and accountability tensions.- Digitalization may strengthen administrative information processing, coordination, and operational efficiency while simultaneously transforming bureaucratic discretion, organizational dependencies, and accountability.- The interaction between bureaucratic, managerial, and digital arrangements may generate hybrid administrative configurations with context-dependent implications for policy implementation. By bringing together theoretical, comparative, and empirical contributions across policy sectors and administrative systems, the panel aims to develop a more nuanced understanding of how administrative organization and transformation shape implementation processes and outcomes.

POLICY TOPICS
Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P253. The Time and Temporality Triangle: Connecting Policy Analysis, Policy Process Theories, and Public Administration
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Lahat
G. LOTTA
D. Béland
ABSTRACT

Time runs through every part of public policy, yet we rarely study it as an object in its own right. Policies take time to emerge, unfold, and change. They shape how citizens spend their time. Public employees deliver them, and their time is increasingly scarce. Many social science disciplines have theorized time, but public policy and public administration scholarship still approach it in fragmented ways. This panel brings three largely separate streams together into what we call the "Time and Temporality Triangle." The first vertex is policy analysis and design, where time is a resource, experience, and an outcome. Building on time-use and well-being research (Goodin et al., 2010; Lahat & Sened, 2020; Lahat, 2026; Gregory, 2026), this stream asks questions such as: How do policies shape people's use of time? Which policies expand time discretion? How can policy design reduce time poverty across diverse populations? The second vertex is policy process theory, which treats time and temporality as dimensions of change and critical aspects of policy (Howlett & Goetz, 2014). Historical institutionalism highlights path dependence, sequencing, and policy feedback (Pierson, 2004). It also highlights gradual change through layering, conversion, and drift (Hacker, 2004; Béland, 2007). Work on temporariness and citizenship shows that time itself can be a policy instrument that distributes rights and status to immigrants (Cohen, 2015). Other frameworks ask why policy windows open at particular moments and how timing shapes outcomes. The third vertex is public administration, where time constrains governing. Pollitt (2008) showed that public management often neglects the past and reform's temporal horizons. Recent work calls for temporal dynamics and longitudinal designs in the field (Murdoch et al., 2023). At the street level, workloads, administrative burden, and accelerating demands shape how public employees allocate their time. In turn, this shapes how citizens experience the state, including the time costs citizens bear to access services. The main question we want to explore in this panel is: How can perspectives on time from policy analysis, policy process theories, and public administration be connected to better explain how policies are made, delivered, and experienced? Examples of questions to explore: How does policy design distribute time burdens and time discretion?In what ways is ‘time poverty’ a policy outcome?How do the temporal dynamics of the policy process, such as sequencing, feedback, and drift, shape not only what policies do but also the temporal conditions in which administrators and citizens act?How do administrative time constraints mediate between policy design and outcomes?How does time help to understand the policy process and policy outcomes from a comparative perspective?Can time in public sector organizations transmit or amplify time inequalities? Integrating the three vertices yields concepts and research designs that single-stream approaches miss, such as longitudinal, time-use, and comparative designs. By connecting these streams, the panel aims to build an international community of scholars working on time at the policy and societal levels.

POLICY TOPICS
Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics
P30. AI Governance in the Global North and Global South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
I. Roberge
L. Liu
M. Campbell-Verduyn
ABSTRACT

Artificial intelligence has become a key feature of governance at the global, regional, domestic and local levels. AI systems are increasingly embedded in public administration systems and across policy fields, including health care and social welfare, education, finance, security and environmental management. These applications create opportunities to improve public service delivery and enhance capacity. At the same time, they raise concerns about accountability, transparency, bias, surveillance and privacy, exclusion, environmental costs, and the concentration of state, corporate and technological power. Governments are developing policies and institutional arrangements to steer the design, deployment, and use of AI systems. AI governance is not merely a technical issue. It is also deeply connected to questions of power, development, sovereignty, sustainability, and institutional capacity. Different countries and regions approach AI through distinct political, economic, institutional, and developmental contexts. While the Global North has often shaped dominant debates around AI innovation policy, risk regulation and ethics and market governance, countries in the Global South face additional questions concerning digital dependency, technological capacity, data governance, development priorities, and unequal participation in global rulemaking. AI governance depends on understanding how global regulatory debates interact with diverse national and regional governance contexts. This panel moves beyond universalistic accounts of AI governance and examines how different governance traditions, state capacities, political economies, and development strategies shape AI governance in practice. Despite the growing body of research on AI governance, the existing debates are primarily shaped by experiences and regulatory models from the Global North. Less attention has been paid to how AI governance is understood, adapted, contested, and institutionalized in the Global South, and to how Global South countries navigate between global standards, domestic priorities, and geopolitical pressures. We invite contributions that examine AI governance comparatively across and between the Global North and Global South. Submissions should move beyond purely technical discussions of AI and instead examine the institutional, political, economic, and social dimensions of governing AI. Suggested Topics We welcome submissions addressing, but not limited to, the following themes: AI Governance Frameworks in the Global North and Global South Comparative analysis of AI governance models, strategies, and regulatory frameworksThe diffusion, adaptation, and contestation of global AI governance normsThe role of state capacity, administrative traditions, and policy institutions in shaping AI governance Comparative studies of AI governance in Asia-Pacific, European, North American, African, and Latin American contexts AI Governance and Digital Sovereignty AI governance, digital sovereignty, and national development strategiesData governance, data localization, and cross-border data flowTechnological dependency, platform power, and infrastructure controlNational AI capacity-building, public digital infrastructure, and computational resources Public Values in AI Governance Public attitudes toward AI governance and algorithmic decision-makingCultural, ethical, and social foundations of AI governanceCommunity-based and participatory approaches to governing AIAI literacy, public communication, and social acceptance of AI systemsThe politics of trust, legitimacy, and accountability in AI governance Papers that consider global and regional AI governance arrangements and the management of AI and environmental sustainability will also be considered.

POLICY TOPICS
State and Policy Capacity Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy
P47. When Does State Capacity Produce Outcomes? Implementation, Learning and Adaptation in Complex Public Systems
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
K. Ayanda
ABSTRACT

Public policy scholarship has generated substantial knowledge about state and policy capacity, implementation, policy learning and governance. Yet a fundamental puzzle remains: why do some public systems translate policy ambitions and institutional capabilities into sustained outcomes, while others accumulate reforms, organizations, expertise, technologies and policy instruments without commensurate improvements in implementation or public value? For this panel, capacity refers to the resources, competencies and institutional arrangements available to public authorities to formulate policy, organize collective action and carry decisions into practice. State capacity concerns the broader ability of public institutions to exercise authority and undertake collective tasks; policy capacity concerns the analytical, operational and political capabilities relevant to particular policy functions. These capabilities include the ability to understand problems and assess evidence, mobilize resources and coordinate delivery, and secure authorization, legitimacy and support. They operate at individual, organizational and wider system levels. Capacity is therefore understood as a potential for action, whose existence must be distinguished from its effective deployment and from the outcomes ultimately achieved. The “capacity-to-outcomes” problem concerns the conditions and mechanisms through which these available capabilities are mobilized and translated—or fail to translate—into implementation performance and substantive policy results. Implementation performance includes whether decisions are executed and services delivered; outcomes concern subsequent changes in the conditions that policies seek to influence. The problem encompasses both the failure to activate existing capabilities and the possibility that effective implementation may produce limited, uneven or unintended outcomes because of policy design, political choices or contextual conditions. It does not assume that capacity alone determines results or that outcomes necessarily reflect the intentions of policymakers. The panel examines this relationship by bringing into conversation scholarship on state and policy capacity, policy implementation, policy learning, policy dynamics, bureaucratic organization, and network and multilevel governance. Its central question is: under what conditions do state and policy capacity contribute to effective and sustained policy outcomes? Related questions include: What explains variation in this relationship across sectors, jurisdictions and governance levels? How do political authorization, bureaucratic agency, institutional incentives, coordination and accountability shape the deployment of capacity? When do evidence, evaluation, citizen feedback and implementation experience generate learning, and when does learning lead to adaptation? Why do apparently capable systems sometimes become rigid, fragmented or unable to respond to changing conditions? The panel also considers how governance arrangements spanning state, private, civic, community and transnational actors alter these relationships. Such arrangements may extend the capabilities available for implementation, while raising questions about who directs collective action, whose objectives are pursued and how responsibility for results is assigned. The panel advances a relational and dynamic perspective: capacity, implementation, learning and adaptation interact over time. Implementation may reveal previously unrecognized capability constraints, while learning and adaptation may strengthen or weaken future capacity. Several propositions follow for theoretical and empirical examination: similar formal capacities may generate divergent outcomes under different political and organizational conditions; learning may fail to produce adaptation when authority or incentives constrain change; and hybrid governance may expand delivery capabilities while introducing coordination and accountability difficulties. Scientifically, the panel seeks to clarify the mechanisms connecting institutional capabilities to outcomes and encourage comparative inquiry across established public-policy literatures. It welcomes contributions that distinguish capacity from its exercise and effects, examine how these relationships change over time, or challenge the panel’s underlying propositions. By asking when, how and under what conditions capacity becomes consequential, the panel aims to advance a more precise account of how complex public systems implement, learn, adapt and perform.

POLICY TOPICS
State and Policy Capacity Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy
P60. Legislatures in the Age of Algorithms: Data Science, AI, and the Policy Capacity of Legislative Bodies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Florano
ABSTRACT

Legislatures are among the most information-intensive institutions in any political system, yet they have long operated at an informational disadvantage relative to executives, which control most administrative data, analytical staff and technical expertise. Data science and artificial intelligence (AI) may be changing this. The IPU’s World e-Parliament Report 2024 (Inter-Parliamentary Union [IPU], 2024b), drawing on 115 chambers in 86 countries, found that 29 percent of parliaments already use AI tools, chiefly for document management, transcription, bill tracking and legislative drafting support (Gentilucci, 2026). Brazil’s Chamber of Deputies has built Ulysses, a suite of AI modules that routes drafting requests, suggests committee referrals and clusters citizens’ comments on bills (OECD.AI Policy Observatory, 2026a, 2026b, 2026c). In December 2024, the IPU (2024a) issued Guidelines for AI in parliaments, urging human oversight, transparency and a risk-based approach. However, the same report documents a persistent digital divide between high- and low-income parliaments. Scholarship has not kept pace with practice. The literature on legislative informatics and “ParlTech” (e.g., Koryzis et al., 2021; von Lucke et al., 2022) is largely descriptive and practitioner-driven, while the public policy literature on AI concentrates on executive agencies, public service delivery and algorithmic regulation. Legislatures appear mostly as regulators of AI, rarely as its users. As a result, we know little about whether data science and AI alter legislatures' policy capacity, the quality of ex ante and ex post scrutiny, how citizen input is aggregated, or the accountability relationships at the heart of representative democracy. This panel asks: How are legislative bodies adopting data science and AI, and what consequences does this have for their policy capacity, oversight of the executive, and democratic legitimacy? The panel will explore four hypotheses/propositions. First, adoption is concentrated in administrative and procedural functions rather than core policy functions such as policy analysis, budget scrutiny, and evaluation, limiting its effect on legislative policy capacity. Second, where analytical uses do emerge, they can narrow the information asymmetry between legislatures and executives, but they may also create new dependencies on vendors, executive-held data, or a small cadre of technical staff. Third, adoption depends less on financial resources alone than on institutional factors, including data governance, staff capability, political sponsorship, and digital maturity, which helps explain variation among legislatures in the Global North and South. Fourth, AI use in drafting, sorting public submissions, and member-facing tools raises distinctive questions of representation, transparency, and accountability that differ from those raised by AI in executive agencies. By bringing together comparative, theoretical, and empirical work across national, subnational, and supranational legislatures, the panel aims to build a research agenda that treats legislatures as policy actors in the age of AI. It welcomes contributions from established and emerging democracies and particularly encourages work on Asia, Africa, and Latin America, where legislative strengthening and digital transformation are advancing together. References Gentilucci, R. (2026, February 6). AI nei parlamenti europei: Casi, benefici e rischi per la democrazia [AI in European parliaments: Cases, benefits and risks for democracy]. Agenda Digitale. https://agendadigitale.eu/cultura-digitale/ai-nei-parlamenti-europei-casi-benefici-e-rischi-per-la-democrazia Inter-Parliamentary Union. (2024a). Guidelines for AI in parliaments. https://www.ipu.org/resources/publications/reference/2024-12/guidelines-ai-in-parliaments Inter-Parliamentary Union. (2024b). World e-Parliament report 2024. https://www.ipu.org/resources/publications/reports/2024-10/world-e-parliament-report-2024 Koryzis, D., Dalas, A., Spiliotopoulos, D., & Fitsilis, F. (2021). ParlTech: Transformation framework for the digital parliament. Big Data and Cognitive Computing, 5(1), Article 15. https://doi.org/10.3390/bdcc5010015 OECD.AI Policy Observatory. (2026a, August 5). Ulysses – Bill procedural routing analysis [Policy initiative]. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. https://oecd.ai/en/dashboards/policy-initiatives/ulysses-bill-procedural-routing-analysis OECD.AI Policy Observatory. (2026b, August 5). Ulysses – Legislative demand router [Policy initiative]. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. https://oecd.ai/en/dashboards/policy-initiatives/ulysses-legislative-demand-router OECD.AI Policy Observatory. (2026c, August 5). Ulysses – Smart analysis on e-polls [Policy initiative]. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. https://oecd.ai/en/dashboards/policy-initiatives/ulysses-smart-analysis-on-e-polls von Lucke, J., Fitsilis, F., & Etscheid, J. (2022). Using artificial intelligence for legislation: Thinking about and selecting realistic topics. In Proceedings of EGOV-CeDEM-ePart 2022 (CEUR Workshop Proceedings). https://dgsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/CEUR-proceedings-2022.pdf

POLICY TOPICS
State and Policy Capacity Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy Other
P83. Policy Capacity and Capacity Building: Drawing Boundaries, Bridging Gaps for a Transforming State. Fostering Global North–South Dialogues.
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Munoz del Campo
A. Romero-Tarín
ABSTRACT

Policy capacity is widely recognized as a determinant of policy success, yet its conceptualization remains highly diverse. A recent review by Cameron and Evans (2024) illustrates this ambiguity, noting that a simple Google Scholar search for “policy capacity” yields more than 17,000 results. Definitions range from functional assets for decision-making (Painter & Pierre, 2005) to disaggregated frameworks emphasizing competences, institutional arrangements, and governance legitimacy (Wu, Ramesh & Howlett, 2015). Wu, Ramesh and Howlett (2015, p. 166) themselves observed that most definitions “focus on what can be done with it … but fall short of specifying not only what constitutes policy capacity but how existing and potential resources and skills can be combined to augment and deploy it”. How capacities combine, reinforcing or blocking one another, thus remains largely open.A second gap concerns capacity building. Brenton, Baekkeskov and Hannah (2023) identified “missing links” between the theory of policy capacity and the initiatives through which capacities are actually built. Training, education and institutional development for state and non-state actors are rarely analysed in terms of the capacities they are meant to produce, and capacities that are never specified cannot be deliberately built, only assumed.Recent work offers a starting point for rethinking how we conceive capacities. Its central argument is that a value is not a capacity; the ability to mobilize values in judgment and in public action is (Muñoz-del-Campo, 2026). From this claim, the framework is expanded beyond its analytical, operational and political dimensions to incorporate the deontological and human dimensions of policy work, understood as transversal capacities that enable or limit the others. The proposal is testable, and it reopens three questions: what counts as capacity, how capacities combine, and how they are built.These questions are sharpened by neighbouring notions. State, institutional and administrative capacity are often used interchangeably with policy capacity in scholarship, indices and reform agendas, shaping what is measured, which actors are considered and what capacity building is expected to achieve.This panel is a joint initiative of the Study Group on Policy Capacity and Capacity Building (RELAPP–IPPA). It brings Global North and Global South perspectives into dialogue, so that concepts and evidence are shaped through interaction rather than transfer.Its objectives are to: (1) delimit policy capacity, the central concept, from its neighbours; (2) examine how capacities combine, including ethical and human dimensions; (3) bridge policy capacity and capacity building, for public officials and other actors; and (4) identify the capacities a transforming state requires in the face of artificial intelligence, cultural diversity, changing public values and collaborative governance.The panel offers comparative, theoretically oriented contributions that move policy capacity from invocation to specification. Selected papers will contribute to a special issue.

POLICY TOPICS
State and Policy Capacity Crises, Risks and Wicked Problems
P179. SDG-2 and Global South: Food Security, and Inclusive Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
K. Gowd
ABSTRACT

General Objectives In SDG 2 (Zero Hunger), improved nutrition and sustainable agriculture are highlighted to end hunger and achieve food security. Despite remarkable gains in agriculture output and social safety nets, hunger, malnutrition and inequitable access to nutritious food continues to be a plaguing problem globally in the Global South. The challenges emphasise how far we need to go before production-based interventions in order to have holistic public policies addressing institutional inequities, livelihood insecurity, climate vulnerabilities and differential access to public resources. This panel will discuss the role of public policies, governance institutions and political processes in SDG 2 implementation in Asian, African and Latin American countries. It aims to provide comparative analysis on agricultural income support, public food distribution systems, nutrition programmes, climate-resilient agriculture and digital governance. Policy implementation and institutional capacity, intergovernmental coordination and policy distributional impact on smallholder farmers, women, rural households and socially disadvantaged groups will be covered in greater detail. Research Questions The Panel will discuss three interrelated research questions: What are the impacts of institutional arrangements, political economy and administrative capacity on the design and implementation of food security and agricultural policies in the Global South?2. How effective are public interventions, such as agricultural subsidies, direct cash transfers, public distribution systems and nutrition programmes in enhancing food security, livelihoods and equitable access to key resources?How can comparative policy learning, South–South cooperation and innovative governance approaches augment the integration of food security, social protection and environmental sustainability in the pursuit of SDG 2? Scientific Relevance The scientific interest of this panel is to link the SDG implementation with the current contentions in comparative public policy, development governance, and the political economy of welfare. Research in this area often focuses on the impact of institutions on agricultural productivity and food security outcomes, but more attention should be given to the impact of institutional contexts, institutional design, implementation mechanisms, and social inequalities on agricultural productivity and food security outcomes. The panel's discussion will look at how comparative, empirical and interdisciplinary approaches help to understand the varying outcomes of similar policy interventions in different countries and subnational contexts. It will also examine how experiences in the Global South can be put to use in the wider theoretical discussions on state capacity, policy innovation, distributive justice and sustainable development. The panel's most significant contribution is to not just view the Global South as a beneficiary of international development policies, but also as a source of institutional innovation and policy knowledge. The results will contribute to comparative knowledge on food security governance and the development of context-specific solutions for the strengthening of inclusive, resilient and sustainable food systems. Towards this end, the panel aims to foster academic debate and discussion between public policy research and the operational problem of meeting SDG 2 in the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.

POLICY TOPICS
State and Policy Capacity
P100. Ingredients for Responsible AI: Rethinking Capacity and Coordination in AI Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Sehra
P. Joshi
ABSTRACT

In recent years, innovations driven by artificial intelligence (AI) have been developed and deployed across sectors, including healthcare, agriculture, education, finance, policing, public administration and business. Globally, its growing use creates new governance challenges. As such, governments across the globe are working with technology companies, researchers, professional organisations, civil society, international organisations and other stakeholders to shape regulatory and overall governance frameworks that can promote responsible and ethical use of AI. However, governments may not always have access to the technical knowledge, data, infrastructure or financial resources needed to understand and regulate AI. Different government departments may also have different responsibilities, which can create coordination problems. At the same time, technology companies may control important technologies, data, expertise and infrastructure. As a result, AI technologies develop much faster than existing policies and regulatory processes. We aim to contribute to the dialogues for public policy on responsible innovation for AI with the following key question: Do governments have the capacity to coordinate these different actors and effectively govern AI? In this backdrop, this panel brings together research on two connected issues mapping AI governance: capacity and coordination. First, it examines what types of capacity are required to govern AI effectively, including technical, analytical, regulatory, organisational, financial and relational capacity. Second, it asks how different actors coordinate and why some coordination arrangements work while others produce delays, conflict, or limited results. The panel also moves beyond the idea that governments either ‘have’ or ‘lack' capacity. In AI governance, governments may depend on private actors for technical expertise, data, computing infrastructure, or standards. Therefore, an important question is not only who has resources, but also who controls access to those resources and who can influence how they are used. Therefore, AI governance is understood as a process in which capacity and power are closely connected. It seeks to explain how different actors mobilize resources, coordinate their actions, and influence policy outcomes. The contributions may examine AI governance at national, sub-national, regional, or global levels and may focus on any sector or policy area.

POLICY TOPICS
State and Policy Capacity Bureaucracy, Administration and Policy Process Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P118. Building Capacities for Mission-Oriented Policies: How STI Organisations Learn, Coordinate and Adapt
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
G. Leme
M. Pavan Serafim
D. Alves
ABSTRACT

Mission-oriented public policies seek to address complex challenges such as decarbonisation, public health and inclusive development. However, setting ambitious goals does not, in itself, explain how organisations develop the means needed to achieve them. Beyond ministries and government agencies, these policies mobilise a diverse range of actors, particularly science, technology and innovation (STI) organisations, including universities, public and independent research institutes, research funding bodies, innovation intermediaries, public-sector innovation laboratories, behavioural insights units, science diplomacy and technical advisory structures, research and development (R&D) centres, foundations, incubators, accelerators, associations and firms. Studies highlight the heterogeneity of the organisational and governance arrangements of these different actors (Bonilla, Serafim and Bámaca-López, 2021; Leme et al., 2025; Bolliger et al., 2025; Alves et al., 2026; Leme, Alves and Serafim, 2026). This heterogeneity raises questions about the capacities these organisations need to fulfil their roles and the processes through which such capacities are developed. The policy capacity literature distinguishes analytical, operational and political competences at the individual, organisational and systemic levels (Wu, Ramesh and Howlett, 2015), while the dynamic public-sector capabilities approach emphasises strategic direction-setting, coordination, experimentation and learning (Kattel and Mazzucato, 2018). In turn, studies of transformative and mission-oriented innovation policies highlight tensions between established institutional routines and new organisational requirements associated with challenge-oriented approaches (Ulmanen, Bergek and Hellsmark, 2022; McLaren and Kattel, 2025). Although these approaches provide important conceptual foundations, there remains a need to understand how capacities develop across organisations with different mandates, legal statuses, resources and accountability arrangements. Against this background, a central question emerges: How do STI organisations, within and beyond government, develop the capacities needed to design, coordinate, implement, participate in, and inform mission-oriented public policies? To explore this question, the panel adopts a relational, institutional and process-oriented perspective. The discussion is structured around three complementary questions: (i) What? Which capacities are needed at different stages of mission-oriented public policies, and by which actors? (ii) How? Through which processes do organisations develop these capacities? (iii) Why? Which factors explain differences and similarities in capacity development across organisations and contexts? Building on these questions, the panel welcomes different theoretical explanations of the conditions that enable or constrain capacity development, considering their potential complementarities and tensions. Such development may depend not only on the resources available to individual organisations but also on the connections established among public, academic, private and civil society actors. Learning, for example, may generate enduring competences when embedded in organisational routines and institutions, but it may also create vulnerabilities when dependent on temporary programmes, external consultants or political leaders. Similarly, collaboration may strengthen collective action while also concentrating authority or creating dependence on external expertise. Thus, rather than assuming that mission orientation necessarily improves public action, the panel seeks to understand the conditions under which capacities are developed, accumulated, redistributed or weakened, as well as the implications of different organisational configurations for mission implementation and democratic accountability in mission governance.

POLICY TOPICS
State and Policy Capacity Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Research and Higher Education Policy Development Policy
P262. Hollowing Out or Scaling Up? AI Substitution, Human Oversight and State Capacity in Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Ebling
L. Póvoa
ABSTRACT

Governments are moving from experimenting with artificial intelligence to delegating core policy work to it. Generative and agentic AI systems now synthesise consultations, draft regulations, process cases, and produce evaluation reports. Advocates promise faster, cheaper, and more consistent public administration, an appeal particularly strong for resource-constrained states. Amidst declining public trust in political and administrative institutions, AI is also promoted and perceived as an impartial, technocratic alternative to fallible or partisan human decision-makers. Yet substitution differs from assistance. When AI takes over cognitive tasks, it reshapes who in the state knows how to do what, how policy problems are framed, who checks outputs, and who answers for results. The question is no longer only how to govern AI, but what AI does to the state's capacity to govern.Scholarship offers building blocks to address this question but has not yet joined them up. Research on policy capacity (Wu, Ramesh and Howlett 2015) shows that effective governance rests on analytical, operational, and political competences embedded in public organisations. The hollow state and consultocracy literatures (Milward and Provan 2000; Mazzucato and Collington 2023) warned that outsourcing erodes the state’s ability to steer what it no longer produces internally. Digital government studies traced the shift from street-level to system-level bureaucracy (Bovens and Zouridis 2002), while work on algorithmic accountability (Busuioc 2021) and automation bias (Alon-Barkat and Busuioc 2023) questions whether human oversight works as intended. However, most evidence concerns routine implementation and individual decisions. Much less is known about policy formulation and evaluation, where problem definition, value trade-offs, and counterfactual reasoning are central.This panel asks: under what conditions does substituting AI for human work strengthen or hollow out state and policy capacity, and what are the risks and benefits of reducing human involvement in policy formulation and evaluation?The panel explores five hypotheses:1. Capacity paradox: substitution yields short-term efficiency gains while eroding long-term skills, tacit knowledge, and institutional memory.2. Stage-dependent and epistemic risks: risks are modest in routine, codifiable tasks but acute in formulation and evaluation, where foundation models may induce epistemic homogenisation and self-referential evaluations.3. Oversight illusion: without verification capacity and incentives, nominal human-in-the-loop designs degenerate into rubber-stamping, while officials still absorb the blame for failures, becoming “moral crumple zones” (Elish 2019).4. Technological dependence: substitution relocates analytical capacity to private providers, creating sovereignty dependencies most consequential in the Global South.5. Legitimacy paradox: declining trust in human institutions makes AI appealing as a neutral arbiter, risking the depoliticization of value-laden policy choices.

