Format

P165. Selling Reforms Across Borders: A Global Market for Policy Advice?

Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process / State and Policy Capacity
PANEL CHAIR(S)
claire Visier
Université Rennes I
Main chair
Marylou HAMM
Université Rennes I
Second chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
Knowledge, Science and Expertise in Policy Process State and Policy Capacity
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
Policy advice Expertise and Consultancy Markets Reform Assistance
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

European public policy and development aid are increasingly shaped by projectification: the spread of projects as a pervasive mode of organization, underpinned by a growing emphasis on evaluation, accountability, and performance.
In development aid, this mode of governance has a long history. It grew out of concerns over financial control and a persistent distrust of recipient states, and has been reinforced by the “NGO-isation” of aid and the proliferation of intermediaries (Bierschenk, Chauveau and Olivier de Sardan, 2000; Mosse, 2005; Lewis and Mosse, 2006). The European Union can be understood as a form of ‘government at a distance’ that increasingly delegates the design and implementation of its policies to projects (Büttner and Leopold, 2016). is the EU is both a site where project-based practices are deployed and an actor that actively promotes their diffusion in its internal and external policies alike (Thyrard, Hamm and Lebrou, 2026). It is a major provider of development aid and technical assistance to third countries, both in the Global South and in its own neighbourhood (Visier and Dakowska, 2018). More recently, it has significantly extended this approach to its own member states through technical assistance for structural reforms (Hamm, 2025).
Projectification thus constitutes a distinctive “social world” (Büttner and Leopold, 2016), marked by the growing involvement of consultancies and external experts. These actors provide flexibility, specialized methods, and expertise for time-limited assignments, ranging from programme design and funding to implementation (Béland and al., cited in Seabrooke and Sending, 2019).
Recent studies have examined these actors and their roles in a range of settings:development and public policy in the Global South (Boughedada, 2023, 2026; Aguillon and Al Dabaghy, 2024; Aguillon, 2022; Bourblanc, 2021; Bredeloup, 2019); the functioningof EU institutions and policy processes (Thyrard, Hamm and Lebrou, 2025, 2026); or European interventions in neighbouring countries (Bonnard and Robert, 2020).
These studies do resist reducing such a heterogeneous population to a single, a priori definition. Yet there is still little systematic, comparative research on the full range of actors involved in technical assistance and reform support. They work under different contractual arrangements, for different donors and across different regions.
This panel sets out to map the contours of the transnational market for consultancy and other technical assistance in support of public sector reform. It brings together empirically grounded studies spanning different geographical contexts, policy sectors, and categories of consultants and experts. It also offers an opportunity to compare and discuss the conceptual frameworks through which projectification and consulting practices have been studied. These draw on several intellectual traditions: political science and the sociology of public policy, transnational governance and transnational circulation of policy ideas and model, political economy, development economics, and the socio-anthropology of development.

CALL FOR PAPERS

This panel welcomes case studies of experts advising on state reform, funded by various donors, across sectors and geographical contexts. Papers should present empirical findings. Approaches may include, for example, network analysis, open EU data, prosopography or more ethnographic methods. Papers should make their conceptual framework explicit, so that the panel can discuss whether and how concepts travel across research traditions.
Each paper should address at least one of the following questions.
1. A single market or many? Does the expertise mobilised in state reform assistance form a single transnational market, with shared rules, actors and circulations? Or is it made of distinct segments, structured by geography (North/South, EU/neighbourhood/third countries, intra-EU), national institutional contexts, donors or sectors? Are these segments insulated or hierarchically interconnected? To what extent do these hierarchies reproduce historical legacies?
2. How is the market changing? Reform assistance to the EU’s Eastern member states fuelled aid flows and brought new experts onto the market (Tulmets, 2013). How do these newcomers integrate? More recently, how is the market being reshaped by the sharp decline in development aid since 2025 (dismantling of USAID, budget cuts, reallocations in OECD countries), the growing emphasis on national security, defence and geopolitical stability, or the shift towards performance-based public policy through “structural reforms” in EU member states?
3. What does market structure do to public policy? How do segments, hierarchies, entry barriers, tendering rules and intermediary chains shape the effects of expertise on reforms? Do findings confirm or challenge overarching approaches that see consulting as private capture and hollowing out of the state (Mazzucato and Collington, 2023), or as depoliticisation and North/South domination (Ferguson, 1990; Mitchell, 2002; Escobar, 1995)?
Two complementary entry points are proposed.
- Calls for tender, where donors’ demand for expertise meets the supply of consultants and experts. They define budgets, eligibility criteria, expected profiles, procedures and consortium composition. Do these rules produce a homogeneous market, or do differences between donors, regions and policy areas sustain distinct markets with their own barriers to entry and networks of operators? How might funding cuts affect intermediary chains?
-Individual and collective expert trajectories. Mobility, and its barriers, reveal market hierarchies: research on transnational circulation of elites and knowledge shows it is neither unrestricted nor symmetrical (Dezalay and Garth, 2002; Seabrooke and Henriksen, 2017). The anthropology of development has examined brokers (Bierschenk, Chauveau and Olivier de Sardan, 2000), translators and aid workers within hierarchies, including the “international”/”national” expert divide (Lewis and Mosse, 2006; Fechter and Hindman, 2011). Do experts move across contexts or sectors, in which directions, and with what resources (qualifications, networks, status, nationality)? Trajectories help establish whether the market is integrated, hierarchical or fragmented, and whether its hierarchies reproduce colonial and developmentalist legacies.