Format

W03. Implementing Inequities – Street-Level Bureaucracy in the Weak Institutions

Policy implementation, Street-level bureaucrats
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Rik Peeters
CIDE
Main chair
Taly Reininger
Universidad de Chile
Second chair
Gianinna MuñozArce
Universidad de Chile
Third chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
Policy implementation, Street-level bureaucrats
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

What laws formally guarantee, politicians promise, and public policies aim to achieve needs to be materialized in our daily interactions with public organizations. There, we often encounter street-level bureaucrats, low-ranking public servants, or frontline workers who process our applications for a social benefit, provide access to public services such as health care or education, and enforce traffic and safety regulations. The academic literature has established a common ground in understanding these civil servants. It is well-documented, for instance, that street-level bureaucrats, or frontline workers, shape policies and public services rather than merely implement them (Lipsky, 1980; Maynard-Moody & Musheno, 2003). They do not simply apply formal rules to individual cases. Instead, a hospital’s emergency staff decides which patients to attend to first, police officers on the street decide whom to pull over and how to treat each specific case, and social workers negotiate with their clients about treatment plans. Although the specific organizational and work context matters, street-level bureaucrats always have some form of discretion in the way they interpret, apply, or bend the rules and deal with citizens (Hupe & Hill, 2007; Evans, 2011).

 

What happens in street-level bureaucracies, however, when basic resources are not provided or are simply non-existing? Or when adverse working conditions limit the extent to which job expectations and client demands can be met? For example, in many places, nurses and medics face a lack of basic materials to provide health care. Police officers are expected to enforce rules in violent urban contexts or remote rural areas. Desk clerks have to make decisions in the absence of clear formal guidelines. And many social workers lack the means to attend to the problems of highly marginalized communities. This panel is about those street-level bureaucrats and seeks to contribute to understanding how structurally adverse working conditions affect bureaucrats’ decisions and behavior and how these impact policy implementation and citizen-state interactions. Rather than understanding street-level bureaucratic behavior and decision-making as a “collection of isolated individual actions” (Gofen, 2014: 485), we tap into a strand of research that highlights the way organizational contexts (May & Winter, 2009; Brodkin, 2012), societal expectations (Sandfort, 2000; Møller & Stensøta, 2019), formal rule systems and accountability regimes (Hupe & Hill, 2007), and professional networks and deliberation (Møller, 2021) shape frontline work.

 

More specifically, this panel builds upon studies that draw attention to contexts where street-level bureaucrats commonly face adverse social and working conditions, such as precarity, instability, and endemic violence or corruption (Peeters & Campos, 2022). Most research on street-level bureaucracy has historically been conducted in countries characterized by high levels of administrative capacity, professional bureaucracies, stable rules of law, and in industrialized and often democratic societies (Bertelli et al., 2020). However, most of the world’s street-level bureaucrats work under very different institutional conditions. Politicized bureaucracies, low social trust in government, systemic corruption, precarious labor conditions, and limited state capacities are common traits of bureaucracies in developing countries and post-authoritarian regimes (Lotta et al., 2021). This panel contributes to decolonizing studies on street-level bureaucracy by questioning assumptions about the nature of North and South bureaucracies and the way weak state capacities, patchy service provision, contested state legitimacy, and social inequalities play out in street-level interactions between citizens and the state (Eiró & Lotta, 2023).

 

The panel seeks to further our understanding of the way social inequalities fundamentally affect state-citizen relationships and how the street-level bureaucracies reflect and often reproduce these inequalities (Eiró & Lotta, 2023). Specific topics of relevance include – but are not limited to – the variety of strategies street-level bureaucrats develop to cope with extreme “public service gaps” (Hupe & Buffat, 2014), how territorial differences in policy implementation produce “fragmented stateness” (Perelmiter, 2021), the informalization of street-level interactions in the form of petty corruption (Blundo, 2006), the consequences of street-level bureaucrats’ embeddedness in the communities they serve (Bhavnani & Lee, 2018; Mangla, 2022), and the brokerage function of street-level bureaucrats in “relational states” (Peake & Forsyth, 2022). We hope that bringing forward research on these topics will prove key to decolonizing studies of street-level bureaucracy and to understanding citizen-state encounters across the globe.

 

We welcome papers of all kinds of methods and approaches (public administration, ethnography, political science, etc.) in this panel. Although we aim primarily for scholars studying the Global South, we explicitly do not exclude papers presenting relevant research from other parts of the world. Paper submissions may be theoretical, methodological, or empirical. Relevant topics for this panel include:

-          Street-level bureaucracy and social inequality

-          Comparative studies of street-level bureaucracy

-          Street-level bureaucracy in the Global South

-          Contested citizen-bureaucrat interactions

-          Political influences on street-level bureaucracy

-          State and administrative capacity / institutional weakness and street-level bureaucracy

-          Decolonial approaches to street-level bureaucracy

 

The panel is part of a broader community of scholars working on topics of street-level bureaucracy and frontline work in the Global South, particularly Latin America. During the IWPP 2024, we intend to present the findings from a book project (currently in production with Policy Press: https://policy.bristoluniversitypress.co.uk/street-level-bureaucracy-in-weak-state-institutions) as well as report on initial findings from the Working Group on ‘Street-Level Bureaucracy and Inequalities in Latin America’ of the Latin American Council of Social Sciences (CLACSO - https://www.clacso.org/burocracia-a-nivel-de-calle-y-desigualdades/). We will actively pursue publication strategies for papers presented at the IWPP 2024. To promote feedback and facilitate community building, all contributing authors to the panel will be asked to prepare comments on one of the other submitted papers to the IWPP 2024.

 

 

References

 

Bertelli, A.M., Hassan, M., Honig, D., Rogger, D., & Williams, M.J. (2020). An Agenda for the Study of Public Administration in Developing Countries. Governance, 33(4), 735-748.

Bhavnani, R.R., & Lee, A. (2018). Local Embeddedness and Bureaucratic Performance: Evidence from India. The Journal of Politics, 80(1), 71–87.

Blundo, G. (2006). Dealing With the Local State: The Informal Privatization of Street-Level Bureaucracies in Senegal. Development And Change, 37(4): 799–819.

Brodkin, E. Z. (2012). Reflections on Street-Level Bureaucracy: Past, Present, and Future. Public Administration Review, 72(6), 940-949.

Eiró, F. & Lotta, G. (2023). On the frontline of global inequalities: A decolonial approach to the study of street-level bureaucracies, Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/muad019.

Evans, T. (2011). Professionals, Managers and Discretion: Critiquing Street-Level Bureaucracy. British Journal of Social Work, 41(2), 368–386.

Gofen, A. (2014). Mind the Gap: Dimensions and Influence of Street-Level Divergence. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 24(2), 473-493.

Hupe, P., & Buffat, A. (2014). A Public Service Gap: Capturing Contexts in a Comparative Approach of Street-Level Bureaucracy. Public Management Review, 16(4), 548–569.

Hupe, P., & Hill, M. (2007). Street-Level Bureaucracy and Public Accountability. Public Administration, 85(2), 279–299.

Lipsky, M. (1980 [2010]). Street-Level Bureaucracy. Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services [30th Anniversary Expanded Edition]. New York, U.S.A.: Russell Sage Foundation.