POLICY TOPICS
State and Policy Capacity Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Administration and Civil Service Policy Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy
P169. Beyond Green Colonialism and Green Window of Opportunity: Pathways of Latecomer Economies in the Global Energy Transition
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Wokuri
A. Maillet
ABSTRACT

Recent debates in political economy offer contrasting assessments of how the current global conjuncture affects the developmental prospects of latecomer economies. That conjuncture is marked by intensifying US–China rivalry, the exhaustion of neoliberal development strategies, and accelerating energy transitions (Driscoll et al, 2026; Kuzemko et al, 2025; Meckling, 2025). One camp argues that these dynamics reproduce dependency through new forms of “green colonialism.” On this view, latecomers are locked into extractive roles or subordinate positions within cleantech value chains. Another camp stresses that geopolitical fragmentation, supply-chain reorganization, and the strategic centrality of energy transitions open new developmental opportunities. These include a wider scope for industrial policy, state coordination, and industrial upgrading. Both positions capture important dynamics. Yet both treat green industrialization as a coherent and generalizable process. This obscures the wide variation in how latecomer economies engage with energy transitions, and how these engagements interact with existing development strategies, state capacities, and class relations (Hochstetler, 2020). There may also be considerable unevenness across subsectors, with some areas achieving meaningful advancement while others remain marginal or excluded (Behuria et al, 2026). These issues must also be studied from a policy-oriented perspective. To do so, this panel moves beyond the binary by disaggregating green transitions along two analytically distinct dimensions: -Domestic energy system transformation, meaning the decarbonization of a country’s own power, industry, and transport systems.-Integration into cleantech value chains, meaning participation in the production, processing, and export of green technologies and inputs.These dimensions are neither coextensive nor causally linked. They generate four ideal-typical situations: -Renewables-led transition without industrial upgrading-Cleantech integration without domestic decarbonization-Simultaneous green industrialization-Fossil-locked marginalization Rather than asking whether green transitions open or foreclose development, the panel asks through which pathways latecomer economies engage with them. It also asks what this means for state capacity (Collington, 2026), class coalitions, and modes of integration into global markets (Karas, 2026). We welcome empirically grounded papers, single-case or comparative, that address questions such as: -Which pathways do latecomer economies follow, and how do they fit, stretch, or challenge the four ideal-typical situations?-How do existing development strategies, state capacities, and institutional legacies shape engagement with each transition dimension (Behuria, 2025; Larsen, 2025) ?-How do class coalitions, business groups (Carrasco and Madariaga, 2025), labour, and political settlements shape, and get reshaped by, green transition strategies?-What explains the decoupling, or the occasional coupling, of domestic decarbonization and cleantech industrialization (Allan and Nahm, 2025)?-How do US–China rivalry, industrial policies in the Global North, trade and investment regimes, and critical minerals politics condition latecomers’ room for manoeuvre (Zylinski, 2026)?-Under what conditions do states move between situations, whether through upgrading, lock-in, or reversal (Driscoll and Larsen, 2026)?-How should the two dimensions be measured and compared across cases?-What are the “strategic divergences” (Prontera and Passalacqua, 2026) and convergences between countries and what are their explaining factors?Contributions can also tackle these issues at the subsectoral level, either in single-case or comparative.

POLICY TOPICS
State and Policy Capacity Politics, Institutions and Political Regimes
P172. Policy Capacity in Cross-Border and Protracted Crises in West and South Asia
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Pouradib
M. Mozaffari Falarti
ABSTRACT

West and South Asia are among the world's most challenging environments for public policymaking. Protracted humanitarian crises, forced displacement, growing pressures on shared water resources, and cross-border security challenges confront public institutions with uncertainty, resource constraints, demands for inter-organizational coordination, and the significant presence of external actors. In this panel, cross-border and protracted crises refer to crises whose effects, causes, or governance mechanisms extend beyond national borders and/or whose policy responses persist over time. Nevertheless, public institutions differ considerably in policy design and implementation, coordination, and the sustainability of their responses. The panel therefore focuses not on crises themselves, but on variation in the policy capacity of public institutions to address them. Drawing on Wu, Ramesh, and Howlett (2015), policy capacity is understood as the competencies and capabilities required to perform policy functions and is examined across analytical, operational, and political dimensions at individual, organizational, and systemic levels. Comparative research on West and South Asia has often focused on specific domains, such as health, disaster preparedness, or refugee responses, whereas comparative analysis of policy capacity across multiple crisis domains within a common framework has received less attention. By connecting policy capacity with the literatures on crisis governance and inter-organizational coordination, this panel treats humanitarian crises, forced displacement, water disputes, and regional security challenges as empirical settings for comparing how policy capacity is developed, mobilized, strengthened, or eroded. It seeks to operationalize policy capacity for comparative crisis analysis, examine the institutional and political mechanisms that shape it, and analyze how inter-organizational coordination and transnational and regional actors help translate policy capacity into policy responses. The central research question is: What factors explain variation in the policy capacity of public institutions to manage cross-border and protracted crises in West and South Asia, and how do these differences affect policy implementation, coordination, the sustainability of policy responses, and prospects for regional cooperation? The panel advances three hypotheses for testing, critique, or refinement. First, the quality of inter-organizational coordination, independently of the level of formal institutional resources, plays a decisive role in explaining variation in policy implementation. Second, reliance on external actors increases the coverage of policy responses in the short term, but its long-term effects on domestic capacity depend on institutional arrangements: in the absence of institutional capacity-building, such reliance substitutes for or erodes domestic capacity, whereas when capacity-building is present, it strengthens domestic capacity. Third, the relationship between domestic policy capacity and regional cooperation is reciprocal: domestic policy capacity can strengthen regional cooperation, while regional arrangements can, in turn, affect domestic policy capacity. The panel's scientific contribution lies in applying a common policy capacity framework to compare crisis domains typically examined in separate bodies of literature, while investigating the linkages among domestic capacity, inter-organizational coordination, and regional cooperation. In doing so, it seeks to foster comparative dialogue across crisis domains and countries in West and South Asia and contribute to the theoretical and empirical development of research on policy capacity and crisis governance.

POLICY TOPICS
State and Policy Capacity Crises, Risks and Wicked Problems Global and Transnational Policies General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P278. Building Emergence: Urban Development Policies and State Transformation in Africa
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. ANGUISSA BEKONO
Y. Issekin
ABSTRACT

Over the past two decades, a growing number of African governments have framed their development strategies through the vocabulary of "emergence". Long-term visions and plans, such as Cameroon's Vision 2035, the Plan Sénégal Émergent, Côte d'Ivoire's national development plans, Rwanda's Vision 2050 or Ethiopia's Growth and Transformation Plans, share an ambition to turn national territories, and above all cities, into showcases of modernity. This ambition materialises in new towns and satellite cities, stadiums and sports complexes, transport corridors, business districts and urban renewal schemes, often financed through loans, public-private partnerships and contracts with foreign firms, notably Chinese and Turkish. These projects are not merely physical objects: they are instruments through which states claim legitimacy, allocate resources, reorganise authority across levels of government and redefine who belongs in the city. Critical urban scholarship has described such projects as "urban fantasies" (Watson, 2014), stressing the gap between master-planned visions and the realities of fast-growing, largely informal cities, and the seductive rhetoric that sustains them (van Noorloos & Kloosterboer, 2018; Côté-Roy & Moser, 2019). Political economy approaches have linked them to infrastructure-led development, the return of spatial planning and the developmental state (Mkandawire, 2001; Schindler & Kanai, 2021; Goodfellow, 2022), while the policy mobilities literature has traced the circulation of urban models across borders (McCann & Ward, 2011). Yet these debates remain loosely connected to public policy analysis. Large urban projects are rarely examined as public policies in their own right: through their agenda-setting, their instruments (Lascoumes & Le Galès, 2007), their implementation chains, the coalitions that carry them and their unintended effects. The panel therefore asks: how do "emergence" agendas shape the design, governance and implementation of urban development policies in Africa, and what do these policies reveal about the transformation of the state and of public action on the continent? Contributions may explore several hypotheses. First, emergence may operate less as a coherent programme than as a legitimising narrative that enables exceptional procedures and centralised decision-making. Second, reliance on external financing and contractors may produce hybrid governance arrangements in which policy capacity is negotiated rather than simply transferred. Third, implementation gaps, such as delays, cost overruns or unfinished and underused facilities, may be less mere failures than sites where state priorities and constraints become visible. Fourth, the urban effects of these projects, from displacement to new citizen claims, may feed back into the politics of emergence itself. By treating African cities as ordinary sites of policy-making (Robinson, 2006) rather than as exceptions, the panel seeks to bring African cases into dialogue with general theories of the policy process, policy instruments and state transformation, and to test their assumptions in contexts marked by strong executive power, external dependence and rapid urban change.

POLICY TOPICS
State and Policy Capacity Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy Urban Policy and Planning Development Policy
P247. Digitising the State: Welfare Technologies, State Capacity and the Future of Democratic Accountability
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Chauhan
A. Siddiqui
K. Singh
ABSTRACT

General ObjectivesGovernments across the world are increasingly reorganising public administration around digital infrastructure, including biometric identification, integrated social registries, direct benefit transfers, interoperable databases and algorithmic systems for eligibility assessment and fraud detection. These instruments are transforming how states identify citizens, allocate resources and deliver public services. Although digitalisation is widely associated with improved efficiency, reduced leakages and enhanced administrative reach, its implications for democratic accountability, inclusion and responsiveness remain contested. Existing scholarship on digital-era governance, administrative capacity and algorithmic governance highlights both the potential of digital technologies to improve public service delivery and their capacity to reproduce exclusion, intensify surveillance and obscure responsibility for administrative decisions. This panel seeks to examine how digitalisation is reshaping the relationship between state capacity and democracy through a comparative analysis of digital welfare and public service delivery across the Global South and North. It conceptualises state capacity through two interconnected dimensions: administrative reach, understood as the ability to identify, enrol and serve populations at scale, and democratic responsiveness, understood as the ability to recognise grievances, correct errors and make public authority answerable to citizens. The panel addresses five broad research questions: 1. How and under what institutional conditions does digitalisation enhance administrative capacity while affecting democratic accountability? 2. How do digital identification, social registries and algorithmic decision-making reshape access to welfare, and which groups are most vulnerable to exclusion? 3. How does digital welfare alter the roles of street-level bureaucrats, local representatives, intermediaries and citizens in policy implementation? 4. What mechanisms—including grievance redress, judicial intervention, independent oversight and data-protection safeguards—enable citizens to contest digital administrative decisions? 5. How do political institutions and electoral incentives shape the use of digital welfare for political credit-claiming, executive centralisation and new forms of clientelism?The panel will explore the hypotheses that digitalisation expands administrative reach more readily than democratic responsiveness; that exclusionary outcomes depend not only on technological design but also on institutional arrangements and the availability of effective remedies; and that digital systems can either centralise political authority or strengthen accountability, depending on the distribution of decision-making power and oversight. Its scientific relevance lies in bringing public policy implementation, comparative state capacity, digital governance and democratic accountability into a common analytical framework. Combining qualitative fieldwork, comparative case studies, legal and policy analysis, and quantitative evaluation, the panel will generate cross-regional insights into when digitalisation produces inclusive and accountable governance and when it creates technically efficient yet democratically unresponsive states.

POLICY TOPICS
State and Policy Capacity Agency/Leadership Social Policy Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy
P275. Building policy capacity for the AI era: how public servants and administrations learn to judge, use and govern artificial intelligence
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
I. Steenmans
M. Cross
ABSTRACT

Public administrations are adopting artificial intelligence faster than they are building the capacity to use it well. Governments now expect public servants at every level to commission, interrogate, deploy and govern AI tools, and to make policy for societies increasingly shaped by AI. In response, substantial resources are flowing into AI literacy curricula, digital academies and leadership programmes. Yet we know little about which capabilities public servants actually need, whether and how learning initiatives build them, or whether these investments translate into broader institutional capabilities to use and govern AI. Three literatures speak to this problem but to date little to each other. The policy capacity literature (Wu, Ramesh and Howlett 2015) distinguishes analytical, operational and political capacities at individual, organisational and systemic levels, but predates AI becoming part of everyday policy work; work on dynamic capabilities adds that organisational capacity is more than the sum of individual skills (Kattel and Mazzucato 2018). Public administration research on AI shows that it reshapes bureaucratic discretion and roles in ways that depend on organisational context (Bullock 2019; Giest and Klievink 2024), and that officials' use of algorithmic advice is shaped by automation bias, selective adherence and prior professional judgement (Alon-Barkat and Busuioc 2023; Selten, Robeer and Grimmelikhuijsen 2023). Technical skill alone is therefore insufficient. Research on public sector training, meanwhile, rarely tests whether learning changes behaviour or organisational performance rather than participants' reactions and knowledge, although the studies that do suggest it can, under particular conditions (Kroll and Moynihan 2015; Seidle, Fernandez and Perry 2016). The result is a gap between public investment in AI capability and our understanding of what that investment produces. This panel asks: what capabilities does AI require of public servants and public organisations, and how do learning and development initiatives build them? Papers may explore hypotheses such as: 1. AI capability in public administrations is primarily a matter of judgement rather than technical skill. 2. AI reconfigures existing policy capacities rather than adding a separate "digital" capacity. 3. Individual learning translates into organisational AI capability under particular conditions, such as permission to experiment and adequate data infrastructure. 4. Prevailing evaluation approaches cannot detect the capabilities that matter most, so new methods are needed to capture shifts in practice. This panel's scientific relevance is threefold. Conceptually, it updates policy capacity theory for the AI era. Empirically, it brings together emerging evidence from AI literacy programmes, executive education, regulator training and on-the-job learning across diverse administrative contexts. Methodologically, it advances ways of evaluating capability development beyond satisfaction surveys. It will interest scholars of policy capacity, public sector innovation, digital governance and professional education, and practitioners who design and commission AI learning for government.

POLICY TOPICS
State and Policy Capacity Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments Administration and Civil Service Policy General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P34. Postcolonial Global Governance: Power, Knowledge, and Policy-Making in the Global South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Y. DIALLO
ABSTRACT

Literature Review and Theoretical Positioning Global governance and public policy research has examined how international institutions, transnational networks, policy ideas and multilevel arrangements shape the formulation and implementation of public policies. Work on policy transfer and lesson-drawing has shown how policy models, administrative arrangements and ideas travel across jurisdictions (Dolowitz and Marsh, 2000), while research on transnational policy networks has highlighted the role of non-state actors and intermediaries in circulating policy knowledge (Stone, 2004; Stone and Porto de Oliveira, 2020). Geographical approaches to policy mobility further demonstrate that policies do not simply move intact: they are translated, adapted and transformed as they encounter particular political and institutional contexts (Peck, 2011). Yet these accounts can leave insufficiently examined the historical and geopolitical inequalities that structure global policy circulation: who defines problems, whose expertise is treated as authoritative, which models are promoted as universal, and whose interests shape the terms of international cooperation. Postcolonial and decolonial scholarship offers resources for examining these asymmetries. Quijano’s (2000) account of the coloniality of power explains how colonial hierarchies persist beyond formal empire, while Mignolo and Walsh (2018) examine the epistemic and political dimensions of decolonial thought. In international studies, Acharya’s (2014) call for Global IR challenges the marginalisation of non-Western histories, agency and knowledge in accounts of world politics. Tucker (2018) similarly argues for closer attention to the racialised relations of power and knowledge through which coloniality operates across political and epistemic sites. These perspectives are increasingly being brought directly into public policy and governance research. Jhagroe and Salazar-Morales (2025), for example, theorise policy coloniality to explain how racialised and colonial knowledge can shape policy formulation and the treatment of target populations. Strand’s (2022) study of development cooperation with South Africa shows how aid discourse can reproduce hierarchies between former colonial powers and recipient societies. Recent work on policy evaluation in the Global South also highlights the interaction of colonial legacies, domestic institutions and transnational influences (Ben Brik, 2025). Together, these contributions suggest that global governance should be examined not only through its formal institutions and rules, but also through the historical power relations, narratives and knowledge practices that shape policy agendas and authority. This panel brings these strands into dialogue. It treats postcolonialism not simply as a historical perspective or normative call, but as an analytical approach to contemporary global governance and policy-making. It is particularly interested in how power operates across international, regional, national and local levels; how global policy narratives define development priorities and legitimate interventions; and how actors in the Global South exercise agency by negotiating, translating, resisting or reshaping externally promoted frameworks. Research Questions The panel is guided by the following central question: How do postcolonial power relations and unequal knowledge hierarchies shape global governance and policy-making across multilevel institutions in the Global South? - How do international organisations, donors, transnational networks and national governments shape policy agendas and define legitimate development priorities? - Through which narratives, expertise and policy instruments are particular models of governance presented as universal, necessary or transferable? - How do national, subnational and community-level actors negotiate, translate, resist or appropriate externally promoted policies? - Under what conditions do South–South cooperation, regional institutions and locally grounded knowledge challenge or reproduce existing global hierarchies? - How do colonial legacies interact with contemporary geopolitical, economic and institutional inequalities in shaping policy implementation and outcomes? Methodological Approach The panel welcomes methodological pluralism while encouraging submissions to make explicit how their research design connects power, knowledge and policy processes to observable institutional practices and outcomes. Contributions may employ qualitative, quantitative, historical, comparative or mixed-method approaches. Relevant methods include comparative case studies across countries or policy sectors; process tracing of policy formulation, negotiation and implementation; qualitative analysis of policy documents, legislation, strategies and international agreements; discourse and narrative analysis of development frameworks and governance agendas; and semi-structured interviews with policymakers, civil society organisations, experts and affected communities. Network analysis and quantitative analysis of policy diffusion, aid flows or institutional participation are also welcome where appropriate. Across these approaches, contributors are encouraged to identify the actors and levels of governance involved, trace how policy ideas and instruments circulate, examine how they are translated in particular contexts, and consider whose knowledge and interests are included or marginalised. Comparative work should avoid treating the Global South as a homogeneous category and should attend to differences in historical experience, institutional capacity, political context and regional position. Scientific Relevance The panel’s contribution is to connect postcolonial and decolonial analysis with research on global governance, multilevel policy-making and policy mobility. It shifts attention from the formal transfer of policy models alone to the power relations and narratives that shape their circulation, legitimacy and local effects. By foregrounding both structural inequalities and the agency of Global South actors, the panel seeks to advance comparative explanations of how global policy agendas are produced, negotiated and transformed.

POLICY TOPICS
Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives Multilevel Governance and Local Policy Global and Transnational Policies Development Policy
P110. The Global War of Discourses: Critical Philosophy, Interpretive Policy, and the EU-US-China AI Governance Contest
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
R. Queiroz
G. Ferrari
ABSTRACT

General Objectives The global governance of Artificial Intelligence (AI) is increasingly shaped by a triangular normative and geopolitical contest among the European Union, the United States, and the People’s Republic of China. While a growing body of literature analyses these three poles, current research remains largely tied to legal-institutional comparison: the EU’s horizontal, risk-based AI Act; China’s vertical, security-oriented architecture; and the United States’ fragmented, innovation-led framework organised around technological leadership, national security, and global competitiveness. What remains profoundly understudied is the communicative, interpretive, and discursive dimension through which these different models are justified, projected, and translated into policy choices beyond their own jurisdictions. This panel argues that the EU-US-China relationship cannot be fully grasped as a technical divergence among regulatory systems; rather, it demands the lens of Interpretive Policy Analysis (IPA) and critical philosophy to deconstruct a global struggle over "authoritative discourses" regarding responsible digital statecraft. Through distinct strategic narratives, all three actors project normative authority and shape global debates. The EU positions AI within a macro-discourse of trust, fundamental rights, and ethical oversight, extending the "Brussels Effect". China constructs AI through discourses of national sovereignty, social stability, and state-led efficiency, projecting its model through initiatives like the Digital Silk Road. The US constitutes a third pole centred on innovation, entrepreneurial freedom, and technological leadership, reinforced by a federal agenda aimed at removing regulatory barriers, expanding domestic AI infrastructure, and exporting full-stack solutions to allies. These are not fixed models, but competing narratives structuring markets, alliances, and policy choices. The Lusophone world offers a revealing laboratory for observing how third spaces negotiate, combine, resist, or strategically hybridise these governance repertoires. This investigation is especially timely for 2027, when the EU’s rules enter a new stage of application, the US consolidates its AI leadership strategy, and China expands its global governance model for generative AI. Research Question and Hypotheses Applying a tripartite heuristic—Discourse, Framing, and Narrative—this panel addresses the following question: How do the competing strategic discourses of the EU, the US, and China shape, discipline, and constrain the digital public policies and sovereignty of third spaces, particularly within the Lusophone world? We explore three main hypotheses: The Discursive Tripolarity Hypothesis: The dominant macro-discursive structures promoted by the EU (rights-centric), the US (innovation-centric), and China (state-centric) create a tripolar field of normative competition that marginalises alternative local conceptualisations of digital common goods.The Strategic Framing of Autonomy: Middle powers within the Lusophone space strategically "frame" domestic AI policies by selectively combining European rights-based vocabularies, American technological ecosystems (cloud and semiconductors), and Chinese infrastructural partnerships, enabling them to manoeuvre among competing centres of influence.The Counter-Discourse Resistance Hypothesis: Micro-interactional "plots" deployed by local policy networks, peripheral developers, and civil-society actors resist or reinterpret imported "authoritative discourses" to reclaim local data, linguistic, and technological sovereignty as a requirement for epistemic justice.

POLICY TOPICS
Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives Multilevel Governance and Local Policy Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy Global and Transnational Policies
P80. Empowered Citizens in Environmental Sustainability: From Civic Practices to Transformative Policy Transitions
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Boossabong
F. Fischer
ABSTRACT

The search for environmental sustainability constitutes a major challenge of this century. Despite all of the rhetoric about the need to deal with the coming crisis, the actions to mitigate the crisis thus far have fallen far short of those which needed to put humanity on a sustainable course. Why this failure is a complicated topic, politically, economically, and culturally. Here we seek to explore only one aspect of this challenge, namely the role of citizens and the public. While citizens alone cannot solve the sustainability problem, it is at the same time not clear that it can be successfully dealt with without them. From early on, environmental literature has called for broad citizen participation as a primary requirement for the successful pursuit of sustainable development. It is, moreover, written into key United Nations documents. So far, however, actions to deal with this challenge have not only fallen short of the measures needed to put the Earth on a sustainable course, but also have neglected the role participation. Most of the efforts have largely emphasized scientific and technological solutions, especially those that are driven by market systems. Such attempts to rely on “technical fixes“ have typically occurred at the expense of democratic environmental policymaking and citizen engagement. An important part of this reluctance to engage citizens is the belief, often more latent than manifest, that the public citizenry is not up to the task. Citizens are seen to lack the requisite intelligence; they are not informed enough to meaningfully deal with the sustainability challenge. Despite this common view, this panel seeks to examine real-world existing policies and practices that demonstrate the ways that empowered citizens can help to put politics on a path to sustainability. Toward this end, the panel calls for contributions that draw lessons from a range of deliberative participatory projects and governance practices that illustrate the importance of the role that empowered citizens can play in the pursuit of democratically just and sustainable transitions.

POLICY TOPICS
Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives Citizens, Participation and Social Movements Development Policy General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P284. Perceptions on Public Policy, Democracy and Justice: Values, Ideas, References, Discourses and Legitimacy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Justo
P. JANNUZZI
ABSTRACT

Public policies constitute an important point of interaction between the state, government, and citizens, through which demands, preferences, and political interests are both communicated and shaped. Because public opinion influences and is, in turn, influenced by state action, this two-way relationship has implications for the social and substantive dimensions of democracy. Although voting is the primary mechanism through which interests are represented, and state action is legitimized in relation to the preferences of the majority of the population, citizens do not directly choose policies; rather, they elect politicians. The decisions politicians make, as well as the measures and actions they adopt in the realm of public policy, do not necessarily reflect preferences that can be assumed to be homogeneous or representative of a majority. Instead, they tend to reflect the preferences of particular groups or, at most, coalitions of interests representing larger minorities. This underscores the particular importance of examining public perceptions of policy priorities, which cannot be inferred from electoral outcomes alone. As Howlett (2000) argues, public opinion—whether understood in general terms or as the opinion of the majority—cannot be treated as an independent variable determining public policy formulation. Government actions, whether through direct and deliberate interventions or through unintended effects, also shape public opinion in a dialectical process of mutual influence and feedback. According to the policy feedback literature, citizens’ experiences with public policies can shape their perceptions of government and their rights, corresponding to the interpretative or ideational effects of these policies. This type of mobilization can affect bureaucrats as well as policy beneficiaries. Campbell (2003), for example, identified an increase in political participation among older adults in the United States, driven by their perception of themselves as worth citizens, which stemmed from their relationship with social security policy. Spink and Burgos (2019), in turn, identified bottom-up policymaking processes emerging from state absence in peripheral communities in Brazil, challenging the assumptions underlying most implementation analyses. Finally, Evans (1993) demonstrated the importance of participatory policies through the example of Brazil’s participatory budgeting, whereby part of the public budget is allocated according to civil society’s preferences. This type of bottom-up policy would foster democratic state capacities, enhancing the state’s responsiveness to society. Thus, it is important to understand the multiple effects of public policies on democracy, as well as the effects of democracy on public policies, in order to improve both. To this end, this panel seeks contributions that investigate the conceptions of democracy and justice underlying public policies, as well as their ideational and behavioral effects, which may, in turn, influence governments and public policies themselves. Accordingly, research into public perceptions of public policies is particularly relevant, especially when focused on social policies, given that these policies have expanded and contracted over time across different historical contexts, affecting social groups in distinct ways. The so-called Political Sociology of Public Action, which originated in France, has flourished and gained international recognition, incorporating and fostering productive dialogue with Anglo-Saxon scholarship—particularly historical neo-institutionalism. This exchange has enriched its theoretical assumptions, analytical frameworks, research concerns, variables and interdependent factors of interest, as well as its methodological tools. Drawing on the work of authors such as Gramsci, Foucault, Bourdieu, and Latour, its interdisciplinary character makes it particularly well suited to the analysis of public policies. Moving beyond critiques of monolithic perspectives, this approach has sought to articulate ideas and action through a range of analytical elements, including territories, knowledge and forms of expertise, culture, symbolism and narratives, policy sectors, intersectorality and intersectionality, as well as what may be termed the various “I’s”: ideas, interests, institutions, individuals, and instruments. These approaches are characterized by a democratic and participatory analytical orientation and a particular concern with processes of transformation and the legitimacy of public policies. As Muller and Jobert (1987), Muller (1990), and Hassenteufel (2008) argue, public policies contribute to the construction of identities. Consequently, citizens’ responses to such policies may take the form of either endorsement or rejection at different stages of the policy process: when a policy is proposed, when it is experienced, and when it is discontinued. Opinions about public policies are shaped by the information available to citizens but also derive, to a considerable extent, from the beliefs, values, and frames of reference that guide the political behavior of groups sharing distinct political subcultures. The analysis in terms of frames of reference, as proposed by the sociology of public action, incorporates into the analytical and evaluative dimensions theoretical elements such as “the inevitability of change and the relationship between actors’ assertion of identity and the question of legitimacy” (TOMAZINI, 2021, p. 203). These elements are often overlooked due to the predominance of rationalizing and linear paradigms. When a frame of reference becomes hegemonic in policy production, it not only guides policy by indicating the direction to be taken but also identifies the actors who occupy central positions. From this perspective, however, it is not only influential and prominent actors who sustain and advance ideas; rather, ideas themselves confer influence and centrality upon actors (TOMAZINI, 2021, p. 204). Thus, “the cognitive frameworks internalized by actors structure conflicts and tensions surrounding public policies. Cognitive and normative elements are therefore central to explanations of change” (TOMAZINI, 2021, p. 18). Accordingly, if public policy is understood as being inherently defined by change, as Muller (2005) argues, the cognitive approach offers a theory of change (MULLER, 2005; SUREL; PALIER, 2010; TOMAZINI, 2021) that, when considered alongside neo-institutionalist approaches (LEVI, 1991; NORTH, 2018; STREECK; THELEN, 2005; MAHONEY; THELEN, 2010), enriches explanations of policy dynamics. In the wake of the constructivist turn and the development of discursive neo-institutionalism (SCHMIDT, 2010), the cognitive approach, or the political sociology of public action, has gradually gained ground in public policy analysis. This development has occurred alongside related or complementary approaches, including policy paradigms (HALL, 1993), epistemic communities (HAAS, 1992), networks (RHODES, 2006), advocacy coalitions (SABATIER; JENKINS-SMITH, 1993), multiple streams (KINGDON, 1995), punctuated equilibrium (BAUMGARTNER; JONES, 1993), and street-level bureaucracy (LIPSKY, 2010). It also encompasses more recent approaches, such as the three “I’s” (PALIER; SUREL, 2005), the pragmatic approach (ZITTOUN, 2021), the socio-historical approach (PAYRE; POLLET, 2021), and actor-centered approaches that examine elites, elected officials, mediators, brokers, professionals, bureaucracies, political parties, identity-based and interest groups, and social movements (in HASSENTEUFEL; OLIVEIRA, 2021). In addition, more methodologically oriented approaches include policy instrumentation (HALPERN; LASCOUMES; LE GALÈS, 2021) and field analysis (DUBOIS, 2021). There is, therefore, a rich and still insufficiently explored field for further debate and research on public policies, particularly if we recognize that “ideas also matter” (ROCHA LUKIC; TOMAZINI, 2013). In the French context, the shift away from the term “public policies” toward the expression “public action” was associated with a critique of traditional approaches to public policy studies, which centered on the state, in favor of a perspective in which public action is collectively constructed by multiple, interconnected actors operating across different levels and contexts (OLIVEIRA; HASSENTEUFEL, 2021). This perspective draws attention not only to the political and formal dimensions of democracy but also to its social and substantive dimensions (BOBBIO, 2005).

POLICY TOPICS
Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives Social Policy
P295. Public Policy and Dramaturgy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Zittoun
C. Ansell
J. Dodge
ABSTRACT

The aim of the panel is to discuss the way they use dramaturgy to grasp public policy and the policy process and to explain what dramaturgy allows them to understand about policy making that other approaches miss. Policy scholars have long drawn on dramaturgy to understand public policy and the policy process. However, the way they understand policy as a drama and deploy dramaturgical concepts like narrative or plot to policy analysis are very different. For some, drama is a metaphor that helps describe political life and policy process as staged. For others it is a method for analyzing rhetoric, symbols and emotions in political and policy speech. Dramaturgy can serve as an interpretive lens on how citizens narrate their encounters with authority, or a way to identity the dynamics of moral outrage, or a practice of intervention that uses theatre to transform who gets to decide. This inspiration began early, with Kenneth Burke, who analyzed the vote on a law proposal as an “act” and studied the rhetorical strategies used by members of parliament to persuade others (Burke 1975). Cobb and Elder used dramaturgical metaphors to describe agenda-setting as a staged drama (Cobb and Elder 1972). Merelman explored the “dramatic nature of ideology,” while Edelman famously evoked the “political spectacle” (Merelman 1969; Edelman 1985). Joseph Gusfield analyzed the policy process through a dramaturgical lens, identifying two levels of social life: one in which society is spoken about and defined, and another consisting of social activities (Gusfield 1981, 18). The success of dramaturgical metaphors continued to shape policy studies after the 1980s. Notably, Martijn Hajer (2005) used dramaturgy to analyze policy processes as “sequences of staged performances of conflict and conflict resolution.” In recent years, it is fascinating to see how dramaturgical elements are used in so many different approaches to policy studies. We find it in the positivist perspectives that focus attention on the definition of the problem or with the recent development of the Narrative Policy Framework, and also in the constructivist and interpretative perspectives where attention to discourse and narrative is always central. Rather than opposing these perspectives, it is interesting to highlight that the way they use dramaturgy corresponds more or less to two different traditions of the dramaturgy in the social sciences. The first tradition views public policy as a drama expressed through the stories it conveys and the frames it produces, which affect a broader audience, the public. Klapp (2017, 1962) suggested that policy can be read as a theatrical monologue, with dramaturgy helping us to interpret “heroes, villains, and fools.” Edelman developed this idea, showing how politicians construct problems to justify solutions and legitimize themselves as “incredible leaders” (Edelman 1988). For Gusfield, policy discourse appears as a fictional or illusory narrative in which society is presented as definable, predictable, and under government control (Gusfield 1989). Following Goffman, public policy is thus understood through its capacity to frame meaning for its audience. These perspectives inspired important concepts such as Deborah Stone’s “causal stories,” Emery Roe’s “narratives,” Frank Fischer’s Framing Public Policy, Maarten Hajer’s “policy drama” and Zittoun’s “policy statement (Fischer 2003; Stone 1989; Hajer and Oomen 2025; Zittoun 2014; Kuenzler et al. 2025).” The narrative policy framework also belongs to this tradition, with its structured approach to exploring narrative form through categories and plots (Jones and McBeth 2010). From this perspective, public policy is seen as a drama/story/narrative that not only defines the society where problems are solved and order restored, but also legitimizes certain actors or coalitions that intervene to ‘solve’ the problem. The second tradition considers the policy process itself as a performance, analyzing policymakers as actors playing roles, and their interactions as a succession of staged scenes. Inspired by Goffman’s analysis of everyday life and Durkheim’s notion of ritual, this approach emphasizes the role as a “pre-established model of action developed during a performance,” and the “social façade” as a “collective representation” of the role—even when individuals distance themselves from it (Goffman 1990). From this micro-perspective, policymaking can be studied as a plurality of scenes in which actors display their skills and adapt their roles to different contexts. While Goffman did not study policy processes directly, he examined meetings and conferences, highlighting their performative dimensions (Goffman 1981). Other scholars have tied these ideas more directly to political and policy analysis. For example, Edelman (1998) depicted politicians as actors performing a spectacle, Alexander (2010) applied dramaturgy to presidential elections, Hajer (2005) analyzed “deliberative dramaturgy,” where the process sets its own rules, and Hendriks et al. (2016) emphasized the role of media in shaping political performance. This tradition ties in with the recent work on rituals, ritualistic visual narratives and the vast array of studies on emotions and policy processes (Baele and Balzacq 2022; Durnová 2019; Pierce 2021; Salgó 2017).

POLICY TOPICS
Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives Policy Process Theories
P132. Discursive Agency in (Environmental) Politics - Concepts, Applications and Perspectives
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
T. Herdlitschka
H. Hempel
A. Luo
S. Leipold
P. Roos
ABSTRACT

Policy change hinges on the ability of alternative discourses to challenge long established policy paradigms. Yet, alternative perspectives often struggle to gain traction, while established narratives continue to shape policy priorities and limit the scope of what is considered legitimate. Studying discursive agency is crucial if we want to better understand actors’ role in language and narrative use, their relationship to strategic practices, as well as their ability to construct problems, legitimize particular solutions, and gain political influence (Schmidt 2008; Leipold and Winkel 2017). Despite its growing analytical relevance in times of regression and policy stalemate, research on discursive agency remains fragmented across theoretical approaches, empirical cases, and policy fields. As a result, opportunities to compare how discursive agency is conceptualized and operationalized remain limited. Furthermore, important questions remain unanswered regarding the conditions under which actors exercise discursive agency and the ways in which this agency can contribute to political change or reinforce existing power relations. This raises questions about how discursive agency operates across institutional levels, how material conditions enable or constrain discursive interventions, and how methodological approaches can capture these dynamics across different policy contexts. Addressing these issues is particularly important in environmental policy, where established political paradigms, such as ecological modernization, face ever-growing challenges, while transformative alternatives continue to be pushed to the sideline amid shifting global power dynamics. Bringing together scholars working on discursive agency, this panel seeks to advance a more systematic understanding of discursive agency and it’s methodological foundations, empirical applications, and explanatory potential. By identifying commonalities and tensions across approaches, the panel aims to investigate how discursive agency can help explain the ways in which actors shape, contest, and transform policy processes. Ultimately, we seek to foster dialogue across contributions and explore how discursive agency can contribute to a broader understanding of policy change.

POLICY TOPICS
Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Other
P139. Searching for complementarity: Can empiricism and interpretivism collaborate?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Tangney
I. Verhoeven
ABSTRACT

In the last 50 years or so, interpretive policy analysis has established itself as a significant alternative to positivist and/or rationalist policy sciences. Described variously in terms of post-positivism, the Argumentative Turn, communicative rationality and participatory or deliberative policy analysis (Dryzek 1990; Fischer and Forrester 1991; Hajer and Wagenaar 2003), interpretivist scholarship now constitutes a substantial portion of the policy studies literature. Alongside this burgeoning scholarship, there has been much debate and discussion of the limitations of empiricist policy-analysis in terms of its failure to adequately account for the values and partial perspectives that infuse its methods (Johnson 2005). More recently, interpretivist and positivist scholars have argued that the divide between interpretivism and empiricism has been exaggerated due to somewhat unfair caricatures on each side (Durnová and Weible 2020). Lasswell's policy sciences, it turns out, was not actually as positivist as had often been assumed, incorporating contingent, critical and reflexive perspectives in its pragmatic orientation to policy analysis (Torgerson 2022). Post-positivist rationalism, it has been proposed, might effectively work in tandem with interpretivism (Weimer 1998). Some argue that we should seek out theory-building and methodological complementarities between traditional empiricism and interpretivism, for instance through side-by-side research, integrative research, mutual learning about research techniques, or joint applied research (Durnová and Weible 2020). We see potential in searching for such complementarities, and to explore this possibility further. In part, our optimism springs from our perception that, in the past, positivism (i.e. we can find the ‘truth’), rationalism (i.e. we can apply informed reason to choose and implement the ‘best’ policies) and empiricism (i.e. we can enhance policymaking and implementation through the collection and analysis of relevant data) may have been unduly conflated under one positivist umbrella. We suggest that empiricist methods may be under-appreciated in terms of their potential for advancing interpretive policy studies. We also note the increasing use of generative AI (genAI) tools for policy analysis in recent years, and we see potential for methods that can advance both empiricist and interpretivist programs in complementary ways. By focusing on complementarity, this panel seeks to advance our understanding of how interpretivism and empiricism can collaborate. References -Dryzek, J.S. 1990. Discursive Democracy: Politics, Policy and Political Science. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press -Durnová, A.P., Weible, C.M. 2020. “Tempest in a teapot? Toward new collaborations between mainstream policy process studies and interpretive policy studies”. Policy Sciences, 53: 571-588 -Fischer F. and J. Forester (eds). 1993. The Argumentative Turn in Policy Analysis and Planning, Durham, NC: Duke University Press -Hajer, M. Wagenaar, H. (eds). 2003. Deliberative Policy Analysis: Understanding Governance in the Network Society. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press -Johnson, G.F. 2005. “Taking Stock: The Normative Foundations of Positivist and Non-Positivist Policy Analysis and Ethical Implications of the Emergent Risk Society”. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice, 7(2): 137-153 -Torgerson, D. 2024. The Policy Sciences of Harold Lasswell: Contextual Orientation and the Critical Dimension. Edward Elgar Publishing -Weimer, D.L. 1998. “Policy Analysis and Evidence: A Craft Perspective”. PolicyStudies Journal, 26(1): 114-128

POLICY TOPICS
Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives Methods & Research Design General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P153. The Same Words, Different Policies: Contested Meanings in Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Bhatnagar
S. Ravindranath
A. V Kumar
ABSTRACT

Public policy frequently mobilises terms that attract broad agreement: inclusion, wellbeing, resilience, participation, equity and empowerment. Yet agreement on vocabulary can conceal substantial disagreement over policy purposes, responsibilities and instruments. Inclusion may entail expanding access to existing institutions or transforming the arrangements that produce exclusion. Resilience may justify strengthening collective provision or placing greater responsibility on individuals. Participation may involve consultation, shared decision-making or the legitimation of decisions already taken. These differences make the interpretation of shared language a consequential political process. This panel asks: How do actors use shared policy terms to advance competing agendas, and under what conditions do particular interpretations acquire authority and shape policy decisions? The panel brings interpretive policy analysis, discursive institutionalism, framing research and the study of policy narratives into conversation. These approaches illuminate how language constitutes public problems, establishes legitimate knowledge and organises political action. The panel focuses specifically on situations in which actors appear to agree because they use the same terms, while attaching different meanings, causal assumptions and expectations to them. Three connected research questions guide the discussion. First, how do actors construct and contest the meanings of widely endorsed policy concepts? Second, through what processes do interpretations become embedded in policy instruments, funding criteria, indicators and administrative routines? Third, when does ambiguity enable cooperation across different interests, and when does it obscure conflict, weaken accountability or marginalise alternative visions? The panel examines both strategic uses of language and differences arising from institutional position, professional practice, lived experience and cultural context. Actors may deliberately preserve ambiguity to sustain coalitions. They may also discover competing interpretations only when broad commitments are translated into operational decisions. Meaning is therefore negotiated throughout the policy process, including within frontline practice and encounters between public institutions and affected communities. Attention is given to power: who can define an authoritative interpretation, whose understanding becomes measurable and actionable, and whose meanings remain peripheral. The panel also considers how policy concepts travel across jurisdictions, languages and sectors, and how translation changes their political significance. The panel distinguishes agreement on terminology from agreement on problem definitions, policy goals, instruments and the distribution of responsibilities. It invites contributions that trace connections between discourse and concrete decisions without assuming that language alone determines outcomes. Its scientific contribution lies in explaining how apparent discursive consensus can coexist with divergent policy trajectories. By comparing concepts, sectors and institutional settings, the panel seeks to identify when shared language enables collective action, when it sustains symbolic agreement, and how struggles over meaning shape policy legitimacy, equity and accountability.

POLICY TOPICS
Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives
P176. Digital Technology and the Governance of the Social Order: Critical Policy Perspectives
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Mathur
N. Jadeja
ABSTRACT

Digital technologies have now come to occupy the dominant site where states define and locate policy problems, sort populations and produce order. Biometric identification, algorithmic eligibility systems, predictive analytics and platform-mediated service delivery are often presented as neutral instruments of efficiency and “evidence-based” policy. This panel proposes to explore the promise of platform-based governance beyond its instrumental premise: that it represents technologies of social ordering. Under this premise Digital Technology decides who is visible to the state, who counts as deserving, and which behaviours are normalised or treated as deviant. Critical policy analysis has long argued that policy is a value-laden political process of problem construction and not a technical response to given problems (Bacchi 2009; Fischer 2003; Yanow 2000; Schön and Rein 1994). Work on governmentality and datafication shows how quantification makes populations governable (Foucault 2007; Rose 1999; Desrosières 1998; Porter 1995; Scott 1998). Recent scholarship shows these logics intensified by digital infrastructure: system-level bureaucracy (Bovens and Zouridis 2002), automated welfare and policing (Eubanks 2018; Dencik et al. 2022), algorithmic discrimination (Noble 2018; Benjamin 2019), opacity (Pasquale 2015; Danaher 2016; Ananny and Crawford 2018) and data colonialism (Zuboff 2019; Couldry and Mejias 2019). Studies of India’s Aadhaar show how infrastructures of inclusion also produce exclusion (Khera 2019; Rao and Nair 2019; Singh 2019). Yet mainstream policy studies often treat digital governance as a question of implementation capacity, and reinforces the dominance of the datafication discourse. We develop the notion of social order through Fischer’s (1995) logic of policy deliberation. Fischer links four nested levels of policy deliberation: the technical verification of programme outcomes, the situational validation of the programme in its context, the societal vindication of the policy’s contribution to the wider social system, and social choice, where the fundamental values underpinning that system are examined. A defensible strategy at the level of social choice must be consistent with the social order the policy upholds. Digital governance isn’t just an artefact of the level of technical verification but seeks to reshape the social order within which it assumes centrality. The panel’s central question is: how do digital technologies of governance construct, stabilise and reshape the social order, and what happens to equality, legitimacy and democratic accountability? We invite contributions to explore three themes within these broad questions : Problematisation: Digital systems embed particular representations of social problems and target groups, narrowing the policy alternatives that can be imagined, yet appear as neutral data management projects.Differential visibility: Data infrastructures redistribute state recognition and create hard-to-contest exclusions that appear technical and diffuse.Foreclosing higher order policy deliberation and counter-politics: When values and political alternatives are reduced to digital singularity how does counter-politics to technological governance emerge and what forms do they take?

POLICY TOPICS
Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives State and Policy Capacity Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P195. Methodological dilemmas and the craft of interpretation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. van Bommel
M. van Hulst
ABSTRACT

Interpretive policy analysis is an established approach. Discourse analysis, policy ethnography, interviewing, narrative analysis and participatory action research are widely used to study how meanings shape policy. Interpretive methodologists have long argued that such research cannot be reduced to strict procedure. Yet research institutions often still expect a linear sequence of steps: methods sections, review criteria and funding templates leave little room for describing the judgements, iterations and bricolage the work involves, such as how to construct a case, when an interpretation is sufficiently grounded, how to handle one’s own position in the field, how to move from fieldwork to argument, how to read the literature, and how to defend these choices to reviewers, funders and ethics committees expecting positivist standards. Yanow and Schwartz-Shea have articulated the logic of interpretive research design and its own criteria of quality, such as reflexivity, transparency and trustworthiness. Others have shown that interpretive policy analysis is itself a practice of meaning-making (Wagenaar; Fischer), and that methodological judgement is a form of practical wisdom (phronesis) that cannot be reduced to rules (Flyvbjerg). Interpretive methodological knowledge is thus largely craft knowledge and its practice, developed through engagement with concrete cases, and this craft is constantly in motion. Three examples of internal debates, changing political and organisational environments and new technologies illustrate the renewing interpretive policy analysis (cf. van Bommel, 2025). First, poststructural approaches question the fieldwork site as a geographical location and treat interviews as sites where problematisations and subject positions are constituted, while multi-sited research follows people, objects and ideas as meanings travel and are translated. Second, alongside interviews and documents, the researcher’s body has become recognised as an instrument for grasping tacit understandings, increasingly mediated by video, digital and online methods. Third, the lone ‘I-witness’ fieldworker is giving way to more team-based and international collaboration in fieldwork, analysis and writing. Such developments make familiar challenges more complex: building rapport and trust across dispersed sites and within research teams, avoiding flattened representations of actors’ experiences, and deciding what counts as data and as a good interpretation, and who decides. This panel asks: how are interpretive methods enacted in practice, and what methodological and ethical questions does this raise? The panel builds on the interpretive policy analysis community’s methodology workshops, modelled on the master class in music, in which presenters discuss a concrete methodological question with experienced respondents. Comparable formats, include the Methods Café created by Yanow and Schwartz-Shea, which has been a regular part of the American Political Science Association’s main programme since 2006 (Funk 2019) and has also featured at International Studies Association and other conferences and at the ECPR and Methods.Net Methods Schools. Each session brings together three or four papers, each presenting methodological questions raised in interpretive research. Two discussants respond and draw out connections across cases, followed by discussion with all attendees. Sessions deliberately combine scholars at different career stages, because methodological dilemmas recur throughout a research career. The panel thus aims to make the evolving judgements of interpretive research explicit, comparable and open to collective scrutiny.

POLICY TOPICS
Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives Methods & Research Design Other General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P197. Researching the politically sensitive: interpretive research on contested policy issues
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. van Bommel
T. Metze
ABSTRACT

Policy research increasingly takes place on politically sensitive terrain. Climate and agricultural transitions, migration, gender, public health and land use are not only contested policy domains; they are also fields in which researchers face polarisation, institutional pressure, online hostility and, in some contexts, democratic backsliding. For interpretive and action researchers these pressures are particularly acute. Their methodologies depend on proximity such as gaining access to policy actors and communities, building trust, co-producing knowledge with participants and making visible the meanings at stake in policy conflicts. The same proximity that makes interpretive research valuable also exposes researchers, participants and partners to political risk. Many of the hardest decisions are taken in the field, often in the moment. We need to decide whether to continue an interview when a participant becomes exposed, how to respond when gatekeepers try to steer the research, what to do when witnessing conflict or intimidation, and when to withdraw because one’s own safety is at stake. The literature offers important starting points. Work on sensitive research (Sieber and Stanley; Lee and Renzetti) has long shown that sensitivity lies in the potential consequences of research for those involved rather than in the topic as such. Interpretive methodologists have emphasised reflexivity, positionality and the co-constitution of knowledge (Yanow and Schwartz-Shea), and scholars of action research in policy analysis have shown how researchers become participants in the processes they study (Bartels and Wittmayer). Work on “ethics in practice” highlights the gap between procedural ethics approval and the ethically important moments researchers encounter in the field (Guillemin and Gillam). Yet these strands rarely meet, and we know surprisingly little about how policy researchers actually navigate political sensitivity from research design through fieldwork to publication, and with what consequences for the knowledge produced. This panel asks: how do interpretive researchers in public policy deal with political sensitivity, and how does the way they deal with it shape what their research performs? We explore three issues. First, political sensitivity is not an inherent property of topics but is relational and performed. It emerges in interactions between researchers, participants, institutions and wider political contexts, and shifts over the course of a project. Second, institutional ethics regimes manage sensitivity largely procedurally. This can protect participants, but it can also displace situated ethical judgement, discourage research on contested issues and silence particular voices. Third, the strategies researchers adopt, such as negotiating access, anonymising, reframing findings for different audiences, or keeping distance from or aligning with particular actors, are not merely technical choices but political interventions that shape what knowledge becomes possible and sayable. By bringing together reflexive, empirically grounded accounts from different policy fields and political contexts, the panel aims to develop a shared methodological vocabulary for politically sensitive policy research. Each session combines paper presentations with an extended response from experienced interpretive and action researchers, so that individual cases become the basis for collective methodological learning.

POLICY TOPICS
Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives Other General Public Policy (no specific sector) Other
P237. From Imaginaries to Policies: How Illiberal Imaginaries Shape the Policy Process
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Hejzlarová
K. Cada
ABSTRACT

The central question of this panel is whether and how the rise of illiberal actors is reshaping established policy-making processes and institutions, and whether the conceptual tools developed within mainstream policy process research remain adequate for explaining policy-making under these new political conditions (Kingdon 1995; Sabatier & Jenkins-Smith 1999; Baumgartner & Jones 1993). Building on recent scholarship on illiberalism and democratic backsliding, the panel seeks to bring the study of illiberal political projects into closer dialogue with public policy research by examining how illiberal ideas, actors, and governing practices affect the formulation, adoption, and implementation of public policies (Laruelle 2022; Varga & Buzogány 2021). Since illiberal voices have recently risen to power across many democratic countries, it is crucial to understand their impact on policy processes and public policies. Among the range of analytical perspectives that can be used to study this phenomenon, we focus on social imaginaries. Social imaginaries (Castoriadis 1997, Laclau 1990, 2005, Taylor 2004, Beckert & Bronk 2018, Císař & Kolmaš 2026) are ways people imagine their social existence, the expectations they normally hold of one another, and the deeper normative notions and images that underlie those expectations. In the panel, we focus on illiberal imaginaries. Drawing on Laruelle's (2022) conceptualization, we view illiberalism as a reaction against contemporary liberalism across multiple domains. Such dynamics entail the reinterpretation of key liberal concepts, including freedom, democracy, and rights, which become invested with new and often profoundly illiberal meanings (Krzyżanowski & Krzyżanowska, 2024). However, we are not interested in illiberal imaginaries per se, but in their policy consequences and in bringing the study of illiberalism closer to public policy scholarship. We examine the impact of these imaginaries at three main levels: (1) at the level of the formulation of political problems and solutions – what these imaginaries perceive as a problem, and what solutions they propose; (2) at the level of public administration – what institutional policies, the structure of administrative processes, and the politicisation and depoliticisation of public policy-making entail; and, last but not least, (3) at the level of the imagination of the political system and the nature of sound policy-making. The panel has a cross-cutting nature and aims to bring together what we know about the effects of illiberal governments on policies, specifically on the individual stages of the policy process. Our aim here is neither description nor normativity, but rather to advance our understanding of how illiberalism is relevant to policy-making and to the scholarship. Although developments such as the weakening of institutional checks and balances or the increasing use of coercive policy instruments raise important normative concerns from a liberal democratic perspective (Schneider & Ingram 1997), our primary interest is analytical rather than evaluative. We ask what public policy scholars can learn from examining how policies are formulated and implemented in illiberal contexts.

POLICY TOPICS
Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives Policy Process Theories Other
P241. Narratives and temporalities in energy policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Bruncrona
D. Gritsenko
ABSTRACT

References to time are abundant in energy policy debates (Fouquet & Pearson, 2012; Marquardt & Delina, 2021). Yet research on temporality in energy policy seem to remain fragmented across distinct lines of study. Scholars exploring temporality in policy narratives (McGovern et al., 2026), alternative memories (Feldberg, 2023), imagined futures (Christley & Ullström, 2025), and the like, speak to one another only indirectly, despite all being concerned with how pasts, presents, and futures are socially constructed in energy politics. This panel seeks to bring these conversations together and examine temporality as a central element of energy policy narratives. Rather than treating different temporal dimensions in isolation, this panel aims to explore what patterns emerge when they are analysed together. The core question is: What does temporality actually do in energy policy narratives? Of particular interest is whether different temporalities do different kinds of political work. References to the past may serve to establish caution (Boscarino, 2019), narratives of the present may construct urgency (Delina & Sovacool, 2018), while imagined futures may generate support for not-yet-feasible energy solutions (Lefstad et al., 2024). In this respect, we ask: (1) Is temporality a single narrative resource, or do references to pasts, presents, and futures perform distinct functions? and (2) Under what conditions do policy actors rely on memories, urgencies, or imagined futures to mobilise support of various stakeholders, resist change, or shape public perceptions of energy transitions? References Boscarino, J. E. (2019). From Three Mile Island to Fukushima: The impact of analogy on attitudes toward nuclear power. Policy Sciences, 52(1), 21–42. Christley, E., & Ullström, S. (2025). Desired or contested futures? Competing discourse-coalitions for sustainable aviation in Sweden. Critical Policy Studies, 19(3), 414–435. Delina, L. L., & Sovacool, B. K. (2018). Of temporality and plurality: An epistemic and governance agenda for accelerating just transitions for energy access and sustainable development. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, Sustainability Science, 34, 1–6. Feldberg, O. (2023). From dinosaurs to nuclear fallout: Multiple temporalities of scale in memory studies. Memory Studies, 16(6). Lefstad, L., Allesson, J., Busch, H., & Carton, W. (2024). Burying problems? Imaginaries of carbon capture and storage in Scandinavia. Energy Research & Social Science, 113, 103564. Marquardt, J., & Delina, L. L. (2021). Making time, making politics: Problematizing temporality in energy and climate studies. Energy Research & Social Science, 76, 102073. McGovern, R., Soderman, C., Osei-Kojo, A., Jones, M. D., & Olofsson, K. L. (2026). Time’s Sentimental Tale: Operationalizing Plot Within the Narrative Policy Framework. Policy Studies Journal, 54(3), e70152.