Lotta, G., Lima-Silva, F., & Favareto, A. (2021). Dealing with violence: Varied reactions from frontline workers acting in highly vulnerable territories. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space, 23996544211031560.

Mangla, A. (2022). Making Bureaucracy Work: Norms, Education and Public Service Delivery in Rural India. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

May, P. & Winter, S. (2009). Politicians, managers, and street-level bureaucrats: Influences on policy implementation. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 19(3), 453-476.

Maynard-Moody, S.W. & Musheno, M. C. (2003). Cops, Teachers, Counselors: Stories from the Front Lines of Public Service. University of Michigan Press.

Møller, A.M. (2021). Deliberation and Deliberative Organizational Routines in Frontline Decision-Making, Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 31(3), 471–488.

Møller, M.Ø., & Stensöta, H.O. (2019). Welfare state regimes and caseworkers’ problem explanation. Administration & Society, 51(9), 1425-1454.

Peake, G., & Forsyth, M. (2022). Street-level bureaucrats in a relational state: The case of Bougainville. Public Administration and Development, 42(1), 12‑21. https://doi.org/10.1002/pad.1911

Peeters, R. & Campos, S.A. (2022). Street-level bureaucracy in weak state institutions: a systematic review of the literature. International Review of Administrative Sciences. https://doi.org/10.1177/00208523221103196.

Perelmiter, L. (2021). “Fairness” in an unequal society: Welfare workers, labor inspectors and the embedded moralities of street-level bureaucracy in Argentina. Public Administration and Development, 1– 10. https://doi.org/10.1002/pad.1954.

Sandfort, J.R. (2000). Moving Beyond Discretion and Outcomes: Examining Public Management from the Front Lines of the Welfare System. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 10(4), 729-756.

CALL FOR PAPERS

This panel seeks to contribute to decolonizing studies on street-level bureaucracy by questioning assumptions about the nature of North and South bureaucracies and the way weak state capacities, patchy service provision, contested state legitimacy, and social inequalities play out in street-level interactions between citizens and the state. Discussions and presentations in this panel are aimed at improving our understanding of the way social inequalities fundamentally affect state-citizen relationships and how the street-level bureaucracies reflect and often reproduce these inequalities. Specific topics of relevance include – but are not limited to – the variety of strategies street-level bureaucrats develop to cope with overdemand and resource shortages, how territorial differences in policy implementation produce inequalities, the informalization of street-level interactions with citizens, the consequences of street-level bureaucrats’ embeddedness and the brokerage function of street-level bureaucrats in the communities they serve.

 

We welcome papers of all kinds of methods and approaches (public administration, ethnography, political science, etc.) in this panel. Although we aim primarily for scholars studying the Global South, we explicitly do not exclude papers presenting relevant research from other parts of the world. Paper submissions may be theoretical, methodological, or empirical. Relevant topics for this panel include:

-          Street-level bureaucracy and social inequality

-          Comparative studies of street-level bureaucracy

-          Street-level bureaucracy in the Global South

-          Contested citizen-bureaucrat interactions

-          Political influences on street-level bureaucracy

-          State and administrative capacity / institutional weakness and street-level bureaucracy

-          Decolonial approaches to street-level bureaucracy

ABSTRACT

What laws formally guarantee, politicians promise, and public policies aim to achieve needs to be materialized in our daily interactions with public organizations. There, we often encounter street-level bureaucrats, low-ranking public servants, or frontline workers who process our applications for a social benefit, provide access to public services such as health care or education, and enforce traffic and safety regulations. What happens in street-level bureaucracies, however, when basic resources are not provided or are simply non-existing? Or when adverse working conditions limit the extent to which job expectations and client demands can be met? This panel is about those street-level bureaucrats and seeks to contribute to understanding how structurally adverse working conditions affect bureaucrats´ decisions and behavior and how these impact policy implementation and citizen-state interactions.

 

We build upon studies that draw attention to contexts where street-level bureaucrats commonly face adverse social and working conditions, such as precarity, instability, and endemic violence or corruption – common for the Global South or other weak institutional contexts. Specifically, the aim of this panel is contributing to decolonizing studies on street-level bureaucracy by questioning assumptions about the nature of North and South bureaucracies and the way weak state capacities, patchy service provision, contested state legitimacy, and social inequalities play out in street-level interactions between citizens and the state. Discussions and presentations in this panel are aimed at improving our understanding of the way social inequalities fundamentally affect state-citizen relationships and how the street-level bureaucracies reflect and often reproduce these inequalities.

BIOGRAPHICAL PRESENTATION

Taly Reininger

Taly Reininger earned her PhD in Social Work and Social Welfare from Fordham University in New York. She is currently an Assistant Professor at the Department of Social Work, University of Chile. Her research interests include social policy, program implementation, and poverty and inequality. She has recently published on the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on social program implementation, front-line professional resistance, as well as the implementation of Chile’s Conditional Cash Transfer Program.

 

Gianinna Múñoz Arce

Gianinna Muñoz Arce holds a PhD in Social Work from Bristol University (UK). She is Associate Professor at the Department of Social Work, University of Chile. Her research interests are critical theory, social intervention, and social work. She teaches Social Work Theoretical Approaches in several PhD programs in Social Work (La Plata University, Argentina, and Alberto Hurtado University, Chile). Her recent publications include “Decolonising community social work: contributions of front-line professional resistances from a Mapuche perspective” (Critical and Radical Social Work) and “Decolonial feminism and practices of resistance to sustain life: experiences of women social workers implementing mental health programmes in Chile” (Affilia).

 

Rik Peeters

Rik Peeters is associate professor of public administration at the Center for Research and Teaching in Economics (CIDE) in Mexico City. His main research interests are street-level bureaucracy, citizen-state interactions, and digital government. In recent publications, he has analyzed street-level interactions in social programs, the distributive effects of administrative burdens, and the digitalization of citizen-state interactions.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Sostenibilidad de la vida e implementación de políticas sociales: propuestas en clave feminista.
Mitzi Duboy (Universidad Alberto Hurtado)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Las políticas sociales en América Latina han estado construidas en lógicas desde un ethos que fortalece condiciones laborales de precarización, que brindan escasos recursos para la ejecución de los programas y que están atravesadas por problemas de corrupción. Dichos problemas también han sido experimentados por quienes implementan las políticas sociales en Chile. Así, se han detectando muchas de estas lógicas de precarización en los ejercicios profesionales de quienes implementan programas sociales, en las consecuencias que el Estado tiene en la vida de las personas, en la forma en cómo el Estado se despliega en el territorio para la aplicación de estas políticas y en el mecanismo a través del cual se despliega esa relación. Sumado a lo anterior, reciente literatura a puesto en la palestra los efectos generizados para quienes implementan las políticas sociales, es decir, que hay una forma de ejercer la discreción profesional que se distingue por género. En esta línea, se ha mostrado como la implementación de las políticas sociales sostiene una posición desfavorable para las mujeres, tanto laboral como relacionalmente y, a su vez, han afirmado la idea de que la discreción profesional también tiene manifestaciones generizadas.

Aunque estos enfoques han ampliado la forma de entender la implementación de políticas, no se han preocupado especialmente por enlazar la relación entre políticas sociales y la sostenibilidad de la vida.