POLICY TOPICS
Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives Crises, Risks and Wicked Problems Energy Policy
P271. Power systems: the energy transition as an interpretive struggle
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Dodge
T. Metze
ABSTRACT

In current geopolitical constellations, energy transitions towards decarbonization and electrification of energy production and consumption are politically deprioritized, despite urgent drivers of change including climate change, energy autonomy, resilience and adaptivity. Energy transitions are widely acknowledged as requiring changes in the socio-technical system encompassed in the configuration and interplay of technology, policy, markets, user practices, and infrastructure that fulfills societal functions (e.g., energy, mobility) (Kanger, 2021). Furthermore, transitions are often governed from a rational-technocratic perspective focusing on the techno-economic system at different ‘sites’: (inter)organizational, projects and programs, and at local, regional, national, global scales. Increasingly, academic literature calls for more radical thinking about the changes needed to escape ‘captured futures’ (Hajer and Oomens, 2025), thus shifting from “transition” to “transformation” of energy systems. A transformation involves third order learning aimed not at optimizing existing practices, but exploring unknown futures (Termeer and Metze, 2019) and adaptive changes. Transformation also involves multiple shifts, including “…shifts in perception and meaning, changes in underlying norms and values, reconfiguration of social network and patterns of interaction, changes in power structures, and the introduction of new institutional arrangement and regulatory frameworks” (O’Brien et al., 2012, 436). Such transformational change foregrounds emergent policy conflicts and their relational, material, cultural/meaning, and emotional aspects (Verhoeven and Metze, 2022; Berglund et al. 2022;), while foregrounding power dynamics in transformational change. In other words, transformations are deeply culture, meaning-oriented, relational, and material, including the interactions of these elements. Following this line of inquiry, this panel focuses on the ways sustainability transformations evolve relationally, materially, culturally and emotionally. Our interpretive approach foregrounds power dynamics – in their discursive and material dimensions – in the interplay between these elements as they cut across ‘sites’, including offline engagement. Discursive power foregrounds shifting interpretations of meaning, changing systems of knowledge and practices that support authority, and new materialities, all of which may open or close future possibilities toward transformation.

POLICY TOPICS
Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives Crises, Risks and Wicked Problems Energy Policy Environment and Climate Policy
P32. Knowledge under Pressure: Epistemic Accessibility and Crisis Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Bandelow
S. Saurugger
ABSTRACT

Governments confronted with crises must make consequential decisions under conditions of uncertainty, time pressure and incomplete information. Research on crisis governance has therefore paid increasing attention to expertise, policy advice, policy entrepreneurship and the institutional organization of knowledge. Work on policy advisory systems has shown that governments draw on increasingly plural and differentiated constellations of civil servants, scientific experts, advisory bodies, consultants and other knowledge providers. At the same time, research on crisis governance demonstrates that crises can alter advisory structures, centralize decision-making, politicize expertise and create strong temporal pressures.Yet we still know comparatively little about a prior condition of evidence use and policy learning: who produces the knowledge available, whether relevant knowledge is actually accessible to the actors who need it, when they need it, and whether it remains accessible over time. These questions matter not only for immediate crisis response, but also for prevention and preparedness, for the resilience of governance arrangements under stress, and for learning, adaptation and institutional change after a crisis has receded.This panel uses epistemic accessibility as an umbrella concept for examining these conditions. It asks how policy-relevant knowledge is generated, selected, transmitted, interpreted, stored and retrieved across organizational, sectoral and territorial boundaries, especially before, during and after crises. The concept directs attention not only to scientific evidence but also to administrative experience, implementation knowledge, institutional memory, evaluations, anticipatory knowledge and other forms of expertise. It also raises questions about who is recognized as a legitimate knowledge provider, which types of knowledge enter advisory processes, and which remain excluded or difficult to access.The central research question is: How do institutions and actor constellations shape the accessibility of policy-relevant knowledge before, during and after crises, and with what consequences for preparedness, crisis response, resilience and longer-term policy development?The panel invites work on several related mechanisms. First, crisis-driven centralization may accelerate the transmission of selected knowledge while narrowing the range of accessible perspectives. Second, reliance on person-bound expertise may improve rapid access in the short term but weaken institutional memory and longer-term accessibility. Third, formalized advisory structures, documentation practices, repositories and cross-organizational routines may increase the reach and durability of knowledge, but do not necessarily ensure its political uptake. Fourth, politicization and conflict may affect not only whether advice is followed, but which actors and knowledge claims become accessible and authoritative in the first place. Fifth, the capacity to preserve, recombine, update and reactivate knowledge across crises may be an important component of institutional resilience, while crises themselves can leave durable effects on advisory structures and knowledge infrastructures.By bringing together research on policy advice, crisis governance, policy learning, policy capacity, expertise and knowledge management, the panel seeks to develop a more systematic account of the institutional conditions linking knowledge production to actual policy use across prevention, immediate response, recovery and longer-term adaptation.

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Crises, Risks and Wicked Problems
P73. Vicious and Virtuous Circles of Policy Advice: Power, Institutional Dynamics & Expert Quality
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Bakir
M. Howlett
ABSTRACT

General Objectives This panel examines why vicious and virtuous circles emerge, coexist and change in policy advisory systems (PASs). It seeks to explain how relations between experts and political leaders shape policy advice, policy outcomes and institutional dynamics across different political regimes. Building on third-generation PAS research on the management and quality of advice (Howlett et al., 2025), the panel brings together behavioural and institutional perspectives. Migone and Howlett's (2025) Hirschman 2.0 model helps identify advisory behaviours and their implications for quality. The structure–institution–agency (SIA) framework (Bakir, 2022a, 2022b) directs attention to the causal conditions under which these behaviours emerge, persist or change. The broader objective is to understand why some advisory practices become self-reinforcing while others remain fragile or give way to different practices. Research Questions The panel addresses four interrelated questions: Under what conditions do vicious and virtuous circles emerge, coexist and compete across political regimes and policy domains?How do structural and institutional complementarities, together with enabling conditions, motivate and empower actors to engage in particular advisory practices?What explains transitions between vicious and virtuous circles? Why do some advisory practices become institutionalised while others remain vulnerable to change?How do policy outcomes and political legitimacy feed back into expert–ruler relations, reinforcing or disrupting existing advisory practices?Scientific Relevance PAS research has increasingly examined advisory quality, management and expert behaviour. Yet much of this literature focuses on established democracies. Less is known about how advisory practices vary across political regimes, coexist within the same system and change over time. This panel contributes to addressing these gaps in three ways. First, it extends PAS research to include illiberal and authoritarian settings. Second, it treats vicious and virtuous circles as dynamic and potentially competing processes rather than fixed characteristics of advisory systems. Third, it moves beyond identifying advisory behaviours to explaining the causal conditions under which these behaviours shape policy and institutional outcomes. An important issue is the asymmetry between the two circles. Vicious practices may become self-reinforcing through institutionalised repression, co-optation and expert compliance. Virtuous practices may depend more heavily on political support for credible advice. Moreover, effective policy advice does not necessarily imply democratic governance. The panel welcomes comparative and within-case studies using different theoretical and methodological approaches. It seeks to advance a context- and process-sensitive research agenda connecting comparative public policy, public administration and political economy. Its central concern is to explain when expertise informs political authority, when political authority distorts expertise, and why these relationships change over time. Proposal Why do political leaders seek expert advice in some policy areas but marginalise it in others? Why does expertise sometimes improve policy performance while, at other times, it serves to legitimise decisions already taken? Under what conditions do these practices persist or change? This panel invites contributions examining the vicious and virtuous circles of policy advice across different political regimes and policy domains. It focuses on how relations between political authority and expertise shape the production, use and influence of policy advice. Particular attention is paid to the conditions under which advisory practices emerge, coexist, become institutionalised or change over time. Recent research on policy advisory systems (PASs) has shifted attention towards the management and quality of policy advice (Howlett et al., 2025). Migone and Howlett's (2025) Hirschman 2.0 model offers insights into how advisory behaviours influence quality. Building on this research, the panel seeks to explain why different advisory practices arise and how they affect policy and institutional outcomes. Vicious circles may emerge when political leaders control expertise through repression, co-optation and selective rewards. Advisers may respond by withholding inconvenient evidence or adapting their recommendations to political preferences. Such practices can legitimise political authority in the short term while contributing to policy failures over time. Virtuous circles may emerge when political leaders support credible advice and its effective implementation. Yet these circles are neither mutually exclusive nor necessarily permanent. Even authoritarian regimes may display virtuous advisory practices in particular policy fields or periods (Bakir, 2023). The structure–institution–agency (SIA) framework (Bakir, 2022a, 2022b) offers one approach to explaining these dynamics. It directs attention to how structural and institutional complementarities motivate actors, and how enabling conditions empower them to act. The panel also welcomes alternative theoretical perspectives. We particularly encourage papers addressing the following questions: Why do vicious and virtuous advisory circles emerge, coexist or compete within and across political regimes?How do political authority, institutional arrangements and advisory behaviours shape the quality and influence of expertise?Under what conditions do advisory practices become self-reinforcing, and what explains transitions between vicious and virtuous circles?How do crises, political leadership, policy entrepreneurs and transnational advisory networks influence these dynamics?How do policy successes and failures feed back into expert–ruler relations, policy learning and political legitimacy?We welcome theoretical and empirical contributions from comparative public policy, public administration, comparative politics and political economy. Papers may examine democratic, illiberal or authoritarian settings and different policy sectors, including economic policy, social protection, public health, climate change and national security. Comparative studies, within-case analyses, process tracing and longitudinal research are particularly encouraged. The panel aims to advance a comparative, context- and process-sensitive understanding of policy advice. Its central concern is not simply whether advice is good or bad, but why particular advisory practices emerge, how they shape policy outcomes, and when they reinforce or challenge existing relations between expertise and political power.

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Other
P97. The Everyday Politics of Policy Knowledge: Critical and Interpretive Inquiries into the Micro-Dynamics of Policy Practice
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Sacramento
N. Turnbull
ABSTRACT

Policy studies has in recent years renewed its attention to policy knowledge: what counts as knowledge for policy, how it is produced, and how it comes to bear on decisions. This attention unfolds under conditions that unsettle the authority of knowledge itself. Post-truth politics contests the standing of expertise, overlapping crises outpace the capacity of established knowledge systems to frame problems, and the rise of populism, authoritarian rule, and illiberal democracy reconfigures who may speak for the public and on what grounds. These pressures are usually examined at the level of institutions, regimes, and the science-policy interface. Yet policy knowledge is made, contested, and unmade in the micro-dynamics of everyday policy work: in meetings and briefings, consultations and negotiations, field encounters and informal exchanges. It is in these settings that macro-level pressures become lived practice, and where the politics of policy knowledge is most visible. The founding debates on knowledge and policy offer a productive point of departure for this inquiry. Lasswell (1970) distinguished knowledge of the policy process from knowledge in the policy process. Lindblom and Cohen (1979) contrasted professional social inquiry with the ordinary knowledge on which much social problem solving relies, cautioning against overestimating the decisiveness of the former. Radaelli (1995) reframed the role of knowledge in the policy process, moving beyond linear models of utilization. The argumentative, interpretive, and practice turns deepened these insights. Majone (1989) showed that the knowledge claims of policy analysis are argumentative, not demonstrative. Fischer (1990, 2000) exposed the politics of expertise within technocracy and defended the epistemic standing of local and citizen knowledge. Yanow (2000) placed local knowledge at the center of interpretive policy analysis. Tenbensel (2006) further pluralized the concept, treating policy knowledge as a mix of scientific, practical, and political knowledge drawn upon in policy work. However, even where this scholarship has turned to practice and policy work, it has tended to examine knowledge at the level of the policy process, its institutions, and its arguments. The finer moments in which knowledge gains or loses authority within policy work have received less sustained attention: who speaks and who is spoken for in a meeting, whose data enters a briefing and whose experience is set aside as anecdote, and how silence, deference, and tact shape what can be said and known. Extending this tradition toward the micro-dynamics of policy work opens a complementary line of inquiry that treats these everyday encounters as sites where the politics of policy knowledge is negotiated, performed, and made consequential. Attending to these micro-dynamics also unsettles a premise that runs through much of the field. Influential accounts of problem structuring and policy deliberation tend to imagine the encounter between knowledges as an exchange among participants who can openly contest problems and weigh plural claims. Yet everyday policy work in many settings unfolds through relations of hierarchy, deference, patronage, informality, and translation across languages and knowledge systems, often within developmental, hybrid, or authoritarian states. What becomes of policy knowledge when the conditions for open contestation cannot be assumed? How are knowledge claims performed, authorized, and silenced in everyday interactions, and whose knowledges count in the process? How do practitioners translate between expert, bureaucratic, and local knowledges, and what is gained or lost in that translation? And how do these micro-practices reproduce, accommodate, or resist the broader pressures of post-truth politics, compounding crises, and democratic decline? This panel seeks to answer these questions by bringing together critical and interpretive inquiries into the politics of policy knowledge as it is practiced in diverse political settings. In doing so, it aims to theorize policy knowledge from the ground up, to test the deliberative assumptions that underpin much of the field, and to contribute to a more situated and epistemically just understanding of public policy. Call for Paper: This panel invites papers that examine the politics of policy knowledge as it unfolds in the micro-dynamics of everyday policy work. We welcome contributions that attend closely to the encounters, practices, and relations through which knowledge is produced, claimed, contested, and made authoritative in policy settings, and that connect these micro-level dynamics to broader political conditions. We are particularly interested in papers that engage policy work in settings where the conditions for open contestation cannot be taken for granted, including developmental, hybrid, and authoritarian contexts, as well as in democracies under strain. We are also interested in how scientific knowledge and its use in policy become sidelined by political factors, including transactional exchanges, institutional weakness, research contracted out to the private sector, and political rhetoric. Contributions from Asia and the Global South are especially encouraged, alongside work from other regions that reflects critically on the situated character of policy knowledge. Potential topics include, but are not limited to: - Everyday interactions in policy work (meetings, briefings, consultations, negotiations, and informal exchanges) as sites where knowledge gains or loses authority - Hierarchy, deference, patronage, and silence in shaping what can be said and known in policy settings - Translation and brokerage between expert, bureaucratic, local, and indigenous knowledges, and what is gained or lost in the process - Language, multilingualism, and the politics of knowledge in policy encounters - Front-line and street-level knowledge practices and their relation to policy decisions - The performance and staging of expertise, evidence, and credibility in policy work - Citizen, community, and experiential knowledge in participatory and co-productive policy processes, including their limits - Micro-practices of policy knowledge under post-truth politics, populism, authoritarian rule, and democratic backsliding - Knowledge work in the face of compounding crises, uncertainty, and urgency - Epistemic injustice, exclusion, and recognition in the everyday production of policy knowledge - The applicability and limits of deliberative, argumentative, and problem-structuring frameworks in non-ideal political settings - Reflexivity and positionality of researchers and practitioners in the study and practice of policy knowledge We welcome theoretically informed empirical studies as well as conceptual and methodological contributions. Papers may draw on policy ethnography, interpretive and narrative analysis, discourse analysis, rhetoric, practice-based and action research approaches, or other critical and interpretive methods. Comparative and cross-regional papers that bring diverse settings into conversation are particularly welcome.

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P46. Knowledge in (Public) Organizations: Evidence, Expertise, and the Changing Politics of Policy Advice
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Rahm
T. Bodenstein
ABSTRACT

Public policy research has long examined the influence of knowledge in policymaking (Boaz et al. 2009), but often through separate literatures. Research on evidence-based policymaking has explored how research and other forms of evidence enter policy processes (Stoker & Evans 2016); scholarship on policy advisory systems has examined the organization of expertise and advice (Howlett & Mukherjee 2025); work on policy evaluation has focused on the production and use of evaluations (Contandriopoulos & Brousselle 2012); and research on policy learning, transfer, and policy diffusion has investigated how policymakers draw lessons from abroad (Porto de Oliveira, 2021). Despite their shared concern with how knowledge matters for policy, these literatures have only rarely been brought together. This panel starts from the premise that an important research frontier lies at this intersection. Rather than asking whether policymakers use evidence, we ask how (public) organizations produce, select, evaluate, authorize, and use different forms of knowledge in policy processes. Recent scholarship stresses that knowledge does not enter policymaking through a one-way evidence-to-policy pipeline (Cairney et al. 2026). Evidence use is often indirect and relational, shaped by political values, professional expertise, organizational capacities, and context. Evaluation and policy learning research further shows that the relationship between producing knowledge and learning from it is contingent, non-linear, and embedded in wider political processes (Dunlop & Radaelli 2023). The panel therefore focuses on the organizational and institutional processes through which some knowledge becomes relevant to policy design while other knowledge is ignored, displaced, forgotten, contested, or rendered unusable. This perspective also opens the analysis beyond knowledge. Recent work on ‘non-knowledge’ highlights how ignorance, amnesia, mis/ and disinformation can shape policy processes (Hannah et al. 2023), while emerging forms of knowledge production, including the growing use of AI in policy advisory (Koenig & Wurzelberger 2025), raise new questions about how evidence is generated, assessed, and authorized within (public) organizations. Bibliography: Boaz, A., et al. (2009). Assessing the impact of research on policy: A literature review. Science and Public Policy, 36(4), 255–270. Cairney, P., et al. (2026). Interviewing policymaker elites: Improving lessons for researchers at the evidence-policy interface. Policy Design and Practice, 9(3), 376–385. Contandriopoulos, D., & Brousselle, A. (2012). Evaluation models and evaluation use. Evaluation, 18(1), 61–77. Dunlop, C. A., & Radaelli, C. M. (2023). Policy learning and policy evaluation. In F. Varone, S. Jacob, & P. Bundi (Eds.), Handbook of Public Policy Evaluation (pp. 76–92). Edward Elgar. Hannah, A., et al. (2023). The role of ‘non-knowledge’ in crisis policymaking: A proposal and agenda for future research. Evidence & Policy, 19(1), 116–130. Howlett, M., & Mukherjee, I. (Eds.). (2025). Handbook of Policy Advice. Edward Elgar. Koenig, P. D., & Wenzelburger, G. (2025). The potentials and limitations of using artificial intelligence for policymaking. In M. Howlett & I. Mukherjee (Eds.), Handbook of Policy Advice (pp. 622–637). Edward Elgar. Porto De Oliveira, O. (Ed.). (2021). Handbook of Policy Transfer, Diffusion and Circulation. Edward Elgar. Stoker, G., & Evans, M. (2016). Evidence-based policy making and social science. In G. Stoker & M. Evans (Eds.), Evidence-Based Policy Making in the Social Sciences (pp. 15–28). Bristol University Press.

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments General Public Policy (no specific sector) Administration and Civil Service Policy
P164. Comparing Knowledge Governance: Policies, Politics, and Processes
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Jungblut
M. Chou
ABSTRACT

Knowledge, long identified as the foundation on which societies and economies flourish (Erkkilä et al. 2023), has now again been linked to global competition and even human extinction (Gates 2026). While previously a mainstay of science fiction, these two opposing paradigms of knowledge use—as a gift but also a threat—have been competing for governance attention and solutions recently. How knowledge is, and should be, governed is driving multiple change processes around the world at a transformative pace (Martini and Robertson 2026; Stranger et al. 2024). This is, for example, visible in how governments are now pursuing science diplomacy: Traditionally framed in cooperative terms, it has become an avenue for addressing competition and geopolitical conflicts (Huang and Meng 2026; Pinna 2025, 2026). Similarly, knowledge and research security have been transformed from technical policy concerns into central organising principles in research governance. We also observe a pivot in how governments are exploiting the migration-higher education policy nexus: Migration policies have been previously used to internationalise higher education; today, we see higher education practices contributing to migration control (Brunner 2025; Cerna and Chou 2023). Indeed, universities and faculty are currently employed as new security institutions and agents, poised at the forefront of detecting and preventing knowledge espionage. These developments can be observed globally, but regional responses differ (Christensen et al. 2014). In the US, the potential for power projection and economic gain inherent in the application of new knowledge is used to secure or expand a hegemonic position through attempted control and exclusivity in access. In Europe, the focus is on the one hand on cooperation among European countries and with interested parties, but also on norms and values such as academic freedom (Maassen et al. 2025); for example, visible in the “Choose Europe for Science” strategy of the European Union. In Asia, the picture is even more diverse. On the one hand, China acts as the main competitor to the US (Landwehr-Matlé et al. 2026) that employs different and, at a first glance, less coercive strategies in their knowledge policies, while on the other hand the countries in the region have to position themselves between the two competing powers, carefully choosing how and when to cooperate with both (Capano et al. 2025). This panel brings together scholars working on the politics and policies of knowledge around the world. Specifically, the contributions from this panel examine one or several of the following three overarching themes. First, the politics of knowledge governance focusses on how governments steer knowledge governance and the tools used to ensure that key sectors and institutions (e.g., universities) meet state and societal expectations. Second, the framing of knowledge governance over time explores how governments talk about knowledge use and the linkages they create between knowledge and other issue areas (e.g., economic growth, social mobility, national security). Third, the varieties of knowledge governance identify the forms and mechanisms driving scientific and scholarly collaboration. Together, the contributions explain how knowledge governance has evolved over time and under conditions of uncertainty, test the robustness of existing analytical frameworks and concepts of knowledge governance through comparative case studies, and identify knowledge governance specificities concerning the role(s) of key actors, discourses, and structures in policy processes.

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Other Research and Higher Education Policy
P294. Global Health Populism: Politics, Public Health, and the Politicization of Health
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Fox
ABSTRACT

This Panel aims to explore the growing trend of “health populism,” which has recently found expression in the global anti-Vax movement and in the Make America Health Again movement in the United States. Largely embraced by the populist radical right, but also sometimes finding expression on the left, health populism refers to political rhetoric that is designed to 1. Appeal to ‘the people,’ (as pitted against ‘the establishment’ or the dominant power structure); 2. Justify swift and decisive action in an emergency; 3. Simplify and dramatize discourse by exaggerating threats and offering of ‘common sense’ solutions to complex issues (Lasco & Curato, 2019). Concerningly, health populist discourse and coordinated disinformation campaigns around the globe are contributing to the politicization of our everyday health behaviors and have the potential to contribute to the adoption of policies that will lead to thousands of preventable deaths of thousands globally. Related concepts include, anti-science extremism (Hotez, 2023); anti-intellectualism (Motta, 2024), health polarization and the politicization of everyday health behaviors (Gadarian, Goodman & Pepinksy, 2022). This panel is interested in submissions that seek to: - Better theorize and define the concept of health populism and its relation to related concepts (e.g., anti-science, anti-intellectualism, right-wing populism; appeal to nature fallacy) - Explore the root causes of health populism, for instance, the extent to which grounded in the erosion of institutional trust versus more deliberate efforts by bad actors to seed mistrust - Document case studies from around the globe of health populist movements - Analyze the impacts of rising health populism on health policies and outcomes Populist approaches to health have become increasingly visible across diverse political and national contexts. From opposition to vaccination and other public health interventions to challenges to scientific and medical authority, political actors and social movements are increasingly framing health controversies as conflicts between “the people” and powerful or unaccountable elites. These dynamics have been particularly visible in the global anti-vaccination movement and in the recent Make America Healthy Again movement in the United States, but health populism is not confined to any single country, ideology, or political movement. In turn, the politicization of health can contribute the erosion of public health policies that protect population health and the adoption of policies harmful to health. Drawing on Lasco & Curato’s (2019) concept of ‘medical populism,’ we use the term health populism to describe political rhetoric and mobilization that (1) appeals to “the people” in opposition to an establishment, elite, or dominant power structure; (2) invokes the need for swift and decisive action, particularly in response to perceived emergencies or threats; and (3) simplifies and dramatizes complex health issues by emphasizing threats and offering ostensibly “common sense” solutions (Lasco & Curato, 2019). Health populism may draw on legitimate concerns about institutional failures, conflicts of interest, inequality, or the exercise of expert authority, while also contributing to distrust of scientific and public health institutions. The rise of health populism raises important questions about the relationship between political contestation and population health. Coordinated disinformation campaigns, anti-science movements, and increasingly polarized health debates can transform everyday health behaviors—including vaccination, masking, dietary practices, and the use of medicines—into markers of political and social identity. Such politicization may undermine collective responses to health threats and contribute to preventable morbidity and mortality. At the same time, health populism may emerge from genuine grievances concerning the distribution of health risks, unequal access to care, institutional failures, and perceived exclusions from health decision-making. This panel seeks to advance conceptual and empirical understanding of global health populism, including its origins, manifestations, consequences, and potential responses. We welcome scholarship examining health populism across political systems, geographic regions, and ideological traditions, as well as work examining its relationship to broader transformations in trust, expertise, science, and democratic governance. Central Questions We invite panel submissions addressing questions including: How should health populism be defined, conceptualized, and distinguished from related phenomena such as anti-science extremism, anti-intellectualism, conspiracy theories, health polarization, and right-wing populism? Under what political, social, economic, and institutional conditions does health populism emerge and gain political traction? To what extent does health populism reflect genuine erosion of trust in health institutions versus deliberate efforts by political actors, organizations, or other “bad actors” to produce or amplify mistrust? How do populist actors construct “the people,” “the establishment,” and threats to public health? How does health populism influence health policy, public health institutions, scientific authority, and health-related behaviors? What are the consequences of health populism for population health, health equity, and the capacity of governments and health systems to respond to collective health threats? Under what circumstances can health populist rhetoric produce constructive challenges to established health institutions, rather than undermine public health? How do health populist movements differ across countries, political systems, and ideological traditions? What policies are likely to be effective at combatting harmful forms of health populism and health disinformation? What strategies can public health institutions, policymakers, clinicians, scientists, and civil society employ to respond effectively to health populism without further intensifying polarization or undermining democratic debate? References Gadarian, S. K., Goodman, S. W., & Pepinsky, T. B. (2022). Pandemic politics: the deadly toll of partisanship in the age of COVID. Princeton University Press. Hotez, P. J. (2023). The deadly rise of anti-science: a scientist's warning. JHU Press. Lasco, G., & Curato, N. (2019). Medical populism. Social Science & Medicine, 221, 1-8. Motta, M. (2024). Anti-scientific Americans: The prevalence, origins, and political consequences of anti-intellectualism in the US. Oxford University Press.