Por lo mismo, en esta ponencia desarrollaré un abordaje que entrelaza el enfoque de la sostenibilidad de la vida y la implementación de políticas sociales, con la intención de generar algunas propuestas que emanan de la práctica de ejercicios de discreción profesional y de las resistencias profesionales, de quienes implementan programas sociales en Chile. Estas reflexiones emergen de resultados de investigación de dos proyectos Fondecyt Regulares en los que he participado. Aunque ninguno de estos partió problematizando las relaciones de género ni los feminismos, los relatos de quienes han participado de la investigación no han tardado en mostrar una infinidad de imbricaciones posibles, lo cual me/nos ha invitado a pensar estos cruces que han visto la luz en dos artículos académicos dedicados específicamente a mostrar resultados de investigación leídos desde este marco (Duboy-Luengo & Muñoz-Arce, 2022; Muñoz-Arce & Duboy-Luengo, 2023). Sin embargo, lo que hoy (me) propongo, es ampliar la mirada para proponer insumos que, desde el enfoque de sostenibilidad de la vida, contribuyan en tres direcciones: hacia quienes implementan políticas sociales; hacia quienes diseñan políticas sociales, y; hacia quienes enseñan estas materias en los diferentes espacios educativos.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - How to resist a “scientifically” validated program? Street Level Bureaucracy in the relationship of science, technology and society network based on a mental health program in Chile.
Cristóbal Villalobos (Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Incipiently, research on street-level bureaucracy in Latin America has investigated how implementers questioning, resist, and transform the political-institutional frameworks from which social interventions are built. In the region, these processes of resistance and agency occur mainly around relatively new programs, with little evidence of their impact and organized mainly under the logic of New Public Management (NPM). In this context, in this presentation we ask ourselves, how are the processes of professional resistance articulated and developed in the face of a “scientifically” validated program? Starting from the conceptual articulation between the theories of professional resistance, the analyzes of street-level bureaucracy and the of actor-network theory, we study the motivations, implications and processes of resistance that occur in the Skills for Life Program (Habilidades Para la Vida, HpV in Spanish), the largest mental health program for children and adolescents in Chilean schools. Based on an analysis of 23 semi-structured and group interviews, as well as the analysis of the available documentation of the program, the preliminary results show that the empirical evidence of the program acts as a blanket of validation of the national strategies and guidelines, limiting the possibility of resistance at the local level. Likewise, we find that resistance is articulated by seeking to promote new evidence - rather than questioning the criteria with which it is constructed - showing the interweaving between professional resistance, implementation of policies and validation and scientific production in social programs in Latin America.

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Analysis of primary school teachers' attention to cases of family violence, through the theoretical model of street-level bureaucracies
Cynthia Lucía Carpio Valencia (El Colegio de Sonora)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In Mexico, emergency calls due to family violence represented, during 2023 (January-November), 3.8% of total actual calls. In turn, the State of Sonora occupied (in the same period) the first place nationally in reports for this reason with a record of 44,787 calls (SSP,2023). The main victims of family violence are women, girls and boys. In all cases, girls and boys are victims of psychological violence due to being exposed to and witnessing the acts of violence that occur against women, and where they can also be directly attacked (UNICEF, 2019). For their part, schools are obliged to report all cases of violence against children and adolescents (NNA), which arise in the school, family and community space (DOF, 2019). For this, action protocols have been generated. In this sense, this article argues why it is relevant to use the theoretical model of street-level bureaucracies for the analysis of the process of attention to cases of family violence from the participation of teachers.

The theoretical model of street-level bureaucracies proposed by Lipsky (1980) redefined the perspective with which the implementation of public policies was traditionally analyzed, to emphasize the actions of the people who apply certain policies - especially the bureaucrats who are at the end of the hierarchical chain, who serve the recipients and beneficiaries of a certain service or government program.

The relevance of this model is based on the fact that it is a theoretical proposal for the analysis of the process of implementing a public policy, which recognizes in the foundational work the figure of teachers as street-level bureaucrats. The characterization of Maynard and Portillo (2014) constitutes a guide to analyze the practices of teachers regarding one of their functions - compliance with action protocols in cases of violence-. Likewise, the notion of coping strategies (copin) explains the different ways in which public servants cope with the demands of the job. This notion constitutes an incorporation of psychology into this conceptual framework. Furthermore, the theory of street-level bureaucracy recognizes the importance of the contextual elements where people operate, which is particularly useful for the analysis of this research where schools are located in areas of high marginality.

With all this, we seek to argue that this theoretical model allows us to analyze a research problem from a perspective that has been little studied in Mexico and provides theoretical-methodological elements that allow us to delve deeper into the behavior of teachers in the face of this new demand.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - The differentiated take-up of state benefits by minority groups: a view from the literature of take-up and bureaucracy at the street level.
Adriana Ramirez Ruiz (Centro de Investigación y Docencia Economicas)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The take-up of benefits from the target population of public policies is a key element in achieving the policy's objectives. For this reason, the take-up literature has been dedicated to delving into the elements that lead an individual to decide to take-up a benefit. However, this perspective does not examine the external factors that affect individual costs and tends to homogenize findings for the entire population.

This causes two problems, the first is that the impact of the elements of the State, such as the treatment of the bureaucrat to the user, on the take-up of benefits is ignored. The second is that because minority populations have higher costs in contrast to those of the average population, their mechanism of taking up benefits has great risks of being different from that of the general population, if this happens it may increase the inequalities of these populations. 

Within the literature on street-level bureaucracy, it has been found that street-level bureaucrats impact state-imposed administrative burdens (elements like take-up costs) by increasing or decreasing them. This action of bureaucrats can occur consciously or unconsciously, based on ideas of deserving and social labels. However, it has not been explored how the treatment of the bureaucrat from the user's perspective modifies administrative burdens and affects the take-up of the benefit.

The objective of this article is to know the differentiation in the take-up of minority groups by interacting the user's perception of the treatment of the bureaucrat at the street level with the traditional costs associated with take-up. This is intended to have a broader understanding of the take-up of state benefits and how this is carried out in minority groups by combining elements of the literature on street-level bureaucracy and take-up. In addition, the selected case will give a glimpse of the bureaucrat's behavior toward minority groups in a context characterized by work overload, weak institutions, and strong informal institutions, little-studied areas of the mainstream of the literature.

To this end, the information provided by ENSANUT will be taken, which is a survey that includes questions related to the process of obtaining a health service in Mexico. A PCA was applied to all those questions related to the evaluation of the bureaucrat's treatment at the street level, and several additional questions were selected to represent the traditional costs of take-up. The information was analyzed through regressions by minority social groups with interactions between costs and the treatment of the street bureaucrat and fixed effects. Preliminary results indicate that the treatment of the bureaucrat does influence the costs of take-up and that take-up is differentiated for minority groups. Specifically, results show that minority groups have a worse perception of the treatment of the bureaucrat which increases their take-up cost. Many reasons can be given to these results but most of them relate to the specific condition of the Mexican bureaucracy that made them act in a discriminatory form.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - The reproduction of structural inequalities in Chile's Conditional Cash Transfer Program
Taly Reininger (Universidad de Chile)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Conditional cash transfer programs have been and continue to be the dominant model for addressing extreme poverty in Latin America since the late 90s. While these program types vary by country, Chile’s model has been heralded as innovative due to its psychosocial accompaniment component. Under this program model, frontline professionals accompany beneficiary families for 24 months through home visits, seeking to ‘activate’ families by completing the objectives of the family intervention plan. Frontline professionals are thus responsible for providing families with information regarding available public services and programs while motivating them to undertake actions in order to improve their well-being.
 
The temporality of the relationship, the intimacy produced by conducting sessions in families’ homes, and the personal and often intimate content addressed in the home visits often produce emotional bonds between female program beneficiaries and frontline professionals. Presenting preliminary findings from a 3-year longitudinal qualitative study of Chile’s conditional cash transfer program, this paper argues that the emotional bonds formed between frontline professionals and female beneficiaries are mobilized in order to minimize the structural inequalities the program fails to address. This includes issues related to the lack and quality of public services, as well as the precarious employment conditions frontline professionals confront on a daily basis, thus reproducing inequalities. 

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Can public policies aggravate or (re)produce inequalities? Theoretical and methodological aspects
Cosmo Junior (Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

When we talk about public policies, especially social policies, we immediately think that they are formulated and implemented with the aim of mitigating or remedying some kind of social inequality. It turns out that in some concrete cases this is not the reality. On the contrary, some public policies, when implemented, end up aggravating existing inequalities or reproducing new types of inequality. With this in mind, this study sought to synthesize theoretical and methodological aspects that enable empirical analysis of concrete cases. This analysis can be applied both to top-down studies - checking the processes, i.e. the arrangements and instruments for implementing the public policy, and to bottom-up studies - looking specifically at the interaction between the actors involved in implementing the policy and the target subject. To this end, the study has a qualitative approach and as a technical procedure used a literature review for convenience. As a result, the literature presents two unwanted social effects: material - linked to access to and coverage of public policy; and symbolic - referring to the reproduction of stereotypes and, therefore, the relationship of subordination.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - administrative and territorial tensions in the implementation of public policies in week state institutions in Chile
Cristian Leyton Navarro (Universidad de O'Higgins)
CO-AUTHORS
Francisca Irarrázabal Gonzalez (Universidad Alberto Hurtado)
ABSTRACT

Research in public policies in Latin-America has certainly benefited from the use of Street-level bureaucracy theory to better understand the process of policy implementation. Nevertheless, it has also started to become clear that there are aspects of the theory that need to be revisited to make it more relevant and analytically pertinent to the social and institutional contexts that differ from the ones of the global North from where this theory emerged. This paper contributes to the discussion on the use of street-level bureaucracy theory on the study policy implementation in contexts where weak state institutions can be recognized. To address this issue, this paper examines the implementation of three social programs developed at the local level under a formal agreement between central public services and local institutions (municipalities). Drawing on sixty individual and group interviews with program coordinators and implementation teams who conduct their jobs in urban and rural areas throughout the country, this research explores how street-level bureaucrats deal with the difficulties of implementing a standardized program in very heterogeneous social and geographical contexts, different institutional and professional capacities, precarious working conditions, and attending the needs of highly vulnerable citizens. The paper shows tensions and difficulties of NPM in action and also that street-level bureaucrats’ who work in a context of weak state institutions show a tendency to assume the administrative burden of a public policy which does not provide adequate resources for its implementation and does not consider territorial differences as well as the heterogeneity of the targeted population.

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - The motivations and strategies of street-level policy entrepreneurs: a case study in China
Guangyao Zhong (Hunan University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Research on street-level policy entrepreneurs (SLPEs) is a new, ongoing trend in the literature of street-level bureaucrats. Implementing certain policy innovations has become a strategy for street-level bureaucrats to interact with citizens in adverse working environments. Existing studies have defined such street-level bureaucrats as Street-Level Policy Entrepreneurs (SLPEs). Different from previous literature that street-level bureaucrats only participate in policy implementation, recent literature suggests that street-level bureaucrats can conduct policy innovation and participate in the policy-making process (Arnold, 2015; Arnold, 2021; Cohen et al., 2021; Raadschelders, 2022). As the connecting point between the state and civil society, street-level bureaucrats can better grasp the contradictions and gaps between public needs and policies than other public sector personnel, which will make public policies more in line with public needs(Arnold, 2015).

 

Existing literature has pointed out that the motivation of street-level policy entrepreneurs for policy innovation is to avoid losing and to deal with inter-organizational competition(Arnold,2021; Golan-Nadir, 2021). Lotta et al. (2021) suggest that street-level policy entrepreneurs will carry out policy innovation out of defensive motivation at times of crisis. These studies provide an excellent analysis of the motivations of street-level policy entrepreneurs, but these analyses are not enough. Apart from factors discussed, there are other factors influencing street-level policy entrepreneurs that need to be discussed. In addition, the strategies and paths of policy innovation have not been discussed enough. Based on this, this paper will analyze the motivations and strategies of street-level policy entrepreneurs in policy innovation based on two examples from southern China.

 

The research method of this paper is case study. The cases are two policy innovations carried out by street bureaucrats in southern China. In the first case, a civil servant in a town explored the policy of "centralized management" and extended it to the whole city to address the scattered and large number of street vendors. In another case, a government official from the market regulation agency of a county explored the product traceability policy of "one product, one code" in response to the problem of illegal additives in fishery varieties, and extended the policy to the whole city. In both cases, we interviewed the street-level bureaucrat and relevant personnel in charge of initiating policy innovation and tracked the whole process. This work has provided a wealth of primary data to analyze the motivations and strategies of street-level policy entrepreneurs.

 

This research indicates that, apart from avoiding loss and inter-organizational competition, the motivation of street-level policy entrepreneurs can also be summarized as the contradiction between resource constraints and administrative pressure, promotion incentives, etc. Moreover, due to the resource constraints and low levels of street-level bureaucrats, their strategies in agenda setting, policy design, policy promotion, and overcoming departmental resistance are different from those of ordinary policy entrepreneurs. This study can further advance the discussion of street-level policy entrepreneurs and add empirical evidence from developing countries like China.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Teorías críticas y feminismo decolonial para el estudio de las BNC en América Latina
Gianinna MuñozArce (Universidad de Chile)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Buena parte del estudio de las BNC se ha basado tradicionalmente en enfoques que ponen al centro el carácter racional de la acción de los burócratas a nivel de calle. Desde estas perspectivas, la acción de estos burócratas se guía por la maximización de los beneficios por sobre los costos, el análisis pragmático de sus consecuencias, optimización del tiempo y orientación al logro, y fidelidad a los diseños de política. En este capítulo se plantea que más que ejecutores racionales de las políticas, o meros adaptadores o traductores de las mismas, los BNC son agentes cuya subjetividad está atravesada por dinámicas de poder y conocimiento, memorias, historicidad e identificaciones, relaciones y afectos, que reproducen posiciones de alienación y/o resistencia en los procesos de implementación de políticas a nivel de calle. En base a las aportaciones de la teoría crítica, los feminismos y el pensamiento decolonial latinoamericano, se problematiza la propia noción de burócratas de nivel de calle. Se propone que estos agentes tienen el potencial de contestar y subvertir las orientaciones y mandatos institucionales de acuerdo con el despliegue más o menos explícito de agencia moral y el desarrollo de estrategias y coaliciones para la resistencia. En un escenario caracterizado por una institucionalidad débil, como el latinoamericano, estas prácticas de resistencia se vuelven cruciales para sobrevivir a las precariedades de la implementación, pero también pueden ocultar la reproducción de humillaciones, desigualdades e injusticias.