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process
P82. 1. From Evidence to Rules: Contested Expertise and the Making of International Norms
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Salazar Urrutia
D. Demortain
L. Cornilleau
C. KERDUEL
C. Robert
ABSTRACT

International governance increasingly claims to rest on science. Climate targets are framed by IPCC assessments, food safety standards by Codex Alimentarius risk assessments, EU chemical and food regulation by expert agencies such as EFSA or ECHA, and environmental protocols in the Antarctic Treaty System by the advice of scientific committees. Yet the passage from scientific knowledge to international norms is neither linear nor automatic. Evidence is selected, translated, negotiated and stabilised by situated actors, through choices that are already political, before it becomes a guideline, a standard, a list or an obligation. Quantification and modelling instruments are central in this process: they can embed and lock in policy choices through “political calibration” (van Beek et al. 2022). This passage is increasingly contested. The crisis of environmental governance and the transgression of planetary boundaries (chemical pollution, biodiversity loss, freshwater and land-system change) put expertise under pressure. Expert communities and disciplines compete to define problems and solutions, for instance when economic expertise enters issues long dominated by climate, biophysical or ecological sciences. These “battles of expertise” are reinforced as states and non-state actors use science to defend their interests. Beyond the influence of diplomacies (De Pryck 2022), private actors – from consultancies to industry and philanthropic organisations – increasingly produce data and may seek to influence the translation of expertise into norms. Symmetrically, transnational civil society can back, and even produce, scientific claims, but it can also call for the creation of new expertise bodies (Cornilleau 2019), or push regimes to innovate (Salazar forthcoming). Work in international relations on epistemic communities (Haas 1992) stressed the role of expert networks in policy coordination, but its explanatory capacity has been questioned (Demortain 2017). Science and technology studies (STS) show how knowledge and political order are co-produced (Jasanoff 2004), how boundary organisations manage the line between science and politics (Guston 2001), and how modellers act as institutional entrepreneurs in global governance (Cornilleau 2019). Public policy research on standardisation and risk regulation reveals how technical instruments carry political choices (Demortain 2011; Lascoumes and Le Galès 2007). The growing dialogue between these strands has opened new questions on the politics of expertise (Littoz-Monnet 2017). Building on it, this panel asks: how, by whom and under which conditions is scientific knowledge transformed into international norms, and how do competition and contestation among forms of expertise shape this transformation? We explore three hypotheses. First, norm-making depends less on the volume of evidence than on intermediary arenas and instruments (scientific committees, secretariats, models, indicators) that translate knowledge into regulatory formats. Second, competition between expert communities, disciplines, and public and private producers of knowledge shapes which risks are recognised as policy problems and which instruments are adopted. Third, appeals to science both depoliticise and repoliticise international negotiations (Louis and Maertens 2021): they can legitimise consensus, but also fuel conflicts between states, experts and stakeholders, with uneven participation from the Global South. The panel welcomes comparative and single-case studies in global and regional settings, combining public policy analysis, international relations and STS.

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Global and Transnational Policies
P91. From Evidence to Policy? What Works to Keep Students in School and Learning in the Global South, and What Gets Adopted
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Garcia-Jaramillo
D. Maldonado
ABSTRACT

Education systems in the Global South have expanded access over the past three decades, yet three challenges persist. Many students, especially in secondary education, attend irregularly and leave school before graduating. Most critically, enrollment has not translated into learning: an estimated 70 percent of ten-year-olds in low- and middle-income countries cannot read and understand a simple text (World Bank et al., 2022), and these gaps accumulate in secondary school. These deficits concentrate among poor, rural and disadvantaged students, reproducing inequality across generations. Evidence on how to address these problems has grown rapidly. Hundreds of experimental and quasi-experimental evaluations have tested conditional cash transfers, structured pedagogy, teaching at the right level, tutoring, early warning systems, information on returns to schooling and school management reforms, and syntheses such as the “Smart Buys” (GEEAP, 2023) rank interventions by cost-effectiveness. Yet this literature centers on primary education; less is known about secondary education, where dropout and learning gaps converge. We know little about what happens after an evaluation is published. Knowledge use is rarely linear: evidence may be used instrumentally, conceptually or symbolically. Policymakers do update their beliefs in response to research (Hjort et al., 2021; Vivalt & Coville, 2023), but adoption depends on implementation capacity, political incentives and the intermediaries who translate findings (DellaVigna et al., 2024). Promising pilots often lose effectiveness at scale, and cost data are seldom reported in ways that inform budget decisions. This panel connects the “what works” literature in education with research on policy learning, transfer and diffusion. It asks three questions. (1) What works, and what does not, to improve attendance, graduation and core learning (literacy, numeracy and other key competencies) in K-12 education, particularly secondary education, in the Global South? (2) To what extent, through which channels and under what conditions has evaluation evidence been translated into policy design, reform, scale-up or termination? (3) What is known about the cost-effectiveness and scalability of effective interventions, and does this information reach decision-makers? The panel explores four hypotheses. First, evidence uptake depends less on the strength of the evidence than on whether evaluations are co-produced with, or embedded in, government. Second, interventions that fit existing delivery systems and teacher routines are more likely to scale while retaining their effects. Third, evidence is more often used to legitimize or adjust existing programs than to launch new ones or end ineffective ones. Fourth, the absence of credible cost and implementation data is a binding constraint on cross-jurisdictional learning. By bringing impact evaluation and policy process research together, the panel clarifies the potential and limits of evidence-informed education policy in the Global South. References DellaVigna, S., Kim, W., & Linos, E. (2024). Bottlenecks for evidence adoption. JPE, 132(8). Global Education Evidence Advisory Panel (GEEAP) (2023). Cost-effective approaches to improve global learning. World Bank et al. Hjort, J., et al. (2021). How research affects policy. AER, 111(5). Vivalt, E., & Coville, A. (2023). How do policymakers update their beliefs? JDE, 165. World Bank et al. (2022). The state of global learning poverty: 2022 update.

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Policy Transfer/Diffusion/Learning Education Policy Social Policy
P103. From Data to Decisions on Emerging Public Security Problems in the Global South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
O. Uwada
J. Becker
M. De Oliveira Pinto
ABSTRACT

Public security agencies increasingly face problems that evolve faster than the evidence available to address them. Digital fraud, violence against older persons, cybercrime, technology-facilitated gender-based violence, mobile phone theft and its illicit markets, money laundering and missing persons are emerging problems, with little accumulated evidence on what works. Many are wicked problems in Rittel and Webber’s (1973) sense, as they lack a definitive formulation, are symptoms of other problems and have no stopping rule (Head, 2022), while depending on data held by private actors such as banks and digital platforms. Violence against older persons is illustrative, as it is conceptually contested and heavily underreported (WHO, 2002; Goergen & Beaulieu, 2013; Anetzberger, 2023) and urgent as Latin America ages rapidly (IDB, 2022). Problem-oriented and evidence-based policing (Goldstein, 1979, 1990; Sherman, 1998), built largely on street crime in the Global North, offer limited guidance for such phenomena. Data analytics has expanded the toolkit of governments, which now includes geospatial and network analysis, machine learning, natural language processing of police reports and large language models. Yet most applications remain exploratory, few assess whether analytics changes decisions or outcomes, and even robust causal analyses of administrative data (Piquero & Sherman, 2025) come from high-income countries. The gap between research and practice persists (Goldstein, 2003; Nutley, Walter & Davies, 2007), amounting to a “dialogue of the deaf” between police and academia (Bradley & Nixon, 2009). Bridging it requires professionalising evidence use (Sherman & Murray, 2015), analytical capacity (Keay & Kirby, 2018), “pracademics” (Braga, 2016) and a shift from research on the police to research with the police (Goode & Lumsden, 2018). In the Global South, unequal state capacities compound these challenges (Eiró & Lotta, 2023), although embedded research units can mediate this relationship (Uwada, Becker & Alvarenga, 2026). This panel asks how data analytics can help public security agencies detect, understand and respond to emerging problems for which established evidence is still scarce. It examines analytics across diagnosis, decision-making and evaluation, and explores four hypotheses. H1. Analytics applied to administrative and unstructured data can reveal underreported and rapidly changing patterns earlier than traditional statistics, enabling informed action where experimental evidence is not yet available. H2. The contribution of analytics to decision-making depends more on institutional infrastructure, such as data integration, data sharing with private actors and internal analytical capacity, than on model sophistication. H3. Partnerships between researchers and practitioners and embedded analytical units increase the likelihood that analytical outputs are used in operational and policy decisions. H4. International evidence and practices can effectively inform Global South policies only when adapted to local institutional, legal and data conditions. Theoretically, the panel connects policy analytics and evidence-based policing with debates on wicked problems and research use. Empirically, it brings evidence from Global South agencies, still underrepresented. Normatively, it asks how analytics can be used accountably, without reproducing ageism and other biases embedded in data systems (WHO, 2021; Rosales, Svensson & Fernández-Ardèvol, 2023) or eroding fundamental rights.

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Crises, Risks and Wicked Problems Security, Defense and Risk Governance Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy
P128. What’s New in Evidence-Informed Policymaking? Rethinking Theories of Knowledge, Power and Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Bandola-Gill
B. Head
P. Cairney
J. Christensen
J. Parkhurst
ABSTRACT

Over recent decades, a range of institutional arrangements have developed to connect scientific evidence and expertise with policymaking. Yet the traditional assumptions underpinning this model are eroding. Among the challenges reshaping evidence-informed policymaking are the rise of populism, ‘post-truth’ politics and democratic backsliding, which unsettle assumptions about institutional stability and the political value of expertise (Craft, Head and Howlett 2024; Perl; Bauer et al. 2021), and rapid digitalisation and the emergence of generative AI, which are transforming how evidence is produced and who is recognised as an expert (Tyler et al. 2023; Messeri and Crockett 2024). This is a pivotal moment when the historically established and institutionally stabilised systems of evidence provision are becoming disrupted. This is not only an empirical and normative challenge but also a theoretical one, as existing theories and concepts may be insufficient to explain these ongoing transformations. Therefore, this panel’s key objective is to explore new theoretical approaches to capture this rapidly changing landscape of evidence-policy interactions. Several theoretical traditions have advanced our understanding of these relationships, yet their contributions have often developed in parallel rather than in dialogue with one another. Institutional approaches examine how advisory arrangements and governance structures shape evidence use and the conditions for its legitimate and effective mobilisation (Parkhurst 2017). Relational and constructivist perspectives foreground the practices through which knowledge is co-produced, translated and made actionable (Boswell and Smith 2017; Rhodes and Lancaster 2019; Bandola-Gill, Arthur and Leng 2023). Interpretive and narrative approaches show how stories, values and competing truth claims shape what counts as evidence and how it acquires political meaning (Crow and Jones 2018; Fischer 2021). Systems and complexity approaches, in turn, offer ways to examine interactions across actors, institutions and processes (Rutter et al. 2017; Haynes et al. 2020). Yet important questions remain about how these perspectives relate to one another, what each makes visible or obscures, and how they can account for contemporary political and technological change. This panel is concerned with both theoretical developments in the study of evidence use such as systems- and institutional perspectives as well as communicative and narrative approaches (questions 1-3) but also how the use of evidence in policymaking is changing in relation to contemporary shifts (questions 4-5) 1. Which new concepts and theories best capture contemporary evidence–policy relations? 2. What do systems-based and institutional approaches add to theories of evidence use?3. How can we theorise political communication, storytelling and narratives in the uptake of evidence by policymakers?4. What theoretical tools explain the changing role of evidence under populism and democratic change? 5. How does AI reconfigure evidence-based policymaking, and what does this demand of our theories? By consolidating an emerging theoretical agenda, the panel offers scholars a shared vocabulary for comparing cases across sectors and political systems, and gives practitioners a firmer conceptual basis for strengthening evidence institutions.

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P141. The Production and Use of Evidence in the Policy Process
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Hornung
J. Salazar
F. Sager
B. Stauffer
ABSTRACT

Research on the production and use of evidence in the policy process is thriving. The COVID-19 pandemic has put the influence of scientific policy advice on crisis responses center-stage (Hornung & Trein, 2025; Lemor & Montpetit, 2024; Schlaufer et al., 2025). Policy advisory system research is experiencing its third wave, reflecting not only on the location and dynamics of policy advice, but also on its quality (Migone & Howlett, 2025). The distinction between evidence and expertise (Hadorn et al., 2022) and the role of evaluation (Bundi & Pattyn, 2026) in the policy process refine what counts as substance of knowledge, while typologies of actors investigate its senders and receivers (Ingelbeen et al., 2026; Koiranen & Christensen, 2026; Migone et al., 2022; Valin & Huitema, 2023). However, studies are not always clear about the terminology of information, knowledge, expertise, and evidence and how it is produced and used in the policy process. The proposed panel aims to address this conceptual and intellectual lacuna and provides a platform for dialogue on how different forms of evidence and knowledge more generally are produced, under which conditions they are used, and by which actors. It therefore seeks to contribute to answering the following research questions: What counts as evidence in the policy process? Which different forms of knowledge are produced for and in the policy process? By which actors? Under which conditions and in what ways are different forms of knowledge produced and used in the policy process? By which actors? Bundi, P., & Pattyn, V. (2026). It Does Matter. A New Framework on the Influence of Policy Evaluation. Policy Studies Journal, 54(3), e70149. Hadorn, S., Sager, F., Mavrot, C., Malandrino, A., & Ege, J. (2022). Evidence-Based Policymaking in Times of Acute Crisis: Comparing the Use of Scientific Knowledge in Germany, Switzerland, and Italy. Politische Vierteljahresschrift, 63(2), 359–382. Hornung, J., & Trein, P. (2025). Policy advisory system quality under multilevel governance: the German COVID-19 experience. Policy and Society, puaf005. Ingelbeen, J., Haesevoets, T., & Wauters, B. (2026). Academic Experts in Policymaking: Divergent Patterns but Persistent Profiles Across Parliament, Government, and Media. Public Administration, n/a(n/a). Koiranen, I., & Christensen, H. S. (2026). Experts, Experts Everywhere! Survey Experimental Evidence on How Involving Expertise Affects Decision-Making Legitimacy. Political Studies, 00323217261450951. Lemor, A., & Montpetit, É. (2024). Exploring the role of uncertainty, emotions, and scientific discourse during the COVID-19 pandemic. Policy and Society, puae010. Migone, A., & Howlett, M. (2025). Kicked cans and poison pills: third generation policy advisory system studies and the management of quality political advice. Policy and Society, puaf002. Migone, A., McGregor, M. R., Brock, K., & Howlett, M. (2022). Super-users and hyper-experts in the provision of policy advice: Evidence from a survey of Canadian academics. European Policy Analysis, 8(4), 370–393. Schlaufer, C., Mavrot, C., Hornung, J., & Sager, F. (2025). Challenges to the Legitimacy of Scientific Policy Advice in Three Swiss Crises: Can Institutionalization Shield Against Politicization? Policy Studies Journal, n/a(n/a).Valin, N., & Huitema, D. (2023). Experts as policy entrepreneurs: How knowledge can lead to radical environmental change. Environmental Science & Policy, 142, 21–28.

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process
P157. Governing by Technique. Technocracy, Policy Instruments and Policymaking in Local Governments
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Lippi
T. Vitale
ABSTRACT

Context. Local governments now make policy through a dense layer of technical intermediaries: senior municipal and metropolitan officials, agencies and publicly owned companies, consultancies, data and modelling firms, evaluators, policy advisors, advocates, audit bodies, and the professional communities that design indicators, contracts and plans. National recovery plans, European funding conditionality, climate adaptation, digital platforms and, more recently, artificial intelligence have multiplied the instruments through which cities plan, allocate and evaluate. These instruments travel with the experts who know how to operate them. Technocracy has become an ordinary condition of local policymaking, rather than an exception reserved for crises or central executives. State of the art. Research on technocracy has mostly examined national executives, central banks, independent authorities and expert governments (Radaelli 1999; Esmark 2020; Bickerton and Invernizzi Accetti 2021), and has framed the question as a trade off between output legitimacy and democratic accountability. The sociology of policy instruments offers another entry point. Instruments are not neutral tools: each carries a theory of the problem, a representation of the target population and a distribution of power among actors (Lascoumes and Le Galès 2007). Technique and politics are produced together in the choice, design and use of instruments. These two literatures rarely meet at the local scale, where the boundaries between elected officials, administrators and external experts are thinner, more personal and less codified, and where technical choices bear directly on who gets housing, care, water or public space. Research question. The panel asks how technocrats (in a broad sense) and instruments shape local policymaking, and under which conditions they widen or narrow the space for democratic choice. We treat technocracy in the plural, as a configuration of actors, knowledge and instruments whose effects depend on the institutional field in which it is embedded. Hypotheses. We propose three working hypotheses. First, at the local level technocratic influence works less through formal delegation than through instrument design: indicators, eligibility rules, procurement criteria, algorithms and evaluation frameworks fix the terms of choice before elected bodies deliberate. Second, technocratisation can depoliticise distributive conflict by turning claims on resources into procedural questions of compliance, optimisation and performance; contested demands persist, redirected toward technical arenas where fewer actors can intervene. Third, the democratic effects of technocracy vary with the capacity of local administrations, the plurality of expertise mobilised, the reversibility of instruments and the presence of independent expertise held by unions, associations, residents and opposition parties. Under some configurations technical knowledge strengthens accountability and policy learning; under others it locks in choices and shields them from contestation. Bringing together policy science, political sociology, public administration and local government studies, the panel moves the debate on technocracy from the central to the local state, and from a normative opposition between experts and democracy to an empirical analysis of how technique and politics are assembled in public action.

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Multilevel Governance and Local Policy Urban Policy and Planning Social Policy
P165. Selling Reforms Across Borders: A Global Market for Policy Advice?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Visier
M. HAMM
ABSTRACT

European public policy and development aid are increasingly shaped by projectification: the spread of projects as a pervasive mode of organization, underpinned by a growing emphasis on evaluation, accountability, and performance.In development aid, this mode of governance has a long history. It grew out of concerns over financial control and a persistent distrust of recipient states, and has been reinforced by the “NGO-isation” of aid and the proliferation of intermediaries (Bierschenk, Chauveau and Olivier de Sardan, 2000; Mosse, 2005; Lewis and Mosse, 2006). The European Union can be understood as a form of ‘government at a distance’ that increasingly delegates the design and implementation of its policies to projects (Büttner and Leopold, 2016). is the EU is both a site where project-based practices are deployed and an actor that actively promotes their diffusion in its internal and external policies alike (Thyrard, Hamm and Lebrou, 2026). It is a major provider of development aid and technical assistance to third countries, both in the Global South and in its own neighbourhood (Visier and Dakowska, 2018). More recently, it has significantly extended this approach to its own member states through technical assistance for structural reforms (Hamm, 2025).Projectification thus constitutes a distinctive “social world” (Büttner and Leopold, 2016), marked by the growing involvement of consultancies and external experts. These actors provide flexibility, specialized methods, and expertise for time-limited assignments, ranging from programme design and funding to implementation (Béland and al., cited in Seabrooke and Sending, 2019).Recent studies have examined these actors and their roles in a range of settings:development and public policy in the Global South (Boughedada, 2023, 2026; Aguillon and Al Dabaghy, 2024; Aguillon, 2022; Bourblanc, 2021; Bredeloup, 2019); the functioningof EU institutions and policy processes (Thyrard, Hamm and Lebrou, 2025, 2026); or European interventions in neighbouring countries (Bonnard and Robert, 2020). These studies do resist reducing such a heterogeneous population to a single, a priori definition. Yet there is still little systematic, comparative research on the full range of actors involved in technical assistance and reform support. They work under different contractual arrangements, for different donors and across different regions.This panel sets out to map the contours of the transnational market for consultancy and other technical assistance in support of public sector reform. It brings together empirically grounded studies spanning different geographical contexts, policy sectors, and categories of consultants and experts. It also offers an opportunity to compare and discuss the conceptual frameworks through which projectification and consulting practices have been studied. These draw on several intellectual traditions: political science and the sociology of public policy, transnational governance and transnational circulation of policy ideas and model, political economy, development economics, and the socio-anthropology of development.

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process State and Policy Capacity
P218. Rethinking Power in Artificial Intelligence Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
I. Ulnicane
R. Radu
ABSTRACT

This panel aims to examine the role of power in Artificial Intelligence (AI) policy. One of the defining features of the field of AI is a high concentration of power in a small number of Big Tech companies from the United States (e.g., Google, Amazon, Microsoft) and China (e.g., Alibaba, Tencent, and Huawei). This high concentration of power has major economic, political and social implications, including influence on AI policy (Khanal et al 2025; Ulnicane 2027). As AI technologies are diffused across all sectors of society from public services and law enforcement to education and health, it is crucial that AI policy protects public interests, fundamental rights and freedoms of citizens. The high concentration of power in a small number of Big Tech companies, raises major questions of how well public policy represents public interest; what kind of influence Big Tech has on agenda setting, and whose interests dominate in AI policy-making? Research has demonstrated how Big Tech has exerted influence on AI governance and regulation directly through lobbying, regulatory capture and ethics washing as well as indirectly by funding research and civil society organizations (Bradford 2023; Gorwa et al 2024; Rikap and Lundvall 2021). At the same time, important questions can be asked about more subtle and less visible ways of how Big Tech attempts to influence public discourse by promoting ideas and discourses that fit their interests (Foucault 1980). Against this background, this panel invites to revisit and rethink the concepts of power and the relationship between power and public policy in the context of fast-developing AI policy. What dimensions of power, including direct decision-making, indirect agenda setting, and preference shaping are at play in AI policy (Lukes 2004)? What forms of power - structural, institutional and ideational - can be observed in AI governance and regulation and how do they interact (Béland 2010; Carstensen and Schmidt 2016)? Do we encounter cases of power-over, power-to and power-with in AI policy-making (Pansardi and Bindi 2021)? How well do existing concepts of power help to analyse AI policy? What kind of theoretical, conceptual and methodological advancements are needed? To advance our understanding of power in public policy, this panel examines the following questions about AI policy: - How does high concentration of structural, institutional and ideational power in a small number of Big Tech companies from the US and China shape agenda-setting, priorities and outcomes of AI policy nationally and globally?- What is the impact of the power of Big Tech in AI policy on global inequalities and the Global South? - What are opportunities for civil society organizations, affected communities and marginalized groups to resist and challenge the power of Big Tech in AI policy?- Are governments and public sector organizations reinforcing or reshaping power asymmetries in AI governance?- Is power in AI policy only constraining and coercive or can it also be enabling and emancipating?

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy
P261. Science–Policy Interfaces Under Pressure? Science Skepticism and the Future of Evidence-Informed Policymaking
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
U. Zeigermann
ABSTRACT

A fundamental assumption of modern democratic governance is that public policy should be informed by scientific knowledge and expertise to effectively address complex societal challenges. This applies across policy domains, including climate and environmental policy, public health, and transportation. Yet policymaking is never solely driven by scientific evidence. Political decisions are also shaped by values, competing interests, institutional constraints, limited resources, and incomplete information. Consequently, the relationship between scientific knowledge and political decision-making has always been complex and contested (Head, 2016). In recent years, however, science–policy relations have come under increasing pressure. Political actors who openly question the credibility, legitimacy, and relevance of scientific expertise have gained influence within parliaments, governments, and other political institutions. Particularly in the context of rising populism and political polarization, scientific knowledge is increasingly challenged, selectively appropriated, or publicly delegitimized. Recent scholarship on populism and science has highlighted the political dynamics underlying these developments and their implications for public trust in science (Eslen-Ziya & Giorgi, 2022; Zapp, 2022). These developments raise fundamental questions about the changing role of scientific expertise in policymaking and the conditions under which evidence-informed public policy remains possible. Science–policy interfaces (SPIs), understood as the institutional arrangements, practices, and interactions connecting scientific knowledge production with political decision-making, are particularly relevant in this context. The panel aims to explore how science–policy interfaces are being challenged, transformed, and potentially reconfigured in response to growing science skepticism, anti-science politics, and changing political environments. It seeks to advance theoretical and empirical understanding of the relationship between scientific knowledge, political authority, and evidence-informed policymaking across different policy sectors and levels of governance. The central research question is: How do growing science skepticism and changing political conditions affect the functioning, legitimacy, and effectiveness of science–policy interfaces? The panel invites contributions examining several potentially competing developments: whether political contestation weakens established science–policy interfaces; whether it encourages new forms of knowledge exchange, participation, and institutional adaptation; and whether the political use of scientific expertise differs between public discourse and less visible decision-making arenas. By bringing together comparative, theoretical, and empirical perspectives, the panel seeks to contribute to broader debates on knowledge utilization, science–policy relations, democratic governance, and the future of evidence-informed policymaking.