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - Allocating inequality: analyzing state violence against adolescents deprived of liberty in Brazil
Eduarda De Almeida (Fundação João Pinheiro)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Inspired by the Convention on the Rights of the Child and with the aim of regulating art. 227 of the Federal Constitution (CF/1988), the Child and Adolescent Statute (ECA) was published in Brazil in 1990. The ECA delimited the practice of the delinquent act as conduct described as a crime or misdemeanor. This means that upon committing an infraction, adolescents and young people will have their acts investigated within the scope of the Juvenile Justice. If convicted, social and educational measures will be applied as a strategy of accountability, social integration, and conduct disapproval. In practice, however, since the implementation of these measures is usually carried on inside deteriorated and violent detention centers, both adolescent’s integrity and their conditions to resocialize are severely threatened, weakening the effectiveness of the policy. Literature highlights the recurring problems in guaranteeing the rights of adolescents deprived of liberty (AGANBEN, 2002; ALMEIDA et al, 2023) and denounces state violence directed against the black, youth and poor adolescents inside the detention centers (FERNANDES, 2021). Despite being a widespread phenomenon (JESUS, 2009; GOMES, 2014; GODOI, 2018), due to lack of access to relevant data, state violence analysis has not yet incorporated the implementation actors (a.k.a. security officers) perspectives. Because of that, analysis have failed to grasp state violence in its full complexity, as a situated event that takes place within socio-education centers organizational routine. Considering that, this research aims to understand how state violence works against adolescents deprived of liberty, observing security officers’ decisions. The officers are seen as street level bureaucrats entitled with discretionary powers whose decisions are subjected to serious moral and resource allocation dilemmas (LIPSKY, 2019; LOTTA, 2012; LOTTA et al., 2020; NOVATO, NAJBERG e LOTTA, 2020). The analysis will consider the officer’s account of the facts, obtained in 1941 security reports of youth detention centers of the Minas Gerais’ State/Brazil. The reports represent unprecedented data in Brazil’s in both juvenile justice and policy studies. The records analyzed frame interns as delinquent, uncontrolled and violent, justifying the use of progressive physical violence as a necessary measure to control the adolescent during a security crisis. Recurrently that violence generates critical injuries. Some files also report controversial acts of self-violence committed by the interns, some tragically resulting in self-extermination. The results run against a great amount of evidence that points to the presence of torture as a diffuse phenomenon inside deprived liberty governmental facilities (FERNANDES, 2021; FERRAZ E SANTOS-CHIES, 2022). The findings raise relevant questions about the causes of state violence against young interns of socio-educational system in Brazil. On the one hand, there is an attempt to maintain state violence as an invisible, unspeakable, unindictable, and unpunishable crime (MAIA, 2006). On the other hand, elastic concepts of torture might have been contributing to let the kinds of justifications provided by the security officers’ narrative to stand out.

ACCEPTED
Format
11 - Examining the Nexus between Street-level Bureaucracy and Xenophobia in South Africa
Chigozie Udensi (University of Johannesburg)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This research paper will critically examine the intersection between street-level bureaucracy and xenophobia in South Africa, contributing to the decolonization studies on bureaucratic practices. By scrutinizing the bureaucratic processes at the grassroots level, the study will uncover how these practices intersect with and contribute to xenophobic attitudes and behaviors within the country. Specifically focusing on immigration management, the paper will illuminate the mechanisms through which street-level bureaucrats inadvertently perpetuate xenophobia within South Africa's institutional context.

 

Drawing on empirical evidence and theoretical frameworks, the research will endeavor to deepen our understanding of the complex dynamics underlying xenophobic sentiments. It aims to challenge assumptions about the nature of bureaucratic practices in South Africa’s contexts, particularly regarding weak institutional capacities, unreliable service provision and social inequalities. Discussions and presentations within the paper will further explore how social inequalities fundamentally shape state-citizen relationships, with a focus on street-level interactions.

 

This study will be approached using theories such as Critical Race Theory, which helps to uncover the underlying power dynamics and structural inequalities that perpetuate xenophobic attitudes. Additionally, Social Identity Theory can provide insights into how individuals' perceptions of their own identity and group membership influence their attitudes towards immigrants. Methodologically, a mixed-methods approach combining qualitative interviews with street-level bureaucrats and quantitative surveys of community members affected by immigration policies can offer a comprehensive understanding of the complex interplay between bureaucratic practices and xenophobia.

 

Key themes of interest in this study include the strategies employed by street-level bureaucrats to navigate overdemand and resource shortages, as well as the territorial disparities in policy implementation that exacerbate inequalities in service provision. Additionally, the paper will delve into the informalization of street-level interactions with citizens and the consequences of street-level bureaucrats' embeddedness in the communities they serve. Moreover, it will examine the brokerage function of street-level bureaucrats and how their actions can perpetuate or challenge existing power dynamics.

 

By critically examining these issues, this paper aims to advance our understanding of street-level bureaucracy and its role in reproducing social inequalities. It seeks to foster dialogue and collaboration among scholars and practitioners to generate new insights and approaches for addressing xenophobia and strengthening state-citizen relations at the grassroots level in South Africa. Through interdisciplinary perspectives and empirical case studies, this paper will contribute to the broader discourse on decolonizing studies on street-level bureaucracy and addressing systemic injustices.

ACCEPTED
Format
12 - Frontline Decision Autonomy under Decentralization: Evidence from Health Sector Reform
Alan Zarychta (University of Chicago)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Decentralization is designed to transfer autonomy from more central to more local actors, yet studies show differences in the autonomy realized under these reforms.  Drawing on the case of health sector decentralization in Honduras, we utilize the decision space approach and original data for over 600 frontline health workers in a matched sample to explain facility-level autonomy.  We find that reported decision autonomy in four functional areas is slightly reduced under decentralization, reductions are most pronounced where decentralization is led by municipal governments or associations, rather than NGOs, and differences across staff types are modest.  Furthermore, capacity and resources are necessary for expanded autonomy, particularly in organizing service delivery, while supportive accountability allows for increased autonomy in human resources and finances.  Our research shows the importance of including frontline staff in studies of decision autonomy under decentralization, and considering the distribution of autonomy across levels in hierarchical service delivery systems.

ACCEPTED
Format
13 - Serving citizens or serving the political machine? The implementation of a new social policy during elections in Mexico
Sergio A. Campos (Centro de Investigación y Docencia Económica (CIDE))
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Frontline work is inherently uncertain. However, this uncertainty may be amplified in countries with weak institutions for multiple reasons. One of these reasons is the volatility of public policies. This means that the actions and programs carried out by governments can respond primarily to clientelistic and patronage rationalities rather than to the relevance of solving public problems. In this context, street-level bureaucrats are subject to implementing volatile actions that can change overnight, generating more significant uncertainty and workloads than they are typically accustomed to. This uncertainty can have harmful effects on the way frontline workers act, from uncertainty in their job to discontent with decision makers, especially if public programs are used for political-electoral purposes and frontline workers are forced to implement new clientelistic programs. Based on qualitative data from a case of public policy change in a local government in Mexico, this research explores the responses of street-level officials to the public policy volatility they face.

ACCEPTED
Format
14 - Discussions
Rik Peeters (CIDE)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Discussions

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Las políticas sociales en América Latina han estado construidas en lógicas desde un ethos que fortalece condiciones laborales de precarización, que brindan escasos recursos para la ejecución de los programas y que están atravesadas por problemas de corrupción. Dichos problemas también han sido experimentados por quienes implementan las políticas sociales en Chile. Así, se han detectando muchas de estas lógicas de precarización en los ejercicios profesionales de quienes implementan programas sociales, en las consecuencias que el Estado tiene en la vida de las personas, en la forma en cómo el Estado se despliega en el territorio para la aplicación de estas políticas y en el mecanismo a través del cual se despliega esa relación. Sumado a lo anterior, reciente literatura a puesto en la palestra los efectos generizados para quienes implementan las políticas sociales, es decir, que hay una forma de ejercer la discreción profesional que se distingue por género. En esta línea, se ha mostrado como la implementación de las políticas sociales sostiene una posición desfavorable para las mujeres, tanto laboral como relacionalmente y, a su vez, han afirmado la idea de que la discreción profesional también tiene manifestaciones generizadas.

Aunque estos enfoques han ampliado la forma de entender la implementación de políticas, no se han preocupado especialmente por enlazar la relación entre políticas sociales y la sostenibilidad de la vida.

Por lo mismo, en esta ponencia desarrollaré un abordaje que entrelaza el enfoque de la sostenibilidad de la vida y la implementación de políticas sociales, con la intención de generar algunas propuestas que emanan de la práctica de ejercicios de discreción profesional y de las resistencias profesionales, de quienes implementan programas sociales en Chile. Estas reflexiones emergen de resultados de investigación de dos proyectos Fondecyt Regulares en los que he participado. Aunque ninguno de estos partió problematizando las relaciones de género ni los feminismos, los relatos de quienes han participado de la investigación no han tardado en mostrar una infinidad de imbricaciones posibles, lo cual me/nos ha invitado a pensar estos cruces que han visto la luz en dos artículos académicos dedicados específicamente a mostrar resultados de investigación leídos desde este marco (Duboy-Luengo & Muñoz-Arce, 2022; Muñoz-Arce & Duboy-Luengo, 2023). Sin embargo, lo que hoy (me) propongo, es ampliar la mirada para proponer insumos que, desde el enfoque de sostenibilidad de la vida, contribuyan en tres direcciones: hacia quienes implementan políticas sociales; hacia quienes diseñan políticas sociales, y; hacia quienes enseñan estas materias en los diferentes espacios educativos.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Incipiently, research on street-level bureaucracy in Latin America has investigated how implementers questioning, resist, and transform the political-institutional frameworks from which social interventions are built. In the region, these processes of resistance and agency occur mainly around relatively new programs, with little evidence of their impact and organized mainly under the logic of New Public Management (NPM). In this context, in this presentation we ask ourselves, how are the processes of professional resistance articulated and developed in the face of a “scientifically” validated program? Starting from the conceptual articulation between the theories of professional resistance, the analyzes of street-level bureaucracy and the of actor-network theory, we study the motivations, implications and processes of resistance that occur in the Skills for Life Program (Habilidades Para la Vida, HpV in Spanish), the largest mental health program for children and adolescents in Chilean schools. Based on an analysis of 23 semi-structured and group interviews, as well as the analysis of the available documentation of the program, the preliminary results show that the empirical evidence of the program acts as a blanket of validation of the national strategies and guidelines, limiting the possibility of resistance at the local level. Likewise, we find that resistance is articulated by seeking to promote new evidence - rather than questioning the criteria with which it is constructed - showing the interweaving between professional resistance, implementation of policies and validation and scientific production in social programs in Latin America.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In Mexico, emergency calls due to family violence represented, during 2023 (January-November), 3.8% of total actual calls. In turn, the State of Sonora occupied (in the same period) the first place nationally in reports for this reason with a record of 44,787 calls (SSP,2023). The main victims of family violence are women, girls and boys. In all cases, girls and boys are victims of psychological violence due to being exposed to and witnessing the acts of violence that occur against women, and where they can also be directly attacked (UNICEF, 2019). For their part, schools are obliged to report all cases of violence against children and adolescents (NNA), which arise in the school, family and community space (DOF, 2019). For this, action protocols have been generated. In this sense, this article argues why it is relevant to use the theoretical model of street-level bureaucracies for the analysis of the process of attention to cases of family violence from the participation of teachers.

The theoretical model of street-level bureaucracies proposed by Lipsky (1980) redefined the perspective with which the implementation of public policies was traditionally analyzed, to emphasize the actions of the people who apply certain policies - especially the bureaucrats who are at the end of the hierarchical chain, who serve the recipients and beneficiaries of a certain service or government program.

The relevance of this model is based on the fact that it is a theoretical proposal for the analysis of the process of implementing a public policy, which recognizes in the foundational work the figure of teachers as street-level bureaucrats. The characterization of Maynard and Portillo (2014) constitutes a guide to analyze the practices of teachers regarding one of their functions - compliance with action protocols in cases of violence-. Likewise, the notion of coping strategies (copin) explains the different ways in which public servants cope with the demands of the job. This notion constitutes an incorporation of psychology into this conceptual framework. Furthermore, the theory of street-level bureaucracy recognizes the importance of the contextual elements where people operate, which is particularly useful for the analysis of this research where schools are located in areas of high marginality.

With all this, we seek to argue that this theoretical model allows us to analyze a research problem from a perspective that has been little studied in Mexico and provides theoretical-methodological elements that allow us to delve deeper into the behavior of teachers in the face of this new demand.

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The take-up of benefits from the target population of public policies is a key element in achieving the policy's objectives. For this reason, the take-up literature has been dedicated to delving into the elements that lead an individual to decide to take-up a benefit. However, this perspective does not examine the external factors that affect individual costs and tends to homogenize findings for the entire population.

This causes two problems, the first is that the impact of the elements of the State, such as the treatment of the bureaucrat to the user, on the take-up of benefits is ignored. The second is that because minority populations have higher costs in contrast to those of the average population, their mechanism of taking up benefits has great risks of being different from that of the general population, if this happens it may increase the inequalities of these populations. 

Within the literature on street-level bureaucracy, it has been found that street-level bureaucrats impact state-imposed administrative burdens (elements like take-up costs) by increasing or decreasing them. This action of bureaucrats can occur consciously or unconsciously, based on ideas of deserving and social labels. However, it has not been explored how the treatment of the bureaucrat from the user's perspective modifies administrative burdens and affects the take-up of the benefit.

The objective of this article is to know the differentiation in the take-up of minority groups by interacting the user's perception of the treatment of the bureaucrat at the street level with the traditional costs associated with take-up. This is intended to have a broader understanding of the take-up of state benefits and how this is carried out in minority groups by combining elements of the literature on street-level bureaucracy and take-up. In addition, the selected case will give a glimpse of the bureaucrat's behavior toward minority groups in a context characterized by work overload, weak institutions, and strong informal institutions, little-studied areas of the mainstream of the literature.