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Agenda-Setting/Problem Definition General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P264. Conceptual and methodological challenges in Policy Analysis
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
T. Metze
S. Hinrichs-Krapels
L. Scholten
ABSTRACT

In 1951 Laswells (1951) famously called for a problem-oriented policy sciences. After introducing systems’ analysis in the USA defense department in 1966; its application spread out to other USA departments (Fischer et al Handbook (2019). This analytical orientation was adapted by several consultancy groups. A-political or technocratic policy research over the years found a home in bureaucratic government organizations (see for example, Radin 2000 and Fischer et al 2007). From the 1980s onward, scholars began to question the assumption that policy decisions could be optimized solely through rational analysis. Wildawsky in Speaking Truth to Powers (1979) argues that policy analysis cannot be reduced to technical problem solving but must engage with political choices, competing values and social interactions. Alternative perspectives, also developed in systems thinking, emphasize the roles of political institutions, stakeholder interests, ideas, discourse, and bounded rationality in shaping policy outcomes. As a result, contemporary policy analysis combines quantitative and qualitative methods and recognizes that policymaking is both an analytical and a political process. Contemporary policy analysis can have at least three faces, as distinguished by Douglas Torgerson (1986): (1) Technical-Rational Face in which policy analysis is seen as a scientific, objective activity and experts use data, models, and evidence to identify the "best" solutions. Politics is treated as a problem that can be overcome through rational analysis. The key idea: Better knowledge leads to better decisions. (2) The Critical Face considers politics masquerades as knowledge and for that reasons, policy analysis is never neutral. Expert advice often reflects underlying political values, interests, and power relations. Claims of objectivity can hide ideological assumptions. (3) Post-Positivist (Interpretive) Face in which knowledge and politics are reconciled. Policy analysis should acknowledge both evidence and values. Analysts can be facilitators of dialogue rather than detached experts. Public deliberation, participation, and interpretation are central and different forms of knowledge are relevant. In this face, good policy emerges through informed democratic deliberation, not purely technical expertise. In this panel we set out to advance the field and explore if there is a fourth face of policy analysis taking shape. In current geopolitical times, the questions of dual use and politics of policy analysis (Cairney 2021) is ever more urgent. How can different strands in policy analysis combine efforts in contributing to positive (democratic and sustainable) societal transformations? Cairney, P. (2021). The politics of policy analysis. Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-66122-9 Fischer, F., Miller, G. J., & Sidney, M. S. (Eds.). (2007). Handbook of public policy analysis: Theory, politics, and methods. CRC/Taylor & Francis Lasswell, H. D. (1951). The policy orientation. In D. Lerner & H. D. Lasswell (Eds.), The policy sciences: Recent developments in scope and method (pp. 3–15). Stanford University Press. Mayer, I. S., van Daalen, C. E., & Bots, P. W. G. (2004). Perspectives on policy analyses: A framework for understanding and design. International Journal of Technology, Policy and Management, 4(2), 169–191. https://doi.org/10.1504/IJTPM.2004.004819 Radin, B. A. (2000). Beyond Machiavelli: Policy analysis comes of age. Georgetown University Press. Torgerson, D. (1986). Between knowledge and politics: Three faces of policy analysis. Policy Sciences, 19(1), 33–59. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02124483 Wildavsky, A. B. (1979). Speaking truth to power: The art and craft of policy analysis. Little, Brown

POLICY TOPICS
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Methods & Research Design Environment and Climate Policy Energy Policy
P17. Data Center Development: Actors, Ideas, and Institutions
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
K. Hartley
J. Fisk
S. Opp
ABSTRACT

The rapid expansion of hyperscale and AI-serving data centers is generating political and policy conflicts that raise questions about governance of emerging technologies. Inherent to this rapidly evolving policy issue are tensions and tradeoffs around the distribution of benefits and costs. On one hand, data centers consume vast amounts of energy, generate thermal and electronic waste, and may require extensive water use for cooling and electrical generation. They also pose infrastructure, environmental, and fiscal challenges for governments with limited administrative or technical capacity and for stakeholders including ratepayers, developers, and others impacted by sustainability concerns. On the other hand, data centers power AI and other digital technologies that can increase efficiencies and accelerate innovation related to energy and sustainability. They have also been promoted as catalysts for local economic development and global technological competitiveness. These tensions point to a broader public policy challenge: governments are being asked to govern rapidly scaling technological infrastructure through arrangements designed for very different or outdated forms of development. This creates an opportunity to examine how governments leverage institutions, capacities, and policy tools for technologies whose fiscal, environmental, and social consequences emerge faster than existing regulatory arrangements can adapt. This panel brings together scholars working across methodologies and topical domains to examine how current understandings of governance can explain emerging patterns of data center governance and identify where existing theories, concepts, and methods require further development. The intent is to chart a pathway for an emerging research subfield around the governance of physical infrastructures supporting AI. The panel approaches data center governance through three angles that each constitutes its own subpanel: actors, ideas, and institutions. Drawing on Hall and others (1997) and the ‘three institutionalisms,’ these perspectives direct attention to complementary dimensions of governance: how interested parties use resources and power; how problems, solutions, and forms of expertise acquire meaning and legitimacy; and how rules, authority structures, and institutional legacies constrain or enable action. The following questions guide each panel: 1. Actors panel a. Who is involved in decisions about data centers, and whose interests are represented or excluded? b. What are the power dynamics and imbalances among these actors? c. What are the prevailing interests and narratives in policy discourses? d. How do actors mobilize resources to influence policy decisions? 2. Ideas panel a. How are data centers framed as policy problems or economic opportunities? b. What ideas, narratives, and assumptions shape how policymakers understand costs and benefits? c. How does the rise of AI data centers alter existing policy paradigms around technology? d. What forms of knowledge and expertise are privileged, and how do various forms of knowledge interact or conflict? 3. Institutions panel a. How do existing institutional arrangements shape regulatory decisions about data centers? b. How are responsibilities for data center governance distributed across jurisdictions and levels of government? c. How do institutions mediate conflicts among concurrent objectives like economic development, energy reliability, and community interests? d. How do institutional legacies and entrenched policymaking structures shape capacity to manage AI infrastructures?

POLICY TOPICS
Politics, Institutions and Political Regimes Citizens, Participation and Social Movements Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy Urban Policy and Planning
P20. Public Policy and Democratic Backsliding
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Morais de Sa e Silva
M. Fernandez
ABSTRACT

This panel is anchored in a central question: how do autocratic governments reshape public policy processes, and what does this reveal about the dynamics of contemporary democratic backsliding? While democratic erosion has received growing scholarly attention, the panel advances the debate by placing public policy, rather than political institutions alone, at the center of the analysis. Democratic backsliding is understood not only as a political or constitutional process but also as a policy-driven phenomenon, unfolding through the reconfiguration, weakening, or elimination of policy arrangements and the institutions that sustain them (Peters & Pierre, 2019; Bauer et al., 2021; Oliveira & Fernandez, 2021; Morais & Gomide, 2024). The panel examines how policymaking changes under autocratic and illiberal governments, where political survival may take precedence over institutional continuity and problem-solving. Policies can be strategically dismantled through material retrenchment, including budget cuts and institutional restructuring, as well as discursive strategies that delegitimize expertise, science, and minority rights. These processes can also erode policy capacities by weakening bureaucratic autonomy, politicizing administrative structures, and undermining accountability mechanisms. Importantly, such transformations often occur incrementally, preserving the formal appearance of democratic institutions while hollowing out their substantive functioning. This panel also extends policy dismantling approaches (Bauer & Knill, 2014) by examining strategies such as non-decision, symbolic action, active dismantling, and institutional hardball (Morais & Gomide, 2024), as well as other practices that undermine the pluralist foundations of policymaking. By bringing together research across countries and policy subsystems, the panel seeks to identify both common mechanisms and context-specific variations in how democratic backsliding reshapes policymaking. Ultimately, the panel shifts attention from whether democratic backsliding occurs to how it is operationalized through the state, its institutions, and policy processes. It conceptualizes policies as both targets and instruments of political transformation and examines how governance arrangements, administrative routines, state capacities, decision-making, and implementation are reconfigured under autocratic and illiberal governments. By combining theoretical, comparative, and empirical perspectives, the panel seeks to advance the study of the intersection between politics and public policy and illuminate the long-term institutional, administrative, and societal consequences of democratic backsliding. Bauer, M. W., & Knill, C. (2014). A conceptual framework for the comparative analysis of policy change: Measurement, explanation and strategies of policy dismantling. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice, 16(1), 28–44. Bauer, M. W., Peters, B. G., Pierre, J., Yesilkagit, K., & Becker, S. (Eds.). (2021). Democratic backsliding and public administration: How populists in government transform state bureaucracies. Cambridge University Press. Morais, M., & Gomide, A. (Eds.). (2024). Public policy in democratic backsliding: How illiberal populists engage with the policy process. Palgrave Macmillan. Oliveira, V., & Fernandez, M. (2021). Políticas de saúde no governo Bolsonaro: Desmonte e negacionismo. In L. Avritzer, F. Kerche, & M. Marona (Eds.), Governo Bolsonaro: Retrocesso democrático e degradação política (pp. 113–128). Editora Autêntica. Peters, B. G., & Pierre, J. (2019). Populism and public administration: Confronting the administrative state. Administration & Society, 51(10), 1521–1545.

POLICY TOPICS
Politics, Institutions and Political Regimes
P185. Towards a Public Policy of the Global South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Klein
Y. Campbell
ABSTRACT

A significant body of scholarship suggests that public policy scholarship, as conventionally taught and practised, may not be well equipped to address the critical public policy challenges faced by Global South populations such as the climate crisis, inequality, poverty and genocide. Several interlocking concerns animate this debate. First, questions have been raised about the extent to which public policy as a discipline, accounts for its own history, and specifically how its foundational commitment to liberal democracy, developed through and within broader circuits of colonial and imperial domination, contributes to what Mignolo (2011) calls “the darker side of modernity” (see also Klein and Campbell, forthcoming, Ahmed 2024; Alkadry, 2004). Second, critical scholars have challenged the field’s tendency to treat policy as a set of universal and portable tools applicable across contexts regardless of ontology, history or power (Jhagroe & Salazar-Morales 2026; Eiró, and Lotta 2024). Third, imperialism, white supremacy, and colonisation are often reduced to mere policy context rather than treated as shaping policy formation, tools and knowledge, having material, epistemological, and ontological consequences for public policy (Haque 1996; Phiri, 2021; Klein 2024). Fourth, longstanding debates persist over the field’s state-centrism, with scholars of civic engagement and non-state actors continuing to press for broader conceptions of who counts as a policy actor, and the role of informality and resistance in policymaking (Chatterjee, 2006; Klein and Campbell, forthcoming). These debates raise pressing questions for how public policy is researched, taught, and practised, where Northern policy frameworks are universalised globally, rather developing scholarship and practice based on local histories, governance traditions, diverse ontologies and struggles from the South (Nisar, 2023). Recognising that the terms ‘global North’ and ‘South’ depict an imprecise distinction between populations that have benefited from dispossession, colonisation and slavery and postcolonial, subaltern and Indigenous populations who live daily with the implications of these process every day, albeit in differing ways (Müller, 2020), we understand these North/South as metaphors and an analytical approach for understanding politics, histories and economics of public policy (Sud and Sanchez-Ancechea, 2022; de Sousa Santos, 2014). This panel provides a space for scholars to engage critically with these questions, and asks: 1. How might public policy scholarship reckon with its colonial and imperial histories? 2. How are Global South governments, movements, and scholars already reworking dominant policy framings, and what can be learned from these efforts? 3. How are diverse ontologies informing public policy theory and practice? The panel welcomes diverse theoretical, empirical, and pedagogical perspectives on these questions, offering a forum for rigorous debate rather than advancing a single, settled position.

POLICY TOPICS
Politics, Institutions and Political Regimes Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics Development Policy Global and Transnational Policies
P198. The Politics of Uncommoning: Public Policy, Institutional Interactions, and the Making of Distributed Enclosures
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Das
L. Suresh
N. Tyagi
ABSTRACT

Commons are central to livelihoods, ecological resilience and struggles over development and resource justice. Scholarship has long examined how commons are enclosed, appropriated and dispossessed, and how institutions and collective practices sustain or rebuild them. A question remains for public policy research: how do interacting policies and institutions transform commons, even where individual policies recognise collective rights or pursue legitimate aims such as conservation, restoration and climate mitigation? By commons, we mean resources such as forests, grazing lands, wetlands, lakes, fisheries, water systems and urban spaces that are used and governed collectively. In the commons literature, they are marked by difficulty to exclude and subtractability, and depend on shared rules (Ostrom, 1990). Three further features guide the panel’s scope. They serve multiple uses, such as grazing, fuel, water and fishing (Jodha, 1986). They are not held by a single owner: rights of access, use and management are layered among communities, individuals and the state, and may be customary, formal or both (Schlager & Ostrom, 1992). And they are sustained through stewardship, meaning shared care for the resource and its users (Bennett et al., 2018). The panel covers commons whether or not they are formally recognised or owned by the state, and focuses on land, water and urban commons rather than knowledge or digital commons. Because ecological conditions and institutions shape each other, we treat commons as social-ecological systems (Berkes & Folke, 1998; McGinnis & Ostrom, 2014). Building on studies of how states make resources legible and governable (Scott, 1998; Li, 2007, 2014) and how access and authority are negotiated (Ribot & Peluso, 2003; Sikor & Lund, 2009), the panel explores two working ideas. Policy-produced uncommoning describes how policy framings, legal classifications and administrative routines change the recognition and use of collective resource relations. Distributed enclosure describes the gradual loss of access, authority and benefits when policies, institutions and actors interact, without any single decision to enclose or privatise. Both sit within existing work on enclosure, decommonisation, dispossession and commoning. Our working hypothesis is that such loss often arises less from any single policy than from the interaction of several, each pursuing its own aim. The panel sets 3 questions in the context of these dynamics in forest governance, pastoral landscapes, wetlands, urban commons and land transitions linked to renewable energy and infrastructure: 1. How do policy framings and institutional arrangements transform commons?2. When do interacting policies, institutions and actors produce cumulative enclosure, and how is it different from policy inconsistency, implementation failure or isolated dispossession?3. How are these changes distributed and contested, and when can collective action and institutional reform sustain or rebuild commons?We invite conceptual, comparative and empirical contributions linking commons scholarship with public policy theories of institutional change, implementation, policy interaction and power, attentive to differences of caste, class, gender, ethnicity, occupation and livelihood dependence, and to the possibility that institutional change and commoning can also strengthen collective resource governance.

POLICY TOPICS
Politics, Institutions and Political Regimes Policy Change/Continuity/Dynamics
P208. Lawsuits as an instrument of environmental and climate policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Weigel
A. Wenz-Temming
A. Toeller
ABSTRACT

Over the past ten years, lawsuits have increased in both their number and significance as an instrument of environmental and climate policy. Environmental and climate litigation is not merely a legal process; it also gives expression to social and political conflicts and brings them into the judicial arena. Issues under consideration include distributive and intergenerational justice, local impacts and national or international strategies, the relationship between the economy and the environment, the handling of ‘green-to-green’ conflicts, and the responsibilities of the state, the private sector and society in climate policy. This is reflected, firstly, in lawsuits that challenge the compatibility of existing environmental and climate protection law with higher-ranking law (constitutional law or human rights), often in the form of constitutional complaints lodged by individuals before constitutional courts. Secondly, private-law lawsuits are being brought against companies, seeking compensation for damage caused by climate change or seeking an injunction against actions harmful to the climate (both fall into the category of climate litigation); it remains to be seen whether states affected by climate change, such as Nepal at present, will in future successfully hold other states that have contributed to climate change liable under international law (see ICJ opinions). Thirdly, recognised environmental organisations are bringing legal actions on the basis of the Aarhus Convention to ensure compliance with existing environmental or climate protection law (class actions). Research has documented the rapid growth of climate and environmental litigation and examined the strategic character of climate litigation. Yet, important research gaps remain regarding actor constellations, the institutional contexts shaping litigation strategies, and the effects of litigation on policies, implementation, and environmental outcomes. These research gaps raise a number of questions that cut across climate and environmental litigation: · Who is bringing the claims and who, if anyone, is behind them? What motivates the claimants? Why are they bringing these claims and why do they choose specific types of action? · To what extent, and why, are legal frameworks structured differently as legal opportunity structures, thereby hindering or facilitating the bringing of claims? · What role do strategic lawsuits play, and does this vary depending on the subject matter of the claims? · What effects do lawsuits have, both directly on policies, law enforcement or environmental quality, and indirectly, for example on the dissemination of certain interpretative frameworks and concepts, the assessment of risks and the adaptation of action strategies? · What role do lawsuits play in the current backlash against environmental and climate policy?

POLICY TOPICS
Politics, Institutions and Political Regimes Interest Groups/Lobbying Environment and Climate Policy
P238. The Politics of Public Policy: Governing in Critical Perspective
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Zittoun
F. Fischer
ABSTRACT

This panel proposes to discuss the complex relationship between policy and politics and to highlight the important contribution of Frank Fischer, who challenged the dominant idea that policy analysis, even that which claims rationality and apolitical objectivity is and remains a political activity. Following Habermas' analysis of "science and technology as ideology," this perspective challenges the positivist theories of policy analysis, including those of the policy process, to offer a better understanding of the art and craft of governing people and society. Coming back to the origins of the discipline, Lasswell was one of the first authors to clearly distinguish policy from politics. He explained how "the word 'policy' is commonly used to designate the most important choices made (…) [and] is free of many of the undesirable connotations clustered about the word political" (Lasswell, 1951, p. 5), and he proposed to clearly distinguish "policy sciences" from "what is studied by political science, the term in common use for academic teachers and writers about government" (p. 4). This intention to distinguish the two concepts was largely developed during this period. Dahl and Lindblom, in their book Politics, Economics and Welfare (1953), highlighted how "reform depends not upon our choice among mythical grand alternatives but largely upon choice among particular social techniques" (p. 6). This distinction between policy and politics was particularly influential in the development of policy studies and policy analysis. It echoes two main but different conceptualizations of the relationship between policy and politics. The first understanding is grounded in an ontological distinction between politics and public policies. It posits a fundamental difference in nature between the political system (politics) and the public policy system (policies). The second understanding shifts from an ontological to an epistemological distinction. It maintains the autonomy of the political system but does not consider public policies as inherently apolitical; rather, they are susceptible to politicization. Since the publication of The Argumentative Turn and specifically the work of Frank Fischer, the critical perspective has rejected both the ontological separation of systems and the epistemological distinction between political and non-political objects. Instead, it posits that public policies are ontologically political. From this perspective, the very processes of designing, implementing, and evaluating public policies are political activities. Authors such as Maarten Hajer (1995), Carol Bacchi (2009), and Fischer and Forester (1993) argue that policy processes are inherently normative, contested, and power-laden. Policy design is not a neutral act of problem-solving but a political process involving the imposition of certain values, priorities, and worldviews over others. Drawing on Habermas's work on "science and technology as ideology," Fischer highlights that this claim to neutrality is essentially a political manipulation strategy used by experts to impose their positions. The aim of this panel is to discuss this political dimension of policy and to better understand the consequences of this perspective for the study of the policy process. A "public policy" is not simply "what the government chooses to do," to follow Thomas Dye, but is first and foremost the way government defines the society it wants to intervene in, shapes legitimate discourse, defines the problems it wants to consider and solve, structures the social categories it wants to recognize, distributes values, distinguishes what behavior is "normal" and must be encouraged from what is not and must be sanctioned, identifies the "representative" actors it wants to negotiate with and on what terms, domesticates behavior, and designs the promising future it wants to build. Public policy is both what government acts for and how it acts to shape this division of society (the domain), reduce uncertainty, distribute social roles, structure human and non-human behaviors, identify beneficiaries (winners) and culprits (losers), and design a future world order. It is also the way government defines itself as the entity capable of managing problems, establishing order, reducing uncertainty, acting on society, modifying its future, and legitimizing itself. In other words, policy is the way through which government exists, defines itself, and shapes its legitimacy. It is not the government as a substantial entity on one hand and what it does on the other; it is an entity that exists because it acts. Conversely, public policy is also the way individuals construct and structure their own relationship with the State and society. Policy is at once the way government seeks to domesticate human and non-human behavior and the way individuals structure their own agency within the constraints imposed by government. This relationship is never simply what government expected, nor is it nothing. It impacts behavior, but usually never as anticipated, provoking a permanent transaction between State and society.

POLICY TOPICS
Politics, Institutions and Political Regimes Discourses, Ideas, and Narratives
P285. Governing the Health Workforce: Political Institutions, Interests and Policy Change
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Topp
T. Nguyen
V. Sriram
K. Vikash
ABSTRACT

General Objectives Health workforce policy provides a valuable empirical setting for examining enduring questions in public policy theory concerning the exercise of power, the influence of institutions, the formation of policy agendas, and the conditions under which policy change occurs. Although workforce challenges are frequently framed as technical problems of supply, distribution, skills and productivity, the policies intended to address them emerge through political processes involving competing interests, established professional hierarchies, institutionalised rules and overlapping jurisdictions. These dynamics raise broader theoretical questions about why particular policy problems gain attention, whose interests and ideas shape the available solutions, and why established policy arrangements persist despite recognised pressures for reform. Public policy scholarship offers multiple theoretical approaches to understanding these processes. Institutional theories draw attention to the ways historical legacies, formal rules and organisational arrangements structure policy choices and constrain change. Political economy and theories of power illuminate how competing interests, professional authority and distributions of resources shape policy agendas and reform trajectories. Policy process theories offer explanations of agenda-setting, coalition formation, contestation and policy change, while theories of multi-level and cross-sectoral governance foreground the challenges of coordination where authority and responsibility are dispersed. Yet the explanatory value, complementarities and limitations of these approaches remain insufficiently explored in relation to health workforce policymaking. This panel brings together theoretically informed research examining how political institutions, actors, ideas and interests interact to shape health workforce policy across different political and health system contexts. Health workforce policy offers a particularly productive setting for such inquiry because decisions concerning education, migration, employment, professional regulation, financing and service delivery span multiple sectors and levels of government, often involving overlapping or competing forms of authority. The panel is organised around an overarching question: How do political institutions, power relations and competing interests shape contemporary health workforce policy choices, their implementation and prospects for change? It invites contributions addressing four related dimensions: The panel is organised around four interrelated theoretical questions: Power and policy influence: How do competing interests, political coalitions, professional authority and unequal distributions of power shape the definition of workforce problems and the selection of policy responses?Institutions and policy persistence: How do formal and informal institutions, historical legacies and established governance arrangements explain continuity, resistance and path dependence in workforce policy? Historical legacies and policy change: How do established workforce arrangements, professional hierarchies and past policy choices shape resistance, continuity and opportunities for reform? Governance and institutional interdependence: How do fragmented authority, competing institutional mandates and interactions across policy sectors and levels of government shape policy coordination, implementation and outcomes? By bringing different theoretical traditions into dialogue, the panel seeks to move beyond identifying political influences on workforce policy towards explaining the mechanisms through which power, institutions and policy processes shape policy choices, persistence and change. In doing so, it aims to contribute both to the theoretical understanding of health workforce governance and to wider debates in public policy scholarship.

POLICY TOPICS
Politics, Institutions and Political Regimes Multilevel Governance and Local Policy Health and Well-Being Policy
P287. The Institutional and Organizational Architecture of Public Policies on Access to Information for Accountability: A Comparative Perspective
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Salgado Remigio
ABSTRACT

Since the 1990s, access-to-information (ATI) laws have spread across every world region, turning the right to know into a standard component of democratic governance (Michener, 2011; Worthy, 2017). Yet adoption says little about effect. Who enforces the right, whether an information commissioner, an ombudsman, an autonomous collegiate body, a court or a unit within the executive, is a decisive yet poorly understood variable. This choice is not stable. Mexico, long a regional reference for its autonomous constitutional guarantor, dissolved it in 2025 and transferred its functions to an agency subordinate to the Ministry of Anti-Corruption and Good Government (Diario Oficial de la Federación, 2025), while Chile created a separate autonomous Data Protection Agency (Biblioteca del Congreso Nacional de Chile, 2024). Elsewhere, governments merge access and privacy mandates, cut budgets or reshape appointment rules without formally abolishing the right. Research has explained why governments adopt transparency laws (Berliner, 2014; Michener, 2015) and how strong those laws are on paper, as measured by the Global Right to Information Rating (Centre for Law and Democracy & Access Info Europe, n.d.). A second strand shows that the link between transparency and accountability is uncertain: disclosure produces answerability only when actors can turn information into voice or sanctions (Fox, 2007; Hood & Heald, 2006; Meijer, 2013). Studies of oversight bodies have mapped their models and functions (Holsen & Pasquier, 2012; OECD, 2019), and the literature on democratic backsliding shows how executives reshape bureaucracies (Bauer et al., 2021). Two gaps remain: comparative evidence on how the institutional and organizational design of guarantor bodies conditions effective accountability (Salgado, 2019), and on why these bodies are redesigned, merged or dismantled. The panel asks: under what conditions do institutional and organizational designs for access to information turn the formal right to know into effective accountability, and what makes the bodies that guarantee it resilient or vulnerable to political redesign? It can explore five hypotheses. H1: formal autonomy (appointment rules, tenure, budget and binding powers) increases compliance only when the guarantor is embedded in a chain of horizontal accountability with courts, audit institutions and legislatures. H2 (autonomy paradox): the more visible and powerful the guarantor, the more likely it becomes a target of executive backlash. H3: bundling access and data protection in a single body shapes how disclosure and privacy are balanced. H4: digital infrastructures, such as national transparency platforms, create path dependencies that outlive organizational redesign. H5: journalists, civil society and requesters are the main counterweight that sustains the right when guarantors weaken. By comparing regions and regime types, the panel shifts the debate from whether countries have ATI laws to how their institutional and organizational architecture works, erodes or recovers, offering evidence for policy design amid democratic stress. The panel seeks to update research on ATI policies worldwide, trace the historical trajectory of the processes that have advanced this human right, and foster comparisons of two or more cases through the comparative method, in order to strengthen accountability.