To this end, the information provided by ENSANUT will be taken, which is a survey that includes questions related to the process of obtaining a health service in Mexico. A PCA was applied to all those questions related to the evaluation of the bureaucrat's treatment at the street level, and several additional questions were selected to represent the traditional costs of take-up. The information was analyzed through regressions by minority social groups with interactions between costs and the treatment of the street bureaucrat and fixed effects. Preliminary results indicate that the treatment of the bureaucrat does influence the costs of take-up and that take-up is differentiated for minority groups. Specifically, results show that minority groups have a worse perception of the treatment of the bureaucrat which increases their take-up cost. Many reasons can be given to these results but most of them relate to the specific condition of the Mexican bureaucracy that made them act in a discriminatory form.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Conditional cash transfer programs have been and continue to be the dominant model for addressing extreme poverty in Latin America since the late 90s. While these program types vary by country, Chile’s model has been heralded as innovative due to its psychosocial accompaniment component. Under this program model, frontline professionals accompany beneficiary families for 24 months through home visits, seeking to ‘activate’ families by completing the objectives of the family intervention plan. Frontline professionals are thus responsible for providing families with information regarding available public services and programs while motivating them to undertake actions in order to improve their well-being.
 
The temporality of the relationship, the intimacy produced by conducting sessions in families’ homes, and the personal and often intimate content addressed in the home visits often produce emotional bonds between female program beneficiaries and frontline professionals. Presenting preliminary findings from a 3-year longitudinal qualitative study of Chile’s conditional cash transfer program, this paper argues that the emotional bonds formed between frontline professionals and female beneficiaries are mobilized in order to minimize the structural inequalities the program fails to address. This includes issues related to the lack and quality of public services, as well as the precarious employment conditions frontline professionals confront on a daily basis, thus reproducing inequalities. 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

When we talk about public policies, especially social policies, we immediately think that they are formulated and implemented with the aim of mitigating or remedying some kind of social inequality. It turns out that in some concrete cases this is not the reality. On the contrary, some public policies, when implemented, end up aggravating existing inequalities or reproducing new types of inequality. With this in mind, this study sought to synthesize theoretical and methodological aspects that enable empirical analysis of concrete cases. This analysis can be applied both to top-down studies - checking the processes, i.e. the arrangements and instruments for implementing the public policy, and to bottom-up studies - looking specifically at the interaction between the actors involved in implementing the policy and the target subject. To this end, the study has a qualitative approach and as a technical procedure used a literature review for convenience. As a result, the literature presents two unwanted social effects: material - linked to access to and coverage of public policy; and symbolic - referring to the reproduction of stereotypes and, therefore, the relationship of subordination.

CO-AUTHORS
Francisca Irarrázabal Gonzalez (Universidad Alberto Hurtado)
ABSTRACT

Research in public policies in Latin-America has certainly benefited from the use of Street-level bureaucracy theory to better understand the process of policy implementation. Nevertheless, it has also started to become clear that there are aspects of the theory that need to be revisited to make it more relevant and analytically pertinent to the social and institutional contexts that differ from the ones of the global North from where this theory emerged. This paper contributes to the discussion on the use of street-level bureaucracy theory on the study policy implementation in contexts where weak state institutions can be recognized. To address this issue, this paper examines the implementation of three social programs developed at the local level under a formal agreement between central public services and local institutions (municipalities). Drawing on sixty individual and group interviews with program coordinators and implementation teams who conduct their jobs in urban and rural areas throughout the country, this research explores how street-level bureaucrats deal with the difficulties of implementing a standardized program in very heterogeneous social and geographical contexts, different institutional and professional capacities, precarious working conditions, and attending the needs of highly vulnerable citizens. The paper shows tensions and difficulties of NPM in action and also that street-level bureaucrats’ who work in a context of weak state institutions show a tendency to assume the administrative burden of a public policy which does not provide adequate resources for its implementation and does not consider territorial differences as well as the heterogeneity of the targeted population.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Research on street-level policy entrepreneurs (SLPEs) is a new, ongoing trend in the literature of street-level bureaucrats. Implementing certain policy innovations has become a strategy for street-level bureaucrats to interact with citizens in adverse working environments. Existing studies have defined such street-level bureaucrats as Street-Level Policy Entrepreneurs (SLPEs). Different from previous literature that street-level bureaucrats only participate in policy implementation, recent literature suggests that street-level bureaucrats can conduct policy innovation and participate in the policy-making process (Arnold, 2015; Arnold, 2021; Cohen et al., 2021; Raadschelders, 2022). As the connecting point between the state and civil society, street-level bureaucrats can better grasp the contradictions and gaps between public needs and policies than other public sector personnel, which will make public policies more in line with public needs(Arnold, 2015).

 

Existing literature has pointed out that the motivation of street-level policy entrepreneurs for policy innovation is to avoid losing and to deal with inter-organizational competition(Arnold,2021; Golan-Nadir, 2021). Lotta et al. (2021) suggest that street-level policy entrepreneurs will carry out policy innovation out of defensive motivation at times of crisis. These studies provide an excellent analysis of the motivations of street-level policy entrepreneurs, but these analyses are not enough. Apart from factors discussed, there are other factors influencing street-level policy entrepreneurs that need to be discussed. In addition, the strategies and paths of policy innovation have not been discussed enough. Based on this, this paper will analyze the motivations and strategies of street-level policy entrepreneurs in policy innovation based on two examples from southern China.

 

The research method of this paper is case study. The cases are two policy innovations carried out by street bureaucrats in southern China. In the first case, a civil servant in a town explored the policy of "centralized management" and extended it to the whole city to address the scattered and large number of street vendors. In another case, a government official from the market regulation agency of a county explored the product traceability policy of "one product, one code" in response to the problem of illegal additives in fishery varieties, and extended the policy to the whole city. In both cases, we interviewed the street-level bureaucrat and relevant personnel in charge of initiating policy innovation and tracked the whole process. This work has provided a wealth of primary data to analyze the motivations and strategies of street-level policy entrepreneurs.

 