POLICY TOPICS
Politics, Institutions and Political Regimes Policy Design, Formulation & Instruments
P29. Health and Crisis in Public Policy Research
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Hornung
S. Profeti
F. Toth
P. Trein
ABSTRACT

Public policy research has widely treated the COVID-19 pandemic as a pivotal case study to understand how policymakers respond to public health crises. (Asticher & Hornung, 2026; Fossati & Trein, 2023; Profeti & Toth, 2023). However, COVID-19 is not the only health policy issue that deserves attention from public policy scholarship, nor is it the only health issue potentially related to crisis. This panel aims at broadening the perspective of research on health policy and crisis, by bringing together different strands of research that analyze the interplay of health and crises from a public policy perspective, to address the following research questions: - To what extent do public policy theories provide insights on health policy processes in a comparative perspective, and on public health crises beyond COVID-19? - What can we learn from COVID-19 public policy research for current or future public health crises? - How can and should we fruitfully bridge research on crisis governance with public policy research, to gain insights into public policymaking in times of crises? The intersection of research on health and crisis in public policy is fragmented. On the one hand (public) health policy is often decoupled from public policy research (Deruelle, 2021; Desson et al., 2020; Francetic, 2021). Studies that explicitly apply theoretical lenses from public policy to health policy as a sectoral case exist (Bandelow et al., 2024; Béland et al., 2020; Béland et al., 2018; Capano & Toth, 2023; Hornung, 2022; Trein & Maggetti, 2020), but they tend to be rare compared to studies on environmental or education policy, although this depends on the applied theory (Jones et al., 2016; Pierce et al., 2020; Pierce et al., 2017). On the other, policy process research conceptualizes crises as factors (sometime using different terms, like critical junctures) influencing public policies and policy change (Kaplaner et al., 2026; Saurugger & Terpan, 2015; Skagen, 2026). Public health crises like COVID-19 can serve as an empirical case, for instance explaining agenda setting in the Multiple Streams Framework (MSF) (Asticher & Hornung, 2026; Karokis-Mavrikos, 2024) or the use of narrative strategies of political leaders (Mastroianni & Profeti, 2025). The panel starts from the assumption that a more integrated dialogue can enhance theoretical and empirical research on health policy processes and public health crises, or the influence of crises and crisis governance on decisions in the (public) health sector. It seeks papers that: - examine the empirically and theoretically the management and decision-making of health crisis - bridge the literature on crisis governance and management with public policy research to examine current and future public health crises - study the acceptance and compliance with (public) health policy in times of crisis and non-crisis - investigate the role of different actor types in health policy, such as (but not limited to) the role of experts and scientific evidence in health policy processes and public health crises - examine the coordination of health with other policies in the context of crises, such as public health and climate crisis

POLICY TOPICS
Crises, Risks and Wicked Problems Policy Process Theories Health and Well-Being Policy
P61. From Prediction to Pre-emption: The Nexus of Policy Analytics and Anticipatory Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Florano
ABSTRACT

Governments are increasingly expected to act before crises fully materialize. Two bodies of practice have grown in response, but largely in parallel. Policy analytics applies data science, modeling, and decision analysis to support each stage of the policy cycle (Daniell et al., 2016). Anticipatory governance, rooted in science and technology studies and strategic foresight, seeks to build the capacity to manage emerging issues while they can still be shaped (Guston, 2014), and has entered public sector reform agendas (Tõnurist & Hanson, 2020). Yet the two seldom meet. Analytics units tend to focus on monitoring, nowcasting and short-horizon prediction, while foresight units produce long-horizon scenarios that are often narrative and weakly linked to budgets and decisions. Where the two have been coupled, the results are instructive. In disaster risk reduction, anticipatory action frameworks link impact forecasts to pre-agreed actions and pre-arranged finance. The Philippine framework for tropical cyclones, for example, releases up to US$6 million from the UN Central Emergency Response Fund when a model predicts that totally damaged houses will exceed regional thresholds, up to 72 hours before landfall (UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs [OCHA], 2025). Such arrangements turn predictions into decisions, but they also raise questions about whose risks are modelled, which futures are excluded, and who is accountable when forecasts fail. Critical scholarship warns that analysis and anticipation can close down rather than open up the range of futures considered (Stirling, 2008; Muiderman et al., 2020). This panel asks: Under what conditions does policy analytics strengthen anticipatory governance, and how does coupling prediction with decision reshape policy choices, accountability and the politics of the future? The panel will explore four hypotheses/propositions. First, analytics and foresight remain institutionally decoupled, housed in different units with different time horizons, methods, and audiences, which limits the policy impact of both. Second, coupling is most likely where formal decision triggers, pre-arranged finance, and clear mandates connect forecasts to action, as in anticipatory action, contingent financing, and early warning systems. Third, the more anticipation relies on quantitative models, including machine learning, the more it privileges measurable and probable futures over deeply uncertain or plural ones. Fourth, the capacity to couple analytics and anticipation depends on data infrastructure, analytical skills and political demand, so that governments facing the greatest risks, often in the Global South, may have the least capacity, or may innovate by necessity. By bringing together conceptual, comparative and empirical work across policy domains such as disaster risk, climate, health, food security and fiscal policy, the panel aims to build a research agenda on the analytics–anticipation nexus as a distinct object of policy studies. It particularly welcomes contributions from Asia, Africa and Latin America, where anticipatory instruments are being tested under acute risk and constrained resources. References: Daniell, K. A., Morton, A., & Ríos Insua, D. (2016). Policy analysis and policy analytics. Annals of Operations Research, 236(1), 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10479-015-1902-9 Guston, D. H. (2014). Understanding ‘anticipatory governance’. Social Studies of Science, 44(2), 218–242. https://doi.org/10.1177/0306312713508669 Muiderman, K., Gupta, A., Vervoort, J., & Biermann, F. (2020). Four approaches to anticipatory climate governance: Different conceptions of the future and implications for the present. WIREs Climate Change, 11(6), Article e673. https://doi.org/10.1002/wcc.673 Stirling, A. (2008). “Opening up” and “closing down”: Power, participation, and pluralism in the social appraisal of technology. Science, Technology, & Human Values, 33(2), 262–294. https://doi.org/10.1177/0162243907311265 Tõnurist, P., & Hanson, A. (2020). Anticipatory innovation governance: Shaping the future through proactive policymaking (OECD Working Papers on Public Governance No. 44). OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/cce14d80-en UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs. (2025, October 3). Anticipatory action framework Philippines – Tropical cyclones. ReliefWeb. https://reliefweb.int/report/philippines/anticipatory-action-framework-philippines-tropical-cyclones-03-october-2025

POLICY TOPICS
Crises, Risks and Wicked Problems Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process Security, Defense and Risk Governance Technologies, Digital Governance, and AI Policy
P206. Insurance policies for climate risks: stakeholders, instruments, and inequalities
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Hetzel
A. Desroches-Touchain
M. Fois Duclerc
ABSTRACT

This panel aims to bring together studies focusing on the restructuring of insurance policies against climate-related risks in different geographical zones and from various theoretical perspectives. Three major trends illustrate the significance of these issues. Firstly, as a result of climate change, hazards such as droughts, heatwaves, floods, landslides are becoming both more frequent and more intense. Secondly, the worsening of these phenomena are fueling debate over the ability of insurance mechanisms to provide effective protection against environmental risks. Finally, these discussions bring together a wide range of stakeholders, both public and private, engaging in interactions from cooperation to conflict. These observations raise many empirical questions. Is it only possible to provide protection against risks exacerbated by climate change? Who is protected (or not) by these insurance policies? Through which tools and which actors can this financial protection be provided? Under what funding arrangements? How is the insurance market structured ? What is the balance between calls for prevention and claims for compensation for climate-related disasters? This panel proposal draws on a dynamic trend of research in social sciences. Firstly, studies in the field of the sociology of disasters address “disaster governance” from the perspective of crisis management and risk anticipation (Peek et al. 2021; Giry 2023). Anthropology of disasters also procure significant insights about disaster memory and long-term effects of disasters (Revet and Langumier 2013). Surprisingly, the sociology and anthropology of disasters have overlooked insurance systems and infrastructure. When they do, it is primarily from a bottom-up perspective, with few regard to the compensation received by households (Rhodes and Besbris 2022). A second body of work focuses on solidarity policies. These studies focus on risk governance (Ewald 1986; Borraz 2008), disaster governance (Collier 2008, 2014; Collier, Elliott, and Lehtonen, 2021), on the moral economy of responsibility (Barry 2024) and loss (Elliott 2021), on risk socialization (Keucheyan 2025). They examine the various systems of protection against environmental disasters (Beaussier et al., 2026) and highlight tensions at the core of solidarity policies: should the cost of protection be mutualized or individualized? Should these policies emphasize on disaster prevention or recovery? Building on this body of work, this panel aims to give greater prominence to the concrete process of public policies - policy entrepreneurs, funding, tools, implementation, institutions, ideological grounds, etc. Lastly, comparative works have highlighted how the reinsurance sector creates markets for extreme events (Jarzabkowski et al. 2015) and emphasized the frequency of government support for this sector through “protection gap entities” created for this purpose (Jarzabkowski et al. 2023) . Nevertheless, it does not explore how these “entities” are integrated into public policy and shape power relations across all levels of analysis. What is the role of public policies regarding environmental insurance in the context of climate change? • One hypothesis suggests the strengthening role of public support in a context where insurance markets are facing difficulties or disappearing. • Another questions if the financial focus on compensation is an obstacle to adapting to climate change, despite the importance of prevention in policy discourse. • The last one supposes that compensation systems reproduce social inequalities through public tools of government.

POLICY TOPICS
Crises, Risks and Wicked Problems Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process
P290. Governing Policy and Organizational Crisis
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
V. Arnhold
P. Zittoun
ABSTRACT

While crises have been the subject of substantial research in the field of organizational sociology (Perrow 1984; Weick 1993; Vaughan 1996; Borraz & November 2025) and crisis management (Rosenthal, Charles and ‘t Hart 1989; Boin et al. 2005; Ansell, Boin and Keller 2010), they remain comparatively understudied in public policy (Capano and Toth 2024; Capano et al. 2026). Paradoxically, Policy Studies have built a large literature showing how problems emerge, are defined, framed, and tamed, exploring the complex link between problem agenda-setting and policy formulation (Rochefort and Cobb 1994; Kingdon 1984; Blum 2021; Zittoun et al. 2021). Yet this literature has essentially treated crisis as an exogenous “focusing event”, shock, or critical juncture that pushes problems onto the agenda or punctuates policy equilibria (Kingdon 1984; Baumgartner and Jones 1993; Birkland 1997; Zittoun 2025). In this panel, we propose to revisit this question by examining crisis as both a policy and an organizational phenomenon. Rather than separating, on epistemological grounds, the definition of a crisis from its policy and organizational management, we consider crisis as a specific experience in which the ordinary policy process, and the organizations that carry it, no longer work (Zittoun 2025b). Crisis is a trial in which policymakers confront events that their usual ways of knowing, deciding, and legitimizing cannot grasp. Following Dobry’s continuity hypothesis (1986), crises should be studied with the same tools as ordinary policymaking in a stable organizational world. In ordinary times, policymaking consists in translating disruptive events into treatable problems that fit established frameworks, often by defining them in terms of solutions already at hand (Wildavsky 1979). This translation relies on a stable organizational order where problems are “domesticated” by being grasped through definitional devices, being attached to a policy sector or domain and to the bureaucratic division of labor among ministries, departments and agencies, identifying who owns the problem and who is legitimate to address it (Gusfield 1981; Zittoun 2025a). Each organizational segment carries its own expertise and knowledge devices to make it intelligible and predictable (Zittoun and Hassenteufel 2026). It also carries its own standard operating procedures and repertoires of solutions (Allison 1971; Cohen, March and Olsen 1972). Crises begin when events overflow this policy and organizational order (Arnhold 2023; Callon 1998). Events that cannot be understood within established knowledge devices challenge the expertise on which organizations rely, as organizational sociology has shown in its analyses of incubation and the collapse of sensemaking (Turner 1978; Weick 1993). Crises may become situations in which ordinary institutional or sectoral boundaries are questioned (Dobry 1986). They are also intrinsically related to critique: Crises are the result of a “second-order judgment” (Roitman 2014) that implies a statement of failure, and therefore a potential for critique of public actors (Arnhold 2026) and their capacity to govern crisis. Crisis can thus be seen as the moment when the organizational order of policymaking is both disrupted and revealed. We hypothesize that crises in public policy can be understood as “trials of delegitimation” (Zittoun et al. 2026; Capano et al. 2026), in three different ways. When events cannot be made intelligible in regular knowledge devices, they constitute a problematization trial that destabilizes the process of problem definition. When no available solution can be coupled with these events, the institutionalized way of policy-making is put to the test and becomes a policy-ization trial. When these events circulate across sectors, organizations, and levels of government, they blur the boundaries that assign problems to owners and become a political trial, in which the legitimacy of those in charge is called into question (Zittoun and Hassenteufel 2026). Considering crisis as a trial of delegitimation of a policy process that relies on diverse organizational configurations makes it possible to revisit the responses governments put in place once they have lost their grip on events. Drawing on the three forms of governing crises proposed by Capano, Zittoun and Profeti (2026) (governing during the crisis, governing the crisis and governing by the crisis), we propose to examine how crisis governance deals with the policy and organizational boundaries that the crisis has blurred, and how it recomposes, or fails to recompose, new grips on events and new boundaries.

POLICY TOPICS
Crises, Risks and Wicked Problems
P135. European integration meets public policy: Applying policy analysis approaches to post-pandemic socioeconomic breakthroughs
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
D. NATALI
I. Guardiancich
A. Terlizzi
ABSTRACT

This panel invites papers that engage with the theoretical intersection between European integration and public policy studies, with a particular focus on the application of policy analysis concepts (related to governance, crises management, policy cycles, policy design and other analytical tools) and policy process theories to the post-pandemic socioeconomic regulation, coordination and redistribution breakthroughts. While the last years have seen policy studies that focus on the EU, the synergy between the different strands of the literature is still partial and need of more dialogue. Policy studies are increasingly involved in the analysis of the European integration, but such involvement could be more coordinated and supportive of the accumulation of knowledge in this area. The panel aims at contributing to such advancement through a typical multi-disciplinary and methodologically eclectic perspective. Key research questions at the cross road of policy and EU studies are often related to: - the question of stability and change (both in institutional and policy terms) of the EU; - the capacity of the latter to progress through crises (with the usual reference to polycrisis and permacrisis and the room for integration/disintegration); - the evolution of the EU administrative and institutional capacity in the context of a compound polity (with reference to regulation, redistribution, and coordination; - and to the role of single level of governance, e.g. supra-national, national, regional, local). Some policy studies have also proved the potential to contribute to the theoretical debate on the role of functionalism, post-functionalism, intergovernmentalism, neo-institutionalism, and the governance approach. The latter are used to shed light on the EU as a compound polity: a decentralized, multi-level political system - where sovereignty and authority are shared between a central or supranational framework and distinct constituent units - that sees persistent (if not growing) challenges to address crises and complex policy problems in a changing political context.

POLICY TOPICS
Crises, Risks and Wicked Problems Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition General Public Policy (no specific sector) Global and Transnational Policies
P277. Legitimation in the Policy Process: Expertise, Leadership, and Public Discourse in Crisis Preparedness
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Petridou
ABSTRACT

Legitimacy is a central concern of public policy because the latter is the means through which governments ask citizens to comply, often against their immediate interests. Policy legitimacy rests less on an objective correlation between a policy and the public good than on whether affected publics experience the policy as meeting real needs and addressing perceived problems (Hanberger, 2003). Procedure matters as well: the incubation of ideas, the framing of appeals, and stakeholder engagement can explain the fate of a reform when effectiveness cannot (Wallner, 2008). Crises bring legitimacy and legitimation to the forefront. The COVID-19 pandemic and (in some contexts) the threat posed by the Russian invasion of Ukraine required compliance with restrictive measures under uncertainty, and the speed demanded compressed the consultative processes that normally generate legitimacy. Survey evidence from six European democracies indicates that perceived procedural transparency shapes trust and compliance more than objective performance does (Coroado & Frateur, 2025). Preparedness is therefore a policy problem and a legitimation problem at once (Christensen et al., 2016).The panel adopts legitimation as its organizing concept. Legitimacy has often been treated as a property that an actor or institution possesses (Suddaby et al., 2017). A process perspective asks how beliefs in legitimacy come to be held, by whom, and through which interactions (Galán, 2018), and it gives weight to agency. Actors can gain, maintain, and repair legitimacy, and each strategy carries characteristic risks. Policymakers also operate in an arena where epistemic, managerial, and political claims to legitimacy compete and can undermine one another (Galanti, 2023). The type of crisis matters: transparent communication and expert involvement helped one government keep a situational crisis from becoming an institutional one (Petridou et al., 2020). Studies of the pandemic add the contrast between pluralistic and monotonous public discourse (Baekkeskov et al., 2021), the visibility of experts and political leaders (Rubin et al., 2021), and the role of policy capacity and trust (Zahariadis et al., 2023). These literatures remain separate, concentrate on the acute phase of crises, and rarely compare a prolonged crisis with a security threat.The panel therefore asks: How do the legitimation of policy processes, policy outcomes, and expert knowledge shape the design and acceptance of crisis preparedness, and how does this change as crises unfold and normalize? Additional questions concern which actors perform these functions and which transition points punctuate legitimation.Papers may explore research questions such as the following:• How does the balance between procedural and substantive justification, including effectiveness and proportionality, shape the acceptance of preparedness policy as crises become prolonged?• How do epistemic, managerial, and political claims to legitimacy interact, and what follows for governments that rely on one of them?• How does public discourse, from pluralistic to monotonous, relate to legitimacy across the phases of a crisis?• How does legitimation differ between health crises and security threats, given differences in the openness of the epistemic communities involved?The panel welcomes comparative and methodologically pluralistic contributions from any national or sectoral context.

POLICY TOPICS
Crises, Risks and Wicked Problems Agency/Leadership Security, Defense and Risk Governance
P22. From Risk Assessment to Protection: Data, Technology and Intersectoral Governance in Policies Addressing Violence Against Women
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
D. Menezes
ABSTRACT

Violence against women poses a complex public policy challenge that requires governments to identify risks, coordinate multiple institutions and provide timely and appropriate protection. Yet public responses often remain fragmented across police, justice, social services, health and other sectors. Risk assessment tools have increasingly been adopted to support professional decision-making and prioritize cases, while digital technologies and integrated information systems create new possibilities for case management, monitoring and interagency coordination. However, evidence on how these instruments translate into effective protection remains fragmented, particularly regarding the institutional and governance conditions required for their successful implementation. The literature on violence against women has increasingly emphasized structured risk assessment, multi-agency responses and coordinated interventions. International experiences such as Spain’s VioGén system and risk-management approaches developed in the United Kingdom illustrate different ways of connecting risk classification, information systems and institutional coordination. At the same time, growing use of digital platforms, data integration and artificial intelligence raises questions concerning governance, accountability, privacy, professional discretion and the adaptation of technological solutions to different institutional contexts. Against this background, the panel asks: Under what institutional and governance conditions can risk assessment, integrated data systems and intersectoral coordination improve public responses to violence against women? The panel will explore four complementary hypotheses. First, risk assessment is more likely to improve protection when embedded in integrated governance arrangements rather than used as an isolated screening instrument. Second, the effectiveness of risk-based approaches depends on the capacity to transform assessment data into actionable information that can support coordinated decisions across institutions. Third, risk classification is more likely to produce meaningful protection when connected to clear referral protocols, case management and intersectoral decision-making. Fourth, the effectiveness of international models depends on institutional adaptation rather than straightforward policy or technological transfer. The panel will bring together comparative, empirical and theoretical contributions addressing these questions. It will draw, among other experiences, on the emerging case of Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil, where the government is developing an integrated system combining risk assessment, information management, case follow-up and coordination across the protection network, informed by international experiences including the VioGén model in Spain. The discussion will also benefit from international academic and policy collaboration, including engagement with the London School of Economics and Political Science. The panel aims to advance the debate on how governments can move from risk identification to coordinated protection, contributing to research on evidence-based policy, digital government, policy implementation and intersectoral governance.

POLICY TOPICS
Equity, Gender, Inclusion and the Diversity in Public Policy State and Policy Capacity Justice Policy
P21. Rethinking Positive Discrimination in a Changing World: From Group-Based Affirmative Action to Intersectional and Inclusive Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
K. Gowd
ABSTRACT

The purpose of this panel is to explore the development, impact and shortcomings of positive discrimination and affirmative action policies in various countries and policy contexts in a critical manner. It aims to conduct a comparative analysis of the various responses of states to historically deep-rooted inequalities by caste, race, ethnicity, gender, indigeneity and socioeconomic disadvantage and assess the effectiveness of current policy frameworks in the context of fast evolving patterns of exclusion. The current body of knowledge about affirmative action and positive discrimination and social justice offers a critical backdrop to reimagining current strategies for inclusive public policy. Galanter (1984), Goldman (1979), Anderson (2004), Fredman (2011, 2022) and Khaitan (2015) provide foundationally important work on the normative, legal and institutional basis of group based affirmative action and its importance in redressing historical discrimination and structural inequalities. The debates on substantive equality, redistribution, recognition, participation and institutional change are also advanced by Young (1990), Fraser (2008), and Fredman (2016). Single-axis theoretical frameworks of inequality are confronted by the emergence of intersectionality as a critical analytical tool, most notably in Crenshaw (1989, 1991) and Collins (2000).Single-axis theorisations of inequality are challenged when intersectionality as a critical analytical framework emerges, most notably in Crenshaw (1989, 1991) and Collins (2000). Comparative scholarship is also provided by Kennedy-Dubourdieu (2006), Gururaj et al. (2021), Carvalho, Pradelski and Williams (2025) and Bengtson (2023), discussing the nature of affirmative action in diverse political and institutional settings, and the meaning of multidimensional identities for policy design, representation and inclusion. One key goal is to consider a regular and evidence-based oversight of positive discrimination policies. New and evolving expressions of marginalisation related to migration and displacement, refugee status, LGBTQ+ identities, disability, statelessness, ethnicity, language and other axes of disadvantage are being lived by in contemporary societies. The panel will explore how public policy can address these developments while not overlooking historically entrenched structural inequalities. The panel will also explore the participation of governance institutions, policy networks, civil society organizations, social movements and affected communities in the recognition and influence on inclusive policy responses to new forms of discrimination. The panel will answer the following questions: How has positive discrimination and affirmative action policies developed across the various national and regional contexts and what are the evidence for their effectiveness?What are the key positive aspects, flaws and paradoxes of current affirmative action policies?How well do traditional, collective models, address new and intersectional forms of disadvantage?What is the role of migration, refugee status, LGBTQ+ identities, disability and other new aspects of marginalisation in addressing contemporary policy agendas of equity and inclusion?5. What institutional arrangements should governments put in place to review periodically the categories and eligibility criteria of beneficiaries and policy instruments?6. In what ways can intersectionality, good data and democratic participation help design and measure positive discrimination policies?How do policy networks, civil society and cross-national coalitions help to uncover new inequalities and shape policy change? The scientific value of the panel is the linkage of comparative public policy, social justice, governance and intersectionality, with a view to creating a more dynamic approach to the understanding of positive discrimination. Existing scholarship has focussed on the nature of affirmative action in specific national contexts and there is still plenty of room for comparative study of the capacity for affirmative action to be flexible in the face of rapidly changing demographic and social dynamics.

POLICY TOPICS
Equity, Gender, Inclusion and the Diversity in Public Policy Governance, Policy Networks and Coalition Justice Policy Social Policy
P28. Public Policy, Gendered Inequalities, and the Social Reorganization of Care in Global Perspective
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
D. Lemus Muñiz
J. Romero Galván
ABSTRACT

Care has become one of the most pressing challenges facing contemporary public policy. This challenge is unfolding against a profound transformation of the world’s demographic landscape. The global population reached approximately 8.2 billion people in 2024 and is projected to continue growing to around 10.3 billion by the mid-2080s, while fertility has fallen to 2.25 births per woman and is already below replacement level in more than half of all countries and areas (United Nations, 2024). At the same time, people are living longer: global life expectancy reached 73.3 years in 2024 and is projected to rise to 77.4 years by 2054. Population ageing is therefore becoming a particularly significant policy challenge. By the late 2070s, the number of people aged 65 and older is projected to reach 2.2 billion and surpass the number of children under 18; even earlier, by the mid-2030s, the population aged 80 and over is expected to reach 265 million, exceeding the number of infants worldwide (United Nations, 2024). These trends coexist with very different demographic realities across regions: while some societies are experiencing population decline and rapid ageing, others continue to have relatively young and rapidly growing populations. Together with transformations in labor markets and family structures, these demographic shifts are reshaping both the scale and the nature of care needs across the world. From a feminist perspective, care cannot be understood solely as a question of service provision or social policy design, but rather as a central arena in which gender relations, social hierarchies, and relations of dependency are produced and reproduced (Fraser, 2016). Historically, the social organization of care has rested on a gendered division of labor that has assigned women primary responsibility for caregiving and social reproduction, both through unpaid work within households and through paid forms of care work (Federici, 2015, 2018). Feminist scholarship has further shown that paid care work is frequently characterized by low wages, precarious employment, limited recognition, and weak labor and social protections, particularly in sectors such as domestic and migrant care work (Glenn, 1992; Tronto, 2013). These inequalities cannot be understood through gender alone: the organization of care is also structured by class, race and racialization, ethnicity, migration status, citizenship, age, and territory, producing highly unequal distributions of both care responsibilities and access to care (Glenn, 1992; Hochschild, 2000; Razavi, 2007). This panel proposes to examine contemporary transformations in care policy from a global, comparative, and feminist perspective. Its general objective is to analyze how different states and societies are responding to the so-called care crisis and, more specifically, the extent to which current policies challenge or reproduce the traditional gendered division of labor. The central question will be: Are emerging care policies producing a meaningful redistribution of care responsibilities among the state, the market, communities, families, women, and men, or are they institutionalizing pre-existing inequalities in new forms?

POLICY TOPICS
Equity, Gender, Inclusion and the Diversity in Public Policy State and Policy Capacity Social Policy
P51. When Inclusive Policies Produce Unequal Outcomes: Examining the Interplay of Policy Design, Institutional Capacity and Implementation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Chawla
ABSTRACT

Social policies are designed to promote societal well-being through improved access to essential services, reduced inequalities and equitable allocation of public resources. However, translating these normative objectives into equitable outcomes remains a challenge. Even when policies explicitly aim to promote inclusion, their benefits are often unevenly distributed across social groups, and geographic regions—despite being governed by uniform policy frameworks. This paradox raises a fundamental puzzle in policy scholarship: why do policies intended to promote inclusion and equity frequently produce or reinforce existing inequalities? Policy scholars have typically addressed this question through segmented theoretical lenses dividing analytical attention between, policy design, implementation capacity and governance or organizational capacity. On one hand, policy design scholarship illustrates how policy instruments, eligibility rules, and social constructions of target populations systematically allocate benefits and burdens across social groups (Schneider & Ingram, 1993). On the other hand, implementation studies emphasize how administrative bottlenecks, resource deficits, intergovernmental frictions, and frontline discretion undermine policy intent (Pressman & Wildavsky, 1973; Lipsky, 1980). While these perspectives offer valuable insights in isolation, their dynamic interaction remains undertheorized. Complex eligibility rules and standardized policy designs often interact with unequal institutional capacities to generate substantial administrative burdens, shifting the costs of access onto disadvantaged populations and forcing frontline bureaucrats to ration services unevenly. Understanding the persistence of unequal outcomes requires analyzing how policy design choices, organizational resources, and frontline discretion intersect. Against this background, the panel convenes theoretical, empirical, and comparative research examining why inclusive social policies produce divergent outcomes across social groups, regions, and institutional contexts. It aims to illuminate how policy design, institutional capacity, frontline practices, and governance arrangements interact to shape the distribution of policy impacts and social equity. To address these objectives, the panel will focus on three interconnected research questions: 1. How do policy designs, administrative instruments, and institutional capacities interact to influence the distribution of benefits and burdens across different population groups and regions? 2. Under what organizational and political conditions do administrative discretion, street-level practices, and local governance arrangements mitigate or reinforce structural inequalities? 3. How do policy disparities, citizen feedback, and accountability mechanisms shape administrative learning and inform subsequent policy reforms? The panel encourages comparative research across countries, social policy domains and levels of government, alongside theoretically grounded case studies of specific policy settings. Particular attention will be devoted to examining why standardized, "one-size-fits-all" policy instruments frequently fail to generate equitable outcomes when deployed across uneven local contexts. The scientific contribution of the panel lies in bridging the divide between policy design theories and implementation scholarship through comparative empirical evidence. By identifying the causal mechanisms and contextual conditions that drive disparities in policy delivery, the panel seeks to advance scholarship on policy design, street-level bureaucracy, multi-level governance, and distributive equity.