This research indicates that, apart from avoiding loss and inter-organizational competition, the motivation of street-level policy entrepreneurs can also be summarized as the contradiction between resource constraints and administrative pressure, promotion incentives, etc. Moreover, due to the resource constraints and low levels of street-level bureaucrats, their strategies in agenda setting, policy design, policy promotion, and overcoming departmental resistance are different from those of ordinary policy entrepreneurs. This study can further advance the discussion of street-level policy entrepreneurs and add empirical evidence from developing countries like China.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Buena parte del estudio de las BNC se ha basado tradicionalmente en enfoques que ponen al centro el carácter racional de la acción de los burócratas a nivel de calle. Desde estas perspectivas, la acción de estos burócratas se guía por la maximización de los beneficios por sobre los costos, el análisis pragmático de sus consecuencias, optimización del tiempo y orientación al logro, y fidelidad a los diseños de política. En este capítulo se plantea que más que ejecutores racionales de las políticas, o meros adaptadores o traductores de las mismas, los BNC son agentes cuya subjetividad está atravesada por dinámicas de poder y conocimiento, memorias, historicidad e identificaciones, relaciones y afectos, que reproducen posiciones de alienación y/o resistencia en los procesos de implementación de políticas a nivel de calle. En base a las aportaciones de la teoría crítica, los feminismos y el pensamiento decolonial latinoamericano, se problematiza la propia noción de burócratas de nivel de calle. Se propone que estos agentes tienen el potencial de contestar y subvertir las orientaciones y mandatos institucionales de acuerdo con el despliegue más o menos explícito de agencia moral y el desarrollo de estrategias y coaliciones para la resistencia. En un escenario caracterizado por una institucionalidad débil, como el latinoamericano, estas prácticas de resistencia se vuelven cruciales para sobrevivir a las precariedades de la implementación, pero también pueden ocultar la reproducción de humillaciones, desigualdades e injusticias.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Inspired by the Convention on the Rights of the Child and with the aim of regulating art. 227 of the Federal Constitution (CF/1988), the Child and Adolescent Statute (ECA) was published in Brazil in 1990. The ECA delimited the practice of the delinquent act as conduct described as a crime or misdemeanor. This means that upon committing an infraction, adolescents and young people will have their acts investigated within the scope of the Juvenile Justice. If convicted, social and educational measures will be applied as a strategy of accountability, social integration, and conduct disapproval. In practice, however, since the implementation of these measures is usually carried on inside deteriorated and violent detention centers, both adolescent’s integrity and their conditions to resocialize are severely threatened, weakening the effectiveness of the policy. Literature highlights the recurring problems in guaranteeing the rights of adolescents deprived of liberty (AGANBEN, 2002; ALMEIDA et al, 2023) and denounces state violence directed against the black, youth and poor adolescents inside the detention centers (FERNANDES, 2021). Despite being a widespread phenomenon (JESUS, 2009; GOMES, 2014; GODOI, 2018), due to lack of access to relevant data, state violence analysis has not yet incorporated the implementation actors (a.k.a. security officers) perspectives. Because of that, analysis have failed to grasp state violence in its full complexity, as a situated event that takes place within socio-education centers organizational routine. Considering that, this research aims to understand how state violence works against adolescents deprived of liberty, observing security officers’ decisions. The officers are seen as street level bureaucrats entitled with discretionary powers whose decisions are subjected to serious moral and resource allocation dilemmas (LIPSKY, 2019; LOTTA, 2012; LOTTA et al., 2020; NOVATO, NAJBERG e LOTTA, 2020). The analysis will consider the officer’s account of the facts, obtained in 1941 security reports of youth detention centers of the Minas Gerais’ State/Brazil. The reports represent unprecedented data in Brazil’s in both juvenile justice and policy studies. The records analyzed frame interns as delinquent, uncontrolled and violent, justifying the use of progressive physical violence as a necessary measure to control the adolescent during a security crisis. Recurrently that violence generates critical injuries. Some files also report controversial acts of self-violence committed by the interns, some tragically resulting in self-extermination. The results run against a great amount of evidence that points to the presence of torture as a diffuse phenomenon inside deprived liberty governmental facilities (FERNANDES, 2021; FERRAZ E SANTOS-CHIES, 2022). The findings raise relevant questions about the causes of state violence against young interns of socio-educational system in Brazil. On the one hand, there is an attempt to maintain state violence as an invisible, unspeakable, unindictable, and unpunishable crime (MAIA, 2006). On the other hand, elastic concepts of torture might have been contributing to let the kinds of justifications provided by the security officers’ narrative to stand out.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This research paper will critically examine the intersection between street-level bureaucracy and xenophobia in South Africa, contributing to the decolonization studies on bureaucratic practices. By scrutinizing the bureaucratic processes at the grassroots level, the study will uncover how these practices intersect with and contribute to xenophobic attitudes and behaviors within the country. Specifically focusing on immigration management, the paper will illuminate the mechanisms through which street-level bureaucrats inadvertently perpetuate xenophobia within South Africa's institutional context.

 

Drawing on empirical evidence and theoretical frameworks, the research will endeavor to deepen our understanding of the complex dynamics underlying xenophobic sentiments. It aims to challenge assumptions about the nature of bureaucratic practices in South Africa’s contexts, particularly regarding weak institutional capacities, unreliable service provision and social inequalities. Discussions and presentations within the paper will further explore how social inequalities fundamentally shape state-citizen relationships, with a focus on street-level interactions.

 

This study will be approached using theories such as Critical Race Theory, which helps to uncover the underlying power dynamics and structural inequalities that perpetuate xenophobic attitudes. Additionally, Social Identity Theory can provide insights into how individuals' perceptions of their own identity and group membership influence their attitudes towards immigrants. Methodologically, a mixed-methods approach combining qualitative interviews with street-level bureaucrats and quantitative surveys of community members affected by immigration policies can offer a comprehensive understanding of the complex interplay between bureaucratic practices and xenophobia.

 

Key themes of interest in this study include the strategies employed by street-level bureaucrats to navigate overdemand and resource shortages, as well as the territorial disparities in policy implementation that exacerbate inequalities in service provision. Additionally, the paper will delve into the informalization of street-level interactions with citizens and the consequences of street-level bureaucrats' embeddedness in the communities they serve. Moreover, it will examine the brokerage function of street-level bureaucrats and how their actions can perpetuate or challenge existing power dynamics.

 

By critically examining these issues, this paper aims to advance our understanding of street-level bureaucracy and its role in reproducing social inequalities. It seeks to foster dialogue and collaboration among scholars and practitioners to generate new insights and approaches for addressing xenophobia and strengthening state-citizen relations at the grassroots level in South Africa. Through interdisciplinary perspectives and empirical case studies, this paper will contribute to the broader discourse on decolonizing studies on street-level bureaucracy and addressing systemic injustices.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Decentralization is designed to transfer autonomy from more central to more local actors, yet studies show differences in the autonomy realized under these reforms.  Drawing on the case of health sector decentralization in Honduras, we utilize the decision space approach and original data for over 600 frontline health workers in a matched sample to explain facility-level autonomy.  We find that reported decision autonomy in four functional areas is slightly reduced under decentralization, reductions are most pronounced where decentralization is led by municipal governments or associations, rather than NGOs, and differences across staff types are modest.  Furthermore, capacity and resources are necessary for expanded autonomy, particularly in organizing service delivery, while supportive accountability allows for increased autonomy in human resources and finances.  Our research shows the importance of including frontline staff in studies of decision autonomy under decentralization, and considering the distribution of autonomy across levels in hierarchical service delivery systems.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Frontline work is inherently uncertain. However, this uncertainty may be amplified in countries with weak institutions for multiple reasons. One of these reasons is the volatility of public policies. This means that the actions and programs carried out by governments can respond primarily to clientelistic and patronage rationalities rather than to the relevance of solving public problems. In this context, street-level bureaucrats are subject to implementing volatile actions that can change overnight, generating more significant uncertainty and workloads than they are typically accustomed to. This uncertainty can have harmful effects on the way frontline workers act, from uncertainty in their job to discontent with decision makers, especially if public programs are used for political-electoral purposes and frontline workers are forced to implement new clientelistic programs. Based on qualitative data from a case of public policy change in a local government in Mexico, this research explores the responses of street-level officials to the public policy volatility they face.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Discussions