POLICY TOPICS
Equity, Gender, Inclusion and the Diversity in Public Policy Implementation/Street-Level Bureaucracy General Public Policy (no specific sector) Social Policy
P170. Who Shapes Public Policy? Social Identity, Political Representation, and the Informal Exercise of Power
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
V. Mishra
M. Narula
ABSTRACT

Public policies are not produced by institutions alone; they are also shaped by the preferences, identities, incentives, and power relations of the individuals who occupy positions of authority. Although theories of democratic representation emphasize the relationship between citizens' preferences and policy choices (Osborne & Slivinski, 1996; Besley & Coate, 1997), foundational scholarship on political representation distinguishes between descriptive and substantive representation (Pitkin, 1967) and highlights the importance of the presence of historically underrepresented groups in decision-making institutions (Phillips, 1995; Mansbridge, 1999). An important question therefore remains: how, and under what institutional conditions, do policymakers' social identities influence public policy priorities and outcomes? This panel examines the relationship between policymakers' social identities, political representation, and policy outcomes across different institutional and geographical contexts. It invites contributions examining identities such as gender, caste, ethnicity, religion, class, educational background, and political lineage, alongside the institutional arrangements that mediate their influence. The panel also considers how formal representation interacts with informal power structures, including elite capture, proxy leadership, party hierarchies, and unequal access to decision-making. Existing research offers important insights into the effects of political representation on public goods provision, education, health, welfare, and other developmental outcomes. Studies of gender quotas and reserved political positions, for example, demonstrate that changes in representation can influence policy priorities and citizens' aspirations (Chattopadhyay & Duflo, 2004; Beaman et al., 2012; Clots-Figueras, 2012). Research on caste and minority representation also suggests that policymakers' social backgrounds may affect resource allocation and developmental outcomes (Pande, 2003; Bhalotra et al., 2014; Chin & Prakash, 2011). Similarly, research on political leadership has examined the influence of educational qualifications, professional backgrounds, and political dynasties on governance and economic performance (Besley et al., 2011; Carnes & Lupu, 2016; Daniele et al., 2021). However, the relationship between descriptive representation and substantive policy change is neither automatic nor uniform. Institutional constraints, party discipline, electoral incentives, administrative capacity, and entrenched social hierarchies may strengthen, mediate, or limit these effects. The panel seeks to advance this debate by addressing three interconnected questions: 1. Identity and policy preferences: How do policymakers' social identities and educational backgrounds shape legislative agendas, resource allocation, public spending, and developmental outcomes? 2. Representation and institutional power: Under what conditions does descriptive representation translate into substantive representation, and how do informal power relations constrain or enable policymakers' autonomy? 3. Institutions and policy effectiveness: How do electoral systems, quotas, party structures, administrative institutions, and accountability mechanisms influence the relationship between representation and policy outcomes? The panel welcomes theoretical, quantitative, qualitative, comparative, and mixed-methods contributions. Relevant approaches include legislative text analysis, parliamentary questions and debates, administrative and electoral data, field interviews, ethnographic research, and comparative case studies. By bringing together scholarship on political representation, institutional behavior, and public policy, the panel aims to move beyond the assumption that greater diversity necessarily produces more inclusive governance. It seeks to identify the mechanisms through which representation matters, the institutional conditions under which it produces substantive change, and the circumstances in which formal inclusion fails to redistribute decision-making power. The broader objective is to develop a comparative understanding of how political institutions can translate diverse social experiences into more responsive, equitable, and accountable public policies.

POLICY TOPICS
Equity, Gender, Inclusion and the Diversity in Public Policy Politics, Institutions and Political Regimes Social Policy General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P223. Recognition without Authority? Indigenous, Tribal and Adivasi Women in Environmental Governance and Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Bara
ABSTRACT

Who protects the environment, and who governs it? What happens when policies celebrate indigenous/tribal/adivasi (ITA) women’s ecological knowledge and environmental practices, but withhold their autonomy and authority? (ITA deliberately used for contested/ context-specific categories) This panel critically examines recognition, authority, and governance, focusing on the paradox of ITA women's recognition as environmental protectors, alongside their exclusion from decision-making processes. As climate change, biodiversity loss, and environmental degradation intensify, environmental policies increasingly seek to incorporate local, indigenous, and traditional knowledge. However, authority over environmental governance and policy remain largely concentrated within states, markets, and transnational/supranational institutions (Bumpus and Liverman, 2008; Biermann et al., 2012). Existing scholarships document ITA women’s diverse contributions to environmental protection, from forest patrols in Odisha (Mohanty and Suresh 2026) to Garo women’s struggles in Bangladesh (Datta et al. 2026) and Tukano biocultural monitoring in Colombia (Amaya et al. 2025). Despite their increasing recognition as pivotal to environmental protection globally (Singh et al. 2026; UN Climate Security Mechanism [CSM], 2026), their autonomy and authority remains limited. Recognition can cast ITA women as virtuous custodians, adding responsibility without authority (Arora-Jonsson 2011), while rendering their knowledge legible for state and market use (Scott 1998; Nadasdy 1999; Coulthard 2014), risking extraction and romanticization. At the same time, land dispossession, displacement and extractive concessions steadily erode their knowledge and practices. Three gaps emerge from literature: policies recognize knowledge without autonomy and authority; they render it legible without safeguards against extraction or romanticization; and evidence that locally controlled governance conserves better (Dawson et al., 2021) is rarely disaggregated by gender or linked to policy design. Against this backdrop, the panel investigates five interrelated questions: How do ITA women’s ecological knowledge and practices interact with environmental governance and policy? How do land dispossession, displacement and extractive concessions erode them? Does recognition result in extractive and/or romanticized inclusion and under what conditions does it yield autonomy and authority? What does gender-disaggregated evidence show about locally controlled governance? Is a shift from participatory and co-developmental frameworks to shared authority and leadership the way forward? The panel explores several hypotheses: First, policy recognition alone may be insufficient to produce meaningful authority unless accompanied by institutional mechanisms that redistribute decision-making power. Second, governance frameworks that value indigenous knowledge without addressing structural inequalities may facilitate inclusion without empowerment. Third, locally controlled governance arrangements may generate more equitable and effective conservation outcomes when women exercise substantive leadership. Finally, environmental protection outcomes are likely to be strongest where recognition, land rights, and governance authority are institutionalized together. Bringing feminist political ecology, indigenous feminist, intersectional, and decolonial theories, into conversation with public policy analysis, the panel seeks to shift focus from participation to autonomy and authority. Its scientific relevance lies in advancing comparative, gender-disaggregated, and South-South analyses of environmental governance while generating insights for emerging policy frameworks. By asking whether policy coherence on recognition is matched by authority to decide, the panel speaks to the policy topic. It welcomes interdisciplinary contributions from political ecology, law, anthropology, gender studies, public policy, and related fields.

POLICY TOPICS
Equity, Gender, Inclusion and the Diversity in Public Policy
P194. Alcohol and Violence: The Policy Intersect
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
K. Smith
M. Langton
A. Clarke
H. Jordan
ABSTRACT

Alcohol remains a major global public policy challenge. While alcohol consumption is widely embedded within social, cultural, and economic life, it is also associated with a substantial burden of preventable harm, including injury, chronic disease, violence, family and domestic violence, road trauma, community safety concerns, and broader social and economic costs. Governments across jurisdictions continue to grapple with questions regarding the effectiveness, legitimacy, and unintended consequences of different policy responses, including population-level regulation, place-based interventions, treatment and prevention initiatives, industry regulation, and community-led approaches. The relationship between alcohol and violence represents a particularly important area of policy inquiry. Alcohol-related violence occurs across diverse settings, including licensed venues, public spaces, homes, and communities, and disproportionately affects some populations. Despite significant investment in policy reforms and prevention initiatives, considerable debate remains regarding the most effective mechanisms for reducing alcohol-related harm and violence, as well as the role of evidence in informing policy development and implementation. This panel seeks to explore contemporary alcohol policy through the lens of violence prevention, community safety, family and domestic violence, Indigenous health and wellbeing, and social justice. It aims to bring together researchers working across public health, criminology, anthropology, sociology, law, social policy, Indigenous policy, and governance to examine how evidence is produced, mobilised, contested, and translated within alcohol policy environments. The panel will provide an opportunity to examine a range of questions, including: What forms of evidence are most influential in alcohol policy development? How have different jurisdictions responded to alcohol-related violence, and with what outcomes? What role do local communities, Indigenous organisations, governments, health systems, and regulatory agencies play in shaping policy responses? How can policymakers balance public health objectives with considerations of equity, self-determination, economic interests, and individual freedoms? Contributors may explore competing hypotheses regarding the drivers of alcohol-related violence and the relative effectiveness of different policy approaches. These may include hypotheses concerning the role of availability and pricing controls, cultural and social determinants of drinking, place-based regulatory interventions, prevention and early intervention initiatives, community-led governance models, and structural factors that contribute to patterns of violence and harm. Through comparative and interdisciplinary perspectives, the panel seeks to advance understanding of one of the most enduring and contested challenges in contemporary public policy.

POLICY TOPICS
Equity, Gender, Inclusion and the Diversity in Public Policy Other Health and Well-Being Policy Justice Policy
P242. Moving Beyond Barriers: Operationalizing Intersectionality Across Policy Processes
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
G. Hunting
O. Hankivsky
ABSTRACT

Intersectionality is increasingly referenced in policy spaces, but this uptake is often surface-level. It is often brought in late as an add-on, reduced to identity categories that overlook intersecting structures of power, and cut off from its roots in Black feminist thought and social justice activism. This is compounded by intensifying backlash against equity-focused initiatives globally. Demand for guidance has grown alongside this uptake. Governments, international organizations, researchers and community organizations have produced a growing body of frameworks, toolkits and guides, such as Canada’s Gender-Based Analysis Plus, the Intersectionality-Based Policy Analysis Framework (Hankivsky et al. 2012, 2nd edition forthcoming), and UN Women/UNPRPD Intersectionality Resource Guide and Toolkit (2021). Many policy actors also draw on related approaches attentive to power, including antiracist and decolonizing frameworks. The barriers to using such approaches are well documented, in the intersectionality literature and in decades of gender mainstreaming research showing how equity commitments get absorbed into routine procedure and lose their political edge. Far less is known about what people actually do to move past those barriers, what works in which settings, and at what cost to those doing the work. The chairs’ nearly completed 4.5-year program of research, including a critical scoping review of frameworks, as well as interviews, workshops and surveys with international researchers, community actors and policy actors, points to promising, context-specific strategies and examples of successful operationalization that are rarely detailed in the literature. This panel shifts the focus from diagnosis to strategy. It asks what critical operationalization of intersectionality requires and looks like across policy processes, and what researchers, policy actors, decision-makers and community actors are doing to make it happen. Building on critical policy studies, the panel treats policy as a relational and contested process rather than a technical instrument, and covers the full cycle from research generation and use to analysis, design, budgeting, implementation and evaluation. The panel explores four hypotheses. First, intersectional policy work is more likely to change inequity when it addresses intersecting structures of power and not only identity categories, and when it shapes problem definition from the start rather than being added late. Second, epistemic hierarchies determine whose knowledge counts in policy processes, including within intersectionality work itself, so strategies that shift those hierarchies are central to operationalization and not a side issue. Third, reflexivity about positionality and institutional location is a condition of critical practice. Fourth, actors working under backlash or limited support develop strategies such as reframing, coalition building and working from the margins of institutions, and these carry trade-offs between keeping the work alive and watering it down that need closer study. By bringing together empirical, methodological and conceptual work across jurisdictions and sectors, the panel aims to build a shared and practical account of what intersectional policy work looks like when it moves beyond naming barriers, and to connect this to wider debates on policy design, knowledge use and implementation, with the aim of more equitable and effective policy.

POLICY TOPICS
Equity, Gender, Inclusion and the Diversity in Public Policy Politics, Institutions and Political Regimes General Public Policy (no specific sector) Health and Well-Being Policy
P177. Evaluating Public Policy Transitions: Governance, Learning and Democratic Challenges
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Halpern
V. Pattyn
ABSTRACT

Climate change, biodiversity loss, resource scarcity and energy security are increasingly understood as complex public policy problems (Auld et al., 2012 ; Head, 2023). Such challenges are characterised by epistemic uncertainty, controversy, multiple and often competing objectives, long time horizons, interdependencies across policy sectors and levels of government, and interactions among a wide range of public and private actors. Addressing these problems requires governments to act under conditions of incomplete knowledge while simultaneously adapting policies to changing contexts and societal expectations. These characteristics have fuelled growing interest in policy learning, policy capacity and adaptive governance within public policy research (Dunlop & Radaelli, 2013; Howlett & Ramesh, 2015; Dupont et al., 2023). At the same time, these developments challenge conventional approaches to public policy evaluation. Evaluation frameworks have traditionally been designed to assess relatively bounded interventions with clearly defined objectives, stable causal assumptions and measurable outcomes. Yet complex policy problems rarely conform to these conditions. Outcomes emerge through interactions among multiple policies, organisations and contextual factors; objectives evolve over time; and causal relationships are often difficult to identify. In response, evaluation research has increasingly engaged with complexity through approaches such as developmental evaluation, systems evaluation, reflexive evaluation, contribution analysis and complexity-aware monitoring and evaluation (Patton, 2011; Leeuw, 2012; Bamberger, Vaessen & Raimondo, 2016; Nabielek and Kunseler, 2026). Rather than focusing exclusively on accountability and performance measurement or relying solely on expert-led assessments, these approaches emphasise learning, adaptation, reflexivity and decision-making under conditions of uncertainty. This “complexity turn” in evaluation research resonates strongly with recent developments in public policy scholarship (Cashore, forth). Research on policy learning has examined how policymakers, administrations and stakeholders acquire, interpret and use knowledge in situations characterised by ambiguity, contestation and uncertainty (Dunlop & Radaelli, 2013; Dupont et al., 2023). Similarly, the literature on policy capacity has highlighted the analytical, operational and political capabilities required to design, coordinate and adapt policies addressing complex and systemic challenges (Howlett & Ramesh, 2015). Recent contributions in evaluation research have further argued that evaluation should be understood not only as an accountability mechanism, but also as means of supporting adaptive governance, learning and capacity-building (Pattyn, 2019). The panel aims to contribute to ongoing debates on how governments can develop the capacities required to govern transformative change while safeguarding democratic legitimacy, accountability and collective learning. It addresses the following question: what role can evaluation play in strengthening governance, policy learning and policy capacity in contexts of long-term systemic change? Three hypotheses guide the discussion. First, public policy transitions challenge conventional evaluation approaches as well as the underlying rationales for evaluation (Stern, 2024), which often rely on predefined objectives, stable and linear causal assumptions and short-term performance indicators. Second, evaluation can support policy learning by generating knowledge that enables adaptation, experimentation and coordination under conditions of uncertainty. Third, evaluation may contribute to policy capacity and adaptive governance by strengthening governments’ ability to analyse, navigate and govern complex processes of transformative change.

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Evaluation Policy Transfer/Diffusion/Learning Environment and Climate Policy General Public Policy (no specific sector)
P293. Beyond Unintended Consequences: Toward a Theory of Policy Side Effects
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Y. Choi
A. Fox
ABSTRACT

How do the consequences of a policy become a source of social problems? This inquiry has been enduring in the social sciences and has generated a long line of research. In an idealized account of the policy process, policies are conceived as deliberate solutions to social problems or designed to benefit particular groups without harming others. In practice, however, policies oftentimes give rise to new problems, whether unintentionally or at times intentionally. This paradox is common, and we can find rich examples: e.g., stricter enforcement has been found to widen social disparities in the justice system, minimum wage increases have been linked to higher unemployment, and raising the legal drinking age has been associated with riskier patterns of alcohol consumption. Social science scholars have long recognized them. Robert K. Merton in 1936 and Aaron Wildavsky in 1980, for example, already drew attention to policy side effects, which they framed as unanticipated or unintended consequences. Economists and policy analysts have since developed sophisticated tools for assessing policy trade-offs, such as cost-benefit analysis and cost-effectiveness analysis, which are widely used in policymaking practice today. In political science, policy feedback theory explains how policies reshape politics by structuring political behaviors and decision-making. However, these early insights have yet to be integrated into public policy scholarship in ways that address the practical challenges of managing policy side effects. Framed as unintended or unanticipated consequences, side effects have often been treated as unpredictable. Some, however, may follow generalizable or tractable patterns amenable to systematic investigation and theorization. This need is especially evident in responses to national emergencies, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, financial crises, and natural disasters, where governments implement strong, when governments adopt strong, far-reaching policies that affect individuals and society along multiple dimensions. Recognizing this gap in the policy literature, this panel seeks to open an academic discussion on policy side effects as a phenomenon that can be systematically investigated and theorized, and invites papers that examine them theoretically or empirically. To explore this possibility, the panel aims to identify the conditions and mechanisms through which policies produce side effects, and to understand how these consequences come to be recognized, contested, and addressed as social problems. Questions of interest include, but are not limited to, the following: - Which policy side effects are predictable, and how can they be better anticipated? - What are the social and political ramifications of policy side effects? - How and under what conditions do policies produce side effects? - To what extent are policy side effects socially constructed? - What moral dilemmas arise in implementing policies whose side effects are anticipated? - How can side effects be monitored and mitigated, and do mitigating measures create new problems?

POLICY TOPICS
Policy Evaluation
P107. Bringing space and place into education policy analysis and practice
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Fontdevila
A. Giudici
A. Zancajo
ABSTRACT

Place and space are becoming increasingly relevant in the design, implementation and evaluation of public policies. Whether interventions should be tailored to local contexts or remain spatially blind has been intensely debated in the regional development policy literature (Barca et al., 2012). More recently, persistent territorial disparities, geographically uneven effects of major economic and social trends, and related discontent have brought into prominence place-based policies that account for variations in local needs and capacities across various domains (Beer et al., 2020). Yet, these debates have centred on whether interventions should be place-based, with less attention to the tools and policy processes through which such approaches are designed, governed and implemented (Klepac et al., 2023). Education, moreover, has largely remained at the margins of these debates. Despite the role it plays for local communities, the implications of place-based approaches for education policy have received relatively scant attention. While the spatial turn in education has brought into sharp relief the uneven distribution of provision and its role in shaping educational inequalities (Butler & Hamnett, 2007; Lubienski & Lee, 2017), there has been limited engagement with developments in public policy studies that emphasise that policy processes and instruments shape and are shaped by these spatial patterns (Brenner, 2004; Michener, 2018). Indeed, research examining the relationship between place, space and education policy is still emerging and fragmentary, with little dialogue between different approaches to space and place, and between different scales and dimensions of spatial inequalities. This contrasts with the more systematic engagement with spatial perspectives found in other areas such as public health, environmental policy or urban planning (Stead, 2021; Hannum et al., 2025). This panel seeks to bring spatial perspectives on education into dialogue with public policy studies. Several theories of the policy process already carry a spatial dimension, from the place-bound construction of target populations (Sidney, 2005) to spatial policy instruments (Stead, 2021) and territorially uneven feedback effects (Michener, 2018), although their potential for education policy analysis remains largely unexplored. The panel thus builds on the premise that connecting these perspectives can deepen our understanding of how education policies shape, and are shaped by, space and place. This dialogue offers three main advantages. First, it invites us to consider how spatial inequalities are constituted as a policy problem, and how places and their populations are constructed as policy targets, drawing on the social constructionist approach (Schneider & Ingram, 1993). Second, it connects levels of analysis that are typically addressed separately, including territorial disparities between subnational units; the distribution of resources within education systems; and the spatial imaginaries and strategies mobilised by different actors to navigate spatially uneven opportunities. This directly speaks to research on multilevel governance and the role of local contexts in the implementation of public policies (Hooghe & Marks, 2003; Sausman et al., 2016). Third, it creates opportunities for methodological cross-fertilisation, by bringing approaches extending beyond quantitative GIS (such as qualitative GIS and spatial ethnography) into dialogue with public policy analysis and thus broadening the analytical repertoire for studying the spatial dimensions of education policy. By drawing together researchers working on spatial inequalities related to education policy, the panel addresses four questions: - What are the theoretical, analytical and normative implications of foregrounding the spatial and place-based dimension in education policy analysis? - What methodological approaches and advances can best support the analysis of education policy from spatial and place-based perspectives? - How do spatial inequalities shape the design, implementation and effectiveness of education policy instruments? - What is the potential of place-based and place-sensitive approaches for more effectively addressing spatial inequalities in education, and how can education policy incorporate them? References Barca, F., McCann, P., & Rodríguez‐Pose, A. (2012). The case for regional development intervention: place‐based versus place‐neutral approaches. Journal of Regional Science, 52(1), 134-152. Beer, A., McKenzie, F., Blažek, J., Sotarauta, M., & Ayres, S. (2020). Every place matters. Routledge. Brenner, N. (2004). New state spaces: Urban governance and the rescaling of statehood. Oxford University Press. Butler, T., & Hamnett, C. (2007). The geography of education. Urban Studies, 44(7), 1161-1174. Hannum, K., Wellstead, A. M., Howlett, M., & Gofen, A. (2025). Leveraging GIS for policy design: Spatial analytics as a strategic tool. Policy Design and Practice, 8(1), 35–49. Hooghe, L., & Marks, G. (2003). Unraveling the central state, but how? Types of multi-level governance. American Political Science Review, 97(2), 233-243. Klepac, B., Mowle, A., Riley, T., & Craike, M. (2023). Government, governance, and place-based approaches: Lessons from and for public policy. Health Research Policy and Systems, 21, 126. Lubienski, C., & Lee, J. (2017). Geo‐spatial analyses in education research. Geographical Research, 55(1), 89-99. Michener, J. (2018). Fragmented democracy: Medicaid, federalism, and unequal politics. Cambridge University Press. Sausman, C., Oborn, E., & Barrett, M. (2016). Policy translation through localisation: implementing national policy in the UK. Policy & Politics, 44(4), 563-589. Schneider, A., & Ingram, H. (1993). Social construction of target populations. American Political Science Review, 87(2), 334–347. Sidney, M. S. (2005). Contested images of race and place: The politics of housing discrimination. In A. L. Schneider & H. M. Ingram (Eds.), Deserving and entitled: Social constructions and public policy (pp. 111–137). SUNY Press. Stead, D. (2021). Conceptualizing the policy tools of spatial planning. Journal of Planning Literature, 36(3), 297–311.

POLICY TOPICS
Other Education Policy
P213. Non-Western Innovation Policy: Direction, Value and Institutions
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Chafik
W. Drechsler
Y. Yan
ABSTRACT

Across three themes, this panel examines how innovation policy unfolds in the context of non-Western (Buddhist, Confucian, Islamic, and beyond) governance traditions. The first theme is direction: from a specific industry to the larger techno-economic path, what and who determines where resources and effort are aimed, and on what grounds. The second is value: what accounts of public benefit and of human flourishing underwrite those determinations of innovation policy. The third is institutions: what organisational and legal forms have embodied those accounts and directed collective effort in practice. Research Questions - What (historical or contemporary) accounts of direction, value and institutional form do non-Western governance traditions supply, and how do these differ from those within mainstream (global-Western) innovation policy? - Where such traditions influence innovation policy in practice – whether explicitly invoked, quietly operative or negotiated vis-à-vis imported models – what difference do they make to instruments, processes, and outcomes? - Which categories of contemporary innovation policy prove parochial under this comparison, which travel – and in case of the latter, where (within the governance tradition or beyond?) A core objective of the panel is to produce a special issue (target: Journal of Responsible Innovation) consolidating the scholarly findings and contributions. Scientific relevance After post-war R&D and national systems of innovation, transformative change has emerged as a third framing for innovation policy (Schot & Steinmueller 2018), alongside a normative turn across the field toward the values and orientations underlying innovation. For the latter, mainstream policy and scholarship have largely remained procedural, with ethical concerns diluted into checklists that often reinscribe the very structures that responsible innovation in particular set out to challenge (Pansera 2025). Directionality, understood as making social choices over alternative pathways of development, has been one promising area of scholarship, although the focus is mostly on how direction is set as opposed to what direction is (normatively) worth setting (Stilgoe et al. 2013). Emerging work on mission-oriented approaches asks how public organisations should be structured and how risks and rewards shared (Mazzucato et al. 2020), and on dynamic capabilities asks not what states possess in terms of resources but what they must be able to do (Kattel 2022). Yet societal goals and values themselves are largely taken from existing international consensus – some of which are plausibly common to all human societies. This panel, however, seeks to investigate precisely the area(s) of difference and their provenance (Drechsler et al. 2025). Recent comparative work makes the limit visible: a study of DARPA, China’s New Energy Vehicle Plan and EU smart specialisation distinguishes challenge-based entrepreneurialism, hierarchy-based experimentalism and rule-based proceduralism (Gronchi 2026). Institutional variety is therefore already legible to the field, yet read as variation in implementation rather than in purpose. As such, treating non-Western governance traditions as sources of substantive normative content makes this panel a timely contribution to innovation policy scholarship, but also a concrete decolonisation effort by foreground these sources on equal terms with those from the global-Western in facilitating dialogues across different traditions (Yan 2026).

POLICY TOPICS
Other
P249. Policy impacts on End-of-Life Decisions
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Stewart
ABSTRACT

Research QuestionHow do government policies and regulations shape individual and population health and health behaviours at the end of life? What empirical, theoretical, and methodological tools best identify these causal effects?We invite contributions that engage with topics related to aging, dementia, serious illness, and end-of-life care. How do financing, delivery models, and legal frameworks influence diagnosis, caregiving burden, care quality, place of death, and costs for older adults and people living with dementia? What are the effects of long-term care policy, guardianship rules, MAID/assisted dying statutes, advance-care planning, and palliative/hospice integration on outcomes and equity? How does policy change individuals’ end-of-life decisions?Context Health care is a central issue for many families and represents a large share of government budgets in most countries. Health and health care interact with economic, demographic, environmental, political conditions and often involve difficult tradeoffs between competing moral goals. Aging populations, climate and heat risks, medical care costs, technological change, shifting industrial structure, and evolving social norms further complicate the policy landscape. Understanding the effects of public policies on health and other life course outcomes is essential for policy planning to address efficiency and equity issues. Policy relevant research by economists, demographers, sociologists, political scientists, epidemiologists is important in estimating causal relationships, illuminating underlying causal mechanisms, and identifying problems, unmet needs, and unintended consequences. Institutional analysis and implementation science also have an important role to play. Governments increasingly face choices that trade off near-term fiscal sustainability against long-term health outcomes; high-cost therapies against equitable access; standardization against local tailoring. The panel situates itself at this intersection: we seek work that is methodologically strong and policy-relevent, sensitive to institutional detail, and attentive to distributional consequences.State of the Art Three currents define today’s frontier:Causal Inference & Novel Data. Advances in econometric and machine learning tools combined with increasingly rich administrative and clinical datasets (claims, EMR, registries, mortality linkages) have enabled research on a wider range of research questions that are relevant to health policy.Health and Social Tradeoffs. Environmental exposures, social determinants, and public health infrastructure interact with medical care in complex ways. Evidence on how to design policies that are robust to behavioral adaptation, provider gaming, and geographic heterogeneity has a high priority. And research that clarifies tradeoffs between alternative social goals is of central importance.

POLICY TOPICS
Other Health and Well-Being Policy
No panel matches your filters.